On a clear, dark night, away from city lights, the Milky Way arcs overhead as a soft river of stars - and buried in the dense, glowing crowd of that river's centre sits something almost too strange to picture: a supermassive black hole roughly four million times heavier than our Sun, compressed into a region smaller than the orbit of Mercury. This episode follows the decades-long detective story that revealed it, from patiently tracked stars swinging around an invisible point, to the 2020 Nobel Prize, to the blurry orange ring released to the world in 2022 as the first image of our own galaxy's central black hole. You'll come away understanding what a black hole actually is and isn't, how astronomers weighed something they couldn't see by watching stars orbit it, why Sagittarius A* is strangely calm compared with the ferocious black holes blazing at the centres of other galaxies, what the Event Horizon Telescope actually captured, and why nobody yet has a settled answer for how black holes this large came to exist so early in the universe's history. Talking Science is sponsored by Kinsoft. Visit www.kinsoft.com.au Further reading: NASA - "Black Holes" overview and Sagittarius A* mission pages; Event Horizon Telescope Collaboration - public results on the 2022 image of Sagittarius A*; The Nobel Prize (Nobel Foundation) - 2020 Physics Prize scientific background; European Southern Observatory (ESO) - long-term Galactic Centre star-tracking research.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
So imagine you are standing outside on a properly dark night, like, you know, somewhere way out in the country, far enough from any city streetlights that the sky actually looks the way it looked to, well, basically every human being who lived before electricity. Oh, yeah. A truly dark sky is just a stunning sight. It really is. And if you look up, you will see this pale, hazy band stretching completely from one horizon to the other. which is the Milky Way. Right. It's the edge -on view of our very own galaxy, just, you
know, seen from the inside. Exactly. And if you trace that glowing kind of hazy band toward the constellation Sagittarius, you're looking more or less straight at the very center of our galaxy. But, I mean, if you look there with the naked eye, you won't see anything unusual, right? It just looks like a particularly dense, glowing crowd of stars. Yeah, just a lot of stars. But sitting right in the middle of that cosmic crowd, completely invisible to any telescope that simply looks for light, is one of the strangest, most extreme objects known to science. It really is. It is a black hole, and not just any black hole.
This is a monster with a mass of around 4 million suns. And here is the kicker. All of that mass is squeezed into a space smaller than the orbit of the planet Mercury. Yeah, trying to even visualize that level of density genuinely strains the human imagination. I mean astronomers call this object Sagittarius A, usually pronounced Sagittarius A star. And that is our mission for today's deep dive. We've got this massive stack of sources on the table today, Nobel Prize citations, decades of astrophysics research papers, and the incredible
data releases from the Event Horizon Telescope team. Oh, there's so much amazing data. There really is. We are going to explore Sagittarius A, detailing exactly how scientists proved this invisible giant exists without being able to see it, how we miraculously managed to actually photograph it, and why this terrifying, light -bending... cosmic monster is actually shockingly quiet and honestly a bit poorly fed. Yeah, to really appreciate the monumental effort it took to understand this object, we first need to establish what exactly we are dealing with here. Because
the term black hole gets thrown around in pop culture a lot, usually as a synonym for like a vacuum cleaner in space. Yeah, exactly. Just sucking everything up. Right. But in astrophysics, it has a very precise meaning. So a black hole forms when an enormous amount of mass is compressed into a small enough space that its gravity becomes absolutely overwhelming. OK, let's unpack this because gravity is everywhere, right? I mean, Earth has gravity. The sun has gravity. I'm anchored to my chair by gravity right now. Thankfully,
yes. Right. So what fundamentally separates a black hole's gravity from the gravity of just a really, really heavy star? Well, the defining feature of a black hole is a boundary called the event horizon. Right. understand it, we have to talk about escape velocity. Okay. So if you throw a baseball straight up in the air on Earth, it comes back down. But if you could throw a fast enough, which is about 11 kilometers per second, it would completely break free of Earth's gravity and fly into space. Wow. Okay. That is Earth's escape velocity. So the heavier and denser
an object is, the higher its escape velocity. So the event horizon is like the exact distance from the center of the black hole where the escape velocity perfectly equals the speed of light. That is the absolute core of it, yes. And since a fundamental law of our universe is that absolutely nothing can travel faster than the speed of light, well, once you cross that invisible boundary, you are permanently trapped. Permanently. Permanently. No signal, no particle, no radio wave, literally no information of any kind can ever climb back
