Stand under a leafy tree during a partial solar eclipse and something strange happens to the ground: instead of round blobs of sunlight, you get hundreds of tiny crescents, every gap between the leaves quietly turning into a pinhole camera. This episode explains why solar and lunar eclipses happen at all, unpacks the extraordinary coincidence of size and distance that makes total eclipses possible, and traces the science from ancient eclipse records through to the 1919 expedition that helped confirm Einstein's general relativity. You'll come away understanding the difference between solar and lunar eclipses, why eclipses don't happen every month, what the saros cycle is, what actually happens during totality, how a solar eclipse once helped prove one of the twentieth century's biggest scientific ideas, and how to watch one safely. Talking Science is sponsored by Kinsoft. Visit www.kinsoft.com.au Further reading: NASA - eclipse science and safety pages; Royal Astronomical Society of New Zealand and Astronomical Society of Australia - public eclipse guides; Nature - historical coverage of the 1919 Eddington eclipse expedition; Bureau of Meteorology and Geoscience Australia - public astronomy resources.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
So I want you to picture yourself on a just a really warm, lazy afternoon. You're sitting right under this large leafy tree. Oh, nice. Setting the scene. Right. And if you look down at the footpath around you, you'll see what you always see under a tree on a sunny day. Just thousands of those ordinary scattered round patches of dappled light filtering down through the canopy. Yeah, totally mundane. everyday physics exactly it's a completely mundane site but now picture that exact same afternoon that same tree but
uh during a partial solar eclipse oh things get weird they get so weird the moon has just taken a little bite out of the sun's disc up in the sky right and if you look down at the footpath now suddenly All those patches of light are not round anymore. Not at all. Every single gap between the leaves above you has completely transformed. You are looking at a footpath scattered with thousands of tiny repeated crescents. It's honestly one of the most beautiful accidental science demonstrations in all of nature. Right, because it is a perfect miniature copy of whatever shape
the sun currently is, just repeated over and over again on the ground. Yeah, and nobody arranged those leaves to do that. You know, it happens purely because of a phenomenon known as the pinhole camera effect. OK, so break that down for us. For anyone who hasn't encountered that term before, what is a pinhole camera? Well, it's a very simple optical trick, really. When light passes through a remarkably small opening. like the tiny gaps between overlapping leaves, that opening actually acts like a simple optical lens. Wow. Yeah. It takes the light from the source, which in this
case is the sun, and faithfully projects an inverted image of that source onto whatever surface happens to be behind it. So the ground. So instead of just letting a generic, you know. blob of light through, the leaves are literally acting as thousands of tiny natural movie projectors. That's a great way to put it. Yeah. They're beaming the live status of the sun directly onto the dirt. Which is really the perfect entry point for what we are exploring today, because an eclipse itself is, I mean, it's really just a much grander version
of that exact same basic idea. It really is. And the goal for this deep dive is to take an unhurried walk through the mathematically precise shadow play of eclipses. I love that. Shadow play. Yeah. We're going to explore the geometry that makes them possible, the history of how early humans figured out the patterns, and just the sheer visceral mechanics. of these cosmic alignments. Well, to really understand that grand shadow play, we have to zoom out from that tree for a second and look at the solar system as a whole. Okay, zooming out. An eclipse, fundamentally,
is just one object in space blocking light on its way to another object. It's casting a shadow shaped by very simple geometry. Right, and there are two main types, solar and lunar. And the difference basically comes down to which object is doing the blocking. Exactly. So in a solar eclipse, the moon steps between the sun and earth. The moon's shadow falls on us. But in a lunar eclipse, Earth steps between the sun and the moon, and our massive shadow falls onto the lunar surface. Right. But if we start with solar eclipses, there is this fundamental question of scale that
always kind of blows my mind. But the perfect fit. Yes. When you look up during a total solar eclipse, the moon seems to perfectly, exactly cover the sun. It's not too big, not too small. Does the math just happen to work out that they are physically the same size? Oh, not even close. The sun is massive. I mean, it is roughly 400 times wider than the moon. 400 times. Yeah, but there's this staggering geometric coincidence at play here. The sun is also, on average, roughly 400 times further away from Earth than the moon
