Switching things up. Normally, the Buntzcast is a Marc Maron/Terry Gross style podcast, in which the guest distills his or her essence for the audience. We’re doing it a little different this time: this is the first installment of the Buntzcast Book Club. Boschian Belle (https://x.com/boschianbelle) pops into The Buntzcast to discuss Thomas Mann’s epochal novel of ideas, The Magic Mountain, in which the protagonist, Hans Castorp, experiences “the intoxication of ideas and the lure of eros.” You don’t want to miss this one. (If you plan on reading the novel, I’d recommend only listening to the first half though because we do give a lot away.) The next installment of the Buntzcast Book Club will be on Yukio Mishima’s The Temple of the Golden Pavilion. Read it with us. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit sambuntz.substack.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_02Do you like hearing your own voice?
SPEAKER_00That's a loaded question Is it? Cause the answer is probably yes I mean like I don't like hearing it in person like when I'm talking right now It's the opposite for me where I like hearing myself talk but I don't like listening to recordings of myself See I do I like listening to recordings of myself cause it's uncanny and weird
SPEAKER_02That's what, did you see the thing that was like Lea Seydoux Yeah She said that like she never like really wanted to be an actress but like she wanted to see like the proof of her existence by like the acting and becoming an actress was just a byproduct of her desiring to like see a proof of her Existing in the world.
SPEAKER_00It sounded like a really French thing. Yeah. Anyone's ever said... But she was your pick for who we should cast for the filmic version of Magic Mountain. As Frau Chauchat.
SPEAKER_02Yes, because she has the upturned eyes. She has the cat-like... Yeah. Yeah, physiognomy.
SPEAKER_00The epicanthic fold?
SPEAKER_02I don't think she has those... Yeah, and plus madame- I think few slobs have epicanthic folds.
SPEAKER_00My family has that. Who? Like my brother and my aunt and my mom's side of the family.
SPEAKER_02I need to see a picture to confirm.
SPEAKER_00I think because we're Magyars, you know? or Hungarian a little bit I guess I don't really know what epicanthic folds are like I know how to identify them on like an Asian face but I'm not really sure how to if I would recognize them as such on a Caucasian or on a more Caucasian build there's a whole detailed explanation in the Magic Mountain of what an epicanthic fold is I know yeah they go right into the specific It's like where the skin on the corner of your eyes extends and
meets your eyelid.
SPEAKER_02But your eyelid is connected to the corner of your eye. It's like a contiguous line.
SPEAKER_00It's kind of exactly what you'd expect.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, but I still can't imagine it on a Hungarian face.
SPEAKER_00It's like
SPEAKER_02or like just Google and show me a white person with a epicanthic bolt.
SPEAKER_00I don't know if Gunther Grass has an epicanthic bolt. All right. Well, actually, I'm not actually on the internet.
SPEAKER_01So now you can look up white people with an epicanthic bolt.
SPEAKER_00I'm really worried. Yeah. I'm kind of okay. He doesn't really. Yeah. Wait, see, look, come on.
SPEAKER_02Okay. Yeah. But that looks like he just has like sagging eyelids Christopher Hitchens said he looked like he just dismounted a shaggy pony off the step yeah that's really that's actually really insightful yeah because it was the tartar yeah he looks Wajian I guess and he's German well he's
SPEAKER_00got he's from Danzig right okay I don't really know who this person is He wrote The Tin Trump. He's also a German novelist.
SPEAKER_02Okay, I should know that. You have to cut that out.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, we will. We'll cut all this out. Because you see, folks, Emily is a scholar of, well, why don't you tell us what you're a scholar of?
SPEAKER_02I think AI will tell you, actually. I think it knows who I am because there's so few people with my name.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, but this is a human-centric podcast, so I think you have to introduce yourself to our audience instead of forcing them to get the Google AI overview of what your name is. Yes. Or what your name, um, or what your expertise is.
SPEAKER_02My, well, I don't, I can't claim to have expertise in anything, but, um.
SPEAKER_00Stop being all humble and self-effacing.
SPEAKER_01Um, no, I'm not.
SPEAKER_00You're in America now.
SPEAKER_01Sorry.
SPEAKER_00This is time for self-promotion.
SPEAKER_02Uh, self-aggrandizement. Um, No, I'm, uh, yeah, I, I'm, I basically just read a lot. Um, and I get paid to do it. Um, by graduate school.
SPEAKER_00So we are going to call you your real full name on this Emily.
SPEAKER_02Yes.
SPEAKER_00And we're not going to call you by your anonymous internet troll. It's not, that's not,
SPEAKER_02it wasn't even my troll identity, but I did take my name off it last, last year, I think. Um, yeah. Boschian Bell.
SPEAKER_00So now you've doxed yourself.
SPEAKER_02I haven't. Well, I don't. Yeah. No, I thought that we were going to go with my Twitter name. Yeah. Instead of my real name. But we can go with both.
SPEAKER_00So we're doing something kind of different this time with the Buntz cast. Normally, this is like a Terry Gross, Marc Maron style interview podcast in which the guest kind of lays out their whole shtick But this time we're transitioning into literary analysis Yes We're kind of We should do this with every book we read in our reading group I think that would be a good idea Here in Chicago And the next episode will be on
Mishima's Temple of the
SPEAKER_02Golden Pavilion Which is my imposition Yeah
SPEAKER_00And if we weren't learned one thing from the Internet, there's a desperate hunger for summaries of books without actually reading those books. Right. So if we can distill the essence of what makes a great excuse me, German novelist like or novelist of any ethnicity like Thomas Mann into quotable, clippable sound bites that our audience will probably go. Bananas for that.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I really don't think that there are any sound bites in The Magic Mountain, the 700 page novel. There are, what do you think that? I mean, but like, no, just because it's so like, you know, arcane or like, it's not, it's not, it's not quippy. It's not really like suitable for a really nice little, brevity's not its strong suit. so you're not you're not being soft spoken anymore on the podcast look at how the
waveform is just as yeah it's perfect yeah the um I might I might actually go on the ground though because um that's fine yeah that'll be I think that'll compensate for the difference in uh wavelengths so I imagine the bunz cast audience which is
SPEAKER_00probably one of the most literate Podcast Audiences That Are Really Out There Right Now Really Verifiable They Probably Know Why You Should Be Interested In The Magic Mountain But In Case They Don't Why Did We Read This Book Aside From The Fact That It Ties In With Your Area Of Study
SPEAKER_02it's true well no I mean because I shouldn't disclose that because it's embarrassing I never read Mon before it's not that embarrassing didn't you read Death in Venice I'm rereading it I read it ages ago in undergrad yeah um now I'm rereading it it's 78 pages so I'm planning to finish it again tonight yeah um but
SPEAKER_01no I mean I like Thomas Thomas Mon was like not on my radar but um You have to cut this out because I don't want to Just be eating cheese and then
SPEAKER_00talking over the cheese apps?
