Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Talking Science

Talking Science artwork

Renewable Energy – Sun, Wind and Water

Jul 24, 202623 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

The world is racing to shift how it makes electricity, away from burning fossil fuels and towards energy drawn from the sun, the wind and moving water. This episode explains how the main renewable technologies actually work - and the real engineering challenge they still face. You’ll come away understanding how solar panels and wind turbines turn nature into electricity, why hydro is the quiet giant of renewables, what “intermittency” means, and why energy storage is the key that unlocks the whole transition. Talking Science is sponsored by Kinsoft. Visit www.kinsoft.com.au Further reading: International Energy Agency - “Renewables” reports; CSIRO - “Renewable energy”; David MacKay, Sustainable Energy - Without the Hot Air.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

So I want you to think about a just a simple flip of a light switch. You probably did it this morning. Oh, yeah. Or even just a few seconds ago. Exactly. Your hand brushes that plastic plate on the wall. You hear that little click and instantly a dark room is just flooded with light. Or, you know, you press a button and your coffee maker springs to life. It is it's probably the most mundane action in the modern world. It really is. Yeah. But for the entirety of the industrial age, that tiny little switch was powered in fundamentally one way, which is by burning

things. Right. It's basically this unbroken lineage of fire. For generations, the story of our electricity has really just been the story of combustion. Yeah. We dig up coal. We pump up oil and gas. All these ancient fossilized fuels. Buried underground for millions of years. We bring them up and we set fire to them and we use the immense heat from those fires to boil water. Which creates steam. Right. Highly pressurized steam. The steam is forced through these big turbines to make them spin and that spinning motion generates the electricity. But of course, in the process

of setting all those fires, we have loaded the atmosphere with carbon dioxide. Yeah, and irreversibly altered the climate of the planet. Exactly. So today we are going on a deep dive into the alternative. We're going to explore how we can power our entire modern lives. You know, everything from the smartphone in your pocket to the heavy commuter trains running through your city, but without the burning. And to do that, we're going to unpack the three great pillars of renewable energy, the sun, the wind and moving water. We really want to look closely

at how these three pillars actually work on a mechanical level, like how they physically convert nature into electricity. Because understanding the mechanics completely changes how you see the world around you. Totally. And don't worry, you do not need a science degree for this today. We are going to take our time and walk through the physical realities of these technologies. We also have to talk about the single, massive, shared obstacle standing in their way, right? The physical reality of pulling this global transition off. Yeah, we can't ignore the challenges. But to kick things off, let's look at a technology

that is genuinely alien compared to the spinning turbines of the past century. You're talking about solar power. I am. Almost all other electricity generation, whether it's a coal plant or like a nuclear sub, relies on motion. Something has to physically spin. Right. But a solar panel has zero moving parts. It just sits completely still in a field or on a roof, and it generates electricity directly from sunlight. Using something called the photovoltaic effect. Right, which

sounds incredibly sci -fi. It does, but if we break that technical term down, photo just means light, and voltaic means electricity. So it is literally a direct conversion of light into electric current. And how does a flat, silent panel actually pull that off? Well, that direct conversion is made possible by the material the panels are built from. A solar panel is essentially made of specially treated slices of silicon. Silicon? Like what's in our laptops? Exactly the same stuff. It's a semiconductor, the exact same basic material used to make microscopic computer chips

for your phone. And ultimately, silicon is derived from silica, which is the primary component of ordinary sand. Okay, so you basically start with a sheet of highly refined treated sand. Yeah, that's a good way to look at it. So sunlight is made up of these tiny packets of energy called photons. Right. These photons travel all the way across the vacuum of space. They hit our atmosphere and they finally strike the silicon surface. And when they hit, they have enough physical energy to actually knock electrons loose

from the atoms inside the material. Wow. OK. But knocking electrons loose isn't enough on its own, right? No, because if they just scatter randomly, you don't get power. The engineering brilliance is in how the panel is manufactured. manufactured and layered, it has a built -in electric field. Ah, I see. So once those photons knock the electrons loose, the internal structure of the panel naturally nudges all those freed electrons to flow in one specific direction. And a steady directional flow of electrons is the very definition of an electrical current. Exactly. You know, I always picture this like

a giant game of pool. Okay, I like that. How so? Well, the sunlight coming down from the sky is the cue ball, right? And it comes smashing into the rack, breaking the arrangement, and scattering all the billiard balls across the table. And the billiard balls are the electrons in this scenario. Exactly. Now, the solar panel itself is designed like a slightly tilted pool table. So when the sunlight scatters all those electrons, the tilt of the table ensures they all naturally roll down into one specific pocket. Which creates this continuous directed stream.

