There's a persistent piece of trivia that old windows are thicker at the bottom because glass slowly flows downward over centuries, like an extremely patient liquid. It's a wonderful story, and it's wrong, but working out exactly why it's wrong opens up one of the more genuinely strange materials in everyday life. This episode looks at what actually makes glass different from ordinary crystalline solids, how it's made, why it's transparent, how toughened and laminated glass are engineered to fail safely, and how ultra-pure glass fibres ended up carrying the modern internet. You'll come away understanding the real difference between amorphous and crystalline solids, why the old-glass-flows myth persists despite being false, how sand becomes a window, why glass lets light through at all, what makes toughened glass shatter the way it does, and how a hair-thin strand of glass can carry a conversation across an ocean at the speed of light. Talking Science is sponsored by Kinsoft. Visit www.kinsoft.com.au Further reading: Corning Museum of Glass - public education resources on glass science and history; American Chemical Society - explainers on amorphous solids and the glass transition; CSIRO - research on optical fibre and photonics; Nature Materials - reviews on the physics of glass.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Picture this. You are standing in a magnificent heritage building, like maybe a centuries -old European church, right? Oh, yeah, like the ones with those massive towering stained glass windows. Exactly. And you're looking closely at one of the original clear window panes, and you notice something a bit, well, peculiar. The glass looks wavy. Right, it's got those ripples. Yeah, it's slightly distorted, and it is noticeably thicker at the bottom than it is at the top. And then a tour guide leans in and tells you a secret.
They say that glass is actually a liquid. Ah, yes, the classic tour guide fact. Right. They say that over the centuries, it has been slowly, you know, imperceptibly flowing downward under its own weight, pooling at the base of the frame. I mean, it is a genuinely charming idea. And honestly, it makes so much intuitive sense when you're staring right at those old windows. We naturally want to categorize things, and the idea of a solid acting like a super slow liquid, well, it feels like discovering a glitch in the physics of our everyday world. It really does. It's a great piece of pub trivia. You see it
in travel blogs. You hear it at dinner parties. But there's just one problem with this idea. It is completely, entirely false. Completely false, yeah. Today we're doing a deep dive into our sources on the actual physics of glass, and the truth is, well, it's far weirder than a slow -moving liquid. Okay, let's unpack this because just using logic here, if glass is literally a liquid that flows over time, shouldn't we see this happening everywhere? Yeah, I think so. Yeah, like why doesn't a glass patio table warp
in the middle of a Texas summer? Or why don't the lenses of my reading glasses slowly pool at the bottom of the frames? Right. And the physical reality is that at room temperature, glass just does not flow at all, not even a fraction of a millimeter over centuries. To understand why those church windows look the way they do, we actually have to travel back in time and... look at the realities of early window manufacturing. Okay. Because before we had massive factories churning out perfectly flat sheets, craftsmen used a technique called crown glass. Which involves
blowing a glass bubble. Exactly that. They would... blow a large hollow bubble, and while the glass was still soft and glowing hot, they would spin it rapidly on the end of a metal pipe. Just spinning it by hand. Yeah, just spinning it. And the centrifugal force from that spinning would fling the bubble open, flattening it out into a rough circular disc, or alternatively, they would blow a long cylinder, cut it down the middle, and let it unroll in a kiln. But doing that by hand, I mean,
you're never going to get a perfectly uniform sheet. No. No, definitely not. A spun disc of hand -blown glass is going to be wavy. It's going to have thick spots and thin spots. Right. And that naturally uneven sheet is exactly what they had to work with. So when the historical glaziers came along to cut that spun glass into rectangular panes for a window frame, they were left with a heavy side and a light side on almost every piece. Okay, so they had a practical choice to make about how to actually install it in the frame. Exactly. Oh, I see where this is going.
