Thank you KRZ, Jeff Zekas, Me By The Sea, Kathy Swinson, Sebast, and many others for tuning into my live video with Pyotr Kurzin! Join me for my next live video in the app. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit ryanmcbeth.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Hello, everyone. Welcome back to another live stream here on Substack and YouTube with everyone's favorite, how to say, lively expert audience. It's Ryan McBeth. We're rejoined by Ryan for another breakdown of some of the more technical and structural sides. I think in this case, military says, Ryan, let's just jump straight into it. We're right on the end of this Yalta Conference 2.0. What a day. New world order.
SPEAKER_01Everything's changed forevermore.
SPEAKER_00It's like the Timu version of Yalta. This is not the Yalta I ordered. You got President Trump. It was like watching the human centipede, right? You got President Trump up Putin's ass. You got Putin up Xi's ass. And it's the weirdest damn thing. Like, how did we get here? But this isn't Yalta. This is not Yalta, man.
SPEAKER_00It's Yalta. And look, I think it would probably be a good idea to have generally fewer nuclear weapons, right? Like it probably wouldn't be a bad idea to do a start to nuclear weapon, trilateral nuclear weapon deal between Russia, China and the United States. China is going to have about a thousand nuclear warheads by 2030. And, you know, that. It would be nice to get the world inventory of nuclear warheads down
SPEAKER_00to whatever we might need to blow up an asteroid or something. I'm not a nuclear asteroid redirection expert here, but I assume you might use that or maybe just push against it if you can get it out long enough, right? But Noble Gold, but they met for an hour. Yalta was like eight days.
SPEAKER_01No, no, no, 90 minutes. Don't undermine it, Ryan. It was 90 minutes, of which a good 15 was public statements of everything that we could have interpreted. And also Stalin had controlled half of Europe by the point they met in Yalta and Putin can't even control it. There are a little bit of some differences there. That's a bit awkward, I guess. No, I can't. I'll stop joking around. I can't find it funny enough that the fact that this was Putin's idea,
SPEAKER_01Putin's proposal, and it was so embarrassing, most of all, I think, for him. You know, obviously the Russian government will frame it as being a high degree of success, but he was snubbed by Xi in the greetings.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it was the if you look at the protocol they did, the order, like I guess President Trump was on she's right. And then Putin was next to she's wife, which I guess is like somebody has to be on a different side. Right. But the fact that Trump was on the side of honor is kind of a telling thing. Right. Like someone has to choose. Where that where they where they go.
SPEAKER_00And, you know, I think that it's I almost feel like in some ways Russia is a vassal to China. And I mean, if you want to look at manufacturing. We're kind of a vassal to China in that sense, right? I mean, it's where we buy a lot of our crap. I mean, not this shirt. I mean, this shirt was made in the USA, although I believe the Nicaragua actually made the actual shirt, but it's printed in the USA. But, you know,
SPEAKER_00when you look at the relationship, the trade relationship, right? Like, essentially... Russia sends China cheap oil, and China sends Russia components, dual-use components, to continue their war, whereas we still buy cheap crap from China. And what do we actually export to China? Pork. Now, China actually owns, I think it's Smithfield.
SPEAKER_00I want to say, I believe it's the Smithfield pork producer. I think it produces about 20% of the pork in the United States. I'm doing this off the top of my head, so I could be wrong. But, you know, that would be kind of interesting if the U.S. turns into China's, you know, little agricultural center and, you know, we exist by buying cheap crap from them.
SPEAKER_01Well, I think it was also embarrassing because she greeted Trump at the plane, which he's never done before for any world leader. Putin got some lowly Chinese official. That was it last night. Despite their special relationship, the big brother, little brother, it's actually she likes his counterpart. Maybe he doesn't like short people. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00You know, I wonder if you did a If you did a poll, that's actually a really good question. I wonder if world leaders tend to be taller,
SPEAKER_01you know, on average.
SPEAKER_00I wonder what the average height of a man is. What is the average height of a global leader? That's a really good question. I wonder if...
SPEAKER_01I think it tends to be short. I think it tends to be pretty average, maybe a little bit taller. People like people in power who demonstrate leadership, control, posture. I mean, unless they are an incredible thinker or strategist like Napoleon, although he was average age height for his time.
SPEAKER_00I wish I was a little bit taller. I wish I was a baller. I wish I had a girl in the hood. I would call her.
SPEAKER_01Beautiful. You're too young for that, I guess. Well, it just makes me think of GTA 6, which I should definitely be playing as well. Maybe we should do a stream of us gaming GTA 6 sometime.
SPEAKER_00You know, I wonder if you can smoke cigars indoors in GTA 6. Is that one of the crimes you can commit? Because I would definitely be doing that. That's, you know, that's certainly a crime. I'm smoking my gas tank. I wonder if.
SPEAKER_01I'm currently in Cyprus and they don't give a shit about smoking or anything like that. But okay, let's talk about then the Kirks Bridge because that was what I was particularly interested to have your thoughts on. You made a video a few days ago about how you got the Kirks Bridge wrong.
SPEAKER_00Why? Yeah, so it's kind of like one of those things where You might predict, well, my wife and I are never going to get a divorce. And then aliens invade and the aliens use a mind control ray to make all women hate their husbands. And then you get a divorce and you're like, man, didn't count on the aliens, right? If all things were kind of moving forward normally. Then I think that prediction would have held true.
SPEAKER_00So back in 2022, Ukraine did not have any long-range cruise missiles. They had Tachkiyu. No, they had not Tachkiyu. They had, I can't remember the damn name of the ballistic missile they had. But they had some ballistic missiles, some short-range ballistic missiles. And they also had... Su-24s, which were fighter bombers that could theoretically be used to attack the bridge with gravity bombs, you know,
SPEAKER_00large Fab 500 gravity bombs to collapse the Kirk Strait Bridge. Now, in the five years, almost five years since then, Ukraine has developed a domestic arms industry. They've developed remote-controlled drones. They've developed underwater drones. They've developed jet skis with bombs on them. And finally, they developed cruise missiles with massive warheads. I think the Flamenco has a 1 ,500 -pound warhead. Again, I'm doing this from memory.
SPEAKER_00The Flamenco cruise missile, I want to say it's a 1,500-kilo warhead, which means it's, what, like 3,000 pounds, something like that? That is an insane amount of warheads. I know that the war out on the flamenco is larger than the Americans' 1,000-pound tomahawk. So it took Ukraine five years to get to the point where they could develop the kind of weaponry that was needed to take out the bridge.
SPEAKER_00And you would have to have a crystal ball to predict that. But bridges traditionally are very difficult to hit. They're usually well defended. They're designed not to collapse in the first place. And if you saw pictures of the Curt Strait Bridge, Russia had radar reflectors there. That way, any missile coming in that was using active radar would hit these radar reflectors and be dazzled and maybe go off on the wrong course. So now you had to have this confluence of some sort of guidance system.
SPEAKER_00Could have been AI that was using cameras. To look for a specific span or look for a specific support. And that tech just didn't really exist in 2022. Ukraine had to invent the tech and wait for some of the tech to catch up in order to develop the systems it needed to destroy this bridge. I never thought they would be able to do it. And also, here's the other thing. I've talked about this before at the bridge. While them hitting the bridge is an incredible accomplishment,
SPEAKER_00I actually believe Operation Spiderweb was the greater accomplishment. Operation Spiderweb being the effort to knock out Russia's strategic bombers that were firing cruise missiles into Ukraine. I say that because I've often said, shoot the archer, not the arrow. But if you're really smart, you shoot the Fletcher. You shoot the guy who's making the arrows. And right now Ukraine is getting bombarded by Russian cruise missiles,
SPEAKER_00Russian ballistic missiles, and Russian drones. To me, the targets they really should be after are those missile manufacturing sites. Now that being said, for every missile you fire at that bridge, that is one less missile that you can destroy a factory with. And I'm sure there's going to be plenty of Ukrainians who are looking at their phone and smiling in the cold and the dark looking at footage of that bridge.
SPEAKER_00But hitting that bridge doesn't help keep the lights on in Kiev. Now, there are other strategic advantages, such as destroying that bridge means Russia has to spend more resources. There's about 2 million or so people in Crimea, maybe 1.9 million people. They all have to be fed. They all need water. They all need fuel. It's a state the size of Massachusetts, or I guess Wales, roughly.
SPEAKER_00So you have all these people packed into that peninsula. And the only way out is through that corridor in Zaporizhia or a ferry. Now you got a heck of a lot of trouble because supplies are only going to be able to come in through ferry or through any kind of road or rail network that's monitored by Ukraine, who's actively launching drones against it. And Ukraine is launching drones into the Sea of Azov, blowing up ships. You couldn't pay me to get on a ferry to cross the Kerch Strait.
SPEAKER_00So yeah, it could cause Russia to... Push more resources into Crimea, which means they're weaker in other places. And Russia might actually, and I don't want to say this is the scary part, but the other part is Russia could evacuate Crimea. They could say, you know what? And yeah, it's nice to imagine the authoritarian state, you know, Putin will twirl his non-existent mustache and go, I don't care about those 2 million people. I mean, he doesn't. But a state can't let 2 million people starve.
SPEAKER_00They would have to either bring food in or evacuate those people from Crimea. If you evacuate people from Crimea, now Ukraine actually has a bigger problem in the sense that Russia isn't pushing resources toward there. So, I don't know. There's good and bad in this, but it's done. Ultimately, strategically, I think it's probably a strategic win for Ukraine, but how much at the expense of how many Factories that could have been destroyed because we're never going to know the number of missiles they had to fire
SPEAKER_00at that bridge that were intercepted and could have been used for something else.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, interesting. So you, yeah, but isn't this one of the most important strikes just for exposing Russia's, well, facade, right? So this is, well, according to one guest I had on earlier, The Konstantin of Inside Russia. This is the second most heavily defended site outside of Putin's palaces, residence, whatever. Moreover, the fact that it's causing huge issues now for Crimea and access there,
SPEAKER_01let alone the symbolism. Isn't that making it, doesn't that make it worth it?
SPEAKER_00I mean, that's, so I don't have access to the intelligence that the Ukrainians have. And from an egg on the face standpoint, it's a great political win. When you look at the Doolittle Raid, I don't know if you're familiar with the Doolittle Raid. After Pearl Harbor, we put a bunch of B-25s No, B -25s on an aircraft carrier. We stripped everything out of these planes, and they only carried like four bombs.
SPEAKER_00And the idea was, we're going to strike at the heart of Japan and let them know they're not untouchable. And the mission, if you want to get technical, was a complete failure. These planes, they were designed to ditch in China. There was no going back to the carrier. A lot of these planes crashed. There were a couple of survivors. And ultimately, they dropped a couple bombs. Onto selected targets in China. Now, it let the Japanese know, hey, you're not untouchable.
SPEAKER_00We will reach out and touch you. You touched our boats. Don't touch our boats. But at the end of the day, it was a propaganda victory for the U.S., which could be nice. But there was no actual strategic value to doing it. There was a propaganda value, which could be useful. But again, my fear is that what's the propaganda value? You have people sitting in the dark in Ukraine on their phones smiling, but the heat is off and the lights are off.
SPEAKER_00But they get to look at a picture of a bridge on their phone. Now, there might be some leaders in Europe who are going, you know, oh, my God, they did it. Maybe they are winning. Maybe we should give them more stuff. And there is certainly an advantage to looking like you're winning and accomplishing such a difficult feat and then holding your hand out and saying, please, may you loan us some more money so we can finish the fight.
SPEAKER_00And also, when you look at the timing of this strike with the Malta-like, the Timu-Malta-like conference, Inside, you know, in Xinjiang, China, you know, Putin has to walk off that plane knowing that a bunch of rebels blew up as, not rebels, I shouldn't say it like that, a bunch of Ukrainians blew up his bridge. And everybody knows it, but nobody's going to talk about it, right? You know, it's like the guy who's going to the Christmas party and he lost his job
SPEAKER_00the week before and you got to like handle that guy with kid gloves. Don't tell, don't ask Steve about work. Don't ask Putin about the bridge. Right. So it's kind of embarrassing, but ultimately from a strategic standpoint, I don't think it prevents any missiles from being launched to Ukraine, which I believe is a bigger threat than what that bridge represented.
SPEAKER_01Can't say you're going to be very popular amongst some of the hosting community, Ryan.
SPEAKER_00I think a lot of people will disagree with you on that. They're welcome to disagree with me. You know, look, that's that's you have a bunch of analysts and this is one of the things I get paid to do. I get paid actual money and people ask me for their advice. And I say, well, here is my assessment based on this. And I think if I were whispering into Zelensky's ear, I probably would have told him, hey, look, I know the footage from hitting some of these factories.
SPEAKER_00Isn't going to be great because nobody's recording a factory in the Urals that gets blown up. But if we blow up this factory, then they'll have a harder time making missiles. However, if you go towards the route of blowing up this bridge, I mean, yeah, you're going to get some great footage and people are going to share it on Twitter. But ultimately, it doesn't prevent the main problem, which is the blackouts in Kyiv. Shoot the archer, not the arrow. Shoot the fletcher, not the archer.
SPEAKER_00So, I mean, we can disagree. It's fine to disagree. Ultimately, it's the political leader that makes the decision.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, I'm just reading through some of the comments. Some people think, don't worry, it's nothing too bad, but some people think you know your technical stuff, but they don't agree with you on the strategic implications. They don't have to do that. Like I said, they're totally allowed to do that.
SPEAKER_00But from a strategic or an operational sense, what's more important right now? And could this attack have come in the spring when the consequences of having the power out in Kyiv is less severe during the spring than it is during the winter? If Zelensky was asking me for advice, I'd probably say, let's hit the freaking missile factories first.
SPEAKER_00Keep the bridge until spring. But ultimately, it's the political leader that makes that decision. My job is to get them all that information so they can make the very best decision.
SPEAKER_01I think people, yeah, I think part of the reason why people think it's effective is because it's, you did it right on, they did it right on the, on the, Eve of this Yalta meeting, Putin is the one that pushed for this meeting. Putin is The One That Has Been Now Louding About How Successful It Is and Yalta is the place where the original 45 conference occurred and yet they've struck the bridge that connects his beloved Crimea to Mother Russia so I think people really are putting emphasis This is on the symbolism of the strike
SPEAKER_01and how much that's going to be a boost for morale.
SPEAKER_00Which is great, But I can't heat Keeve with symbolism. I can't put a bunch of symbolism in a boiler and light it on fire and make sure my people have heat and electricity. But that's, you know, again, that's the president's choice. And the president may have said, you know what? If we take out this bridge, it's going to be a big deal. And we might get more funding from the EU, more weapons from the EU. And ultimately, it's going to be worth it.
SPEAKER_00But that is the choice that the president makes.
SPEAKER_01And so, I mean, it goes further, though, because we're just talking about the event itself. But there's obviously plenty of aftermath, and I haven't seen too much satellite image.
SPEAKER_00There's been no satellite, zero satellite images, because the companies won't sell to us anymore. There's usually a blackout period now. Which sucks. You just, you can't get good information. At the start of the war, I could pay $250, get a good satellite image. Some cases, synthetic aperture radar. And now, like, we got, we got bupkis. You know, we got nothing.
SPEAKER_01Well, I was just, I was more interested on specifically just like, you know, everyone's, Russia says they'll rebuild it.
SPEAKER_00Right? They're just going to be good luck.
SPEAKER_01Well that's my point. Doesn't that offer a huge logistical issue? Like, how the hell are you going to rebuild a bridge this big, this extensive and for this long if you can construct it again?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's a huge logistical issue if you choose to do it, right? Because when you're doing project management, do nothing is always one of those options. And if Russia decides, you know what, we're going to try to supply Crimea via ferry or we're going to evacuate Crimea, put all those people someplace else inside Russia, which does have a cost. And again, remember... Crimea is the size roughly of Massachusetts or Wales, right? They have their own food production.
SPEAKER_00They have their own source of water. The big source of water was the Dnieper River, which Ukraine dammed. Ukraine essentially shut off when Russia took Crimea. But you have to look at those choices, and Russia could look at Crimea and go, you know what? We're not going to build the bridge again. It's a huge waste of resources. It's going to take five years to fabricate the arch and float it in place. We're going to have to do it under combat conditions.
SPEAKER_00Now, in a case like that, I mean, sooner or later, the world is going to forget about that bridge, right? And now you can move those resources that you were going to use toward rebuilding that bridge and put them toward more missile production, right? If you have a finite amount of steel, you can put those steel into girders. You can put those steel into missiles. And if you decide not to rebuild that bridge, yeah, I mean, you might lose your crown jewel of Crimea and you're going to have to evacuate people. But now you have more steel to put into missiles that are going to pound Ukraine.
SPEAKER_00So that's actually the scary thing, isn't what if Russia tries to rebuild the bridge, but what if they don't? What if they don't try to rebuild the bridge and they decide to evacuate Crimea? And now it's essentially off the board. As a place of strategic importance that has to be very well defended because there's civilians there and infrastructure there. If you remove all the people, nay, I just have a bunch of farmland.
SPEAKER_00I mean, you might have some troops there. You lose a vital staging ground. You lose a vital. Actually, you'd probably still launch missiles from there. Yeah, I would still launch missiles from Crimea. But the scary part is taking people out. And now you don't have to worry about that. What was that book? Shoot. World War Z. Did I ever read World War Z? Or is it called The Rediker Plan? Where they left some cities. There's a zombie attack. They left some cities intact.
SPEAKER_00And they supplied those cities knowing that those people were going to die. But giving them supplies because it drew the zombies away. Right? So right now, you have people in Crimea. Take the people out of Crimea. Not really much to defend. Now you can move some of those resources into other places. So there's good and bad with these strikes.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, there are. I've just seen a message from someone asking what I think about Eldridge Colby at the Berlin Talks. I think he's a wanker. And I think he's a wanker because I met him and he was a wanker. I'm not saying I had a long conversation with him on extended exposure, but I just remember a couple of years ago, it was before he had influences, but he was appearing at think tanks. I would go to think tanks and I'd speak to people or ask questions. And I remember asking a question and the way he framed the response.
SPEAKER_01I think there was a video of it somewhere on mine. He was just a Just condescending and to the point where I even interjected to sort of push back and it was just frowned upon. Anyway. Who are you referring to? Eldridge Colby.
SPEAKER_00Oh, that guy.
SPEAKER_01The way he behaved at the Berlin talks, the Berlin appearance earlier today, yesterday, whenever it was. He's just a, I don't like him. I think I had an openness to consider him or his perspective, you know, maybe to be hawkish on certain foreign policy issues, but I just think he's a bit of a... I just think he's a worse reflection of the Trump administration.
SPEAKER_00He's a relatively competent policy guy, but... He has this hatred for Ukraine. I can't figure this out. Supposedly, there is a rumor going around Washington that he was the guy that essentially stopped sending things like mortar rounds over to Ukraine back when, I guess it was at the start of the Trump administration. I don't know if you remember this or not, but we suddenly cut off all aid to them.
SPEAKER_00And nobody knew who had done it, and it was reinstated within eight hours or something. But that was one of those things that supposedly it was Elbridge Colby who did that, and he was doing it because, oh, we're doing this pivot. His big thing is we must pivot to the Pacific. And he is a competent guy. It's just he's very China-focused to the detriment of everything else. And I'm not sure what a wanker is.
SPEAKER_00I guess that's a bad word. Ryan. Nah, I'm kidding. I know it. I know exactly what it is. I was just hoping you would stumble and try to define it for me. Oh, hell no.
SPEAKER_01I'm not falling for that. That would make me a complete twat.
SPEAKER_00Yes. And by the way, where's my honeypot shirt could be found on Bunker Branding. I know one of your...
SPEAKER_01Viewers was asking about that. I need to get some merch. I don't know how to make merch or what makes good merch, but people say they want merch, but I don't really know what to do. You know what makes good merch?
SPEAKER_00Making it about the fan and not about you. No one's going to buy a Ryan McBeth shirt, but someone might buy a shirt that they can use as a little cruise missile. Then they can wear under their uniform that says Live, Laugh, Launch. You know, something that... No, I tried to do that.
