Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Talking Science

Talking Science artwork

Crystals – Order Inside Solids

Aug 18, 202624 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Tip a little table salt onto a dark plate and look closely, with a magnifying glass if you have one, and you'll find that every single grain is a tiny, near-perfect cube, formed with no human hand shaping it at all. This episode explores why solids sometimes arrange themselves this precisely, what a crystal lattice actually is, how crystals grow from solution and from molten rock, how shining X-rays through a crystal revealed the structure of DNA itself, why a thin slice of quartz can keep remarkably accurate time, why every snowflake is six-sided yet genuinely unique, and why "crystal healing" has no scientific basis at all. You'll come away understanding what makes a crystal different from an ordinary solid, why crystals grow with flat faces and sharp angles, how crystals form from solution and from cooling melts, how X-ray crystallography works and what it revealed about the structure of DNA, what piezoelectricity is and how it's used in quartz watches, why snowflakes are six-sided but never identical, and why claims about crystal healing don't hold up against basic scientific scrutiny. Talking Science is sponsored by Kinsoft. Visit www.kinsoft.com.au Further reading: Royal Institution of Australia (Cosmos) and Royal Society of Chemistry - explainers on crystal structure and crystallography; Nobel Prize organisation - background on the discovery of DNA's structure and the contribution of X-ray diffraction; Scientific American - features on piezoelectricity and snowflake formation; CSIRO - public science resources on minerals and materials science.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

If you look closely enough at the salt on your kitchen table, you'll actually see these millions of perfectly carved microscopic cubes. Yeah, it's pretty wide. Right, like they have these totally flat faces and possibly sharp right angles, and they basically look like they were, you know, painstakingly chiseled by some microscopic sculptor. But no one carved them. I mean, they built themselves. Exactly. And so today we're doing a deep dive into how this invisible habit... of atoms arranging

themselves into perfect geometry is basically the secret engine behind everything. Right. From the watch on your wrist to the microchip in your phone to, well, the very shape of your DNA. Yeah. And for you listening, I mean, the device you're using right now relies on this exact principle. It's entirely about atomic preferences. You know, sodium and chlorine atoms, the ingredients in table salt, they just naturally settle into that cubic shape when they get the chance. And understanding why they do that. That unlocks the whole scientific definition of what a crystal actually is. Yeah, exactly. Because I think that's where we need

to start. For you listening, you hear the word crystal and you probably picture, I don't know, shiny rocks in a museum or like a fancy chandelier. Right. Something sparkly. Yeah. But in chemistry and physics, we aren't just talking about something sparkly. Not at all. I mean, a crystal is a highly specific state of matter. To a material scientist, it's any solid where the atoms or molecules are arranged in this deeply orderly, repeating, three -dimensional pattern. And that pattern has a name, right? Yeah, it's called a crystal lattice.

And in a perfect crystal, that lattice just extends indefinitely in every single direction. The analogy that really helps me picture this is invisible scaffolding. Oh, yeah. That's a good way to look at it. Like you have this one fundamental building block, this specific arrangement of particles, the unit cell, I think it's called. Exactly. The unit cell. And a crystal is just that one unit cell stacked identically over and over millions of times. Yeah. But how does that differ from just any hard object? Like if I pick up a glass

marble, that's solid, but is it a crystal? It is a solid, yeah, but it is not a crystal. Glass is what we call an amorphous solid. Amorphous meaning? Basically meaning the atoms are frozen in place, so the object holds its physical shape, but internally those atoms are entirely jumbled. Oh, wow, okay. Yeah, there's absolutely no long -range repeating pattern in glass. So if a crystal is like a perfectly constructed brick wall where every single brick is aligned, an amorphous solid is just a... a disorganized pile of those exact