up. I've always thought of it like, imagine you are in a canoe, right? And you're rowing upstream toward a massive Oh, I like this analogy. It's that invisible line in the water much further upstream where the current of the river simply becomes faster than your absolute top paddling speed. Yes. Once you cross that line, it doesn't matter how hard you paddle. The water is pulling you backward faster than you can move forward. You are going over. That is a brilliant way to
picture the mechanics of it. Yeah. Once anything crosses that line, all of its mass is thought to be crushed down toward a single infinitely dense point right at the center, which we call the singularity. Singularity. Right. Though to be perfectly upfront, our best mathematical models of physics genuinely break down at that point. Yeah. I mean, nobody claims to fully understand what is actually happening at the singularity. It's basically the ultimate cosmic mystery box. It really is. But even if the center is, you know, a mathematical headache. We do know that
the objects themselves are real and they come in different sizes. Right. You have your stellar mass black holes, which are born when a single massive star runs out of fuel and collapses at the end of its life. And those usually weigh between five and, say, a few dozen times the mass of our sun. Okay, so that's the smaller. Yeah. Then you have what Sagittarius A is, which is a supermassive black hole. Yeah, these are a completely different beast, weighing anywhere from hundreds of thousands to many billions of solar masses. Now, at 4 million solar masses,
our local black hole actually sits toward the very small end of that supermassive range. Which is still incredibly massive. Absolutely. But that actually begs a structural question. We have stellar mass black holes that are a few times the mass of the sun and supermassive ones that are millions or billions of times the mass of the sun. What about the middle? Like, are there black holes that weigh, say, 10 ,000 suns? That is actually one of the biggest active mysteries in astrophysics right now. There is basically no well -established population of medium or
intermediate mass black holes. Really? None? Pretty much none. We see the little ones, we see the absolute giants, but essentially nothing in between. We'll actually come back to why that missing middle is so puzzling when we look at how these supermassive objects might have formed later on. Okay, looking forward to that. But before we get to how it formed, I have a massive detective problem with this entire concept. Okay, what is it? If a black hole, by its very definition, traps all light and emits absolutely zero light of its own, how on earth do you even find it?
I mean, you can't exactly aim a telescope at nothing. Right, you can't. Let alone weigh that nothing so accurately that you can confidently declare it weighs exactly 4 million solar masses. The answer to that is just one of the most elegant, patient pieces of detective work in modern astronomy. Because the trick to finding a black hole isn't to look for the darkness. It's to watch how the light around it behaves. Oh, okay. You don't look for the black hole. You watch the stars in its neighborhood. Wait, so scientists stared through the entire... dense disk of the Milky
Way, like through cosmic dust and through Earth's incredibly blurry atmosphere, just to track individual dots of light circling a dark patch of sky. They did. For decades, actually. That's wild. Yeah. Starting in the early 1990s, two independent teams of astronomers, one in Germany led by Reinhard Genzel and one in the United States led by Andrea Ghez, they decided to use the largest telescopes on Earth to track individual stars at the very center of the galaxy. But as I mentioned, they faced those massive obstacles. Huge obstacles.
First, the galactic center is shrouded in incredibly thick clouds of gas and dust. Visible light simply cannot penetrate it. So both teams had to shift their observations to infrared light. Oh, because it has longer wavelengths. Exactly. Those longer wavelengths can just slip right through that cosmic fog. Okay, but the second obstacle is just living on Earth. Right. Our atmosphere is constantly shifting and swirling. It's, you know, what makes stars twinkle to the naked eye. Right, the twinkling. Trying to take a precise measurement
through that is like trying to read the date on a coin sitting at the bottom of a rushing swimming pool. That's a great way to put it. To solve the swimming pool problem, they utilize this wild piece of engineering called adaptive optics. Adaptive optics? How does that work? They shine a powerful laser high up into the atmosphere to create an artificial guide star. Computers then measure exactly how the atmosphere is blurring that laser, and then they use that data to physically deform a thin mirror inside the telescope. Wait, physically deform it? Yeah.