Right. That steady stream of balls dropping into the pocket is your electrical current ready to be wired directly into your house. That is a brilliant analogy. And the sheer tranquility of that process is what really sets solar apart. Because it's completely silent. Yes. Sunlight lands on a steel panel, and electric current flows straight out the back. There's no fuel being burned. There are no heavy steel parts grinding against each other or wearing down over time. It's sand and sun. It is a silent translation of raw solar radiation into usable power. But,

I mean, solar has an obvious limitation. When the Earth rotates and the sun goes down, that pool table stops catching photons. It does. It goes completely dormant. Which forces us to look for... complementary natural forces, right? Things that often pick up in the evening or maybe off the coast, which brings us from silent stillness. Back to motion. Wind power. Right. And modern wind turbines, they aren't just big flat sails catching a breeze and being pushed backward like old school windmills, are they? No, the physics

are entirely different. A modern wind turbine is this absolute marvel of aerodynamics. Oh, so? Well, if you stand underneath one and look closely at the blades, you'll see they are curved and shaped remarkably like the wings of a passenger airplane. Really? Like airplane wings. Exactly like them. As the moving air flows over the curved surface of the blade, the air moving over the curved side actually travels faster than the air moving across the flatter side. Okay. And that speed difference creates a difference in air pressure. And that pressure difference creates lift. You got it. It's the exact same aerodynamic

force that allows a heavy commercial jet to take off from a runway. That is wild to think about. But because the turbine blades are fixed to a central hub, they can't fly away. That lift just forces the blades to rotate in a circle. Okay, so that rotational motion is the first step. The spinning blades turn a long central shaft inside that housing at the top of the tower, right? Right, the nacelle. And that shaft is connected to the absolute workhorse of the modern industrial world, which is the generator. And just so we're clear, how exactly does a generator

work? A generator makes electricity by spinning massive magnets past tightly wound coils of copper wire. Wait, wait. So if I'm understanding the underlying mechanics here, spinning a magnet past a wire is the exact same trick a traditional coal plant uses. It is the universal trick of electricity generation. Yeah, it's rooted in this fundamental law of electromagnetism called electromagnetic induction. basically when you move a magnetic field near a conductive wire the magnetic force literally pulls and pushes the electrons within the copper atoms setting

them flowing through the wire Mind blown. So whether you are burning pulverized coal to create steam or splitting uranium atoms in a nuclear reactor to create steam, the ultimate goal is literally just to turn a turbine that spins a magnet inside a coil of wire. That is the whole point, yes. With wind power, we are simply cutting out the middleman. We aren't setting anything on fire to boil water. Nope. We are just letting the moving atmosphere do the mechanical work of spinning the magnet for us. When you put those two pieces together, I mean, the aerodynamics...

and the electromagnetism, you realize that a modern wind turbine is essentially an airplane wing attached to a giant magnet. Pulling invisible energy right out of the sky. That is just incredible. And the scale of these things is staggering, too. I read that some of the offshore turbines being built today are taller than a lot of city skyscrapers. They are massive. And the scale you're seeing, it's purely a function of efficiency and fluid dynamics. Meaning bigger is better. Exactly. The bigger the blades, the larger the swept area they cover, which allows them to capture vastly more wind energy in a single rotation.

And they have to reach really high up, right? Yeah, because down near the surface, wind is highly turbulent. It's disrupted by trees, hills, buildings. But several hundred feet up in the air, the wind is a smooth, powerful, continuous physical force. So they reach up to catch that steady flow. Right. The turbine's job is to capture as much of that kinetic energy as possible. and feed it right into the generator. Okay, so if the universal trick to generating electricity is spinning a magnet inside a coil of wire with a natural force, we don't have to limit ourselves

