Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Permanent Problem Podcast

The Permanent Problem Podcast artwork

Virginia Postrel on everyday ambition, everyday abundance

Aug 5, 20261 hr 7 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Virginia Postrel has made a career out of seeing the extraordinary in the everyday - from the growing importance of “look and feel” in the products we buy, to the power of glamour to arouse our sense of longing, to tracing the history of humanity through its production and use of textiles. In this episode of The Permanent Problem podcast, Virginia joins me to discuss how the unleashing of everyday ambition has given us a world of everyday abundance - and why that world, for all its material blessings, still fails to satisfy. In a wide-ranging conversation, we review how the early American republic transformed ambition and restlessness from traditional vices into the source of world-transforming dynamism, reminisce about the Bicentennial and compare it to the fizzle of the recent Semiquincentennial, review the wide variety of ways in which humans seek to “matter,” and speculate on the coming impact of AI and the future of mass full-time employment. Below is a video recording of our conversation, followed by a lightly edited transcript. But first, a few links relevant to our chat: Virginia’s new podcast with Charles Mann, “Everyday Abundance” Charles Mann’s essay series on “How the System Works” Virginia’s essay on America’s democratization of ambition My first-ever big-think essay, written for Virginia’s Reason magazine back in 1992, with a similar take on democratized ambition My Substack essay updating those 1992 thoughts Virginia’s essay on Rebecca Goldstein’s The Mattering Instinct Brink Lindsey: Hello everybody, and welcome to The Permanent Problem podcast. I’m very happy to have as my guest today my first return engagement on the show, my longtime friend, Virginia Postrel. Virginia, welcome to The Permanent Problem. Virginia Postrel: It’s always great to talk to you, Brink. Lindsey: Let me give you a proper introduction. Virginia Postrel is an author and an essayist. She’s the author of several excellent books starting off with The Future and Its Enemies. Most recently, The Fabric of Civilization. She’s an editor at the superb newish publication, Works in Progress. And she’s got a new podcast out with Charles Mann, who’s probably best known for his book 1491, but the podcast is called Everyday Abundance. So, tell us a little bit about it and the thinking that went behind it. Postrel: Yeah. So, Charles and I had occasion to do a panel, or rather he was supposed to give a talk and then he said, “I want to interview you.” And I said, “No, they got you to give a talk. I’ll interview you.” This was at the Roots of Progress conference. And so, he had recently written a series of articles for The New Atlantis called “How the System Works” and had become very aware of people… Lindsey: And those were just great, by the way. I feel like those should be part of the K-12 curriculum. Postrel: Well, actually, so does he. And that’s what he wrote. So, let’s see if I can remember. There’s one about the system that brings us electricity, one about water, one about public health, and one about food. So, they’re all about these big complicated systems, where they came from, how they work, because he had realized that especially younger people have no clue, and people in general as well. So, that was what we were discussing, how to do this Q&A at this conference. But this led to a general discussion about how people don’t know where anything came from. When we talk about technology, we talk about things like AI and everything to do with computers as if that’s the only technology in the world. And in fact, we’re surrounded by all kinds of technologies. And of course I wrote The Fabric of Civilization, which is about textiles, which are one of the oldest technologies. And the root of the word technology comes from the word for weave. But anyway, one thing led to another and we came up with this idea of doing a series of podcast episodes where we explored the hidden histories behind everyday activities and the technologies you didn’t even know were technologies. Lindsey: So, what are some of your recent episodes? Postrel: The most recent one is on doing laundry. Greatest invention ever, the washing machine, the electric washing machine. They don’t have to be electric now. They could be gas. I keep thinking of the ones that are coming out. We have one coming out on blowing your nose, on driving the car, which is about not the invention of the car, but what had to be done in order to have driving as a regular thing. We did one on working out, about everyday exercise. The first one we did was on brushing your teeth. So, you get the kind of idea. There are all these everyday activities. One that we have coming out is shopping for groceries. And that actually has four different inventions in it, which are not the only ones that are needed, but we go from packaged goods to self-service grocery stores all the way up to scanners and barcodes. So, it’s all these things that people take for granted. Shopping cart, that’s the one I forgot. It’s just actually an invention. Lindsey: In a previous life, I was a lawyer and one of the joys of my job… I was an anti-dumping lawyer. So, we represented clients that were exporting to the United States and accused of selling at an unfairly low price. To defend those cases, you had to know a lot about the production process as well as about the sales process and all their accounting details and so forth. And we always had to do factory tours and know something about how the production process worked. So, I got to do tours of everything from the lowest tech, just injection plastic molding cigarette lighter factories to high-tech, making the flat panel displays for laptops, all up and down the scale of complexity. And it’s always so much more phenomenally complicated than you can imagine. Postrel: So much more phenomenally complicated. And one of my recent Works in Progress columns is about disposable diapers. And there I really, really wanted a factory tour, but they’re incredibly secretive and I couldn’t get one. Lindsey: So, now that I’m on this current jag with The Permanent Problem, I find myself in this very peculiar and lonely position of simultaneously thinking that we really ought to be much, much more conscious of the incredible bounty that consumerism has given us and to understand the cleverness and ingenuity that had to compound over time to give us all these things. So, we should be simultaneously much more conscious and appreciative of that - and, simultaneously, much more conscious of the limits of what consumerism can do for our lives. The most important things in life are not the things you can buy at the store. And those are, for a lot of people, getting crowded out these days. And so, I find myself flopping back and forth between those two positions and angering everybody in the process. Postrel: I was thinking about your perspective in the context of the Everyday Abundance podcast. And I was thinking that our stories are for the most part about unheralded people who created important things. And I think people who are really into their work tend to overemphasize the importance of work as a source of meaning in life, but it is an important source of meaning in life. Sylvan Goldman, who created the shopping cart, is an important guy in the world that we live in. He was also a philanthropist in different things in his town, but his legacy is that he changed our world in this little way. And most people, I mean, obviously I know his name. He’s not completely unheralded. You can find out things, but there are also people who are unknown or cases where things are misattributed, all those kinds of things. And then there are also people who get up every day and go to work and make sure that our water isn’t full of sewage and stuff like that. And those are not glamorous jobs and not just because sewage is icky, but just those are not the jobs that we tend to honor and they are really important. I think that’s an element of it is to recognize the t… This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit brinklindsey.substack.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Welcome to The Permanent Problem Podcast. I'm your host, Brink Lindsey, a Senior Vice President at the Niskanen Center. Each episode, we take a deep dive into the messy and uncertain transition from mass affluence to mass flourish, exploring what I call capitalism's triple crisis and the potential for rising above it. Hello, everybody, and welcome to The Permanent Problem Podcast. I'm very happy to have as my guest today my first return engagement on the show, my longtime friend, Virginia Postrelle.

