Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Talking Science

Talking Science artwork

States of Matter – Solid, Liquid, Gas and Beyond

Aug 9, 202623 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

An ice cube melting in a glass of water quietly demonstrates one of the most fundamental ideas in all of physics and chemistry: matter changing between states as the balance between molecular attraction and molecular energy shifts. This episode explains solids, liquids and gases at the molecular level, why phase changes absorb or release hidden latent heat, why boiling point depends on pressure, and what lies beyond the familiar three states - plasma, supercritical fluids and the exotic Bose-Einstein condensate. You'll come away understanding what actually distinguishes a solid from a liquid from a gas, why a boiling pot of water stops rising in temperature, why water boils at a lower temperature on a mountaintop, what a supercritical fluid is, why plasma is really the universe's most common state of matter, and what a Bose-Einstein condensate reveals about the strange edges of quantum physics. Talking Science is sponsored by Kinsoft. Visit www.kinsoft.com.au Further reading: NIST - background on the 1995 Bose-Einstein condensate experiments and the 2001 Nobel Prize in Physics; Royal Society of Chemistry - resources on states of matter and phase changes; Scientific American - features on plasma physics and supercritical fluids.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Picture this. You're sitting outside on a patio. On a warm, lazy afternoon. Hopefully with a cold drink. Exactly. You've got a tall glass of water in your hand, and right in the middle of it is this single, solitary ice cube. Just floating there. Right. And if you watch it for a few minutes, it shrinks. The sharp edges get, you know, a little soft, a little round, and eventually it just completely vanishes into the liquid. Yeah. It just becomes part of the water. But then, say an hour later, you take some of that exact same water, you put it in a kettle on the stove.

and it completely disappears again, but this time into the air as invisible steam. It is such an incredibly ordinary sequence of events. I mean, you see it every day. But today, our mission for this deep dive is to take that totally ordinary melting ice cube and that boiling kettle and basically completely shatter your understanding of what is actually happening. Because while we all learn about solid, liquid, and gas in school, you know, the classic three states of matter, those are really just the prologue to a much, much wilder story. They really are. So

we are going to build our understanding from the ground up today. We're going to look at what happens at the microscopic level, why boiling points are actually kind of an illusion, and why the universe's most common state of matter is likely one you rarely even think about. Yeah, exactly. We're going to look way past the everyday surface and focus entirely on the fascinating why behind these things. By the time we finish, you will... You'll never look at a glass of ice water the same way again. Okay, let's unpack

this. Because to understand the truly bizarre states of matter out in the far reaches of the universe, we really have to start right in front of it. Start with the basics, yeah. Right. We have to define what fundamentally makes a solid, a solid, and then liquid, a liquid. So if we stop looking at the ice cube itself and zoom way, way down to the microscopic level, what is actually going on? Well, right down at the bottom. Every substance is built from a huge number of tiny particles, either individual atoms or molecules, which are really just groups of

atoms bonded together. And the key thing to realize is that these particles are never perfectly still. They're constantly vibrating, jostling, moving around. Even in a solid. Even in a solid. The state that a substance is in, whether it's solid, liquid, or gas, is entirely the result of this endless tug of war. A tug of war between... Explain kinetic energy and attractive forces. So the kinetic energy is the energy of motion. That's the energy pushing the particles to move around, to vibrate and spread apart from one another.

Right. They want to move. Exactly. But working directly against that. you have attractive chemical forces pulling the particles together, trying to lock them in place. So in a solid, like our ice cube, I'm guessing the attractive forces are winning the tug -of -war. Oh, they're winning decisively. The attractive forces are so strong, and the kinetic energy is relatively low, so the particles are just locked into fixed positions. But you said they're not perfectly still. Right. They aren't frozen dead still. They are constantly jiggling and vibrating in place, but they just

don't have enough energy to break free of that grip and swap places with their neighbors. Oh, okay. That locked -in grid is what scientists call a crystal lattice. Well, if it forms a perfect repeating pattern anyway. Or amorphous, if it's all jumbled together. But either way, they are locked tight. Which, I mean, that perfectly explains why a solid holds its shape. If I take an ice cube out of my glass and put it on the table, it stays an ice cube. Exactly. It has a fixed shape and a fixed volume because the molecules physically cannot leave their assigned seats.

