Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Talking Science

Talking Science artwork

Nuclear Power – Splitting the Atom

Jul 22, 202622 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Nuclear power is one of the most emotionally charged technologies we have - associated in many minds with disaster and weapons, yet it quietly produces vast amounts of low-carbon electricity. We explain how splitting atoms makes power, look honestly at the accidents and the waste, put the real risks in context, and lay out the genuine case for and against without taking a side. You'll come away understanding what nuclear fission is, how a reactor is controlled, what actually happened at the famous accidents, why the waste problem is real but smaller than it feels, and why reasonable people land on opposite conclusions. Talking Science is sponsored by Kinsoft. Visit www.kinsoft.com.au Further reading: World Nuclear Association information library; IAEA resources; “Our World in Data” energy and safety comparisons.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

What if I told you that the energy source humanity is most terrified, the one that conjures up all those images of glowing apocalyptic wastelands and, you know, mutant monsters, has actually saved millions of lives by quietly preventing invisible air pollution? It sounds totally contradictory, right? But it's true. It really is. Today, we are opening the ultimate Pandora's box in this deep dive. We're talking about nuclear power. We're stripping away the politics, looking at the raw physics and answering the questions you

actually care about without needing a Ph .D. to follow along. And honestly, it is the perfect topic for us to dig into today because there is well, there's virtually no middle ground in the public imagination when it comes to nuclear energy. It's usually framed as either this like utopian clean energy savior that will rescue us from a warming climate or. Or it's a ticking time bomb just waiting to render a continent uninhabitable. Exactly. There's no in between. OK, let's unpack this, because right out of the gate, we need to set some ground rules for you listening. Neither of us is taking a political

or ideological side today. Like at all. Our mission in this deep dive is simply to impartially report on the factual physics, the historical data and the very honest tradeoffs of this technology. We are laying out the ledger, you know, the cold, hard pros and cons so that you sitting there right now have the actual mechanisms and facts to do your own weighing up. And that approach is just so vital. Because nuclear power is, I mean, it's the ultimate example of a subject where thoughtful, well -informed people can look

at the exact same set of physical facts and reach completely opposite conclusions. Right, because the science is what it is. Exactly. The raw data of how a reactor works doesn't change, but how human beings interpret the risk of that data well, that changes drastically based on what we inherently value and what we fear. So before we can even begin to debate the safety or the politics or, you know, the environmental footprint. We really have to start at the foundation. We need to understand the extraordinary, almost unbelievable mechanics of where this energy actually comes from. Yeah, we have to start with the atom.

And we are going to take this nice and slow because the physics here are, I mean, they're mind -boggling when you really look at them. They really are. So everything in the universe, the device you are listening to this on, the air in the room, your own body, it's all made of atoms. And at the very center of every single atom is this tiny, incredibly dense core called a nucleus. It's like the heavy architectural center of the atom, basically. Precisely. And inside that nucleus, you have a cluster of particles. And for our

purposes today, we really only care about the neutral ones, which are called neutrons. Now, most atoms are perfectly stable. They just exist. But in certain very heavy, massive atoms, the nucleus is large and just a little bit jittery. Like unstable. Yeah, just a little bit unstable. And uranium is the... absolute workhorse here if you take a specific type of uranium atom and you fire a single stray neutron at it like a microscopic bowling ball hitting a pin the nucleus can actually split right into just cracks down the middle It does. And this specific process

is called nuclear fission. And whenever you hear that word fission, don't let it intimidate you. It's a heavy sci -fi word, though. It sounds like it. But it simply means splitting. Nuclear fission is literally just splitting the nucleus. But here is the magical part. When that nucleus splits, two vital things happen. First, it releases a massive burst of energy. Okay, why? Because if you put the two new broken pieces on a scale, they actually weigh very... slightly less than the original whole atom did. Wait, mass just

vanishes? Like, where does it go? It doesn't vanish, it transforms. That tiny, almost imperceptible amount of missing mass is converted directly into pure energy. And because the speed of light is squared in that famous Einstein equation you've probably heard of, even a microscopic amount of mass equals an astronomical amount of energy. Wow. Right. And the second thing that happens when it splits is that it spits out a few more loose neutrons. Oh, I see. And those extra loose neutrons are the spark for the whole engine because they go flying off and they slam into other neighboring

