Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Talking Science

Talking Science artwork

El Niño and La Niña – Australia's Boom-and-Bust Rainfall

Sep 8, 202625 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Ask an Australian farmer about the years that stick in their memory and you'll usually hear about extremes: a drought so long the dams cracked, or a wet season so relentless the paddocks turned to lakes. Much of that boom-and-bust rhythm traces back to a single, slow-moving climate pattern playing out across the tropical Pacific Ocean, thousands of kilometres from any Australian coastline. This episode explains El Niño and La Niña in plain terms, from trade winds and the Walker circulation to bushfire risk, flooding, the Indian Ocean Dipole, and the real, honest limits of forecasting them. You'll come away understanding what the El Niño-Southern Oscillation actually is, why it swings Australia between drought and flood, how the Indian Ocean Dipole adds a second layer to the picture, and how the Bureau of Meteorology and CSIRO track and forecast these patterns, along with a realistic sense of how far ahead that forecasting can actually see. Talking Science is sponsored by Kinsoft. Visit www.kinsoft.com.au Further reading: Bureau of Meteorology - ENSO Outlook and Indian Ocean Dipole updates; CSIRO - climate research on ENSO and Australian rainfall variability; Bureau of Meteorology and CSIRO - State of the Climate reports; World Meteorological Organization - seasonal climate outlook resources.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

You know, there is a very particular kind of memory that a lot of Australians carry. For sure. It doesn't even matter if you spent your whole life working on the land or if you've, you know, never left the city. It's that memory of a summer defined by just relentless dust. Right. The really bad ones. Exactly. Like dry dams, total fire bans stretching on for weeks, the sky completely hazy with smoke. And then maybe just a few years later, you get the exact opposite. Total whiplash. Yeah. Summer of absolute relentless rain, swollen

rivers, paddocks turned into shallow lakes and like mold literally growing on your shoes in the closet. It is. It's a landscape defined by incredible extremes. And looking at those wild swings going from bone dry to completely underwater. it is incredibly tempting to just write it off as, you know, random runs of bad luck. Or just the chaotic nature of the weather acting out, right? Exactly. But the reality is far more structured than that. Right. And that's exactly why we're here today. I've got a massive stack of sources in front of me for this deep dive, research papers,

climate data, and particularly this incredibly detailed, extensive article that breaks down the actual mechanics behind Australia's extreme climate swings. It's fascinating stuff. It really is. And the mission... of our deep dive today is to take all this source material and decode this massive, slow moving ocean and atmosphere pattern that dictates these wild extremes. And I think the wildest part of all this is that the pattern governing whether an Australian farm gets rain or dust is happening thousands of kilometers

offshore. Yeah, way out in the middle of the tropical Pacific Ocean. Which is just crazy to think about. We are talking about the El Nino Southern Oscillation. Or scientists usually just shorten that to ENSO. Right, ENSO. And it is, without a doubt, the single biggest driver of year to year climate variability affecting not just Australia, but large parts of the globe. So our goal today for you, the listener, is to break down exactly what this is, the physical machinery of how it pushes the weather between such wild extremes, and honestly, the limits

of our ability to predict it. And we're going to do it without relying on a textbook full of jargon. OK, let's unpack this, because before we can understand how the weather breaks down into these crazy extremes, we have to understand the baseline. Right. What's normal? Yeah. If we are looking at the Pacific Ocean in a quote unquote normal year, what are the baseline rules? Well, the best place to start looking is right along the equator. In an ordinary year, you have prevailing winds called the trade winds. Okay. And these blow steadily from east to west. So

picture a massive continuous current of air moving from the coast of South America, tracking all the way across the vast expanse of the Pacific Ocean, heading straight toward Australia and Indonesia. And because that wind is blowing across thousands of miles of open ocean constantly, it is actually doing physical work on the water, right? Like it's creating friction. Exactly. Friction. And that friction is dragging the sun -warmed surface water of the ocean westward. The wind literally pushes this thin layer of

