Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Talking Science

Talking Science artwork

Space Junk and the Kessler Problem

Jul 24, 202622 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Orbiting the Earth alongside our working satellites is a growing swarm of debris - dead spacecraft, spent rocket stages and countless fragments - hurtling around the planet fast enough to destroy anything they hit. This episode explores space junk, and the unsettling scenario in which it could feed on itself. You'll come away understanding where orbital debris comes from, why even a fleck of paint is dangerous at orbital speed, what the "Kessler syndrome" is, and what's being done to keep the space around Earth usable. Talking Science is sponsored by Kinsoft. Visit www.kinsoft.com.au Further reading: ESA - "Space debris" pages; NASA Orbital Debris Program Office; Donald Kessler's 1978 paper (widely summarised online).

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

I want you to try something for just a second close your eyes and picture outer space like really put yourself there right if you're like most of us you're probably picturing this I don't know incredibly clean silent infinite black void yeah totally peaceful exactly peaceful fast but the reality especially in that immediate orbital shell right above Earth where all of our satellites live, is completely different. It's not a pristine void at all. No, not even close. It's basically

a crowded hyperspeed junkyard. Yeah, and that contrast between the sci -fi imagination of space and the physical reality is, I mean, it's staggering. We tend to view orbit as this... cinematic backdrop, you know. But it's a highly active, highly polluted physical environment. And what's happening up there is no longer just a problem for like astronauts or astronomers. It's this compounding environmental crisis. And it's actually beginning to threaten the foundational technology that you rely on every single day. Which is wild to think about. So welcome to this deep dive. Our mission today

is to explore this invisible ring of rubbish encircling our planet. We're going to dig into the terrifying physics of why A tiny fleck of paint in space can be as deadly as a bullet. Yeah, that part is crazy. Right. And we'll get into the sheer logistical nightmare of managing space traffic and the wildly ambitious ways engineers are trying to clean it up before we essentially lock ourselves out of orbit. I'm really glad we're tackling this because we need to look at

near Earth space the exact same way we look at our oceans or atmosphere. I mean, for decades, humanity just treated orbit like an infinite dumping ground. Out of sight, out of mind. Exactly. Yeah. But we are rapidly approaching a physical limit. And understanding the mechanics of how this happened, well, it's the only way we're going to figure out how to fix it. So I want to start with those mechanics. Yeah. Because before we even talk about how much junk is floating around up there, we have to understand the physical reality of being in orbit. And the danger up there, it isn't really about mass, right? No, not at all. It's entirely about velocity. Yeah.

And to put that in perspective, we first kind of have to redefine what it actually means to be in orbit. Because when you watch footage from the space station, the astronauts appear to be floating. Right. They're doing flips and stuff. Zero G. Right. It looks like zero gravity. But gravity is actually still pulling on them with about 90 % of the force we feel right here on the ground. Wait, really? 90 %? Yeah. They're not floating. They are just falling. Okay, but they never hit the ground. Exactly, because they are moving forward so incredibly fast that as

they fall, the curvature of the Earth essentially just drops away beneath them. Okay, wait, let me rephrase that because I know we need to nail down the speeds here for the listener. They have to travel fast enough to essentially match the curve of the planet. That is the crucial concept, yeah. To maintain that freefall around the planet without hitting the atmosphere, an object in low Earth orbit has to travel at roughly 28 ,000 kilometers an hour. 28 ,000? Yeah. That is the baseline speed limit for anything up there, whether

it's a multimillion -dollar communications satellite, the space station, or, you know, a discarded wrench. Just a wrench hauling along at 28 ,000 kilometers an hour. Let's ground that in an everyday experience for you listening. Imagine you're driving down the highway at a normal speed, maybe 100 kilometers an hour, and a bug hits your windshield. Right. It's a smudge. Right. Annoying, but harmless. Now imagine a pebble hits your windshield at that same highway speed. You get a star crack in the glass. Yeah. But in space, objects aren't

moving at highway speeds. They are moving at like 10 times the speed of a rifle bullet. And this is where the physics of kinetic energy gets genuinely terrifying. Oh, I bet. Because the formula for kinetic energy squares the velocity. So if you double your speed, you don't just double your destructive power, you multiply it by four. Oh, wow. Yeah. So when you scale a speed up to 28 ,000 kilometers an hour, the amount of energy carried by even a microscopic object becomes just completely catastrophic. I was reading up on the damage sustained by the International

