Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Real Third World

The Real Third World artwork

The Real Third World Season 2 Episode 5

Dec 6, 202417 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

The Organization to End All Wars

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00The Real Third World, Season Two, Episode Five, The Organization to End All Wars. Hey, Doberdan, Mullibuanji. Alo, I'm Ruthie, and from Sarevo to Red Africa, welcome to our podcast about the people and history of the real Third World. Forget the telethons, the phrase the third world came about as an act of defiance, when several smaller and mainly post-colonial nations decided they didn't want to choose between the Western First World or the Eastern Second World, but to choose their own third way.

SPEAKER_00Alone, they couldn't rival the superpowers, but together they could be a force to be reckoned with. And even more, the events of the world today directly descend from the third world's past. In our last season, we laid some foundation of various third world countries, and this season we'll be drawing even more lines to show how we got to the world we are living in today. These stories have been overlooked long enough, and we're going to tell them to you here.

SPEAKER_00It was called the War to End All Wars. And even though today we know perfectly well that it wasn't, at the time it was the only phrase that seemed to come close to accurately depicting the immense tragedy of the First World War. Even before the assassination of an archduke or a war whose scars would remain on the earth more than a hundred years later, there were men and groups which began advocating for a world organization that could act to stop such international conflagrations from happening.

SPEAKER_00The Interparliamentary Union, for example, was formed in 1889, although it wasn't tremendously effective. The Geneva Conventions are actually a series of treaties which go back to 1864 to deal with the treatment of sick and wounded soldiers. The Hague Conventions date to 1899, when Europe decided to follow suit with the American Lieber Code that governed the conduct of the Union Army. The first Hague Convention was actually proposed by the Russian Tsar Nicholas II and opened on his birthday.

SPEAKER_00The second, in 1907, was initiated by American president Theodore Roosevelt. The Hague Conventions, to put it in a very overly simplified manner, were meant to deal with the issues of war crimes and crimes against humanity. Notably, the use of poison gases was explicitly forbidden. It is worth noting here that both Germany and the UK signed and ratified this declaration, something which seems to have been ignored in the trenches of World War I.

SPEAKER_00In any case, a growing chorus of voices were in favor of an overarching global organization dedicated to the cause of world peace. These voices found a historically significant figure to plead for the cause in the American president Woodrow Wilson. On January 8th, 1918, eleven months before the battlefield guns fell silent, Wilson gave a speech before the U.S. Congress outlining his plan for peace, the fourteen points.

SPEAKER_00Incidentally, the response from the French Prime Minister Georges Clemenceau to Wilson's optimistic plan was fourteen points, the good lord only gave us ten, and do we abide by those? But Wilson's speech and his claim of the need for a just and secure peace touched a nerve in many. fourteen answered the growing call for an organization above the heads of state to control the baser instincts of martial nations.

SPEAKER_00It read A general association of nations must be formed under specific covenants for the purpose of affording mutual guarantees of political independence and territorial integrity to great and small states alike. Amongst the support of Wilson's ideas for a new world order, some came from a surprising source, Jan Smutz of South Africa. In November of nineteen eighteen, Smuts wrote a pamphlet titled League of Nations A Practical Suggestion.

SPEAKER_00The pamphlet, which ran 60 pages, outlined a proposed structure for the organization, including a permanent council which would be composed of the great powers and a rotating schedule of lesser powers. Wilson loved Smutz' ideas. He later said Between the writing of the Magnolia Draft and the time of the formation of the Commission on the League of Nations, I had the advantage of seeing a paper done by General Smutz of South Africa, who seemed to me to have done some very clear thinking.

SPEAKER_00There was still much negotiating to do, but the ideas of Wilson and Smutz featured heavily in the formation of the new organization, which was signed into being as a part of the Treaty of Versailles on june twenty eighth, nineteen nineteen. An important item of note here. Women's organizations held a simultaneous conference to try and influence the men negotiating the Versailles Treaty to include the vote for women and equal protection to men under the law as pillars of the new League of Nations.

