Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Talking Science

Talking Science artwork

Nuclear Fusion — The Star in a Bottle

Jul 22, 202620 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Fusion is the reaction that powers the Sun, and for seventy years it's been the great dream of clean energy - limitless fuel, no carbon, no long-lived waste. It's also famously "always thirty years away." We explain what fusion actually is, why it's so fiendishly hard to do on Earth, what recent milestones did and didn't achieve, and why the optimism and the caution are both justified. You'll come away understanding the difference between fusion and fission, why you have to build a machine hotter than the Sun's core, what "ignition" and "net energy" really mean, and why fusion is a genuine hope rather than a con - but not a quick one. Talking Science is sponsored by Kinsoft. Visit www.kinsoft.com.au Further reading: ITER (iter.org); the US National Ignition Facility results (2022); the UK Atomic Energy Authority fusion resources.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

So there is this famous and I guess admittedly slightly cynical joke among 70 -year -old physicists. Oh, I think I know the one you're talking about. Yeah, it goes like this. Fusion power is the energy of the future and it always will be. Right, yeah. The ultimate scientific running joke. I mean, the promise of unlimited fusion energy has famously been, you know, 30 years away. For about 70 years now. Literally 70 years. Exactly. If you track the headlines through the decades,

it just always seems to be sitting perpetually over the horizon, right? Like it's never quite arriving. Always the bridesmaid, never the bride. But, you know, the reason we're doing this deep dive into these sources with you today is because the mood in the global scientific community has genuinely shifted. It really has. We aren't just looking at the same old theoretical promises anymore. I mean, laboratories around the world have actually crossed some. very real historic milestones recently. Yeah, the conversation is definitively moving from pure science fiction into the realm of applied engineering. I mean,

the physics is essentially proven at this point. The question now is just how we actually build the machine. Which brings us to our mission for this deep dive. We're going to completely demystify this science for you. We'll strip away the dense academic jargon and get down to the absolute core of the matter. Like, what actually is fusion? Right. Why is it so absurdly, impossibly difficult to pull off? And, you know, most importantly, is this this fresh wave of optimism justified? Or is it just another round of billion dollar

hype? And we should probably set the ground rules right now for everyone listening. We are taking this at an unhurried, welcoming pace. Absolutely. The concepts are, they're mind bending, sure. But the underlying logic is something anyone can grasp. Yeah, totally. And if you're listening to this right now, I really want to remind you that absolutely no prior science background is needed today. We're going to break this down together. Step by step. Exactly. So to understand the future of energy, we really first need to understand the present. And that means clearing up the perpetual confusion between the two major

F words of nuclear physics. Oh, yeah. Fission and fusion. Right. They sound nearly identical. But the mechanisms couldn't be more opposed. Yeah, they really are total opposites. I mean, fission is the current standard, right? It's the technology running inside, well, every single nuclear power plant operating on the grid today. Right. And in mechanical terms, fission basically means splitting apart. You take a massive heavy atom, usually an isotope of uranium, and you strike it so that its nucleus just, you know, breaks apart into smaller, lighter pieces. Okay,

let's unpack this. If fission is splitting a heavy atom apart, Then fusion is the exact opposite. Fusion means merging. Right. You're taking very light atoms, specifically forms of hydrogen, and you are forcing them to smash together to build a slightly heavier atom. Splitting the heavy, merging the light. But the immediate question that usually trips people up is this. If they're doing completely opposite things, how do both processes release such massive amounts of energy? Yeah, it seems like a paradox, right? You'd think one would absorb energy and the other would release

it? You would think so. But it really comes down to this concept called the curve of binding energy, which is essentially the universe's quest for stability. Okay, how does that work? So imagine a valley. Everything in nature wants to roll down to the lowest, most stable point in that valley, right? For atomic nuclei, the bottom of that valley, the most stable state, is actually iron. Iron. Okay. Yeah. So uranium is way up high on one side of the valley because it's too heavy and cumbersome. And hydrogen is way up

on the other side because it's too light. Oh, I see. So whether you are cracking uranium apart to make it smaller or smashing hydrogen together to make it bigger, you're moving toward that stable middle ground. Exactly. And when the universe settles into a more relaxed, stable state, it sheds the excess energy it no longer needs. And that excess energy just comes flying out as intense heat and light. Wow. Yeah. And in a fission plant, we just use that heat to boil water, create steam, and spin a giant turbine to make electricity.

