Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Talking Science

Talking Science artwork

Weather vs Climate – Why the Difference Matters

Jul 22, 202620 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

“It's freezing today - so much for global warming.” It's a common jab, and it rests on confusing two different things: weather and climate. We untangle them, explain why one is predictable only days ahead while the other can be projected decades out, and show why a cold snap tells you nothing about long-term warming - using an analogy about a dog on a lead that you'll never forget. You'll come away understanding what separates weather from climate, why chaos limits forecasts, how scientists can be uncertain about tomorrow yet confident about 2070, and why this distinction is one of the most abused ideas in public debate. Talking Science is sponsored by Kinsoft. Visit www.kinsoft.com.au Further reading: Bureau of Meteorology “Understanding climate” pages; NASA “What's the difference between weather and climate?”; the IPCC FAQ resources.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Welcome to today's Deep Dive. You know, I was reading through our sources for this one and I came across this fascinating sort of paradox about weather forecasting. Oh, right. The one about the meteorologists. Yeah, exactly. Basically, if a meteorologist misses just a single solitary gust of wind in their data today, like maybe just a tiny breeze rustling through a valley in the Andes that, you know, a sensor didn't pick up, their forecast for a month from now isn't just a little bit wrong. It is. mathematically

completely useless. Right. Which is wild to think about. It is because the physics of our atmosphere just dictate that predicting the specific weather like several weeks out is literally impossible. But, and this is the big question for today's deep dive, how can scientists stand on a stage and claim to know exactly what the Earth's climate will look like in the year 2070? I mean, it sounds like a total contradiction, doesn't it? Yeah. It basically sounds like they're just throwing darts blindfolded and asking you to trust the results. Exactly. Which perfectly explains why,

you know, the moment the temperature drops below freezing in November, you will inevitably hear someone at a bus stop or maybe at a family dinner just shivering and saying, it's bloody freezing today, whatever happened to global warming? We've all heard it. We've all thought it, honestly. Right. And honestly, when you are standing there freezing your toes off, it feels like a knockout argument. I mean, you've been told the planet is boiling, yet you literally can't feel your toes. The immediate physical reality just completely overrides the abstract scientific projection.

Well, yeah, because we process the world through what is right in front of us. I mean, when the immediate data like ice on your windshield conflicts with the long term claim of a warming planet. our brains just kind of short circuit. Yeah, it's a massive disconnect. But our mission today is to untangle that exact confusion, right? Exactly. Because that tension, that exact contradiction you just set up about the meteorologist missing a gust of wind is actually the key to unlocking this whole debate. By the time we wrap up this deep dive, you're going to have a mental toolkit

and frankly, a few really brilliant analogies from our sources to make sure you never confuse weather and climate again. Which I think we really need. Because the confusion just stems from a fundamental misunderstanding of what scientists are actually measuring when they talk about the future. So let's just dig straight into that impossibility of predicting the weather. Yeah, let's start there. Because I think a lot of people assume meteorology is just a... Like if we just had better satellites or faster supercomputers or AI, we could easily predict the rain three

months in advance. Right. Like it's just a technology problem. Exactly. But we can't. And according to the sources, it has literally nothing to do with technology. It has to do with chaos. Chaos in the strict scientific sense. Yeah. Because the atmosphere is basically the ultimate chaotic system. Yeah. And. But a chaotic system is one that is just exquisitely, fiercely sensitive to microscopic differences in its starting conditions. Which brings us to the 1960s, right? The Edward Lorenz story. Yes, exactly. So Edward Lorenz was this mathematician and meteorologist, and

he was running an early computer simulation of the weather. And one day, he wanted to rerun a specific sequence. But instead of entering the full starting number, which was 0 .506127, he just typed in 0 .506. Oh, wow. Wow. So he just chopped off the very end of the decimal. Right. He rounded off a fraction of a fraction. A difference of less than one part in a thousand. I mean, you'd think the weather output would be maybe, I don't know, a fraction of a degree different a few days later in the simulation. You would think so. But instead, the simulation produced a completely radically different weather

