Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Talking Science

Talking Science artwork

The Oort Cloud – The Edge of the Solar System

Sep 10, 202622 minAudio

Far beyond Neptune, past even the icy Kuiper Belt, astronomers believe an enormous, invisible shell of ancient comets surrounds the entire solar system: the Oort Cloud. This episode traces how a Dutch astronomer inferred its existence from comet orbits alone, why it has never been directly observed, how it differs from the closer, flatter Kuiper Belt, and what "the edge of the solar system" actually means once you look closely at the question. You'll come away understanding what the Oort Cloud is thought to be and how it likely formed, why long-period comets are the key evidence for its existence, the difference between the Kuiper Belt and the Oort Cloud, what the heliopause is and how it differs from the Oort Cloud as a definition of the solar system's edge, and why honest science communication means treating the Oort Cloud as a well-supported hypothesis rather than a confirmed, directly observed structure. Talking Science is sponsored by Kinsoft. Visit www.kinsoft.com.au Further reading: NASA - "Oort Cloud" and "Kuiper Belt" overview pages (Solar System Exploration); European Space Agency - background on comets and the outer solar system; Australian Academy of Science - public astronomy explainers; Scientific American - features on comet origins and the outer solar system.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

So picture a relative who visits so rarely that nobody currently alive in your family has ever actually met them face to face. Right. Not a single person. Yeah, not a single one. But the whole family still keeps a chair ready for them at the dinner table. Which is kind of spooky if you think about it. It really is. And it's because the footprints they leave behind on each of those rare visits are, well, they're absolutely unmistakable. And in this strange, poetic way. That is sort of the exact relationship humanity

has with the subject of our deep dive today. I mean, it really is the perfect way to frame it. Because we are basically dealing with an invisible guest at the solar systems table. We really are. Welcome to the deep dive, everyone. Today, we are pulling from a really fascinating stack of research and articles to explore the true, the completely unseen edge of our solar system, the Oort cloud. Yeah, the famous Oort cloud. Right. And our mission for this deep dive is to figure out what this massive structure actually is, why we are so incredibly confident

it exists, even though, you know, we've never seen it, and how it just Completely redefines what we consider to be our cosmic neighborhood. And, you know, the word unseen is really doing a lot of heavy lifting here. Oh, totally. Because no telescope has ever taken a picture of the Oort cloud. None. And no spacecraft has ever reached it. And to be perfectly candid. No spacecraft built with current technology will ever reach it in our lifetimes. Which is just wild to me. It's so strange and exciting to dedicate a whole

deep dive to something that is literally invisible. I mean, if you are listening to this, you probably have a mental map of the solar system from grade school. The standard poster on the science classroom wall. Exactly. The sun in the middle, some rings showing the planetary orbits, maybe an asteroid dealt if the poster was fancy. But once you start asking where that map actually ends, everything. you thought you knew completely flips. It does. And to understand that invisible edge, we kind of need to build that mental map outward first.

Right. Start with what we know. Exactly. We have to understand the neighborhood we actually can see so we can contrast it with the one we can't. So zooming out from Earth, the inner solar system is pretty tidy. You've got the rocky planets, Mercury, Venus, Earth, Mars, all crowded relatively close to the sun. Then you move further out. and hit the big guys, the gas giants, Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, and Neptune. Right. And Neptune is our outermost major planet. It sits at roughly 30 times the distance from the Earth to the sun. And when I was reading the source material for

today, I noticed astronomers use a shortcut for that distance, right? So they aren't constantly saying the distance from the Earth to the sun over and over. Oh, yeah. It gets credious. They call it an astronomical unit or AU. Yes, an AU. It's a really foundational measuring stick in astronomy. It's about... 93 million miles. So instead of dealing with billions of miles, we just say Neptune sits at about 30 AU. That makes it so much easier to picture. Exactly. Now, just past Neptune, from about 30 AU out to maybe 50

AU, you hit a region called the Kuiper Belt. Now, this is the famous zone where Pluto lives, right? That's one resident, yes. Pluto's out there. And the Kuiper Belt is basically this giant... donut shaped band of icy debris. Right. It holds hundreds of thousands of frozen bodies that are just left over from the very era when the solar system was forming. Like construction scraps. Exactly. And structurally, it is essentially a flattened disk. It's a wider, colder extension of the same swirling disk of gas and dust that

the planets, you know, condensed out of billions of years ago. And the fact that it is a flat disk is a crucial detail, I think, because the Kuiper Belt is where most of our short period comets come from. Yes. These are the comets that swing past the sun on orbits lasting maybe a few years to a couple of centuries. Halley's Comet, for example. Right. And when you map their paths, they stay roughly in the same flat plane as the planets. They don't swoop in from the top or the bottom. No, they are very much part of that original planetary disk. But the Oort cloud, the Oort cloud is something else entirely.

