Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Jeff-alytics Podcast

The Jeff-alytics Podcast artwork

Smarter Ways To Think About Reducing Gun Violence with Shani Buggs

Oct 14, 202632 minAudio

Most of what we think we know about gun violence comes from policing data. Dr. Shani Buggs thinks that’s part of the problem. An associate professor at UC Davis’s Violence Prevention Research Program, Dr Buggs came to this work through public health - studying gun violence the way epidemiologists study disease, tracing risk factors, mapping patterns, and asking what conditions make communities more or less vulnerable. She’s spent the last fifteen years trying to build the evidence base for what actually works. In this episode, we get into what a public health approach to gun violence actually means in practice, why community violence intervention has been so hard to study rigorously, and what the data does and doesn’t tell us about the historic crime drop of the last few years. The current moment may be making the research harder just as the field was starting to hit its stride, but there is still a ton to learn and do to reduce gun violence. Dr. Shani Buggs, PhD, MPH, is an Associate Professor with the Centers for Violence Prevention at the University of California, Davis. Her public health and health policy expertise includes structural and social drivers of violence and safety, firearm violence prevention, community-level violence intervention and prevention, transformative first response strategies, and comprehensive community safety. Dr. Buggs is also the co-founder and Advisory Committee Chair of The Black & Brown Collective for Community Solutions to Gun Violence, a multidisciplinary network organization committed to rigorous and equitable research in service of the prosperity of communities disproportionately harmed by violence.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00I'm Jeff Asher, and this is the Jeffalytics Podcast. Most of what we think we know about gun violence comes from policing data. Dr. Shani Bugs thinks that's part of the problem. An associate professor at UC Davis's violence prevention research program, Dr. Buggs comes to this work through public health, studying gun violence the way epidemiologists studied disease, tracing risk factors, mapping patterns, and asking what conditions make communities more or less vulnerable. She spent the last 15 years trying to build the evidence base for what actually works. In this episode, we get into what a public health approach to gun violence actually means in practice, why community violence intervention has been so hard to study rigorously, and what the data does and doesn't tell us about the historic drop in crime over the last few years.

SPEAKER_00The current moment may be making the research harder just as the field was starting to hit its pride, but there's still a ton to learn and do to reduce gun violence. Let's get into it. My guest today is Dr. Shawnee Bugs. Shawnee, thank you so much for joining me. Thank you for having me. Just getting started, can you walk me through what is your background? How did you get to be with us today?

SPEAKER_01So I am presently an associate professor at the University of California, Davis with the Centers for Violence Prevention. Got to this place from my love of public health. I studied public health and public policy. And my career in firearm violence prevention and community violence prevention was a second one. I started my career after college in management and really thought that I was going to focus on public health lifestyle improvements and population level health improvements.

SPEAKER_01But I found myself drawn to understanding what public health had to say about gun violence prevention. And before I started my studies, I did not know that public health had a role to play in understanding and preventing gun violence. And so I ultimately changed the entire trajectory of my career and ended up for the last almost 15 years now being in the field of public health and public policy related to gun violence prevention.

SPEAKER_01This is my sixth year anniversary as faculty here at UC Davis.

SPEAKER_00Congratulations. Is there one story or anecdote or experience that led you down this path or was it more of a cumulative thing?

SPEAKER_01I started my graduate studies in public health because I knew that I wanted to help influence population level health and well-being. And within a few weeks of starting my studies, the Aurora, Colorado movie theater shooting happened where a dozen people were killed and dozens were injured. And I was in Baltimore, Maryland at the time and was really struck by how different the response was to that shooting nationwide, how many calls there were for action, policy change, resources delivered to that community while I was in Baltimore and there were just no parallel conversations happening about violence in Baltimore.

SPEAKER_01There was very little public discussion around what could be done differently besides more police, more punishment. As I was at a school at Johns Hopkins, Bloomberg School of Public Health that had a center for gun policy and research and was very focused on what public health could do, pulling all levers of safety and health, thinking about population level change, thinking about policy that could help shift the trajectory of gun violence at the individual level, at the community level, and at the societal level.

