Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Jeff-alytics Podcast

The Jeff-alytics Podcast artwork

How Cities Succeed and Fail in Public Safety Policy with Gloria Gong

Oct 21, 202633 minAudio

One of the hardest questions facing any mayor - and a question that most mayor’s struggle to answer fully - is how you actually know if what you’re doing is working. Gloria Gong co-founded the Government Performance Lab at the Harvard Kennedy School twelve years ago to help cities bridge the gap between policy and implementation. Her work sits at the intersection of data, delivery, and the very pragmatic question of why good ideas so often fail to translate into real-world results. In this episode, we get into why crime statistics alone don't capture whether people actually feel safe, what it looks like when a city gets its structure right, and why the mayor's police chief is often the wrong person to be leading the public safety agenda. Gloria Gong is the Executive Director of the Government Performance Lab at Harvard University’s John F. Kennedy School of Government, where she leads the GPL’s efforts to accelerate the pace of change on serious social problems by improving state and local government. Before joining the Government Performance Lab, Gloria worked on a variety of state and national governance and legal programs including serving as the lead evaluator for the Connecticut Judicial Branch on an evaluation of its mortgage foreclosure mediation program, in the Massachusetts Department of Early Education and Care on the agency’s early education initiatives, and in China at the Yale China Law Center on rule of law projects including criminal justice and judicial reform. Gloria received her Juris Doctorate from Yale Law School, where she was a Public Policy Fellow at the Institute for Social and Policy Studies. She holds a BA magna cum laude from Brigham Young University.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00I'm Jeff Asher, and this is the Jeffalytics Podcast. One of the hardest questions facing any mayor, and a question that most mayors struggle to answer fully, is how you actually know if what you're doing is working. Gloria Gong co-founded the Government Performance Lab at the Harvard Kennedy School 12 years ago to help cities bridge the gap between policy and implementation. Her work sits at the intersection of data, delivery, and the very pragmatic question of why good ideas so often fail to translate into real-world results.

SPEAKER_00In this episode, we get into why crime statistics alone don't capture whether people actually feel safe, what it looks like when a city gets its structure right, and why the mayor's police chief is often the wrong person to be leading the public safety agenda. We also talked about one city's outcomes-based approach to community violence intervention that Gloria loves, and you'll have to tune in to find out what city that is. Let's dive in. My guest today is Gloria Gong. Gloria, thank you so much for joining the show.

SPEAKER_01Happy to be here.

SPEAKER_00So, first question to every guest, walk me through. What is your background? How did you get to be here today?

SPEAKER_01I run the government performance lab at the Harvard Kennedy School, which I helped co-found 12 years ago. And we work with states and cities all across the U.S., specifically in helping them figure out how to bridge from policy into implementation.

SPEAKER_00And how do you approach sort of public safety as an issue? And then you know, how did that become something that you were sort of interested in as from the lab perspective?

SPEAKER_01Jeff, we try to listen really closely to the governments that we work with. And so one thing that I think really sent us down this pathway is that we were convening mayors and state leaders at Harvard, and we were asking them just what are the most important things that you're facing as a public servant? And I think every mayor that we talked to told us that public safety was their number one concern. So as a lab, then we want to be responsive to that because we're hearing so many mayors say that this is something that's important to them. But it's also something that unearthed a topic that I think you'll probably also be really interested in, which was that as a kind of nerdy lab focused on questions around how do you measure then?

SPEAKER_01How do you actually drive performance? We would immediately ask the mayors, okay, great. And so how do you know if you're achieving public safety? And a bunch of the mayors would then say to us, I need help on that. That's actually something that I'm struggling to figure out. I have crime stats, but I don't have a way of actually knowing if I'm achieving public safety.

SPEAKER_00I want to take like four steps back and ask you just like, how did you get into this concept of a lab that, you know, advises policy and specifically advises mayors on how to improve better policy? And then I want to get more into like the definition of public safety and how that experience sort of translated into all this. But how did you get started with just this idea?

