Galen Wolfe-Pauly, CEO and co-founder of Tlon, pops into the Buntzcast for a deep dive into the promise of a decentralized internet. Tlon Inc. is developing the Urbit computing platform, which moves away from the internet’s current state of sclerotic capture, in which tech giants use the centralized internet to their advantage, owning and selling your data and relentlessly seeking to devour your attention. Galen discusses how Tlon lets users own their own servers and maintain control over their data. Thanks for reading The Muted Trumpet! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work. We also talk about finding beauty in software, how Tlon is like a Japanese homeware store, whether Tlon is really “neo-feudalism,” and how we’ve been discovering new music and books online. We also touch on the origin of the name “Tlon” in the work of the great Argentinian writer, Jorge Luis Borges. If you’re interested in signing up for Tlon and accessing a new “tool of conviviality,” the messaging app Tlon Messenger, you can join here: tlon.io/buntz Links to some books mentioned in the episode: Tools of Conviviality by Ivan Illich: https://a.co/d/9kWZCWr Deschooling Society by Ivan Illich: https://a.co/d/52wh3i8 This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit sambuntz.substack.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01I might be too stupid for Silicon Valley.
SPEAKER_00I doubt that. I feel like one thing that's interesting about Silicon Valley, to get this podcast off on kind of a random note, I feel like when the people who move out there, they tend to be more left-brained, colloquially speaking. But then when they move to Silicon Valley, they do become more Californian. They become more mystical. not mystical per se, but like maybe more like, you know, like, uh, like on the show Silicon Valley where the one tech founder had
a spiritual advisor.
SPEAKER_00They get excellent. They get excellent. Yeah. That's exactly what I'm trying to say.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Uh, yes, that, and they like learn to love to eat Mexican food or whatever. Um, uh, it's like, they kind of go hand in hand. You, you just self-realization and burritos. It's like part of the, part of the deal. Um, I'm from here for what it's worth. So I didn't. This is just like how I grew up. Yeah. But I know what you're talking about.
SPEAKER_00And with that, the extreme makeover that Zuck went through, I feel like that was like the full transition from Northeastern to California.
SPEAKER_01You think he's, yeah, but he's kind of like Southern. It's like a Southern California thing, right? Kind of.
SPEAKER_00I don't know. It's like a member of the band sublime or something like that.
SPEAKER_01That's a good idea. Or, or it has a, it feels very like Bieber influenced or, you know, it's like, it's very LA. It's like, to me, I don't know. I don't know if I'm reading that correctly.
SPEAKER_00Bieber influenced. Yeah. That sounds right. Maybe they're friends, you know, but you've grown, you've grown up there. You're a Bay area guy.
SPEAKER_01Yes. I, well, I did like middle and high school here kind of at the edge of, in like rural, like an hour and a half from San Francisco. So, um, like, uh, South of Santa Cruz. Uh, and I left for 20 years. I didn't think I would ever come back here for a long time. And then, yeah, have since slowly, I was in San Francisco before this and now I'm back kind of close to where I grew up. Um, uh, and I honestly love it. I think I'll probably be here forever.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I got to get out there.
SPEAKER_00I've never been, honestly. That's crazy. Where are you from? I'm from Scranton, Pennsylvania, originally. So I grew up there, went to school in New England, lived in New England for another five years, I think, after school. Yeah, so. What prior to Chicago? Work. I was working for an immigration law firm here. Interesting. I think we all got replaced by AI or something though.
SPEAKER_01I don't think we're quite there yet.
SPEAKER_00Maybe not. Well, people have been jumping the gun, right? And then being like, we're sorry. We're inviting you all back. Like Farna did that. And I think IBM did that, right? They were like firing everyone and then they were like, wait.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it feels a little, I mean, they are useful tools, but I think that that, you know, when you're in Silicon Valley, you really get familiar with the difference between when you're being pitched something and like the reality of the thing. Um, and I do feel like the AI discourse is like people responding to the pitch and not to the thing, you know, like, um, like AGI is the pitch, you know, it's a good pitch. Like the AGI market is a big market, but there's a big difference between our ability to actually
deliver that as a
SPEAKER_01product. And, um, you know, what these companies are actually doing, uh, I'm still unsure how we're actually going to get there.
SPEAKER_00Well, the way Walt pitched Talon to me, I thought was really attractive and really good because he was saying that the centralized way in which the internet is currently configured tends to just maximize user engagement and keep you constantly looking for more You know, I mean, he didn't say dopamine hits, but I guess that's kind of what you're constantly getting addicted to. Whereas with Tlan and Tlan Messenger, you're trying to create a more organic feeling internet that
will sort of maybe
SPEAKER_00connect to the real world and to real life communities.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you can think of us as a that's a good that's a great summary. I the way I like highest level, I think I just want to build beautiful software. And so that's kind of, I think that's the, I'm going to botch the actual formal mission statement, but you know, Talon exists to build beautiful software is the way I think about it. And that is, I think actually somewhat against the grain because most software is built to,
SPEAKER_01you know, kind of capture the largest market possible as fast as possible with the most people spending the most time doing the most stuff, you know? And yeah, I don't think what that mission would have been even taken seriously 20, 30 years ago or whatever, because we hadn't made software like such a huge part of every part of our life, you know, and because it's just such... ubiquitous infrastructure for how we communicate and stay connected.
SPEAKER_01It's possible now to say, well, what if we just built, you know, tools that did exactly what they said they did and serve what people want? I think that at least that's, I think that's possible. It's still like, obviously it's a long project, but as a company, I feel like the company is still really young. And so, yeah, we build the first product there is just, it's just a messenger. just lets you talk to people. There's no algorithm, there's no ads, there's no spying. It is very, you know, built from scratch to make this promise that you own the thing,
SPEAKER_01you can always own the thing, you can keep it forever, you can hand it to your grandkids. It's a very different way of thinking about what software should be. Just, it's a tool, just use it, do what you need to do. So yeah, I guess I'm Maybe being from here, I'm so jaded by the pitch version of software or whatever, right? That I want our pitch to just be true and not to be so hyperbolic that it maybe is disconnected from the thing that we make.