SPEAKER_00Virginia, welcome to The Permanent Problem.

SPEAKER_01It's always great to talk to you, Brink.

SPEAKER_00Good, good. Let me give you a proper introduction. Virginia Postrell is an author and essayist. She's the author of several excellent books, starting off with The Future and Its Enemies, most recently The Fabric of Civilization. She's an editor at the superb new Newish publication, Works in Progress, and she's got a new podcast out with Charles Mann, who's probably best known for his book, 1491, but the podcast is called Everyday Abundance.

SPEAKER_00So tell us a little bit about it and the thinking that went behind it.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so Charles and I had occasion to do a panel, or rather, he was supposed to Give a talk. And then he said, I want to interview you. And I said, no, they got you to give a talk. I'll interview you. But this was at the Roots of Progress conference.

SPEAKER_00Okay. Yep.

SPEAKER_01And so he had recently written a series of articles for the New Atlantis called How the System Works and had become very aware of like people.

SPEAKER_00And those are just great, by the way. I feel like those should be like part of the K through 12 curriculum book.

SPEAKER_01Right. Well, actually, so does he. And that's sort of what he wrote in the mind. So let's see if I can remember. There's one about the electrical, the system that brings us electricity, one about water, one about public health and one about food. So they're all about, you know, these big, complicated systems, where they came from, how they work, because he had realized that especially younger people have no clue and people in general.

SPEAKER_01So that was what we were discussing how to do this Q&A at this conference. But this led to a general discussion about how people don't know where anything came from and don't sort of – When we talk about technology, we talk about things like AI and everything to do with computers as if that's the only technology in the world. And in fact, we're surrounded by all kinds of technologies. And of course,

SPEAKER_01I wrote The Fabric of Civilization, which is textiles, which are one of the oldest technologies in the world. Root of the word technology comes from the words of weave. But anyway, one thing led to another. And we came up with this idea of doing a series of podcast episodes where we explored the hidden histories behind everyday activities and the technologies you didn't even know were technologies, which then got...

SPEAKER_00So what are your recent episodes?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so the most recent one is on doing laundry. Greatest invention ever, the washing machine, the electric washing machine. They don't have to be electric now, they could be gas, but yeah, we've done... Let's see. I was like, what did we do? I keep thinking of the ones that are coming out. We have one coming out on blowing your nose and driving the car, which is about not the invention of the car, but what had to be done in order to have driving as a regular thing.

SPEAKER_01We did one on working out, about everyday exercise. The first one we did was on brushing your teeth. So you get the kind of idea. There are all these everyday activities. Some of them, one that we have coming out is shopping for groceries. And that actually has four different inventions in it, which are not the only ones that are needed. But, you know, we go from packaged goods to self-service grocery stores, all the way up to scanners and barcodes.

SPEAKER_01Right. All these things that people sort of take for granted. The shopping cart, that's the one I forgot, which is actually an intervention, yeah.

SPEAKER_00So, in a previous life, I was a lawyer, and one of the joys of my job, I was an anti-dumping lawyer, so we represented clients who were exporting to the United States and accused of selling at an unfairly low price. Right, right. To defend those cases, you had to know a lot about the production process as well as about the sales process and all their accounting details and so forth. But we always had to do factory tours. So I represented and know something about how the production process worked.

SPEAKER_00So I got to do tours of, you know, everything from the lowest tech, you know, just injection plastic molding, cigarette lighter factories to high tech, you know, making the flat panel displays for laptops, all up and down the, you know, the scale of complexity. It's always so much more phenomenally complicated than you can imagine.

SPEAKER_01So much more phenomenally complicated. And one of my recent works in progress columns is about disposable diapers. And there I really, really wanted a factory tour, but they're incredibly secretive and I couldn't get one. Oh, my God.

SPEAKER_00So now that I'm on this current jag with The Permanent Problem, I find myself in this very peculiar and lonely position of simultaneously thinking that we really ought to be much, much more conscious of the incredible bounty that consumerism has given us and to understand the cleverness and ingenuity that had to compound over time to give us all these things. So we should be simultaneously much more conscious and We're more appreciative of

SPEAKER_00that and simultaneously much more conscious of the limits of what consumerism can do for our lives. The most important things in life are not the things you can buy at the store and those are for a lot of people getting crowded out these days. And so I find myself flopping back and forth between those two positions and angering everybody in the process.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, one thing I was thinking about, you know, your perspective in the context of the Everyday Abundance podcast, and I was thinking, you know, really our stories are, for the most part, about how people, about people, unheralded people who created important things.

SPEAKER_00Yes.

SPEAKER_01And I think, I mean, I think people who are really into their work are Tend to overemphasize the importance of work as a source of meaning in life, but it is an important source of meaning in life. And I think that recognizing that the people who, you know, Sylvan Goleman, who created the shopping cart, is an important guy in the world that we live in. He was also, you know, a philanthropist and different things in his town.

SPEAKER_01But, you know, his legacy is that he changed our world in this little way. And most people, I mean, obviously, I know his name. He's not completely unheralded. You can find out things. But there are also people who... are unknown or cases where things are misattributed, you know, all those kinds of things. And then there are also people who get up every day and go to work and make sure that our water isn't, you know, full of sewage and stuff like that.

SPEAKER_01And those are not glamorous jobs and not just because sewage is icky, but just, you know, those are not the jobs that we tend to honor and they are really important. And so I think that's an element of it is to recognize that the things that are important that people do, you know, no one will argue with you, Brink. I'm sorry.

SPEAKER_01No one is going to argue that having a lot of stuff is the only important thing in life. And that's the source of all meaning. No one is going to say that.

SPEAKER_00Not explicitly, no. No. But they will tell me if the lines are going up on capitalism, you have nothing to complain about. That's not capitalism's job.

SPEAKER_01But that is, by the way, I don't like the word capitalism. I never have. I like the word markets, which is a different thing. But I do think that the fact that we only sort of recognize in our public discourse about five different jobs is so big.

SPEAKER_00Right, right.

SPEAKER_01And so that's one reason for doing a show like this. Also, it's just fun and interesting. And people have an insufficient sense of history and one weird aspect of having two baby boomers do it. I mean, I'm 66 and... Charles, I think it's 70, but is that a lot of things that we remember are now history. So we have to explain about how did you count out cash change at the register

SPEAKER_01before it would just tell you and how did you put the sales tax in and all these kinds of things.