Space Station, and this one detail completely blew my mind. The reinforced multilayer glass windows on the ISS, they've actually been chipped and cratered by literal flecks of paint. Yeah. Like a piece of paint that just peeled off an old rocket stage somewhere. It's true, and the mechanics of that impact are fascinating because it doesn't just bump into the glass. At orbital velocities, a fleck of paint doesn't even behave like a solid object hitting another solid object anymore. What does it do? Well, the kinetic energy

is so high that upon impact, the paint and the immediate surface of the glass instantly vaporize into plasma. Wait, vaporize into plasma from a pin chip? Yes. It creates this tiny shock wave that literally blasts a crater into the material. That is, I mean, that's horrifying. It is. Now take that mechanism and scale the object. up from a paint chip to something the size of a Markle or, you know, a lost bolt from a rocket hatch. Right. A strike from an object just a few centimeters across doesn't just dent a spacecraft.

It hits with the explosive force of a hand grenade. It will punch completely through the shielding, vaporize the internal electronics, and instantly kill a satellite. Which makes me wonder how anyone in their right mind thought it was okay to leave trash up there. because knowing how devastating a single collision can be, How do we end up with a massive cloud of these high speed projectiles? Well, I mean, for decades, the standard operating procedure for the most advanced engineering projects on the planet was to just detach their garbage

and leave it in orbit to become rogue shrapnel. Yeah, I mean, we really have to look at the historical constraints of rocketry to understand why that happened. Getting any mass into orbit is just punishingly expensive. Right, and fuel costs. Exactly. It requires a tremendous amount of fuel. So in the early decades of the space race, every spare ounce of was dedicated to the payload itself. Reserving extra fuel just to steer a dead rocket stage back down to Earth? Unthinkable. Yeah, it was considered an unacceptable waste of resources. So the engineers just kind of assumed space was

infinitely large and, you know, a few dead rocket stages wouldn't hurt anything. The ultimate out of sight, out of mind. Precisely. And for a long time, the sheer volume of space meant that the risk of two things colliding was statistically close to zero. Sure. So satellites would reach the end of their 10 -year lifespans, run out of the propellant they used to maintain their orientation, and operators would just shut off the transmitters and leave them tumbling in the dark. But the routine, the dead satellites and

all that, that's only half the story, right? Yeah. Because my research for this deep dive showed that the truly massive spikes in space junk didn't come from dead satellites just slowly accumulating. They came from what are called bulk events. Yeah, those bulk events are the real turning points in this crisis. A bulk event is a sudden catastrophic fragmentation. Like an explosion. Exactly. Sometimes it happens because an old dead rocket stage was abandoned with leftover pressurized fuel still inside its tanks. Oh, that sounds like a bad idea. It is. Years later,

the thermal stress of passing in and out of the sun's shadow causes the tank to rupture. And the entire stage explodes, turning one large piece of trackable debris into thousands of jagged, untrackable pieces. And some of them were intentional, which is wild. I was looking into that 2007 incident where... a country decided to test an anti -satellite weapon. They literally fired a missile into one of their own defunct weather satellites. Yeah, and that test remains one of the most severe debris generating events in history. By intentionally

obliterating a large satellite in a heavily populated orbit, they instantly created over 3 ,000 pieces of trackable shrapnel. 3 ,000. And probably hundreds of thousands of pieces that are just too small to track. But even that intentional explosion kind of seems overshadowed by what happened two years later in 2009. This is the event that really caught my attention. It wasn't a missile strike. It was a complete accident. Yeah, the 2009 collision. Right. An active communication satellite, Iridium -33, and a massive, completely dead Russian military satellite, Cosmos -2251, just slammed into each

other at orbital speeds. That was a massive wake -up call for the entire global aerospace community. meaning the speed at which those two huge satellites were moving toward each other was over 40 ,000 kilometers an hour. Unbelievable. They completely annihilated each other. And that added another 2 ,000 large fragments to the orbital environment. Now, here is the part I really struggled to understand when I was reading about that. We have all these

