Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Talking Science

Talking Science artwork

Space Weather – When the Sun Attacks Our Technology

Nov 15, 202625 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

The Sun is an active, magnetic star, and every so often it hurls bursts of radiation and clouds of charged particles toward Earth, a phenomenon called space weather. This episode explains solar flares and coronal mass ejections, traces the history from the 1859 Carrington Event to the 1989 Quebec blackout, and looks at how satellites, GPS, aviation and power grids are affected today, including Australia's own monitoring effort. You'll come away understanding what solar flares and coronal mass ejections actually are and how they differ, why the Carrington Event of 1859 and the 1989 Quebec blackout matter as case studies, how satellites, GPS, aviation and power grids can be disrupted by geomagnetic storms, how short the real warning times are and why that gap matters, how Australia monitors space weather, and why the risk deserves serious engineering attention without tipping into scaremongering. Talking Science is sponsored by Kinsoft. Visit www.kinsoft.com.au Further reading: NASA - space weather and heliophysics explainers; NOAA Space Weather Prediction Center - forecasts and educational resources; Bureau of Meteorology - Australian Space Weather Services; Nature - reporting on geomagnetic storms and grid vulnerability.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Picture this. It's an ordinary Tuesday morning. You get in your car, you tap your destination into the phone mounted on your dashboard, and you just completely trust that little blue dot to guide you through peak hour traffic. Right. We do it without a second thought. Exactly. But then suddenly... The blue dot jumps sideways by like 50 meters. Or maybe you're listening from a farm and a satellite -guided precision tractor suddenly veers off course. And our immediate reaction is always to blame the technology right in front of us. I mean, we assume it's a software

glitch or a bad update or just a failing antenna. Yeah, we tap the screen a few times, maybe restart the app and, you know, curse our cellular provider. Oh, absolutely. What we almost never suspect is that a star... sitting 150 million kilometers away, just hurled a billion tons of magnetized plasma out into space. And, well, we just happened to be in the crosshairs. It sounds wild when you put it like that. Right. But that's today's mission. Welcome to the Deep Dive. We're going to unpack this incredible chain of events known

as space weather. We're exploring how a storm on the sun can reach all the way down to your daily commute and why understanding this is really all about preparation rather than panic. Which is a crucial distinction, honestly, because the sheer scale of what happens during a solar storm, it sounds like science fiction, but the mechanics behind it are incredibly tangible. And I want to assure you, the listener, you absolutely do not need a background in astrophysics to follow this. We are going to take it step by step. Nice and unhurried. A very relaxed approach. Exactly.

Because to understand how the sun can break our GPS, we first have to understand what the sun is actually made of. I mean, it isn't just a giant placid campfire up in the sky. No, not at all. It is a churning, highly violent sphere of a state of matter called plasma. Okay, plasma. Break that down for us. So to picture plasma, imagine taking a normal gas and heating it up to such an extreme degree that the electrons are literally stripped away from their atoms. Wow, just completely torn off. Exactly. And what you're left with is this superheated soup of

freely roaming charged particles. Because they carry an electrical charge, this soup responds intensely to magnetic fields. Essentially like a giant boiling magnetic fluid. Yeah, and a highly complex one at that. Different layers of the sun rotate at completely different speeds. Oh, so it doesn't all spin together as one solid thing. Right. And as these layers rotate unevenly, the sun's internal magnetic field lines get twisted and tangled up in each other. These intense twists tend to cluster in relatively cool, dark patches

on the solar surface. Which we call sunspots, right? You got it. Sunspots. Okay, so I'm picturing... Winding up the propeller of a toy airplane. You keep twisting that rubber band tighter and tighter and it gets all knotted up on itself. That is a perfect analogy. And eventually that tension reaches a breaking point and the rubber band just violently snaps, releasing all that stored kinetic energy in a fraction of a second. Yes. That violent snap is exactly what physicists call magnetic reconnection. On the sun, those tangled magnetic lines snap and instantly realign