SPEAKER_00So everyday abundance gives us comforts, convenience, entertainment, and those are Shouldn't turn our nose up at those, right? Those are really important. If you don't think they're important, try massive discomfort, massive inconvenience, soul-trushing boredom, right?

SPEAKER_01Try washing all your laundry by boiling water on the stove and making your own detergent and all these things. I mean, you'll have a lot less of your life to do whatever meaningful thing there is.

SPEAKER_00That's right. So my argument is that those are important goods, but we can't lose sight of the fact that there are even more important goods. All right. I want to switch gears to something you just wrote recently, this piece for the Law and Liberty website called American Ambitions that you wrote as part of the commemoration of- Liberty Fund.org. Liberty Fund.org. Okay. Yeah. Okay. Sorry.

SPEAKER_01I know they have like four sites. It's confusing.

SPEAKER_00And you wrote this, you know, in commemoration of the- Of the semi-quincentennial, America's 250th birthday. So before we talk about the essay, we both lived through the bicentennial. So we've lived through two of these things. And this one, I mean, just put aside the shambolic, corrupt screw up of the national celebration. Just as a mass phenomenon, it was nothing compared to last go around. That's my impression.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I mean, I can't tell partly it's because we're old. Right. And when you're 16 and having the bicentennial or however you were a little younger than me, but 14, it's different. You know, you're doing things in school. Whereas when you're just going on in your life, you know, maybe not so much. So that's part of it.

SPEAKER_00So, you know, there were national celebrations back then and they were stately and lovely. But there was enormous, first there was just enormous commercialization. People were selling bicentennial, the red, white, and blue, everything. Everything, yeah. And there were community projects. In our town, we painted all the fire hydrants to look like Revolutionary War soldiers. That was a thing. And that was apparently a thing in communities all over the country. But I think maybe the most important thing As far as why it was drilled into our skull so much,

SPEAKER_00for two and a half years, every night we had a Bicentennial Minute on CBS.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, on TV, which we all watched TV.

SPEAKER_00There were three networks. The biggest one was CBS. Every night from July 4th, 1974 through December 31st, 1976, they had a minute-long... Break somewhere during the eight o'clock hour where some CVS person or celebrity or politician would tell what happened 200 years ago today. So and then that the whole Byzantino Minute thing became kind of a cultural phenomenon and people made jokes about it on sitcoms and so forth.

SPEAKER_00So. It just, the whole thing loomed so much bigger in our consciousness. Just two rock bands, two rock bands that I followed in high school, Rush and Styx. I was a big Rush fan, casual Styx fan. They both had bicentennial-themed songs that came out in 1975. So, much bigger deal.

SPEAKER_01I don't know if you know, but Rush is having a moment. I know, of course I do. It's been covered in variety, so it must be true.

SPEAKER_00I was never a Rush fan.

SPEAKER_01But I, you know, I associated the bicentennial with two things. One were plays that we did in my high school because I was very involved in theater and particularly making costumes to make a lot of 18th century movies. Pseudo 18th century costume. And the other was being extremely sunburned because on the actual day of the bicentennial, on July 4th, I went with this summer program that I was,

SPEAKER_01governor school program that I was, we went to the beach and I got the worst sunburn of my life.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01It's nothing to do with the Bicentennial, other than we went to the beach, you know, to sort of celebrate. But this year, actually, we went, I also have a place in Orange County, and we were down there, and we went to Tustin, and we had to the Tustin High School fireworks and picnic, and we had a wonderful Bicentennial. It was, they had lovely fireworks, they had a band, they had food trucks, it was, you know, looked like California.

SPEAKER_01The crowd, there were lots of families, you know, every shape, size, color and age. Yeah. So it was really, it was really nice. Good.

SPEAKER_00For a lot of different reasons, we have come to this state of affairs, but maybe the bicentennial minutes were one of them. There was a poll that came out recently that the Cato Institute did showing the shocking number of people who don't know what happened on July 4th, 1776. So for people 65 and older, 72% of them identified it correctly. But for people 18 to 29, only 39% identified it correctly.

SPEAKER_01Well, that's not good. I thought Hamilton was supposed to cure us of that.

SPEAKER_00Doesn't ask to see buckets from them being years ago now.

SPEAKER_01But yeah, right. I was going to say now it's old. Yeah, those people were like not born yet or they were not conscious.

SPEAKER_00OK, so let's talk about your essay. You describe how the American Revolution launched a new kind of social order, a new dynamic, wide open order that democratized ambition. Ambition had been thought of as as an elite capacity, kind of dangerous. It's glorious, but dangerous. Not something you want to see in ordinary people, but the freedom and economic circumstances of the new American continent brought forth a democratized ambition, and you describe it in all kinds of ways. So tell a little bit more about that essay.

SPEAKER_01Well, the first thing you have to realize, and that we tend not to, because we think of ambition as a good thing, is like ambition was It was a bad word. It was ambition and avarice. They were negative concepts, you know, right up in, I would say, at least through the 17th century. Ambition, I mean, even Machiavelli wrote a poem about the evils of ambition and how it creates war and kills all these people.

SPEAKER_01So, I mean, by the time of the American Revolution... The meaning had softened so that Adam Smith wrote about ambition, but it was always ambition within a sense of hierarchy. So it was like you were ambitious to get elected to parliament or you were ambitious to rise in the military. They were... The idea that, you know, you might be ambitious to be like the best runner in your local running club

SPEAKER_01or something, that was not a concept. Right. But these sort of small ambitions that Americans are, we don't even think about them, but it's a very, very American characteristic to have a million little ambitions. And Tocqueville thought, this is a really weird country. You know, everybody is ambitious, but nobody has big ambitions.

SPEAKER_01And I think when he says these big ambitions, he's like literally thinking of Napoleon. I can't prove that. But I think, you know, that's the old notion of ambition. Yeah. Particularly in the early republic, which is mostly what I was writing about, because I was also writing about the 250th anniversary of the Weldon Nation. So I was trying to, you know, sort of look at Smith and look at that period and see what was changing there. In the early republic, you know, once...

SPEAKER_01By 1800, the election, Joyce Appleby, the historian in my quote, makes a really good case that this sort of chain is established securely by the election of 1800. There is just this notion that America is this... Right.

SPEAKER_01Sense of people moving around, trying different things, leaving their hometowns, leaving their homes, coming back to their homes, settling the frontier. There's just all of this. I mean, people using the term restless. It's a very common word

SPEAKER_00used to describe it. And that was a bad word.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, that was the people were using or like, what is with these restless Americans? It's so odd, you know, because even Adam Smith, one of Adam Smith's in the Wealth of Nation, one of his big concerns is that there are various regulations and. But even Adam Smith assumes that's like within the same town.