SPEAKER_01But yeah, that's what we're up to. It's still a very young thing, I think. That's how it feels to me. But you can, I mean, you can use it. We use it every day. Like it works. I just mean that in terms of the holistic vision of what I would like to be able to pull off. It's like, I feel like I'm just getting started.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And how did you get involved in this? Like what to, just to back up a little bit, like what was your trajectory after leaving the Bay area for 20 years and how did you ultimately find yourself in involved in fun? Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Is this a, is this a Joe Rogan length podcast or, um, no, I guess not. I'm just kidding. Uh, like that's a lot. It's all, I'll do my best to shorten it. Um, I, uh, so yeah, I, I, I grew up actually like on the early internet and around a lot of kind of cypherpunk, like people who were, um, interested in the types of sort of privacy and freedom, uh, stuff that I'm still, and, or I ended up surrounded with again. Um, But when I was a kid, I felt like, man, the real world is elsewhere.
SPEAKER_01I live in the boonies. These crazy people are on the fringe of the world. So I spent quite a long time in New York City. I studied architecture there. I was like, very much interested in designing and making things and just kind of figuring out how to do that, I guess, in the highest throughput way possible. I mean, I guess I went to school for architecture because I felt like that was the oldest design discipline. So I wanted to understand kind of how have people thought about making things and making things kind of for communities,
SPEAKER_01for society at large for the longest period of time. And I do think architecture is really like kind of the oldest continuous discipline that's concerned with that. But I was always building, I kind of could never stop building software. Sometimes out of necessity, because it's a great way to pay my rent. And also because I found it really interesting and really fast. Software, if you're, you know, by comparison, right, can take a decade to get a building built. You know, you and I can build something right now,
especially with the tools available today.
SPEAKER_01But even before all this stuff, you know, it's just so, The iteration time's amazing. If you're a designer, you like making stuff, which is definitely me. Software, by comparison to physical stuff, is just incredible. So yeah, I spent my early career in kind of like agency, doing a lot of different, just building websites and software, many different kinds. It was around kind of entrepreneurial stuff and helping people start businesses. And then I felt like I could start it. If I looked at software, maybe the way I think about it would be
If I looked at software as an architect, so purely just, hey, how is this thing structured?
SPEAKER_01How does it fit together? What are the consequences of how we build software? Meaning, when I build something for people to use, I have to stand up a server. Everyone connects to that server. I become the sort of benevolent dictator of that thing. I decide everything for all of those users. I felt like, hmm, that's... That just doesn't really make sense. That can't make sense. It is structurally incorrect. Turns out that's a hard problem.
SPEAKER_01So if you want to change that and say, no, actually, there shouldn't be one person in charge of how the software is delivered to people over the network. Instead, everybody should be able to run their own computer on the network. That, which is what I grew up with, right? That's how the early internet was. My PC connected to your PC. We end up with servers in between, right? Yeah. But looking at this client-server model, I thought, this is totally broken. This doesn't make any sense. You have to kind of rebuild it from scratch. That's a huge proposition that I spent a long time working on,
working on Erbit.
SPEAKER_01So the first problem was like, hey, can you build a user-centric platform where every user runs their own node? All those nodes connect to each other peer-to-peer. Everybody actually owns those things cryptographically. And yeah, you build a system from scratch that actually is designed to just host applications for people, not necessarily to do like what a Linux server does, which is a big industrial appliance. So I spent a long time working on that purely in some ways as like a system software project. And two years ago, three years ago, I was like, okay,
this is kind of mature enough that you could actually build products on top of it,
SPEAKER_01which is maybe seven, eight years into working on the thing. Yeah. Yeah. So I guess I'm pretty patient, but frankly, that was what I, this, the stuff we're doing now is like what I always wanted to do was just to build stuff that people use. But I felt like the existing model was just not going to work for me. Yeah. Yeah. Does that make sense?
SPEAKER_00No. Yeah, it totally makes sense. Um, and did, did you feel like the principles of architecture, like actually the architecture of buildings and the architecture of software that, that background kind of like aligned?
SPEAKER_01Oh yeah. I tend, I feel like when people, whenever people ask me for, um, or, or, you know, anyone who's like interested in building software or just like making things in general, I think usually I tell them just like, go make something and like go make something in the shop or go make physical stuff like, um, you know, building furniture, building, build a garden shed, whatever. Um,
architects have to think at once, like very abstractly and, and extremely concretely, right.
SPEAKER_01You need to like understand the material, understand if it can stand up, understand how much it costs, understand how hard it is to get to the site, how, how long it takes to assemble. Um, And think about, does it feel spiritually correct for this thing to exist in the first place? Does it serve the people who need to use it? You have to learn to navigate this really complex cloud of concerns. And that is... I mean, even if you're just an engineer, right?