Right. But then you leave that ice cube on the patio, you add heat energy from the sun, and that heat translates directly into kinetic energy. So they start jiggling faster. The particles start vibrating harder and faster, and eventually... They gain enough kinetic energy that those attractive forces just can't hold them rigidly in place anymore. The grip finally loosens. And it becomes a liquid. Yes. In a liquid, the particles stay close together. They're literally touching their neighbors, which is why a liquid still takes

up a fixed volume. I mean, you can't compress water easily. Right, right. But because the rigid bonds are broken, the particles can now slide past one another. the exact shape of the bottom of its container. And then if we move from the patio to the stove and just keep adding more and more heat energy, the kinetic energy completely overpowers the attractive forces entirely. Complete domination. The particles just fly apart, moving totally independently as a gas. They fill whatever

shape and volume is available. If I release a gas in a room, it spreads out evenly to fill every corner. Yeah, a really great way to visualize this whole sequence is to imagine a crowded dance floor. Oh, I like this. Imagine a solid as a dance floor where everyone is standing in a highly ordered fixed formation. You're holding hands with the people next to you. You can sway to the music. You can rock back and forth. That's the kinetic vibration. Exactly. That's the vibration. But you aren't changing your exact spot on the floor. So if a solid is like a synchronized line

dance and a gas is where everyone has just left the building and they're spread out across the sprawling outdoor festival grounds, moving totally freely, is a liquid essentially just a really polite mosh pit? Yes, that is perfect. In that liquid mosh pit, you are still packed in tightly. You're bumping shoulders with everyone, taking up the same amount of total floor space as the line dancers did. But you're moving around. Right. You're wandering around, squeezing past people, swapping neighbors constantly. You don't have a fixed arrangement anymore. So changing states

is fundamentally all about pumping energy into the system to change the dynamic on the dance floor. But there is a deeply surprising secret about what happens to temperature during that process, right? There really is. But first, we probably need to define what temperature actually is. Okay, lay it on me. It's not some mysterious invisible quality. Temperature is simply a direct measurement of the average kinetic energy of the particles in a system. It is literally just a measure of how fast those microscopic things are moving. Right. Okay, so let's trace the sequence

on the stove. I put a block of ice in a pan and turn on the heat. I'm pumping energy into it. The particles vibrate more violently, so the temperature goes up. Yep. Eventually, they break free, sliding past each other. That's melting. I keep heating that newly formed liquid water. The molecules move faster and faster. The temperature goes up until they break the grip entirely and fly off as steam, boiling. But here is the crazy part. During the exact moment of a phase change... Like while the ice is in the process of melting, where the liquid water is in the actual process

of boiling, the temperature stops rising entirely. Wait, really? So if I'm boiling water for pasta and I turn the burner all the way to maximum, the water itself doesn't actually get any hotter. The thermometer just stalls. What's fascinating here is that the thermometer absolutely stalls. At sea level, a pot of boiling water hits 100 degrees Celsius, and it stays exactly there. Wow. No matter how much fire you put under that pot, The liquid water will not get hotter than 100 degrees. But I'm actively pumping intense heat into it. If the temperature is a measure

of kinetic energy and I'm adding energy, where's it going if it's not speeding up the molecules? It is going into what physicists call latent heat. Latent comes from the Latin word for hidden. Hidden heat. Think back to our tug of war. That extra heat energy from your stove isn't speeding up the particles anymore. Instead, it is doing the heavy lifting, the actual mechanical work of ripping those attractive bonds apart so the molecules can finally separate and fly away as a gas. So it's essentially paying the toll to let the particles leave the mosh pit. Precisely.

You are physically stretching and breaking the electromagnetic bonds between the molecules. And that requires a massive amount of energy. I can imagine. Turning boiling water into steam? takes several times more energy than heating that same water all the way from freezing up to boiling in the first place. All that energy from your stove gets stored in the steam as hidden latent heat. Which honestly explains why steam causes much more severe burns than boiling water. I've always heard that, but the mechanics of it are wild. It's completely counterintuitive

until you know the physics. Right. Like if boiling water hits your skin, it burns you with this 100 degree temperature. But if steam hits your skin, it doesn't just burn you with temperature. It hits your cooler skin, condenses back into a liquid. And in that instant, it releases all of that massive, hidden, latent heat. All the energy it used to break its bonds. Exactly. Directly into your tissue. It is a phenomenal amount of energy transfer. Completely invisible to a thermometer. thermometer until it changes state. But this actually brings us to another assumption we need to break. OK, what's that? We just talked about

water boiling at 100 degrees Celsius. But heat isn't the only variable in this molecular tug of war. There is an invisible hand. constantly pressing down on everything around us. Atmospheric pressure, the literal weight of the sky pushing down on us. Exactly. And it fundamentally alters the rules of boiling. Boiling point is not a fixed universal number. It's not. No. Let's look closely at how a bubble forms. When you heat a pot of water, a molecule at the bottom gets enough energy that it wants to become a gas.

