Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Chudstack Review

The Chudstack Review artwork

Australian History, Jewish Nietzscheanism & New Rhodesia, w/Oz

Jun 19, 20261 hr 20 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In this episode of the Chudstack Review, I talk to my favourite Australian history blogger, Oz. We discuss: * Why did we stop being polygamous? * Is Tinder just a new form of polygamy? * Why aren’t doctors having babies? * Is education reducing the fertility rate? * Were the founding fathers of Zionism Nietzscheans? * Should we build a city like Dubai in Alice Springs? * Why is the Australian history we’re taught at school so boring? * Is “Dark Emu” b******t? * Should we terraform the Australian interior? * Should we colonise Antartica? * What does Australia’s future look like? This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit russellwalter.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Okay, I'm joined today by fellow Australian, Oz. He has a great blog, which is Kvetch. He writes my favourite historical essays on Australia and he writes many, many, many interesting essays. Actually, today I thought we might kick off by talking about a series that you wrote I think you published it in 23 or maybe even 22 and it was on um sort of on like the the domestication of man the title is wife economics but

I actually read this because I myself uh published like a blog um or posted publish sounds a little bit grandiose I posted a blog um I think maybe a couple months ago

SPEAKER_00and it was called uh Is having a family embarrassing now? And you went and linked to this because one of the things I talked about in this blog is there's a growing sentiment, particularly on certain sections of the online right that like monogamy is a form of domestication that any like true viral testosterone filled man should reject. So it's this weird critique of domesticity coming from the right. And this is something you spoke about in great length over the

course of this series. So Oz, maybe just explain what was this series about and what made you want to write about it? Yeah well look first of all thanks Russell for having me on before I answer that and it's a great question can I just say you probably have the highest ratio of viral pieces to subscribers I've ever seen I don't know how many hits you've got you've probably got I don't know half a dozen or maybe even like three to six absolute monster hits on a bunch of your pieces so I want to

know what your secret

SPEAKER_00is I think I think that something's happened with The algorithm or something, I don't know what it is, but yeah, I've actually on Substack, because Substack standards, I think if people aren't used to Substack, to say something is viral or blowing up, you're assuming it's tens of thousands of likes but on Substack something is viral if it's kind of like what would you consider viral how much would you say I'll give you so I think I've done fine I've got a great audience my most popular post

probably has I don't know 150 likes or something like that okay which is which is fine it's pretty respectable in Substack land you've got like a bunch and I've got like I had more subscribers than you at the time I think you may have grown or

SPEAKER_01similar or whatever but like Now you've got like thousands on some of them, which is just like, you know, and one I can forgive as an accident, but like half a dozen, I'm like, what is going on? I think it's amazing. Good for you.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, yeah. I've gotten lucky. I don't know what it is exactly. I think maybe sometimes I've got my finger on the pulse of the culture in some way. And I think that what I try to often do Russell Walter Steele

Well done I just want to note that like honestly it's like the number one most wild ratio of like viral posts to subscribers so I appreciate that no I appreciate that

SPEAKER_00a lot that means a lot yeah I love being onSubstack I've Really enjoyed it. I noticed that because I actually had a YouTube channel for some time before I got on Substack and I much prefer Substack because I noticed the engagement that you have is so much better. The quality of the comments is so much higher and I really do think it is the social media platform for me. I just love it. It's so good. I look it's the only one I'm on more or less and I love it as

well so look your piece like I wrote that a few years ago like I mean it's funny if you I reckon if you just look at what I'm writing at any given time you're just following what I'm interested in and my thought process is live so I don't it just represents what I was kind of thinking about at the time I've been reading a lot about American

SPEAKER_01Indian history Russell Walter Steele Russell Walter Steele

SPEAKER_01Russell Walter Steele They're happy-go-lucky Like it is a brutal joint kind of mission, okay? And both parties are kind of harnessed to this great project And this harness, this social technology of marriage, you know, is this kind of joint It's a social technology that leads to civilisation, you know? And so I end up starting from this place of, hey, you know,

When I look around the world You don't really see many polygamous people People have one wife or husband Sorry to interrupt you But you start the piece You paraphrase Rousseau You're like Man is born polygamous But everywhere he's

SPEAKER_01monogamous And this whole 15,000 words Russell Walter Steele Russell Walter Steele

SPEAKER_01And to be honest, my convictions have kind of hardened towards monogamy even over the last few years. I think men do actually tend to be more monogamous by nature in terms of inclination, like things I've read and the like. So it's partly outdated, but to be honest, it was just a series that kind of explored the rule. I found all these fascinating examples of like, you know, Russell Walter Steele

SPEAKER_01Russell Walter Steele Russell Walter

SPEAKER_00Russell Walter Steele Russell Walter Starr

SPEAKER_00Russell Walter Starr Yeah, I guess the reason I'd be against that is not, like, I think it's a total thing.

SPEAKER_01Like, if you have a whole bunch of excess men, you know, historically you lose them in wars and you do other things and you kind of manage it. But right now we have inadequate young men, right? We have a declining population with fewer young men and women. And we're kind of ruled by this ageing population. Clown of class and so we don't have excess young men who aren't kind of pairing like no one's pairing everyone's kind of gobbled up in their phones basically and

that's what's trying to happen your point I mean around polygamy I think what I

SPEAKER_01kind of A lot of this sounds stale now, because I think over the last three years, these ideas have been run out a lot more. It felt fresher. I'm not going to claim the originator of any of this stuff, but it was a bit fresher at the time. And I think it's aged well. I think I called the new Tinder economy the Uber Eats model for dating, right? And so that is a kind of pseudo-polygamy, which is I think what I called at the time. I think that's kind of borne out pretty well.

