A tagged bar-tailed godwit once flew more than thirteen thousand kilometres from Alaska to Tasmania without landing once. This episode explores why animals migrate at all, from godwits and humpback whales to monarch butterflies and homing salmon, how tracking technology has revealed these journeys in detail, and the honest, still-unsettled science of how animals navigate, including magnetoreception. You'll come away understanding why migration evolved as a seasonal survival strategy, what makes the bar-tailed godwit's nonstop flight so extraordinary, how humpback whales and monarch butterflies manage their own remarkable journeys, how sun compasses, star compasses and salmon's sense of smell have been experimentally confirmed, why the biological mechanism behind magnetoreception remains a genuinely open scientific question, how modern tracking technology has transformed what we know, and why protecting migratory routes means protecting habitat on the other side of the planet. Talking Science is sponsored by Kinsoft. Visit www.kinsoft.com.au Further reading: BirdLife Australia - shorebird migration and East Asian-Australasian Flyway resources; CSIRO - research on migratory species and tracking; Nature - reviews on animal navigation and magnetoreception; Australian Antarctic Program - humpback whale migration research.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
So I want to start today with this story from October 2020. There was this young bar -tailed godwit, just a small shorebird, and it lifted off from the mudflats in Alaska. Right, and it had that tiny satellite tracking device strapped to its back. Yeah, exactly. And once this bird was in the air, it just it kept flying like day after day, night after night. It flew over the open Pacific Ocean for 11 straight days. Just incredible. No landing to rest, no drinking,
no stopping to feed. It finally touched down in Tasmania, which means it covered more than 13 ,000 kilometers in a single unbroken flight. I remember when that tracking data first hit the servers. And ornithologists globally were just stunned. I mean, we were talking about a bird that weighs about as much as a small tub of margarine. A tub of margarine. That's wow. Yeah. And it's pulling off this physical feat that, honestly, human engineers would struggle to replicate with a high -tech drone. Right. And to put that in perspective for you listening, that distance, 13 ,000 kilometers, that is roughly
like flying from Perth to London and then most of the way back again. All powered entirely by body fat. Right. With a set of wings beating continuously for nearly 300 hours, it's just... It's hard to wrap your head around. It forces us to completely redefine our understanding of physical endurance, really. And the wildest part of the source material we're looking at today is that this isn't an anomaly. Right. It's just one spectacular data point in this massive, invisible phenomenon that happens quietly all around us
every single year. Like, while you are commuting to work or grabbing a coffee, billions of animals are navigating this invisible highway right above your head. And deep in our oceans, too. Yeah. Which brings us to the mission of our deep dive today. We're taking the sources you brought in to solve this evolutionary puzzle. Like, why do animals do this? Yeah, the fundamental why. Exactly. And then how are creatures the size of a teacup executing these navigational and physical miracles that seem biologically impossible? And perhaps more urgently, what tracking technology
is telling us about the fragility of these journeys. Because the sheer scale of it really does bring up that fundamental question for biologists. You gotta look at the math, you know. Why would an animal ever take on such a deadly risk in the first place? I am so glad you brought up the math because this is where I get completely stuck. Oh, really? Yeah, I mean, from a human perspective, if winter is coming and it gets cold, we just, we put on a sweater or turn on the heat. For an animal, the stakes are obviously life and death. But is migrating actually the
safest option? It doesn't seem like it, right? No, I look at a small bird facing unfamiliar predators, massive ocean storms, just pure exhaustion. And I have to wonder, wouldn't it be mathematically safer to just tough out the winter or maybe hibernate? It definitely seems counterintuitive. But evolutionarily speaking, toughing it out is actually a guaranteed death sentence for these specific animals. OK, why is that? Well, hibernation works for a bear. Because it can store massive amounts of fat and