both in its unimaginable distance and its shape. Because unlike the Kuiper Belt, the Oort cloud isn't a flat disk at all. Far from it. It is modeled to be a vast, roughly spherical shell of icy bodies that entirely encloses the solar system. So to help you visualize this at home, think of it like this. If the Kuiper belt is a flat spinning pizza dough sitting on a counter. I love this analogy. Right. The Oort cloud is the entire spherical oven surrounding it. Or another analogy from our sources is to picture

the way the skin of an orange surrounds the fruit inside, but unimaginably thicker. And so, so much further out. Yeah, the distances are really where the human brain just starts to short circuit. Oh, absolutely. Because the Kuiper Belt ends around 50 AU, like we said. Oh. But the inner edge of the Oort Club, that doesn't even begin until somewhere around 2 ,000 to 5 ,000 AU from the sun. That is just a massive jump. It is. And it's outer edge. That might stretch as far as 100 ,000 or even 200 ,000 AU away. Okay, let me do the mental math on that for a second. In light years, that outer edge is getting on for

a quarter to a half of the entire distance to Proxima Centauri. Which is the nearest star to our sun. That is just a staggering expanse. Let's put that into a scale that might actually, you know, make sense to a human brain. Please. If you imagine the distance from the sun all the way out to Neptune was just the length of your thumbnail. Okay, my thumbnail. The outer reaches of the Oort cloud on that exact same scale would be a full kilometer away. Wait. A kilometer away from your thumbnail. A full kilometer, yeah. You really have to sit with that image for a

second. It just completely changes how you view our home. We aren't just this neat little mechanical clock of planets. No, not at all. The solar system is actually an enormous, mostly empty sphere of space with our sun and planets just huddled together right at the very, very center. It's a profound shift in perspective, for sure. But, okay, this raises a huge red flag for me. Okay, what is it? If this structure is a kilometer away on our thumbnail scale, and it's entirely in the pitch black of deep space, how on earth

did anyone figure out it was there? I mean, if we can't see it, how is it science? Well, the smoking gun was a different kind of visitor. Earlier, we mentioned the short period comets coming from the flat Kuiper belt. Right, the pizza dough. Exactly. The evidence for the Oort cloud comes from long -period comets. Okay, so these are the comets whose orbits around the sun take longer than 200 years. Yes, sometimes tens of thousands of years. Wow. And unlike the short -period comets, their paths are not confined to the flat plane of the planets. They streak in from every conceivable angle. So they aren't

following the pizza dough rule. No. They dive bomb from above the planets. They swoop up from below them. They come in from the sides. And their orbits are so highly elliptical, meaning they're stretched out like really long rubber bands, that when astronomers calculate their trajectories, the comets appear to be falling in from a distance far beyond anything we had previously mapped. And this brings us to a Dutch astronomer named Jan Oort, right? Back in 1950. Yes, Jan Oort. He was actually building on some earlier work by an Estonian astronomer, Ernst

Opec. Right. And Ort looked at the orbits of a couple dozen of these long period comets, and he noticed a really striking geometric pattern. He did. If you trace their wildly stretched orbits backward to their furthest point from the sun, they all seem to originate from roughly the same enormous distance. And again, this was regardless of which direction they came from. Yeah, the math was incredibly consistent. It pointed to a, well, a spherical reservoir of material at a very specific, immense distance. But I have

to push back on this, though, on behalf of everyone listening. Sure, go for it. I appreciate the math. I really do. But you're telling me scientists just traced some orbital lines backward on a chalkboard in 1950, saw they intersected really far away, and just declared a giant shell exists. It sounds a bit crazy when you put it like that. Right. Is that really enough evidence to call something a scientific fact? Well, it's a fantastic question, and it really requires us to be very honest about how science operates at these extremes. Okay. Good science communicators should always

