Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

THE BUNTZCAST

THE BUNTZCAST artwork

Buntzcast 25: Tolstoy vs. Dostoevsky (Feat. Phil Klay)

Oct 14, 20261 hr 15 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Phil Klay, National Book award-winning author and newly elected President of PEN America, pops into the Buntzcast to compare the merits of Tolstoy and Dostoevsky. I’m Team Tolstoy, Phil’s Team Dostoevsky - though we find a lot to like about both authors. Nothing seems to stimulate the literary world to paroxysms of rage and ecstasies of appreciation like placing these two Russian authors in tension, so I think you’ll enjoy our conversation (though you’ll have to supply your own paroxysms of rage). You can find Phil’s books - Redeployment, Missionaries, and Uncertain Ground - wherever fine literature is sold. Pictured below, Tolstoy beard-mogging Dostoevsky: This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit sambuntz.substack.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

[music]

SPEAKER_00This week on The Bunzcast, we have Phil Kly, who was just named the president of PEN America like a few hours, I think, before coming on the podcast. So that's exciting.

SPEAKER_01Going right into the most contentious areas of literary life, Tolstoy versus Dostoevsky.

SPEAKER_00Exactly right. You're following in the footsteps of... Susan Sontag and Norman Mailer. And I think going back pretty far, Arthur Miller. Yeah, I mean, you could really end up wading into controversies because I know when Sontag was running Penn, that was when the fatwa against Solomon Rushdie was issued. And that was like a huge thing, huge controversy. Yeah, it happens. But yeah, that's awesome. And congratulations. Thank you.

SPEAKER_00But yeah, you're also the author of... Redeployment, National Book Award winning short story collection, which I'd recommend to all of the Bunzcast listeners. It's a fantastic collection. Yeah, one of the major literary depictions of the Iraq War from a lot of different perspectives of people in the military, right? From chaplains to psyops guys attending college post-war. Post military service.

SPEAKER_00And also you're the author of the novel Missionaries, right? Which was on, I think, widely critically acclaimed and it made Barack Obama's end of year book recommendations, if I'm not mistaken.

SPEAKER_01Yes, it did. Yes, it did. Which was cool.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And you also host, co-host Manifesto, a podcast with the writer Jake Siegel. Yeah. Which I've been listening to for a number of years. You guys have been doing that for a while now, right?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, we're sort of taking a pause on it. It's just for the two of us, it's just been a little bit difficult. But yeah, that's been a fun and insane project that we greatly appreciate anybody who listened to it because it is a very weird thing.

SPEAKER_00No, it's a good idea for a podcast to have a manifesto that you go through all the manifestos or things that could be conceivably called manifestos. Let's see. But the way this transpired, this podcast that we're doing right now is we're both tweeting about Tolstoy and Dostoevsky. And it became clear that you're more of a fan of Dostoevsky, right? And I'm, I guess, more of a fan of Count Leo Tolstoy.

SPEAKER_00And this became like a not between us, but people on Twitter got very heated about this.

SPEAKER_01Well, I put out a sort of puckish post saying that because I recently reread War and Peace and having finished it, I sort of put out a little bit of a puckish post saying something along the lines of, you know, I just reread War and Peace and it's great. But it confirmed for me my thought that if you like Tolstoy better than Dostoevsky, you need to have your head examined.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01So I can't claim that I was not inviting a certain amount of light and heat. I mean, I actually like these things, you know? And I love these kind of debates. Who's better? How should we rank? And there's always somebody who's like, How Philistine it is to rank great literature or say that we must choose,

SPEAKER_01you know, and why can't we like them both? And it's like, no, no, you can like them both, but you have to choose, right? That's the way that I feel, you know, it's like, look, it matters. It is nonsense to say you don't have to choose. Choosing is an act that forces you to consider what you find possible. Most valuable, right? What are the sites of critical, moral, spiritual, political crisis in the world and the way of seeing that you find most vital and alive and a guide to how you move through your own life?

SPEAKER_01That is what at stake when you were choosing between truly great artists. It doesn't matter whether you like Ed Sheeran better than Jack Harlow, right? You can enjoy them both. You can hate them both. Nobody cares. It does matter. For Tolstoy or Dostoevsky, because they have a different view of the world and a different way of seeing it and a different set of things they find most vital. And so it is a personally instructive act to think through what appeals to you in both of them and what you reject.

SPEAKER_00Yes. Yeah, I totally agree with that. Yeah, the point of the ranking and finding about who's better isn't to suggest the existence of some kind of platonic series of tiers of literary greatness existing in the ether. But maybe that exists. But it's more to get a sense of the person's own soul, right? Their own likings and dislikings and what they value and what they don't.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think that, yeah, it was interesting to me. And it's interesting to me how these two writers really do seem to bring that into focus for a lot of people. I posted something that was like, it was a quote from Tolstoy from Maxim Gorky's I thought that was hilarious because it would be terrible. Why would you want to chill down Dostoevsky?

SPEAKER_00It would negate his whole thing as a writer, basically.

SPEAKER_01Actually, Steiner has a great bit about this, because Steiner has the famous book on Tell a Story of Dostoevsky. People talk about Dostoevsky like he's the arch example of creative neurosis, right?

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01So, you know, Thomas Maness, the distinction between the Olympian health of Goethe and Tolstoy and the sickness of Nietzsche and Dostoevsky, right? And Steiner writes, in actual fact, Dostoevsky was endowed with exceptional strength and powers of endurance with tremendous resilience and animal toughness. These sustained him through the purgatory of his personal life and the imagined hell of his creations. John Kauper Powys notes as central to Dostoevsky's nature, a mysterious and profoundly feminine enjoyment of life, even while suffering from life. Absolutely.

SPEAKER_00Well said. And if you wanted to put it in a more like disrespectful way, which I wouldn't, I actually consider this a compliment, but like Joseph Conrad, who did not like Dostoevsky, said that his writings were like fierce mouthings from prehistoric ages.

SPEAKER_01But that sounds awesome too.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, that sounds good. Yeah. Yeah. It sounds amazing.

SPEAKER_01I would love to write fierce mouthings from prehistoric ages. That'd be incredible.

SPEAKER_00One thing I was thinking about when I was getting ready for this conversation was... Do you remember when Mary Gates was on Manifesto and she said that she talked about that Nirvana song, Moist Vagina? Yes. And this is going to connect back to Dostoevsky. But she said that many of the writers she had in her creative writing classes that she taught, she felt like they wanted some kind of like full-throated expression like that song or like Nirvana. And it was like trying to come out. And I remember wondering at the time, like,

SPEAKER_00Can literature have that same full-throated effect that Nirvana has at full blast? Or do we have to settle for somewhat quieter and more subtle effects? And I think Dostoevsky, while being more articulate than the lyrics of the song Boy's Vagina, for sure, definitely significantly more a great philosophical writer. He has a very full-throated expression, and every character is this hyper-real character.

