Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Talking Science

Talking Science artwork

The Cosmic Distance Ladder – How We Measure the Universe

Oct 18, 202623 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

How do astronomers know a galaxy is two million light years away, or thirteen billion? This episode climbs the cosmic distance ladder rung by rung, from bouncing radar off Venus, to parallax and the Gaia satellite, to pulsating Cepheid stars and exploding white dwarfs, to the redshift of the expanding universe itself - and arrives at a genuine, unresolved disagreement between two ways of measuring the universe's expansion rate. You'll come away understanding how radar and parallax give us rock-solid distances close to home, how Henrietta Leavitt's discovery about Cepheid variable stars unlocked distances across galaxies, why Type Ia supernovae work as standard candles reaching billions of light years, how each rung of the ladder is calibrated against the one below it, and what the Hubble tension is, and why it remains one of the open questions in cosmology today. Talking Science is sponsored by Kinsoft. Visit www.kinsoft.com.au Further reading: NASA - "Hubble Constant" and distance ladder explainers; ESA - Gaia mission science pages; Nature - reporting on the Hubble tension; Scientific American - features on standard candles and the expanding universe.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

So picture yourself for a second standing right on the edge of a wide, just incredibly deep river gorge. Okay, I'm picturing it. And you're looking out and there is this specific tree on the far bank. You really want to know exactly how far away that tree is. Right. But there's a massive problem. You can't just walk across and pace it out, right? And you can't, like, stretch a tape measure over open air and 100 meters of rushing water? Obviously not. You are completely stuck on your side of the cliff. Welcome to our

deep dive for today, by the way. I'm your host, and today we're looking at an article about how human beings actually measure the vastness of the universe. And I'm your resident astronomy expert. Yeah, that feeling of being stuck on one side of an uncrossable gap. That is the exact position humanity is in every single time we look up at the night sky. Because we want to know how big the universe is. Exactly. We want to know how far away things are. But we are permanently stranded on Earth. We just we can't stretch a tape measure to the stars. But if you know just

a little bit of geometry, you don't actually need to cross that gorge. You can just walk a short measured distance along your own side of the cliff. Right, which we would call a baseline. Right. So you measure the angle to the tree from the start of your walk. Then you walk, say, 10 paces. And you measure the angle to the tree from the end of your walk. Suddenly you have a triangle. And simple trigonometry hands you the distance across the water. No crossing required. It's so cool. It really is. And that simple geometric trick, using a known baseline and a couple of

angles to find a distance you can't measure directly, that is the seed of one of the greatest achievements in modern astronomy. Which is what they call the cosmic distance ladder, right? Yeah, exactly. It's the exact system astronomers use to figure out the distance to almost everything in the cosmos. From, you know... our own moon out to galaxies so ancient their light has been traveling toward us since before the earth even formed wow okay let's unpack this because climbing that ladder is basically our mission for this deep dive if you want to understand how we measure

the universe without prior astronomy knowledge you really have to understand this ladder and it really is a ladder Because no single measurement method works at every scale of the universe. You literally have to climb rung by rung. Right. Each new technique you use is calibrated against the one right below it, which lets you reach further and further out. Exactly. I mean, if everything relies on the step below it, we have a chicken and egg problem. To measure the tree across the gorge, I had to walk 10 paces. I had to, like, establish a physical baseline. If we

are stuck on Earth... How do we get that very first baseline to start measuring space? Well, we just bounce a signal off our neighbors. Wait, really? Yeah. The absolute bottom run of the ladder doesn't rely on starlight at all. It relies on radar. Oh, like air traffic control. Exactly like that. We use the exact same basic mechanism, but astronomers aim it at solid planets within our solar system. You send out a burst of radio waves into space toward Venus or Mars, and you just wait for the echo to return to Earth. So

we are just timing the echo. Yep, because we know how fast radio waves travel. They travel at the speed of light, which is a fixed universal constant. It never changes. Okay, so if I send a radio burst to Venus and it takes exactly, say, four minutes for the echo to hit my receiver, I can just do the simple math to figure out the total distance of that round trip. Right. And because these measurements are direct and physical, they give us these rock solid distances within our own solar system. Like we can measure the distance to Venus down to a matter of meters. That's insane. Down to meters. Yeah. But if we

