BUY THE STUD: CLICK THIS LINKLiam and I discuss: * Has market logic colonised family life? * To what extent is surrogacy ethical? * What is Liam’s novel, The Stud, about? * Is post-industrial, white-collar life sterilising people? * Are girlbosses actually good? * What is a straggot? * How has Liam’s day job as a corporate lawyer influenced his prose style? * Is lookmaxxing leading to the boyification of men? This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit russellwalter.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Okay, I'm joined by author of the starred Liam Blackford and someone I consider a friend despite the fact that we've never met. We've spoken and we talk in a roundabout way pretty much every single day but I was actually thinking like there's something to be said for these like uh these like Online friendships. I kind of thought about like, you know, back in the day how people had like pen pals. There's like famous examples of this of like authors with pen pals. I can't remember who HP Lovecraft was,
SPEAKER_01but you know, he was talking with this and like, actually, like even if those people had never met in the flesh, I imagine that they would consider themselves close friends. You know what I mean?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, for sure. I mean, actually, so we're going to meet in a week for the first time, which will be awesome. But actually, I think there is a bit of an art to the group chat. And I feel like maybe when you're in your 30s, as I am, or let's just say I'm in my... I'm a 30-something or whatever. Everyone's working, everyone, you know, like a lot of my friends have got kids or whatever. You actually don't see each other in person that much. So you're kind of like always in a group chat, actually. And I feel like there's a real art to like socializing in the group chat and like the medium of the group chat. Is actually very dominant.
SPEAKER_02I have to admit, I get social anxiety from group chats a bit, like possibly more than in person, you know, I'm kind of like, I want my contributions in the group chat to be, you know, high quality and like not slop or whatever. But anyway, we're having fun in our group chat, I think.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, yeah. No, it's good. I mean, I've actually deleted Substack from my phone and Messenger, Facebook Messenger. So my two most used apps now are Signal, which is what our group chat is in, and... So they've become my two most used apps. And I deleted Substack because it's very easy to trick yourself into thinking that Substack is something that it isn't. You're like, oh, you know, I'm reading blogs. It's like, no, Substack. You are reading, you're effectively on Twitter.
SPEAKER_01You know what I mean? And I'm definitely like a dopamine demon. Like I will spend, like I was spending too much time on it and I just realized it's not really productive. Like I do miss the AI research. I don't have any of these things. So I'm probably spending way too much time on Signal.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02No, I'm with you. I mean, the other thing about like the signal chat or whatever, like all group chats or whatever, is that there's a bit of an art to like, like if you have a day off from the group chat, you'll come back and there'll be like 200 plus, you know, notification, like new messages. And I think that like, you know, there's an attempt to catch up and to kind of like weigh in post facto on what everyone was going off about. But I think you have to be ready. I have to let that go, guys. Yeah. I'm sorry. I missed it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that is crazy. But anyway, I want to call this episode Studs, Stragots and Sex Work, just because of the alliteration. But we are going to be talking about The Stud, your book, which is, I'll just say from the outset, is fantastic. Actually, an incredible book. One thing that just surprised me about it was, I mean, it's not a self-published book. It's going to be published by, I guess, an indie publisher, right? Yeah.
SPEAKER_01That struck me, having read some more indie alt-lit, was how, I would say, professional it was. I don't know if it comes across as super professional because the narrator themselves, the narrator, sorry, kind of does talk in a very professional tone, you know what I mean? Because the narrator's voice is kind of similar to the characters in it, in a way. But... I was just struck by how professional this was. If this was published by Penguin or whatever,
SPEAKER_01Simon & Schuster, it would seem totally normal to me, right? It wouldn't struck me as unusual at all, right? Whilst a lot of the indie stuff that I've read, it would, you know what I mean? So I was amazed at how... Just well-written it was. To say professional sounds, I don't know if that gets across. But then also another thing, I think for me, I know I'm enjoying a book if it fucks my sleep up.
SPEAKER_02I'm sorry.
SPEAKER_01Because I think it's not a short book. I want to say it's 120,000 words, something like that, right?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I cut it down. It was roughly that, but I cut it down a bit to 110. But yeah, it is long. Yeah. Like it's definitely longer than average.
SPEAKER_01It's not a short book and I'm not a quick reader and I read it, I think I want to say in less than a week. And it was because I was staying up. I was staying up till like, so I go to bed really early and I was just staying up and I literally couldn't put it down. Literally could not put it down. It's an amazing book. Like I said to you, you may be my favorite Australian author because... It's kind of a backhanded compliment because I don't know that many
SPEAKER_02Australians. Yeah, big fish in a very small pond, maybe.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, no, no, but it is truly, I think that this is a phenomenal book. This is seriously a phenomenal book. I am really hoping that it's as successful as it should be because it's an amazing book. I'll stop glazing you now, though. But I want to talk about that. We're obviously going to be talking about that. But quickly, for the sake of the title, what is Astragut? What's Astragut? Oh,
SPEAKER_02my God. Well, hang on. Just before I... I'll tell you what a straggard is. I will. But I just want to really comment first just on the point about the professional language. Just because, I mean, there might be just a bit of context there, which is... Important and relevant, which is that, you know, in my day job, I'm a corporate lawyer. I have been for more than 10 years. I've worked in Australia and in Hong Kong and for a very small time in China as well. That sort of language in the novel is very familiar to me.
SPEAKER_02I mean, you know, I think maybe you said two things. It's like, you said it's professionally written and it's well written. I don't know. Or like, at least it's like... You know, like, uh, polished or something.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, polished is that, that's the quality I was trying to get at, is that a lot of the time these alt-lit books, they have a kind of, uh, rugged quality to them, which can be both good and bad. You know, it feels like, like, maybe they probably needed a little bit of editing. And the funny thing is that I actually was reading an older version of The Stud. You sent it to me a while ago, and I didn't bother to get, to read the more updated version. So it's been even more polished since I, uh, And I found it extremely polished.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, yeah. So, yeah, sorry.
SPEAKER_02I mean, that's kind of, no, no, I mean, like, that's kind of how I write. But actually, I find that style of writing, like, actually, a friend of mine recently, she absolutely headshotted me. She was like, Liam, have I, you sound like Google AI Overview, but you actually always have, like, before Google AI was a thing. And, like, that's obviously so brutal and I'll never recover, but... Also, I think what I want to point out is that that style of writing is actually extremely funny. Like it can be very, you know, I want to say camp.
SPEAKER_02I always think that that's kind of like the tone of voice. Like it's self-serious and it is polished, literally, but it's also like... There's something like kind of artificial and insincere about it, which means there's a great potential for comedy, but okay. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01No, no, no, no. Let's continue with this. The way that I would put it is, so, again, we're kind I'm kind of jumping ahead. I do want to get the Stragger thing, but it was like, maybe actually you can just at the end, just tell me what a Stragger is. I just need it for the title.
SPEAKER_02Okay.
SPEAKER_01All right. So you have the book is following these professional ladies, right? And they absolutely much more so than the narrator, like the narrator does have a voice. You know what I mean? Like the narrator does have a voice. Um, cause it's written in the third person. Um, But the professional ladies are full HR LinkedIn speak. You know what I mean? Like they are more so than the narrator, but it's like the narrator does have a little bit of that themselves. You know what I mean?
SPEAKER_02That's true. That's true.
SPEAKER_01A little bit of it. So yeah, with that said, maybe let's just begin with the basic premise of the book. Yeah. What's the basic premise?