It alters its shape thousands of times a second to perfectly cancel out the atmospheric distortion in real time. Wow, it's essentially noise -canceling headphones, but for light. That is a perfect analogy, yes. And all of that deeply complex engineering and patient observation paid off because they found something breathtaking. What did they see? They watched these stars at the galactic center trace out genuine closed elliptical orbits, just like planets orbiting the sun, but
they were orbiting an entirely invisible point. And one star in particular became the absolute star of the show. Yes. From our research notes, this is the star cataloged as S2 by the European team or S02 by the American team. And its orbit is relatively short, right? Yeah, about 16 years. Right. So astronomers have actually watched it complete more than one full lap around the dark center. And we really need to pause and appreciate how fast S2 is moving here. Oh, it's flying. It really is. At its closest approach to the black hole, S2 swings past at 7 ,000 kilometers
per second. Good grief. Which is over 2 % of the speed of light. And it passes within just 17 light hours of the black hole. Which doesn't sound like a lot in space terms. It's not. To put that scale in perspective, 17 light hours is just a bit further out than Pluto's orbit around our sun. That speed is just staggering. But I want to make sure I understand how tracking a fast -moving star actually gives us the weight of the black hole. Well, it comes down to the exact same... basic Newtonian physics that Isaac
Newton used to explain how planets orbit the sun. Okay. The rule is very straightforward. The heavier the central object is, the faster and tighter a star must orbit it to avoid falling in. So by measuring exactly how fast S2 was moving and exactly how tight its curve was, they proved mathematically that whatever S2 was orbiting had to possess the mass of 4 million suns. 4 million suns packed into a space so small it couldn't possibly be an ordinary cluster of stars because, I mean, a cluster that dense would just
collapse in on itself anyway. Exactly. So a supermassive black hole was literally the only physical explanation that fit the data. And that undeniable, decades -long body of work is what earned Genzel and Ghez a shared half of the 2020 Nobel Prize in Physics. Wow. And the other half went to theorist Roger Penrose, right? Yep, who decades earlier proved mathematically that black holes are an unavoidable prediction of Einstein's general relativity. The math is so elegant, and the indirect evidence of watching the stars dance is just rock solid. But human curiosity is demanding.
It is. Knowing a monster is in the room isn't enough for us. want a picture of it. But if the event horizon is a boundary that traps all light, how do you photograph it? Well, you have to capture the silhouette. You look for the incredibly hot, glowing gas swirling just outside the event horizon, and you look for the dark shadow the black hole casts against it. Okay. But to see something that small from 26 ,000 light years away, you need to build an Earth -sized camera. Enter the Event Horizon Telescope, or the EHT. Yes. The EHT is an extraordinarily ambitious project, because in astronomy, there is a fundamental
rule regarding resolution. The physically larger your telescope dish is, the sharper the details you can resolve. Right. But no single telescope dish you could possibly build on Earth is big enough to see the environment immediately surrounding a distant black hole. So rather than building a single impossible dish, they cheated in the best way possible. They totally did. They used a technique called very long baseline interferometry. Let's explain how that actually works because it's a marvel. They took radio telescopes all
over the planet from Hawaii to Chile to Spain. all the way down to the South Pole. And they pointed them all at Sagittarius A at the exact same time. At the exact same time. Yeah. And they used ultra -precise atomic clocks to timestamp every single incoming radio wave down to the microsecond. And then, this is my favorite part, they literally flew hard drives full of this data on airplanes back to supercomputers because the data files were simply too massive to send over the internet. Isn't that wild? Sneakernet on a global scale. It's amazing. So the supercomputers