is. Wait, let me make sure I'm visualizing this correctly. So it would be like holding a tiny little coin right at arm's length and realizing that this tiny coin perfectly covers up a massive dinner plate that somebody's holding all the way on the other side of a long room. That is precisely how it works. When you multiply those two facts together, the 400 times width and the 400 times distance, you get this extraordinary visual trick. It's like an optical illusion built into the solar system. Exactly. Seen from our vantage point here on Earth, The sun and the
moon appear to be almost exactly the same size in the sky. They are so perfectly matched that during a total solar eclipse, the moon can precisely cover the sun's bright disk. No more. And no less. Which, I mean, that raises the question of why. Is there some gravitational law or, I don't know, physics rule that mandates this exact ratio in planetary systems? Yeah, and that's the wild part. As far as anyone in astronomy or astrophysics can tell, there is absolutely no known physical reason why those two objects
have to line up this neatly. Wait, really? It's just random. It is simply a pure coincidence of how our particular solar system happened to form. That is wild. Well, this perfect match isn't even a permanent fixture. Because the moon isn't stationary, right? Like it's slowly drifting. Exactly. The moon is gradually moving away from Earth over these extremely long time scales, which means that total eclipses, as we experience them right now, are a temporary feature. Wow. Yeah. In the very long run of our planet's multi
-billion year history, this... Perfect alignment is just a passing phase. We just happen to exist during the exact right window of time to see it. Okay, so we have this perfect temporary alignment. But the moon is orbiting the Earth, completing a lap roughly once a month, right? Correct. And it passes between us and the sun during every single new moon phase. Right, exactly. So if it's passing between us and the sun every single month, why aren't we plunged into darkness every 30 days? Right, that's the obvious question. And it all comes down to what you could call
orbital fussiness. Orbital fussiness, I like that. The key is that the moon's orbit is not perfectly flat relative to Earth's orbit. Okay. If you imagine the flat plane that the Earth travels on as it orbits the sun. Astronomers call this flat plane the ecliptic. Ecliptic, right. Yeah. So the moon's orbit around Earth doesn't sit perfectly level on that ecliptic. It is actually tilted by about five degrees. Okay, so if I picture like two hula hoops, one inside the other. Like an analogy. The outer hula hoop is the Earth going around the sun.
And the inner hula hoop is the moon going around the Earth. But the inner one is just slightly tipped. Yes. So most of the time, the edges just don't actually line up. Exactly. I mean, five degrees sounds pretty negligible, right? But in the vastness of space, it is huge. Right, because of the distance. Exactly. It's more than enough that during most months, when the new moon passes in front of the sun, from our perspective, it actually passes slightly above the sun. you know slightly below it so it just misses the mark completely yeah his shadow gets cast out
into empty space completely missing earth what actually has to happen for the shadow to hit us then well for an eclipse to occur a new moon has to happen very close to what astronomers call nodes yeah nodes these are the exact specific intersection points where that tilted lunar orbit physically crosses the flat plane of the Earth's orbit. So you need the moon to be at the new moon phase, and you need it to be sitting right at one of those precise intersection nodes. That's why eclipses are these rare, geometrically fussy
events, and not just a monthly routine. Right. But even when they do hit those nodes and cast a shadow on Earth, the shadow doesn't always look the same, right? Like, we don't always get a total eclipse. Right, exactly. Sometimes we get an annular eclipse or a partial one. But if the ratio of the sun and moon size is so perfect, like we just talked about, what causes those variations? That comes down to another slight imperfection in the system. The moon's orbit isn't a perfect circle. It is slightly elliptical, meaning it's a bit oval -shaped. Oh, I see. So
the physical distance between the Earth and the moon actually changes a bit throughout the month. When the moon happens to be at its closest point to Earth during one of those node alignments, it appears very slightly larger in our sky. And that's what gives us a total solar eclipse. Yes. The moon completely covers the sun's disk, plunging the area beneath the shadow into that eerie, temporary daytime darkness. But if the moon happens to be on the further end of that oval orbit when it crosses the node, then it appears very slightly smaller in the sky. So it isn't quite big enough
to cover the whole solar disk. Right. And this is what creates an annular eclipse. People often call it a ring of fire. Oh, yeah, the ring of fire. Those pictures are incredible. They really are. Because a brilliant, thin ring of actual sunlight remains visible around the dark silhouette of the moon the entire time. And a partial eclipse would just be when the alignment isn't perfectly dead center? Exactly. Or maybe the observer on Earth is standing off to the side, you know, in the outer weaker part of the moon shadow. The moon only covers a chunk of the sun. Which
