Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Spice Traders

Spice Traders artwork

The Destroyer by Meg Smitherman Part 2

Apr 16, 20241 hr 24 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

This week the Traders venture into the world of archaeology and magic in The Destroyer by Meg Smitherman. Part 2 of 3, chapters 13-27. Triggers: dubious consent Tropes: Dark Academia, Magic, Enemies to Lovers, Slow Burn, Touch Her and Die KU: yup Recommendation: Yes For more of the author, check out @megsmitherman on TikTok.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hey friends, just a quick reminder before we get into today's episode, come join us over on our Patreon. That's where we release bonus episodes every other week and we've already got over 20 episodes from 2023 that you can download and binge right now for as little as $3 a month. We've covered so many good books there, Haunting Adeline, Chateau, Gotha Canna, and so many more. That's also where we'll cover any books in a series we continue, so Serpent in Dove, High Mountain Court, Serpent in the Wings of Night. You can continue those series with us on Patreon right now.

Finally, as a patron, we let you know what we're going to read every month so you can read along with us if that's your jam. Anyway, that's all from me, on to today's episode. Because otherwise I think someone would comment like, wow it's big today or something. Wow. Big today. I don't love your sex tape. Walked right into that one. I really did. I'm okay with it. I'm okay with that.

It's a good one. Welcome to Your Saved Space, the podcast your partner, friends, parents, whoever thinks is dirty. Don't have time to read books, want to understand the jokes and the tics-hacks, we got you fam. We're the Spice Traders and we deal in spicy books. I'm Katie and I need it to make sense. I'm Liz and I'm hypercritical. As always we start every episode with three things. The first is a generic trigger warning. You can find specific triggers for this book in our show notes so please check those out. Also we do use foul language and talk a lot about sex. If you have sensitivity to any of this, please give this episode a skip.

Secondly, we talk about books. The whole book, nothing but the books, so help me goddess. If you plan to read this book and don't want something spoiled right now, don't listen to this episode. Lastly, we acknowledge that a good book can hit you at the wrong time. The views expressed in our discussion are our opinion and we absolutely don't want to diminish the work and the talent of the authors in our community. That said, we have some notes. Alright, so let's get into it.

Yeah, yes let's because if not we're going to debrief the whole book. Yeah, there's just really not a lot that happens in these chapters. This is part two of The Destroyer by Meg Smitherman. We will be covering chapters 13 through 27 and this will be the middle part so we will not go over our ratings until the third part which will be released in two weeks. So stay tuned for that. If you haven't listened to part one or read the book, please do that because you'll be lost if you don't. So when we last left our Mary Band of Ascels, Rue was being kind of shown out of a dining

room of the royal court by a character named DeLuke. We recently, at the end of part one, realized that this character is the leader of the children which is kind of this culty weird group of people that seems to have a weird amount of power in this court of mirth but she is looking for a way out and she can't find one. So I for sure thought in this situation that something nefarious was going to happen with this whole exchange because like dude fully walks her to her room and then I thought like

maybe someone would try to steal the artifact or something. I expected anything to happen. And it's just totally a non-event. Threaten her, question her. Yeah, it's just I guess a longer amount of time for Rue to be like oh he's a pretty stand up guy. Yeah, which. Girl, come on. Come on. Come on. I mean it's pretty obvious to us as readers that this guy is bad news but Rue's kind of

infatuated because he can talk about science with her. They'll look on your face. Okay, I got frustrated later when they're like and we will get to it when we say it right now. When they are okay we're all going to look at the artifact and we're all on board that it's magic but no one else wants it to be magic so we have to explain it scientifically. I'm just like okay but like you don't have to remind me of that 27 times. No, oh my god.

And the children don't believe in science. And I'm like okay. Then why are they here? And then why does Diluc believe in science? If he's the goal leader, you like science? I know. It doesn't make a whole lot of sense. No. But so Diluc draws through off and is basically like deusas and she's like oh how kind. She falls asleep and like everything's fine and she's not woken up again until it's time to leave. So at the Ascrack of Dawn, Sibeth like bangs on her door and is like we gotta go and so

they leave. That also I was like why is this, it almost felt like they were leaving urgently. Right. They're not. This is just when they plan to go I guess. I would have protested. I would have been like can you give me until the sun is up? Yeah I'm not a morning person so this is just you're making it harder on yourself if you're making me get up before the sun. Also you just like had me party all night so I mean not really but what you doing guys?

But effectively. And so this weird scene ensues where she's like ushered out, she's like packed up ushered into this like royal looking carriage and like no one is there to say goodbye except for the regent and Diluc. Like Fenn's not there, her brother's not there and she like clocks it but she's not like over like as disappointed as I thought she would be. I know like and she seems to be more disappointed about Fenn but then she pretty quickly is

like well why would he come with me anyway? Which yeah you're right. You're right but I would be pretty mad about my brother but like her brother she doesn't really question. She was like alright. Yeah I mean especially since like you haven't seen him in forever and then like both of them just kind of dipped before you could say goodbye at dinner like it's just very weird. It's very weird and there's just like okay so I did picture this carriage, this Cinderella carriage like yeah just this round blue powdery thing. Yeah cause she does describe it as kind of being ridiculous.

She's like I'm not getting in that. Well I love the conversation she has I think I don't know if it's with Sibeth or it's with someone but she I think to the regent she was like I don't need this like I can ride and Sibeth is like no you can't you hate it I saw you ride you're gonna fall to your death. Right get in the fucking carriage. I know she's like I am tired. So she decides to get into this carriage willingly and we learn that she'll be escorted by three writers so the writers that we've come to know Lear, Sibeth and Rosala and four Kings

Guards who are all male and unnamed. So before they set out the regent and DeLuke see her off as I mentioned and both of them warn Rue to be vigilant on the journey and keep the artifact safe. They instruct her when she's there to give them weekly reports of her research and she commits to this willingly even though she kind of bristles she's like I mean I know what I'm doing but do you? This commitment that she makes to like keep them abreast of her research is kind of a little weird thing for Rue to commit to based on something we learned when we actually get

to the tower. Oh yeah oh it is weird. Because they're basically like yeah you got you are going to lead the research like go for it girl but that's not a given as it turns out. It's definitely not which makes sense because she's just a student also. Right exactly. So that is that is weird. So they start off through the town on their journey and as they're going through the streets Simon assaults the carriage bodily like he just thumps against the side of the carriage

and like climbs in through a window or something seemingly for no other reason than to boast that he saw Rue and DeLuke at the dinner last night and to wish Rue well. Literally no new information here. And for such a weird entrance like yeah he already just like body slams the carriage climbs in through the window they have a weird conversation about nothing and then he climbs out through the window. Also doesn't door like.

Why does it go through the window? I don't understand why this scene exists at all because it gives us no information it's bizarre as hell. So bizarre. And like. Like manic pixie dream girl Simon I'm like okay. Truly. And we were talking about in our debrief like at this point I have finished the book and I truly believe that half of this content could have been cut this is one of those chapters that could have just not existed and I would have been fine. And when you had mentioned this the scene I was like okay we must get some valuable information

at least where he's like after DeLuke left you last night he was like canoodling in the corner with I don't fucking know but no he's just like. Right. And that made sense because. Rue is enamored of how attractive DeLuke is he's described as being very very handsome. Yes. So it could have been like this weird like oh well he's just kind of a fuckboy thing. But that was also weird so like because only the region and DeLuke see her off right and Rue has this thought of like the region walks away and DeLuke follows her.

