Gildhelm and I discuss: * Is Christianity a revolt against nature? * Why did the German Romantics turn to nature and the Greeks? * Why did the romantic movement start in Germany? * What does the word “persona” really mean? * The German origins of the hippy movement. * What was the Wandervogel youth movement? * Did German Romanticism lead to National Socialism? * Can worship of nature lead you to dark places? * Could a Wandervogel revival ever happen today? This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit russellwalter.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_02Alright, I'm joined today by Guildhelm, who has a very interesting substack. It's called the Wandervogel substack. And he's been putting out these extremely high quality radio casts. I just listened to one yesterday on romantic paganism. And I was actually thinking this morning, or after I listened to it, I kind of felt like it's very easy to get down on the internet in general and kind of just think it's a curse for mankind. But then occasionally you come across a piece of Content or you find something,
SPEAKER_02you kind of think, wow, like the internet is fucking awesome. Like that, that's what I was thinking after listening to your radio cast on romantic paganism.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, man, I appreciate it. Glad you enjoyed it. I have to remind you, have to be careful with how you pronounce von der Vogel. You have to pronounce it subtly wrong every single time. I have a few Germans who like listening to my stuff and I cover... Germany a lot. And every single time you could find in the comments on every single one of those radio casts, they politely saying, hey, stop speaking German words. It's irritating me. Sorry, I'm going to keep doing it.
SPEAKER_02Well, you just like, this is what I've said, because I say Puglia. They're like, the G is silent. And it's like, well, guess what? We fucking won World War II, so I can pronounce it however the fuck I You know what I mean? Like, I'm going to say Wanda Vogel. I'm going to pronounce these words however the fuck I want because English is the lingua franca of the world. Get used to it, buddy. But yeah, I'm so bad for all French pronunciations. Like German, I'm constantly butchering it. But I've just lent in at this point.
SPEAKER_02You just embrace it, I think. Absolutely. Yeah. Um, I was going to ask you, right. So I, I mean, I actually, maybe I'll try and describe your content and you tell me if you feel like this is an accurate, um, accurate description, right? So you, you, you definitely interested in religion, interested in paganism, but then interested in things like neoclassicism and romanticism, um, Nietzsche, Ludwig Clargus. Um, yeah. Is this, is this a fair characterization of your work?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's totally right on it. The thing that I find interesting about that whole time period with German Romanticism, Neoclassism, and so on, it It really seems to repeat the same types of categories of thought that we have today. So you've got your Reddit atheists, you've got your strict Bible-thumping Lutherans, and then you've got a weird sort of resurgent part of the population
SPEAKER_01that is infatuated with the Greeks and the ancient religions and so on, and they're trying to redo their whole thing. And I mean, It really just seems kind of like a recapitulation of the things that we see today with religion. All of that is very much evident in the romantics and that whole time period. And as interesting as it is, how quickly it comes is how quickly it seems to vanish off the face of the earth.
SPEAKER_01And then it's sad as crow from there on out. But.
SPEAKER_02How did you get interested in paganism? Did you come to it through Nietzsche? I feel like that's the most typical route for most people.
SPEAKER_01Yes. So my background was going through college and whatnot. I was actually evolution. So it's a weird trajectory. I got criticized the other day for... Somebody was very confused about how it could be pagan while talking about evolution going back and forth in the articles and the radio cast too. The way that I got to paganism through that was the
SPEAKER_01problems that I had growing up. I was raised Christian, Baptist. The problems that I had was I couldn't link it to... Anything organic. I mean, it's very clearly it says itself that it's a sort of revolt against nature. It comes at its own specific point in history and it starts at that point and then it goes about going towards the end. So when you're trying to think of concepts of something like,
SPEAKER_01you know, man in the state of nature and things of like things like that, You have to go much further back in time. It's hard to, I mean, you can learn as much as you need to about the Old Testament and the influence that the Greeks had on that and so on and so forth. But you're still only at about 500 or 300 BC or so, and that's the farthest you can get back. So you're left wondering, okay, well, what was everything else that came before?
SPEAKER_01And not even with just the Greeks, but I mean, you're talking going back even further and further, 5,000 BC, 10,000, 20,000. You keep trying to kick it back as far and far as you can, trying to understand what is the original and default religious expression of mankind. And that is the sort of project that I'm trying to lean into. So I have to use a wide variety of different things to try and answer that question. Evolution is one of them.
SPEAKER_01Different types of ancient texts and so on. It's all part of it.
SPEAKER_02It's so interesting, right? Because I was thinking about even this word religion. People have pointed this out before, where it just does mean radically different things to different people, right? So for a lot of people, religion is really just almost a synonym for law, right? And then for other people, it means something radically... What does religion mean to an Aboriginal Australian? What is religious experience? It's clearly very, very different to what we mean by it today, right?
SPEAKER_02Because we can see even now, what does religion mean to a Hindu versus a Christian? There's pronounced differences there. But then when you start to, like you're doing, you're literally trying to reconstruct or work out what was religion like For primitive man, it's extremely difficult and you're having to go off like not a great deal of evidence. Like, you know, often it's like, you know, these kind of anthropological records. Yeah. So your pieces, I said to you yesterday.
SPEAKER_02They're extremely interesting. They're extremely deep, right? Like you can tell reading them, this is someone who has thought, like you're not a popularizer, like you're dealing with the text like in that thing. And it is complicated. It's an extremely complicated question, but it's obviously one that fascinates you.
