Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Chudstack Review

The Chudstack Review artwork

You Will Not Escape the Permanent Underclass, w/ARX-Han

Jul 14, 20261 hr 22 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

We discuss: * Why is Asian American literature boring? * Can any culture or ideology survive contact with liberalism? * Do MFA programs filter out the “crazy” people who make the best writers? * Are Europeans better writers, and if so, why? * Is literary fiction dying, or just shrinking into a niche “conservatory” art form? * Was it worth it for writers who sacrificed everything and didn’t “make it”? * Does Substack work for serializing fiction, or does it cheapen the work? * Are novelists failing to reckon with how fast AI is changing the world? * Is heroism obsolete now that drones do the fighting? * Will the future split into a genetically/technologically enhanced elite and everyone else? * What is “androgenic fiction” and “new wave fiction” - and who’s writing it? * What was “fratire,” and why can’t it be published anymore? * Is Christ vs. Nietzsche (egalitarianism vs. transhumanism) the next big cultural fault line? * Can the indie Substack lit scene ever produce something truly great, or just modest personal wins? This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit russellwalter.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Okay, welcome back. This is a new - another episode of the Chudstack Review. We're speaking today with ARX Han. I'll just call you Han, I guess. He's a novelist. He's written a book called Incel. I haven't actually read Incel, so we're not going to be speaking about it today, but I have I've ordered it. It. It's on the way. But he's also an essayist, and he has a blog called Decentralized Fiction, which I've been And avidly reading. Reading over the past month, I would say. And yeah, so Han, thank you for coming on.

SPEAKER_00Thank you for having me. I'm always He's interested in doing. Doing podcasts and I see that you have put in the work to read through these essays fairly closely. And, uh... And I have a lot of fun with Being, uh. Into a Obstruse Literary. Literary theory and And kind of just chitchat. Chatting about it. So we're looking forward to getting started here.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so I think let's start with the Asian American literature is boring because liberalism is the mother of all identity shredders and our literary elites Our approval seeking. Seeking strivers. So you yourself Aura, are you? Are, you're a Asian American and the basic contention of this piece, If I was to summarise. Summarize it, is that like, basically, When we think about novels, one of the things that makes novels interesting is character, identity, right?

SPEAKER_01Which is sort of another way of saying identity. But liberalism is the mother of all identity shredders um when we think about Like Asian -Americans in. In particular, Asian-Americans are often described as Model Minority. Minorities. The idea is that they sort of shed All of that. Their previous identity, especially East Asians. They shed all of They previous identity. Identity in So there's nothing really left. And then it's like you can't draw from the soil. You know what I mean? It's like you end up with a the sort of a vapid sort of mass man, right?

SPEAKER_01That's the basic contention, right?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. And so the essay kind of starts with a completely or an apparently tangential data point, which is, Sort of my observation about, quote unquote, the dog that didn't bark as it pertains to the genocide of the Palestinians in Gaza. So, you know, basically, you know, it starts with this analysis of I love 9 -11 as this. This apocal event.

SPEAKER_00You know, I'm a, without placing myself exactly, let's say I'm like roughly a mid-age millennial. So, you know, when 9-11 happens, I'm watching it on TV. I'm watching everybody freak the fuck out and You know, I'm sort of like relatively young and, you know, for me, it's almost like watching a movie. It's like watching, I might as well be watching a Michael Bay thing. Like, I don't even remember being afraid at all. I was just sort of... Thank you. Sort of enraptured by the weight of the moment. And what I find so interesting.

SPEAKER_00Then what I found interesting about that was that we actually didn't see a resurgence of Islamic terrorism, Um, even though. Though we basically watched for one or You know, two years. Years There's children being. Being Mass murder. Murdered and dismembered on a live stream. Uh, with American art. Armaments. And what didn't happen was He's basically young. Young American Muslim men taking up arms against the Americans.

SPEAKER_00American state. And when I started to think about that, that occurred to me that something had actually shifted quite substantially. And my hypothesis was that the reason that, quote unquote, the dog didn't bark Was because liberalism had essentially swallowed Muslim American identity and put them through the identity shredder successfully.

SPEAKER_01You said there was like, and this is so true, which is like, as opposed to being drawn now to jihadism, right? Like international jihadism. Now, All the Muslims. Muslim, like American man or the Muslim in any Western country, right? Like a young Muslim man is instead drawn towards like Andrew Tate, right? Which is itself, you know, like it And it is again, like. Like To describe it as a form of liberalism sounds funny, but in a sense it is.

SPEAKER_01That does represent a form of assimilation, right? Even though he's a bogeyman or whatever, it's like They have been a similar. Assimilated into a version of of West. Western culture. So, Whitney.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, which is entirely hilarious because his own rhetoric, which is Almost maximal. Maximally retarded, is always complaining about the matrix. But of course, You know, what could you do? Could be more subsumed under liberalism Um, then. Then the act of sort of just hedonic maximization, which is a sense and sort of masculine cosplay as almost as like just more as a performative thing than Andrew Tate. In the act of. Right? So yeah, like these guys are not watching speeches from Hassan Nasrallah or something like

SPEAKER_00that. Right there. And, and For me, that was very interesting. And even, let's say they're left-oriented, well, basically, they're just becoming engaged with conventional American left politics, which has become multiracial, which has subsumed the left-hand side of the political spectrum among, let's say, the Muslim American diaspora. So you have, I mean, I'll see you next time. Russell Walter The contemporary figure of Zoran Mandami, obviously, just as another data point. He's not, you know, no matter what, you know, America and Boomer Khan say, he's not a Muslim radical.

SPEAKER_00He's a But he's a progressive. Progressive cosmopolitan leftist, and he is a part of the system. Um, uh. See you next time. He's seeking to reform the system from within, which itself indicates that the system has assimilated that community to its own internal logic. And of course, there could be positive things that come about as a result of that process. But for me, That was, that was. Was so interesting because when I look back on jihadism, In say the early In the 2000s.

SPEAKER_00as this is very profound. Profound and violent counter reaction. Um, if. That could not survive liberalism, then how could the ideological substrate of the East Asian possibly even hope to survive the identity shredder? And so basically my hypothesis is that when the East Asian And, you know, and it basically. Basically when I say East Asian, I'm really Strictly speaking, I just. Essentially referring to Koreans, Japanese, and Chinese, right? And then, okay, maybe we have some ancillary states like,

SPEAKER_00you know, Hong Kong before assimilation or Singapore or Taiwan, et cetera. But let's call it this sort of trinity or Our trifecta of groups. Groupings. You know, these people come here and basically, essentially nothing substantive survives We'll see you next time. With liberalism from the old world. Absolutely nothing. You know, these people don't retain Buddhism. They don't retain What, you know, Mark's. Marxist socialism or whatever, right? Like the things that are retained are subsumed And under... under some combination of I've started seeking.

SPEAKER_00Seeking and the relentless pursuit of techno capital. And And sort of my. My, my, my coda to the piece, you know, that I would argue essentially is that actually, I think Asian American culture, You know what I mean? I think that's a good question. Is It's really just about the. The pursuit of techno capital in so many terms. And it's some combination of that and sort of status acquisition. Thank you, sorry.

SPEAKER_01To interrupt, but even if you think about like unassimilated, like Asians, Like who had. Haven't really like assimilated that well in that they would still have like a very thick Vietnamese. Oh, well, you're speaking about East Asian, but yeah, like it's like I speak about just this This was the example that comes to mind. It's a Chinese guy. He runs a fish and chip shop. It's like he barely speaks English. But even though he hasn't assimilated into the culture, basically what they're doing, like you're saying, is they're being productive. Productive business owners.