Rue comments like almost puppy-ish and I lost some of the appeal for DeLuke and I was just like because of that because he was following her also I kind of got the feeling that the region was more of the follower of DeLuke than vice versa so like that scene was weird. Yeah that was very weird. And then so for this to happen to be nothing. Yeah big nothing burger. Go through the door you fucking weirdo. Right and it could have been just like a couple of lines like you know the journey was harrowing

or you know long or whatever but it was really nice to finally see Simon at the walls when he like caught up with us to say goodbye. Done. Done. That would have been fine. Right. Also who are these guards that just led essentially a stranger climb in through the window of the woman you're guarding. So good. Even Sibeth is just like oh and he's like don't worry I'm with the band or whatever and like I'm like Rue could be dead in five seconds like you guys suck at your job. I know because I can't I mean because Rue is really a nobody besides like the article

she wrote so like I don't think her and Simon being related is like known. Big prevalent news because no one would give a shit. Right. Everybody's just like who. Like what is happening here. Okay. Okay. Okay. So Simon leaves like a bat out of hell. Literally. And for the rest of the trip or for a good part of the trip Rue falls asleep in the carriage. When she wakes up she becomes aware that they've stopped moving and when she peeks outside

she sees that the Kingsguard and the writers are having a bit of a standoff. It's clear that the Kingsguard want to get to Rue and the writers don't want to let that happen. Rue is anxious. She doesn't really quite understand what she's seeing but she tries to make a break for it out the other side of the carriage. Unfortunately she makes a bunch of noise doing this so one of the Kingsguard like tracks her and tackles her pretty easily but remember these guys are in like armor and shit so when he bodily tackles her he breaks some of her ribs in the process because he's so heavy.

So Deuter is like manhandling Rue trying to like get her to cooperate and Rue is fighting tooth and nail but not doing a very good job because her ribs are broken and also this man is huge and she's an academic and hasn't gone through a training montage. So fortunately Sibeth appears pretty quickly and kills the man shocking Rue so she like pulls him off, leaves his dead body there and basically looks at Rue and is like get the fuck back in the carriage but Rue can't like get it together. She's shocked. This is like the first time that someone's been killed like that in front of her and

so she's just kind of staring at these unseeing dead eyes of this guard and just like losing it a little bit. Even though she just murdered like 30 people but that's fine. Yeah. Well so one of the things that I liked about this book was I'm gonna say that I like it and then I'm gonna give it a caveat. I did like how realistically the author dealt with things like this because I feel so often in these like fantasy like romance books that we read like people die and there's not an

appropriate amount of reaction from yes art protagonists. That's a really good point and it is because she doesn't know what happened at the artifact sites like she didn't see anyone die she just knows they're gone. Which until we get to later like I still had questions as to like. Yeah I saw questions. Okay okay okay because I'm still not sold. But you're right that is a good way to like that shock of like oh shit.

Yeah my caveat is that I think that the author deals with it a little bit clunkily because Ru will just be like going through her day and being fine and then she'll like have this like freeze moment where she's like I killed a man once and then she like goes on with her day and so it's a little bit ham-fisted in that way but I think I understand what she was trying to do and I appreciate it. I killed a man. Yeah I do appreciate it but you're right it is a little odd it's like someone who read a paragraph about PTSD and is like I know what that looks like.

Exactly. Yeah exactly. So a fight breaks out and in the ensuing chaos Ru is trying to get away but again she's kind of frozen and her movements are jilted a little bit and another guard comes for her and starts manhandling her right trying to push her towards one of the horses to try to like essentially steal her away. She's fighting again giving him a really hard time and this guy really feels like he's not into doing this job because one of the other guards starts to approach and he's like

oh brother thank you so much for your help can you like deal with this creature I don't want to please. And Ru is convinced that this other guard is coming toward her to unalive her right. And so she's like preparing for her fate she's looking up into the eyes of like this helmet that's approaching her and rather than running a sword through Ru this guy decapitates the guard currently holding Ru. So sometimes the wording is weird in this book this was a part where it was disgusting

but it was very well worded where it's like he talks about the sword going through his neck like a wire through clay. I was like what? Yep. But it painted a picture. Really good picture it's a really sharp sword. So it's quickly revealed after this guard is killed like a wire through clay that the guard who killed this other guard is actually Fen in disguise and she's just like what? Oh shocking.

Shocked gas who could have known. I didn't know. I didn't suspect. I really thought that Fen was just like fucked off and I was like okay. I mean I thought Fen was end game but I thought he was just gonna like pop up at the tower for some reason. Yeah that's kind of what I pictured. So he kind of like holds Ru and tells her that she's safe now it's clear that she's in shock but she's grateful as hell to see him and so they kind of come back down from the adrenaline rush and regroup with the other battered riders.

They learned that all of the other guards are dead obviously the one the two that attacked Ru are dead. The riders took care of the third one and the fourth one is obviously Fen so really much more of an evenly matched battle. But after this encounter the party is a bit in shambles. They don't really have a plan. They obviously can't just continue on and pretend like nothing happened because they were attacked by Kingsguard so they're thinking there's treachery in this elite squad so Sibeth

is like okay let's split up. I'll ride ahead to Myrith to warn the region of this treachery. Razela you'll accompany the carriage back to the palace and Lear, you and Fen will ride ahead to the tower with Ru as fast as you possibly can so they do this. When Lear and Fen and Ru arrive at the tower the other professors are shocked at the state of Ru because she's covered in blood in and out of shock and she's got this gash on her face. She's almost passed out from the pain in her ribs.

She's in a bad way right now. She's in a bad way. I think one of the professors refers to her as an unearthed corpse. So Professor O'Brahle which she kind of takes the lead here and I love her because she's described as having a cloud of pink hair. Is the one who has pink hair that shaped mushrooms or something? It seems like her hair takes on different whimsical shapes and I just love that. I do love that. I do. Not magically.

She does it. She styles it like that. But so O'Brahle kind of takes the reins here and she's like wow you look awful. Did these men hurt you? You're safe now. You can tell me it's okay. And she's ready to throw Fen and Lear in the dungeons. Which I appreciate. I do too. But Rue's like no no they helped me. I just need a minute. I'm fine. So O'Brahle takes Rue to her chambers and cleans her up a bit. And this is the scene that we learn that Rue won't actually have carte blanche to study

the artifact as she likes. She's not even guaranteed to be on the project. What will have to happen is that there will be a deliberation within the leadership of the tower and that's how they'll decide who will leave the project and who will be on the project. So it's weird that she committed to giving updates about something she wasn't even sure she was going to participate in. But I also feel like none of this deliberation had to happen. This slight wrench. But it also makes sense because again Rue is just a fucking student.

So I don't know why even the regent was like you have full power right? And she's like I'm an undergrad but yes. I don't know why she wouldn't know how that works. How the tower works. To your point about this whole deliberation thing. This is one of those scenes that illustrates the show up early leave late kind of error that this author is making. Because this entire scene with a brawl could have just been summarized by Rue either in

an internal monologue or a conversation with Finn or somebody later. But it were made to watch them from the courtyard all the way through the tower up the stairs down the hallway through her room being cleaned up and it's just boring. It's so boring and it's just so unnecessary to have that level of detail. Right. I don't need it. I don't need it. I don't need it. So Rue goes to sleep and when she wakes up she has an almost undeniable urge to touch

the artifact with her bare hands but only the thought of Finn makes her come to her senses and wrap the thing back up. So she's like wow that was a close one. I have to be more careful because this thing clearly has an influence over me. But I kind of like it because I'm the chosen one. Her relationship with the artifact I liked it most of the time but then sometimes it confused me. So I was like do you like this? And then she also seems to be confused by certain things.

I'm like I don't know why like I know I'm jumping ahead but when she talks to it later she's like I couldn't do that. I'm like it talks to you. I liked so one of the things that I really like about this book is I feel like the plot is new. I haven't read something like this before. No. No. And I really like that. However, I feel like the mechanics are clunky. So like the way that the relationship that she has with the stone is described and how

it interacts or affects her or her other relationships. Like you were talking I was I'm not quite sold on that mechanic because it seems contradictory at times. It does because sometimes she seems afraid of it but then another time she's really possessive of it and like that could be an interesting thing like that my precious like the one ring like I'm afraid of it. I want it it's mine but it's not handled very well sometimes and it gets confusing to me. Yeah the other thing that I think we'll get to in this part but is that she purports to

be a scientist who wants to discover magic but her actions don't prove that point out right like she very consciously makes decisions to curtail her ability to understand what's happening in the stone or with the stone and I'm like okay that doesn't feel like a choice that you would actually make. Yeah and then it makes me wonder like is this deeper than it seems like is she being controlled by or possessed by the stone but we don't get enough evidence of that I just want an

explanation. Yeah. The other thing this is mechanically and a less interesting point but I was consistently confused over how big the stone was because she like it's wrapped up right and sometimes it would be like in her pocket or like in her jacket and other times she says it's like bundled into her arms and if you say something's bundled in your arms I'm picturing you holding like a blanket like it's like a big thing. Right. Is it just a little stone in like a lot of wrapping or is it a big stone and like the wrapping like I how big is this thing.