SPEAKER_01No, that's right.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so your ambition overlaps a lot with the flourishing I talk about all the time, that ambition is a quest for self-improvement, to better your economic circumstances, but also to better your mind, to better your place in society. So it's an attempt to realize your potential, right? You've got something in there, and I'm going to figure out what it is, and I'm going to make it happen. Right.

SPEAKER_01And one of the things when the country is very open is that people feel the ability to do that. And over time, and Tocqueville predicted this as well, you start to get lots of rules that are often designed to make things fairer that end up stifling people's ability to pursue their ambitions or pursue their best self, whatever you want to say.

SPEAKER_00So I could say that the circumstances of antebellum America, putting aside the huge exception of slavery, were very conducive to mass flourishing. You had this wide open social order where within the constraints of the technology and knowledge of the day, people had more freedom to realize their potential and be all they can be than any large group of people, any society we'd ever seen before. But you're a celebrity, you know, it's a celebratory essay, but it has a bit of an elegiac tone.

SPEAKER_01I then saw the down note.

SPEAKER_00So because you talk about, quote, the combination of economic circumstances and liberal principles made this happen. But economic circumstances today are quite different. You talk about back then ambition was no longer, you know, winner take all. But there's a lot of winner take all markets these days or winner take most markets these days. You talk about a diverse, dynamic society with countless sources of status and respect. I feel like as we've nationalized our economy,

SPEAKER_00the channels of competition have gotten, you know, they include more people, but there's fewer of them. So there are fewer ponds to be a big fish in than there were back in a country of just an archipelago of small towns.

SPEAKER_01I'm not sure that's true. And part of the reason I'm not sure that's true is that, as you know, I'm from South Carolina and my family is still there. And the towns that they live in have grown enormously. The one I grew up in, Greenville, is huge and Charleston area where one of my brothers lived in. And they still very much have many different little Outlets for Ambition.

SPEAKER_01And even Los Angeles does.

SPEAKER_00And there's been a huge proliferation of subcultures that you can be cool with.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, there are all these subcultures. I mean, I think our conversation about this is the problem is there's too many people like us. Who went to these elite schools. And of course, back when I went to Princeton, and I don't know about you, but I mean, I just went there because I was a nerd. I had no, I mean, and it was more open than it is today because somebody like me who went to a Public high school in South Carolina and had a somewhat spotty preparation

SPEAKER_01and just had really high SAT scores. And I don't think somebody like me could get in now. And in fact, it's the case that fewer, even though South Carolina has grown tremendously since 1978 when I was applying and there were 13 people admitted, fewer people.

SPEAKER_00Oh, that's interesting.

SPEAKER_01The last time I checked, it was nine. Like fewer people get in from South Carolina and the schools are better. You know, so the schools are improved. The population has grown tremendously. And fewer people get into Princeton, you know, which partly is because it's more of an international university than it used to be. But it's also because I think their idea of what is a promising student has narrowed it. I can't prove that, but I think they're, you know, but that is the Tocqueville argument,

SPEAKER_01that as you get things, you know, persistently. You aren't as willing to. But that said, I still think there are lots and lots and lots of niches for ambition.

SPEAKER_00I agree completely.

SPEAKER_01People who hang out with elite, highly educated people, hang out in Washington and New York and Los Angeles and San Francisco, have a kind of distorted view of the world. But not you and me, of course,

SPEAKER_00of course. I agree that certainly relative to the rest of the world, American ambition is still robust and exceptional. But there's still a sense of wide openness and you can be anything in America. That sense is more alive in America than it is in a lot of places. But I don't feel like it's as alive as it was in the 1830s and 1840s. It's just sort of, you know, kind of... The sense of limitless possibility and free land and every ordinary person,

SPEAKER_00all they need is drive and will to make a success of their lives. And that just isn't true anymore.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, there is a quote that I didn't use in the article, but that I read, I believe it was from Shabali, one of the European visitors who quoted, who said, The amazing thing about America is that a man can get off the boat from Ireland with nothing but the strength of his body and make his way. You told this story, you're like, make his way getting hired as a laborer and then get land and basically build

SPEAKER_01a life. And when you have a society which is hungry for labor, which was true in the United States for a very, very, very long time. I mean, I would argue it's still true, but people don't want to talk about that. But it was, we had lots of land, we had lots of resources like timber and coal and things like that, but we were short on people, which is one reason there were others that we had all these immigrants.

SPEAKER_01I actually think, I've written about this on my Substack and I hint at it in the article, I actually think the problem was that we shut off immigration in 1924. And so then the vaunted greatest generation and the silent generation and the baby boomers all grew up in an America without contemporary immigrants. Right.

SPEAKER_00Right. And it's in those communities that you see this all-American striving to better themselves and improve their condition at its most vital.

SPEAKER_01And those are the generations. That produced the anti-Promethean backlash. This whole thing that you've dubbed it. And this thinking came to me when Jason Crawford from Roots of Progress was interviewing me for something. And he was saying like, look, there were other times where you could have had anti-Promethean backlash. Why did it happen in the 70s? And I was like, why did it happen in the 70s? And then I started doing the math. And it's like, yeah, you had these...

SPEAKER_01Three generations of people who grew up in an America where they're contemporary. So their parents, their grandparents may have been immigrants, but they didn't go to school with people who were first generation Americans. They took the country and the prosperity and all of these things kind of for granted. And then they became generations that focused more on,

SPEAKER_01even though, you know, supposedly the 60s, but they really focused more on protecting their stuff. You know, they became sort of, you know, stasis, as I would say, in the future in the Senate. And I think, and so now we have these new, you know, post-65 waves of immigrants, which are now creating, you know, there's a backlash against them. And that would suggest that we're setting ourselves up 50 years hence for another.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, maybe.

SPEAKER_01Who knows?

SPEAKER_00We've had 50 years of mass immigration now and I'm not seeing things unwind.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, it's hard to unwind things, as you know. Once they're in there, they're hard

SPEAKER_00to unwind. I would throw something else into the mix. I think the 20th century experience of World War I and industrialized slaughter, World War II and the Holocaust, and then the threat of nuclear annihilation. All of those convinced a whole lot of intellectuals that technology was bad.

SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah.

SPEAKER_00And then that seeped into the mass culture by the 60s with the baby boomer cohort.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. World War I killed a Victorian optimism in Britain and filtered throughout. It didn't really filter so much into the US, but it had a huge effect in Europe.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01World War II and the Holocaust is- Then

SPEAKER_00a lot of those Europeans moved over and started teaching at American colleges.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's more complicated. For whatever reason it happened, that's a concern. But now we're in the periods, this is why people are hating on you, Brink, where the people who want to sort of keep things, protect the status quo, Tend to do a lot of chin pull or go backwards.