SPEAKER_01Yes. Yeah, it's very difficult. Yeah. I do have people that I read that have tried to make that type of effort before, like Kalagas and Bakof are two that come to mind. Nietzsche, to some extent, talking birth of tragedy, Nietzsche. But for the most part, what you see today with pagans is they're very comfortable with just saying, going back to the Norse, Germanics, Greeks, any of the The Indo-European populations. That's the big popularized conception of paganism now is just going back to
SPEAKER_01the Indo-Europeans on the Pontic step. We want to be based invaders and pillage through all that kind of fun stuff that people like to talk about. But something that I notice a lot when I read a lot of these different texts and Engaging in the evolutionary argument to some extent is even when you look at the Greeks in very old texts, you'll notice constantly they're talking about,
SPEAKER_01they'll drop little hints of the religion that came before them. So the other day I was reading Aeschylus' tragedy, Agamemnon, the first of the Oresteia trilogy. And at the beginning when the chorus first comes onto the stage, They're talking about Agamemnon's sacrifice of Iphigenia to Artemis before the Siege of Troy. And the chorus members are trying to give this prayer to Artemis
SPEAKER_01and they say they're overcome with darkness and they have to stop the prayer and start praying to Apollo instead to get them away from that old Dark religion that came before them and they go on and begin a prayer to Zeus and it repeats it. Thank goodness for Zeus saving us from that barbarous old time. And even later in that tragedy,
SPEAKER_01the humanities where they're instituting the Orestes essentially is being chased by these spirits of the earth, the Furies. It's supposed to be almost like a psychological fact of self-torment for killing his own mother. And basically the way the story goes is Athena overrules them and says they can no longer...
SPEAKER_01Chase after Orestes. He's been purified. He no longer has any guilt to worry about. Constantly you see references from Athena and Apollo saying, go away, you were hated by the gods. And so you have this new order enshrined for the Greeks, always reflecting back on what came before. So like I said, it was the same problem that I had with Christianity. It's like, okay, I can explain this perfectly fine, but what is that?
SPEAKER_01So it's like now I have to go even further back, like not even Homer and Heads. It's good enough, like 700, 800 B.C. That's not good enough. And now I have to go and look at stuff that doesn't even have any textual record at all. And at that point, you're running out of options, but. I was thinking about this the other day. I don't remember where I heard this phrasing. If it's like a specific idiom to the American South or something, it's like a fun game.
SPEAKER_01It's like, what was the name? You're supposed to answer this question. What was the name of the first Native American who crossed the Mississippi River? We know by logic that there was someone who first crossed Mississippi, but We'll never know his name. There's absolutely no way. We might as well say he's Chief Kick-A-Bitch of the Slapaho tribe. You can make it up if you want. You know that there was someone, but you can't really say too much definitive about it.
SPEAKER_01It's an interesting play that you have to engage with, but it's not good enough for me just to say, well, I can't really know that much about it. I'll just... Cease the operation there. I think we know, we can know a lot more than we would assume we can.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, yeah. The link, what you said before, right, like that you said that basically what made you interested in paganism or what disillusioned you with Christianity was its kind of revolt against nature. And I think like this is a point that Camille Puglia has made and I think is true, which is that Christianity is a religion in... Like revolt against nature, right? Like you can think about even like Christian iconography where you have like, you know, the emaciated Christ or you have, you know, even like the pacifism of Christ or you think about its attitude towards nudity
SPEAKER_02and even procreation and things of that nature. It's definitely a religion in protest against nature. And when we think about, so this is where the sort of link in a way between paganism and romanticism lies because someone could go, why are these two things connected? What's the link? It really is that I think for the romantics, they saw paganism as something more aligned with nature and from the sounds of it, that's how you view paganism as well.
SPEAKER_01Yes, correct. So I know a lot of people really dispute the fact that Christianity does have that, I'll just call it a tinge towards nature. But the two myths that I like to compare side by side to give an example of it is... If you may be familiar with St. Francis of Assisi, he's the supposed patron saint of nature and wildlife. He would preach to animals and so on and so forth. So a lot of the ecological or conservationist type writings will dedicate to him
SPEAKER_01and say, this is the model for Christian stewardship and so on. But he has a myth associated with him about the Wolf of Gubbio. Gubbio is a town just to the northwest of Rome. And this is where he was at one day. Basically, the people of the village of Gubbio... Had a wolf problem. There is a wolf that was continuously coming in and attacking the people of the village, eating their livestock, tasting the flesh of man.
SPEAKER_01And they brought Francis in to sort of deal with it. And he basically, you know, he talks to the animal as he can. And he he says, look what you're doing to these good people. You're you're you're You're an affront to God. You're upsetting the order and attacking people that are superior to you. But I'll tell you what, I'll give you two options. One, you can continue on and be destroyed,
SPEAKER_01or you can come into the village, cease your attacks, and these people will feed you and take care of you for forever. And so the wolf agreed with it. They shake hands and he goes into the village and he Essentially, he's domesticated. He becomes a house dog. And to this day, there's actually a church in Gubbio where they uncovered the remains of a wolf that was buried underneath the church.
SPEAKER_01So it might actually be somewhat of a true story. But what I pull from that is the wolf was decried as sinful for the nature of being a wolf. And the solution to that problem was for him to be domesticated into the civilization of man to become a house dog. And you can compare that with, for example, I mean, there's millions upon millions of pagan myths about wolves and about nature, but the one that's immediate to me is Romulus and Remus.
SPEAKER_01So they were raised by the she-wolf. The barbaric upbringing is part of How they were said to institute civilization as we know it. So the pagans seem to have a kind of idea how nature produces civilization and the Christian system tends to put more of a contrast between them. But So that's that. With the Romantics, yes, it's certainly an emphasis of nature.