SPEAKER_02Okay, so the premise of the stud is that it's set in a version of Western Australia, the Republic of Western Australia, which has seceded from the Federation of Australia, become an independent republic. And it's kind of like leaned in hard to a hypernatal country. A policy framework where it's encouraging its citizens to have babies in as many ways as possible, in whatever way works for them. And I've written a few different stories and premises in this universe,
SPEAKER_02in this idea, and the stud is actually just one of them. But in the stud, the idea is that it's centered around this idea of a mother Leader, father, labourer framework where multiple women will live together and pool their resources and they will insource a shared male partner who is their joint employee. He's their subordinate. He's on their payroll who will impregnate them all and help raise their children. So it's kind of like a,
SPEAKER_02you know, it takes a village sort of idea, but it's like, yeah, one house. And so the idea in the stud is that There are these three women, Eloise, Inez and Sophia, who have all been together for a few years already, and they've had this stud set up. I mean, they don't use the term stud. They consider it very offensive. Stud is kind of like a secret way that everyone refers to it in shorthand. But they have a stud called Luke, who has already given them, I think, five children at the time the novel starts. And then it's been successful so far.
SPEAKER_02So they invite a fourth woman to join the house because they've got a bit of extra space. And Martina is the fourth woman. She's interested in... Martina's story is that she's a corporate lawyer. She's in her late 30s. She has goals of motherhood and family, but the traditional pathway of boyfriend, husband, nuclear family hasn't worked for her. So she joins the stud house. She likes the ladies. She likes Luke, the stud. And then it goes from there. She does get pregnant, but there is a bit of drama.
SPEAKER_02Is that a good statement of the premise?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, absolutely. I actually thought I want to actually talk about the book, but beforehand, maybe let's talk about the literary inspiration and then also maybe the... Because, you know, when reading this, Willebec does absolutely come to mind. It definitely could be described as Willebec yet. I mean, no one would say it that way because I'm an Australian and it probably sounds retarded to anyone. Well back. I say, I say it's the same as like, I've said this before.
SPEAKER_01It's like, I say Paglia, like I say Paglia, I will never say, uh, you know, Paglia, I'm not going to do that. And I've said the reason I'm not going to do that. It's like, it's the lingua franca, like, you know, English is the lingua franca of the world. We won world war two. It's like, we can kind of say things however the fuck we want.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah. Actually bronze age pervert has this thing where he's like, um, He's like, I say Peking. I don't say Beijing. I speak English. In English, we say Peking. It's like, okay,
SPEAKER_01okay. I'm actually one of those people, like, if I mispronounce something once, Like I have a friend of 10 plus years. I mispronounce his name. It is like a, it's like a Jewish, Jewish name, like a Hebrew name. It's not a conventional English name. And I mispronounced it when I was in, and I just, I always, if I mispronounce something the first time, I will continue to mispronounce it forever, no matter how much people correct me. So yeah. That is okay. It is. I was, so, so I think you were saying that.
SPEAKER_01You can see it in, I actually read all of the Lubbock's novels like back to back. So they blur into one for me. So like, you know, The Map and the Territory, Submission, Elementary Particles, like all of them, whatever, read them back to back. So they blur into one. I can never really remember which one is which because they're all so similar yet different.
SPEAKER_02You know what I mean?
SPEAKER_01The protagonist is always kind of the same. And, and, you know, one of the things is in his books, he typically will do what we call like speculative fiction, right? So there'll be, it'll be set in, you know, 2015 or whatever, but then the book will jump maybe a hundred years into the future in some weird world. And the world is very much related to the ideas being discussed in 2015. So yours is speculative fiction in the spirit of Willowbeck,
SPEAKER_01but it is all speculative fiction, right? It's all set in this world. You're not jumping between worlds. And like, is it 2035 or something?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, it's like sometime in the 21st century, very much the near future, you know, but very conceivable.
SPEAKER_01It absolutely feels totally conceivable. Like, it sounds weird, but I've actually, like, The Stud House, for example, I've literally thought, like, this could conceivably be something that happens even prior to reading this book, because I have noticed it's very common. For professional women to live in share houses together. Like I don't know if this is the case in Perth as much, but in Melbourne, I know a lot of women earning amazing money, amazing jobs, and they all live in share houses together.
SPEAKER_01And they're all in similar positions to Eloise, Martina and stuff like that, which is that they're struggling to find a man. And in the book, you know, the funny thing is right. Like in the book, men are like, I'm having a mental blank. What's the tattooed trans person?
SPEAKER_02Yorkie, Muhammad York. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01So Yorkie is like the most powerful guy in this republic.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01But he's not actually a guy.
SPEAKER_02No, he's a trans. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Who's given birth to children, which is just such a, that was such a bizarre choice. And yet like they're the most masculine guy conceivable. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, Yorkie's one of my favourite characters. I mean, he has appeared in a lot of the other stories that I've written, even outside The Stud. I think I really like that character because it's like, he's meant to be just like a pure, like, Nietzschean avatar of Will, where he's, you know, he was born a woman, but then decided to become a man and then became, you know, founded a business empire and became the richest man in the country. And it's just like an extreme, like... Like, a gentic person who, like, even invented his gender basically for himself.
SPEAKER_01MMA fighter, businessman, like, sex worker, mother.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, All of that.
SPEAKER_01And it sounds like, that just sounds on face value, that sounds so absurd. And yet, in the book, it doesn't feel absurd for whatever reason. Like, it feels very believable. But, yeah, go back to your, maybe just start with your influences for the book.
SPEAKER_02Well, I mean, so on Welbeck, so I would say, like I've read, I haven't read all of Welbeck. I haven't read The Map of the Territory. I haven't read Annihilation. But I've read the others. And I think the two which are probably the most influential on the stud are Platform and Submission. I think because... Well, just like one by one. The thing about platform is that that's obviously the idea that like it's based on the idea that like a major hotel group,
SPEAKER_02I think it's based on Accor, the French hotel group, but they call it something different. He calls it something different in the book, but that they just, they realize that like it'd be a huge money spinner to offer package sex tourism, like hotel and travel packages to the likes of Thailand, basically, which is obviously something in like Western countries that we would consider kind of I wanted to borrow something from the idea that in this hyper-liberal republic of Western Australia that is trying to set up an economy independent from the rest of Australia, that we would start prostituting our
SPEAKER_02I have another story about a non-verbal sex worker who grew up as a feral child in the In the West Australian wilderness, basically. But it's just like,
SPEAKER_02you know, it's meant to be this totally like brothelized version of a economy, which to be honest, like I know that also sounds preposterous and absurd, but actually I don't think it is. Like, I think, you know, we've seen from the last 10 years of culture that like, you know, everyone from Denise Richards and her daughter are having OnlyFans and, you know, Bella Thorne has an OnlyFans, you know, like people are very willing in our economy to... Sell themselves basically. So the whole idea was that it was meant to, have I got you?
SPEAKER_02You're frozen. Oh, sorry. I'm here.
SPEAKER_01Sometimes my video freezes, but I'm still here. All good.
SPEAKER_02Okay, great, great. So that was the platform one. And then just turning to submission. So I guess like the whole concept of submission is that it's a complete ideological regime change in France, you know, and everyone has, well, submission sort of follows the transition from, you know, like a kind of Western country to sort of like an Islamic Republic. But like I wanted to sort of It showed that this transition could be, and it's not necessarily in the Islamic Republic in my stories,
SPEAKER_02but like that you could have this total ideological victory of this sort of total hyper-liberal, hyper-global concept in a Western country. And the thing about like Western Australia is that, you know, I'm from Perth, I'm born and raised in Perth. So are you, low-key. Yeah, yeah. But I actually do think there is something, I kind of do think that Western Australia is the most frontier and
SPEAKER_02the most vital state of Australia actually.
SPEAKER_01It's also the most rootless. You actually go to a place like Perth, and it really does feel like... I've compared it to a Dubai, right? It does feel like a place where a sort of ideological revolution, a total break with history... It's conceivable in a place like Perth. And it is very Faustian in that, like, you know, you, you even read about stories because, because my, uh, uh, my, um, family actually settled.