uranium atoms, which then split. release their own burst of energy, and spit out more neutrons, which hit more atoms and so on. You've got it. It creates a chain reaction. That chain reaction is the entire reason nuclear power is worth all the extreme engineering trouble. The energy locked inside that nucleus is millions of times denser than the energy found in, you know, normal chemical bonds. When you think about our traditional power sources, it really puts this into perspective. Because we are so used to burning things for

power. Wood, natural gas, coal. But if I'm getting this right, burning a lump of coal is really just like lightly rearranging the outer furniture of an atom, its electrons, its surface -level chemistry. But splitting a nucleus, that is tapping into the mighty architectural foundation of the universe itself. The scale of it is just hard to wrap my head around. That is a brilliant way to picture it. You are bypassing the furniture and striking the very foundation. And the math completely reflects that reality. A single kilogram of uranium fuel can release as much energy as

millions of kilograms of coal. A kilogram? That's what, roughly the weight of a bag of apples at the grocery store, equaling massive freight trains full of coal. Yeah, that absurd energy density is the entire appeal of the industry. You get enormous, continuous, reliable power from a comically tiny amount of physical fuel. And crucially, because you are splitting atoms instead of setting fire to carbon, there is absolutely zero carbon dioxide produced by the reaction itself. Okay, I understand the splitting atom. The chain reaction

makes sense. But how do we actually capture that foundation -shaking energy and turn it into electricity to charge my phone or power a city? Because the engineering always sounds impossibly futuristic, but the text says the actual mechanism is basically, well, a kettle. A very sophisticated multi -billion dollar kettle. Yes. The whole art of a nuclear power station is just controlling that atomic chain reaction so it ticks over steadily generating a tremendous consistent amount of heat. So we're just making heat. Exactly. That heat is transferred to water. The water boils and creates high pressure

steam. The steam is pushed through pipes to spin a giant fan blade called a turbine and that spinning turbine spins a magnetic generator which creates electricity. Wait, so the back half of a nuclear plant is exactly the same as a 19th century coal plant. Just steam spinning a wheel. Fundamentally identical. The only difference is the furnace. Instead of lighting coal on fire to boil the water, we are splitting uranium atoms to boil the water. Okay, but this raises the exact question that terrifies people. Here's where it gets really interesting. If we are relying on a chain reaction

of splitting atoms, throwing off neutrons that split more atoms in a compounding loop, why doesn't this sophisticated kettle just detonate? like a nuclear bomb? It is the most natural question in the world. Everyone wonders that. And what's fascinating here is that a nuclear detonation in a commercial power reactor is actually physically impossible. Like it literally cannot happen by the very laws of physics. I have to stop you there because the public perception is absolutely that these places are ticking bombs. Why is it physically impossible? What is the actual difference

between the reactor and a weapon? So think of weaponized bomb -grade uranium, like a pile of highly explosive dry gunpowder packed tightly into a sealed steel barrel. The explosive atoms are highly concentrated or enriched to force a runaway instantaneous explosion. Okay, all packed together. Right. But reactor fuel is fundamentally different. It is barely enriched at all. It would be like taking that dry gunpowder, mixing it with huge buckets of sand, and spreading it out over a wet lawn. It can absolutely burn, and

it can... generate a lot of heat, but a chain reaction explosion is physically impossible. The atoms simply aren't packed densely enough to detonate. Ah, so the fuel itself is just the wrong recipe for an explosion. Exactly, the wrong recipe. And beyond the fuel, a reactor has physical brakes. They use what are called control rods. These are long rods made of specific materials like boron or cadmium that absolutely love to soak up neutrons. Think of them like a sponge soaking up water. If the reactor is getting too hot, The human operators, or the automated safety

systems, slide these control rods down into the core. The rods absorb those bouncing neutrons, starving the chain reaction and slowing it right down. If they need more power, they pull the rods up a little bit, letting the neutrons fly freely again. You literally steer the heat of the reactor by sliding these metallic sponges in and out. Yeah. Okay, you've convinced me a commercial reactor can't detonate like a nuclear weapon. The physics don't allow it. But I watched the news in 2011. And I know Chernobyl blew a literal hole in the roof in the 1980s. Yeah.