into a simpler, lower energy shape. And I'm guessing that releases a lot of energy. An incomprehensible amount. Energy that might have been building up for weeks is just dumped in a matter of minutes. And this release triggers two very distinct phenomena. The first one is a solar flare. Which is basically the light show. Right. A solar flare is an intense, sudden burst of pure radiation across the entire electromagnetic spectrum. We're talking radio waves, visible light, X -rays, gamma rays, the

works. And since it's pure radiation, it travels at the speed of light. Exactly. Exactly. It takes about eight minutes to cross the distance from the sun to Earth. Meaning by the time our telescopes can actually see the flare happening on the sun, the radiation is already hitting our atmosphere. Literally zero warning. None at all. But thankfully, that flare is often accompanied by a second event, which is much more physically dramatic. Okay, what's the second event? It's called a coronal mass ejection, or a CME. A CME is a colossal bubble of magnetized plasma erupting from the

sun's outer atmosphere, which is called the corona. So this isn't just light. This is physical stuff. It is physical stuff with actual mass. We are talking sometimes billions of tons of it. And because it is physical matter, it cannot travel at the speed of light. That makes sense. It's too heavy. Right. It moves incredibly fast, sometimes thousands of kilometers per second, but it still takes time to cross that 150 million kilometer gap to Earth. Typically, a CME takes one to three days to arrive. Okay, so it's just like a thunderstorm

here on Earth. The solar flare is the flash of the lightning bolt. It arrives instantly. You see the flash the second it happens. Right, right. But the coronal ass ejection, the CME, that's the thunder and the heavy wall of rain that rolls in a bit later. That's a great way to think about it. And it's that heavy rain, the physical CME, that causes the most significant disruptions if it happens to be aimed directly at us. Which brings up a really important point about our own defenses. I mean, the Earth isn't just a bare rock floating in space, right? Yeah. We have our own protective magnetic bubble. Yes,

the magnetosphere. It normally deflects the everyday solar wind harmlessly around the planet. So what actually happens when that billion -ton physical wall of magnetized plasma slams into our defensive bubble? Does it just bounce off? Well, it depends. If the incoming CME's magnetic field is oriented in just the right way, it connects with Earth's magnetic field and literally peels it open. Peels it open. That sounds bad. It triggers what we call a geomagnetic storm. It forcefully shakes

and distorts our protective bubble. And we know exactly what a direct massive hit from one of these storms looks like. Because humanity actually experienced one, right? Long before we had modern electrical grids to lose. Exactly. We have to go back to the Victorian era for this one. September... 1859, to be exact. The famous Carrington event. Yes, named after Richard Carrington, who was an English astronomer. He was looking through his telescope, sketching sunspots, and he actually witnessed the flare. He was the first human to ever observe and record one. Just sketching away,

and suddenly the sun flashes at him. And just 17 hours later, which, by the way, highlights that this was an exceptionally fast -moving CME Earth, was hit by an unimaginably powerful geomagnetic storm. 17 hours is incredibly fast. And the visual effects were global, weren't they? Oh, absolutely stunning. Auroras, those shimmering curtains of light that are usually confined to the poles, were pushed incredibly far south. They were seen shimmering over the Caribbean. Accounts from the time described the sky glowing so brightly

that people were stepping outside and reading newspapers at midnight. I mean, it must have been completely surreal to experience that. It would have felt like the end of the world to some people. The visual spectacle was amazing, but the technological impact is what truly matters for our understanding today. Because they had technology back then. It wasn't just candles and horses. Right. The cutting edge technology of 1859 was the telegraph network. It was basically the Victorian Internet. And when the storm hit, that network went completely haywire. Haywire.

Telegraph operators reported actual sparks leaping out of their equipment. Some machines literally caught fire. Wow. And I read that in some instances, the operators realized they could completely unplug their batteries, like completely disconnect their normal power source and still tap out messages. using only the electricity that was being provided by the sky. It's a true story. They were transmitting messages powered by the geomagnetic storm. Okay, now, as amazing as that historical parlor trick sounds, let me push back a bit here for the listener.