I had that same thought too because she very specifically has two bits of imagery I don't know if it's in this part or at some point in the book she describes it at once being the size that could fit in the palm of her hand in particular. She's described as being average I'm pretty average that's a very small thing for me right. But then at another point in time she describes it sitting on a table and it looks like a loaf of bread and I'm like there is no loaf of bread that fits in the palm of my hand. No. No there's not. So is it changing in size like what's happening here.

Because if it's changing in size no one really mentions that but no and the loaf of bread makes sense for like the bundled in my arms but I certainly couldn't fit a loaf of bread like in my jacket pocket. No definitely not. I have a feeling that that's just inconsistency. So as we're getting ready to go to the deliberation a brawl comes in to collect the artifact and put it somewhere safe and I'm a little surprised that they left it with Rue overnight to begin with and they weren't immediately like give that to me. Yeah especially if they're not even sure that she's going to be on the project for them

just to be like you can keep that you can keep your pet rock. Yeah exactly with the googly eyes. With the googly eyes especially when they know that it do people at the tower know what happened at the site yet. Yeah so the people at the tower that's a good point do know what kind of the bare bones of what's happening because the regent had written a letter to them beforehand and also gossip so they know Rue went to the site, destruction happened, they found this artifact,

Rue and some people are traveling there to study the thing and we'll learn later it's not giving anything away but like the tower has split opinions over whether or not this is a good idea because like this thing is basically an unknown bomb and they're just being forced to house it. Yeah. Yeah. You don't know how volatile this thing is and you're just like well. No idea. So as a brawl is taking the artifact Rue panics at this thought of being separated from it

but ultimately gives the thing to the professor. She kind of talks herself away from the ledge she's like they're just going to put it somewhere safe I can go visit it whenever I want it's fine. So a brawl takes the thing and as she's leaving she tells Rue that the deliberation isn't an hour and to not be late. Because a brawl takes the artifact away and is like walking out of the room down the hall away from her Rue can still feel the artifacts touch in her mind and her panic at being physically separate from it subsides she's like okay so even though I'm not in the same room it

hasn't left me I'm good. It still loves me. Still loves me I'm still the chosen one. So she finishes getting ready and she realizes how terrible she looks when she looks in the mirror she's got dark circles under her eyes and a huge bruise from the fight with the guards on her face. It does occur to her that her reaction and connection with the artifact could also be a hallucination brought on by exhaustion but she quickly dismisses that idea she's like man I look terrible am I sure that this is real? No it's totally real it can't be unreal.

This made me think a little bit about um what's the name of that book the one with knock and like the pokemon. Oh um um kingdom of exiles yes. Well done. Thank you um kingdom of exiles where she's like oh I'm looking sick but I'm just tired I'm not dying. Definitely not dying. It kind of felt like this to me like I don't think it's the same thing but I was like.

So she brings up how terrible she looks pretty frequently and I really wanted that to be tied in to the artifacts effect on her in some way. Yeah but it's just it's not it's it's completely separate but it is weird that she calls it out so much that it's completely unrelated. It is weird and like so I want it to be related. I also sort of appreciate it from author's standpoint it's another thing that I like

from an author but it just wasn't handled very gracefully because a lot of times in these books we will have like a fight montage and a character will get injured and then we like unless it's a grave injury we never go back to their injuries like they're just good. So the fact that like she still has a black eye she's still sore for a while like I like that that realism because they don't have magic to heal her or anything but she does bring it up a lot more than necessary for it to really serve no purpose.

Yeah and that connection with things that just end up being red herrings like it's almost the thing that you want to introduce theories in your book from an author's perspective like you want to introduce things that make your reader think about it but you don't want to do it so much that it feels like foreshadowing and then not deliver on that and I feel like that's what the author is doing with this. Yes that's a really good way to phrase it. But regardless as she thinks about this her thoughts turn to her friends Archie and Gwyneth and she wonders why they haven't sought her out yet or Fen and I'm like girl you got here

less than 24 hours ago like cool it. Also you don't know that Archie's even back he could still be at that dig site. That's true but like this is one of those instances where Rue is so self-centered I'm like girl. I know like you just got here I need you to calm down. When would they have sought you out you've been you got here you got your shit cleaned up and then you went to sleep for like 14 hours. Like when would they have seen you. They might have you just didn't know. Yeah and also essentially they've got shit to do. Like this is probably a cool Tuesday right.

Yeah. They've got research or whatever. And they probably also don't know that you are damaged. Damaged. And Archie saw you like four days ago so. That's true it really hasn't been all that long. Because she goes to the site everything happens immediately. They travel to where the region is which is like maybe another day. They're there for a night. They have another night on the road and now she's here. It's like been a week. Yeah it's not been long.

Yeah I was just like okay girl. Calm down. So she goes to the hall where the deliberation will be held and both her friends actually happen to be waiting there for her. So I'd like to call out that we're 42% of the way in and we finally meet a character. We were ostensibly introduced to way too early. Cool. And that's Gwen by the way. Yeah we didn't need to know about her. No. 300 pages ago. Nope didn't need to. We didn't need to know like so much about her. She could have been like because she fully introduces Gwen in the first chapter.

First name, last name. How long they've known each other. Her family tree. Yeah. Like all of this shit. You could have just said Gwen and Archie and I like we're super tight. Yeah. And then move on. And then you could have added more information when we meet her here. Exactly. But now it's like you already know her. It's fine. Yeah okay. Their reunion is warm but not particularly interesting. And as they take their seats, Rue can't help but look for Fen and Lear but she also can't help but feel disappointed when she doesn't see either of them there. And I'm like poor Lear is getting dragged into your friend circle and I'm not even sure

that you know his last name. No, I don't know why she suddenly cares about Lear because she doesn't even care about um, Sibeth or Rosala. Yeah. Like who we never see again by the way. They're just gone. They're just gone. They're just going back to their day jobs. So I don't know why Lear is like now you're one of my friends. I know. Well okay but there's a point in the book where we never see Lear again even though he's there and I'm like oh okay. Yeah that was weird too. And like that would have been fine if she didn't care about him here.

Right. So I don't need to see him again. Care about him here and then I think, I don't know if we'll get to it there but at some point he becomes a Kingsguard. He's just like, unmoved. Oh yeah and they like run into each other and she's like oh and I was pleased for him. And they like affirm their friendship. I'm like you've known each other for like three days. Well that was a point where I wanted the whole like Kingsguard. Treachery. Betrayal. Yeah to come back up but like.

It never does. I mean not in this book. No. Because the fact that Lear is probably promoted because three of them are dead now. Whoops. I don't know what I'm talking about. No. Is it that thing where like if you kill a Kingsguard you can take their place? Well maybe. Yeah. So the deliberation begins and Rue's friends urge her to advocate for herself and be the lead on the project and Rue is like frozen. She's got deep deep imposter syndrome.

When students start to come up and be able to pitch their own hypotheses, Rue doesn't for a while. She's traumatized from the reaction of her paper when it was first published and she doesn't want to be seen like a freak essentially. But eventually she does make her way to the podium and basically says because she encountered and survived the initial reaction from the artifact she believes that she's intrinsically linked to the artifact and the research into how it works. She seeks to prove that it is magical in some way. This hypothesis gets a lot of chuckles from the audience and Rue takes her seat kind of

like a little embarrassed. But she is confident in her hypothesis and what she said and she believes that it's the right way to go. At the end, Gwen then goes up to the podium and she starts by saying, I don't have a hypothesis. I just wish to talk about some salient points. And she brings up namely that the rock is dangerous and that anyone advocating to lead the research must realize that and has likely weighed the possibility that their life might

end as a result of the research with the pro of being able to research the artifact. And she also brings up the fact that they've probably thought about the fact that Rue is potentially the only person immune to the artifacts, effects, and they've also weighed that risk as well. And then she's just like, dooses and go sits down. Which I did appreciate, but it was very much just like, I'm here to point out some things that maybe the reader didn't know, so we're going to go back now.