SPEAKER_01Or you're a systems engineer. I mean, I don't know. This probably doesn't matter if you're just building widgets on a website or something. But if you want to really build systems, it's the same thing, you know, that you're kind of always balancing all these different concerns and figuring out how to actually get it done. i and and realistically like the the in both cases like the kind of vocational part you know like how do you pound nails or whatever like how what brackets fit together how does joinery work versus you know i don't know
like just data structures and algorithms uh you know network protocols whatever it's gonna the the specific stuff is like not you know any you can learn that you know i mean at this
SPEAKER_01point your your uh uh your llm can do it for you but or it can teach it to you. I mean, it's not that hard to learn how to, to, to go get something done, but it is hard to learn how to think. And it's worth spending the time to do that. I think, or I got a lot out of it. Yeah. So yeah, no, I think it was like, and it's good to like get away. I feel like it's kind of like a classic in any creative pursuit, you know, like if you get too into the material, you know,
SPEAKER_01you get lost in it. So it's good to like zoom out and think more broadly. And so, yeah, I, I, that was really important for me. I don't know, maybe it's not for everyone, but yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And one thing I was wondering about that you said earlier too, with with the centralization of the internet and having these services all delivered by one, one entity, Um, like how did that happen? How did the original sort of decentralized promise of the internet kind of evaporate and get like captured on all these different mega platforms?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's a good question. Um, it's kind of, and it's, the answer is that it's just like, it's like anything, right? It's like kind of an accident and, uh, you know, when something is cheaper and you can make money doing it the cheap way, like then that's what happens. Right. So one of the early, earliest examples, and certainly like, if you think of like the really early successful businesses on
the internet,
SPEAKER_01you know, when you're, when you're building a business, like if you're building Amazon and you're just selling books, right. Oh, I mean, it doesn't, really matter if everyone runs like the Amazon app themselves. It's actually way faster for them to just connect to you. You manage all your inventory. You manage delivering the UI. You can really control and streamline that thing. And in that case, like in the storefront case, like the business case, it kind of makes sense. I go to the business.
SPEAKER_01I don't know. They don't come to me, right? But in the case of things like messaging and communication, collaboration, like social networking, maybe broadly speaking, if you look at the rise of those, there were decentralized protocols for that. Usenet, IRC, XMPP, there are all these ways in which we can message with each other, move documents around, comment on stuff. They're not that fast. right? And they're not that immersive.
SPEAKER_01And there's certainly the user experience is just not that good. They're initially really just for college students who happen to have an internet connection in like 1988 or 92 or whatever. And so if you want to make them good and fast and engaging and addictive and I mean, let's say you just want them to grow fast. You want them to grow fast enough that you can build a business around them. Like you could defensively raise money and potentially make money on it.
SPEAKER_01The only way to do that is to run one server. Like it's just too slow and complicated to figure out how these protocols are going to work. So if you're, you know, sitting in your dorm room in 1998 or 99 and you're like, man, people are going to want to talk to each other on the internet. You're not thinking... I'm not like, Sam, we got to design a protocol, man. Like, and this protocol is going to connect everything. We're going to design the whole thing. You're like, no, we're going to stand up a server. Everyone's going to connect to the server. We're going to run everything and we're just going to get this done.
SPEAKER_01And I don't think any of those people were thinking like, and we're going to spy on every single user and we're going to sell all that data to a bunch of advertisers and we're going to give it to the government. and we're going to control the way that people think, and it's going to be awesome. That's all a complicated mess that no one really anticipated, and most people who run those platforms probably don't even like that much. Those are just the byproducts of trying to get to market really quickly, and I think genuinely people who just want to build cool stuff.
SPEAKER_01I actually think most of the people in charge are... genuine they're totally genuine and they just want to build great products but they're naive to the to the fact that yeah when you structure it in a certain way you get kind of you kind of paint yourself into a corner in terms of your like responsibility to your to your users so anyway that's like brushing over a lot of the or glossing over all the details but does that that's kind of at least that's how I read it right it's just kind of like an accident it's
like everyone trying to
SPEAKER_01get to market as quick as possible
SPEAKER_00Yeah. No, that makes a ton of sense. Let's see. Oh, and I was wondering how you settled on the name Twan. I know it's from the Jorge Luis Borges story. Yeah. Akbar Orbis Tertius. I think it's the full title.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. So that's where the name comes from. It's a name that we have many times over thought about changing because it's so weird. And then now in this world, everyone's like, Elon? T-lon? So they want to call us T-lon? Yeah. So yeah, it's a long product. The company's actually, as a company, like Entity has been around for a really long time. And... the goal was always the same, right?
SPEAKER_01It was like, we want to build products that are extremely high quality, that users own and can control. To do that, we need to build this system. So the company was kind of dormant in a way as we worked on the open source project. And, you know, in the story, Talon is like this secret society that actually it turns out has kind of paved over the whole world. Like they are sort of everywhere and are everything. And I think the thinking was like, well, if you want to build a new network, then you have to do it in a quiet, you know, it's a kind of like slowly and then all at once kind of thing.
SPEAKER_01Like that's the only way it ever works. And that story is like a great example of that happening. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00You know what I was kind of just thinking now, it sort of reminds me of like, have you ever read The Crying of Lot 49 by Thomas Pynchon? I actually haven't, but it's one of those ones that's like, you know, forever.
SPEAKER_01I mean, now maybe now I have to. It's the only one of his that I've read because it's like, you know, short.
SPEAKER_00It's like 100 pages, I think, something like that. But in it, there are like these two dueling communication networks. And there's like this conspiracy theory about them. But I think it's a real theory. And it's like the noble European house of Thern and Taxis or Taxis. I don't know. You pronounce it German. It real exists. They have like been controlling the mail everywhere. I think on earth for like however, however long.
But then there's this other underground network of like dueling mail carriers
SPEAKER_00called like Tristero. I guess Tristero is kind of like carrying the information that you really need. And it is this like. um decentralized uh kind of well we could have that would have been the alternate name yeah trustero like t like trust ero yeah that's pretty good yeah i think you can get away with that that might be the friendlier version because yeah talan actually is just like it's such a weird name i've always been like i don't
SPEAKER_01But then every time I'm like, oh, I don't know. I'm like, oh, just lean into it.
