Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Spice Traders

Spice Traders artwork

The Irresistible Urge to Fall for Your Enemy By Brigitte Knightley Part 1

Nov 10, 20261 hr 35 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Triggers: graphic violence and gore, depictions of a fictional plague, on-page sexual content (including masturbation), and themes of parent death and chronic illness KU: No Recommendation: No, (give the author money and then go read the AO3 original) For more of the author, check out https://brigitteknightley.com/

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Welcome to your safe space. The podcast, your partner, friends, parents, whoever thinks it's dirty. Don't have time to read books? Want to understand all the jokes and the TikToks? We got you fam. We're the spice traders and we deal in spicy books. I'm Katie and I need it to make sense. I'm Liz and I'm hypercritical. Before we get to today's episode, we want to encourage you to check out our Patreon, where we publish extra episodes every other week, as well as ad -free versions of our regular feed episodes. Also, any series we read past the first book, all that coverage is Patreon only, so think series like Akatar, Fourth Wing, Guild. Anyway, we really

appreciate the support and encouragement to continue doing something we love and sharing it with you. Thanks in advance for checking that out. As always, we start this episode with three things. First is a generic trigger warning. You can find specific triggers for this book in our show notes, so please check those out. We also use foul language and talk a lot about sex. If you have sensitivity to either of those things, our podcast probably isn't for you. Second, our episodes talk about books, the whole book, nothing but the book, so help me goddess. If you don't want something spoiled, don't listen to this episode. And finally, we acknowledge that a good book can hit you at the wrong time. Our views discussed in our episodes

are our opinion, and we don't want to diminish the work or the talents of the authors in our community. That said, we have some notes. So what did you think of this book? Okay, so if I didn't know that it was a Jermaini fanfic originally

on AO3, I think I would have hated it. I know. Because it's not great. No. But I had a great time. And I really think it's just because I went into it with warm fuzzies because I was like, oh, it's fanfic. And that kind of excused everything else. Yeah. I get that. Yeah, I was bored. And I was so bored also. Enough with the

slapstick. Like, Jesus Christ, can you just have a conversation? Yeah. And, like, she's so unlikable. I was waiting for her to come around in any way, have, like, any kind of personality at all, besides being a cold, hard bitch. God, she's the worst. And, like, he's likable. I think he's a delight. But she has zero personality. She's, like, it's like... I'm going to keep referring to it as

a fanfic because it is. And I think if you look into it, you can find like it's not a secret. Yeah. Sorry, author. But it's like she took all of the shit parts of Hermione and just did those. And I was like, yeah. Why, though? Yeah. I mean, I think the thing, too, like and I'm going to say this in our in our main like section, like there is something to be said for a lot of the legwork that an existing universe does for a fanfic. Yes, because like in a fanfic you can

just say this is Hermione and we'll be like, oh my god I love her Right because I've already read eight fucking books about her Exactly and watched nine movies Right. And so I don't have to come up with a personality. I don't have to come up with a backstory like it's already just built in exactly and Without that with these people like one I thought their characters were just flat They were so flat And then also, like, the prickly parts about Hermione that make her,

like, kind of an uptight bitch, like, weren't married with a similar level of, like, friendliness to anybody except for some prostitutes for, like, a hot minute. Right? Because Hermione is warm and friendly and caring and nerdy. Like, this lady's just a bitch. And I don't know why she's a bitch. We go to her home life, and it's fine. I don't know. And the other thing that I thought was kind of a miss is, yeah, she's smart. She's

a bookworm. But the part that Hermione as a character knows she's a bookworm in the way that nerds know that they like to learn. This character, and I also hate her name. Yeah. I don't even remember her name right now, honestly. She just. She truly believes she's a genius and like nobody can touch her smarts. And those are two very different personality traits. I don't like you thinking that you're just literally better than everyone else. Like Hermione doesn't think she's better than anyone. She's smarter. That's really

the thing, right? Like, because, because when it was, when it was, um, when it was a, God damn it, Malfoy and Hermione, Malfoy and Granger, the whole last name thing, I'm going to talk about that too. But when it was - I hate the last name thing. When it was Draco and Hermione, right? Like - Hermione had a legitimate reason to hate him because he bullied her as a child. And also... Yes. And like, frankly, that's the biggest thing, right? Like, yes, he works for the Dark Lord, right? But like, you could argue