SPEAKER_00Sort of Shakespearean creation that seems more real than real people. And their personalities are just kind of like, yeah, set loose and are kind of blasting on full blast. You know, I always think it's almost like in a very different register, like the way in Curb Your Enthusiasm, everyone's like ids are just on display and they're never like inhibited. That's how everyone in Dostoevsky is, but in different ways. Like in Curb Your Enthusiasm, it's all like one way, right? It's like being rude or like saying the things you're But in Dostoevsky,

SPEAKER_00it's a more full-throated disinhibition of the deep inner fears

SPEAKER_01and hopes. There's obviously a matter of temperament in terms of who you like. I would say, too, that if you prefer Tolstoy to Dostoevsky, it's because you're reading Dostoevsky wrong. And this is what you need to do. This is what I did. Okay. So when I was a teenager, I went on a... Trip to visit relatives in Montana. And during that time, I took a day pack out and went hiking in the woods alone. And I kept seeing these white cliffs, right?

SPEAKER_01Very beautiful. And I wanted to climb them, but they were like off the path. It's stupid to free climb in general. And I wasn't like a climber. I didn't really know what I was doing. I was just like a dumb teenager willing to risk my life. And eventually I was like, ah, it looks awesome. I want to climb those cliffs. So I went off the trail. Hiked through the woods a little bit, got to the base of these cliffs, started climbing. Like maybe, I don't know, 50, 60 feet up, like not like high enough that you would necessarily die if you fell,

SPEAKER_01but high enough that you would almost certainly break lots of stuff and then just like be in pain and agony at the base of a cliff far from trail in the woods of Montana. And, um, And I had two good handholds and like a sort of decent foothold and I go up to another foothold and it breaks. And so I shift all my weight to my other foothold, which proceeds to break. And then I'm just hanging from this cliff with my two hands and like looking around

SPEAKER_01and like those footholds were how I got up here in the first place. So I'm not really sure what to do or how I can get out of there. And I'm sort of thinking like, huh, I wonder if I'm just going to hang here. Until I get too tired to hang and then I'm going to fall and die. So I've got like, you know, I don't know, maybe like 10, 15 seconds of that. And then I kind of figure out how to like pull myself up and kind of get leverage off of where the cliff wall kind of comes out a little, you know, and get to another handhold and kind of get past that spot.

SPEAKER_01And by the time I get to the top of the cliff, I'm totally exhausted. There's like a bramble bush in my way. And instead of going around it, which would have been easy, I just go right through it. And it like tears at my shirt. And I like I'm bleeding a little from scratches. And I sit up on the top of this cliff and I take the Brothers Karamazov out of my bed. And I read the Rebellion and Grand Inquisitor chapters for the first time in my life after having felt like I was about to die and looking on this beautiful Montana Valley.

SPEAKER_01And if you think Tolstoy is better than Dostoevsky, I urge you to do that and it'll change your mind.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, I think that's a good idea. I mean, maybe you should also bring the death of Ivan Ilyich with you or Master and Man and read those. In addition to those chapters, because those do have a lot to do with death, which seems to be the problem that really preoccupied Tolstoy. Back when I was in college, There were these two classes I always wanted to take taught by the same professor and it always, I know other requirements got in the way of it, but the titles were Tolstoy and the Problem of Death and Dostoevsky and the Problem of Evil.

SPEAKER_00So maybe there was some, maybe part of what like attracts people's interest to one or the other is might be connected to which of those two problems seems more potent, though not necessarily.

SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm.

SPEAKER_00But yeah, the rebellion- That's true that

SPEAKER_01Dostoevsky has some amazing death scenes. The death of the sort of like the father and demons at the end where it's sort of, he's like this absurd creature, sort of pitiful and you kind of love him and his death is comic and intensely sad. I mean, it's just, it's a, And Tolstoy did death pretty good too.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Some of Dostoevsky's, and I think this might get to why I don't like him as much as Tolstoy. Some of his scenes, well, like when I'm thinking about it.

SPEAKER_01Because he's a big hot mess of a writer.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. The soap operatic melodramatic nature of like Sonia's stepmother dying in crime and punishment. It's very like overwrought and sort of. Yeah, I don't know, like sensationalistic and kind of like... Yeah, it's all at a

SPEAKER_01high pitch.

SPEAKER_00It's a little high pitched. And yeah, I think that that is... Like with Dostoevsky, the chapters I like the best are the philosophical debates, right? I know some people claim that... No, I like the farcical set pieces where they're all arguing about like a carp at the beginning of The Brothers Karamazov. You remember that part where they're arguing about the carp?

SPEAKER_01I will say this, like... Dostoevsky is really funny in a way that Tolstoy is not. I mean, like, it's not that Tolstoy couldn't do humor. The scene where Pierre becomes a Mason in War and Peace is hilarious. And there's like this, even this moment where like, Pierre starts to think like, maybe this is all ridiculous. But then he's like, well, no, all the people around me are important people in society. So we're not all ridiculous. You know, it's very funny. But I mean, Dostoevsky's Really funny.

SPEAKER_01And also, like, mean. I mean, the portrait of Turgenev in Demons is so mean and so funny. It's just incredible. But yeah, he definitely, on humor, Dostoevsky definitely wins. And also, like, the philosophical passages. Because, you know, I mean, one of the reasons that I sent out that puckish tweet was because after, like, all of these amazing scenes. And, like, in any given moment, Tulsa is going to write it better. Right.

SPEAKER_00Okay. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01On average. Right. Um, and even when like, cause you know, when I started war and peace, it was sort of funny. Right. Cause it was like, um, you, you know, this was like the prestige television of its day. There was no television. So you're kind of reading it and you're like, okay, you know, like it's all really well handled. Um, Sometimes the writer's room gets tired and they're like, let's throw in a rich guy with a secret will,

SPEAKER_01you know, and you're reading it and you're like, but I already read that in the last season of George Eliot, you know, but, um, but it's handled really, really well, you know, and the observation is wonderful and, uh, and the guy not sure of what he's supposed to do around his father's death is really kind of beautifully handled. And then you get to these scenes like that once you get to the Battle of Austerlis, you're like, oh my God, this is genius, right? This writing. Whereas, you

SPEAKER_01know, Demons is the one of Dostoevsky's that I reread most recently. So it's the one that I keep referencing. But, you know, when I restarted it, you know, for the first hundred pages or so, I was like, I thought I remembered liking this book. And then you get to the passages that have this incredible intensity that reshape you as a human being in ways that you don't understand, right? Yes. That reach a kind of feverish power and intensity that I frankly don't really find

SPEAKER_01in Dostoevsky. I will find scene after scene that I admire so much. You know that poem, the Rilke poem, but the archaic torso of Apollo, where in that poem, it's not that you're observing the archaic torso of Apollo. You have a sense that, even though there's no head and no eyes, that it's observing you.

SPEAKER_01Of course, the famous line is, you must change your life. Dusty F.C. writes those scenes for me in every book over and over again in ways that are... It's not even, I think, a matter of... I'm not necessarily even talking about skill because it's a sort of approach to the world, right?

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Dostoevsky is directly challenging you, and there's a kind of remove in Tolstoy that's a little different. He wants you to confront death. That's very clear.

