Right now, a hundred trillion particles from the Sun are passing through your body every second, and you'll never feel one. This episode traces the neutrino from Wolfgang Pauli's reluctant 1930 prediction, through its first detection near a nuclear reactor, to the decades-long solar neutrino problem and its resolution through neutrino oscillation, the supernova that let neutrino detectors beat light to the punch, and the giant ice-bound telescope now using neutrinos to study the most violent events in the universe. You'll come away understanding why Pauli proposed neutrinos to rescue energy conservation, why these particles interact with matter so rarely, why detecting them demands enormous underground and under-ice observatories, what the solar neutrino problem was and how neutrino oscillation solved it, what Supernova 1987A revealed, and how IceCube is opening up neutrino astronomy. Talking Science is sponsored by Kinsoft. Visit www.kinsoft.com.au Further reading: CERN - public explainers on neutrinos and the weak force; IceCube Neutrino Observatory - public science pages; Nobel Prize organisation - background on the 2015 physics prize for neutrino oscillation; Scientific American - features on solar neutrinos and Supernova 1987A.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
I want you to do something for me. Wherever you are right now, whether you're sitting at a desk, out for a walk, or just, you know, relaxing on the couch, I want you to hold perfectly still. Yeah, just for one second. It feels like you're doing absolutely nothing. Right. But right now, in that single second you just held still, roughly 100 trillion particles from the sun just passed straight through your body. 100 trillion. Yeah. Every single second. And you didn't feel a single one. I mean, no matter how long you live, you will never, ever feel these particles brushing
past your atoms. It sounds totally like science fiction, honestly. It really does. But looking through the massive stack of research papers and historical notes you sent over for today's deep dive uh this is a hard physical reality it absolutely is so our mission today is to unravel this mystery for you the mystery of these like ghost particles known as neutrinos yeah it's just a phenomenal story We're going to explore how physicists literally predicted this particle just to save a foundational law of nature, how
they finally caught one, the decades -long mystery it created about our own sun, and how it's currently unlocking the deepest secrets of the universe. We are dealing with a piece of the universe that is so profoundly reluctant to interact with anything that it is essentially invisible to normal matter. Which is mind -blowing. But to understand why a ghost particle even needed to exist in the first place, we kind of have to go back to the early 20th century. Right, to a time when the world of physics was in a state of absolute existential
panic. Panic is a good word for it. Oh, it was crisis. The whole thing centered around the conservation of energy, which is, you know, arguably the bedrock principle of physics. Basically the rule that energy can never be created or destroyed. Exactly. It can change forms, like how the chemical energy in a piece of coal turns into thermal energy when you burn it. But it can't be created out of nothing, and it can never just vanish. The cosmic accounting books always have to balance perfectly. Which brings us to Beatty Decay. Precisely. So physicists were studying this specific type
of radioactive decay, which happens when an unstable atomic nucleus spits out an electron and transforms into a slightly different nucleus. Okay. And because they knew the precise mass and energy of the starting nucleus and the exact mass and energy of the resulting nucleus, they could calculate exactly how much energy that escaping electron should be carrying away. It should be a fixed number, right? Right. It should have been one specific predictable amount every single time. But when they actually measured those escaping electrons, the numbers were just a total mess.
They were coming out with a totally random spread of energies. It made no sense. Sometimes the energy was a little lower than expected. Sometimes it was a lot lower. Energy was simply vanishing from the equation. It was completely unaccounted for. It's kind of like if you go to an ATM to withdraw exactly $100. The bank's computer deducts $100 from your account, but the machine spits out like $80 one time. Right, or $92 the next time. Exactly. And another time it gives you
$45. And the bank swears the full $100 left the vault, but it is definitely not in your hands. And no one can figure out where that missing cash went. That kind of accounting failure was so terrifying to physicists at the time that some of the most prominent minds in the field were genuinely prepared to concede that the conservation of energy might just be wrong. Wow. At the subatomic level, they were ready to accept that the universe just casually destroyed energy. Which means throwing out centuries of physics. But rather than accept
that, an Austrian physicist named Wolfgang Pauli wrote a letter in 1930. And he didn't even present this at a formal panel, right? No, not at all. He wrote it half -jokingly to a conference of fellow physicists that he couldn't attend. He famously addressed it to, Dear radioactive ladies and gentlemen. I love that. Pauli proposed a radical desperate guess. He suggested the conservation of energy was perfectly intact and that the missing energy wasn't vanishing at all. Instead, it was being carried away by a brand new unseen particle.