Sure, go ahead. If a massive solar storm in 1859 just resulted in, you know, some sparks, a few small fires, and some free battery power, why is space weather considered a potential trillion -dollar threat today? I mean, a wire is just a wire, right? Well, it comes down to a fundamental principle of physics called magnetic induction. Magnetic induction, okay. A rapidly changing magnetic field will automatically induce an electrical current in any sufficiently long conductor it passes over. That moving magnetic field literally

pushes electrons down the wire. So if you run a wire far enough and a magnetic storm washes over the planet, electricity is going to flow through that wire whether it's plugged into a wall socket or not. That is the core mechanism, yes. In 1859, the longest conductors humanity had built were just telegraph wires. But today, we have accidentally constructed the ultimate catching net for space weather. Modern power grid. Exactly. We have transmission lines that stretch for hundreds, sometimes thousands of kilometers across entire continents. So a storming

today isn't just sparking a little telegraph key. It's pumping massive amounts of unwanted electricity into our entire power infrastructure. Precisely. A strong geomagnetic storm induces what are called geomagnetically induced currents, or GICs, directly into our power lines. And the critical issue here is the type of current. The type of current. Yeah, these induced currents are direct current, or DC. But our power grids are built to operate on alternating current, AC, where the electrical flow rhythmically reverses

direction back and forth. Oh, I see. So we are forcing a massive continuous shove of DC power into a system that's designed for a rhythmic back and forth swing. Yes. And the component that bears the brunt of this mismatch is the transformer. The big metal boxes at substations. Right. Transformers are massive, heavy, custom -built machines that step voltage up and down across the grid to move electricity efficiently. When this extra direct current floods in, it pushes the transformers into a state called saturation.

And what does saturation actually do to the machine? Does it just shut down? It's worse than that. It essentially overwhelms the magnetic core of the transformer. So instead of cleanly transferring alternating power, the core absorbs that continuous DC energy as pure heat. Oh, so they just cook themselves. They rapidly overheat. They can distort the current flowing through the rest of the network, which tricks the grid's protective systems into tripping the entire grid offline. It's a complete blackout. Yeah. And in the worst case scenarios, the copper windings inside the transformer physically

melt, destroying a piece of equipment that takes months or even years to manufacture and replace. And this isn't just some theoretical doomsday model. We actually saw this happen in March. 1989, didn't we? We did. The Hydro -Quebec event in Canada. A powerful geomagnetic storm swept across the northern hemisphere. And in the space of about 90 seconds, just a minute and a half, induced currents triggered a cascading failure across the entire Hydro -Quebec grid. 90 seconds to take down a whole grid. Six million people

were plunged into darkness for nine hours, right in the middle of a freezing Canadian winter. And I understand geography played a massive role in that specific failure, right? The grid in Quebec sits on top of the Canadian Shield. Yes. The Canadian Shield is a massive expanse of ancient igneous rock. And that specific type of rock is highly resistant to electricity. So it acts like an insulator. Exactly. Normally, when these induced currents hit the Earth, they naturally want to dissipate safely down into the ground. But because the rock resisted, the current had

nowhere to go. Because electricity always takes the path of least resistance. Right. So the current was forced to travel up through the grounding wires and further along the grid's transmission lines, which completely overwhelmed the system. It was a massive wake -up call for power authorities globally. I can imagine. Okay, so if the power grid is our giant catching net down here on the ground, what happens to all the technology sitting hundreds of kilometers above us? I mean, satellites are practically sitting out there in the firing line. They are, and satellites face multiple

distinct threats from space weather. The first one is physical drag. Drag? Like air resistance in space? Basically, yeah. During a severe space weather event, Earth's upper atmosphere absorbs vast amounts of extra energy from the storm, causing it to heat up and physically swell outward. Ah, so it puffs up. Exactly. Satellites that normally orbit in the incredibly thin upper atmosphere suddenly find themselves plowing through much thicker, denser air. Okay, so imagine you're running on the beach in, like... ankle deep water