SPEAKER_00I guess one thing that Dostoevsky doesn't really do particularly is, you know, I think I'm pretty sure you're fond of this. You know, I know you like Joseph Conrad, right? I love Conrad. Conrad's amazing, yeah. And his famous motto is that the writer is supposed to make you see, right?

SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm.

SPEAKER_00And Dostoevsky, it's like, I actually felt like I was seeing St. Petersburg in Crime and Punishment, but he doesn't really describe it. And in The Brothers Karamazov, he doesn't really describe the town. And it sounds maybe kind of like a trivial objection. I think that there are some writers who will just describe endlessly to no particular purpose and can get a little I love John Updike, and I think a lot of his descriptive writing is beautiful,

SPEAKER_00but sometimes I feel like he's phoning in the prose poetry at the expense of actually doing something with it or telling a compelling story. But yeah, Dostoevsky really doesn't do that. It's all personality. And also the plot hijinks, which seem a little not that important to me. But there's also the...

SPEAKER_01Complexity of social relationships, right? So if you think of Notes from a Dead House, right?

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01I mean, that is the great prison book, right? And it's not because he spends so much time physically describing things, right? Which obviously Tolstoy would excel at. Yeah. But the way in which this very particular group of people interact and behave in

SPEAKER_01a very particular way, and I think that that is the social landscape, right, is absolutely and astoundingly worked out. In a lot of Dostoevsky. There is a kind of remove in Tolstoy. Tolstoy doesn't make me feel suffering.

SPEAKER_01Encounter with death, yes. Suffering, not so much.

SPEAKER_00About the death of Ivan Ilyich? I feel like there's a lot of suffering leading up to the actual dying.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00I do love that book.

SPEAKER_01But it is mostly the sort of existential confrontation with mortality, right? Which, again, like, it's really good at. And it's over and over again in a lot of his work. Yeah. But, you know, you think about, say, Pierre deciding that the suffering he endures as a prisoner is not so different depending on your state of mind from an aristocrat facing momentary unpleasantness. And compare that to the speech about poverty being a vice in crime and punishment, right?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Got how the material conditions of life and power relations could have these huge spiritual effects, right? And in Notes from a Dead House, there's this sort of amazing passage where he's basically talking about the etiquette and relationship of a man being beaten by the man who's going to beat them and what they appreciate. And the prisoners appreciate not the guard who's ashamed to do it, but the guard who takes a kind of delight in it, right?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. There's this kind of tremendous understanding, not simply of what suffering is, but how it echoes throughout society. So I think that even though Tolstoy would describe the prison better, and you'd actually sort of probably understand the hierarchy and everything better than if Tolstoy would write about it, and actually sort of amusingly enough, I think it is Tolstoy who wrote the greatest scene of a guy who thinks he's about

SPEAKER_01to be executed. Because there's an amazing one in more piece. But I do think that there's something really important that there's no question that Dostoevsky gets better. And I think about those characters all the time.

SPEAKER_00I mean, I think Tolstoy, though, captures the suffering of just, like, ordinary life. Like in The Death of Ivan Ilyich, Ivan Ilyich is, you know, the horror of his death is partly that he realizes he's wasted his entire life, right? He's never really come alive. He's never lived for anyone aside from himself. He's just been a creature of routine and habit, right? The thing he enjoyed the most was playing bridge. And then when he Is trapped in the isolation of dying.

SPEAKER_00Everyone around him wants to pretend it's not happening. Right. Yeah. He has to confront the nature of his own relations to them. Right. Like he he says his marriage was just sort of a thing that happened. It didn't come out of any deep passion. And everyone's just pretending everything's OK, except for his servant, who is like helping him use the bathroom and doing all these sort of, you know, nursing. Type things like taking care of him and actually is the only one who says who

SPEAKER_00through the things he says recognizes that he is dying. Right. And like to have someone else say that to you is like a relief. Right. Because you're being allowed to recognize reality and recognize what's going on. And there is this kind of, you know, without needing to bring in. The aid of the ghosts of past, present, and future, like for Scrooge, there is this change of heart that Tolstoy excels at producing, not just in The Death of Ivan Ilyich, but in

SPEAKER_00Master and Man and Father Sergius and some other stories, and in Anna Karenina as well, where... It's a naturalistic but also spiritual process of this change brought about inside people, some sort of moral change that I find really compelling. And when I'm reading about that stuff, it does give me a sense of like, oh, yeah, this is what it actually is like. I think that with Dostoevsky, it's a little more like, yeah,

SPEAKER_00capturing things about life that That really are profound and important and are there, both a lot of stage fire and theatricality almost, which is a good thing. It's not a bad thing. But in Tolstoy's case, it's like this weird usurpation of like, this is what living is actually like. Like, this is how this actually feels. And yeah, I have like,

SPEAKER_01probably some of- One thing that people have pointed out, which I think is quite true, that Tolstoy actually does happiness quite well, which is difficult. Yeah, that too. Someone was asking me like, getting married, what's a good book to read for somebody getting married? And I said, Anna Karenina, which, okay, everybody laughs because they're like, the suicide book. But there is a portrait of a happy marriage, right? In that book that is astounding and quite beautiful. And yes, so there are aspects of life

SPEAKER_01To really important, if you'd like to live a good one, that you will find in Tolstoy and you will not find in Dostoevsky. Yes. And the Dostoevsky characters tend to be extreme, but at the same time, there are these extremes that you recognize again and again. I was talking with somebody over like, there's this sort of intense kind of, Among the extremes of the right wing, like a hatred of Zelensky, right?

SPEAKER_00Yes.

SPEAKER_01In charge of Ukraine, which is like, which is bizarre, right? Because it's one thing to say like, okay, your country got attacked by like a horrible dictator who is brutal. And you, even though you could have fled, have stayed in your fighting for your homeland and, you know, Me, because I'm like a, you know, I have a particular, so I support Ukraine.

SPEAKER_01I think we should support Ukraine.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, for sure.

SPEAKER_01But like, if you're like, oh, I think we need a more isolationist foreign policy and blah, blah. I could understand why you would go like, it's very sad and whatever, but we don't have the, you know, missiles to spare. It's not our problem or it's

SPEAKER_00Europe's problem or

SPEAKER_01whatever. I can understand that argument intellectually. And I was talking with somebody, he's like, but what I don't get is this loathing for him, right? That you see. And, you know, because people will accuse him of wanting to start World War III, you know, acting like he's this sort of monster. It's very peculiar. And then, you know, there's that kind of shameful encounter with J.D. Vance where he's berating him.

SPEAKER_01And this is a guy whose country is fighting for its life in a very, very real way and taking incredible casualties doing it. And he was saying, but why this loathing for him? And I said, I think Papa Karamasov explains it. Because there's a bit in Brothers Gay where the father says, he's talking about somebody that he loathes. And they ask him why. And he says, he never did anything to me, it's true.