So basically a ghost taking the missing cash from the ATM. Pretty much. He argued this theoretical particle had to have no electric charge, an extremely small mass, and be so incredibly faint and reluctant to interact with matter that it was just slipping past every single detector they had. And he actually felt guilty about this. Oh, incredibly guilty. He stated later that he had done something a good theoretical physicist should never do, predicting a particle that might never be observed. But then Enrico Fermi later built Pauli's idea into
a formal mathematical theory and gave the particle the name we use today. The neutrino. Italian for a little neutral one. But Pauli's guilt over inventing an unseeable particle lasted for, what, 25 years? Because it took that long to actually catch one. Yeah, and the reason a neutrino is so ridiculously elusive comes down to the fundamental forces of nature. Neutrinos only interact with matter through something called the weak nuclear force. And as the name implies, it is extraordinarily feeble. Right. And we can contrast that with the electromagnetic force, which is essentially
the traffic cop of the atomic world. Exactly. Like when you press your hand against a wall, your hand doesn't pass through it because the electromagnetic forces in your hand's atoms are repelling the electromagnetic forces in the wall's atoms. But because neutrinos have absolutely zero electric charge, they are completely immune to that traffic cop. The electromagnetic force doesn't even register them. They don't bounce off atoms. They don't get absorbed like light does. They glide right through the empty space inside atoms. So a single neutrino can pass through
thousands of kilometers of solid rock or fly straight through the entire Earth with only the absolute faintest, most statistically improbable chance of ever bumping into a nucleus. Most of them zip through the planet as if it were entirely hollow. Which is why those hundred trillion solar neutrinos are streaming through your body right now without a trace. Exactly. But wait, let me push back on this for a second. If this thing is completely immune to electromagnetism and can pass right through thousands of miles of solid iron and rock, how on earth could a scientist
in the 1950s possibly build a trap for it? Any cage you build, it would just ghost right through. Well, that was the exact realization of two physicists in 1956, Clyde Cowan and Frederick Raines. They knew finesse wouldn't work, so they engineered a brilliant brute force solution. Just overwhelming numbers. Right. They realized that if the chance of catching one neutrino is vanishingly small, your only option is to play a numbers game on a massive scale. So they built a large tank of water. But they laced it with a very specific
chemical, right? Cadmium chloride. Yeah, the chemistry here is what made the trap work. They designed the setup so that if a neutrino did happen to score a highly improbable direct hit on a proton in the water, it would trigger a very specific reaction. The collision would produce a positron and a neutron. And those two new particles are what they actually looked for. Exactly. The positron would immediately collide with an electron and annihilate, creating a flash of light. And then a fraction of a second later, that free neutron would be absorbed by the cadmium they
added to the water, which would release a second light flash of light. Oh, wow. Yeah, that specific double flash, flash, pause, flash was the unfakable fingerprint of a neutrino collision. But a tank of laced water alone isn't enough because normal background neutrinos are way too rare. So they literally took this entire setup and parked it right next to a nuclear reactor. A nuclear reactor is a massive concentrated source of neutrinos. The fission reactions inside a reactor core pump out absolutely enormous numbers of them every single second. So it's basically a flood. Exactly.