If you're holding a piece of glass that's heavy, heavy on one end, you're not going to balance it on its thin edge. You'd install it heavy side down. I mean, it makes perfect structural sense for stability. It is the exact same logical instinct that makes you, you know, set a wine glass down base first on a table rather than trying to balance it on its delicate rim. Oh, wow. So what looks like centuries of downward flow is really just a snapshot of the exact day it was installed. The glazier just put the heavy end at the bottom. Yep. They just built it that way. And all those
watery ripples. Those are just manufacturing imperfections. They are variations from the manual spinning process, permanently frozen in time the moment the glass cooled down. Okay. So if glass isn't flowing like an incredibly slow liquid, what actually is it? Because it clearly doesn't act like most other solids we interact with. Like if I hit a brick wall. I mean, it doesn't shatter into transparent shards. No, it doesn't. And this brings us to a really fundamental distinction in material science. Most familiar solids that
you interact with, think of table salt, a piece of metal, a quartz crystal, or even an ice cube. Those are what we call crystalline. Crystalline, okay. Yeah. Which means their atoms or molecules are arranged in a highly ordered, repeating, three -dimensional pattern. It's called a crystal lattice. Our sources had a great visual for this. If I'm picturing a crystalline solid, it's like a perfectly built, highly ordered brick wall. Every atom is a brick, and they are stacked neatly, row after row. extending in all three dimensions
that is a very helpful way to visualize it but glass is wildly different from that glass has essentially no long -range order at all its atoms are arranged in a jumbled chaotic structure chaotic how well if you could zoom in closely enough to look at the atomic level the structure would look remarkably similar to the chaotic swirling arrangement of atoms in a liquid except they are completely locked in place okay so instead of a neatly built brick wall it's like Like someone just dumped a pile of bricks on the ground and
instantly glued them all together in midair, like a frozen jumble. That's the perfect term for it, a frozen jumble. The scientific name for this is an amorphous solid. The word amorphous comes from a Greek root meaning without shape or form. Oh, right. And it isn't referring to the windowpane itself, obviously, but to that chaotic internal atomic structure. Because of how it's made, glass is sometimes casually referred to as a supercooled liquid, but physicists today treat it as its own distinct state of rigid matter. But how do we actually force matter to do that?
I mean, how do we stop the atoms from naturally forming that neat, orderly brick wall when they solidify? It all comes down to the chemistry of the ingredients and the sheer speed of the cooling process. The foundational ingredient of almost all glass is silica, which is silicon dioxide. You find it most commonly as just ordinary sand. But I know enough about the beach. No, you can't just like... Throw a bucket of sand at a campfire and get a window. You certainly can't because silica has a massive melting point. We're talking over 1 ,500 degrees Celsius. Wow.
Yeah, trying to achieve and maintain that kind of extreme heat is difficult and incredibly energy intensive. So early glassmakers discovered a clever workaround. They add soda ash, also known as sodium carbonate. What does the soda ash actually do to the sand, though? It acts as a flex. So on an atomic level, the sodium disrupts the strong bonds between the silicon and oxygen atoms in the silica. It essentially creates loose ends in the molecular network. And because those bonds are broken up, the whole mixture requires significantly
less thermal energy to melt. It drastically lowers the melting point. Well, that sounds like a great shortcut. Now wait, if you're breaking up the chemical bonds, doesn't that weaken the final product? It weakens it severely, actually. Glass made only from silica and soda ash is chemically unstable. It is so vulnerable that it is actually water -soluble. Wait, really? Water -soluble glass? Yes. Over time, moisture in the air or just regular rain would seep into those disrupted molecular bonds, and the glass would literally
weather away and dissolve. Which is obviously a terrible property for a window to have. Exactly. Which is why they add a third crucial ingredient, limestone or calcium carbonate. What does the limestone do? The calcium acts like a structural glue. It cross -links those broken chemical bonds, stabilizing the entire atomic network and restoring its durability and water resistance. So this specific trio sand, soda, ash, and limestone gives us what we call soda -lime glass. It is the formula for the vast majority of everyday
glass in your windows, bottles, jars, everything. Okay, so we heat this mixture of sand, soda, and limestone into a glowing molten liquid. But the frozen jumble part happens during the cool down phase, right? Yes, exactly. It is a race against time. If you cool that molten mixture slowly, the silicon and oxygen atoms have the time and the energy to naturally organize themselves. They will settle into that neat, repeating crystalline lattice. Because they want to form that organized brick wall. Right. They want to be organized. But we don't want a brick wall. We want glass.