If the physics don't allow a nuclear explosion, what exactly blew up? We absolutely have to talk about the accidents because dread of these specific events drives the entire global conversation on this. Let's start with Chernobyl in the Soviet Union in 1986 because it is the ultimate. Worst case scenario, it was not a nuclear detonation. It was a massive steam explosion. Steam. It blew the thousand ton roof off the reactor with just steam. Yes, because Chernobyl utilized a fundamentally

flawed reactor design that simply wouldn't be legally allowed to operate in most of the world today. In a standard modern reactor, if the cooling water boils away, the nuclear chain reaction naturally slows down. The physics inherently pumped the brakes. Right, the water is part of the process. Exactly. But Chernobyl's specific design had a fatal flaw. If the water turned to steam, the nuclear reaction actually stood up. Wow, that sounds incredibly dangerous. It was wildly dangerous. And then you add to that flawed design a catastrophic human element. The operators were running a highly reckless late

-night test, overriding and actively disabling the automated safety systems. Yeah. The reactor surged, the water instantly flashed into steam, and the immense pressure of that expanding steam blew the reactor apart. It then caught fire, spreading radioactive material across Europe. It killed dozens of plant workers and first responders directly, and is estimated to have caused additional cancer deaths in the population over time. So a perfect storm of bad engineering and terrible human judgment. But what about the accidents

in democracies with strict regulations, like Three Mile Island in the United States in 1979? Right. At Three Mile Island, a reactor did partially melt down due to equipment malfunction and operator confusion. But the crucial mechanism to understand there is containment. American reactors were built inside massive reinforced concrete and steel domes designed to hold in pressure and radiation if everything went wrong. And did it work? It did. The core melted, but that containment structure did its job. It held. Essentially, no measurable physical harm came to the public.

It was a financial disaster for the operating company, obviously, but it was not a public health disaster. Okay, but then you have Fukushima. in Japan in 2011, and that was a modern high -tech society. Futushima is a vital case study, but it was triggered by an unprecedented natural disaster. A massive historic earthquake and a subsequent tsunami breached the sea walls and flooded the plant. Now the reactors actually shut down automatically when the earthquake hit. The control rods dropped in, fission stopped. Wait, if the splitting stopped, why did it melt

down? Because of something called decay heat, even when you completely stop the chain reaction, the radioactive byproducts left behind in the fuel rods are still intensely hot. It's like turning off an electric stove. The burner is still hot enough to burn you long after the dial is at zero. Right. That makes sense. Those fuel rods need a constant flow of fresh cooling water for days after a shutdown. But the tsunami flooded the backup diesel generators. Without power, they couldn't pump the water. The water boiled away. The rods overheated. they melted. But the

outcome of Fukushima is where our assumptions really get challenged, because the death toll from that event was horrific. The death toll from the tsunami was horrific. Upwards of nearly 20 ,000 people died from the wall of water. But strikingly, the radiation released from the Fukushima reactor meltdowns is thought to have directly killed very few, if any, people. Really? I have to push back there? Yeah. You're saying a triple reactor meltdown didn't cause the massive death toll we associate with that disaster? It did not. The tragedy of the nuclear element of Fukushima is that the frantic, panicked evacuation of hospitals

and nursing homes caused significant real harm. Moving highly vulnerable people rapidly in the chaotic wake of a natural disaster resulted in numerous deaths. The psychological terror of the radiation caused far more immediate human damage than the physical radiation itself. Psychological mismatch is so stark. It feels perfectly aligned with our fear of flying versus driving. We get into our cars every single day without a second thought, even though the statistics clearly show driving is incredibly dangerous. But we get on

a commercial flight, which is mathematically one of the safest environments on Earth, and we grip the armrests in absolute terror because we are picturing a dramatic named disaster. A plane crash makes global news, but a car crash doesn't. If we connect this to the bigger picture, that flying versus driving analogy is perfectly mirrored in how we view energy. If you tally up the actual documented deaths per unit of energy produced over the last several decades, nuclear power turns out to be one of the statistically safest sources of power humanity has ever invented.

