Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Chudstack Review

The Chudstack Review artwork

Aristocratic LARPing, w/Derek Suszko

Jul 26, 20261 hr 31 minAudio

Derek and I discuss: * What “aristocracy” actually means. * Is Derek’s "aristocratic" worldview just a self-flattering story (i.e., cope). * Is a bourgeois life (job, marriage, kids, mortgage) a worthwhile life? * Is tech-capital now unstoppable, or could it be overthrown by a nascent aristocracy? * Is the internet creating a new kind of aristocracy through attention and status? * Why are so many young men rejecting ordinary life? * Is Gen Z’s pessimism a sign of coming rebellion? This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit russellwalter.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01All right, today I'm joined by Derek Susco, who's been blowing up on notes, on Substack Notes. He has been advocating that downwardly mobile men date BPD women, and it's sort of sparked a furor on the Substack timeline. But I don't really want to talk to him about that today. I want to talk to him about sort of life strategies and conceptions of the good life and what should... Young downwardly mobile men be doing.

SPEAKER_01Um, yeah. So anyway, thanks for coming on Derek. Yeah. Thanks Russell. Okay. So I thought we would begin, um, I, I'm critical of some of the life advice that you you're giving, but first things first, I really want to make sure that I understand it so as not to be like straw manning what you're saying. So you, Um, have, I think you've identified like yourself as like a, uh, a sort of Nietzschean aristocrat. That's correct. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. It's, it's a LARP of course. Yeah. Which I've never denied and no one should deny. Uh, but it's sort of just taking on the aesthetic view of the world that would be associated with Nietzscheanism or vitalism or, you know, uh, ancient Greece, uh, Sort of just having that as sort of your template for how you view things, how you view philosophy and life. So, yeah, it's a fair, it's a fair moniker for me.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And I guess first things first, this is going to seem really nitpicky and semantic, but I actually do think it's important, is how do you define aristocracy?

SPEAKER_00So it's not social class. This is something I've really tried to hammer through in a lot of my notes. It's not social class. What it is, is a psychobiological cast. It's a certain way of viewing the world. So that's how I use it. And you can almost think I'm using it synonymously with aesthetic. So when I say something, when I say like you have an aristocratic view of the world, what it basically means is You're not dogmatic,

SPEAKER_00you're sensitive to aesthetics, you're sensitive to like power hierarchies, hierarchies of beauty, hierarchies of intelligence, hierarchies of status. And so you basically have sort of a, in a way, an honest, more honest, less idealistic view of the world. So you're not egalitarian. But at the same time, you You have sort of like an aesthetic view. So you have tastes in high culture or you sort of view the world through the lens

SPEAKER_00of extravagant experience both ways, both in terms of suffering and in terms of ecstasy or exhilaration. So that's an aristocratic view. And I often contrast that with what I call the bourgeois view. Which, again, is a Marxist term that I've sort of adopted in a different way, even though you could say it's talking about the same people. Basically, the bourgeois view, they're very dogmatic, which means they're universalists.

SPEAKER_00So they believe that everybody should be doing the same things. So there's one moral code. There's a universal laws to life that everyone does. And They're very siloed. That's the other term I use to describe the bourgeois, which is they think what they're doing in life, the purpose of life is some kind of siloed community, some kind of siloed familial project.

SPEAKER_00And they don't really think in broader conceptions of civilizational destiny so much. And they're also idealistic. And so They have egalitarian tendencies, even if some of them aren't entirely, you know, rampantly egalitarian. But they basically want to believe all humans think relatively the same way. All humans have relatively the same ambitions and desires in life.

SPEAKER_00And so it's sort of a leveling. It's a leveling psychology. So it brings everybody sort of into the same pool.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. So do you see the risk of separating like you're definitely like when you try to define aristocracy? I actually don't totally disagree with what you just said. Like, it's clear when you look at aristocratic cultures, like, you know, if you think about like a small state in the Holy Roman Empire or something like that, right? That aesthetic perspective. The Russell Walter, Rwalter, The Russell Walter, Rwalter, The Russell Walter, Rwalter, Rwalter, Rwalter, Rwalter, Rwalter, Rwalter, Rwalter, Rwalter, Rwalter, Rwalter, Rwalter, Rwalter.

SPEAKER_01Attributable to like a very rigid breeding program, right? So I don't totally disagree with that. I think that aesthetic concerns are primary for aristocracy, but I think to separate it from social class, more importantly, like my conception of aristocrats is primarily like a warrior caste, right? I like that story, I'm sure you've heard of it, where the British were beginning to accept merchants into the aristocracy

SPEAKER_01so they were knighting them. And this old aristocrat, he's in the House of Lords and he's like, well, it's ridiculous, it's ridiculous, why are they here? And they're like, they shouldn't be here. And it's like, well, how did your ancestors get here? And he's like, through the battle axe, sir. That's the only way that you can really be considered a true aristocrat is if your ancestors conquered. So I think that your definition, while I don't totally disagree with it, I think there does need to be that warrior element to it, doesn't there?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so I would say you're absolutely right. And Historical aristocracies go through cycles. So I think that's important to understanding, you know, when we're talking about any specific example of an aristocratic culture an aristocratic class, at what stage are they at? So, in other words, when building up an aristocracy, it's basically focused on extreme cultural and self-discipline.

SPEAKER_00Because historically, it was the more physically robust, the more capable of war, the more power you could have through conquest. And so a nation aristocracy that's like coming into its own. Is basically entirely concerned with self-disciplining and cultural regulation. And this is why their laws like the Spartan laws are so severe. It's because they're cultivating the type of people that can remain in power.

SPEAKER_00And at that stage, these aesthetic things aren't primary because- They're like barbarians originally.

SPEAKER_01There's that famous Nietzsche quote, right? Where it's like talking about how all aristocracies began as like, you know, barbarians. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Right. And then once they get to positions of power, that's when they start gaining sort of, they have the life of leisure to look at everything through the aesthetic lens. So they engage in patronage, they engage in building, all of these things that come from being in power on the basis of having developed some kind of excellence that got them there. And some of that then leads to a decadent aristocracy. So you know, like, you have the image of The pre-French revolutionary aristocracy,

SPEAKER_00they were entirely obsessed with social intrigues, operas, you know, whatever. And a lot of the charismatic presentation that maintained their power started to decline. And so, you know, when an aristocracy gets too, I guess, distracted by purely aesthetic projection or I think it's possible for it to lose sight, and it's not only possible, it happens quite a bit. It loses sight of the sanction for its authority,

SPEAKER_00which is always projecting some kind of psycho-biological charismatic superiority to the populace. And so when the people just have the idea that they're a bunch of decadence and they're just wastrels, the aristocracy loses legitimacy. So that's basically like a cycle, I think, that you can see, which is An erosion of self-discipline leads to basically it losing its legitimacy. And so this is basically just the great men create easy times, you know, that whole cycle.

SPEAKER_00And with historical aristocracies, it basically happens the same way generally every time. And so like as of right now, you would say, well, we have a very decadent elite class that isn't even really... Aristocratic in the old way of promoting high culture. And so...

SPEAKER_01It's a bourgeois elite, definitely. A bourgeois elite.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. But my... Oh, sorry. Continue. Well, I was just going to say, so questions of all this talk about a counter-elite, it would basically have to be a faction of people, young men primarily, who discipline themselves very severely. And that's why I constantly go to Sparta. Because... In order to actually get that kind of legitimacy, you have to impose upon yourself a kind of life that is more severe and,

SPEAKER_00in fact, harder by a long shot than the kind of people who dominate your society. So a lot of my recommendations just come back to I'm actually kind of encouraging young men to embrace a certain level of hardship.