SPEAKER_01I'm gatekeeping my dissertation topic Oh,
SPEAKER_00okay Well, you don't have to just reveal your dissertation topic You can just say something like I'm studying Thomas Mann My advisor thought it fruitful that I read Thomas
SPEAKER_01Mann
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I feel like the audience wants an answer from your soul, though, for why you wanted to read The Magic Mountain. It was required for school.
SPEAKER_01I really didn't know what I was getting into reading the book, though. I didn't know it was going to be my favorite book. When people ask me what my favorite book is, now I say Magic Mountain.
SPEAKER_00That's official. That's a very distinguished sounding choice, too, for The Magic Mountain. For your favorite book.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Well, it's one of those long... long books that people talk about. Well, like something with a sort of like similar ring to it that I imagine is totally different, but I can't tell you because I've never read is a gravity's rainbow.
SPEAKER_00Oh, yeah.
SPEAKER_01That's that seems to be an equally sort of like, it seems to me an equally solemn choice in terms or like a choice with with as much gravitas as Magic Mountain, but that's totally based off speculation only. Yeah, it's one of those books that's just sprawling and it ends up covering everything, right? Well, that's... Isn't that... We've got... M.M.?
SPEAKER_00That's what I'm saying.
SPEAKER_01Okay.
SPEAKER_00That's what yokes them together. So my... Or like Ulysses or, you know, In Search of Lost Time. All these great modern novels. I mean, I guess people say Gravity's Rainbows. Gravity's Rainbows. Gravity's Rainbows is more like postmodern, but... Yeah, you know, it's this idea that the novel can encompass all of the most fundamental interests of human beings. But it's not just that. It's funny too. It's ironic, right?
SPEAKER_00I don't know if Magic Mountain is like laugh out loud funny.
SPEAKER_01I chortled. Yeah. There are many moments where I chortled.
SPEAKER_00It provokes a lot of chortles, I would say. Specifically chortles.
SPEAKER_01If it's audible, it's a victory. Snickers.
SPEAKER_00Snickers, Chortles, Chuckles.
SPEAKER_01No bellowing laughter. It's not like there's something about Mary or Dumb and Dumber, but it's very witty.
SPEAKER_00It has a good macabre sense of humor because, of course, it takes place in a sanatorium in the Alps where everyone's dying from tuberculosis.
SPEAKER_01There's actually a... highlighted a or I selected a passage where Mon is talking about irony or he has his characters talk about irony and Mon is famous for being ironic in this text yeah it's like it was a point of contention in our reading group whether Mon was being ironic yeah because one guy was like this guy's just such a German he's just solemn and serious he's not yeah right he's not like capable of having that kind of
SPEAKER_00detachment but it's like a solemnly It's like fake solemn. It's like iron-o solemn.
SPEAKER_01Iron-o solemn.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01I have the passage ready.
SPEAKER_00You want to read it?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's Setembrini talking about irony. And he says, ah, yes, irony. Beware of the irony that flourishes here, my good engineer. Talking to the protagonist. Beware of it in general as an intellectual stance. When it is not employed as an honest device of classical rhetoric, the purpose of which no healthy mind can doubt for a moment, it becomes a source of depravity, a barrier to civilization, a squalid flirtation with inertia, nihilism, and vice.
And since the atmosphere in which we live provides very favorable conditions for
SPEAKER_01this swamp plant to flourish, I may hope, or perhaps I must fear, that you do understand me. yeah and it's kind of that in and of itself is irony because it's like having a character in the book voice the critique of Thomas Mann himself yeah um because he's all about even though the book doesn't necessarily end up in this place he is
SPEAKER_00all about that like what was it squalid like a squalid
SPEAKER_01says a squalid flirtation with inertia, nihilism, and vice. There's a lot of squalid flirting with inertia, nihilism, and vice in this book.
SPEAKER_00And the guy saying all that stuff, Herr Settinbrini, this Italian gentleman, he is like the liberal conscience, the rationalist conscience of the book saying, hey, don't get too... Obsessed with how interesting death is and how interesting illness is sex is yeah
SPEAKER_01Right, he's the humanist and Right, what contra the who's the guy that he's sort of yeah The medievalist Nafta, but I feel like we should be introducing before we get into yes these guys Our hero
SPEAKER_00Hans Kostor who Mon almost always refers to by his full name Hans Castorp he just has one of those names that you say the whole name right what um I feel like we sort of just took that for granted after noting on is this true for me yes it is um we noticed
SPEAKER_01that the protagonist was always referred to by his full name and then we stopped talking about it why yeah what's up with that well I think we stopped talking about it because we couldn't really tease any deeper meaning out of it but the thing about I would flag the like two moments in the 700 pages where the rule is deviated from yeah there's a couple moments where the narrator just says
SPEAKER_01Hans yeah it does yeah I remember it sticking out to me because yeah suddenly out of nowhere I was like what does this mean yeah it doesn't I don't think it means anything but um and so Hans Kostorp is like this perfectly normal guy he's a young oh I also yeah I I also um pointed out uh The moment in which Hans is described as the... Not a perfect pupil.
SPEAKER_01That's Harold Bloom's words, right?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, Harold Bloom called him a perfect pupil.
SPEAKER_01His virtues as a protagonist is explicitly mentioned. Page 119.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, he just wants to know what's going on. He... Thomas Mann makes a big deal about how mediocre he allegedly is, right? It's like he's not someone who comes into the world with his own definite character and point of view. He's trying to develop a point of view, right?
SPEAKER_01He's a perfect blank slate, I guess. And he doesn't even know that this is what he's after until he gets to the Magic
SPEAKER_00Mountain, right? Where he's visiting his tubercular cousin, Yoakum, who is... a soldier and a man of action and a man of duty and consequently doesn't really have anything to say about like the life of the mind right right Yokum's sort of a likable and important character but he He's a nice guy but he doesn't have a lot to say But he's the perfect foil Or Mann
Constantly does The sort of juxtaposition Between different characters And their different dispositions So if Joachim is A man of Deeds Hans sort of We see his
SPEAKER_01development into a man Of words or like a man Of Not really a man of words, but just as a guy who entertains all these notions that he picks up in his years at the sanatorium.