SPEAKER_01So that incident really turned my eye towards understanding disparate responses to gun violence in our country and understanding that there were other ways of approaching gun violence besides just thinking about law enforcement and punishment.

SPEAKER_00So I guess walk me through those. I'll frequently hear, you know, we have to treat gun violence as a public health issue. And it's frequently, I feel like a talking point that doesn't get the, you know, the understanding of what that exactly means. So can you fill me in on that?

SPEAKER_01Sure, sure. And I think people do have different approaches for what that means. When I started studying gun violence as a public health issue, it was not commonplace to hear that in the public discourse. So I had to myself learn what that means and what does it mean to me. The public health approach is very much focused on defining the scope and magnitude of the problem, understanding the underlying risk and protective factors, and then implementing piloting interventions that address those risk and protective factors and then scaling and advocating for what works at a larger scale.

SPEAKER_01But when I think about a public health approach to gun violence, it is recognizing that there are many factors that lead to gun violence or deep structural and societal factors, policies, and practices that advantage some communities away from having sticky and concentrated gun violence, and other communities that have long-standing histories of concentrated gun violence. Understanding the why, understanding what led to those factors and using all forms of government, all forms of the ways that we think about how we live, sleep, work, play, the environmental and structural factors that are associated with increasing safety or decreasing safety.

SPEAKER_01And so to me, the public health approach is really about looking at what all can be done related to those factors that increase the likelihood of gun violence at the individual and community and societal level, and what factors decrease that risk and that likelihood. And there are lots of different factors. Gun violence is not caused by one thing. It is not reduced by one thing, by one policy or one practice. It's a constellation of factors. And so public health really is thinking about as many of those levers that we can pull, as many different roles that government can play, that business can play, that community can play to help reduce the likelihood of gun violence.

SPEAKER_01Or if gun violence happens, what can be done to reduce the likelihood of it happening again via retaliatory violence or unresolved trauma and anger and all of the ways that we can think about decreasing that likelihood because it is such a devastating and it has such a rippling impact on individuals and families and communities.

SPEAKER_00Do you have like an overarching theory? I hate getting this question, so I'm glad I'm asking the question and not having to answer it. But do you have an overarching theory on why, first off, in 2020 we saw such an explosion of gun violence? And then over the last four or so years, why we've seen such an immense decline?

SPEAKER_01Sure. I think many uh researchers have theories. We don't have yet the data to fully support or we don't have the evidence to really understand what exactly happened at the granular level. But what we do know is that the constellation of the COVID-19 pandemic and the devastating impact that it had on disproportionate death, particularly in black and brown communities in the United States, and the ways that it really devastated families, matriarchs, patriarchs, community leaders.

SPEAKER_01It really ruptured the social fabric of communities, both in the that relational way, but also in terms of social infrastructure. So, you know, teachers and community workers and violence interventionists and social workers and all of the kinds of safety nets and social supports that we have in communities that were particularly vulnerable to shocks like COVID-19 or to disasters were worsened because of the lack of connection that COVID caused.

SPEAKER_01Everybody was staying at home. There was widespread fear and uncertainty. People were not able to connect and receive financial, social, emotional supports that they normally did. We also had a massive increase in firearm sales at the same time. And research has shown that when we see spikes in firearm sales, we have an increase in gun violence. It's a period of about 18 months following those that rapid increase in firearm sales that you see increase in gun violence as well.

SPEAKER_01And so this constellation of things were happening on top of the fact that we were all sitting at home worried, scared about COVID-19, and very much connected to our screens. And we then witnessed a series of extrajudicial and police related killings of first Ahmad Aubrey and then Brianna Taylor, and then, of course, George Floyd. And the research has shown that when you have high-profile killings, you see increases in gun violence.