SPEAKER_01Tend to do a lot of chin pulling about How everybody had a meaningful life when everybody had a good union job working on an assembly line, which is just nonsense.

SPEAKER_00No, it's not. Yes.

SPEAKER_01It's just nonsense. First of all, that was a tiny percentage of the labor force. Just happens to be concentrated in some swing states. Secondly, those jobs were incredibly boring. And it's... If people had good lives because of them, it's because they took the money and they had their family and the job wasn't

SPEAKER_00the gimmick. The way I would put it, the jobs were dirty and dangerous and just awful, just physically awful. You read these accounts of assembly line workers and the first day on the job, they just can't believe anybody can really do this every day. It's so awful.

SPEAKER_01They were bad, but I had a high school teacher, my ninth grade social studies teacher, who actually had come to Greenville because he went to Bob Jones University. But he was from Michigan and he worked on an assembly line during his summers off in an automobile plant. And so this was in the 70s. It would have been in the early 70s, I guess. And the people would be so bored, they would like deliberately wreck Some of the things they were building.

SPEAKER_00Increasing sabotage in the 70s.

SPEAKER_01At that point was not so incredibly dangerous so much as incredibly boring.

SPEAKER_00Yes. Yes. So, but... Yeah, the jobs were not intrinsically fulfilling, but they put you on an escalator of rising living standards that moved faster than any such escalator had ever moved for any large group of people ever. And that feeling of just like time-lapse photography, seeing your circumstances change, that was exhilarating for people and made people proud of what they had been able to accomplish.

SPEAKER_00Also, even though, you know, blue collar factory work was not the majority of low skilled work, but it was the most salient and most culturally visible of low skilled work. And it was a kind of an aspirational work to get a good factory job. You could end up with a middle class lifestyle. And and it was important. It was clearly crucially important to the health and progress of the overall system. Ordinary working stiffs were arrayed on the technological frontier along with their managers and bosses and owners pushing the technological frontier forward

SPEAKER_00in the steel industry, in the automobile industry, etc. When they struck, when they exerted their collective power, right? In those industries, you know, that whole industry is ground to a halt. And it was a national security crisis if the steel industry went on strike. Global, you know, global security was at stake. So these people knew in their bones that what they did was existentially important and it mattered in a way that I think is very different from what a lot of jobs in the kind of post-working class in today's service sector are doing.

SPEAKER_00Jobs that, you know, they provide some kind of service and people are willing to pay for it, but people don't have the feeling that what they do matters in a way that they did back then. And they don't have the status. They don't have the status as contributors to the common wheel that factory workers did back then. They were glorified and people now are not.

SPEAKER_01You know, health care absorbs a huge number of those people. And everybody thinks, I mean, people may complain about the system or it's too expensive or whatever, but nobody thinks that being an x-ray technician is not important.

SPEAKER_00No,

SPEAKER_01that's right. Or spending the day giving women mammograms or even working in medical billing or answering the phones in an optometrist's office or whatever. I mean, health care is a huge percentage of the economy. Many of the jobs that were once, many of the kinds of people who used to do factory jobs now work in health care. Part of the problem is it's a little gendered. I would argue it's not super gendered,

SPEAKER_01especially certain things like phlebotomists and x-ray techs and certain kinds of jobs where I've encountered plenty of men working at them. But I just think... When everybody worked in agriculture, everybody thought their job was important because food. And farmers today will still tell you that they have the most important jobs.

SPEAKER_01That's not a great way to make the rest of the other 98% of Americans. If we could convince everybody that farmers had the most important jobs, I don't think that would be good for society.

SPEAKER_00But anyway, so- So we spend a big chunk of our lives on the job. The majority of our waking hours during most of our vital adult years, we spend working for pay. So how that experience is goes a lot to what the overall conditions for human flourishing are in a society. Do you have hope?

SPEAKER_00So jobs today are, they're less dirty, dangerous. They pay better than they did before. My sense is for a lot of people, they're not especially fulfilling. Most people, they're not really very fulfilling. It's mostly for the paycheck. That's why they do it.

SPEAKER_01And so has it been from time immemorial. Yes, but the...

SPEAKER_00So is progress getting people cooler and cooler jobs so one day everybody has a cool, fulfilling job? Or is progress getting so rich that working for pay becomes more and more discretionary?

SPEAKER_01Well, I think the jury's out on that. You know, it's... I think reveal preference is part of it. What are people going to want to do? But I was going to say about jobs, another thing about today's jobs, particularly ones that are lower skill or lower pay, is that they're much more social than they used to be.

SPEAKER_00Yes, absolutely.

SPEAKER_01I, many years ago, probably 20 years ago, I talked to some people who owned a very nice, you probably heard me tell this story before, but a very nice furniture factory outside of Dallas. And when I say it was nice, I mean, it was not unpleasant to work in, but it was factory work. You still had to do it, but it was clean. It wasn't particularly noisy. People worked in small teams. And most of the people who worked in it were immigrants.

SPEAKER_01And the factory was unable to hire their children, even children who were kind of blue collar, because they would rather go and work at Target for less money because it was less regimented and more social. You know, so that's a factor. I'm not saying working at Target is the be all and end all of work, but people get damaged. A number of different things out of their work. Some people get a sense of flow and craftsmanship and intellectual stimulation,

SPEAKER_01that sort of thing. Other people get the social aspects. And I think it's a huge mistake to try to put everybody working at home. I mean, I've been working at home since 2000 and it has its advantages, but I don't.

SPEAKER_00No, I agree it's not for everybody.

SPEAKER_01If I didn't travel and go to conferences and stuff, I would be miserable because I don't have any colleagues.

SPEAKER_00Revealed preferences show up here too. And people really liked not having that two hours of commuting.

SPEAKER_01Commute is a huge deal.

SPEAKER_00And people like being able to deal with their kids' doctor's problems during the middle of the day. So when the call to return to the office after COVID happened, there was a lot of non-responders.

SPEAKER_01Right, right, right. I think it's really bad for people who are early in their careers, which also means they're younger, they don't have kids. You know, there's certain, they might live, they might even live closer to the job. You know, there's certain things that become bad. More important as you get older. And you've already established kind of your professional networks and friendships and stuff. But where do I think the world is going? I think that AI is going to,

SPEAKER_01it'll happen slowly, it'll be complicated, but I think a certain number of, I think there is going to be some shift from some types of white collar work to more, how should I put it, physical work.