SPEAKER_01And if you doubt that at all, you can just look at all of the Romantic art of the period. Pretty much the mainstay of the Romantic oil painting is a landscape. Even with Transcendentalism in America, which offshoots that quite significantly, even though with a much more Christian character... I think the main way this comes about is replying to the Enlightenment, which was really the whole point of Romanticism.
SPEAKER_01The Enlightenment was one of its main things, if you think of Newtonian or Baconian science, is getting rid of The observer, like if something is true, it should be true for regardless of who is observing it. And the way that romantics like Goethe would respond is that experience is the only way to know anything. And so you get German idealism like Kant comes from this a little bit too. But the whole idea of Goethe and Gerdian science,
SPEAKER_01he has his own field of science because he was just capable of doing something like that. It's all Ruled upon immediate and personal internal experience of the external world. So what do you experience? It's nature. So much of that is returning back to that. Many of the romantics, the things that they are romanticizing, Is the old view of nature that Christianity did come to replace
SPEAKER_01to some significant degree, I would say.
SPEAKER_02I was thinking there's so much that I thought of whilst you're talking. I thought of that Nietzsche quote, I think it's from Twilight of the Idols where he's like, he who knows what goes on in menagerie doubts very much whether... Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. He did read that book that Isaiah Berlin wrote on the topic.
SPEAKER_02And he also gave lectures on the topic. And the account that he gave was pretty good. It was basically like, first and foremost, we need to recognize that Germany was at the spearhead And he said, well, I don't know, I don't know. Oh, no, no. Not an Enlightenment, pardon.
SPEAKER_02A Renaissance. My mistake, right? So he's like, so there was an Italian. Yeah, there was an Italian Renaissance. You know, there was a French Renaissance. But Germany was sort of like a cultural backwater during that time. And I guess Nietzsche would probably say that if anything, like he has that line about Luther sort of ending the Renaissance, right? With his Protestant Reformation. It's like it was a cultural backwater. And Basically, his idea was that like they felt this real cultural inferiority to France and,
SPEAKER_02you know, thinkers like Isaac Newton in England and then also like obviously Voltaire is an incentive. In some sense, it was a revolt against civility, if you will. It was like, you know, we might not be so fancy, but, you know, we have nature. Like that was his contention, which I think was interesting, right? Which was that basically it was... Germany kind of recasting the fact that it didn't have a renaissance as an actual asset or the fact that it wasn't,
SPEAKER_02you know, a leader in enlightenment thought in the same way maybe France was that that that was the reason. And I think it's also going back to what you were saying about Newton. You think about Newtonian physics. It's this idea that, hey, there is a universal law that can be observed everywhere. And it's true regardless of who you are, right? Or where you are. And... I think that people like Voltaire or maybe just the Enlightenment philosophers
SPEAKER_02in general began to think like, hey, we can probably come up with a kind of life philosophy that is like a law of physics, basically. Like in some sense, you could say utilitarianism. Yeah, absolutely. I mean, the problem with Germany being somewhat of a backwater, you know, true Germany, you could exclude Austria from this
SPEAKER_01In the 1700s, I think it's fair to say. But even in the mid-1750s, when Winkelmann, he was the founding father of archaeology, really, neoclassicism, Hellenism, and that goes straight into Romanticism in Germany, too. He was from somewhere in Brandenburg, I think. Magravate was literally just a big marsh. There was nothing for him there. So when he gets his position to go out and study,
SPEAKER_01and this is true with Gerda too, the first place they always go is Italy. They go into Venice and Naples and all of their travels are taking them. Further and further south. And Winkelmann has this funny theory or line attributed to him that the casual nature of the Mediterranean climate, its ease of living, is what bears the great art,
SPEAKER_01the noble simplicity and quiet grandeur that he terms it. And then Goethe, he has a bunch of... Yeah, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01You still have this problem with Germany not having quite the prestige that it wants. I recently did a little bit on Novalis, Friedrich von Hardenberg and Schlegel, the first Jena romantics, the first romantics as they're called. And they're writing incessantly, page after page, that we need a new mythology, what they term it, a new worldview.
SPEAKER_01And they say, we don't have it yet, but we're right on the precipice of getting it. So these were all young men in their 20s or so, yeah, 20s and 30s, somewhat mentored by Goethe and also... Friedrich Schiller, a great poet. He's always associated with Gerda. His statue is right next to... They have a statue at the Weimar Theater. It's Gerda and Schiller. They're always associated with one another. But yeah, this whole period, they do seem to keep going back to nature because...
SPEAKER_01There's really nothing else to go off of. They're not satisfied with the Christian status quo that they have. What they're seeing coming out of France and the Enlightenment and everywhere else isn't really palatable either. So the place that they return is firstly the immediate nation that they do have. This is also where you get the birth of German nationalism.
SPEAKER_01Fichte would probably be one of the first people that started formulating that. And then the other one is the Greeks. And, you know, so...
SPEAKER_02They actually see the Greeks, as we were saying before, part of the appeal of the Greeks is that the Greek is a more natural man, right? That's how they conceptualize it.
SPEAKER_01Greek people, like the Spartans, will say that they were migrants or war refugees, like the Romans coming from Troy, all this kind of stuff. But the Athenians uniquely said that they sprang from the soil. Of course, they came from somewhere else, but Athenian culture and the Athenian way of life that we know it could only come from that ecological setting. And so they very much admired that
SPEAKER_01Trying to replicate that for themselves in Germany. Because with romanticism, a lot of people think that they're really just trying to go back and redo something. So like Winkelmann said that any great movement must first imitate the Greeks. So even then it's not just like copy, but even that was too close to the misconception for Gerda. He modified that and said we must... Just quickly, I was going to say that I've never really been interested in history.