So we have to cool it fast. Exactly. We cool the molten mixture rapidly. By dropping the temperature quickly, the atoms get trapped. They basically lose the thermal energy required to move around before they ever have a chance to organize. They just get stuck. Yep, they get locked into their disordered liquid -like arrangement. And this specific transition, where a cooling liquid becomes rigid without crystallizing, is called the glass transition. It is genuinely amazing to think that humans figured out this complex chemical balancing act thousands of years ago. Yeah. Way
before anyone knew what a molecular bond or an amorphous solid even was. It really is. The historical timeline of glass is just a fascinating study in trial and error. We have archaeological evidence of ancient Egyptians and Mesopotamians making opaque glass beads roughly 5 ,000 years ago. 5 ,000 years. Wow. Yeah, but for a long time, glass was a rare, highly prized luxury. It was mostly formed by casting it in molds or wrapping hot glass threads around a core. That sounds incredibly tedious. How did it become something
common? Well, the massive turning point happened around the first century BCE when Syrian craftsmen invented glass blowing. They realized you could use a hollow iron tube to gather a blob of molten glass and just inflate it with your breath. Oh, so instead of painstakingly carving or molding a solid chunk, they could just blow a usable vessel in a few minutes. Right. It completely revolutionized production. It was faster, it required less raw material, and it made the glass thinner and more transparent. This innovation spread rapidly through the Roman Empire. Glass
transformed from this luxury reserved for the elite into a utilitarian material. You know, cups, bowls, and storage vessels that ordinary households could afford. I read in our sources that... Fast -forwarding to the Renaissance, the center of the glass universe was Venice, specifically the island of Murano, and the Venetian authorities essentially trapped the glassmakers there. They absolutely did. By the late 13th century, Venice had developed the most advanced glassmaking techniques in the world, creating these unparalleled mirrors and clear glass. And
this was a massive economic driver for them. So to protect their monopoly, the Venetian state forced all glassmakers to move their foundries to the island of Murano. Was that just to keep them isolated so they couldn't share their trade secrets? That was the primary economic reason, yeah. The laws were so strict that if a glassmaker left the Republic to share their knowledge, the state could literally send assassins after them. That is intense for glass. Very intense. But there was also a very practical, localized reason. Glass furnaces require immense, constant heat,
and they pose a massive fire risk. Venice was a crowded city built largely of wood, so moving the foundries to an island protected the main city from just... burning to the ground okay i have to jump in here though because you mentioned earlier that all this historical glass was either blown into vessels or spun into wavy discs sure if i look at the window in my living room right now it is a massive sheet of completely flawlessly flat glass there are no waves no thick edges how did we get from spinning bubbles to that It is a phenomenal piece of applied physics,
and it's actually remarkably recent. We owe it to a British company called Pilkington in the late 1950s. They invented the float glass process. Float glass. Yeah, and the name is quite literal. Instead of blowing or rolling the glass, you pour the continuous stream of molten glass onto the surface of a massive, shallow pool of molten tin. Wait. You just poured liquid glass onto liquid metal? Why doesn't it just mix together into a cloudy metallic sludge? Because of the physics of the two materials. Molten glass and
molten tin do not mix. Their densities and surface tensions are entirely mismatched. So the molten glass just floats right on top of the liquid metal. Oh, I see. And because it's a liquid resting on another perfectly flat liquid surface, gravity just pulls the glass out. Gravity does all the work for us. The glass spreads out into a perfectly flat layer of uniform thickness. It naturally forms a smooth, parallel surface on both sides, which means it requires absolutely no grinding or polishing afterward. That is brilliantly simple. But earlier you mentioned that the glass transition
requires rapid cooling to freeze that atomic jumble. If you have a massive flat sheet of glass, how do you cool it down without the whole thing just shattering from the temperature shock? You've hit on a really crucial engineering challenge. Once the amorphous structure is locked in -like, once it has passed the glass transition, the rest of the cooling process actually has to be very slow and deliberate. This is called annealing. What does annealing actually do? Well as glass cools, the outer surface inevitably cools slightly faster than the inside. This temperature difference
