Gun violence is not a one-size-fits-all concern. It can be a different issue depending on where you live and whether it is an urban or rural community. And that makes the problem genuinely hard to address at scale. Austin Davis has been working on this since he was 16 years old, when gun violence happened on his block in McKeesport and he walked into a city council meeting looking for answers. That experience set the course for everything that followed. He's now the (newly re-elected) Lieutenant Governor of Pennsylvania and chair of the Pennsylvania Commission on Crime and Delinquency, which has directed over a billion dollars in grants into communities across the Commonwealth since he and Governor Shapiro took office. In this episode, we talk about what's behind the historic crime drops in Philadelphia and Pittsburgh, a brand new law he championed to help law enforcement solve cold cases for families still waiting on justice, and how Pennsylvania has managed to keep gun violence reduction genuinely bipartisan. Lt. Gov. Austin A. Davis is the youngest Lieutenant Governor in the country and the first Black Lieutenant Governor in Commonwealth history. Inspired by the history-makers who came before - leaders like Pennsylvania House Speaker K. Leroy Irvis and State Supreme Court Chief Justice Robert Nix Jr. - Austin is determined to motivate a new generation of public servants to break even more barriers. As Lieutenant Governor, Austin presides over the Pennsylvania Senate, chairs the Pennsylvania Board of Pardons, leads the Local Government Advisory Committee and serves on the Pennsylvania Emergency Management Council. Gov. Josh Shapiro has also appointed Austin to chair the Pennsylvania Commission on Crime and Delinquency.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00I'm Jeff Asher and this is the Jeffalytics Podcast. Gun violence is not a one-size-fits-all concern. It can be a different issue depending on where you live and whether it's an urban or rural community. And that makes the problem genuinely hard to address at scale. Austin Davis has been working on this since he was 16 years old when gun violence happened on his block in McKeesport, Pennsylvania, and he walked into a city council meeting looking for answers. That experience set the course for everything that followed. He's now the Lieutenant Governor of Pennsylvania and chair of the Pennsylvania Commission on Crime and Delinquency, which has directed over a billion dollars in grants into communities across the Commonwealth since he and Governor Shapiro took office.
SPEAKER_00In this episode, we talk about what's behind the historic crime drops in Philadelphia and Pittsburgh, a brand new law designed to help law enforcement solve cold cases for families still waiting on jobs, and how Pennsylvania has managed to keep gun violence and reduction genuinely partisan. Let's get into it. My guest today is the Lieutenant Governor of Pennsylvania, Austin Davis. Austin, thank you so much for joining us. Jeff, thank you so much for having me.
SPEAKER_01It's great to be with you.
SPEAKER_00My first question is how did you get to be here? What is your background? What led you to this position?
SPEAKER_01You know, I grew up uh in a small community called McKee Sport, right outside this uh city of Pittsburgh. It's a former steel mill industrial town that had been struggling for a number of years due to the collapse of the steel industry. And when I was 16 years old, there was an incident of gun violence that happened on the block that I lived with my family. And uh that was something that really shook me. It really shattered my sense of safety and security. So I went to a city council meeting uh at 16 years old because I wanted to know what folks were doing about the issue of gun violence.
SPEAKER_01And unfortunately, there wasn't much happening. And so I decided to organize as a young person and start a violence uh prevention organization with some of the folks from my high school to work on addressing youth violence, in particular gun violence, in our community. And this has been the issue that I've worked on uh throughout my entire career. When I graduated college and I got a job serving as a senior advisor in Allegheny County government, I helped launch the county's first office of gun violence prevention under then county executive Rich Fitzgerald. When I became a state representative, I helped launch uh what was called the Gun Violence Reduction Initiative, which is now the violence intervention and prevention grant program that I run as chairman of PCCD.
SPEAKER_01I've met survivors and people who've lost loved ones to gun violence, not just in my community, but all across Pennsylvania. And I've really dedicated my career, my time in public service to making sure that Pennsylvania communities are safer. Uh, and now as Lieutenant Governor, I chair the Pennsylvania Commission on Crime and Delinquency, which has driven out more than a billion dollars in grants to make our community safer since Governor Shapiro and I have taken office.