connect this to the bigger picture, the real power of this radar trick isn't just knowing where Venus is. If we map out the distances to the other planets, we can use the laws of gravity to perfectly calculate the exact size of the Earth's orbit around the sun. OK, I see. So we use. the radar to figure out the distance from the earth to the sun and i know there's a technical term for that right yeah that specific distance is called an astronomical unit you got it And so that single number, that astronomical unit, that becomes the baseline for the next rung up

on our ladder. Yes. We use the entire Earth's orbit to recreate your trick at the River Gorge. Which brings to mind a trick a lot of us played with as kids. Oh, the finger trick. Yeah, the finger trick. If you're listening, you can do this right now. If you hold your finger up right in front of your face and you close one eye. and then open and close the other eye, your finger seems to jump left and right against the background of the room. It's a great analogy. And the closer your figure is to your face, the bigger that apparent jump is. Right. And astronomers call that apparent shift parallax. It happens anytime

you view the same object from two slightly different positions. For your finger, the two positions are your left eye and your right eye. And for a star. For a star, astronomers use the Earth's orbit. they look at a nearby star in january then they wait six months until july by july the earth has traveled hundreds of millions of kilometers to the complete opposite side of the sun so january is one eye and july is the other eye exactly and the background of the room is the field of much more distant essentially fixed

stars when they look at the target star again in july it appears to have shifted slightly against that background. Wow. And because the radar measurements gave us the exact diameter of the Earth's orbit, we know the exact length of our baseline. We measure the angle of the star's shift, and geometry hands us the distance to the star. It's incredibly elegant. Because you don't need to know anything about the star itself. You don't need to know how bright it is or how hot it is. It's just pure math. It's just triangles, yeah. But stepping back for a sec, when you look at the sheer scale

of what they're trying to measure, it seems kind of impossible. The shift they're looking for isn't like a finger jumping across a wall. It is staggeringly small. It is very, very small. The source mentions we are talking about a fraction of an arc second. To put that into human terms for you listening. Observing that shift is roughly equivalent to trying to measure the width of a single human hair viewed from several kilometers away. Yeah, it's wild to think about. Trying to do that from the surface of the Earth, looking up through our blurry, turbulent atmosphere, it seems like a nightmare. And it was, was a

massive limiting factor for a long time. The atmosphere constantly distorts the light, which meant we could only use parallax for a few thousand of the very closest stars. To get past the blur, you have to leave the atmosphere. So in 2013, the European Space Agency launched a space observatory called Gaia. Oh, I've heard of Gaia. Yeah. By operating in the vacuum of space, Gaia has been able to precisely map the positions and parallax shifts of well over a billion stars. It pushed reliable geometric measurements out from a tiny

local bubble to distances of many thousands of light years. A billion stars. That is just, I mean, that's incredible. But even with Gaia. In space, there has to be a physical limit to this, right? Yeah. The universe is massive. Yeah, there absolutely is a limit. Because if a star is millions of light years away, the angle of that shift eventually becomes so infinitesimally small that no telescope could ever measure it. The geometry math just breaks down. We need a new rung. We do. When geometry runs out, we have

to start judging distance by brightness. Which means we run into the campfire problem. The campfire problem, exactly. Imagine you are standing in a dark field at night and you see a light in the distance. How do you know if you are looking at a massive bonfire 10 miles away or like a tiny matchstick just one mile away? You don't. Right, they might look exactly the same brightness to your naked eye. In astronomy, the solution to that campfire problem is finding what we call a standard candle. A standard candle, okay. Yeah, the whole trick of a standard candle is finding

an object in space where we somehow already know its true intrinsic brightness. If we know exactly how many watts of light a star is pumping out and we measure how dim it appears from Earth, the laws of physics tell us exactly how far that light had to travel to fade by that amount. I see. But getting that intrinsic brightness is the hard part, isn't it? We can't just fly out to a star to check its wattage. How do we know the true brightness of a star we've never been to? Well, the breakthrough came from a rather unassuming type of star known as a Cepheid variable.