SPEAKER_00Absolutely, and I think the thing is, I see the problem as kind of intractable, not to be too pessimistic, because really, like, so one of the things that you spoke about, this was in the third piece where you were explicitly talking about Tinder, I mean, you go through looking at nomadic bands that practice polygamy, and then you talk about the emergence of monogamy, which again, it's kind of crazy, you You point out, if you went to a party and you said, how crazy is it that we ended slavery? People would be like, what?

SPEAKER_00That's not crazy. They just take it for granted. But in a sense, monogamy now, because we take it for granted as an institution,

SPEAKER_01It is totally crazy that we have marriage in the way we do. It is totally crazy we don't have slavery. It's totally crazy. We've had slavery, endemic slavery in every society forever until pretty recently. And same with marriage. It's totally crazy. And sorry, I don't mean to preempt you, but the kind of unbundling of marriage is super dangerous and super precarious position because it was such a fragile and long evolved for social technology that without it,

SPEAKER_01I think society is in a lot of trouble. Well, one of the points that you made, which I think was a good one to make, which is that... It the fact that this became stigmatized among poor and rich alike that like you know that if you wanted to divorce your wife it's like well you're going to potentially have to go to war for that like even if you're a king you know what I

SPEAKER_00mean like if you're a king and you want to divorce your wife and remarry You're potentially going to get, well, we know you're going to get excommunicated It's crazy,

SPEAKER_01right? It's like I'm the richest guy around I have all these armies God forbid I divorce my wife It'd be like Trump Russell Walter Steele Russell Walter Steele

SPEAKER_00Well, I think about the example of King Solomon, right? Like how many wives was King Solomon said to have? It was like 700 or 800 concubines. And then, you know, there's other stories of sultans and kings with similar arrangements where we're talking, or you think Genghis Khan, 16 million descendants, right? Like, so that was sort of the norm historically, which was that many men, um, Russell Walter Steele

SPEAKER_00The thing is, we kind of are at this time where we can tell that the norm of marriage is obviously breaking down, right? If Trump has a slave, we're all like, no. If Trump was to divorce Melania and remarry, we'd be like, so what?

SPEAKER_01He's done it twice.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, exactly. And we just accept that as a sort of norm, now especially among Russell Walter Steele Russell Walter Rwalter

Men you know what I mean who are unable to find wives and you know it's because I think like you said in the piece historically that was a serious social problem within like the enemy was within the gates and the enemy was young men right and you needed to work out what to do with them so you would conscript them in foreign wars or you know you'd get them to go and colonize Paraguay or something like that right that was that's what you did with your young men I mean now what a funny

SPEAKER_00thought to think of like conscripting In cells to go and fight it's it's you couldn't form an army it's you know what I'm saying so it feels like the situation is so different in part probably because of things like pornography but then also just like the nature of the civilized settled domesticated nature of modern man yeah I agree with all that What I was saying though is the intractable nature of it is it's very difficult to

SPEAKER_00imagine monogamy coming back. It's almost impossible to imagine a situation where a powerful man would be as... Can we imagine a situation where a powerful man... Will not be able to get divorced. It's just, you know, it's not feasible. Like, is there ever going to be...

SPEAKER_01I mean, I think the harder thing is to, like, is to, you know, I mean, people can get divorced and that's fine, you know, or like, you know, I mean, we still prefer a couple of people. I think it's still higher status or rephrase, but to kind of stay married, right, than to divorce. But the question is, for example, can you put the sexual revolution genie in the bottle, right? Like, is it... Can we imagine it being taboo again to not be sleeping around before marriage? Or can we imagine it being normal to be a virgin before marriage?

SPEAKER_01I reckon it's pretty hard to imagine that, you know, in like modern Australia or like modern America. It's a total Chesterton's Fence moment because like I myself think like back to

SPEAKER_00when I was like a teenager, right? And I was that sort of like naive new atheist and... The idea of like sex before marriage being taboo, I just think like, okay, that's just like fuddy-duddy religious stuff.

SPEAKER_01I totally agree. We swam in the same water, it'd be ridiculous.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, but then you start to realize, you're like, oh, all of these second order effects that follow from that, you know what I mean? And you're like, oh, hang on a second. Well, now we have a birth rate of whatever. And actually, that's maybe a good segue, right? Because one piece you wrote, again, I don't know when this was, maybe 23, 24, was kid maxing. I know you yourself, I think, have a big issue. Yeah, sorry? Yeah.

SPEAKER_01I've got four kids.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, you've got four kids and you really advocate that and you are concerned about the fertility rate, aren't you? Look, I guess I'm concerned about the fertility rate for a whole bunch of social reasons.

SPEAKER_01Honestly, I'm not having kids for that, obviously. Like I don't say, hey, you should go have, it's not in my nature to go, hey, you should be doing stuff for society or something. I think like, I think it's hard enough to maintain Russell Walter Starr I think it's like, you know, if you were to ask me that Peter Thiel thing of like,

SPEAKER_01you know, what's the truth that you see that everyone else doesn't see, however you phrase it, like, it's probably that. I mean, it's not like, it's literally not only me, obviously, but like, I just think, you know, I think kids are such a great blessing for yourself, right, and for those around you and the like, that obviously you should be having way more kids than you probably are. And so, you know, that kid maxing piece, you I was at a birthday and I just saw Russell Walter Steele

Because you'll be better for it It's as simple as that I don't think anyone's ever had kids Because they were trying to improve the TFR But people do the opposite They say I'm not going to have kids Because of the environment They make up a bunch of other Social reasons for it Which may be fake But they do say that at least I don't know if you know that Johan Kurtz guy On Substack Have you seen him?