that they're kids. But you were a dick to me, right? And I think that that's... You bullied me. I think that's integral to Hermione not being a dick to other people, right? Like... Yes. She's not a bully. Right. And so like for this Farah and Aryan, whatever her name is, like to just swan about like she's God's gift to everybody. I'm just like, I don't like you. No. And I just I kept waiting for it to change. Yes. It never

did. Right. I kept waiting to see like. a kernel of insecurity and like that's why she puts on such a show or you know whatever it is or like her parents are dead and so she has to like take care of her 47 siblings or whatever it is but like should we go to her house and like she has nothing like she's fine her parents are lovely her parents had more personality than than she has the entire book yes uh so i'll just it this will come out in the readings but like it reads

like a fanfic and i think yeah I think we haven't read Alchemized, which is the public use version of Manicold, right? Right. But I always hear good things about that. I think that's because that is just a really good writer. I think, and I don't know the order of operations, I could be wrong, but I think that like Manicold to Alchemized kind of paved this road to be like, oh, we can publish fanfic if we like change the names and

stuff enough. Sure, but something should just stay on AO3. And I think this one should have just stayed on AO3. Yeah, or had more of a brutal editor, right? Because I really do like the way that this author writes. I think it's very whimsical. And I think it's very dry. And I could get behind that. But frankly, this didn't need to be two books. I don't even need to know what happens in book two. But when it ended, I was like, you've got to be fucking kidding me. I know. It's shorter. Cut it, cut it down. Because I get the, okay,

like this book, it's the first book, but it's just one big travel montage. This whole book is a travel montage where they get nowhere. Yeah. And then kind of at the end, kind of at the end, but then other, other things also happen that don't drive, like, don't really mean anything towards the story. Like I just, this feels like I have a big head and little arms and I'm just wondering how well thought out this plan was kind of book. Yes. Yes, exactly. And especially with, like, all of the holes that she had to fill in the universe with, like, these 12 kingdoms

or seven kingdoms. I don't even know. And there's these, like, magical clans. Like, I have no fucking idea what's going on in this world. It's too complicated. Like, the clans, cool. The kingdoms I didn't need. Why are the fucking, like, ley lines, right? Like, the port keys, basically. Sure. Why are they all, like, port keys inside pubs with stupid names? Like... Those are, like, three different things that have to happen at the same time every time, and I don't understand why. Right. Which I was here for, but, like,

really make that make sense and remove one of the other things, right? Like the kingdoms. Like the kingdoms, or even just, like, the different types of magic. Just let there be light and dark magic. Yeah, light and dark magic. And even if you want, like, light, dark and that, like, Hedgewitch gray area, that's fine, too. Cool. But the fact that there's, like, certain types of light magic and certain types of dark magic, but... In the back, we have this index with all, like, 12 factions. We really only know about two of them. So, like, just talk about two of them. Everyone else can

be regular people and then just have, like, the healers and the mercenaries. That's all I need. Right. That's really all I need. And, like, the way that this world works also doesn't make sense because, on the one hand, you want me to believe that this is a functioning society. On the other hand, we know that there is a plague for all of the poor children and also towns where there

has been enough war that they have not been rebuilt. Because that's where the assassins were meeting at, right? Like, yeah. Yeah. I don't believe where are like. No. Just no. That doesn't make any sense. The society is not stable, and it doesn't make sense to me. And you have a glittering party at fucking Hermione's parents' house? Like, where did all these people come from? Where do they live? The party. I was like, what are we

doing here? Like, they just live in a house. I thought everybody lived behind a castle because it's like war or whatever. And we're in these kingdoms that, like, we're divided all the time. Right. Also, are the kingdoms the same as the factions? No. Also, is everybody in a faction? I don't know. I don't understand. I don't know. I don't think so, because, like, her parents seemed fairly non -magical to me. Yeah, so then, like, where does the magic come from? Like, if you want to just have muggles, that's fine. But, like, do you choose your path or does it choose you? Right. OK, that goes back to the, like,

I forget what book we were talking about, but it's like, are you just killing people who were born into this because they were born into it? Like, that's genocide. Yeah, that was guild, right? The fucking like cannibal people that like, fuck them, they get to go to prison. