Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The official Ryan McBeth Substack Podcast

The official Ryan McBeth Substack Podcast artwork

The Truth About Elon Musk and the Ukraine Starlink Timeline

Oct 26, 202611 minAudio

My team and I put 74 major moments in the Elon Musk-Starlink-Ukraine controversy on a timeline using more than 160 sources. Put the statements next to the events, and the story gets complicated. This video is free for all members. Please share it and please consider becoming a paid member for only $2.50. In this video, I walk through Starlink’s arrival in Ukraine, the controversy over coverage near Crimea, Pentagon contracts, reports of Russian access, and the competing explanations for service restrictions. We examine what Musk and SpaceX have said, what reporting alleges, and where the record has been corrected. Then we get to the bigger question: When a military depends on a private company’s communications network, who decides how that network can be used - and who is accountable when access changes? Explore the timeline and check the sources:https://gmichaelrapp.github.io/musk_timeline/ Support the research, dashboards, maps, and timelines Michael, Gary, and I produce. Become a paid member. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit ryanmcbeth.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00I plotted out every single significant event with Starlink, Ukraine, and SpaceX Chairman Elon Musk on a timeline, and it's pretty damning. Someone is lying, but much of the current media coverage ignores the complexities and history behind all of this. Mr. Musk is not being straight with the American people, and the US government is worried it could cost the United States in foreign military sales and contracts, and honestly, I don't blame the foreign governments that might be afraid of buying American right now.

SPEAKER_00Mr. Musk and even members of SpaceX have claimed that Ukraine has violated the service agreements attached to their Starlink equipment and service. Now, let's break down some key moments from this fiasco so we can get down to the brass tacks. Before we begin, if you haven't subscribed to the channel, subscribe, hit the bell. My name is Ryan McBeth. I'm a software engineer and intelligence analyst who uses software to fight misinformation using facts, not factions. Please share this video, especially with your congressmen or legislators in your associated country.

SPEAKER_00For those of you who like data, my team and I have a special treat for you. Gary is going to show you screenshots of a timeline that we built using 160 sources recording 74 major moments I say this a lot, but if you could support my work on Substack at ryanmcbeth.substack.com, you'd help me produce more content like this, including dashboards, maps, timelines, all of which we spend hours, days, and weeks creating. Michael and Gary do amazing work, but they're not cheap. Your support makes this possible. I was reminded of Mr.

SPEAKER_00Musk's flip-flopping nature when I read a post by Greg Bagwell on X, formerly known as Twitter. He began his posting thread with, Elon Musk has attempted to close this issue with Starlink in Ukraine, but here is a tale in seven tweets that suggest it's far from closed. The throttling back of speed limits on Starlink terminals occur around 14 October, so let's get back to this and then his timeline. On the surface, I agree with what Bagwell is trying to do here. He is trying to get to the truth behind this fiasco where Mr. Musk claims that he was told to shut off access to that service for Ukraine.

SPEAKER_00But the math isn't mathing. Something is off and something smells funny about Mr. Musk's own story. Instead of relying solely on Bagel's timeline, which isn't bad, my team and I developed our own timeline complete with sources, each sources cited using our own in-house citation system with active links double-checked and commentary on our findings along the way. The link to the GitHub repository that stores this current version of the Musk Starlink timeline has been added at ryanmcbeth.substack.com.

SPEAKER_00Like everything I do on this channel, this timeline leads you down to our sources to verify what we looked at here. Good science is reproducible. We checked and double-checked all our sources and cited them using our in-house citation system so you shouldn't have any trouble finding them. Instead of regurgitating what 166 sources say, I'm just going to hit the highlights. Back in 2022, Mikhail Fedorov, the former Defense Minister of Ukraine, asked Elon Musk to supply Ukraine with Starlink. And he said, Elon Musk, while you try to colonize Mars, Russia is trying to occupy Ukraine.