SPEAKER_01So I co-founded it with a professor at Harvard named Jeffrey Liebman. He'd been coming back from the White House. I was coming out of working internationally in China and then being at law school and was looking for a way to do things in state and local government in the US. And I think both of us saw this gap, both around supports for state and local leaders. At the time, there was a huge amount of focus if you were interested in US domestic policy on the federal level, but there was very, very little focus on questions around what about governors and state agency heads, mayors and their staff.

SPEAKER_01But then the other thing that I really felt was missing is that you had a lot of people asking questions in the academy around what works, what doesn't. And then it didn't seem like we really had the tools to translate those findings in a way that were actually usable for them. So, you know, people were publishing things in respected journals and just assuming that mayors had the time to go find those articles and read them. But even if you translate the findings over, all of the questions that public leaders have are like, how do you actually do this? What kind of staffing structure do I need? How do I translate it? What happens when I try to do this in my local jurisdiction and I run into these real operational concerns?

SPEAKER_01And it didn't feel like there was any support that I could see really coming out of the academy for public leaders around those types of questions focused not on what should we be doing on paper, but on the real kind of questions around delivery when you go out to do it in the real world. So that's where our lab kind of drew its origins was asking, what are the supports that real world government leaders need, not in you know, theory, but actually in the field and getting stuff done.

SPEAKER_00And I know, you know, you're not supposed to say which child is your favorite or anything like that. Broadly speaking, do you prefer to work with sort of the baby mayors that are just getting started and all the problems are someone else's problems? Or is it the mayor that's and the city that's sort of gotten going, you know, everything's working, the machine is running and they're able to implement change easier?

SPEAKER_01I think you can do totally different things with people who are in transition or early in their administration versus folks who have had a long runway and have figured out how government works. But I'll tell you two of my favorite things. One of the things we focus on a lot is folks who run agencies. I think they are the completely ignored kind of stepchildren within government where everyone is focused on the senior execs, but the senior execs spend almost all of their time on legislation, communications, and crisis. So it's actually the people who lead agencies who are the ones who are out doing the actual work.

SPEAKER_01And there are almost no supports for them, your state agency lead, your department head. So those are some of our favorite folks to work with. One thing that makes this so interesting to me is there's really not enough knowledge transfer between those folks who have figured out how government works, aren't about to leave office, and the new folks who are coming in. In so many administrations, you see people coming in and they're having to reinvent the wheel. How does government work? How where are the levers? How do I actually get stuff done? And one question we're really focused on is how could you shorten that time so if someone entering can benefit from what other people have learned?

SPEAKER_00Turning more to public safety, is there a common definition? Do you all offer a common definition? Or is a city like New Orleans, whose public safety largely revolves around gun violence and protecting tourists, because we're a tourism city, differs very much from, you know, Topeka, Kansas or something like that?

SPEAKER_01I don't think there's a common definition, but I'll tell you all the mayors we talk to have a really good working gut definition. And it's something that I don't think criminology or public safety is typically studied has really gotten its arms around yet, which is that mayors are really interested in the question of whether people who live in their cities feel safe. And as you know, a lot of what's studied are specific measures of particular crimes happening. And partly that's because law enforcement tends to be the basis for almost all of our data about what we think of as public safety.

SPEAKER_01And so we think about crimes committed, how we respond, different metrics of response. But mayors are really working a step back from that and actually just asking in my city, do people feel safe? And so one project that I've been really interested in recently is trying to think about how we might create more comprehensive measures of public safety that take into account not just the absence of crime or the absence of the measurement of crime, but trying to figure out if we could get our arms around the positive existence of a sense of safety.

SPEAKER_00And I definitely want to talk about this perception of safety issue because you know, if you tell me how do we measure public safety, it's here are the seven UCR crime stats and let's measure those and let's show them over time. What are sort of the lessons that you've learned about how there's this enormous disconnect between the actual data, what the crime data often clearly shows, and where that perception may lie, both at the public perspective and then also from the civic government mayor perspective? Because I'm guessing that those differ sometimes.

SPEAKER_01You know what's interesting, Jeff? We had this moment where we had these two separate strands of work that we were doing that ended up kind of colliding in a way that was really helpful for me. So on the one hand, we were meeting with mayors and state public safety folks and police chiefs. And what they were starting to coalesce around as we brought them around the table is that the mayors were saying, listen, my police chief can show me that we're the seven majors, you know, the measurements of kind of traditional measures of crime are dropping in the city. But when I hear from residents, they are not telling me that they feel safer.