state plainly. that the Oort cloud remains unobserved. Unobserved? Yes. Not one single object out there in the main cloud has ever been directly imaged. Astronomers refer to it as an extremely well -supported hypothesis, rather than a directly observed structure like, say, Saturn's rings. But with all the incredible space telescopes we have today, I mean, why can't we just point James Webb out there and take a picture? It comes down to the inverse square law of light. combined with the nature of the objects themselves. Oh,

right, because they're in the dark. Exactly. These bodies are tiny, mostly just a few kilometers across. They're essentially dirty snowballs made of ice and dust. Right. And at 100 ,000 AU, the sunlight reaching them is vanishingly faint. For us to see them, that incredibly faint sunlight would have to hit a tiny, dark, dirty snowball, bounce off, and travel all the way back across that same immense distance to our telescopes. They just don't reflect enough light to even register. No, they sit in permanent, undisturbed

darkness. We only ever see them when they get nudged inward. As they fall closer to the sun, the solar radiation heats them up, their ice vaporizes, and they form that massive, glowing comet tail we can actually see. Which brings up the next obvious question, right? Which is? If these icy rocks have been sitting out there in a deep freeze for billions of years, what suddenly pushes them toward the sun? I mean, if they are on stable orbits, what provides the nudge? It all comes down to gravity acting over extraordinarily long timescales. And it works

in two primary ways. Okay. First, you have the gravitational influence of passing stars. Because our solar system isn't just sitting still in space. Right. We are orbiting the center of the Milky Way galaxy, and so are all the other stars. And occasionally, on a cosmic timescale of millions of years, other stars pass relatively close to our solar system. And because the objects in the outer Oort cloud are so far from our sun, the sun's gravitational grip on them is incredibly weak. So a passing star can exert just enough

of a tug to disrupt their orbits. It's a little nudge. Yeah, a tiny nudge. Some objects get sent plunging inward toward us. Others get flung out of the solar system, entirely just lost to interstellar space. Wow. But our sources mention a second force at play, too, something called the galactic tide. Yes. Which, I have to admit, sounds like something out of a sci -fi novel. How does a galaxy have a tide? It operates on the same basic principle as the tides on Earth, really, just on a galactic scale. Okay. Earth's oceans bulge

because the moon pulls harder on the side of the Earth that's closer to it. Well, in the Milky Way, our solar system is embedded in a massive flattened disk of stars, gas, and dark matter. Okay, I'm picturing the galaxy as a giant spinning plate. Exactly. And as our solar system travels around the galaxy, we don't just move in a perfectly flat line. We bob up and down through that disk, kind of like a horse on a carousel. Oh, I didn't know that. Yeah, we bob up and down. And the gravitational pull from all that mass in the galactic disk exerts a differential force on

the incredibly vast Oort cloud. Because the cloud is so huge. Right. It squeezes and stretches the cloud ever so slightly over millions of years. This gentle but relentless tide constantly stirs the outer reaches, essentially dribbling a steady trickle of comets in toward the sun. And because these forces like passing stars and the galactic tide are so gradual and chaotic, these comets arrive totally individually without any warning. Exactly. It's not a predictable meteor shower you can mark on a calendar. It's one bright comet

appearing in the sky, maybe for the only time in human history. Right. Which makes you wonder, how did all this icy material get out there in the first place? I mean, did it form out there in the deep freeze? The leading picture. based on some really intense computer simulations of orbital mechanics, is no. They could not have formed out there. Oh, really? Yeah. The material in the early solar system was simply too sparse at those distances to clump together into objects kilometers wide. They had to have formed much closer to the sun. Ah, okay. So they were made in the same region where the giant planets Jupiter,

Saturn, Uranus, Neptune were assembling. Yes, exactly. They were made of the exact same icy building blocks as Uranus and Neptune. Okay. But as those giant planets grew, their immense gravity began to dominate the region. When small icy bodies passed too close to a growing Jupiter or Saturn, they experienced a gravitational slingshot. Like what we do with satellites. Yes. It's the exact same physics we use to accelerate space probes to the outer solar system, but just on a massive chaotic scale naturally. So to put

this in everyday terms, these icy rocks are basically local kids who got bullied and kicked out of the neighborhood by the growing gas giants. That is a remarkably accurate analogy, actually. The giant planets flung a huge amount of this surrounding icy debris in all directions. Some of it was thrown into the sun, some was ejected from the solar system entirely, and a huge portion was flung outward. on massive elongated orbits. But wait, if they were flung outward on stretched out orbits, how did they form a spherical shell?