SPEAKER_01People are less likely to engage with the legal system, less likely to engage with law enforcement, less likely to call 911. You also have, just as Pat Sharkey at Princeton University has talked about, a rupture in the social contract. The agreement that we have as society to respect each other, to lean on the institutions that govern our society and govern the ways that we live and work and play and interact with each other, all of that was fractured in our very eyes, you know, in front of our very eyes during that summer.

SPEAKER_01And so all of those things, it's hard to pinpoint one particular thing, but all of that constellation of fear, uncertainty, anger, increase in gun sales, lack of supports for young people and young adults to connect, to have healthy outlets, to be in places where the risk of violence is low. So school or work or home, even staying at home, was encouraged, but often not even available to many around the country because of the illness and the need to do something with all of that energy.

SPEAKER_01So all of those things really, I think, created this perfect storm that led to this, you know, historic increase in gun violence.

SPEAKER_00And what about the last couple of years where we've seen, you know, 2023 was a record drop, 2024 was a record drop, 2025 was a record drop, 2026 is probably not going to be a record drop, but is going to go down a lot. Do you have any sort of rational explanation for that?

SPEAKER_01Yes. So again, we don't have the data to fully examine at this time. We don't yet have granular and discrete data to be able to exactly understand what has happened. But we have seen in cities around the country, as you said, we've seen um small cities, large cities, cities in blue states, cities in red states experience historic declines over these last couple of years. And when we look at the patterns of what's been going on in those cities and what happened at the national level, there are a few signals to suggest that we do have a sense for what has been going on over these last few years.

SPEAKER_01We saw historic investment by the federal government following COVID-19 to help stimulate the economies at the local and state levels. So there was unprecedented investment in not just community violence intervention and prevention efforts, but also in government infrastructure to help support families and communities in economic development and housing stability and youth development, all of the kinds of factors that in public health we know help reduce the likelihood of violence.

SPEAKER_01We also saw incredible investment in policing and following that, the what I refer to as the social justice summer of 2020, following that deep focus on racial equity and brief but deep focus on racial equity, policing was really focused more narrowly on what it could do to reduce violence without expanding its footprint in communities. And so you saw greater investment in technology, greater investment in investigative detective work, greater investment in increasing clearance rates for gun violence, a real focus on the most serious kinds of violence by both police and prosecutors.

SPEAKER_01We also saw local government take a more whole of government approach to gun violence. And so rather than just focusing on investing in policing and that traditional arm of public safety, local governments were investing in family development and community engagement and neighborhood safety and offices of violence prevention that were more broadly thinking about what are the various arms of government, what is their role in reducing violence.

SPEAKER_01And that whole of government approach is more aligned with the public health approach, where you are thinking about all the different factors that relate to increasing violence. So lighting and housing and transportation and after-school programs and job placement programs and training and mental health supports. You saw all those kinds of investments happening at the local level. You saw states also investing in supporting those local jurisdictions as well.

SPEAKER_01So all of those things have been happening. They started in 2021 and 2022. And so we've been seeing the impact of those investments over these last few years. I think that is what's been playing out.

SPEAKER_00So if you were sort of the czar of gun violence reduction and, you know, what you said went and at the top of the government and could immediately enact policy and, you know, unlimited budget, what are the steps that you would take, both from a law enforcement perspective and also from a non-law enforcement perspective, a community perspective?

SPEAKER_01I would start with using data and research to really understand where gun violence is happening, why it's happening in the places where it's happening. So engaging deeply with community, with the people who are at the center of violence, with the people who are living with high rates of violence, and understanding where it's happening, using law enforcement data, police data, using community intel, understanding where gun violence is happening and getting as close to understanding the why as happening.

SPEAKER_01Because gun violence, it's a complex issue. It is not driven always by the same motivations. There are the same underlying structural and societal factors that increase the likelihood of gun violence. That is pretty universal in communities around the country. And yet the motivations for particular instances of gun violence or the motivations that lead to some communities to have higher rates of gun violence than others, even given similar structural or societal factors, can be different.