ground radars, right? We know where the active satellites are. Right. So how on earth did nobody see two school bus size objects? speeding toward each other why didn't the active one just you know swerve Well, the tracking systems did see them, but it highlights this massive flaw in how we monitor space traffic. Radar isn't like GPS on your phone. When you track an object using ground -based radar from hundreds of miles away, there's a margin of error. You don't know exactly where the satellite is down to the millimeter. You know it's somewhere within a three -dimensional

bubble of probability. A bubble of probability. Yeah, often shaped kind of like a long pizza box. A pizza box. Okay, so when the radar predicts a close pass, it's really just... saying, hey, these two pizza boxes, these uncertainty bubbles, they might overlap. Precisely. And back in 2009, there were no automated space traffic control rules. The company operating the active satellite was receiving dozens, sometimes hundreds of these close approach warnings every single week for their entire fleet. Hundreds of warnings. Yeah. And almost all of them were false alarms. Swerving

a satellite uses precious fuel, which actually shortens its lifespan. So operators become desensitized. Boom. It's the boy who cried wolf. It's the ultimate boy who cried wolf scenario until the one time the wolf is actually there. And the consequence of that impact is that those thousands of pieces of frapnel don't just fall back to Earth. In those higher orbits, they keep whipping around the planet, spreading out like a net, just crossing through busy traffic lanes for centuries. Which leads us to a concept first described in the late 1970s, the Kessler syndrome. Right. Donald

Kessler. He was an astrophysicist at NASA who looked at the math of these collisions and realized we were heading toward a runaway tipping point. The logic is chillingly simple, honestly. Every collision creates a cloud of new fragments. And I found the easiest way to visualize this is like a game of pool. Oh, that's a good analogy. Yeah, imagine the opening break. where the cue ball slams into the triangle and the balls scatter across the table. But imagine if, instead of the balls eventually losing momentum and stopping,

every time a ball hit a bumper or another ball, it shattered into 10 smaller balls. And those smaller balls kept flying around at full speed, shattering into even smaller pieces every time they hit something. Eventually, the entire table is just this chaotic, inescapable blizzard of shrapnel. That cascading chain reaction that is the Kessler syndrome, once the density of debris in a specific orbital shell reaches a critical threshold, the rate of random collisions basically outpaces the rate at which atmospheric drag pulls the debris out of orbit. So it just

feeds itself. Exactly. The environment begins to aggressively pollute itself even if we never launch another rocket. But the timeline on this is important to clarify, right? Right. Because it's really easy to picture a Hollywood scenario where a satellite blows up and suddenly, boom, the entire sky is full of explosions. Yeah. Gravity style. But the reality is much slower, which in some ways actually makes it harder to mobilize people to care. A full Kessel Cascade doesn't happen in an afternoon. It takes decades. Decades. Right. A collision happens, creating a cloud

of debris that slowly spreads out over months. Ten years later, a piece of that debris hits another satellite. It is a slow generational locking down of our most valuable orbital real estate. And this is where it stops being an abstract problem for astronauts and starts being an immediate problem for you, the listener, because it's incredibly easy to take space for granted. But if we lose safe access to those orbits, modern life essentially breaks down. I really don't think most people realize how deeply their daily routine relies on a clear orbital path. Oh, it is entirely invisible

infrastructure. I mean, most people understand that satellite television or the mapping app on their phone relies on space, but it goes so much deeper into the industrial backbone of society. Like what? Well, for example, the global financial system relies entirely on the precise timing signals beamed down by GPS satellites. Wait, really? The stock market uses GPS? Oh, absolutely. Every GPS satellite carries a highly precise atomic clock. When a bank processes millions of high frequency trades or even when you just

swipe your card at an ATM, the system needs a universally synchronized timestamp to prevent fraud and keep the ledgers in order. And they get that from space. They pull that timing signal straight from GPS. If you lose the GPS constellation to a debris cascade, the global supply chain, aviation routing, worldwide banking systems, they would all face catastrophic disruptions within hours. That is terrifying. And what makes this even worse is that Kessler was worried about this tipping point back when there were only like a few hundred active satellites. Today,

the volume of traffic in space is skyrocketing at a rate we've never seen before. Yeah, we have officially entered the era of the mega -constellation. Right. Private tech companies are launching networks made up of thousands and soon tens of thousands of small satellites to beam high -speed internet to every square inch of the globe. Which is an incredible technological feat. It is. And I want to be fair here, because bringing low -latency internet to remote and underserved areas, that's a massive leap forward for humanity. But from