SPEAKER_02You know how there was that trend, I think it was associated with this historian Collingwood, which was like, you are just trying to replicate the past as accurately as possible in your historical work. So I've always preferred sort of like self-evidently self-interested historians who are kind of approaching history with questions from their own age. And then I've always liked this idea of like, Like a rebirth. That re is doing a lot, right?
SPEAKER_02Like the idea of like- Yes. And then an imitation, right? It's so cool how sometimes an imitation, like with that next iteration, it can actually be more interesting. You know what I mean? Like, so I think that that is- Because otherwise it would just be reactionary, right? I mean, what makes it generative and cool is that these people are not trying to go back. It's like they're taking inspiration from something. Yeah. So I just think that that's worth pointing out because a lot of people...
SPEAKER_02I think there's that Evola quote, everyone does it. It's like, what is it? Not the worship of ashes, but the preservation.
SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah. Gustav something, yeah. It's tradition is not the worship of ashes. It's the preservation of fire.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, yeah. That's like a Twitter. But it's a good quote. Yeah, it's definitely overdone.
SPEAKER_01That one, that was baby's first red pill, that quote. That one got me good.
SPEAKER_02But I was also going to talk about the Greeks and just, um, quickly because the worship of nature as a concept, right? I think for a lot of people that, that almost evokes like hippies in their mind, but it was clear that like, you know, it's not a coincidence that like a man like Hippocrates, um, the first true, like, you know, a medical man in a way, it's not a coincidence that he comes from this culture that's obsessed with nature. Nature here should really be understood, um, In a somewhat like biological scientific way as well.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, absolutely. Calagas has this, I don't know where he gets it from. I wish I knew, but in his essay, Man and Earth, that was given to the von der Vogel in 1913, he He mentions the Greek relationship to technology a little bit and says that they largely regarded technology as like a toy for women and slaves. And he gives the anecdote about the belief in the genius loci, the spirit of a place.
SPEAKER_01And in Germany, when the head of the household would pass away, they would go out and And informed the trees of the property of the bad news. And any time in Greece they wanted to build a bridge over a stream, they would have a large ceremony basically appeasing the stream of this great crime that they're about to commit. So they understood that they couldn't just stay as cavemen for their whole lives.
SPEAKER_01But nevertheless, they... Even though the progression of Greek society, if we're just talking about the Greeks, and this is true for largely many other populations too, even though they slowly get away from this over time and try and expel the idea, and I covered this in the Homer article that I wrote, The belief in the spirit of a place,
SPEAKER_01in animism as we know it, that each and every individual thing, every stream, every mountain, every sun, sunrise, every blade of grass, like Huelbeck said, One of his books, I can't remember which one it is, he has this line about a depressed man opening his closet and sympathizing with a lonely rack of coats in his closet. It's this type of way of connecting oneself with the rest of the world.
SPEAKER_01And so they have this this whole time.
SPEAKER_02But people still have that
SPEAKER_01today, don't you
SPEAKER_02reckon? Like as in...
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I joke with people saying that Tucker Carlson is actually the best example of this because everything's a demon.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01He is, he is, he is a daemonist.
SPEAKER_02And he also talks about how like the buildings are like trying to like, like this conspiracy of like modern architecture to like, like, you know, just, but people go to like a suburb and they, even like the most secular person still reaches for the word soulless when they go to like suburbia, you know, like, so people do still have a kind of latent animism in a way.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. No, it's, this is what, One of those things where I try and say, of course, when I investigate religion and I say I have to go as far back as possible, most of it's going to be pagan, but it's still fundamental to all religious thinking, including Christians. I tell this story last year, and this will be a glimpse into the insanity of a lot of the Protestant churches
SPEAKER_01in America, too. I took my family trick-or-treating on Halloween into one of these subdivisions, and right next to it is an old church that we used to go to. I think it's a Church of Christ or some type of Pentecostal church, if anyone cares. But you look through this tree line, and you see people marching around a fire and chanting, and you're like, what the fuck is going on over here? Is there like a witch revival or something going on at this church?
SPEAKER_01What is going on? We just kind of go on, ignore it. And I come back home later that night and I see on their Facebook page that they're actually having a cathartic ritual, like a household purge. So if they have anything in their lives that they think is demonic, so it could be your old crystals, your tarot decks, Harry Potter books, whatever you don't like. You bring it to the church and you cast it into the fire and you sing your praises to God.
SPEAKER_01So you still have the animistic belief there. Personally, I would expect a Christian... And evidently I was wrong to look at a tarot deck and say, this is just a freaking stack of cards. What the hell does this have to do with me? If it really annoys me, I can just wave the sign of the cross at it and then it's done. It doesn't have any power over me. What this makes no significant fact. But no, they thought it was very important to get this stuff out of their lives and out
SPEAKER_01of their household to prevent that thing having some type of power over them against their will. And things like that, it's the belief that even the most mundane things have some type of psychological, spiritual, whatever word you want to use, significance in that regard, more than just what its atomic composition is. I see that everywhere in religion. And with Tucker Carlson, too, talking about buildings,
SPEAKER_01the way that Clogus was helpful in explaining this to me Because he largely bases his psychology back in that old religious way of thinking in old Greece, like Mycenaean, or he calls it Pellasgian Greece. And he makes the distinction between persona and character. So persona belongs to anything. It comes from Latin personere. It means you have a mask. It's like a mask. It's a mask. Yeah, it's a mask.
