Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Jeff-alytics Podcast

The Jeff-alytics Podcast artwork

Rebuilding a Police Department in Free Fall with Brian O'Hara

Sep 2, 202640 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Minneapolis recorded more shooting victims than it had sworn police officers in 2021. At that time, a huge chunk of the department had walked out the door just as gun violence had surged and the city council was publicly vowing to reorganize what remained. Someone still had to show up and run the thing. That someone was Chief Brian O’Hara. A career law enforcement officer who started as a beat cop in Newark in 2001, Brian rose to become that city’s public safety director before taking on what may have been the hardest job in American policing: rebuilding the Minneapolis Police Department from near-collapse while simultaneously trying to win back a traumatized community. Brian O’Hara was the 54th Chief of the Minneapolis Police Department, taking over in the wake of the murder of George Floyd. He previously served as Deputy Mayor and Public Safety Director in Newark, New Jersey, and is the founder of the O’Hara Leadership Group, LLC.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01I'm Jeff Asher, and this is the Jeffalytics Podcast. Minneapolis recorded more shooting victims than it had sworn police officers in 2021. At that time, a huge chunk of the police department had walked out the door just as gun violence had surged and the city council was publicly vowing to reorganize what remained. Someone still had to show up and run the thing. That someone was Chief Brian O'Hara. A career law enforcement officer who started as a beat comp in Newark in 2001, Brian rose to become that city's public safety director before taking on what may have been the hardest job in American policing: rebuilding the Minneapolis Police Department from near collapse while simultaneously trying to win back a traumatized community.

SPEAKER_01In this episode, we get the inside story of that experience. The triage, the trauma, and the work Chief O'Hare credits with turning the tide. We also talk about consent decrees, federal immigration enforcement, and what the gap between what the data shows and what people believe actually reveals. Let's dive in. My guest today is Chief Brian O'Hara. Chief, thanks for joining me.

SPEAKER_00Good morning, Jeff. Thank you for having me.

SPEAKER_01So let's start with the question I ask everybody. What is your background? What brings you here today? And I'm excited to say that you are the first person that has held the role of police chief that is on the program. So I don't know how I made it this long, but I'm excited to finally have a chief.

SPEAKER_00Wow, I I didn't actually realize that. I mean, there's been a lot of episodes already. Well, thank you. I'm honored. Well, I started off as a police officer in Newark, New Jersey in 2001, just before, uh, just before September 11th, actually. Uh, and then rose up through the ranks there, ultimately becoming the public safety director and a deputy mayor in the city before uh leaving to become chief of the Minneapolis Police Department about two years after the murder of George Floyd.

SPEAKER_00Um my time in Newark, the later part of my career was uh had a lot of involvement with the implementation of a federal consent decree there, as well as some work around supporting new partnerships and uh community violence intervention and that kind of thing. So uh a lot of similarities between the latter part of my career in Newark and a lot of the issues that that were front and center post-2020 in Minneapolis.

SPEAKER_01Okay. And how do you use that background today? How has that sort of contributed to your outlook?

SPEAKER_00Well, it's all been cumulative. I'm continuing to learn as I move forward. I've had uh just a lot of experiences and hope to try and share uh what I've learned, things that I've gotten wrong with with others in the profession, uh, because this is uh this is a profession that uh hopefully we're continuing to try and advance to get better and to try and continue to improve into the future.

SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell So you have a lot of experience with the consent decrees, and they they get a lot of um publicity, frequently not positive publicity, but I think that and I've had a lot of guests have sort of that experience with consent decrees, that there's like so much that's unknown. So what do you have like an overarching thought, a summary of consent decrees as a process, as a a thing that a lot of agencies are going forward?

SPEAKER_00I mean, it's it's so different uh between different cities. Yes, there's a lot of similarities and experiences, but I think how it plays out in different cities depends a lot around who the specific players are in different situations. So, for example, I know you're you're from New Orleans. I remember years ago, people would talk about the judge, the federal judge, in the New Orleans consent decree and how they would just show up at police precincts and that kind of thing, how engaged the judge is.