SPEAKER_01So on one side of my family, on one side it's English, right? And they came recently, but on one side, um, he was a pharmacist who actually settled, um, created the first, um, pharmacies and helped settle, um, Busselton, I believe. So you read about these accounts and it's clear that it was one of the most inhospitable places in all of Australia to try and settle. And, you know, like even the fact that the Dutch, the Dutch knew about West Australia for a long time and never bothered to colonize it because really,
SPEAKER_01and this is the point I think Geoffrey Blaney has made. You really can't have Australia without the industrial revolution because it's just too inhospitable. And that is so true of fucking WA where it's like, what enables the settlement That's right.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Very Faustian and very cool about that. And it's also like, I think people don't know this, but someone told me per capita, most self-made millionaires in the world, West Australia.
SPEAKER_02True. I didn't know that. But I mean, I believe it. You're totally right about the industrialization. I mean, Western Australia has, you know, the largest iron ore deposits in the world. It has like extremely large petroleum reserves. We have uranium. We have lithium. We have, you know, some of the most... We've got the best rocks in the world, basically. The most valuable rocks in the world.
SPEAKER_01Rockingham! Rockingham is the best fucking ice in the world. That's what I... Oh, true.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, exactly. That is the rock of choice
SPEAKER_01in Rockingham.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's so right. Um, but yeah, like Australia probably, uh, avoided a recession from, uh, definitely after the GFC as a result of selling iron onto China, like China's China's, um, uh, 21st century development is very much attributable to Western Australian iron ore. The thing is that people are like, Liam, you write so much about seceded Western Australia. Are you a secessionist? How serious are you about this?
SPEAKER_02Of course, I'm not serious at all. Not at all. To me, it's just a preposterous curiosity of an idea. But then there are times where I'm like, we'll do it. Like watch us, watch us do it.
SPEAKER_01And you could actually, people don't realize, I think that West Australia is like consistently the only state which is like contributing more tax than taking, right? Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. Sorry, I cut you off.
SPEAKER_01No, I was just going to say it definitely punches above its weight. One thing I really despise is that there's just this general economic illiteracy, especially in the East Coast. All these people are like, we need to shut down coal and stuff like that. It's like, dude, this whole thing, the only productive fucking sectors that we have in this country are mining and agriculture.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01L's is like parasitic pretty much. Like that's obviously a simplification, but like, it's pretty fucking true. Like you, you, that is the thing. Like insofar as that we are like one of the wealthiest people in the world, it's because of those fucking rocks.
SPEAKER_00You know what I mean?
SPEAKER_02That's right. That's right. I mean, you know, so, you know, our, um, Our friend, I'm going to call him my friend. He's probably your friend. He doesn't know who I am probably, but Misha Oz just wrote a really great essay about the Australian economy actually kind of pointing out that we have so much wealth, but we're hampered from one way or another from exploiting it. I mean, I, you know, when I went to uni and, you know, I think this happens a lot when you're a young person. Like I have had a lot of, you know, very liberal lefty friends, you know, environmentalist friends.
SPEAKER_02I still, I still do, of course, you know, and I'm not, I'm not like a perfect, you know, avatar of any particular political position, but like, you know, what, What was made the news in the last few years was a stop by a pub and like anti Woodside protests and stuff. And, you know, some activists chained themselves out outside the house of Meg O'Neill in City Beach and, you know, they wanted to stop these developments, whatever. But my time in other countries, especially China, Has made me realize that we are so lucky.
SPEAKER_02We are so lucky as a country and it's very fragile. We're very blessed with all of these things. We can't shoot ourselves in the foot. We're too complacent with... Wealth and it could all disappear in a generation. I mean, I always think that we're one generation away from being Argentina, basically, like we could really squander, you know, we could fumble the bag big time, you know. So I'm kind of like, yes, you know, like we do need to, you know, respect environmental, you know, we can't blow up,
SPEAKER_02we can't, we shouldn't have blown up Duke and Gorge, but there's got to be a...
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02I'm
SPEAKER_01just saying like, as like a, you know, as a, uh, you know, I think, I think most people it's like, I probably describe myself as like a romantic conservative or at the very least I'm sympathetic towards like romantic conservatism. So of course it's like, you love nature. I'm like a hiker. I love those things. You know, you want to preserve, um, you want to preserve, uh, wilderness. You know what I mean? Um, But then it's like, you also don't want to be naive. You don't want to bite the hand that feeds you basically. So yeah, but basically you're saying that like, so it's,
SPEAKER_01but it is because of this sort of Faustian spirit that we do see in a place like WA, I think that It is conceivable that there could be like a total revolution in which the sort of like many, I mean, it's not a total ideological revolution because you recognize many of the talking points that the characters have, right? They're milquetoast talking points that we have today. The key difference is that the society is obsessed with fertility, right? As opposed to now
SPEAKER_01where I feel like fertility is something that's like it's changing, obviously, but it's Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I feel like this is such a...
SPEAKER_01That's an insightful quote for the start. So it says it's a fact that in societies like ours, sex truly represents a second system of differentiation, completely independent of money. And as a system of differentiation, it functions just as mercilessly. This is the key part. The effects of these two systems are furthermore strictly equivalent. No, no, this is the key part. Just like unrestrained economic liberalism, and for similar reasons, sexual liberalism produces a phenomena of absolute pauperization, right?
SPEAKER_01And you can see in this, like, I just see what you see in the stud is like that sort of economic liberalism has been charged up to like a thousand percent, right? But then it's just the sort of logic of the market has completely... Completely colonized the concept of family, right? Like you can see that increasingly for most people, like relationships, like the relationship between Martina and Luke is a contractual one, right?
SPEAKER_01It's one of employer-employee, right? So it's like the logic of capitalism has completely colonized relationships. And that's what I think is, it's a fascinating exploration of that. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, the other kind of things which are touched on in the stud, which are part of this, is that like industries such as commercial surrogacy are entirely liberalized and also trade in human genetic material. So, you know, sperm trade, egg trade. So, there's total liberal, like, you know, you can, you know, buy an egg from person, from, you know, woman A, you can buy a sperm from a man and then you can put it in a Third-party surrogate and, you know, have a baby and it's totally, you know,
SPEAKER_02this industry is completely mainstreamed and then it completely industrialized and completely stratified. So it's like, you know, there's the premium end of the market, there's the public system. So it's like, you know, I got a surrogate through the public system sort of thing, you know, and this kind of like the family and, you know, and relationships actually are totally different. Like productized, basically, and economized, I guess, is the term. I mean, the stud is just one story, but, you know, I've got other ones, you know,
SPEAKER_02involving like one of my most popular stories online is The Come King of Cottesloe, which is about like a... I read that. I read that. Did you like it?
SPEAKER_01I loved it. Yeah, I loved it. It's about like, I can remember, it's about basically this like elite sperm donor who, again, it's so interesting, right? Because it's basically like, it's very much conceivable, isn't it? That like, okay, right now, and we've spoken about this previously, right? Not here, but previously we've spoken about like how What is probably going to take the place of like this left wing, right wing dialectic is increasingly like a humanist, transhumanist debate.
SPEAKER_01And it's like, to what extent do we want to interfere with nature? And right now, like, you know, I actually don't know the laws. You probably do. But like, you know, there's not I don't think there's such a thing as like, you know, There's no one who's making millions of dollars donating their sperm. You know what I mean? I don't think that exists. But you can imagine if we do start to become more transhumanist, that's very much conceivable, right? It's a finite product, right? You could only produce so much of it.
SPEAKER_01And people will want it. It's like, hey, I do want, what was the guy who owns, is it Signal or Telegram? I can't remember. You sent it.
SPEAKER_02Oh, see me. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Oh, wait a second.
SPEAKER_01A guy like that, like a high IQ athletic guy. I think he is donating his sperm, but it's like, it's very conceivable that you could start to sell it as a product, right? And that behind demand, and like the come king of Codisloe, you could have millionaires who are selling their semen. Like, they make millions from selling their semen. Like, it's not as absurd as it necessarily sounds.