SPEAKER_01So it's really important to understand what's happening at the local level. The next thing I would do would be to utilize that information to narrowly focus law enforcement on the highest rates of violence and be very clear and certain in how they are engaging around that issue. We have evidence to support that non-law enforcement community responders, whether they be violence interventionists, whether they be social workers, whether they be government or community workers trained in de-escalation, trained in community engagement, those individuals have the ability to help address lower levels of crime, to help address issues of crime and disorder, help address things like behavioral health and mental health crises.

SPEAKER_01So I would employ and develop that cadre of professionals to help lower levels of crime so that the police could focus very narrowly and intently on violence. And I would make sure that there is regular feedback and regular communication between police and community to ensure that accountability was happening on all sides, to ensure that the model is working and to make sure that we are achieving the results that we want to achieve.

SPEAKER_01There also cannot be an honest conversation in our country about gun violence without talking about gun policy and without talking about what we should be doing about firearms and the approach that we are currently taking at the national level with a patchwork of gun laws that restrict access in some cities and states, but don't restrict access in other cities and states. The loosening of gun laws that is currently happening, the federal administration is now allowing 18-year-olds to purchase handguns that was previously legislation that was enacted to prevent young people from having access to lethal weapons at a time when 18 to 20-year-olds have the highest rates of both firearm homicide and suicide victimization.

SPEAKER_01So I would, as a czar of public safety, I would absolutely be looking at our firearm policies and looking at what the best evidence shows around reducing the likelihood of firearm harm through those policies and things like access for young people, ensuring that firearms are safely locked and unloaded and stored safely, ensuring that we have strong laws around prohibitions for individuals who have demonstrated harm with firearms in the past.

SPEAKER_01Those things are necessary if we are to be thinking about how do we truly reduce gun violence sustainably, because unfettered access to lethal weapons is not helpful if we're trying to reduce gun violence sustainably and effectively for generations to come.

SPEAKER_00I know you've done a lot of like really deep dives into community violence interrupters and places that are trying to reduce violence through non-law enforcement techniques. I sort of have a two-part question related to that. First, why is it so difficult to get really high-quality research that tells us, hey, this program works, this program probably doesn't work? And second, um, which is probably related, why are cities, states, municipalities, local government so oftentimes so hesitant to work with researchers to understand, you know, whether what they're doing, like leading the way, having the research tell us whether or not what we're doing is working?

SPEAKER_00Or is that just completely wrong?

SPEAKER_01I think there are cities and states that are engaging with researchers, and increasingly there is an appreciation for what the data can tell us about the magnitude and scope of the problem and what the underlying risk and protective factors are. And research has a vital role to play in helping cities and states understand that. Community violence intervention, up until just a few years ago, was not considered a legitimate field. It was born organically, the community violence intervention approach of community caring for community.

SPEAKER_01And it is particularly in communities that have been disinvested, communities that have been marginalized, that have not been able to fully benefit from the structures and institutions of safety and accountability in our country. Community violence intervention was born out of the need for there to be homegrown violence interventionists, homegrown peacemakers, because leaning on the law to help make that happen consistently and effectively was not happening, has not happened.

SPEAKER_01And so community violence intervention models, approaches have been around for decades. And they have been, up until again, a few years ago, loosely funded, very underfunded, short-term grant funded in disparate places around the country. So when you ask about why, you know, why we don't have better research and data, we have not funded the work of community violence intervention, the practice of community violence intervention, or the research around how it works to a level to have great reliable data consistently around how these programs work, why they work, who they work for, in what places they work, under what conditions they work.

SPEAKER_01We don't have sufficient and consistent data around how many people do we need, what types of conflicts can they most help to address? What sort of resources and supports are necessary to be available at the fingertips of those interventionists? Because if you are interrupting conflict and intervening with people who have complex needs, then you need to also have resources and supports and services available to those individuals to help address those needs.