same bricks that someone just glued together. And that perfectly captures it. Yeah. Both are solid walls. But only one has that deep internal geometry. Right. And that internal geometry brings us back to those salt cubes. When a crystal is forming, atoms are arriving from the surrounding environment, right? Okay. And as they arrive, they don't just stick randomly. They naturally migrate to the positions on the surface that fit the most snugly. Which is the most stable, lowest energy position. Exactly. They are constantly seeking that lowest possible energy state. I was reading through the sources for this deep

dive and I was picturing like a crate of oranges at the grocery store. I'm not sure. When you stack oranges, they don't sit in a random heap. They naturally settle into the little grooves between the oranges beneath them because, well, that's the most stable arrangement. Right. And atoms operate under the exact same physical laws. And because this settling happens uniformly in every direction as the material grows, the external shape you see is just a massive magnified reflection of that internal atomic arrangement. So salt forms cubes because the sodium and chlorine pack

into a cubic lattice. Yep. And quartz forms those hexagonal prisms because its silicon and oxygen atoms pack into a six -sided lattice. The flat faces aren't just decorative, you know. They are microscopic geometry magnified up to the human scale. That is just, it's wild to think about. But how did the atoms actually pull this off out in the wild? Like, if I'm out hiking and I find a huge chunk of quartz, how did those atoms organize themselves into that perfect scaffolding? Well, there are two primary environments where

this happens naturally. The first is growth from a solution. Okay. Meaning a solid material is dissolved into a liquid, usually water. And as conditions change, like maybe the water cools down or evaporates. The liquid can't hold all that dissolved stuff anymore. Exactly. It reaches a state called supersaturation. The water is basically holding more material than it comfortably can. Right. So the atoms of the dissolved substance are essentially... Forced out of the liquid. But they don't just form a cloudy sludge. If

they have a surface to attach to, they deposit themselves atom by atom, slipping right into that lowest energy lattice arrangement. Like making rock candy on a string. Exactly like rock candy. And it's also how massive natural minerals form in caves, you know, with mineral -rich groundwater seeping through over thousands of years. That makes sense for caves, yeah. But what about crystals in solid rock? Because there isn't exactly water flowing through the middle of a granite boulder. Right. So for that, we look to the second method, which is growth from a melt. A melt. Yeah. Crystallizing

directly out of a cooling liquid with absolutely no water or solvent involved. This is how the vast majority of the Earth's crust formed from molten magma. Wait. So when the rock is molten, all the atoms are just sort of buzzing around chaotically. Yeah. Immense heat means high kinetic energy. The atoms are moving way too fast to bond to each other. other okay but as the magma cools they lose that kinetic energy they slow down and eventually the attractive forces overpower their movement and they start locking into their preferred geometric lattice and the notes mention

that the speed of this cooling process dictates everything right everything it's the most important factor if magma is trapped miles underground insulated by the earth it might take tens of thousands of years to cool Wow yeah and that gives the atoms an incredible amount of time to migrate through the thick liquid and lock into massive visible crystals. Oh, so that's what you see when you look at like a granite countertop. Yeah. Those large distinct speckles are individual crystals that just had a ton of time to grow. Precisely. Now contrast that with

lava erupting out of a volcano and hitting the cold ocean. Right. The temperature would just plummet. Instantly. Instantly. The atoms are rapidly drained of their kinetic energy while they're still disorganized. The fluid becomes super viscous so fast that the atoms literally cannot travel to their proper lattice positions before the whole thing freezes solid. So what do you get then? You end up with microscopic crystals, or if the cooling is violent enough, you get obsidian, which is volcanic glass. Oh, which goes back to what we said earlier. Glass

is an amorphous solid. Exactly. Obsidian has absolutely zero organized lattice structure because the atoms were just frozen mid -chaos. That is fascinating. Yeah. But it makes me wonder, you know, if these atomic lattices are forming deep underground or at a microscopic scale in water, how did we ever figure out what the actual geometry looks like? Yeah, that's a great question. Because we obviously can't put an atom under a regular microscope. No, we definitely can't see them with visible light. But we can map them using a technique called X -ray crystallography. X