Wouldn't they just keep coming back to where they started? That is where the galactic tide and passing stars come back into the story. Oh, the stirring. Yes. Once those objects were flung far enough away from the sun, the external gravity of the galaxy began to tug on them. Over billions of years, those external forces pulled sideways on those elongated orbits. Okay. And that lifted their closest approach to the sun further and further out, rounding out their paths and basically scattering them into a spherical shape. So the Oort cloud is essentially built from the solar

system's own leftover construction material. Yeah. Gravitationally exiled to the outer darkness and then gently molded by the galaxy itself. It's an incredibly elegant piece of scientific deduction. It really is. And we are actually starting to find pieces of evidence that bridge the gap, aren't we? The source material mentioned a sort of middle ground that we can actually see. Yes. Astronomers refer to it as the inner Oort cloud. Or the Hills Cloud. The Hills Cloud. Right. It's closer in, more disc -shaped, and denser than the outer spherical cloud. It acts

like a staging ground that gradually resupplies the outer cloud. And we have found a few unusual objects sitting in this transitional zone. Like the dwarf planet Sedna. Sedna is a perfect example. Its orbit is highly elliptical, taking about 11 ,400 years to go around the sun. That's a long year. Yeah. And even at its absolute closest approach, it never comes anywhere near Neptune or the Kuiper Belt. It is completely detached from the planetary zone. So it's too far out to be in the Kuiper Belt, but not far enough to be in the classic spherical Oort cloud. Right.

Sedna is like a little breadcrumb proving that the transition zone exists. It gives us a real observable handhold on this whole theory rather than just relying on the math of comets falling in. It really confirms that the space out there is structured exactly as the orbital models predict. So let's talk about the actual physical reality of this outer suburb. If we have this massive spherical shell of exiled ice, does that mean there's just a solid wall of material out there? Just how many objects are we talking about? Oh,

the population estimates are mind boggling. Astronomers estimate there could be anywhere from hundreds of billions to several trillion individual objects out there. Trillions. Trillions, each measuring at least a kilometer across. Wow. But given the scale we established earlier, the sphere that is a light year across, they must be incredibly spread out. Oh, entirely. The volume of this spherical shell is so vast that the actual density of the material is almost incomprehensibly low. Okay. They're spread so thin that they will almost

certainly never collide. In fact, if you were standing on an Oort cloud object, the next nearest object would be tens of millions of miles away. So it wouldn't look like an asteroid field in a movie. No, not at all. You wouldn't even be able to see the next object. So if you gathered all trillions of them up and, like, squished them together? The total combined mass might only be a few times the mass of the Earth. Wow. Just a tiny fraction of the solar system's total mass spread over a light year, which really emphasizes how empty space is. It is mostly nothing. And

that leads directly to a question that causes a ton of confusion, but is deeply fascinating to unravel. Does this massive shell mean our solar system is much bigger than we are traditionally taught? Because when I think of the edge of the solar system, I think of the solar wind. Isn't that where it ends? You've hit on the central debate. There are two perfectly reasonable ways to define the edge of the solar system, and they give you wildly different answers. You just described the magnetic or particle edge. Right, because the sun is constantly streaming out a flow of

charged particles called the solar wind, inflating a vast bubble around the planets called the heliosphere. Yes, and where that solar wind finally weakens and gets overwhelmed by the interstellar medium, the gas between the stars, you hit a boundary called the heliopause. The heliopause. Right, and that sits at about 120 AU from the sun. Which is famous because of the Voyager 1 spacecraft, right? Yeah. It launched in the 1970s, and we always hear the headline that it left the solar system in 2012. Yeah. It crossed that exact heliopause

boundary. Voyager 1 absolutely crossed the heliopause. By that magnetic definition, it entered interstellar space. But... There is a second definition. The gravitational edge. The gravitational edge. Because the sun's gravity doesn't just hit a wall and stop like the solar wind does. Right. Gravity keeps going. Gravity has an infinite reach, though it weakens with distance. So the gravitational edge of our solar system is defined by the Hill Sphere. Hill Sphere. Yeah. That's the region where the sun's gravitational pull is stronger than the gravitational pull of any neighboring