causes uneven contraction, which create internal stress at the atomic level. If you let a large sheet cool naturally, those locked -in stresses would be so chaotic that the glass would shatter the moment you tried to cut it, or even if just a cold breeze hit it. Oh, well. Yeah. So annealing means passing the glass through a long, temperature -controlled kiln called a layer. It cools it down so gradually that those internal stresses are relieved, allowing you to safely cut and shape the final pane. So the float process gives us the perfectly smooth surface. But smoothness
alone doesn't explain the most magical property of glass, which is transparency. I mean, a flat, polished sheet of stainless steel is incredibly smooth, but it's completely opaque. Why can't I see through a solid wall of glass? To understand transparency, we have to look at the interaction between the electrons inside the material and photons, which are individual packets of light energy. In many solid materials, like your sheet of steel or a brick wall, the electrons within the atomic structure are readily available to absorb the energy of incoming photons. When visible
light hits the material, the electrons absorb that energy, convert it to heat, or reflect it back. That absorption stops the light from passing through. Let me see if I can picture this with an analogy. If the electrons are like people standing at the bottom of a staircase, the photons of visible light are trying to give them a boost of energy to jump up a step. In an opaque material, the steps on the staircase are spaced close together, so the light provides exactly the right amount of energy for the electron to easily jump up one step, and the light energy is entirely consumed and absorbed. That is an excellent analogy. But
the atomic structure of ordinary glass creates a totally different environment for its electrons. In glass, the electrons are bound in a way that creates what physicists call a wide band gap. A wide band gap. Okay, so keeping with the analogy, the glass staircase has a massive missing step. Precisely. The gap between the energy levels is huge. So the energy provided by a photon of visible light just isn't a big enough jump to get the electron across that wide gap to the next available state. Oh, I get it. Because the electron literally cannot absorb that specific
amount of energy, it just ignores the visible light entirely, and the photon passes straight through completely undisturbed. It simply doesn't have the key to unlock that electron. And there is a second structural reason glass is so clear, which goes right back to our frozen jumble. Because glass is amorphous, it lacks grain boundaries. What is a grain boundary? In crystalline materials, the internal lattice isn't usually one single perfect infinite crystal. It's made of many smaller crystal regions kind of crammed together. The internal seams where those regions meet are called
grain boundaries. Like the seams in a patchwork quilt. Exactly. And when light travels through a crystal and hits those seams, it scatters, which creates a cloudy or translucent appearance. But because glass has no repeating crystal structure, it has no grain boundaries. It is one continuous chaotic network which avoids that source of light scattering cloudiness completely. Here's where it gets really interesting, though. We know glass isn't always perfectly clear. Stained glass windows exist. Beer bottles are brown or green. If transparency
is caused by this massive missing step on the staircase, how do we change that to create color? We do it by deliberately introducing impurities. If you add small quantities of specific metal oxides into the molten glass mixture, you are introducing new atoms with their own electrons into the network. And these new electrons have different energy requirements. So we're essentially adding a smaller step back onto the staircase. Yes. We're adding an electron that can absorb a specific narrower slice of the visible light spectrum. The wavelengths of light that are absorbed disappear and the wavelengths that aren't absorbed
pass through to your eye. That remainder is the color you see. What kind of metal oxides are we talking about? Iron oxide is a very common one. It occurs naturally as an impurity in most sand. It absorbs the red and blue parts of the spectrum, which is why if you look closely at the thick edge of a standard piece of window glass, you'll see a faint green tinge. Oh yeah, I've noticed that. Yeah. To get absolute colorless clarity for things like optical lenses or phone screens, manufacturers have to work extremely hard to purify the sand and remove that iron.
On the other hand, if you deliberately add cobalt oxide, you get a rich deep blue. Add chromium oxide and you get a vibrant green. Okay, so we've covered how we make it flat, how we make it clear, and how we color it. But ordinary annealed glass still has a rather fatal flaw for everyday use. It is incredibly brittle and when it breaks it shatters into large razor -sharp shards. How do engineers design around this disaster waiting to happen? They use a brilliant piece of materials engineering called toughened or tempered glass.