you're making good time moving usually suddenly the tide rushes in and now you're trying to run at the exact same speed in waist -deep water. The physical resistance is immense. That increased atmospheric drag aggressively slows satellites down. It can pull them right off their planned trajectories. So they just fall out of the sky? If left unchecked, yes. It forces operators to burn precious onboard fuel just to push them back into their proper orbit. This drastically shortens the satellite's operational lifespan. And in extreme cases, some satellites can even

be pulled so low they burn up in the atmosphere entirely. That's the blunt force threat, the drag. Yeah. But there's also a more surgical threat up there, right? Yes. It's called a single event upset. During a solar storm, highly energetic particles can penetrate the physical shielding of a satellite. If just one of those microscopic particles strikes a sensitive microchip in exactly the wrong spot, it can literally flip a single bit of computer memory from a zero to a one. Just randomly changing the code. Just flipping a switch. Most of the time, the system's error

correction fixes it. But occasionally that flip bit corrupts a critical command or damages a component. Which is why they put them in safe mode sometimes. Right. Satellite operators have to track space weather constantly to know if they should proactively shut down non -essential systems and switch their satellites into a protective safe mode until the storm passes. And a corrupted satellite is bad enough. But, you know, those satellites are constantly beaming signals down to us, like the GPS telling your car where to turn or guiding that precision agriculture track.

we mentioned earlier. And those signals have to travel through a layer of Earth's upper atmosphere called the ionosphere, which is packed with charged particles. When a solar storm hits, the ionosphere becomes highly turbulent and uneven. Like looking through a funhouse mirror. Exactly. As the weak radio signal from a GPS satellite travels through that turbulence, the signal gets bent, delayed, and scattered. And because GPS relies on calculating incredibly precise travel times to figure out

distance, even a tiny delay in the signal arriving at your phone translates into a massive error in where it thinks you are. Usually, commercial GPS is accurate to within a few meters. But during a severe storm, that ionospheric distortion can grow the error to tens of meters. Which might just cause a missed turn on a road trip for me. But if you are an airline pilot using a satellite approach system to land a plane in heavy fog, or a farmer relying on millimeter... accuracy to plant seeds, it becomes a severe operational hazard. Right. And if the ionosphere is turbulent

enough to bend a GPS signal, what happens to the standard high frequency radio waves that airplanes use to communicate, like over oceans and polar routes? Well, high frequency radio relies on the ionosphere acting like a mirror. The radio wave is transmitted up into the sky. It bounces off the ionosphere and travels back down to a receiver way over the horizon. But if the storm hits... If the ionosphere is disturbed by space weather, that mirror effectively shatters. The radio signal doesn't bounce. It gets absorbed or scattered out into space. Communication degrades

or completely blacks out. This is especially dangerous over the poles, isn't it? Because Earth's magnetic field... acts like a giant funnel, guiding all those incoming charged particles straight down into the atmosphere at the North and South Poles. Exactly. So commercial flights are sometimes entirely rerouted away from those efficient polar paths. Just to maintain communication. Not just because they lose radio contact, but because the crew and passengers on high -altitude polar flights face elevated radiation exposure when the planet's magnetic shield is being battered

like that. It is a vast, multifaceted threat environment. Which raises a really obvious logistical question for me. If we know a massive storm is coming, and we know it can melt a custom -built, multimillion -dollar transformer on the grid, why can't we just flip a giant breaker switch? Just turn it all off. Yeah. Turn the grid off, let the space weather wash over dead wires, and then just turn it back on a few hours later. Well, in theory, powering down vulnerable sections of the grid would absolutely protect them. But

turning off a massive, interconnected national power grid safely is an incredibly delicate, dangerous operation. Because hospitals, water treatment plants, and communication hubs all rely on that power. Exactly. People could die. So to make that call. Grid operators need exact, precise timing. They need to know exactly when the storm will hit and exactly how strong it's going to be. Wait, hold on. Let me unpack this. We just established that the coronal mass ejection, that massive physical wall of plasma, takes one to three days to get here. That's right. And

