Deciphering The American Way Of Killing with Malcolm Gladwell
37 minAudio
The 50th episode of the Jeff-alytics podcast called for a special guest and this episode delivers. Today's guest, Malcolm Gladwell, has a new book out today titled The American Way Of Killing and he was kind enough to come on the show to talk about it. The American Way Of Killing is an attempt to diagnose why America can't have an honest conversation about gun violence and what we're missing because of it. In this episode, we get into why improvements in trauma medicine may be quietly masking the true scale of gun violence, the Second Amendment's actual origins, and why work done in Boston thirty years ago should speak to us about how to reduce gun violence today. This was a terrific, engaging conversation on what we know and don't know about gun violence in the United States. Malcolm Gladwell is a journalist, a speaker, host of the hit podcast Revisionist History, and the author of several New York Times bestsellers including The Tipping Point, Outliers, David and Goliath, Talking to Strangers, and The Bomber Mafia. His forthcoming book, The American Way of Killing (out September 29, 2026), is an incisive investigation into gun violence, America’s deadliest and most polarizing crisis.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00I'm Jeff Asher, and this is the Jeffalytics Podcast. New York City underwent one of the most dramatic drops in crime in American history in the mid-1990s. Today's guest, acclaimed author Malcolm Gladwell, was there to watch it happen and couldn't figure out why. That question became the seed of the tipping point. Since then, he's written six more books, hosted the Revisionist History Podcast, and co-hosted a podcast with Barack Obama. His new book, The American Way of Killing, is an attempt to diagnose why America can't have an honest conversation about gun violence and what we're missing because of it.
SPEAKER_00In this episode, we get into why improvements in trauma medicine may be quietly masking the true scale of gun violence, the Second Amendment's actual origins, and why work done in Boston 30 years ago should speak to us about how to reduce gun violence today. Today's guest is one of the very few writers out there who can make a criminologist and a casual reader both feel like their book was written for them. Let's dive in. My guest today is the great Malcolm Gladwell. Malcolm, thank you so much for joining the show.
SPEAKER_01It's my pleasure, Jeff.
SPEAKER_00So uh my first question is uh, you know, talk me through. What what is your background? Why did how did you get into writing?
SPEAKER_01Oh, how do you get into writing? And everything. By by accident, as much as anything. I just didn't know what to do when I graduated from college and randomly got a job at a magazine and just kind of stuck with it. There was no uh there was no intention behind my career choices.
SPEAKER_00Obviously, you you've put out a a number of books. How do you choose your subjects in these books?
SPEAKER_01It's just things I'm interested in. I, you know, when I was at the Washington Post, I that was my first real job in journalism. I I covered the healthcare industry, pharma, then I covered the healthcare bureaucracy in DC, and then I went to New York and was a New York correspondent just as New York was going through its incredibly tumultuous mid-90s. And it was a sci-I's a science writer for a while. So I maintained an interest in those kind of worlds. You know, urban affairs, science, medicine have all been things I've just come back to again and again.
SPEAKER_00Aaron Ross Powell When you're choosing these subjects, obviously you've written a lot about sort of crime and policing and punishment. Um we're chatting here today. Uh I've actually I've wanted to have you on the show for quite a while, but you also have a book that's out, uh, The American Way of Killing, which I will show, even though this is an audio-only podcast. What keeps pulling you back to this specific territory? Of crime. Yeah, of crime and and justice.
SPEAKER_01This is something you would know more about than me, but it struck it struck first of all, I find the general topic fascinating, as do many people. I crime exposes human beings and human society at their worst. And so it's a kind of there's something riveting about it. But I'm also, but more importantly, I feel like I've been sort of a really fascinated with crime ever since I moved to New York in the mid-90s, just as New York was undergoing this dramatic drop in crime. And I found that story to be just so interesting and to be present as it was happening.
SPEAKER_01I literally arrived in New York when everyone was terrified of crime, and then I always tell the story that when I got first came to New York, when I went out with my friends, we would pool our money at the end of the evening so everyone could take a taxi home, because there's no way we would ever let anyone drive the ride the subway. And then, like, four years later, everyone just rode the subway. Like it wasn't even a thought, like it just had changed so dramatically. And I found that that was the kind of one of the impetuses for writing my first book, Tipping Point. I just was I was just so baffled and amazed by that transformation.
