All of the blessings of modernity, Ryan Avent argues in a fascinating new book, rest on faith. It is our faith in others, our ability to trust strangers we will never meet, that makes possible the large-scale cooperation that has given us science, modern economic growth, and liberal democracy. But if everything depends on our ability to weave and maintain particular webs of complex meaning, what happens when we allow those webs to weaken and fray? In his book In Good Faith, Ryan contends that the dysfunctions and discontents plaguing 21st century democracies reflect such underlying neglect. We have been seduced by what he calls the "Modern Faith" - the belief that good system design and proper incentives are all that is needed to keep society running smoothly. In this episode of The Permanent Problem podcast, Ryan and I discuss the Modern Faith's critical blind spots, explore the interplay of culture and institutions in shaping social change, and ponder whether anything can replace the cultural grounding provided by organized religion. Below is a video recording of our conversation, followed by a lightly edited transcript. Brink Lindsey: Hello everybody, and welcome to The Permanent Problem Podcast. I’m delighted to have as my guest today Ryan Avent, author of the new book In Good Faith: How the Nature of Belief Shapes the Fate of Societies, just out from Yale University Press. Ryan, welcome to The Permanent Problem. Ryan Avent: Brink, thank you so much for having me. Lindsey: It’s great seeing you again. I was just reflecting today on when we first met each other and I had that combination of sensations. The sensation that time accelerates the older you get, the faster time passes. Also, the sensation that I’m old - put those two together. And we’ve known each other for a long time, but it feels like I met you the day before yesterday. It’s been well over 20 years at this point, I think. Avent: Yeah. Lindsey: Right around 20 years, right around. Avent: Right around 20 years is right, yes. Lindsey: Yeah. So I met you when you were still just a blogger. I don’t think you were even freelancing with The Economist yet, back in the good old days of blogging. But then you were a freelancer at The Economist, then a staff writer for The Economist for many years. And then a few years ago, you decamped for the private sector. But with this book already in mind or already started - at any rate, to finish a book like this while being somebody with a real job in the private sector, that’s a true labor of love. So tell me, how did the book come about and why did you write it? I have a feeling that it started as one thing and it grew, given the times you were writing in. Avent: Very much so. Yeah, that’s true. I had started it before I left The Economist, and initially it was really focused on some thinking I’d been doing and writing I’d been doing about blind spots in economic thinking about how institutions work, how people choose to behave, what their motivations are, things like that. And so I had started digging into this and doing reading around it. Lindsey: You had written a book that came out, I think in 2016, called The Wealth of Humans about our new labor abundance and how that was shaking up the world with the global labor market and what that entailed. And there was a chapter in there, as I recall, that was homing in on this idea of business culture as a big determinant of competitive success. So it was your thinking there about this blind spot in economics, where everything is about design and incentives and not so much about culture. And you wanted to fill in the blanks. But then you had the idea as you were going on that this blank you were filling in had a lot more explanatory power than just this narrow wonkish task - you were explaining why the world was going crazy. Avent: Absolutely, yeah. So in the 2016 book, there was this chapter on, as you say, how businesses work. And really what I pulled out of economics research, business research, and other things was just how important culture is to guiding these businesses. And people have this code more or less for what it means to be a part of an organization, and they’re intrinsically motivated to abide by that, and that helps generate these good collective outcomes. And I thought on this and realized this applies in many more cases other than just the business world. And if you take seriously the idea of what people’s beliefs are and how they see themselves as identifying with different institutions or different groups, and you think that’s really driving a lot of behavior, then there’s a good reason to think that that is an important part of what holds us all together in aggregate and shapes what we’re capable of as a society. So that’s the direction the book began heading in. Lindsey: And when you start heading in that direction, you are going against some headwinds, right? The contemporary smart set is allergic to cultural explanations of anything. It’s too mushy to quantify and really get a good analytical, rigorous handle on. And also it’s not actionable - you don’t get a five-point policy reform to fix the problem, because that’s not how culture works. So it’s some combination of this being loose, unrigorous thinking, and also, “I don’t care where you dropped the keys, that’s gloomy over there. Right under here, under the streetlight, we can see what’s going on.” Avent: That’s right, that’s right. Yeah, and for most of my time working in and writing about economics, I shared that view. I was like, it’s unserious people who really think about this fuzzy stuff. And if we really want to fix a social problem, we need to think about it in terms of incentives and adjust the dials just so, and then if we do enough of that, we’ll get to a good place. But that just ended up feeling inadequate. And I think it felt a little inadequate to me before 2020 and everything that’s followed from there. But after that, and going through the wrenching experience of those years - and I guess really beginning around 2016 and then through the next decade - it felt to me like this isn’t a small thing, this isn’t a small detail. This aspect of what holds societies together that we’re ignoring, actually it’s really, really important and maybe becoming ever more important as we move into this post-materialist society, where we don’t have to spend most of our day focusing on how we’re going to put bread on our table. It really ends up mattering a lot more how we feel about ourselves and what we think matters and what we’re trying to achieve in our lives. Lindsey: And there has been serious, rigorous academic interest in culture and cultural evolution over the past couple of decades that has somewhat weakened the taboo on exploring this terrain, but still. And when you step back and don’t take for granted the conventional wisdom, I mean, human beings are cultural animals - that is our distinctive thing, right? We have a whole repertoire of behaviors that we didn’t come here with instinctually. We learned them from others and then we pass them down to the next generation and they survive us, they predate us and they survive us. And we’re finding little bits of culture in the animal world, but nobody does it like us. The wealth of cultural inventiveness and the sheer crazy variety of things we can believe and organize our lives around and take completely seriously, that’s as close to the core of human identity as anything. So it makes sense it’s an important explanatory variable. Avent: I mean, I certainly agree. And I think the anthropologists and behavioral scientists who studied this take this idea very seriously, but in economics, and probably just in the lay community as well, I don’t think we have ever really fully appreciated the extent to which our evolution as a species was driven by this, right? That our ability to begin to use culture as a way to coordinate our activities and store knowledge that persists over time, that was r… This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit brinklindsey.substack.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Welcome to the Permanent Problem Podcast. I'm your host, Brink Lindsey, a Senior Vice President at the Niskanen Center. Each episode, we take a deep dive into the messy and uncertain transition from mass affluence to mass flourish, exploring what I call capitalism's triple crisis and the potential for rising above it. Hello, everybody, and welcome to The Permanent Problem podcast. I'm delighted to have as my guest today Ryan Avent, author of the new book,
SPEAKER_00In Good Faith, How the Nature of Belief Shapes the Fate of Societies, just out from Yale University Press. Ryan, welcome to The Permanent Problem. Brink, thank you so much for having me. It's great seeing you again. I was just reflecting today on when we first met each other and I had that sort of combination of sensations. The sensation of that time accelerates the older you get. I met you when you were still just a blogger.