SPEAKER_00I mean, I think- Things where- IRL work, right? Touch grass work. In real life work, right?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Things where people's physical presence is important. I was just at a conference, really interesting conference that Abundance Institute ran on AI and music that had lots of people from music, musicians and producers, as well as tech and policy people. And- Everybody agreed that, you know, everybody's going to want to do more and more, you know, that concerts and connecting with other fans in person,

SPEAKER_01all these things are the future. I mean, they're already the present, but it's just going to get more and more important to have that presence. My nephew is making, you know, Really high-end furniture and doors and things like that. He's a really great woodworker and always studying for his contractor's license. But that's one thing. Another nephew on the other end of things is in Silicon Valley making medical robotics.

SPEAKER_01And actually, I have a lot of robots in my family. Another nephew is working on underwater robots that work on

SPEAKER_00like oil. And this fits in with the broader cultural kind of touch grass or longing to touch grass again in an age where we're just online all the time. So you're seeing, you know, vinyl records are back. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01There's places you can go to

SPEAKER_00play board games with people.

SPEAKER_01Right, right, right, right. So I reviewed this book by Christine Rosen, whose name, I forget the name of the book, but it was all about how, oh, it's so terrible. We no longer have physical bodies and it's all about.

SPEAKER_00The Extinction of Experience. Is that what it was? Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_01And it was just a terrible book. I expected to disagree with it. I didn't think it would be a terrible book. Those are two different things. But it was just there were four contradictions on every page. But one of the things that really struck me is like, I don't know where she, well, I know she lives in DC, but she certainly doesn't live in my neighborhood because everything is like a Pilates class and a personal trainer and a massage place and a get your nails done place. And it's all about your body.

SPEAKER_01It's not about being online, you know. And I think the whole, I mean, I think the whole looks maxing thing is weird and the particular look is weird. But I think that's also this kind of physicality is and even professions associated with it is part of the future because that's for people who are not intellectuals. And this is often a very important form of self-fashioning.

SPEAKER_01But I do think that – I sent you a link to my essay about Rebecca Goldstein's book, The Mattering Instinct, because I really like her book. I think it makes a very important point – well, two very important points. The first one is the thesis of the book, which is that human beings have – An instinct to matter, and that is not just to matter to someone, but to matter in some sort of existential sense, to have a sense that all the things we have to do

SPEAKER_01to maintain our individual lives are worth it, that if we disappeared tomorrow, it would matter in some sense. But the other thing, which is what I think is really important, is that she talks about how This manifests itself in very different ways among different personalities and people have a tendency to think if they are sort of an achievement or their sense of mattering is about achievement,

SPEAKER_01they think everybody's is about achievement or if their sense of mattering, which is kind of what you wrote about Ned Phelps and His notion of flourishing is very, oh yeah, this guy won a Nobel Prize. He is very oriented. But other people, if their sense of mattering is all about family life or religion, They also think that's the answer. You have to have their answer. And she has like five different categories.

SPEAKER_00Transcenders and strivers and competitors. So I felt that overlapped a fair amount with my own Attempt at categorization of flourishing.

SPEAKER_01I talked about projects,

SPEAKER_00relationships, and experiences.

SPEAKER_01She draws it a little bit finer. No offense, I like yours, but I also think hers, by drawing it a little more finely.

SPEAKER_00I agree. In particular, she breaks projects up into just achieving something versus being better than somebody.

SPEAKER_01Which is a very big difference in personality type and how you see things.

SPEAKER_00Absolutely. So to get back to kind of the future of employment. So in my book, attempting to sketch out a hopeful future, I sketch out one in which I think employment is significant. Not as big a deal as it is today. Right.

SPEAKER_00That's never been in the cards. I look forward to the possibility of another kind of lifestyle emerging, one that would have to require a cultural break for it to ever get off the ground. It would have to require people really in mass adopting a kind of threshold earners mentality that... That, you know, once I make, I'm going to earn this kind of, you know, standard of living and that standard of living is enough for me and then I'm going to devote my time to other stuff. And I imagine that the technologies that we have going on today,

SPEAKER_00particularly AI, are going to make that available. Sooner rather than later, you know, in the coming decades. Whether people take up on it or not, I don't know. But I think there's at least a possibility of creating a kind of post-mass employment lifestyle that I think can then circle back around and have real resemblances to the old antebellum period, where... There, the Republicans, you know, the early Republican Party Republicans had their ideals.

SPEAKER_01Call it the antebellum period because that sounds like you're talking about the South. Call it the early.

SPEAKER_00Okay. Anyway, pre-Civil War America. So the Republicans, their philosophy was the free labor philosophy. And, of course, that was drawn in stark contrast to slavery. But they also still had the idea. Yeah, that a wage labor was at best semi-free, that he was dependent upon the will of somebody else. So they broke away from that. They said there's a big difference. He can quit and go work for somebody else. And they also said, hey, being subject to the arbitrary will of an Employer sometimes beats the hell out

SPEAKER_00of being subject to the arbitrary will of Mother Nature. So they upgraded employment, but they still saw wage employment and particularly impoverished urban working class as workers. It's something that was Europe's problem, that we were blessed not to have it. And so they liked the idea that employment was just kind of a way station, that you come here, you don't have any skills, you get a job for a little while, you save up some money, then you go out and you open your shop or you start your own farm. So in my 21st century,

SPEAKER_0022nd century version of this, a lot of people worked for a while, but they set up Being a proprietor of their own life or proprietor of their community, which may have a commercial element, but may not.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. So I think, too, if we hadn't made housing so scarce and we hadn't tied health insurance to employment, we would pretty much already be at this stage that you're describing. So I have this hairdresser, who I go to like twice a year, But anyway, she's been working since she was 16. She has a ski clothing line that's totally separate.

SPEAKER_01And for a while, she started a massage place, too. Part of her gimmick was that she hired people who spoke English, but it was very affordable. And she got completely disgusted with these young people who were, I mean, I got a lot of massages from them. They were very good, but they didn't have her work ethic. She said, as long as they have their phone, I think she said their phone and their weed, they're fine. And that's all the money they care about earning. Yeah. I don't know how they live. I mean, this is in LA, but I mean, I don't know where they live.

SPEAKER_01Maybe they live with their parents. But so she was kind of disgusted. But that is a thing. I think the trick in your scenario, I think there are two tricks in your scenario. It could very well be, and it could very well be good. But one is what people do with their time.

SPEAKER_00Yes. Yes.

SPEAKER_01Because, for example, if you say, well, it's really important to have flow, this between boredom and anxiety sense of psychological state. And that is definitely true. That is a big part of flourishing. One of the very best ways is certainly the easiest way, most accessible way for people to have flow is by playing video games. And and when people spend a lot of their time playing video games, even if they play video games with their friends and they people like us go like all these people wasting their lives playing video

SPEAKER_01games.