SPEAKER_01But then what's happened is I feel like criminology in general and the kind of practice of understanding crime has evolved so rapidly in the last 25 years, it's just the most interesting story out there. I mean, name me another field of such social importance where the conversations we're having today have almost nothing to do with the conversations we had in 1990. Cardiologists are still talking about cardiology, they're still talking about like strokes and you know, and hearts and and blocked arteries and you know, everyone else is having versions of the same conversation.
SPEAKER_01I feel like in the world of crime fighting, particularly in homicide prevention, we're just having a different conversation. And that's anytime you can sort of, as a journalist, hit your wagon to a world that's evolving that quickly, it's it's um captivating.
SPEAKER_00You talked about the 90s in New York, and it fascinates me. First, I want to like I want to hear more about what was it like living through the, you know, the the grave from 2,000 murders to like 400 murders in the span of of you know a presidential administration. And why are we still discussing it sometimes? I mean, you see New York's a hellhole, or the people don't necessarily accept and understand the degree that things have changed and changed in four years, but have are just so dramatically different now than they were 30 years ago.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. There was a JD Vance tweet before he became vice president. It was half joking. He's like, I'm I'm going to New York City. Can anyone tell me, you know, how to how to deal with the with the mayhem and the craziness or something? And like everyone in New York who read that laugh because, of course, Cincinnati, where he lives, is like so much more dangerous than New York City. It's not even close. It's like two X more dangerous. So this is another fascinating feature of crime, which is the gap between what's happening on the ground and public understanding is so enormous.
SPEAKER_01I can't think of another field where what people think is happening and what is actually happening are just two completely different stories. And I think it's because people's feelings about crime are it's a fantasy, right? We have fantasies about crime. You know, we we think of ourselves as being um in harm's way when statistically we're not. You know, like you know, in in New York City, for example, you'll read every day in the paper you can read some incredible crime, an account of some incredible heinous crime. And they don't mention, of course, that the denominator is whatever, nine million.
SPEAKER_01Yes, in a city of nine million there'll be one heinous crime a day. Like that that's that's actually a small number, right? So I don't know. There's I that's another thing that fascinates. I think I think it really it's because we don't get our understanding about crime from actual crime. We get our understanding from uh the movies and television and that kind of stuff.
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell So you have this book coming out. How would you summarize it?
SPEAKER_01Aaron Ross Powell Broadly speaking, it's an attempt to explain, not in a systematic way, because I don't know enough to do it in a systematic way. And I d it would also require a systematic examination of this question, would require thousands of pages. But I was trying to figure out why America has such a l higher violent crime problem than its peers around the world. I don't know the exact numbers at the moment, but it's the difference in the murder rate between, you know, Germany and the United States is what is it, like 4X, something like that.
SPEAKER_00I I don't know the exact numbers, but yeah, it's it's murder's the thing that stands out between America and everything else. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01I was trying to figure out why why is that so? And along the way, the asking that question allows you to ask other connected and deeply important questions, which is do we, when we talk about crime, non-specialist, that is, are we having a real conversation, an honest conversation? Do we know what we're talking about? Are we defining things properly? Do we have an accurate picture of what's happening on the streets or with so the second theme of the book in an instrument question, I try and get at what I think is dishonest about Americans, the way Americans talk about crime.
SPEAKER_01I just feel like there are a lot of dishonest conversations in America about lots of topics, but few are as kind of so unmoored from reality as the way we talk about gun violence. And I wanted to kind of educate people a little bit. I always try this in my books. I don't think I can convince people, but I think I can at least prompt them to ask a different set of questions. So that was the intention of the book.
SPEAKER_00As you said, it's not systemic about crime, but it is sort of systemic about America. And I appreciated that when reading it.
SPEAKER_01Yes. It is it's really asking the question, what's going on with America that creates this kind of blind spot or this misunderstanding about crime? And so there are chapters that talk about when the Supreme Court gets to gun rights, they kind of lose their mind. And I have two chapters talking about how kind of crazy their discussion of gun rights is. Or I'm fascinated by the role that healthcare medicine has played in altering our perception of the of the gun violence epidemic.