SPEAKER_01You know what I mean? Like, so even when, and their children will fully Assimilate in. Into that culture. But yeah, like even when they're quote unquote not assimilated, they are assimilated in that My techno finance. Financial sense.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And I'll, I'll look. Let me double click on that a little bit more because, you know, my contention is that But like. All right. I think fundamentally culture is actually not too dissimilar from technology in that it's made by some small fraction of individuals who within the group, right? And so almost invariably it's produced by elite actors within that particular diaspora group, right? And when you look at Asian American elites, you see an absolutely. Absolute Dearth of support, any type of substantive patronage for the arts.

SPEAKER_00These people, like, I think of a figure like, I mean, everybody loves to shit on this guy, but it's partly because he's so cringe. Uh, like the CEO. CEO of Y Combinator, Gary Tan, he's sort of this like middle-aged elder millennial sort of like pudgy guy. And he's got these glasses and he appears to have sort of Really no interest other than making the number go up where the number is sort of his wallet and technology is just like a mechanism Is, you know.

SPEAKER_00To meet that number. Number go up. Although of course there is some degree of interest in that. And like that to me is sort of the prototypical Asian American elite, which is So, basically people in Silicon Valley who I I mean, what is Mean, what are they really doing for a quote-unquote Asian American culture? The answer is fuck all. Because what they do. Because what they really care about is making the fucking number go up.

SPEAKER_00You know, You have a line that's so

SPEAKER_01relevant to this. This is from the piece. It says, what exactly are We are literary elite. Elites doing, whether male or female, they have comfortable institutional sinecures, white partners, half-white children, They Comfort and Controlled Level. Are homing missiles programmed to seek status. They are speedrunning American assimilation to level up their white adjacency As fast as humans. Humanly possible in a fervent attempt to extinguish their Asian -ness from their own lineal bloodline. How can Confucius survive what jihadism did not?

SPEAKER_01Which is like kind of going back to what we were talking about previously, right? Where it's like okay um jihadists you know what I mean? Like the reason they will they scare us so much Is because because you have people who say what you want You know what I mean? Like, and yeah, it's a great line to think like, okay,

SPEAKER_01even those guys who, like, I think that Islamic extremism probably was at least ideologically more common Um, kind of just off. After 9-11, right? It's like now even that, it's just not happening anymore. Like we're not having these, like These are trains. Trains getting blown up or whatever in Brussels. Like, you know what I mean? That just doesn't seem to be happening anymore.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. And I There are all kinds of interesting reasons for this. In part, I almost think of liberalism as the devouring mother. Right? It's that Part of this is that these people ultimately were offered a place in American society. Right? And I think it's easy. Easy to forget that. You know, in the piece, you know... I talk about there's There's some like female. Female Muslim superhero in the Marvel Cinematic Universe.

SPEAKER_00And And, you know, I think. in the early 2000s. 2000s, we would have kind of thought of that as retarded, right? But under the logic of liberty. Liberalism, it actually fulfilled its purpose. Um, it, it. Even with jihadism too, I think what's really interesting about this is I have a theory that this stuff is very trend-based in part. And most of what we think back to from that era was, I think, Sunni-related extremism.

SPEAKER_00And now actually, the Islamic militaries and paramilitary forces that perform best are actually Shiites. You know, the... So even that balance has really kind of shifted quite substantially. Uh, but with. With regard to the Asian immigrant experience, I just think it's demanding. Demonstrably true that the ideological substrate that is produced there is just comparatively very weak compared to,

SPEAKER_00say, liberalism or American culture. It's just, it is a. a weak ideological substrate. Whatever form it takes, it is not strong. It is not retained. It cannot contain. Contest liberalism. And perhaps nothing can, as far as I can tell, really. Yeah that's this is the better argument

SPEAKER_01right Is the meta argument. Meta-argument of the piece, right, is even jihadism, right, which is probably stronger, right? It's like, Jihadism He can't stand up to live. Liberalism, right? That's basically what you're saying is like these young Muslim kids are turning to Andrew Tate. It's like, yeah, so it's a sort of end of history sort of argument where it's a Fukuyama argument where it's like, effectively liberalism, yeah, like you said, it devours everything. It really is capable of a. assimilating even the most crazy things that you wouldn't think it would be capable

SPEAKER_01of assimilating. It can do that. And do that. And you... This is the classic Nietzschean last man argument. The last man is obviously incapable of producing great art. And it's kind of an interesting question. Is He's a like liberal man. Liberal modernity is it. It currently exists capable of producing anything interesting? And it doesn't really seem like it. I mean, there's... Because I know you're skeptical. Skeptical of the current...

SPEAKER_01Like, this is the kind of state. State of literature. Um, there's actually a good. Good, if you don't mind, sorry, I mean, in that... And I end up recording these things. Things, but you have a great quote here, which is like, think about the level of conscientiousness and psychological formalization that is required to accrue sufficient credentials to get into a modern MFA writing program. The amount of group consensus, always homogenizing, required to get through the struggle session of the modern MFA circle of critique. Here we see a chomps. Chomskyite System of self.

SPEAKER_01Self-selection that's immediately going to select out a lot of chaotic shit disturbers. Basically, you just think about interesting people. Like again, going. Going back to this idea, what is He's unique about it. The novel? It is the fact that it gives you Incredible action. Access to a person's interiority. You can't actually do that in film. You can do the internal monologue. But that can only be done quickly, right? Like if you had full scenes where for 10 minutes, you've got an internal monologue, it actually wouldn't work.

SPEAKER_01Whilst the novel can do that. So we get like this crazy access to someone's interiority. What is going on inside their head? And no other medium really seems capable of doing that yet. I can't think of any. So Really like. Really, It is – then the question becomes, becomes, well, what is going on inside your head? Right. Like, like that needs to be. Be interesting. And in some ways, when we walk down the street, there are people, Well, you know. You go to work with them, and inside their head, they're thinking about killing people.

SPEAKER_01You know what I mean? There are people you work with. You have insane interiorities, right? And those people are actually some of the people who probably make good writers, right? Because they have a rich internal life. And the point that you're making here is that there's a degree of psychoticism. You know what I mean? Like that kind of, uh, that's what draws us to them. But the point you're making here is like the sort of person who goes to school for eight years or whatever it is they spend, like they go to high school then in addition to that, they go and

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I, like. And obviously this is not a Sort of unique. Unique take of mine per se. I think Like, Ashley. Actually this discord. Discourse on Substack around the MFA as a force of Um, professionalization and therefore homogenization Has, has kind of been been going on for the past several years and is now, I think, almost become to an extent a kind of consensus take,

SPEAKER_00even though I don't think it's really shifted things on the ground in Interesting. Terms of who gets published at, say, a conventional practice. Press or like a mainline leader. Literary press, as it were. But The Like the general hypothesis. Hypothesis that I have essentially is that I I think the argument. Artistic failure mode of the Asian American artist is that they basically Um, like. Lapse into this mode where they sort of treat a a career.

SPEAKER_00as a writer. Literary novelist as basically another type a literary novelist has basically another type of sort Sort of of academic standards. Stamp collecting enterprise, as it were, right? And, and if. And of course, the problem with this is that any time you professionalize and institutionalize the production of art, you basically, like, it becomes very hard for, Like, it's... Um, like really short.