it has a low surface area to volume ratio to retain that heat. Right. A big body keeps the heat in. Exactly. But a tiny songbird physically cannot store enough fat to keep its internal furnace burning through six months of freezing darkness. I mean, it would freeze solid in a day. Oh, wow. So the risk of staying is literally 100 percent mortality. Yeah, which suddenly makes the perilous journey look like a bargain, right? I guess so, yeah. Migration only persists in species where the long -term payoff, things like
reliable food, safety from predators, breeding success, where that payoff is significantly higher than the massive energy costs of the trip. So give me a sense of what that payoff looks like, say, for a bird migrating to the Arctic. Because why fly all the way up to the top of the clove just to lay an egg? Well, it's all about the midnight sun. In the Arctic Spring, the ice melts and you get this short, explosive, overwhelming burst of insect life. Oh, right. The bug hatch. Huge bug hatch. Combine that with 24 hours of daylight and you have an environment where parent
birds can forage constantly. They can feed their hungry chicks around the clock without having to stop for nightfall. Because the sun never sets. Exactly. It is a temporary paradise. But the second that short window closes, the ice returns, the insects die off. And staying means starvation. They have to leave. That makes total sense for birds because they can fly over obstacles. Yeah. But the sources also highlight that this same life or death math applies to massive overland migrations too, like the wildebeests in East
Africa. Oh, absolutely. Well over a million wildebeests undertake this continuous year -round circular migration across the Serengeti and Maasai Mara. A million animals. That's wild. It is. And they are chasing the seasonal rains that dictate where fresh grass grows. If they stay in one place, they graze it down to the dirt and they starve. I read that part of the source material and immediately wondered about the mechanics of it. You say they're tracking the seasonal rains. How does a herd of a million animals actually know where it is raining hundreds of miles away? They're relying
heavily on their senses, specifically hearing and smell. I mean, wildebeest can hear the low -frequency rumble of thunder from incredibly far away. Really? Just listening for storms? Yeah. And even more fascinating, they can smell the moisture. You know that distinct smell when rain finally hits parched soil? Oh, petrichor. Yeah, I love that smell. Exactly, petrichor. They are literally following the scent of incoming storms across the savanna to find the green wave of new grass. That paints such a vivid picture, just sniffing out the rain. And then you also
have caribou in the North American Arctic doing something similar, but for a completely different reason, right? Right. For caribou, the movement from winter forests. to the open summer tundra is partly about food, but heavily about defense. Defense against what? Wolves? Yep, wolves. The forests provide cover in winter, but when it is time to give birth, the forests are full of predators. By migrating out onto the flat, exposed tundra, the caribou enter an environment where wolves really struggle to ambush them. Because
there's nowhere to hide. Precisely. It keeps the newborn calves significantly safer until they're strong enough to run. And... Just to cover all bases, we see the exact same logic in the ocean too. Whales and fish following seasonal blooms of plankton, which just as a quick definition for you listening plankton, are those tiny drifting plants and animals that basically form the base of the entire ocean food web. Exactly. Plankton blooms shift with ocean currents and sunlight, and the massive predators just follow them. The
underlying rule across all these environments is that no single place on Earth offers perfect conditions all year round. So moving is the only way to avoid a season of deadly scarcity. You hit the nail on the head. Okay, so the evolutionary economics check out. But a spreadsheet might say a trip is worth the risk while the physical body still has to actually survive it. Let's go back to our bar -tailed godwit crossing the Pacific Ocean. Yeah, let's look at the physiology. Right, because it's a 13 ,000 kilometer flight with no islands to rest on. stone. If you stop flapping, you drown. And a bird doesn't have
a fuel tank, so how does its body biologically handle that? Well, they essentially become flying fuel tanks. In the weeks before departure, a godwit will gorge itself on coastal mudflats and roughly double its body weight. Debullet. Yeah, packing on these thick layers of specialized fat. But wait, doubling your weight makes it harder to fly? You need more lift, which requires more energy. So aren't they working against themselves? Which leads us to one of the most extreme physiological adaptations in the animal kingdom. To compensate for the heavy fat, the godwit literally shrinks