pattern because that tiny rounding error didn't just persist, it amplified. It multiplied. Exactly. In a chaotic fluid like the atmosphere, a microscopic error today doubles tomorrow. Then it redoubles. Then it redoubles again. The system just multiplies uncertainty without any limit. And that's the actual science behind the butterfly effect, isn't it? I mean, we've all seen those sci -fi movies where a butterfly flapping its wings in Brazil causes a tornado in Texas. Right, which always makes it sound like the butterfly has some sort

of magical superpower. Yeah, exactly. But from what we're looking at here, the butterfly is just a metaphor for unmeasured data. Like, the flap of the wing creates a tiny, tiny change in air pressure. And because the system is chaotic, that microscopic change gets folded into the atmospheric math, doubles, redoubles, and, you know, a month later, the entire global weather map is totally unrecognizable from what it would have been without that one butterfly. Precisely. Because we can never measure every butterfly or, you know, every exhalation of a deer or every

shifting leaf on the planet, our starting data will always be slightly imperfect. Therefore, a specific weather forecast a month out is provably impossible. OK, hold on. I want to stop you right there. Because if the atmosphere is a giant compounding error multiplier, then doesn't that prove the skeptics completely right? What do you mean? Well, if you cannot tell me if it's going to rain next Thursday because the errors have multiplied into infinity, then predicting the temperature in the year 2070 is just pure mathematical fiction.

It's a brilliant question. And it would be fiction if scientists were actually trying to predict the weather. on, say, January 15th, 2070. But they aren't. They're doing something entirely different. OK, so what are they doing? Well, to see the difference, let's establish the basic definitions. Weather is immediate and local. Is it raining in Melbourne this afternoon? Will it be windy in Perth tomorrow? Climate, on the other hand, is the long -term pattern. The classic rule of thumb is climate is what you expect, weather is what you get. Climate is what you expect, weather is what you get. I like that.

It's a golden rule. And to really visualize this, I want you to picture a person walking a dog up a long, steady hill. Okay, I have the picture. Just a person and a dog on a hill. Right. But the dog is on one of those really long, stretchy, retractable leashes. Now, the person is walking at a very steady, deliberate pace, straight up the incline. That person represents the long -term climate, the underlying trend. But the dog... The dog represents the daily weather. And the dog is just going absolutely everywhere.

Everywhere. I mean, it darts ahead to the end of the leash, then it spots a squirrel and lunges to the left. It sniffs a bush on the right. It gets distracted by some wrapper on the ground and runs completely backward as fast as it can downhill. Just total chaos. Exactly. At any given second, that dog's movements are chaotic and unpredictable. Okay, let's unpack this for a second because this ties right back to our intro. If I'm looking through a telescope and I'm zoomed in super tight and I only watch the dog for like five seconds, I might see it sprinting downhill.

Right. And I would logically conclude, oh, this walk is heading downhill. I mean, I'm looking at the freezing Tuesday morning. I'm experiencing the cold snap. I'm watching the dog run downhill. And I'm entirely blind to the person holding the leash. That is the perfect visualization of the category error people make. Saying, it's freezing today, where is global warming, is a statement about the dog. Global warming is a statement about the person. They are linked. I mean, the dog can only run so far from the human, but tracking one specific movement of the dog tells you absolutely nothing about the

elevation of the hill they're climbing. Let's apply that to the physical atmosphere for a second, because when we experience that dog running downhill, a brutal cold snap in an era of overall warming, what is physically happening with the heat? Because, I mean, the heat didn't just vanish into thin air. No, it didn't. The atmosphere is essentially this massive circulating fluid. It's constantly churning to balance out temperature differences between the equator and the poles. Weather is really just the mechanism that moves that heat around. So it's basically a mixing bowl. A giant