warm water. And over thousands of miles, that water piles up. It forms a remarkably deep layer of warm water near Indonesia and northern Australia. And there's a name for that, right? Yeah, oceanographers call this the warm pool. The warm pool. Okay, so the wind is shoveling all this warm surface water to the west. But, I mean, there can't just be an empty hole in the ocean back in the east near South America. Something has to replace the water that was pushed away. Nature abhors a vacuum, right? Exactly. So as that warm surface water departs toward Australia, colder water

is drawn up from the deep ocean off... the coast of South America to take its place. Okay, that makes sense. This process is called upwelling. The Earth's rotation actually helps pull this deep, frigid water to the surface. So the end result is that in a typical year, the western Pacific near Australia is noticeably warmer at the surface than the eastern Pacific near Peru and Ecuador. You've got it. Think about it like having a giant bathtub. If you turn on a massive industrial -sized fan on one side of the tub blowing across the surface, that wind is going

to physically push all the warm water to bunch up on the far side. That's a great way to picture it. Right. So one side of your bathtub now has a deep pile of warm water, and the side near the fan has colder water rising from the bottom to replace it. That bathtub is our baseline Pacific Ocean. And that seemingly simple temperature difference. I mean, sometimes it's just a few degrees between the east and the west. It has enormous consequences. Because it affects the air above it. Exactly. It acts like an engine for the atmosphere. This difference in sea surface

temperature drives a massive loop of air, which meteorologists call the Walker circulation. Which operates on a pretty simple thermodynamic principle, right? Hot air rises. It does. So over that deep, warm pool near Australia and Indonesia, the ocean heavily heats the air directly above it. Okay. That warm, moisture -laden air rises high into the atmosphere. As it gains altitude, it cools down. And cool air can't hold as much moisture. Right. So it releases all that water as rainfall. This is the primary reason why northern Australia

and Indonesia get such reliable heavy rain in a normal year. But that air doesn't just stay up there in the stratosphere. I mean, it has to go somewhere once it hits the ceiling of the lower atmosphere. Yeah, it gets pushed eastward at high altitude, traveling all the way back across the Pacific. Towards South America. Exactly. By the time it reaches the eastern Pacific near South America, it has cooled significantly and it begins to sink back down over that colder, upwelling water. And here is a fundamental rule of how our weather works, which you see all over

the sources. Sinking air suppresses rainfall. Yes, it creates high pressure and clear skies. So the eastern Pacific stays relatively dry. And then what? Finally, that air flows back westward along the ocean surface as those trade winds we started with. It's an elegant, self -reinforcing loop. The wind pushes the water. The warm water heats the air, the air rises and makes rain, and then flows back east to sink and create more wind. It's a perfectly balanced engine. But the focus of our sources today is what happens when

that engine breaks down, the phenomenon known as El Nino. Right. During an El Nino event, that giant fan over the bathtub loses power. The winds just stop. Well, the steady trade winds weaken, and in some rare cases, they can even briefly reverse direction. Wow, reversed completely. Why does that happen? The reasons are incredibly complex. It often involves temporary disruptions in the atmosphere, like... Large waves of stormy weather traveling eastward along the equator, which interrupt the steady flow of the trade

winds. So the wind just loses its grip on the ocean, and without that steady westward push, gravity takes over, right? The tub levels out. Exactly. That massive warm pool of water that was banked up near Australia and Indonesia just sloshes back eastward across the Pacific. Migrating towards South America. Yeah. The term oceanographers use is a Kelvin wave, but slosh is honestly a brilliant way to visualize it. A giant slosh. It is a slow motion migration of millions of square kilometers of warm ocean water. It takes months for this warm water to travel across the