SPEAKER_00Um a lot of these things, uh, these consent decrees, how they're implemented, how well they work, depend a lot on the monitor and the outlook that the monitor has. Uh the role of the U.S. Attorney and the Department of Justice can also be pretty influential. What the local politics are, you know, particularly with, for example, in Newark, where we had a very progressive mayor, but one who had kind of was deeply established in the activist community.

SPEAKER_00Uh, in in uh had had parents that were leaders in the civil rights movement in that town, which gave him a lot a lot of legitimacy whenever he spoke about the things that the police department actually was doing to reform. So I think these things play out differently in different spaces. They are overall good, right? We want to always improve, become learning organizations and ensure that everything is done constitutionally and we're minimizing unintended harm and all those things, improve our training, all of that.

SPEAKER_00And they can require local governments to make investments in police departments that they otherwise would choose not to. And those things are all good. But they tend to drag out. There is not a requirement for, for example, for a monitor to have to be responsible for the whole picture. You know, we in Minneapolis, for example, I I inherited a police department that was in free fall. It was in the midst of collapse. About half the department had left in the aftermath of of George Floyd.

SPEAKER_00And at the same time, we're trying to just, you know, stabilize things. We were dealing with the the highest number of shootings that they had ever had before. And there's just a massive amount of reform that was uh being required at the same time. And of the monitor, you know, the activist groups and that kind of thing, um, they're only concerned about the reform piece. But the police chief, mayor, you know, and the community at large is concerned about how the whole thing operates.

SPEAKER_00So there's a lot of challenges that need to be worked out. They tend to take too long, but I don't think anyone has come up with kind of a better way on how to implement these things yet.

SPEAKER_01That's a good segue into my next question, which is how do you balance that need? You you have the thing that got the department into the consent decree. In new in New Orleans, it was rampant abuse, uh, aorta of corruption, you know, enormous civil rights and constitutional violations. With so you need to solve those, but you have to balance with the the things you were talking about, that the monitors can be expensive, they can take too long, they can not have terrific transparency at times.

SPEAKER_01How do you balance all of this with you know the the legitimate complaints with the need to reform and reform quickly? But the fact that it's it's just a lot of stuff. How do you balance all that together?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and and a lot of you said need to reform quickly, which is absolutely true, especially in the wake of a crisis, but it requires resources to reform. And these consent decrees, they're, you know, I think I don't I don't remember how many paragraphs New Orleans was, but they're sometimes a few hundred paragraphs, right, of requirements. They're very, very legally intensive. Uh you know, there's they're they're very document-heavy, right? Uh, and then there's these processes that are baked in that you can't just change a policy, you have to go through all this drafting process and community review and all of that before you can get a policy approved and then start working on the training to roll it out.

SPEAKER_00So it is inherently a very long process, right? And it takes people to get that work done. So, for example, in a place like Minneapolis, where you know, everything was collapsing, crime was through the roof, there's zero public trust, and you're struggling just to answer 911 calls every day, let alone try and investigate the serious crime that's happening at levels that they had never seen before.

SPEAKER_00It's a challenge to then try and reassign people so that you can have people conducting new training, you can have more people assigned to internal affairs, you can have more people assigned to uh, you know, policy writing and that kind of thing. So it it's it was an extreme, uh it was an extremely difficult, difficult balance in in Minneapolis. We had a lot of challenges around, like, for example, being able to investigate shootings, non-fatal shootings, domestic violence cases. We were drowning in and just staffing patrol. Um so it it was an enormous challenge.

SPEAKER_00And the best you can do is take take the data, the evidence that you have, try and triage things as best you can, get help and additional resources wherever, wherever feasible, and do the best you can to try and implement things according to the process.

SPEAKER_01So I I was just looking up real quick. New Orleans had 490 paragraphs of uh in it. That's great. Um when we talk about a paragraph, that's not like you're reading a paragraph in a book, it's three sentences. This is like a thing that the department has to do.