SPEAKER_00Sort of Kind of crazy motherfuckers to get shit done, shit through that system, right? And oftentimes it's like the most deranged people And end up writing the most. Most, you know, the best stuff. Now, of course, like, you know, there's some point at which somebody is just too disorganized to actually complete, you know, So like a work that's. That's really compelling and stuff like that, right? And And it's funny, I think I was. Was reading about this and I think it's... So this is this is speculative on my part,

SPEAKER_00but I was reading some Scientific American piece and apparently sort of But the genes that are. Are correlated to artistic creativity when you are also correlated to basically having psychotic disorders, right, where you lose touch with reality. And so, you know, like it might be the case that there's some like optimal trade tradeoff between having these genes that simultaneously make you more creative and more psychotic. Uh, and, and like, like there's like,

SPEAKER_00maybe there's some like intermediate level of having this like latent talent where you like, you don't develop like disabling, Like super cool. Critical mental illness, but you're still like different enough to like, I don't know. Like draw together insights that, um, Are difficult and unusual To draw it together. Together in some way, shape or form. And somewhat related to this, although distinct nonetheless, You know,

SPEAKER_00tell Tao Lin is probably the best known Asian American novelist on the male side, as far as I know. As far as I know, I mean. Some people maybe have sold more books, but aren't really remembered in the same way. Like Chang Ray Lee, I think, isn't really remembered. He's a Korean American novelist. I think he teaches at Yale or something. Um, but um But Tchau, Lynn. Tao You know, has. Has gone public saying that he was diagnosed with autism and stuff. And if you read his books, You know, like it's reflected in the work, but it's reflected in an interesting way.

SPEAKER_00There's just an interesting character to it that you don't see with somebody necessarily who has gone through the system and gone to the right schools and done stuff like that. Um, And I'll sort of pause there.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, dude. Yeah. It's actually interesting you bring this up because I think that that psychoticism idea is associated with the psychologist. I don't know how to pronounce his name. It's like Hans J. Eisenk, right? But he was a pioneer in personality theory. So, you know, like the big five personality He trades the ocean. Ocean model, like that. Oh, interesting. He didn't come up with that, but he came up with the first model that was ultimately supplanted by that. And yeah, he spoke about psychoticism, right, as this trait.

SPEAKER_01And obviously at the excess, you get like literal psychoticism, like, you know, schizophrenia, et cetera. But, you know, you have these, What he considered cyclical. Psychotic individuals Who are extremely dis - disagreeable, neurotic, et cetera. And he thought that that was sort of like the personal personality type of the genius of the creative individual. And this, I'd be interested to see what you think about this, right? Because Um, I've always got to be in. Interested in, you know, And, uh... Artistic accomplishment.

SPEAKER_01I mean, I think it's undeniable that Europeans have just been overrepresented artistic when it comes to like, you know, Cultural accomplishment. Accomplishments. It's one of those Interesting facts of here. History. And I don't think it's just Eurocentrism. I actually think that you can make a very Um, reasonable case for that. That being in the Soh. And you kind of stop and you think about that. It's like, oh, hang on. Like, okay, you think about IQ. I think that it is true that like Chinese have a higher average IQ. And yet That Europeans have. Probably accomplished quite a lot more culturally.

SPEAKER_01And And the thesis made. Maybe is that it's because psychoticism is actually higher among Europeans that they, they're like more disagreeable. Like you think about, even you think about like, uh, Europe's arm. It's a hero. Heroes, like people like Christ and Calvin and, you know, various martyrs, like often they are, or Socrates. It's like the person who stands up against the group, you know, and says no. Um, so these sort of psychotic in a way, highly disagreeable individuals, um, um, And it's almost like what's happening now with these MFA programs He's like that.

SPEAKER_01That sort of archetype is being disprivileged in favor of a more conscientious It's status tribal. Driver.

SPEAKER_00So there's another one. Number of threads there. Look, I think anytime you professionalize That's something. Something And systematizing. Systematize it and it's a creative endeavor, just create some level of... Like you just. Selection and conformity pressure, right? Yeah. Now, Like in terms of the creek. Creativity thing, I'm not sure I agree with that. And I'm not sure how you would even really study that, basically.

SPEAKER_00Because I'll just give you one example. If you look at the diversity of, say, I, Japan's artist. Artistic production. There's like an entire universe there That's, it's obvious. Almost Entirely in Paris. Parallel. Right. So like, I find it kind of hard to metricize this sort of thing because fundamentally that's sort of like an empirical claim. Right. I like, so for me, Hey, I do. Don't really, I haven't really thought of it. Thought about that question of like compare,

SPEAKER_00let's say comparative civilizational cultural, um, And, uh... Production, Like just like sort of like. Of stack ranking them like a basketball game or something like that. I almost, like to me. Me, I think the more interesting question to me that emerges out of that is that the Successful universe. Universalist ideologies have almost entirely come out of the West, as far as I can tell, As far as I can tell.

SPEAKER_00Right? That's great. And And that, like, I think that's interesting. So, I mean, what are the universities? Universalist ideologies, right? Well, broadly speaking, We have the social. Essentially The Russell Walter Substack. Christianity in part, right? Um, and uh that, of course, you know, then gets wrapped into European military, technological, you know, advantages and in turn, imperialism and colonialism. But then, And my feeling feeling,

SPEAKER_00frankly, is that I think liberalism is sort of the secular lineal descendant of Christianity. Obviously, a lot of people have this take. This is not a unique take at all, but I think it's at least directionally correct. So I think like that to me is quite interesting that it seems to me that there's something about whether it's, you know, cultural or, you know, like you can make all kinds of speculation, maybe So, uh... Gene Culture Revolution. Evolution, like who knows, right? But is there something about,

SPEAKER_00say the European populational substrate that is more likely to produce a totalizing and universalist ideological framework. And populational. Framework? That's an interesting thing to speculate on, right? Because, I mean, I guess you could argue, you know, Classical Islam falls into that category, but, you know, that was not paired in the long run with military But, um... Thank you. Technological Technologicals. Supremacy.

SPEAKER_00And so there was like a boundary on like how far that was able to expand. But if you look at the American empire, if you look at, you know, liberalism So, liberalism in. In maybe even the broader sense, then you could argue that that is sort of one in most jurisdictions. All right. Right. And I think I'm even at the point now, theoretically, where I kind of wonder, like, You know, when we say liberalism, is that actually just like techno capital almost, right? Like, you know, I'll give you just one example, right? Like everybody's scrolling on TikTok on smartphones,

SPEAKER_00you know, in the, in the developing world or in lower income countries, these technologies Thank you very much. Uh, I think, you know, even more popular perhaps than they are here because I, you know, I think a phone is sort of like this easier entertainment device to access and, you know, lower income countries and you sort of need money to do other stuff. And, um, what could be More of a distance. Distillation of liberalism than just scrolling, like, you know, women dancing on Tik Tok and, you know, cat videos and stuff like that. Right.

SPEAKER_00And then clicking on the ads to buy things. Right. So There's a lot of theory The That I had to respond with there because I think it does fold into a lot of these like themes that that I've also been thinking about.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, in terms of the basketball metrics, I think that Charles Murray, he wrote a book called Human Accomplishment and he did literally Like quantifier. Quantify it and put all these charts up. And yeah, I understand that it's kind of... It's kind of almost impossible to quantify, but I thought maybe we'd change tune. We might actually talk about this article you wrote, which was. Is sometimes I wish I had it in me, which is talking about your struggles As a sort of artist, like,

SPEAKER_01we have this, in our culture, we have this, like, archetype of, like, the struggling artist. And you talk about Cormac McCarthy as, like, the archetypal example of that. He spent most of his life unsuccessful, poor, just working, fully devoting himself to his craft, his writing. And, um... you know, you yourself, I think you have, like, a sort of, like, a corpo. You have a corporate job. You... But you're a novelist Just on the side. Side and you sort of had this sense like you wish maybe that you had done away

SPEAKER_01with like the comforts of middle class life and it devoted all your energy to your art like Cormac McCarthy, right? That's kind of sort of the thesis of the article.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, I think most people who've taken a serious stab at literature... And not made it You know, he's beautiful. Meaningful sense. And I, just to be clear to Anybody listening on. I fall into that category. You know, like, look, most of us who put a lot of time into a novel, Uh, even, even like. Like by indie standards, you know, it's done quite well. I think I've sold about a thousand copies, which is, And. You know, if you're a self-published literary novelist, that's certainly on the upper end.