SPEAKER_01Hmm. Yeah. So the thing is, so this is getting a little into like the historical weeds, right? But I take a more just literal definition of aristocracy, which I take to mean like a land owning elite. And I mean that in two ways, right? So that means literally like we're Aristocracy's wealth resided in the land, right? In some cases, they didn't even have currencies. So the main currency is like actual things like bushels of wheat, et cetera, et cetera.

SPEAKER_01But then also, if you think about aristocracy, they tend to literally be land powers in the sense of... Not naval powers, right? They tend to be like, like Sparta as a good example, right? They did not have a very good Navy. The Athenians, which were the more mercantile of the two had, and the more liberal, if you will, open-minded, they had the naval, they were naval power and Sparta was land power. And I read this book, which was, this is actually, this book was sort of the beginning of my disillusionment in a way with this kind

SPEAKER_01of way of thinking. It was a weird book. It was written by a maritime historian. I think it's called Maritime Supremacy. So he was in the Navy. And his basic contention, which I find extremely compelling, which is if you look at the last 500 years of history, naval power has consistently dominated and beaten land power. And his contention was that politics is actually kind of downstream of military technology.

SPEAKER_01So if you think about sea powers, like a good example that comes to mind is the English and the Dutch, right? Both of them are bourgeois, right? Its power, the reason it was able to conquer the world was because of its, I would say because of its bourgeois elite. Even its aristocracy was bourgeois. It's one of the things that distinguishes the British aristocracy from the continental aristocracy is that they actually did engage in commerce in a way

SPEAKER_01that, you know, the French never did. The French, you know, they kind of look at like... If you're engaged in it, they look at you like you're a Vietnamese fishmonger. You know what I mean? They have complete contempt. And a lot of aristocracies maintain that complete contempt. Whilst one of the distinguishing features of the British aristocracy was that they did actually engage in coal mining, etc. They were commercial. And I think something similar could be...

SPEAKER_01The Dutch, again, are very much a bourgeois power. And basically his contention is if you look at these bourgeois powers, these liberal, which are liberal, right? Because to engage in global commerce, right? There's a degree of like openness that's required, a degree of liberalism, if you will. They also are like suspicious of central authority because they kind of want to be able to engage in free commerce without, you know, taxation.

SPEAKER_01Something that's probably not appreciated about France enough is that France was actually like very authoritarian, right? Like if you read Voltaire, Voltaire loved England because of how liberal it was in comparison to France, which still just had no habeas corpus, nothing like that. But anyway, the point is that these bourgeois powers have just destroyed aristocratic powers and aristocracies have always claimed to rule by virtue of the sword. And the fact is that now they, and not just now, but for however many years, literally.

SPEAKER_01Literally for centuries, they have not been able to defeat the bourgeois. The bourgeois are just more powerful because in the technological age that we live in, an age of global commerce, power stems less from the sword. I think techno capital is the true seat of power in modernity.

SPEAKER_01Basically, it's kind of a last man of history argument. I see that as unstoppable. I see the bourgeois as unstoppable, basically. No aristocracy will be able to defeat them. That is my contention.

SPEAKER_00Even if there's something like an apocalyptic collapse?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, well... The only thing that I could see changing that would be an apocalyptic collapse. That's the only thing. So that is the caveat. If there was an apocalyptic collapse that sent us back technologically, then yes, you probably would have something like the re-emergence of aristocracy. But that's the only condition on which I see that happening.

SPEAKER_00Okay. Yeah. So that's actually super interesting. And I think... I've got, you know, when I talked to Walt, uh, Bismarck, he, he basically pushed back on that. He said, all of it's, it's LARP because the bourgeoisie won. We're in such a, uh, technocratic situation now that any, any kind of discussion of, uh, historical landholding warrior caste ruling anything is over. Um, uh, so your historical model, um,

SPEAKER_00I think one of the one of the things that my system asserts is that the Industrial Revolution created the conditions for bourgeois supremacy, and the tech revolution actually reverses it. And so basically, what is happening with technological development in the 21st century, my argument is psychological. So the algorithm is an aristocracy. Because when you have an economy in which attention is essential is the currency,

SPEAKER_00so not necessarily, you know, who makes the best products, who streamlines revenue the best. These are the basis of bourgeois industry. And these are why these industrialists became far more powerful than the landholding class that they were replacing. It's because the Industrial Revolution created specific conditions for This kind of psychological type, the low in narcissism,

SPEAKER_00high in vocational agency, the kind of guy who can basically do meticulous routine work and become very wealthy doing it for a period of time. And that's the whole basis of industrial capitalism. Sorry to interrupt you.

SPEAKER_01I was just going to say, I'm going to be extremely nitpicky here. And I'm going to say that it predates the industrial revolution. I would say that it goes back to the 1500s even, or the 1600s. I would say international commerce, when you had a true age of Like international commerce, you had the rise of the merchant class, right? That was happening in the 1600s. It was even happening in the 1500s, right? So I think that it predates the industrial revolution.

SPEAKER_01That's not a here nor there because I don't think that contradicts anything that you've said. But I just want to point that out is that I think the bourgeois have been ascendant for a lot longer and it wasn't simply the industrial revolution. It was international commerce. I think that, you know, The spice trade, etc. Like that's what actually gave rise to the bourgeois. But anyway, sorry, that's a, I feel like a, I'm doing a, actually.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I do believe. Well, I actually think that's an important point to make. And what I would say, and this is a very general statement, but. Prior to the Industrial Revolution, the European middle classes were inclined to side with the aristocracy against the peasant class. So you're right. There was essentially a bourgeois revolt at the Reformation. And Martin Luther sided with the old aristocrats. And so basically what could have been the French Revolution 250 years early in Germany didn't become it because the emergent middle class

SPEAKER_00with its independent ideas about Religion ultimately said, well, we'll work with the aristocrats if they follow our religion. So you're absolutely right that the rise of the domination of the Western middle class can be dated back to the early modern era, the Renaissance, the Reformation. What the Industrial Revolution really kicked off, though, was the Sort of the egalitarian idealism of this class that was inclined to side against an aristocracy instead of defend it in the interest of,

SPEAKER_00you know, peasant avoiding peasant revolt. And so that that's the distinction I'd make. So I'd say the industrial revolution is crucial because this was the moment when this large middle class realized they don't really need to take any orders from people on the basis of, you know, lineage or You know, genetic prestige. And so the aristocracies across Europe eventually declined. Eventually, all of them lost all political power. But getting back to the point of the idea of aristocracy

SPEAKER_00or aristocratic thinking now, I think it's very much tied to what the psychological changes of the tech revolution. So I know so many young men Who have zero interest in like a professional white collar career. They just have no interest in doing it. And they want to be poker players or they want to get some kind of attention on the internet. This drive to win the algorithm is...

SPEAKER_00Far more important for a lot of people in the tech generations than it was for people prior to it. And that is I mean, you say using aristocracy to talk about that sounds so outlandish, but it's fundamentally a explosion of narcissism. It's an explosion of a desire for prestige, social prestige, a hyper awareness of considerations of status. And everybody's gunning for it. And that is a society in which you now have very strongly imposed social hierarchies.

SPEAKER_00So whoever like you succeed on the Internet, you're succeeding because of attention. So you're succeeding because there's something about you that makes you superior. Most often just you look good, but it's exploded. The and you wrote about this in your article on Like the status, like considerations of status. Everyone is hyper aware of it. And when everyone's hyper aware of it, and they don't have these bourgeois silos that they used to have,

SPEAKER_00where it's like, well, I'm important in my community. You now have everyone in this giant race. And it sort of maximizes considerations of social hierarchy. And an aristocracy is a political system that sanctions social hierarchy. So So the discrepancy between a society that is nominally egalitarian and that nominally preaches democratic values and the reality of what the tech revolution exposes essentially drives people into open acknowledgement

SPEAKER_00that egalitarianism clearly isn't true. So I think the tech revolution has contributed to the complete collapse of egalitarian idealism.