SPEAKER_01So there's something that's not working about the traditional way that we are measuring public safety because there's a gap in what I'm hearing from residents and what I can see on paper. And the mayors then felt like they were having to do something you don't ever want to be doing in politics, where you're explaining to people that their experience doesn't match your data. And at the same time, we were doing work with this amazing youth-led organization in St. Paul when Mayor Melvin Carter was there, where we were asking the youth to co-conduct research with us, asking young people in high violence areas of the city what their experience was.

SPEAKER_01And we specifically asked them how their behavior was changing based on whether or not they felt safe. And what they described is they described these really significant changes in their behavior, where some of them talked about not taking jobs because they didn't feel safe traveling to them or having to take lift every day because they felt that public transportation wasn't safe, or really radically altering their patterns of movement. And we asked the kids, like these young people, if you could change something in your neighborhood so that you felt safe, how would we know from the outside?

SPEAKER_01You know, what would you change about your behavior if you did feel safe where you lived? And they described these really ordinary behaviors. They would say to us, well, I'd go outside, I'd ride my bike, I'd go to the park with my friends. So I felt like we heard from these young people in St. Paul that the other side of what we were hearing from the mayors, which was that people didn't feel safe. But if they did feel safe, you would have actually been able to see it in measurable, observable ways. You wouldn't have to just ask people over and over for vibes. You would have seen it in things like foot traffic or presence in parks or people's behavior on public transportation.

SPEAKER_01So that was really intriguing for me because we were hearing from both residents, these young people, and from mayors that there was some definition of public safety that just measuring crime didn't capture. But it also seemed like it wasn't just this intangible thing. There were actual observable things that you might be able to capture in some way.

SPEAKER_00Are there ways that mayors or cities can lead in, you know, a big believer in attitude reflects leadership? And that obviously you don't want to tell people you feel safe, but that you can lead to make people feel safe or to shape their perceptions based on actions. And I'm just thinking of we had Megan Grable on the podcast a couple of weeks ago who talked about in uh Fort Wayne, Indiana doing a crime prevention through environmental design project where they had this high crimes quarter and the city went out and they did all of these things to make people feel safer on this street.

SPEAKER_00Are there other ways that you've worked with cities that the city can not wait for the people to tell them what to do, but can actually go out and proactively push that perception of safety?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Let me talk about two things here. One is I think people should do what you are saying, which is that they should actually listen and be responsive to when people tell them they don't feel safe. I think it is a fool's errand to try to take graphs out and show people that they ought to feel safe. I think it's important for leaders to listen to people and try to figure out why they don't feel safe and then figure out how to respond. And exactly as you just touched on, a lot of things that we heard from people are not things that fall into the traditional law enforcement bucket, which means they're often falling into these cracks in between agencies where people are actually talking about kind of visible signs of public disorder, cleanliness, other things that are a signal to them from their environment about whether they're safe.

SPEAKER_01And I think for a long time people brush those off because they said, well, that's not real. But I think it's important when you're leading in a city to actually listen to people and try to be responsive to them. But the second thing I think Americans do is, or a deputy mayor of public safety or someone to whom this is entrusted, is that they can try to narrow in on those places where things aren't happening because it has fallen in the cracks between different agencies' mandates. So a former deputy mayor of public safety in New York City described to me this project of taking a bunch of agency heads out to a neighborhood that had high violence and walking through the neighborhood and trying to find things that each agency could do.

SPEAKER_01So they would walk through and say, the lights are out here, it's making this area darker. Who can replace the lights? There is trash here, it makes this area look disorderly, who can clean it up? And what he's one of the things he described to me is he said, when you do that exercise, you realize how fragmented agencies are. So people were saying, like, oh, we can't take care of that trash because it's actually on the sidewalks, but sidewalks are different than streets, and we do only sidewalks. And actually, curbs are under a different jurisdiction. So if it crosses over to an issue with the curb, then neither of us can take care of it. And we, you know, like we take care of this street light, but not that street light.