SPEAKER_00Oh, God, you could be in one paragraph could be an entire policy that has to be developed, right? I mean, it's just uh it's enormous. And then uh all the lawyers that have to get involved and debate, you know, over the comma here is right kind of thing. I mean, it's just it's inherently just a very, very, very, very long process.

SPEAKER_01I know this is difficult to ask you to summarize from all of these different perspectives, but how are consent decrees, is is there a general consensus about them in sort of the police leadership ranks? How was the consent decree seen in within the Newark police department? And then also as Minneapolis sort of starts to head towards that, how is it seen there?

SPEAKER_00I would say in policing in general, especially over the last couple of years, the the pendulum has swung to the right. There's a very strong feeling that consent decrees are, you know, exorbitantly expensive and not worth it, and that monitors are out more for patting their pockets than they actually are about implementing change. So I think that's a a broad generalization, but I think that's generally true in policing circles where the country is today. I don't think that was necessarily the case a few years ago, but obviously, you know, politics and things kind of influence that.

SPEAKER_00I would say in Newark, I just remember the massive amount of resistance when I was first appointed to try and implement the thing. Uh, anytime we were trying to implement any kind of changes, right? I remember uh we implemented a requirement that you had to fill out a form whenever an off and report whenever an officer pointed their firearm at someone. And it wasn't a big deal. It was just like it had a couple added check boxes that you you'd you know, add on to your normal police report. But people went crazy over it.

SPEAKER_00I mean, I remember a captain telling me, like, really upset over this, and and he was sincere, saying that I was gonna get a cop killed because I was going along with implementing this. And then over time, uh, in Newark, anyway, it became less and less of a big deal. I think over the last couple of years that they were in it, there really wasn't much happening anyway that affected cops' lives on the ground. So I think it was almost forgotten before the judge lifted it. Minnesota, totally different story. You know, other cities uh, you know, are still under consent decrees for many, many years now.

SPEAKER_00And I think in in Minneapolis, it still remains to be seen how that's gonna play out. They're not under a federal consent decree, right? Because the the DOJ had dropped it before uh the judge was able to implement it, but they are under a state consent decree, and they've pledged to, uh, along with that implement the reforms that were complicated, uh contemplated in the in the federal consent decree. So the tough thing for Minneapolis is there there isn't really the involvement of a judge uh in the matter in the way that there would be in federal court.

SPEAKER_00And I mean, just frankly, a lot of the stuff that is in the agreement and the way that has played out, in my opinion, has made things unnecessarily complicated. I think it's easy to go too far to an extreme where we're writing policies that are just, you know, so, so too many words, too many requirements. You know, we're making uh in policing, I think it's easier to hold cops accountable when you make clear rules, you set clear guidelines that are easy to teach, easy for cops to remember.

SPEAKER_00I think in certain aspects, particularly the way the use of force policy there has played out, it has become unnecessarily overly complicated. And that's something that stresses cops out, right? Because they may not remember how to just simply report what they did the appropriate way or how to describe it the appropriate way when we've added just so many, uh, so many requirements to the thing.

SPEAKER_01You're obviously the chief of police in Minneapolis during an extraordinarily difficult time. I think you mentioned having lost so many officers. I don't I think that Minneapolis had the largest percentage drop of any large department in the country. They weren't number one, they were number two. Like a lot of places, enormous increase in gun violence. And on top of that, you have the aftermath of the killing of George Floyd and then the killing of Alex Predi in January. You know, can you describe that experience for me? What did you take away from that?

SPEAKER_00You know, I think all of what you said is correct, but what gets lost is the experience that you get actually being on the ground living through that and just being able to talk to people who lived through that, right? So you mentioned that the enormous drop in staffing. I think it was typically about a 900 officer department, slightly over 900, I think, at the start of 2020. By the time I got there, over 500, over 500 of those particular 900 officers had separated from the department.

SPEAKER_00We'd only the department had dropped down, I think about 40%, you know, because you know, they were still, they still had hiring and that kind of thing. But when you think about it, over about I think it was over the course of about three years, um, they lost more than half of the people that were there. So, I mean, you're talking about experience, knowledge. If you talk to people on the ground there, they would tell you a lot of those folks needed to go, uh, which I'm sure is true. But at the same time, I'm sure there were a whole lot of people that were consummate professionals that knew a lot about doing the job right, that just had experience and knowledge that was lost.

