Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The official Ryan McBeth Substack Podcast

The official Ryan McBeth Substack Podcast artwork

Global Warning 38 : Starlink, Strategy, Shutdowns

Nov 22, 202620 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Want to advertise on Global Warning? Contact me and receive a media kit. Intelligence product for paid subscribers at the bottom of the page. This will unlock for free members on Sunday. Or get it from Perks. This economy sucks, so become a paid member for only $2.50. In this episode: * Ukraine seeks alternatives to Starlink and Starshield. * China suffers from peace disease. * Fast-following and the future of warfare. * A look at America’s vulnerable network infrastructure. * Trump’s Asia trip, Iranian dams, and the UK cozies up to the EU again. Free members can listen to Global Warning every Sunday on: Spotify Apple Podcasts And YouTube Intelligence briefing below: This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit ryanmcbeth.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01How do you make an engineer cry in just five words? We tested it in production. Yes, many of those cyber outages last week likely came from engineers pushing out software updates due to the rush in fixing software before the debut of Grand Theft Auto 6 and the Thanksgiving holiday because people are going to be taking off and we'll have less coverage. So I'd like to thank the three people who are listening to this episode right now. I couldn't do it without you. In this episode of Global Warning, I discuss Ukraine seeks alternatives to Starlink and Starshield.

SPEAKER_01China suffers from peace disease, fast following, and the future of warfare. A look at America's vulnerable network infrastructure. And finally, three stories to keep on your radar this week. Trump's Asia trip, the reason behind all these unnecessary Iranian dams, and the United Kingdom cozies up to the European Union again.

SPEAKER_02Let's get started. As we know, there are known knowns. There are things we know we know. We also know there are known unknowns. That is to say, we know there are some things we do not know. There are also unknown unknowns. The ones we don't know, we don't know.

SPEAKER_00Global Warning with Ryan McBeth.

SPEAKER_01This is Global Warning's 36th episode. Global Warning is your trusted source for intelligence and expert analysis. Now, if you enjoyed this content, consider subscribing to my Substack at ryanmcbeth.substack.com. Hey, look, it's only $2.50 a month. The best deal you can find online, original content, in-depth research, professional-looking videos. Thank you, Gary. Intelligence and cybersecurity. And it's way cheaper than replacing that server the IT department has on life support right now. Hey, funny story about that. Twitter once had this little iMac mini that became critical infrastructure almost by accident.

SPEAKER_01An engineer named Brady Catherman originally set it up to provide a secure tunnel into Twitter's administrative tools. It was a quick fix, and it worked. And the more internal services started depending on this little iMac server that was in a closet. Now, eventually, the IT department was cleaning out a closet. They found this computer with no useful label. Ownership information. And their troubleshooting strategy was just to disconnect it and see who complained. And almost every internal service went dark. Engineers lost access to tools like Git, which is a software repository, and Jira,

SPEAKER_01which is a tool that allows you to do production planning. And Katherman, he sprinted to the closet and he found the Ethernet cable unplugged and he reconnected it. And he restored access. And I'll tell you this, nothing is more permanent than a temporary solution that hasn't broken yet. You know, that story wasn't even in the script. See all this extra content you get on Global Warning. So let's get to the first story. Ukraine looks to lessen its use of Starlink and Starshield.

SPEAKER_01Reports are coming in, again, that Starlink and Starshield access for Ukrainians is being throttled. This issue has been known to Ukrainians who become painfully In fact, a 2025 Wired magazine article suggested that Ukrainians need to find better alternatives that don't rely on Starlink or Starshield satellite networks for connectivity. That same Wired article mentioned Amazon Leo, Iris 2, and even OneWeb, all of which face serious limitations in coverage and usability

SPEAKER_01in places like Ukraine. Starlink and its military equivalent, Starship, have proven hard to replace for a reason. As the world's largest communication satellite network, Starlink can typically support high-speed internet and data streams for any user or vehicle with a relatively compact Starlink terminal. The combination of satellite network coverage and easy-to-use terminals has allowed Ukrainians to keep communications going for civilian and military purposes. The Ukrainians even have used their network to manage their air defense and strikes

SPEAKER_01of Russian targets. And I know, I know, the tech bros are going to come out and be like, but they violated the terms of service agreement on their Starlink. I don't know why they all sound like that, but they do. But saying that is like saying they're giving out speeding tickets at a NASCAR race for driving fast. I think that that little section in Starlink's terms of service is legalistic language designed to set parameters so Starlink doesn't get sued if some rebels use Starlink to control a flying bomb and cause mass casualties. Ukraine has been using Starlink in violations of those terms of service for years.