a traffic management perspective, how do you manage thousands of new vehicles merging onto a highway that is already filled with invisible hypervelocity shrapnel? You've hit the nail on the head. It fundamentally changes the math of orbital risk. These Internet satellites operate in lower orbits, which means they need huge numbers of satellites to get full global coverage because each one can only basically see a small patch of the Earth at a time. OK, so that. drastically multiplies the number of objects we have to monitor. Yes. I was looking at the mitigation strategies,

and honestly, it feels like we're just dodging bullets in the dark. The Space Force and international agencies use giant ground -based radars to track the big stuff, right? They do. We currently track over 25 ,000 objects larger than, say, a softball. And that data is fed to operators around the world. So they have a heads up. Yeah. When the International Space Station gets a red alert that a piece of tracked debris is going to violate its safety box, they literally fire up the thrusters and physically alter the station's orbit to dodge

it. Wow. They have to execute these avoidance maneuvers constantly now. But that only works for the objects large enough to bounce a radar wave back to Earth. Right. What about the lost bolts, the shattered pieces of that Cosmos satellite, the paint flecks? And that is the structural vulnerability of our current space economy. There are estimated to be over a million fragments ranging from a centimeter to 10 centimeters in size, and we just cannot track them. We're just blind to them. Spacecraft operators simply have to accept the risk. There is no dodging what

you cannot see coming. Which means we can't just play defense anymore. We have to actively clean up the mess. And I was diving into some of the engineering proposals for active debris removal, and it honestly sounds like science fiction. Space harpoons, robotic tentacles. Active debris removal, or ADR, is the absolute frontier of aerospace engineering right now. The basic concept is launching a specialized chaser spacecraft that matches orbit with the dead satellite, captures it, and then physically drags it down into the

atmosphere to burn up. Okay. And they are testing concepts that use giant nets, magnetic tethers, and yes, literal harpoons. A harpoon in space. But the engineering challenges of a space harpoon seem almost insurmountable. I mean, if you have a multi -ton dead satellite tumbling end over end at 28 ,000 kilometers an hour and you shoot a metal spear into it, aren't you risking hitting a pressurized fuel line and creating the exact kind of explosion you're trying to prevent? Yes. You are hitting on the core nightmare of debris removal. These targets are completely uncooperative.

They aren't designed to be caught. Right. They have no handles, they're spinning chaotically, and their structural integrity might be degraded from decades of solar radiation. If your robotic arm slips or your harpoon shatters a solar panel, you just turn one piece of trackable debris into a hundred pieces of untrackable trapdoor. Oops. Yeah, very expensive. Oops. It requires a level of autonomous precision that we are really only just beginning to achieve. And dragging dead satellites out of orbit? One by one, that sounds

exhaustingly expensive. Who's going to pay $100 billion just to take out the trash? Yeah. But from my research, it seems nature... actually offers us a helping hand here. There's this geographic wrinkle to how orbits work. The Earth's atmosphere doesn't just hit a hard ceiling and turn into a perfect vacuum. Exactly. The atmosphere's boundary is actually pretty fuzzy. It fades out very gradually. Down in low Earth orbit, which is where the space station flies and where all these new internet mega constellations are being deployed, the environment is not a true vacuum. There is still a microscopic

whisper of atmospheric gases up there. A whisper of the atmosphere. So let me try an analogy here to see if I've got this. Imagine you're jogging on the dry sand at the beach, and then you decide to start wading into the ocean. Even if the water is only up to your ankles, that tiny bit of fluid dragging against your legs It slows you down over time. Analogy, yes. You have to expend more energy to keep your speed up. That is exactly what happens to objects in low Earth orbit. That faint atmospheric drag is constantly pushing

against the satellites and the debris. Just a little bit of friction. Yeah. And over a period of months or years, that friction steals kinetic energy from the junk. It slows down, its orbit decays, and eventually gravity pulls it deep enough into the thick atmosphere that it safely burns up upon reentry. So low orbit actually has a built -in natural self -cleaning mechanism. It does. And interestingly, this natural cleanup even accelerates during periods of high solar activity. Wait, how does the sun help? Well, when the sun releases a solar flare, it heats