SPEAKER_01And I see why you, I do see why you, like, okay, so we're talking about looks maxing in a way, or like this obsession with looks that's emerged. It's always been there, right? But it seems particularly heightened now, right? Because of the dating ecology that we're in. But I think... I think that there is something kind of brutal about it in the sense that if you're better looking, taller, there is just a genetic, undeniable genetic component to that and there's no denying that

SPEAKER_01and it's instantly legible, right? I think that you're over-indexing on that because... The technological revolution absolutely empowers the bourgeois in certain domains, right? So maybe in this sort of like cultural domain and maybe among Gen Z right now.

SPEAKER_01But at the end of the day, it's like who owns the data centers? Who owns artificial intelligence? Like that is the true seat of power. It is not like who is getting attention on the internet. Like I understand that that is like a very valuable prestige economy that people care about. But that at the end of the day is a distraction. True power is in the hands of the bourgeois people like Musk, like Zuckerberg, like Bill Gates.

SPEAKER_01These people are absolutely bourgeois and they are going to be the most powerful people in the world. I don't know what you think about AGI or any of that. I'm not completely convinced, but if someone does create that, That person has dictatorial power. You know what I mean? They have true power. So I think that the tech revolution does not in any way empower like a nascent aristocracy. It's the opposite. It intensifies the power of the bourgeoisie.

SPEAKER_00So I dispute that. Quite a bit just because and people will say that sort of my views on it are quite old fashioned, but I really don't believe there's any substitute for like psychological resonance. So when we're talking about a guy like Zuckerberg, how many people would die for Zuckerberg? Hmm.

SPEAKER_01I know exactly what you're getting at, right? Where it's very obvious the reason these guys started taking peptides and steroids is because they recognize that on like a primordial level, people do not respect them. They're extremely powerful. But again, I would say that's a sort of biological hang up, right? Because yes, I agree with you on a fundamental psychological level. Nobody recognizes those peer people. As supreme or, you know, like they don't, right?

SPEAKER_01They're ridiculed till this day, right? And considered fundamentally uncool, et cetera, et cetera. But at the end of the day, if you have billions of dollars of capital, people might not perceive you as powerful or whatever, but nothing substitutes for the fact that like you can pay for mercenaries, you can change elections, you Who can fundamentally change the course of countries. Like Elon Musk can change the course of, like he's done that, right?

SPEAKER_01And it doesn't matter if people think he's a fucking autistic freak, right? Because he's got a trillion dollars, right? And that is like power. That is power. And he's not being unseated by a handsome man. Sure, his wife might prefer to sleep with a handsome man. But he nevertheless is still, you know, powerful in the realpolitik sense. Maybe not in a social. You're kind of talking in like a social sense, right? More so than like a really political one.

SPEAKER_00Because I basically view all politics as ultimately downstream of psychobiological considerations. So like, let's, let's take that thought experiment you said, which is, let's say one of these tech boyars, oligarchs, you know, tries to get a mercenary army, and basically is like, I'm going to take independent military authority, I'm going to go against the state's monopoly on violence.

SPEAKER_00The kind of person who can actually do that and not be totally discredited has to have such a level of resonance, like a charismatic resonance, that it simply overpowers all the... You know, habitual assumptions of the society that had existed before. So, I mean, the, the ultimate example of that is Caesar, obviously, but you can find numerous ones where, like,

SPEAKER_00the amount of appeal, you have to get going, the amount of psychological resonance you have to produce to actually Defy a state's monopoly on violence is enormous.

SPEAKER_01The amount of techno-capital you need, though, as well. You know what I'm saying? I get your point, though, because realistically, these guys, like a Zuckerberg, would never be the face of a counter-revolt. But he would work through people. That's the point. And he would exert his will on them in a more... Through subterfuge, basically. I get what you're saying. The charisma, in a sense, is what makes you the guy. But I think that without techno capital, you don't really have anything, right?

SPEAKER_01Even you look at like a man like Trump, who is undeniably charismatic, you know, he has ultimately, in my opinion, largely been subverted through capital, right? Like through massive donations, they have managed, the oligarchs and the rest of it have managed to exert their will over him. And I don't see how in the technological landscape that we're living in, it could be otherwise. I really don't.

SPEAKER_00Well, so no one would dispute that they're going to have quite a bit of power. I mean, like, if you have money, that is always going to be a form of power. And so this was true. This was true under the old aristocracies. And you could say, well, it was more limited then because these aristocrats sort of had them up. But I mean, the industrial tycoon, the merchant tycoon, These are always going to have power, mostly related to financial accumulation.

SPEAKER_00And so their interests are always going to be factored into the politics. And there's just nothing anyone can do about that. So, you know, with something like tech development, like, yeah, they can buy a lot of power. And it doesn't really matter whether it's some democratically elected president or whether it's some military dictator. They have a tool that is one of the greatest. I mean, money is a tool of power and it always will be. So there's no governmental form that can eradicate that and sort of the high degree

SPEAKER_00of influence these people can assert. And so I don't know. I mean, this is a topic where I need to become a little better read as far as anticipating, you know, where the tech You know, where the tech is going to go, because it's already been so rapid in my lifetime. And like, you know, to the degree that states are going to outsource their military operations to, you know, tech companies. These are all questions.

SPEAKER_00I just think that the most important thing is these guys can't just dominate a state without some kind of psychological buy-in from the population. The population won't cloud that. And so it's the difference between like, You know, like I brought up Julius Caesar, like Crassus was the wealthiest guy in Rome and he didn't, he didn't become the Caesar, you know?

SPEAKER_01So, so I think there's always this, this is the, the point where I come in, right? So Sparta defeated Athens, right? So the, the aristocratic regime defeated the more mercantile open one. And like you were saying, like Rome fundamentally land power, right? Um, but As commerce has risen, right? Like the amount of financial activity occurring now is heightened, 10, 20, a million fold, right?

SPEAKER_01Like the importance of money has increased exponentially, right? And I would say, you know, that was true. Even you take, like, you give the examples of the Medicis as an aristocratic family, but the Medicis, in my opinion... And the Medici's were bourgeois in origin, right? They were a banking family. And they used their financial power to...

SPEAKER_01Basically, you know, take over the state, right? So this is my point. I think anyone who's serious about politics, anyone who is serious about becoming a counter-elite or a ruling elite is fundamentally concerned about attaining capital, right? So that's why I would say the best advice, and I think this is going to be very counter to the advice that you give young men, is if you're interested in political power, then you should be studying law, right? You should be going into banking.

SPEAKER_01You should be literally trying to ascertain as much capital as humanly possible in order to be a true political player. And I think that if you are not willing And I think a counter-elite is emerging right now. It's people like Peter Thiel. These are the people who will probably end up controlling the future.

SPEAKER_01It's not handsome, charismatic people. Those oligarchs may work through people like that, but ultimately I think true power will reside with people with money. That's my belief.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think we do... I mean, I agree with you more than I think I sometimes convey in how I write, where I have this total focus on money's ugly, money's like bourgeois, people don't like money, people are rattled by tech development. So you can definitely read me and come away with the sense of, okay, he's really hammering these ephemeral charisma and aesthetic authority and aesthetic appeal. He's really hammering these things Way more than he really should be.