SPEAKER_00OK, if they're playing with their friends.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. But what if they're playing with their online friends, you know, or whatever?

SPEAKER_00It's a matter of degree. Yeah. It's just a matter of degree. The doughs mix the poison.

SPEAKER_01Right. So that, of course, that's the case with anybody. So that's one thing. And the other thing is, at the risk of being ad hominem, and I don't mean to, but how much of your adult life have you spent self-employed as opposed to on a salary? Yeah, none. Well, let me tell you, it doesn't feel free. It's a constant source of anxiety, right? It is not, I mean, I have more- I'm

SPEAKER_00talking about early retirees mostly, right?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so I like to pretend I'm employed, but I'm really, you know, I can only do like, I don't have- My income suggests otherwise, so let me put it that way. But, you know, I've been self-employed since 2000, except for the three years I spent at the Atlantic where I had a halftime salary and thank God the world's best health insurance because I also had cancer. But you are not in charge of your destiny in some sense. I mean, in the way that people who are not self-employed sort of imagine that you are.

SPEAKER_01You are having to think about, like, what can I do? Who's going to hire me? Where can I, you know, in my case, where can I pitch this? What can I do? But I had, when I first moved into... And the condo that I'm talking to you from in 1992, there was a couple who lived across the way from us where the man was a court reporter and had a court reported business. And the wife used to laugh at people who thought it was so great to have a small business.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so I'm picturing, you know, graduating from pressing economic considerations, right? Not picturing that, you know, cobbling together an Uber gig and a mechanical turk gig makes a good life.

SPEAKER_01Although, you know, but I do think that these gig work kinds of things are a great move in that direction.

SPEAKER_00Free flexibility.

SPEAKER_01Right, right. I mean, I was just... Being driven around on a trip to this conference I mentioned by various, you know, going from the airport to the hotel. And, you know, one guy was retired from an engineering job and he was just like, basically drives Uber because he lives by himself and it's boring otherwise. And he said, I get up, I exercise, and I'll be like, what am I going to do today? Oh, I might as well drive some.

SPEAKER_01He plays golf twice a week, you know.

SPEAKER_00So what do you make of the inordinate pessimism about AI in the United States? And in particular, the pessimism that it's going to make us so rich that we don't have jobs anymore, right?

SPEAKER_01Unclear on the concept, yeah.

SPEAKER_00So that, you know, people are freaked out because they have no idea what they would do with themselves otherwise, which to me indicates that... That we have a lot of kind of social reconstruction to do so that people have an idea of what's important in life other than working for money.

SPEAKER_01Well, I don't think that that's the source of the anxiety around jobs. I think it's much simpler than that. I think people are just afraid of unemployment and not having money.

SPEAKER_00It goes beyond that. There's existential fear of even if there's a UBI, we're all just going to be

SPEAKER_01motivated

SPEAKER_00zombies. Right.

SPEAKER_01It exists, but that is among intellectuals. The general public being afraid about AI and jobs is not like, oh, my God, I'm going to lose my job. What am I going to do all day? Just taking money from the government. I mean, they're worried. Oh, my God, I'm going to lose my job. How am I going to pay my mortgage and my kids' tuition and my health care bills? I mean, I think it's just like the Luddites, the original Luddites. They were not ideologues. They were just people who didn't want to lose their

SPEAKER_00jobs.

SPEAKER_01But they benefited from the earlier wave of spinning machines. Anyway, so I think that it's that.

SPEAKER_00Do you have an intuition? Who knows? It's probably the only honest answer. But do you have an intuition as to whether AI is going to be an engine of income convergence and upgrading the more humbly skilled? Or is it going to be an engine of further... Kind of, you know, inequality that the AI, there's a small group of AI superstars who are enabled to do wonders and everyone else kind of becomes, you know, they've outsourced their brains to Claude and they're way out of them now.

SPEAKER_01I think first we have to think about this, what's already happened pre-AI and why it makes people discontent. We've gone through a long period where the poor got richer, the middle class kind of stayed more or less the same, the upper middle class got richer, and the rich got richer. So basically, you had a lot of people who in the past, like when we were kids, would have been middle class who are now,

SPEAKER_01they still probably think of themselves as middle class, but they're making hundreds of thousands of dollars a year, like $400,000 a year. Buying very expensive homes. And what's happened is People's picture as a result of this, this mass affluence, what used to be a very rarefied lifestyle that did not affect most people's perceptions of what was normal has become a model of what's normal.

SPEAKER_01Normal is going on ski vacations multiple times a year. Normal is taking a year abroad when you're in college.

SPEAKER_00Normal is what I'm seeing on Instagram.

SPEAKER_01Right. Yeah. Normal is what I'm seeing on Instagram, which is glamour. I have a book on that. It doesn't talk about Instagram because it came out too early. But, you know, normal is the lifestyle of people who are in the top 20 percent. Yes. Whereas 50 years ago, normal was the lifestyle of the people who are in the middle 50 percent or 40 percent. It's not that people and so people who are doing fine by any,

SPEAKER_01you know, mid 20th century measure of doing amazing are feel resentful because they're left behind. So that is the background in which we step into this AI thing. And and. So I don't know. I think what will happen is there will be winners and losers, and it's not going to all be skewed one way or the other. There's going to be rearranging. And I think that part of the pessimism today, there are a lot of factors, you know, political polarizations.

SPEAKER_01People just generally feeling out of control, aging society, that sort of thing. But it's also the fact that journalism has been in a depression for 30 years or for at least 25 years. People have, all the people who are telling you these stories have seen their, you know, Friends lose their jobs. They've lost their jobs.

SPEAKER_00From technological progress from the internet.

SPEAKER_01From technological progress. And I would be the last person in the world to say the internet hasn't been wonderful. It's been fantastic. But, you know, it has wreaked havoc with my income. And I'm one of the lucky ones. Part of it because I spent years writing for Bloomberg, which was paywall, but the opinion section was subsidized by the very lucrative Wall Street terminals. But all the people who are writing these stories in

SPEAKER_01the traditional media have seen just absolutely, it's been like being a steelworker in the 80s. And if you're not in it, you can't appreciate how bad it has been. And it's gone on and on and on, also like these sort of rust belt industries. And that flavors the way the news is presented. It's not the obvious thing going on.

SPEAKER_00I think that's fair. I think that's fair.

SPEAKER_01So my intuition- By the way, the big contrast is the way AI is perceived in China. Right. Which is partly a function of government's spin, but not really because the AI companies aren't as controlled by the government and the government's a little, CCP is a little nervous about them. But I think it's because if we'd had AI in 1970 or 1968 or something, Americans would have- Perceived it through the history of all that post-war growth.