Yeah, and it's couched very much like Gwen is trying to make sure that Rue is, like she has her back in that way. But it also points out of glaring issue with these deliberations. It's like every man for themselves and nobody's actually thinking about what makes sense in some of these situations. But that's okay, I'm not an academic. So what do I know? I am, but it's still weird.

So Gwen's points quells the fervor in the room quite a bit. The lead professors call for a vote. So that's another weird thing about this celebration. It's not just the professors that vote, it's the whole school. So they call for a vote and they start with Rue at the request of one of the candidates who had thrown their hat in the ring. And when they call that vote, it's unanimous that Rue lead the research. Rue is then immediately ushered into a parlor where the professors proceed to express their trepidation at having to host this thing at all, especially given the events on the road.

Rue understands where they're coming from and admits to herself that she never thought about how others would feel at the tower from her actions. And I'm like, we know you're self-centered, it's okay. She's self-centered. I am surprised that they... I mean, this is a valid point. Like this essentially wiped out a city twice and then was attacked on the road. And there's probably a lot of important research going on in this building for them to just be like, you can do it in the basement. I'm like, you can offsite Annex would be better.

Okay, an offsite Annex would be better for so many reasons and we will get to it when they actually start their research. So many reasons. So the professors are kind of like talking above her and Rue completely spaces out during the rest of the discussion thinking about Fen. The professors kind of noticed that and the professor, Abral is like, hey girl, you good. And she's like, where's Fen? Like out of the blue. She's so thirsty. And the professors are like, oh, he and Lear are in the guest wing.

Like you good. And she's like, yep. And she immediately stands up and goes to find them. Like you are so weird, so strange. So strange. I would be questioning her mental capacity to like lead this research project. Yeah, truly. Like she's concerned with getting laid girl. What's happening? The social cues are just not very high with her. Not at all. No, not a bit. So she goes to the guest wing, but she immediately realizes that she doesn't have a plan because

the guest wing has a lot of rooms and she doesn't know which one she's looking for. So she turns back to her own room and ends up running into Fen heading back from her quarters like essentially looking for her. Right. It's not that he's coming out of her room. He's just coming out of the wing that her room is in. So like they had the same thought like, I'm going to go look for you. Fuck. I don't know what room you have. Right. Like this is basically a dorm. I don't know where to go. There's no names on the doors. Like, yeah. Nothing I can do. So they're both elated to see each other.

Fen touches Rue's cheek and asks after her health and they end up spending a rather lovely day in the gardens together. As they talk, Fen agrees to stay and help Rue with her research. He says he couldn't think of anywhere else he'd rather be. Rue goes on to ask how he knew the guards would try something on the road. And Fen says that he had noticed a weird energy in some of the guards and courtiers at the palace when they arrived. But it wasn't until Simon whispered his suspicions at the end of dinner that he decided to act.

He tells her that he kept Rue in the dark to minimize the possibilities that the guards would try to be more secretive in their movements. If she had known that Fen was with them, that might have given his cover away. I have so many questions because what did Simon see to make him suspicious? Why did Simon trust Fen with that information? Like, I don't understand why everyone just trusts Fen. We don't know who Fen is. He came out of the fucking forest.

So I have questions about that and I suspect, I hope, what is happening is that he is influencing people. That's what I suspect is happening. Because that's the only thing that makes sense. And we see that a little bit later when Rue is being influenced by the artifact. So the groundwork is there. I just really hope that that's what's happening. Because there's no reason for Simon to know who Fen is to trust him with any kind of information.

Yeah, because it's the thing when he approaches Fen at the dinner, aside from the fact that Rue and Fen were together upon arrival, that's all he knows about them. And Fen goes and steals Guard's uniforms. Potentially killed the Guard he replaced. Because we don't know where he got that uniform. I meant to say this when that comes out. But I think, please don't tell me you stole that. Fen is like, don't ask questions you don't want the answers to. And where's that other Guard?

Is he just like, tied up, hog tied somewhere? That's the best case scenario, yes. Yeah, he's probably dead. But I have so many questions, like why? Yeah. Well, and even to the point of Fen is allowed to participate in this research project because Rue just wants him to. Right, because he's a self-proclaimed historian, but he is not affiliated with the tower or the palace or anything. Like he says he's a historian.

We have no proof of that. He is the definition of a rando. Yes. We don't even know if his name is real because it's not like we have driver's licenses up here. But like, no, he hasn't shown any paperwork or anything like that. No, and they're all just like, hey, you can stay here. You can be on the project. This is fine. Rue loves you. Yeah, don't worry about it. Don't worry girl, okay. He has to be. He has to have some power. I hope that that does come out in the second book because if it doesn't, that mechanic just doesn't work. So anyway, Fen goes on to vow yet again to protect Rue from any threat, including jealous

academics or otherwise. When they return to Rue's room, she realizes that with Fen, she doesn't feel the pull of the artifact at all. She again asks Fen why it feels like she's known him all her life, but before he can answer, Gwen joins them. I had, I don't know at what point, but it was somewhere in here with her like realization that she doesn't really feel the artifact when she's with Fen. I know in the first part, we hypothesize that Fen was the destroyer.

I wonder if Rue was somehow the destroyer, like reincarnate. You smiling because you finished the book. I finished the book and like, it's both. Okay. I don't think I like that, Catherine. So that's what I'm saying, like I'm here for this book. I mean, I'm going to read the second one. Yes. Like I just, the author needs, it's clear this is the first thing that she's written

and published. Okay. Hopefully the next book ties it all together nicely. It seems like it's just a duology. I think it's just a duology. Yeah. Okay. Excellent. All right. Proceed. So Gwen joins them and this will be a trend that you'll notice. Gwen is a study in cock blocks. Thanks girl. Oh my God. I had that note like three times. It's just like, girl, read the room, knock or something. Nope. Nope. I'm here. I mean, I think maybe to be fair, she does knock this time, but like, you don't have to

answer the door girl, like say five minutes. No, like later they're like on the bed together and she's like, hello, I'm here. Yeah. She just barges in. Yeah. So turns out that Gwen has gathered as much of the bibliography of Rue's original paper as she can handle like physically that she can hold and she insists that both Fen and Rue join her and Archie for dinner. She also drops that Archie and she intend on helping Rue study the artifact as well. So this kind of becomes the research group. It's Fen, Rue, Archie and Gwen, the foursome, which is why I feel like the whole thing of

the deliberation didn't need to happen because I feel like this was always going to be the foursome. Right. And do they not have a faculty sponsor? Apparently not. This is so poor planning. I know. Well, the thing that I don't understand is that nobody's reviewing this research plan and like to your point about a faculty sponsor, like nobody's like, hey, have you thought about XYZ thing? Yeah. Like, and I know that these, these characters are older than the students I work with, but I'm just picturing like giving really important research to just three students and some rando

off the street and not giving any supervision. Like, I mean, kind of, but they're like graduate students. They are like, they're still early twenties. I was a moron in my early twenties. Yes. Like, you couldn't tell me anything. I would, no, absolutely. I'm not going to trust a 24 year old with this research. No. And it's such important research. Like it was history defining stuff. It's already shown how dangerous it is. So you just be like, yeah, have fun with your rock.

It's very cavalier. And I will say, I wouldn't trust a 24 year old without oversight, right? Exactly. You can run it. There's no oversight. That's where I feel like, what's your, I want to call her a walla. O'Broll. O'Broll. Thank you. I feel like that she should have like, and I don't have to see it. So like, I don't have to see it, but just this background of like, she reads the reports first before they go to the region or something. Right. Or she gave us more ideas. Yeah. She's with them at the annex that they don't have.

