In some coastal cities, ordinary high tide on a clear, calm, cloudless day is now enough to send seawater bubbling up through the drains and into the streets, with no storm in sight at all. This episode explains what's really driving global sea level rise, from the warming ocean simply expanding to ice sheets and glaciers adding new water, why melting sea ice doesn't raise sea level at all but melting land ice does, the surprising "gravitational fingerprint" left by shrinking ice sheets, why some coastlines are sinking or rising independently of the ocean itself, how scientists actually measure sea level with tide gauges and satellites, and why future sea level rise is discussed in honest ranges rather than single confident numbers. You'll come away understanding the two main physical causes of global sea level rise, why floating sea ice melting doesn't change sea level but melting glaciers and ice sheets does, what a gravitational sea level fingerprint is, why land can be sinking or rising independently of the ocean, how tide gauges and satellite altimetry are used together to track sea level, why local sea level trends can differ dramatically from the global average, and why genuine scientific uncertainty about future rates isn't the same thing as doubt that sea level is rising. Talking Science is sponsored by Kinsoft. Visit www.kinsoft.com.au Further reading: NASA - sea level change portal and satellite altimetry data; NOAA - tide gauge records and sea level trend reports; IPCC - Sixth Assessment Report chapters on sea level and the cryosphere; CSIRO - Australian sea level research and coastal monitoring.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Picture a coastal street on a perfectly clear, sunny afternoon. You're just looking up at the sky and there are absolutely no storm clouds anywhere, no rain, nothing that looks even remotely like flooding weather. Right. Just a beautiful day. Exactly. Just a beautiful day. Yet you look down and seawater is quietly bubbling up out of the stormwater drains. It spills over the curbs and slowly spreads across the road, pooling around the tires of parked cars. Yeah. It's a striking image. And honestly, almost surreal
when you see it in person. It totally violates our basic expectations, right? Like how weather and the ocean are supposed to interact. Oh, absolutely. I mean, we are deeply conditioned to associate rising water with, you know. Violent storms, hurricanes, high winds. Right. But when I first started going through the source material for today's deep dive, I realized this isn't some rare freak event anymore in low -lying coastal cities. It's become this recurring nuisance. Yeah, people informally call it sunny day flooding or sometimes a king tide event. Right. You expect
floods during a hurricane, but you don't expect them on a random Tuesday when you're just like walking the dog in sunglasses. No, you definitely don't. And what really stood out to me in the data was that this bizarre local phenomenon is actually one of the clearest everyday signs of a massive slow motion process playing out across the entire planet. Yeah. The overarching process being sea level rise. Which, well, it sounds like a very straightforward concept on the surface, doesn't it? It does. But the underlying mechanisms are actually full of surprises. It's vastly more
complex and, frankly, more fascinating than just, you know, a simple line moving up on a graph. Okay, so let's unpack this because whenever I hear the phrase sea level rise, I immediately picture a bathtub. And I think almost everyone does, right? Sure. It's the most common analogy. Yeah, like you turn on the faucet, the water slowly fills up the tub, and the surface just rises perfectly and evenly from all sides. But the research insists this intuitive mental image is actually totally misleading. So I need you to help me break this down. Why does the bathtub
analogy fail so spectacularly? Well, our brains really rely on that analogy because it perfectly aligns with our everyday experience of water in small containers. A bathtub, a sink, a glass. Right. But to understand a planetary ocean, we first have to define the baseline. Like, scientists measure something called global mean sea level. Wait, hold on. Global mean sea level? How do you even calculate an average on an ocean that is, you know, constantly churning? It's not easy. I mean, you've got massive waves daily, high
and low tides, storms pushing water all over the place. You can't just take a ruler to the beach. You certainly cannot. It requires continuous measurement and a tremendous amount of mathematical filtering to sort of... smooth out all that daily noise. So you have to mathematically subtract the tides. Exactly. You subtract the familiar rise and fall of the tides and the choppy unevenness of local weather. And when you finally filter out all that chaos, you are left with a planetary baseline. Okay. And the data shows that this