SPEAKER_00Maybe it works. I think the weirdness of it is a selling point. And maybe the fact, too, that people would mispronounce it and you have to correct them almost would instantiate it in their memories more. Because it creates a little moment where you're like, no. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01People do remember it. Yeah, no. I think it ultimately probably is good. I'm just, I don't know. You know, there's... Well, actually, with most things that I make, I think I'm like... really fuss over it for a really long time and then i'm like okay it's done it's like just you gotta ship it but the name for some reason i just will infinitely uh second guess i guess i don't know why um yeah yeah um well i guess one of the
SPEAKER_00things um with with plan and with erbit is that even though it's combating this centralized internet, people have tagged it with this digital feudalism thing, I suppose, because of Yarvin's initial involvement. I think the Erbit planets and stars were originally... I think he originally wanted to call them lords and something.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I showed up after that. When I showed up, they were naval. Like ships and...
SPEAKER_00uh, destroyers and carriers. That's interesting. Yeah. Um, but yeah, it's like I, when I was doing a little research or just reading up a little bit beforehand, I saw that you said it's really more like a Japanese homeware store. And I was wondering if you could, uh, expand on it.
SPEAKER_01Well, I think Talon, yeah, the Talon, uh, Talon is more like the idea is to kind of build a Muji of software, but I can build the bridge for you. Yeah. Um, Let's see. So yeah, Curtis was my longtime collaborator. I can't make it through any of his essays. I mean, I think I probably forced myself a couple of times. But yeah, I was never particularly interested in the work.
But we had a fantastically productive collaboration as someone that I love working
SPEAKER_01with and I think personally have a lot of love for. Yeah. But I can't even claim to fully understand what Curtis is, what thinks about on the sort of political side. And definitely have, you know, taken plenty of feedback about it. And the way that that's always worked for me, I guess, I mean, I come from a background of like, you can ask any question, you know, I mean, it's fine. Like, yeah, let's get into it. Like, what are you worried about? And I have come up empty handed
in terms of trying to figure out how the system itself is somehow against its users. The fact that it was so much user-oriented and completely under the control of the
SPEAKER_01people using it is exactly why I was interested in it. Yeah, I worked with many, many people over the years who probably rewrote the entire thing many times over. And so being intimately familiar with every single part of it, I'm like, I'm pretty sure this does not fold back in on itself and become somehow controlled by any one person or small group of people. Actually, it's quite the opposite. So Urbit as a system is like every node belongs to the person
who runs it. They actually hold a key to it in the way that they own it, like they own Bitcoin, right?
SPEAKER_01And so as the network grows and those keys get more distributed, the network becomes impossible to be, you know, to be re-centralized basically, right? You'd have to go buy it all up or compel people to give it back. I mean, it doesn't even make sense. Like it's like physically impossible. There's a difference between who owns the network and the software that the network runs. There are root nodes that distribute the kernel of the operating system.
SPEAKER_01You don't have to accept those updates. You can run whatever you want. You can read the source code. It's completely up to you as a user, which is, of course, is it's kind of like just the exact opposite of any existing platform right so i use telegram telegram does everything for me i mean there is no option i can't fork telegram i can't run my own telegram i can't inspect the source code of telegram that's actually they do release some of their source code but regardless you can't fully run it yourself um this is true of you know any you know
Even the most privacy sensitive of those centralized things are still completely
SPEAKER_01under the control of the companies that make them. So Signal, Telegram, WhatsApp, they belong to those companies. And then, of course, you can zoom out to Instagram. You are owned by Instagram. Instagram decides everything about how Instagram works, everything about how your algorithm works, et cetera. Yeah, I always thought this was a funny one because I'm like, I think the world you live in is the feudal internet. And this is the opposite of that. But, you know, I don't know, man. Yeah. So the homeware store,
SPEAKER_01the Muji idea was basically like, if you think about, okay, so let's think of what's the physical equivalent of a very feudal you know, situation that you might live in. Well, maybe it's like living in a hotel, right? If you, you know, when I go, I go to the, I go to Facebook, like, let's say I physically go to Facebook just to like make it something I can imagine. It would be like, I go to the, you know, Luxor or whatever. I go to the Hilton because when I show up on my page or in my room,
SPEAKER_01it's like the art has been predetermined. The TV is in one place. The furniture is there already, right? I don't get to have any agency over the things that I use to, you know, do whatever it is I'm going to do there. So it's like, I have all my friends over. I mean, you got to just use the Facebook branded furniture. Like it's just a, it's, it's a prebuilt thing, which to me, as someone who cares about, I mean, everything maybe cares a lot about my environment.
SPEAKER_01That feels totally fucked. Like that's crazy. I don't like someone telling me what to do or how to live or how to talk to people. It just it feels deeply unsettling to me. So I don't want to live in a hotel. Yeah, I want to live in a house where I get to move the furniture around. and set it up how I like and host people the way that I want to host them. And even if you live in a fully, you know, IKEA generated environment, I mean, it's still, I think that level of agency and ownership is really important.
SPEAKER_01Like it makes a huge difference. And so it's the difference between you live in a hotel that's company run versus like you live in your own house, you pick your own furniture. And so what's the company that delivers you all that furniture? Well, that's kind of, that's the Talon idea. It's like, well, if Talon can just make you these utilitarian tools that you use in the digital space that you live in, that would be great. And you could combine them however you want. And yeah, maybe we make a messenger, we make a document editor, we make a, you make an image editor, you make a,
SPEAKER_01you keep going. There's, I mean, is, do we actually want to build that entire suite of things or does that really actually, can that all live within one thing? Who knows? I think that's part of why we started by building a messenger was like, You can see how the messenger can expand to be this incredibly powerful thing. The Asian super apps are amazing. And even like existing social networking is really powerful. So I'm not necessarily saying that we become, that everything we make has to be really atomic and you can recombine them
SPEAKER_01necessarily. But you know, you get the idea. It's like, you should have digital tools. Those tools should be up to you to how to use them. You should be able to customize them, modify them, make them your own. And the platform under the hood matters a lot, right? Like if you don't, if the platform under the hood isn't yours to keep, then it can't actually deliver you the customizability, the real durability and ownership like you could keep this forever. No centralized platform can offer you that. So yeah,
SPEAKER_01you really have to have Urbit under there, which is, if it were deeply feudal or owned you in some fashion, then it would never you know, it could never support the Japanese home goods store. I don't know if that's fully connecting the two things, but that's my best shot.