Their reasoning was that by placing their tank in the middle of this staggering flood of neutrinos, eventually, purely by statistical chance, one of them was going to hit a proton. It's the ultimate lottery strategy. I mean, your chances of winning with one ticket are effectively zero. But if you buy 100 trillion tickets every single second, you are guaranteed to get a winning ticket eventually. And it worked. They caught those unmistakable double flashes. They confirmed Pauli's 25 -year -old prediction, which eventually earned Raines a Nobel Prize. Incredible. And more importantly,
this brute force strategy building a huge detector, waiting patiently and relying on overwhelming numbers, became the foundational method for all neutrino physics. So having successfully caught neutrinos from a nuclear reactor on Earth, physicists naturally turn their attention to the biggest, most obvious nuclear reactor in our solar system, which is the sun. Right. Deep inside the sun's core, nuclear fusion is constantly crushing hydrogen atoms together to form helium. This process releases the immense energy that powers our solar system,
and a direct byproduct of that fusion is the neutrino. But the journey of a neutrino out of the sun is fascinating when you compare it to light. It really is. Because the actual photons of sunlight created in the sun's core take what? tens of thousands of years to slowly bounce and diffuse their way out from the unimaginably dense core to the visible surface. Yeah, they have to fight their way out before they finally escape into space. The light warming our faces on a summer day was actually generated inside the sun tens of thousands of years ago. Which is
wild to think about, but neutrinos don't bounce. No, because they are immune to electromagnetism, they don't have to fight their way out through the dense solar plasma. They stream straight out of the core at nearly the speed of light. reach Earth in just eight minutes. Meaning neutrinos give us a real -time, completely uncorrupted window into what is happening in the core of our sun right this very minute. Exactly. And to look through that window, a physicist named Raymond Davis Jr. built a massive detector in the 1960s. He went deep underground into the
Homestake gold mine in South Dakota. Using the miles of rock overhead to shield his experiment from cosmic rays and background radiation. Right. And he filled a huge tank with 100 ,000 gallons of standard dry cleaning fluid. Perclorophthalene. Yes. The chlorine in that fluid was the target. When a solar neutrino occasionally struck a chlorine atom, it would transform it into an atom of radioactive argon. So by counting those argon atoms, Davis could count the neutrinos. But when he ran the numbers, there was a massive discrepancy. Astrophysics
models dictated exactly how many neutrinos the sun's fusion should be producing. But Davis was only finding about one third of that predicted number. Two thirds of the solar neutrinos were simply missing. Two thirds. That's huge. It became known as the solar neutrino problem. And it persisted for decades. At first, you know, many assumed Davis's detector was simply inefficient or just broken. Sure. You blame the equipment first. Exactly. But in the following decades, totally independent experiments came online using different
detection chemicals like gallium, which were sensitive to lower energy neutrinos that Davis's chlorine tank couldn't even see. And those new gallium detectors found the exact same shortfall. Yep. The missing two -thirds were consistently missing across the board. That consistency had to force a very uncomfortable realization on the scientific community. Oh, definitely. Either our entire highly verified model of how the sun works was fundamentally wrong, or... our understanding of this ghost particle was fundamentally wrong. Well, the resolution to this mystery proved that Pauli's ghost particle was far more complex than
he ever imagined. Because it turns out, the neutrino is a shapeshifter. Physicists eventually discovered that there isn't just one type of neutrino. There are actually three distinct types, which the field refers to as flavors. You have the electron neutrino, the muon neutrino, and the tau neutrino and the crucial piece of the puzzle here is that the specific nuclear fusion happening inside the sun only produces one of those flavors the electron neutrino right And Davis' dry -cleaning fluid detector in the gold mine, along with the
gallium detectors that followed, were chemically designed to only react with electron neutrinos. They were completely blind to the muon and tau flavors. Okay, so it's like the sun is standing way over there and it throws an apple at the Earth. I like this analogy, yeah. But while that apple is flying through the vacuum of space, it randomly morphs into a banana, then it morphs into a pear, and then it morphs back into an apple. By the time it hits the Earth, it could be any of the three fruits. But Davis's detector was a net specifically built to only catch apples. That's spot on. The missing two -thirds of the
neutrinos were never actually missing. They had just changed their identity during the eight -minute journey from the sun to the earth. That is just so weird. It's a genuine quantum phenomenon known as neutrino oscillation. As the neutrino travels, its identity isn't fixed. It flips back and forth, governed by quantum wave interference between the different possible states of the particle. Wow. So to prove this was actually happening, we had to build a net capable of catching the bananas and the pears, essentially. And that happened in the early 2000s with the Sudbury