It's named after the constellation Cepheus, where an early one was spotted. Okay, a Cepheid variable. What does it do? A Cepheid isn't a static star like our Sun. It rhythmically brightens and dims over a period of days or weeks. It is literally pulsating. Its outer layers physically expand and contract. Oh, wow. So it's basically a giant. cosmic blinking light. Pretty much. And the way we cracked the code on these blinking lights goes back to an astronomer named Henrietta Leavitt at the Harvard College Observatory in the early 20th century. Right. She was studying photographs

of thousands of these pulsating cepheid stars in a specific cluster called the Small Magellanic Cloud. And her choice to study that specific cloud, that is the brilliant part. And unlocked everything. Because the small Magellanic cloud is a dwarf galaxy orbiting our own. So since all the stars Leavitt was studying were packed together in that one distinct cloud, she could safely assume they were all roughly the exact same distance from Earth. Oh. Which isolates the variable. Oh, exactly. If she sees two blinking

stars in that cloud and one looks brighter than the other, she knows it isn't because it's closer to Earth. It has to be genuinely intrinsically brighter. Right, and she realized the rhythm tells you the brightness. She discovered a mathematically consistent rule called the period -luminosity relationship. Basically, the longer a cepheid takes to pulsate, The slower its blinking rhythm, the more intrinsically luminous the star actually is. So a slow blink means a massive bright star. A fast blink means a smaller, dimmer star. That

is such an elegant key to the universe. It's beautiful physics. But how do we put it on the ladder? Like, we know the rule now, but we still need a hard distance to calibrate it. We use the rung below. Astronomers looked for cepheid variables that were close enough to Earth that we could measure their distance using the parallax geometry we just talked about. The parallax gave us the exact distance. Knowing the exact distance allowed us to calculate the exact intrinsic brightness of those nearby cepheids. And that calibrated Henrietta Leavitt's rule. Wow. And once it's

calibrated, parallax doesn't matter anymore. Not at all. We can look deep into space, find a completely new cepheid. Time its blink, use leave its math to find its true brightness and just calculate the distance. And this was the exact tool Edwin Hubble used in the 1920s to change our entire understanding of reality. It really was. Because before Hubble, people saw these fuzzy patches of light in the night sky and assumed they were just gas clouds inside the Milky Way. They thought the Milky Way was the entire universe. Which is funny to think about now. Right. But Hubble found cepheids inside

those fuzzy patches, timed their blanks, and realized those patches were entirely separate galaxies, located millions of light years away. The universe got unimaginably bigger overnight. It was a profound paradigm shift. But just like with parallax, Cepheids eventually hit a wall. As we try to measure galaxies billions of light years away, individual pulsating stars just fade from view. Too far away to see the blink. Exactly. Even our best telescopes can't pick out a single Cepheid in a galaxy halfway across the observable

universe. So we need a brighter candle. We need an explosion. Yes, we do. Which brings us to the next rung on the ladder. A specific kind of stellar detonation called a Type Ia supernova. Right. And these are some of the most violent events in the cosmos. A Type Ia supernova starts with a white dwarf. Okay, remind me what a white dwarf is. A white dwarf is essentially the dense, compact corpse of a star that was once similar to our sun. Imagine this dense white dwarf is locked in a tight orbit with a normal living companion star. Because the white dwarf has such

intense gravity, it starts siphoning gas off its companion. Oh man, so it acts like a cosmic vampire just constantly feeding off the other star? That's a good way to picture it. But it can't just gorge itself forever, right? A star's core can only support so much weight. before gravity crushes it exactly there is a very specific physical threshold as the white dwarf pulls more and more gas onto itself its mass increases eventually it approaches a critical mass limit and then what the moment it hits that exact threshold

the core can no longer support its own weight The white dwarf collapses inward, triggering a runaway thermonuclear explosion. The entire star detonates. The whole thing. And because that detonation is triggered at the exact same mass limit every single time, the resulting explosion is almost exactly the same size every single time. Right. The physics dictate that the bomb always has the exact same yield. It creates a thermonuclear flashbulb so bright it can briefly outshine an entire galaxy of 100 billion stars. And because they are phenomenally bright and

incredibly consistent, Type Ia supernovae are the ultimate standard candles. We can spot them in galaxies billions of light years away, far beyond the reach of any individual cepheid star. But wait, so what does this all mean for the latter? Every rung has to connect. We know the supernova explodes at a specific mass, but we don't automatically know its exact brightness in watts. True. We have to calibrate the flashbulb. which means we have to wait for a type E supernova to go off in a galaxy that is close enough to

us that we can also measure the Cepheid variables in that same galaxy. And that is the defining vulnerability of the entire cosmic distance ladder. The supernovae are calibrated by the Cepheids. The Cepheids are calibrated by parallax. Parallax is calibrated by radar. Nothing stands alone. It's a house of cards. Basically. If we made a tiny math error decades ago calculating the distance to Venus with radar, that error propagates up. It corrupts the parallax, which corrupts the cepheids, which means our entire map of the deep universe is wrong. Tell me cosmologists