SPEAKER_00The year before I got there, there were over 650 people shot in this in the city. And that's a city of about 420,000 people. It was there were more people there were more shooting victims that year than there were sworn police officers in the entire department by the end of the year, which I don't know if any other major city could could say that. They were not, they were so overwhelmed. We had to collapse the, they had a non-fatal shooting team, we had to get rid of it and collapse it into the homicide unit.

SPEAKER_00And there was just uh there was an enormous percentage of non-fatal shootings that were just not being assigned because we didn't have one, we didn't have the investigators, and two, the the challenges around trying to investigate a lot of these cases, right? Where the victims and uh witnesses were were not cooperative and that kind of thing. All that stuff has since changed, but it just shows you it kind of the amount of triage that has to go into it. Other thing I'd say that that's really important to understand is to talk to the people who lived there. I assigned 38th in Chicago, is where George Floyd died.

SPEAKER_00It was a no-go zone. I think for over over a year, the police did not respond into the area, and they kind of had some barriers set up around so that traffic couldn't get in and that kind of thing. I had assigned two officers to walk that neighborhood after becoming chief, and I walked it with them. And I'll never forget some of the things that were said, but one was a an elderly woman who lived about a block away was telling me she used to come out of her house every morning in the summer of 2020 with a broom and a dustpan to sweep up shell casings because she knew the police wasn't coming.

SPEAKER_00Um I mean, just these types of things that people live through that they tell you these stories. They talk about uh trying to defend their businesses when the entire, you know, the main corridor, Lake Street, uh running through South Minneapolis, nearly the entire thing was on fire uh in the summer of 2020. You know, just the the amount of guns that were in circulation there, the amount of fear, you know, it is it is it's so much and it's so heavy, uh, and it's so much more than what we're just able to tell uh by the numbers kind of explaining what happened.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And I mean the the numbers are astounding. Uh 2019, just looking through some of the data, Minneapolis had 861 officers. 2023, it had fallen to 571. Three year to date, in 2021, 372 non fatal shooting victims up from 170 in 2019 as of you know early August. Well, as we record this, how do you avoid not becoming overwhelmed by all of this?

SPEAKER_00It it it was overwhelming. Uh, I think part of what helped me in the beginning was I I was just I was naive to how deep some of the issues were. Not with the data, uh, that's obvious, but just how deep the trauma was, both in the community and among the police officers. And just how difficult the the political situation was there. You know, the a majority of the city council had vowed to disband the police department in the aftermath of George Floyd. And several council members, you know, took stand very vocally as a part of their politics to constantly speak out against the police department, uh, seemingly no matter what was going on.

SPEAKER_00Uh so it doesn't tend to encourage recruitment uh when you're in this environment, right? It doesn't make policing any less expensive, particularly when you're trying to reach out to uh communities that have not been represented in the police department in the past. It's just uh all this stuff is just not helpful. And then in terms of the people that were actually there, you know, if the the officers, that kind of thing, um, there was uh an unbelievable uh uh amount of trauma, which I think, you know, uh uh uh through the process of time, some of that has healed.

SPEAKER_00But just like the community, there's there's still a lot of open wounds uh around all of these issues that that have just not resolved themselves.

SPEAKER_01And in spite of that, there's been dramatic progress in Minneapolis. Um, I said 372 gunshot wound victims at this point in 2021 down to 158, which is actually pre bef better than pre-COVID. You know, carjacking's down a ton, homicides down a ton. And even staffing has rebounded from 571 in 2023 to 622 now, which is obviously well below where it was pre-COVID. To what do you attribute this success?

SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell So just just a quick note on the staffing. For most of my time as chief, the department continued to get smaller month after month after month. At the rate we were hiring police officers, if we continued at that rate, we could go on until infinity and never make the the city's charter minimum for staffing, let alone get back to uh the the 900 that had been typical. Um so it's a relatively new trend, is is the increase. It's only probably a year and a half or so, I think.