its own internal organs. Wait, slow down. They shrink their own organs? They really do. How does a living creature just delete part of its stomach? It is a process related to what biologists call phenotypic plasticity. The bird's body deliberately breaks down the cellular tissue of its own digestive tract. That is insane. It acts like a highly controlled localized starvation where the body absorbs those non -essential proteins to help build up the flight muscles. Since they won't be eating over the open ocean anyway, carrying
a full -sized stomach is just dead weight. Okay, that reminds me of, like, a human body entering extreme ketosis, breaking down muscle for fuel when it runs out of carbs, but this is entirely localized and intentional. Right, it's very targeted. It's like a racing team stripping the heavy passenger seats, the radio, and the air conditioning out of a car to make it ultra light for the track. But we're talking about a living creature. It's a great analogy. And just like a car needing its seats back for a normal road trip, The bird has to regrow those organs when it finally lands
in Australia or New Zealand. Oh, of course, because it has to eat eventually. Exactly. For the first few days after touchdown, they actually can't digest heavy meals. They have to eat very small, easily digestible food to literally rebuild their digestive tract from the remaining tissue. That is deeply unsettling and completely brilliant. But what about the opposite end of the size spectrum? The source material details humpback whales doing these incredible journeys, and their budgeting problem seems completely inverted. Yeah. Where
the godwit is minimizing weight, the humpback is maximizing mass. During the summer, humpbacks feed in the nutrient -dense waters around Antarctica. They gorge on, krill these tiny shrimp -like crustaceans, and build up a massive reserve of thick blubber. Getting ready for a winter migration. Right. They travel thousands of kilometers north along the coast of Australia to the warmer tropical waters of the Great Barrier Reef and the Kimberley region. And they go there to mate and give birth.
But there's a catch, right? A huge catch. The tropical waters are practically a desert when it comes to the whales' actual food. So they're swimming a 10 ,000 -kilometer round trip, giving birth, and nursing calves that drink, what, dozens of gallons of milk a day, all without eating a single thing. Not a single bite. They rely entirely on the fat reserves built up months earlier in Antarctica. The sheer scale of that caloric budget is just mind -boggling. It's basically an extreme fast. They are endurance fasting while performing some of the most energy -intensive activities in their entire life cycle. Okay,
so we have birds dissolving their own stomachs and whales starving for half a year. But here is where the sources completely broke my brain. What happens when a migration route takes longer to complete than the animal's actual lifespan? Ah, yes. We step into the realm of generational relays, and the prime example here is the North American monarch butterfly. Right. I've seen pictures of this. It's stunning. It really is. Every autumn, monarchs from as far north as Canada
fly thousands of miles south to very specific, high -altitude fir forests in central Mexico. Millions of them cluster tightly together on the tree trunks creating this living blanket to conserve warmth through the winter. Which is a beautiful image, but the timeline is the crazy part to me. The butterflies clinging to those trees in Mexico, they've never been there before, and they will never make the return trip, right? Correct. It takes multiple generations to complete the full annual cycle. The butterflies flying south are typically the great -grandchildren of the butterflies that left Mexico the previous
spring. So how does Generation 4 know which patch of forest to aim for? There's no living relative to show them the way, no older butterfly to follow. Are they just blindly flying south and hoping for the best? They aren't flying blind at all, actually. They are following a set of instructions genetically hardwired into their biology. So it's inherited. Yes, they inherit a biological compass and an internal map that tells them not just to head south, but the specific trajectory needed to hit those specific mountain ranges. It just feels like magic. I mean, it really does.