Pacific. Right. And here is the mechanism that actually changes the weather. The rising air and the massive rain clouds, they don't stay over Australia. They follow the warm water. Because the heat source moves. So the storm clouds move with it. Right. I really want to emphasize this point for everyone listening. The rain doesn't magically vanish from the earth. It literally just relocates to the central or eastern Pacific. That's spot on. But for Australia, that relocation is devastating. Because the rain is gone. Because

the rising air moved away. Yeah. Yeah, the system flips. You end up with sinking air over the Australian continent. And as we established... Sinking air suppresses rainfall. Exactly. That means below average rainfall, a sharply increased likelihood of drought, and a severely elevated risk of bushfires because the vegetation dries out and soil moisture plummets. Though it shifts the odds, right. It doesn't mean a catastrophic fire is guaranteed in every single town because local geography and weather fronts still play a role. Right. It's not a guarantee. But it heavily loads the

dice toward drier conditions across huge swaths of the continent. Very much so. But here's something I found really fascinating in the research. Scientists don't just look out the window and say, looks dry, must be El Niño. No, no, not at all. They have incredibly strict metrics for this. How do they actually measure the slosh? Well, they focus their instruments on a very specific patch of the central and eastern tropical Pacific. It's designated as the Niño 3 .4 region. Nino 3 .4. Yeah. This specific box of ocean is monitored

because it acts as the pivot point for the whole atmospheric engine. Forecasters constantly compare the current water temperature in that box against the long -term historical average. So they're basically waiting to see if that specific patch hits a certain temperature threshold. A temperature threshold sustained over time. For an agency like the Bureau of Meteorology to officially declare an El Nino. that Niño 3 .4 region has to remain warmer than average for several consecutive months. It can't just be a quick spike. Exactly.

And furthermore, it must be coupled with the atmosphere. The ocean and the sky have to agree. What does that mean? You need the warm water in that box, plus the observable weakening of the trade winds and the shift in rainfall patterns we talked about. And the sources note that this entire system can swing in the complete opposite direction too, which gives us La Niña. If El Nino is the fan turning off, La Nina is the fan getting stuck on overdrive. That's a great way to put it. During La Nina, those trade winds overperform. They blow with far more intensity

than normal. Pushing even more water. Yeah. This drives an excessive amount of warm water into the western Pacific, building an unusually deep and intensely hot, warm pool right on Australia's doorstep. Which means the updraft of rising air goes into overdrive, too. The rising air and convective rainfall intensify dramatically over Australia and Indonesia. This brings massive amounts of moisture, leading to above average rainfall. Which sounds nice during a drought. It sounds like a relief, but it brings a severe risk of catastrophic flooding. This is especially

true if you get multiple consecutive La Nina years. Because the ground is just full. Exactly. The soil becomes so saturated that any new rain immediately turns into floodwater, much like the devastating multi -year floods eastern Australia saw in the early 2020s. I do want to push back on something here, though, acting on behalf of anyone who follows climate news. Okay, sure. The sources state that neutral conditions, where the ocean is neither El Nino nor La Nina, are actually the most common state. They are. The Pacific spends more time in neutral than in either

extreme. But wait, if that's true, why does it feel like we are constantly hearing about El Niño or La Niña in the news? Are we just obsessed with the extremes? It is a totally valid observation. But the reason the extremes dominate the conversation is entirely due to human impact. Because normal doesn't make the news. Right. A neutral year means the weather is generally doing what we expect. Farmers get their average rainfall. Fire seasons stay within normal parameters. We don't write news headlines about the bathtub staying perfectly full. We only care when it breaks.

We make headlines when the bathtub overflows and destroys the house or when it runs completely dry and the crops die. Yeah. The extremes dictate our disasters. Right. So when that temperature needle in the Nino 3 .4 region starts to move. The entire world pays attention because food security, the economy, and lives are on the line. Here's where it gets really interesting. We threw these terms around El Nino and La Nina, and they are used by serious meteorologists running supercomputers today. But their origins have nothing to do with

modern science. Not at all. The origin story is centuries old. It originates from a completely different kind of observation. Generations ago, long before weather satellites, Fishing communities along the coast of Peru and Ecuador noticed a recurring pattern. Under normal conditions, their coastal waters were freezing cold, but incredibly rich in nutrients, all thanks to that deep ocean upwelling we discussed earlier. Because the cold water pulls up nitrogen and phosphorus from the ocean floor, right? Oh, wow. Which feeds the phytoplankton, which feeds the fish. It is an