align those microscopic timestamps, effectively using the rotation of the Earth to sweep these separate dishes across the sky, stitching the data together to create a single virtual telescope the size of the entire planet. And in 2019, they released their first triumph using this method, an image of a supermassive black hole in a distant galaxy called M87. Right. And then in 2022, they finally released the image of our very own Sagittarius A. Though we should refine what we are actually
looking at in that famous 2022 image because it shows a glowing, bright, slightly lopsided ring of hot gas. And right in the middle is a dark central shadow. Yes. Earlier we compared the event horizon to a bathtub drain, but I don't think that does the visual physics justice. A black hole isn't a literal hole you look down into. It's a spherical object in three -dimensional space. That is a crucial distinction. It's not a flat drain. So taking this picture is more like trying to see a perfectly transparent glass sphere. floating in a dark room, you can't see the glass sphere itself. But the room isn't totally
dark because there is glowing dust blowing all around and behind that glass sphere. The gravity of the sphere bends the light from the glowing dust, trapping some of it. So what you end up seeing is the shadow the invisible sphere casts against the glowing environment around it. That's a really great way to visualize it. And what makes that image so ironic and such a testament to the scientists involved is that capturing the image of Sagittarius A was actually considerably harder than getting the image of the distant M87 black hole. Wait, really? Yeah, even though
ours is astronautically much closer to us. But wait, if ours is in our own galactic backyard, why would it be harder to photograph? Because our black hole is roughly a thousand times less massive than M87's, so the physical space around it is much smaller, meaning the glowing material swirling around Sagittarius A completes an orbit in a matter of minutes. Oh, wow. Minutes. Exactly. With M87, the material takes days to orbit. Ah. So M87 is like having your subject sit perfectly still in a chair for an old -timey portrait,
while Sagittarius A is like trying to take a crisp photo of a hyperactive toddler running in circles. Yes. It's a frustratingly blurry, constantly moving target. The astronomers had to develop entirely new algorithms to average out those rapid minute -by -minute changes just to get a clear image. That's incredible. But seeing that glowing ring of gas brings up another fascinating reality. Compared to other supermassive black holes in the universe, ours is shockingly dim. Oh yeah. If you dive into black hole research,
you inevitably hear about quasars or active galactic nuclei. Right. These are supermassive black holes in other galaxies that are eating so much material so incredibly fast that the Friction heats the gas up until it shines brighter than the entire host galaxy combined. I mean, they can be seen clear across the observable universe. But our black hole is absolutely not doing that. It emits a little bit of radiation, some x -rays, some radio waves, and occasionally it flares up briefly. But overall, it is remarkably faint and quiet. Here's where it gets really interesting. This
implies that a black hole's terrifying power isn't an inherent trait of its size. Its visibility and destructive energy are entirely dependent on its food supply. That's exactly it. A black hole does not glow on its own. The intense glow comes entirely from the matter falling into it. Right. As gas and dust spiral inward, they form a flattened structure called an accretion disk. As the material gets closer to the event horizon, traffic jams form basically. The gas gets incredibly compressed and friction heats it up to millions
of degrees. Millions of degrees. Yeah, and that superheated disc is what actually glows. So an active quasar is just a black hole at an absolute all -you -can -eat cosmic buffet pulling in massive amounts of gas, maybe from like two galaxies colliding. Exactly. But Sagittarius A is on a very strict lean diet. There just isn't much gas available in its immediate surroundings for it to eat. It is less like a blazing furnace and more like a smoldering, mostly starved ember. Which is a primary reason it was so difficult to detect and photograph in the first place.