SPEAKER_00And what I'd say to that is that so it's always going to be a mix. I mean, there was petty nobility in the aristocratic system who never showed themselves. They were hated by, you know, the peasantry and and, you know, czarist Russia had this constant thing where. The peasants loved the visible czar who had absolute power because he constantly crushed the boyars, the petty nobility and a more bourgeois society or one

SPEAKER_00that developed along more bourgeois lines like Britain more successfully, I might add, was always glorifying its petty nobility, taking power from the king. Right. So the Magna Carta, the English Civil War. So they had this. They basically saw the middle as the good guys, whereas in Eastern Europe, you often get this thing where The middle is the pesky, you know, tax riders, the people who don't even try to make themselves appealing to the populace.

SPEAKER_00And we need a czar to come in and basically keep them down. So I think that's actually what you might see more of while there's always a chance that these people can just buy influence. And they will, in certain cases, the don't discount the appeal of a charismatic figure who basically rides to power by saying, All these creepy tech people are going to control your life. I'm going to keep them in line, you know, and the risk of selling off or or not selling off, but selling out is always there where there's just simply enough money.

SPEAKER_00They're involved in too many governmental processes. And so they have their way with the the strong man. You know, that's that risk is always there. But there is huge. Like electoral appeal or, you know, popular appeal by framing yourself as you give me power and I will keep these people from ruining your life. These, these unattractive people who, you know, people are worried about what they're doing behind the scenes. They're worried that they're, you know, trying to create a mass herd like surveillance state.

SPEAKER_00And so I think what you're going to see is the strong man who comes out of, Western Europe and the United States is going to be someone that postures themselves against the tech elite very, very strongly. And whether that literally means that the tech elite can't buy them off, that's an open question. But publicly, that will be the posture. But don't you need to be

SPEAKER_01one of those people? Like I'm saying, like, use the example of Trump is that he himself was a bourgeois elite, right? He had millions of dollars that which meant that he didn't need to be beholden to. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Or an aristocratic nature, let's say, where you, you know, I sympathize with all this, right? Don't get me wrong. Like, we come from the same intellectual heritage and trajectory. The thing that I think distinguishes us is the is and the ought. Like, You could say this is the way things ought to be. This is how it should be. I say that techno-capital is the way things are, right? Like techno-capital is what you need, right? If you are serious about politics. If you want to be an aristocrat and you care about establishment,

SPEAKER_01And you disdain shopkeepers and commerce and boring nine to fives, et cetera, et cetera. Go be a bohemian, right? Like I think that like really for aristocrats now, like aristocrats of the soul or whatever, like politics is not for you. Like really there's... Politics, you're not going to... Yeah, it's not going to be you. You can be a demagogue or whatever, right? You can be a populist. But aristocrats, I would say, increasingly, as a class, are politically irrelevant. But I think that as a... Yeah,

SPEAKER_01you can see a lot of artistic people, right, who may devote themselves to aesthetics for their entire life. It could be writing a book. It could be painting. And they just live like bohemians. They disdain... Money, and they live simply, and they devote their whole life to art. And there's definitely an aristocratic quality, like in the sense that you even began with, right? This commitment to aesthetics. But my point is just, if you want to be a counter-elite, which I heard you say, right? In the Bismarck conversation, you said...

SPEAKER_01The group of guys that you're putting together, we want to be the new elite. Like, we want to be a new aristocracy. And my point would be, you will not be a political elite unless you are telling people to make money, right? You need money. Money is more important than ever before. The importance of money is continuously increasing. The only way you could possibly be a counter-elite is if there was a catastrophic, apocalyptic That is the only way I foresee an aristocracy emerging in

SPEAKER_01the political sense.

SPEAKER_00You're probably yeah, you're probably right in in the broadest terms on that. But we have to we have to be careful about how we're talking about sort of the time. So no, it's like, what's our frame of reference here? So if the frame of reference is the 21st century, right? I very much think by the end of the 21st century, there will be balkanization in the United States. There will be breakdown of federal power. There will be states that increasingly seek to become independent.

SPEAKER_00There may even be splinter factions. And those very much can respond to purely charismatic leadership in the locality. So I think that within my lifetime, stuff like that could occur. It's not going to be some kind of... It's not going to be an aristocratic takeover in my lifetime, in the in the aesthetic sense that we've been talking about it, where you basically have a, you know,

SPEAKER_00A ruling elite that takes on sort of the posture of the historical aristocracy. You're not going to have that at scale in my lifetime. Certainly not. But one of the things that I'm actually making, trying to do and still in my group is this idea that you're actually breeding very far out. So the choices you make right now, given your circumstances, you develop a subculture that thinks very, it's very much focused on lineage, on cultivating the type of man you want to see,

SPEAKER_00not in your children, but in your children's great great grandchildren, you know, so it's extremely farsighted in that sense. And that That basically makes it less practical, basically makes it less appealing to a lot of people. But I think it's necessary because like all of these historical aristocracies were cultivated over many generations. This was, I'm a big proponent of epigenetics,

SPEAKER_00where basically, once you start getting certain qualities rolling in a bloodline, it's like a, it's like a snowball, where it just accumulates to the point where now these things are ingrained. And so And I mean things like fundamental courage, fundamental ability of psychological endurance, so willingness to go to prison, willingness to basically live a really nasty life,

SPEAKER_00which a lot of the middle class in the West simply doesn't have. They would break, you know? And I think they would break because that's how they've been bred. So if you start breeding contrary to those things, you basically start saying, I am thinking of this as a massive intergenerational project. You're suddenly building the foundation for in 100 years, assuming it's not nuclear apocalypse, that Your descendants will have the psychological hardiness to emerge in a situation

SPEAKER_00of like social collapse. And so that's sort of how I pointed out, whereas under no circumstances am I suggesting that anyone LARPing as an aristocratic counter elite and meeting in a bar or something is actually going to wind up ruling LARPing. A western nation state in the 21st century. So it's just a long-term ambition and it's a subculture. So it's basically the creation of a new value subculture that has a very long window

SPEAKER_00for consideration of its aims.

SPEAKER_01You know what's funny to think about? Because I think that you're Polish by ancestry, right? Is that correct? Yeah. Polish-Ukrainian. Yeah, Polish-Ukrainian. Well, I'm thinking like I'm Anglo, like going back, you know, like, yeah, so I'm Anglo and I'm just thinking like, so I have like a kind of respect for the bourgeois elite, right? And I'm wondering to what extent, you know, that's been like bred into me because I think like the British,

SPEAKER_01the Anglos are like the bourgeois elite part I just think people do not appreciate how powerful it is. Another thing I want to say is that like even culturally, I think it's underappreciated. Like we often what we do is we compare degraded. A degraded bourgeois elite with an aristocratic elite in its prime. You know what I mean? Like, I think that you need to compare the bourgeois elite,

SPEAKER_01like the Founding Fathers, for example. Like... You need to compare them to aristocratic elites. You know what I mean? In order to have a fair comparison because sure today we have a degraded bourgeois elite. You know what I mean? It's not fair to go and compare them to like, I don't know, Alexander the Great or Leonidas or whatever. It's just not a fair comparison. And I also think, like, you look at the bourgeois actually, like, so the Venetians, the Swiss, the British, obviously, the Americans.

SPEAKER_01I'm just trying to think of bourgeois regimes. Yeah, the Dutch. These are all, like, bourgeois cultures that I actually think have made positive cultural contributions. They're obviously money-grubbing cultures. But, yeah, yeah. I don't know. This is actually, though, a good turning point, though, because I actually wanted to ask you point blank. Is bourgeois life worth it? I mean, maybe first define what you...

SPEAKER_01When I say bourgeois life, what do you think I mean? And then do you think it's something to aspire to or no?

SPEAKER_00No. And I think it depends on temperament. So in other words... I always ask, you know, how is this person view the world? You know, so I don't believe in universalism. So in other words, when someone says you ought to live like you ought to like marry, you ought to get married and work a job and do your part for society. There's all kinds of roles.