SPEAKER_01I had a friend who's working in the senior strategy level in Arizona send me a map the other day of jurisdiction over tree trimming in downtown Phoenix, where he had said they were trying to figure out basic questions like who can maintain the trees, you know, which gets to questions around public safety, like are they blocking lights? Do it, does it feel safe to walk in this area? And he said that he figured out that there were nine entities that had jurisdiction over trees in downtown Phoenix and created a map that showed where every entity was responsible for which trees.

SPEAKER_01And it's this insane map of this pretty small 30-block area. And so my point overall is as a mayor, you're often one of the few places that crosses those agencies' silos. And if what you're trying to do is advance safety downtown, you actually gonna have to break down some of the silos between those places where people are like, well, that's not my tree. So I can't get that, I can't uncover that light because that's somebody else's tree. And you're gonna have to figure out how to get people to work together to say, like, no, we want lighting here. We want it to feel safe when we walk on the streets, and we need a bunch of these entities to actually figure out how to work together.

SPEAKER_00It sounds a lot like, I mean, almost like broken windows policing, but the broken windows theory, but not the sort of version that it became, which is that we need to police every, you know, gaywalker to make sure that we have no nothing bad happening in a neighborhood. Is there a way to do these steps that don't also include like a massive increase in enforcement? Where are the places that are successfully implementing these concepts without immediately bringing in law enforcement and leading to lots of arrests and then lots of other bad things potentially?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I mean, actually, let me push a little bit on what something you just said, Jeff, which is funny because like nothing I just described actually has to do with enforcement. No, enforcement actually is also probably something that you want to be thinking about what's the right level and what is it that residents want and those types of things. But a bunch of things that I just named aren't even inside law enforcement's purview. But if you talk to residents, there are the things that people often name as the signals to them about whether things are safe or not. This is just me riffing. This is this is not from research. But I think there's a version of broken windows, which was, you know, like the way broken windows ended up getting interpreted is like, oh, therefore you have to then like blink it with a massive amount of enforcement.

SPEAKER_01But there's a different way of interpreting that, which is one of the things that makes people feel safe is a sign that there is capable government that is there to respond. And you look for signs of that in your environment from things like were there things that broke it, where did broken things get fixed? Did things that look like they should have a response in them get handled? And so one thing I would, if a mayor was asking me for advice, one thing I would say is you'd be working with people who don't typically get pulled into these conversations, like your sanitation department or your Publix Works Department, and figure out whether there are all of these broken window equivalents that signal to people that the government is not capable and is not responsive or is not coordinated enough and that can feed into a sense of distrust and go fix them.

SPEAKER_00Are there is there advice that you give mayors on the back end rather from the policy side, but like this is how you should organize your department? You need an analytics department that can take in all of this data and push out these are the things that we need to fix. Are there steps that you guys push or suggest to mayors that aren't on the policy end but on the organizational end to achieve these goals?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I mean, I think there's this one really basic thing that has become increasingly interesting for me as we talk to different cities, which is if you think about all of the things that cities do that are important, almost all of them have a very clear senior role who leads that entire like mandate, has budget and has staffing behind it. So you have schools and you have public works or you have sanitation and like those are empowered positions where you're leading a fleet and you have staffing, that kind of stuff. We have so proxied public safety for law enforcement that the person who often fills that role in a city is a police chief.

SPEAKER_01But when you talk to police and you talk about these things that mayors are hearing about public safety, you know, public disorder, homelessness, these kind of built environment things, most police chiefs will tell you those things are not our job. Like very fairly, police are pushing back a little bit and saying those are things that sit in other agencies' jobs that are now coming and being laid at our feet. But our job is not to end homelessness or to figure out how to connect people to services. Where are those agencies?

SPEAKER_01And so one thing I think is really interesting is public safety very clearly is something broader than law enforcement. But we have talked about police chiefs as the public safety lead in cities, which means that often there's actually this huge gap. Like where is the deputy mayor for public safety or the person who sits in the mayor's office whose job is to work across agencies to drive public safety? Unlike in education or in sanitation or any of those other kinds of core city responsibilities, that's not a consistent role across cities.

SPEAKER_01So you often don't have a person whose job is to coordinate across law enforcement and other agencies to advance public safety for the city.