incredibly productive food web. Exactly. But these fishermen noticed that every few years, this cold water would vanish. The outpouring would stop. The coastal waters would turn unusually warm. And without those nutrients, the fish stocks would completely collapse. Just a disaster for them. Their livelihood would be devastated. And the timing of this warm water arriving usually peaked around December. Around Christmastime. Right. So out of a cultural connection to the season, they named this periodic, devastating

warming of the ocean El Nino. which translates to the boy child, referring directly to the Christ child. It is staggering to think about the butterfly effect of that. A term coined by Peruvian fishermen to describe why they couldn't catch any fish in December is now the strict scientific label for a phenomenon that dictates whether an Australian wheat farm survives the summer. It really shows how connected everything is. Later in the 20th century, scientists began connecting the dots and added the second half of the acronym, the Southern Oscillation. This is the SO in ESO.

Yes. They discovered that the ocean temperature changes were directly linked to a massive atmospheric seesaw in pressure. They found that surface air pressure at Darwin in northern Australia and air pressure at Tahiti out in the Central Pacific move in exact opposite directions. So if the pressure goes up in Darwin, it goes down in Tahiti. They are connected. Meteorologists track this using the Southern Oscillation Index, or the SOI. By comparing the pressure difference between those two locations, they have a reliable mathematical

gauge of how the atmosphere is responding. So it's another way to measure it. Yeah, it tells us whether the whole system is leaning toward El Nino, plunging into La Nina, or just sitting in neutral. And the shockwaves of that atmospheric seesaw travel far beyond the Pacific Rim because the atmosphere is deeply interconnected, altering the walker circulation messes with the jet streams globally. The teleconnections are vast. The exact same reshuffling of heat that causes drought in eastern Australia will simultaneously bring torrential flooding rains to the arid deserts

of South America. It alters the timing and intensity of the monsoons in South Asia, which directly impacts the food supply for billions of people. Our sources even point out that it messes with hurricanes on the other side of the planet. Oh, absolutely. El Nino alters the high altitude winds over the Atlantic Ocean, creating wind shear that basically rips hurricanes apart before they can form, leading to a quieter Atlantic hurricane season. Right. But La Nina. La Nina removes that wind shear, allowing Atlantic hurricanes

to become supercharged. An ocean temperature shift off the coast of Peru can dictate whether a hurricane hits Florida. It highlights how fluid and connected the Earth's systems are. But, you know, if you want to fully understand the extremes of Australian weather, the Pacific is only half the story. There's more. The atmosphere doesn't care about the lines we draw on maps. There is another major ocean pattern happening simultaneously on the western side of the continent. We have to look at the Indian Ocean Dipole, or the IOD. Okay, so a different ocean, but a similar kind

of seesaw. How does the Indian Ocean Dipole operate? It operates on the same basic thermodynamic principles, just on a slightly smaller geographic scale. The IOD measures the temperature difference between the western Indian Ocean over near the coast of Africa and the eastern Indian Ocean, situated near Indonesia and Australia. So what does a positive phase of this dipole look like? In a positive IOD phase, the water near Africa becomes warmer than average, and the water near Australia becomes cooler than average. Okay, and cooler

water means? Cooler water means less evaporation. Less evaporation means there is significantly less moisture rising into the atmosphere to form rain clouds that would normally sweep across Australia from the west. So it dries things out. The result is a suppression of rainfall, bringing severe dry conditions, particularly to the southeastern parts of Australia. And conversely, a negative IOD means warmer water pools closer to Australia, pumping vast amounts of moisture into the air and leading to much wetter conditions. Exactly. But the real devastation happens when you realize

these two oceans, the Pacific on the east, the Indian on the west, are acting on the same landmass at the same time. That's when things get truly bad. Think about it this way. Having an El Nino year is like having a truly terrible day at work. You're stressed, your resources are depleted, things are dry. But a positive IOD is coming home from that bad day at work to find you also have a flat tire. The two events compound each other to make the situation catastrophic. That synthesis perfectly describes Australia's darkest