SPEAKER_00No, that makes a lot of sense. And it's, yeah, it's a great explanation too, of like Twan being like the company that helps deliver the furniture for your own home that you're making, as opposed to being trapped in like the Luxor, which is a very intriguing image of... of like the internet itself as as captured by these like centralized platforms because like going to vegas is like no matter where you go no matter um whether it looks like the eiffel tower or a pyramid or caesar's palace or
whatever on the
SPEAKER_00inside it's essentially the exact same fake over and over the funny thing is i i uh that one i i i haven't been to vegas in a long time but one of my like core vegas members is going there as a kid and staying in the luxor randomly with some like family friend or something and i got i think just an absolutely you know life-changing migraine like i was so sick the
SPEAKER_01whole time Coming from living in the woods to being trapped in an air-conditioned, tightly controlled environment does not suit me. But yeah, Vegas is kind of... I mean, yeah, the internet does feel like Vegas. And I think it's worth... The other thing that's weird or often I think it's confusing about what we're doing is that people think we only succeed if we change everything. And it's like, no, no, Vegas isn't going away. It's fine. But there are a lot of people who probably also want to live... in a different way, you know?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. The, I often make it, or the way I explain that is often like, you know, it's like there's, there, there's fast food now, right? We have the fast food internet, you have the McDonald's internet, but like, you might like, you probably also want a whole foods alternative. Like not everyone's gonna go to whole foods, but you, you want that to exist or I, or there's probably a market for it. We, we tend to think there is probably a market for it. Like another, maybe another way to think about it.
SPEAKER_00Yes. No, totally. Yeah, that makes a lot of sense, too, as an analogy. Yeah, there's this Marshall McLuhan quote, which is like, the digital retrieves the medieval. And I guess he meant that in the sense of like... it makes it more like a village square as opposed to like dominated by centralized power. Cause like in the middle ages, you know, even though it's become kind of this, um, by word sort of for authoritarianism or like draconian control is like,
SPEAKER_00it actually was hard to exert centralized power over, anyone because you would just like send a you know i think the pope would send the bishop a message telling them to do something or whatever and the bishop would just be like well that got lost i don't know you know yeah that makes sense yeah yeah i think like growing up on the early internet i got this at a very young age you know you you had this experience i mean i like i think many people
have this you have
SPEAKER_01this experience of these you know, communities that are kind of organically emergent, self-regulating and non-geographically contiguous, right? Like it's just this group of people, you don't live in the same place, you happen to get along and you can, you know, add a size of maybe eight to around a hundred, probably less. it's great. Like you can learn so much from each other. You can build lasting connections. You can solve problems together. There's so much that can,
that can come out of these small communities when they are not living in a
SPEAKER_01panopticon. Like I actually just think there's something that changes the I mean, there are two things that change. So I think modern social media, because it is so – like it is very much designed to keep you engaged and very – Yes. Insidious but persistent. Like persistent and ubiquitous. Like everything about it, you just kind of go slowly in how you use Discord or –
SPEAKER_01Slack or Facebook or Instagram, whatever. And if you just carefully look at, I mean, even the smallest ways in which you are encouraged to, you know, send another message, like another thing, see another thing. You know, if you look at the page, just look at the page and how many other options there are for you to do other things on the page, right? So I think that fact changes the quality of the discourse completely. So what I'm talking about of like a small number of people just connecting with each other, The focus is on the things that they have to say to each other,
SPEAKER_01the things they have to share with one another. I just don't think that's possible with these things. Like I just, it's not possible. And I think, so I would agree, like, I think, yeah, I mean, McLuhan understood this stuff really well, though in some ways he understood it in this very purest sense. So in the purest sense, right? We just connect these people. We let them do their own things. Like what emerges from that? Yeah, it's like a very tribal thing. It's a very pure and sweet and powerful thing, I think, right?
SPEAKER_01Where people can kind of self-organize and explore new stuff. But when you're constantly kind of nudging them towards fighting with each other or seeing other stuff or being distracted or getting... I don't know. It just actually, I don't know. It seems, I don't think it's the same thing. I think it's a different thing.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah. I don't think so either. Do you use Twitter?