SPEAKER_01Yes.

SPEAKER_00That's a completely fair point. So my intuition is that AI is likely to intensify in egalitarian trends. So ever since this transition to a post-industrial service economy, we've had what's called skill-biased technological growth. That is that AI. The technological progress has tended to increase the relative demand for highly skilled workers and reduce the relative demand for less skilled workers. And there are arguments that AI could go another way,

SPEAKER_00that it could offer disproportionate step up to the productivity of the less productive. But my sense is that it's going to turbocharge people at the top. And that a whole lot of people are going to outsource their cognitive abilities to the AI future and are not going to be in a position to be masters AI. There are going to be dependents on it. And my sense is that a whole bunch of current... Kind of middle of the road down to scuddy white collar work is going

SPEAKER_00to get automated and that is going to reduce relative demand for the sort of bottom half of the white collar knowledge worker class. And that, so we, I think our populist, you know, uprising right now is a long brewing process. Reaction to decades of feeling marginalized, both economically and culturally, by the non-college educated class. And these are the least articulate, hardest to organize people, and they are causing a lot of commotion right now.

SPEAKER_00So if a good chunk of the knowledge worker class gets to feeling the same way, then I imagine lots of fireworks politically in the years ahead.

SPEAKER_01Well, I think you're, I mean, I tend to agree with you about sort of low productivity, white collar jobs. The people who, you know, send me, grind out endless stupid press releases and send them to my email box where, you know, because it's, they can just blast emails. Once upon a time, you had to get on the phone and call people up and it was painful on both sides if you weren't interested. And to be honest, I have contempt for these jobs, not for the people.

SPEAKER_01I don't know them, but the jobs are stupid.

SPEAKER_00I do not.

SPEAKER_01And if they go away because of AI or if people are not spending their time making PowerPoints, but using AI. But I think it's more complicated than what you're saying, because first of all, I think I think you're going to see AI empowering people who are now not part of the ladder. And I was just at this conference with musicians.

SPEAKER_01And at one point early on, actually, Charles and I were on a panel with somebody who's a musician and producer and won Grammys, a very big shot. And he's black, which is relevant, because at one point he was trying to say, he says, like, these tools, the people who are like at Princeton are worried about these tools, the people, I don't know what to call urban, you use all these euphemisms, like all these euphemisms. They're, you know, they're embracing them, they're using them, they're doing stuff with them.

SPEAKER_01And I thought, oh, that's interesting.

SPEAKER_00And that's so we could see a big increase in these kind of physical kind of jobs and with some AI packets to make things easier to do the business in. So, yeah.

SPEAKER_01He was talking about musicians, but yeah, I mean, and again, you know, my nephew has his furniture and contracting business. He uses a lot of AI to run his business. There's a lot of this sort of, especially among younger people, turning to it. But you're absolutely right. The people who used to, you know, just do perfunctory music. Write lousy papers and get bees because the professors can't give them what they deserve.

SPEAKER_01We'll now use AI to write lousy papers. And I think eventually that's just going to get weeded out. And I think my college, my prediction, I mean, I don't know, I always hate to make predictions, but is that colleges are going to bifurcate and there's going to be colleges that are about, you Yes,

SPEAKER_00the life of the

SPEAKER_01mind. College for nerds, like life of the mind. And then there's going to be colleges that are basically finishing schools. You go so that you have a social experience between the ages of 18 and 22. So you have a chance to sort of grow up, become an adult in a somewhat protected environment where you have football games and parties and maybe there's some modicum of something that resembles classes, but it's not really pretending to educate you.

SPEAKER_01It's a finishing school.

SPEAKER_00At least in the early 80s was a nice combination of the two, wasn't it?

SPEAKER_01Well, I didn't do much finishing school stuff. I did go to basketball games, but unlike your legendary blow pong skills, I didn't drink really. I come from a long line of teetoglers and I barely drank. And my friend group was mostly people who didn't drink much either. So that's a different experience. But yeah, I mean, I think you're – I have a tendency to think that – and it's not that you won't necessarily have parties and stuff at the ones where it's life of

SPEAKER_01the mind. But you're not going to be pretending that the people who are just there for the football – and I don't mean the athletes – Because the athletes are actually learning stuff, just learning athletics. The people who are just there for the football games are there for something else. Because why should you?

SPEAKER_00I'd like to see that evolution. I think that would be a hopeful turn. With AI generally, I think the only attitude is just... Being very ready to change your mind about stuff as new data comes in. The uncertainty is massive. The possibilities are exhilarating and terrifying. They're not boring. So for people like us, doing our third act in a time of sort of wide open uncertainty is maybe not what we had in mind, but it's not boring.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's not boring.

SPEAKER_00And you're doing your part to interpret what's going on for all of us. And so keep at it. Virginia, we're at the end of our time. So I'm going to wrap things up here. Thank you so much for being on the show. Thanks for listening to The Permanent Problem Podcast. Check out my essays on The Permanent Problem over on Substack, as well as in the Scan and Center website. And be sure to catch all our episodes on Substack, Spotify, Stitcher, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you love tuning in. Until next time, I'm Brink Lindsey, signing off.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Seth Kaplan on fragile neighborhoods and social poverty

    Nov 5, 20261 hr 5 minAudio

    Seth Kaplan had built a career as an expert on “fragile states” - countries plagued by dysfunction and institutional disrepair. But as politics here in the United States plunged into its current time of troubles, Kaplan...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Jonathan Rauch on responding to the crisis of liberalism

    Aug 12, 20261 hr 11 minAudio

    Liberal values and institutions now face aggressive challenges from both right and left extremism, so how should defenders of the embattled liberal center respond? It’s become clear now that the question exposes an...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Phil Levin on living near friends and family

    Jul 23, 20261 hrAudio

    America is experiencing an epidemic of loneliness: marriage and birth rates, the number of close friendships, time spent with friends, and community involvement more broadly are all in decline. Phil Levin, my guest on...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Adrian Wooldridge on liberalism's cycles of crisis and renewal

    Jul 15, 20261 hr 4 minAudio

    In the heady days after the collapse of the Soviet Union, many imagined that we had arrived at the “end of history” now that liberal democratic capitalism had chased all ideological competitors from the field. Just a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Ryan Avent on the power of faith and culture

    Apr 30, 202656 minAudio

    All of the blessings of modernity, Ryan Avent argues in a fascinating new book, rest on faith. It is our faith in others, our ability to trust strangers we will never meet, that makes possible the large-scale...

    Credit the people on this episode