Which is always so wild to me. The irony of our most advanced fission reactors is that they're ultimately just incredibly sophisticated ways to boil water. It really is funny when you put it like that. And fusion would also generate heat to spin turbines, but the raw energy release per reaction is significantly higher. And just to connect this to your everyday experience if you're listening, every single time you feel the warmth of the sun on your face, you are directly feeling the results of a fusion reaction. Yep. That pleasant warmth on a summer afternoon is literally the heat of hydrogen nuclei fusing

into helium, 150 million kilometers away. and it travels across the vacuum of space just to hit your cheek. Which naturally brings up the trillion -dollar question. If the sun is already doing this naturally, and, you know, if we already have fission reactors down here on Earth boiling water and keeping the lights on, why are governments and private companies spending billions of dollars and decades of research trying to recreate a star on Earth? Yeah, I mean, why reinvent the wheel if the fission wheel is working? Well, on paper, fusion is as close to a flawless energy

source as humanity could theoretically conceive. That's a big claim. It is. But let's just run through the checklist. First, the fuel. To run a fusion plant, the primary fuel is hydrogen, specifically isotopes called deuterium and tritium. And deuterium can be extracted directly from water, H2O. So, meaning the fuel supply is essentially an ocean. Exactly. We've basically never run out. Never. Furthermore, regarding the climate, a fusion reaction produces zero carbon dioxide. There's no combustion involved at all, so it doesn't contribute to greenhouse gases or global

warming. Okay, so limitless fuel and zero carbon. But here's where I kind of want to push back a little. Because when people hear the word nuclear, they immediately picture, you know, glowing green barrels of radioactive waste that we have to bury deep inside a mountain for 10 ,000 years. Right. The Homer Simpson barrels. Exactly. That's the major political and environmental controversy with fission. Sure. But the waste profile of fusion completely changes the equation. Because when you fuse those hydrogen atoms together,

the primary byproduct that emerges is just helium. Wait, literally? the stuff we put inside party balloons. The exact same stuff. Completely inert, harmless helium. Now, to be completely transparent, it's not entirely magic. Okay. While the fuel and the byproduct aren't long -lived radioactive waste, the fusion reaction does release incredibly high energy neutrons. And over time, those neutrons bombard the physical walls of the reactor chamber, which actually makes the steel structure itself somewhat radioactive. Right, so the machine eventually

becomes low -level waste itself. Yeah, exactly. But, I mean, that's a completely different scale of problem. We aren't dealing with... spent uranium fuel rods that's being dangerously radioactive for millennia. We're talking about reactor parts that might need to be stored for, what, a few decades before they're safe to recycle? Yeah, a few decades. It's a vastly more manageable issue. And then we hit the final piece of the utopian promise, which is safety. Because the word most feared in the nuclear industry is meltdown. Right. Chernobyl, Fukushima. Exactly. Which is

physically impossible with fusion. Wait, really? Impossible? Physically impossible. A fusion reaction is incredibly delicate. It requires perfectly maintained extreme conditions just to keep the atoms merging. If a catastrophic event happens, like an earthquake or a grid failure or even just a minor sensor malfunction, the plasma instantly cools and the reaction simply stops. Oh, wow. Yeah, there is no chain reaction. There is zero physical risk of a runaway meltdown. Okay, so limitless clean energy, no carbon emissions,