Right. But they should have. She suggests that they use an annex instead of the dungeon. Yes. Anyway. But that's fine. None of that happens. So. So they go to dinner and Fen and Archie are finally introduced. Fen is passed off as a historian and it's a tense meeting. Archie clearly takes a dislike to Fen for the only reason that Archie still has feelings for Rue and both Rue and Gwen know it. As they eat, Archie and Gwen press Rue on whether she'll be okay to study the artifact

because you know, she's had a lot of trauma dealing with it and she reacts badly to this. She's being forced essentially to remember what happened. She's like kind of caught off guard because these questions kind of come. I mean, if they don't come out of nowhere, but there's no preamble to the questions, right? She's gently leading her into it. And so she kind of gets these flashbacks of Lady Marin and the devastation that happened at the destruction and she doesn't handle it well.

It's clear that she's got some kind of PTSD about it. So she's kind of spacing out a bit. Verbally she's protesting that she'll be fine. Well, and this is terrifying because to be fair, I did skim much of the narrative. But this is the first time that I remember reading about her remembering anything that happened. And so some of her flashbacks here and later are of like people dissolving into like their atomic structures. Like that's so scary. What the fuck?

Yeah. Like her memories definitely get more specific. And that is a trend that we'll see with because she has more than one episode of like interacting with the stone and something like this happening. But like the further she gets away from that interaction, the more clear her memories become. And I liked that detail. But it's terrifying what she remembers about the destruction. It's so scary. It's not what I pictured. And I'm not mad about it because I like the detail of it, but it's really scary.

Yeah. It's just, it reminds me of like how people describe like an atomic bomb going off. Yes. So it's clear that Rue is not fine and Fenn steers her back to her room. She's like, okay, that's enough for the questions for right now. And when they get there, he tells her that magic could react to strong emotions and that she'll have to keep hers in check in order to study it. He reveals that he knows this because he studied magic as well. Rue is shocked, but gladdened because she thought that before when they had talked about magic and he said that he believed in it, that he was just telling her what she wanted to hear.

Also makes him more suspicious to me. Little bit more suspicious. Don't be suspicious. Don't be suspicious. I feel about him. So Fenn goes on to comfort her and it's clear that he has a soft spot for her, but before anything really can develop, he tells her to get some rest and leaves her for the evening, which is another theme and regular occurrence that we'll see that I fucking hate. Yes. Me too. And it's like a switch, right? Like they'll be close to like a kiss or an embrace and he'll just like, it's like somebody

redirected his programming and he'll like straighten up back away and be like, you should get some rest and leave. It is. It's weird. It's exactly like that. And it's fucking weird. Yeah. So some days later, Rue and Gwen are in one of the libraries gathering some more research material. But one of the things that I like about the tower is that they have a lot. It's not just a tower. Like it's that's the name of it, but the complex that they're in is much more like a castle Lee place and there's a lot of libraries here and they're all different.

I also like the clarification of like, it's not really a tower. Right. Because I was picturing. That's just what they call it. Right. Like an ivory tower kind of thing. Yeah. So they're in one of these libraries, one of the smaller ones. And Gwen is very juvenile Lee and stereotypically asking about whether Rue and Fen are fucking, but she asks it like legitimately, are you, you know, and I'm like, girl, just, you're adults. Just ask the last time I asked whether somebody was sleeping with somebody like that.

I think I was in high school. Yeah. Because I feel like you and I've had conversations somewhat recently, which is like, so you fucking did you do it? Right. Which is just say what you want to say. And I do appreciate that Rue was just like, she says something and I love the line. I'm like, you're going to have to use language. I understand. Yeah. She's a very deadpan. I know. Because she knows what she's asking. She's just refused to give into it. Yeah. And Gwen refuses to ask outright. So I'm not going to, they're both kind of having this push pull of like, you're not

going to ask and I'm not going to say. So finally Gwen's like, okay, so you wouldn't mind if I made a move on with Fen. Like that wouldn't bother you. And Rue's like, okay, fine. I called it. Stop it. I know. Which I did. I did think that was a funny way to like, even though she's not going to be an adult about it. I was like, okay. Yeah. So then we get an interaction with Archie and what you were saying in the first part about not being an Archie fan, I'm not team Archie like at all.

There's just something about him. He's a bad friend and I think he's got big in cell energy. He's a bad friend. So I hate it. So let's get into the scene. Even Archie have tea in Archie's room and he starts the conversation by asking quote, I know everyone must be asking, but are you, you know, all right, not taken by madness or ready to leap out of a five story window or anything like that. And I'm like, it fucking excuse me.

What an offensive way to ask that. I feel like the author is trying to make him be like that awkward like posh upper crust British dude, but wow, I would have left. I would have left to, I would have left a few times in this conversation and she never does and it upset me. Yeah. It's clear that their relationship dynamic is not healthy. No, no, and he has no sense of boundaries. No, or he's very in cell energy. He's like, you love me.

We know you love me. Yeah, come on. So yeah, with that kind of energy, he does go on to try and rekindle what they had. Rue tells him that she doesn't feel that way about him anymore and he accuses Fen of coming between them. Rue tries to assert that Fen is irrelevant, but Archie tells her to be honest, at least with herself, if not with him. And it's clear that Rue and Fen are infatuated with each other. Rue asked to talk about something else, but the moment is tense and Archie starts like

cleaning up the tea. So she's like, okay, I guess I'm leaving. I guess I'll go now. I'll see myself out. Yeah. And it's just one of those conversations, but I know most of us have had this conversation where somebody is macking on you. You're like, I no longer wish to mack with you. And they bring in your new crush as it's their fault. And it's like, no, I do have a crush on them, but I still don't want to be with you.

They could not exist and I still would not want this to happen. And that's what I appreciated about the way that this was set up, because it's very clear that Archie and Rue's relationship has been done for a while, like before Fen even existed, which I like because otherwise you'd get into the whole like love triangle thing. But to your point, like he has nothing to do with this. We've already talked about how we don't work. Yep. But then he brings up that insult thing of like, well, that was then this is now, could

it be different? No, no, I don't know why it would be. And there's a way to ask like that was then and this is now, could it be different now without getting into this territory? Like one, don't try to make a move on me and then ask that question. Bring it up like an adult and be like, Hey, I still have feelings for you. But so I just want to ask and you just have to tell me once and that's it. Yeah. I just got to know. We could try again. Right. Things have changed. Yeah.

And don't be a child and bring up this new guy. Right. And when you don't get the answer that you don't want, don't like powderly start putting away the tea and like effectively dismiss me. Right. When like I thought we were friends. So very clearly you don't want to be my friend also. No, no, you don't just want to be my friend. Cool. Got it. So after that interaction, Rue continues on to the laboratory wing of the tower where

all of the non dangerous artifacts are housed and she finds her pots, all the ones that she dug up at dig site 20 or 33 and other places. She tries to calm her mind and center herself by thinking about how many lives touched these vessels in the past, but she's too distracted between what happened with Archie, her feelings for Fen and how the artifact is affecting her. She can't get her mind to focus. So she determines to see the person who knows exactly what she's going through. Fen.

She goes to the guest wing and though she feels a bit foolish, she ultimately does knock on his door. He lets her in clearly intrigued. She finds his room covered in books and papers and is impressed that he's not wasting his time at the tower. He asks what's wrong and she tries to deflect, but ultimately confesses that she needs someone to talk to. She feels different and she's not sure if it's a good thing, whether the world has changed or she has changed or both. One of the things that I like about the way that Rue and Fen interact is that Rue is a

very evasive person and every single time she tries to deflect with Fen, Fen's like, you're deflecting again. I really like that. Yeah. I love and I like their relationship, but I also don't trust him. I like their relationship, but I'm also like not fully bought in. Like I didn't get the stomach butterflies. No, no, because it is such a slow, I wouldn't even call it a slow burn because like we're

not even burning. Nothing's burning yet. Smoldering. Nothing is smoldering. Like it seems, and I think that's because I don't trust his motivation because I don't understand his motivation. Like she clearly is attracted to him, but we don't get the same. Like I don't get the same feelings from him. Like he's interested in her for something, but like it doesn't feel sexual to me. Right. And like the other plots in this story, not a follow up question to be seen.