Neutrino Observatory in Canada. Right. They built this detector deep inside a working nickel mine. But instead of cleaning fluid, they filled an enormous acrylic sphere with a thousand tons of heavy water. And just to clarify, normal water has standard hydrogen, just one proton. But heavy water uses an isotope of hydrogen called deuterium, right? which has a proton and a neutron. Exactly. That extra neutron in the heavy water molecule changes everything. It allows the heavy water to be broken apart by a specific type of collision
called a neutral current interaction. that is sensitive to all three flavors of neutrinos, not just the electron flavor. So when they turned the detector on and tallied up the electron, muon, and tau neutrinos together, the books balanced perfectly. They did. The total count matched the original astrophysics predictions for the sun exactly. the sun was working exactly as we thought it was our incomplete understanding of the neutrino causing the deficit yes but proving that neutrinos oscillate carried a massive paradigm
shifting implication for physics because for a particle to oscillate and change flavors as it moves through space Quantum theory dictates that it must experience time, and therefore it must have mass. Which completely shattered the standard model of particle physics, didn't it? Oh, it broke it. Up until that point, the fundamental assumption was that neutrinos were perfectly massless, traveling exactly at the speed of light, just like photons. But finding out they shapeshift proved they have weight. The mass is incredibly tiny, but it's unequivocally not zero. This discovery
actually earned a Nobel Prize in 2015. And finding the precise mass of these three flavors remains one of the most intense active frontiers in particle physics today. And what's amazing is that the necessity of building these giant subterranean vats of weird fluids to catch shape -shifting particles led physicists to construct the most colossal scientific instruments on the planet. Truly colossal. And entirely by accident, these giant underground caverns turned into a brand new way to observe the cosmos. The scale really
is staggering. Consider Japan's Super Kamiokande Observatory. It is buried deep under Mount Aikana to block out cosmic rays, housing a massive cylinder. tank filled with 50 ,000 tons of ultra -pure water. And the walls of that tank are lined with over 11 ,000 individual light sensors, all staring into the pristine pitch -black water, waiting for a single microscopic flash of what is called Cherenkov light. Cherenkov light is a really fascinating physical effect. When a high -speed jet plane travels through the air faster than the speed of sound, it compresses the sound waves
ahead of it, creating a shock wave that we hear as a sonic boom. Right. And light has a universal speed limit in a vacuum. But when light travels through a medium like water, it slows down by what? About 25 percent. Building on that, if a high energy particle like an electron knocked loose by a neutrino collision zips through that tank faster than light can travel through that same water, it creates an optical shockwave. An optical sonic boom. Exactly. Compresses the light waves ahead of it, producing a faint directional flash of blue light. The optical sonic boon is
Cherenkov light. So in February of 1987, those sensors were sitting in the dark, waiting for those blue flashes, when several underground detectors around the world suddenly registered a brief, intense burst of neutrinos. It was a flurry of flashes in the water, far above the normal background rate, all clustered within a span of about 13 seconds. Hours later, astronomers looking through traditional telescopes spotted a sudden, brilliant point of light in a nearby galaxy called the Large Magellanic Cloud. A massive star had collapsed and exploded in an event we
now call Supernova 1987A. Right. But the incredible part is the underground detectors caught the burst of neutrinos hours before the optical telescope saw the flash of light. Which sounds backward, but the mechanics of a dying star perfectly explain this head start, right? Exactly. When the massive core of a star exhausts its fuel, it collapses in on itself, creating unimaginable density. The light generated by that explosive, fiery collapse is entirely trapped by that density. The photons physically have to fight and bounce
their way out through the turbulent outer layers of the dying star. A chaotic process that delays the light by hours. But the neutrinos are born the exact millisecond the core collapses. And because they don't interact with the star's dense outer layers, they just go straight through the explosion instantly. They get a massive head start. They cross 168 ,000 light years of space and hit our underground detectors on Earth. Hours before the light from the explosion finally broke free and arrived at our telescopes. So these giant tanks of water literally function as an
early warning system for a dying star. Yes. This single event birthed the entire field of neutrino astronomy. We were no longer restricted to observing the universe solely through light. We could now look at it through the lens of ghost particles. But to push this new field of astronomy to its absolute limits, physicists realized they needed a detector far larger than any cavern they could possibly excavate. They required a volume of clear material so massive that it could only be found in nature. And they found it in Antarctica.