And interestingly, it involves reversing the logic we just talked about. Annealing is about cooling glass slowly to remove internal stress. Tempering is about deliberately putting extreme stress back in. Wait, you just told me that internal stress causes a window to shatter if a cold breeze hits it. Why on earth would you intentionally add stress back into the glass? Because this is a highly controlled balance stress. To temper glass, you take a finished piece of ordinary glass, heat it up until it's almost soft, and
then blast its outer surfaces with jets of extremely cold air. Okay. So the outside surfaces cool and contract rapidly. But the inside of the glass is still hot. Exactly. The inside cools much more slowly, so the outer layers shrink and harden. But as the interior finally cools down and tries to shrink, it is locked to the already hardened outer layers. So the inside is pulling the out. outside layers inward. Yes. When the whole pain finally reaches room temperature, the outer layers are locked in a permanent state of compression. They are being heavily squeezed inward. Meanwhile,
the interior is left in a state of tension. It is permanently pulling outward. Wow. So it's a material that is quite literally holding itself together through immensely powerful opposing forces. That balanced tension makes the glass incredibly strong and resistant to blunt impacts. It can take a serious hit without bending or breaking. But the real genius is what happens when those forces are finally overcome. If you hit tempered glass hard enough to breach that compressive outer layer, the entire balance system
fails instantly. Oh, I see. All that stored internal energy is released at once and the glass violently shatters across its entire surface. Turning into thousands of tiny granular pebbles. Exactly. Relatively blunt fragments, which is a brilliant safety feature disguised as a catastrophic failure. If you slip in the bathroom and hit the shower screen, or if you're in a car crash and your side window breaks, you want it to instantly turn into a pile of pebbles rather than giant guillotines of sharp glass. Wait, speaking of cars, when a rock kicked up on the highway and hit my windshield once, it didn't turn into pebbles.
It cracked into a massive spiderweb shape, but the glass stayed completely intact. Is the windshield not tempered? No. Windshields require a different technology entirely called laminated glass. Because a windshield needs to survive an impact at highway speeds without disintegrating and letting debris fly right into your face. Laminated glass doesn't alter the cooling process at all. Instead, it uses a sandwich approach. A sandwich what? Engineers take two ordinary sheets of glass and place a tough, transparent plastic layer between them,
usually a material called polyvinyl butyral. They bake the sandwich under heat and pressure so it fuses into a single pane. So when a rock hits your windshield, the glass itself does break. But it doesn't fall apart. Right, because that tough plastic inner layer firmly grips all the broken shards holding them in place. It prevents them from separating into loose projectiles, keeping the pane intact as a single spiderweb -cracked sheet. That's amazing. We engineer this chaotic jumble of atoms to protect us from the weather and even to protect us from its own broken shards. But some of its most transformative applications
don't involve windows at all. We are pushing the clarity and thermal properties of glass to absolute extremes. We really are. If we look at the bigger technological picture, arguably the most important use of glass today is optical fiber. We are talking about long strands of ultra -pure glass engineered to an extreme standard of transparency. They're often thinner than a single human hair. When you say ultra -pure, I mean, how pure does it have to be compared to my living room window? By a massive margin.
If a window pane had slight impurities, like that trace of iron oxide we discussed, you wouldn't really notice looking through a few millimeters of it. But in an optical fiber, a light signal has to travel for hundreds or thousands of kilometers. Right. Even the tiniest speck of an impurity would absorb the signal, generate heat, and kill the transmission entirely. But even if it's perfectly clear, how does the light travel down a curved glass hair for thousands of kilometers without just, you know, leaking out the sides? Through a physics phenomenon called total internal reflection.
An optical fiber isn't just one type of glass. It's actually a core of glass wrapped in an outer layer called the cladding. The cladding, okay. The cladding is made of a slightly different glass formulation with a lower refractive index, which means light bends differently when it passes through it. So when the light pulse travels down the core and hits the boundary of the cladding, the difference in the glass prevents it from crossing over. It just bounces back into the core. Yes, exactly. Because it strikes at a shallow angle, it reflects entirely inward. It bounces
along the internal walls of the fiber for kilometer after kilometer with incredibly low loss of intensity. Every web page you browse, every streaming video, every digital phone call gets converted into rapid pulses of light and sent down these flexible glass fibers. Glass forms the literal physical backbone of the global Internet. It carries data across entire oceans far more efficiently than copper wires ever could. And it doesn't stop at communication either. I think of science and medicine like the Pyrex beaker I use in high school chemistry. I could put that glass right
over an open Bunsen burger flame and it wouldn't shatter. Ordinary glass would crack instantly. That's because it's borosilicate glass. By adding boron trioxide to the silica mix, you alter the atomic network in a very specific way. When most materials heat up, their atomic bonds vibrate and lengthen, causing the material to expand. But the boron integrates into the glass network and makes those bonds much less prone to stretching when thermal energy is applied. So the glass simply doesn't expand as much when it gets hot.
