Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Talking Science

Talking Science artwork

Gravity – The Weakest Force in Charge of Everything

Oct 13, 202622 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Pick up a small fridge magnet and use it to lift a paperclip off the table, and you've just watched electromagnetism, working through a scrap of moulded plastic and metal, casually beat the gravitational pull of the entire planet Earth. Gravity is, by a staggering margin, the weakest of the four fundamental forces of nature - and yet it's the one that holds you to the ground, keeps the Moon circling Earth, and shapes the large-scale structure of the entire universe. This episode explores that paradox, from Newton's tidy law of universal gravitation through Einstein's stranger and more accurate picture of gravity as curved spacetime, and ends at the edge of what physics still can't explain. You'll come away understanding just how weak gravity really is compared with the other fundamental forces, how Newton's law succeeded for centuries including predicting the discovery of a new planet, why Einstein's general relativity was needed to fix a small but real crack in Newton's picture, what's actually happening during weightlessness and ocean tides, and why unifying gravity with quantum mechanics remains one of the biggest unsolved problems in physics. Talking Science is sponsored by Kinsoft. Visit www.kinsoft.com.au Further reading: NASA - "What Is Gravity?" and general relativity mission pages; Australian Academy of Science - public explainers on Einstein and gravitational physics; Scientific American - features on quantum gravity and unification attempts; Nature - research summaries on tests of general relativity.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Here is a small experiment you can picture right now, or honestly, you could just go into your kitchen and do it later. Take an ordinary fridge magnet. And just use it to pick up a paperclip off a table. Right. Something we've all done a million times. Exactly. It works easily. You don't even have to touch the paperclip. You just hover the magnet close and it jumps right up. But think about what that actually means for a moment in terms of raw physics. Oh, it's wild when you actually break it down. It really is. That little magnet, which is just a few grams of molded plastic and metal, is pulling that

paperclip upward with more force than the gravitational pull of the entire. planet Earth yeah all six thousand billion billion tons of our planet are pulling that exact same paperclip downward and gravity loses I mean it loses every single time it really is a stunning realization when you frame the physics that way I mean we experience gravity as this inescapable grounded reality right yet it is effortlessly defeated by a cheap souvenir from a gift shop Right. And that small

demonstration captures something genuinely strange about the universe, which is basically the mission for our deep dive today. We've got a lot of ground to cover. We really do. We've compiled a fantastic stack of sources for this. We're looking at everything from historical letters exchanged by 19th century astronomers to the latest astrophysical research papers and theoretical physics frameworks. And what all these sources point to is the ultimate paradox of gravity. Exactly. We want to understand how the absolute weakest force in nature somehow

built the galaxies, dictates our daily lives, and somehow remains the most stubborn unsolved mystery in modern science. It's the biggest puzzle out there. It is. So we're going to break down everything from falling apples to colliding black holes and explain the actual mechanics behind them. And we are assuming absolutely no prior science background on your part. And to really understand those mechanics, it helps us start by looking at where gravity is. sits in the cosmic hierarchy. Right, the big picture. Exactly. Physicists currently describe the universe as being governed

by four fundamental forces. And gravity is remarkably isolated from the other three. Yeah. When you look through the standard model outlined in our sources, gravity is practically sitting at the kids' table. That's a great way to put it. You have the strong and weak nuclear forces doing the heavy lifting at the microscopic level, right? Cramming positively charged protons together in atomic nuclei and governing radioactive decay. Right. They handle the tiny stuff. And then you have electromagnetism powering everything from light and chemical bonds to, well, that fridge

magnet we just talked about. Gravity is just the ultimate underdog here. It is an underdog. by a margin that is genuinely difficult to comprehend. I mean, physicists often describe gravity as being roughly 10 to the power of 36 times weaker than electromagnetism between two charged particles. Wow. Wait, 10 to the 36th? Yeah, that is a 1 followed by 36 zeros. To put that difference in strength into perspective, it is roughly equivalent to comparing the width of a single atom to the width of the entire observable universe. That

is insane, which now naturally raises a pretty glaring question. If gravity is that unimaginably weak, it doesn't intuitively make sense that it ends up running the show at large scales. Right, shaping galaxies and holding planets in their orbits. Exactly. But reading through the astrophysics papers, the explanation comes down to a couple of very specific behavioral traits. First, unlike the nuclear forces, which only operate over tiny microscopic distances, gravity has an effectively unlimited range. It reaches... Right. It weakens as you move further away, but