SPEAKER_01I always thought that would be an issue, that, you know, maybe if doctors get better at treating gunshot wounds, they're gonna make it seem like gun violence is not as bad as it really is. And I sort of convinced myself in writing the book that improvements in medical care play a much bigger role in reducing homicides than we have than we realize. There's a study that was done in Memphis, and Memphis is in many ways, as you would know, a sirigenerous city. It doesn't does not stand for America when it comes to gun violence. But in Memphis, you can make a pretty plausible statistical argument that their gut level of gun violence is getting worse and their homicide rate is falling.
SPEAKER_01And that the difference, the paradox is explained by the fact that their healthcare got a lot better, their trauma care. That's interesting. That's really interesting to me.
SPEAKER_00One of the things, and I I think that looking at this from like a much closer lens, I think that what we see, and and again, one of these is this is a data challenge.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00We don't have good victim-level data of Memphis gun violence. We don't have, for most places, good victim level data. What we tend to see in the cities that sort of have that published is that over sort of the short term, you know, the last five years, 10 years, we see kind of a steady level. And this is a question I've always I've thought was really interested. Like Chicago is not necessarily seeing over the last decade a decline in the share of shooting victims that die, but it makes total sense that over the last 20 or 30 or 40 years, they've seen a big drop. I've always thought what we're not seeing is that the scale of uh the caliber of ammunition that's on the streets, the number of guns that can do horrible things to a body, worst thing to a body, have sort of increased as met the medical profession.
SPEAKER_00And so it's sort of created this balancing. Does that make sense? Are there other factors that could be in the short term explaining this?
SPEAKER_01Every single I talked to a whole bunch of ER docs and trauma care people, and every single one of them said the same thing, said exactly what you just said, which is that there is this kind of risk homeostasis when it comes to gun violence, that as they've gotten better at treating gunshot wounds, the shooting practices of would-be uh murderers on the streets have gotten more extreme. And you can measure it within a hospital. So if you look at, so this was use Memphis again as the example, in a study from the big University of Tennessee Trauma Center in Memphis that I mentioned, they so they just use their patient population and they compare it over time, and they do see over the last whatever it is, 20 years, greater severity of wounds, more cases of multiple gunshot wounds, and an increase in the caliber of of handgun being used.
SPEAKER_01And then anecdotally, I heard it like so many times I stopped keeping count that they were saying the kids used to shoot once and now they're shooting four times. So, like, and whether that's kind of unconsciously connected to the fact that he that medicine's gotten so much better, or maybe it's being driven by some people I talked to said, you know, it's that's just the way shooting happens in video games and and the movies now. No one does a single shot. And they're just, you know, this is all there's a theatrical element to this. People are reflecting, they're picking up their cues from fictionalized portrayals.
SPEAKER_01And maybe that is too. I don't know, I don't have a good explanation for it, but I do I think that there's absolutely something to what you just said.
SPEAKER_00It it feels so important because as I look at the cities that do have that data, New Orleans and Baltimore, a third of shooting victims die. In Chicago, it's 15%. In Rochester, New York, it's like 12%.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you sent me that chart. I thought that chart was fascinating. Pittsburgh, yeah, very high number of shooting victims die in Pittsburgh. But I was wondering, I asked my f the guy I wrote about, the trauma surgeon at at Howard University Hospital in um DC. And because I was wondering whether that Baltimore number, is it because there's a smaller number of of um high-level trauma centers? Are they taking longer to get to the hospital? But that doesn't seem right.
SPEAKER_01And I don't understand Pittsburgh because Pittsburgh's not a big place. And Chicago recently opened a trauma center on the south side. So I don't know the answer to that. I would imagine I think a a a really, really interesting PhD thesis for somebody would be to examine different urban cultures around gun violence. So it makes sense that there might be kind of very, very localized norms about what it means to shoot somebody.
SPEAKER_00It's so important because it's not the ideal way to r reduce murder, you know, you saving more lives, but you you obviously want fewer shootings as the way that you reduce murder. But if you can find out what's in the water in in certain cities that's not in the water in others, it logically to me for like a decade has seemed like a really smart approach to murder reduction.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I th I agree with that. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00So how do you do research for a book like this? Do you just have an idea, write down a bunch of smart people and go out and start talking to them? Or is there a lot of academic book learning that goes into this?