SPEAKER_01It's only recently become an issue. Interestingly here, while Elon Musk worries about the non-existent nuclear exchange between the US and Russia, his competitors seem to be salivating at the opportunity to provide internet access to countries like Ukraine. In fact, HughesNet, also known as EchoStar, might be looking into jumping into the fray. According to Ukrainian Pravda, USAT, or Ukraine Satellite Initiative, has signed an agreement with satellite provider HughesNet, allowing them to provide subleasing services.

SPEAKER_01In the future, with a large number of clients, USAT could rent transponders as part of a satellite communications system. EU-TELSAT, which operates one web, only offers around 600 satellites for coverage compared with Starlink's over 10,000 satellites. The Iris II constellation is due to become fully operational in 2029 with 300 satellites. Another potential solution comes from Orbanano, which is intended to be operated and maintained by Ukrainians to ensure it meets its most fundamental needs.

SPEAKER_01The Constellation here is a joint venture between Gomspace of Denmark and Hymera, which comes from Ukraine. Hymera and Gomspace also envision eventually producing spacecraft and ground terminals within Ukraine. Ironically, there's a lot of ironies here. The Constellation was launched into space aboard a SpaceX craft. Ukraine has even signed letters of intent with Nokia and IceEye, which produces satellites. The whole affair is slowly waking up to the Europeans, who fear that they are quite dependent on American satellite space capabilities.

SPEAKER_01And are also reliant on American defensive stocks for its own air defenses. Europe lacks a deep stock of long range land attack munitions and also lacks long range air defense systems with anti ballistic missile capability for land attack. Europe still mostly relies on the United States and its Tomahawk cruise missiles for air defense, American made Patriot. And THAAD or Terminal High Altitude Air Defense batteries and the Standard Missile or SM3 batteries provide the largest measure of coverage.

SPEAKER_01The Europeans are scrambling to plug a gunshot wound here left by a mercurial tech bro and possibly a president whose own policies are coming under fire across America. Ukrainians will likely benefit from the Euros sloshing around and the telecommunications solutions that are yet to come, but they will be slow to materialize, and Ukraine needs this stuff now. The Ukrainians are trying to replace their dependence on Starlink and Starshield with more reliable technologies, and one technology that is somewhat more reliable is

SPEAKER_01a cell phone LTE modem called Grim, which is supposed to help control drones without worrying about speed throttling, but even this feels like a band-aid at the moment. So why does this matter? Starlink and Starshield are once again losing connectivity on equipment moving over 100 miles an hour, nearly three weeks after experiencing a similar connectivity gap. Soldier in the trenches might not notice this, but a drone speeding through the air certainly notices this right away. While it seems like the whims of a billionaire could be used to quiet U.S.

SPEAKER_01policy and squeeze Ukraine, That is certainly a frightening outcome, the idea that an independent person could influence U.S. policy. Nobody seems to own the switch that throttles Internet access, and that's what makes this such a problematic development. The president has been loud about his intent to restore the strategic balance between Russia and Europe, and Musk appears to support this even if he does so in a roundabout legal way, and now everyone else is watching.

SPEAKER_01Any government that has wired its military into American commercial space has just learned that access can be dialed down mid-war by people who won't explain themselves. And this is why the European scramble isn't only industrial policy, it's a credibility problem for the United States as an ally. And if you're walking the dog, it's time to turn around. Next, China's peace disease and Taiwan. The Chinese have determined this peace disease. It's something that afflicts their military and command structure. The country hasn't fought an actual war since 1979.

SPEAKER_01A recent support by the Center for Strategic and International Studies challenges whether the People's Liberation Army or PLA can handle future conflicts. The report concedes that China could handle short, pre-planned military operations close to its homeland, But as conflicts become longer, further away, and messier, the PLA's capabilities begin to break down. The report authors aren't asking whether the Chinese have the military kit needed to fight a war. They clearly have some good equipment. China now builds 53.3% of the world's commercial ships compared

SPEAKER_01with America at 0.1%. That's not a typo. We've seen overestimations before as well. Plenty of defense analysts argue that before Ukraine, the Russians had a formidable, modernized defense establishment. Turns out that was all smoke and mirrors. So CSIS is looking at the PLA's weak points to kind of tease out new insights into how the organization might hold up in a fight with, let's say, the United States. The team that authored the report held discussions with more than 100 officials

SPEAKER_01from the United States, Australia, India, Japan, the Philippines, and Taiwan, including pilots, sailors, and soldiers who have dealt with the PLA at sea, in the air, and on the Sino-Indian border. What did these guys find? Well, the PLA is great at following the script. It's a lot less great When the script catches fire. And in wartime, the script catches fire. Operators told CSIS that PLA pilots, surface commanders, and ground officers are comfortable working from scripts but can freeze up and seek leadership guidance when an adversary does something unexpected.