SPEAKER_01I don't think so

SPEAKER_00Well, he has a great piece. I'll send it to you afterwards. And his contention, right? Because it's not obvious what causes the fertility crisis, right? Because the temptation is to say, oh, it's religion, right? Like the decline in religion. And then you look at a country like Iran, and I believe that has below replacement fertility rate.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, agreed. So his contention was that it was status right and it's basically like the title of the piece is it's embarrassing to be a stay at home mom and the point is that his point is like if you look at the status games we play in like meritocratic

SPEAKER_00Russell Walter Steele

SPEAKER_01Russell Walter Steele Russell Walter Steele Russell Walter Steele

Yeah, it's definitely one of those things where people project whatever their pet issue is.

SPEAKER_01And it's all probably right or it's all wrong. Who knows, right? I think it's just really hard to know is the reality.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, exactly, exactly. Well, I think that one of the things you did cite, which is, again, one of those uncomfortable truths, which does seem like female education does have some role to play in it, right?

SPEAKER_01Female education has a massive role to play. I mean, like, people are worried about. They're like, hey, let's educate women so they have kids later and that we can help the economy. I mean, in Australia, we talk about increasing female workforce participation, right? That's the thing and handing your kids off to childcare centres I just think it's funny and I do the same thing we use childcare I'm not attacking people or whatever but I think it's funny that communism and and capitalism have converged in the same solution of

outsourcing child-rearing to,

SPEAKER_01like, strangers. It's so bizarre. And, yeah, I mean, I think it's tough for the reason you said. Like, it's not like, hey, you know, I've got two daughters and, like, I'm not going to say, hey, don't, like, be educated, you know? And so...

SPEAKER_00Exactly right. Exactly right. As in, you would... Most people, like, even, it's funny, like, even the people who's a LARP as, like, trad cats would probably, in real life, struggle with the idea of, like, not...

SPEAKER_01I'll tell you a funny story. This is totally true. You know, I, um... Russell Walter Steele You know, I just can't wait to live overseas when I grow up.

SPEAKER_01I'm like, what are you talking about? Like, you want to live away from me? She's like, you can't expect me to stay in Australia my whole life. I want to see the world. You know, I'm going to be, you know, my wife's from Mexico. They've traveled to Mexico a bit. They've traveled here and there. Like, I want to go to Mexico. I want to go to other places, you know. And hey, like, she's like deeply. And to be fair, I was the same. My wife was the same. We've traveled the time. We want to see the world. There's this kind of explorer thing, which I'm deeply sympathetic with. On the other hand, I'm like, A, terrified that she's going to land far away from me.

SPEAKER_01I don't want her to be far away from me. I want her to be nearby. And B, that she'll fall into this trap of never having kids. And she's eight. And so I'm like, jeez. And obviously I'm not going to say, hey, you can't go travelling overseas or whatever. I want to afford her all these opportunities. And so I'm not preaching to anyone. I'm living this kind of pragmire of trade-offs. I don't really know what the answer is.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's so funny. The travel thing comes up all the time. This is more... There's so many people that I know because I'm 30 right and so most of my friends are in that sort of age bracket where it's like well realistically you probably want to be thinking about having kids and so many of them they're like yeah I'd love to have kids but I just want to do a little bit more traveling first and it's like all right it's like you're 32 or something you're 33 it's like uh you probably need to start thinking about this soon but you made in that piece you did make a

SPEAKER_00point that is is, I think, worth considering, right? Which is, okay, we acknowledge that education is obviously a major reason why the fertility rate has dropped is because women are pushing back having kids later. And then often what's happening, especially to elite women, highly educated women like doctors or surgeons or whatever, is that they're often having to spend so long in education, which they basically just end up

SPEAKER_01This is a recent piece I wrote. I wrote a piece, this is like a month ago, so I remember it better than all these other ones. It's like, you know, I say infertility is being driven by male inadequacy, okay? And what I mean by that is that women are incredibly vulnerable when they have kids. You know, they... They're physically vulnerable, they're emotionally and financially vulnerable. In the past,

when they're a wife and they don't have work and say they're subject to a husband

SPEAKER_01who's a bad man, he's abusive, maybe he's a gambler, maybe he does other stuff, whatever, they're financially dependent on him and that's a bad situation for her to be in. Russell Walter Steele Russell Walter Steele

SPEAKER_01And I asked him about it. Obviously, I didn't say that to them, obviously, just for the points of doubt. But like, you know, I asked my cousin later, you know, is this normal? He's like, mate, no one has kids, right? And I just thought, my God, you know, medicine is like this medical path is like this. We basically created this giant incinerator of IQ. We're going to like attract these bright, brilliant, conscientious women. And then like Russell Walter Steele