SPEAKER_00When you say years at the sanatorium, he doesn't come to the sanatorium expecting to spend seven years there, but he does, right? He's just taking a little vacation.
SPEAKER_01The length of his stay is only revealed at the very end.
SPEAKER_00Yes. Spoiler But then being there awakens his latent tuberculosis apparently He um right he sort of discovers his love of um playing king is what he calls it Yeah Is just uh really setting up ideas against each other and seeing uh what holds Yeah and if you want to get allegorical about this this is supposed to be like the average European bourgeois man
Thinking about all these different ideologies That are coursing through society In the years before World War I Right you have the liberal point of view The science Scientifically minded liberal point of view Represented by Settinbrini Who is a Freemason Yes but also he's like Well what Mann does so well Is that he Troubles
SPEAKER_01the clear-cut distinctions that we assume from the get-go because Sedgum Brini is also like sure he's a classicist and a humanist but he's also he also sort of invokes the figure of Satana like there there is something like I don't know irreverent I mean he's he's he's a Freemason yeah he talks about how
in the Italian revolt right I think it's called the Risorgimento I'm probably pronouncing it wrong but it's the revolt right that Garibaldi and Manzini lead to unify Italy and they were Freemasons right so and part of the Garibaldi was a
SPEAKER_01Freemason?
SPEAKER_00I think they all were yeah I didn't know that. The leaders. Because in Europe, Freemasonry was this incubator of like secular liberal ideology, right? You didn't have to believe in God to be a Freemason in France or in Italy. It became like a club for secular liberals. Wait, we should, I want to, right, point to the passage where it talks about uh hans virtue as a sort of blank slate protagonist yeah yeah
actually read that could you read that yes um okay um hans kastorp's loyalty in which he did not take
SPEAKER_01any particular pride by the way consisted, and no value judgment is intended, of a certain stodginess, slowness, and stubbornness of spirit, a sustaining mood that caused him to regard conditions and relationships of long-standing attachment to be that much more valuable the longer they lasted. He also tended to believe in the infinite duration of the state and mood in which he happened to find himself at a given moment, cherished it for just that reason, and was not eager for change. And so his heart had become Oh,
SPEAKER_01this is where he's talking about Privyslav Hippa Hippa Yeah, earlier I asked Google what mom's sexuality was just out of curiosity about what it would say and it said that the AI thing said that he was a closeted homosexual who, despite his orientation had six children with his wife Well it's interesting because it's like closeted but he
literally does everything but say I'm gay Yeah well I mean like Hans' love interest in the book Shoshat Claudia he likes her because she reminds him of like a crush on a boy that he had
SPEAKER_00as a schoolboy Yeah Pribislav Hippah The Kyrgyz boy They both look really Kyrgyz They keep saying The Orasians Yeah Yeah we were just talking before about the the way Slavs have epicanthic folds sometimes or whatever Yeah and what he borrows a pencil from Pribislav Hippo which some people think is alluding to some sort of Yeah and there's actually that moment in
SPEAKER_01Fleabag do you remember when there's like a pencil when like It's like you, oh, why do people, why are there erasers on tops of, on the top of pencils so that you can have, so that you can like erase your mistakes or something? Well, that is literally what erasers are for. No, but people interpreted that to be like a condom on top of the pencil or something. What? No, I swear there's a pencil penis thing going on in that joke.
Well, pencils, I mean, naturally lend themselves to phallic symbolism, I guess, right? Well, yeah, the eraser on the top of them really makes that analogy complete.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, because you're creating babies or you're creating art, right?
SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_00Though, well, there's a lot of sidetracks. You could go down with this because Mon, he sees, it's kind of like this weird Even though it's a sanatorium and people have tuberculosis and a lot of them are dying from tuberculosis, there's like this weird fertility to dying or to being sick.
SPEAKER_01Right. Mon is troubling the very category of illness where the whole point of the air up in this mountain. They're in Switzerland. Yeah. They're in Switzerland. They're just down the road from Davos Yeah There's a whole thing about how the air there is supposed to sort of be good for the illness in both
ways in that it's good for the illness in that it cures the illness but it also makes the illness fester
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah Well in Hans' case it brings out the tuberculosis, right? The doctor, Barron's who runs the sanatorium I think he says that he's like oops like in some cases I mean the air is supposed to be really good for patients with tuberculosis but in other cases like yours it brings out your latent tuberculosis it makes you sick like and Hans thinks that he first had that latent tuberculosis from when he was in
SPEAKER_00love with uh Pribislav HIPAA he tells Shoshata really He was like, yeah, I borrowed this pencil from you years ago. And that was back when I brought out the initial tuberculosis. That's when they had, like the whole speech where he finally talks the show shot after. Yeah, but he says that he suspected that he had tuberculosis in his engagement with the
SPEAKER_01schoolboy.
SPEAKER_00I think that's why he thinks it's latent in the system.
SPEAKER_01Well, there's the whole connection between illness and luck.
SPEAKER_00Yes. And there's constant allusions that like the Polish assistant to the director is
SPEAKER_01making to psychoanalysis and how love in itself is a form of illness. So Mon is sort of making, well, troubling the condition of being ill in general, where love makes the body act in certain ways and vice versa.
SPEAKER_00There's this idea that if you're healthy and everything's going good, you don't really have to think about stuff, right? And getting ill for Hans is also what brings out his propensity for actually thinking about stuff, right? Because he goes up on this hillside and he starts daydreaming and then he remembers the whole HIPAA thing that comes back to him, right? And then he starts... Coughing up blood at the end of that reverie, right?
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_00Classic tuberculosis symptom.
SPEAKER_01But he's also desperate to have his temperature. Like he wants to justify his stay there. So he's constantly trying to get his fever up.
SPEAKER_00Yes.
SPEAKER_01And trying to be sick so that he has a reason to be at the sanatorium. Yeah he's worried it's gonna his symptoms are gonna go away because he's gotten addicted to well it's like part of the reason he wants to stay there is because of the Eros element being in love with Shivshat and then the other thing is what's the other reason oh well because it's his education right for the first time he's coming alive to the life of the mind and he has this tutor now
Setembrini who is like at the beginning in the first half of the book Setembrini is like the foil to show shot Yes right because Setembrini hates the Orient or he sees the Orient as
SPEAKER_02the sort of the realm of everything antithetical to what he stands for as mystification and um all these sort of unsavory influences yeah um tablespoon
SPEAKER_00Wait, what was I going to say about this? Oh, and Chauchat, even though her name is French and a pun on hot cat I didn't know that Yeah, and Chauchat also is used in France like in the United States to refer to female genitalia We did talk about that in the group, right?