No, not a one. Like she'll try to ask like, Hey, why are you here? And he'll be like, I can't think of a better place to be. I'm like, that's not an answer. No, he has a lot of really sketchy answers. Yeah. And she's just like, Oh, how sweet. I'm like, no girl. No girl. No, no, what are you talking about? No. So they end up sitting on his bed and have a bit of a moment. Fen tells Rue that he's read her paper multiple times and that she's an enchanting writer.

He loves how she communicates and sees the world. Fen is entranced by Fen's flattery of her, but Fen again breaks the moment just before they can kiss or do anything more and tells her that she should get some sleep, which she does. Well, and this is so weird too, because like there she walks in, they're talking, he like goes out of his way to make space on there on his bed, sits on the bed next to her. And then it's like, you should go to sleep. And it's complimenting her and like brushing her hair back.

Yeah. And then he's like, I like, it is like he's a computer and he's just been like, restart. But that's why like if he was influencing people through some kind of magic, it would be really interesting to me if like every time he pulls back, he thinks that he's influencing her with magic and is just like, Oh wait, I this. Oh, when he's trying not to. Oh, I like that. I have no basis for that. So it might not be the case. But I hope that's the case.

Because I do like that. Where she's explained so much about this. That would explain so much. We're like, he wants us to be purely consensual. And for her, it well, I think for her it is. I don't think he's manipulating her. But if he thinks that he is. Yeah. Interesting. And every time this happens, she's like, she's it's a little bit gaslighting for her because like he said, she she does have feelings for him. She's like attracted to him like wants to like get a little bit physical.

And every time this happens, she's like, we must just be friends. Like this has to be just me. It has to be in my head. Like I'm just really misreading all of these cues. Right. And so she's kind of beating herself up like about these interactions and she's like, Okay, cool. Just friends. He's very interesting person. He's going to be good for research. That's cool. We can be friends. It's fine. Totally good. I can keep it in my pants. I promise. I promise. Cool. But as Ru dreams that night, she dreams of Fen coming to her room and climbing on top of

her and kissing her neck and touching her. And it's very clear that she wants to be more than just friends. She wants to know him biblically. Biblically. Girl, can I get your digits? I will say that dream sequences like this, I'm fine with. I don't mind that. I don't mind that. Because you're also giving me information and you're not doing this weird like cookie crock. I don't have to go on my rant about dream sequences again. I mean, but you're more than welcome to. I'm here for this. Yeah.

Because this also feels like relatable, right? Because it's like, I dream about the things that I was thinking about before I go to bed most of the time. Yeah. And that's how dreams work. And if you have these hypotheses about what's going on, it confirms that he's not, if he's manipulating her, that he's not always manipulating her, that she has genuine desires. Correct. Unless he can dreamwalk and he actually came to her in her dreams. But we don't know that. So.

Well, but we'll never know. We'll never know. Maybe we'll have to read book two. So Rue wakes up with a start and she's like hot and bothered and she's like, wow, that was a lot. I need to like get it together. Full shower. We're going to be successful. Yeah. Well. As she gets ready for the day, she finally starts to recognize herself in her own reflection and she's pleased to know that she's looking more and more like herself.

So the bruising is going away. She's looking less gaunt, filling out, you know, the color in her skin, that kind of thing. So that morning is the first day of studying the artifact in earnest and the supplies from the region have arrived. So when Rue requested to study at the tower, the region was like, if you need anything else outside of the tower, let us know. And I had a question about this. I was like, if you're going to send for more instruments, why do it at the tower? But it turns out the tower has most of these instruments. She just wanted her own copy of it, which totally tracks with who she is.

She's like, oh yeah, the tower has a couple of these, but there's like a wait list for months to use them or something like that. And if I have the region on my side, I'm going to get whatever the fuck I want. Right. Because the region did say like anything you need, like we will either get you or get you the money to buy it. You just have to justify why. Right. And it's for justification, like I don't want to wait in line. I mean, I think a justification is if I have to wait in line, it's going to be a couple

months, which is fair. And they don't want that. Right. So when Rue goes to receive the items, she realizes that they've come with some clingers on specifically three members of the children and a handful of Kings guards. The cult members are completely unlike their care charismatic leader though. And Rue remarks that they almost feel like animated corpses because they are so unemotional. The other thing about this is that there's a letter that comes with these people that

basically is like, don't mind these folks, please house them like blah, blah. But the letter specifically asks about, you know, if this one guy is still at the tower, like he'll look after them or something like that. That never comes up again. No, it doesn't. And that was weird. Yeah. Why bring it up at all? Yeah. I have a lot of questions like that in this whole ass book. Why bring it up at all? Right.

So Rue and Professor O'Broll go into Professor O'Broll's office and this is where they review the letter that the regents sent. So along with saying, hey, these people are there, it says, or it asks specifically that the children be allowed to supervise the research and Rue bristles at not being fully trusted on her own. But it also addresses the mention of treason, right? So they sent Kingsguards. Kingsguards were the ones that attacked Rue on the road. But the letter is basically like the threat has been dealt with and then moves right the

fuck along. Which I would not take at face value. Also, who are these children that are going to supervise me? Truly. Like, so weird. It's so weird. But yeah, I didn't feel great about the, don't worry about the treachery. Yeah. Don't worry about it. It's been neutralized and wavy stuff. Right. Another letter has been sent for Rue specifically, but she doesn't get a chance to read it because Abral presses Rue about Fenn's involvement in the research as well. It's clear that she sees him as a distraction, but one that she can't prevent Rue from indulging

in. I'm like, yes, you can. He's not a student. Right. He doesn't have any right to be here. Like you could exclude all of these people. You could kick the children out. Like. I just, it seemed like such a throwaway line to be like, well, I can't stop you. I'm like. But you can though. You can. Okay. 100%. At the very least, you could stop Fenn from being involved in the research. Yeah. Like you don't know him. Academy business. Get out of here. Yeah. You don't get to just be here. Also again, again, I imagine there's a lot of research happening at the tower.

That's kind of the whole point. Some of that has to be relevant to the government. So like this rando is just free reign in this place. Yeah. That's a great, that's a great point. So Rue joins her fellow researchers down in the dungeons where guards have already been posted. When they're alone before the children arrive, Rue shares all that she's learned from the region's letter along with her own suspicions. She argues fervently that she trusts DeLuke enough to believe his followers wouldn't intentionally stifle their research, but it's clear that she has a soft spot for DeLuke for some reason.

And that feels naive to me and her fellow researchers also don't think that's a good idea. And then Patently dislikes DeLuke and says so out loud. I don't understand why she just trusts DeLuke. It's such a bad call. It's such a bad call and it doesn't make any sense. You met once. Well I think one of Rue's fatal character flaws is that she's easily flattered. She definitely, she's got a big ego.

And DeLuke obviously saw that in immediately everything that he says to her is flattery, right? Yes, which works. And he is a cult leader literally. He is charismatic. That's kind of their shtick. Kind of their shtick. The Mary Band of Assholes agrees to be civil with the children if only for Rue's sake. And so they go on with their day. They spend most of that day unpacking all of these instruments and getting ready for their research in general. And once the day is done, Rue is back in her room in the evening and she reads the other

letter that was sent along with the instruments and it turns out that it was from Simon. He warns her that the children expect results quickly and if they don't feel she's progressing, more will show up and attempt to properly motivate her, though he's not sure exactly how they intend to do so. And I'm like, what? I don't like that. I don't like that. And I don't understand who Simon is and what he knows and what he sees. He doesn't seem particularly useful. No, he doesn't. Because even this letter and this threat, I mean, it's creepy.