SPEAKER_00But But, you know, I'm not sure. Certainly not paying my rent with Amazon Amazon book sales. So, you know, I think. I think a lot of contemporary literary writers Those are are basically just in a state of mourning About the role. Relative loss of stature of the literary arts. Because what's so appealing about the story of McCarthy is that McCarthy ultimately did make it in the end. So McCarthy won. He got a MacArthur G.

SPEAKER_00Genius Grant and Did you use that? That trite Blood Meridian and then Blood Meridian And, you know, yes it's a, yes. It's a Reddit meme book. Yes, everybody's been talking about it now for years and years, but it is extremely good. He is one of the greatest American writers ever. Uh, but But those of us now, I think if you're going to make that level of sacrifice in terms of

SPEAKER_00the material conditions of your life, most of us like We really still are. Only do that if they believe that there's some commensurate reward at the end there, I think. Right? And I think We're just now in a - an era where it's effectively impossible to imagine that even being the case. And I think when we ask ourselves, like, what is, you know, literary fiction? And like, what is that in material terms?

SPEAKER_00What it is basically... What it appears to be is This is a mission. Mish Hobby. Hobby for And I think that's a good question. Um, it's - a small group I've been. Increasingly Aging and L. elderly and irrelevant Millennials live. Living in the city of Manhattan, which demographically skews female because men are Playing video games Or, you know. Or So, longing per. Perps on Hyperliquid or sports gambling or whatever Or whatever the fuck, right?

SPEAKER_00Fuck. There was this period in my life where I took some time off to publish and sell and I put a tremendous amount of effort into it. It basically Was my own publishing company. I spent a good sum to have the cover professionally designed in Japanese anime style, which I thought was a cool idea. I had the book professional. Professionally copyedited, Which was also not. Non-trivial expense. I had the book professionally designed.

SPEAKER_00Now, a lot of the stuff I overpaid for because I think AI can probably do Like stuff like book design. Design really well now and also the copy editor. Copyediting too. At the time, there was... tools were not great and even stuff like Grammarly wasn't that good. So I ended up using a I'm a copy editor, but... but I published it. Ended up using our copy editor, but you know, I The first month, I think I sold like 20 copies or something. And then it was just like, Well, fuck, why did I just spend all these years working my ass off?

SPEAKER_01Well, you spent literally 11 years. I just feel like that would be so demoralizing, like working so hard and And, and get to. To get like 20 sales would just be like so demoralizing. It's interesting because it feels like this This is like a something the paper says. People are talking about right now, the demise of textual culture and the rise of oral culture.

SPEAKER_01And this idea of a second orality and stuff like that, it feels like the reading public will probably not really exist in... You know what I mean? It kind is ceases to exist. And then what does that look like? You know, it's very easy to blackpill, but I actually think in some ways there could be some good in that, like, historically speaking, you know, like people like Tolstoy and all the rest of it, like, who did they write for? They wrote not for a reading public, you know. They wrote for like an one...

SPEAKER_00I think it's true And it is. it will. function. Functionally become a form of elite culture. And number two, I do think this is also at the same time a meaningful loss in terms of the relative stature of literature and In part, a coach. Cope. But I think both of those, You know, I like to think dialogue. Dialectically, let's say, right? Even though I've never read Marx, so I can't claim to be educated on that topic. But here's how I see it, right? All right.

SPEAKER_00Literary fiction is, and And Tony told him. Tony Tamudi, who's an I'll see you next time. Asian American writer, Uh, one of the best Asian American novelists, he wrote this collection called Rejection, which part of it is really exceptional. But He made the comment years ago that literary fiction is becoming a conservatory art form, and I think that's the best metaphor I've encountered, right? So in the same way that people still go to the symphony, but That's some small. Small fraction of the American elite goes to the symphony,

SPEAKER_00or maybe they watch the ballet or something like that, um I don't know. Uh or go to the opera or what have you, I think literary fiction is evolving in that direction simply based on the So, we're going to talk about the... Extraordinary hyper hyper-optimized addictive potential of things like short form video. And As disturbed. Disturbing As the slot. Sloppification of mass culture is, particularly around things like TikTok and the fact

SPEAKER_00that Zoomers are functionally illiterate, I think the truth is, is that there's no way that this is the final form of mass entertainment as an addictive hyper super stimulus, Because we have. Haven't even got to widespread VR adoption yet, or AR adoption, right? Um, when that shit gets. Gets hyper-optimized, people are just going to fucking drop out of base reality, right? And to And to the extent that they reach. Read text, they'll read it inside of a fucking simulation that they're in, right?

SPEAKER_00While they're wearing a headset, right? But all that being said, And I do believe. Believe that in the same way that classical And people still go to this. The symphony because it remains compelling for some small Stata of of, frankly, the elites or Perhaps even the Cog. Cognitive elite in some respect. I don't think literary fiction is ever going to go away, go away. Right. In the same way that people still stay. Stage live plays in New York City.

SPEAKER_00Right. Um It will become a niche conservatory art form for a small group uh. Of individual individuals Those who have high taste. Taste. And um, uh, It will be preserved and it will just not be magical in the way that The late 20s. 20th century was magical for the American novelist. We won't have these titanic figures Over a Hemingway. Hemingway or a Mishima.

SPEAKER_00Of the novel. Novelist as this famous character who's known in mass culture and who appears Appears in magic. Magazine profiles and is photographed and people look at an image of the novelist and they know who that person is, right? You know, yeah, I'm pseudonymous, but nobody would, Nobody, bro. You know, whether or not my face is public is actually irrelevant because nobody fucking reads books anyway. So why, it's like it doesn't even matter, right? Um, and actually that's. That's fine in the sense that it does select for a certain pure,

SPEAKER_00like almost like kind of quasi autistic purist, right? Which is that writing Long -form literature. Literary fiction is He's in a... sense, That makes sense. Particularly when you use a word processor, right? If you're using a word processor, you can add it in real time. It's in some ways analogous to a single player video game. And Justin Murphy, who's an American writer has made this comment. I think it's a very interesting paradigm, but, So, um...

SPEAKER_00Like when you're in a word processor, when you're in a flow state, your ability to shape and mold the text is almost sculptural because you get instant feedback. Yeah. Whereas Even auditors. And on a typewriter. Typewriter, long form of handwriting, it's very hard to make modifications without the actual feedback loop becoming this horribly messy thing. So I think you're, I think what I would say is I think you're half right. I think this is becoming a form of niche and elite culture for a small, high taste group of people.

SPEAKER_00That's a tragedy because we lose the broader mass literary culture from which you had a wider net of individuals from which you could draw out genius. But at the same time, the flame will continue, I think until, you know, the slop singularity hits or whatever.

SPEAKER_01Well, we're just going to bifurcate. There's going to be like two separate races. It's going to be like The long, the people like. People who only let their kids read long form and then there's going to be like the... Yeah, the people are just watching short form. I actually feel like there is He's genuinely like. Genuinely something to that. I'm obviously exaggerating and joking a little bit, but there is this sci-fi element of I I do think it kind of... bifurcation will go on where it's in the same place, you'll have people who are almost extremely different people by virtue of...