thermal mixing. Bowl. Yeah. So if you are freezing in Melbourne or New York or London, it's often because the jet stream, which is this band of fast moving air that usually keeps cold Arctic air penned up at the poles, ahead of buckled. It gets wavy, right? Exactly. It gets wavy. And a deep trough of that cold air just spills south over your city. But, and this is a really fascinating detail from the text, the atmosphere is a closed system. If a massive block of cold air pushes south, It has to displace something. It's like

pushing your hand into a bathtub. The water has to go somewhere else. Right. The warm air that was previously sitting over your city gets shoved north to replace the cold air that just left the Arctic. So while you're shivering at the bus stop, completely convinced the planet is cooling, a monitoring station up in the Arctic Circle is recording unseasonably, terrifyingly warm temperatures. Which is why taking the temperature of your own backyard is entirely meaningless when discussing the climate. are experiencing local distribution, not global energy retention.

The only way to see the person walking up the hill is to average out the dog's movements across the entire surface of the globe over decades. But OK, I understand the visual of the dog and the walker, but I really want to push back on the mathematics of it for a second. Because if the individual data points, like the daily weather events, are governed by chaotic compounding errors, how can you possibly average them out into something reliable? I see where you're going with this. Right. Because if every piece of data is essentially just random noise after two weeks, shouldn't

an average of random noise just be, well, more random noise? It's a fair question. To answer that, we have to look at how statistics actually constrain chaos. Let me hand you an imaginary coin. If I ask you to flip that coin and predict whether it'll land on heads or tails, can you do it? Obviously not. I mean, it's a 50 -50 shot. The physics of my thumb hitting the coin, the air resistance, the height of the flip. It's a micro chaotic system. Right. The single flip is unpredictable. It is the weather. Now, what

if I want you to flip that exact same coin 10 ,000 times and tell me how many heads you're going to get? Out of 10 ,000. Well, I can guarantee it will be incredibly close to 5 ,000. But how can you possibly know that? You've just admitted that you can't predict a single flip. So how can you predict 10 ,000? Because the underlying physics of the coin, the fact that it's evenly weighted with two sides, creates a boundary. The individual flip is free to be whatever it wants within that boundary. But over a large enough sample, the physical reality of the coin dictates the average. The physical reality dictates

the average. That right there is the exact definition of climate. Weather is the single coin flip. Climate is the behavior of 10 ,000 flips. We don't need to predict flip number 4 ,321 to know the total average. Just like we don't need to predict a thunderstorm in August of 2070 to know the global average temperature. That makes so much sense. Let's take that concept out of statistics and put it into a physical environment to make it even more relatable. Think about a pot of water sitting on a stove. Okay, a pot on a stove. You turn the burner on. As the water starts to

heat up, it begins to churn. Currents form. Now. If I ask you to track the exact path of one single churning bubble rising from the bottom of that pot, you couldn't do it. It gets bumped by other bubbles caught in microcurrents. Its path is completely chaotic. Right, the bubble is the dog on the leash. Exactly. But if I reach out and turn the dial on the stove from medium to high... I don't need to calculate the trajectory of a single bubble to know with absolute certainty that the average temperature of the entire pot

of water is going to rise. Because you change the boundary conditions. You change the total amount of energy entering the system, and the climate operates on that exact same thermodynamic principle. It's just basic physics. Yes. While the day -to -day weather is driven by chaotic atmospheric fluid dynamics, the long -term climate is driven by massive, steady physical drivers. And the biggest driver is the balance between the energy we receive from the sun and the energy the Earth radiates back out into space. And this is where greenhouse gases come in, isn't it? They are basically the dial on the stove. They

are the dial. Gases like carbon dioxide and methane are transparent to the shortwave radiation coming in from the sun. So the sunlight passes right through them, hits the Earth, and warms it up. The Earth then tries to shed that heat by radiating it back out as long -wave infrared radiation. But the greenhouse gases block it. Right. They are not transparent to infrared. They absorb it and radiate it back down. So the energy comes in easily, but it really struggles to get out. We are thickening the blanket. We are trapping more energy in the system. And that is not a