SPEAKER_00I don't think you were even freelancing with The Economist yet. Back in the good old days of blogging. And then you were a freelancer for The Economist, then a staff writer for The Economist for many years. And then a few years ago, you decamped for the private sector.
But with this book already in mind or already started, but at any rate, to finish a book like
SPEAKER_00Tell me how the book came about and why did you write it? I have a feeling that it started as one thing and it grew given the times you were writing it.
SPEAKER_01Very much so. Yeah, that's true. I had started it before I left The Economist. And initially, it was really focused on some thinking I've been doing and writing I've been doing about blind spots. You had written a book
SPEAKER_00The Permanent Problem Business Culture is a big determinant of competitive success. So it was your thinking there about this kind of blind spot in economics where everything is about design and incentives and not so much about culture.
SPEAKER_00And you wanted to kind of fill in the blanks. But then you had the idea as you were going on that this blank that you were filling in had a lot more explanatory power than just this kind of narrow wonkish task. You were explaining why the world was going crazy. Absolutely.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So, I mean, in the 2016 book, there was this chapter on, as you say, how businesses work. And, you know, really what I pulled out of, I mean, you know, economics research, business research and other things was, you know, just how important culture is to guiding these businesses. And I thought on this and sort of So that's the direction the book began heading and
And when you start heading in that direction, you are going against some headwinds, right? The contemporary smart set is kind of allergic to cultural explanations of anything. It's too mushy to quantify and really get a good analytical, rigorous handle on.
SPEAKER_00And also, it's not actionable. You don't get this five-point policy reform to fix the problem because that's not how culture works. So it's some combination of this is loose, unrigorous thinking and also I don't care where you drop the keys, that's gloom over there, right under here under the streetlight we can see what's going on That's right, that's right
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and you know, for most of my time working in and writing about economics, I shared that view, right? I was like, you know, it's unserious people who really think about this fuzzy stuff, you know, and if we really want to fix a social problem, we need to think about it. I think about it in terms of incentives and, you know, adjust the dials just so and then we can, you know, if we do enough of that, we'll get to a good place. But that just ended up feeling inadequate. And I think it felt a little inadequate to me before 2020 and sort of everything that's followed from there.
SPEAKER_01But after that and sort of going through the wrenching experience of, you know, those years and I guess really beginning around 2016 and then sort of through the next decade. It felt to me like this isn't a small thing. This isn't a small detail. This aspect of what holds societies together that we're ignoring. Actually, it's really, really important and maybe becoming ever more important as we move into this post-materialist society where we don't have to spend most of our day focusing on how we're going to put bread on our table.
It really ends up mattering a lot more how we feel about ourselves and what we
SPEAKER_01think matters and what we're trying to achieve in our lives.
SPEAKER_00I mean, there has been serious, rigorous academic interest in culture and cultural evolution over the past couple of decades that has somewhat weakened the taboo on exploring this terrain. But still, when you step back and don't take for granted the conventional wisdom, Human beings are cultural animals. That is our distinctive thing, right? We have a whole repertoire of behaviors that we didn't come
here instinctually with. We learn them from others, and then we pass them down to the next generation, and they survive. We're finding little bits of culture In the animal world But nobody does it like us The wealth of Cultural inventiveness And the sheer crazy variety Of crazy things we can believe And organize our lives around And take completely seriously That's as close to the core Of human identity as anything So it kind of
makes sense It's an
SPEAKER_00important explanatory variable
SPEAKER_01I mean, I certainly agree. And, you know, I think we, you know, sort of the anthropologists and behavioral scientists who sort of studied this, I think, take this idea very seriously, but, you know, in economics, and then probably I don't think we have ever fully appreciated the extent to which our evolution as a species was driven by this. Our ability to begin to use culture as a way to coordinate our activities and
Store Knowledge That Persists Over Time You Know That Was Really Fundamental In Driving Human Evolution Forward And Then You Know Once We Became Homo Sapiens That Was Sort Of The Key Way That We Adapted To New Scenarios You Know We Didn't Do It
SPEAKER_01With Our Genes For The We did it through the evolution of culture. It's been critical all along for our whole existence as a species. I feel like we got to this point where we felt like we outgrew that. We're now modern man and woman. We're rational. In this world, we don't need to rely on that anymore. I think that's fundamentally wrong.