brings us right back to our opening under the tree, producing all those little crescent shapes on the footpath. Full circle. Yeah, it's all dictated by distance and angles. And because this geometry operates basically like clockwork, it is incredibly predictable once you actually know the mechanics. Right. But early humans didn't know the mechanics. No, they definitely did not. I mean, before we understood elliptical orbits and five degree tilts, an eclipse must have been deeply, deeply unsettling. Just imagine you're going about your day and the sun just gets eaten by a black void. It would be terrifying. There's
actually an old Chinese legend about two court astronomers, Hai and Hou, and they were supposedly executed for failing to predict an eclipse and warn the emperor in time. Oh, wow. High stakes. Right. And whether that's folklore or hard history, it really illustrates how early societies viewed these events. They weren't fun science demonstrations. They were terrifying omens that demanded an urgent official response. And because ancient astronomers were so heavily motivated to see these omens coming, They started noticing patterns. Because
their lives literally depended on it. Exactly. Even without knowing the underlying physics, they realized eclipses weren't entirely random. And this led to the discovery of the Saros Cycle. Okay, the Saros Cycle. How does that cycle actually work? It is a marvel of early human observation. It is a period of very close to 18 years, 11 days, and 8 hours. 18 years, 11 days, and 8 hours. That is very specific. Extremely specific. And after that exact amount of time, the sun, the
earth, and the moon return to a nearly identical relative geometric arrangement. Because of this, a very similar eclipse will recur. But the extra 8 hours is the catch, though, right? Because 8 hours is a third of a day. meaning the Earth has rotated a third of the way around its axis since the last eclipse. And you nailed it. So the shadow will fall on a completely different part of the globe. Exactly right. And the reason the Saro cycle works at all is because it represents the precise moment when three completely separate lunar rhythms happen to sync up simultaneously.
Wow, okay. Yeah. You have the time it takes the moon to return to the same phase. You have the time it takes the moon to return to the same node, you know, that intersection point in its tilted orbit. And you have the time it takes the moon to return to the same distance from Earth in its oval -shaped orbit. So it's like having three different ticking clocks, all with slightly different lengths, and just waiting for the exact moment they all chime at the same second. That is a perfect analogy. What stands out to me is that Babylonian, Chinese, and Greek observers figured this out through... Through
sheer brute force pattern spotting. It's incredible. They kept meticulous records over centuries just to predict these events, long before they understood gravity or orbits. Though, you know, we should give credit where it's due. The Greek philosopher Anaxagoras actually did correctly guess the geometry way back in the 5th century BCE. Wait, really? The 5th century BCE? Yeah. He argued that a solar eclipse was just the moon passing in front of the sun. It was a strikingly modern explanation
for an ancient world that still largely relied on mythology. That is amazing. But if Anaxagoras was the start of understanding eclipses, the absolute pinnacle of eclipse science has to be 1919. Oh, absolutely. Because this is the moment a shadow literally changed how we understand the fabric of the universe. You're referring to Arthur Eddington's expedition. Yes. In May of 1919, the British astronomer Arthur Eddington led teams to the island of Principe off West Africa and to Sobral in Brazil, specifically to observe a total solar eclipse. But he wasn't
there to study the eclipse itself, though, right? No, not at all. He was using the eclipse as a tool to test a brand new, highly controversial theory published by Albert Einstein. General relativity. Precisely. Einstein's theory proposed something totally radical. that massy objects like our sun actually bend the physical fabric of space and time around them. Which sounds completely wild. It sounded absurd to a lot of people. But because of that bent space, Einstein predicted that light traveling from distant stars should be deflected or bent very slightly as it passed
close to the heavy mass of the sun on its way to our eyes here on Earth. Right, but the problem with testing that... on a normal tuesday is that you can't just look at stars right next to the sun no definitely not the sun's glare is blinding the sky is bright blue and the stars are completely invisible which is why totality is so crucial for this during those few minutes of a total solar eclipse the sun's bright disk is completely blocked by the moon the sky goes dark suddenly
stars close to the sun's position in the sky become briefly visible right in the middle of the day. It's like turning off the lights in a room so you can see out the window. Exactly. So Eddington's team photographed those stars during the eclipse. Then they compared those photos against photos of the exact same stars taken months earlier at night when the sun was nowhere near them. And when they developed those photos, the stars in the eclipse image appeared to have shifted. Yes. They had moved by almost the exact amount that Einstein's math predicted.