SPEAKER_01We used to have a session with a couple of other YouTubers called Two Liberals and a Marxist. My favorite was Trump's idea of a proposal for a peace plan. I thought a peace plan was a proposal, but, you know... Just a few things like that. I need to, yeah, I need to come up with some people. If people want merch, they need to tell me what the hell I should put on it. Anyway, continue, Ryan. I mean, look, what's to say? So then, you know, okay, so the broader point I think here where...
SPEAKER_01And I'm kind of interested from your technical standpoint, is that how much can Ukraine maintain its, what I think is a pretty nutty strike strategy, right? They're striking not just deep into Russia, they're striking across Russia and the diversity of targets. We're hitting infrastructure, data centers, ore refineries, petroleum something. Military outposts, you know, is this a good thing or you think it's spreading themselves too thinly or forcing Russia to spread themselves too thinly?
SPEAKER_00No, I mean, Russia is a very big place. Right. So you're going to have to like production. I mean, when you look at, oh God, what was it? Pencil. Right. Like. I did a video about this when people were asking me about the F-35 because the lead is from Nigeria and the wood is from Ecuador and the metal is
SPEAKER_00from Brazil and the rubber is from Malaysia. So that's four or five countries just to make a freaking pencil. Now try to make a weapon system. So all this production might quite likely be spread out all over Russia. So you're going to have to spread yourself in hitting various targets. Now, the good news is that, you know, if it takes one unit of lead, it's like Minecraft, right? One unit of lead, one unit of wood, one unit of graphite, one unit of wood,
SPEAKER_00one unit of metal, one unit of, what's this called? Rubber to make a pencil. Oh, the paint. Yeah, the paint is from Estonia. Five, right? So if it takes one unit of each of these things to make a pencil and you want to make 100 pencils, but you can only get five units of paint from Estonia, then you're only making five pencils, right? Maybe you don't need to paint it. So maybe the metal or maybe the, you know, you can't have it without graphite.
SPEAKER_00Graphite's a critical component in the pencil. Else you have a stick of wood. If you can knock out that one critical component that goes into your weapon systems, then it doesn't matter how many other factories you have that are making components, you're not going to be able to manufacture that particular weapon system unless you can find a substitute supplier. So Ukraine's strategy of spreading out and hitting multiple Russian factories,
SPEAKER_00it might not be a bad idea. I mean, it's just the easiest way of doing things, but They certainly are going to figure out what are the critical components to developing these weapon systems so we can hit them and hopefully make it harder for Russia to develop systems that can target Ukraine.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. A couple of other questions to me, which I'm going to pass to you because I think I'm interested in your takes. I would say someone just asking, why isn't Ukraine hitting LNG in St. Petersburg? Is it because some of you countries still buy LNG from Russia? I mean, in my mind, what is Ukraine's about a thousand kilometers from the Baltics? They did strike that ship. In what, last week? Which was quite a big deal. But is that purely a distance thing? I think they can get more damage and more impact by striking elsewhere
SPEAKER_01than necessarily in St. Petersburg and the Baltic.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, that's just – that's the question, right? So if you look at Moscow and St. Petersburg which are two targets that are going to be heavily defended then it gets – I mean I sound like a project manager whenever I say this but is the juice worth the squeeze? If it takes 20 missiles to maybe get one through in St. Petersburg, is it better to target smaller refineries where you can get 20 missiles through, right? And again, this is going back to the bridge for a second here,
SPEAKER_00blowing up a missile in St. Petersburg, On a fuel refinery, it's gorgeous footage. There's going to have footage all over Twitter. But is that necessarily moving the needle? I mean, if you do it enough, it certainly could. But if you fire 20 weapon systems and all 20 of them are shot down, then what do you got? Right. So it may be a more complex operation and just the juice might not be worth the squeeze. Interesting.
SPEAKER_01Wow. I feel like I should be standing around a water cooler. If you're enjoying the chat, everyone do drop a like or subscribe if you want. We try to keep it some levity when we can. Ryan, I guess, I don't know. Okay, so let's shift back to more of your wheelhouse and the technical front. What do you think are some of the biggest bottlenecks facing either side right now?
SPEAKER_00Some of the biggest problems? Both countries are having manpower problems. We can't ever discount the fact that Ukraine is having trouble getting people into uniform and out to the front, and Russia is having less trouble getting people into uniform and out to the front because they have more people to draw from, but it's still an issue. And anybody who says that's not true is they're They're a true believer,
SPEAKER_00which is great to be a true believer, but you have to face facts. So that's one problem. The second problem is both sides know that AI-powered drones are probably going to be a thing by the summer. And these would be essentially Terminators, right? Right. Where you're going to launch a drone and tell that drone to fly and try to find a specific target to hit. And if you can't find a command post, find a truck.
SPEAKER_00If you can't find a truck, then find a person and detonate yourself on that person. That's probably going to be, AI-powered weapons are probably going to be a thing by the summer. And once that happens, we're not putting the genie back in the bottle. That's going to be one of those things that every country is going to be watching this in absolute horror as computers hunt down and kill people. And we're going to have to have those weapons soon, too.