SPEAKER_00It's an IQ, it's an IQ shredder. Like, and again, that's one of those things where it's like, are we going to talk about this? Again, no one wants to talk about it because it's such a thorny problem, but it's, it's, I mean, the word for it, it's dysgenic. Like it is dysgenic when you have your best and brightest not having children or having next to no children. And I remember, I mean, again, this is a vague memory. I read this book by Edward Dutton, which was called At Our Wits End. And it was about declining intelligence and And he was looking at England, I don't know if it's true of Australia,

SPEAKER_00I would guess it was, but he found that the only group in England with above replacement fertility was people who were welfare recipients, right? And then you think, I think there's basically an inverse correlation between education, wealth, and fertility. And historically speaking, it's been the complete opposite, right? Wealth and education are associated with high fertility, right? Russell Walter Steele

Harmish and Haredim and other kind of high you know low technology low innovation but high fertility cultures kind of catching on and that's dangerous for kind of global norms around innovation and the like and I think that's one but I think that's the macro concern you know like because otherwise you know right now we're living in a you know technological revolution right and so you know it's hard to Pair That With Like This Dysgenic Idea Because Actually We're

Doing Great Like

SPEAKER_01Technologically And So You Know I Don't Know How To How To Square That

SPEAKER_00True, it could almost be more, the more negative ramification could be what it does to personality traits. Because I think that personality traits are somewhat heritable, right? And you think like right now, if you're a high openness person, I suspect that there's probably a correlation, like think about travel, right? If you're a high openness person, you want to see the world. Russell Walter Steele

I think that it is a bit intractable but we'll see what happens I mean who knows I think a lot of the time when we the doom and gloom predictions are based on the idea of if things continue as they will but I think things will inevitably change

SPEAKER_00as conditions on the ground like on the ground change

SPEAKER_01Yeah, look, who knows, right? And this has happened before, you know, the Roman Republic famously, you know, kind of encountered this similar kind of decadence with declining fertility and that all kind of went bad. And then, you know, but like, we're not, we're not the same society as 2000 years ago, you know, I don't You know, I don't know how it kind of plays out, to be honest.

SPEAKER_00I can totally see it.

SPEAKER_01You know, I don't think, as we said before, in the past this would have potentially led to violence or this kind of collapsing of like marital norms and the like, but we just don't have violent young men anymore. Everyone's kind of pacified on their phones and the like. And so, you know, I think the future will be different to the past.

SPEAKER_00Definitely. Well, I think let's talk about Australia. You've been... You've been in the coal mines writing about Australia. It's hard to write about Australia because, I mean, there's just not that many of us. So it's kind of difficult for the essays to get traction. But I love your essays on Australia. I love reading all of them. I mean, we just were talking before you started. I think about a month ago, you wrote this essay on... uh what was called Nouveau Australia or something New Australia

so New Australia I mean this is just an unbelievable story you know in fact before I jump into that story like I don't know a couple years ago I just started this Australia bitch I kind of realized hang on like I don't really understand the society that I live in

SPEAKER_01okay I've read a bunch of history elsewhere and I don't like Russell Walter Steele is how beautiful these histories are. Like, you know, the work of Robert Hughes, of, you know... Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_00Adel Shaw is, yeah.

SPEAKER_01So beautiful. It's an amazing book. But, you know, not just that, like all these great, you know, Geoffrey Blaney's great, you know, like there's just all these great Australian historians. And, you know, I think that's massively underappreciated. Like we have like out, we have these amazing writers and I'm just saying like two or three, but there's like at least a dozen or probably dozens of Russell Walter Steele

SPEAKER_01Russell Walter Steele Russell Walter Steele

SPEAKER_00And one, I do think that in the 90s, there was a push, a pedagogical push to nationalize the Australian historical curriculum. And by nationalize, what we mean is sever it from it's British. Like, typically, I think like if you had gone to school in maybe the 80s or maybe the 70s or the 60s, rather. You would have started Australian history by learning about Britain, right? And that is the only logical way to study Australia because otherwise,

SPEAKER_00if you start with Captain Cook, it's like this guy came and then all of a sudden Russell Walter Starr Russell Walter Steele

SPEAKER_00Russell Walter Steele And some of the least advanced people, people who, I know that there's this whole Bruce Pascoe idea that, you know, indigenous people were, you know, that they had gone through the farming revolution, but I think Blaney has definitely demonstrated. It's just blah.

SPEAKER_01Russell Walter Steele Basically there was this guy called Bruce Pascoe and what he did was he argued that

contrary to like racist yada yada yada people indigenous people did farm and one of the sources that he cited right was I can't remember the guy's name but basically

SPEAKER_00the guy drew a sketch of indigenous people farming And he was a real estate guy He sold plots of land to people in England And it's like, dude, he's trying to make it look like arable land You know what I mean? And that was the evidence that he cited in the book

SPEAKER_01I started reading Bruce Pascoe's book and it was self-evidently rubbish. The fundamental flaw of that whole mission is to tie moral worth with technological advancement, okay? And you don't need to, right? Like, just because, you know, like I make the point, you know, all peoples were at some point Russell Walter Steele

SPEAKER_01Russell Walter Steele Russell Walter Steele

SPEAKER_01Russell and he was like, no, we are not here to antagonise the natives, let's just do our thing. If that is not the most liberal posture imaginable where you could totally Russell Walter Steele

SPEAKER_00Well, Arthur Phillip, I think that the sort of convicts themselves hated him because they felt like, one, Russell Walter Steele

Supremacist does and I think that maybe like even even like um you can go and read parliamentary debates like I just picked up this book it was like um great it was something like you know a document that it was a book that dealt with important historical documents in Australia random page and it was a parliamentary debate on

SPEAKER_00the topic of indigenous people and you can tell it's as fierce and as Russell Walter Steele

SPEAKER_01Oh, the stories of that, I mean, these are like the bush rangers. Like, there are some horrible stories, especially in, like, Tasmania, where they, like, select Aboriginal heads and stuff like that. They're, like, these horrendous stories. And you're absolutely right. I mean, it's the convicts and the settlers, right? Like, if you're a farmer out there and, like, some Aboriginal's taking your sheep or something, you're just, like, going. Russell Walter Starr

SPEAKER_00These people, sometimes like these simplistic narratives, like if it is as simple as like white v black, it's like, well, you don't even need to bother learning about anything. You know what I mean?