SPEAKER_01Well, I mean, to my great dishonor, I only discovered you like a couple months ago. I what I should have done is I should have started just by reading lots of Jeff Asher substacks. That would have gotten me far further along. No, I started in the evening academic literature and then I a lot of it is just talking to people. Like the chapter on we've been talking about trauma surgeons, there's a chapter on his the most interesting case of the career of this guy named Eddie Cornwall, who's considered, among people who treat gunshot wounds, considered to be the best. He's like the king of this.
SPEAKER_01He's probably treated more gunshot wounds than anyone else in the country. There, I just went to see him and he told this incredible story about this one case he'd had. And so that's that's the way I like to work. I realized, oh, this is a great story. And I will use this story to make a point about the relationship between homicide and the quality of trauma medicine.
SPEAKER_00And can you talk through that story? Because it is I I thought it was the most fascinating part of the book was learning that and then going up and being a data nerd and doing the research that like So I I we'll get to that, but I sent your chart to Eddie.
SPEAKER_01Okay. So I go see Eddie Cornwall, and he's this guy in his late 60s, mid mid-early 60s, who's he trained at LA County in the 90s and late 80s, height of the crack epidemic. Then he goes and runs the trauma center at Hopkins in Baltimore in the early aughts, in the middle of it all. And then he goes to DC, former murder capital of the world. So his so imagine someone, he's now in his early 60s. So he spent 30 years in South Central LA, uh Baltimore, and central Baltimore and Northwest DC.
SPEAKER_01So, like, he's seen an astonishing number of gunshot victims. And he told me this story about a guy comes in with two gunshots to the chest, a gunshot to the thigh, and a gunshot wound to the scrotum. And he's in really, really, really rough shape. And he's almost certainly going to die. They wheel him in, they do everything in their power. He has massive blood loss. He's going through this kind of um uh vicious cycle of blood loss where you the more blood you lose, the more uh acidic it becomes, the harder it is to clot, and then it sort of gets worse, you so you lose even more blood because you can't clot, and your blood acid, your pH levels go to even higher, and eventually life cannot be sustained.
SPEAKER_01And this this kid's in that death spiral. And they've all but given up on him, and they they go and they you know remove the bullets and do everything they can, and they take him out, and he's in the OR for your for thing, and they pretty much have given up. And then he survives. He's wheeled in at like five o'clock in the afternoon. By morning, he's fine. And they don't understand it. Like, by all of their algorithms and statistics, he should be dead. And they try and figure out, like, well, what why would this guy have survived? And what he realizes is, what he hypothesizes is the gunshot wound to the scrotum essentially castrated this kid.
SPEAKER_01So his levels of testosterone plummet. And so he is effectively, in that instance, he is responding to his gunshot wound much more like a woman would than a man. And what Cornwall realizes that hypothesizes is that, wait a second, women are have to evolutionarily have to have evolved to be able to sustain regular bouts of very large blood loss. As a result, you might expect them to be able to survive massive hemorrhagic shock much better than men.
SPEAKER_01And maybe what's making men more susceptible to massive hemorrhage shock is testosterone. So we took this kid's testosterone away by chance, because he happened to be shot in the scrotum. And we cast treated him for eight hours or whatever it was. He responded as as well as a as a woman responds in that instance. You know, he then looked at various databases that determined that showed, yes, in fact, women do seem to survive massive hemorrhagic shock better than men. You went in your database and you sent me, which I sent to Eddie Cornwall, a comparison of male and female survival rates of gunshot wounds in whatever what was it, eight eight big American cities.
SPEAKER_0012 cities, I think.
SPEAKER_01In 11 of the 12 cases, women had a large and statistically significant advantage in gunshot wound survival than men. And so, like, the it's fascinating. Like, until Eddie Cornwall had this, this has never occurred to anyone to think that there may be so now he's thinking maybe one way we can help save gunshot wound victims is to give them a testosterone blocker. Just to let get them through the night, you know, when they come in. But my my broader point was this is such an American thing. It's a one in a million observation that comes from a one in a million case where a guy happens to have had two gunshot wounds to the chest and had his sensament discastrated by a bullet.
SPEAKER_01And that case happens to have been seen by one of the most, you know, learned and experienced gunshot wound experts in in the world. No other country in the world has such a thing called a gunshot wound expert, has seized so many gunshot wounds that they would, you know, in order to see a one in a million case, you have to see a million cases, right? No one else has a million cases. It's such an ironic, we have these in, we've developed this perverse specialty in saving people who have been, you know, brutally attacked with guns because we've got an out-out-of-control gunshot wound problem.