SPEAKER_01No, I don't remember that Yeah So Shershot, uh, what?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, didn't we talk about that in the group? No. Well, I think I found it out from, like, Wikipedia or something late in the... Nah, I don't know if it was Wikipedia, but...
SPEAKER_01Like, her name means pussy in French?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's hot pussy. What? No, uh, well, yeah, actually.
SPEAKER_01I loved, uh, Claudia Shershot as a character, and I really liked her, um, Yeah her characterization as being like slovenly and kind of dusty and kind of lazy and just like not put together it felt like a great vindication of my own character The slamming of doors Yes I thought was a really great touch like the way Hans first becomes aware of SureShot is when he's in the cafeteria
at the sanatoria and He gets really annoyed because she slams the door and whenever she enters and it's like the violent intrusion of lust slash love into his world is hearing the banging
SPEAKER_01door slam all the time I found the opposite passage for this Okay Bang, the old maid said, that's her. You don't even have to look up to make sure who just came in. Of course, there she goes. And what a charming way she has about her. Like a kitten slinking to its bowl of milk. I wish you could change seats with me so you could observe her as easily and effortlessly as I can. I do understand that you don't always want to turn your head to watch. God only knows what she might think if she noticed Now she's greeting her table You really should have a look It's so refreshing to watch her When
she talks and smiles the way she's doing now A little dimple shows in one cheek But not always Only when
SPEAKER_01she wants it to Yes, she's a darling woman A spoiled creature That's why she's so careless We all love people like that Whether we want to or not Because when they annoy us with their carelessness The annoyance becomes just one more reason for being fond of them What fun it is to be annoyed at people and yet have no choice to love them It's such a deep insight It is it really is Yeah and Setembrini is obviously annoyed at this Oh well one thing I thought was funny about Setembrini doesn't he
is impervious to the charms of women it seems like Well yeah but one thing that's never really followed up on is early on when they're hanging out with Setembrini and getting to know him he like whistles and sings sort of flirtatiously at a bunch
SPEAKER_02of girls That's right I forgot but that's never really followed up on no and it seems like if Setembrini is really into anyone it would be probably Hans Castor right there's a sort of um like erotic tension in the in the um tutorship because Setembrini is like at one point he's
SPEAKER_00like you remind me of uh a monk with your like chaste disposition no not a monk you remind me of a nun you're like a chaste novice nun and he'll tell him like oh you parry my thrusts gracefully yeah but yeah so naturally he and Shoshat are kind of at loggerheads and one thing about Shoshat is that I kind of, because of the way Ma is describing her, I pictured her as like this darker, like mysterious kind of woman from the east.
But she actually has gold red hair tied in a braid that is like spun around her
SPEAKER_00head in this like Star Wars haircut.
SPEAKER_01Okay.
SPEAKER_00Which isn't what I visualized, like a spiral braid.
SPEAKER_01Like Leia from Star Wars?
SPEAKER_00Something like that. Yeah. Okay.
SPEAKER_01Does that make you question your casting choice for Lea Seydum?
SPEAKER_00Nah, because with Hollywood movie magic, we can't do anything.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you said Ryan Gosling for Hans as well. Yeah. I question that decision.
SPEAKER_00We'll de-age Ryan Gosling 10 years with AI. And then, yeah.
SPEAKER_02But to be fair, I can't really think of an alternative.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. and so Kostorp is up there and he's learning about being rational and liberal from Sed and Bree but at the same time he wants to know about anatomy because he's getting interested in women and it gets into Well like the illness that's festering in Shoshat's body sort of like turns him on to the physical sort of the material
SPEAKER_01realm makes him curious and there's this crazy chapter it's maybe my favorite chapter one of my favorites where he's just learning about anatomy but then it spirals off into um like
SPEAKER_00wondering about the whole meaning of life do you remember this chapter?
SPEAKER_02I remember the chapter it's um yeah
SPEAKER_00What is that chapter called? Because I did want to read the...
SPEAKER_01I didn't get to... Research, maybe.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, we were kind of just ad-libbing this entire podcast. But I feel like even though we're improvising this...
SPEAKER_01I think we're doing a good job, actually.
SPEAKER_00We're kind of following roughly the order of the book.
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_00But yeah, he's studying anatomy, right? And just biology and learning all about science because he's interested. He's interested in the physical body, but also research research. Yes. And there's that part where he like is speculating on how matter was actually this like coagulation of the spirit. It gets real into a real Schopenhauer type zone. Yeah. well the um idea of like how the body this is 263 yeah um how
in illness like the union between body and soul is out of whack yes where the body I think um sort of Outdoes Like the outer Transcends the inner Or the outer Right there Let's see The outer manifestation Like the outer doesn't Or does the outer Reflect the inner In
material The material dissolution Of the body That you find in illness It's a Yeah Constant question So yeah I found the passage I was remembering Okay It's on 281
SPEAKER_01Okay Okay
SPEAKER_00and we're using is this the vintage edition this is the yes the John E.
SPEAKER_01Woods translation yeah I'm reading next up next we're reading Dr. Faustus there's so many weird speculations in this chapter like had not one researcher in his visionary boldness spoken of the beasts of the Milky Way cosmic monsters whose flesh bones and brains were formed from solar systems that's on 280 The 281 passage is also a banger That was the part I really You
should read it We both marked this one There's a part where he says He's saying that disease was
SPEAKER_00life's lascivious form And for its part, what was life? Was it perhaps only an infectious disease of matter? Just as the so-called spontaneous generation of matter was perhaps only an illness a cancerous stimulation of the immaterial The first step toward evil, toward lust and death was doubtless taken when, as the result of a tickle by some unknown incursion, spirit increased in density for the first time, creating a pathologically rank growth of tissue that formed
half in pleasure,
SPEAKER_00half in defense, as the prelude to matter, the transition from the immaterial to the material. This was creation's true fall, its original sin. The second spontaneous generation, the birth of the organic from the inorganic, was only the sad progression of corporeality into consciousness, just as disease in an organism was the intoxicating enhancement and crude accentuation of its own corporeality. Life was only the next step along the reckless path of spirit turned disreputable,
SPEAKER_00matter blushing and reflex, both sensitive and receptive to whatever had awakened it.