global average baseline has been rising for well over a century. Currently, the well -documented rate is just a few millimeters a year. Okay, a few millimeters. I mean, that is literally the thickness of a couple of coins. I'm just trying to figure out why anyone would panic over something that small. But before we get into the actual danger of that, I want to understand what is physically pushing the water up in the first place. Right. Because I always assumed it was just melting ice caps, but the source material points to the water itself as the first major driver. Yeah, the very first cause we need
to look at is thermal expansion. And it's actually a beautifully simple piece of physics. Okay. Lay it on me. So the climate system is warming, right? Yeah. And our oceans basically act as a massive sponge for that extra heat. They absorb an enormous share of it. Right. They're like the planet's heat sink. Exactly. And as ocean water absorbs that thermal energy, the individual water molecules within it begin to move more vigorously. They gain kinetic energy, bouncing off each other with a little more force. Which
means they spread out. Yes. On average, they spread slightly further apart. Okay, so I was trying to picture this on a human scale while I was reading. It's almost like a crowded dance floor. Oh, I like that. Yeah. Like if a slow song is playing. Everyone is just swaying in place, packed in really tight. You can fit a lot of people in a small space. But then the tempo speeds up. The tempo speeds up and people start dancing more vigorously, jumping around, throwing their arms out. Right. And suddenly they naturally just need more space. The crowd expands and pushes outward, taking up way more
room on the floor, even though nobody knew walked through the door. That captures the dynamic perfectly. Now, if you apply that thermal expansion to, say, a single glass of water on your kitchen counter, the effect is utterly negligible. You'd never see it. You would never notice the water level rise. But we have to scale that microscopic jostling up to an ocean containing an almost unimaginable volume of water. spread across the entire globe. And miles deep, right? Yes, extending kilometers deep. So when you multiply that tiny
per molecule expansion across miles of depth, it adds up to a genuinely massive increase in overall volume. So the ocean is literally just physically swelling up. The sea level rises even without a single extra drop of water being added from outside the system. Exactly. Careful measurements of ocean heat content taken from this whole global network of submerged instruments show the oceans have absorbed a staggering amount of trapped heat. So thermal expansion accounts for a major portion of the sea level rise we've measured over the past century. Wow. Okay, but there is
a second driver. And this one does involve adding genuinely new water to the ocean. And here is where I had to correct a massive misconception I had about exactly which ice we should actually be worrying about. Right. This is a very common point of confusion because we hear a lot of news about shrinking Arctic sea ice. Yes. The frozen seawater that forms and floats directly on the ocean's surface. The ice the polar bears are standing on in all the documentaries. Right. Sea ice. My instinct is to say that when that ice melts. the sea level goes up. But the research
says that's wrong. It goes back to Archimedes' principle, doesn't it? It does. Think about, well, a glass of water filled right to the very brim with a big ice cube floating in it. Okay. When that ice cube melts, the glass won't overflow. Because the floating ice is already displacing exactly its own weight in water. Oh, so the volume it takes up under the surface is exactly equal to the water it turns into when it melts. Exactly. Meaning the melting of sea ice in the Arctic is, well, it's terrible for polar bears and for the ecosystem, but it isn't flooding coastal
cities. Okay, wait. So does it matter at all for sea level then? It matters for the climate. The loss of sea ice is a profound indicator of a warming climate, and it drastically reduces how much sunlight the planet reflects back into space, which, you know, just accelerates the overall warming. Ah, so it makes the thermal expansion worse. Right. But its melting does not meaningfully raise global sea levels directly. The real culprit when it comes to adding new water is land ice. Land ice? Yes. We're talking
about mountain glaciers and the two vast ice sheets covering Greenland and Antarctica. Because they are sitting on continental rock, they aren't in the bathtub yet. That's the key. They hold the overwhelming majority of the world's fresh water. just locked up on land. When large chunks of this ice break off and slide into the sea, a process called calving, or when it melts and runs off as rivers, it is dumping completely new water into the ocean basin. Okay, so we have thermal expansion making the existing water swell and melting land ice dumping new water into the
system. This seems like it should just raise the water level everywhere equally, like a filling pool, but... But it doesn't. Right. Here's where it gets really interesting. I mean, reading this part of the deep... dive completely broke my brain. It says that melting ice absolutely does not raise sea levels evenly. No, it does not. In fact, if you are standing right next to the Greenland ice sheet as it melts, the sea level on your local beach might actually fall. It might actually drop. How on earth is that possible? I mean, it's melting right there. What's fascinating
here is that we have to talk about gravity. Gravity. Yeah. We usually only think of gravity in terms of like the earth. pulling an apple to the ground. But everything with mass has its own gravitational pull. Okay. And a vast ice sheet like Greenland's contains an immense mass of ice. I mean, we are talking about a frozen block that is miles thick, covering landmass the size of Mexico. I mean, I know mountains have mass, but I never considered that ice could have enough gravity to actually pull on an ocean. It does. The mass is so tremendous
that it exerts a strong gravitational pull on everything around it, particularly the surrounding seawater. Wow. The ocean water is miserably pulled toward the ice sheet. It effectively drags the water and piles it up unusually high near the coast. So the sea level there is artificially elevated by the sheer gravitational attraction of the ice. That is mind -bending. Ice is literally pulling the ocean up against itself like a magnet pulling on iron filings. That's a great way to visualize it. Yeah. So consider what happens as that ice sheet melts. It is losing hundreds
of... Billions of tons of mass. Right. And as the mass decreases, its gravitational pull weakens. And because the gravitational magnet is getting weaker, the seawater that was piled up against the coast isn't being held there anymore. Exactly. The water begins to relax. It sloshes back outward, away from the now less massive ice sheet, and redistributes itself toward distant parts of the ocean. So Greenland dumps billions of gallons of new water into the ocean, but the ocean level
actually drops locally because the water flows away. It flows away and piles up in places far across the globe, sometimes rising dramatically on the exact opposite side of the planet. That is wild. Scientists actually call this a sea level fingerprint. Each melting ice sheet, whether it's Greenland or specific regions of Antarctica, stamps its own unique calculable pattern of rising and falling water across the globe. Okay, so... If Antarctica's ice melts, it might drastically raise the sea level on the coast of North America, while Greenland's melt might drastically raise
it somewhere in the southern hemisphere. Yes, precisely. The water is literally just warping around the globe. It is a deeply complex redistribution of mass. So the water itself is being pushed and pulled by these invisible gravitational fingerprints. But to make things even more chaotic for our hypothetical coastal city you're living in, the ground beneath your feet isn't sitting still either. No, it's not. And this introduces another critical concept, which is relative sea level. Right, relative sea level, which is just how
high the water appears to rise from the perspective of someone standing on a specific dock, right? It's the reality local residents actually experience. Exactly. If the water is rising... but the land you are standing on is simultaneously sinking, your relative sea level is going to climb incredibly fast. Yeah, that makes sense. And that sinking of land is our first major localized variable. It's known as subsidence. So why is the land sinking out from under people? Like, what's causing that? Well, in many low -lying coastal cities
built on river deltas, the land is composed of soft sediment that slowly compacts naturally over time. But human activity heavily. heavily accelerates this. How so? When a city pumps vast amounts of groundwater or, say, extracts oil and gas from deep underground aquifers and reservoirs, it creates these empty void spaces beneath the surface. Ah. I was trying to picture the mechanics of this, and I keep coming back to a jelly donut. A jelly donut? Yeah, like if you have a plump donut and you take a syringe and suck the jelly
out of the middle, the top layer of dough has nothing supporting it anymore, so it just caves in. Well, yeah, actually. The sediment layers above those depleted aquifers behave the exact same way. They gradually compact and settle downward into the empty space. Wow. So for cities built on this settling ground, the residents face a compounding crisis. The ocean is rising globally. And their city block is dropping locally. That is a terrible combination. But the research also highlighted the flip side, right? Where the land is actually rising up to meet the ocean. Yes. Through a really fascinating geological process
called post -glacial rebound. Or sometimes it's called glacial isostatic adjustment. Okay, that sounds incredibly technical. But it connects back to the Ice Age, right? It does. During the last glacial period, enormous ice sheets pressed down on parts of the northern hemisphere, places like Scandinavia and parts of Canada. Okay. They pressed down with such tremendous weight that the underlying crust of the Earth was literally compressed downward into the molten mantle below. Oh, so the crust is slightly flexible, like sitting
on a really firm memory foam mattress. Exactly like a memory foam mattress. Like if a heavy person sits on it for a long time, it leaves a deep depression. And when they finally stand up, the foam doesn't just snap back instantly. It slowly puffs back up over time. That's perfectly put. The ice melted tens of thousands of years ago, lifting that heavy weight. But the Earth's mantle is incredibly viscous, like thick syrup. So it's still moving. Yes. The crust is still slowly springing back upward today. So if you live in one of these rebounding regions, the
land beneath your feet is moving upward fast enough that your relative sea level might actually be falling. Even though the total amount of water in the global bath cub is increasing. Exactly. Furthermore, we have to factor in ocean currents. Right. Currents. The ocean is threaded with massive currents driven by wind, temperature differences, and the Earth's rotation. And these currents move. enormous volumes of water around, but they don't do it evenly. Yeah, what really stood out in the sources was the U .S. East Coast. It mentioned
that shifting ocean circulation patterns are causing warm water to physically mound up slightly along that coastline. Yeah, when currents create a bottleneck or shift direction, warm water accumulates. Yeah. And where you have concentrated warm water, you get more of that localized thermal expansion we discussed earlier. The dance floor. Right, the energetic dancers taking up more space. Okay, let me just, let me take a breath and try to stack all this up because it is honestly dizzying. That's a lot. lot. We have thermal expansion swelling the water from heat. We have melting ice sheets creating a gravity fingerprints that
pull the ocean across the globe. We have the land itself moving up or down like a deflating donut or a rebounding mattress. And we have shifting currents mounding hot water in random places. That's the picture. Yeah. With all this localized chaos happening at the exact same time. How do scientists actually figure out the global average? I mean, it seems impossible to decouple the ocean from the land. It's an incredible scientific challenge. Yeah. And it requires multiple sort of complementary tools to get it right. The oldest
method relies on the tide gauge. Which is essentially a very sophisticated ruler attached to a coastal pier continuously measuring the water height, right? Right. And tide gauges provide an invaluable historical record stretching back. Well over a century. But as you just pointed out, a tide gauge captures the total localized mass. Because it's attached to the land. Exactly. Because it is physically anchored to the land. It measures the ocean rise combined with any local land sinking or rebounding. It gives you the relative sea level. Which is exactly what a coastal mayor
needs to know for city planning. But it's terrible if you want to know what the total volume of the global ocean is actually doing. Precisely. To find the true global trend, you need an instrument that completely ignores the land. And that is where satellite altimetry comes in. Space lasers. Basically, yes. Since the early 1990s, satellites orbiting overhead have been bouncing precisely timed radar pulses off the ocean surface and measuring exactly how long they take to return. And because the satellite is orbiting in space,
it doesn't care if the ground in Florida is sinking or the ground in Canada is rising. It measures the height of the sea surface relative to the center of the Earth. It provides a clean, absolute global reference frame. Additionally, satellites can measure the water height far out into the deep open ocean, where you could never practically install a tide gauge anyway. Oh, that makes sense. By cross -checking the historical coastal data from tide gauges with the absolute global data from satellites, scientists have built independently corroborated confidence in the overall trend. Okay, so what does this all mean for us, like
for you listening to this? We know the global average is rising a few millimeters a year. But I still struggle with the scale. Why does a rise of a few millimeters pose an existential threat to island nations or river deltas? A millimeter is tiny. It is tiny. But you have to remember, sea level rise does not act alone. It functions as a rising baseline. A rising baseline, meaning the starting floor is permanently higher. Yes. Think about all the temporary natural events that push water onshore. A normal high tide,
a storm surge from a passing low pressure system, or just a period of unusually strong onshore winds. Right, the stuff that happens all the time. Right. Coastal infrastructure like seawalls and storm drains, they're specifically engineered to handle those temporary spikes based on historical averages. Okay, I see where this is going. If you permanently raise the floor that those spikes launch from, even by just a few inches over a couple of decades, the math totally changes. It totally changes. An entirely ordinary weather event, one that historically would have just splashed harmlessly against a seawall, now suddenly