SPEAKER_00In terms of the turnaround around shootings, the the increase was just astronomical. Like as you see some of the numbers there with victims. I mean, uh there's there's other data that we know, right? We have shot spotter in the city. The city's had it, you know, 15 plus years. The first time fully automatic gunfire was ever detected in the city was in the summer of 2020. And by the next year, I mean, there were just there were literally thousands of detections, you know, with fully automatic gunfire.

SPEAKER_00So, I mean, very, very, very dramatic increase, right? And and very, very quick. I think it shook the entire city. And you did have a lot of community-based organizations that started to pitch in, a lot of philanthropy and you know, uh business community that got serious about trying to help. Hey, what can we do? Everybody trying to get together. And at the same time, eventually the the police department was able to start doing the things that we know are effective, right? Uh, there was uh federal joint federal operations that were conducted that took down, I think, over a hundred gang members, many of whom were charged with racketeering.

SPEAKER_00Uh, I think that had a a pretty significant uh impact on shootings in particular. Uh that that gang takedown was focused on the north side of the city, which for the majority of the time that the city's been recording shootings separately from aggravate assaults, that's accounted for a majority of the city's violence. I think last year, last year that precinct, uh, for the first time ever was not number one in terms of shooting victims for the city. So very dramatic increase where shootings had typically uh occurred the most.

SPEAKER_00But at the same time, there's still a lot of challenges in other parts of the city where crime and quality of life has declined significantly since the since the riots, since the destruction of the city. So there's just so much going on, obviously. And and part of it, thank God, is that that enormous spike did not become the new normal. Um, but there just there really is just so much to unpack and so much to talk about. And and I do think one thing I do think that's important that I don't hear people talking about is kind of what what actually happened in 2020 uh around that dramatic, dramatic increase?

SPEAKER_00I mean, if you think about it, and and just from talking to people who lived there and lived through all of this, you know, they watched a police station get abandoned and burned while the you know, neighborhoods were on fire, where people were standing outside, business owners had rifles on the roofs and people had garden hoses trying to protect the property. I mean, what kind of effect psychologically did that have on the community and on people in the community? I mean, I just think, you know, in general, on a kind of a basic level, like we we depend on in society, we depend on people voluntarily complying with the law, right?

SPEAKER_00We we we depend on most people voluntarily, you know, just following the law. I just wonder what type of psychological impact, you know, kind of the burning of the police station and people seeing just all of that chaos kind of had, you know, in a criminogenic kind of way. And and then at one point, was there any sort of effect in the opposite direction? I I don't know.

SPEAKER_01Well one of my complaints that I talk about frequently is that, especially when we talk about like why everything is happening, that crime, murder, uh they're the ultimate story of you know, failures and orphans success has many fathers. That everyone wants to talk about you know, here's the thing I did, and it's going down, and then it's silence when it's going trust.

SPEAKER_00A police chief knows that best because when it's goes right, and everybody wants to get behind the microphone. Anytime there's a disaster, it's just me.

SPEAKER_01Well, so how can chiefs be better about talking about things? This was a 2020, where it was not any police chief's fault. It was not any mayor's fault that murder went up everywhere, that everything went crazy everywhere. And yet I feel like we were hesitant to talk about the fact that it was going up, because somehow talking about it would imply that if I acknowledge this, it's my fault that it's happening. How can we be better about talking about this from especially from sort of the holders of the data standpoint and acknowledging when things are going up, that even acknowledging it does not mean that it's accepting blame for it.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I mean, I think I think there were, I do remember, I do remember some of us speaking, and maybe it was just in meetings and on Zooms, but speaking about the things that were happening. And it's the same stuff that I've heard from many academics and other folks in the years since, right? The the schools being closed and you know, kids not having anything to do, and all these kinds of things, like during the pandemic, right? But I think the the larger issue in general, um, I think is is almost a consequence, in my opinion, to just how polarized the country is today.