SPEAKER_01So good.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that was one of my favorite It is such a good passage It gets real cosmic And, uh, yeah And he also, again, Sedumbrini's wishes Starts visiting all the people who are dying, right? He has this curiosity about death But Sedumbrini is Well, Sedumbrini is very skeptical of this Of the valorization of illness And the sort
SPEAKER_01of, um, uh, deriving any kind of, like yeah or it's more like he doesn't think that illness is dignified that yeah well he he says that the only way to think about death that doesn't lead in a destructive direction where you're like idolizing death as something that's better than life
SPEAKER_00and stands in contrast to life is to see death as a part of life and You can tell Mon is kind of making fun of him He's pro-life Yeah But on the one hand Mon takes that I think he's presenting that as like a serious idea That you should take seriously But then he has Senabrini working to like Build this He's drawing up plans for an ideal crematorium And where people will be cremated Right next to it There'll be this like statue of There'll be
this hall of life right with like greek statues and stuff in it and it'll remind you of like life in the midst of death he's Apollonian yeah but then Nafta who we'll get to he mocks this whole idea right he's like oh you just want to like As soon as you're done cremating someone you want to turn around and start thinking about sex and looking at all these like renaissance paintings and like Greek news
SPEAKER_01Does Nafta accuse him of being interested in sex? I thought Nafta was the horny one Well he's a Jesuit Sedan Brini is kind of like he's not he's not very sexual Well aside from whistling at those girls Yeah well that was like one that was yeah that was an exception
SPEAKER_00It's true, yeah, because Centipurini tries to warn Hans away from the allure of Frau Chauchat because Hans hasn't even talked to her. He's just been like looking at her in the cafeteria and thinking about her and he goes to see a painting of her that the doctor who apparently hooked up with Chauchat at some point,
SPEAKER_01it's implied No, it's not. That's not implied That is implied Really? Yeah I didn't, like they hooked up It's implied like yeah it's implied subtly but then it's implied like more it's it is stated overtly at some point later on where it's like yeah i'm pretty sure that barons i didn't pick up on that at all and i don't think we talked about that in the reading group we might not have but it does come up i'm pretty sure it was like a it was like a subtle like the subtle subtlest of um yeah uh
no it was it was
SPEAKER_01already very subtle when the book um intimates that uh hans and claudia hooked up well but yeah it's it's subtle but then it does say like they hooked up right because they have this wild like remember she's like meet me well okay let's back up for a sec so he finally does start talking to show shot on walper well it's called walpergus night but it's
SPEAKER_00actually mardi gras uh or carnival and Finally they have this license to use informal pronouns which is weirdly important in this book like to call someone well it's important to Germans yeah to call someone do instead of see right and so he uses that license to strike up a conversation for her when he needs a pencil which hooks it back up to the purpose lab thing because they're trying to they're doing this game
where they're like
SPEAKER_00blindfolding themselves and they're trying to draw a pig Yes And he The pencil's like A nub at this point When Castle Orp is trying to do it But then So he goes to her To try to get a pencil And she has one And they have a conversation And they hook up At the end of it Yes But before he goes to talk to her Sentin Brini is like No Whatever But he's against All kinds of like Bodily indulgences He's against The body He thinks it's excessive He
thinks The body is
SPEAKER_01extraneous To the soul well but he also is a scientific materialist right he wants to make an encyclopedia like called the sociology of suffering where he documents every instance of human suffering and so we can eliminate it he's kind right he's a he does have a sort of impulse to classify yeah and define and he thinks it's morbid to be visiting the dying people in the sanatorium which Hans starts doing what is why do you think Hans starts doing that Because he's being drawn into this world of his curiosity about
love and sex and death all kind of makes him want to actually see what it's like to be dying,
SPEAKER_00right? Because there is this sense of transcendence caught up with death, right? Of going to the beyond He even stakes out a plot at the cemetery for one of the
SPEAKER_01women he and Johan visit Yeah and I think he also likes um like he is trying to be nice to these people right he's trying to be show some kind of compassion for them which no one else at the sanatorium wants to really do because they they don't want to think about how they're dying too and I think the book is explicit about um how he does derive some kind of like sense of being a good Christian yeah I think that's true like
SPEAKER_00Christianity isn't like a huge part in the book originally um Mon well it is what am I saying because Nafta represents a weird version of Christianity communist sadistic masochistic sadomasochistic version so yeah because when Hans hooks up with Claudia it turns out that she's leaving the next day right so he's kind of upset about all that but when she's gone her
role as being this sort of antagonist to said to bring a well this opposite pole right gets replaced by this guy nafta who we should talk about now he's he's like a sickly he's described as like as like extraordinarily ugly he's a little he's like a he's a Jew
SPEAKER_01who joins the Jesuit order
SPEAKER_00Yeah, he's Jewish and his father was a kosher butcher and a learned scholar of Judaism
SPEAKER_01Murdered in a pogrom Yeah,
SPEAKER_00murdered And yeah, so Nafta ends up because of these He's like nailed to the door Yes In the form of a cross I think so, right? Yeah And Nafta associates the sacred with cruelty Right Yes um and he likes the idea of self-flagellation and mortification of the flesh and all this stuff he loves the flesh so he's the count he's the direct counterpart to Setembrini insofar as Setembrini is um like the champion of
spirit and reason well but Nafta loves the he doesn't love the flesh he likes the idea of torturing the
SPEAKER_00flesh to liberate the spirit he likes indulging in the flesh Oh he yeah but Seth and Brini doesn't really believe in a soul separate from the body and Nafta does I don't know it's confusing because they all have like there's the one chapter where they're arguing and they end up contradicting each other and
SPEAKER_01saying and which is what Mana is doing at large yeah um is making things confusing and making what initially appeared to be a clear-cut distinction. Yeah, just obfuscating those distinctions.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so Hans doesn't really know what to think at that point.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_00Though he actually does, kind of. Well, when he gets stuck in the snow later on and almost dies, he kind of hashes out in a visionary way what he thinks the right course, the right approach to life is.
SPEAKER_01In favor of Satombrini.
SPEAKER_00Not really... Well...
SPEAKER_01He has a vision of the witches.
SPEAKER_00He doesn't oppose reason to death. He opposes love to death. Right? I think that that... And that is a little more Christian. Because the weird thing about Nafta is even though he's Catholic, he doesn't really emphasize love. He likes the idea of killing people and the Inquisition and being cruel. Which is why he also likes terror.
SPEAKER_01Right, but he likes... But he... is wedded to this communistic vision of people triumphing over order. He sees the communist revolution as a possible gateway to restoring the Middle Ages, right? Yes, he's a medievalist.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, he likes this idea of anonymous and communal art. And he has this primitive version of the Pieta of Mary holding the body of Jesus' dead body.