SPEAKER_00These requests were ignored. Women were, however, given the approval to serve in any of the League's positions. The structure of the League of Nations is familiar to anyone who looks at the UN, a General Assembly, an Executive Council, and a Secretariat of Specialists and Bureaucrats to keep the system running smoothly and explore policy ideas. Auxiliary organizations, such as the Permanent Court of International Justice, were groundbreaking. In the case of the PCIJ, proceedings were, for the most part, open in public record.

SPEAKER_00This was truly revolutionary in the field of law. The first meeting of the League of Nations occurred in Paris on january sixteenth, nineteen twenty. By November 1920 it had moved to Geneva, Switzerland as a nod to Switzerland's role as a neutral nation, and because it was the home of the International Red Cross. Forty-two founding members signed on with the League of Nations, including the United Kingdom, Belgium, Japan, China, France, and the kingdoms of Serbs, Croats, and Slovenes, later Yugoslavia.

SPEAKER_00In the wake of the disintegration of Tsarist Russia, Armenia, Azerbaijan, Georgia, and Ukraine also applied for membership, but were refused because they quote unquote did not appear to have a stable government whose authority extends over the whole of its territory. By 1922, all of these nations were swallowed up by the emerging Soviet Union. Still, during the 1920s, the League of Nations was a meeting place for nations to discuss differences seriously.

SPEAKER_00It handled the Eland Crisis of 1920-21, and its decision has proven remarkably effective through today. It determined a border between Albania, the soon to be Yugoslavia, and Greece, although not without a significant issue arising between Greece and the bombastic Benito Mussolini in Italy over the death of an Italian general in 1923. Despite League restrictions on waging war without their permission, Mussolini responded to the death of his general by invading the island of Corfu and demanding reparations.

SPEAKER_00In a stark harbinger of what the 1930s would look like, Mussolini received his payoff. Even within an organization dedicated to ending war, might often makes right. And in all honesty, the League of Nations was ineffective in handling the issue of the city of Vilnius, which ended World War I in the hands of the Lithuanians and was then seized by Poland. Orders from the League for Poland to vacate Vilnius were met with agreement, and then never implemented.

SPEAKER_00Poland assured the League of Nations it would leave, and then it didn't. But it was the nineteen thirties which proved to be the downfall of the reputation of the League of Nations as an ineffectual body unable to influence nations or events. The Japanese invasion of Manchuria in 1931 kicked off the League's death spiral, showing that it had absolutely no ability to act other than shaking a finger, if that, when one nation decided to invade another.

SPEAKER_00The League did condemn the invasion and commissioned a report which found Japan to be the aggressor, although with a few nuances of somewhat mitigating factors. Japan refused to accept the rebuke of the League of Nations and withdrew in 1933. But other aggressive leaders had noticed. Japan withdrew from the League in March of 1933, and in October of 1933, the new government of Adolf Hitler also tendered their withdrawal.

SPEAKER_00Germany, or at least the Nazi government, had become increasingly bitter over restrictions on their military expansion and growth. Outside the League, they had no real restrictions, and arms and propaganda factories were soon humming. Italy's Mussolini took the opposite tactic. Rather than withdrawing and then rearming and invading other nations, Italy went on its merry way doing whatever it pleased while still retaining League membership.

SPEAKER_00Its invasion of Ethiopia in 1935 violated nearly every treaty and agreement previously signed, including the use of asphyxiating gas dropped from airplanes on civilians. When Ethiopian Emperor Haley Selassie appeared to speak before the League of Nations in 1936, Italian journalists booed, whistled, and catcalled him until they were finally escorted out forcibly, in the words of one journalist. Help was not forthcoming.

SPEAKER_00Although some rather empty sanctions were put into place which could be easily evaded. Three days after Emperor Selassie spoke, the suicide of Stefan Lux took place on the assembly floor in July. Lux, a Czechoslovak journalist, shot himself while shouting This is the final coup to protest German treatment of Jews. At the time, the suicide was dismissed as the act of someone who was mentally ill, or in the words of Germany, an idiot.

SPEAKER_00Lux was neither, though. He left behind letters showing a pregent understanding of what was hurtling toward the world at an ever faster clip. It is not the League of Nations but humanity that needs reforming, Lux quoted in a letter to Britain's Anthony Eden, who purportedly never received anything. The only effect of Lux's act was increased security on the floor of the League of Nations. The Spanish Civil War provided yet another moment of missing the mark for the Erstwhile League.