SPEAKER_02No, not at all.
SPEAKER_01Especially in a transhumanist, like, if we become increasingly transhumanist, which we obviously are. Yeah,
SPEAKER_02no, for sure. I mean, so I'm aware of, this was reported on, there were a few articles, I think it was this year and last year, even in the Washington Post of like a phenomenon of mostly Chinese, extremely elite Chinese people. So some Chinese billionaires becoming hyper prolific fathers and having like sourcing eggs from like models and basically like kind of selecting and curating things. Eggs from various sources and then matching them up to their sperm. And then there's this one guy who had this whole vision where he was like,
SPEAKER_02I want to have a hundred daughters. I want them all to marry world leaders, which is like, you know, okay, you know, whatever. But he has this, you know, grand plan for himself. But I mean, even closer to home, like I actually know these, uh, this gay couple in Perth and, um, uh, they, they have this vision, which, which is happening. Like it's in train where, uh, They're having three children from a surrogate in the United States. For each children, they're paying US$150,000, so US$450,000 in total, which is a huge amount of money.
SPEAKER_02800,000 Australian dollars. And in any case, it's a huge amount of money. And it's very expensive because the surrogate is in the United States. And if they had gone to a surrogate in, for example, Thailand, which is more common, or Indonesia or the Philippines, you know, then that's more bargain basement, so to say. But the point of this is that, like, there actually is an industry of human genetic material. It's uncomfortable to talk about because it's, you know, it's because it is Putting price tag on people, human wombs and human labor.
SPEAKER_02And, you know, why does a surrogate in the United States get to charge more than a surrogate in the Philippines? And it's because the United States is a more, you know, regulated, healthier country or whatever. So it's like this all exists.
SPEAKER_01It comes, it literally does come back to this debate. So I can see now why, like, when you listen to the ARX Han thing that you like resonated with that point, because it comes down to, I guess there'd be like a Christian or a humanist notion, right? Where it's like a person is... Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And there'd be people who just say categorically, you cannot do that. But it's like, that's already being done. And it kind of made me think there is this Huxley quote. I tried to find it then, but I couldn't find it. It's basically about like, what makes a dystopia good? Basically, you need to look at things that are already happening and then just enhance them, right? Or take them to their logical conclusion. I mean, that's what the stud does. It takes... Things that are already happening now in, you know, sort of beta form and just like ramps them up,
SPEAKER_01take them to their logical conclusion, which is why it's believable. But then that got me thinking like a question, is this a dystopia or is it kind of like a utopia? Because I feel like all good dystopias...
SPEAKER_02You never really know what they are. I was actually going to bring that up because people have said to me, oh, you know, it's a dystopian. I think some of the copy that's going around is that, you know, saying it's a dystopian novel. And I don't agree. And I didn't write it as a dystopia. And I don't like, you know, I've just counter signal, like I've just, you know, you know, made comments about. Everything I've commented about or whatever, and maybe that sounds like I'm railing against it. But actually, I wrote this book and this kind of universe because I found it quite exciting
SPEAKER_02and interesting. I mean, maybe not the idea of everyone being a fucking prostitute or whatever, but more like I liked the idea of, for example, the hyper-globalized element, like this Western Australia where everyone speaks Chinese. For me, I was kind of like, that's cool. That's great that we're sort of... The idea that, like, you know, we're a Western country, but we've actually, like, we're sort of a Western country that has sort of never existed before. Maybe, you know, this sort of kind of country has never existed.
SPEAKER_01It's extremely Faustian. It's an extremely Faustian. And in some ways, like, it's got that sort of, like, yeah, it's like, it feels like it's unchanged. You know what I mean? It's like they've unchained themselves from a number of things. And there is moments, like, you know, it's funny... So there's this thing called stud chat. It's where all the studs go. It's like Facebook for studs or something, right? And they go and share. And there was this moment towards the end where it was this stud who had aged a little bit.
SPEAKER_01He was talking about how he'd gotten a bit pudgy and kind of lost a bit of his hair. But he was talking about how he had taken his brood of 25 kids, which he had raised in this stud house. And it's like, actually, genuinely, like, a nice mo- like, I don't know if that's a weird reading, but I actually found it like a nice moment. I'm like, that's- it seemed like, you know, he was being sincere, and he was like, really proud that he had managed to have these 25 kids. But I actually do think that, again,
SPEAKER_01this goes to the complexity of this book in that it could very convincingly be read as a dystopia. Very convincingly. Even though, like, you know, you could usher in so much evidence, right, to suggest... In fact, dystopian. And yet I do see how someone could be like, no, this isn't dystopian. There are moments in this book where you're kind of like, this place seems kind of cool. And actually it's embracing like all these novel solutions to a very pressing problem.
SPEAKER_01And it does look, it is forward thinking. And yeah, like I've used the word Faustian way too many fucking times, but yeah. So, so I, and I think that that's always the mark though, of like good thinking, Good, in some sense, literature is that you do, like, that's what distinguishes it from propaganda, right? Propaganda is only interpreted in one way, whilst this book could be interpreted in radically different ways, depending on your own personal prejudices, you know what I mean?
SPEAKER_02Well, yeah, absolutely, and I, sorry, excuse me, I have a, I have a kind of, like, it's sort of a question for you, it's a comment and it's a question, but like, The thing about when I was writing the books, I wrote a draft of it and then I got some feedback actually from Quentin S. Crisp, who is a popular writer that people know. And some of the feedback that I got from him and from others was that The plot was a little light on drama.
SPEAKER_02The conflict was a bit too weak and a bit too... I think he said something like the conflict needed to come sooner, come harder, and be a bit more existential sort of thing. I'm paraphrasing. So I actually did read... When I initially wrote the story, I wanted it to end... Leaving the reader with a sense that, like, this arrangement could work. And what it ended up with is, like, a much more dramatic story where,
SPEAKER_02I mean, in theory, and I guess this is a question, like, right for you. And, like, you know, obviously, you know, the listeners haven't, don't know the story, whatever. But, like, do you think this arrangement could kind of work where, like, you know, these professional women who are, like, elite, high powered, they're the breadwinners or whatever. They're focused on their careers, but they want, you know, they want children. Yeah. They insource a man, they share a man who, like, you know, in other circumstances would not have been their, like, preferred choice of partner. But he's essentially, like, a stay-at-home dad who's on the payroll, who's not really on their level.
SPEAKER_02Like, he's not matched, you know, like, he has far less cultural capital. He's, you know, whatever. He's like a, you know, he's, yeah, he's... I want to... He's almost like a maid, essentially.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, like Luke is very much like, I think you described him as like a Labrador. He is there, like, you know, he's not negging the women, that's for sure. He's very much just doing... Doing whatever he says, whatever he thinks will please them. And like, he is there to please them. And if he doesn't please them, they let him know. And sometimes they bring up the terms of contract, you know, when they're unhappy, you know what I mean? So I actually have thought about this.
SPEAKER_01That's the thing is I've actually thought about this exact topic. I could see right where... Because this is very much based in reality. We know now. I've heard people say this. I haven't fact-checked it myself. But apparently among Zoomers, women are out-earning men, right?
SPEAKER_02Yes, I think that's true.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so women are out-earning men. And God, this is all very passe red pill stuff. But it is true, right, that women are hypergamous. They do want to marry men who are a higher station than them for the reason being that sperm is cheap. And eggs are not. Okay. And the women has to like, like, you know, you can go around impregnating all these women. It's like, she needs to carry that baby for nine months. She needs to be more discerning in her choices. Right. So you have this, I think hypergamy is just a fact.
SPEAKER_01Right. Um, Okay, so you have women, they're hypergamous, they want to marry men who earn more than them, and yet, like, now, the norm is that men earn less than them, right? And men are dropping out, right? Like, it is a phenomenon, men are dropping out of society. So what do you do about that? It's clear that maybe some of the bourgeois norms that we have around marriage, which is that you basically have a looks matched, income matched, education matched pair. You know what I mean? That's the norm.