Wait, safer than fossil fuels? Oh, it is vastly safer. Nuclear safety record is essentially comparable to wind and solar power. Meanwhile, oil, gas, and especially coal quietly kill massive numbers of people. every single year. Through air pollution. Exactly. The World Health Organization attributes millions of premature deaths annually to respiratory illnesses caused by air pollution, which is heavily driven by burning fossil fuels. But those deaths don't come in a sudden terrifying event with breaking news coverage. It's a quiet, invisible,

daily pollution. So we just accept it. We don't fear it the way we fear a reactor accident. All right, let's assume the safety statistics hold up. Let's assume the day -to -day operation is incredibly safe. There is still a giant glowing elephant in the room that makes even the most data -driven people uncomfortable. The waste. The thousand -year trash. Because fission leaves behind radioactive byproducts that remain dangerously lethal for tens of thousands of years. It just feels inherently irresponsible to create a substance that must be safely isolated for longer than

human civilization has even existed. It is a profound geological scale responsibility, no doubt about it. But if we're looking at the honest ledger, we have to contextualize that waste with two crucial facts. First, the sheer physical volume. Because uranium is so insanely energy dense, the actual amount of waste left over is remarkably small. How small are we talking? All of the high -level radioactive waste produced by a major country's entire fleet of nuclear power plants over several decades can fit into a surprisingly modest space. Like a single warehouse.

Hold on. You say it fits in a warehouse, but that feels like a statistical trick to minimize it. It might be small in volume, but it's highly toxic for millennia. How is it somehow better just because it takes up less physical space? Because being small and solid means you can physically contain it, monitor it, and control it. Compare that to a coal or gas plant. They don't store their waste in a warehouse. They pour billions of tons of invisible planet warming carbon dioxide directly into our atmosphere, permanently altering

the global climate. The nuclear industry is entirely unique because it physically contains and financially accounts for every single ounce of its own waste. Okay, I see the distinction. One is solid and contained, the other is gaseous and dumped in the sky. But what is the actual solution for the radioactive rods? We can't just leave them sitting in a heavily guarded warehouse for 10 ,000 years. The technical solution is a scientific consensus deep geological storage. You take the spent fuel, you seal it inside incredibly robust, multi -layered containers made of vitrified glass,

thick copper, and cast iron. Then you bury it deep underground in geologically quiet rock formations. So just burying it. But carefully. We are talking about bedrock that hasn't shifted, fractured, or seen groundwater flow in hundreds of millions of years. Out of sight. Deep below the biosphere. Exactly. And countries like Finland are literally building these permanent repositories right now. The hurdles to nuclear waste storage haven't really been technical or scientific. They have been almost entirely social and political. You know, the whole not in my backyard sentiment.

Which brings up a great point about where we go from here. Because if the hurdles are massive costs, long build times and political opposition, how does the industry survive? What is the live frontier of this technology? The focus right now is shrinking the scale. The industry is developing what are called small modular reactors or SMRs. The idea being that instead of spending 15 years building a massive custom designed $10 billion cathedral of a power plant, you build smaller standardized reactors on an assembly line. Right.

You build them in a factory, ship them on a truck and plug them in. It aims to solve the staggering financial costs. But crucially, SMRs are engineered with a massive leap forward in physics called passive safety. How does that work? How is it different from the pumps at Fukushima? So remember how Fukushima failed because the backup diesel pumps lost power and couldn't circulate the cooling water? Right. The tsunami knocked them out. Passive safety designs don't rely on electronic pumps or human intervention. They rely on the unchangeable laws of physics, like gravity and natural heat

convection. Hot water naturally rises. Cold water naturally sinks. If a passive SMR loses all power and every human operator walks away, the reactor is designed to automatically cool itself through this natural circulation of water. safely shutting down without a single pump ever turning on. Wow. So it takes human error and mechanical failure completely out of the equation. Though it is worth noting that many of these SMR designs are still unproven on a wide commercial scale, mostly just sitting on the drawing board or in early prototype phases. That's true. It's early days.