SPEAKER_01So it's... It's basically the ego. It's the personal image that you give out to someone that you can converse to and whatnot. But a character, it completely lacks any, you can think of it as something that doesn't have a rational soul, if you want to stick with the Christian terminology. But Klaga says that all of these things have souls. He quotes, Dailies, Pansoplara Theon, all things are full of gods.
SPEAKER_01And so anything that has a bodily appearance gives off a certain character. So skyscrapers can have a certain character. If they're lighted up a day or at night, the character changes. Rocks have characters, places have characters, periods of history, peoples, races. So that That's an example of that old type of thinking that I think is still, as much as people try and get away from it, It's still there.
SPEAKER_01It's very hard to get away from it because it's so fundamental to just the human way of thinking.
SPEAKER_02What do you make of that etymological thing? Because I think when people are often trying to understand a word or a concept, etymology can be very instructive. Anyone who's read Nietzsche knows that, right? That's always really struck me as interesting, this etymological link between the word person, persona, mask. It's like, what to make of that? What do you make of that?
SPEAKER_01Well, the theory that Clogus gives is that the original view of the soul, or the first ones that we can really have access to, Didn't really, so like when we talk about our souls, like we talk about when we die, and this is just the common belief of the afterlife for anybody alive in the West. When you die, you sort of close your eyes and you wake up,
SPEAKER_01you blink, and you're like laying on your back in a meadow or something where you can see your departed family members. The point is, is that Whether or not it's really your body or a shade of it, it's still you. It's your ego, yourself. You go into that other world, wherever it is, and you meet everybody else who still continues as themselves in that next life. But the view of ancient peoples was...
SPEAKER_01Far more confusing, way more confusing. If you read the first few pages of Jung, Man and His Symbols, he tries to explain to the best of his ability the beliefs of some African peoples relating to the bush soul, as they call it. You can change your soul into a crocodile bush soul or a tree bush soul. If you have the crocodile soul, then you're more safe when we're swimming in the river
SPEAKER_01and they probably won't eat you because they sort of see you as theirs. It's very, very, very different. But the thing about the mask is you don't really have that belief in the individual ego. And at least the points where you do... Particularly in, I would say, with Greek tragedy. By then, of course, they have an idea of the self.
SPEAKER_01The reason why they're putting on the mask is to really expel the self off of the stage. Whoever is underneath the mask, whoever the actor is, nobody cares. It's not them. There's some things to believe that Aeschylus was the one who was performing Orestes in his plays. Nobody knew. It's his place. He's the one who made it. Nobody knows who he is until, you know, at the end, he takes his mask off. But isn't that like, that seems to me
SPEAKER_02like the, like, that seems like that masks dissolve the person rather than like, then why would it be etymologically linked? Do you get me? Like, I don't know if that's a stupid question, but it's like, it seems to me then like, it's like, like you're saying, it's like, okay, by putting on a mask, you're dissolving the ego. I associate the ego with personhood.
SPEAKER_01So it's weird that Yeah, it's one mask of another ego dissolving your own, right? So it's, you know, I'm sure the conception is far older than that word actually is. You know, that's Latin. But it's, that's, yeah, there's no telling how far back you could go with that. But that's the way that I've read that through Calagas and Nietzsche on tragedy is...
SPEAKER_01The point of the mask is to get the actor out. And whatever he's portraying comes in, whether it's a god. And I give a lot of different examples. You can see this in other peoples, like in Japanese no theater, like the very still Japanese masks that they wear for their theater. It's eerily similar to Greek tragedy. They're doing the same thing. It's like this still... Emotionalist mask that always faces the audience.
SPEAKER_01And you also have the binding fire rituals. A lot of the Native Americans in the Pacific Northwest have this type of conception where they're putting on a type of mask to let something else inhabit them. So it's another personality, essentially. But I kick it back even further in saying it's not even that, but.
SPEAKER_02I want to go back to Romanticism quickly, German Romanticism, because I remember reading this book. It was on like the Victorian high country. And I don't know how accurate this was, but what they were kind of talking about, because basically it was written by the people who ended up... Basically making the Victorian high country a national park, like preserving it from, you know, grazers and all the rest of it. And they were talking about conceptions of nature. And it was quite interesting because they were saying like, you know, at the time of settlement, like, like, I guess that we all take it for granted.
SPEAKER_02Like we are all very much indebted to romanticism. We all operate under sort of romantic assumptions. So when we see like wild nature, our first instinct is to be like, oh, that's so beautiful. But these guys who wrote this book, they made the point that like, it was actually the opposite at the time of settlement in Australia. Like when you saw wild nature, it was like, um, And it invoked fear. And it was almost like, we need to get rid of this. And they actually, in this book, again, I'm not making this claim.
SPEAKER_02They actually said that that was sort of a Christian attitude. They linked it to passages about domain. You know what I mean? That Bible thing where it's like, do you have domain over the earth? And they actually did credit romanticism with changing that and actually making it that all of a sudden people did start to see a virtue in wild nature. But I think that's one of those funny things where like now, I guess, like we most people have these romantic assumptions about nature when it's like that probably wasn't the case in, you know, the 18th century.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, absolutely. And there's a lot of very understandable practical reasons for not seeing nature so rosy with rose-tinted glasses, as you will. In America, the Indian wars, as we call them, they lasted from Columbus all the way till 1927, I think was the last Apache raid. It was just a funny little... A couple of reservation teenagers stealing some horses,
SPEAKER_01but that was the last documented instance of Native American aggression towards the colonial stock. So they had a much different... Yeah, it's the Christian too, but it's also because it's foreign. It's like, it takes a while. So like with the German romantics, like Germany is theirs. They've been there for thousands of thousands of years. They're as much as a part of the environment as anything else.