SPEAKER_01And again, up until only just several years ago, have we had investment at a sufficient scale to even begin to talk about community violence intervention as a field. So the research is coming, but research is slow. Research takes deep time and community violence intervention has been funded yet to be implemented consistently at a level where we Can have reliable data to be able to compare and really understand what's happening with programs and practices around the country.

SPEAKER_01And the deep investment was short-lived because in April of 2025, the federal government, under the current administration, stripped away most of that investment in community violence intervention work. And so I think it will be even more difficult to gather great data and conduct really effective and research that can be applied across various contexts because of this disruption and investment at the federal level. States and cities have been trying to supplement that federal investment in various ways, but it will be difficult.

SPEAKER_01All that to say, I think that we do have some data suggesting that community violence intervention, when it is funded appropriately, when it is implemented with accountability and oversight and fidelity, and there is political support for community violence intervention. So recognizing that implementing something that is very community driven, where we are learning and customizing as it goes to meet the needs of each specific community, understanding that there are challenges and obstacles that may occur.

SPEAKER_01And yet there's a need to continue to invest and to continue to stick to the course and make sure that we don't interrupt community violence intervention as soon as we hit obstacles and challenges. Because without that continued investment and that political support long term, we don't ever build the evidence, we don't ever build the research to really understand all that it has to offer and understand how we can best implement it at a scale that would work for various communities within a city or various cities around the country.

SPEAKER_00Especially I'm interested in sort of the non-law enforcement side of things, because there's obviously a lot of things that cities do from law enforcement that don't work. But are there things that cities tend to invest in that as a researcher, as an academic that studies, this drives you nuts, or that maybe doesn't quite get to the driving you nut stage, but that you set tend to see a lot of and you would say if you could tell them, hey, don't do that?

SPEAKER_01Well, I think the first biggest mistake that cities do is not utilizing data to help understand what is going on with violence in their cities and violence in particular communities. There is often a narrative around who's driving violence and what is driving the violence. And without aligning action with the data, then cities are implementing ineffective or inadequate strategies to address it.

SPEAKER_01That's the biggest mistake, though one of the biggest mistakes that I have seen is not using data to inform the policies and practices to address violence in a jurisdiction. Another is related. If the focus is on reducing violence, then you have to understand what sort of interventions can align with the population that is helping to drive violence. So I'm a public health person. I strongly believe in primary prevention, but investing in early childhood education is not going to immediately help to reduce violence in a particular jurisdiction.

SPEAKER_01Investing in school programs, after school programs, unless they are focused on those young people who are at highest risk of violence. You are doing important work. You are investing in the young people and in the communities that may need it, but that is not focused narrowly and intently on violence. And so it's really important that cities understand what is driving violence, who is driving violence, why is violence being driven, and then match interventions to the needs of those populations and those communities.

SPEAKER_01I think another area that needs more development in cities is responding to the aftermath of violence. Violence is devastating to families, to the loved ones of individuals on both sides of violence, and to the communities where it occurs. And cities, in my opinion, as a whole, do too little to recognize and address the trauma, the fear, the anger, the sense of helplessness and hopelessness that can come following incidents of violence.

SPEAKER_01And so there is a great opportunity for cities to do more in response to violence. At the federal level, with the White House Office of Gun Violence Prevention under the previous administration, there was an effort to really develop a rapid response model when there were instances of mass casualty shootings or when there were instances of multiple individual incidents of violence in communities, recognizing that there's a real need to respond to the communities and help to address mental health, emotional health, psychological health, and resource needs in communities that are impacted.

SPEAKER_01And so that is an area that I think cities could really do a better job with. But there's a lot of good things that cities can do, in addition to that narrow focus in law enforcement and thinking about interventions that are really focused to the populations at highest risk of violence, which could be, you know, depending on the data, it could be individuals who are 18 to 20, for example, or it could be individuals who are 30 to 35. And the intervention should look and could and need to look different for those different populations.