SPEAKER_01Like these people, it's... Yeah, I mean, my kids learn that. They're like, hey, you know, they come home from school and they're like, oh, so the white people came and they killed the aboriginals. And it's like, well, you know, like, no. Like, actually, you know, the great tragedy is that disease... Russell Walter Steele

SPEAKER_01People successfully kind of, you know, the same stories in the US, you know, disease just spread everywhere. It was a different story in Africa where the whites would just die every time they rocked up in Africa. Yeah, and that's why the blacks became slaves. Russell Walter Steele Russell Walter Steele

SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, actually, this will be a good segue, right? Because I heard someone say recently, and I think they were half joking, but they're like, you know, white people, when you get them in like a tropical environment, it's like they go troppo and they start enslaving everyone. It's like, no, that's not what actually is happening. It's like there was this widespread belief back then that, you know, You couldn't really as a white person work in those environments and here's the segue right is obviously in far north Queensland um you did have slavery right you did have um the Pacific Islanders who were imported into F&Q

and I think that there

SPEAKER_00was um There was a, for a time, a talk of separating, right? Like they wanted to separate and form their own state. And that in part was one of the things that contributed to the White Australia policy, which you've written about so much. So we'll get to the new Australia soon, but perhaps maybe we'll start with the pieces that you've written on White Australia.

SPEAKER_01Russell Walter Steele I was reading Neville Meany recently and he was recommended by Hugh White, the great security analyst out of Australia and Neville Meany was a great security analyst who Hugh White has said he looked up to and his work he admired.

SPEAKER_01And I was just blown away by these essays. So a lot of, I wrote this kind of series and a lot of it was based on a lot of these essays and these books that I was reading by Neville Meany. And I guess for me, the first question was kind of why did Australia end? And, you know, I don't think we've really Russell Walter Steele

SPEAKER_01Russell Walter Steele Russell Walter Rwalter

SPEAKER_01Russell Walter Russell Walter Rwalter

SPEAKER_01Russell Walter Steele Russell Walter Steele

SPEAKER_01Russell Walter Steele Russell Walter Rwalter

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, yeah, it was a bunch of complicated questions around and racially provoked questions, but a lot of it was like security. It was like, hang on, you know, we need to unite for security reasons because the Japanese are starting to, you know, they're starting to become more expansionist. They just beat Russia, by the way, in like a war for the first time, and actually we can't trust the British to look after us. And so that's a Russell Walter Steele

SPEAKER_00Russell Walter Steele the Japanese were the bad guys and we did need to defeat them and they did try and attack us actually all those things were like bang on correct right and like and these days it's like scare quotes it's like what are you talking about and like it

SPEAKER_01is so bizarre and so um And so actually, but the nuance there is that it was against British interests. Britain was allied with the Japanese, right? And they were allies through World War I. But the Australians, like Beacon and Barton and the other Australian leaders, were so prescient and were so alive to the national interest in

Australia.

SPEAKER_01Like, it's almost unimaginable today. Russell Walter Steele Russell Walter Steele

SPEAKER_01Russell Walter Starrer The Russell Walter Starrer Timber tempered that basically the kind of racist impulse I don't know go away from that was definitely this racial element thing in society and the political class

but like actually the main drivers of like Federation rate like white Australia and racism were like foundational to Federation and you should know I mean Federation is like the greatest political flowering in Australian history like it was a deeply generative important event and so rather than you know I think it's instructive

SPEAKER_01that that Brought a posture by the elite at the time was so generative and useful to this country.

SPEAKER_00Anyway, I've rambled a lot to you, but there's a lot there. There's so much there I want to speak about. I think the tension with Britain is so key and is overlooked, right? Because you recognise that that the British always kind of saw Australia as an economic zone. I think that that's one of the key things. They always saw Australia as an economic zone. They always thought that, like, even when they were against the white Australia policy, right, when it was introduced.

SPEAKER_01It was embarrassing to them. They put the Indian colonies. They were like, this is terrible for us. They put the Japanese allies. They didn't want that.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, exactly, exactly. So I think that that tension, right, where I think in some sense there was this, because you would have had constant streams of British immigrants and then you had the native born Australians who obviously this is where Australian nationalists Russell Walter Rwalter

SPEAKER_00Russell Walter Steele Founding Fathers Supported the White Australia Policy for very obvious reasons, right? Which is if you have British people, British business people importing large amounts of colour labour,

SPEAKER_00undercutting Russell Walter Rwalter The Russell Walter Rwalter The Russell Walter Rwalter

SPEAKER_00Russell Walter Steele

SPEAKER_01Russell Walter Starr I actually am somewhat like and this is controversial to admit is that I would remain sympathetic to the white Australia policy and I actually do and even I would

say that I'm sympathetic towards like ethno-nationalism the problem is that when you say that what I personally think that's a totally uncontroversial position right it is the standard default position of most nations on earth right is

SPEAKER_00ethno-nationalist And I think that it's only really controversial because of the political climate that we're in, right? Am I making sense here?