SPEAKER_00How do you get cities? How do you convince them that this is what you have to do?

SPEAKER_01I mean, listen, I would say this like any mayor who is transitioning in, I would say you need to have clear in your mind who is the public safety lead on your team that is not just the police chief. And sometimes in a lot of smaller cities, it is the mayor, but that means it has to come out of the mayor's like very limited time. So I think an easy fix to this is name a deputy mayor of public safety. Now, some cities are kind of doing this by creating offices of neighborhood safety, but that hasn't quite fixed this structurally if those offices are set up as being at odds with police, because on almost all of these topics, you need to be coordinating with law enforcement and with other agencies.

SPEAKER_01And many offices of neighborhood of safety also haven't been set up to actually be peers with those types of department leads. So you could solve this maybe by taking your office of neighborhood safety and elevating it so it's a co-equal and has the ability to convene folks across those, or you could have a deputy mayor of public safety. But I would certainly say to some mayor, listen, if this is a top priority for you and you can't name the person in your office whose job is to wake up every day and advance it, then you don't have the right structure to making this happen.

SPEAKER_00Do you have, you don't have to name the city, but you can because this is a good question. Do you have a favorite success story?

SPEAKER_01I have a story that I keep telling to anyone who will listen, which is that when Mike Duggan was mayor in Detroit, he had a bunch of ARPA funding and wanted to grant it out through community violence intervention and had the decision of whether they were going to use it to kind of start a new office of neighborhood safety or just get it out in grants. And so one of the first decisions they made was let's get this money out on the streets as fast as we can and figure out what works. And then we'll retroactively build the structure to support it if it is effective. So that first of all, I think is really unusual in government.

SPEAKER_01In government, we like to build bureaucracy first and then see if we can get things to work. They had a very outcomes results-driven focus, which was like get it out fast, find out what works, then build something to sustain it. They put these grants out as outcomes-based contracts, which is super unusual in government. And they said, we're gonna measure on whether shooting drops. But as the kind of trade for being hyper focused on outcomes, they gave the providers enormous amounts of flexibility. They said, you can propose the zones where you have the most proximity to people in your neighborhoods.

SPEAKER_01You can propose the models. We're not gonna micromanage you and tell you exactly what you have to do. And what we're specifically not gonna do is measure you on inputs. So Mayor Duggan said, you know, I was a prosecutor for a long time and I saw all these providers getting paid on touch points, but I don't want to pay on touch points. I want to pay on whether or not we actually have fewer kids getting shot in our city. And that model, I think, is one that mayors should think about because it's so different from business as usual, but it lets you really focus on whether the thing that you want to have happen is actually happening. Well, at the same time, it lets you trust and invest in your provider community and lets them be innovative and flexible and try new things and pivot when things aren't working.

SPEAKER_01When I heard him talk about it and then went on the ground with their providers to see what was happening, felt to me like government trying to work in a way that was innovative and outcomes-focused and flexible that you almost never see.

SPEAKER_00I guess I'm loading this question of a and feel free to, if I'm wrong, disagree with it. But why do you think civic leaders, at least in my experience, and maybe that's just because I'm a place that's more anecdote-driven, why do you think that they resist that? Let's measure everything we're doing, let's research it, let's really understand whether or not it's working. In that, like, let's find out what works as quick as we can and move on to stuff that works. Why do you think that cities resist this? Or alternatively, am I completely wrong?

SPEAKER_00And cities aren't resisting this. This is something that's like healthy and exists.

SPEAKER_01No, I think there are tons of structures in place that make it hard to do stuff like this. I really want to tell you the story about it, but I'm about to teach this class at Harvard and I don't want to like spike the ending for my students.

SPEAKER_00Students, turn off, pause the interview here and you know, go on three minutes. Yeah, exactly.

SPEAKER_01Students, you're not allowed to listen to this part. So when I teach us, I split the class up into three parts. And I say to a third of the class, you're the mayor's office. And I say, then I say to a second part of the class, like, you're the legal and finance office. Your job is to protect the city from things that are risky. Like you've got all these like hot shot politicos running around wanting to do stuff, but your job is to make sure that like we don't get sued or that we don't have some kind of fiscal problem. And then I say to the other third of the class, you're the nonprofit providers. You need to decide whether you want to bid on this contract.