SPEAKER_00I'll get to the modern faith in a little bit and what has gone wrong. But let's start with what's gone right. So we take it for granted. This is the world we were born into. Why isn't it better? But step back and think about where we are and where we are in relation to just about every other. The Permanent Problem The Permanent Problem
And we live in these enormous collectives relatively peacefully together.
SPEAKER_00That's kind of astonishing. And we have figured out ways to organize our activities in incredibly intricate divisions of labor and responsibility. We have harnessed Magical Seeming Technologies. And this is all, you know, this is all the handiwork of culture. So you have a kind of history of how we got here in the book. So you want to go through that a little bit? Yeah, absolutely.
SPEAKER_01Once we were sort of became cultural creatures, like we did end up storing more and more information about how to behave, you know, why to behave in that particular way in our culture. And that's sort of a thing that allowed us to learn new tricks to survive in different niches. But, you know, All the, if we think about all the different aspects of culture now, all the different ways that we conceive of behavior with all the different subtleties, all those things had to be sort of discovered or invented or stumbled upon.
SPEAKER_01And the process of stumbling on those things... And the sort of stories that we found that allowed those things to make sense to us opened up new capabilities for humankind. And so in the book, I sort of, you know, I try to pick out a few. And, you know, one, I think, is as we learn to find new ways to live in larger societies, and a huge part of how we did this was kind of stumbling on religion, We could operate in tribal groups of hundreds rather than bands
of a few dozen.
SPEAKER_01And that may not sound like a huge difference, but actually, when you're thinking about trying to accumulate a body of technologies that will allow you to do more Or When You Think About As we learned to do that and became accustomed to larger societies,
that was a contributor to accelerating technological development and accelerating
SPEAKER_01sort of growth in our overall capabilities. And this has sort of happened repeatedly. So, I think that's really important for us. There were bodies of meaning that were evolving all along the way that helped us adapt ourselves.
SPEAKER_00Somewhere right around there, we figured out writing, too. So we figured out a way to store our culture externally, not just in the noggins of other humans, but somewhere that can survive us. That opened up a huge can of worms.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I mean, all of this did, right? I've been struck when reading historical takes and analyses on this, how much people want to attribute the emergence of something like writing or of a particular kind of state to this purposeful behavior by clever people. Like, oh, you know, writing emerged because it was a way that kings could exercise greater control over their populations. And I think, you know, obviously writing allowed people to have that greater capability,
SPEAKER_01but these things were evolutionary. You know, you had to... It had to become more widely accepted that submitting in certain ways to a king was a good thing or a reasonable thing to do, maybe not a good thing, but something that was appropriate for a person to do. Or that someone reading into these crazy symbols and saying that they meant this or that was a legitimate thing. I think in a lot of ways the governor on what a society can be is what do people feel is appropriate. Certainly that's something that's continued up to this modern day.
SPEAKER_01It's something when I think about the political situation we're in now it's you have these ideas about what's appropriate that constrain behavior and then then they go away but we're getting to that and then sort of if thinking about how we then sort of get to modernity I think there there had to be some pretty significant changes to the body of shared meaning changes in the way we feel about behavior to allow that and and the book talks about that a little bit it's a few things I think part of it is about getting past kinship networks and sort of Interacting with others as if they're all more or less okay to
interact with.
SPEAKER_00And in making that step, you ascribe an important role to Christianity.
SPEAKER_01I do, yeah. And I don't know how people receive this because it's if you sort of say that Christendom could become the first industrializing part of the world because of Christianity, I think that can be a difficult thing for a lot of The Point I Try To Make Is That The Spread Of Christianity Throughout Western Christendom And The Way That It Evolved In Interaction With Other Different Forces Really Led To The Displacement Of This Old Moral Structure
Which Really Was Kin Group Based And Where You Treated People Outside Your Kin Groups Quite Differently
SPEAKER_01And Held Them To Different Moral Rules Than You Held Internally That ended up being replaced by this more universal moral code. It didn't happen overnight by any stretch of the imagination. But as that happened, we became more flexible. We became better able to be a part of many different groups, overlapping groups, and that unlocked a lot of potential for complexity.
SPEAKER_00You have a nice metaphor, at least nice for a baby boomer geezer like me, of saying that we went from a society where you built cultural institutions out of Lincoln Logs to a Lego society where you've got these kind of modular pieces that can be, you know, you can build stuff with Lincoln Logs, but you're kind of constrained by what you can build. Whereas with Lego, you can build anything. So once you get to this Universal morality that highlights the free and sovereign
individual, that's your Lego block.
SPEAKER_00Once you've got that belief structure in people's minds, the ways you can combine individuals and new configurations becomes virtually
SPEAKER_01limitless. I think this ends up being incredibly powerful because all these little subdivisions within society, the different groups of which people can be a part, have their own little cultures holding them together with But the particular sets of meaning and those things can evolve over time as well. And so if you look at something like the development of science and the set of values that goes around with that, you know, this emerged from this sort of subgroup of societies. The Permanent Problem
SPEAKER_01These important sub-beliefs like science is good. It's good to turn a profit. It's good to try to work hard and develop your own capacities as an individual. All these different things that really contribute it to modern economic growth.
SPEAKER_00So faith is in the title of the book. Faith figures prominently in the book. Explain how faith fits into this cultural explanation of what's happened to us and where we are.