But if we were talking about mind -bending distances, we have to talk about the undisputed distance king from the sources, the Arctic tern. Oh, the tern is phenomenal. It doesn't do a single nonstop flight like the godwit, but it holds the record for cumulative distance. Right. It's a small seabird that breeds in the Arctic during the northern summer. And then when autumn hits, it flies all the way down to the waters around Antarctica to catch the southern summer. It essentially lives in permanent daylight. But I look at a map of a bird flying from the North Pole to the South Pole, and the energy expenditure seems
impossible. A tiny bird flying 70 ,000 kilometers in a single zigzagging round trip. How can any animal consume enough calories to fuel that? Wouldn't they burn more energy looking for food than they actually get from it? That is the genius of the turns route, actually. They don't fly in a straight line. Oh, they don't? No, they take a massive meandering path. across the oceans, deliberately riding global wind currents to save energy. And unlike the Godwit, which fasts over
the Pacific, the Arctic tern feeds on the wing. Okay, so they're snacking as they go. Exactly. They plunge dive into the ocean to catch small fish and krill along the way. They are pacing themselves, constantly refueling at sea. And the sources say they can live for over 20 years, which means over its lifetime, a single Arctic tern flies millions of kilometers. It's staggering. Literally the distance from the Earth to the moon and partway back. It really puts our morning commutes into perspective, doesn't it? But looking at the monarch hitting a specific forest and
the tern navigating the globe. brings us to probably the most fiercely debated question in migration science. Which is, how do they know exactly where they are? Exactly. Well, let's start with the mechanisms we actually understand. Because we know animals use celestial compasses, like they navigate by the stars and the sun. Yes, and there was a fantastic experiment that proved the star compass using indigo buntings. Researchers took these young birds and raised them inside a planetarium. Taking birds on a field trip to the planetarium
is just a great visual. It really is. But it was brilliant because it let the scientists control the night sky. They discovered that the young birds observe the rotation of the stars. Oh, great. They identify the fixed point in the sky that the other stars rotate around, like Polaris, the north star, and they memorize that pattern. They use that celestial center point to orient themselves when they're released into the wild. That is so smart. But a star map only works at night. I know birds and monarch butterflies also use a sun compass during the day. But here's
what I don't get. Since the sun moves across the sky from east to west, how do they use it as a reliable fixed point? It's a great question. Because, like, if I tell you to walk towards the sun at 9 a .m., you go east. If I tell you to do it at 4 p .m., you go west. You've hit on the exact complication. To use the sun, the animal must also possess an internal circadian clock. Oh, a built -in timer. Right. If a bird's internal clock knows it is morning and it sees the sun on its left, it knows it is heading south. If its clock says it is late afternoon, it knows
the sun should be on its right to keep heading south. Wow. They're constantly doing this subconscious trigonometry, correcting their heading based on the time of day. Okay, so vision and time cover the sky. But the source material also dives into a term called olfactory homing, which simply means finding your way home using your sense of smell. And this is where salmon takes center stage. Yes, the salmon's life cycle is iconic. A salmon hatches in a specific freshwater stream, swims out to the open ocean, and spends years growing to adulthood. Then, when it is time to
spawn, it returns overwhelmingly to the exact stream where it was born. thousands of miles of featureless ocean, they find a single puddle of water. Like, how sensitive does a sense of smell have to be to pull that off? Incredibly sensitive. When a salmon is a juvenile, its olfactory bulb absorbs and memorizes the unique chemical signature of its home stream. Like a fingerprint. Exactly like a thumbprint. Every river has a distinct chemical makeup made of dissolved minerals surrounding soil types and local plant life.
Salmon's brain logs that precise chemical cocktail. So years later, they literally sniff their way up the coastline, detecting parts per trillion of those specific amino acids in the water to find the right river mouth. It is the extreme biological version of catching a whiff of a specific perfume or, like, a baking recipe and being instantly transported back to your grandmother's living room. But they're doing it underwater, across an ocean. It is remarkably effective. Researchers have even temporarily plugged the nasal cavities of migrating salmon, and their homing ability
completely collapses. They just wander aimlessly. Oh, so it's entirely smell -based. That's wild. So we understand stars, the sun, and smell. But if we want to talk about an unsolved mystery, we have to look at magnetoreception. This is the proposed ability of an animal to sense the Earth's magnetic field. Right, and we have decades of behavioral data proving that birds... Birds, sea turtles, and fish definitely respond to magnetic fields. We know they use it. The debate in the scientific community is over the physical how.