It tries to expand into a microscopic vapor bubble. Okay. But the entire weight of the Earth's atmosphere is pressing down on the surface of the water, crushing that little bubble before it can grow. Boiling only happens when the vapor pressure inside those bubbles is strong enough to push back against and overcome the atmospheric pressure sitting on top of the liquid. Here's where it gets really interesting. So atmospheric pressure is basically a heavy lid on a jack -in -the -box. That's a great way to put it. At sea level, the lid is pretty heavy so the little vapor springs

inside the water need a lot of force, like a full 100 degrees of heat energy to pop the lid open and escape as bubbles. Right. But what happens if we take our pot of water up Mount Everest? Well, on Mount Everest, you have far less atmosphere above you. The air is thinner. The pressure pushing down is much weaker. So your jack -in -the -box lid is incredibly light. So they pop open easier. Exactly. Because of that, the water molecules don't need nearly as much energy. to push back and form bubbles. They don't have to fight as

hard. So water boils at a noticeably lower temperature on a mountain than it does at sea level. Which completely ruins cooking. I mean, if you try to boil an egg or cook rice on Everest, the water boils away before it actually gets hot enough to cook the food. Yep, it just evaporates. The water is actively rolling and bubbling, but the liquid itself is physically cooler than a pot of simmering water in a kitchen at sea level. That's why mountaineers often complain that their tea tastes strangely weak at high altitudes. Really? I never thought about that. Yeah. The boiling water they pour over the leaves simply

isn't hot enough to extract the flavor compounds efficiently. The mechanical action of boiling is happening, but the thermal energy just isn't there. And we use this exact same physics in reverse in the kitchen, right? The pressure cooker. We do. In a pressure cooker, you clamp a heavy lid on the pot and seal it tight. As the water heats up, steam tries to expand. but it's trapped. So it builds up inside. Because it can't escape, it pushes down on the liquid water. The pressure inside the pot builds up far beyond normal atmospheric

pressure. Now, your jack -in -the -box lid is incredibly heavy. Ah, so the water molecules need a massive amount of energy to form bubbles against that crushing pressure. Exactly, which means the water is forced to reach a much higher temperature before it can finally boil. You get genuinely hotter liquid and hotter scheme, which drastically cuts the cooking time for tough meats or dried beans. Okay, so if we can manipulate the boiling point just by changing the pressure, what happens if we push both pressure and temperature to absolute unnatural extremes? Beyond heavy

cooking pots, beyond mountains, do the rules just break? They don't just break, they vanish. Every substance has something called a critical point. This is a highly specific, extreme combination of temperature and pressure. And when you force a substance past its critical point, the ordinary distinction between a liquid and a gas... completely breaks down. Wait, how does that even look? Normally, if I have a half -empty water bottle, I can see the liquid water at the bottom and the air and water vapor at the top. There's a clear line,

a physical surface boundary between them. Below the critical point, yes, that surface boundary is always there. But if you take a sealed, incredibly strong glass tube of liquid and gas and you start cranking up the heat and the pressure simultaneously, something bizarre happens. I'm listening. The liquid expands and becomes less dense. The gas gets compressed and becomes more dense. And right at the critical point, their densities perfectly match. You watch that visible boundary literally fade away and disappear into a fog. And what's left behind? The substance merges into a single

phase called a supercritical fluid. A supercritical fluid? Yeah. It is a true physical hybrid. It acts like a liquid because it's dense enough to dissolve. other substances efficiently. But it acts like a gas because it has no surface tension. It can spread and diffuse deeply into tiny microscopic pores of solid materials in a way a liquid just can't. Are we talking about a ghost liquid? It sounds like it shouldn't exist. How can something behave like an expanding gas but clean like a liquid? If we connect this to the bigger picture, this ghost liquid is actually

incredibly practical. The prime example is decaffeinating coffee. Wait, my morning decaf is made with extreme hybrid physics. It is. Industrially, they load unroasted coffee beans into a massive chamber and pump in supercritical carbon dioxide. Oh, what? Because it has gas -like diffusion, the supercritical CO2 penetrates deep inside the cellular structure of the raw coffee beans. But because it has liquid -like dissolving power, it acts as a solvent. It selectively grabs the caffeine molecules and pulls them out. And it

doesn't ruin the coffee. No, because supercritical CO2 is highly selective. It grabs the caffeine but leaves the delicate flavor compounds behind, avoiding the harsh chemical solvents they used to use in the past. That's amazing. And the best part. When they're done, they just open a valve and release the pressure. The supercritical fluid instantly reverts back into ordinary CO2 gas. It just floats away, leaving absolutely zero chemical residue on your coffee beans. That is wild. Okay, so we manipulated pressure and temperature to get supercritical fluids. Let's look at another