it never cuts off entirely. Right. And the second crucial trait is that gravity is always attractive, and it always adds up. Meaning it never repels anything. Exactly. Mass, which is the source of gravity, only comes in one sign. Electromagnetism, by contrast, comes in positive and negative charges. So over any decent -sized object, like a planet or a star, those positive and negative charges largely cancel each other out because matter is, on the whole, electrically neutral. So if electromagnetism is... like a giant tug of war

you have incredibly strong teams pulling in opposite directions all over the place perfectly balanced right and because they are perfectly matched the rope barely moves the forces just cancel each other out but gravity is like millions of tiny ants i like that analogy Individually, each ant is incredibly weak, but they are all pulling relentlessly in the exact same direction. None of them ever pull backward. They just keep pulling. Yeah. Put enough mass together, and eventually the combined pull of an entire planet becomes

overwhelming. And that additive nature is exactly why gravity dominates the macro universe. The individual atomic contribution is fantastically weak. But it compounds endlessly. It just keeps stacking up. Exactly. And because it adds up at those massive scales, humanity naturally started noticing the mathematical rules governing these giant cosmic objects long before we understood atoms. This is where Isaac Newton comes into the picture in the late 17th century. Right. Newton. He proposed the law of universal gravitation, which basically states that every object with

mass attracts every other object with mass. It sounds simple. But it was revolutionary. And the sources detail how he figured out the precise geometry of this. The force grows stronger the more massive the objects are, but it falls off with the square of the distance between them. The inverse square law. Right. Meaning, if you double the distance between two planets, the gravitational pull doesn't just drop by half. It actually drops to a quarter of its original strength. It spreads out geometrically. And what made Newton's law so remarkable was how universally

it applied. Proved that the math governing an apple falling from a tree was identical to the math governing a planet tracing its orbit around the sun. Which had to blow people's minds at the time. Oh, it was a massive paradigm shift. It allowed astronomers to calculate planetary orbits with striking precision and even predict the return of comets. And it culminated in that incredible story from the mid -1800s with the hidden planet. Oh, the discovery of Neptune. Yeah. Yeah. Astronomers noticed Uranus wasn't following quite the orbit Newton's law predicted

it should, given the known gravitational tugs from the Sun and the other planets. It was wobbling slightly off course. Right. So two mathematicians, John Couch Adams and Urbain Le Verrier, worked independently and basically decided to trust Newton's math completely. They calculated that an undiscovered planet of a specific mass in a specific location would perfectly account for Uranus's weird behavior. Yes, and in 1846, astronomers pointed their telescopes exactly where the math told them to look. And there it was, Neptune.

That's just wild to me. It was discovered essentially on paper in the dark before anyone had ever directly observed it. It was the ultimate vindication of Newton's math. But, you know, there is a clear disconnect here in the history. If Newton's math was literally good enough to find a hidden planet millions of miles away in the dark, it seems like that should have been the final word. You think so, right? Yeah. But obviously we needed Einstein to come along a few decades later and rewrite the entire rulebook. Why wasn't Newton's math the final answer? Well, the need for Einstein

came down to a tiny, stubborn anomaly that refused to go away, even with Newton's equations. It showed up in the orbit of Mercury. Okay, Mercury, what was it doing? So Mercury's orbit isn't a perfectly closed loop. It slowly rotates over time, a behavior called precession. Newton's law predicts almost exactly how much that precession should be once you account for the tugs of all the other planets. Right, because Jupiter and Venus are pulling on it too? Exactly. But there was a leftover discrepancy of about 43 seconds

of arc per century. Which is an incredibly small measurement. I mean, a second of arc is 1 3600th of a degree. It's tiny. So over an entire century, the prediction was off by a fraction of a degree. It is far too small to notice in everyday life. but it was measurable with careful astronomical observation. Newton's law simply couldn't account for it. It just didn't work. Right. Astronomers were so desperate to save Newton's theory that they even proposed another undiscovered inner planet, nicknamed Vulcan, was causing the tug.