SPEAKER_00How do we take that to the next step? Um, I just pulled up the chart and you look at Baltimore, 28, 29% of male shooting victims between 2022 and 2026 died compared to 20% of female. Uh Chicago at 17.5 to 11.5. Boston at 17 to 12 and a half. I mean, it's you just go down the list. Cincinnati being the only city, and that's virtually tied. It's 17.3 to 18.1%. What is the next step? How does this turn into something that can help save lives?
SPEAKER_01We need to test out Eddie Cuomo's idea that giving a testosterone blocker to someone suffering from massive hemorrhagic shock and see whether that improves survival. In a macro sense, you can argue perversely it makes the problem worse. Because my argument is the better we get at treating gunshot wounds, the less urgency there is to do anything about gun violence. I totally think that on some level, that is what has bedeviled America's attempt to address this problem. You can't get people's attention because the doctors have made the problem go away.
SPEAKER_01I have no idea what this is an accurate estimate, but there's a study I cited tried to calculate what the annual decrease in gunshot wound mortality that is due entirely to improvements in healthcare. If all things were held equal, the murder rate in this country would drop 2% a year just because doctors were better at treating gunshot wounds. And if you gain that out over 50, 60 years, you know, we would if we held levels of health care constant at 1960, in 1960, like at 1960 levels, we'd have 75,000 gunshot uh deaths in America today.
SPEAKER_01It's huge.
SPEAKER_00We don't talk about the benefits of the Vietnam War and the Gulf Wars and Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Like we just learned so much. That's insane. Can you imagine living in a country where we had 75,000 gunshot deaths a year? Like that's just unimaginable.
SPEAKER_00And we're we talk about, you know, the US versus Germany as uh four times now. Imagine.
SPEAKER_01Imagine, yeah. What do we do?
SPEAKER_00Uh one of my favorite quotes, uh the one that stuck with me was uh where you talk about the blind man and the elephant. I'd never heard that analogy, but everyone's looking at this different set of statistics or zeroes in on one particular fact. You know, one guy's holding the tusk, one guy's holding the leg, one guy's holding the tail as a storyteller, as a communicator. How do we get that to not be true? Because that's a problem I run into all the time with crime data.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Uh well, I think we need to distinguish between, I mean, one of the between the there are two conversations that have to happen in this and in any other area of kind of importance in this country. There's the internal conversation and there's the external conversation. You are actually one of the few, since I've started to read you. I feel like you're one of the few people who is adept at both those conversations. So I can imagine your stuff being read by a criminologist steeped in all this stuff. But also lay people, I mean, I'm a lay person, I read your stuff and I lap it up.
SPEAKER_01That's super rare. Normally, any kind of person in the world and all this is capable of only one kind of conversation at a time. Or at least, if they want to have both conversations, they have to dramatically change the way they communicate. So for the external conversation with the outside world, you have Have to tell stories. People aren't numerate enough and don't have the patience or expertise, understandably, to make sense of any kind of statistical statistical argument. For the inside conversation with other experts, you have to use that language.
SPEAKER_01Because telling stories does not help us, right? If we're if we're anal analyzing the data from a gunshot violence reduction in X number of cities, for them to tell a story about they met a kid on the street and he had listeners, it's like that's nonsense. It doesn't help anybody, right? You need data. What I think happens is that each side sort of throws rocks at the other side. The the data people, the inside people throw rocks at the storytelling outsiders and say you're not rigorous. And the outsiders throw rocks at the insiders and say, I can't understand what you're talking about.
SPEAKER_01Right. Happened, it's ha happens in medicine all the time. It's kind of and my point is you need both. And my job, I'm doing the outside conversation. I I so I'm telling stories, and I'm hoping that if you tell a story the right way, you will excite someone's curiosity to the point where they will start to venture and participate in the inside conversation. That's my goal. That's my holy grail, is the reader who makes that transition.
SPEAKER_00What about the person, I guess, that is holding a tail and is telling you that it's a leg? I mean, it's the person that doesn't believe it. Um, I'm just thinking, so the White House uh recently was quoted me and um I was included in their press release on crime being down. And I I really appreciate that because I I like that that conversation that matches reality. And 10 months ago, I was in Charlotte for a congressional hearing testifying and getting castigated by Republicans for saying that crime was down. The same message that I've been saying now.