SPEAKER_01And then I have them think through the pros and cons. And I had this student the other day when I was teaching it from the mayor's office, he was saying from the mayor's office perspective, why would you do this? It seems like there's only downside. And no upside. He's like, Are you telling me that I have$7 million of ARPA funding and I can do one of two things? I can announce that I've created an office of public safety or an office of neighborhood safety, and I can have a ribbon cutting and a photo op, and I can tell everyone that I've made an office that has the name of the thing that they care in the title, or that I can put$7 million of funding out on the streets to see if we can drop shootings in the highest violence areas of Detroit and that I'm going to measure it so there's a public scorecard that tells people if it worked or didn't work.

SPEAKER_01He was like, as a mayor, wouldn't you just do the photo op that has only upsides for you? And he's like, minus the fact that people will keep dying, maybe, but like, you know, a lot of these things are really hard and out of your control. And doesn't the system just push you to want to announce that you did things and not actually do hard things? And I think he got it exactly right. It's not anybody's fault, but there's a system which is, you know, don't do high risk, no, don't do hard things that might not work. Do things that are like get political wins and make everybody who is, you know, like already bought into the system happy and just like keep things moving forward because these are really tough problems to solve.

SPEAKER_01And if you take swings at them, you might not, you know, you might not succeed. So it's a little bit better to not know.

SPEAKER_00My kids, when they were in kindergarten, the statement was you can do hard things. And it's funny that at the mayor's office we're like, no, don't do hard things.

SPEAKER_01I mean, look, and I'm and again, I'm not trying to be glib about it. It takes a lot of work. Like to do this in Detroit, the mayor had to personally expend a lot of political capital and show up all these meetings and like kind of knock heads and get people who had a hard time working together to work together and get the procurement office to put things out in a way that they hadn't done before and absorb risk. And so I think if you're a mayor and you're looking at the 10,000 things you have to do, you might decide this isn't the one that I want to do. But I do think mayors who are willing to and like want to try this have to think about doing things not as a kind of in a kind of business as usual way.

SPEAKER_00Do you see, and not asking you to name cities, but do you see commonalities in the cities that aren't succeeding in their approach to public safety, sort of big picture?

SPEAKER_01I mean, I've kind of shown my cards here, but I will say as someone who is nerdily very focused on the question of delivery, a super common mistake that we see all the time is people thinking that when you've made a policy, that's the end of the journey. So you have passed a piece of legislation, you've allocated some funding for something, maybe you've hired someone and the name of this thing is in their title. And a lot of times that's when people kind of, you know, dust their hands off and walk away and say, we did it. And in my view, that you have just started the process of trying to deliver effective policy for your residents, but you have to actually stay the course and get it to work.

SPEAKER_01And so I would say that's a very common problem at all levels of government, which is just that if you're a policymaker, you often are trained to think that the legislation or the city council ordinance or the allocation of funding or even the initiation of the grant is the finish line when it's actually the starting line.

SPEAKER_00And are there things that in sort of the menu of options that cities have that you would say in your experience get talked about too much versus things that don't get talked about enough as potential options?

SPEAKER_01That's a great question. I mean, gun buybacks probably get like more like way more.

SPEAKER_00The research on those is just awful. Like we could do a whole episode.

SPEAKER_01They just don't work, but they feel great. And then you like physically have all these guns, so like it feels like you did something.

SPEAKER_00Revolver from 1922. Look at that.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, exactly. So like that's like I think one of the main ones, which is like we have we should probably just not do things that a lot of people have shown are defect.

SPEAKER_00What about things that don't get talked about enough? Are there ideas that hey, we should be doing these easy, these three things that are really easy or anything like that?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, again, kind of nerdy, but Jens Ludwig's got all this great stuff on CBT and just most people are not doing it. And I think part of it is this exact reason. Like it doesn't fall directly in policing. It would actually sit with maybe schools, it could sit with juvenile justice, but the actual sites of implementation would not sit just under law enforcement. And so it goes into this kind of orphan space in a city where you can look at what UChicago has done and be like, wow, those are great results, but it doesn't map exactly onto something in your org chart where someone who's thinking about public safety has a mandate to move it forward.