SPEAKER_01Yeah, like the sort of media that they're engaging with. But you're right. Actually, all of this is super relevant to the piece you wrote on, like, I think the title is something like we're all science fiction writers now. And you're talking about, And uh, you were twi - just talking about AI.

SPEAKER_00Sorry, give me a moment. I'm going to get the quote up. Yeah, I'm happy to riff on that while you're looking for the quote. But so basically the idea was that Until recently, the novel was written in an era where the rate of technological progress was sufficiently slow that you could spend 1, 1 -3 -4. 10, 20 years on a book even, and the book would be legible Uh, to the people. People reading it. And the point is,

SPEAKER_00point that I make in the article essentially is that it seems to me that we are now entering a historical phase where the rate of technological progress is accelerating so dramatically that if you spend three years writing and rewriting a literary fiction novel, let's say maybe that's like the average length it takes to write some of these books. You know The Basic work. World model that is implicit or explicitly detailed in the text We'll become.

SPEAKER_00Become so irrelevant to the reader that they'll become confused and disoriented when they read it. They'll say, oh, this character went to McDonald's, but they got served by a human instead of a unitary robot. What the fuck is going on? I'm like, this is. Shit doesn't make sense. Why Like, why are they hailing hailing Uber? Why aren't they hailing Waymo? So why are, you know, why? Are there still Uh, customer. Customer support agents in this character? Everybody knows that none of them have jobs anymore.

SPEAKER_00And so So I think, I think. Think essentially what we're about to see, this is my belief, is I think we are about to experience It's a kind of match. Mass future shock to the, to technologically driven unemployment. And I think people are really going to start to just hate technology and to hate these frontier AI labs and to truly despise them. I do, I'm not. I'm not really confident that this will substantively lead to any sort of like

SPEAKER_00I love it. Say like terrorism or anything like that. I think it will large. Largely be a protest movement that is contained within the American political system. You know, people... Staging Town Hall. Halls to prevent data centers from being built in their community. But I think When I think the minute. Minute that the real unemployment starts to hit, and of course, this is still in part a subject of controversy, I think people are going to really start to fucking hate these companies with

SPEAKER_00a passion. And that, of course, will do absolutely nothing because techno capital is unstoppable and it always wins. But as it pertains to literary fiction, And what is prescribed? Prescriptive for me as a writer is I Um, you I. think you kind of just have to write faster now because I think The average American contemporary writer of literary fiction is actually contemptuous of Silicon Valley elites

SPEAKER_00and large language models, AI in general. Broadly speaking, they think it's a scam or a trick or it's just autocomplete. Most of them, I think, don't really use these tools in their work because You know, they don't. Work, say, maybe And even a software. Software adjacent field. You know They work, you know. Work Writing fucking like essays for some magazine You're like, you know, I heard some A. NGO or whatever, right?

SPEAKER_00But they're not like friends with people necessarily who Really, this. Necessarily understand the magnitude of what's happening and they're largely skeptics. And I think we're hitting multiple intersecting And accelerate. Accelerating Sort of technological. Technological growth trajectories or developmental trajectories, primarily AI, of course. uh. But I think this is all happening at a pace that if you're writing a novel about And, uh...

SPEAKER_00having an affair with your creative writing student or something, it's sort of like Um, I think, you know... dinosaur. Dinosaur, like. Uh... You know, writing a novel about some lizard on the ground and, like, there's this giant fucking meteor that's coming. Like, you're kind of missing the point, right? Is what I'm saying, right? And I think it's important to, like... And, look, I'm not a maximalist singulitarian. Like, You know, my timelines are. On when we get to, like, transformative AI are...

SPEAKER_00I have a wide range. Wide uncertainty You know, Boris here. Here, like confidence interval, what have you. I can imagine five years, I can imagine 25 years or something like that. But even if it's 25 years, this is arguably the most important moment in human history. And so if you are making art right now, So, you should be. You should understand what fucking time it is, bro.

SPEAKER_00And that really... I just, sometimes I just want. To shake people. Like, this is an opportunity. Opportunity to document this moment that will never come again and what it was like to be alive now. And you are not fucking. Fucking paying attention because, you know, like your, you're. Contempt for how cringe these people Yeah. Are is blinding you to how serious this moment actually. Actually is for everybody, Including, you know.

SPEAKER_00the word self. Cell class. So, forgive my rant. Rant there, but I think that is kind of where I'm at now on I think we're going to talk a little bit about that on this.

SPEAKER_01It's it's fun. Funny you mention that because I was at the, I was there against mine. My will. I didn't go there willingly. I had a reason for being there, but I was at the Melbourne Writers Festival, right? Which is It's like. As horrible as it seems. Sounds. And anyway, there was this lady, she was talking about her young adult book that had recently been published. And it was set in like a hundred years from now. And the main character was a patriarchy hacker. ha, ha.

SPEAKER_01Anyway, basically it was a patriarchy hacker. So Would it involve? Involved was like getting into people's Neuralink and like, I don't know if she was, I think she was like, you know, deleting the patriarchy from people's Neuralink or something. Anyway, Um, she was like my my character Talks to chat. ChatGPT. And I just thought, it's so funny that you think like a hundred years in the future, like that people will still be talking to ChatGPT. You know what I mean? Like, just that example.

SPEAKER_01of life. Like what you were talking about where it's just like over indexing on the current moment and not seeing like that things are radically going to change and a lot of these things are just going to be totally dated. But the quote that you... Well, and also there was, so there's two quotes from this article that I want to cite. The first is not only are we able to witness the death of popular politics, which only ever existed because of the power of labor and small arms, we're about to witness the death of the average person being able to do Much of anything that matters.

SPEAKER_01And so the point that you were making before about like Um, people hating these. These AI companies, it's like, it actually does not really matter because It's your voice. Voice This actually is going to. And if that is the case, why was the 20th century... Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Then And suddenly, the po - political power just dissipates. And I think that that's like this, I think in a funny way, like you're, I think in that article you talk about how people, when they spoke about artificial intelligence, they're always imagining the robot with the gun that's running around killing people like Terminator. But like the more in a way like grim reality is it's like, We're just going to have to deal with the, like, the obsolete. Obsolescence of humanity. Like, that is something within our lifetime that we will probably have to grapple with is,

SPEAKER_01like, our own obsolescence. Not just in the economic sphere or the warfare sphere, but, like, even perhaps, like, creative spheres, which is really depressing. Yeah. And you're so right. It's like, I think about like the smartphone. I don't know if I'm misremembering, but I do remember when the smartphone came out and I felt like the mood was generally optimistic where it was like, hey, you can listen to music and you can play games and you can get in contact with your friends. And there was a sense it was like actually like an unalloyed kind of gourd.

SPEAKER_01And it's funny how. How now, the fact is we're We're really in the earth. Early stages of AI adoption And, um... already? Already there's a kind of Like widespread pest. Pessimism and it's like, how much more intense is that going to become As AI acts. Actually begins to really become part of our life?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, So, I... Man, I have so much to say here because there is just so much to say, right? So, I think what - one thing is that I don't know. Think we will look back on the 20th century As this. As a brief and atypical interregnum period We're... The Cog. Confluence The Russell Walter Substack. Basically A small arm. Arms and human intensive industrial manufacturing briefly made mass political movements

SPEAKER_00like possible or something like that, right? And then everything since then has been sort of like downhill in terms of the dispersion and distribution of power and the trend has been towards power concentration, right? uh. And I think human disempowerment is He's obviously... Obviously, completely locked in techno historically right now. It's just it's completely obvious that it's just like it is absolute lock in.