The Ice Cube Observatory, which is just an absolute engineering marvel. I mean, instead of building a tank, they melted over 80 holes, each one and a half kilometers deep, straight down into the pristine Antarctic ice sheet. It's brilliant. They lowered strings containing thousands of sensitive optical detectors down into those holes before the water refroze. By doing this, they effectively turned a full cubic kilometer of solid ancient ice into a single massive neutrino telescope. A full cubic kilometer of ice looking for that faint blue Cherenkov flash. But with
a detector that massive, how do they differentiate a neutrino flash from random cosmic radiation hitting the ice? The mechanism they use is really clever. Background radiation, like muons created by cosmic rays, rains down from the sky above. But neutrinos can easily travel entirely through the Earth. So the IceCube sensors are programmed to look specifically for flashes of light moving upward through the ice from the bottom to the top. Oh, wow. They use the entire bulk of the planet Earth as a filter to block out the noise from above. Exactly. Coming up from below has to be a neutrino. That is so smart. And using
this setup in 2017, IceCube caught an incredibly high energy neutrino moving through the ice. Because of the vast three -dimensional grid of sensors, they were able to track the exact trajectory of that blue flash and trace the ghost particle back to its origin in deep space. They traced it back to a blazar, which is a supermassive black hole at the center of a distant galaxy that is actively devouring matter and blasting a highly energized relativist. jet of particles out into space. In this specific case, that cosmic
jet was pointed almost directly at Earth. And when IceCube calculated the trajectory, they alerted traditional light -based observatories to point their telescopes at that exact coordinate in the sky. The telescopes observed the blazer actively flaring in gamma rays at the exact same time the neutrino arrived. This established the era of multi -messenger astronomy. For all of human history, we have only been able to study the universe using one messenger. electromagnetic radiation or light. By combining optical telescopes with neutrino detectors, we now have an entirely
new secondary sense to study the most violent, extreme, and previously opaque mechanisms in the cosmos. And the practical applications of mastering this particle aren't just limited to deep space either. Physicists are using this exact same underlying science right here on Earth. Like, remember how Cowan and Raines caught the first neutrino by placing a tank next to a nuclear reactor? Yeah, today, physicists use smaller, highly sensitive neutrino detectors to monitor nuclear reactors remotely because the specific neutrino output of a reactor core directly and
unavoidably correlates with the fission reactor. actions happening inside, it creates a unique, unfakable signature. So you can point a detector at a facility and know exactly what specific nuclear isotopes they are burning inside, which provides an incredibly powerful tool for international security and nuclear non -proliferation. A rogue state cannot shield or hide their neutrino emissions. It's impossible. Furthermore, the planet Earth itself is a massive source of neutrinos. Deep inside the planet's crust and mantle, radioactive elements like uranium and thorium are constantly
undergoing radioactive decay. Producing what geologists call geoneutrinos. Earth ghosts, essentially. Earth ghosts, I like that. By detecting these geoneutrinos streaming up from beneath our feet, geophysicists have a completely novel way to measure exactly how much radioactive decay is happening inside the Earth. This data is crucial for understanding our planet's internal heat budget. Because it helps answer fundamental questions about how much of the Earth's internal heat is left over from its formation versus how much
is actively being generated today to drive volcanoes, plate tectonics, and, you know, the magnetic field that protects our atmosphere. It is a remarkable century -long arc. We started in 1930. with Wolfgang Pauli making an uneasy, desperate guess just to balance a math equation. It took a quarter of a century in a nuclear reactor just to catch one. We spent decades staring at the sun, deeply confused, because the particles were shapeshifting from apples to bananas in flight. Right. And that confusion forced us to rewrite the foundational
rules of particle physics to give them mass. And today, we have turned a cubic kilometer of Antarctic ice into a telescope to watch black holes in other galaxies. while simultaneously using them to x -ray the heat of our own planet's core. It is a staggering legacy for a particle that physicists originally assumed we would never be able to observe. Truly. Which brings us right back to you listening to this. As we've been talking, you've just been sitting there going about your day. But you aren't really sitting
still. You are standing in the middle of a torrential cosmic rainstorm. a hundred trillion invisible messengers are still quietly seamlessly crossing right through you every single second this is ghosting right through it leaves you with a thought i really want you to mull over If we as a species spent all of human history utterly and completely blind to 100 trillion particles passing through our bodies every second, right up until we figured out how to build the exact right tank of water to see a tiny blue flash, what other invisible
realities or forces might be streaming right through you at this very moment, simply waiting for us to invent the right detector to finally see them?
Nanotechnology works at a scale where a nanometre is to a metre what a single centimetre is to the distance across a football field roughly a hundred thousand times over. This episode explains what nanotechnology...
A tagged bar-tailed godwit once flew more than thirteen thousand kilometres from Alaska to Tasmania without landing once. This episode explores why animals migrate at all, from godwits and humpback whales to monarch...
The Sun is an active, magnetic star, and every so often it hurls bursts of radiation and clouds of charged particles toward Earth, a phenomenon called space weather. This episode explains solar flares and coronal mass...
An ordinary wave rolls onto the sand every few seconds; a tsunami can take tens of minutes between crests and cross an entire ocean at the speed of a jet aircraft while barely rippling the surface. This episode explains...
A folded square of paper and a butterfly's wings share the same simple visual idea: a shape that looks the same after some transformation. This episode follows that idea from everyday geometry into the deepest...