SPEAKER_01A lot of those ideals are probably going to go by the wayside. And I do think the stud is the right framing because, you know, you can say Luke is, for example, not that educated. He's a nice guy, but you get the impression that this is a kind of virile dude in other ways, right? Like he's physically fit. He lifts weights. And like, I don't want to get into my personal life, but let's just say I know guys who sort of fit this description, right? Where they don't, They're kind of like wild guys,
SPEAKER_01extremely charismatic, healthy, fit, virile, but, you know, institutionally have had zero, not much success, right? And these guys will get with women who are like professionals, right? This does happen, right? That a lot of the time, like these guys who are, it's weird. You do see that this, it's like the middle guy never gets the top girl, but sometimes the guy at the very bottom Can in a roundabout way get these really attractive women.
SPEAKER_01And then it's like, could we actually enter into an arrangement where it's like, Hey, you seem, even though you haven't really got your shit together in other ways, you do seem like a good genetic prospect, right? It's almost like they're being valued more for their genes than anything else. You know what I mean? And, um, I actually could see that happening where it's like all of a sudden like yeah you do see the sort of like powerful professional women pairing up with like younger virile guys
SPEAKER_01who maybe just like you know they're a bit like fuck boys or whatever and yeah I think it's absolutely conceivable and in regards to what you were saying on the feedback it's funny because I'm not like a very good, I feel like I would be terrible at giving feedback because generally speaking, if I like something, I really like it. And if I don't, I don't. And it's not like, oh, I liked it, but here's how it could be better. It's like, I thought, I found it gripping from the start. I was very... Absorbed in the world, I think.
SPEAKER_01And I think that that's what you did at the start. Like the first part of the book is definitely slower than the second, but it's because you are building this world. And I would say that this is a question for you. I would consider your best asset as a writer, your world building. And that's probably like, do you agree with that? Because I feel like you've created this convincing world and that's perhaps why I, unlike other reviewers, really enjoyed the start because I think that that world building was so engrossing.
SPEAKER_02Oh, well, thank you. I mean, so I love world building and the world of the start is extremely detailed and is very gestated. And I have this cast of characters. We talked about Yorkie before. We talked about the Cum King or whatever. These are all these kind of colorful characters in this universe. Yeah. And there's a lot of like, you know, in, in, in universe institutions and stuff, you know, which, yeah, exactly. The euthanasia Institute, you know,
SPEAKER_02ridiculous, you know,
SPEAKER_01it's like Rebecca was speaking at the euthanasia Institute about, like, it's like, she's doing like a female empowerment. It's like, what the fuck?
SPEAKER_02But you know what's so funny? I mean, when you're writing a book, it takes a year at least to write a novel. And so it's like, I'm just sitting at my house completely alone, writing this, being like, I'm having so much fun on my own. But anyway, coming back to your question. To your point, the thing about, you know, world building is that I think my major flaw as a writer has been like, I've often written stories which are sort of pure premise and have no, like, and when I think about this, like,
SPEAKER_02I really love Borges, like, he's one of my favourite writers and he could be guilty of writing stories which are composed of pure premise, just like exploring, like taking an idea, exploring it in great detail and the reader is like dazzled by it, but You know, some readers actually want plot. And I think that I am weak on plot.
SPEAKER_01Is that actually a weakness though? Because here's what I've come to realize, right? You can't have the rose without the thorns. It's like people have this idea that you could just be good on every account. And it's like, I actually think For example, I've noticed in books, very good stylists tend to be very bad at plot, right? If you are a really good stylist, they tend to just get high on their own supply and it's like, nothing is fucking happening. And they're just like playing with words. And it's like,
SPEAKER_01I feel like it's the same with like, sometimes the strength of It's almost like the weakness is going to be built in. It's not even a weakness. It's just doing something else. You know what I mean? So actually for me, the funny thing is I think that I love premises and I actually think that fiction is an amazing avenue for exploring premises, right? And this probably comes from the fact that I'm... You know, I'm not, like, into, like, what is it, like, the literary pyrotechnic stuff.
SPEAKER_01Like, I like, I like to, I kind of like fiction that explores premises and ideas and things like that, which is probably why I love The Suds so much. Like, an example of, like, a book that I hated is, like, that, that, um, Against Nature or... Oh,
SPEAKER_02yeah, yeah. Avra Boar by Wiseman. Yeah, yeah. You didn't like it? I haven't read it, so...
SPEAKER_01I hated that book. I hated that book, right? Like that to me is, and like, that is obviously a widely regarded book, but I hate that book, right? And that's because it's like, there isn't any plot. It's just descriptions of things, you know, like these detailed descriptions of the room. And I'm like, I just can't deal with that. You know what I mean? Like, I don't, I just don't find that interesting. Like some of my favorite books are, like, you know, it's very cliche, whatever, but I do love people like Huxley. You know what I mean?
SPEAKER_02Right, right.
SPEAKER_01Like, you know, and I would say Huxley does that. Or even, you know, someone like Orwell where it's like the characters are like very two-dimensional in a way. Like you read all these.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01I actually reread 1984 recently and I'm like, wow. I did not enjoy that because the characters are so just two-dimensional, but that's something that, you know, Rand, Huxley, Orwell, they all do like the- Characters are like a stand-in for an idea and there's dimensionality to them. But the point is that I like Atlas Shrugged. I like books where it's more about a premise. And I think that people have this idea where it's like,
SPEAKER_01oh, well, that's not actually literature. And it's like, well, yeah, it is. It's just a different type. You know what I mean?
SPEAKER_02Sure, sure. Well, I mean, actually, you know, before I was, we were talking about Welbeck and like, you know, that he's a big influence, but actually probably the most foundational influence for me as a writer is William Gibson, which I always feel embarrassed about because it's like my teenage fixation or whatever. But like two of the most important novels I ever read in my teen years were Neuromancer and Pattern Recognition. Have you read them?
SPEAKER_01No, I haven't. I should.
SPEAKER_02Oh, I mean, Neuromancer is amazing. Neuromancer, I mean, it did come out the same year as Blade Runner, but people always say it invented cyberpunk. And I'm kind of like, well, if it came out the same year as Blade Runner, it kind of, but it did like, it was hugely influential for the cyberpunk genre. But then pattern recognition is like my personal favorite because it's sci-fi, but it's like, it's sci-fi sort of in the, Contemporary world. And I feel like the type of speculative fiction that is pattern recognition is
SPEAKER_02the same sort of speculative fiction that is submission by Welbeck or platform by Welbeck and the stud, which is kind of like, it's almost like an uncanny, it's a fantasia of art. It really does feel totally familiar to anyone, particularly probably in Australia, but like I said, that is its strength. It's noticing
SPEAKER_01Trends. And I think that's an amazing, that's what all, I know it's not dystopian, but I'm saying that that's what I think all good speculative fiction needs to do is identify a trend and then think about what would be the logical conclusion of this thinking, right? Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Like, yeah, it will be, because you read so many books where it's like, the year was 2000, you know, it's written in
SPEAKER_02the 90s.
SPEAKER_01And it's like so off the mark.
SPEAKER_02And where we've colonized Mars or something like, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Well, I actually feel like the stud is, I would not be surprised if some of these sort of arrangements did exist.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Well, I mean, like, so just coming back to the point that you raised before about like hypergamy and like, not to, not to open up like a, you know, red pill or like gender slot debate or whatever about that sort of thing. But like, I think in the stud and this, this, I feel like is a kind of like a tension and maybe it's like something I've not resolved, but like Martina and maybe the other women. Sort of feel a disappointment actually that they haven't found like a traditional husband. And, you know, there's a scene where like Martina attends the wedding of one of her friends, you know, where she has...