to the air, do we? Not at all. We can harness the Earth's heaviest moving resource, which is water. So let's talk about the quiet, heavyweight giant of the grid, hydroelectric power. Hydro is the oldest large scale renewable energy source we have. I mean, we've been using it for well over a century, long before solar panels and wind turbines were even seriously considered for grid scale power. Yeah, it's easy to forget that. People do forget that hydro still provides more electricity worldwide than solar and wind

combined. Wow. More than both combined. Yep. It is the heavyweight champion. And the mechanics of how it pulls off that magnet trick. are remarkably straightforward. You find a massive river, typically flowing naturally through a valley, and you build a giant concrete dam Right across it. Right, creating a massive artificial barrier. And that barrier holds back a huge reservoir of water at a significant height. You are trapping all the potential energy of that water high up in the valley. Exactly. And then, when you need

power, you simply open heavily reinforced gates at the base of the dam and let that water rush down through massive enclosed tunnels. And as millions of gallons of water fall through those tunnels, the immense weight, pressure, and velocity of the fluid just slam into large turbines positioned... in the flow. So it's gravity doing the work here. Yes. Gravity's downward pull spins the turbines, which, just like the wind turbines, spin the generators. Magnets rotate past copper wire, and electricity flows out. So instead of wind creating lift, it is gravity pulling a heavy

liquid from high to low. That's the mechanism, yeah. Now, looking at our sources, it notes that hydro has a massive operational advantage over the sun and the wind. It is highly reliable, and easily controlled. Very easily controlled. Grid operators can switch it on and off relatively quickly just by opening or closing those intake gates so they can adjust the flow of electricity to match exactly what the city needs at any given moment. And control is the most valuable trait you can possibly have on a power grid. But, you

know, the limits of hydro are incredibly strict. Because of the geography, right? Yeah. You can't just build a hydro dam anywhere you want power. It requires very specific, rare geography. A powerful river flowing through a deep valley to create that necessary reservoir. I have to pause on the whole clean energy label for a second here. Because we constantly hear renewables pitched as universally green and clean. Right. But reading about the sheer physical reality of hydroelectricity. I mean, building giant concrete walls across

major waterways and intentionally flooding massive valleys. It's clear that renewable energy can severely damage the local environment. Yeah. The physical reality is that nothing in energy production is free of tradeoffs. Nothing. Hydroelectricity is renewable because the water cycle naturally replenishes the river and it doesn't pollute the atmosphere with greenhouse gases. But the environmental footprint is undeniable. It's huge. Building a large dam permanently floods vast tracts of land, destroying natural forests and

habitats. It displaces entire human communities who lived in those valleys. And it messes with the river itself, doesn't it? It completely severs river ecosystems in half. It prevents fish from migrating, and it traps nutrient -rich sediment behind the concrete wall. Oh, which slowly starves the downstream wildlife that depends on that natural flow. So renewable does not automatically mean zero impact. Not at all. It just means... the fuel source won't run out and it isn't altering the global climate. But it still leaves a very real permanent scar on the local physical landscape.

That is the sober reality of large -scale infrastructure. However, hydro's superpower, you know, the fact that humans can control it, open a gate, and dispatch power exactly when demand spikes, that highlights the most difficult obstacle we face with solar and wind. Right, which brings us to the core technical hurdle of the entire energy transition, intermittency. Yes, the big hurdle. So for those who don't know, a power source is intermittent if it does not produce electricity continuously on command. Because the plain unavoidable

fact is that the sun does not always shine and the wind... does not always blow. A solar panel produces absolutely nothing in the dead of night. And its output drops drastically on a cloudy, rainy afternoon. And a wind turbine falls completely still when a high pressure weather system brings calm air. But the root of the problem is that human demand is not intermittent, is it? No, our demand for power doesn't politely pause to match the local weather patterns. We expect the hospitals to keep running their life support machines, the server farms to keep the internet

alive, and our refrigerators to keep our food cold at 3 a .m. Right. Just as reliably as we do on a bright, breezy Tuesday afternoon. I like to think of this like a restaurant. Relying strictly on wind and solar is like having a brilliant chef who only cooks exactly when they feel inspired by the weather. Okay, yeah. But you have a restaurant full of hungry customers arriving at exactly 7 p .m. How do you feed them if the chef isn't cooking right then? You can't. And on the electrical grid, you have to balance that second by second. Historically, if demand spiked at 3 a .m., a