Like what's the actual hardware doing it? Exactly. What biological tool is inside their bodies capturing that magnetic signal? I am dying to hear the theories because it honestly sounds like science fiction. It does. So the first major hypothesis involves magnetite. Magnetite is a naturally occurring magnetic mineral. The theory suggests these animals have microscopic crystals of magnetite clustered in specific cells, perhaps in their beaks or their inner ears. Okay, so actual magnets. Yeah, these crystals act quite literally like microscopic cum. compass needles, physically
pulling or twisting in alignment with the Earth's magnetic field and triggering a nerve impulse to the brain. Having a physical compass built into your face, that makes a lot of intuitive sense. But the sources highlight a second theory that is much, much weirder. The second hypothesis, which is gaining a lot of traction right now, involves a light sensitive protein found in the eyes of migratory birds. It's called cryptochrome. And this relies on quantum chemistry. Quantum chemistry inside a bird's eye. Please break this
down for me. Okay, so when a photon of blue light enters the bird's eye and hits this cryptochrome protein, it triggers a chemical reaction. It creates what are called radical pairs. Radical pairs, got it. Think of them like two tiny spinning tops inside the cell. Normally, they spin perfectly in sync with each other. Okay, two synchronized spinning tops. But the Earth's magnetic field is washing over the bird. Depending on the angle the bird is facing, that magnetic field subtly bumps one of the spinning tops, knocking it slightly out of sync with its partner. And the bird can
feel that. The bird's brain has a way of detecting that tiny disruption in the spin, yes. So the magnetic field is altering a chemical reaction in the eye itself. Does that mean a bird might literally be seeing the magnetic field? Like a visual overlay, a heads -up display in a video game showing them with ways north? That is the most thrilling, speculative part of the theory. It might appear as a dark spot or shifting color perception that moves as they turn their head. That is just wow. I know. Both the magnetite
and the cryptochrome hypotheses have strong experimental support, but neither has been definitively proven as the sole mechanism. It's very likely some species use both. You know, one is a rough global map and the other for fine tuning their exact heading. The fact that we are even able to debate quantum reactions in a bird's eye is just a testament to how far our observation tools have come. Because none of this, the 13 ,000 kilometer flights, the zigzagging routes, none of this was known a century ago. Not at all. For a long time, the
best we had was bird banding. You know, you attach a uniquely numbered metal ring to a bird's leg in Alaska. And you just pray that someone in New Zealand happens to catch that exact bird a year later to report it. The return rate on that must have been abysmal. Oh, roughly one in a thousand for small birds. It was foundational, but it relied on sheer luck. The real revolution started with geolocators. These are tiny, lightweight devices that don't transmit data. They just record ambient light levels. Wait, how does recording
the brightness of the sky tell you where a bird went? Well, you still have to catch the bird a second time to download the data. But once you do, you look at the timing of sunrise and sunset for every single day. Oh, I see where this is going. The length of the day tells you the bird's latitude because summer days get longer the further north you go. And the exact time of solar noon tells you the longitude because the sun peaks later the further west you go. That is incredibly clever. You are calculating global coordinates using nothing but a shadow clock. But as you said, you still have to catch
the bird twice. Which is why satellite tags, like the one glued to our bar -tailed godwit, change the game. They transmit GPS coordinates directly to satellites in real time. We can literally watch the migration unfold from our laptops. Oh, the dream. The major limitation, though, is that the batteries make them too heavy for a butterfly or a tiny songbird. Which brings us to a massive engineering solution detailed in the sources. The MODIS Wildlife Tracking System. How does this work? MODIS is a collaborative
global network of automated radio receivers. So instead of putting a heavy battery on a bird to transmit to space, scientists put incredibly tiny, lightweight radio tags on the animals. How tiny? Some are small enough for large insects. Then researchers build thousands of listening stations on schools, farms, and hillsides across entire continents. Oh, so the infrastructure is on the ground, not on the animal. Exactly. Whenever a tagged animal flies within about 15 kilometers of any station, it pings the network. It allows researchers to track tiny creatures