SPEAKER_01Sure. Well, I think it's central. I think we often think of ourselves as being distinct mostly because of our capacity to reason and to work through problems and innovate and come up with solutions to them. And I think that's actually, I mean, it's very important that we can do that, but I don't think that's the thing that really sets us apart. First of all, apes can do that, not nearly as well as we can, but they're pretty clever and they're good problem solvers. But what really unlocked the capacity to use culture to
cooperate was faith, right?
SPEAKER_01That we were able to develop this capacity to trust others, even though they weren't blood relations or close blood relations. that we found ourselves able to believe things and sort of live in a way consistent with those beliefs, even though we didn't really understand why. And there's a lot of interesting anthropological work that sort of makes this point, right? That over time... Indigenous groups would develop these incredibly complex procedures for processing
SPEAKER_01food or building housing or fighting wars. And there were tricks embedded in these things that no individual could have come up with. It's not like someone invented out of nowhere that there was no research labs or anything like that. And so... These things can only work and help us survive and adapt if we continue to do things that on their surface don't make sense. If we add lime or ash to our maze to help us access the niacin in the maze, who's going to just randomly throw ash in there?
And so it was really faith that allowed us to survive all these hundreds of thousands of years. And I think that if we are honest with ourselves and reflect on how we live today,
SPEAKER_01that's still just an absolutely critical part of modern society. You know, we walk out our door believing we're going to be okay, believing that everyone is going to abide by laws and conduct themselves in a way that's going to allow our lives to work as we expect them to. And, you know, even, you know, modern science rests on unprovable assumptions, right?
SPEAKER_00That we can trust our senses. You know, we're not just brains in a vat being tricked by some demon, right? That something's real going on that we're experiencing. The orderliness of the universe, right? That there are natural regularly recurring patterns and we can figure and they are finally comprehensible to us. So none of that is a given. It's all, you know, but it's a precondition for getting anywhere. If we're going to say, no, we don't need faith anymore because we've got science, well, we don't have science without faith.
SPEAKER_00That's right, yeah.
SPEAKER_01And I think, you know, there's the other aspect of faith that the book sort of works through and focuses on as it thinks about the present and where we're going is the extent to which faith is necessary really to get through life. You know, that life is difficult. There's a lot of reason to think that things will go wrong in disastrous ways. And it's, you know, particularly in our sort of In our modern society where skepticism of things like faith is
sort of the marker
SPEAKER_01of being a serious mind, we sort of fail to appreciate how you have to believe that a tomorrow is possible, whether or not there's any evidence for that, in order for there to be a tomorrow.
SPEAKER_00And this is a good time to throw in the fact that your book, while it has this huge theme of the grand sweep of history, also has autobiographical elements interspersed throughout it. So we'll get to the kind of crisis of faith that our liberal democratic societies are undergoing right now, but you had a kind of a personal crisis of faith. At least partially triggered by this larger societal crisis. You kind of interweave those stories.
SPEAKER_00You get personal as far as that. Culture starts with belief. Belief starts with what's going on inside one person's head. That's a nice jumping off point, but you got the gratitude for There are wonderful things that I get to be privy to because I'm alive and I'm grateful for that and I don't want to let those people down and so I need to get my shit together so that I can live up to them and so it was what you're grateful for and then your obligations to those people you're grateful for
kind of pull you out
SPEAKER_00of your you know your funk right so tell tell the story a little bit.
SPEAKER_01Well, I mean, you've done a great job sort of summarizing. I mean, I think the sort of short version is that I, as many people do, and when you get to sort of midlife, you start to question a lot of things. You know, I'd always been sort of prone to depression. And so I was struggling with that as per normal, but as the world developed around me in ways that seemed very ominous, that kind of added to the burden that I felt like I was bearing. And as we got into the pandemic,
SPEAKER_01and the aftermath and the aftermath of January 6th, I really became quite deeply depressed and just sort of didn't really know what to do with myself.
SPEAKER_00And it's fair to point out, like a lot of people had, you know, have had tough times over the past decade. And certainly a lot of people had tough times during COVID. But most people have the luxury of tuning politics out, right? So... People with weird jobs like working at think tanks or working for a political magazine, you don't have that luxury. So we had to, you know, like poor Malcolm McDowell with his eyeballs propped open while they're beaming the
SPEAKER_00horrors at him, right? We couldn't look away. We couldn't look away. No. And we had to try to think about where it was going, you know, would lay ahead. And that could often be a bleak thing to contemplate.
SPEAKER_01But I, you know, I eventually got fed up with myself. And I sort of, you know, landed on this personal realization that if I take this incredibly, you know, gloomy outlook as my baseline, like, I'm always going to be miserable. I'm not going to be a good person for the people who love me. I'm not going to be able to work effectively to try to help the situation in whatever ways I can. And I realized that I need to believe that tomorrow can be better,
SPEAKER_01even if I don't really have a lot of things I can point to that make Give me strong confidence that this is true. And I think the reason that ends up making its way into the book is because that shaped my understanding of how we work together as a society, of kind of what ends up being the mode of power that keeps the society going. And it really fed into my kind of understanding of what seems to be going wrong and what we might need to do to fix the problem.
SPEAKER_00I mean, this, you know, it's, You're personally miserable. I'm not happy. I'm not maximizing my utility for beans right now. So that project is not going well. So you turn around and you think about a different project, the people who matter to me and doing right by them. So being a good person and doing good for the people who matter for me. Okay, then I need to shake out of this torpor and I need to have faith that tomorrow could possibly be a better day so I can do good by the people
that matter.