grid operator could just instruct a natural gas plant to open a valve and burn more fuel. They could match the supply to the demand on command. Exactly. But you cannot command a cloud to move. You cannot command the wind to blow harder. So the problem isn't that we can't generate enough renewable energy. When the conditions are right, wind and solar are frequently producing massive surpluses of the cheapest electricity available on the market. The problem is having the energy available when the grid demands it. So if we

can't command the weather to cook on our schedule, we don't need to change the weather. We just need a really good refrigerator to store the meals. We need grid -scale energy storage. Exactly. Storage. So how do we bottle nature up? Storage is the linchpin of a renewable future. Now, the most familiar solution to this is the lithium -ion battery. Like in our phones. Yes. But we are talking about vast installations composed of thousands of individual battery cells. They are deployed at grid scale, like the famous massive battery farms built in South Australia or California.

And how do they operate on the grid? They sit there, quietly connected to the system, absorbing electricity when there's a huge surplus of midday solar, and then they instantly release that stored chemical energy back into the system as electrical current. The millisecond there is a shortfall. That's amazing. And battery technology is advancing rapidly, costs are dropping, but lithium -ion batteries require intensive mining for materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel. They're a huge amount of mining. And they are incredibly complex to manufacture at the scale required to back

up entire continents. Which is why grid operators rely heavily on another ingenious, heavily utilized, and honestly surprisingly low -tech method of storing power. Pumped hydro. Pumped hydro. I am fascinated by this concept. It is brilliant. Pumped hydro is effectively a colossal geographical water battery. It uses the principles of a traditional hydroelectric dam, but runs the process in both directions. Okay, bring that down for me. So you need two massive reservoirs of water, one located at the bottom of a steep hill or mountain,

and one located at the top. On a remarkably sunny and windy day, when your solar panels and wind turbines are producing way more electricity than the city actually needs, you don't just throw that extra power away. You use that surplus electricity to power massive industrial pumps. So these pumps literally suck millions of gallons of water out of the bottom reservoir and push it up. through enormous pipes fighting gravity all the way until it dumps into the top reservoir. You just move

a lake to the top of a mountain. That is exactly what you do. You pump it uphill and you leave it there. It just sits in the top reservoir perfectly quiet. Okay. Later that night, say it's 3 a .m., the wind has died down, the solar panels are completely dark, and the city's power demand starts creeping up. You simply open a massive valve at the top reservoir. And gravity takes over. Gravity takes over. The water rushes back down the hill through the pipes, and as it falls, it spins a turbine, which spins a generator. You get your power back. I mean, it is hilarious and brilliant. But break down the physics of

it for me. How does simply leaving a massive pool of water sitting at a higher elevation actually translate into saved electricity. It comes down to the difference between kinetic energy, which is the energy of motion, and potential energy, which is stored energy based on position. Potential energy, right. When you use surplus electricity to pump water uphill, you are doing physical work against gravity. The higher you push that water, the more gravitational potential energy you store in it. Ah, I see. So the water at the top of the hill is literally holding on to the

energy you used to put it there. The physical elevation of the water is the battery. Wow. When you let it fall back down, that potential energy converts back into kinetic energy, spinning the turbine and returning the electrical energy to the grid. It is beautiful. simple you're storing electricity in the form of gravity waiting to happen exactly and working out the cheapest biggest and most reliable ways to store energy across the grid whether it's lithium batteries for short fluctuations or pumped hydro for multi -day lulls is one of the most critical engineering races

of our time which leads directly to the physical reality of rewiring a global economy yeah scaling these generation and storage solutions to run modern civilization It isn't a theoretical exercise anymore. No, it is happening right now. And it requires an unimaginably large physical footprint in the real world. We aren't just putting a few solar panels on a suburban roof. We are talking about thousands of square miles of land. Because the windiest places like the Great Plains or the middle of the ocean and the sunniest places

like vast deserts are rarely located right next to the dense, power -hungry coastal cities where the electricity is actually needed. So that geographic mismatch requires completely overhauling the electricity grid. We have to construct thousands of miles of new, high -voltage transmission lines to move the power from where nature produces it to where humans actually consume it. Yeah, and we also have to implement incredibly complex grid management systems. Traditional pole and nuclear plants have immense physical inertia.