SPEAKER_01Uh, not really. Yeah. Twitter's bad, man. Yeah. Cause a lot of people thought that like the Elon Twitter would sort of like change things and it would be maybe more like the early internet in terms of the,
SPEAKER_00um, freedom, but it doesn't feel like that way. It actually feels like what ended up happening was probably cause he lost so much ad revenue. It ended up being like, we have to like promote, uh, subscribe the subscriber model and like big accounts and then all the little accounts which you used to see pop up all the time they don't have any voice anymore they're just like bystanders and the whole thing and it ends up becoming all like slop and i don't know videos that i haven't seen so many of these anymore fortunately but there was a while where it was like a video of
someone getting stabbed in a mall i don't know you know all that kind of stuff right yeah i mean you can't have a random person getting stabbed in a mall in a place where you're
SPEAKER_01trying to have a car like it having a real conversation. That is fucking impossible. That is crazy. And I don't, it's, it's so insane to me that we ever take it seriously from these. I try not to make it to like purse. I feel like a lot of the, you know, people in charge of these giant platforms, like take, they kind of like take shit for the wrong things, I guess. This was sort of my feeling like, but at the end of the day, I mean, there's a lot to be annoyed about. Like, I'm not saying it's not there, but,
SPEAKER_01but I think it's, um, uh, the, the, the, the fundamental problem is that, yeah, if you're basically running a media company, your job is to drive impressions and, um, that's it. That's the whole job. Like, and so you got to stop believing the bullshit basically. Like, it's like, uh, you know, you are a mark, you are an impression, like, don't, don't be a fool. Um, and I think there's just no way that you can,
SPEAKER_01you should never, you know, it's like trust, you should trust no one about, you should have to trust no one. It's not that you should be paranoid it's that like you don't want to have to trust someone who controls the protocol you don't want a person in charge of that you just don't you want it to be a protocol um meaning you can either point to the source code or you can point to the governing body of some form you know there it just has to be a functional thing it can't just be a person um because people like that are i
mean i think anyone who
SPEAKER_01I mean, that person is just the leader of an organization that ultimately has to serve its shareholders. I mean, and there's nothing wrong with that, but that is what it is. yeah yeah do you think that um like substack is kind of a a better model i mean it's different from what taunt's doing but do you think because i do feel like the thing i regretted the most um when elon took over twitter was that he and substack like immediately got into a fight and i was hoping like as someone who writes for substack i was like oh i thought it was going to be the other
way around i thought
SPEAKER_00like we're going to like have this whole new like way of promoting, you know, sub stack. I think they even have similar investors too. I think Twitter and Substack have a lot of investors. So it's like, why did this, um definitely like when you're painting creators the business is different so yeah i guess what i'm saying is like look at the dynamics of the business like that will determine how the business is going to treat you as a user right like that's just that's just how it is um and so yeah i think uh the sort of creator focused businesses are always going to have different incentives and it
and it's yeah it's definitely incrementally better for sure yeah um uh i mean the business is more
SPEAKER_01aligned with you um But they're also, I mean, yeah, I don't know. I find Substack a little frantic. I feel like every time I use Substack, it's like, yeah, it's trying to get me. It's like, you need to subscribe to some more stuff. You need to be reading, you know? And I'm like, hey, man, I just came here to look at one thing. Like, that's all. I'm not, I'm good, you know?
SPEAKER_00Well, yeah, there's the thing where it's like, if you subscribe to one Substack, they'll be like, do you want to subscribe to another five Substack? Yeah, yeah. I mean, I support that if it includes my Substack. But yeah.
SPEAKER_01I mean, it's fine. It's not, but yeah, it's a little... it doesn't i i guess yeah i'm a kind of a i want just tools you know i just want like things that just do exactly what they say they're gonna i mean i just think this stuff is like when you open a book it's not like like i hate this about the kindle right you finish a book on your kindle and it's like hey would you like to buy some more books and you're like man fuck off like it's a fucking book like i didn't finish a book and it's like hey why don't you go buy some more books it's a book come on um yeah so yeah there's something weird about like
SPEAKER_00I have Kindle and I like it, but there is something weird about it showing advertisements to you on the front of the Kindle and the way it'll be like... Maybe it's more aligned with my interests now, I'm not sure, but it used to always be like... romance novel slop stuff that would come up or it would be like grumpy boss like whatever it was like like yeah about a yeah fantasy like for women about like their grumpy boss being converted to man with the heart of gold or
something there is this yeah i mean all the ad the ad i'm like a i do my absolute best to you know live in a cave so to speak in the sense of like i'm like ad block everything and
SPEAKER_01just i don't know yeah out of my life, but I do think, um, I just don't think it's a good, I don't think it's actually a good user experience. I don't know. I'm very divided on this. Like it's very different. Like I think like Google is an amazing business, right? And you can look at the numbers, you can look at the dynamics of the business, such an incredible business, right? Because when I'm searching for, um, uh, whatever, um,
books about disgruntled employees and there's an ad for Grumpy Boss or whatever.
SPEAKER_01I actually don't mind clicking the ad. It's a predator handshake between all involved. It's getting me what I want. It's getting the seller connected to a buyer. Totally makes sense. But there is a big difference, I think, In doing this in a social context, maybe that maybe that is the difference. And that's the thing I find really weird about when people are like, think that. So like Google's ability to capture intent is,
you don't feel bad about it, right?
SPEAKER_01But in the case you're describing of like, your intent is to read a book, not to buy another book. It actually erodes your trust in the person who made the thing. It's not building trust. You're not like, oh, cool, you connected me with the guy who has the book I want. It's like you're being interrupted with something you don't want to see. If you think of these things as tools for how society is... stitched together then they're not actually doing that you know like they're not helping you do the thing you want to do which is whatever connect to more
information um and get you there more efficiently uh uh or kind of but it just feels like if i don't know like it i think i think everyone experiences it as annoying basically that's i mean that's kind of the bet i'm making too but yeah
SPEAKER_00Totally. One thing I was thinking too that might be an interesting reference point for you guys to look at is if you want to get away from the digital feudalism accusations or whatever, there's this guy, Ivan Ilyich, who wrote this book, Deschooling Society. And I feel like a lot of his ideas, which are associated... He's a Roman Catholic priest, but he was also a political thinker and associated... Yeah, what's the... anarchist thought tool.
SPEAKER_01Uh, yeah, I know who you're talking about.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. That seems like it would be, I haven't read that one. I don't know what, but yeah, it's close. It seems like it would be close to what the one is going for,
SPEAKER_01but I think I read that a really long time ago, but yes, that, um, uh, is the, what is the, wait, there's another, there's a book that's so closely adjacent to that, that I think of as like the, um, Oh man, I'm really falling down on my intellectual history. But yeah, I mean, the basic bet is like, it's basically saying we believe in the creative power of the individual. And when you give people powerful tools, they do amazing things.
So just give them the tools and have them pay for them and let them do whatever they want.