chaotic process. That is... basic immovable thermodynamics. When you turn up the dial on the stove, the pot gets hotter. You don't need a perfectly functioning weather model to understand that a planet retaining more solar energy will, on average, have a higher global temperature. The whole predictability paradox just vanishes entirely. So scientists are utterly blind to the dog and completely focused on the walker. Both things are true at the exact same time. Okay, so the dial on the stove has been turned up. The average temperature of the whole system is rising. Let's ground this in

everyday reality for a moment. Because I think another trap people fall into is imagining that a warming climate means a smooth, uniform increase. Oh, definitely. Like people think if the average goes up, winter just gets abolished and every Tuesday is slightly warmer than the Tuesday before it. Which leads right back to the bus stop confusion. If it snows heavily, people assume the dial on the stove must be broken. But climate change isn't a linear progression of hotter individual days. It is a shift in the probabilities of what

kind of weather you are going to experience. To visualize this, I want you to picture a bell curve. Okay, like a standard statistical distribution, a big sloping hill of data. Yes. Think of that bell curve as containing all the possible weather days for your city. The vast majority of the days sit right in the bulky, tall middle of the curve. Those are your average, unremarkable days. And the sides of the curve just taper off into those long, thin tails. Exactly. The left tail contains your extreme cold days. The right tail

contains your extreme hot days. Under normal conditions, the weather randomly pulls from this curve. You get a lot of days from the middle and very occasionally a day from one of the extreme tails. So what physically happens to that bell curve when you turn up the dial on the stove? The entire curve, the whole bulky middle and both tails, slides to the right. It slides toward the hotter end of the temperature spectrum. Which explains everything we've been talking about. Because sliding the curve to the right doesn't magically chop off the cold tail on the left.

The cold tail is still there. It is absolutely still there. You can still reach into the curve and pull out a freezing morning. the dog can still run downhill sometimes. Right. But the odds have fundamentally shifted. Because the curve moved, the temperatures that used to sit in the extreme heat tail on the far right are now sitting closer to the bulky middle. They become much more common. And more alarmingly, the very edge of that right tail gets pushed out into empty space. Into completely uncharted territory. Yeah, it gets pushed into brand new temperature zones that the previous climate literally

never reached. We hit new scorching extremes we've never seen before. It is exactly like playing a game with loaded dice. Imagine you have a pair of standard dice. You can roll anything from a 2 to a 12. Now imagine someone tampers with them. They weight the dice heavily toward the higher numbers. Maybe they even paint a seven on a couple of the faces. Okay, but if I roll those loaded dice, I can still roll a two. A two is physically possible. But if you roll a two, you wouldn't jump up and declare, aha, the

dice aren't loaded. You know they are loaded because over 50 rolls, you're rolling sevens, eights, and twelves at a highly unnatural elevated frequency. Climate change is a load and die. A single cold snap is just a roll of a two. It's entirely expected within the system. Exactly. The proof of the loading is in the frequency of the heat waves, the intensity of the storms, the breaking of historical records year after year. It's all about probabilities. So let's bring this all together. Because armed with this mental toolkit we've built here, you know, the chaotic dog and the steady walker, the unpredictable

coin flips averaging out, the thermodynamics of the stove and the loaded dice. can instantly spot the massive logical fallacy driving so much of public debate. It really is just a simple category error. People are holding up a piece of microdata and trying to invalidate a macro trend. Saying it snowed today, therefore global warming is fake is entirely indistinguishable from saying the dog just ran backward, therefore the hill doesn't exist. And honestly, it is vital to point out that this logical fallacy cuts both

ways. Oh, absolutely. If someone points to a single brutal heat wave in July and says, see, this proves climate change is real. They are making the exact same category error. A single heat wave is also just weather. It is just the dog running quickly uphill. Right. Now a scientist will tell you that a heat wave is exactly the type of weather you expect more frequently when you load the dice. But honest science does not build its case on one hot summer. No. The evidence for the warming planet doesn't care about your hot July or your freezing November. The evidence rests entirely on the decades -long global trend.