SPEAKER_00And I think there's kind of this kind of like the two extreme kind of ways to think about crime and policing in this country and all the issues around it. Uh, and I think a lot of people get their information through social media and through media that kind of aligns with sort of one view or the other. And I think that that influences people in general and influences their perception and their outlook. I think police chiefs are are are no different because we're all from coming from the same society.

SPEAKER_00But I think I think in general chiefs could use some help at communicating all of these issues to the public and and being better able to find opportunities to communicate and educate the public. I think I've seen a lot of chiefs that kind of they shy away from the media and and try not to uh try not to speak almost as a protective mechanism. But I think coming forward publicly and using the media and using social media as kind of an opportunity to sort of educate people about what we're seeing and and being better able to kind of communicate those things could could could be helpful to address that.

SPEAKER_01So you were chief when Rene Good and Alex Purdy were shot and killed by ice in January of this year. Could you walk me through that experience?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. There was also Jose Sosa Celis was also shot by ice in between and survived. But that was also, uh, other than the fact that he did not die, that was also an equally terrible shooting. The surge of Minneapolis started, I think, the first week in December. It lasted for about 12 weeks. It progressively got worse week after week. There was really no meaningful communication between whoever was in charge of the operation and the people running the city or running the police department.

SPEAKER_00I had very good relationships with people in federal law enforcement that lived in Minnesota. Uh, but it was clear from the beginning that they weren't the people in charge of the surge as it played out. And it was a just it was an overwhelming situation. I don't know the truth around the exact number of agents, but it was in the thousands that were deployed. Again, if the police department had about 600 people, and we had I think it was somewhere around at least 3,000 additional federal law enforcement assigned, you know, at the at the height of this thing.

SPEAKER_00And there were law enforcement agencies, a variety of agencies, right? It was Homeland Security, it was ICE, it was uh the Border Patrol, it was the uh Customs and Border Protection Office of Field Operations. There were even Federal Bureau of Prison Officers in the city assigned to this thing. It was very chaotic. It seemed like it was uh just not coordinated, and it just seemed like very, very, at best, very, very poor, poor tactics that were being used. A lot of jump outs.

SPEAKER_00They were stopping off-duty police officers, uh, police officers' family members. It was always a case where the officer or their family was not white. So, you know, it it's clear what was happening. Um, and that's not to say that, you know, all of federal law enforcement that was there was engaging in this, you know, this kind of uh behavior, but enough of it was happening to make you think that that this is what they were being told to do. And these shootings, the three shootings that happened, were were literally foreseeable.

SPEAKER_00They were predictable. I I had been saying for weeks in the weeks leading up to it, that unless unless some folks came to the table and started to talk about what's going on here and figure things out, that we were gonna have a tragedy. And when I was saying that, I I literally did mean somebody could get seriously hurt or die, whether that's a federal law enforcement officer or a member of the public. And unfortunately, uh unfortunately that's what happened. And even after the first shooting, it it was just, it was shocking to me, you know, as as a police officer for so long that uh in this day and age there was a shooting.

SPEAKER_00It was fatality. There was very, very immediately very, very significant, you know, demonstrations around this and and a lot of tension in the community. Even with that, the Border Patrol and other folks assigned with them continued to ride around the city in that area that afternoon and do jump outs. It was unbelievably crazy to me, and just, you know, not something that I would fault again, the folks on the bottom that got forced to show up there and do that, but certainly the leadership, uh, whoever was making these decisions, just incredibly bad leadership.

SPEAKER_01How would you advise policymakers, police chiefs in similar situations about needing to balance? You have federal partnerships. You mentioned the you know, the feds that live locally, that you you don't want to give up those partnerships because they're of immense value to a city's public safety. Yeah. But how do you balance that with the other end of there's just federal partners you can't work with?

SPEAKER_00I mean, I just told you earlier a credit, probably one of the most significant reasons to why I think less people were shot and less people died. One of the significant reasons why that happened was the partnerships with federal law enforcement, the RICO cases, the taking down of uh, you know, gang members that have been pulling triggers repeatedly. That is for sure something that had a positive impact that saved people's lives. We had fantastic relationships. The federal agents, prosecutors that I knew were absolutely mortified by what was happening.