SPEAKER_02You know, her friend has found a husband and I think Martina is like essentially jealous. And I think the stud house for them is this like grand compromise where they're like, well, you know, we had these dreams of motherhood and family and, you know, we couldn't achieve them. We wanted to zig, but we had to zag sort of thing. So we're in the stud house and we're making do sort of, you know, and there is drama and, you know.
SPEAKER_01Eloise especially is kind of always like very bluntly pointing out how like Luke is not her first choice of man. You know what I mean?
SPEAKER_02I know. But you know, I also, I think that Eloise is, she's completely locked in, in terms of like, I think that she's, she has the least, like, what's the term? I know. But that's because Eloise is like, in my opinion, like Eloise of all of them is like the most...
SPEAKER_01How to put it. Like you think about Sophia, like Sophia is like playful and like, you know what I mean? She's playful and she like can banter with other people whilst Eloise is like the most girl boss in a way. But then she's a particular type of girl boss in that like, she's the like, Very procedural. It's like they're all type A, but she's like the most type A. And you could tell like, you know, she really flourishes as all type A people do. They flourish within sort of confines and contractual obligations and things like that.
SPEAKER_01And I think in part, that's why maybe she's the best fit for... I mean, in theory, and this might, this might kind of,
SPEAKER_02Sound like a misogynist comment or something, but like in theory, a woman like Eloise, like even today, like not in the universe of the stud, might have a relationship with her boyfriend, which is something like Luke, where he's kind of like under her thumb and she's kind of calling the shots a bit, you know, happy wife, happy life sort of style of relationship. Yeah, yeah,
SPEAKER_00yeah, exactly.
SPEAKER_02But actually, with the hypergamy point, I think the reality is the story of the 21st century is that females are in the ascendant. I'm not an anti-feminist. I probably consider myself a liberal feminist, actually, to be honest. I'm not a perfect avatar of any position, but I think that more and more that sort of woman, that sort of white-collar professional woman might have to In regards to this point,
SPEAKER_02right, like I've made it before, the point
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Think about an industrial economy. That is so advantageous to men, right?
SPEAKER_01Men are shape rotators. Men are going to be better. They're more physical. They're going to be better at building things, right? Like cars. But actually, generally speaking, you think about the sort of... Absolutely. Absolutely. Absolutely. Absolutely.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I mean, barring some sort of radical change in the economic landscape, it is going to continue. Women are going to continually become more economically ascendant. Yeah. And that means like, yeah, maybe they do need to start thinking about alternative things. The sad thing is that the sexual strategies that work for men don't work for women. If you are a man and you attain accrued wealth and power and all of these things,
SPEAKER_01it greatly increases your dating pool. For women, it shrinks it. I actually think there is something to be said for this probably... This ascendancy in a roundabout way is not good for women and their happiness in a sense because it makes, at least romantically, it makes dating a lot harder.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. I mean, do you, so like, this is a really, this is kind of like above both of our pay grades, but like, you know, the reality is that birth rates are falling, like they're in free fall across the developed world, like. Do you think that post-industrial society is sterilizing? You know, people always say like, oh, modernity is a sterility meme. And I mean, I, from my perspective, like I've always worked in a white collar environment. I've worked with a lot of people who want relationships and children,
SPEAKER_02but who find that they cannot because they're overworked or they're Too busy and have no sex drive on SSRIs. Locked in, essentially. Essentially too focused on their career, basically. And sometimes I'm like, maybe we have... And I'm talking about men and women, not one or the other. Obviously, women face other biological barriers and stuff. If you're pushing 40, you've got to make something happen quickly or whatever.
SPEAKER_02But I think that the whole... I think the industry or the whole economy that we've set up for young people could be contributing to sterility on a mass scale. Maybe it's not insightful. Maybe everyone knows this, but what do we do about this?
SPEAKER_01I actually feel like so often a metaphor can be so insightful, because you're right, people will say, oh, it's a sterile work environment, right? And in that, it's like most people, what they mean by that is, you know, whatever, but quite literally. It's a sterile work environment. Corporate law is a sterile work environment. Medicine is a sterile work environment. These people are sterile. So it does seem to be the case that...
SPEAKER_01And people, again, there's these... Because the right has these comforting beliefs, right? Which is that, again, it's feminism. It's like, well, go look at Iran. Iran is not a feminist country... They have a low birth rate. You know, people think it's about religion. It's like, well, religious countries have a low birth rate. It does seem to be something about modernity itself. I've also heard quite, this is relevant to the book, right? I've heard other explanations like this guy, oh, I'm having Johan Kurtz.
SPEAKER_01I don't know if you've seen him. Oh, yeah. But he wrote something called It's Embarrassing to Be a Stay-at-Home Mom. And his contention, right, was that basically the fertility crisis could be explained by status, which was an interesting explanation. Basically, he was like, it's now low status to have kids for women, right? And status, in a roundabout way, it's so weird that status is ultimately a means to an end, right? Like, why do you want status from an evolutionary perspective?
SPEAKER_01It's to have children, right? Right. Being high status means more kids, but it's kind of weird that it's kind of like subverting itself or eating its own tail where it's like, yeah, it's a maladaption. Yeah, it's maladaptive where it's like, it's clear that being a lawyer is high status, but the reason that we're kind of wired to want that status, it actually counteracts. So, yeah. And also another thing is you think about men's relative status compared with women. Again, go back to the book. Think about a guy like Dom especially.
SPEAKER_01I mean... He's very low status in, you know, besides his, like, hide and looks, he's a low status dude, you know what I mean?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, yeah. I mean, actually, so I don't know the... Oh, actually, I think I have... I might have read that essay you mentioned. Like, it's embarrassing to have kids, that one, but there was another one on a similar theme, and... The writer, I don't know what her name, it was a female writer, I don't know what her name is because it's in Greek, like it's in Greek letters. But it was like a really popular essay and it was something like, it was about the maiden, mother, matriarch archetypes and how our society has...
SPEAKER_02The maiden has focused too much on the maiden archetype and that where there's too many perpetual maidens and that the mother archetype has been devalued and is now low status. And she observes how modern mothers, even mothers of our generation or even younger mothers, if they have children, what they'll still say to their daughters, you need to have a career. Think about kids later. Like, don't worry about that. Like, you'll get to that, you know, because I think the high status thing for a young woman to do is to study career,
SPEAKER_02you know, focus on herself. Don't worry. A man is not a plan. Stand on your own two feet sort of thing. Like, that's the high status script. Even if these mothers who are telling, you know, passing the script to their daughters are like, actually, I did sacrifice my career to have you and I am happy. I'm happy as a result of having done that. But, What was the point I was going to make? Oh yeah, with hypergamy, we might have to de-script this as an idea. Like we might have to, or like we might have to,
SPEAKER_02Like it might be the boy toyification of like male, female relations.
SPEAKER_01That's happening already. That is what you can see like looks maxing. What is that? It's the boy toyification of men, right? Which is that because men's economic status is decreasing, right? Like you think about women, women traditionally have attained status through their looks and pretty much... They're looks alone, and also their virtue. So their virtue and their looks, they're the two sort of status domains. And now they compete with men and out-compete men economically.
SPEAKER_01So what that means, I think, is that men are going, are starting to embrace these sort of traditionally feminine status hierarchies, which are looks, right? So that's what looks maxing is. Looks maxing is the boy toyification of men. And it's inextricably tied It's inextricably tied to the media. We're not meant to see ourselves this much. You know what I mean? The mirrors, the cameras, it does breed a sort of unchained narcissism in everyone.
SPEAKER_01But I also do think the looks maxing is a response to the decline in male status. And what we were talking about, basically what we're saying is that in light of the fact that men now don't have as much economic status, Increasingly, maybe what women will just go for is maybe like genetic
SPEAKER_02potential,
SPEAKER_01i.e. their looks. So that's probably why there's this great emphasis on looks now. I think it is tied to that.