SPEAKER_00And I think the question is only how far does it go? I I mean, I am certain. Certainly inclined to have a sort of like Landian take on this, which is that it goes into a post human future. Or, you know, eventually I don't know. Don't know how long it takes to get there. I don't know what the shape of that trajectory is. I Like, I think the... the, the. The blowback has not really even begun at all, Yeah, I think.

SPEAKER_00Think, because we have not seen the Mass Unemployed. Unemployment yet. If and when that happens, that is the inflection point. And just as you said, it will not matter because nothing can stop this train. It is inexorable. It is inevitable. It is a locomotive that goes faster the longer that it runs. Take a look at... This horrifying FPV footage From the word.

SPEAKER_00In Ukraine and That and. Look me in the eye and tell me that a human bipedal Bipedal Soul. Soldier with a rifle will still be relevant in five or 10 years. It's ridiculous. Of course not. You know, I have this argument. Argument where I make that the era of bipedal Herobrine. Bipedal heroism is over. And I think that's what we're talking about. And what I mean by that, that is technology will fucking delete human heroism. There will literally be nothing heroic that you can do because

SPEAKER_00a quadrocopter will come at you at 200 miles an hour and blow So, into a... you And to meet. Into a meat cloud, right? Show me your heroism then. What's that going to do for anybody? Right? Nothing is the answer. Yes, this is a very pessimistic view, but I just don't understand how anything other than that could take place. It's why

SPEAKER_01in June, they had to come up with this. Yes, yes. Of like this weird shield that for whatever reason, swords and daggers can pierce the shield but ammunition can't because I think that Frank Herbert realized that you can't have heroism. Like, like the- Like true heroism was like man -to -man combat with swords, you man know, what I mean? And then when You know what I mean?

SPEAKER_01It's not actually, you know what I mean? This doesn't end the way that you think it does, you know what I mean? Because we're just living in a totally different Um, technological. Technological, you know what I mean? Like a world. But the thing is, okay, so this is extremely blackpilling. I think, I think what we. I agree with you completely, but So, I want to end because I. because I I think we have. We've almost been for an hour. So I do want to end on a more optimistic Optimistic, Note. So we're talking now about the concentration of power, the centralization of power.

SPEAKER_01But we can see that there are some cracks, right? When we look at the publishing industry, it's clear that people are recognizing this It's centralized. Fiction has issues like the MFA programs and the state of just contemporary literature is in shambles. And your blog is called Decentralized Fiction. And you speak a lot about like, so I believe it's called New Wave Fiction and Androgenic Fiction. And this is a more like optimistic note. You've clearly identified like, yes, power is centralized, but it's clear that there is room for a sort of avant-garde or like

SPEAKER_01a rearguard action now in like literary world. So yeah, talk to us a little bit about like, what is New Wave Fiction? What is Androgenic Fiction? Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, for sure. So this is really just me sort of trying to identify a kind of taxonomy to describe works that I've seen and that I think have been neglected

SPEAKER_01in some sense.

SPEAKER_00So androgenic fiction essentially is fiction And that. Directly and unflinchingly grapples with male interiority. In a way that is not subject to, say, gatekeeper censorship. And, you know, just as you alluded to earlier, you know, when we look at the interiority of people just in general, right, I think that because of this sort of selective filters that exist in the uh.

SPEAKER_00The, you know. You know, traditional publishing apparatus. It's just really hard to write about maleness in general in a very frank and brutally honest fashion, right? And here and there, Books will sum. Sometimes slip through like Flesh by David Soloy was a traditionally published novel that I tremendously enjoyed lately. But in the American context, first of all, he's a UK writer. And second of all, in the American context, It's been, And, you know, I think our.

SPEAKER_00Very, very long time Since we we've seen somebody like Brady Snellis get able to get published and get substantial literary backing. And part of that is not necessarily just censorship, but part of that also, I think, is the retreat of males into Alternative Alternative pastors. Passwords. Pastimes, things like video games. So I don't want to put all. All the blame Thank you. At, you know, So the. The cultural opera. Apparatus per se. Now, energetic. Fiction, I think, is kind of experiencing some degree of resurgence And just.

SPEAKER_00niche. Niche online literary circles. Most people know, for example, about like delicious tacos and, you know, writers of, you know, that sort. Adam was Reinspecs wrote Wrote a great book called Mixtape Hyperborea. And that was a book about basically the experience of being a sort of late teenage male. And new way fiction It is - This is another... category, concept category that I've come to. And I think this is perhaps a bit more counterintuitive,

SPEAKER_00but the idea here essentially is, is that And I think that's a good question. I I have, I have the. The feeling that people are very burnt out of the culture wars in the Western setting and People are kind of just talking. Tired about arguing about a lot of this stuff. And New way fiction essentially is It's a fiction that is not. Not concern itself with either I don't know. Great question. Leading edge secular progressive values, i.e. it does not concern itself with affirming these values through a sort

SPEAKER_00of moral didacticism in a literary novel, but neither is it The, uh, director. Direct reaction to those values either in the sort of conventional reactionary sense. Right And so it's kind of hitting it on a perpendicular side and saying, you know, this framing is being rejected entirely. And so I would say probably the clearest writer that I feel false. Falls into this category Uh, is a contemporary. Contemporary of mine by the name of Cairo Smith.

SPEAKER_00He's quite a prodigous writer. I recently reviewed his book Scene Bucks. I just bought that.

SPEAKER_01I actually just bought it alongside your book. And then I bought Nutcrank cast. So Yeah, I bought them. Those three.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so I'd say so I'm glad you cited both of them. So Nutcranker by Dan Baltic. Baltic is a good friend of mine and Uh, think a very talented satirist, so So Nutcranker is a perfect example of androgenic fiction. And I think Cairo Smith's Scene Box is a great example of new wave fiction, and he has a number There's a number of new ways. And he has a number of works that I think are very interesting. I also read a book of his called Burn Zone recently that I thought was quite interesting.

SPEAKER_00It was almost like a Netflix. It was like a good Netflix episode. It's more of like a short snappy read. But But here's the, here's. Here's the framing that I'll leave you with. I suspect that the next evolution of cultural conflict, let's say, Well, ultimately. Ultimately be between Christ versus Nietzsche. All right. And what I mean by this basically is that if we take the egalitarianism intrinsic

SPEAKER_00to liberalism. Um, uh, and And we mutate that over time and you subtract the divinity from, sorry, You subtract it. The divinity from Christianity and you have sort of like a Christian moral scaffolding, which is essentially a form of egalitarianism. I, my intuition. Intuition is that that is sort of modern progressivism in part. And conversely, I think when you take a sort of Nietzschean worldview, and I know very little about Nietzschean, so I want to be Constrained Constrained in what I'm doing. What I say about this,

SPEAKER_00but let's just take this like very general And that's the whole idea of of And that's sort of, Um, sort of. Of human enhancement and whether through biotechnology or technology, essentially a form of Silicon Valley transhumanism. I have a strong intuition that this will ultimately be sort of the new axis of conflict in that you will have both the right wing reaction and a left wing reaction to uh... Basically, transhumanist technologies,

SPEAKER_00whether that's mind uploading or biotechnological enhancement that come out of the Silicon Valley elite. And I think that this conflict, this tension will be very fertile ground for artistic Exploration, Particularly in Literature. And I think we are starting to see, I think some novels and some writing enter into that vein that is not just a kind of science fiction parable Terrible that would. What the future might look like, but a deeper examination of the tension between the human impulse toward egalitarianism and the human impulse towards transcendence using technology.