The sheer mass of the sun had bent the light passing by it. It's just phenomenal. A shadow lasting just a few minutes provided the perfect natural laboratory to prove that space -time is flexible. I mean... It established relativity as serious, tested physics. It is a beautiful convergence of events. Yeah. It really highlights just how uniquely valuable totality is for science. And beyond the science, the experience of totality itself is described as just a genuinely startling, bizarre sensory event. Oh, it is. It's profoundly
weird. It's not just that the sky gets a bit dark, right? In the minutes leading up to totality, the quality of the light fundamentally changes. It flattens out. Yes, it flattens. Shadows sharpen in a way that feels incredibly unnatural. You can actually feel the temperature measurably drop as the sunlight is suddenly cut off. And then for anywhere from a few seconds to maybe seven minutes, totality sets in. And to understand what you're seeing in that specific moment, we need to define two distinct parts of the sun. Okay. First, there's the photosphere. That is
the sun's bright, normally visible disk. It's the blinding surface we're used to seeing. Right, the part that hurts to look at. Exactly. During totality, that photosphere is completely blocked. And because it's blocked, something normally invisible is unveiled. The corona. The corona being the sun's atmosphere. Right. It is this wispy pale halo of extremely hot, extremely thin plasma that extends millions of kilometers out into space from the sun's surface. And it's always there, isn't it? It is always there. Under normal
daylight conditions, it's happening right now. But it is roughly a million times dimmer than the photosphere. It is just... utterly overwhelmed by the glare so totality removes the glare and the corona appears exactly and for a huge chunk of the 20th century a total eclipse was basically the only practical way for scientists to study the corona at all it's that dramatic reveal that drives you know eclipse chasers to travel the globe heading to isolated places like xmith in western australia in 2023 or like preparing for
sydney in july 2028 oh yeah they plan years in advance they are chasing these fleeting visual phenomena that only happen for seconds, like Bailey's beads. Oh, Bailey's beads are spectacular. They occur just before and just after totality. What causes them? Well, the moon doesn't have a perfectly smooth edge, right? It is covered in mountains and deep valleys. Oh, right. So right at the edge of alignment, sunlight streams through those deep lunar valleys, breaking up into a scatter of brilliant, distinct points of light around the moon's silhouette. It looks
like a string of glowing lamps. And then as the very last bead fades right before totality, or as the very first one reappears after, you get what is called the diamond ring effect. Yes, the classic diamond ring. It is one single intense glowing point of light attached to this pale ring. It is arguably the most photographed moment of any eclipse. Oh, without a doubt. And while you're watching this, birds are suddenly falling silent, insects start chirping thinking it's night, and you might even see shadow bands. Shadow
bands are such a strange phenomenon. They are these fast -moving, rippling patterns of light and shadow that can race across pale, flat surfaces right around totality. Like ripples at the bottom of a pool. Yes. Exactly like that. They're caused by that tiny remaining sliver of sunlight being refracted unevenly by turbulence in Earth's own atmosphere. That is so cool. Okay, so if the moon's shadow causes all this daytime drama, what happens when we reverse the geometry? Let's talk about lunar eclipses. The lunar reverse.
Right. Earth steps into the middle, and it's our massive shadow blocking the sunlight from hitting the full moon. The immediate question is... If the Earth is completely blocking the sun, why doesn't the moon just go pitch black? That's a great question. Why does it turn that famous deep coppery red, you know, the blood moon? The answer to that lies in our own planet's atmosphere through a process called Rayleigh scattering. Okay, walk us through how Rayleigh scattering turns a dark shadow red. Sure. So as sunlight travels toward Earth, it hits our
atmosphere. And our atmosphere acts like a lens and a filter combined. It bends some of that light inward. toward the shadow behind Earth. But as it does this, it filters out the shorter, bluer wavelengths of light. This exact scattering of blue light is actually the reason our daytime sky looks blue to us down on the ground. Because the blue light gets trapped and scattered around in the atmosphere. Exactly. So if the atmosphere scatters away all the blue light, what's left to pass through? The longer wavelengths. The reds and oranges. Yes. The reds, the oranges.