SPEAKER_00Do you think about the person that that either in good faith because they've just don't think it's true because these are hard to understand through anecdotes, um, or in bad faith is is not addressing the problem appropriately. Do you try to reach that person and change minds, or that those are a lost cause? I'll deal with that.
SPEAKER_01It's that it takes a long time. Even on the inside, it takes a long time. I had a conversation two days ago. I went and interviewed um David Kennedy. You know the I know David Wells. Yeah. Because I wanted to write something about Baltimore, about Western District. And I was like, oh, I remembered Kennedy and Tony Brago were in Baltimore in the 90s, and more famously in Boston in the 90s, doing a version of what's being doing done today. So my question is, wait a second, that was 30 years ago. So we had proof of concept 30 years ago on a homicide prevention strategy.
SPEAKER_01And why'd it take 30 years for us to try it again in a place like Baltimore? Right? That was my question for him. And his answer was, you know, we spent like a good hour on this subject. Even among experts, it's hard. People have their own agendas. People, you know, almost an entire a generation of people has to die off for a new idea to because he was talking about how in Baltimore originally he was trying to convince the Baltimore people to adopt this focused deterrence back in the 90s. And it was got killed by Martin O'Malley, who was then the mayor of Baltimore.
SPEAKER_01And the guy that O'Malley brought in to kill it was Jack Maple, who was the stats guy from the NYPD. And Maple was his charismatic character who had an incredible story he was telling about the crime drop in New York, who had all of these statistics and numbers. You know, he's he was the Comstat. Was he? He was the Compstat guy. And, you know, his story was better than David and David Kennedy and Anthony Bragg's story was kind of like touchy, sounded kind of touchy feely.
SPEAKER_01It was they didn't have great data, they didn't, you know, you know, and Maple was like, I could show you capture and chapter and verse and blah blah blah. And you know, he won the day. And I he shouldn't have won the day, right? Like that was a mistake. Um by the way, who was fooled by Jack Maple? Me. Like I bought that whole thing line hook line and sinker. It's hard. Um, and I don't think so. In a long answer to your question, I have lowered my expectations, and I think my job is just to get people asking the right kinds of questions.
SPEAKER_01Um, and then you can't really do much more than that.
SPEAKER_00David Kennedy came to New Orleans when I was a baby analyst with the New Orleans Police Department and implemented GVRS here, and they immediately had a uh a big decline. Robert Ingall, who was at the University of Cincinnati at the time, they came in, they did all the academic research, they showed because they implemented GVRS, they could prove the causation. And then the city sort of just ran out of steam. And, you know, guy within the mayor's office leaves, and next person comes in doesn't have that background, they don't run it the same. And and it just it was like so interesting to watch this strategy that is not easy and takes it takes resources and it takes, but it takes sort of commitment, and then that sort of dissipated weirdly, and and they lost the strategy completely.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's an it's all about structure and institutions and scalability and like replicability, and it's just uh it's it reminds me a lot of um, you know, you have a school that works really, really well, and then the principal leaves, and then the school falls apart, and you realize the principal's, you know, invariably this charismatic, like brilliant person who does this, this, this, and then they have all these great results, and then it doesn't outlive their departure.
SPEAKER_00The book, um, you know, you said it's not an argument for more gun control, but a reevaluation of the issue. You obviously you delve into the the case history far more than I ever knew about the case history of uh, you know, sort of litigating the Second Amendment. Guests that I I just recently had on, Tom Chitham, talked a lot about how ignored the Second Amendment for centuries, and now we're getting all of this discussion about it. Like, what what was your intended approach to talk about, really address these issues that we don't, I guess we don't address honestly, and neither side really approaches honestly.
SPEAKER_01I deliberately limited my conversation on the on gun control in the book, mostly because I think gun control is greatly overstated as a potential antidote to gun violence. Uh I just think it's an unwinnable war. In a in a perfect world, would we have a lot fewer guns in the street? Yes. Are we ever going to get there? I just don't. I just don't believe we will. If all the energy that went into these fruitless gun control crusades was put into other things that we know work, we'd be way ahead. That being said, I do find there are things about the way the both the right and the left talk about guns that are just ludicrous.