we can physically watch it cross space for three days using our solar telescopes. Yeah. So why are we flying blind here? Why don't we have enough warning? Because seeing the plasma cloud isn't enough to predict its impact. Agencies like NOAA can estimate the CME's speed and its general direction, which gives us a broad one to three day alert that a storm is headed our way. Okay. But to know if it's going to bounce harmlessly off our magnetic shield or peel it open and cause a grid killing disaster, we have to know the CME's magnetic orientation. We need to know precisely

how its internal magnetic field aligns with Earth's magnetic field. field. And we can't just see a magnetic field through a telescope. We cannot measure that magnetic orientation from afar. The only way to know the magnetic structure of a CME is to physically plunge a sensor into the plasma cloud as it flies by. We literally have to stick a magnetic thermometer into it. Basically, yes. We have to sample it directly. The sensors we rely on to do this are positioned at a gravitationally stable point in space called L1, which sits directly between the Earth and the Sun. Okay, so how far away is L1? It is roughly 1 .5 million kilometers

away from Earth. 1 .5 million kilometers. That sounds like a huge buffer zone. It is a vast distance by human standards. But remember, the total journey from the sun is 150 million kilometers. So L1 is basically sitting right on our front porch. Oh, I see. By the time the CME reaches our sensors at L1 and we finally get that crucial, precise magnetic data, the storm has already traveled 99 % of the way to Earth. Oh, wow. So depending on how fast that plasma is moving once it hits that sensor, we only have, what, 15 to

60 minutes of actual warning before it hits the atmosphere. That is the... A terrifying reality. Grid operators would have 15 to 60 minutes to make the call on whether to safely reconfigure or shut down a national electricity grid. That is no time at all. It is the ultimate bottleneck in space weather forecasting. And it's why global governments are heavily investing in better early warning systems. Because a direct worst case hit is not a hypothetical scenario. We had an incredibly close call in July 2012. Right. A massive Carrington level CME. erupted right toward Earth's orbital path. It was exceptionally fast

and powerful. Researchers who analyzed the data later concluded it might have been even stronger than the 1859 storm. And it swept directly through the exact space Earth occupies in its orbit. But Earth just happened to be roughly a week further along in its orbit. Right. We just weren't standing there when the bullet flew past. It was pure orbital luck. The CME instead hit a solar observation spacecraft called Stereo A, which is how we obtained the detailed magnetic data to measure just how catastrophic it would

have been. So if that storm had erupted just a little earlier in the sun's rotation, we would have been squarely in the crosshairs. We would have taken a direct hit. And the economic modeling on a direct hit like that today is just staggering. I mean, if a Carrington -level event fries hundreds of high -voltage transformers, They aren't just sitting on shelves at a local hardware store ready to be swapped out. No, they take months to build. We're talking about global supply chain shortages, months of prolonged power outages in major urban centers, and potentially trillions

of dollars in economic damage. It is the very definition of a low probability, extremely high impact event. And because our warning window from L1 is so painfully short, humanity is forced to watch the sun constantly, 24 hours a day. We cannot afford a single blind spot. Which obviously requires a globally coordinated team effort. You can't observe the sun from one country as the Earth rotates. And I was fascinated to learn Australia plays a surprisingly vital role in this network. They really do. The Bureau of Meteorology's

Space Weather Services manages facilities like the Lermont Solar Observatory in Western Australia. They ensure that as the sun sets over one continent, observatories on the other side of the planet seamlessly take over the watch. Passing the baton. Now, Australia sits at mid to low geomagnetic latitudes, meaning they're slightly further from the magnetic pole. Right, which offers their main power grids a degree of natural protection from the absolute worst of the induced currents, at least compared to a place like Canada or the... Nordic countries. But they are far from immune,

especially considering how heavily their massive remote mining and agriculture sectors depend on high frequency radio and millimeter accurate GPS. A severely disturbed ionosphere still has massive local economic impacts for them. Absolutely. The global economy is completely intertwined with this technology now. OK, let's bring this all back down to Earth. Hearing about trillion dollar damages, melting transformers and 15 minute warning windows. It is a lot to process. It can be overwhelming. So for you listening right now,