-ray crystallography. Right. And the physics behind it is just incredibly elegant. X -rays are electromagnetic waves, just like visible light, but their wavelengths are vastly smaller. Okay. And it just so happens that the wavelength of an X -ray perfectly matches the physical distance between the atoms in a crystal lattice. Wait, really? So the size of the wave literally matches the size of the gaps in the scaffolding? Yes. So when you fire a concentrated beam of X -rays through a crystal, the waves crash into that

repeating grid of atoms. And instead of passing straight through, the waves scatter. Right. They bounce off. Exactly. And because the atoms are spaced perfectly evenly, those scattered X -ray waves interact with one another. In some directions, the peaks of the waves line up and amplify each other. And in other directions, they cancel each other out. It's kind of like ocean waves rolling into a harbor and bouncing off a series of... evenly spaced concrete pillars. You get this complex overlapping pattern of ripples. That is a perfect analogy. That phenomenon is called

diffraction. By placing a detector behind the crystal, scientists capture that interference pattern, which basically looks like a specific arrangement of dark spots. And those spots are like a mathematical fingerprint, right? Exactly. Using a complex mathematical tool, a Fourier transform researchers can essentially run the diffraction process in reverse on a computer. They decode the pattern of spots to map the exact 3D coordinates of every single atom. Which directly leads to one of the most famous moments in all

of scientific history. Absolutely. Because in the early 1950s, this incredibly brilliant researcher named Rosalind Franklin was working at King's College London. And she used this exact x -ray technique on biological molecules. Yeah. She was a true master of x -ray crystallography. She applied it to fibers of DNA. And the resulting image, known as Photo 51, showed a very distinct cross -shaped pattern of diffraction spots. And from the sources to anyone who knows. who knew how to read the math of that spot pattern at cross -shaped screamed one specific geometry.

A helix. The spacing and the angles of those spots provided the exact mathematical dimensions of the turn of the spiral. And that image, along with other critical data from Franklin and her colleague Maurice Wilkins, made its way to James Watson and Francis Crick at Cambridge. It was literally the missing piece they needed to physically build their model of the DNA double helix in 1953. It showed the world exactly how genetic information is stored and copied. Yeah, and while Watson, Crick, and Wilkins won the Nobel Prize in 1962, and I should mention the prize isn't

awarded posthumously, and Franklin died in 1958, her X -ray diffraction work is universally celebrated today as the key that unlocked the code of life. And that legacy continues today. Structural biologists use X -ray crystallography constantly. Really? Like right now? Oh, yeah. They take massive, complex proteins from human cells or viruses, coax them into forming artificial crystals in a lab, and hit them with x -rays to map their atomic structure. Which, for you listening, is absolutely vital for anyone designing medicines

today. Because modern drug design isn't just mixing chemicals together in a beaker. No, it's an engineering problem. Right. You have a target protein causing a disease, and you need to design a drug molecule that physically binds to it. It's almost like a spacecraft trying to dock with a space station. Yes. If you don't know the exact shape and angle of the docking bay, your spacecraft is just going to bounce right off. Yeah. So X -ray crystallography gives drug designers the architectural blueprints of the docking bay. It replaces guesswork with physical

geometry. Yeah. We map the invisible lattice so we can engineer molecules that interact with it perfectly. Okay, wait. I have to ask about something that seems like a glaring contradiction here. Sure. What is it? If X -rays show us that these lattices are perfectly uniform, identical, repeating structures, why aren't all crystals totally transparent, like glass or a diamond? I mean, where do the brilliant, deep colors of gemstones come from if the scaffolding is so perfect? It comes down to something we call trace impurities. Impurities. Yeah. In a textbook,

a crystal lattice is utterly pure. For example, pure aluminum oxide is a mineral called corundum. If you have a flawless lattice of nothing but aluminum and oxygen atoms, the crystal is completely colorless and transparent. Okay. But in nature, crystals do not grow in sterile laboratories. They grow in messy, complex geological stews. Right. So there are just other random elements floating around while the scaffolding is being built. Yes. And occasionally, a stray atom of a different element that happens to be roughly