SPEAKER_02Mm-hmm. and and yeah he wants art to move more in that direction right he's not like a classicist the way I guess that timbrini is right he's not for beauty he's not for like the exaltation of um yeah all that is beautiful not immortal beauty anyway um
SPEAKER_01yeah what does nafta stand for He's not a nihilist even though his impulses seem nihilistic Yeah It's kind of confusing but he seems sort of reminiscent of a kind of personality that maybe always exists and I think you can probably find it represented on Twitter or just
SPEAKER_00around where it's like someone who's religious and a traditionalist and a reactionary which is what Sednabrini accuses him of being and Nafta's like yeah so what you gotta get used to it um but there's not he's not really motivated by love right like at one point he says the deepest wish of a human being is to like kill someone
SPEAKER_01and kill another human being yeah he's horny for violence
SPEAKER_00And that ends up being important. I don't know if we want a spoiler.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, we've spoiled a lot.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I mean, again, you should totally read The Magic Mountain if you're listening to this.
SPEAKER_01It's my favorite book now.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. But if you don't and you're so brain-addled from the internet, your brain's so addled from the internet... but you can only absorb summaries of classic literature this is the podcast for you because we are kind of going through the whole book but then right when they've kind of reached an impasse and Setembrini and Nafta are like just confusing each
SPEAKER_00other and contradicting each other and like one of them's affirming the body and one of them's affirming the spirit but then the other one's affirming the spirit and the other one's affirming the body yeah then Hans has this crazy dream right when he's a vision when he's out skiing by himself and he almost dies in a snowstorm And he has this vision of this Mediterranean landscape with beautiful things going on and pipers piping and shepherds and bucolic delights The
cradle of western civilization But then he sees these weird witches eating a baby And it's like, that's life It's got beauty and love and goodness in it but then it has this bloody
SPEAKER_01feast I didn't really know what to make of that Or how he reconciles the two visions I think he says Love is what reconciles Everything Love is the best thing But then he forgets about this vision I think you're supposed to get the sense That it's sunk into his being Conditioned the way
SPEAKER_00he thinks Like Nafta's worldview
SPEAKER_01Does he get the cannibalistic witch scene from Nafta's cosmic order?
SPEAKER_00It feels like it would fit more with that kind of Because yeah, I think Nafta does kind of see this world as something akin to what the French thinker Joseph de Maestra, if that's how you pronounce his name Demetra said the world is an author in which all that lives is offered up ceaselessly over and over again.
SPEAKER_01Okay, that sounds like Hegel's a slaughter bench of history.
SPEAKER_00Something like that, yeah. And not if there's a Hegelian.
SPEAKER_01I thought Settinbrini was a Hegelian because he worships reason. Well yeah and we read this book with our friend Eric who is a Hegelian and initially Eric was like yeah I'm supposed to like Setembrini and I feel like Man is kind of making fun of Setembrini but then when Nafta came into the story Eric was like okay I kind of do agree with him Wait but that was your own trajectory I thought I thought that you wanted to like Nafta because Setembrini is this like
SPEAKER_01he's like Redditor He's a Redditor He's like um yeah it just takes things to literally in a more sort of clear cut fashion well yeah I mean but Nafta is made into such a yeah he's such a weird freak he is such a freak like uh Costner even says at one point like yeah he makes a lot of good points and beats Septimbrady in a lot of these debates but he's
this like Spanish
SPEAKER_00inquisitor you know and he like freaks me out mhm Yeah, where Setembrini is like kind of good-hearted and wants the right things, but his logic doesn't always seem to hold up. But the polarity between Nafta and Setembrini is sort of dwarfed by the figure of Peeperkorn. Yeah. Oh, yeah. Yeah, we should probably get into it. That's kind of what's coming up next in the narrative, right?
SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm. So yeah Well like that's the point in the narrative where both of where they're sort of contrary intellectual positions that polarity becomes dissolved by this enigmatic figure Shochat's lover So yeah Hans has been waiting this whole time for Frau Shochat to come back but of course it's not going to be that easy or simple
SPEAKER_00and when she does come back she's got a boyfriend and And he's old and chatted He's an elderly Chad from He's a Dutch Which is scary And he's from He ran like a coffee plantation in Indonesia And yeah He comes to the Magic Mountain And even though he's extremely inarticulate He is so magnetic That
SPEAKER_01everyone is just drawn to him He's personality personified
SPEAKER_00Yes, he's a personality, right? And when they all start going on walks together, Nafta, Settembrini, Hans, Shoshat, Peeperkorn, and Nafta and Settembrini try to have their old debates, but these debates feel like flaccid and like empty now that Peeperkorn's huge person, big personality is in the room. And his personality is so sort of attractive or wins you over to the degree that
SPEAKER_01Hans has no problem like with his predicament, which he should feel cucked, I guess.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, because he had dibs because he saw her first. And Shoshat is married, too, by the way, but, like, no one really cares about that. Yeah. So, yeah, but he ends up, like, making friends with Peepercorn, who... is sort of this Dionysian figure who represents the abundance of being, right?
SPEAKER_01Right. He's totally... Right, you said it. He's inarticulate. He doesn't say... Even when he says stuff, the jumble of words that comes out is just totally devoid of any significance.
SPEAKER_00Yes. But the magnetism is still there. Yeah. Like there's that part where he gets everyone drunk, right? And they have this like whole party. Remember that?
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Right. And he's the star of the show. And he kind of tries to give a speech about how like vice is bad and we should
SPEAKER_00appreciate the simple things in life. And then Kostler was like, well, I don't know. Cause like sometimes vice is cool or whatever. And then like, it seems like peepercorn is going to hit him. But really drinking alcohol Is kind of like the best vice Because it's not really a vice It is appreciating the simple things It's not like doing opium or something like that And then Peeper Corn is like okay Everyone loves him You can't help loving him And if you're doing the thing Where you see this
book as an allegory Of Europe before the war Well that's what we're supposed To see it as but we didn't
SPEAKER_01see It doesn't become explicit Until the very end
SPEAKER_00Yeah, but I think Peeperkorn is like the royal personality. He's like this, the royalty of Europe, if you want to see it that way. His presence sort of like casts the shadow on Satombrini and Naphtha where they
SPEAKER_01seem like cerebral losers.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah, he exposes the like It's like the Chad Minhir Peeperkorn and the Virgin Nafta They're both right like they both meet in the middle that is like being neurotic and cerebral like men of letters who aren't actually like right who don't have any power over the world
SPEAKER_01because they're so they're just like working with words and yeah Limited To The Realm Of Thoughts And Ideas They're Just Like Arguing On Twitter Basically Right Exactly Twitter Flame Wars And Yeah And Peeper Corn But Not Really Living It's Faustian But Even Though Peeper Corn Represents The Abundance Of Being All Is Not Actually Well What Do You Mean By That Well He
Spoiler Spoiler Alert He
SPEAKER_00Kills Himself and you thought that the way in which he kills himself was significant but I can't remember why um he has a special syringe designed that looks like a cobra and he like watches it yeah it's like Adam getting bit by the snake or something right and then he has the snake syringe bite him and inject him with poison and then he dies
SPEAKER_01Why?