SPEAKER_01Part of the problem is that every PLA unit has two bosses, a military commander and a political commissar, and they both have equal authority. When they disagree, there's no clear tiebreaker except for kicking it up to higher headquarters where, you guessed it, there's two more bosses. On a PLA submarine, the political commissar is the captain's co-equal. Now imagine needing that sign-off when someone's trying to sink you. Then there's the purges and Boy, there's a lot of purges. Between January 2022 and February 2026,

SPEAKER_01101 officers who served on the Central Military Commission, or CMC, at Theater Command or Deputy Command grade were purged or went missing. All four of the Rocket Force's past commanders have been removed. Even CMC Vice Chair Zhang Yusia is on the list of generals accused of undermining the President Xi Jinping's chairman responsibility system. The PLA Daily mentioned that system about 331 times a year on average from 2012 to 2025. Before 2012, it showed up less than once a year.

SPEAKER_01And then there is corruption, a Chinese Major General said in 2015 that the PLA had going rates and price tags for promotion. Training exercises get trimmed and shaped to please visiting brass, which the report calls bonsai exercises. And that's bonsai as in like trimming little bonsai tree. The PLA's fix here is to put party discipline inspectors into training evaluations and even operational planning. And one staff sergeant's reaction says it all. You're attending the operational planning meeting too?

SPEAKER_01I know someone's going to say, but the U.S. military has problems too. Yeah, it does. CSIS says so. Every military would struggle in a high-end war against a major power, and China is no different. But here's where the report gets really useful. The PLA's weaknesses depend on what kind of war it fights. A blockade of Taiwan run mostly with long-range missiles from in or near Chinese territory plays to the PLA's strengths. Everything can be planned centrally and coordinated from theater command. An invasion is the opposite. Ships and troops are strung out across the Taiwan Strait.

SPEAKER_01Communications get spotty. Junior officers have to improvise across service lines. And they're doing this against a defender who's actively wrecking PLA command and control. CSIS says this puts almost the maximum possible stress on Chinese jointness. CSIS also thinks the PLA won't freeze as much as script harder. It points to Iraq in 1988, which retook the Alfal Peninsula with offenses scripted by its general staff. And that worked right up until the Iranian ambushes and counterattacks broke the script.

SPEAKER_01So what does CSIS want Washington to do about it? Well, we need to hit PLA command nodes in wartime. We need to build up a lot of cheap underwater drones, spread US and allied bases across both island chains, and convince Beijing that a war won't stay inside the Taiwan Strait. It also wants information operations that drive a wedge between One Chinese military scholar quoted in the report is already worrying about the long list of U.S. bases as targets. The DF-26 missile has a long production cycle so it can't be quickly replaced once a war starts.

SPEAKER_01Now, a little cold water here. The report is about weakness by design. Beijing gets to choose the war it fights. If the PLA does best in short scripted close-to-home operations, guess what kind of operations China is going to pick. So why does this matter? Most talk about China's military focuses on counting hulls and jets and missiles, and that's the easy part. The hard part is what the PLA can use them when the plan is set on fire. And that's good news and bad news. The good news is that an invasion of Taiwan would be brutally hard for the PLAs

SPEAKER_01to pull off. The bad news is que Beijing knows this as well. Expect it to lean on what it does well, blockades, missile strikes on fixed targets, pressure campaigns. That way they can stay on script. And there is a deterrence lesson here. The more Beijing believes the war could spread beyond the Taiwan Strait, the more reluctant it may be to start one. And that does cut both ways. China may have more than 1,000 operational nuclear warheads by 2030, and it is likely moving toward launch on warning. So threatening to wage war against that kind of arsenal is not free.

SPEAKER_01While Chairman Xi Jinping is still purging his top generals, it's hard to know whether the PLA's new leadership would fight, and that uncertainty is exactly what makes us so dangerous right now. Next, fast following creates new battlefield paradigm. A rather interesting idea is making the rounds in defense analyst circles, thanks to Mick Ryan, who called this fast following. An advantage can sometimes go to whoever moves first, but there is a complementary and often more decisive approach, fast following, which is the deliberate practice of letting an adversary absorb the cost and risk

SPEAKER_01of a new idea, then copying and improving it faster than they can. The idea was inspired by something found in business. Fast followers typically fail less than first movers, and this could be used to the advantage of many militaries worldwide, including the United States and its allies and partners. A fast follower watches closely what works, then enters the market at speed with an improved version. Fast following works best where imitation cycles are short and copying is cheap in conditions that hold in only a few commercial sectors, but You know,

SPEAKER_01this actually accurately describes a modern battlefield. Fast following has become increasingly apparent in the Russo-Ukraine War, where everything from drones to electronic warfare has changed at breakneck speed. In a recent CSIS report, McRyan suggested the Western military institutions do the following. Number one... 1. Build intermediaries linking users, industry, and procurement. 2. Create rapid acquisition pathways that trade technical risks for speed. 3. Systematically study foreign wars. 4. Learn directly from combat experienced partners such as Ukraine.