no risk of a meltdown, and no... long -lived nuclear waste. I mean, it sounds like pure magic. So what is the catch? Why isn't every city on earth running on seawater right now? Well, the catch is the physics. Achieving fusion is a profoundly difficult problem, and it's rooted in the fundamental forces of nature. We basically have to figure out how to force two atomic nuclei to touch. Let's get into the mechanics of that, because at the center of every atom is the nucleus, right? And nuclei are positively charged. So if you

ever played with strong magnets as a kid, you know exactly what happens when you try to force two positive poles together. Yeah, the electromagnetic force pushes them apart. The closer you bring them, the more violently they repel each other. They desperately want to avoid touching. It honestly feels like there's a dense invisible rubber ball between them. And atomic nuclei repel each other fiercely at close range. So how do you overcome that invisible rubber ball? You have to force them so close together. that a completely different fundamental force takes over, and that's the strong nuclear force. It's the force that binds

the universe together at the microscopic level, but the strong nuclear force only works at almost unimaginably short distances. So to get the atoms close enough for that strong force to just click them together, you have to smash right through that furious electrical repulsion. And really the only way to smash through that barrier is to hurl the atoms at each other at colossal speed. Exactly. And in the world of physics, You know, when you're talking about gases, speed is the exact same thing as temperature. So to make hydrogen nuclei move fast enough to collide and fuse,

you have to heat the fuel to well over 100 million degrees Celsius. Yeah, and just to put a pin in that number for a second, 100 million degrees Celsius. That is roughly 10 times hotter than the center of the sun. Right. And what's fascinating here is that the sun actually has a massive cheat code. A cheat code. Yeah. it doesn't need to reach 100 million degrees. The sun's core is incredibly hot. It's around 15 million degrees. But it achieves fusion primarily through gravity. I mean, the sun is so unfathomably massive that

its own sheer weight crushes its core to this unimaginable density. That intense gravitational pressure essentially squeezes the atoms together, allowing fusion to happen at lower temperatures. Which makes sense, but we obviously cannot build a machine that reproduces the gravitational crush of an entire star here on Earth. No, definitely not. So without that pressure, we have to compensate the only way we can, which is just pure unadulterated... We have to crank the temperature up to that 100 million degree mark. Which introduces a completely

new state of matter. Because when you heat gas to these extreme temperatures, it just stops acting like a normal gas. The heat is so intense that the electrons are violently stripped away from their nuclei. And what you're left with is this searing, highly charged soup of free -floating particles. Right. And that is what we call a plasma. For anyone listening, it's the fourth state of matter. You have solid, liquid, gas. and then plasma yep that's exactly it and this plasma is again 10 times hotter than the core of a star which brings up a staggering engineering

dilemma yeah because if we create a plasma that hot there isn't a single physical material on earth that can contain it right i mean steel tungsten Carbon fiber, diamond, it doesn't matter. Any physical container would vaporize instantly upon contact. Yeah. So how do you hold something in a box when it can't be allowed to touch the walls of the box? Yeah, how to hold a star. It's the ultimate problem. Over the last several decades, the global scientific community has essentially split into two camps, devising two brilliantly distinct engineering strategies to contain the

uncontainable. Strategy one is called magnetic confinement. Because we just established that plasma is a soup of electrically charged particles. And because they have an electrical charge, they are heavily influenced by magnetic fields. So the strategy here is to use incredibly powerful magnets to grip the plasma in midair, basically suspending it entirely inside a giant vacuum chamber. It acts as an invisible bottle made entirely of magnetic force fields. The plasma just hovers in the vacuum, never touching the solid walls. But the shape of that bottle is

crucial, right? Because if you just put plasma in a straight magnetic pipe, it's just going to shoot right out the ends. Oh, absolutely. The geometry has to be perfect. And the most successful design for this is called a tokamak. It's this massive donut -shaped chamber. And by curving the magnetic field lines back onto themselves into a closed loop, the plasma endlessly chases its own tail around and around the donut. And this isn't just some theoretical blueprint in a textbook somewhere. The biggest example of this approach is iTour. Yes. It's an absolutely