SPEAKER_00I mean, that's an incredible story. And I feel so unaccomplished as someone that didn't do any of that at 16 years old through uh where you are today. What is sort of your impression? You you're a teenager and you go to a city council meeting. Do you remember what it felt like, what you were expecting, versus sort of the perception of what you got at the meeting? Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So, you know, I think I was expecting to see like a robust debate around community safety and safety and people addressing the issue of gun violence. And I think what I remember was seeing folks who were really struggling to address the issue themselves, right? And at that point, as a 16-year-old, these were much older adults in my community who were had been elected to Oves and were serving in public policy-making positions. And so I realized that, you know, everyone had a role to play. And so I wanted to play a role in making my community safer. And I was really fortunate that there were elected officials in my community who supported a young person who wanted to get involved, who wanted to make a difference.
SPEAKER_01And they worked with me to start that violence prevention organization. And they thought that young people should have a seat at the table. And I think, you know, that is what I have found throughout my entire career that every one of us has a role to play in making our community safer. Some of us can do it from an elected office, some of us do it from volunteering at a community-based organization or working with young people in our community. But I decided that I wanted to make a difference in my community and the place that I lived, primarily because I wanted to live in a safe community. And if you live in a community that's plagued by gun violence, even if you are not a direct victim of gun violence, you are affected.
SPEAKER_01You're affected by the way you interact with your neighbors. You're affected, you know, what you do outside of your home. And if you don't have that sense of safety and security, it really affects everyone. And so that's really what spurred me to get involved. And I have viewed government and politics as a way to give back to my community and make a large difference. And I'm really proud of the work that we've done. Uh, since I've been lieutenant governor, we have fulfilled a promise of funding 2,000 more police officers across Pennsylvania. We've taken a real comprehensive approach to this issue.
SPEAKER_01We've increased state funding for violence intervention and prevention programs that have invested in hundreds of community-led efforts. And for the first time ever, we created the Boost Initiative, which funds after-school programs for young people here in Pennsylvania.
SPEAKER_00So I talk all the time on this podcast about changing the perceptions of usually members of the public to match the reality of the data. We have the data, it shows now things are going down when things got really bad. People often, you know, on opposite ends of the political spectrum would either believe it or not believe it. Your story is much more of a changing the perspectives of people that are holding public office and making their perception meet the reality of the situation. Do you have any advice for how members of the public that are engaging with well-meaning politicians who maybe just don't have an understanding of the issues, how can that perception be changed?
SPEAKER_01Well, I think one of the things, first, as an elected official, you have to recognize that if people don't feel safe in their communities, really nothing else matters. And if one instance of gun violence happens in a community that's one too many, right? And so while we have made progress, we can never let our foot off the gas in working to stamp out violence and particularly gun violence in our communities. I would encourage elected officials to listen when folks are speaking up, particularly around issues of public safety, and to respond, to not just look at the statistics, right?
SPEAKER_01Because people don't, you know, that's not what people live by, right? They live by whether they feel like their street is safe, whether they feel like their community is safe, whether they feel like they live in a safe place to go out at night, right? Our work never stops until people have that sense of community and that feeling. And then I would encourage people who are just regular citizens to think about how they can get involved in making their community safe. And that looks different from every person, whether that's serving your neighborhood watch or volunteering at a local organization that's giving young people a safe place to grow up and to play and to be a young person.
SPEAKER_01So they're not doing something negative in their community, or, you know, running for office to serve in a leadership position uh to help address the issue of public safety. I think this is an area where all of us have a responsibility to play a role.
SPEAKER_00Pennsylvania is so interesting, I feel like, geographically, in that you've got really big cities, you've got steel towns, and you've got a lot of rural communities as well. How does crime and specifically gun violence differ based on sort of the geography of the cities and the rural areas and the suburbs and all of all that Pennsylvania brings?
SPEAKER_01So I will say in big cities like Pittsburgh and Philadelphia, it's gun violence on the street that you see predominantly. But if you go to rural parts of Pennsylvania, suicide by gun violence is a massive issue in more rural communities. Also, safe storage of weapons in those areas is a huge problem. So young people or people in general getting access to guns because they're not safely stored. Those are particularly the issues that you see in more rural and suburban communities. And I will say, no matter where you're at in Pennsylvania, this is an issue that folks are concerned about, even if it looks different in their communities.
SPEAKER_01So to your point, Pennsylvania is a big diverse state. I think I would argue that the state that's most representative of America in a lot of ways, given our makeup. But I think gun violence shows in different forms depending on where you're at. But it's a big issue. Suicide is one of the leading rates in rural and suburban communities in Pennsylvania, by God.