I think the whole like more will just keep coming. But like, what are they going to do? Are they going to torture her? Like what are you, what are you warning me of? And I can't research his research. I can't make the results come any faster than they're going to come. Not really. Right. Well, and the whole thing about Simon's warnings slash like bad feelings about the children is he never gives her a good reason. Like he's just like, I have a bad feeling about them. And she's like, okay, well, tell me more about that.

And he's like, I'd rather not. Right. And no one else really will either. I mean, even Fen doesn't particularly explain why he doesn't like DeLuke. No, I mean, Fen seems to be purely motivated by jealousy because DeLuke is charming and Rue like turns it on for him. Yeah. So I'm sorry, Fen. You were the one who ignored her at dinner. Truly. Why she talked to DeLuke. Children. They're children. Like Rue is definitely at fault here, but I think so is everybody else.

Like nobody's giving her a good reason why her thought process is wrong. Exactly. She doesn't have a good reason. And she's not being told why she should rethink anything. No. Like she's not really being challenged. She's just being vaguely warned. Beware. Beware of the children. So the next morning, Rue goes straight to the dungeons and discovers that Lear has now turned into a Kingsguard, as we mentioned before. And he is one of the two standing watch that morning. She is delighted as they greet each other and they kind of have this weird like, oh,

we're friends. It's so cool that you're here now. And I'm like, I have so many questions about how this happened. How it happened, why it happened, why we should care. Right. So poor Lear is just there for like five minutes and then for like a good 25% of the back half of this book doesn't exist. It doesn't exist. So why was he even introduced as a person who matters? I don't know. Okay. Okay. So she continues inside and she finds Fen already there.

And before long they are joined by Archie and Gwen as well. It seems that Archie is all better now because Rue remarks quote, she saw in his easy smile in his interactions with Fen that any lingering wounds between them had been healed. And I'm like, somehow I doubt it. There's no way in hell. There's no way in hell this isn't going to be a problem. And also there's no reason for it. Like, no, there's no reason. It's almost like the author didn't want to write like that animosity anymore. And so she was like, okay, we need to get rid of this. And why did you introduce the animosity? Truly. And Archie from here on out becomes a non entity.

He does not have a personality. He doesn't have a pivotal role in the story. And I'm just like, why are you here at all? Yes. Like why even introduce any of the romance, conflict? Like, why are you here? It's just another one of those mechanics that I think is pretty ill conceived. Yes. Ill conceived, ill executed. Yes. So, Rue kind of starts today by laying out her research plan, which has three phrases.

One, what is the nature of the object? Two, what is the purpose of the object? And three is the object magical. I like this structure, but she doesn't go into any more depth and to like what kind of experiments or like what the gates are for like each one of these things. And this is really where professorial oversight would be key, I think. Yeah. So, okay, define nature, like you're looking at physical substance, are you looking at like its origin? Are you looking at like, there's a lot of additional questions here. Yes.

And how are you going to decide if it's magical if no one believes in magic? How are you going to prove that it's magical if you refuse to interact with it in a way that elicits a magical response? Well, and this is like, I know it doesn't matter, but the whole thing that they're trying to prove all of this scientifically, how can you prove something as magical scientifically? Doesn't that negate the magic of it? Well, you're trying to disprove that it can be proven scientifically. That's confusing. Well, it's like, it's like inherently they have this disconnect between science and

magic and I'm like, if I'm thinking about other magical systems, you could approach that scientifically because like the magic has rules and is repeatable. Yes. Or you could run an experiment with magic, but the way that you're approaching this, you're refusing to interact with any potential magical properties like your like intelligent bond with this stone. I don't know why that like, for some, okay, that's not the problem I have with her even running this project because she's so cagey about things she knows, like no one else needs

to know about this bond, but that seems to be relevant. It doesn't seem to be. It's 100% relevant to all parts of your research. Yep. Why do you have this bond? Where does this bond come from? That should have been one of your phases. Yeah, but all kinds of don't worry about it. And then like, are you protecting the artifact? I just, I don't understand. I don't understand. No. The final thing they agree is to use oven mitts to handle the object at all times, which

okay. I'm not just like gloves. I'm just picturing like I have those a little sweary. Yes. That's what I'm picturing. Like bright colors, but they fuck and I'm just like, I'm ready. I have an artifact. I don't understand why it would be oven mitts and not gloves. Like, don't you want to be able to use your fingers? Yeah, at least have the articulatable ones, right? Yeah, no, just. And I picture them being like very oversized, like, oh yeah, a little sweary, but like Nikki Mouse sized.

So Rue continues on to unwrap the artifact and she has a momentary pang of jealousy that maybe Archie or Gwen might have a similar connection with the thing, but she quickly tamps that down. She's like, that's ridiculous. When she sees the thing again, she stares at it for a while until Gwen calls her back to reality by going, are you good girl? Good. You having a moment? Rock. And Gwen again asks through if she'll be okay studying the thing given the past events and Rue inwardly scolds herself for being so obvious while protesting aloud that she'll

be fine. And this whole, she literally says like, I can't be so obvious about this. And I'm like, why not? It's like you're a teenager sneaking around with like a bad, a bad guy. I know. I don't understand why you can't be obvious about this because again, I think your connection is really meaningful. You've been through a trauma. So that trauma response is fair, which is why Gwen's asking you about it in the first place. Right. And you advocated that you had a special connection to this thing in your defense, like in the

deliberation. Oh, I forgot about that. And use this as an, an opportunity to like expand upon that. I forgot that was like her primary argument. Yeah. Okay. All right. Okay, Rue. So they go on to spend the morning taking rudimentary measurements like the size, the weight, the refraction, et cetera. And at midday, they are joined by the children and we learn their names, Inda, Ranto, and Nell. Rue had thought that these children would stay at the fringes observing, but instead

they're like all up in everybody's business asking in-a-n questions the whole time. Like literally questions like, what are you doing when somebody is measuring the thing? Why are they supervising this? This rubs everybody the wrong way, but Archie in particular seems to have a temper that easily flares and Rue has to pull him aside and be like, dude, be cool. Like get your shit together. I feel like this temper is going to be a problem. Dude, right? Some days later, Archie and Rue are in her room trying to write a letter to DeLuke on

their progress, which hasn't been much. They talk about how it's clear that the children aren't scientific, nor are they looking for a scientific breakthrough because they don't understand half of the things that Rue and her colleagues are doing, nor do they seem able to parse the lies that Rue and her colleagues tell them about what they're doing. It's clear that the children are hiding what they're really after, but neither have a clue as to what that is. It's also shady. And again, I don't understand why they're allowed to do this. I don't understand why they're allowed to do this.

And Rue mentions the fact that her and the rest of the researchers are lying about what they're doing. And I'm a little unclear as to why they're lying because on the one hand, they seem to be like lying about results that they're getting, but I don't understand why they would do that. I don't understand why they would do that either because they don't seem to be trying to lie in their letters to DeLuke. Right. So why are you trying to manipulate the children?

I don't know. That's very weird. Unless they're lying just out of like, you're annoying, so I'm not going to tell you what I'm doing. Yeah. That's kind of maybe the other vibe that I was getting, which makes sense. It does make sense, but it makes for a confusing story. It does. And they never come out and say that, so you're left to kind of infer what she's talking about. Yeah. Because it could be one thing where it's like, they asked what I was doing as I held up a ruler. I'm seeing what color it is. I'm defining its nature.

Yeah. That was like that I did notice in this part because the first part I mentioned that this book doesn't seem like it's taking itself seriously. Like it's kind of tongue in cheek. That goes away. It does go away. There's none of that left here. No. Which was a little disappointing because I didn't understand the nature of that and now I super don't understand the nature of that and it tells me that that must have been meant seriously. But I liked that stuff. So I'm kind of like, okay, well. I did too.