SPEAKER_00And there's been some ideas floated of how to treat this on a Geneva Convention level. Maybe we should ban these AI-powered weapons completely. But if this war doesn't end before the summer, I do predict that we're going to have AI-powered weapons, and neither side is really prepared for that. So I think both sides are concerned about that. I think a third thing that is more
SPEAKER_00of a concern for Ukraine is war fatigue in Europe. Now, every day that Russia is able to perform these pissant little sabotage attacks or help a radical right party get elected or create the conditions so that some nutjob chick in France might actually win the presidential election, it's another day ticking away for Ukraine's time.
SPEAKER_00In which they'll actually receive money from Europe. Because right now we have a France and a Germany that is relatively friendly toward Ukraine, getting them the Euros and the weapons systems that they need to fight. That might not be the case in April of 2027, depending on who gets elected in France and later on who gets elected in Germany. So if you have those two weapon powerhouses flip their switch, all we have left is England.
SPEAKER_00Right. And Poland, I would say. But, you know, Spain isn't exactly pumping out stuff for Ukraine. Right. Portugal isn't. Now the Baltics, you know, they're doing what they can. But that's a big issue for Ukraine. The clock is ticking for Europe because Europe certainly has war fatigue. And as you get more pro-Russia people into elected office, that's something to be concerned about. The other side of that coin is in two years,
SPEAKER_00you may have a different administration in the White House.
SPEAKER_01It is not impossible.
SPEAKER_00That you could have the elections in 2028 and you see a return to a MAGA light where you have a J.D. Vance elected who is apathetic toward Ukraine. But you could have someone else. I don't know who the heck the Democrats are running. They're probably going to dust off Biden again and put him up there and have him run again. God knows. Give the man a rest. So that's kind of a wild card there.
SPEAKER_00For Russia, I think that for one thing that they're scared about, that Ukraine isn't necessarily scared about, is... They're probably looking over at China. If I'm China and I'm looking at a place to invade because I want resources, yeah, you got Taiwan, but it doesn't really have any resources. I mean, it has chips, but once you take over Taiwan, everyone who knows how to run a chip fab is going to leave. And so you're going to have a bunch of machines that you don't know how to operate.
SPEAKER_00But Russia has a hell of a lot of resources. I mean, shoot, if I were China, I would invade Russia right now. It'd be the perfect time to do it. I mean, yeah, you lose out on their oil, but get your own freaking oil. Grab a whole slice of territory from Russia, you can get as much oil as you want. So I think that Russia's probably looking over their shoulder at China, kind of wondering what they're doing, because I could easily see China performing some sort of operation.
SPEAKER_00In southern Russia to grab some territory that they don't need to cross 100 miles, 160 kilometers of water to get a rock, essentially.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, in the time that we spoke, was it Silent Crow? And these Belarusian bloggers, whatever, had done this analysis on the fatality rates for Russia. How accurate do you think they are? And at what rate is the Russian death machine? I'm not even going to call it a war machine, but like, as someone who's looked at military stuff, served in the way you have.
SPEAKER_00So I can't... I can't tell you the rates of death and it's likely accurate, but I do know that at least as of the last time I looked at it and got good data, which was in, I want to say, March of this year, Russia was bringing on or was hiring between 30 and 35,000 troops per month. Which equates to 400,000, 450,000 or so troops every year.
SPEAKER_00Now, that could tell you something about the replacement rate. At least if you extrapolate back to why are you bringing these troops on. If you're replacing people. Some people are dead, right? Some people might actually hit the end of their contract. And once they hit the end of their contract, then they get to go home. Some people might be wounded. Some people might be rotated out because they go to a training unit
SPEAKER_00to train Russian soldiers up to go to battle. And I know there's going to be people who go, oh, they don't get any training. They still get some kind of training. Right. As much as nice as it is to think of Russia today as enemy at the gates, you know, when the person in front of you gets killed, pick up their rifle and continue on like that's not a great strategy. Right. They still need some sort of training. So you're going to have people from the front lines come back and go to training schools and at least give some of these guys,
SPEAKER_00some of these volunteers a little bit of knowledge to hopefully survive long enough. But if the replacement rate, the hiring rate is roughly 400,000, it's not inconceivable that you're losing around 400,000 people a year, whether that is to attrition, to casualties, to people finishing their contracts or to people rotating out of the combat zone. So I think that number might be relatively correct.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think it's within the restimations that most other organizations or entities have done. Um... So yeah, to me, it's just a, well, it's quite horrible to see really as someone who has links to the country. It's not very nice. The irony is that Putin obviously talking about demographic issues and trying to get more people to have children or to change policy to encourage more procreation, more childbearing.
SPEAKER_01And it's like, Okay, but you are killing off half the men needing to do it. So that's a clever approach forward. What about Ukraine's in-house development though? Aside from manpower, you know, the big argument is that sort of manpower can be offset by tech and drones and flamingos and you don't, I think you're going to disagree with that, right?
SPEAKER_00I mean, so nothing's ever going to replace the infantryman. Right. Like that's just, that's, you're always going to need an infantryman. Now, what Ukraine has done is pioneered things like drone raids, where they'll carry, they'll use a large cargo drone, sling an armed drone, an armed ground drone underneath it, move that inside of Russian lines and use that to conduct an attack.