SPEAKER_00I feel like you're the like 12th guest I've had from Pennsylvania on the show. And I'm not asking this rudely, but like, why do I have so many Pennsylvania guests? Is there something in the water? I mean, just like really smart people like Jerry Radcliffe at Penn. I've had Larry Krasner on, I've had it feels like all sorts of guests. It just feels like so many smart talking points and smart opinions are coming on these particular issues from Pennsylvania. Do you have any insight into why that might be the case?
SPEAKER_01Pennsylvanians fundamentally want the opportunity to be safe and feel safe in their communities. And so it has required a comprehensive approach to tackle gun violence from all levels of government, whether you're at local, state, or federal. And I think you've really seen a collaborative effort in Pennsylvania to create a community of folks who are working to stamp out the issue of gun violence in Pennsylvania. So one of the things that I did when I became lieutenant governor was re-establish the Office of Gun Violence Prevention to deal with the issue of gun violence strategically and comprehensively, to work with law enforcement, violence intervention organizations across Pennsylvania to really create a community where folks could learn from each other, could understand best practices and what is working effectively.
SPEAKER_01You're seeing that play out in all the guests and all the folks who are doing work across sectors in Pennsylvania to make Pennsylvanians feel safe and be safe. And so I think that's something that's really special and unique to Pennsylvania.
SPEAKER_00So one of the programs that you recently were heavily involved in and getting launched is I've written it down so I get all the entire acronym correct, violent incident clearance and technological investigative methods, the victim program. Can you walk me through what that is and sort of why that work is so important?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. You know, over the years, I've met with so many people who lost loved ones to gun violence. And I've been really inspired by how they've turned their pain into purpose in a lot of ways. And I truly believe that those people who are closest to the pain should be closest to the power. Unfortunately, some families are still dealing with the fact that the perpetrators who have committed violence upon them or their family members have yet to be found and prosecuted. These families, quite frankly, deserve justice. They deserve some measure of closure from what is a horrific incident.
SPEAKER_01And our communities are less safe because the perpetrators are still on the streets. So we've made significant progress in reducing gun violence across the Commonwealth, but we can't truly celebrate that progress until we can celebrate when the families who are waiting for justice finally receive it. So that's why our administration has created this new Victim Act program to provide grants to local law enforcement so they can solve homicides and other violent crimes. Our most recent state budget included about$2.5 million for the victim program to be administered through the Pennsylvania Commission on Crime and Delinquency, which I'm proud to leave.
SPEAKER_01But we also partnered with Arnold Ventures and they kicked in an additional million dollars in philanthropic funding on top of our investment to help police departments modernize their crime data reporting practices and meet federal standards. And it's my hope, and I think all of our hope, that these grants can help police departments go back and solve, you know, what we call cold cases where killers have so far eluded accountability and justice. Back in August, we held a news conference in Philadelphia to talk about this program. And we brought together legislators from both sides of the aisles, Democrats and Republicans, as well as local law enforcement leaders and family members who've lost uh loved ones to gun violence.
SPEAKER_01And we had dozens of people on stage with us, people who, quite frankly, had almost given up hope. And they said this new program is giving them hope again. And that's why this program is really just so important. And we want these families to know that their loved ones will never be forgotten. And quite frankly, as elected officials and as law enforcement professionals, we're going to keep fighting until we get justice for them and their families.
SPEAKER_00Do you have any other thoughts on ways that further future bipartisan gun violence reduction might be possible?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, look, I think this is an area that's that's really uniquely bipartisan in a really partisan time. We can't simply police our way out of this problem. We have to address the root causes of poverty and help create ladders of opportunity for folks to succeed. And so that means, yes, investing in law enforcement so that we get more cops on the street, but also investing in violence prevention programs that are doing the work every day in communities to stop violence before it happens. But also investing in after-school programs so young people have educationally enriched environments to thrive and to learn so they're not out uh doing things that they shouldn't be doing, but also means creating ladders of opportunity.
SPEAKER_01So investing in education, making sure we're investing in workforce development programs, so there's multiple ladders of opportunity to succeed. The best way to take a gun out of somebody's hand is to put a paycheck in it. And we have to make sure that we're creating those opportunities for folks to thrive and live the American dream so they don't resort to a life of violence.
SPEAKER_00How do you, whenever you come across somebody that doesn't believe the data, be it a member of the public that you're talking to or a fellow elected, how do you deal with that? How do you address that as an issue if the data says one thing clearly and the person just won't believe it, even if it's being approached in good faith? How do you handle things like that?