SPEAKER_00So shifting from homo economicus and I'm here to maximize utility to a different, you know, mix of meanings, life as an opportunity and an obligation to do good. You're explicit in making that, planting that flag in the ground in a way that a lot of contemporary liberals are very shy to do, right? That we don't want to tell anybody how to live or what's good. It's all up to them. We're just going to set the conditions for them to figure it out on their own. But you've broken from that.
SPEAKER_01Yes, and part of the evolution that happened with me was looking around and wanting others to behave better, to behave more responsibly, more conscientiously, wanting them to do that because that would make the world better or prevent bad things from happening, but also because I felt like it would make it easier for me to be better, right? That we all... It's important that we all hold each other accountable. And so I think looking around at how things have sort of
happened over the past few
SPEAKER_01years, it's been incredibly frustrating the number of people who haven't Hewn to what I sort of would think are the right sort of paths of behavior. You know, they haven't done what they were supposed to do. They haven't stuck by the principles that I thought we all took seriously and so on. And so I think it's very difficult for me to look around and see that shift in behavior and not think that that's closely linked to what's going wrong. Feels like we've given ourselves permission to behave
incredibly self-interestedly,
SPEAKER_01to not heed the obligation to do right by others. Because that's so important to keeping society functioning well, That ends up being a key cause of sort of... Even talking about the obligation to do good and the reason we're on earth is to do
SPEAKER_00good and help make us better into better people, that just all kind of sounds cringe, you know, by 21st century standards, right? So we're coming up against the modern faith. Different kinds of faith have brought us to... This kind of exalted position And the story you tell of progress is not a wig kind of triumphalist story at all It's an evolutionary story where people are doing things by accident I think I was looking at email
correspondence to you Right after I read the manuscript I said it's like just a series of slipping on banana peels Until suddenly you find yourself almost at the summit of Mount Olympus That's right
SPEAKER_00So, but now we're sliding back down. And why is that? What is the modern faith that we have substituted for the faiths that got us to this place?
SPEAKER_01You know, I think that if we... The way I tell the story about how we got to modernity, to modern economic growth, it is one where our beliefs and values shifted and those beliefs and values changed our behavior in ways that allowed us to unlearn. The Permanent Problem
SPEAKER_01The late 18th, early 19th century, they took this for granted. They didn't think that we were all these isolated particles. Smith understood very well that what allows these economic forces to work as they do is the set of ethical, moral obligations we give ourselves and take seriously.
SPEAKER_00Right. He didn't start writing The Wealth of Nations until he had already pumped out the theory of moral sentiments.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely. And in some ways, the theory of moral sentiments is the more encompassing work, the general theory, right, where the wealth of nations would be the special theory. But anyway, so... But as industrialization proceeded and as history proceeded, I think we became very sort of rationalists about how societies function. We sort of came to think of ourselves more as rational engineers rather than kind of moral actors. And also, I think there were many appealing things about that way of
thinking about society
SPEAKER_01that sort of allowed them to spread. And I think if you took Yeah. But then also the sort of moral guidance it ends up providing ends up being a very convenient one where markets are going to turn our behavior
into an ideal outcome
SPEAKER_01if we behave in a self-interested way. So really the right thing to do is to behave in a self-interested way. This was tempered by prevailing moral and ethical views, but over time I think that story became more dominant and the things that it sort of tempered that story eroded. And so we got to a point where it really feels like everyone has permission to get theirs. So anyway, the modern faith, I guess, to answer your question is this belief that once we land on the
correct sort of
SPEAKER_01systems of social organization, like a market economy, that's the thing. That's the thing that we've gotten to the point we need to get to, and it doesn't matter what individuals do or whether or not they're moral. We've engineered the system correctly, and so it should work, but that's mistaken.
SPEAKER_00Let me back you up here and then I'll give you a little bit of pushback. But so the modern faith is that everything comes down to system design and incentives. That if we set up the system correctly, then the little human being balls will bounce through the The Permanent Problem
SPEAKER_00An engineer walks up on a beach after a shipwreck, and they're scrounging around to see if anything turns up that they can use, and they find some canned goods, but no can opener, and the engineer is trying to figure out some way to rig some sort of thing to whack open the cans, and the economist says, no, no, no, let's just assume a can opener. Economists living in this moral economy of people with their heads full of all kinds of beliefs observed how those citizens of a moral economy
responded to incentives and saw that incentives can be really powerful in shifting behavior but incentives of humans that are enmeshed in a moral economy and gradually that
SPEAKER_00context just You know, leeches away until you end up with this assumption of homo economicus, this, you know, rational utility maximizer that isn't really like anybody you and I have ever met. And it occurs to me one, an interesting kind of example. One example of how this eats away at our moral fiber over time is Milton Friedman, who comes up in your book, but Milton Friedman's line on corporate social responsibility. So he famously said that the only responsibility
That Corporations Have Is To Make Profits Within The Rules While Staying Within The Rules Right So Maximize Profits While Playing Within The Rules You Have Satisfied
SPEAKER_00Your Corporate Social Responsibility Okay That While Playing By The Rules Assuming A Lot Right But It Starts Dropping Away Okay Play Bit Within The Rules But The Rules Aren't Fixed For All Time We Can Change The Rules So We Can Lobby And Make The Rules You Know Favor Us And There's A Whole Lot Of That Going On Steve Tell Us and I wrote a whole book about it called The Captured Economy. And then beyond that, well, the rules just say that if we violate the law, we get fined. So we'll pay the fines.
SPEAKER_00That's the cost of doing business. But we don't care if it's right or wrong. It's just because right is maximizing profits. So you start with You know, a fairly sensible observation. There's very little a corporate manager is going to do to make the world a better place over and above running his business well. There's a lot of truth in that, but the context around it just keeps eroding until you end up with just, you know,
SPEAKER_00licensed sociopathy. Basically, yes.