climate moments. When those two systems lock into their dry phases simultaneously, the continent is essentially starved of moisture from both sides. Both sides. Look at the millennium drought, which crippled Australian agriculture from roughly 2001 to 2009. That was driven by a relentless sequence of El Nino and neutral years, with virtually no wet La Nina years to break the cycle and refill the soil moisture. And the sources specifically highlight the Black Summer bushfires of 2019 and 2020. Black Summer is the textbook example of a compound disaster. How so? The continent

had already endured years of background drought, so the vegetation was critically dry. Then a remarkably strong positive IOD materialized, shutting off moisture from the West, while the Pacific also leaned dry. completely dry from all directions. It created an environment where the fires burned with an intensity and scale that was historically unprecedented. Then in a total whiplash event from 2020 to 2022, the system flipped and delivered three consecutive La Nina years, which the sources note is statistically

very rare. Highly unusual. It wasn't just a heavy rainy season. It was a relentless multi -year soaking where the soil couldn't absorb another drop. The rivers had nowhere to drain, culminating in the massive catastrophic floods across New South Wales and Queensland. The damage from both ends of the spectrum runs into the billions of dollars, not to mention the immense human and ecological toll, which makes predicting these shifts one of the most critical scientific endeavors on the planet. Given the destruction these compounding ocean patterns cause, the logical next question

is, How do we defend ourselves? Like, how good is our crystal ball? Well, we have vast institutions dedicated entirely to this. The Bureau of Meteorology continuously monitors these oceans and publishes seasonal outlooks. Right. Underpinning that is the CSIRO, Australia's National Science Agency, conducting the deep research into how these systems behave. Since the 1980s, the physical infrastructure has improved exponentially. Like satellites and things. Yeah. We have arrays of moored buoys

plunging into the deep ocean, fleets of autonomous gliders, and satellites measuring sea surface height and temperature down to the millimeter. With all that hardware, you'd think we could predict this perfectly. But the sources outline a major limitation called the autumn predictability barrier. What exactly is that? It is a notoriously difficult window for meteorologists. During the Australian autumn months, roughly March through May, the temperature gradients across the tropical Pacific are at their weakest. So they're not strongly leaning one way or the other. Exactly. The system isn't strongly anchored in either

El Nino or La Nina. Because the ocean and atmosphere aren't tightly coupled together during this window, the entire system becomes highly volatile. meaning it can change quickly. It is incredibly susceptible to being tipped in one direction or the other by completely random short -term weather events, like a random burst of spring storms. So a forecast made in April about what will happen in December is inherently less reliable than a forecast made in August. Exponentially less reliable. And this brings us to the fundamental truth about predicting

the weather. The Earth's climate. is a chaotic system. When you say chaotic system, you mean chaos theory. The classic idea of a butterfly flapping its wings in Brazil causing a tornado in Texas. The butterfly effect is the perfect way to understand it. In a chaotic system, the future state is highly, almost unimaginably sensitive to tiny, unmeasurable differences in the initial starting conditions. Okay, so if one number is slightly off... Exactly. If our satellite reading of the ocean temperature is off by just a fraction

of one degree... Or if a wind speed measurement misses a small gust, that microscopic error multiplies over time in the computer models. Within a few months, that tiny uncertainty cascades into a completely different forecast. So, what does this all mean? If the system is chaotic and prone to tiny errors, how do scientists provide any useful warnings to farmers or firefighters? They don't try to predict one perfect future. They use a technique called ensemble forecasting. Ensemble forecasting. Instead of running one

single computer simulation, they run dozens, sometimes hundreds, of separate simulations of the ocean and atmosphere. But for each simulation, they slightly tweak those initial starting conditions. Oh, I see. They change the wind speed by a fraction or bump the ocean temperature up by a hundredth of a degree. They intentionally inject the chaos to see what happens. They run a hundred different parallel universes to see where they all end up. And then they look at the consensus. If 90 out of 100 simulations agree that the warm pool is going to slosh east and form an El Nino, forecasters