SPEAKER_00Why does he kill himself? Were you the one that sent me that howling mutant tweet that was like people say that people make fun of Eve for having been tricked by a snake but it was Adam who
SPEAKER_01was just tricked by a dumb broad or something? Well it was like at least Eve was tricked by the devil Adam was just tricked by
SPEAKER_00some dumb broad Yeah Yeah, I didn't really make much of the apparatus with which Peeperkorn killed himself. Yeah. Will the critics make much of it?
SPEAKER_01What? Yes. I'd like to know.
SPEAKER_00I know. It was in some Harold Bloom essay about this.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you were reading up on the secondary sources.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. But why does he kill himself? If he's so magnetic and people love him so much I think it's implied that he's Well he was ill He was like feeble at that point Yeah that's why he's at the sanatorium And he wanted to go out on his own terms I think it's implied he's impotent Really? Yeah because he looks at Kastorp with this bitterness When he realizes Kastorp has got with Chochat in the past I think Sammy's here maybe And
they become like blood
SPEAKER_00brothers Yeah instead of having like a duel of this or something yeah they um they bond it was kind of sweet actually yeah um is sammy heading over yes he says he's okay okay cool um so um oh i wanted to um we didn't talk about this in the reading group but
SPEAKER_01um there's the turn at the very end of the novel where uh Mon goes full in on like ghosts yeah this is supernatural the weird thing is that the story oh and also so yeah after Peepercorn dies Shoshat just like leaves the sanatorium and it's just like she's gone from the story and Kostorp is just like over her well she like thanks Hans for like being there yeah helping take care of me observe his demise
and then she just bounces because Hans is like instead of trying to cuck this great personality I'm gonna like he's won over by the personality he's like I'm gonna conspire with you to like make him happy that's kind of sweet but then he kills himself he does so then Hans is left alone there oh and Joakim his cousin has also spoiler died from tuberculosis and so now Hans is kind of like alone on the magic
SPEAKER_00mountain And after Joachim dies, time stops getting kept in the novel. Man stops telling you when. Like, how much time has gone by. And stops, like, laying out the markers of, like, and now it was Mardi Gras. After a year two, maybe.
SPEAKER_01After a year two or three, it's no longer, time is no longer kept. Yeah, so, like, the last five years or whatever just kind of start flying by.
SPEAKER_00And Hans gets really into listening to music. and there's a moment actually where Centimbrini voices his suspicion of music where he thinks it's like he thinks that as an art it's politically suspect because it arouses the passions it's not governed by reason right wait I have a passage for that which I thought was really good yeah he says he says yes I
am a fancier of
SPEAKER_01music Which is not to say that I particularly revere it Not, for instance, as I love and revere the written word The bearer of the human intellect The tool The shining plow of progress Music There is something only semi-articulate about it Something dubious Irresponsible Indifferent You will object, I presume That it can also be quite clear But nature can be clear as well A brook can be clear But what good does that do us? It is not true clarity, but a dreamy, empty clarity that demands nothing of us,
SPEAKER_01a clarity without consequences, and therefore dangerous, because it seduces us to take our ease beside it. But, if you like, let music assume its most high-minded pose. Fine, and then our emotions are inflamed, and yet the real point should be to inflame our reason. Music, it would appear, is movement for its own sake, although I suspect it of quietism. Let me overstate my case. My distaste from my distaste for music is political.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And that actually kind of goes against the position on music that I think some of Thomas Mann's greatest influences took Schopenhauer and Nietzsche. He was and he was in the audience for the premiere of that orchestra I sent you.
SPEAKER_01I can't remember now the the I'm blanking on this but I'm pretty sure Mahler's uh oh that number nine okay interesting um which was uh yeah partially based on uh Faust part two so yeah again Hans is going off in directions that Settombrini doesn't want him to go into of getting really into music and then also getting into the occult which he promises Settombrini he won't get into because this woman who's but Settombrini being like
SPEAKER_01oh don't Mess With That Stuff Yeah The Lady Doff Protests Too Much Because Why Would He Be Worried About It You Know I've Always Thought People Were Were A Little Freaked Out By That I've Noticed That I've Noticed That What Do You Mean Well People Who Are Agnostics Or Like Science Oriented Will Be Like More Freaked Out About Right Like Don't Mess With That Stuff But Then It's Like Then You're Right Like Then You're Sort Of Acceding To The Power Of The Occult
SPEAKER_00Yeah, which is portrayed as being real in the book, I think, right?
SPEAKER_01Unquestionably, I think.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, there's this medium, this young Danish girl who shows up at the sanatorium and they start holding seances with her because the one psychoanalysis guy, what was his name? Krakowski? Krakowski. Yeah, he starts holding seances with her. It's supposed to be scientific research, but... And Hans ends up summoning up the ghost of Joachim Who appears wearing the uniform that the German soldiers will end up wearing in World War I So
it is like a precognitive vision of something that hasn't happened yet Because Hans doesn't The uniform he's wearing isn't one that they were wearing yet at the time But it's the
SPEAKER_00one that Hans himself will be wearing Upon reading that I didn't catch that What's the kind of thing You have to go into the secondary literature To realize It was a weird uniform With a giant jug tub thing On his head The helmet Whatever it is It's similar to what they would have been wearing But that's how the story ends Is with Hans getting sent off To fight
SPEAKER_00in World War I and he's singing the songs um that he was like familiarizing himself he has music in his heart now but before we get to that we didn't talk about how the Settumbrini and Nafta issue and also I wanted to but before we move on I wanted to point out
SPEAKER_01that Settumbrini actually um compares Hans to Odysseus um he says uh But at the very beginning when Hans comes to the sanatorium despite being a healthy he's just there as a visitor to his sick cousin Settumbrini calls him or compares him to Odysseus sort of stepping over as it were like Odysseus in the realm of shades Yeah,
SPEAKER_01going into the underworld But the shades do happen That actually happens, yeah
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's true. And the same way Ulysses sees Achilles in the underworld, I guess he sees Joachim. Yeah, there's kind of a weird irony with like you're going up the mountain, but you're actually descending down into the underworld.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Nietzsche's Zarathustra.