SPEAKER_00And then the drone that is The aerial drone then hangs out as a relay so you can talk to and operate the ground drone. Once they get to a point where there's AI loaded on those things, you're not even going to need the relay drone anymore. It can come back. And now you have the Terminators. Now, Ukraine can offset... Some of it's manpower issues by using more drones and using some of these tactics
SPEAKER_00where you're hitting the rear using these armed ground drones. But the battery on that thing is only going to last so long. You can even put a gasoline engine on it, which is going to increase the noise. But if you're shooting a gun off it, you know, there's going to be a lot of noise anyway. All right. So you put a gasoline engine on it. What do you get out of it? Maybe four hours. Maybe eight hours, depending on how large a fuel tank is, right? So a human being, I mean, you can give a human being a meal,
SPEAKER_00and a human being can go 30 days without food. They're not going to be very combat effective, but fat from calories is a much more effective battery than lithium ion, right? Or lead acid. The energy density in a protein bar. It has a lot more energy than that same equivalent of gasoline, right? At least the way we metabolize it. So I don't ever see the infantryman becoming obsolete,
SPEAKER_00but you can certainly use these ground drones in order to increase your reach and your capabilities. And that being said, theoretically, Russia could do the same thing. We just haven't really seen it. We haven't really seen, we've seen innovation come out of Russia. What's interesting is they seem to be doing what we would call fast following, where Ukraine has an innovation and Russia might copy it. The difference is that Russia used fiber optic drones first.
SPEAKER_00They're the first guys to come up with the fiber optic drones. And then there was this big debate in Ukraine. I was there when it happened. Talk, well, it wasn't in Ukraine. I was a round, shoot, I might have said something I shouldn't have said. I was working with people at the time who were familiar with the situation. And there was a view in Ukraine that we shouldn't be making these fiber optic drones.
SPEAKER_00And there were other people who were heading some brigades in Ukraine who were saying, no, we need these because Russia has these. And eventually the fiber optic drones kind of won out. But they still make a mix of that stuff. So Russia can theoretically copy what Ukraine is doing. They just don't they don't seem to be taking to the ground drones as much as Ukraine has. And that might be because they still view human beings as relatively cheap. And therefore, it's easier to get a, what do they call it in Chernobyl,
SPEAKER_00biorobots than it is to make the actual robots. You know what? The other thing might be they also, Russia is probably going to have a tougher time accessing the chips. Because Ukraine can still buy AI-powered chips and adrenos and graphics cards on the open market. Whereas Russia has a tougher time doing that. They might have to set up a shell company in Turkey, which buys it from a shell company in Hong Kong, which gets it across the border as washing machine parts.
SPEAKER_00So Russia might have a tougher time building the ground drones than Ukraine would just because they have a tougher time actually accessing the electronics.
SPEAKER_01Interesting. Curious. So where does this leave us then, Ryan, if we're going to see more of these strikes occasionally from Ukraine? And what's Russia going to do? Because I think the retaliation thing is often something everyone's like, oh, they're going to retaliate. But what else can they realistically do? Well, they don't need an excuse.
SPEAKER_00They're kind of evil to begin with. There are people who say, oh, Russia's going to retaliate. This is going to escalate. Escalate where? Yeah. The only thing they can go to is a nuclear weapon, and that's not going to do anything. It's not going to realistically win the conflict. So where are they going to escalate? Russia doesn't need an excuse. There was a really good interview. With Palmer Luckey of Andrel, who was kind of defending Elon Musk a little bit when he said,
SPEAKER_00why should Elon Musk be forced to use his satellite network and risk his satellite network getting shot down or attrited either electronically or cyber-wise by Russia just to support democracy in Ukraine? Why should he? Because he paid for all those satellites going up. And yeah, that's true. He did. But the one thing that people forget is that Russia doesn't need an excuse. They don't follow the rules. If Russia wanted to take out Elon Musk's Starlink satellites, they don't need an excuse.
SPEAKER_00They could just do it. They might manufacture an excuse or want an excuse to point at it later and say, we had to do this because whatever. But Yeah, that's one of the things that I think people get wrong when they think of Russia. They think of it as a country that needs a mandate. And that's one of the reasons I was saying to people that everyone's forgotten about this.
SPEAKER_00Do you remember a couple of months ago when people were saying, oh, After the elections, Russia's going to have a draft. And I was like the only guy who was saying, this is not going to happen. It's just not going to happen. And the reason is that Russia doesn't need a mandate. The elections are theater. There are some elections that are genuine. You can throw out a corrupt mayor. There are some elections that are free and fair-ish.
SPEAKER_00At least at the local level. But re-electing the, oh God, I forget the name of the Russia Now Party or whatever the party that, Putin isn't actually part of a party, but I can't remember the name of the party that's in power, the majority party that's in power in Russia right now. But they don't need a mandate from the people. Like if they're- United Russia. What's that? United Russia. United Russia. Yeah, Putin isn't part of United Russia,
SPEAKER_00but I guess he's technically affiliated with it because he doesn't believe the president should be part of a party. So if United Russia gains a majority of seats in the Duma, that doesn't necessarily mean the public has a mandate to continue the war in Ukraine. The mandate, the majority was already decided. This is just theater. It's just show. When you look at like, oh God,
SPEAKER_00the popular, Russia doesn't need permission to do anything evil. It doesn't need a mandate to do anything evil. They kind of do that naturally. So yeah, I'm not too concerned about escalation or about, oh my God, what if Russia does this? I mean, they might do it anyway. You gotta kind of prepare for that as a contingency in the first place, that they're bad guys to start with, and we need to worry about what they might do regardless of how we try
SPEAKER_00to appease them.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, I mean... I don't know, one likes to believe that he's going to face the wrath of the elites or the people more broadly, but it just doesn't seem to overcome. Why didn't we see a draft then? Oh, because they don't need one, right?