SPEAKER_00Meeting a few months after the fighting started, a non intervention committee was put together, and most European nations signed a non intervention pact, which was just as quickly ignored by Germany, Italy, and the Soviet Union, who already had stakes in the proxy war. The League limped along for a few more years as more and more nations were subsumed by aggressive neighbors. Nothing was done on Anschluss with Austria in nineteen thirty eight, or when Hitler's armies took Czechoslovakia in nineteen thirty nine.

SPEAKER_00The last big act of the League of Nations was to expel the Soviet Union upon their invasion of Finland in 1939. The USSR did not even bother to respond. The twentieth session of the General Assembly of the League of Nations was held in nineteen thirty nine. For more than six years the Palay Wilson, its home in Geneva, sat empty as nations of the world fought a war even more terrible than the war that had midwifed the League of Nations into being.

SPEAKER_00When the League met again for the twenty first session in nineteen forty six, it was merely a meeting to dissolve. We know that world war began in Manchuria fifteen years ago, said Philip Noel Baker at the final session. Manchuria, Abyssinia, Munich have killed another great illusion. The belief that appeasement, seeking the national interest at the expense of others, individual action, secret bargains could bring us peace.

SPEAKER_00The League is dead. Long live the United Nations, was the epitaph given by Robert Cecil. The failure of the League of Nations in keeping world peace was not, however, merely a failure of the League of Nations, as alluded to by Mr. Noel Baker. The League itself had no way to enforce any of its decisions and had to rely on the voluntary compliance of its members. Members which really had no reason to punish themselves. Diplomacy is a lovely idea, but without a threat of some sort backing up earnest words, there's no need for anyone to actually listen.

SPEAKER_00But the 1930s was also a time of world economic collapse. The situation on the ground surrounding the League of Nations changed, and humanity itself was looking for a way to regain former glory and success. But aside from security issues, there were actually areas where the League of Nations was a resounding success in ushering certain progressive beliefs we now take for granted onto the world stage. Enormous strides were made in effecting change for workers, including the fight against child labor.

SPEAKER_00Slavery was also defined and attacked with some very big victories. And as an overarching ideal, the idea of human lives, all lives having value, began to take its place as the default more and more often. These issues too were not without downsides. The League of Nations system of mandates certainly kept non-Western states down, and under the thumb of an alternatively classified colonial control. Jan Smuts, whose fingerprints were all over the League of Nations Covenant, and who, incidentally, was the only man to sign both the Treaty of Versailles establishing the League of Nations and the United Nations Charter, certainly hoped that these international organizations would be able to keep the balance of white power in Africa when he participated in their formation.

SPEAKER_00And the League's treatment of Ethiopia certainly highlighted beliefs about non-European nations and people. But still, the commonly held view of the League of Nations as an absolute failure is not borne out when looking at its actions and effects as a whole. And, quite frankly, the successor organization of the United Nations has been unable to deter those who are determined to invade and conquer as well. Perhaps Stefan Lux was far more overarchingly correct than he is given credit for in his quotation from Nikolai Titulesh.

SPEAKER_00It's not the League of Nations, but humanity that needs reforming. But, as always with our podcasts, we have barely scratched the surface of the history of World War I, occupations, the League of Nations, neutrality, and anyone involved in these historic events. It would take far more than a 15 to 20 minute podcast to even begin to untangle the nuances of history. And I hope you'll use this as a jumping off point to continue researching more deeply.

SPEAKER_00Please read more, go back further, and for heaven's sake, make sure you can find these places on a map.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Real Third World Season 4 Episode 3

    Nov 6, 202617 minAudio

    Tyranny With Habsurgian Glee

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Real Third World Season 4 Episode 2

    Oct 16, 202621 minAudio

    What Exactly Is a Tyrant?

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Real Third World Season 4 Episode 1

    Sep 18, 202619 minAudio

    The Tyranny of a Benevolent Tyrant

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Real Third World Season 3 Episode 11

    Jun 5, 202616 minAudio

    Imperial and Royal Information

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Real Third World Season 3 Episode 10

    May 15, 202615 minAudio

    The French Spy Who Kickstarted the American Revolution

    Credit the people on this episode