SPEAKER_01They are autocathones like the Athenians were. But those of us of colonial stock, we come right off the ship and there's strange sounds whooping and hollering from the dark tree line. And we're just... Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So I don't want that in my... No, it's extremely dangerous, even up until the 19th century. But back to the romantics, it's very, very difficult to explain the modern environmental movement as we have it without the romantics, because all of those are specifically romantic conceptions. And even the... I talk about every once in a while a book that I read... Um, it was called, um, eco-fascism, like lessons from the German experience.
SPEAKER_01It was written by these, um, these two, you've read it.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Dude, I,
SPEAKER_02I read it.
SPEAKER_01I got two pages in before I started just like getting a highlighter and like, I need to read this guy. I need to read this guy. So like, I kind of, the only time that I heard of, um, of Ernst Hackel, like in college was you learn about, um, his, his theory of, um, Ontology recapitulates phylogeny, basically something that grows in an egg or a womb. It starts off as like a bacteria, then a lizard, and then a bird, and it's following its history of its own evolution. And so you get this whole lecture about how this guy was
SPEAKER_01a complete fucking imbecile, and he closed the book, and you never hear about him again. But reading books like this, the whole point of this book is to just... Character assassinate everybody from the romantics all the way till 1933 to say that this whole enthusiasm with nature is what brought about the Holocaust. Clogus, this is the first place that I saw Clogus, was in this book.
SPEAKER_01And they're covering his man and earth, and they're saying he's lamenting that indigenous peoples are in a three-piece suit. He's talking about the extinction of bird and whales and deforestation. And they're like, so wow that this is all happening in 1913. No one's ever done this before. And then... You turned the page. Unfortunately, Clogus was a vicious anti-Semite and a politically arch-conservative. And she was like, shit, you
SPEAKER_00can't do it.
SPEAKER_01Damn, I can't read him anymore. The whole book is like that. It is actually a great book because it's illustrating this point that we're talking about.
SPEAKER_02I think people don't-
SPEAKER_01Finger-wagging at it.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. But also, I think it would be almost worth doing, because I wouldn't be able Yeah. Start there maybe and work forwards. But you start to get like even long after the romantic movement quote unquote ends, you still have these movements like Lieben's reform,
SPEAKER_02which I kind of got into researching a little bit. Lieben's reform. It's basically the proto-hippie movement and the actual seed of the proper hippie movement. There was this guy I read called Adolf Just. It's been a long time since I read him, but the book was called Return to And he was like a, like a nudist, vegetarian, et cetera, et cetera. And he's really pioneered the Lebensreform movement,
SPEAKER_02which was all about, you know, getting back to nature, not wearing shoes. And actually like the, the thing that I found so interesting was that he, The Lebensreform movement that he kind of helped pioneered, right? Like, literally, a lot of his followers and the people, part of that movement, the Germans, they moved to California and started the hippie movement we know today, right? Wow, okay. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01I didn't know it was that committed, connected.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so the waterfogel, it was this weird mishmash of like a million different types of youth organizations. You could sort of compare it to like Boy Scouts or something like that, but the... It was much less organized in structure. So you would have communist right next to what would eventually become like the Hitler Youth type parties.
SPEAKER_01To give an example, very plausibly Ernst Jünger, we know he was a member of the Von der Vogel with a chapter in Saxony. He probably went to that 1913 gathering The Hohenbeissner, the Meissner Gathering is this huge, basically all the kids from across Germany, all the youth movements, they all hiked to one mountain and they chanted songs, some of them that they revived from German medieval period.
SPEAKER_01Some of them they were making their own, writing songs, poems, making art. And they all gather and they come and sit down and they listen to a bunch of people who give lectures. And so it's very plausible that Junger had heard Clogus' speech, basically initiating the modern environmental movement that we know today. And then I think three months later is when he fled to Verdun to join the French Foreign Legion.
SPEAKER_01So you've got someone like that, his love of war, Getting shot, like he's seeing his friends get blown up with artillery. He's like, that was awesome. Give me some more. And then right next to him, you've got some proto-communist movements that were bubbling about. And then you've also got the right-wing hippies, the left-wing hippies, the nudists, all of them coming together. And just this big movement, sort of, the mission what they had was trying to say what the next generation
SPEAKER_01of Germans wanted. And those people in all of their different ways, you'd see them in adulthood in the Weimar period and just all the different insanities that is going on. The Weimar is, if it's known for anything, it's just how many radically opposed different ideologies were all like dominant and commonplace right next to each other.
SPEAKER_01And that whole generation was the Wundervogel generation. And then, you know, of course, the one that won out in the end was the National Socialists. And eventually the Wundervogel itself was actually integrated into the Hitler Youth in the 1940s. And then after the war, it took some time, but it did come back pretending that never happened. But yeah, it's... Lost my train of thought.
SPEAKER_02Wherever we're going with it. You seem pretty skeptical about this link between German romanticism and National Socialism, but I really do think you can make a pretty plausible claim. Right. Because like we said, like the Wandervogel movement, it grew out of the Lebensreform movement in a way, which grew out of German Romanticism. And I think that, you know, you said the Wandervogel movement, like that is Hitler Youth. You know what I mean? Like that is what it was based on. I think it integrated very seamlessly with one another.
SPEAKER_02And Camille Puglia, she has this idea that Where it's in sexual persona, which is like that decadence, sorry, romanticism leads to decadence, right? And the basic idea is like, okay, you have a Rousseau who tends to have like a very sanitized conception of nature, right? Right. And then the students of Rousseau who sort of adopt that worship for nature, they begin to realize, well, hang on a second, like nature is often red in tooth and claw. Right. Like it's it's it's violent.