SPEAKER_01The way I think about it. Sorry, you finish.

SPEAKER_00I was just going to say, like, even what you said before, like, when we were talking about disbanding the White Australia policy, it's like, why did we need to do that? It was because Japan found it so offensive. It's like, Japan... Russell Walter Starrer The Russell Walter Starrer The Russell Walter Starrer The Russell Walter Starrer The Russell Walter Starrer

um like you know that that that that liberal tradition so I think even if you went back to 18th century England there were synagogues right and there were you know a gazillion different churches um Benjamin Disraeli 19th century right it's like that's a strain within that that is in part what it does mean to be Australian like you can't completely reject that heritage but that so so I would always you know

SPEAKER_00kind of welcome like you know you you would want it you would want different people right we're a seafaring people like we're always going to be a mercantile seafaring people we're not going to be a closed society we're always going to be an open society but that doesn't mean you need to support like mass unfettered immigration right effectively the way the debate is characterized is it's like you're either a liberal or you're like a racist and it's and it's sort of like no you actually can like for example i

think that you could

SPEAKER_00say We want to remain a super majority Like we like immigration But we believe that like you know The European population should stay at around let's say 70% How you would govern that I don't know But that doesn't strike me Like the idea that you would conserve your demographics The idea that that's like radical or revolutionary or beyond the pale That just seems absurd to me But anyway The way I

SPEAKER_01Russell Walter Steele Okay, by the country, not just by the immigrant, okay? My family came to this country in 1991 and I'm really grateful that Australia took us, okay? But if Australia said,

no, you can't come here because we just don't want to, right?

SPEAKER_01Like, we just don't want to. That's a legitimate choice. Like, what right do I have to go anywhere else? I want to. It's a bizarre thing to invoke. It'll be like me saying I can just go into your house whenever I want. It's like, well, no, I can invite you in and maybe if you're not going to ask me for something, you can pop in. But it's bizarre for me to just impose Russell Walter Steele

SPEAKER_01Russell Walter Steele Pause immigration and just choose to make it zero to prove that

we can then pretend that we have to accept half a million or a million immigrants every year and

SPEAKER_01there's nothing we can do about it because that's just how things are. It's a total abdication of agency and our pretending to have control. And our politicians just go, actually, we're going to look at this and have total control and do whatever we want rather than pretending we can't do anything about it.

SPEAKER_00And you know what else really annoys me, right, is if you were to go and talk to these like liberal party conservatives, you know, if you were to ask them to invoke a thinker who influenced them, they would probably say Burke, you know, they would say they're Burkeian conservatives. And, you know, one of the things that Burke spoke about was, you know, Politics in some sense, or this idea of a contract between the people who are living, the people who are dead, and the people who are coming, right?

SPEAKER_00And I in some sense feel like I have an obligation to my children and my grandchildren, but then I feel like I have a sense of obligation to the people who came before me. And I do sort of think like what would Deakin think about the current state of Australia you know like or even you know what would the people who went and fought in Southeast Asia think you know what I mean I think that they would be dismayed I think in many ways they would be and I don't want to paint a totally negative picture I think in many ways they would see what we've built

and they would be impressed but in other ways I think they would be questioning what we had done you

SPEAKER_00know like what's happened here um

SPEAKER_01Well, I don't know. I'll spice this up a little bit. I'm a Zionist, right? I think it's okay to have a land for the Jews in Israel, okay? And if I believe that, how strange would it be if you said to me, you haven't said this to me, but if you said to me, I believe Australia is for the Anglos or something to that effect, or maybe let's have like a land for the Anglos. Let's call it England. Let's call it England Hypothetically, let's call it England I'd be like,

yeah, why can I have

SPEAKER_01Russell Walter Rwalter It's just like, actually, don't, like, piss or get off the pot. Don't have ass with these, like, parasitic institutions on an Anglo society. Go and, like, build your own, carve out your own land and, like,

SPEAKER_01do it properly if you want to, right? If you want to. You don't have to, obviously. Russell Walter Steele

SPEAKER_01Russell Walter Steele

SPEAKER_00Well, the funny thing is, yeah, I agree. It absolutely is. But it's like, in some sense, to be Anglo is defined by individualism and openness and all of these things. So I don't know, like you see these sort of like, let's say white nationalist movements, right, in Australia, which do exist, right? There are white nationalist movements calling for the barring of immigration. It's funny like they're never anglos they're always like italians or like you know

what i mean like or like and they all have and they all have asian wives yeah yeah yeah they're all like yugoslav or something like that so it's it's just funny like i feel like anglos they just are not clannish i think like whatsoever you know what i mean they're just not clannish or tribalistic um whatsoever um yeah but this

SPEAKER_00that's a that's an interesting pivot point because I mean before we we started we were talking a little bit about like um the pioneering spirit which defined Australia in its sort of early stages but it's just so absent today from our like bureaucratic class and I was saying to you you know that same pioneering spirit you can really see that in the founding fathers of Zionism who were like I think like I myself like I read a biography of Herzl And I found that so bizarre Like it's not what people would

expect Like he was a Germanophile And then you've got these guys like Jabotinsky Who I think are like Nietzschean Like very few of them are like They're not like Torah reading Jews They're like often like extremely radical Weird thinkers Jabotinsky was like