colossal international collaboration currently under construction. in the south of France. I mean, it involves dozens of countries. Yes. And is easily one of the most complex engineering projects humanity has ever attempted. It's right up there with the Large Hadron Collider or the International Space Station. Yeah, ITER really represents the pinnacle of the magnetic approach, gripping that continuous plasma donut. But strategy two takes the exact opposite approach. It's called inertial confinement. Okay. So instead of trying to hold a continuous ring of plasma suspended for minutes or hours, you go for a sudden, violent,

microscopic burst. Right. So you take a tiny... perfectly spherical pellet of hydrogen fuel, roughly the size of a peppercorn. You place it in the center of a target chamber and you blast it from all sides simultaneously with the world's most powerful lasers. Yeah. And the mechanics of how this works are incredibly clever. It's a process called ablation. The lasers don't just crush the pellet directly. They hit the outer shell of the pellet, vaporizing it instantly. Oh, and because of Newton's third law. Every action has an equal and opposite reaction. As that outer shell explodes violently outward,

the inner core of the fuel is driven violently inward. Exactly. It's like billions of microscopic rocket engines pushing the fuel inward at 400 kilometers per second. The compression is so fast and the heat is so intense that the fuel fuses in a billionth of a second. It literally happens before the pellet even has time to realize it's exploding and fly apart. That is insane. Done at the National Ignition Facility, or NIF. in California. So just to lock this in for you listening, humanity is trying to hold a star

either by trapping it in an invisible magnetic donut. or by instantly crushing a peppercorn of fuel with massive lasers before it can escape. Yep, those are the two pads up the mountain right now. And keeping those massive laser beams in mind leads us directly to the historic milestone that shifted the scientific mood so dramatically. Here's where it gets really interesting. Because in late 2022, the National Ignition Facility out in California, the laser ablation facility we just talked about, made a monumental announcement. They sure did. They announced that for the very first time in human history, a fusion reaction

produced more energy than the laser light delivered to the fuel pellet. Yeah. In physics, this threshold is called ignition. The reaction was genuinely net positive. The pellet gave back more energy than the lasers pumped into it. I mean, we proved the concept. We finally whipped the star and got a return on our investment. It is an undeniably historic first. The physics works. However, if we connect this to the bigger picture, we have to be extremely precise about what that milestone actually means for our energy grid. Right. Because this is where the media hype and the engineering

reality start to part ways. So what is the catch with the 2022 announcement? Well, the catch is a slight accounting trick. When the facility claimed a net positive reaction, they were using a metric called target gain. They only compared the energy contained in the laser beams actually striking the pellet versus the energy the pellet produced. Okay, so laser energy in, fusion energy out. Exactly. But what that accounting leaves out is a metric called wall plug gain. It completely ignored the vastly larger amount of electricity required from the California power grid just

to fire those massive inefficient lasers in the first place. Oh, I see. It's kind of like running a business where you finally made a $10 profit on a single product, but it cost you $100 in overhead electricity just to keep the lights on in the factory. That is a perfect analogy. The lasers at the National Ignition Facility were built in the 1990s. They're terribly inefficient. So when you look at the entire facility, counting every bit of electricity pulled from the wall, the operation used far, far more energy than

the tiny fusion reaction released. Synthesizing this. Yeah. Both things are entirely true, right? It is a genuinely historic scientific milestone because the fusion physics worked exactly as predicted. Yes, absolutely. But we are still incredibly far away. from a commercially viable power plant that you could actually plug your house into. You have to hold both of those truths in your head at the same time. We have crossed a massive threshold in theoretical physics, but we haven't yet solved the far larger engineering puzzle of net electricity generation on a macro

scale. So what does this all mean for us, for you listening to this right now? Is fusion just a perpetual money pit, or is it something to genuinely root for? Oh, it is undeniably a real hope, but it requires a mindset of patient optimism. This isn't a theoretical con game anymore. The physics is completely sound. The sun proves the physics works in nature, and the lab in California proves we can spark a net positive reaction here on Earth. So the remaining hurdles aren't mysterious