up the Earth's upper atmosphere, causing it to expand outward. That increased density acts like a giant brake on low -orbit debris, dragging it down much faster. That is an amazing natural fail -safe. But there's a catch, isn't there? Not all satellites are in low orbit. The massive telecommunications and weather satellites sit in geostationary orbit, which is, what, over 35 ,000 kilometers up? Yeah, and up there, that faint atmospheric drag completely vanishes. You are operating in a true vacuum. So no friction at all? None. If a satellite breaks apart in

geostationary orbit, nature is not going to help us clean it up. Debris at that altitude will linger for centuries, maybe even millennia. Wow. So understanding this altitude difference between the self -cleaning shallow end of space and the infinite deep end that really dictates the future of space strategy. It defines the new rules of the road. We can utilize the lower orbits for large fleets of expendable satellites, provided we design them to de -orbit quickly when they fail. Right. Let the atmosphere do the work. Exactly. But we must guard the high orbits jealously,

because up there, whatever we break stays broken forever. Okay, so bringing this all together, we have hypervelocity paint chips, dead rocket hulks, the looming threat of the Kessler syndrome, and experimental space harpoons. What does this all mean for us as a society? What is the core takeaway you want the listener to walk away with? I think the underlying lesson is actually a deeply familiar one. We've just relocated it to a new frontier. What do you mean? For the first 50 years of the space age, we treated the space

around Earth as infinite and resilient. We treated it the exact same way the Industrial Revolution created our rivers and our air. Ah, as a place where you could dump your byproducts without consequence. Exactly. We thought space was too big to fail. But we're learning that near -Earth orbit is a shared, limited environment. It's a commons. Right. It can be spoiled. Keeping it usable for future generations is going to require immense global cooperation, strict regulations on what gets launched, and heavy investments in active cleanup technologies. Space is not

an empty void. It is a delicate neighborhood. And we are absolutely responsible for keeping it clean. A delicate neighborhood. I love that. Thank you so much for bringing your insight to this and walking us through the mechanics of all this. It's been incredibly eye -opening. My pleasure. It is a really critical conversation to have right now. And to you listening, I want to leave you with one final thought to mull over, something that builds directly on this idea of space as a shared commons. Down here on Earth, if you rear -end someone's car on the highway, there is a clear system for liability. You call

your insurance, they sort it out. But space is an environment without borders. So who actually pays the bill or takes legal responsibility when a piece of anonymous 40 -year -old space junk launched by one nation takes out a brand new multimillion -dollar satellite owned by a company in another nation? That's the million -dollar question. Right. While there are treaties from the Cold War era that broadly say nations are responsible for their space objects, practically applying that to a cloud of untrackable hypervelocity

shrapnel is an entirely different story. It is the ultimate intergalactic traffic dispute, and humanity hasn't quite figured out the insurance policy for it yet. We really haven't. So next time you look up at that clean, silent, black night sky, remember, there's a whole lot of high -speed history flying around up there. Catch you on the next deep dive.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Nanotechnology – Building at the Scale of Atoms

    Nov 19, 202626 minAudio

    Nanotechnology works at a scale where a nanometre is to a metre what a single centimetre is to the distance across a football field roughly a hundred thousand times over. This episode explains what nanotechnology...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Animal Migration – Navigation Without Maps

    Nov 17, 202625 minAudio

    A tagged bar-tailed godwit once flew more than thirteen thousand kilometres from Alaska to Tasmania without landing once. This episode explores why animals migrate at all, from godwits and humpback whales to monarch...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Space Weather – When the Sun Attacks Our Technology

    Nov 15, 202625 minAudio

    The Sun is an active, magnetic star, and every so often it hurls bursts of radiation and clouds of charged particles toward Earth, a phenomenon called space weather. This episode explains solar flares and coronal mass...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Tsunamis – Waves That Cross Oceans

    Nov 12, 202623 minAudio

    An ordinary wave rolls onto the sand every few seconds; a tsunami can take tens of minutes between crests and cross an entire ocean at the speed of a jet aircraft while barely rippling the surface. This episode explains...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Symmetry – Physics' Deepest Idea

    Nov 10, 202620 minAudio

    A folded square of paper and a butterfly's wings share the same simple visual idea: a shape that looks the same after some transformation. This episode follows that idea from everyday geometry into the deepest...

    Credit the people on this episode