SPEAKER_01If I remember correctly, like an Edesan cosmopolitan who went to Italy, fast about for a few years, a bit of a cad, okay, and then just like radicalised a little bit and, you know, he was very well read, he was a journalist and so much, you know, and Ben Guion, the kind of father of modern Israel, you know, he was bookish, semi-intellectual out of like a Polish steddle, you know, Herzl, as you said, this kind of German file Kind of You know what I mean Like the whole And you

know Like even like Golda Meir This frumpy Girl out of You know Who was kind of Raised in the US Like It's such an unlikely Assembly of characters These are Yeah these You know They're the opposite Of Nietzschean Creatures Like these supermen They're like These like

SPEAKER_01academic Journalists and some of them were in armies and the like Jabotinsky from memory. He was in some army. I think it was a British army. I'm probably mixing it up.

SPEAKER_00But then he started one called like the Beta, B-E-T-A-M.

SPEAKER_01But he killed one person He killed one person, I think And this is like not super confirmed But it's kind of implied He killed a Turkish soldier Which they had to leave behind for whatever reason And he kind of regretted it for the rest of his life These are not like superhero dudes What they accomplished is just even more unlikely and strange.

SPEAKER_00It was a rebellion against themselves. It sounds weird, but that's the impression that I get is that in some sense that all of them possessed a degree of self-loathing and actually you could go so far to say anti-Semitism, right? Which sounds paradoxical, but in some sense they looked at Jewish people and obviously being like, um, You know, like being nomadic or I guess the more correct term would be diasporic people, right?

SPEAKER_00There are certain things, right? If you're diasporic people, you do not serve in the military, right? Russell Walter Steele Russell Walter Steele

SPEAKER_01That's obviously been the national myth of Israel. I would not say Ben-Gurion or Jabotinsky load themselves or Golda Meir. That was not what I read and what I saw. But certainly at the time there was this Israeli... Russell Walter Steele

SPEAKER_01incredible warrior, basically, through all of Israel's wars. That is certainly the national Russell Walter Steele

SPEAKER_00What would be the equivalent? It would almost be like Someone crossing the Bosphorus And taking back Constantinople And like reviving the Latin language I think about this all the time

SPEAKER_01I mean like Well the Anglo equivalent was kind of Rhodesia I guess, you know, or something like that, you know, which is another deeply misunderstood and wild story, but like, or, you know, maybe the US actually, maybe the Puritan, you know, yeah, America was founded in a similar way. I mean, you know, how, like, again, what's kind of striking when you look back at Federation in Australia, if that's the least crazy example,

SPEAKER_01like you beat the US, you look at these other examples, That level of nation building and that level of kind of, you know, agency is just so shocking and so missing today. And so, you know, I think that's the thing that's astounding because you can't imagine our current crop of leaders doing anything remotely and as kind of gargantuan, basically.

SPEAKER_01It's just impossible to imagine. So, you know, you mentioned Nueva Australia, which is this wild story of this, like, effectively this unionist in Queensland, kind of sick of Australia. It wasn't white or socialist enough for him. And he was like, that's it. And he basically took, you know, these 200 people Russell Walter Rwalter

SPEAKER_01Russell Walter Rwalter Rwalter

Who is so capable and inspired to do this crazy thing of crossing the world,

SPEAKER_01start a new nation? I think we are so missing. You and I are looking around us and we want to manifest that sense of destiny and that sense of agency and creation. It's so missing from our societies and our day-to-day lives. Yeah well it wasn't he he was called himself like a prophet but yeah I think that that's what I called him a prophet I'm gonna show you I don't remember I just think like I thought what a wild dude you know like it's didn't he

wasn't didn't he um adopt like some pseudonym which was it meant yeah yeah that's right you're right yeah so I don't know like yeah that's that's right it's like that kind of it's statesmanship then it's that like visionary element to like politics which is just

SPEAKER_00totally missing

SPEAKER_01Yeah,

SPEAKER_00and that's why I've always felt like with Zionism, because obviously Zionism is the bogeyman at the moment, right? But as an Australian in particular, right? As an Australian who admires, you said before, like as a Zionist. It's very hard to go and be like well you can't have A homeland And I feel like in the same way As someone who admires The early settlers It's like of course I admire Jabotinsky And Herzl And I would love to have You know 20

Australian men like that you know what I mean because you realize like you have 20 guys like that it's it's that's what you need like you need those visionaries and there is nothing more opposite to that than our current leaders like you could not find anyone more diametrically opposed but yeah maybe um maybe new Australia where

SPEAKER_00would it be in Antarctica The Antarctica I think about I was So don't make me sound Like a nutter But you know I was traveling Through South Africa And Namibia About five years ago Or maybe a bit less now With my family Okay We rode trip for two months around And You know Like Both have Strange Long histories That are very different Colonially You know Namibia was colonized By the Germans You know South Africa has its own history But

SPEAKER_01You know I really just Russell Walter Starr

SPEAKER_01But really, you kind of go to Cape Town and you're like, man, you could rule the world from this place, okay? It is like this decaying Sydney, okay? And, you know, and look, maybe they're the wrong places, but I really think, you know, 100 Russell Walters or something like that could, you know, Russell Walter

SPEAKER_01You know, I don't think it'd be very many people today in practice. I think most of these small societies really, we overestimate the scale of governance. And I think you underestimate the ability of a few men to have a massive impact.