The steady, relentless figure walking up the incline measured across thousands of data points over decades. The inability of a supercomputer to tell you if it will rain three weeks from Tuesday isn't a failure of climate science. It's just the reality of chaotic fluid dynamics. The weather is what you get on any random day. The climate is what you logically expect based on the physics of the system. So the next time someone points out the window at a cold day, you know, hoping to settle a massive, complex scientific debate with what's happening in their driveway,

you will know exactly what is happening. Their brain is watching the dog. Exactly. They are fixated on the chaotic, short -term noise, and they are completely ignoring the underlying physics. The dog runs everywhere, but the person keeps walking uphill. If you want to understand the future, you have to look past the dog. Keep your eye on the person walking uphill. Look past the dog. It's such a clarifying way to view the world. And as we wrap up this deep dive, I actually want to invite you to take that exact same clarifying lens and turn it away from the atmosphere and

point it at your own life. Oh, that's an interesting thought. Because the human brain's vulnerability to this category error, our tendency to be, you know, hijacked by immediate chaotic feedback while completely missing the underlying truth. trend doesn't just ruin conversations about the climate. It actively sabotages us in our daily lives. It really does. Think about it. Where else in your life are you currently obsessing over the darting dog and completely missing the person steadily walking uphill? Maybe you've been investing in the stock market for years,

but the market has a terrible, brutal two week dip. The dog sprints downhill. Do you panic, sell everything and abandon the strategy, forgetting that the long term historical trend of the market is a steady climb? People do it all the time. Or maybe you are trying to learn a new skill or you've started a new diet or a new career path. You are putting in the work. You're changing your underlying habits. You are essentially turning up the dial on the stove, but you step on the scale one morning or you bomb one. It's so easy

to be tricked by the short -term weather. We are biologically wired to react to the weather in our lives, the immediate cold snaps, the sudden thunderstorms. But true progress, whether it's in atmospheric science, wealth building, or personal growth, is always about the climate. It is about the long -term averages, the underlying habits, the steady direction of the walk. Well said. So this week, when things inevitably get chaotic, take a breath. Ask yourself, am I reacting to the dog or am I trapping the walker? Thanks for

joining us on this deep dive. We will catch you on the next one.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Nanotechnology – Building at the Scale of Atoms

    Nov 19, 202626 minAudio

    Nanotechnology works at a scale where a nanometre is to a metre what a single centimetre is to the distance across a football field roughly a hundred thousand times over. This episode explains what nanotechnology...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Animal Migration – Navigation Without Maps

    Nov 17, 202625 minAudio

    A tagged bar-tailed godwit once flew more than thirteen thousand kilometres from Alaska to Tasmania without landing once. This episode explores why animals migrate at all, from godwits and humpback whales to monarch...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Space Weather – When the Sun Attacks Our Technology

    Nov 15, 202625 minAudio

    The Sun is an active, magnetic star, and every so often it hurls bursts of radiation and clouds of charged particles toward Earth, a phenomenon called space weather. This episode explains solar flares and coronal mass...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Tsunamis – Waves That Cross Oceans

    Nov 12, 202623 minAudio

    An ordinary wave rolls onto the sand every few seconds; a tsunami can take tens of minutes between crests and cross an entire ocean at the speed of a jet aircraft while barely rippling the surface. This episode explains...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Symmetry – Physics' Deepest Idea

    Nov 10, 202620 minAudio

    A folded square of paper and a butterfly's wings share the same simple visual idea: a shape that looks the same after some transformation. This episode follows that idea from everyday geometry into the deepest...

    Credit the people on this episode