the same size as an aluminum atom will accidentally lock into the lattice, taking aluminum's place. It just sneaks in. Yep. And the lattice simply continues building around it. So if a few stray chromium atoms slip into a corundum crystal, they actually alter the way the crystal absorbs and reflects incoming visible light. I saw this in the notes and it genuinely blew my mind. The chromium absorbs certain wavelengths of light. and reflects others, turning that completely clear crystal into a deep, vivid red ruby. Exactly.

And if instead of chromium, you have stray atoms of iron and titanium slipping into the lattice, that same corundum crystal reflects light differently. And you get a blue sapphire. You get a sapphire. So a ruby and a sapphire are literally the exact same rock. They really are. They're both just aluminum oxide corundum. The only difference is... Which microscopic impurity happened to photobomb the scaffolding while it was cooling? The underlying architecture is identical. And the same is true for the purple gemstone amethyst. It's just ordinary quartz, silicon, and oxygen.

But with an impurity. Right. Trace amounts of iron slip into the lattice, and the natural background radiation from the surrounding rocks alters the electrical charge of those iron atoms. It doesn't change the shape of the crystal, but it changes its interaction with light, giving us that brilliant purple. So a few rogue atoms give us the crown jewels. That is so cool. But what about the geometry itself? Does the physical shape of the lattice actually do anything besides just looking pretty? Oh, absolutely. This brings us to a phenomenon called piezoelectricity, and quartz is the star

player here. P is electricity. Okay. Yeah. We know quartz has a specific repeating geometry, but that geometry has a quirk. It lacks a center of symmetry. What does it actually mean for the atoms, though? It means the arrangement of the positively charged silicon atoms and negatively charged oxygen atoms is slightly asymmetrical. Under normal conditions, everything is balanced out. But if you take a quartz crystal and physically squeeze it. You deform the perfectly balanced lattice. Exactly. You physically push the atoms

closer together. And because of that asymmetry, squeezing it forces the positively charged atoms slightly toward one side of the crystal and the negatively charged atoms toward the other. Wow. You literally create a temporary positive and negative pole, just like a battery. You generate a measurable electrical voltage. voltage simply by applying physical pressure to the rock. Squeeze a crystal, get electricity. I mean, that feels like magic. But the notes say this works in reverse too, which is almost even weirder. Oh, the reverse piezoelectric effect is what runs our modern

world. If you apply an electrical voltage to a quartz crystal, those asymmetrical positive and negative atoms react to the electricity and the lattice physically flexes and distorts. So you shock it? And it twitches. Basically, yeah. And if you cut that piece of quartz to incredibly precise physical dimensions and apply a steady electrical current, the crystal will flex and snap back, vibrating at an extraordinarily stable, predictable frequency. Which is exactly what is happening inside a quartz watch. Exactly. Like there is a tiny piece of quartz shaped like

a tuning fork and a small battery sends electricity into it. That specific piece of quartz vibrates exactly 32 ,760. times every single second. It's remarkably precise. A microchip counts those microscopic physical vibrations, and when it hits that number, it takes the second hand forward. It's infinitely more precise than the old mechanical gears. You're wearing a vibrating rock on your wrist to tell time. And piezoelectric crystals are also the spark mechanism in push -button lighters, the sensors in electric guitars, and

they even generate and detect the high -frequency sound waves in medical ultrasound machines. It's everywhere. But if we're talking about crystals running the modern world, we definitely have to talk about silicon. Because the microchip running the laptop or the phone you're listening to this on is made of silicon. But it's not just... like a chunk of silicon dug out of the ground. No, it has to be a single, flawless, continuous crystal. You see, in most rocks or metals, you actually have millions of tiny microscopic crystals