SPEAKER_00Neo-Victoria. I've been writing that we should we should reconkiss to Victoria we should just

SPEAKER_01like take it back like it's

SPEAKER_00Oh, all right. Well, excellent. I reckon, I don't know. That was really fun. It's been, and it's also kind of late where we are now. So yeah, maybe we'll, I didn't actually run to all the topics I wanted to chat to you about, but maybe we'll talk again in six months or a year or so. Yeah, let's do that. I love all your stuff, like your historical writing, especially your writing on Australia. Like I'm always excited to see that. So keep it up. It's, it's, it, like I said, it's unfortunate, like, because I think I myself have written about Australia. I did a full series, a 10 hour podcast on the discovery of Australia.

And it was probably one of the least watched things I ever did, but I love doing it.

SPEAKER_00So someone's going to do it as well. Someone's going to do it.

SPEAKER_01Look, my policy with my Substack is I don't charge for it. Hardly deliberately because, you know, no one's expecting of me. I don't watch, you know, my livelihood doesn't depend on it. You know, deliberately I just write whatever stirs me in the moment and sometimes that's going to be not very popular and sometimes it's going to be more popular and it's a thing to build over decades. And so, you know, I really love, I think Australian history is just inherently super interesting and underrated and

SPEAKER_01I suspect even though my readers don't love it so much, I suspect I'll just keep writing about it. And actually again just like a word of encouragement before we finish stop and I don't know if you saw this this guy Jeff Giesa I think his name is um uh he's associated with Peter Thiel but um he wrote this article it's like the humanities revolution and the basic thesis was that um what has happened is that like Stuff that traditionally went on within the academy is now going on outside of it,

right?

SPEAKER_00And you think about a topic like Australian history, if you were to go into the academy now and learn about Australian history, my God. How, like, how terrible would that be? Like, what would they be talking about? Nothing interesting. So it's actually kind of crazy to think that right now what you're doing is probably really important in that it's not being done within academia. You know what I mean? I mean, actually, I, yeah, another way of reframe what you're saying, like, lots of people write about lots of things on Substack and

elsewhere.

SPEAKER_01How many people are writing about Australian history? Like I'm obviously not the only one. There are others and there are really great people writing a bit, but like, I don't know, a handful, like not many people.

SPEAKER_00I'm Australian and I'm like addicted to Substack. And I, if someone was to ask me like, oh, is there anything good on like Australian history? I would recommend your blog and I wouldn't be able to recommend any others. So it's like, It's an extremely important thing to do because you think Blaney is going to die soon. You know what I mean? There's that quote by Frederick Hayek where it's like old truths always need to be articulated. Russell Walter Steele

Stagnation and there are all these interesting political things going on and there's all this opportunity for Australia like we've kind of been in a bit of a

SPEAKER_01malaise, but we could be so much better off so much wealthier, you know, in going in such a better direction and for me. Russell Walter Steele

SPEAKER_01And yeah, I think, you know, it's these things are always kind of come in waves and I'm sure others will, you know, will enjoy it over time. And we need to take more Zionist inspiration, which is irrigating the interior.

SPEAKER_00We need to terraform the interior. And like in that ambitious Australia article you wrote, it's like we need to start like Dubai cities in like It comes down to agency again.

SPEAKER_01It's like, you know, maybe some of those ideas are dumb, maybe they're uneconomic, maybe they're not worthwhile. Like, you know, we could be doing way more. We need to lift our ambition and I think the world's our oyster.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I agree. I agree. I feel like it's a continent. Who knows? You know what I mean? Who knows what this country could become? Anyway. Thanks again, Russell. We'll catch you soon. Yeah, good convention with you about the poor state of Australian politics.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Complete Normiemaxxing Guide, w/ Drunk Wisconsin.

    Nov 14, 20261 hr 15 minAudio

    In this episode of the Chudstack Review, Drunk Wisconsin and I discuss: * What is the “state school upper middle class,” and why does nobody talk about them? * Are many online voices downwardly mobile elites? * Why...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. German Romanticism & Nazi Hippies, w/Gildhelm

    Oct 1, 20261 hr 8 minAudio

    Gildhelm and I discuss: * Is Christianity a revolt against nature? * Why did the German Romantics turn to nature and the Greeks? * Why did the romantic movement start in Germany? * What does the word “persona” really...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Great Zombiefication & The Decline of Literary Culture, w/Owen Yingling

    Sep 19, 20261 hr 11 minAudio

    Owen Yingling and I discuss: * Have Zoomers been Zombified? * Is it alienating being a highly literate Zoomer? * Why do so many university students care more about credentials than learning? * What is a university...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Studs, Straggots, & Sex-Work

    Sep 7, 20261 hr 25 minAudio

    BUY THE STUD: CLICK THIS LINKLiam and I discuss: * Has market logic colonised family life? * To what extent is surrogacy ethical? * What is Liam’s novel, The Stud, about? * Is post-industrial, white-collar life...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Lions of the West, RISE UP!!! w/Dan Baltic

    Aug 24, 20261 hr 10 minAudio

    Dan Baltic and I discuss: * How political should an author be? * Is Nutcrankr actually a right-wing book? * How much does Nutcrankr owe to A Confederacy of Dunces and Don Quixote? * How autobiographical is Spencer? *...

    Credit the people on this episode