SPEAKER_01But I once played a most shameless, nasty trick on him. And the moment I did it, I immediately hated him for it.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Hmm. Yeah, it is a weird impulse. Uh... Yeah, because, yeah, like you're saying, you can understand the people who are pure. Yeah, we're just like isolationists. Don't want to get involved in any foreign entanglements. But at the same time, like so many of the people who are opposed to the Ukraine war are pro Putin. They are like pro war. And this is they like want Russia to win the war, which seems very puzzling to me.

SPEAKER_01Well, I mean, I don't know how many of these actual people there are. There's certainly a lot of like weirdos online and robots on Twitter.

SPEAKER_00So that's probably more where I experienced the anti-Zelensky.

SPEAKER_01But it is definitely, it's definitely a thing, you know, and I think some of those voices like the current vice president the United States listens to, right?

SPEAKER_00So it's not something you can purely

SPEAKER_01relegate to, you know, bizarre social media land.

SPEAKER_00But Phil, if Dostoevsky was alive today, he totally would be supporting Putin.

SPEAKER_01I mean, look, Dostoevsky is a mess, man. Yeah. There's the work and then there's everything else, right? I'm talking about the novels.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah. I was hesitant to bring up this point, the Russian nationalism and the anti-Semitism as well. Because they're the kind of things that like, well, people always bring these up, right? I feel like the best things about a writer transcend their, yeah, the mess of their ordinary personality, their ordinary ego. Like Yates said, the person who writes the poems isn't the same bundle of like egotism and anxiety that sits down to eat breakfast.

SPEAKER_01This is true, but it's also, it's not unrelated to the work, right? It's not unrelated because you can find it in the work.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah. And so in Dostoevsky's case, I picked this one because there's something about it, but it's one of the weirdest passages in the Brothers Karamazov. So it's when, what's her name? Is it Liesel? Liza? The sort of girl who likes Alyosha. What's her name? Liesel? Liesel? Blank out. Yeah. Yeah. She's talking to Alyosha at one point in the book, and I guess she's kind of like losing it.

SPEAKER_00And she's like, I talked to no one but myself and you, only you in the whole world, and to you more readily than to myself. And I'm not a bit ashamed with you. Not a bit. Alyosha, why am I not ashamed with you? Not a bit. Alyosha, is it true that at Easter the Jews steal a child and kill it? And then Alyosha, the moral and spiritual conscience of the book, says, I don't know. Not awesome. That's not good. It's not great. No.

SPEAKER_00She says, there's a book here in which I read about the trial of a Jew who took a child of four years old and cut off the fingers from both hands and then crucified him on the wall, hammered nails into him and crucified him. And afterwards, when he was tried, he said that the child died soon, within four hours. That was soon. He said the child moaned, kept on moaning, and he stood admiring it. That's nice. And Alyosha says, nice. And then she says, nice. I sometimes imagine that it was I who crucified him. He would hang there moaning, and I would sit opposite him eating pineapple compote.

SPEAKER_00I'm awfully fond of pineapple compote. Do you like it? Alyosha looked at her in silence. Her pale, sallow face was suddenly contorted. Her eyes burned. It's a weird, well, it's not just weird. I mean, there's obviously deeply unpleasant, hateful things kind of brewing at the back of that. And it's also just weird on another level, too, because it's like, what is going on here? I guess the point is just to demonstrate evil or original sin or something like that brewing in the hearts even of this young girl.

SPEAKER_00And I don't know, I find it like a really weird thing. Like I'm not entirely sure what we're supposed to be getting out of it. And it also, obviously it's like bringing up the blood libel and not really taking like a position against it for sure. And sort of implying it, there's a chance it might be real or something, you know?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Oh yeah. I mean, I, you know, I was talking with a friend about, uh, as a Jewish friend, uh, as Jake was, he was talking about like being a, Like, Jewish and lover of great literature, there's like a particular type of eye that you have to have when you get to those passages in Dostoevsky or Dickens or Orwell, you know, where all of a sudden there's this swerve.

SPEAKER_00Yes. Yeah, it is surprising how much, how frequently it leaps out with you, even up until like fairly recently in... In time. Yeah, I feel like the things that when people want to criticize Dostoevsky, rightly, these are the kind of things they would point out, right? Or his like extreme Russian nationalism. I think he thought Christ favored Russia or that like the, you know, Eastern Orthodoxy was the only true faith. And so Russia had this sort of like imperialist mission to like spread it to

SPEAKER_00the rest of the world. It's kind of interesting too that he thought there was something, I guess maybe... Like looking towards liberation theology or something or things that he thought, he thought that Catholicism would become like communist or would lose its spirituality and just fuse with it. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01I mean, he was also fervently anti, I mean, like the Grand

SPEAKER_00Inquisitors, the evil Jesuit, right? Yeah. But it happened in his country, not really.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. But yeah, Nabokov, whose literary views I frequently find way weird and off base, but...

SPEAKER_01By the way, I love great writers making an ass of themselves with their literary judgments. I mean, Nabokov is like a great one for that because he's like very strident, strong denunciations of people who are just geniuses. And actually Tolstoy too. Tolstoy wrote a whole essay about why Shakespeare is bad. Yes.

SPEAKER_00It's kind of hilarious to read. It's weird. It's weird. It's weird because there's something you... Can learn from it even

SPEAKER_01though it's so wrong. But you know, it's funny because to go back to Steiner, Steiner says that like, Dostoevsky had the dramatic temperament, right? Yes. And you can see like the, almost like the staging of a lot of his scenes, right? Yes. Whereas Tolstoy has the epic temperament for Steiner. And, you know, it's just very obvious that Shakespeare is this... I don't know, a thing that he can't enter into for whatever reason.

SPEAKER_01He particularly dislikes King Lear. And of course, King Lear has so much more in common with Dostoevsky than with anything that Tolstoy ever wrote.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, there was something he said about... Here, I'm trying to find it in my notes. It was in that same quote where he said he should have read Confucius and the Buddha to chill him out. Oh, he said... And yeah, I don't agree with this, but it kind of mirrors his criticisms of Shakespeare, too. He says... It's all painful and useless because all those idiots, adolescents, Raskalnikovs and the rest of them, they are not real.

SPEAKER_00It is all much simpler, more understandable. And it was the theatricality of Shakespeare too that he partly objected to. Like he said that the only one who didn't speak like an actor was Falstaff. Yeah. But is that what I object to about Dostoevsky or Tulsa? I mean, I think that like, Part of it for me is just these weird long, I don't like as much, maybe some of the things people find funny, I think I'm kind of like lacking in Context for it,

SPEAKER_00like that long sequence in the Brothers Karamazov where Dmitry is trying to win Grushenka back from that Polish cavalry officer that she fell in love with years before. And there's kind of this like long sequence where the Polish cavalry officer is depicted as this like weird clown with these weird mustaches. And it's like it goes on and on. And it is some sort of like weird Russian nationalist propaganda going on in the background. Kind of this weird like cry bullying thing a little bit where it's like, yeah,

SPEAKER_00this like Polish, this like superficial dandy Polish cavalrymen is like trying to get this Russian woman at like defending the honor of Russia against him or something a little bit.