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell Yeah, look, I think that ultimately goes back to how people feel, right? And I think we have a responsibility to make sure that every person has the opportunity to be safe and feel safe. And so I would certainly say that while the data has trended significantly in the right direction, that we still have more work to do, right? This is quite frankly a never-ending battle to make sure communities are safe. And we need to be doing that in the most comprehensive way and supporting the things that we know work. And so I think I, you know, throughout my time in Office, I've been able to work with folks on all sides of the spectrum who might say that they see the progress, but we still have a lot of work to do.
SPEAKER_01But we need to make sure we're funding the things that are actually working and they're continuing to drive down uh violent crime. And eventually we will get to the point where folks feel safe in their communities.
SPEAKER_00I want to kind of dig deeper into that because Council on Criminal Justice recently had a poll that found they asked people basically like, you know, why don't you feel safe or what are the things that you most fear? And number one was like identity theft. Number two was, I forget what it was, but it was like computer fraud or something like that. It was uh something non-active law enforcement investigative type thing. And then the third was residential burglary. And those were like by far the three things that people in this poll at least seemed to fear.
SPEAKER_00And two of those, you know, there's nothing that law enforcement can really do necessarily from a like, we're gonna go out and patrol for identity theft, probably not gonna happen. And residential burglary is something that has fallen like an astounding amount in the last 30, 40 years, according to all the data that we have. Are there ways that we can sort of match this where the the fears of the people, the things that people fear most, are not necessarily the things that we're uh engaging our law enforcement dollars in? How can we match up the ways that we're spending?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So as it relates to like identity theft, I think as technology gets more sophisticated, people get more sophisticated on how they take advantage of people, right? And I think it's incumbent apart all of us, and particularly in in elected office and public safety, to think about how do we how do we attack those problems from a technological standpoint to protect people. You know, I think a lot of our conversation around violence and in public safety rests on like gun violence, on violence in our communities, on you know, making sure folks feel safe in their communities.
SPEAKER_01But like I I think particularly as technology and AI changes, you're gonna see more people being taken advantage of from whether it's identity theft, whether it's hacking. And so I think that honestly may be a new frontier and public safety for a lot of us. And so I think government sometimes is a little bit slower to respond, but I think to your poll, people are feeling that anxiety already. And so I think we just have to adapt how we develop our public safety strategies to make sure that we're keeping people from being taken advantage of, and particularly senior citizens who who, you know, I think are overwhelmingly uh taken advantage through through some of those means.
SPEAKER_00Pittsburgh and and Philly, obviously being the two biggest cities in your state, have seen just enormous declines in in gun violence over the last five years. I just pulled up the numbers. Philly in 2022 had 387 murders, and this year it's at 124. Pittsburgh had 169 homicides or nonfatal shootings at this point in 2021, and is it 74 right now? My two questions are one, from a messaging thought standpoint, how do you balance the fact that that's amazing success in terms of declines, while also 124 murders is a lot.
SPEAKER_00That's way too many tragedies. And then my second question is to what do you credit these enormous, like historic declines in these places?
SPEAKER_01I think I credit that to really the comprehensive approach we've taken. I mean, you said in the last five years, those declines, we've been in office for four years now. We have taken a very comprehensive approach in terms of the way we fund law enforcement and violence intervention programs on the ground. Uh, but we also have really good partners in the mayors, in terms of the mayor of Philadelphia and the mayor of Pittsburgh, who have really centered public safety in the work that they do every single day. And so I think for the first time, and certainly in my memory that I can remember, you have the state administration with the governor and the lieutenant governor completely in lockstep with the mayors of the two largest communities to help root out violence in our communities.
SPEAKER_01And so everything that we've done on the state level, from putting more investments in police officers on the street and funding violent intervention programs, those are the same things that they're doing in Philadelphia and Pittsburgh. And so there are much more resources on the street to make our community saver. So I would attribute a lot of those results to the coordination that you've seen across the Commonwealth. Uh, I think, you know, we recognize that we still have, to your point, one life being lost is too many, right? And so we still have work to do to eventually hopefully drive that down to zero.
SPEAKER_01And part of that is making sure we're aggressive on the law enforcement front. We're creating opportunities for folks to succeed. I said earlier that I firmly believe that the best way to take a gun out of somebody's hand is to put a paycheck in it. And I think we have a real opportunity to do that. We've invested in workforce development programs significantly. In our time in office, we've created over 260 new apprenticeship and pre-apprenticeship programs. We've created multiple ladders of opportunity to succeed. So if a young person wants to go to college, we want them to be affordable for them. If they want to go into an apprenticeship program and get a skill trade, that's an option.