The coppery colors. This reddish light survives the trip through the edges of Earth's atmosphere, gets bent into our shadow by refraction, and falls squarely onto the moon's surface. So the Earth's atmosphere is basically acting like a giant cosmic color filter. Pretty much. It tosses out the blue light and it bends the reddish light from the edges of the Earth. It's projecting the collective light of all the world's sunsets and sunrises onto the moon at the exact same time. That is an incredibly accurate way to describe it. A blood moon is quite literally illuminated by every sunset and sunrise happening on Earth
in that specific moment. That is almost poetic. It really is. And what makes lunar eclipses so accessible is their scale. Earth's shadow is massive compared to the moon. Right. So when a lunar eclipse happens, you don't have to travel to a tiny specific path like you do for a total solar eclipse. A lunar eclipse is visible to the entire nighttime hemisphere of Earth simultaneously. And it lasts for hours, not minutes. You literally just walk outside and look up, which actually brings us to a really critical safety point here.
Yes, very important. Looking at a lunar eclipse is perfectly safe. Looking at a solar eclipse, however, requires understanding a very real biological danger. We have to be very direct about this. Looking directly at the sun at any point during a partial solar eclipse or even during the partial phases leading up to and following totality is intensely dangerous to your eyesight. Even if the sun looks dimmer or a large chunk of it is missing? the invisible radiation is still hitting your eye. And the scariest part is that you won't feel it happening. No, you won't. The retina,
which is the light -sensitive tissue at the back of your eye, has absolutely no pain receptors. None. So you just don't feel it burning. Exactly. This means you can literally burn permanent blind spots into your vision without feeling a single thing while the damage is occurring. The damage is silent and it is permanent. And regular sunglasses don't help, right? Ordinary sunglasses, regardless of how dark or how expensive they are, offer zero protection against this specific kind of solar radiation. So to view a partial solar eclipse
safely... You must use purpose -built certified solar filters, you know, the specific cardboard eclipse glasses with international safety ratings. Yes. Or you go back to where we started this deep dive, indirect viewing. You make a pinhole projector with a piece of card and you safely watch the projection on the ground, just like the leaves do. There is one and only one genuine exception to this rule. And that's totality. Yes. The brief window of 100 % totality. Only when the sun's bright disk is completely, totally
covered by the moon does it become safe and truly spectacular to look directly at the Carina with the naked eye. But you have to be absolutely certain totality has begun. Exactly. And the second that diamond ring flashes and the sun starts to reappear, the protective filters must go straight back on. It requires care, but the payoff of seeing the corona is apparently just life -changing. It's unparalleled. So, as we wrap up our journey through the shadows today, I want to bring you back to that warm afternoon. Put yourself back under that leafy tree. Right
back where we started. The next time you find yourself standing under a canopy on an ordinary sunny afternoon, remember what is actually happening. Every single gap in the leaves above you is quietly acting as a camera, faithfully tracing the truth of the cosmos right onto the ground at your feet, whether anything unusual is happening up there or not. It is a quiet, ongoing record of our solar system's mechanics. But, you know, understanding these incredibly precise mechanics opens up one final, fascinating reality to think about. Oh,
what's that? We talked earlier about how the moon is gradually moving away from the Earth, right? Right, the slow drift. Because of that drift, We know that one day, millions of years from now, the moon will be too far away to ever fully cover the sun's disk. Total eclipses will simply cease to exist on Earth. Wow. Future beings will only ever see partial or annular eclipses, never a total one. That's sort of heartbreaking, but also amazing. It really is. And it invites a pretty profound question. What other temporary cosmic masterpieces are we just taking for granted
right now, simply because our tiny slice of human history happened to align perfectly with the clockwork of the universe? Something to mull over the next time you're standing in the shade.
Nanotechnology works at a scale where a nanometre is to a metre what a single centimetre is to the distance across a football field roughly a hundred thousand times over. This episode explains what nanotechnology...
A tagged bar-tailed godwit once flew more than thirteen thousand kilometres from Alaska to Tasmania without landing once. This episode explores why animals migrate at all, from godwits and humpback whales to monarch...
The Sun is an active, magnetic star, and every so often it hurls bursts of radiation and clouds of charged particles toward Earth, a phenomenon called space weather. This episode explains solar flares and coronal mass...
An ordinary wave rolls onto the sand every few seconds; a tsunami can take tens of minutes between crests and cross an entire ocean at the speed of a jet aircraft while barely rippling the surface. This episode explains...
A folded square of paper and a butterfly's wings share the same simple visual idea: a shape that looks the same after some transformation. This episode follows that idea from everyday geometry into the deepest...