stars. And that dominance stretches all the way through the Oort cloud, nearly halfway to Alpha Centauri. Wait. So if Voyager 1 has been flying for 50 years at roughly 38 ,000 miles per hour, and it's the furthest human -made object in history, where is it relative to the gravitational edge? Not even close. By the gravitational definition, Voyager 1 hasn't even reached the inner edge of the Oort cloud yet. Oh my gosh. Yeah. At its current speed, it'll take another 300 years just

to reach the inner edge. And it will take tens of thousands of years to clear the outer edge and truly leave the sun's gravitational grip. That is just, it really reframes our place in the universe. We've been flying for half a century, and we haven't even reached the front gate of our own property. It is a very humbling perspective on cosmic scales. Definitely. Now, while our probes are struggling to get out, it is worth noting that things do occasionally come in from the outside. Interstellar interlopers. Conceptually, yes. Everything we've discussed in the Oort cloud

is gravitationally bound to our sun. Right. Even on a 100 ,000 -year orbit, an Oort cloud comet will eventually loop back. But in recent years, astronomers have discovered a new class of objects entirely, genuine interstellar objects tumbling through our system. Meaning they originated around some entirely different star system, and they are completely unbound by our sun's gravity. They're just passing through. Exactly. They arrive from interstellar space, plunging in on... hyperbolic trajectories that tell us they are moving far too fast to be captured by the sun. Wow. They

whip around our star and shoot back out into the void, never to return. They can look super fitfully like comets, but their incredible speeds prove they don't belong to us. Which really ties everything we've talked about together beautifully, I think. It does. The story of the Oort cloud is such a perfect example of how the scientific method operates at the frontier of our knowledge. Reasoning carefully from indirect evidence like the orbits of long period comets. Staying honest about what we don't know. Right. And testing hypotheses with computer models. Using physics

to map a vast, ancient, silent shell of ice that surrounds literally every spacecraft we've ever launched. It is astronomy working exactly as it should. And as our survey telescopes become more advanced, scanning huge swaths of the sky night after night, we will likely catch more of those transitional objects like Sedna. So the picture will keep getting clearer. Yes. But the fundamental detective work from 1950 holds remarkably strong today. So, for you listening, the next time a bright, unannounced comet makes

the headlines, you'll know exactly what you are looking at. Yeah, it's not just a rock. Right. Don't just think of it as a rock coming from space. You'll know it's a frozen leftover from the chaotic birth of our very own solar system. It's an icy building block that got bullied out into the dark suburbs billions of years ago, and it's finally falling home. A silent visitor from our deepest past. I want to leave you with one final provocative thought to mull over today. We talked about how passing stars and the galactic tide constantly stir the outer Oort clouds, sometimes

flinging our exiled ice completely out of the solar system, right? Right. And we just talked about those interstellar objects tumbling through our system from other stars. If you put those two facts together, if every star in the galaxy is doing this, throwing off its own leftover construction material into the dark, how much of the vast, supposedly empty space between the stars is actually filled. Think about it. There might be a slow drifting traffic of lost ice from countless alien solar systems just waiting to tumble through ours. Thanks for joining us

on the Deep Dive. See you next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Nanotechnology – Building at the Scale of Atoms

    Nov 19, 202626 minAudio

    Nanotechnology works at a scale where a nanometre is to a metre what a single centimetre is to the distance across a football field roughly a hundred thousand times over. This episode explains what nanotechnology...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Animal Migration – Navigation Without Maps

    Nov 17, 202625 minAudio

    A tagged bar-tailed godwit once flew more than thirteen thousand kilometres from Alaska to Tasmania without landing once. This episode explores why animals migrate at all, from godwits and humpback whales to monarch...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Space Weather – When the Sun Attacks Our Technology

    Nov 15, 202625 minAudio

    The Sun is an active, magnetic star, and every so often it hurls bursts of radiation and clouds of charged particles toward Earth, a phenomenon called space weather. This episode explains solar flares and coronal mass...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Tsunamis – Waves That Cross Oceans

    Nov 12, 202623 minAudio

    An ordinary wave rolls onto the sand every few seconds; a tsunami can take tens of minutes between crests and cross an entire ocean at the speed of a jet aircraft while barely rippling the surface. This episode explains...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Symmetry – Physics' Deepest Idea

    Nov 10, 202620 minAudio

    A folded square of paper and a butterfly's wings share the same simple visual idea: a shape that looks the same after some transformation. This episode follows that idea from everyday geometry into the deepest...

    Credit the people on this episode