And, you know, the faintness of it. actually ties into the object's slightly odd name. Oh, right. Let's talk about the asterisk. Where did that come from? So the broader region of the galactic center, known as Sagittarius A, was discovered as a bright source of radio waves back in the 1950s. Okay. But in 1974, two American astronomers, Bruce Bailick and Robert Brown, found a particularly compact, unusually bright point right at the center of that broader radio region. And when they labeled it on their charts,
they borrowed a naming convention from atomic physics, right? Exactly. In physics, when an atom is in an excited or higher energy state, you denote that by marking it with an asterisk. Since this compact core was a very excited, distinctive feature compared to the rest of the sky, they playfully named it Sagittarius A. That's such a great detail. Yeah, and it took decades for Genzel and Ghez to ultimately confirm that the excited asterisk was indeed a black hole. And once we knew the mass was 4 million suns, we could calculate its physical size. Every black
hole has what's called a Schwarzschild radius, which is the mathematical boundary of the event horizon. Okay, so for our 4 million sun monster, that radius is about 12 million kilometers, which honestly sounds huge until you remember the scale of our solar system. Right, space is big. Yeah, that means the entire event horizon would comfortably fit inside the orbit of Mercury around our sun. With millions of miles of room to spare, we essentially squeezed 4 million suns into a space smaller than Mercury's orbit. And that extreme compression
creates an environment with gravity so intense that it becomes the ultimate pristine laboratory to test our most fundamental laws of physics. Specifically, Einstein's general theory of relativity. We brought the star S2 back into the picture for this, right? The one zooming around it at 2 % the speed of light. We did. Because S2 gets so incredibly close to the black hole, it experiences gravitational forces we simply cannot replicate anywhere on Earth. In 2018, during S2's closest approach, astronomers observed a phenomenon called
gravitational redshift. Gravitational redshift? Yeah, and we need to explain why this happens, because it proves Einstein was right about how gravity affects light. Okay, so, when I throw a baseball straight up... as it fights gravity, it loses kinetic energy and slows down. Right. But when light climbs out of an intense gravitational well, It can't slow down because light fundamentally must always move at the speed of light. So instead of slowing down, it loses energy in a different way. Exactly. The energy of a light wave is tied to its frequency. So as the light from the star
S2 struggled to climb out of the black hole's immense gravity, it lost energy by dropping in frequency. Meaning the light waves physically stretched out into longer, redder wavelengths. Yep. Astronomers watched the star's light literally turn redder as it swung past the black hole. Newton's older theory of gravity couldn't predict that. Only Einstein's did. And then, in 2020, they observed something even wilder regarding the orbit itself's short child precession. Oh, this is so cool. Under basic Newtonian physics, an elliptical orbit should be a closed loop.
The star should trace the exact same oval path forever. But Einstein's theory says that extreme mass actually warps the fabric of space itself. Because space is warped near the black hole, the orbit doesn't perfectly close its loop. Every time S2 completes a lap, its oval path overshoots just a tiny bit. Over decades, the entire elliptical orbit slowly rotates, tracing out a shape that looks like a spirograph pattern rather than a single repeating oval. So we used a four million
sun cosmic monster to prove a highly abstract math equation Einstein wrote a century ago on a chalkboard. Pretty much. And the math held up flawlessly. It did. But while Sagittarius A is acting as a quiet, well -behaved physics laboratory today, there is stark evidence hanging over our galaxy that it wasn't always this peaceful. The Fermi bubbles. Yes. Astronomers using space telescopes have detected these enormous, symmetrical, bubble -like structures extending far above and far below the flat plane of the Milky Way. And they blow, right? Yeah, they glow faintly in
high -energy gamma rays. The prevailing theory is that these are the fading relics of a massive, violent feeding outburst from our black hole a few million years ago. So it wasn't always a starving ember. A few million years ago, which is practically yesterday in cosmic time, it was feasting on a massive cloud of gas and blasting out devastating amounts of energy. It's intense. It really is. It just reminds you that a sleeping giant is still a giant. Which brings us to the most perplexing part of our deep dive. How did
a black hole this massive get there in the first place? That is a genuinely unsettled area of science right now. The logical assumption for decades was that a supermassive black hole starts as a normal stellar mass black hole. Over billions of years, it just patiently eats gas and merges with other black holes, slowly growing from a few suns to 4 billion solar masses. But the James Webb Space Telescope completely threw a wrench in that timeline. It really did. Webb has been looking back at the incredibly early universe, very close to the Big Bang. And it is finding