all mashed together at different angles. Okay. The borders between those differently angled regions are called grain boundaries. And why are grain boundaries a problem for a computer chip? Because a computer chip works by directing the flow of electrons through microscopic pathways. and the atomic lattice, it acts like a massive speed bump or a roadblock for electrons. Oh, I see. To make a functioning processor, Chipmakers need an absolutely smooth, uninterrupted electrical highway. They need silicon where the exact same

lattice orientation runs unbroken from one edge of a massive wafer to the other. So how on earth do you force billions of atoms to perfectly align without a single mistake? Through an astonishing feat of engineering called the Tchaikovsky process. I was actually looking at videos of this process. It looks like science fiction. It really does. They start with this massive crucible. Filled with pure molten silicon at like nearly 1500 degrees Celsius. Then they take a tiny perfect seed crystal of solid silicon on the end of a

rod and they lower it down until it just barely touches the surface of the glowing liquid pool. And the temperature control has to be impossibly precise here. The liquid silicon at the surface touches the seed crystal and begins to cool and freeze. Right. And just like we discussed with the salt cube earlier, the atoms from the liquid seek the lowest energy state, which means they... lock perfectly into the existing lattice of the solid seed. And then they slowly, I mean incredibly slowly, pull the rod upward while spinning it. As they pull, the molten silicon is drawn up

by surface tension, cooling and crystallizing into this massive continuous cylinder. And because they never break the process, the entire cylinder, which can weigh hundreds of pounds and be over a meter long, is one single perfect crystal. It's unbelievable. They then slice that massive crystal ingot like a loaf of bread into thin, shiny wafers, and that unbroken lattice becomes the foundation for curving billions of microscopic transistors. Exactly. Exactly. The same fundamental physical rule that makes rock candy on a string

is what allows your smartphone to stream 4K video. We spend billions of dollars and immense energy to engineer those perfect single crystals in laboratories. But nature performs an incredibly complex feat of crystal engineering every time it snows, entirely for free in the atmosphere. Yes. Which brings us to the ultimate childhood question, the snowflake. Why are they always six -sided? And why does everyone say no two are exactly alike? well the six -sided symmetry comes directly from the unit cell of ice water molecules consist of one oxygen and two hydrogen

atoms when they bond to each other to form a solid they use something called hydrogen bonds okay these are highly directional attractive forces so to reach their most stable lowest energy state Water molecules are basically forced to arrange themselves into a repeating hexagonal or six -sided lattice. So a snowflake is born high up in a freezing cloud as this microscopic, perfectly flat six -sided prism of ice. But how does it grow those incredibly intricate branching

arms? Because of the geometry of that tiny hexagon, the six sharp corners stick out further into the surrounding humid air than the flat sides do. Oh, I see. Because they protrude, those six corners intercept water vapor molecules faster. They just grab the moisture first. Yes. So the corners grow outward faster than the rest of the crystal, branching into long arms. This is known as dendritic growth. But if they're growing so fast, why are they always so perfectly symmetrical? Like, why do all six arms look like perfect mirror images of each other? Because the snowflake is just so incredibly small. As it falls through

the cloud, the tip of every single one of those six arms is occupying the exact same microenvironment. At the exact same time. Right. They are experiencing the exact same microscopic shifts in temperature and humidity at the exact same fraction of a second. So whatever growth spurt or branching event happens to one arm happens identically to all six simultaneously. Wow. But that shared environment is also what makes every single snowflake completely unique, right? Exactly. The interior of a winter cloud is a chaotic swirling mess

of different temperatures and moisture gradients. So as the flake tumbles and flutters toward the ground, its path is entirely random. It might hit a tiny pocket of dry air, which causes the arms to grow flat plates. Right. Then a millisecond later, an updraft blows it into a freezing humid pocket, causing those plates to sprout tiny needles. And because the branching is so wildly sensitive to temperature and humidity, the intricate pattern of the snowflake is literally a physical recording of its exact flight path through the storm. That's