SPEAKER_01I have to say there's a lot of old books where there are scenes with light social comedy. Yeah. That tend not to hit that much for me, you know, like, I mean, Proust does this too. And part of it, I think, is just that we're not a part of that society, you know? Yeah. And so it's this, they're not particularly stakes for us. We're not recognizing the characters and types and scenes because it's sort of, you know, there's,

SPEAKER_01you know, it might have been effective in its time, but is not quite as vital for us. Scenes can be funny. I mean, some of the social commentary in Proust is funny, but it doesn't hit for me as undoubtedly it would hit for somebody contemporary, right?

SPEAKER_00Yes.

SPEAKER_01And that's different, you know, because there's like light social comedy, which is distinct from like, there's a bit in, Condera likes to talk about in the curtain, he talks about a scene in Don Quixote, right? Where Don Quixote shows up at this place and the people there all realize immediately he's a madman, right? Yeah. But then the son is a poet and he starts reciting his poetry

SPEAKER_01and Don Quixote starts praising it to the skies and they all decide that he's completely sane. No longer the slapstick, the quite funny slapstick, actually, of the early passages of Don Quixote. I think Cervantes wrote one of the greatest scenes of people having a massive attack of diarrhea and vomiting ever written.

SPEAKER_00Isn't there a part where Don Quixote is throwing up and then Sancho Pons is throwing up and they're both watching each other throw up? On each other.

SPEAKER_01It's so funny because they drink the balsam of fiebers. It's one of the most hilarious scenes and it's so intensely juvenile and so funny. But this later scene, it's not like one person is exactly the butt of the joke, but there's a kind of more Open comedy, mysterious comedy that's really about basic human nature.

SPEAKER_01All great writers who are writing in a comic vein, I take comedy very seriously as something that should be in the arsenal of a great writer. But some types of humor are more bound to their time than others, right? Definitely. Now, the scene where Dostoevsky is making fun of Turgenev in Demons, I mean, that's just immortal because pompous writers are as immortal. It's a recurring trope.

SPEAKER_01It's not bound by time.

SPEAKER_00Maybe I haven't read Demons. I've only read Crime and Punishment, Brothers Karamazov, and... Notes from Underground. I mean, Notes from Underground is incredible, right?

SPEAKER_01I love the... Oh, the passages. It's just like a... It's indignity to be forced to accept that two plus two equals four. It's such a wild and also philosophically rich book. I think one of the reasons that... I started saying this before, but you know, that I made that slightly puckish tweet about Tolstoy

SPEAKER_01and Dostoevsky was there's this kind of a drag philosophical bits at the end of war and peace. And when I'm reading Tolstoy expounding on his philosophies.

SPEAKER_00Sometimes they're interesting.

SPEAKER_01Sometimes they're less so. But it's not like when Dostoevsky is giving you these insane philosophical speeches that are like deeply profound and challenging to everything you think you know.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. You know, it's funny. You were talking about Steiner with the epic Dimension of Tolstoy and that being his register. But like the Tolstoy that I like the best, I mean, I love Anna Karenina, but like my favorite stories, you know, the stories I think are the strongest maybe short fictions I've ever read are the later stories, the novellas and short stories like The Death of Ivan Ilyich, Father Sergius, and Master and Man, which all kind of Seem related to me in lots of ways.

SPEAKER_00Like Father Sergius, I think. I've never read. It's, yeah, it's not like as famous as Master and Man or The Death of Ivan Ilyich, but it's, uh, you'd like it. It's great. I don't want, I kind of want to give away what happens in it. Um, but it, it has to do with this. He's like a prince, right? A noble, um, And he finds out that the woman he loves is actually the mistress of the Tsar's son. Okay. Okay.

SPEAKER_00And he like is so distraught about this or upset that he like rage quits his promising military career in his whole life and he becomes a hermit and he's like living alone out in the woods and he has this weird encounter with these merrymakers who stopped by his cell and it's like the one woman kind of like hits on him and then in a fit of like rage he like cuts off either his finger or his whole hand. I think it might just be the finger.

SPEAKER_00And then this like weird event that just comes out of his own like pathologies leads to this idea that he's like a saint and a holy man and like all these peasants start getting like faith healed by visiting him. And he gets used to like receiving all their presents and everything. But then he ends up having... Breaking his vow of chastity that he imposed on himself.

SPEAKER_00And he gets led. He's like all in despair. He's like, I'm a fraud. I don't think God exists. What's wrong with me? And he falls asleep and he has this dream where he remembers his cousin who... He kind of made fun of this one time and everyone felt bad. And then he heard that she had like a hard life and was like married to an alcoholic landlord. And yeah, so he but he feels like the dream is telling him to go visit her. And he goes and visits her. And He's like, you know, people think I'm this holy man or whatever, but that's all wrong.

SPEAKER_00I'm actually full of sins and I've done like every evil thing you could imagine. And then she's like, well, he's like, so you have to like, tell me how you live. And then she's like, well, you know, it's kind of a wretched existence. Like I have to take care of all these people and my kid, like kids and Well, she only has one kid, but I think like, yeah, all these people who depend on her and serfs and servants. And she's like busy with all these little tasks, taking care of people and living for others. And she's like, yeah, you know, I go to church, but like I pray kind of mechanically and I just sort of feel like I'm kind of

SPEAKER_00a poor sinner or whatever. And then he kind of walks away from this encounter being like, oh, wait, that's what I was supposed to do. Like I was supposed to just live a decent, humble life for other people. And then the way the story ends, I gave away the whole thing. But it's like, where's that part?

SPEAKER_01These little.

SPEAKER_00Okay. Yeah. It's like, he's kind of tramping around Russia as like a pilgrim slash vagrant and they arrest them for vagrancy and transport him to Siberia. And then it says in Siberia, he settled down as the hired man of a well-to-do peasant in which capacity he works in the kitchen garden, teaches children and attends to the sick. And then the story ends. And that's like, it's such a, a stare kind of like seemingly bleak story, but this is supposed to be a triumph.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, he's good at that. There's a scene in, so Death of Ivan Illich, it begins with the corpse, right? And there's this passage where he says, the dead man lay as all dead men lie. Unusually heavy with its dead weight, with rigid limbs sinking into the soft lining of the coffin, and his head bowed for eternity on the pillow, and he displayed what dead people always display, a waxen yellow forehead with bald patches over his hollow temples and

SPEAKER_01a protruding nose that seemed to be pressing down hard on his upper lip. He had changed a good deal. He was thinner than he had been when Pyotr Ivanovich had last seen him, but as with all dead bodies, his face had acquired greater beauty. More to the point, greater significance than it had had in life. Its expression seemed to say that what needed to be done had been done and done properly. More than that, the expression contained a reproach, or at least a reminder to the living. The reminder seemed out of place to Pyotr Ivanovich, or at least he felt it didn't apply to him personally.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01And that's a little funny at the end.