extreme. What if we just take temperature and push it as far as it can possibly go? What happens when a gas gets so hot that the kinetic energy just goes off the charts? Does it just get hotter forever? No, it eventually hits a breaking point. When you heat a gas to extreme temperatures, the particles are moving so incredibly fast and colliding with each other so violently that the atoms themselves literally begin to tear apart. They break. Yeah, the collisions are so forceful, they knock the negative electrons completely loose from their orbits around the atoms. Leaving

the pieces floating around. Exactly. You are left with a churning soup. of free -floating negative electrons and the positively charged atomic cores they left behind. Those positively charged cores are called ions. So you basically have a highly energized ionized gas. And this is the fourth state of matter, plasma. And because the particles in this soup carry electrical charges, unlike ordinary neutral gas atoms, it behaves completely differently, right? Very differently. Because of all those free -floating charges.

Plasma conducts electricity incredibly well, and it responds very strongly to magnetic fields. Ordinary gases don't care about magnets. Plasma does. So what does this all mean? Is this just something that happens inside a fusion reactor? Not at all. You actually see plasma on Earth all the time. Really? Where? If you look at a glowing neon sign, the gas inside that glass tube is being energized by a high voltage electrical current until electrons are knocked loose and it becomes a glowing plasma. Oh, I had no idea. Yeah. A lightning bolt is a brief, violent tube

of plasma superheating the air. Even the very tip of a candle flame has a tiny bit of plasma dancing in it. But Earth is kind of the exception here, right? Yes, very much so. To really appreciate plasma, you have to look up. Out in the cosmos, plasma is king. The sun, and virtually every single star in the night sky, is an unfathomably massive ball of plasma. That makes sense given the heat. The heat and pressure is so intense that atoms just cannot hold on to their electrons. Even the vast, seemingly empty space between

stars and galaxies is filled with a very thin, invisible mist of plasma. Wait, if the stars are plasma and the space between the stars is plasma, does that mean solid, liquid, and gas? The things we think of as the normal states of matter are actually the weird... rare exceptions in the universe. It really does. Physicists joke about it, but it's factually true. By volume, plasma makes up the overwhelming majority of all ordinary matter in the observable universe. Solid, liquid, and gas only really exist on relatively

cool dense little rocks like Earth. That completely flips my perspective. The default state of the universe is a glowing, electrically charged soup. Okay, so extreme heat rips atoms apart into plasma. What about the exact opposite? What if we remove almost all the energy? What happens when we approach absolute zero? Absolute zero is the coldest temperature theoretically possible. It's minus 273 .15 degrees Celsius. It is the absolute floor of physics, the point where kinetic energy is almost entirely gone. The motion just stops. Exactly. In 1995,

scientists decided to see what would happen if they pushed matter right up to that edge. They used a complex setup of lasers and powerful magnets to cool a small cloud of atoms down to just a tiny fraction of a degree above absolute zero. Wait, lasers? Lasers are intense beams of light. They burn things. How on earth do you use a laser to cool something down to absolute zero? It sounds totally counterintuitive, I know. But remember... Cooling something down just means slowing the atoms down. Right, kinetic energy. Atoms are flying around wildly. Yeah. If you tune a laser perfectly, you can fire a stream of photons,

particles of light, directly at an atom that is moving toward the laser. When the atom absorbs that photon, the impact pushes back against it, slowing its momentum just a tiny bit. Ah, like a head -on collision. Yes. It's like throwing millions of ping -pong balls at a rolling bowling ball. Eventually, the bowling ball slows to a halt. Okay, that makes sense. So they trap this little cloud of atoms, they bombard it with lasers from all sides until the atoms basically stop moving. And what happened? Did it just become the hardest, most brittle solid ever? No, it

did something far stranger. At that incredibly low temperature, everyday classical physics completely breaks down and the bizarre rules of quantum mechanics take over. Things get weird. Very weird. You see, in quantum mechanics, particles also act like waves. Normally, those waves are incredibly tiny. But as the atoms got colder and colder and slower and slower, their quantum waves began to stretch out and expand. And since they were trapped in a tight magnetic field, their expanding waves began to overlap. And when they overlapped,