SPEAKER_01And if they want to go in, start a small business and become an entrepreneur, we have resources for that as well. And so I think we need to continue that approach here on the Commonwealth. And it's clearly working.
SPEAKER_00How do you suggest balancing? Obviously, we have to improve criminal justice. We have to improve our willingness to oftentimes allow people second chances. And that can be an enormous factor in improving the lives of the people that are in involved in the criminal justice system and eventually, you know, improving society down the road, with that risk that if you let somebody out that otherwise would have been serving a longer sentence, justified or not, there is that risk that something happens, that that person is involved in an incident.
SPEAKER_00And there's there's political risk. There's obviously risk of creating future victims and future tragedies. How do you balance those two ideas?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I will tell you, I chair the Pennsylvania Board of Pardons as lieutenant governor. So uh this a part of my day-to-day work every single day is kind of making those evaluations. What I have seen traditionally in Pennsylvania, if you're seeking a pardon, they are people who have already served their sentences and who are back in the community already and serving. And usually the folks who are successful in that process have have demonstrated years of successful behavior, have quite frankly earned a pardon, how they've conducted themselves in terms of turning themselves around from what was probably one of the worst decisions of their lives.
SPEAKER_01And so I will tell you the folks that that do receive a commutation go through a pretty strict evaluation process and, you know, quite frankly, have earned that commutation. So I think there's certainly a balance, but I think we have a really good structure in place that kind of rewards the folks who have truly turned their lives around and earned a second chance. I have not, at least certainly in my time and recent history, I've I have not seen second chances be diametrically opposed to good public safety policy.
SPEAKER_00And my last question is I I've asked this to most of my guests. What are your thoughts on the role that AI can play in criminal justice or in governance? Is there a productive role, or is this something that we need to look at much more cautiously? I'm I'm curious where you fall on that.
SPEAKER_01Well, I I think there is a productive role. And, you know, Governor Shapiro signed an executive order a number of years ago, I think it was in like 2023, kind of setting a set of guardrails and principles for how state government was going to engage with AI technology. And I think it's really important that if you're going to engage in it, and I think at some point it's going to be hard not to, to really be clear about what you're going to use it for, setting up guardrails and principles for how you're going to interact with AI to both enhance your work and make you more efficient in terms of public service delivery, but also making sure we're protecting the rights and freedoms of folks who live in this Commonwealth.
SPEAKER_01And so I think it's a balancing act that will certainly evolve over time. But I think we need to be very clear on what our principles are about how we're going to engage in it.
SPEAKER_00That's great. I really appreciate this. Lieutenant Governor, what is next for you? Any any future innovative ideas in gun violence reduction?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I'm really excited to build on the work that we've done through the Office of Gun Violence Prevention. We're bringing together stakeholders from all across Pennsylvania for our first Office of Gun Violence symposium. I'm excited to continue to build that community, to continue to provide resources to folks who are doing this critical work all across the Commonwealth. I will tell you, I think when my time is done, it'll be some of the work that I'm the most proud of in my time as Lieutenant Governor.
SPEAKER_00Thank you so much for coming on the show. I really appreciate it. It's been a great conversation and uh keep up the great work. Thank you so much. It was great, great meeting with you. Thanks for listening to the Jeffalytics Podcast. Be sure to subscribe and to learn more, head on over to ahdatalytics.com for more information and previous episodes. If you like what you heard, please leave a glowing review, which will help others to discover the show. Until next time, I'm Jeff Asher.
Police departments said they solved 92 percent of homicides nationwide in the early 1960s. Today that figure hovers around 60 percent most years. Phil Cook has spent the last half century figuring out what that enormous...
Dan Semenza is a criminologist and director of research at the New Jersey Gun Violence Research Center at Rutgers University’s School of Public Health - a position that puts him deliberately at the intersection of two...
It takes a certain kind of leader to see a city deemed the country's "murder capital" and actually want to take on that problem. Chief Ann Kirkpatrick has spent 44 years working in some of the most challenging...
One of the hardest questions facing any mayor - and a question that most mayor’s struggle to answer fully - is how you actually know if what you’re doing is working. Gloria Gong co-founded the Government Performance Lab...
Most of what we think we know about gun violence comes from policing data. Dr. Shani Buggs thinks that’s part of the problem. An associate professor at UC Davis’s Violence Prevention Research Program, Dr Buggs came to...