SPEAKER_00And so going up and down. As the war approaches everyone starts acting all crazy in the sanatorium and like an anti-Semite guy shows up and he like ends up getting into a fight with a Jewish guy there who he keeps like attacking and insulting Everybody is just like pissed off and like on edge It's like people are attacking the waitress the like dwarf who works as their waitress um people are just being petulant right the chapter's called
The Great Petulance and that kind of rounds off with well that's the most explicit part of the novel that um makes legible the claim that it's a that it's a metaphor yes for the conditions yeah leading up to the war and Nafta and Septimbrini finally have a falling out because even though they have these opposite points of view they're
SPEAKER_00like They're buddies They're like attached to each other They love arguing with each other Well they need each other to sort of be able to posit their own stances Yeah But it reaches some point where I forget what the actual issue is that they fall out over Yeah I can't remember why things come to a head but they do Enough the challenge is set to bring me to a duel and insists on using pistols Right Cause he wants to kill somebody Yeah he's very yeah he's really
eager And it sets you up to thinking Yeah it sets you up to think Nafta's gonna kill Septimbrini but since that's sort of like so would be too obvious it's not what really happens Cause the thing when you're being a gentleman in a duel is you're supposed to not actually kill the other person you fire your gun off in the wrong direction or like
SPEAKER_01shoot it over their heads Is that really what you're supposed to do? That's good form yeah like when Aaron Burr killed Alexander Hamilton he did not observe that custom Huh If I'm remembering correctly I see Yeah cause you get the satisfaction of the duel but and keep your honor but you're not actually shedding
SPEAKER_02blood But the other guy shot
SPEAKER_00Yeah well in that yeah Baron Bird did kill him. Okay I didn't I didn't um see that parallel it's interesting and uh so what happens though with Setembrini and Nafta Setembrini fires his gun off into space and doesn't shoot Nafta and then Nafta's so frustrated because he wants to shoot him or something but instead he shoots himself Very disturbing scene Or did he want Centumbrini to kill him and his upset
SPEAKER_01Centumbrini didn't kill him There's like some beautiful line about how he understands that it takes more courage to shoot than to be shot at Yeah Wait doesn't it take more courage to be oh to shoot than to be shot at yeah I guess that makes sense And then he right in shooting himself he he's observing both positions he's getting shot at and shooting Yeah and so it's really disturbing to everyone It's also not
technically like a very Christian Jesuit thing to do to shoot yourself in the head in a duel Because it's confusing with NAFTA right because sometimes he does seem like oh he's really a Christian but then other times he does seem almost like nihilistic right and just
SPEAKER_00like he just hates life and wants to like is waging war against it Right he's not I mean he doesn't really seem like a Christian like when does he
SPEAKER_01really seem like a Christian? Well I think I think Kostorp even well I mean he's got the pietan in his room and stuff and he praises the Middle Ages and praises Christianity Yeah but like is he really a Catholic? Yeah well like isn't that something Kostorp wonders about he's like is this guy
SPEAKER_00really like an Orthodox Jesuit? He doesn't really seem like Exactly to be doing that I mean I guess he loves suffering Yeah He reveres Yeah he puts suffering on a pedestal Yeah So we kind of covered the whole book Yeah I
SPEAKER_01thought we weren't going to do spoilers We weren't going to do spoilers?
SPEAKER_00I don't know Well we kind of just improvised Yeah It's a beautiful book It's great and yet we didn't really cover like we covered all the serious novel of ideas stuff that is in the magic mountain but it really is just a fully realized world with like weird colorful things happening and a lot of goofball secondary characters bumping around in the sanatorium like um um like uh
the half the people
SPEAKER_00in the half lung club who have had this surgery that makes them have only half of a lung and they kind of like breathe out of a hole in their chest which was like a real treatment that existed anyway yeah so final thoughts um yeah it's um I can't extol the virtues of this book enough it's a yeah yeah it's a
SPEAKER_01masterpiece it's really great I mean it's yeah I you really shouldn't listen to the whole second half of this when we spoil everything that happens but yeah read this book I mean I yeah it's like every good movie I see I'm like oh this is my favorite movie but like and I do it is the same with books because I have a bad memory but no I don't think I've read anything like it yeah and I want to read more of Mon now
SPEAKER_00You've read Death in Venice, right?
SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm. I did read Death in Venice. Barely remember it. So I'm on my second reread. But after that, after I finish that tonight, I'm reading. I'm starting Dr. Faustus.
SPEAKER_00Okay, perfect. Yeah, so Death in Venice would be a good warm-up to read before you read The Magic Mountain. Because originally The Magic Mountain was just supposed to be a companion novella to Death in Venice.
SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm. but then it ended up turning into this like lengthy 700 page book yeah um but yeah it feels fresh it feels like all these ideas are still living for people today in one form or another and I think it's good too because it's a building's ramen and
SPEAKER_00it's like people hunger for some sort of wisdom some sort of educational experience that goes beyond what they're learning in the brainwashing mills that we, the AI generated brainwashing mills that we pretend pass for institutions of education. Yeah, it's great.
I fully recommend It's a beautiful work I haven't read anything like it before Yeah
SPEAKER_00Two thumbs up I'm trying to find a note to end on that's less insipid um oh these are really good yeah those off-brand Pringles well they're not off-brand they're actually yeah they're like it's more expensive these are elite Pringles they're like yeah they're like sprinkles amazing you
Phil Klay, National Book award-winning author and newly elected President of PEN America, pops into the Buntzcast to compare the merits of Tolstoy and Dostoevsky. I’m Team Tolstoy, Phil’s Team Dostoevsky - though we...
Foreign policy expert, frequent CSPAN viewer, radical feminist, fiction writer, and future Chicago mayoral hopeful Grace Morgan pops into the Buntzcast to engage in media training for her political career and air her...
Galen Wolfe-Pauly, CEO and co-founder of Tlon, pops into the Buntzcast for a deep dive into the promise of a decentralized internet. Tlon Inc. is developing the Urbit computing platform, which moves away from the...
The Buntzcast roars back into life after nearly two months of mysterious, unexplained silence. Noah Kumin, editor of The Mars Review of Books and author of the new novel Stop All the Clocks, pops into the studio. We...
Georgina Rose (aka Da'at Darling), a popular Youtuber, podcaster, and expert on all things magical and occult, drops by the Buntzcast. We have a wide-ranging and intriguing discussion, touching on the best places to do...