the individual atoms actually lost their separate identities. They stopped being a collection of distinct individual particles and merged into a single unified quantum wave. They acted as one single giant entity. So if we take our dance floor analogy down to absolute zero, is it like the music completely stops, the temperature drops, and everyone freezes so perfectly still that their physical bodies literally blur together and become one giant singular dancer? Yes. From a quantum perspective, the dancers lose their individuality entirely. You can no longer point

to an atom and say, oh, that one is atom and that one is atom B. They're all everywhere at once within that trap. That's terrifying and amazing. This state is called a Bose -Einstein condensate. It was predicted mathematically by Albert Einstein and Satyendra Nath Bose in the 1920s, decades before we had the laser technology to actually create it. Wow. They just knew the math worked out. Yeah. When scientists finally achieved it in 1995, it won the Nobel Prize because it gave scientists a way to observe quantum behavior, which is normally invisibly small, on a macro

scale that we can actually look at. That is incredible. And this raises an important question, you know, about how limited our everyday perception of the universe actually is. Because the deeper physicists look, the more exotic states they find. Have you ever heard of a super solid? I've heard the term, but I have no idea what it actually is. If you cool certain liquids, like liquid helium, down close to absolute zero, they undergo quantum phase change and become a superfluid. In a superfluid, the liquid has absolutely zero internal friction. None. Its viscosity is zero.

How does that even work? Well, if you stir a cup of coffee, it eventually stops spinning because the fluid rubs against itself and the cup. If you stir a cup of superfluid helium, it will spin forever. No way. Seriously. In fact, because it has zero friction, a superfluid will literally creep up and over the walls of its container. defying gravity just to find a lower energy state. Wait, it just crawls out of the bowl? It crawls right out of the bowl. And on the other end of the extreme, beyond plasma, you have something called quark -gluon plasma. If you smash atoms

together in a particle accelerator with enough unbelievable heat and force, you don't just knock the electrons loose. What happens? You literally shatter the protons and neutrons themselves into their fundamental building blocks, quarks and gluons. It's a state of matter that hasn't existed naturally since the first fractions of a second after the Big Bang. It completely humbles you. I mean, our whole lives are built around solid, liquid and gas, the ice cube, the water, the steam. But they are just a tiny, fragile sliver of reality dictated by the very specific, very

moderate temperature and pressure we happen to live in on the surface of the Earth. They are definitely the exception, not the rule. So the next time you are sitting on the patio and you watch that ice cube melt in your glass, I hope you look at it with a newfound respect. It's not just water warming up. Not at all. It is a quiet, microscopic demonstration of latent heat. It's the eternal tug of war between kinetic energy and attractive bonds. It is the exact same foundational physics that dictates how a pressure cooker traps steam, why neon signs glow,

what powers the blazing heart of the sun, and what happens when atoms blur together into a single quantum dancer in the coldest high -tech laboratories on Earth. And I'll leave you with this one final thought to ponder. All right, what is it? We only discover things like supercritical fluids and boson sine condensates because human beings invented incredibly complex machines to force matter into artificial extremes of temperature and pressure. But the universe has natural extremes we can barely fathom. What completely unknown, unimaginable states of matter might currently

exist naturally inside the crushing gravity of a black hole or deep within the unimaginably dense core of a neutron star just waiting for us to figure out they are there. Man, it makes the universe feel a lot bigger and a lot stranger. Thank you so much for joining us on this deep dive. We'll catch you next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Nanotechnology – Building at the Scale of Atoms

    Nov 19, 202626 minAudio

    Nanotechnology works at a scale where a nanometre is to a metre what a single centimetre is to the distance across a football field roughly a hundred thousand times over. This episode explains what nanotechnology...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Animal Migration – Navigation Without Maps

    Nov 17, 202625 minAudio

    A tagged bar-tailed godwit once flew more than thirteen thousand kilometres from Alaska to Tasmania without landing once. This episode explores why animals migrate at all, from godwits and humpback whales to monarch...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Space Weather – When the Sun Attacks Our Technology

    Nov 15, 202625 minAudio

    The Sun is an active, magnetic star, and every so often it hurls bursts of radiation and clouds of charged particles toward Earth, a phenomenon called space weather. This episode explains solar flares and coronal mass...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Tsunamis – Waves That Cross Oceans

    Nov 12, 202623 minAudio

    An ordinary wave rolls onto the sand every few seconds; a tsunami can take tens of minutes between crests and cross an entire ocean at the speed of a jet aircraft while barely rippling the surface. This episode explains...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Symmetry – Physics' Deepest Idea

    Nov 10, 202620 minAudio

    A folded square of paper and a butterfly's wings share the same simple visual idea: a shape that looks the same after some transformation. This episode follows that idea from everyday geometry into the deepest...

    Credit the people on this episode