SPEAKER_01So that's one example. I think another one is lighting. Again, like this is not only something that you see in the literature, but also residents will name all the time. But in the same way, unless you have someone whose mandate is public safety, who's gonna go work with the people who are thinking about lighting, you roll your lighting out, you know, along your kind of long-term capital improvement plans and on, you know, some kind of like the other ways of monitoring it that have nothing to do with public safety. And so there's just that gap of where the person is whose job is public safety, who's gonna go work with the department who oversees the lighting and try to figure out what would it take to either get more lighting here, replace lighting more quickly?

SPEAKER_01It's a great intervention that isn't the most complicated thing in the world, but it's fallen into this gap where there's no one who owns it on the city side.

SPEAKER_00That's one thing that I point at as one of the like potential drivers of this big drop in crime we've seen. It's like a 90% increase in state and local government spending on lighting infrastructure and in the aftermath of COVID. Are there other like similar little things that you think that maybe are driving this decline in terms of the non just riffing here, the non-traditional public safety ideas that maybe are helping to contribute?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, you're way more in this space than I am. So you're gonna I mean, there are all of those questions around like maybe everyone being online all the time and on their phones is making it so they don't go outside and do crime. So we should get maybe we should give all young people more devices.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. These social media limits are gonna lead to rises in crimes.

SPEAKER_01Somebody can follow and see whether the Jonathan Hayes stuff actually leads to an increase in crime as young people are doing more in real life stuff with each other. Trevor Burrus, Jr.

SPEAKER_00That'd be an interesting uh case study. So last thing I want to talk about, and I'm really interested in this because I ask everybody about AI, and usually it's just sort of like a personal opinion. Do you see smart cities embracing AI in a way that sort of takes advantage of the technology while also appreciating the drawbacks and the potential limitations of the technology?

SPEAKER_01I think cities are doing a bunch of experimenting, so that's great. I'll tell you where I see the biggest gap here, which is that a lot of the innovation I see happening around AI is still being driven on the commercial side. I think we need a lot more investment in public leaders to understand how to be good consumers. Because if you can't be a smart consumer, you can't shape the market. And so right now, what we've essentially done kind of is broken into camps of people who are very kind of AI forward and are just experimenting a ton with like creating new apps, but that's largely on the commercial side.

SPEAKER_01And then you've got a bunch of people who are concerned about AI safety very understandably, but which means they're focusing almost completely on safety and governance and how to slow things down. I think it's really important that people who are concerned about the public welfare also learn how to bend the development of AI so that it has public benefit. I don't want all of the people who are interested in public benefit to only be playing defense and all of the people who are just interested in commercial gain to be the ones who are experimenting and innovating and playing offense.

SPEAKER_01I think it's pretty important that public leaders who whose job is to protect their residents and to deliver better results for them also learn how to demand of AI what the best things are that could be delivered for cities. And I'll give you two examples. We're doing kind of like an early test project right now on whether you could use 911 calls to create a benchmarking tool that would actually let you create a sandbox and then test new AI technologies that are being proposed to governments against some kind of measuring stick.

SPEAKER_01We don't know if it's going to work yet. Hey, so if there are cities out there that want to give us cities out there that want to give us their 9-1 call data, call me. You can be part of this exciting frontier project. But the point here is actually that vendors are coming to cities all the time saying we've got this new technology, you should use it. And the cities have very few ways to verify or test whether the technology actually works. So you run into like very classic procurement traps that governments have had issues with for technology, you know, for decades and are they not new to AI, which is that if you're bad at buying it, you're gonna spend millions of dollars on things that don't work, or you're gonna miss the opportunity to do something that would have really helped deliver better things, but you can't tell because you don't have the internal capacity to gauge the effectiveness of the technology.

SPEAKER_01So one of the things we're asking is can you build ways at like more neutral third-party institutions like a university or you know, somewhere that sits both outside, like outside the commercial sector, but maybe also outside government that can actually set these more rigorous measurement abilities so that governments can come and say, like, hey, someone's telling me that this can actually help parse calls more accurately. Is that true?