SPEAKER_02Maybe it's the rise of the female gaze, like we're going to have the female gaze. But what's interesting is that like, you know, we sort of in our society at the moment, like if a senior high status male has like a young girlfriend, you know, like a kind of, you know, imagine like a sort of middle-aged, you know, bloke kind of who has like a... A young girlfriend, you know, and everyone kind of cringes at this a bit because they're like, oh, you know, God, she's only interested in him for his, you know, money status or whatever. And of course, you know, maybe that's true.
SPEAKER_02He has something to offer her. She has something to offer him.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02You know, we, we cringe at it and we haven't so far had a mainstream gender swap version of that. Um, maybe we will, like maybe.
SPEAKER_01That is, that is the start. The start is. Yeah. And, and, and basically again, going back to, um, This is actually conceivable, right? That we would have, we'll start to see a gender swap where suddenly like the hunky spunky man is with like the 40 year old girl.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, the hag. Well, sorry to all the girl bosses out there for using that term, but actually in that essay, and I'll send the link to you later because it's really good. The one with the Greek. She talks about Mamma Mia. She talks about Meryl Streep in Mamma Mia and how like Mamma Mia. So like Meryl Streep is this kind of like aging lioness who is just like, you know, fucks a succession of boy toys in Italy or whatever. And how that's meant to, that's like seen as aspirational or whatever. Maybe we're going to have like a Mamma Miafication of culture where, yeah.
SPEAKER_02But actually I just want to like, while the point's in my head. So we were talking about the birth rates before. One country's birth rate is very interesting and I have found it a little bit somewhat inspirational, which is Israel. Because I believe that Israel is, I think it's the only developed country which has an above replacement birth rate.
SPEAKER_01Three, I think it's got, they're having like three kids. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. And the explanations I've heard for that, like it's, you know, obviously Israel has a, is a, well, it's all of, it's hard to speak. Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So basically like status hierarchies can just change overnight. Right. And, and the person who is low status can become high status in a different ecology. Like right now, a lot of guys are in MMA gyms. They're not high status. They, they just want to fight people, but they don't really have an outlet. So they need to do this surrogate activity. But a lot of those guys, if they existed in a military state at war, you know what I mean? They would all of a sudden be like the guys. And I'm saying like Israel is sort of in a perpetual state of war, more or less.
SPEAKER_01You know, even when they're at peace, they're getting bombed. So that is very conducive to like, it's very much a male status hierarchy.
SPEAKER_02This is such a good idea. And actually, so that's not the... Explanation I heard, but imagine maybe what we need to do in Western countries to boost the birth rate is we need to have some sort of perpetual war to mobilize and revitalize the leftover men who can then have a high status boost from participation in the military. But I don't know what war we're going to have.
SPEAKER_01Imagine the birth process. West Australia's new and innovative birth program to boost the birth rate colonizing Africa.
SPEAKER_02Oh my God. Well, did you know, like, well, I've got, I've got, I'm all over the place, but what I'm imagining is that like, what if we had like, cause you know, so many incels, whatever, like video gamers, what if we had like an Enders game style war room where we had all the incels, you know, fighting some sort of like drone war or whatever. Yeah. I still think that that's kind of low status though. Like I feel like it would work.
SPEAKER_01Well, that's the problem is that warfare actually, unfortunately going back to the technological thing is that warfare actually now is not a really heroic masculine outlet because it's becoming so mechanized and really like the technician is still sort of supreme. Well, increasingly it's like the supreme quote unquote warrior. But I actually wanted to quickly, something just is in my head, Because one of the things that I think I said it in the group chat is like the reason the novel I think will never...
SPEAKER_01Why it will always be a relative medium is because it's the best tool for exploring new psychological types or archetypes. So obviously an archetype is constant. They're eternal. They've always existed. But the way that archetype expresses itself within any given time will change. You know what I mean? It'll be unique and different. So I think that we have, I don't know what the archetype of the, what the girl boss archetype is.
SPEAKER_01Maybe it is the shrew. I don't know. But I was going to say that I do think, I actually don't know if that's correct, honestly, but I was going to say like this book, The Stud is the best psychological exploration of the girl boss. And again, what makes it good is it's not didactic or ham-fisted. I can tell that you are sympathetic to these women, probably because you encounter them in your work life. I can tell that you like girlbosses, but you... You also clearly identify some of their failure modes, right?
SPEAKER_01So yeah, maybe I thought we could just talk about like, yeah, the girl boss. Cause like I said, you do such a good job of exploring this psychological type. What are her features? What are her characteristics? Do we have sort of on the spot taxonomy?
SPEAKER_02Okay. Well, so I remember, so before I remember you mentioned like, okay, uh, DEI, has the girl boss been parachuted into place by DEI? And the answer is no. Actually, there is no competency crisis among girl bosses. Girl bosses are competent. Female lawyers, senior females in all industries in the world, these are the most effective people in their fields. These are extremely high performance, elite people who deserve to be there.
SPEAKER_02So it's like, I'm not I'm not like an anti-feminist. I'm not like a chauvinist. Although, you know, I have many haters who claim otherwise, but like I'm not a misogynist. Like these women deserve to be that. These women deserve their success. So the girl boss is not a fraud or a charlatan. The girl boss is, you know, a... Probably like, you know, maybe a gifted child. The girl's boss is probably a narcissist and is fixated on her own image.
SPEAKER_01Hermione Granger is kind of like that.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. Oh, I mean, incredible. One of the premier girl bosses of all time, you know. And, you know, like, how do we feel about Hermione? Like, you know, she's a hero. Like, everyone thought she was a fucking bitch initially. But, like, you know, she became... The friend of, you know, Harry and Ron or whatever, but like, Hermione's a girlboss, you know. And yeah, these people are, one of my favourite girlbosses in culture is Ripley from Alien,
SPEAKER_02played by Sigourney Weaver. And I remember in the first Alien, which is one of my favourite movies, the Ridley Scott original Alien. The, um, you know, they go off onto the planet and they get infected by the, you know, the egg breaks, whatever blows into the face of, uh, not William Hurt, John Hurt. Anyway, he gets infected and then they come back to the ship and then Ripley is like, I can't let you guys in. You have to stay in quarantine now. Like you have to stay in containment. Um, And they're all like, whatever, like,
SPEAKER_02let us in, you know, you're being a bitch, like, forget about the rules, you know, and she's like, no, like, I'm sorry, but we can't, we can't let you in, you know, like, you've been compromised, whatever. And they over, so what's his name overrides Ash, the Ian Holm, who is the robot, the secret cyborg. And of course, you know, everyone's then like, you're a fucking bitch Ripley, like you should have let us in. Of course, she was completely right and they all died as a result of, you know, the alien invasion. So she was, you know, girl boss,
SPEAKER_02knew what was right, was ready to take a hit for, you know, her reputation.
SPEAKER_01It's outlier conscientiousness. Like they have like the high, like a true girl boss will have like Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. You need authoritarian people, you need high conscientious people, you need people who follow and enforce rules.
SPEAKER_02That's right.
SPEAKER_01But, you know, there is always going to be... But that is also a failure mode, though, because especially if the rules are unjust or bullshit, you know what I mean?
SPEAKER_02That's right. I mean, another... The thing that is worth talking about is like the Karen archetypes. Obviously, like in the pandemic, you know, everyone was making fun of Karens and, you know, Karens are easy to make fun of, you know, like, you know, the typical, obviously we were doing race discourse at the time of Karen. So it was like, you know, they're white women who are entitled and, you know, can I speak to the manager, you know, sort of thing. But in a functioning society, that sort of woman who demands a level of service and who demands standards from, you know,
SPEAKER_02the community she's in or whatever, we need this person to actually hold it all together. Otherwise, we'll degenerate into total squalor, you know, not just with, you know, she's not the only bulwark against degeneration, but she's an important one, you know, like maybe we need to, you know, Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So you can kind of see, and these people would claim to admire the Puritans, you know what I mean? So yeah, I think that the thing that is kind of annoying, another feature seems to be this necessity to be seen as good. Especially in Eloise, that she's the character it is the most pronounced in. But the reason it can be annoying, right, is because they're so absorbed in this, like, desire to be seen as good,
SPEAKER_01like Eloise, that even when she is doing something that's actually very selfish, it's always framed in a way that's, like, selfless. You know what I mean? Like, so even, I'm thinking, like, the girls, actually all of them do this, Sophia, they all do it, like, It's never like I'm putting myself first and I'm putting my kids second. It's always like the patriarchy, just, you know what I mean? There's always an excuse. And I mean, I can't, there's something I really want to talk about, but I feel like it's a spoiler.