taking all this in, is this a situation where you should be stockpiling canned goods in a bunker or grabbing a lawn chair and watching the sky? It is firmly a lawn chair situation. Good to know. It really is all about perspective. The sun operates on a roughly 11 -year cycle. We have periods of quiet, known as solar minimum, and periods of high activity, solar maximum. And we are currently moving through the active phase, right? Yes. Solar flares and CMEs are more frequent right now. But this is completely normal behavior that we've observed for well over a century. The sun isn't doing anything

today that it hasn't been doing for billions of years. Okay, so the star itself isn't suddenly out to get us. Not at all. Truly extreme events, like the Carrington event, are genuinely rare. Based on historical and geological records, they occur perhaps once every century or even every few centuries. The sun hasn't suddenly become more dangerous. What's changed is us. Exactly. What has changed since 1859 is that we built a modern civilization completely dependent on sensitive electrical grids, satellites, and delicate

timing networks. We strung the wires, and now we simply have to manage the risk. And engineers are actively designing more resilient transformers, satellite operators are perfecting those automated safe modes, and scientists are continuously working to stretch that 15 -minute forecasting bottleneck. It deserves serious attention from the experts, absolutely. But for the average person, the most common effect of a geomagnetic storm is just a stunning natural light show. An awe -inspiring reminder that we live inside the magnetic influence of a star. Beautifully put. So to wrap this up,

the next time your Tuesday morning commute goes wrong because your GPS blue dot drifts into a river on the map, you'll know exactly what's going on. You'll know there is a physical chain of events at play. It starts with a tangled magnetic field snapping on the surface of the sun. Hurling a billion tons of plasma across space, violently shaking our magnetic shield, and filtering all the way down into the satellites and wires that quietly run our modern world. It is an astonishing system to think about. It fundamentally reshapes

how you look at the sky. And, you know, if we connect this entire discussion to the bigger picture, it raises an unavoidable question for our future. Ooh, okay. What's that? Well, we have spent this entire deep dive talking about space weather hitting Earth's magnetosphere, our protective magnetic bubble. But as humanity looks outward, we are actively planning to build permanent bases on the moon and eventually send astronauts to Mars. The next great leap. Right. But neither the moon nor Mars possesses a strong global magnetic field to protect them. Oh, wow.

I didn't even think about that. So as we venture out from under Earth's umbrella, how will future astronauts and their delicate life support systems survive a direct hit from a billion ton coronal mass ejection without a planetary magnetic shield to take the brunt of the impact? Just completely exposed. In many ways, our ultimate space weather challenge hasn't even begun. Building a civilization completely exposed to the raw elements of space. That is a wild thought to leave on. Thank you so much for joining us on this deep dive. Next time your phone glitches, remember to look up,

well, maybe not directly at the sun, but remember the incredible physics happening just over our heads. Stay curious, everyone.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Nanotechnology – Building at the Scale of Atoms

    Nov 19, 202626 minAudio

    Nanotechnology works at a scale where a nanometre is to a metre what a single centimetre is to the distance across a football field roughly a hundred thousand times over. This episode explains what nanotechnology...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Animal Migration – Navigation Without Maps

    Nov 17, 202625 minAudio

    A tagged bar-tailed godwit once flew more than thirteen thousand kilometres from Alaska to Tasmania without landing once. This episode explores why animals migrate at all, from godwits and humpback whales to monarch...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Tsunamis – Waves That Cross Oceans

    Nov 12, 202623 minAudio

    An ordinary wave rolls onto the sand every few seconds; a tsunami can take tens of minutes between crests and cross an entire ocean at the speed of a jet aircraft while barely rippling the surface. This episode explains...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Symmetry – Physics' Deepest Idea

    Nov 10, 202620 minAudio

    A folded square of paper and a butterfly's wings share the same simple visual idea: a shape that looks the same after some transformation. This episode follows that idea from everyday geometry into the deepest...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. How Plants Sense the World

    Nov 8, 202627 minAudio

    A pot plant on a windowsill quietly bends toward the light within days, with no eyes, brain or nervous system involved at all. This episode explores how plants detect light direction and colour, sense gravity through...

    Credit the people on this episode