SPEAKER_01You know, stop trying to tell them what to do. I think there's a long history of you know, civilization was built and rebuilt many times over in this pattern. Right. And it's almost like hard to think about, like, if you think about, yeah, even kind of like rise and fall of, communities laddering up from the tiniest to the large, you know, to the empire. Right. Like, yeah, almost all of them. Yeah. Depended on some tool set, you know, physical tool set that they could like hold in their hands and
do stuff with,
SPEAKER_01right. Whether they're weapons or tools for building or whatever. And I've always felt like, I mean, kind of getting back to like, how did I get into this to begin with? It's like, we like, if all those tools were like, not only owned by the emperor, but like the emperor could just like turn them off. Yeah. I don't know, man. It feels weird. It just doesn't make sense. It's strange. Or another way to put it would be like, that can't work. That doesn't make sense.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah, because let me think. Oh, in de-schooling society, his model was like to get away from the centralized models of schools, you would have like a system, like a voucher system, but not in the sense of like charter schools. It was like basically like you would give people a certain amount of points, right? And they could spend those on... Similar, I guess, to a medieval kind of model, like being apprentices more or less to people who like could teach them whatever
SPEAKER_00they wanted to learn. So that could be anything from, you know, what it's just whatever you're interested in, right. From being an auto mechanic to being, if you want to read Gertrude's Faust, right. You can find someone to do that. And he kind of almost prophesied the internet as like a way of connecting people. I think he wasn't really thinking those terms. I think he was thinking of some sort of like mail network thing at the time, but yeah, he was, you know, Yeah, you could use the internet definitely to generate something like that. And like to a certain extent, that is what it is. That feels like what it's always struggling to be.
SPEAKER_00Like on Twitter, that is what I feel I find interesting or like, you know, to the extent I can get in touch with people who are reading books I'm interested
SPEAKER_01in. Yes, yes. So I think... One of the things, you know, we live in this present moment of like people being so worried about this overwhelming sort of tidal wave of AI slop and kind of like,
SPEAKER_00you know,
SPEAKER_01search results being poisoned by, you know, automatically generated content that's meaningless. And there's a lot of truth to that. I think we all experience that, right? And that's definitely true in social media world as well. But the flip side of that, that I love is it's like, well, then yeah, human connection is so much more valuable and like authenticated human connection is super valuable. Yeah. And you learn so much from, if you really want to learn something, I mean, you can get some amount of information out of an,
SPEAKER_01I mean, out of the web as it exists or out of LLM, whatever. But yeah, I mean, there's nothing like just talking, even if you want, if you certainly you want to learn something, you want to talk to someone and who's, who's good at it. Right. Or know something about it or yeah. Or is your, even your peer, right. You want like a collaborator, you know, a counterparty to just kind of like bounce ideas off of. And I do think that was, or my experience in the, I mean, even like 10 years ago, like it was easier to do that. Yeah. To kind of drop into these niche communities in which you could, um,
SPEAKER_01I don't know. Yeah. Really explore something new or get something new, but something very genuine, like very human. And yeah, I don't think, I do think that is going to go away as these platforms get so flooded with, with garbage content. Yeah. I mean, I think it's, I think it's already almost gone, honestly. Right. I don't know. It doesn't exist for me anymore. But I don't, I've also like retreated from most of them. I think it's like something similar happens with the experience
of reading books
SPEAKER_00for a lot of kids. They end up taking like book reading as something that school makes you do, right? That like the centralized institution is making you do. And you completely lose any sense of like, the adventure and romance of reading and making discoveries. And like, cause like when I was in high school, there were still books that I learned about just from my peers. Right. You know, that were like interesting, that were exciting, you know, like, or if you read something that had like, was like of literary value, but had some like sort of transgressive shocking content to it.
SPEAKER_00Right. Like a clockwork orange or, you know, the whatever, like beat poetry, the naked lunch. I haven't read naked lunch, but you know, that kind of, that kind of thing. Right. Yeah. And yeah, I feel like that is the sort of thing that gets more and more difficult to I think.
SPEAKER_01Don't you think, though, that the cultural context or like literal culture, meaning like the person that recommended it to you, the other group of people who are reading it? I guess for me, like those those kinds of books, certainly music, definitely. Right. It's like part of the community that you're a part of. And yeah, I find it a little dissatisfying to just, you know, it's one thing to get a recommendation from a,
SPEAKER_01you know, from a review site or whatever. It's another thing to have like decided, oh yeah, this is really good. And then you send it to your friend and they also like it and they send it to, you know, it's like once it kind of gets rolling, it's like actually interesting. And there's like a story that builds around it, right? That you guys all kind of... that lives in time, right? It lives in your life at a certain point in time. You read this thing, you know, during this era of your life, whatever. I mean, Yeah, I think that the raw, you know, just having this giant index of human knowledge does not make
it meaningful.
SPEAKER_01You know, like to make it meaningful, you need other people that you are connected to and you are doing something with. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And so, yeah, I think that's... You kind of get stuck in this weird moment of like total Swifty dominance, like Taylor Swift fans. Yeah. It feels like I think like the Billboard charts. Oh, this was kind of interesting. It was like for the first time in 35 years, there were no rap songs in the top 40 songs on Billboard. And I was like wondering why this is. I didn't look at the Billboard results, but my friend did. He was like, it's just all Swifties. I mean, it's all Taylor Swift. It's just total...
SPEAKER_00Taylor Swift dominance because of her new, I guess.
SPEAKER_01This is like, I mean, I don't know. Sometimes I feel like whenever I like sort of like look at culture in any measurable way, it never makes sense. Right. Yeah. But that doesn't... First of all, the billboard charts must just be consuming data from the wrong place or something, right? Or they're not actually capturing the whole thing, which is interesting in its own right. But I feel like this bends in both directions where it's like there are tiny niches of... I think music is so...
SPEAKER_01it's like almost it's more interest i mean it just continues to get more interesting there's so much interesting music because it's there are so many niches right these like little soundcloud niches these little you know regional niches that um can be super ultra productive and people obviously like working together and um uh you know influencing each other and and making stuff really quickly in ways that are so cool to see But they, you know, yeah, like they get 700 views or whatever, right? Like it's not, they're never going to be that big. And so it's this, I mean, that's the retribalization, right?