physics questions. They are basically brutal engineering challenges. Yeah, material science challenges, mostly. I mean, how do we sustain the reaction? and magnetic donut for months or years rather than just fractions of a second. Right. How do we manufacture physical materials for the chamber walls that can actually survive the brutal neutron radiation for years without turning brittle and degrading? And, you know, how do we build lasers and magnets efficient enough that the whole system generates massive net electricity? The cavalry is starting to arrive on that front, though, because it's not just

massive, slow -moving government labs anymore. Oh, definitely not. We are seeing a massive wave of private companies stepping into the arena right now. Yeah. Startups fueled by venture capital are working alongside the big public projects and they're bringing agility. They're deploying brand new technologies, things like high temperature superconducting magnets, AI driven supercomputers to model plasma behavior and vastly superior lasers than what was available even a decade ago. It's still decades away, but the pace of

innovation is clearly. accelerating. I mean the phrase clean fusion electricity is just around the corner is definitely getting ahead of the evidence. But after 70 years of trying we have finally lit the star in the bottle even if only for a fleeting instant. Yeah. Keeping it lit is just the next mountain to climb. Patient optimism is the only way forward. The payoff is just too enormous to stop now. It really is. And as we wrap up this deep dive into our sources today, I want to leave you with one final mind -expanding thought to ponder on your own. Oh, I like where

this is going. Because we've talked so much about the science, but the geopolitical implications of this go so far beyond just paying a lower electric bill. It shifts the entire foundation of modern society. Exactly. Think about this. We have spent the last century watching global geopolitics, wars, alliances and economies be dictated almost entirely by who controls the ground that holds oil, natural gas and coal. Right. Access to fossil fuels has basically drawn the borders and defined the power map of the

modern world. Energy security is national security. Always. But if the ultimate energy source of the future. perfect, limitless fusion power is fueled essentially by hydrogen pulled from everyday water, how completely does that rewrite the power map of the entire human race? It's profound. If energy is no longer something you have to dig out of a specific piece of dirt, but something any nation with a coastline can extract from the ocean. I mean, it changes absolutely everything. Just something to think about next time you turn on the tap or feel that morning sun on your face.

It represents a completely different paradigm for human civilization. It really does. Thank you so much for joining us and exploring this deep dive into the sources today. We hope we cleared up some of the mystery around the most exciting energy puzzle on the planet. Take care and keep looking up.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Nanotechnology – Building at the Scale of Atoms

    Nov 19, 202626 minAudio

    Nanotechnology works at a scale where a nanometre is to a metre what a single centimetre is to the distance across a football field roughly a hundred thousand times over. This episode explains what nanotechnology...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Animal Migration – Navigation Without Maps

    Nov 17, 202625 minAudio

    A tagged bar-tailed godwit once flew more than thirteen thousand kilometres from Alaska to Tasmania without landing once. This episode explores why animals migrate at all, from godwits and humpback whales to monarch...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Space Weather – When the Sun Attacks Our Technology

    Nov 15, 202625 minAudio

    The Sun is an active, magnetic star, and every so often it hurls bursts of radiation and clouds of charged particles toward Earth, a phenomenon called space weather. This episode explains solar flares and coronal mass...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Tsunamis – Waves That Cross Oceans

    Nov 12, 202623 minAudio

    An ordinary wave rolls onto the sand every few seconds; a tsunami can take tens of minutes between crests and cross an entire ocean at the speed of a jet aircraft while barely rippling the surface. This episode explains...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Symmetry – Physics' Deepest Idea

    Nov 10, 202620 minAudio

    A folded square of paper and a butterfly's wings share the same simple visual idea: a shape that looks the same after some transformation. This episode follows that idea from everyday geometry into the deepest...

    Credit the people on this episode