SPEAKER_01That's right. I think you've described it well. Just to clarify, I think it can sound like I'm saying that everyone sat down and read Milton Friedman and then came to this decision. Really, it's more It functions more along the lines of the broader theory of society I have in the book, which is that in response to these attractive ideas, people altered their behavior and that shaped others' perception of what was okay. This is all dispersed outward in a way that's led us to this
SPEAKER_00So my pushback is I'm not sure how widely shared the modern faith is. I think it's definitely something that's in the heads of policy elites, people who think about how to, you know, how to Rearrange the Policies and Institutions Society. You think about society at a macro scale. They're systems thinkers. But like just ordinary Joes, I'm not sure how natural it is to think at a level of abstraction,
SPEAKER_00to think in terms of abstract systems, right? So I think they're more just sort of getting it in the water rather than this is sort of an article of faith in their hearts. So maybe one way to put it is that it's not that the impersonal systems of Markets and Bureaucracy, the systems that create the incentives we live by. It's not that they've inspired too much faith. It's rather that our other faiths in our personal responsibility in our
SPEAKER_00face-to-face lives have kind of withered, right? So once we step out of being, you know, Ryan Avent, Brink Lindsey participant in impersonal systems and step into our face-to-face lives, then we're not thinking so much about utility maximizing. Am I a good husband? Am I a bad husband? Am I a good friend? Am I a bad friend? Am I a good neighbor? Am I a bad neighbor? So that's moralized in your face-to-face life. It just runs by different rules than impersonal cooperation.
And so good faith just obviously can't be dispensed with in dealing face-to-face with others.
SPEAKER_00But Our face-to-face relationships have become a lot less important to our lives than they were, at least practically less important. This is a point I make again and again in my book, The Permanent Problem, that once upon a time those personal face-to-face relationships were just absolutely crucial to our We have a practical, you know, ability to get through the day and get through life. So our, you know, our wife, our spouse was a partner in economic production. Our kids helped out on the farm. They took care of us when we were old. Our neighbors, you know, they helped protect us against bad guys and they were in
insurance policy during
SPEAKER_00bad times. So the people with whom we share an obvious, explicit moral economy bulked very large in determining the quality of our life. Whereas they still bolt very large in determining the long-term quality of our life. But the day-to-day practical efficiencies of our life, we've outsourced all that stuff, a lot of it, to buying things and to getting services from the government. So as
SPEAKER_00The, you know, the part of our lives where we think naturally in kind of moral terms has withered, then it's, it's not too surprising that we carry these habits of life and impersonal systems around and kind of over apply them. Does that make sense to you? It does make sense. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And I think it's, I think it's a good pushback. You know, I will say of the, the, the portion of the book is about the modern faith that is sort of, it, It skates by a lot of the sort of particular mechanisms that are at work. And it also probably over-represents itself as kind of the monocausal explanation of everything that's gone on here. I mean, one thing I've sort of wrestled with as I wrote it was how much to focus on the
SPEAKER_01shifting beliefs of elites in particular. You know, because I think you're right that sort of their... The Permanent
SPEAKER_01You know, I think there's a lot that's going on to contribute to the erosion of those face-to-face interactions, as you note. To some extent, I wonder how much of that is an inevitable sort of outcome of, you know, of a freewheeling cap. Capitalism That Isn't Tempered By Purposeful Action Toward Preservation Of Particular Ways Of Life And So I Think There's A Really Deep Complementarity Between The Position You Take In Your Book Which Is Excellent
And Sort Of What I'm Actually Saying With This Argument Which Is That We've Sort Of Allowed Ourselves To Get To A Point Where Things That Really Matter A Lot We Treat As Though They Don't
SPEAKER_01Matter And so yeah, I think that the place to sort of focus is on how to make that argument more persuasively to the rest of the world.
SPEAKER_00Does that make sense? Yep, yep, yep You say we need a new faith We need a new big story To re-socialize us, re-moralize us So what does that look like? And you describe a kind of faith That's very similar to one I've described In some of my Substack writing Which I call it As opposed to a religious faith That's derived from some revealed Sacred source Just an existential faith that starts with just a sense of
gratitude of being here,
SPEAKER_00that everybody who's alive is a lottery winner. On the night we were conceived, the odds were 100 million to one against us. So we're here, but we get to have this amazing ride. Yes, it's full of sadness, but it's also full of joy and wonder. And it's full of opportunities to, like, tamp down the sadness and build up the joy and make So to lean into the best parts of life, right? So you start with that, just, so we should make the best of this, right? And then at the macro scale,
SPEAKER_00you start with the fact of progress, the fact that we're in, you know, progressive modernity, and That we are in this incredibly exotic and privileged position relative to the overwhelming bulk of our fellow members of our species who live before us. And so this should give us hope that things have gotten a lot better and therefore things can continue to get better and therefore it's our obligation to make them better. Is that how it all kind of... That's sort of the loose syllogism or associational thinking
that pulls you from
SPEAKER_00facts about the world to a sense of moral obligation?
SPEAKER_01I think so. Yeah, I mean, I think the long arc of progress is critical to it. The extent to which that long arc of progress has allowed us to become better people, better societies who treat each other better is an important part of it. But I think, you know, I think the thing that's missing is... The story that allows us to feel connected to both the past and the future and which helps us understand why it matters that we're the bridge.