SPEAKER_01So I can't talk about it.
SPEAKER_02How big a spoiler? Yeah.
SPEAKER_01It's basically, it's about Sophia. Well, I'll leave it up to you. Tell me if we can do this. If you'd rather not, I'll just, I can cut it out.
SPEAKER_02I reckon don't. I reckon, like, let's not.
SPEAKER_01Such a good example of what we're talking about. Oh, go ahead.
SPEAKER_02You know what? Go ahead.
SPEAKER_01Go ahead. No, no, no, no. I'll delete. What I'll do is I'll say it. And if you think about it, I'll delete it from the conversation.
SPEAKER_00I can't do this.
SPEAKER_01I'll delete that from the conversation or I'll beep it out. But like, that is such a prime example where it's like, Oh, I don't know. Like, I mean, she, yeah, that, that actually, you know what, that was the most moving scene for me. And it actually was, it really got me thinking because obviously I have young kids and I was just thinking like, if that happened to me, you know what I mean? I know. That, that moment. And that happens every fucking day that is happening to people. You know what I mean?
SPEAKER_02Yeah. I mean, there's another example. Again, I won't spoil it, but there's an example where Inez does something and then, you know, she does something which upsets Luke and Luke is upset. And she says, it's not about you, Luke. It's not about you. I think the thing about the study is that, again, these women insist to each other and to Luke that their relationship is professional. They've got a contract. He's their employee. Of course, the reality about human relationships is that if you have a baby with someone, actually, your relationship is no longer just professional.
SPEAKER_02Again, I don't want to do a crypto-Christian thing about surrogacy, but at the moment, there's a story about a couple, I believe they're Australian. They've asked their surrogate to abort the child. They've changed the mind and they've asked the surrogate to abort the child. Now I have this instinctive reaction against that. Why? Like in theory, okay, the surrogate offered up their womb as a commercial service.
SPEAKER_02The service is no longer needed. Why don't they just abort the child? The commercial terms and commercial circumstances have changed. There's something about having a child, there's something that makes us think there's more to this than just, you know, and I think maybe, yeah, just coming back to the stud, like, you know, the relationship between these people is not merely that of employer and employee. They wish it would be so simple.
SPEAKER_02And sadly, it cannot be so simple.
SPEAKER_01What I'll do is I'll bleep that out. I actually feel like I'll bleep out what I said and then it'll create a sense of suspense. Okay. Actually, it will make people more interested. Anyway, I've got to go soon, so I wanted to ask you some more quickfire questions. Okay. The first one, is the stud Straussian? Oh.
SPEAKER_02Okay. I don't think so because I don't think I have a hidden moral platform. Again, I'm not a pundit. I'm not a take merchant. Again, like I've said this a few times, I'm a very imperfect liberal. If you said I was right-wing, I would be a very imperfect right-wing person. I don't really have a political platform. I just wrote, I wrote a book.
SPEAKER_02You know what I mean?
SPEAKER_01Well, that's also why, that's also why I think that part of the reason it is so good is you can just tell that you're actually not sure on any of those things, but you can tell they're important questions. You've got to, I can tell you have a lot of questions, but you don't have many answers. You know what I mean? Like, because it starts with big questions. All right. Next one. What is a straggot? Okay.
SPEAKER_02Okay. A straggot is a straight man who acts a little bit gay, a little bit faggy for female attention. And sometimes for the attention of like a gay or a queer audience, but mainly and primarily for female attention. Iconic examples include Harry Styles, who wears a dress all the time. You know, whenever you're in Nam, Melbourne, you see straggots in abundance. Everywhere. Yeah. Men with, you know, Earrings and painted nails and that sort of thing, you know.
SPEAKER_01The straggot has gotten, I've got an earring in, anyway.
SPEAKER_02Okay, yeah, the straggot has entered the chat. Straggots are, you know, a contested controversial category, but, you know, there was performative male discourse this year or last. I think the performative male and the straggot, there's a Venn diagram there because it's performative behavior.
SPEAKER_01All right, last question is, when is the stud out?
SPEAKER_02The start is out in late November. It's coming out with Verjuran, or Verjuran, as we anglicize, say, in Australia, which is a publisher in London, headed up by Pierre, Dallin Cezay, and Nina Power, and Travis Jefferson, and Amir Naaman. Coming out in November. I'll show you the link. Maybe you could put the link in the show notes.
SPEAKER_01Is pre-order available already, or no?
SPEAKER_02Oh, yeah, yeah. It's available.
SPEAKER_01Okay, cool. So I was going to, I don't know when I should release this. I mean, I can talk to you about this afterwards, but I was thinking, does it make more sense for me to release this closer to the date? What do you think?
SPEAKER_02I think, oh, good question. I'm not sure. I think you can release it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Right away. I mean, if we've got a pre-order link, then we can see if we can get some pre-orders going. That would be good.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, there is a pre-order link.
SPEAKER_01I want to show the book. I want to show the book and the last thing. Everyone is talking about the state of cultural decline, particularly in literature. Like Liam is my friend, right? But I'm saying this sincerely. This was a fantastic book. I could not put this down. Liam is actually my favorite Australian author. This is my favorite Australian book. And it's just all around a great book. If you are listening, it's one of those things. It's so easy to listen to this and go, oh, yeah, cool.
SPEAKER_01That sounds good. Yeah, maybe I'll order that and then not do it. It's like, no, hit the link. It will take you 10 minutes. Like this will be listened to by, you know, it'll be listened to by a few thousand people, right? Five thousand people, something like that. Hit the link, spend the $15, $20, $30, whatever it is, right? For you, that is nothing. It's easy to do. For Liam, if enough of you do that, it is huge, right? Because let's say like even 100, 200, 300 people do that.
SPEAKER_01That is huge for him. You know what I mean? And it's not about him. It's just a good book, but do it, right? So yeah, cool.
SPEAKER_02Thanks, Russell. That's awesome.
SPEAKER_01That is my exhortation. I'm a huge stud fan. Put me in the stud house.
SPEAKER_02We just love Zizek. Zizek is signing himself up too.
SPEAKER_01Can we talk about that now? Yeah, Zizek, he's on the blog as well. He read this book. He loved it. So, yes, absolutely. Yeah, thanks, Liam. Cheers.
In this episode of the Chudstack Review, Drunk Wisconsin and I discuss: * What is the “state school upper middle class,” and why does nobody talk about them? * Are many online voices downwardly mobile elites? * Why...
Gildhelm and I discuss: * Is Christianity a revolt against nature? * Why did the German Romantics turn to nature and the Greeks? * Why did the romantic movement start in Germany? * What does the word “persona” really...
Owen Yingling and I discuss: * Have Zoomers been Zombified? * Is it alienating being a highly literate Zoomer? * Why do so many university students care more about credentials than learning? * What is a university...
Dan Baltic and I discuss: * How political should an author be? * Is Nutcrankr actually a right-wing book? * How much does Nutcrankr owe to A Confederacy of Dunces and Don Quixote? * How autobiographical is Spencer? *...
In this episode of the Chudstack Review, John and I discuss: * Why do young people struggle to plan for or invest in the future right now? * How much of generational conflict is really the boomers’ fault versus just...