don't just rely on this one single fragile ladder. Oh, they don't. That house of cards scenario keeps scientists away at night. I bet. So they build independent backup methods to cross -check the wrongs. For instance, there is a principle called the Tully -Fisher relation. What's that? This rule links how fast an entire spiral galaxy is spinning to how intrinsically bright the whole galaxy is. If you can measure the rotation speed, you can estimate the galaxy's brightness and therefore its distance without needing to isolate individual stars at all. Okay, that makes me

feel better. And there is another backup called the tip of the red giant branch. The tip of the red giant branch? Yeah. This looks at populations of aging stars. Right before an old star undergoes a specific internal change in how it burns helium, it hits a very sharp, predictable peak in brightness. That peak acts as an alternative standard candle. Ah, I see. Because these backup rungs generally agree with the suffades and the supernovae, astronomers have a high degree of confidence that the latter is fundamentally sound. That's reassuring. So

we have our ladder. We can measure out to the deepest reaches of space. But what if we want to measure the expansion of the space itself? Then we need a new trick. Right. And to do that, we have to look at how light behaves when an object is moving away from us. If you are standing on a sidewalk and an ambulance speeds past you, the pitch of the siren Sounds higher as it approaches and then visibly drops to a lower pitch as it speeds away. The Doppler effect. Yeah, the Doppler effect. The sound waves get stretched out as the vehicle recedes. And light does the exact

same thing. When a galaxy is moving away from us, the light waves it emits get stretched out. In the visible spectrum of light, longer wavelengths look red. Okay. So as the light stretches, its color shifts toward the red end of the spectrum. Astronomers call this redshift. Redshift. And in the 1920s, Edwin Hubble. the same guy who used cepheids to discover other galaxies, he started measuring the redshift of those galaxies. He was a busy guy. Seriously. He compared how far away a galaxy was to how stretched out its light was, and he found a direct link. He discovered

what we now call Hubble's Law. The further away a galaxy is from us, the faster it is receding. To visualize why this is happening, imagine taking a deflated balloon and drawing a bunch of dots all over it with a marker. Each dot represents a galaxy. Now start blowing up the balloon. As the rubber expands, every single dot gets further away from every other dot. The dots aren't actively crawling across the surface. The rubber itself is stretching, carrying the dots with it. That

is what space is doing. It is expanding in all directions. And because Hubble's law ties distance directly to redshift, it becomes a powerful tool. If you can measure how stretched out a galaxy's light is, you instantly know how fast it is moving and roughly how far away it is. Which sets up one of the biggest plot twists in modern physics. Oh, yeah, this is a big one. In the late 1990s, teams of astronomers were using our ultimate standard candles, the type Ia supernovae, to measure distances to very remote galaxies. But

the data came back weird. The distant supernovae were noticeably dimmer than they should have been. And everyone at the time assumed the expansion of the universe was either coasting at a steady speed or gradually slowing down due to the inward pull of gravity. But the math didn't lie. The supernovae were dimmer. But if they're dimmer than expected, it means they're further away than expected. Yes. What's fascinating here is the only way the math works is if the expansion of the universe isn't slowing down. It is actively accelerating. Space is stretching faster and

faster every single day. It's like throwing a baseball up into the air. And instead of slowing down and falling back to Earth, it suddenly rockets upward into the sky. It defies gravity. Exactly. This discovery proved there must be a mysterious force driving this acceleration, a force we now call dark energy. And the astronomers who figured this out won a Nobel Prize, all because they trusted the upper rungs of the distance ladder enough to spot a discrepancy. And that brings us to the ultimate prize in cosmology, the Hubble Constant. The Hubble Constant. OK. Yeah, this

is a specific number that represents the exact rate at which the universe is expanding today. If we can pin down the precise value of the Hubble constant, we can run the clock backwards to calculate the exact age of the universe. Oh, wow. And we can run the clock forwards to predict its ultimate fate. Okay, here's where it gets really interesting. This is the great mystery we promised at the start of this deep dive. We currently have two independent ways to measure the Hubble constant. And they refuse to agree. They stubbornly refuse.

