
The Real Third World Season 2 Episode 8
To Avoid War, Prepare for War
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

To Avoid War, Prepare for War
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
SPEAKER_00The Real Third World Season 2, Episode 8. To avoid war, prepare for war. Hey Dobrodan, Mullibuanji, Zdravo, how's it? Alo, I'm Ruthie, and from Sarebo to Red Africa, welcome to our podcast about the people and history of the real Third World. Forget the telethons. The phrase the third world came about as an act of defiance, when several smaller and mainly post-colonial nations decided they didn't want to choose between the Western First World or the Eastern Second World, but to choose their own third way.
SPEAKER_00Alone, they couldn't rival the superpowers, but together they could be a force to be reckoned with. And even more, the events of the world today directly descend from the third world's past. In our last season we laid some foundation of various third world countries, and this season we will be drawing even more lines to show how we got to the world we are living in today. These stories have been overlooked long enough, and we're going to tell them to you here. Who should be in NATO?
SPEAKER_00This question is at the front and center of world discourse today. Along with that is the question of what current purpose NATO even serves. Problematically, most of the discussion around NATO, NATO enlargement, and NATO's existence in general is being driven by people without much understanding of how NATO came to be in the first place, to say nothing of the lack of knowledge about how NATO actually works. And to be honest, facts don't always get in the way of those who have decided to believe whatever particular thing.
SPEAKER_00In a nutshell, the North Atlantic Treaty was signed on April 4, 1949, in Washington, D.C. by representatives of the United States, United Kingdom, France, Belgium, Netherlands, Luxembourg, Canada, Italy, Portugal, Norway, Denmark, and Iceland. It was signed within shouting distance of the end of World War II and at the brink of the Cold War, which has left some arguing that NATO pushed the Cold War into being. It's the kind of connection that can be made if someone is merely presented with two dates and told to explain the connection between them, rather like blind men being asked to describe an elephant via touch.
SPEAKER_00The treaty, which led to the multinational organization with the ubiquitous initials, did not spring out of nowhere, nor was it the result of backroom dealing by a cabal of nefarious characters twisting their evil moustaches in glee at the prospect of world domination. Instead, it was a very real response to the rapidly changing world as it was unfolding in the post-war environment. A world in which much of Europe was in rubble, and which the end of the all-encompassing World War II did not mean an end to the fighting.
SPEAKER_00By the end of World War II, many on the Allied side were already harboring suspicions about the Soviet Union. As it rolled through Eastern Europe, liberating countries from Nazi domination, it was also liberating them from whatever local treasures the German army had left behind, as well as personally liberating citizens from their wristwatches. Wristwatches were the hot ticket item for Red Army soldiers, with the most successful flashing arms lined with various and sundry timepieces.
SPEAKER_00One nation managed to expel the Germans while still keeping their sovereignty intact, Yugoslavia under Marshal Tito. But still, at the end of the war, Tito was firmly in the Soviet communist orbit. Grudges were carried out as the Red Army rolled through, notably in Poland, where the nation's seat at the opening UN meeting sat empty because Poland's best and brightest leaders had all been kidnapped and sent to Moscow. The Allies were not amused, but they were also mindful of the extreme losses the Soviet Union had taken in the fight against the Germans, and understood that victory had very much been contributed to by Soviet blood.
SPEAKER_00This and the ensuing exhaustion with war put the Allies in a bind. They capitulated to the spheres of influence proposed by Stalin, which rather echoed the Malinkov Ribbentrop Pact. Eastern Europe could not be protected by the rest of the Allies without a fight, and everyone was tired of fighting. There was still conflict, however. First in August of 1946, when the ink had barely dried on the treaties ending World War II, the USSR was demanding Turkey allow them joint control of the Turkish Straits.
SPEAKER_00Turkey had not allowed Soviet ships to travel through during the war, but the crisis kicked off when a United States battleship was waved through. The Soviets, who wanted Turkey within their sphere of influence, took offense and began building up naval forces in the Black Sea and sending ground troops to the Balkans. The US responded by sending a naval force to Turkey and along with the UK reaffirming their support for the Turkish government. The Soviets backed down, but it was not a lesson learned.
SPEAKER_00The Greek government had been battling for its life against a communist insurgency from March of 1946. The communists had been a hard fighting force against the German occupation of Greece and were supported by the communist leaders of Yugoslavia and Albania. Interestingly enough, Stalin was not fully behind the Greek communists and in fact castigated Tito for Yugoslavia's support. To the world, however, communists were trying to take over Greece, and the Soviet Union was the head communist in charge.