SPEAKER_01Number five, establish doctrinal laboratories. Number six, measure the demonstration to adoption gap. Number seven, reward leaders who adapt and emulate. And number eight, preserve exploration alongside a fast following. So why does this matter? You know, the United States and other militaries want to avoid the slow grind to nowhere. That is face the Russians in Ukraine. And to do this, the United States and other Western militaries need to fold in fast following into their institutional learning. However, as Mick Ryan notes, fast following is not a simple process.

SPEAKER_01Much like other learning and adaption processes, it requires resourcing and institutional buy-in and good leadership. But it is an important complement to the internal innovation and learning systems of a military institution. Next, America's vulnerable network infrastructure is coming into the limelight. A string of technological failures across the United States has highlighted just how vulnerable the country is to cyber threats. Corgi Global recently released a report highlighting 12 major lessons learned from these events that may prove useful to industry leaders and policymakers.

SPEAKER_01And here's some of the highlights. Number one, a real highlight threat to American security here is the change in pipelines, contractors, and maintenance windows. Modernization seams are very soft, meaning the Federal Aviation Administration is running copper and fiber side by side without fully understanding technology. A single route can cause nationwide outages, and this one bug at Microsoft affected 74 countries. This shows that Chinese, Russians, Iranians, and North Koreans only need to target a few nodes to have a huge impact.

SPEAKER_01Outages, putting networks at a greater risk of attack. And back -to -back failures give adversaries the cover they need for fake claims of responsibility or real attacks disguised as ordinary system false. Disclosure, which required an open and free society becomes free reconnaissance for adversaries. So why does this matter? I mean, now everyone's watching. Beijing, Moscow, Tehran, Pyongyang—they just got a free demonstration of how U .S. infrastructure fails, How far the damage spreads and how long recovery takes. If China is already pre-positioned in the U.S.

SPEAKER_01infrastructure, as the U.S. government has warned since Volt Typhoon, this shows what a 24- to 72-hour disruption could look like during a Taiwan crisis. And finally, three stories to keep on your radar. President Trump is in Asia this week for high-level talks. Many worry that President Trump's midterm losses could undermine his ability to produce anything during these talks. I've added a link to the Associated Press article in the Global Warning Intelligence Briefing For you all to check out if you want to follow the story, you can find that briefing at ryanmcbeth.substack.com.

SPEAKER_01Another story from the New York Times caught my attention this week. It offers a tenuous relationship between Iran's numerous and unnecessary dam projects and its secretive nature concerning its own missile and nuclear ambitions. While speculative, this article offers some insights into the Iranian regime. And the link again is in the companion briefing. Finally, it looks like the United Kingdom might be cozying up for the European Union again as Brexit hasn't exactly paid off for the British government or its people. Will this mean the UK jumps into the EU? No. It's hard to say here, but it does show that we're living

SPEAKER_01in interesting times linked to the Economist article in the companion briefing as well. Thank you for listening. New episodes of Global Warning appear weekly at ryanmcbeth.substack.com, where you can also find the companion intelligence briefing. So it's exciting in this episode's companion intelligence briefing using active and embedded links to ensure transparency and replications. [music]

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. UKRAINES HUMILIATES PUTIN AGAIN WHILE AT HIS FAILED YALTA SUMMIT - w/ Ryan McBeth

    Nov 19, 202658 minAudio

    Thank you KRZ, Jeff Zekas, Me By The Sea, Kathy Swinson, Sebast, and many others for tuning into my live video with Pyotr Kurzin! Join me for my next live video in the app. This is a public episode. If you'd like to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Global Warning 37 : Silk, Sanctions Survival

    Nov 15, 202621 minAudio

    Want to advertise on Global Warning? Contact me and receive a media kit. Intelligence product for paid subscribers at the bottom of the page. This will unlock for free members on Sunday. Or get it from Perks. This...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Global Warning 36: Chokepoints, Coercion, Chaos

    Nov 8, 202617 minAudio

    Want to advertise on Global Warning? Contact me and receive a media kit. Intelligence product for paid subscribers at the bottom of the page. This will unlock for free members on Sunday. Or get it from Perks. This...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. What the New Congress Means for America’s Military

    Nov 5, 202619 minAudio

    This video is free for all members. Please consider supporting my work for only $2.50. A submarine waiting for repairs doesn’t become combat-ready because somebody gave a good speech. It needs skilled workers, spare...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Global Warning 35: Money, Munitions, MacGyver

    Nov 1, 202628 minAudio

    Want to advertise on Global Warning? Contact me and receive a media kit. Intelligence product for paid subscribers at the bottom of the page. This will unlock for free members on Sunday. Or get it from Perks. This...

    Credit the people on this episode