across thousands of miles, piecing the journey together ping by ping. And this data has revealed something deeply concerning, hasn't it? Because seeing the exact route on a map proves that a migration isn't just a starting line and a finish line. It's a highly specific chain of locations. It is a chain of crucial rest stops. And breaking a single link in that chain can collapse the entire journey. We see a glaring example of this in the Yellow Sea. Explain what is happening there. Well, the East Asian Australasian Flyway is the route many shorebirds, including our godwits,
take. Millions of these birds rely on a few critical stopover sites, specifically the vast tidal mudflats around the Yellow Sea, bordering China and the Korean Peninsula. You rest up. Right. The birds land there halfway through their journey. completely exhausted to eat worms and rebuild their fat reserves. But the sources show those mudflats have been disappearing rapidly due to coastal land reclamation. Developers are building seawalls and filling in the mudflats to create new land for industry and agriculture. It is the ecological equivalent of trying to drive across a desert
on a tight schedule, only to discover that every single gas station for 500 miles has been bulldozed. That's horrifying. The birds arrive running on fumes and there is nowhere to land and nothing to eat. Biologists have linked this specific habitat loss directly to catastrophic population crashes in several shorebird species. It perfectly illustrates the geopolitical nightmare of conservation. Protecting a bird that nests in your backyard in Australia requires you to somehow protect a patch of mud on the exact opposite side of
the planet. You need cooperation across 10 different borders. But, you know, the tracking data actually gives us a powerful tool for hope here. By definitively proving exactly which mudflats the birds use, scientists were able to present hard data to governments. This evidence directly informed international agreements that protected key wetlands in the Yellow Sea. It proves the chain can be repaired if we know where the broken links are, though the threats are constantly evolving, right? We now have artificial light from cities drawing migrating birds off course and causing building
collisions. Yes. We have climate change shifting the timing of spring so birds arrive in the Arctic after the insect bloom has already peaked and died off. And we have offshore wind farms being built directly in the middle of ancient invisible flight paths. The takeaway is that we can no longer view migration as this resilient, inevitable force of nature. These routes are fragile, biologically engineered systems that require active human maintenance to survive our rapid changes to the planet. Let's bring this all back to where we
started, because depending on the time of year, there is a bar -tailed godwit out there right now, flying over the dark waters of the Pacific Ocean. Its internal organs are shrunken, its body is burning through a tank of stored fat, it is reading the stars, checking its internal clock against the sun, and feeling the magnetic pull of the Earth through quantum reactions in its eyes. It is aiming for a specific stretch of coastline it has never seen, guided by a brain smaller than a thumbnail. executing a feat of navigation that would humble a human sailor with
a GPS. It is a quiet, breathtaking miracle happening right above us. But reading through all the research you shared in this deep dive, it left me with one final lingering thought. What's that? Well, if a monarch butterfly or a small shorebird can inherit a mental map of the stars and a magnetic compass from its distant ancestors, it makes you wonder about us. What deeply buried ancient navigational instincts might still be lying dormant inside our own human DNA, just waiting for us to put down our phones, step outside into the dark, and look up?
Nanotechnology works at a scale where a nanometre is to a metre what a single centimetre is to the distance across a football field roughly a hundred thousand times over. This episode explains what nanotechnology...
The Sun is an active, magnetic star, and every so often it hurls bursts of radiation and clouds of charged particles toward Earth, a phenomenon called space weather. This episode explains solar flares and coronal mass...
An ordinary wave rolls onto the sand every few seconds; a tsunami can take tens of minutes between crests and cross an entire ocean at the speed of a jet aircraft while barely rippling the surface. This episode explains...
A folded square of paper and a butterfly's wings share the same simple visual idea: a shape that looks the same after some transformation. This episode follows that idea from everyday geometry into the deepest...
A pot plant on a windowsill quietly bends toward the light within days, with no eyes, brain or nervous system involved at all. This episode explores how plants detect light direction and colour, sense gravity through...