have high confidence to issue a warning. But if they don't agree? If the simulations are scattered everywhere, some predicting El Nino, some La Nina, some neutral, that widespread tells forecasters that the system is currently too chaotic to call. That uncertainty is honest, valuable information in itself. Which means scientists aren't predicting exact raindrops for a specific Tuesday in November. They are basically counting cards at a casino. that's exactly what they're doing they are looking at the deck the ocean temperatures the wind speeds

the computer models and they are telling water authorities and grain growers the deck is heavily stacked for a dry season we can't guarantee you'll draw a bad hand but you have a significant mathematical edge if you prepare for drought and that mathematical edge dictates major economic decisions Grain growers use those probabilistic outlooks months in advance to decide if they should plant drought -resistant crops. And water management too, I imagine. Yes. Water authorities use them to calculate whether they need to hold on to reservoir water or if they can safely release it for irrigation.

Fire agencies use them to position aircraft and crews before a single dry lightning strike even hits the ground. It's incredible to pull back and realize that a farmer's decision about planting wheat in rural Australia is fundamentally linked to a microscopic temperature change in a patch of water thousands of miles away near South America. When you look out at a flooded river or a parched, dusty paddock, you aren't just looking at local weather. You are witnessing the visible, on -the -ground consequences of a vast, invisible conversation

between the wind and the water across the entire Pacific basin. It is a brilliantly complex machine. And we must also acknowledge the critical context of climate change here. A warming planet is injecting more energy into this entire system. How that excess heat will affect the frequency or the sheer intensity of future El Nino and La Nina events remains an area of intense, unsettled scientific investigation. Because the models aren't totally clear yet. The models show varying projections, so maintaining honest scientific caution while researchers gather more data is

the only responsible approach. It is a system we are still learning to read. Which brings me to a final thought I want to leave you with today. Our sources mention that the CSIRO doesn't just look at satellites. They study ancient coral reefs and tree rings to map out how ESO behaved centuries, even millennia, before the Industrial Revolution. Yeah, that historical data is amazing. It really is. Corals lock in chemical signatures of ocean temperatures in their growth rings. So if scientists can read these ancient records

and see the massive extreme El Nino patterns that happened a thousand years ago. What if we use that ancient data to completely redesign our modern agriculture? Wow. That's an interesting idea. Right. Instead of just planning our farms and water systems around the weather of the last 50 years, what if we build our food infrastructure to withstand the massive extremes that the coral tells us are physically possible? Are we hobbling our preparation for the future by ignoring the deep past? It's a profound question. The blueprint for what the Earth is capable of is written in

the natural world. It just depends on how boldly we choose to read it. So the next time you see a dusty summer sky or a relentless spring downpour, remember. You are looking at the final act of a story that started with the wind halfway across the world. Thank you for joining us on this deep dive. Until next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Nanotechnology – Building at the Scale of Atoms

    Nov 19, 202626 minAudio

    Nanotechnology works at a scale where a nanometre is to a metre what a single centimetre is to the distance across a football field roughly a hundred thousand times over. This episode explains what nanotechnology...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Animal Migration – Navigation Without Maps

    Nov 17, 202625 minAudio

    A tagged bar-tailed godwit once flew more than thirteen thousand kilometres from Alaska to Tasmania without landing once. This episode explores why animals migrate at all, from godwits and humpback whales to monarch...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Space Weather – When the Sun Attacks Our Technology

    Nov 15, 202625 minAudio

    The Sun is an active, magnetic star, and every so often it hurls bursts of radiation and clouds of charged particles toward Earth, a phenomenon called space weather. This episode explains solar flares and coronal mass...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Tsunamis – Waves That Cross Oceans

    Nov 12, 202623 minAudio

    An ordinary wave rolls onto the sand every few seconds; a tsunami can take tens of minutes between crests and cross an entire ocean at the speed of a jet aircraft while barely rippling the surface. This episode explains...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Symmetry – Physics' Deepest Idea

    Nov 10, 202620 minAudio

    A folded square of paper and a butterfly's wings share the same simple visual idea: a shape that looks the same after some transformation. This episode follows that idea from everyday geometry into the deepest...

    Credit the people on this episode