SPEAKER_00Are you a techno-optimist or a techno-pessimist as far as sort of the development of AI and implementation in city governance?

SPEAKER_01Okay, I'll give you my hot take on this, which is I don't think it's about technology, it's about people. So I think the real question is, are you pessimistic about humans? Are you optimistic about humans? And it's clear that the biggest risks about AI actually come from humans. I mean, maybe the bots will go, but the way bigger risk is that human beings will use them to create bioterrorism weapons and those types of things. And so if the question is if I'm optimistic or pessimistic about humans, I'm very optimistic about humans. I think we can solve a ton of problems. And I think we're really, really good at coordinating with each other and getting stuff done.

SPEAKER_01And I think we should use all of the tools at our disposal to do that. And when the tools are bad, we shouldn't use them, and when they were good, we should use them. So for me, it's a red herring to ask about AI. I think the underlying question is actually are humans gonna destroy ourselves, or are we gonna work together and fix problems? And I'm super firmly on the like go humanity, we can do it side of the aisle.

SPEAKER_00That's great. Yeah, I agree completely. I think you see people like, oh, this AI produced X, Y, or Z and it was, you know, had all this slop in it, or it looks terrible. It's like, well, no, the the human that prompted it didn't do the things that could potentially have led to a better outcome, or I'm not really explaining it very well, but I agree with you that there it reflects the user. Like if I type something on Microsoft Word and it's just babble, you don't blame Microsoft Word, you blame the human that typed it.

SPEAKER_01Exactly. I mean, look, AI's got new capabilities, and you know, like if we have recursive self-improvement and then the bots decide that their job is to take over the world or something like that might be an issue. But I think we're all excited to think about that problem because if we actually had to fight aliens or band together to fight robots, we'd be really good at it. And so I think we're always looking for like a good, bad guy to fight. But the real problem here is what AI mostly is a really powerful tool. And then the question is are we gonna use it to do harmful things? Are we gonna use it to solve cancer and solve like serious public problems?

SPEAKER_01And that's a question not for AI, but for us.

unknownYeah, absolutely.

SPEAKER_00Gloria, this has been so delightful. Thank you so much for coming on the show. Uh, where can people follow the lab and and all of that you're doing?

SPEAKER_01We're at govlab.hks at Harvard.edu, and I can send you links that you can post in your notes. I will do that.

SPEAKER_00Thank you so much for coming on. This has been delightful. Thanks for listening to the Jeffalytics Podcast. Be sure to subscribe and to learn more, head on over to ahdatalytics.com for more information and previous episodes. If you like what you heard, please leave a glowing review, which will help others to discover the show. Until next time, I'm Jeff Asher.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Why Fewer Murders Get Solved These Days With Phil Cook

    Nov 18, 202634 minAudio

    Police departments said they solved 92 percent of homicides nationwide in the early 1960s. Today that figure hovers around 60 percent most years. Phil Cook has spent the last half century figuring out what that enormous...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. How Gun Violence Makes America Sick with Dan Semenza

    Nov 11, 202638 minAudio

    Dan Semenza is a criminologist and director of research at the New Jersey Gun Violence Research Center at Rutgers University’s School of Public Health - a position that puts him deliberately at the intersection of two...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. How States Can Address Gun Violence with Lt. Governor Austin Davis

    Nov 4, 202623 minAudio

    Gun violence is not a one-size-fits-all concern. It can be a different issue depending on where you live and whether it is an urban or rural community. And that makes the problem genuinely hard to address at scale....

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Policing the Big Easy with New Orleans Police Chief Anne Kirkpatrick

    Oct 28, 202634 minAudio

    It takes a certain kind of leader to see a city deemed the country's "murder capital" and actually want to take on that problem. Chief Ann Kirkpatrick has spent 44 years working in some of the most challenging...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Smarter Ways To Think About Reducing Gun Violence with Shani Buggs

    Oct 14, 202632 minAudio

    Most of what we think we know about gun violence comes from policing data. Dr. Shani Buggs thinks that’s part of the problem. An associate professor at UC Davis’s Violence Prevention Research Program, Dr Buggs came to...

    Credit the people on this episode