And this conflict has been tearing at the astrophysics community for a decade. Let's look at the two methods. First, you have the local or late universe method. Right, which is everything we just talked about. Building the ladder from the ground up. Radar, parallax, cepheid, supernovae. Exactly. Measuring the redshift of galaxies directly around us. Teams have refined this ladder to a razor sharp edge. And then you have the second method. The top -down early universe approach. This method completely ignores the latter. Instead, it looks at the cosmic microwave background. What is that

exactly? When the universe was born in the Big Bang, it was incredibly hot and dense. About 380 ,000 years later, it cooled just enough for the first atoms to form, and light was finally able to travel freely through space. So it's the literal afterglow of the Big Bang, the oldest light in existence. Yes. We use space satellites like ESA's Planck satellite to map the tiny microscopic temperature variations in that ancient radiation. By looking at the physics of that baby universe, scientists can plug that data into our standard

model of cosmic evolution, mathematically run the clock forward 13 .8 billion years, and predict exactly what the Hubble constant should be today. Okay, so we have a bottom -up measurement using exploding stars today and a top -down measurement calculating forward from the oldest light. in existence. Both methods have been checked, double checked and triple checked by the smartest people on Earth. They have. But when you compare the final numbers, they don't match. They disagree by about 10 percent. Ten percent. Yeah. And in the world of precision cosmology, a 10 percent

gap is a massive, statistically significant chasm. It is well outside the margin of error for either team. This discrepancy is known as the Hubble tension. The Hubble tension. So who messed up? There has to be a math hair somewhere, right? Maybe a smudge on a telescope lens or like a flaw in how we calibrate the cepheid variables. I mean, it could be. A lot of scientists are desperately hunting for a hidden human error or systematic bias in the instruments. But there is another alternative, and it is what cosmologists

are taking very seriously right now. What if nobody messed up? Right. What if both measurements are perfectly correct? The bottom -up ladder is accurately measuring the universe today. The top -down calculation is accurately measuring the baby universe. Okay, but if both are true, it means our standard model of the universe is broken. It means we are missing a completely new piece of physics. There is a hidden ingredient out there, perhaps something we don't understand about how dark energy behaves over time, that we haven't discovered yet. Man, that is wild.

So to bring this all together for you listening, we started this journey... just trying to figure out how to measure a tree across a river gorge. And look where we ended up. Right. We built a ladder of geometry and pulsating stars and exploding white dwarfs, and we ended up standing at the absolute edge of known physics. From bouncing radar off Venus to mapping the oldest light in existence, the cosmic distance ladder is the ultimate detective story. It really is a living, breathing mystery. And this Hubble tension isn't

a failure of science. It's a thrilling reminder that the universe still has massive fundamental secrets waiting to be uncovered in the dark. The book of physics is far from finished. It really is far from finished. And I want to leave you with one final thought to mull over today, building on that massive cliffhanger. If both of these measurements, the baby universe and the modern universe, are completely accurate, what if the hidden ingredient we are missing is that the fundamental laws of physics themselves have actually changed over the last 13 billion years? Ooh, I love that. What if the universe's

measuring stick is actively evolving along with the universe itself? It definitely makes you look at that rushing river gorge in a whole new light.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Nanotechnology – Building at the Scale of Atoms

    Nov 19, 202626 minAudio

    Nanotechnology works at a scale where a nanometre is to a metre what a single centimetre is to the distance across a football field roughly a hundred thousand times over. This episode explains what nanotechnology...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Animal Migration – Navigation Without Maps

    Nov 17, 202625 minAudio

    A tagged bar-tailed godwit once flew more than thirteen thousand kilometres from Alaska to Tasmania without landing once. This episode explores why animals migrate at all, from godwits and humpback whales to monarch...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Space Weather – When the Sun Attacks Our Technology

    Nov 15, 202625 minAudio

    The Sun is an active, magnetic star, and every so often it hurls bursts of radiation and clouds of charged particles toward Earth, a phenomenon called space weather. This episode explains solar flares and coronal mass...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Tsunamis – Waves That Cross Oceans

    Nov 12, 202623 minAudio

    An ordinary wave rolls onto the sand every few seconds; a tsunami can take tens of minutes between crests and cross an entire ocean at the speed of a jet aircraft while barely rippling the surface. This episode explains...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Symmetry – Physics' Deepest Idea

    Nov 10, 202620 minAudio

    A folded square of paper and a butterfly's wings share the same simple visual idea: a shape that looks the same after some transformation. This episode follows that idea from everyday geometry into the deepest...

    Credit the people on this episode