What do you mean by inertia in this context? They rely on incredibly heavy steel turbines spinning at constant speeds. That physical momentum naturally resists sudden changes in grid frequency, providing a sort of buffer. Ah, right. But solar panels have no moving parts. Exactly. They provide zero physical inertia to the grid. So grid operators have to rely on complex power electronics and massive batteries to artificially stabilize the system second by second. It is a monumental undertaking in engineering. It really is. And this leads me to the ultimate skeptical question on behalf

of everyone listening. If every energy source leaves a mark, If solar fields and wind farms require immense amounts of land, if giant batteries require tearing up the earth for intensive mineral mining, and if hydro dams alter rivers and flood ecosystems. Aren't we just trading one environmental disaster for another? Exactly. Aren't we? It is arguably the most important question of the transition. And the honest, balanced truth is that perfectly clean, zero -impact energy does not exist. Energy is never free. It's never free.

There are always physical tradeoffs. The metals must be extracted from the earth. The land must be allocated. The infrastructure must be built. But the case for renewables rests entirely on a strict comparison of scale and consequence. The lesser of two evils. Basically. The physical footprint of mining for batteries and manufacturing turbines is significant. But those tradeoffs are localized and far, far gentler than the alternative. And the alternative is continuing to load the entire global atmosphere with carbon dioxide, acidifying the oceans, and permanently, catastrophically

warming the planet with fossil fuels. Precisely. We are in a position where we have to choose our heart. Transitioning to a system that doesn't fundamentally alter the chemical composition of the Earth's atmosphere, even if it requires substantial mining and land use, is the lesser impact by several orders of magnitude. So how do we wrap our heads around this transition we are living through right now? Well, the next time you are driving down the highway and you see a glittering field of solar panels, or you look out over a ridge and see a slowly turning wind turbine, or you drive over the crest of

a massive concrete dam, you'll know exactly what you're looking at. You are seeing three distinct, incredibly clever ways of catching the kinetic energy and radiation that nature is already offering up freely. You're watching sunlight. Moving air and falling water being captured and converted into the invisible current that runs the modern world entirely without the burning. The engineering is far from finished, obviously. The storage puzzle and the massive grid upgrades are the defining challenges of this generation. But the direction of travel is firmly set. The physical

mechanics are already working all around us, proving that a different system is possible. Absolutely. It is a remarkable shift in how we interact with the planet. And I want to leave you with one final, slightly mind -bending thought to mull over today. Okay, let's hear it. If almost all global electricity, from coal to nuclear to hydro to wind, ultimately relies on this one simple universal trick of spinning a magnet inside a coil of copper wire, what other invisible, untapped natural forces are out there? I mean,

what else is moving on this planet right now, deep underground, hidden in the thermal vents, or out in the immense churning currents of the oceans, just waiting for us to figure out how to put a magnet and a wire next to it? The Earth is full of relentless motion. Finding new ways to tap into it is the next frontier. It sure is. Something to think about the next time you flip that life switch. Until next time, keep digging deeper.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Nanotechnology – Building at the Scale of Atoms

    Nov 19, 202626 minAudio

    Nanotechnology works at a scale where a nanometre is to a metre what a single centimetre is to the distance across a football field roughly a hundred thousand times over. This episode explains what nanotechnology...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Animal Migration – Navigation Without Maps

    Nov 17, 202625 minAudio

    A tagged bar-tailed godwit once flew more than thirteen thousand kilometres from Alaska to Tasmania without landing once. This episode explores why animals migrate at all, from godwits and humpback whales to monarch...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Space Weather – When the Sun Attacks Our Technology

    Nov 15, 202625 minAudio

    The Sun is an active, magnetic star, and every so often it hurls bursts of radiation and clouds of charged particles toward Earth, a phenomenon called space weather. This episode explains solar flares and coronal mass...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Tsunamis – Waves That Cross Oceans

    Nov 12, 202623 minAudio

    An ordinary wave rolls onto the sand every few seconds; a tsunami can take tens of minutes between crests and cross an entire ocean at the speed of a jet aircraft while barely rippling the surface. This episode explains...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Symmetry – Physics' Deepest Idea

    Nov 10, 202620 minAudio

    A folded square of paper and a butterfly's wings share the same simple visual idea: a shape that looks the same after some transformation. This episode follows that idea from everyday geometry into the deepest...

    Credit the people on this episode