beautiful. They are symmetrical because all six arms share the same journey, but they are unique because in the chaotic turbulence of a blizzard, no two snowflakes will ever take the exact same tumbling, twisting path to the ground. The path creates the pattern. Absolutely love that. And honestly, given everything we've covered today, you know, crystals vibrating to keep time, mapping the code of DNA, perfectly symmetrical ice falling from the sky. It's very easy to see why human beings have always looked at crystals and felt

a deep sense of magic. Oh, completely. It makes perfect sense why people attribute, you know, supernatural healing powers or energy balancing properties to them. The historical and cultural fascination is totally understandable. I mean, they look alien, almost unnatural in their perfection. But when we evaluate claims of crystal healing, you know, using stones to cure illness or manipulate personal energy, we do have to look at the scientific reality. Right. Inert mineral lattices do not have biological mechanisms. There is no known physics by which a chunk of rose quartz can detect

human emotion or transmit healing energy. And when researchers actually test this in controlled trials, as our sources point out, what do they find? They find the placebo effect. People genuinely do feel better or more relaxed during crystal healing sessions. But that positive effect is driven entirely by the human brain's powerful expectation and belief, not by any measurable. physical property of the stone itself. Which honestly is an amazing testament to the power of the human mind. But I think the real takeaway here is that we don't need to invent vaguely

defined mystical properties to find crystals profoundly magical. Absolutely not. The real measurable physics. The Pekai's electricity that sparks your lighter. The single crystal silicon running the internet. The x -ray diffraction mapping biological disease that is actual verifiable magic that you rely on every single day. The reality of how the universe builds structure from chaos is wonderful enough on its own without needing embellishment. It really is. So for you listening, the next time you salt your food or brush a snowflake off your coat or even just

look down at your phone, take a moment to appreciate the invisible scaffolding. It's just countless atoms. quietly following the laws of thermodynamics, seeking out their most stable, repeating geometry to build the physical foundation of our reality from the ground up. And that concept invites a much larger question, I think. We've just spent this time exploring how the physical world is entirely dependent on atoms seeking out these deeply stable, repeating, lowest energy patterns. It makes you wonder if everything from the solid rock beneath our feet to the DNA in our cells

is driven by this universal... drive toward stable repeating scaffolding, what other invisible lattices might be secretly structuring the world around us? Oh, I see what you mean. Could the complex webs of our global ecosystems or even the repeating cycles of history and human behavior just be another kind of unseen geometry? You know, a larger hidden lattice just quietly waiting for someone to step back and look closely enough to see the pattern. Man, something to think about the next time you look closely at the soul shaker.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Nanotechnology – Building at the Scale of Atoms

    Nov 19, 202626 minAudio

    Nanotechnology works at a scale where a nanometre is to a metre what a single centimetre is to the distance across a football field roughly a hundred thousand times over. This episode explains what nanotechnology...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Animal Migration – Navigation Without Maps

    Nov 17, 202625 minAudio

    A tagged bar-tailed godwit once flew more than thirteen thousand kilometres from Alaska to Tasmania without landing once. This episode explores why animals migrate at all, from godwits and humpback whales to monarch...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Space Weather – When the Sun Attacks Our Technology

    Nov 15, 202625 minAudio

    The Sun is an active, magnetic star, and every so often it hurls bursts of radiation and clouds of charged particles toward Earth, a phenomenon called space weather. This episode explains solar flares and coronal mass...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Tsunamis – Waves That Cross Oceans

    Nov 12, 202623 minAudio

    An ordinary wave rolls onto the sand every few seconds; a tsunami can take tens of minutes between crests and cross an entire ocean at the speed of a jet aircraft while barely rippling the surface. This episode explains...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Symmetry – Physics' Deepest Idea

    Nov 10, 202620 minAudio

    A folded square of paper and a butterfly's wings share the same simple visual idea: a shape that looks the same after some transformation. This episode follows that idea from everyday geometry into the deepest...

    Credit the people on this episode