overtops it because it started from a higher launching pad. Wow. Which brings us full circle to the sunny day flooding on that clear coastal street we talked about at the beginning. It wasn't a freak storm. It was just a regular high tide doing what it always does. But it arrived on top of a permanently elevated baseline. So the water had nowhere to go but back up through the city's storm drains. And for low -lying island nations, some of which max out at just a meter or two above the ocean across their entire landmass. This permanently rising baseline isn't just an
infrastructure headache. No. It dictates whether the land remains habitable at all. So the measurements are incredibly strong and the physics of the localized threats are very clear. But as we reach the final section of our deep dive here, the research makes a really crucial point about the nature of science. There is an area where scientists remain honestly, genuinely uncertain. Yes, and it is vital to distinguish between honest scientific uncertainty and overarching doubt. Right. The broad physical reality that the ocean is warming, expanding, and absorbing melting land ice is
not in dispute. What is genuinely difficult to pin down is exactly how fast sea levels will rise in the coming decades. Okay, but why is the speed so hard to predict? Don't we have supercomputers modeling every drop of water? We do, but we run into deeply complex ice physics. Specifically, a phenomenon known as marine ice sheet instability. Marine ice sheet instability. Yes. It involves the unique geography of Antarctica. Enormous sections of the Antarctic ice sheet actually rest on bedrock that is below sea level. Wait,
the ice is sitting on land, but the land is shaped like a bowl that dips underneath the ocean. It rests on a reverse slope. The bedrock slants downward as you move inland. Oh, I see. The point where the grounded ice meets the ocean water is called the grounding line. If warming ocean currents melt that grounding line from below, the ice detaches from the bedrock. And because it's on a downward slope? Exactly. Because it's on a downward slope, seawater can rush further underneath, lifting and melting more ice in a runaway, self -reinforcing collapse. Oh, wow.
So the whole sheet just slides downhill into the ocean faster and faster. And modeling the exact tipping point and speed of that structural collapse pushes the absolute limits of current glaciology. Plus, on top of the complex ice physics, there is the unpredictable human element, right? The future rate of rise depends heavily on human choices about greenhouse gas emissions. We haven't even decided how much carbon we're emitting tomorrow, let alone in 20 years. Which is exactly why credible science presents future sea level rise as a range of possibilities tied to different scenarios,
rather than a single falsely precise number. Right. A range of projections isn't a weakness. It is the most honest representation of a future that relies on unwritten... variables. It's just an incredible look at how hyper -connected this system really is. I mean, we started this deep dive talking about a bathtub, and we ended up with a globally warping patchwork of ice gravity fingerprints pulling water across hemispheres, subsiding ground, deflating like a donut, land rebounding from ancient glaciers, and shifting ocean currents. It's all connected. Every single
beach and seawall has its own completely unique combination of these forces. A completely individualized threat. profile for every mile of coastline? Yep. Given that hyper -local reality, it leaves you with something incredibly practical to consider. I mean, think about it. How might the very concept of a 30 -year coastal mortgage or beachfront real estate fundamentally change in the near future? That's the million -dollar question. Truly. Will financial markets, banks, and insurance companies start mathematically pricing in glacial rebound or marine ice sheet instability before
the water even reaches the doorstep? It's a complex planetary... physics problem that is rapidly transforming into a very real neighborhood financial problem. Just something to mull over the next time you walk past a perfectly sunny, clear coastal street and notice the seawater quietly bubbling up from the drain at your feet.
Nanotechnology works at a scale where a nanometre is to a metre what a single centimetre is to the distance across a football field roughly a hundred thousand times over. This episode explains what nanotechnology...
A tagged bar-tailed godwit once flew more than thirteen thousand kilometres from Alaska to Tasmania without landing once. This episode explores why animals migrate at all, from godwits and humpback whales to monarch...
The Sun is an active, magnetic star, and every so often it hurls bursts of radiation and clouds of charged particles toward Earth, a phenomenon called space weather. This episode explains solar flares and coronal mass...
An ordinary wave rolls onto the sand every few seconds; a tsunami can take tens of minutes between crests and cross an entire ocean at the speed of a jet aircraft while barely rippling the surface. This episode explains...
A folded square of paper and a butterfly's wings share the same simple visual idea: a shape that looks the same after some transformation. This episode follows that idea from everyday geometry into the deepest...