SPEAKER_01And the Second Amendment is a great example of that. It's like it is it had nothing to do whatsoever with the way people talk about it now. It was, as I describe in that chapter, you know, it was the southern plantation owners had militia, which they used to keep the slaves down. And they were really, really worried when the Constitution was being written that the northern states were gonna take away their militias. And if you were living in South Carolina and the number of slaves in your community outnumbered the number of white people 20 to 1, you were petrified.
SPEAKER_01And you were like, if I can't have a militia, I'm gonna get killed one night. And they cut a deal. And the deal was you, because we need our militias so much, you gotta, we gotta be able to have our guns so we can keep arming people to keep slaves down. That was what the Second Amendment was about. That's a really beautiful work done by uh by a guy named Carl Bogus, who wrote a really beautiful book outlining this argument. But others have participated in the same general um argument. But like to pretend that this was some kind of like grand statement about a fundamental right owed to every American, it's just nonsense.
SPEAKER_01If you want to be an originalist, which is what the court wants to be, go back and read the history and you will discover like the Virginia Ratifying Convention when the when the all the delegates um from Virginia were gathering for whatever it was, three weeks to figure out whether they were going to affirm this new constitution that had been dreamt up. This is all they argued about. They were like, do we get to keep our militia or not? That's what was on their mind. They're all plantation owners in Richmond, and their wives and kids were at home living in some community where they were outnumbered by enslaved people.
SPEAKER_01And they were like, you know, sitting there scared out of their minds and saying, Oh my God, I hope we have enough guns and enough militia to defend ourselves. You can't follow that particular argument as it has evolved in the last 20 years and not roll your eyes. And, you know, and then I have another chapter where I talk about just how commonplace gun control was in like the 19th century frontier. They have gun regulations that we wouldn't even dream of today.
SPEAKER_01Nothing is more American than gun control. But anyway, like I said, I don't it's a it's a frustrating topic because it is not the most important topic for anyone interested in curbing gun violence.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. The the other data thing that I did, I told you this, um you close with the talking about Dodge City and the American West and all the things they did and how they had uh hired officers and they had a population of 166 people per officer. And you you say that you know you don't think anywhere else has that um ratio. Today, I looked it up. Atlantic City, New Jersey has 133 people per officer and is the only city in America that would meet that.
SPEAKER_01Wait, why is that?
SPEAKER_00I have no idea. I've looked at the 2025 numbers. Miami Beach is close at 170.
SPEAKER_01Well, okay, so here's our explanation though. High places with a high degree of tourist volume have police forces that are designed to meet them to uh to deal with the height of tourist season. And so it's misleading to look at residents, right? I would imagine there aren't a lot of residents of Atlantic City, but there are a lot of people in Atlantic City when the people descend on the casino.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's a much smaller city than I think it probably but that's fast. Um I love I love a book that I can like you bring me through the story, and me as a data nerd can go on my own adventures and find these things. So I really appreciated that. Is there anything that surprised you that jumped out while you were researching this that made you rethink what you were talking about or or dig in deeper?
SPEAKER_01I mean, I I thought the I opened with a chapter on um assault rifles and assault rifle bands and just how kind of silly that conversation is. And I I was surprised in that writing that chapter how cynical some gun control advocates are about assault rifles. They know that an assault rifle ban does nothing whatsoever to curb the lethality of weapons being used by the on the street. But and they're quite open about it, and that sort of surprised me.
SPEAKER_01I was also surprised to look at the data and see how small a role assault rifles play in mass shootings. Um, and how you're more likely to die of a handgun from a handgun than an assault rifle in a mass shooting. For obvious reasons when you think about it, just because you are more likely to be shot more than once with a handgun. You're more likely to be shot up close with a handgun. The guy can get closer to you if he's got a handgun. You don't see him with his rifle far away. The rifle will put you down with one shot, so you're more likely to be lither injured. I mean, there's all kinds of reasons why that would be case.