SPEAKER_00So there's bohemians, as you mentioned, there's those who do do the, you know, the Grunge middle class work. There's those who do dangerous work. And all of these types are going to have different psychologies that make them suited to it. And I think some of the problem with the standard bourgeois life, which I would define as, you know, basically, you're you grew up in a pretty good circumstances in a middle class home, you get a degree, you get married, you have some kids.

SPEAKER_00And You know, you live in the same place, the same home. Generally, you might move around a bit, but you live sort of the stable nuclear family life. I think everyone knows that that is breaking down. And and I think it's breaking down for reasons of some people who want that can't get it. But it's also breaking down because people actually don't feel that that's something they even want. And They might want kids,

SPEAKER_00but they want to have sort of the narcissistic flexibility to pursue a creative passion or even to venture on divorce. And I'm not talking about those things that they're good social practices. I'm just saying that if the psychology of the population changes, the standard life of that culture has to change also. And so a lot of people just really, really don't want the bourgeois life. So like, they want to make money playing poker,

SPEAKER_00they want to make money as an influencer, they want to make money as like, you know, traveling the world and then selling something on that basis. And so this is where this is where the life has gone for a lot of people in the tech age, this is what they want. And sort of the siloed middle class life is losing its appeal. And so So I wouldn't say inherently, well, you shouldn't desire this kind of normative middle class life. I'd say if you want it, then you should aspire to it.

SPEAKER_00But I'm reflecting the reality in what I write that a lot of people don't want it. And it's not like, you know, the boomers when they were in their, you know, prime of youth. They, you know, castigated the system and they're like, we're rebels and, you know. Most of them that got out of the 60s craze, they went into middle class professional work, and they did the suburban living thing. And they had a lot of incentives, because that was the most prosperous time in history.

SPEAKER_00I don't think that's going to happen. You're getting people, both men and women who enter their 30s and 40s, still trying to hang on to this, you know, this dream that they can live some kind of aesthetic bohemian life. And You know, at some point, most people bend to the practical reality of, I just can't do it. But a lot of people are bottoming out, and they're bottoming out by choice, because they don't want it. And so I'm looking at it, and I'm saying, that's where the psychology is.

SPEAKER_00And you can have the idea, well, too bad if you think that way, because you need to do something that actually makes a living. But I really do think the tech revolution has changed fundamentally where the money is going to be. So I could imagine a situation in 100 years where 60% of the population is influencers. We just don't. In other words, if you can, if you can streamline a lot of the functions that used to require actual labor,

SPEAKER_00Or especially in the case of white collar work, which can already be nullified by AI right now, if we really wanted it to. You're basically you have a population of people who no longer need to do these so-called practical jobs that they previously needed. And so they're pursuing sort of the sort of alternative careers and like. You know, I literally believe you could have an economy where 60% of the people are influencers. It's just everybody paying each other back and forth for things that they want to see.

SPEAKER_00And it's a giant, it's like, you're saying there's nothing being produced here, you know, but if a lot of things are streamlined by tech, You don't need to be producing in that sense.

SPEAKER_01The reason I asked you the question is this has been sort of like an obsession of mine, I guess, right? And I'll give you some background information about myself, right? So like I think I said to you before we started recording, I first started reading Nietzsche when I think I was 16, 17. I was obsessed with him. I think I read BAP when I was 24. By the time I was 28, I had kids. I had two kids and bought a home. And... In light of those things, right?

SPEAKER_01Like, so those are the typical bourgeois things, right? And I now live a very typical bourgeois life. And of course, there's always going to be part of me where, you know, people are always going to embrace self-flattering stories. You know what I mean? Like, so when you have a bourgeois life, you're going to depict it as the best life, the only life, et cetera, et cetera, right? But what I wanted to get it right is... The thing was, right, like I've always been probably more bohemian by temperament, if that makes sense.

SPEAKER_01Like, so I think back to when I was young, I've always been more bohemian by temperament. And I struggle with bourgeois life, right? And always have done. So I remember reading like Revolutionary Road in high school and being very moved by that. Like, always kind of looked at like suburban life, especially as disgusting, nine to five, don't want that, et cetera, et cetera. And I would actually say that I agree with you in that that is now, I would say, the dominant sentiment almost,

SPEAKER_01especially among young people, like among young Zoomers, is that, like, you want to escape the Matrix, which is itself kind of becoming a different Matrix now, you know what I mean? Like, but everyone wants to, quote unquote, escape the Matrix. And... I guess here's the thing. Every mode of life has a failure mode. The bourgeois life has an, and kind of going back to what we were saying with these comparisons, like there's a good bourgeois life and there's a bad bourgeois life, right?

SPEAKER_01There is a kind of monotonous, boring, unadventurous bourgeois life. And I think that is a reality for a lot of people with kids. That's just the truth of the matter, right? But it's also worth pointing down. And, you know, I mentioned Revolutionary Road, which is a book about the drudgery of domestic suburban life.

SPEAKER_01You are going to start having books written in 10 years, 20 years, and they are going to be about the drudgery of childless, quote-unquote, bohemian life. And what I'm trying to get at here is... Okay. Some people, I agree. I'm not a universalist. Your temperament matters. Some people are just temperamentally not suited to family life. I do not, I suspect that that, I don't know what that percentage is,

SPEAKER_01but the fact is, I think that the number of people who currently don't have families, like among millennials, for example, like that number is too high. That would be my point, right? Like, Temperamentally, what percentage of the population is not suited to family life? Probably 10%, right? Like you think about like monasteries in medieval England, like they had to have a place for those people. And then there's probably a smaller group, like I would probably classify myself in this group where it's like,

SPEAKER_01They can do it, but they probably struggle with it. You know what I mean? Like there's a degree of psychic tension because they do, you know, I'm a narcissist like everyone else. Like I do have my creative ambitions and my desires to do X, Y, And I recognize like having a family gets in the way of that. Right. So there's a degree of tension. It's not easy for me. It doesn't come easily. And then there's just like however many people who, yeah, that comes easy for. But my point is that I think the percentage of people going down

SPEAKER_01the Bohemian route is actually way too high and is actually going to be really bad for them when they hit When they get past 35, there's probably because once you get past 35, Um, I see that lifestyle just, especially among women, right? Like childless women after 35 who are still partying that you meet them and there's this like a uncanny quality, like, I don't know how to put my finger on it. It's like the ex cool person.

SPEAKER_01You know what I mean? Who's still trying to be in their twenties. It's very depressing. It's as depressing, if not more depressing than suburban life. You know what I mean? So, um, I have to ask you a question though, because I've just been rambling. Basically what I'm getting at is, do you worry about that? Do you see that as an issue? Like in critiquing bourgeois life, do you see that maybe like we're inadvertently pushing people who should probably go for that away? Do you get what I'm saying?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And I have pretty much an essentialist view though. So in other words, You brought up narcissism, and that's basically, so in other words, the tech revolution creates this kind of, it explodes this desire to stay hip, to stay bohemian, because it's exploding narcissism, right? So I think that's the number one explainer of collapsing birth rates is not economic.

SPEAKER_00It's the changes wrought by the tech revolution.

SPEAKER_01I agree with that. I 100% agree with that.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And so basically now with these people, you're like, well, yeah, a lot of them should be having families and they're not. What you often get is they just develop extremist politics in either direction. So in some cases, people will say, well, you could work a job. You're just choosing not to and you're being selfish. Yeah. And that's actually more common than the types of people who are so economically imperiled that they can't.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So there are a huge number of people, as you said, making these choices and doubling down on these choices. And you say, well, reality will click for the 35 year old woman. She's got to, you know, do something to settle into domestic life. Not necessarily. She can just she can take, you know, She can get on a bunch of psychological meds or psychiatric meds and start joining social groups.