Wait, really? Vulcan? Yeah, but Vulcan didn't exist. There was no hidden planet this time. So to solve that tiny discrepancy, Albert Einstein published his general theory of relativity in 1915. And based on the theoretical papers, he didn't just tweak Newton's math. He entirely redefined what gravity actually is. He changed the whole game. Yeah. Instead of an invisible rope pulling objects together, Einstein proposed that mass and energy actually warp the four -dimensional fabric of space and time itself, combining them

into what we call space -time. Right. And the classic analogy people often use here is a heavy bowling ball placed in the middle of a stretched rubber sheet. Oh, I've seen that one in science museums. Exactly. It creates a dip. Then, if you roll a smaller marble nearby, the marble curves around the dip, simulating an orbit. But, you know, the sources actually point out a pretty severe flaw in that rubber sheet analogy. It's true. It has a big problem. It relies on Earth's downward gravity pulling the bowling ball into the sheet in order to explain how gravity works.

You're basically using gravity to explain gravity. It's circular logic. Yeah. A much better way to visualize spacetime curvature is to imagine you are driving a car on a steeply banked waste track. If you hold the steering wheel perfectly straight, you feel like you are driving in a straight line. But you're not. Right. Because the geometry of the track itself is tilted and curved, your car naturally turns in a large circle. You aren't being pulled to the center by a rope. You are just moving straight through a curved environment. And that completely eliminates the

need for an invisible pulling force. What looks to us like the Earth's gravity pulling the moon into an orbit is actually just the moon traveling in a straight line through spacetime that has been curved by the Earth's mass. So the straight path itself loops back around. Exactly. Matter tells spacetime how to curve, and curved spacetime tells matter how to move. And this complete reframing perfectly predicted Mercury's precession right down to those missing 43 seconds of arc. And it was physically proven shortly after in 1919. Einstein predicted that if massive objects warp

spacetime, they should visibly bend the path of starlight passing near them. Which is wild to think about. Yeah. During a total solar eclipse, astronomer Arthur Eddington measured starlight bending around the sun by the exact amount Einstein predicted, which, you know, turned Einstein into a global icon. It made him a celebrity overnight. But moving from starlight back down to human experience, there's a bridge we need to cross here. If gravity is just the geometry of space -time, that doesn't immediately explain the physical

sensation of weight. Right, what we actually feel. Yeah, like when I drop my phone on my face while reading in bed, that feels very much like a localized force pulling it down. Well, Einstein bridged that gap with a concept called the equivalence principle. Imagine you are shut inside a windowless box. Okay, I'm in a box. If that box is sitting on the ground on Earth, you feel your normal weight pressing you to the floor. Now imagine that same windowless box is out in deep space, far away from any planet, being smoothly accelerated forward by a rocket at a rate that exactly matches

Earth's gravity. So the floor of the rocket is actively thrusting up against your feet. Yes. And Einstein realized that you would feel pressed against the floor in exactly the same way. You wouldn't be able to tell the difference. There is no experiment you could perform inside that sealed box to tell the two situations apart. That's fascinating. His profound insight. was to take this not as a coincidence, but as a deep physical truth. Standing on Earth feeling gravity is functionally identical to being accelerated.

Wait, so the sensation of weight isn't actually gravity pulling on you. It's just the solid ground violently pushing back up against you to stop you from following the natural curve of space time toward the center of the Earth. That is exactly it. Wow. Which provides a really elegant explanation for weightlessness, too. I mean, there is a persistent myth that astronauts aboard the International Space Station are floating because there is zero gravity in space. People say that all the time. But at their altitude, Earth's gravity is still around 90 % as strong as it is down here on the ground. They haven't

left gravity behind at all. They're floating because they are in free fall. The astronauts and their spacecraft are continuously plummeting toward Earth. But they never hit it. Right, because they're also moving sideways. incredibly fast, roughly 28 ,000 kilometers per hour. They are moving sideways so fast that as they fall downward, the curve of the earth falls away beneath them at the exact same rate. So they just keep missing the ground. They are falling forever without ever landing. Exactly. And because the ship is

falling at the exact same speed they are, there's no floor to push up against their feet to give them that sensation of weight. Remove the resistance of the ground and the physical sensation of gravity just disappears. Even though the geometry of spacetime is still doing all the work to keep them in that orbital freefall. Now that spacetime geometry doesn't just dictate how objects fall. It actively stretches things across distances. And we can see this happening gently here on Earth with our oceans. Right, the tides. Yeah.

The Moon exerts a gravitational pull on the Earth, but because gravity weakens with distance, the side of the Earth nearest to the Moon feels a measurably stronger pull than the far side of the Earth, which is roughly 12 ,000 kilometers further away. And this difference in strength across the diameter of the planet is called a differential force, or a tidal force. It literally stretches the Earth's oceans into an elongated shape, creating a bulge of water on the side of the Earth facing the Moon. That nearsight bulge makes intuitive sense. It does. But the

physics create a second, highly counterintuitive bulge of water on the exact opposite side of the Earth, facing away from the Moon. And that second bulge is a direct result of that differential force. How so? Well, the Moon pulls on the nearsight ocean the strongest. It pulls on the solid Earth in the middle slightly less. And it pulls on the farsight ocean the weakest. Okay, I follow. Because the solid Earth is pulled toward the moon more strongly than the far side water is, the solid Earth is essentially pulled away from

that far side water, leaving a second bulge behind. Oh, it's remarkably similar to stretching a piece of soft taffy. If you grab it in the middle and pull one side harder than the rest, the whole thing naturally elongates in both directions from the center. That's a perfect way to visualize it. And as the Earth rotates underneath these two bulges of water every day, coastlines crash into them, giving us two high tides and two low tides. And the sun contributes as well through the exact same mechanism. Oh, right. Solar tides. Yeah. When the sun and moon line up, Their forces

combine to make extra large spring tides, and when they are at right angles, they partly cancel each other out, making smaller neap tides. But that stretching effect we see with the tides isn't just limited to water. If you scale up the mass and the violence, say, two black holes colliding instead of just a moon orbiting, the differential force becomes so extreme that it stretches the actual fabric of the universe. The geometry itself stretches. Exactly, which leads us right into gravitational waves. This is one of the most incredible confirmations of

Einstein's general relativity in history. Back in 1916, Einstein predicted that when incredibly massive objects accelerate violently, they should send ripples through the curvature of space -time itself, spreading outward at the speed of light. Sort of similar to dropping a rock in a pond, but the pond is the four -dimensional universe. But Einstein himself thought these ripples would be far too faint to ever detect. I mean, by the time a wave from a distant cosmic event reaches Earth, it would stretch and squeeze space by an unimaginably tiny amount. He thought it was

practically impossible to measure. And yet the sources outline how we actually built an instrument capable of measuring it called LIGO, the Laser Interferometer Gravitational Wave Observatory. LIGO is an absolute marvel of engineering. To measure these microscopic stretches in spacetime, scientists built L -shaped vacuum tunnels that are four kilometers long. Four kilometers? Yeah. They fire a laser into a beam splitter, sending light down both tunnels simultaneously. The light bounces off mirrors at the ends and comes back

to meet in the middle. Okay. Under normal conditions, the light waves are perfectly aligned to cancel each other out. creating a dark signal. But when a gravitational wave passes through the Earth, it literally stretches space in one direction and squeezes it in the other. Exactly. For a fraction of a second, one of those four -kilometer tunnels becomes microscopically longer than the other. So the distance changes. Right. The laser beams travel slightly different distances, so when they meet back in the middle, they no longer perfectly cancel each other out. A flash of light

hits the detector. That is so smart. In September 2015, LIGO detected a stretch smaller than the width of a single proton caused by the collision of two black holes over a billion light years away. A fraction of a proton. Yes. It was a Nobel Prize winning discovery that allows us to literally hear the gravitational ripples of the universe without needing to look for visible light. I mean, measuring a fraction of a proton from a billion light years away using split lasers is awe -inspiring. But it brings up a major theoretical

wall. It definitely does. If relativity is incredibly precise enough to accomplish that, it sounds like Einstein gave us the perfect final rulebook for the universe. But reading through the theoretical frameworks in our sources, it becomes clear that we are absolutely not done here. We are not done at all. And this is the ultimate cliffhanger of modern physics. Why is that? Well, general relativity works flawlessly for the macrocosmos. but it completely catastrophically fails at the microscopic level. It does not play nicely with the other great pillar of modern physics, quantum

mechanics. And the conflict basically comes down to how differently the two theories view reality. Fundamentally different views, yeah. Quantum mechanics governs the other three forces, strong, weak, and electromagnetic, and it views the world as grainy and probabilistic. It dictates that forces are carried by... Tiny discrete particles like photons for light or, you know, theoretical gravitons for gravity. Right. Chunky little packets of energy. But general relativity describes gravity as the smooth, continuous, warping fabric of

space -time with infinitely sloping curves. And that fundamental incompatibility is where the math breaks down. Most of the time this isn't an issue. Because things don't usually overlap. Exactly. Things are either really massive like a star, so you use relativity. Or really tiny, like an atom, so you use quantum mechanics. But there are specific places in the universe where extreme mass and microscopic scales exist simultaneously. Like where? Namely, right at the center of a black hole and in the very first instant of the Big Bang. Oh, wow. And when physicists try to

combine the smooth, infinitely curving geometry of relativity with the discrete, grainy particles of quantum mechanics to understand those extreme environments, the equations literally fall apart. They spit out infinities. The math becomes absolute nonsense. It just doesn't work. No. Yeah. Our current theories simply cannot tell us what is happening inside a black hole because the smooth geometry of space -time refuses to align with the chunky reality. of quantum particles. So we basically have two wildly successful instruction

manuals for how the universe works, but they are written in completely different languages. And they refuse to talk to each other. Which is why physicists are trying to build candidate frameworks to unify them. The sources highlight string theory, which attempts to resolve the math by proposing that fundamental particles aren't tiny dots, but rather microscopic vibrating loops of energy. That's one approach, yeah. And there's also loop... quantum gravity, which suggests that spacetime itself isn't perfectly smooth, but is actually woven from tiny, discrete building blocks. Both are brilliant theoretical attempts

to smooth out those mathematical infinities, but we have to be completely honest here. They're just theories. Right. These frameworks are incredibly difficult to test with our current technology. Figuring out how to merge these two worlds into a functional theory of quantum gravity remains a genuinely unsolved frontier. So to bring this all back to where we started, the paradox of gravity is profound. We've gone from a simple kitchen magnet to the edge of the known universe. Quite a journey. We've seen how the absolute weakest force in nature manages to build galaxies,

keep astronauts in orbit, and stretch our oceans. And it does all of that simply through patience, a limitless reach, and the sheer mathematical power of never canceling itself out. It shapes the largest structures of reality across billions of light years, yet manages to hide its deepest mechanical secrets at the smallest scales imaginable. It really is amazing. And to wrap up this deep dive, I want to leave you with a mind bending thought to mull over. Building on that concept of loop quantum gravity we just talked about.

This is a fun one. If space time itself is truly made of tiny, discrete building blocks rather than a smooth, continuous fabric, does that mean the universe has a pixel resolution? Like a video game. Yeah. Meaning when you walk across a room to grab a glass of water, you aren't smoothly gliding through space, but you're actually jumping from one microscopic cosmic pixel to the next. Think about that the next time you pick up a fridge magnet and casually defeat the gravitational pull of an entire planet. Thank you so much for joining us on this deep dive.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Nanotechnology – Building at the Scale of Atoms

    Nov 19, 202626 minAudio

    Nanotechnology works at a scale where a nanometre is to a metre what a single centimetre is to the distance across a football field roughly a hundred thousand times over. This episode explains what nanotechnology...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Animal Migration – Navigation Without Maps

    Nov 17, 202625 minAudio

    A tagged bar-tailed godwit once flew more than thirteen thousand kilometres from Alaska to Tasmania without landing once. This episode explores why animals migrate at all, from godwits and humpback whales to monarch...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Space Weather – When the Sun Attacks Our Technology

    Nov 15, 202625 minAudio

    The Sun is an active, magnetic star, and every so often it hurls bursts of radiation and clouds of charged particles toward Earth, a phenomenon called space weather. This episode explains solar flares and coronal mass...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Tsunamis – Waves That Cross Oceans

    Nov 12, 202623 minAudio

    An ordinary wave rolls onto the sand every few seconds; a tsunami can take tens of minutes between crests and cross an entire ocean at the speed of a jet aircraft while barely rippling the surface. This episode explains...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Symmetry – Physics' Deepest Idea

    Nov 10, 202620 minAudio

    A folded square of paper and a butterfly's wings share the same simple visual idea: a shape that looks the same after some transformation. This episode follows that idea from everyday geometry into the deepest...

    Credit the people on this episode