SPEAKER_01But in addition to those, those individual level interventions, there's research to support that improving the infrastructure of vacant homes or dilapidated lots, improving the appearance, developing those properties, the improving the facades of lots, improving lighting, access to public spaces, all of those things have been shown to help reduce violence in the areas where they are implemented. And so those are just a few examples of strategies that cities have done and can continue to do to help reduce violence.

SPEAKER_01So I don't want to just focus on uh what all cities have done wrong because there are city leaders that are really implementing some viable research-backed strategies.

SPEAKER_00And my last question, is there a role for AI in any of your work or in any gun violence reduction work that you've seen?

SPEAKER_01That's a great question. Yes, I have actually seen, actually just yesterday, I've seen a new app developed by someone in the CVI, a leader in the CVI field, that is really focused on utilizing AI for documentation of community violence intervention activities to help lessen the burden on violence interventionists and documenting when they're out in the field and engaging with people. Documentation often falls to the wayside.

SPEAKER_01And when they do need to document, then they are often reliving the trauma of the incidents that they were engaging with. So I've seen the use of AI to help simplify the documentation and help to aggregate individual-level intervention efforts up to an organizational level so that leaders can see the performance and engagement of their teens. I've seen AI being used on the research side related to social media and utilizing AI and large language models to help gather data across thousands of social media profiles to understand how violence may escalate or de-escalate on social media, how violence and trauma around violence is expressed via social media.

SPEAKER_01I think that there are probably increasing ways of AI to be used in the research and in the practice of violence prevention. I remain personally remain a skeptic with all of the alarms that we are hearing presently around AI. I remain a skeptic in the security and confidentiality and overall benefit. But I think it can be approached carefully and should be approached thoughtfully because AI has incredible benefits, but we have to be very cognizant about utilizing its capabilities ethically, thoughtfully, with the communities that have been harmed various ways, you know, having them at the center of the conversation, having them helping to lead the way so that we don't repeat harms or or exacerbate harms using technology that is intended to be of benefit.

SPEAKER_00That was such a nuanced answer. That's probably the most wide-ranging, thoughtful answer I think I've got to that question. This has been fantastic. I really appreciate it. Loved hearing all these perspectives, and I really enjoyed the conversation. So thank you so much.

SPEAKER_01Thank you so much for having me, Jeff. I really appreciate the work that you do and the platform that you have. So thank you.

SPEAKER_00Thanks for listening to the Jeffalytics Podcast. Be sure to subscribe and to learn more, head on over to ahdatalytics.com for more information and previous episodes. If you like what you heard, please leave a glowing review, which will help others to discover the show. Until next time, I'm Jeff Asher.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Why Fewer Murders Get Solved These Days With Phil Cook

    Nov 18, 202634 minAudio

    Police departments said they solved 92 percent of homicides nationwide in the early 1960s. Today that figure hovers around 60 percent most years. Phil Cook has spent the last half century figuring out what that enormous...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. How Gun Violence Makes America Sick with Dan Semenza

    Nov 11, 202638 minAudio

    Dan Semenza is a criminologist and director of research at the New Jersey Gun Violence Research Center at Rutgers University’s School of Public Health - a position that puts him deliberately at the intersection of two...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. How States Can Address Gun Violence with Lt. Governor Austin Davis

    Nov 4, 202623 minAudio

    Gun violence is not a one-size-fits-all concern. It can be a different issue depending on where you live and whether it is an urban or rural community. And that makes the problem genuinely hard to address at scale....

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Policing the Big Easy with New Orleans Police Chief Anne Kirkpatrick

    Oct 28, 202634 minAudio

    It takes a certain kind of leader to see a city deemed the country's "murder capital" and actually want to take on that problem. Chief Ann Kirkpatrick has spent 44 years working in some of the most challenging...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. How Cities Succeed and Fail in Public Safety Policy with Gloria Gong

    Oct 21, 202633 minAudio

    One of the hardest questions facing any mayor - and a question that most mayor’s struggle to answer fully - is how you actually know if what you’re doing is working. Gloria Gong co-founded the Government Performance Lab...

    Credit the people on this episode