SPEAKER_00And there's a lot of people.

SPEAKER_01Sorry, you froze. You were talking about how the 35-year-old can get on meds and meet people. So just pick up from there. Go again. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So she can basically make her life... You know, she could basically, I guess you'd say, aestheticize her bad condition and basically turn it into political fuel. And so you're going to get a lot of people who are like, I'm fine with being in the bohemian dregs because I'm, you know, I'm aestheticizing my bad experience. And that's what critics of me would say. And they're not even quite wrong about that because I just don't like democratic liberalism, you know?

SPEAKER_00I don't think that should be the basis of a society whatsoever. And so, in other words, I'd be happy to, it's like, I don't think it's that bad if I had a Bohemia in life my whole life. Like, I've accepted that I've bottomed out of the middle class to a large degree, you know? And I think a lot of other people have accepted it for themselves, too. And they could be doing things more normatively and they aren't doing them and they don't feel a need to do them.

SPEAKER_00And so like you notice this with like like Uber driving, right? Or like these kind of these kind of like service jobs that. Don't have any middle class prestige and foreigners come here and they do them. They happily do them. There's a huge number of people like mainly white men and women who would never do work like that, even though that's their new economic, their socioeconomic station.

SPEAKER_00I mean, we overproduce degrees. We have a lot of foreigners working at all levels of the job ladder. And there's a ton of people are like, well, I'm smart. I went to college. And now my situation is I got to be an Uber driver. I got to be a bartender. And they just say, I won't. I'm not doing it. That's that's beneath me, even though that's the position that they are currently in. And so you say, well, where's, where's the money coming from? I, you know, they're trying to make it online,

SPEAKER_00or they're trying to, you know, they're intentionally living in relative poverty, because they don't want to do the actual work that their socioeconomic station has assigned. And so that's, that's the whole, in a way, I'm kind of, you know, boomer in the sense that I say, a lot of people are complaining about things that they could correct if they You know, if they basically just accepted the kind of work available to them and yet they don't want it, you know, they don't want

SPEAKER_01to do it. We totally agree here. And I've actually sort of been, I've become like, I guess, a Zeleni or Boomer, right? Like that's in that... I hear people talking about the economic circumstance and I do think that what that ignores is the underlying reality, which is that increasingly people don't want those things and then they go and say, well, I don't want those things because I can't get them. When it's like, actually, I would say with a fair degree of confidence that if you are on Substack,

SPEAKER_01you have the requisite intelligence to live a middle class life. And actually, it's quite easy. And that might sound totally out of touch. But like, it's like, if you're willing to do a few things, like myself, right? Like, I'm not a... Stryver, like I work like a normal middle-class job. Like you, right, like you said with online stuff, like I actually almost feel like sometimes I'm definitely more emotionally invested in doing this.

SPEAKER_01Right? Definitely. Right. And I'm kind of sick of people...

SPEAKER_01I'm happy that what you said before is I'm kind of sick of people saying it's impossible that you can't get these things. It's like, yes, you can. You can very easily get these things. Not easily. It's much more difficult now. But it's like people used to live on frontiers, right? Like you're not that distant ancestors lived on a frontier if you're from the new world. Like, you know, my family was establishing colonies in Western Australia. It's like they were building their houses. I can find.

SPEAKER_01You know what I mean? Get a house, even if it's really expensive. It's not that hard. But the reality is that people do not want it. I actually think that's true. Like a significant number of people just they actually do not want that life. They find it uninspiring. Yeah. Now, here's where I would push back. We agree on the analysis, right? But here's where I would push back. I would say aestheticizing your failure is not the move.

SPEAKER_01I would just say that you're better off. You are better off committing yourself to the bourgeois life. For most people, right? For most people, I recognize that there are Small groups of people who definitely not, right? They're just not suited for that. But I would say the number of people who think they're not suited for bourgeois life is much higher than it actually is. That's my contention.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think that's even now that's still right. But the changes in our culture are causing those who... In other words, it's causing people to view it as deadening. Right. So like if you're what is what is the middle class life in the 21st century? It's basically constant consumption of fictional or non fictional. So real stuff online of people having more interesting lives than you. Right. That's what that's what the middle class is. So, in other words, everybody's.

SPEAKER_00They go to their job, and then they go and they watch their shows where people are, you know, doing, they're more interesting, and then they watch some influencer whose life is more interesting. So the amount of psychological pressure this development has done, I think, cannot be underestimated. Like, you didn't have, like, we had, you know, Hollywood, we've had Hollywood for a while, but... If you were like a salesman in the 1950s, you did not have this kind of exposure to all the various,

SPEAKER_00you know, exciting lives that you're not having.

SPEAKER_01You just bombarded by You're bombarded by glittering images. And going back to the status thing, it's like you're constantly confronted with your own, in some sense, inadequacy, right? Because like Walt and I were talking about this. It's like, you know, back in the day, if you were like, okay, you can bench, like let's say you can bench 225 for 10, right? Like that's objectively like a pretty good athletic achievement. You can do, you know, pull-ups, whatever. You jump on Instagram and...

SPEAKER_01And you're just watching these people like just effortlessly lift these massive weights and you're just bombarded with that. And then it's like what would have previously been an actual accomplishment is just seen as like... It's just like, whatever, you know, it doesn't, it doesn't matter. But I think though, here's the key thing, right? Like, cause you, you yourself, you said, you know, it is narcissistic, right? Like people are, it's like they're sort of disdaining middle-class life out of a sort of narcissist.

SPEAKER_01A sense of maybe superiority, like I'm too good for this, for this boring middle-class life. But wouldn't it be better to tell people to address their narcissism? There are obviously things you can do to... Like in the same way that there are certain environmental factors that are going to increase narcissism, which is obviously happening because of the tech revolution. Like there are probably things that you can do to decrease your narcissism, right? And wouldn't that be a more productive strategy?

SPEAKER_01Like telling young men, like, you know, don't be narcissistic. Like, you know, the truth is that... Most people throughout most times in history have had to work a job that they don't particularly like to support a family. And it's like at the end of the day, it's like that, that, uh, For most of you, that will be greater than anything you would otherwise do, right? Like for most people having a family will actually be their biggest accomplishment. Um, and there are of course, exceptions I've said, I want to make myself clear.

SPEAKER_01Like I recognize, for example, you look at philosophers, most philosophers are childless and that's not a coincidence, right? They've totally devoted themselves to their work. Um, But yeah, I don't know. What do you think? Isn't maybe addressing... Maybe this is just the Anglo in me. I don't know. Addressing the narcissism? But have you seen that there's these maps where they do these maps of Europe? And mental illness. So like autism is obviously like Germany, like,

SPEAKER_01you know, and then they actually put narcissism as like France, which for the French strike me as fucking narcissistic, definitely. But then they put England in that narcissistic corner. But anyway, yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, I think... Well, I mean, this would be taking the conversation at a whole different angle. But what you said about sort of Anglo inheritance of certain things compared to Eastern European, that's something I think is very interesting. And I think it affects what kind of political change is even possible in these areas. But that's sort of a broad question. As to the point where you said of Well, you should actually be trying to get them not – in other words, you have a problem.

SPEAKER_00You have a narcissistic problem. You have an ego problem. You got to sort of get a reality check. And I think you get a ton of pushback on that from both men and women of the tech generations because they – Know that the older people giving that advice actually did practically have it better. So it's sort of like this whole thing of practical decline becomes kind of a mask argument for I'm not going to conform.