The overriding notion that we're here to satisfy our preferences just doesn't do it. We're seeing the limits of what that can do in terms of driving society forward. I wish I had a very clear idea of what the correct story is that's going to bring
SPEAKER_01it together for everyone.
SPEAKER_00But you're refreshingly self-deflating, right? You say, I'm not a prophet. This isn't my job to do this. But still, there's an obvious candidate or set of candidates, which is organized religion, right? So you've written a book about faith. You're arguing that our problems are from a loss of faith. But, you know, you've got your – and you're telling your own story as you wind that into the narrative of the book. You talk about how you were raised, you know,
in a fairly fervently Christian community and how you lost that religious faith.
SPEAKER_00But anyway, tell the story. But then – and the losing of the faith, you know, you felt fairly self-congratulatory about, but you came over time to feel, you know, a little bit more, like, wistful about it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. And, you know, I think when I was growing up in the church and then sort of grappling with what I really believed, I overwhelmingly treated the sort of inner dialogue as one that really was just about me and God, right? That whatever I believed, it mattered for me, it mattered for my soul. And that kind of, if I decided to stop believing, like I was the one who was affected by and nobody else. And I think what I came to realize was that actually this is
the foundation of
SPEAKER_01collective purpose in a lot of ways, collective interaction. It matters because of what it does for all of us. And the extent to which we get personal benefits from it, from believing, that's very much tied up in what it does for the society around us, because it gives us all that obligation to look out for others and they look out for us. And I think, you know, if thinking about That lesson for me and thinking about sort of the place I go with it, which is that we need these new stories, you know, it does raise some difficult questions,
SPEAKER_01I think, for someone with liberal commitments, right? You know, that's, that's, that's not gonna, it's not gonna work, that's not appropriate. And, and, you know, and then second of all, it's sort of, you know, do we think it, you know, what do we really think about sort of assigning ourselves the obligation to, to do right by others, you know, Simply because we feel like that leads to a better overall collective outcome.
I think we haven't given ourselves the tools to really work through that yet,
SPEAKER_01and it's something I'm sort of continuing to think about. So you kind of walk right up to, I've got this sense of profound gratitude, and It kind of feels like it makes sense to direct that gratitude towards something, right?
SPEAKER_00That the author of... Whatever it is, if it's an impersonal principle or law or force or whatever, but there is some ground of all being that is the reason why there's something rather than nothing and that something has the nature that it has. And boy, I'm glad that it exists, right? And I'm glad that I exist and I'm glad that I'm a creature of this reality, right? And you say, you know, we could just call that God, but
SPEAKER_00You step back and you don't want to do that. So why don't you want to do that?
SPEAKER_01You know, I don't know if it's right to call it God. I don't know if that's what, you know, if that is an honest way to label it. You know, it'd be easy enough to just sort of not worry about it and just say that that's God. But it doesn't, I sort of feel like I don't, I'm not sure enough about that to run with it. You know what I mean? Yeah. Yeah I feel like you and I are in a very similar boat of sort of seeing the value of religion and religious community and you know it just shows
up in social science there's Robert Putnam who you know the author of Bowling Alone says that praying together beats bowling together and praying alone right in terms of binding communities together so it works and it works better than anything else which you
SPEAKER_00know suggests there's something going on there that's So we resist because the religious story of Christianity is typically presented as a factually true story, and we don't believe that that really happened. So you say, yeah, I don't want to be a pretend Christian. And so this seems to me like a... Spiritual Plight Peculiar To Post Christendom Which Is That I Live In A Buddhist Country Where So I'm In The Thailand Is Theravada Buddhism Is
Really Anchored In The Life And Teachings Of Siddhartha Gautama The Original Historical Buddha But
SPEAKER_00Many Buddhists in the Mahayana tradition, they're completely off. They don't care that much about that historical figure at all. And nobody in Theravada Buddhism is obsessing about the historicity of Siddhartha Gautama or getting much of anything on that, right? And when you get back to his teachings, it's just racist. All the supernatural stuff is like, take or leave it. His message is, life is full of suffering. I've got a spiritual technology to lick it. If you'll follow me, you'll be better off.
SPEAKER_00Judaism, right? The metaphysics, they're very latitudinarian about you just got to follow the rules, right? So you can be a good observant Jew just by following the rules. You don't have to believe anything you don't want to believe. You just have to conform to the practices of the group. So it seems like it would be easier in some religious traditions to make this leap to a scientific worldview where you're just not going to accept miraculous occurrences. And yet recognize that there really is something that
transcended, right?
SPEAKER_00That, yes, we're the cleverest critters on this planet, but I still think that imagining that we can, you know, these overachieving apes can grasp ultimate truth is only slightly more preposterous than imagining that a beetle or a mole rat could figure it all out, right? It's just, no. So there's just... We're in this little tiny bubble of this enormous mystery all around us. We know regularities in nature to an astonishing degree,
but we don't know why they're that way. We're just surrounded by mystery and unfathomable mystery towards which I think the
SPEAKER_00correct emotion is wonder and awe and also a sense of gratitude. Wonder and awe and gratitude towards things that You know, surpass human understanding and doing that in a community where we're all organized that way to think about the most important things there are to think about, get past the bullshit of the next, you know, this work week and get together and have communion about the
most important things
SPEAKER_00there are. It does really feel like there's no substitute for that. But in our culture, the religion on offer is a is a creedal religion. We believe these things. And of course, liberal Protestantism wandered way off into this kind of symbolic, you know, believing things in a symbolic way. But I think in a kind of never explicitly, right? The ministers wouldn't, you know, confess their lack of
belief in the resurrection to the flock because they don't want to harsh anybody's buzz, right?