SPEAKER_02Right. And the true worship of nature. And that's why you have a Rousseau. And it's not a coincidence that shortly afterwards you have a Marquis de Sade. And you can kind of make a similar point about Germany for however many years of history, where it's like the place that pioneered German Romanticism.
SPEAKER_02The Nazis were environmentalists, right? The Nazis were environmentalists. They were planting forests. They were conservationists. Even you think about... The pioneering vegetarian Savitri Devi, like another... I was trying to think of...
SPEAKER_01Rudolf Hess was actually a vegetarian. I mean, the book that we talked about, Ecofascism, it gives like a million different modern German environmental... And tells you the dates of where they were founded. And every single one of them was founded in the 1930s and 1940s. Yeah, yeah, yeah. There's that famous political cartoon where the Nazis, when they first came in power, Goering had completely abolished vivisection and animal torture as part
SPEAKER_01of their butchery. For meat processing and whatnot and for scientific experimentation. They even said that you had to kill lobsters before you boiled them. It was Nazi law that you had to kill the lobster before you boiled them. And there's that cartoon where, like, all of the test subject animals, like the rabbits, the deer, and the dog, they're all throwing a Nazi salute at Goering as he's walking by, thanking him for his service. It's, yeah.
SPEAKER_02I was going to say, though, another famous one is, you know, it's like, never ask a woman her age. It's like, never ask a German environmental, like, association when it was established. Yeah. Yeah. Do you see what I mean? Like, is it even like you can see the Nazis like this, even the emphasis on things like eugenics and which is in a roundabout way, again, an emphasis on on nature and this idea of like dysgenic breeding practices being brought about by you. So are you totally skeptical or can you see that it does?
SPEAKER_02Do you think that it kind of does grow out of romanticism?
SPEAKER_01Do you remember where I said this? I'm completely drawing a blank.
SPEAKER_02No, no, no. Did I just say that? When you were saying it, you sort of spoke about the link between... You spoke about it flippantly. Basically, you sort of dismissed it. You didn't think there was a link. But do you think there's a link or not?
SPEAKER_01Well, yes. Yeah. Firstly, just because Romanticism was so dominant in German culture. You could say that everything that came after the 1800s was so utterly ingrained in it. Even the feminist movements that were going on in Germany, they took this one line from Goethe's Faust, the very end in the eternal feminine draws us upwards. And they said, oh shit, that's us.
SPEAKER_01We're the divine feminine. And they instituted this whole reform about trying to be a new type of woman in the Gerdian model. So that's just one example. The thing you have to remember with the Nazi part of it is by far what had a really profound impact on them in the way that they viewed nature Was Darwin. And so you,
SPEAKER_01if you just had romanticism by itself, and you just had like the evolutionary theory that Gerda was saying, like, everything is a manifestation of like the primordial source, you know, whatever. Very hard to get to something like eugenics programs or something like that out of it. Yeah. Hackle was actually the one who popularized Darwin in Germany. He was very unpopular in Germany at first, maybe because this conception of nature went against the view that they had.
SPEAKER_01I don't know if that would have been the romantic one or the Christian one, and he would have the same problems that Darwin had in England at first, but... Yeah, that is really what brings that worldview into place. It's the complete vision of the veneration of nature, yes, and romanticism, and then a decision of what that actually is. And that largely comes from Darwin.
SPEAKER_01So you have to have both of those things. I don't know if it would have been exactly the way it came out with just... The romantics, it could have just degraded into complete decadence, like Paglia would say. But I don't know. It's just the Nazis, they definitely seem part of that progression, but it really does feel like a clean break in some places.
SPEAKER_01It's kind of hard to get your head around it. Yeah. Yeah, I probably just spoke too liberally. It's, yeah, there's more of a firmer link than I probably said in that.
SPEAKER_02No, well, yeah, I just, I think at the end of the day, it's like when you're talking about an ideology like National Socialism, it's not like it's something that it's completely coherent. It's like, Like, it's actually quite incoherent, like most political ideologies. Different ideologues would emphasize different things. So, yeah. But I do think the worship of nature can lead you to some pretty dark places, right? Because I even think again about that, like, think about the story we were telling about the dog, the domestication of the dog, right?
SPEAKER_02Like, that dog is less violent, right? But, but yes, and is, and is less natural and is in some ways, but, but we all recognize that the dog that's domesticated is degraded. Right. So, um, yeah, it's, it's, uh, I do think that like romanticism, like, uh, As someone I'm very sympathetic towards romanticism. I'm sympathetic towards like romantic conservatism and all of those ideas and like the sort of Berkian ideas of sublimity and all that sort of stuff. But I do think that sort of like,
SPEAKER_02especially the English, like, you know, you look at like, The Lake Poets from the Lake District. Their conception of nature is often... And even environmentalists today, their conception of nature just seems so sanitized. I do think that the true worshiper of nature... Also worships the sort of predatory element of nature. So I do think it can lead to pretty dark places quite quickly. So I don't think, yeah, I think there is something to that idea.
SPEAKER_01That's true for a lot of natural symbolism too. Like, you know, what is the significance of a solar eclipse to ancient peoples? It's bizarre. The end of the world. Something very calamity is on its way. We must rush to the temples, offers. Today we put on sunglasses and ooh and ah at it. We think it is a, wow, something so beautiful. It's something that I observe with a lot of pagans that I talk to is
SPEAKER_01the complete absence of a bad omen. Everything that comes from nature is intrinsically good for you in some way, which I think is a very strong departure from the way that the ancients viewed it. But it's one of those things. It's so ingrained with how we view the world and how we think after thousands of years of doing it this way.