SPEAKER_00While your rockets successfully land from space, Russian rockets attack the Ukrainian civil people. We ask you to provide Ukraine with Starlink stations and to address the sane Russians to stand. Elon Musk later responded, saying the terminals were being sent to Ukraine. On March 12, 2022, Elon Musk challenged Russian leader Vladimir Putin to a contest over who would control Ukraine. Unironically, Putin declined Musk's challenge, but it marked the start of a stormy relationship between Musk and Ukraine.

SPEAKER_00In May of 2022, Roscosmos head Dmitry Rosen said that Elon Musk would be held accountable for supplying Ukraine with Starlink equipment used in its defense against Russia's invasion. Around September 2022, Walter Isaacson, who wrote the 2023 biography on Musk, claimed that Ukraine tried to use a Starlink-guided naval drone to attack the Russian fleet in Sevastopol in occupied Crimea. The connection to the drone ship failed, leading Ukrainians to believe that Musk's company was involved.

SPEAKER_00That same month, Reuters reported that three people close to the matter believed Musk had ordered the cut to Starlink coverage over areas like Kyrgyzstan. Musk later denied the claim, saying they were inaccurate. However, Isaacson's account suggests that Musk spoke to the Russian ambassador to the United States, who claimed that such an attack could lead to a nuclear strike or worse. By October 2022, Musk was proposing a peace plan between Russia and Ukraine, which spurred Ukrainian ambassador to the United Nations, Andrei Melnyk, to write, Fuck off is my very diplomatic reply to you.

SPEAKER_00By October 2022, Musk complained openly on X that Starlink cost the company around $20 million a month. It would cost his company another $400 million over the following 12 months. By 2023, even SpaceX President Gwen Shotwell said that the Ukrainians had violated the service agreement attached to Starlink. Ukrainians, including members of Zelensky's government, criticized her remarks. Around February 12, 2023, Musk claimed in a counter to former astronaut Scott Kelly's criticism on X

SPEAKER_00that he had essentially stopped World War III by intervening. Around June 2023, the Pentagon confirmed that it had awarded a contract to SpaceX to supply Starlink services to Ukraine, but they did not disclose the cost. Dmitry Miedev, a Russia's former president, praised Musk in September 2023, largely because of Musk's comments about Russia and the war. That same month, excerpts from Musk's biography from Walter Isaacson were published, which included claims that Musk had intervened to cut Starlink access to Ukrainians.

SPEAKER_00Musk later took to X, saying to hell with it. Even though Starlink is still losing money and other companies are getting billions of taxpayer dollars, we'll just keep funding Ukrainian government for free. Musk's actions concerning Starlink were condemned by Ukrainian presidential advisor Mikhailo Podolak on X, saying his ignorance and ego were getting people killed. Author Walter Isaacson later posted a clarification on X concerning Starlink access and Musk's role in all of it. To clarify on the Starlink issue,

SPEAKER_00the Ukrainians thought coverage was enabled all the way to Crimea, but it was not. They asked Musk to enable it for their drone sub-attack on the Russian fleet. Musk did not enable it because he thought, probably correctly, that it would cause a major war. In September of 2023, American lawmakers got involved even threatening an investigation into Mr. Musk's role in cutting off Ukraine's Starlink access. In 2024, reports began circulating about Russia's use of Starlink, especially on unauthorized devices. SpaceX, through Starlink's X account,

SPEAKER_00claimed that they did not do business with the Russian government or the Russian military. They even claimed that Starlink didn't work in Russia, although independent analysis found that wasn't entirely true. In March of 2024, House Democrats, Representatives Jamie Raskin and Robert Garcia wrote to SpaceX asking about illegal sales and acquisitions of Starlink equipment in Russia. However, the waters kind of got even more muddied when the Assistant Secretary of Defense for Space Policy, John Plum, argued that the Pentagon should not compel SpaceX to cut off Russian users.