SPEAKER_00Well, yeah, it's like our universe. Well, I don't know if it's universal, but almost our... Sort of universal ability to like imagine death not ever happening to us or like completely ignore it.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, but also giving us this object richly described in the way that he's very good at that becomes imbued with a kind of reproach to the living in a sense of there's like a sort of aura around it, a kind of holiness that thing that had to be done was done. And then the The rest of the novella is going to be showing the sort of torturous path towards achieving that final corpse.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Because for Tolstoy, that was the big question, right? Like in my confession about his religious spiritual journey and transformation, the question he says that really hit him when he was reaching middle age was, what is there in my life that the inevitable death awaiting me won't destroy? Yeah. So it was the attempt, like, and that's what animates, I think, these later stories too. But it was always something that concerned him. You know, I mean, if you go back to Anna Karenina and even like the Cossacks,

SPEAKER_00which I just read recently, which I guess people say is his first masterpiece, it's all animated by this attempt to like live some sort of almost ascetic Christian life in the face of death. And yeah, even though he doesn't have the... Like theatrical intensity of Dostoevsky. He has this like moral intensity. He's not depicting people who are like these total like nihilists, like Svidrigalov in Crime and Punishment or like old Karamazov.

SPEAKER_01What a character. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Come on. Come on. They're great. No, they're great. What a character, man. But yeah. It's the intensity is focused elsewhere. It's focused a lot of times on people who do feel like they are his surrogates. I mean, he's great at creating characters, but I think a lot of his poignancy is invested in these people who represent his own life energies being threatened by annihilation. I think Anna Karenina is that. I think she represents his own intense will to live that was always going

SPEAKER_00to be dissatisfied the more it tried to work itself out in the world. That's what kind of led to this sort of intense version of Christianity. This like very pared down, ascetic kind of Christianity where he wanted to live with the serfs. Yeah, the religious differences between them I think are worth remarking on because I think that they're kind of important.

SPEAKER_00I feel like

SPEAKER_01I mean, look, they're both religious in some regard. It feels Dostoevsky's way into his Christianity is much more resonant with how I think about things, right? Kierkegaard has this bit in one of his books where he talks about how the question of Whether there's a God or not should have the urgency that a man feels when being

SPEAKER_01on the back of a galloping horse that's out of control. You feel that very much so in Dostoevsky. These are the central questions. I'm teaching a course on saints and sinners, images of holiness in contemporary fiction. You know, I give these books to my students and I'm like, okay, you have to actually read them because these are the books

SPEAKER_01that might change your life. No promises, right? But what these authors are doing again and again is staging situations and scenes where characters are forced to make fundamental questions about how they want to exist in the world and their ultimate values, right? And reading these books will force you, if you do it well, if you take them seriously, to ask yourself these same questions. You don't have to like all these books. You might not.

SPEAKER_01They're all great books. And the act of reading them will force you into that space. Dostoevsky forces you into that space with religious questions time and time again. I think Tolstoy does so at more of a remove. I think he forces you into existential questions, right? And again, the confrontation with death is done phenomenally well, time and again,

SPEAKER_01Tolstoy. But I don't feel... That urgency around a lot of the other sort of spiritual questions of life. Particularly, you know, questions of sin and suffering.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. It's funny with Tolstoy because He is basically like a liberal Protestant of his own sect, right? Like he pairs it all down. He seems to get rid of all the miracles. He writes his own version of the Gospels where he cuts out everything that he doesn't think happened or doesn't agree with or whatever. Maybe not doesn't agree, but like the Jefferson Bible, he kind of like pairs it down to the moral teachings, right? Maybe in a more profound way than Jefferson.

SPEAKER_00I haven't read either. I haven't read Tolstoy's Gospels in brief, but you know, it was... Um, so in some ways, I don't know, like, I feel like I should relate to Dostoevsky's version of religion more. Um, but there's something about Tolstoy that like this weird urgency of like living for others and trying to like get out of the, the confines of your own self-centered interests that just, I keep coming back to you.

SPEAKER_00Like I was reading master and man, um, Rereading parts of it to prep for this. And in it, it's like this landowner who's, yeah, again, just sort of self-absorbed and excited to get a bargain price on some land he wants to buy from another landowner. He takes his one surf, Nikita, out in a sled and they get trapped in a snowstorm and they're going to freeze to death. And Nikita, the surf is like, Incapacitated, right?

SPEAKER_00He's like freezing and the landlord kind of like abandons him. And then he just ends up going in circles in the snow and keeps coming back to the sled. And then at the end. It's like he is facing the surf who's freezing and then he, it says Vasily, that's the name of the landowner, Vasily Androvich stood silent and motionless for half a minute. Then suddenly with the same resolution with which he used to strike hands when making a good purchase, he took a step back and turning up his sleeves began raking the snow off Nikita

SPEAKER_00and out of the sledge. Having done this, he hurriedly undid his girdle, opened out his fur coat and having pushed Nikita down, lay down on top of him, covering him not only with his fur cut, but with the whole of his body, which glowed with warmth. So then he ends up being the one who freezes to death instead of the peasant. Right. Yeah. And as he's laying there, he starts having this dream where he thinks that like the police officer in their town is coming to like escort them to escort him to go. For something, to like find some sort of like bargain price on land or something.

SPEAKER_00It's like still kind of like miggled with his old, old things that he wanted. But it says, he whom he was expecting came, not Ivan Matveich, the police officer, but someone else. Yet it was he whom he had been waiting for. He came and called him and it was he who had called him and told him to lie down on Nikita. And Vasily Androvich was glad that one had come for him. I'm coming, he cried joyfully, and that cry awoke him, but woke him up not at all the same person he had been when he fell asleep. He tried to get up but could not,

SPEAKER_00tried to move his arm and could not, to move his leg and also could not, to turn his head and could not. He was surprised but not at all disturbed by this. He understood that this was death and was not at all disturbed by that either." He remembered that Nikita was lying under him and that he had got warm and was alive. And it seemed to him that he was Nikita and Nikita was he, and that his life was not in himself, but in Nikita. He strained his ears and heard Nikita breathing and even slightly snoring. Nikita is alive, so I too am alive, he said to himself triumphantly.

SPEAKER_00And he remembered his money, his shop, his house, the buying and selling, and Mironov's millions, and it was hard for him to understand why that man... Called Vasily Brekhanov, had troubled himself with all those things with which he had been troubled. Well, it was because he did not know what the real thing was, he thought, concerning that Vasily Brekhanov. He did not know, but now I know, and know for sure, now I know. And again he heard the voice of the one who had called him before. I'm coming, coming, he responded gladly, and his whole being was filled with joyful emotion.

SPEAKER_00He felt himself free, and that nothing could hold him back any longer. After that, Vasily Androvich neither saw, heard, nor felt anything more in this world. All around him, all around the snow still eddied. The same whirlwinds of snow circled about, covering the dead Vasily Androvich's fur coat, the shivering McCordy, I guess that's a horse, the sledge, now scarcely to be seen, and Nikita lying at the bottom of it, kept warm beneath his dead master.