SPEAKER_02I think this is so funny.
SPEAKER_01Oh yeah, go ahead.
SPEAKER_02I was just going to say, I do think that there's this kind of veneration, not veneration is actually the wrong word. There's a conception of nature and a sort of like love of nature that can really only come from the person who has almost no contact with it. You know what I mean? Like the person who does live in a city tends to have this extremely sanitized view of nature compared with someone who actually does spend time there. But yeah, sorry, I interrupted you.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's the perennial problem of conservation law. The people that have no contact with nature whatsoever, they tend to have the most absurd views about nature. In America, we have a conservationist known as Aldo Leopold, German immigrant. I don't know what connection he had to romantics. I don't think any at all. But he has a line like someone doesn't really understand nature until he relies
SPEAKER_01on cutting down trees in his own property to warm his own shins. And so that's the problem. You have to be within and at some point destructive to nature in order to really understand it. But then Most of the conservation law that we have across the West, definitely in America, is look but don't touch. It's setting off firm barriers like this is the wild area. You cannot go in there.
SPEAKER_01You cannot live in there. You cannot fish in there unless you have a special license. You probably had to pull a lottery to get it. And so you want people to have a connection to nature within it, but to the degree that you allow for that, you allow for some type of degradation of nature. Well, they don't see, what they do is,
SPEAKER_02like you're saying, that demarcation is that actually we are part of nature. That's what I feel like that they're missing a lot of the time, is it's like they want You want to create this distinction between man and nature, but man is a product of nature. You know what I mean? And when you create these like firm boundaries, it can actually start to feel really alienating, right? Like I've noticed that with these conservationist things, which I agree with, it's like, but if you start to make it really difficult for people to even go to these places,
SPEAKER_02it's like you're actually divorcing us from nature, which is part of the problem. You know what I mean? Yeah.
SPEAKER_01It's never been harder to get out into those spaces too. And it's only getting worse as it becomes smaller and there's more and more people. But yeah, it's the perennial problem with conservation is you want people to have, it's one thing to own nature, but you still have to see yourself within it to some great extent. Otherwise, what's the point? The world is just a big museum to you and there's nothing else to go off of.
SPEAKER_02All right. I'm sorry. This is, this is coming up. I probably need to go soon. I want to ask you, when's the, are we seeing a scouting Wondervogel? Oh no, sorry. Wondervogel. Are we seeing a revival of those? Cause I mean, I'd love to see that. There was talk on Twitter back in the day about like people trying to work out. Cause I think that that would probably be one of the best things that you could do for like, as a kind of like a, A right wing, however you want to conceptualize it, right?
SPEAKER_02But like promoting good kind of like, like these hiking groups, I think it promotes really good virtues in boys and young men. So could you see that happening?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, we kind of have it a little bit with, we call them active clubs. But the problem with those is everybody knows that this is your far right political organization. The hiking is kind of just the far white. I have not seen any black ones hiking to mountains recently. They usually just kind of stroll around the city. We do have them, but that's the problem is everybody kind of knows what they are.
SPEAKER_01They're not as open to the public as they need to be. That was something with the Vondervo that you had. It's like you had school teachers just grabbing their whole class and just leaving school and bringing the whole class onto these trips to go cure people. Talk about these sort of things. And it's, I don't know, it may be one day, but everything feels like it's,
SPEAKER_01the ideological substrate is, it's very, it's too paranoic, like there's too much paranoia right now. Yeah. To really create something new, which is the whole impetus of this. Right now, we're just fighting like hell to keep what we have at this point. That's the prevailing psychology. So I don't know if something like this could happen. I think it would be very fruitful if it did.
SPEAKER_01But again, we got to go back to that same problem. How do we... How do we emulate this rather than just repeating what they did thoughtlessly, hoping that it would have the same effect?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, absolutely. I'm kind of disappointed because I'm really enjoying this conversation, but I can hear my kids outside making, can you hear that or no? I don't know. No, no. Zoom's pretty good at, um, Zoom is pretty good. And, but, but, uh, yeah, I probably need to go. So this was great. I'm talking to you. We should definitely do it again soon. Um, and, uh, these radiocasts, anyone listening, I highly recommend them. They're just like, I can just tell that a lot of work has gone into them.
SPEAKER_02And like, uh, they're just, it's, they're really comp, like, it's not easy stuff. You're talking about complicated, sophisticated things, but you, you do a really good job of, um, I greatly appreciate it. Yeah, it's a lot of work, but I have a blast making them. Audacity is your friend making it seem seamless. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Thank you so much. Have a great day. All right. Thanks. You too. See you.
In this episode of the Chudstack Review, Drunk Wisconsin and I discuss: * What is the “state school upper middle class,” and why does nobody talk about them? * Are many online voices downwardly mobile elites? * Why...
Owen Yingling and I discuss: * Have Zoomers been Zombified? * Is it alienating being a highly literate Zoomer? * Why do so many university students care more about credentials than learning? * What is a university...
BUY THE STUD: CLICK THIS LINKLiam and I discuss: * Has market logic colonised family life? * To what extent is surrogacy ethical? * What is Liam’s novel, The Stud, about? * Is post-industrial, white-collar life...
Dan Baltic and I discuss: * How political should an author be? * Is Nutcrankr actually a right-wing book? * How much does Nutcrankr owe to A Confederacy of Dunces and Don Quixote? * How autobiographical is Spencer? *...
In this episode of the Chudstack Review, John and I discuss: * Why do young people struggle to plan for or invest in the future right now? * How much of generational conflict is really the boomers’ fault versus just...