fully formed supermassive black holes sitting in early galaxies uncomfortably soon after the universe began. Uncomfortably soon. Like way too soon for them to have grown just by snacking on gas bit by bit. Right. The cosmic timeline simply doesn't allow for it. And remember that missing middle we talked about earlier? The lack of intermediate black holes? Yep. The missing middle. That absence suggests these giants might not be growing step by step. So astrophysicists have two main competing theories to explain these ancient monsters, right? Yes. The first is that these early black holes started from unusually
massive stellar seeds. Basically, the very first generation of stars in the universe might have been gigantic, way bigger than any star forming today, which would give their resulting black holes a massive head start. Okay, that makes sense. But the second theory is called direct collapse. This idea proposes that in the extreme dense conditions of the early universe, enormous clouds of primordial gas could have collapsed straight down under their own immense weight into black holes weighing tens of thousands of solar masses. So they would entirely skip the
process of ever igniting into a star. Exactly, just bypassing the star phase entirely and going straight from a gas cloud to a massive black hole. Both ideas are fascinating, and I know neither is fully confirmed yet. But hearing about massive black holes forming and violent gamma ray outbursts, it might naturally make you wonder, is this thing a threat to us? Fortunately, no. Oh, good. Yeah, at 26 ,000 light years away, out here in the quiet suburbs of one of the Milky Way's spiral arms, our solar system is completely
safe. The black hole's direct gravitational pull on us is practically zero. That is a relief. But if we connect this to the bigger picture, though while it doesn't threaten us today, its past outbursts likely influenced how our entire galaxy formed. Oh, interesting. Yeah, many astronomers now believe that supermassive black holes and their social galaxies don't just meet by chance. They grow up together in a deeply intertwined relationship. When the black hole feeds and blasts out radiation, it can heat up or blow away gas in the wider galaxy, which directly controls
how and where new stars can actually form. What does this all mean? We started by standing in the dark, looking up at the hazy band of the Milky Way. And what we found at its heart, hidden behind dust and distance, is something utterly alien. A place where time and space literally break down and gravity traps light itself. Yet it is also incredibly close to home. I mean, in the most literal sense, it is the anchor our entire solar system is quietly orbiting. There is something so... profoundly poetic about the
fact that for decades this monster was entirely invisible to us. We only learned it was there by watching the stars around it dance to gravity's tune, carefully tracking their speed to weigh a ghost. It really makes you look at the night sky entirely differently. It absolutely changes your perspective on our place in the universe. It really does. Which leaves us with one final lingering question to ponder as we wrap up this deep dive. If supermassive black holes and galaxies really do grow up together and the wet telescope is finding these massive black holes shockingly
early in the universe what actually came first well the big question did a massive cloud of gas form a sprawling galaxy which then slowly funneled material inward to create a supermassive black hole at its center or did the black hole form first through direct collapse acting as the ultimate gravitational seed that forced the galaxy to build around it the chicken or the egg on a cosmic scale think about that the next time you look up at the stars
Nanotechnology works at a scale where a nanometre is to a metre what a single centimetre is to the distance across a football field roughly a hundred thousand times over. This episode explains what nanotechnology...
A tagged bar-tailed godwit once flew more than thirteen thousand kilometres from Alaska to Tasmania without landing once. This episode explores why animals migrate at all, from godwits and humpback whales to monarch...
The Sun is an active, magnetic star, and every so often it hurls bursts of radiation and clouds of charged particles toward Earth, a phenomenon called space weather. This episode explains solar flares and coronal mass...
An ordinary wave rolls onto the sand every few seconds; a tsunami can take tens of minutes between crests and cross an entire ocean at the speed of a jet aircraft while barely rippling the surface. This episode explains...
A folded square of paper and a butterfly's wings share the same simple visual idea: a shape that looks the same after some transformation. This episode follows that idea from everyday geometry into the deepest...