And then, beyond SMRs, there is the ultimate dream, the holy grail of energy fusion. Oh, fusion would change the course of human history. Everything we've talked about today, splitting heavy atoms like uranium, is fission. Fusion is the exact opposite. It is what the sun does. It involves taking very light, abundant atoms like hydrogen isotopes derived from seawater and crushing them together under immense pressure and heat until they join or fuse into a heavier atom. And releasing monumental energy in the process. Staggering

energy. But the brilliance of fusion is that it produces virtually no long -lived radioactive waste, and a meltdown is physically impossible. because the moment the conditions drop, the reaction just instantly stops. But it remains incredibly difficult to sustain, always 30 years away as the running joke in the physics community goes. Right. Sadly, yes. Creating a star in a magnetic bottle on Earth is arguably the hardest engineering challenge humanity has ever attempted. It remains out of reach for the commercial grid right now, which means we have to make our decisions based

on the technology we actually have today. Fission. So let's do what we promised at the beginning. Let's lay out the honest ledger impartially. Okay. In favor of nuclear power, it generates massive amounts of electricity with almost zero carbon emissions. It is highly reliable, providing baseload power 24 hours a day, seven days a week, regardless of whether the wind is blowing or the sun is shining. It requires a tiny footprint of land, incredibly small physical amounts of fuel, and statistically... Per unit of energy produced, it is exceptionally safe. And against

nuclear power, these traditional plants are enormously expensive to build, constantly running years behind schedule and billions over budget. The solid radioactive waste requires active stewardship across geological timescales. The enrichment technology overlaps uncomfortably with concerns about nuclear weapons proliferation. And crucially, while a severe accident is statistically incredibly rare, if a meltdown and containment breach does happen, its consequences can spread across international borders and render land unusable for generations. So what does this all mean? We started by saying

nuclear energy is often painted in broad strokes as either a clean miracle or a glowing menace. What we found by actually looking under the hood is that it is neither. It is simply a tool. a piece of technology of extraordinary foundational energy density that demands profound, unwavering responsibility. This raises an important question, and it's one we want to pass directly to you, the listener. We've seen today that the cold hard data shows nuclear power is statistically incredibly safe and mathematically vital if we want a highly reliable low carbon future. But

we've also seen that human psychology is deeply understandably wired to dread the rare catastrophic event like a reactor meltdown far more than the invisible daily harm of fossil fuel pollution. So how do you balance it? When you look at the future of our world, how do you weigh the massive financial cost of building these reactors? against the ticking irreversible clock of climate change? How do you balance your natural human dread of a rare accident against the hard statistical safety data? Ultimately, choosing between these

paths isn't just a math equation. It isn't a purely scientific question. It is a profoundly human one based on what we value most and what we fear most. Will our future energy grids be determined by cold, hard statistics or by our deeply ingrained human psychology? It is a profound question worth carrying with you. Thank you so much for joining us on this deep dive today. Keep asking questions, keep looking past the caricatures, and keep exploring the fascinating, complicated mechanisms of this world we share. We'll see you next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Nanotechnology – Building at the Scale of Atoms

    Nov 19, 202626 minAudio

    Nanotechnology works at a scale where a nanometre is to a metre what a single centimetre is to the distance across a football field roughly a hundred thousand times over. This episode explains what nanotechnology...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Animal Migration – Navigation Without Maps

    Nov 17, 202625 minAudio

    A tagged bar-tailed godwit once flew more than thirteen thousand kilometres from Alaska to Tasmania without landing once. This episode explores why animals migrate at all, from godwits and humpback whales to monarch...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Space Weather – When the Sun Attacks Our Technology

    Nov 15, 202625 minAudio

    The Sun is an active, magnetic star, and every so often it hurls bursts of radiation and clouds of charged particles toward Earth, a phenomenon called space weather. This episode explains solar flares and coronal mass...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Tsunamis – Waves That Cross Oceans

    Nov 12, 202623 minAudio

    An ordinary wave rolls onto the sand every few seconds; a tsunami can take tens of minutes between crests and cross an entire ocean at the speed of a jet aircraft while barely rippling the surface. This episode explains...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Symmetry – Physics' Deepest Idea

    Nov 10, 202620 minAudio

    A folded square of paper and a butterfly's wings share the same simple visual idea: a shape that looks the same after some transformation. This episode follows that idea from everyday geometry into the deepest...

    Credit the people on this episode