SPEAKER_00So in other words, I see various problems with how the social order is constructed, and I'm not going to conform, even if it's a personal choice because of some kind of narcissistic ego thing. It's that they can always use that claim. To say, well, the social order is screwed.

SPEAKER_01You're an unk. You're an unk. You had a good. The thing is that even that, like I'm saying like that itself is sort of like a cope. Maybe, maybe again, I'm standing out of touch, but like I'm, I'm 30. I'm very much on the precipice of Zuma. I don't. And like, I live in a country which has objectively the highest house prices in the world. Like Australia is fucked for house prices, much more so than America. Yeah. But there are obviously advantages to Australia that America doesn't have.

SPEAKER_01But my point to most people would definitely be like, look, we're talking about chuds, right? We're talking about chuds. You and I both, like we, like insofar as we speak to young people, we're speaking to young people. And I would say that like chuds have certain psychological virtues, tend to be extremely intelligent, and they have certain vices, which they tend to be quixotic, overly idealistic, simultaneously paradoxical. They have learned helplessness. And they tend to believe very self-flattering narratives about like, look,

SPEAKER_01the reason I'm not in charge is because we're living in such a degraded time where the hierarchy is inverted. And if I went back 100 or 200 years, I would be a lord. And it's like, you know what? You probably wouldn't. That's the truth of the matter. And actually, you need to build yourself up. Right. And you start small and things, and this is so bourgeois, this is very bourgeois, but it's, I think it's true. It's like, you do need to start small and build yourself up. Um, and like that does require humbling yourself.

SPEAKER_01You know what I mean? Like you do need to humble yourself and that is ultimately like how you will get things. I do believe. Um, yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, so I'd say all of that is absolutely right. And I would encourage, I encourage chuds to basically be honest with themselves and say, well, you know, would I really be comfortable, you know, living in this downwardly mobile condition into middle age? And it's easy to sort of say that when you're young, it's a lot, it gets a lot harder when you're middle aged. And You know, people don't give you instant attention.

SPEAKER_00You don't look as good. You're not as healthy. You don't have any energy. And basically, you know, bottoming out of the middle class is very painful for middle age. And so this that you can't retain that posture unless you absolutely know what what you're going to have to deal with. And so when I say that I tell the political like the politically conscious chuds, I say, You know, OK, except that you're going to be in the service class,

SPEAKER_00except that you're going to be a non pariah to respectable middle class norms. What this means is you are choosing a hard life. You absolutely are. You are not going to be a middle class professional. You are not going to have respectable dating options for children. And you're not going to have a lot of money. And so I always think like political organization should be done, but these guys ought to absolutely understand that they're making the choice to have

SPEAKER_00a harder life. And so if you're not absolutely certain that that's the choice you want to make, then you should do what you're suggesting, which is just just suck it up and try to have a good, you know, as good a life as you can while sort of working in the system.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And it actually is to what extent, this is the crux of the issue, I think, as it comes down to it, is to what extent are you working against the system, right? And I think that my mind is like, You want to swim across stream. You don't want to swim upstream. You want to swim across stream, right? And, and I actually do ultimately think that like working within the system actually does ultimately end up, uh, like, like in terms of actual raw political power, it's definitely the better option.

SPEAKER_01I just think that, and again, another thing is going back to life strategy, right? This is very much front and center in my mind. I was watching a YouTube video yesterday. I wish I could remember who it was by. It's so relevant to what we're talking about, right? There was this guy there at a pub and they're drinking beers and having a conversation. The guy's fucking like an absolute sued. This guy was talking. He was 24 and he's like talking about the employum, you know, not the goyim, the employum, right? And he was very like...

SPEAKER_01And disdaining anyone who worked, you know, very much saw himself as a neatocrat. Like you could tell, you know, he's reading Julia Savola, et cetera. Like, well, pretending to read Julia Savola, I should say. And it fucking enraged me because it just, it's just so indicative of a type that is emerging. And it's the type of extreme, like, it's weird, like, Where they feel extremely superior to everyone without actually doing anything.

SPEAKER_01Right. And that is becoming, I think that's a very pronounced issue, particularly on the right, where it's like the issue of the needocrat that is. And I just feel like. Inadvertently, that is actually what a lot of these dissonant right circles are promoting is they're promoting like needocrats, which is like, you can just like stand on the sidelines of life and like dismiss everyone, which is very narcissistic and very arrogant.

SPEAKER_01If you're going to do that, like, here's my take. If you are going to reject bourgeois life, it's like be exceptional, right? Be exceptional, be an extraordinary person, actually do things, but for the love of God, do not just be like a neat who disdains people. That's my take. You need to do something. That's the thing.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so I think your visceral reaction there was quite justified. I mean, it's LARP, you know, and even if you're sympathetic, LARP There's always something about LARP that bothers people, as it should. Because we know that you're projecting a certain kind of... It's always annoying to some degree. But I do think that there's a lot of men...

SPEAKER_00Who actually would have better lives in some kind of like urban bohemian poverty. I'm not even kidding on this, where they're organized with young men. Because it's basically like, I don't have to deal with the HR, you know, regime. I've basically given up on middle class face saving. And my life is practically going to be harder. But... They still like it because they get this sense of liberation.

SPEAKER_00If you're just a needocrat in your basement who doesn't have any friends, yeah, you're going to have a really, really dour time growing up. But if you basically find burnouts who share your politics, share certain intelligence, this is like in the 19th century, this was like the socialist communes, except it's going in the other direction because you're like, I'm LARPing as an aristocrat. I'm LARPing as a person of high taste. And I'm using the free time I have from bottoming out of the middle class to,

SPEAKER_00you know, read philosophy or to create art or something. And I actually think that can be a more fulfilling life for a lot of these guys nowadays.

SPEAKER_01The thing is, I actually 100% agree with that. And not only that, like, this is a lot of my friends, right? Where they, like, so... Um, for example, I was out, went out with a friend, like just had a blowout night and he, he, he was like a graffiti writer and most of his friends are graffiti writers, right? Like, so, um, you meet them and some of them are 38, 39. And you have to admit like you talk to them and there's a degree of vitality

SPEAKER_01with them, which is wholly lacking in a lot of men who are a similar age. So I don't deny that. But even that, like, I think that the harsh reality for a lot of these quote unquote bohemians is they won't actually be bohemians, right? They will just be like... For all intents and purposes, they're bourgeois in that, like, they primarily live for comfort, right? They just manage to eke out a comfortable existence in maybe their parents' home

SPEAKER_01or something like that, or like, you know, they work just enough. And they're still doing all of, like, you know, yeah. So I think, again, I think what it really comes down to is there are positive images of ways of life, right? And I think that the truth is that whilst you're completely correct, no life mode is universally going to it. It doesn't apply to everyone, right? But generally speaking, most people probably should be prioritizing stable income, family, etc.

SPEAKER_01And the thing is, a lot of people hear that and they go, well, you know, that's not me. Be honest with yourself. Be real with yourself. Are you someone who is going to be an artist? Do you even have any inclination? Do you write? Do you paint? Do you do any of those things? Or do you just like the idea of doing them? If it's politics, what are you doing? Are you tweeting? What are you actually doing? So that's the thing.

SPEAKER_01Just recognize bohemian life is for very few people and you need to... Think about what that's going to look like when you're 40, right? Because for some people, the truth is it looks good. Some people live a bohemian life well into their 40s and it's actually very interesting, right? So yeah, I don't disagree with you there. I just, I think that most people probably the bourgeois route is probably the best for them.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so the only disagreement I think is we would have on that is that you probably think That's more people than I think. In other words, I think what has happened with the tech changes to culture is it has made a lot of both young men and young women basically have this sort of disdainful opinion of all stable, routine, anonymous bourgeois life.