SPEAKER_00But unfortunately, they were powerless around it. And in that the prosecutor's office, the U.S. Attorney's Office in Minnesota lost uh just about all of its leadership as a result of this. And I don't know, it might be I don't know how many prosecutors, but it may be close to half. It's not that big of an office. They just lost a tremendous amount of prosecutors that resigned as a result of what they were seeing, what they were being asked to do, that kind of thing. There were also people who retired and left their positions as federal law enforcement.

SPEAKER_00There were people who were transferred and reassigned. It it on my side of the house, now that's just the ability to do the things that we were able to do in the past, clearly has collapsed, right? Like once you lose all of these prosecutors, you lose all that knowledge. I mean, they had difficulty just keeping up with the cases they already had, let alone taking on new complex cases. But on the police side of the house, particularly if you're in a city like Minneapolis, which political factions there, left and far left.

SPEAKER_00That's it. That's the that's the political environment you operate in. People didn't want to hear anything about, you know, uh partnerships with federal law enforcement, which, you know, just depending on the way it was phrased or what have you, which is terrible for the city. The city needs to have its fair share of good federal law enforcement that can put people away that are causing the worst harm and violence in the community, for sure. But again, it's something else that becomes even more difficult now just to have those conversations locally because of everything that happened to sort of destroy the trust that that had existed in federal law enforcement before this.

SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell So one of the challenges that I deal with frequently that I'm just thinking the there was a couple of posts. I I in New Orleans I write about New Orleans a lot, and talking about how New Orleans is currently on pace to have the fewest murders since 1969 and break a hundred murders for the first time since the 1971. And each time it gets published on you know, I'll do interviews. The mayor had an Instagram post where I had sent her all of this data, and then she posted it.

SPEAKER_01And the first four responses on social media are anywhere, that's great, but I don't believe the data. There's an enormous data trust and communication issue here. Um we certainly see that around all of the topics we've talked about in dealing with federal partners, in dealing with consent decrees. How do we improve this communication? How does how do we make it so that people not just receive the data, but trust the data and that the statistics that they're seeing, the trends that they're being that are being talked to are the actual things that we need to be paying attention to?

SPEAKER_00Well, people perceive things and live their lives, not in the data, but you know, in in their community, right? What they see on the street, how they experience quality of life issues, especially folks from outside of the city, because I think that tends to be, at least in my experience, you tend to get a lot of negativity from folks that are from the outside that come into the city, they see your downtown area, they see some homeless folks, you know, a vagrant or something like that.

SPEAKER_00And that causes a unrealistic sense of fear, right? Uh, because of that. Or, you know, on media and in the regular media and in social media, just these whenever something terrible happens, that's what gets replayed over and over and over again. And that's kind of all people are experiencing, is just the the most terrible things. And then there's truth, right? That, you know, I think many, Minneapolis, for example, uh, the response times the last few years had been terrible.

SPEAKER_00Uh so it's taken cops longer to show up, for sure. There's probably some more reports that might have been taken that were not, but people don't realize it's, you know, it's not the case with a homicide. A homicide is going to be recorded, right? Yeah. So I, you know, I think it's just, it's it's got to be some combination of all of these factors and and and kind of I I don't know, honestly, I don't know if it's possible in the world that we live in, with as polarized as things are, in the world of social media, um if it's possible for us to be effective without fixing some larger issues here, of restoring some sense of legitimacy in in government, in in policing, and helping people trying to see some of these issues outside of their filters.

SPEAKER_01You you said you're you're writing a book. You know, what is it about and and why are you why did you decide to write a book?

SPEAKER_00I am reflecting back on a lot of the experiences that I've lived through in Newark and in Minneapolis, around all the stuff that uh people talk about as being wrong with policing in the U.S., like a lot of these controversial issues around use of force and you know, bias and uh disparate impact based on race, all that stuff that I've lived through, as well as kind of some of the unique leadership experiences, taking over an organization in Freefall, uh Minneapolis police after uh after George Floyd, and trying to rebuild and reform at the same time.