SPEAKER_00And so that is kind of like my next area of interest, my next area of inquiry. And I hope to write a shorter novel That hits this theme perhaps by end of year, but we'll see.

SPEAKER_01That's extremely interesting because I've been thinking about similar things. This is where the right left thing does begin to break down because And you could say that... that the difference between right and left is simply how they view equality, right? So you could say that like the right values quality, The Left Value. Values equality. That works To a degree. Right. But then you recognize that conversely, right. Among many right-wing people, there is a kind of Conservatives.

SPEAKER_01Conservatism, a humanism, Um, a sort of. Of distaste for transhumanism. Right. Um, and that. And So, and that all. Also exists on the left though, as well, because I've been toying with this essay idea. I don't know if I'm going to write it, but it was going to be called like the new, new left. Right. And it was basically going to be like trying to speculate like the left right now is very demoralized And they don't... it feels like maybe that. They themselves are not animated by their own, you know, They themselves saw.

SPEAKER_01Sort of feel like they're not as confident, right? So it's kind of like what happens next? And I sort of had this, there's a philosopher called Peter Singer, he's Australian.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'm Yep, I'm aware of that. Him.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, he wrote a book called Left Darwinism. And his point is... point was that like, it's naive to deny like the truth of Darwinism, right? And what we need to do instead is embrace Darwinism. And like you, I haven't actually... I haven't fully read the thing, but I had this idea of like, imagine a left that sort of recognizes, you know, there are IQ differences between groups and there's IQ differences between people, but we're creating this technology that may actually eliminate all of that.

SPEAKER_01And like with this technology is actually He used in it. An egalitarian way to actually bring about a kind of Homogeneize. Homogenized individual, right? Like where there is no differences in intelligence and Is that where this goes? Or instead, is there a small group of people who kind of control the means of production, namely, you know, the artificial intelligence companies, and They, you. Use that well. Wealth to then enhance themselves and sort of speciate. And it becomes something totally different, like gods among men.

SPEAKER_01You know what I mean? So this is like two competing visions. Or then do you have like a sort of Luddite, a Neo-Luddite Left -wing reaction. Reaction where it's like sort of against capitalism? Or do you have like a Yemen sort of, you know what I mean? Like it's so interesting because I think that politics ultimately, I'm not a Marxist, but I do think, or a Hegelian or whatever, but I do think that That politics is large. Largely downstream of technology. I mean, And when I realized. Realized this, I just kind of realized a lot of this ideological Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Argument is irrelevant because you can say, why All, like, like. Are women in the workplace? Is it because feminism? It's like kind of, but actually a big reason that women are in the work place is because we live in a post -industrial knowledge economy. And say what you want, it's like women actually do very well. People have this idea which is totally naive that the reason that men under the age of... My friend told me the other day, I don't know if this is true, but he said that women under the

SPEAKER_01And the reason - Yeah. It's downstream of technology, but yeah, it's very fertile territory.

SPEAKER_01Um, it's interesting to think about like, where does this go and what does the reaction look like?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So this is, this is, I think the central question of our age, right? Which is that, um, Thank you. Because we exist under conditions of rapid technological change, and because the technology itself For, be. It seems in. In large part to over determine the political structures, which, by the way, is a hypothesis that I broadly agree with.

SPEAKER_00You know, like. Just as a sidebar, the night was like the invincible tank of its era. Right? It's like You know, you could be a peasant and you could be great at sword fighting, but But the night we're still going to... kill you because the knight is basically the tank equivalent. You know, and then the crossbow comes along. And then shortly after that, we have mass politics, right? Because any idiot can fire a crossbow. So So look, might be. Base case basically is that, But, um... you know, wealth inequality becomes incredibly extreme because power accrues to You, uh...

SPEAKER_00The people with the best AIs and this creates a self-reinforcing loop. Hilariously enough, I think the greatest hope that we have against this outcome is that the Chinese continue to produce open source AI and And, you know, these open source sites. And, you know. AIs are kind of fast follow the So, the American frontier. Frontier labs in terms of capability so that they never get this overwhelming advantage. But A lot of people who follow the space believe

SPEAKER_00in things like recursive self-improvement and that the top lab will eventually break away very, very quickly. And, you know. Know, You know, quote unquote achieved. Achieve ASI or artificial super intelligence. And then sort of But you have this. Have this one dominant power and you live in, you know, like basically the American national security state fuses with Silicon Valley and captures the entire light cone for all eternity. Like, you know, maybe that will happen. You know, I don't know. But I just I just so I have a lot of uncertainty about like how power concentration occurs.

SPEAKER_00But my directional bias is This is, unfortunately, fairly. Fairly pessimistic in this regard in that I do suspect that we will have extreme power concentration because of AIs. I do, I do. And also believe that there may be a phase where Silicon Valley elites enhance themselves genetically And I, I just. Uh, you. Using You know, Frontier Bio. Biotech tools and things of that nature, again, to maintain They're sort of lead in the game of techno capital relative

SPEAKER_00to other humans. But, you know, maybe AI progresses so quickly that the biological substrate just simply doesn't matter on a relevant time scale because, you know, think about it now, right? Like if you genetically engineer your kid to be von Neumann, it's going to take him You know, it'll take him like... 12, 15 years to produce anything useful. Even when von Neumann was 12, I don't I don't know how much. Many amazing discoveries he made. He probably had to be a teenager before he was doing any useful work. I don't know.

SPEAKER_00But You know, that like. We're probably well past AGI at that point on that kind of timescale. So it's not even clear to me that the genetic enhancement stuff will even matter. If, if. If timelines are short, of course, it does matter if timelines are long, right?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, that was like the June, because the June vision, right? Like Frank Herbert's vision was like eugenics as like a kind of A humanitarian. Humanitarian alternative to artificial intelligence. And that sort of struck me as like kind of Yeah, like a more inspiring vision of the future where, you know, you've I've been, um. Got You know, the Benny Jezzer. Gesserit and they're like, you know, thinking in terms of thousand years. But yeah, how on earth would that be capable of competing with something like AGI?

SPEAKER_01I mean, I don't know. But yeah, it is very interesting. I'm sorry, I think I probably need to go soon, but I want to actually ask you just quickly. This is more like a quick fight question. Yeah. What are your thoughts And, um. serialized. Serializing novels on Substack? If If, if like think about what we. We've been talking about, like things are moving so quickly. Is there a benefit to serialization? Thank you.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So very quickly, I think this is a highly Any particular writer particularized question about how it does fiction does on Substack. I'd say two things. Number one, I don't think Substack is a good medium for publishing fiction, generally speaking, and for long form fiction in particular. And I'm not convinced serialization is good In, uh... Substack in particular. I I don't know why that is, but I just haven't really seen it work.

SPEAKER_00I think the odd short story will do well, but I think serialization, I don't know why. I haven't thought about this deeply, but I think it just doesn't work. The only time I've seen serialization work for online novels well is basically various forms of fantasy slot that people write. All right. Or like romance, fantasy, slop, or like shit like that. And they're like dedicated websites where people just read that almost like the way that they read magas and stuff, right?

SPEAKER_00So So I, I, uh. What I have anecdotally seen is that I suspect the actual U -Axive Substack. Substack makes the text feel cheaper than it truly is. Yep. And that it's really just hard to get people to value it. And I think actually we want to go the opposite direction. I think we want to promote on Substack, but I think we want to actually sell physical analog books. And that will increasingly actually be the charm of the form. And people even now are performatively reading in New York City, right?