SPEAKER_00And so while you're absolutely correct that The plurality is always going and should follow that path. I think the numbers are far higher that will reject that path. And it's not like an either or. There's people who work a job and then go through the midlife crisis and get divorced and start trying to be a poker player. You do it for a while and sometimes you flip. And sometimes there's people that Go the other way, though,

SPEAKER_00that's harder, where they were living sort of with some like sporadic income, doing something online, and then they just settle into a job and a suburban life. So it's like people will go in and out. But I just think that what has happened in the 21st century with tech advance is it has made the appeal of that life and the aesthetic appeal of rejecting that life Far more common than it had been in the

SPEAKER_01last generation. I 100% agree with you there, but here's my prediction, right? Is that I think this is something that's probably cyclical, right? In that what will happen is that... As that mode of life, let's call it bohemian mode of life, like you could already go and say that like, this is not an original point, like the counterculture became the culture, right? Like there has been a rebellion against bourgeois norms since the 60s, right? Bourgeois norms have largely been eroded.

SPEAKER_01It's kind of in a way... It's becoming kind of unusual to be bourgeois almost, right? Like it would be pretty rare, like, because I think about like the bourgeois mode of life, it would be get married very young, don't have that many sexual partners, have only a few, you know, you don't go traveling, you don't, you know what I mean? And you buy a house when you're very young. Like that is very, very unusual today. And my point is that like we grew up I can speak for myself.

SPEAKER_01I grew up reading literature that was extremely critical of bourgeois life, like Death of a Salesman, like Revolutionary Road. My point is that the millennial novel, if there is a great millennial novel, it will be dealing with something like... This new type of mass man who, it's basically what I'm trying to get at, it's more horrible than we ever conceptualized, right? Like we begin to realize that like increasingly like whole generations

SPEAKER_01or significant numbers of people in generations are just like childless, atomized, And basically like, yeah, in their late twenties and even early thirties, they party, but then they noticed that their appetite for partying isn't what it used to be. And like the fun they get from hedonism isn't what it used to be. And then they don't really have anything to work for or like, you know what I mean? So, so I think that that is coming. Those books are coming and that cultural change, you can already see it a little bit, but that will intensify.

SPEAKER_01So that, I guess that's just a warning, right? Like it's something to keep in mind. But yeah, well, is there anything else? I'm just trying to think, is there anything else that I wanted to ask you? I don't think so. We've been talking for a little bit now. I think it's been a productive conversation. I hope that I made it clear that this is something that I'm grappling with, right? So I'm not dogmatic on this topic. It's something that I grapple with as someone who does have a bourgeois life. I constantly feel the appeal of bohemianism, right?

SPEAKER_01So yeah.

SPEAKER_00Right. And it's, I mean, you know, I think we'll see how many of these people sort of fall into line. And you might be right that it's just the ordinary youthful generation, you know, going up against what their elders are going, or their elders are insisting they do. But the thing that I, and this is just one of those senses, it's like a, you can't really

SPEAKER_00You can't really point to any proof, but it just does seem like this is a quote unquote revolutionary generation far more than like the sort of mock contrarianism of the boomers. It's like, and I think fundamentally you might just say it's the difference between an optimistic and a pessimistic ethos.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00So, you know, the boomers, it was all, well, You know, we're going to have our 60s fun and, you know, shove it at our parents. But there was this like optimism about things. Now it's we're going to do we're going to shove it at our at our, you know, the generations that screwed us over. And we're really mad about it. There's not any sort of sense like, man, we're going to live out a great youth and we're going to, you know, ride off into the sunset in the middle age. It's it's it's pessimistic, which I think.

SPEAKER_00Makes it far more potentially consequential. Because it's a fundamental dissatisfaction, not out of youthful rebelliousness, but out of structural and chronic aspects of the social order. And so I just think when the boomers go, there's no center. There's no center to the politics, right? No, that's right.

SPEAKER_00I don't think a lot of these young guys are really going to actually be adjusting their politics when they enter middle age. I think they'll probably double down. And so that's the thing that I think it's like, you're right. I mean, you're just going to get this political instability because it's not a transition huge swaths of the population want to make. Yeah. Yeah. All right.

SPEAKER_01Well, Yeah, I do agree with you. My thing, though, is I think that, like, one thing that could... Because you're right, they're very pessimistic. Like, Gen Z are a very pessimistic generation. Though the same could be said of millennials. I think the funny thing is millennials actually did have an optimism that I don't think Gen Z do. Like, even though they pretended to be really cynical, I think fundamentally they were perhaps one of the most optimistic generations, right? Yeah. That's my reading, yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_01Well, yeah, Gen Z do feel pessimistic, but it's kind of funny because I think that pessimism can even be an extraordinary, like resentment can be an extraordinarily like galvanizing force. Like all revolutionaries are pessimistic about the current order, right? But pessimism can also. I actually do think that Gen Z could ultimately be a very inconsequential generation. But maybe that's just millennial...

SPEAKER_01Millennial narcissism, I don't know.

SPEAKER_00I've actually said that, that I think Gen Z is a fork road generation where they basically see what they cannot do, you know? It's like they're the first generation that's sort of seen, they're the first generation that's rejected liberalism, you know, in the post-war era. And But they're not going to be the ones with the agentic capacity to dismantle liberalism.

SPEAKER_01There's just like a listlessness, particularly like the young Gen Z guys. Like I'm talking now about like teenagers, like the gym that I go to, like there's just a lot of very young Gen Z guys that I speak with, like 18, 19. What I noticed is it's like an asymmetric generation. So like the ones that are agentic are extremely agentic, right? Like an extremely intelligent and they've used these technological tools to really enhance themselves in an extraordinary way.

SPEAKER_01You know what I mean? Like in an unthinkable way, like they're so smart, they're so whatever. But then the great massive like Gen Z guys I would say are like pretty listless. You know what I mean? Like just lack of energy or just like lack of determination. So yeah, it'll be interesting to see where it goes. But I do agree with you in that like the degree of cynicism and almost like nihilism is like...

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I really appreciate you letting me come on. Yeah, alright, sick. Thanks, Derek. Have a good one. Thanks Russell.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Complete Normiemaxxing Guide, w/ Drunk Wisconsin.

    Nov 14, 20261 hr 15 minAudio

    In this episode of the Chudstack Review, Drunk Wisconsin and I discuss: * What is the “state school upper middle class,” and why does nobody talk about them? * Are many online voices downwardly mobile elites? * Why...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. German Romanticism & Nazi Hippies, w/Gildhelm

    Oct 1, 20261 hr 8 minAudio

    Gildhelm and I discuss: * Is Christianity a revolt against nature? * Why did the German Romantics turn to nature and the Greeks? * Why did the romantic movement start in Germany? * What does the word “persona” really...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Great Zombiefication & The Decline of Literary Culture, w/Owen Yingling

    Sep 19, 20261 hr 11 minAudio

    Owen Yingling and I discuss: * Have Zoomers been Zombified? * Is it alienating being a highly literate Zoomer? * Why do so many university students care more about credentials than learning? * What is a university...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Studs, Straggots, & Sex-Work

    Sep 7, 20261 hr 25 minAudio

    BUY THE STUD: CLICK THIS LINKLiam and I discuss: * Has market logic colonised family life? * To what extent is surrogacy ethical? * What is Liam’s novel, The Stud, about? * Is post-industrial, white-collar life...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Lions of the West, RISE UP!!! w/Dan Baltic

    Aug 24, 20261 hr 10 minAudio

    Dan Baltic and I discuss: * How political should an author be? * Is Nutcrankr actually a right-wing book? * How much does Nutcrankr owe to A Confederacy of Dunces and Don Quixote? * How autobiographical is Spencer? *...

    Credit the people on this episode