SPEAKER_00Learning, learning the hard way of the difference between change and progress, right? Like I remember going out and starting in Minneapolis, and everywhere I went, people said that they wanted, yeah, we want change. It was the cops, the community, everybody wanted change. Uh, and then as soon as I started changing things, people said, Whoa, what are you doing? And I realized, you know, naively that what people were actually trying to communicate is that they wanted progress. They wanted things to get better, but they didn't necessarily want things to change, and then they might experience some sort of loss or that things might not be the way that they've been telling themselves in their heads things are supposed to be, that kind of thing.

SPEAKER_00You know, so I think with a lot of these experiences, and then of course the ice surge, the the we had a horrific shooting almost a year ago now, August 27th, it'll be a year of uh at a Catholic school in in Minneapolis, a mass shooting and you know, the aftermath of that and the impact that had on families and the community. I just think there's uh there's a lot of lessons and broader lessons that could be useful for people when we talk about these things like, you know, organizational change and uh leadership and and crisis and how do we manage these things?

SPEAKER_00So that's my goal to try and create something that people might find useful uh as I kind of reflect back on the things I've been through and and and what I've learned from them.

SPEAKER_01That's great. My last question, it's probably the most important one I'll ask, which is do you prefer the Sopranos or the Godfather for a mafia-related piece of entertainment?

SPEAKER_00Oh man, I guess you know, I have to say I'm uh I'm a Sopranos guy, I guess, particularly since quite a bit of it was filmed in the neighborhood where I grew up. The uh the butcher's shop, and the butcher shop was on the corner of uh the block that I grew up on and some other places. So I guess because of that, uh I you'd have to say I'm a Sopranos guy.

SPEAKER_01And we could spoil this, right? Tony's dead, right? You you know the inside story.

SPEAKER_00Oh man.

SPEAKER_01So uh G th thank you so much for joining us. What is next for you, other than writing a book?

SPEAKER_00Well, I'm doing some consulting work and you know working with some public safety technology companies, trying to help them sort of figure out some of the challenges that are existing both politically and around implementation of these things, and just looking to find ways to stay relevant around the profession and spend more time with my family. Those are the goals.

SPEAKER_01Awesome. Well, thank you so much for joining us. This has been serious informational fun, just incredible conversation. So thank you so much.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and I enjoyed the conversation with you, Jeff. Thank you.

SPEAKER_01Thanks for listening to the Jeffalytics Podcast. Be sure to subscribe and to learn more, head on over to ahdatalytics.com for more information and previous episodes. If you like what you heard, please leave a glowing review, which will help others to discover the show. Until next time, I'm Jeff Asher.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Why Fewer Murders Get Solved These Days With Phil Cook

    Nov 18, 202634 minAudio

    Police departments said they solved 92 percent of homicides nationwide in the early 1960s. Today that figure hovers around 60 percent most years. Phil Cook has spent the last half century figuring out what that enormous...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. How Gun Violence Makes America Sick with Dan Semenza

    Nov 11, 202638 minAudio

    Dan Semenza is a criminologist and director of research at the New Jersey Gun Violence Research Center at Rutgers University’s School of Public Health - a position that puts him deliberately at the intersection of two...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. How States Can Address Gun Violence with Lt. Governor Austin Davis

    Nov 4, 202623 minAudio

    Gun violence is not a one-size-fits-all concern. It can be a different issue depending on where you live and whether it is an urban or rural community. And that makes the problem genuinely hard to address at scale....

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Policing the Big Easy with New Orleans Police Chief Anne Kirkpatrick

    Oct 28, 202634 minAudio

    It takes a certain kind of leader to see a city deemed the country's "murder capital" and actually want to take on that problem. Chief Ann Kirkpatrick has spent 44 years working in some of the most challenging...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. How Cities Succeed and Fail in Public Safety Policy with Gloria Gong

    Oct 21, 202633 minAudio

    One of the hardest questions facing any mayor - and a question that most mayor’s struggle to answer fully - is how you actually know if what you’re doing is working. Gloria Gong co-founded the Government Performance Lab...

    Credit the people on this episode