SPEAKER_00So you have these communities of liberal Protestantism where they're all reciting the Apostles' Creed, but some of them mean one thing and some of them mean another, and they're not talking to each other honestly about it. So it feels like there is a missing kind of Christianity that could have existed, that never has, that's explicitly mythological, that says, look, there are truths about the nature of existence and about the human condition that Can Be Better Expressed In Myth Than And Which Is Kind Of Like
Art Than They Can Be
SPEAKER_00And Just You Know Prose And Through Symbolism And And You Know Kind Of By Indirection And The Myth Of The Christian Story That God Came And Participated In Our Suffering And That He Came As A You Know Not As A King But As A Poor Kid Born In A Animal Trough That's Just An Amazing Story With Amazing Spiritual Truths You Know So, it would be awesome to be able to tap into that cultural power of that myth,
SPEAKER_00but that's not how things evolved. It's just not really an option on the table.
SPEAKER_01No, it doesn't seem so. We're probably particularly hard-headed about it, in part because of the cultural legacy of Christianity that led us down this path toward modernity. At the same time, Views about Christianity have evolved dramatically since, you know, Christ. And there's nothing to say this isn't out of reach. I think I, you know, the thing that I feel a little uncomfortable about in certain terms of,
SPEAKER_01you know, turning the Christianity appreciation into something that's mostly about stories, it's just that I don't want I don't want people who believe other things to feel pressured and I don't feel like you know it's when you say this story is the answer it sort of necessarily implies that other stories aren't and that makes me a little uncomfortable but it's possibly I'm just you know overthinking this in a lot of different ways I guess the sort of the sort of add-on to kind
of my individual perspective about this is that and you alluded to this but you know my feeling is
SPEAKER_00like Now I live in a Buddhist country, so I could do that. It wouldn't be, but I felt there's, I'm almost, I don't want to be a parody of myself, all right? So that's like why I did not buy a Porsche in my 40s. So, and, you know, the searching Western intellectual ends up becoming a Buddhist, that just feels to me A little try hard, right? So we are born into cultures. We didn't choose them, all right? But you and I were born in the West.
SPEAKER_00Our cultural matrix is Christian. So it doesn't feel to me like it's forcing it on other people to say, oh, this is what we're born in. So if we're going to find a religious story to rally around, a Christian one makes a whole lot of sense because that's our culture.
SPEAKER_01You know, I think one thing the book sort of... works through is the, you know, we talked about this earlier, right? The extent to which new forms of belief enabled new collective capacities, capabilities, right? And when I sort of muse at the end on how we can find new stories, I think the thing that's feeding into that in part is that there's There's so much more to discover about the universe.
And discovering those things is going to happen in parallel with us uncovering new ways of conceiving why we're here and what we're meant to be and what to do,
SPEAKER_01right? And so I think in some sense we need to embrace the idea that The stories we have inherited from the past are not going to be the ones that carry us to the future, you know? And maybe that's thinking too far ahead. And if we're just dealing with the next 20 years, like this sort of, you know, that's good enough. But, you know, ultimately we have to, we don't have to, we have We ought to be open to the idea that we can achieve greater
understandings and that
SPEAKER_01we will come to understand, we'll come to appreciate things about the way the universe works, you know, the ways that our society develops that are new and better, you know, and that can be a very hard thing to imagine. And it's another, you know, it's a case where it'd be super helpful if I were a prophet and could say, here it is, you know, but it's a thing that we have to sort of Yeah, and let me just I don't want to leave the impression that I am criticizing
SPEAKER_00Westerners who have turned to Buddhism and find value there. The problem is all on me, right? It's just my sense of self-consciousness, not that that isn't a perfectly fine thing to do. So yeah, so maybe the The story that's going to pull us out of this jam has not been written yet. But maybe there's some little prophet out there right now who's tapping into our spiritual angst and he'll save the day or she'll save the day.
SPEAKER_01Until then, we have to keep the faith, right? We do. We have to realize it matters. I'm hopeful that we will.
SPEAKER_00That's right. So even without any terribly firm ground to rest on, the faith that we made it this far and that there are real possibilities to make things even better than they are today, that ought to be good enough, at least for now. But we've gone over our hour. Orion, I think we'll wrap it up here. Thanks so much for coming on the show. Great talking to you and best of luck with the book.
SPEAKER_01Thank you so much, Brink. It's always great to talk to you and I appreciate you having me on.
SPEAKER_00Thanks for listening to The Permanent Problem Podcast. Check out my essays on The Permanent Problem over on Substack, as well as on the Scan and Center website. And be sure to catch all our episodes on Substack, Spotify, Stitcher, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you love tuning in. Until next time, I'm Brink Lindsey, signing off.
Seth Kaplan had built a career as an expert on “fragile states” - countries plagued by dysfunction and institutional disrepair. But as politics here in the United States plunged into its current time of troubles, Kaplan...
Liberal values and institutions now face aggressive challenges from both right and left extremism, so how should defenders of the embattled liberal center respond? It’s become clear now that the question exposes an...
Virginia Postrel has made a career out of seeing the extraordinary in the everyday - from the growing importance of “look and feel” in the products we buy, to the power of glamour to arouse our sense of longing, to...
America is experiencing an epidemic of loneliness: marriage and birth rates, the number of close friendships, time spent with friends, and community involvement more broadly are all in decline. Phil Levin, my guest on...
In the heady days after the collapse of the Soviet Union, many imagined that we had arrived at the “end of history” now that liberal democratic capitalism had chased all ideological competitors from the field. Just a...