SPEAKER_00And then things got messier and messier for Mr. Musk. On October 24th, the Wall Street Journal reported that numerous anonymous officials from the United States, Europe, and Russia found that Musk regularly contacted Russian President Vladimir Putin, something he publicly denied on X and elsewhere. By the end of 2024, the U.S. government, especially Congress, the Department of Defense as it was called at the time, and NASA believed they could not rely on Musk's SpaceX for defense needs.

SPEAKER_00Throughout 2025, the same things kept repeating in our timeline. Mr. Musk was accused of cutting off or throttling Starlink access to Ukraine, colluding with the Russians, and being a liability for U.S. national security. In 2026, the story gets even crazier, with numerous U.S. senators calling for an investigation into Musk and possibly cutting SpaceX loose if it cannot be trusted in With military contracts. Now, I will tell you this. SpaceX has enormous launch contracts with the U.S. government.

SPEAKER_00That probably isn't going to happen. To add gasoline to the fire, Ukraine has suffered some of the worst attacks on its cities and infrastructure in the last few months. And Mr. Musk knows that Ukraine relies on Starlink for its defense. We have U.S. senators asking for Musk's head on a pike. Ukrainians are crying foul. And the American people are trying to make sense of what is going on. Now, some of these outages look to be spontaneous and we log these in the timeline.

SPEAKER_00Some of these are just too good to be accidents. Mr. Musk has shown his true colors as this war has dragged on. But that isn't what worries me the most. Think about it this way. Mr. Musk, a private citizen, can pull some levers, so to speak, and bring a sovereign country's defenses to a halt. A private citizen can take a big steaming pile of crap on US foreign policy. Who holds Mr. Musk accountable? Again, the link to the GitHub repository for all this data can be found

SPEAKER_00at ryanmcbeth.substack.com. If you just want to browse a timeline, you can do that as well. Thank you to Michael and Gary for spending the weekend putting this together. They don't do this for free, so please consider becoming a Substack subscriber for only $2.50. Thank you for watching.

SPEAKER_01In the modern age of progress and preparedness, one thing separates the professional from the amateur. Appearance. That's why forward-thinking Americans choose Bunker Branding Apparel, the official uniform of those who get what is done. Each shirt is precision-engineered and field-tested under rigorous conditions such as extended YouTube filming operations, Substack editorial duty, and the occasional internet argument. Designed for comfort, durability, and undeniable sense of tactical coolness. Remember, citizens, when you're defending democracy, refueling freedom,

SPEAKER_01or simply mowing the strategic lawn, Bunker Branding keeps you mission-ready, wrinkle-free, and unmistakably American. [music]

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. UKRAINES HUMILIATES PUTIN AGAIN WHILE AT HIS FAILED YALTA SUMMIT - w/ Ryan McBeth

    Nov 19, 202658 minAudio

    Thank you KRZ, Jeff Zekas, Me By The Sea, Kathy Swinson, Sebast, and many others for tuning into my live video with Pyotr Kurzin! Join me for my next live video in the app. This is a public episode. If you'd like to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Global Warning 37 : Silk, Sanctions Survival

    Nov 15, 202621 minAudio

    Want to advertise on Global Warning? Contact me and receive a media kit. Intelligence product for paid subscribers at the bottom of the page. This will unlock for free members on Sunday. Or get it from Perks. This...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Global Warning 36: Chokepoints, Coercion, Chaos

    Nov 8, 202617 minAudio

    Want to advertise on Global Warning? Contact me and receive a media kit. Intelligence product for paid subscribers at the bottom of the page. This will unlock for free members on Sunday. Or get it from Perks. This...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. What the New Congress Means for America’s Military

    Nov 5, 202619 minAudio

    This video is free for all members. Please consider supporting my work for only $2.50. A submarine waiting for repairs doesn’t become combat-ready because somebody gave a good speech. It needs skilled workers, spare...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Global Warning 35: Money, Munitions, MacGyver

    Nov 1, 202628 minAudio

    Want to advertise on Global Warning? Contact me and receive a media kit. Intelligence product for paid subscribers at the bottom of the page. This will unlock for free members on Sunday. Or get it from Perks. This...

    Credit the people on this episode