SPEAKER_00Like, I mean, there are enough people who are willing to sign up. That you don't really need to actually have a draft to force people into the army. So that's kind of number one. Other issue is that if you actually did a draft, there's always been this deal between Moscow and St. Petersburg and the administration that you do whatever the hell you want in the foreign stage, but don't touch our kids.
SPEAKER_00And I'm not too worried about the oligarchs kids. They might actually get drafted, right? And I'm sorry, son, there's really no way out of this, but we'll make sure you're in a signal unit, you know, or you're guarding a penguin sanctuary in Siberia, right? I don't know if there's penguins in Siberia, but there might be. Maybe they're in the zoo. And, you know... Once you start drafting the kids of the elite or the kids of the urban elite in St.
SPEAKER_00Petersburg and Moscow, then you might actually have a social problem that you're not going to be able to control. But yeah, I think it's mainly because they just don't need it. They don't need that level of draftees because they're getting enough volunteers.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, but like everyone's saying, they're running out of capacity to pay their soldiers, they're running out of the ability to... Incentive, like, you know, people are going to, you just don't think Russia's just a vast country, the vast population, so it's not ever going to come to that level yet.
SPEAKER_00I don't really see that. I think that as long as you keep raising the amount of money and giving people that incentive, and it does cause inflation, right? Like, if you're a factory and you're manufacturing, you might be manufacturing, I don't know, missiles for the war. Or a spring that goes into a missile. So if the Army is offering 3,000 rubles a month and you're offering 2,500 rubles
SPEAKER_00a month, that person who's working at the factory might consider joining the Army to be a better bet, even though they could get killed. So you might raise that amount of money up a little bit more to 3,100 rubles a month. And so the Army raises that to 4,000 rubles a month. So that's how inflation starts, right? You have too much money chasing too few goods or all this money getting spread around.
SPEAKER_00So I think right now Russia, there's always enough money for a war. And people say, oh, Russia can run out of money. America is $40 trillion in debt and we're spending like a drunken sailor. God knows, if the Democrats who will be in power come January, oh man, you know, we're going to start saying, we're going to get healthcare. I mean, healthcare sounds great until you see the bill, right?
SPEAKER_00So running out of money might not necessarily mean much. I mean, you can deficit spend to a certain point. And I'm sure Russia still has some foreign currency reserves. We really don't know. And the economic-wise, how much in reserves they have. And supposedly some states in Russia are essentially bankrupt. But, you know, a state can always raise taxes. A state can always issue bonds. I don't necessarily see Russia run out of money, although I can see them run out of cheap money.
SPEAKER_01That's one way to put it. Run out of cheap money. And on that regards, Ryan, anything to leave us with? I always lose track of time talking with you in a good way because it covers so much ground.
SPEAKER_00Well, I do all the talking. Well, I do all the talking. It's supposed to be like being a bad dream. Oh, God, this guy, shut up. Anything to leave you with? Yes, you can buy my, where's my Honey Pod shirt from Bunker Branding. I have Christmas and Hanukkah shirts as well, but they're over there. I'm not going to go grab them, but. Very NORAD Christmas. But I appreciate you having me on.
SPEAKER_01Always, my friend. It's a pleasure. Everyone, yes, do support Ryan, be that on Substack or YouTube if you haven't already. Subscribe to him. He may sound completely off the cuff or lunatic in his deliberate extents, but I No, I'm joking. I really enjoy Ryan's conversations because he brings energy and dynamism, which some stuffy academics, trust me, I have a lot of those, which I never release because I just think they're terrible. And that's why I keep inviting Ryan back because he knows what he's talking about, but he adds entertainment to it as well.
SPEAKER_01Well, thanks so much for watching, everyone. Speak soon. Stay safe out there. Ryan, all the best. Don't like too many. Have a whiskey on me and we'll reconvene with you.
Want to advertise on Global Warning? Contact me and receive a media kit. Intelligence product for paid subscribers at the bottom of the page. This will unlock for free members on Sunday. Or get it from Perks. This...
Want to advertise on Global Warning? Contact me and receive a media kit. Intelligence product for paid subscribers at the bottom of the page. This will unlock for free members on Sunday. Or get it from Perks. This...
This video is free for all members. Please consider supporting my work for only $2.50. A submarine waiting for repairs doesn’t become combat-ready because somebody gave a good speech. It needs skilled workers, spare...
Want to advertise on Global Warning? Contact me and receive a media kit. Intelligence product for paid subscribers at the bottom of the page. This will unlock for free members on Sunday. Or get it from Perks. This...
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit ryanmcbeth.substack.com/subscribe