Like the cavalier nature of it was fun. It was fun. Like I didn't know I had knees. Yeah. So two weeks go by and nothing meaningful is gleaned. The children approach Rue and ask her to speak to the rock directly and see if it reacts. Rue of course is caught off guard because she feels connected to the thing and it feels like they're scratching at that knowledge. All of the other researchers in the room are like, that's a completely stupid thing to ask. And as soon as you do that, like you don't have any purview over this research and they're

like, actually we do. You're going to do it. And Rue's like, I said I would do it. It's fine. It's a weird kind of power struggle. It is a weird part of it because again, I don't understand whether they're allowed to have any purview of the research, but I can't blame the other researchers to be like, this is a stupid thing to ask for because I picture from their perspective. It's like I'm picturing like a normal like chemistry lab with beakers like walk up to the beaker and say hello. Right. Okay. What's it going to do? And they're like, no.

So Rue agrees and she can feel that the artifact is excited at this notion too. It's clear Rue doesn't have a choice, as I mentioned. So she agrees. She goes to the thing, leans in close and asks aloud and in her mind, what are you? The thing responds by flooding her senses with images of things that ostensibly have happened in its past. Slowly at first, she sees a sky darkened with soot and storm clouds, a figure in a dark cloak, but then the images come too fast that she can't parse them and it overwhelms her

and she passes out. She isn't out long, but her vision is gone for a bit, though it returns more quickly this time. Fen covers for her and takes her out of the dungeon to her room under the guys that she likely fainted because she had to eat breakfast. I don't know why anyone buys that. I don't either. It's too... The simplest answer is that something happened with the artifact and she passed out. And the only people in the room who believe that are Archie and Gwen.

And the children clearly don't. No, because it's a stupid thing to believe. Right. Oh, she's just angry. Oh, her delicate woman constitution. We must get her some cookies, which is all we ever see her eat. I know. I'm okay with that. In her room, Fen tries to get rude to tell him what happened, what really happened. She's under the effect of the artifact though and somehow Fen is as well and it strikes me almost like Fen is a succubus trying to use his powers against Rue to get answers because

he like pulls her clothes, kisses her neck, asks her if the stone like answered the question that she asked. It's a weird scene. It's very weird because they're both into it, but like Rue is very out of it. Like she talks about how she feels drunk, like really drunk. Yes. And it's weird because Fen is also like simultaneously flirty and enticing, but also like kind of angry.

Like it's just, it's weird. Yeah. He is angry. Like there's an undercurrent there. Like he's not like shouting or anything obviously. But he's like, what did you do? Yeah. Yeah. So Rue like takes a breath and is able to push Fen away. She's confused and doesn't understand what's happening. She feels they both must be affected by the artifact, but it all feels strange. As she's thinking about like what could be happening, she thinks about those last moments

before she passed out and realizes that she saw a darkness coming from the stone at the last moment and realizes in that moment that if she hadn't passed out, she likely would have killed everybody in the room. Oops. The realization shocks her and she finally admits to Fen that the stone answered her. Fen tells her that he suspected as much because she saw, he saw something in her eyes before she fainted and knew there was something that she wasn't telling him. She realizes that he suspected that for much longer than just today.

Rue goes on to confirm his suspicions and goes on to ask why he trusts her so much. He tells her he returns trust freely given, which is a really cagey answer that she asks no follow up questions about. She doesn't ask any follow up questions ever and he gives really cagey answers all the time. To me, that question of I return trust freely given. She should be like, why do I freely trust you? That's the question. Right. Or how do you know like? How do you know I trust you? Yeah. Weird man. So she asks about what happened between them.

That steamy moment and he says he didn't sleep well and he apologizes for acting un-gently in his fear for her. He's like, I was concerned. I took that out in an inappropriate way. I'm sorry. But Rue can tell that he's holding something back from her. But of course she doesn't act. She doesn't ask about it. Even though he was just like dragging her secrets out of her. Right. So before they can talk further, Archie and Gwen barge into the room. Clock lock at the center. They tell them that the children made them write down the whole thing so that they could

report it back to Duluc. They not know how to write. I guess not. And after they relay that information, Gwen shoes the men out of the room and helps Rue into bed seeing clearly that she's exhausted and unwell. When Rue wakes up, she's alone and she remembers the moment before she passed out as the stone had reacted to her. We were talking about earlier how when things like this happen to Rue, her memories of them start really hazy and kind of undefined.

As she gets further away from the moment, it becomes clearer and clearer what happened. And this is one of those examples. So in this memory that's coming back to her, she sees the children's expression as this darkness comes from the rock. Their expressions morph into something predatory and she realizes that they know that she can elicit a response from the object. And that's bad news bears. It is bad news bears and the predatory nature. Oh, not great. So scary. So she determines that she has to know as much about these children as she possibly can

and goes immediately to the nearest library to try to find more information about who they are and what they want. She's ultimately unsuccessful, but then she thinks about Simon and maybe he'll know and so sends a letter to him via pigeon to ask and I can't help but wonder, girl, why didn't you do that begin with? I don't know. I don't know why she doesn't ask any follow up questions and Simon already reached out with warnings, so I would have responded immediately. And I also don't know why she doesn't ask Fen because Fen very clearly like, why tell me why?

Yeah, it just feels like she has these avenues where she could find out more about the children pretty easily and she just decides to not use it. No, she doesn't. And then I think I was hardcore skinny at this point, but even like the letter she writes to Simon, she's trying to be like really cagey in what she's asking. Right. But I also feel like asking like, yo, tell me more about the children. Isn't that weird of a question? It's not, especially because they're, she could have couched it as like, hey, they're helping with my research. I would like to know more about them. Can you tell me more about them?

Yeah. And like you said, they want results. Do you know what they're looking for? Right. Also, I know that these are adults, but because their name is the children, I picture children every time and it's creepy as hell. Especially with that like predatory glint that she talks about. Yes. I just picture three children in the darkness with this like predatory stare. Cause they're dressed in white and they all have like close cropped hair. So they all look the same. It's all terrifying. It's so scary. And like, they're so creepy to me.

Yeah. Oh, I'm so curious. So that is where we will end our coverage of part two of the destroyer. We will pick up in two weeks to finish the book. I'm so interested, but I feel like nothing happened. I will. So that's the thing. Like things happened, but they happened at such an elongated pace. We didn't need all of that. No. A little bit of editing could have gone a long way in this book. Yes. But I am interested and I'm, I want to finish it.

I want to talk to you about it because now you finish it. I see your faces. Yeah, I'm torn because like I'm glad that I finished it. I feel like I'm ahead, but now I'm like, I feel like I can't like hypothesize with you as much now that I know what's happening. Sorry. Just that's a couple of days. What we're going to do Thursday. I realized we didn't actually end this episode. Sorry, but I got really excited. Oh, that's okay. So until next time, we'll see you. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Irresistible Urge to Fall for Your Enemy By Brigitte Knightley Part 1

    Nov 10, 20261 hr 35 minAudio

    Triggers: graphic violence and gore, depictions of a fictional plague, on-page sexual content (including masturbation), and themes of parent death and chronic illness KU: No Recommendation: No, (give the author money...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Surrendering to Scylla by Wren K Morris

    Oct 27, 20261 hr 10 minAudio

    Triggers: (From the author): kidnapping, violence, discussions of abuse, BDSM dynamics and play, tentacle play, brief descriptions of injured animal (that receives aid), breath play, bondage, depictions of sub drop,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Threshing Day by Rebecca Yarros

    Oct 14, 20261 hr 9 minAudio

    Triggers: war, battle, hand-to-hand combat, perilous situations, blood, intense violence, brutal injuries, death, and poisoning KU: No Recommendation: Yes! For more of the author, check out https://rebeccayarros.com/

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Court of Heathens by K. A. Knight

    Sep 29, 202652 minAudio

    Triggers: from the author: “explicit violence, explicit sexual violence, dubious consent, murder, gore, torture, kidnapping, and more.” KU: Yes Recommendation: No For more of the author, check out...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Under Loch and Key by Lana Ferguson Part 2

    Sep 21, 20261 hr 4 minAudio

    Triggers: death of a parent (off page), grief, fantasy violence KU: No Recommendation: both Traders recommend! This is part 2 of 2. For more of the author, check out https://www.lanaferguson.com/

    Credit the people on this episode