SPEAKER_00The UK was not able to continue to support the Greek government, so the United States stepped in. It marked the first proxy conflict of the Cold War. It also marked two more important events, the first use of containment, which would define Western policy during the Cold War, and the issuance of the Truman Doctrine. The idea of containment had come from U.S. diplomat George Kennan, who would later be appointed U.S. Ambassador to the Soviet Union.
SPEAKER_00In his own words, as part of this so-called long telegram describing Soviet society and motivations to President Truman, Cannon said, Soviet power, unlike that of Hitlerite Germany, is neither schematic nor adventuristic. It does not work with fixed plans, it does not take unnecessary risks, impervious to the logic of reason, and it is highly sensitive to the logic of force. For this reason, it can easily withdraw, and usually does when strong resistance is encountered at any point.
SPEAKER_00The idea of containment, providing that resistance to the Soviets at designated borders to keep them from continuously expanding, was born. Its inspiration was the Cordon Sanitaire of illness and plague outbreaks, and it was meant to keep Soviet influence from spreading. Following, as well as a part of, the idea of containment was its manifestation as the Truman Doctrine. The decision announced to U.S. Congress in March 1947 that the U.S.
SPEAKER_00pledged to support any democratic nations being threatened by outside influences. There was obviously more to it than that simple statement, but you get the gist. Still, a pledge of support was not assigned and stamped agreement, and events continued to roll on. Communist parties in Western European nations, which had been completely destroyed by the fighting, were enjoying a moment in the sun. They had quite a bit of support in Italy and France as well as in Czechoslovakia.
SPEAKER_00But by 1948, support for the Communists was waning. In Czechoslovakia, where the Soviets had staked a sphere of influence claim, likely electoral defeat led to a coup d'etat where rather than risk losing power, the Communist Party took power violently. It kicked off arrests and thousands of refugees in an already refugee-filled Europe. Nearly simultaneously, another area of conflict with the Soviets emerged. This time it was the administration of Berlin, which was physically within the Soviet sphere, but as a capital city was not.
SPEAKER_00Stalin had not been quiet about his intentions for all of Germany to fall under the communist banner. He had given a statement to that effect to the East Germans, and one to the Bulgarians and the Yugoslavs as well. Molotov, Stalin's foreign minister, broke it down as what happens to Berlin happens to Germany. What happens to Germany happens to Europe. Meanwhile, communists lost elections in Germany and the Marshall Plan to rebuild Europe was going full steam ahead. The Soviets had initially been offered participation in the Marshall Plan, but quickly saw that it would disrupt their ability to influence the claimed Soviet sphere.
SPEAKER_00They refused to take part and forced Poland, Ukraine, and other nations still being occupied to stay out of the plan as well. Unfortunately for the Soviets, Western Germany was not a part of their administration. They were free to make their own participation decision, and they chose to sign on. They also signed on to Allied plans to introduce a new currency to replace the ridiculously unstable Reichsmark. The Soviets responded by blockading Western Berlin.
SPEAKER_00The Allies responded in an unprecedented middle finger of foreign and military policy by initiating the now fabled Berlin airlift. The Soviets backed down. The ruthless occupations of Soviet zones and Soviet land grabs after the war convinced Western Europe that whatever the last thousand years of arguments, squabbles, and wars had amounted to in the past, they would not last long on their own against the Soviet threat of expansion. To this end, they began initiating a series of treaties to protect themselves.
SPEAKER_00But by 1948, the reality of the exhausted and decimated nations had sunk in. Without U.S. involvement, Western Europe would not be able to continuously stand. It was not an idea that everyone on both sides of the Atlantic wholeheartedly jumped into. Although several years of hard-fought war had opened American eyes to the increasingly interconnected nature of the world, the U.S. still had an isolationist bent to overcome. And not everyone in Western Europe was happy about inviting someone else in to oversee their business.
SPEAKER_00But the U.S. President Truman was game and believed that U.S. security rested on an economically strong Western Europe able to stand up against the communist threat. It certainly didn't hurt matters that an economically prosperous Europe would also be a great market for American goods. From July to September of 1948, leaders of Europe and the U.S. met in Washington, D.C. to hammer out their issues. For some items, everyone was fully on board and in agreement. The U.S. would be in leadership of the new organization.
SPEAKER_00The organization would not merely be intended as a military vehicle, but would also foster European cooperation and integration. The organization would be dedicated to opposing Soviet expansion. And everyone even agreed to abide by France's discomfort and not allow immediate integration of their historic enemy Germany. There were, however, several areas of disagreement. For one, there was much ado being made about whose military aid from the US was to be prioritized, with France demanding spot number one.
SPEAKER_00For another, there was lively debate over the number of members the organization would allow. But most contentious of all was the proposed wording of what is now the most famous article of the NATO Charter, Article V, which states that an attack on one nation of the alliance is an attack on them all. The wording was not entirely clear and did not definitively state that member states not attacked must respond by lending military force.