SPEAKER_00You know, they want to be seen with infinite jest, right? So, you know, I think that's kind of the direction I'd encourage you to And other writers to go into if they're working on literary fiction. uh... Because I I just feel like the knowledge novel What is meant to be. Be a stack of pages. And that's my view.

SPEAKER_01All right. Another quickfire question. I mean, you've mentioned Cairo Smith. Yeah. Who else is some like self-published authors? And also, Um, actually yeah. Yeah, just to answer that, I've got one more question after that.

SPEAKER_00Sure. Yeah. Oh gosh. That's a good question. So So I've done a bunch of things. Bunch. So self-published.

SPEAKER_01Or indie publishing. It doesn't need to be self-published. Indie publishing. Something like Nutcranker, Scene Marks, things like that.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's a good one. So it's funny I haven't been I haven't been asked for recommendations in a while and most of what I've read lately has has been more sort of contemporary but let me let me just think so. So, um. So if we're we're if we're thinking indie. Andy, I would look at stuff. Stuff from New Ritual Press with Dan Baltic and Matt Pegas leading the mass Masked there, Matt Paik. Pegas did write an interesting book Uh, called Dragon Day. Day, which was kind of like in our sphere.

SPEAKER_00I did think that that was quite interesting. Um, yeah. And And I've heard a lot of good things about a book called Fedbook. Which I haven't yet personally read. Basically, it's a book about the American national security state. And I think my understanding is that it sort of harkens back to some of the, let's call them for now at least, conspiracy theories as it pertains to the Oklahoma City bombing. So, The Russell Walter

SPEAKER_00But wraps into a broader critique of basically the American Nationals. National security state and It's it's it's ability to, let's say, encourage certain acts of terrorism under certain certain conditions. The one shout out that I would give for this in terms of recommendations is there's a podcast called the He's sidebar literary podcast. And But these guys put in. In some really, really high effort book reviews for indie fiction in this sphere.

SPEAKER_00And I would strongly recommend checking them out because they do a lot of good, very good work in the sense that they put the time in to deeply read these authors and to provide very thorough critiques.

SPEAKER_01All right. Two more questions, actually. So it's like, what? What is fratire?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so Fratire was this brief American micro genre. And essentially, it was, you know, it was essentially like Tucker Max books. So I don't know if you so Tucker Max was basically this American male satirist. And this was in this kind of Uh, Kind of raunchy era of culture in the late 2000s.

SPEAKER_00And he just wrote a bunch of You know, various highly. Highly sexualized stories about being a promiscuous American male. And then Chad called. Koltzkin wrote a book that was similar to this called The Average American Male, which I would encourage you to take a look at it because it's remarkably graphic in its depiction of male sexuality and desire. And it's very interesting as a historical artifact because only a couple of years later did it become functionally impossible to publish a novel in

SPEAKER_00that vein, which arguably was a very androgenic novel. Does that answer your question?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. Yep, yep. And the last one is, so we talk about Substack, right? So you're skeptical about serialization. But do you think, like, how bullish are you on this, like, old scene? Like, Mat -Matthew Sinny? Sinney, I don't know if you know here. Him, But yeah. He runs It's a podcast. A podcast called The Getting Lit Podcast. And then there's all of these other kind of figures like, you know, the Neopaseism block, Justin Isis. There's people like dan baltic and the new ritual press

SPEAKER_01And I feel like what I'm noticing is everyone is kind of promoting each other. It feels like even though So, there's not. much institution. Institutional backing, it's almost like you're getting like something like a A scene on. Online. Um, do you feel like. Like this scene could almost Like, Um, kind of like. Like, like for. For these emerging writers on Substack, do you feel like this could actually be something? Obviously, It's not going to be messy. Massive amounts of money or anything like that, but do you feel like it can give people some hope for a degree of success online?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so So I, you're asking to. Two interesting questions here, I think. The first is, can this ever become a scene that really, say, matters in some sense? And the second of all is, can people achieve limited success within this niche scene? My answer to the question. Part two is an unambiguous yes, in that I So I think without this. This scene, I would have sold... That's 50 bucks. Books and with the scene and in particular with Substack. And by the way, the scene is only possible because of Substack.

SPEAKER_00And I'm grateful to Substack. Substack for making that possible. But this scene is really held together by Substack as a social network, if you look at it closely. And I do think that there has people are making good, honest, good faith efforts to make good work and to have literary magazines and to have events and to have parties in New York City and stuff like that. And I salute all of it. You know, I just I just had a piece about the permanent underclass in Anthony Marable. Marigold's Non Grata magazine, which We'll be coming out on soon.

SPEAKER_00Substack Yeah, shortly after. After this is recorded. The Russell Walter Substack. The first question is the more interesting question, which is, Will this seem scene be historically important in some Sticks. Sense? And I think there's two ways to think about that. Number one, in terms of macro impact, is that will there be a breakout hit novel that somehow gets into mass culture? I think probably not. All I'll tell you. Say very unlikely not,

SPEAKER_00although there's one Asian American writer who I think might do it, but I'm not going to name him yet uh... his book book isn't out yet. Yet. But I think the And the real question is, is, will this scene produce It's a... serious, Substantive literature. Literary work that is considered a great literary work? Either Contemporary. Contemporaneously or some short period of time after it is released. And And I am, I am.

SPEAKER_00Am hopeful that it will, All right. But it remains to be seen. And I would say I think maybe. Maybe. I would say Maybe, Slap. Slash ideally. Thank you. Um, I think it is absolutely the case that good works have been produced by this scene, right? So I think the scene has produced good works. Has it produced a truly great work yet? I think the answer is no, but I am hopeful and optimistic that one among us can do it. I think, I think.

SPEAKER_00An optimistic case is one among us could achieve that level of greatness. I don't know who it will be, but I think it is possible.

SPEAKER_01All right, Han, thank you so much. Great conversation. I think we'll end on that optimistic note as opposed to everything you do. Nothing is going to matter. All right. Thanks so much, brother. I appreciate it. Thank you.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Complete Normiemaxxing Guide, w/ Drunk Wisconsin.

    Nov 14, 20261 hr 15 minAudio

    In this episode of the Chudstack Review, Drunk Wisconsin and I discuss: * What is the “state school upper middle class,” and why does nobody talk about them? * Are many online voices downwardly mobile elites? * Why...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. German Romanticism & Nazi Hippies, w/Gildhelm

    Oct 1, 20261 hr 8 minAudio

    Gildhelm and I discuss: * Is Christianity a revolt against nature? * Why did the German Romantics turn to nature and the Greeks? * Why did the romantic movement start in Germany? * What does the word “persona” really...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Great Zombiefication & The Decline of Literary Culture, w/Owen Yingling

    Sep 19, 20261 hr 11 minAudio

    Owen Yingling and I discuss: * Have Zoomers been Zombified? * Is it alienating being a highly literate Zoomer? * Why do so many university students care more about credentials than learning? * What is a university...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Studs, Straggots, & Sex-Work

    Sep 7, 20261 hr 25 minAudio

    BUY THE STUD: CLICK THIS LINKLiam and I discuss: * Has market logic colonised family life? * To what extent is surrogacy ethical? * What is Liam’s novel, The Stud, about? * Is post-industrial, white-collar life...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Lions of the West, RISE UP!!! w/Dan Baltic

    Aug 24, 20261 hr 10 minAudio

    Dan Baltic and I discuss: * How political should an author be? * Is Nutcrankr actually a right-wing book? * How much does Nutcrankr owe to A Confederacy of Dunces and Don Quixote? * How autobiographical is Spencer? *...

    Credit the people on this episode