SPEAKER_01Hmm.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So, I mean, it is about death, right? But it's almost about this, yeah, I don't know, this sacrifice of your own interests or something. It's like, I don't know, the fact that it's sort of shorn of the other elements of Christianity and pared down to this pure human relation, you know, I don't like, that's not fully how I approach it, but There is something that makes it in fiction, I think, very like affecting because you're dealing with the materials

SPEAKER_00that fiction can deal most directly with, I guess.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I mean, I have found, right? So I teach fiction.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01It is much easier to give students a passage from Tolstoy than from Dostoevsky. Yeah. Right? To teach them, you know, to talk about like, Here's how you handle scene, character, whatever it is. And actually, you know, it's funny. And this actually sort of goes back to that Steiner comment about the sort of dramatic versus the epic temperament. I mean, Tolstoy is a master of great scenes. There are great scenes in Dostoevsky, obviously. But like, when I think about

SPEAKER_01the intensity of the scenes, right? There's always... It's like a gathering up of everything in the novel, right? Like the last probably 100 pages of Demons are this unbelievably intense trip, right? But I can't extract little bits from it to read to you in the way that I could very easily read you a section from any one of

SPEAKER_01Tolstoy's novels because It's so much about this sort of buildup of dramatic momentum, right? And there are even the sort of philosophical speeches are always complicated by the surrounding drama, you know, like Marmoledove's speech about poverty being a vice, you can just like extract as a speech about the material conditions of poverty, but it's also about a, it's also a drunk justifying letting his daughter go into prostitution, right?

SPEAKER_01Yes. And The, you know, the axe murderer, obviously, and all the other things that happened in Crime and Punishment. You know, it's this sense of this, like, steady accumulation of dramatic force and power that, you know, obviously there are many fine moments that you can extract. But they... There's so many fine, amazing scenes in Tolstoy.

SPEAKER_01They all work sort of beautifully as a harmonious whole, obviously. But they also work beautifully as sort of extracted set pieces.

SPEAKER_00And also just like his kind of naturalistic eye.

SPEAKER_01There's this wonderful moment in the Battle of Austerlitz where Prince Andrew You know, he like wants his heroic charge and he sees his moment and he's like leading. And as he's doing it, he looks at the battery, right? The artillery battery. And he sees this red haired gunner who's pulling at one end of a mop while a French soldier is tugging at the other. And they're just like tugging this, you know, mop used for, for the artillery piece back and forth. And he's like, why doesn't the gunner run away?

SPEAKER_01Like he's unarmed. And the Frenchman could just stab him, right? And it's just sort of insane scene that he never gets to see how it ends because he's immediately shot or injured right after that. And then he has this kind of amazing reflection is everything that he used to care about sort of trails away. And then Napoleon was walking by after the battle and he sees him and he goes, that's a fine death. And he realizes it's Napoleon,

SPEAKER_00you know?

SPEAKER_01But for me, it's like that little naturalistic detail where it's like there's this thing going on and you're like, why are they tugging on the mop? And it's just continually these little things that are like, Intruding from life and all their strangeness in the overall kind of orchestration of these very powerful and beautifully written scenes.

SPEAKER_00Like when you first see Napoleon in War and Peace, he's having his like back beat with branches or something, right? It's like something weird like that as some health thing, I guess. And then there's, there's so many things like that. And like in Anna Karenina, just a good example of his art, right? Is when she finally, um, Consummates her affair with Vronsky, right? It doesn't show you the sex scene, obviously, but it just cuts to her crying, weeping at Vronsky's side afterwards, right?

SPEAKER_00And just the way it's all done and the way it's laid out, it's like, no one was doing it quite like this

SPEAKER_01before he did it.

SPEAKER_00And just capturing the way people act. The scene in Anna Karenina where After she's giving birth to the child that she has with Vronsky, right? She's like sick and they think she's going to die. And everyone has this moment of like weird reconciliation where it's like the husband, Karen and Vronsky and her, they all have like a group hug or something. It's not a group hug, but it's like, it's like this, it's very emotionally moving moment. And then it just cuts to like, some time has gone by all that. So like everything is just, she's survived and everything just reverts back to what it was.

SPEAKER_01I got a question for you. What are your favorite books of both authors?

SPEAKER_00Let's see. Well, I mean, Anna Karenina and The Brothers Karamazov. And then with the short stories, it would be really hard to choose. But like, yeah, maybe Father Sergius or maybe Death of Ivan Ilyich. It would have to be one or the other.

SPEAKER_01I love Ivan Ilyich. Yeah. War and Peace is great, I mean, but as like a compact, much more compact, obviously, top piece of writing. I mean, I love Ivan Illich. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00And what's your favorite, Dustin?

SPEAKER_01I mean, Pierre is probably in War and Peace is probably my favorite character in all of Tolstoy. Yeah. He's just a marvelous character, and his whole journey is just absolutely incredible from start to finish.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I like Levin in

SPEAKER_01Anna Karenina. For me, the Levin plot is my favorite Anna Karenina. I mean, I think Anna Karenina is my favorite Tolstoy.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so, you know, some people read it and they don't really like the Levin plot. They're just focused on the Anna plot. I'm more sucked into the Levin plot. I mean, I like the Anna plot.

SPEAKER_01Incredible, you know, and the mowing scene in... Yeah. You know, in Anna Karenina where he's just mowing and it's the most beautiful thing you've ever read. And I mean, like those sorts of scenes, the wolf hunt scene in War and Peace is a similar one where you're like, this is Tolstoy pulling out the stops and showing his mastery of a particular type of, you know, sort of physically intense, but also kind of, you know, there's in the mowing scene, there's a kind of spiritual intensity to it that is just extraordinary.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and there are moments with Levin too where I think he's like having some revelation laying in a field or something where he's like, yeah, I'm going to just like live for others. It's something like that again, right? And then he, but it's like what Tulsa really nails is that as soon as he like gets up and goes back to the house, he like snaps at a serpent or something, right? Like he immediately like, but he's still like trying, like it is kind of a revelation, but like he immediately like, Doesn't, you know, live up to it.

SPEAKER_01You know what Pope Francis's favorite Dostoevsky was?

SPEAKER_00Oh, no. What was it?

SPEAKER_01Notes from the Underground.

SPEAKER_00Okay.

SPEAKER_01Interesting.

SPEAKER_00Interesting choice. That's an interesting choice for a Pope. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Because it's like, this is like modern man, you know, without God or severed. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01I think that, that as a character, that, that, Characters is just one of the pure immortal characters who I keep going back to and thinking about. Obviously, Brothers Karamazov and Demons is a hot mess of a book, but it is amazing. It's truly amazing. You got to love somebody who's just writing right in the heart

SPEAKER_01of contemporary politics, but is not captured by them. He's interested in how these politics or expressions of one facet of these characters' lives. So there's like animating them and driving them, but there's like this sort of spiritual depth or horror or what have you behind it. And it's mean and it's funny and it's cruel and it's tender and...