Exactly. And if it barely expands or contracts as its temperature changes rapidly, it doesn't build up the internal stresses that cause ordinary soda lime glass to crack under uneven heat. Which makes it perfect for a lab. Exactly. That makes borosilicate perfect for laboratory flasks and kitchen bakeware. Glass is also chemically inert and highly impermeable, which is why glass vials are still the absolute gold standard for storing vaccines and injectable medicines. It won't react with the chemicals inside. We also use flexible bundles of those optical fibers to create medical
endoscopes. Oh, to see inside the body. Right, allowing surgeons to snake a light and a camera into the human body, avoiding highly invasive open surgery. So it scales down to the microscopic, but we also push it to the cosmic scale. Because when I think of astronomy, I think of massive telescope mirrors capturing the light of distant galaxies. Absolutely. Big research telescopes like the Anglo -Australian Telescope in New South Wales, they don't use simple glass lenses. They rely on enormous reflecting mirrors made of precision ground glass or glass ceramics. These curved
surfaces are polished to an accuracy of millionths of a meter. Because even a microscopic warp would blur a star completely out of focus. And that brings us all the way back to the concept of annealing. Producing a solid glass blank that is several meters wide without any warping or sagging is a monumental feat of thermal engineering. The annealing process, that incredibly slow, controlled cooling, it can literally take months for the largest mirrors. Months just to cool down? Yes, because if they rush the cooling even slightly, they risk locking in the exact same
uneven internal stresses that make tempered glass so strong. But in a telescope mirror, internal stress is the absolute last thing you want. It would ruin the optics entirely. Wow. So what does this all mean? We started with the charming myth of an ancient church window, imagining a solid quietly defying physics as a flowing liquid. But the truth is, the story of glass is the story of a material that has spent thousands of years refusing to settle down. It refuses to form the neat, ordered, predictable structure that almost every other solid takes for granted. It is a
beautifully specific, deliberately engineered arrangement of disordered atoms. And that very chaos, that frozen jumble we talked about, is exactly what makes it so incredibly adaptable. It's transparent enough to bring sunlight into our homes. We can lace it with tension to keep us safe in a high -speed crash. And it lets doctors illuminate the inside of the human body. It's so ubiquitous that it's easy to take for granted. We spend our entire lives looking through glass to see the world outside. But I want to leave you with this final thought. The next time you
browse a webpage, stream a video, or even download this very deep dive, take a moment to stop looking through it and look at the glass. Consider the fact that the information you are consuming right now was delivered to you as silent pulses of light, bouncing thousands of times a second off the internal walls of a flawlessly pure, amorphous thread of glass, resting quietly at the bottom of the ocean.
Nanotechnology works at a scale where a nanometre is to a metre what a single centimetre is to the distance across a football field roughly a hundred thousand times over. This episode explains what nanotechnology...
A tagged bar-tailed godwit once flew more than thirteen thousand kilometres from Alaska to Tasmania without landing once. This episode explores why animals migrate at all, from godwits and humpback whales to monarch...
The Sun is an active, magnetic star, and every so often it hurls bursts of radiation and clouds of charged particles toward Earth, a phenomenon called space weather. This episode explains solar flares and coronal mass...
An ordinary wave rolls onto the sand every few seconds; a tsunami can take tens of minutes between crests and cross an entire ocean at the speed of a jet aircraft while barely rippling the surface. This episode explains...
A folded square of paper and a butterfly's wings share the same simple visual idea: a shape that looks the same after some transformation. This episode follows that idea from everyday geometry into the deepest...