SPEAKER_01I mean, the handgun is an incredibly nasty piece of work. But this sort of mythology we have, like, we've created another mythology around school shootings. And also the fact that school shootings represent such a tiny, tiny, tiny fraction of the overall homicide toll. That number also surprised me. I would have thought it was small, but like appreciable. It's not even appreciable. If you look over the last 20 years, I mean, we could have removed every school shooting, every mass shooting in America, and we wouldn't even, in terms of the statistics, we would not notice the difference.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you wouldn't know.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00There's always there's always these charts that like take the assault weapon ban in the 90s and then it getting taken away, and they try to fit a narrative in there, and it just it never fits with the actual story.
SPEAKER_01It's like such bogus science.
SPEAKER_00So, my last question what is it like co-hosting a podcast with Barack Obama?
SPEAKER_01Oh, that was fun. Uh he uh, you know, he And would he like to come on this show?
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_01You can always ask him. He uh I mean, he's an insanely charming and charismatic guy. And we did this thing, we you're mentioning this thing I did with him on Reconstruction, and he happens to be a student of that era of American history. And it was so delightful to see him in his kind of academic I mean, he was a he's a performer professor, like he's a law professor. It was so delightful to see him in his academic wheelhouse where he just like his grasp of facts and nuance and the literature was just superb, and he was I don't know, it was just like he was I was just kind of my role was just to kind of keep him going.
SPEAKER_01I wasn't I wasn't offering any kind of meaningful insights, but um he was doing all the work. He's a very smart guy. There's a kind of effortlessness to the way that he uh speaks and thinks. Um and I will be having met him now, I'm even more I have even more respect for him.
SPEAKER_00That's fantastic. So what's next for you? Any any next books, a second edition, which includes nothing but chapters about me, uh uh, whatever. Any any ideas for what you're gonna work on next?
SPEAKER_01Hey, can I give a shameless plug for your for your for your substack on your on your podcast? I wish I'd known about it. I now read everything. I am it's fascinating. I don't know where you came from or how you know. And also, but also part of me is sad because in a properly run society, you shouldn't exist.
SPEAKER_02It's like not at all.
SPEAKER_01Like it's why we privatize we've privatized, or the only reason we have like really great data on all these things is like a dude in New Orleans decided to do it. Like, you know, that's that's there is something very bittersweet about what you do.
SPEAKER_00I I referred to myself at like a Washington Post article. I was being interviewed, my wife overheard me calling myself out. Like, it shouldn't be some random guy on Twitter telling people what the nation's murder trends are, but it is. And my wife was like, No, you you pr don't put yourself down like that, but it it's absolutely true. It should be a government agency, possibly a federal bureau of investigation doing these sort of things.
SPEAKER_01But maybe that's the but I wonder actually, maybe this is actually what the future looks like. As databases get more kind of shareable and manageable, and as data gets easier to collect, maybe there maybe we do see increasing privatization of uh uh a lot of our understanding of statistical patterns and things. It's already happened, you know, that's what the academic literature is. It's in some sense, it's standing in for more formal understanding of various phenomena. But anyway, yeah, it's weird that this should matter so much, and that the best source I've found in years and years and years of of reporting on this is you.
SPEAKER_00So it's like I appreciate that, and I I agree with the uh the dude in Lakeview. Go New Orleans. Loving the New Orleans shout out. All right, the the book is The American Way of Killing. Uh, it's out now. Um, highly recommended. Malcolm, thank you so much for joining the show. It's really fun. Thank you, Jeff. Thanks for listening to the Jeffalytics Podcast. Be sure to subscribe and to learn more, head on over to ahdatalytics.com for more information and previous episodes. If you like what you heard, please leave a glowing review, which will help others to discover the show.
Police departments said they solved 92 percent of homicides nationwide in the early 1960s. Today that figure hovers around 60 percent most years. Phil Cook has spent the last half century figuring out what that enormous...
Dan Semenza is a criminologist and director of research at the New Jersey Gun Violence Research Center at Rutgers University’s School of Public Health - a position that puts him deliberately at the intersection of two...
Gun violence is not a one-size-fits-all concern. It can be a different issue depending on where you live and whether it is an urban or rural community. And that makes the problem genuinely hard to address at scale....
It takes a certain kind of leader to see a city deemed the country's "murder capital" and actually want to take on that problem. Chief Ann Kirkpatrick has spent 44 years working in some of the most challenging...
One of the hardest questions facing any mayor - and a question that most mayor’s struggle to answer fully - is how you actually know if what you’re doing is working. Gloria Gong co-founded the Government Performance Lab...