SPEAKER_01Empathetic and beautiful and horrifying. Hell of a book.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. It's been a while since I read it, but I remember really liking it. Well, actually there was something when I was researching for this, there was something I was, it wasn't from, it wasn't from there, but it reminded me of The Underground Man a little bit. It was like, The devil talking to Ivan in the towards the end of the Brothers Karamazov when he sees the devil. It was it was something about how the devil felt himself to be this like anonymous,

SPEAKER_00like empty variable. Yeah, it was like he was like the X on a graph, like with unfilled in coordinates on a graph or something like that. It was really interesting.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00But it reminded me of The Underground Man a little bit. Kind of lost in outer dark, I guess. Yeah, I guess Tolstoy, you know, like as much as I love him and I've been defending him, Dostoevsky does seem to be hitting on the existence. Oh, yeah. Tolstoy doesn't really capture like evil, right? He doesn't like have a character that's like an Iago type person. And yeah.

SPEAKER_00That is something I wonder about. Because it doesn't... It's not something I think you run into in real life that much. You run into much pettier forms of it. Of egotism that don't rise to the level of this titanic evil, this seething void consciousness of... Yeah, of Svidrigalov or... Yeah,

SPEAKER_01but it is there. That's the thing.

SPEAKER_00Yes. And you do run into it. And when you run into it, it matters. Yeah, no, I think it's important. And I think that that's something too with like Tolstoy not liking King Lear. I wonder if part of it was the, you have these characters like Edmund and Goneril and Regan who really are just Yeah. These kind of like creatures of the deep with- Tolstoy

SPEAKER_01wants King Lear to be more intelligible.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01He wants it to have a moral. And that's actually the problem, right? And, you know, we're talking about the kind of religious impulse. I think Tolstoy is- Is more amenable to a kind of modern secular worldview, right? Yes. And Dostoevsky, especially with the underground man, is a giant brick thrown through the crystal palace of the modern secular worldview.

SPEAKER_01And I like that about him.

SPEAKER_00No, I do too.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Also, oddly enough, Seems like when I posted that note on Twitter, all the neoconservatives disagreed with me and preferred Tolstoy. So I don't know what

SPEAKER_00to say about that.

SPEAKER_01Maybe they really like the passages in War and Peace where the guy tries to... Tries to reform the serfs and it all fails and makes things worse for them than before. It's like a very, you know, if you try social reform, it's, it will make things worse. I don't know. No, that's just, I'm sure.

SPEAKER_00But even though Tulsa kept doing that throughout his entire life, right?

SPEAKER_01But it was funny. It was like Charles Murray and John Podhortz were all like team Tolstoy.

SPEAKER_00That's really, that's really interesting. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01I don't think too much should be read into that, but I did get a kick out of it.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, because the normal conservative thing, I think, or... Yeah, but I guess these aren't really neocons. I guess the reactionary thing is sort of to prefer Dostoevsky,

SPEAKER_01but... Well, so the religious reactionary, right? But like, you know, I mean, look, because, you know, in Tulsa, especially like in... It's different, I think, in some of the later work, but, you know, like War and Peace, as I said, there's like the reformer and it's like, ha ha, you tried to make life better for the serfs, but actually... It was better before you did that. And then the guy at the end, like Rostov is like the ideal manager of estates because he's only like trying

SPEAKER_01to make a living, you know, and he's not. Trying to be ideal. And there's just like the minor quibble that when he gets mad, he beats the living hell out of his servants and his wife convinces him that he he should stop not because they don't deserve it, but because you shouldn't behave so, you know, and you yeah, like you compare that to. Dostoevsky talking about the abusive serfs, and you get a very different world picture. It's great, yeah. Not that Dostoevsky cannot absolutely fit into a reactionary worldview.

SPEAKER_01They both can, and they can both be used as evidence for extreme... A kind of radical left-wing worldview. Dostoevsky had his nationalism and Tolstoy had his prophetic pacifism. There are all kinds of strange currents in both of their work. But I think the detached and serene and rational viewpoint that Tolstoy likes to find Is something that Dostoevsky isn't even interested in, right?

SPEAKER_01And certainly for King Lear, right? You know, Dostoevsky is skeptical of reason. He's deeply engaged with mystery. And King Lear is a mysterious and painful play.

SPEAKER_00Yes. Yeah. One thing about Dostoevsky is I think that those depictions of evil in the Brothers Karamazov, like with the child abuse reports, which he took out of the actual newspapers in Russia that are used by Ivan to argue against the existence of God, or at least to not, maybe not even against God's existence, but just against God just Being like, look, if you're creating a world like this,

SPEAKER_00I don't want to like have anything to do with you kind of. I think that those are the most shocking and disturbing parts in the whole the whole book and maybe in all of 19th century literature. I'm not sure anyone ever went that deep into the horror of how bad it can really get. How bad suffering can really get. Yeah. Really touching like the bottom. And yeah, it's it's disturbing, but necessary for sure.

SPEAKER_00So I guess, yeah, you got to get going, right? They're both great. Yeah, they're both great.

SPEAKER_01But also it's great to argue about them. It's been really fun, man. Thank you so much.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's been great talking with you too. And yeah, best of luck with your new tenure as the head of Penn. That's awesome.

SPEAKER_01And remember, if you disagree with me, dangerous free climbing, Brothers Karamazov, you'll change your mind.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, take him up on that. But bring along the shorter works of Tolstoy and jump into Master and Man as well.

SPEAKER_01You don't want too heavy a pack.

SPEAKER_00All right. Yeah, thanks so much for coming on.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Buntzcast 24. Grace Morgan (The Media Training Episode)

    Aug 11, 20262 hr 12 minAudio

    Foreign policy expert, frequent CSPAN viewer, radical feminist, fiction writer, and future Chicago mayoral hopeful Grace Morgan pops into the Buntzcast to engage in media training for her political career and air her...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Buntzcast 23. The Magic Mountain (Feat. Boschian Belle)

    May 26, 20261 hr 13 minAudio

    Switching things up. Normally, the Buntzcast is a Marc Maron/Terry Gross style podcast, in which the guest distills his or her essence for the audience. We’re doing it a little different this time: this is the first...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Buntzcast 22: Galen Wolfe-Pauly, CEO of Tlon

    Dec 4, 202559 minAudio

    Galen Wolfe-Pauly, CEO and co-founder of Tlon, pops into the Buntzcast for a deep dive into the promise of a decentralized internet. Tlon Inc. is developing the Urbit computing platform, which moves away from the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. BUNTZCAST 20: Noah Kumin

    Jul 3, 20251 hr 6 minAudio

    The Buntzcast roars back into life after nearly two months of mysterious, unexplained silence. Noah Kumin, editor of The Mars Review of Books and author of the new novel Stop All the Clocks, pops into the studio. We...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. BUNTZCAST 19: Georgina Rose

    Apr 24, 20252 hr 3 minAudio

    Georgina Rose (aka Da'at Darling), a popular Youtuber, podcaster, and expert on all things magical and occult, drops by the Buntzcast. We have a wide-ranging and intriguing discussion, touching on the best places to do...

    Credit the people on this episode