SPEAKER_00The European nations, just out of the most destructive war the world had ever seen, wanted no ambiguity. The US, however, was reluctant to pre-commit its military might. By September 1948, the wording was all set. The last hurdle deciding who would have access to membership took six months to finalize. When the treaty was signed on April 4th, 1949, it was signed by twelve nations. That number would grow by three in the nineteen fifties, by one in the nineteen eighties, and after the fall of the Soviet Union would admit another sixteen.
SPEAKER_00But signing the treaty wasn't enacting it. Words have to be translated into deeds, and that takes more finesse than it perhaps gets credit for. Any dithering and dallying was put by the wayside after the Soviets tested their first atomic bomb in nineteen forty nine and the onset of the Korean War in nineteen fifty. A unified military command structure was not something that could be indefinitely delayed, and it was something that was immediately needed. From january nineteen fifty one until April nineteen fifty one, the command structure began to take shape at the Hotel Estoria in Paris, under the command of U.S.
SPEAKER_00General Dwight D. Eisenhower, the first Sakure. From April 1951 until March 1967, a permanent headquarters was established near Versailles, France, and known as Shape, the Supreme Headquarters Allied Powers Europe. In 1967, it moved to its present location in Brussels. Initially led by Eisenhower, the leader of the D-Day invasions and future president of the United States, his deputy was Field Marshal Sir Bernard Montgomery, he of the Battle of El Alamein and the Full Monty Breakfast.
SPEAKER_00Eisenhower was well known for his skills in managing his staff. Montgomery was not. His lack of tact and inability to get along caused more than one, far more than one, behind the scenes TIFF. But Montgomery remained several years longer than Eisenhower, who was elected US president in 1952. In 1954, the Soviet Union suggested that it would like to join NATO. The members of NATO, a bit shocked by this development in an organization explicitly created to detour the expansion of the nation asking to join, turned them down.
SPEAKER_00Their belief was that the Soviet offer was less of an olive branch and more of an opportunity to foment discord between the alliance members. But the inclusion of West Germany in the NATO fold was definitely causing angry shockwaves among the Sovs. The NATO allies came to another agreement, this time that they needed a way in which they could counter the Soviet threat and yet still advance their economies. The answer was MC forty eight, the decision that NATO would use nukes at the outset of war with the Soviet Union, whether the Soviets had used them first or not.
SPEAKER_00In common parlance, it is the doctrine of massive retaliation. Incidentally, and to bring our history products full circle, it was the Soviet plans for this contingency that so horrified the Polish military officer Richard Kuklinski that he began passing Soviet military information to NATO in order to avert a nuclear war. NATO has certainly not been without its drama in the 75 years since its inception, but it has also always been more than merely a wall against the Soviets.
SPEAKER_00It was a leading vehicle for European integration, notably in the field of scientific cooperation. The threat of NATO involvement stabilized the European theater of the Cold War, and it wasn't until after the fall of the Soviet Union that NATO began being used as an active force. Tentatively during Gulf War I, and then in response to the possible destabilization of NATO countries from the influx of refugees from the war in the former Yugoslavia in the 1990s, NATO began taking more active military roles.
SPEAKER_00Although Russia was never on the path to NATO membership, and in fact never requested any such thing after 1954, relations between NATO and Russia have certainly been better. When Russian President Putin was asked in 2002 about Ukraine's possible membership in NATO, he responded, our position on the expansion of NATO is known, but Ukraine should not stand aside of the global processes to strengthen world security. And as a sovereign country, it's able to make its own choices in ensuring security.
SPEAKER_00Needless to say, that no longer seems to be his opinion. In the mid-1600s, the philosopher Baruch Spinoza wrote, Peace is more than the absence of war. This is the very heart of the creation of NATO and the early NATO policies. The mission to contain Soviet expansion was only one facet of an organization also dedicated to bringing about a European integration at the tail end of a thousand years of neighboring states and various degrees of war with each other.
SPEAKER_00And after 75 years, it is undeniable that the member states of NATO have not only recovered from the devastation of World War II, but have thrived far above and beyond those who are not a part of the alliance. It would take far more than a 15 to 20 minute podcast to even begin to untangle the nuances of history. And I hope you'll use this as a jumping off point to continue researching more deeply. Please read more, go back further, and for heaven's sake, make sure you can find these places on a map.
SPEAKER_00Zravo, Salani Bueno Oke, ciao, au revoir, videmo se put
Nobody is credited on this episode yet.
Tyranny With Habsurgian Glee
The Tyranny of a Benevolent Tyrant
Imperial and Royal Information
The French Spy Who Kickstarted the American Revolution