Like that's this, it's actually amazing because the variety is so, so big.
SPEAKER_01But the funny thing then I also noticed though, is that in that the mainstream, while the mainstream culture in some ways is like flat, it does feel, I guess like I live in kind of a small town and it feels like some of those things are, just observed among kids, especially like they're still really, they build strong, people build strong bonds around these things that are, you know, incredibly conventional, uh, and, uh, maybe more quickly or it's almost like the stream of content is
like a fire hose.
SPEAKER_01And so there's just even more to talk about with your friends, even though it's like, maybe it's only Taylor Swift news or whatever.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. That's an interesting point.
SPEAKER_01It never, it just feels like pop culture actually is, it's almost like, maybe it's like, it's like a niche, right? I wonder if like, maybe the interesting thing would be like, I wonder if you could compare like net. No, the market must've expanded. I was thinking like, it's almost like net plays on, uh, you know, Madonna song in the nineties or something versus like net plays on the Taylor Swift song. But actually we have so many more devices now that the number is probably many orders of magnitude bigger. It doesn't matter. Yeah. Yeah. Um,
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I don't know. Yeah, I mean, yeah, obviously. I said, I feel like music culture is ahead of, yeah, it's like varied in exactly the right way or something. There's something, I don't know. I just think music and like contemporary music is evolving in so many. It's just great. I love it. I don't know. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, definitely with, like, Bandcamp, you can just continually explore, like, oceans of new music and all kinds of varieties. And it can get a little... Well, one, it's amazing, but it's also hard to, like, navigate that through that.
SPEAKER_01Because it's so... Yeah, I have such a... Addiction to, I mean, yeah, I, yes, but you just, it's like a, it's like playing a video game or something. I feel like, I don't know. I spend so much time like consuming new music that you can get good at it. And it's like, there's like a sort of a ladder of curation, you know, between like record labels and DJs and stuff. So it sort of depends on what you're into, but I just feel like I'm continuously discovering new stuff that I,
SPEAKER_01I mean, at a rate that, like on a weekly basis, it's so incredible. Yeah, it is weird. It feels like literary culture. There are like other parts of culture that don't, I guess it's slower to consume, but maybe it's just me, you know? I don't know. I'm like able to really get through music in a way that with... Visual culture, you know, whatever it might be, design, painting, visual art. I mean, it doesn't really work on the internet, right? Not really got to see it in person. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01And then – but, yeah, literary culture is tough for me. I feel like it's – I mean, outside of friends who send me stuff, I've never found, like, that it doesn't – I can't get – i don't have the same resources i do with music but maybe you can maybe you can help sure yeah no i mean i can definitely think of interesting writers who are bubbling up and who have some sort of like organic kind of online presence you know
SPEAKER_00or came out of nowhere but at the same time um Yeah, it does seem like, yeah, I think it goes back to what you were saying about just it's slower to consume, right? The slow going with literature does make it harder to have like this exciting experience of all these kind of phenomena bubbling up like you do with music, you know? Yeah, actually, my best source for new contemporary literature is a group on Tlant.
SPEAKER_01There's a reading group there that's very active and very interesting, which is exactly what, you know, that's like what I, I don't know. I mean, it's only like, I don't know, it's like 10 people or something, but there's always good stuff. Yeah, I'd love to check that out, honestly. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. You just send me a message and all. Yeah. Okay, cool. Yeah, I will. I'll get you in there.
SPEAKER_00Let's see. I think we covered most of what I had in my own notes to talk about. Yeah. But I don't know. Are there any final thoughts? I know you have to go pretty soon.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Oh, yeah. I mean, people should feel, you know, we've kept this thing pretty hard to get on. on for quite some time um yeah and so yeah anyone listening who's curious should feel uh welcome to come and check it out i think we have like a link for you that we'll put in the notes or whatever um okay and it's still so small that like i'm happy to i mean you can like literally dm me you know talk talk to us about your experience um it's very much like a thing that you can use yeah for like a
reading group a small group of friends like the you know the the the more um uh unhinged boys chat uh that's that's what this is for um at least for now um and so yeah let us let us know how it goes if you're interested um and yeah i'm very easy to find and and
SPEAKER_01happy to chat What else did we forget? I don't think anything. And yeah, you can send me some book recommendations later. And I'll think of the, there's like, there's like a companion book to that Illich book, which I'll send you at some point.
SPEAKER_02Okay.
SPEAKER_01Or that I read at the same time and is like cemented in my memory. And obviously, you know, it's like, uh, I can see the outline of it, but I can't remember the name.
SPEAKER_00Okay. Awesome. Yeah. Yeah. I'll need to check out tools of conviviality too. I definitely want to do that. That's the one. That was a good one. That's a good one. Well, yeah. Thanks so much for coming. Yeah. Thanks so much for coming on. Yeah. This was great. Yeah. My pleasure. Yeah. I think people dig it.
Phil Klay, National Book award-winning author and newly elected President of PEN America, pops into the Buntzcast to compare the merits of Tolstoy and Dostoevsky. I’m Team Tolstoy, Phil’s Team Dostoevsky - though we...
Foreign policy expert, frequent CSPAN viewer, radical feminist, fiction writer, and future Chicago mayoral hopeful Grace Morgan pops into the Buntzcast to engage in media training for her political career and air her...
Switching things up. Normally, the Buntzcast is a Marc Maron/Terry Gross style podcast, in which the guest distills his or her essence for the audience. We’re doing it a little different this time: this is the first...
The Buntzcast roars back into life after nearly two months of mysterious, unexplained silence. Noah Kumin, editor of The Mars Review of Books and author of the new novel Stop All the Clocks, pops into the studio. We...
Georgina Rose (aka Da'at Darling), a popular Youtuber, podcaster, and expert on all things magical and occult, drops by the Buntzcast. We have a wide-ranging and intriguing discussion, touching on the best places to do...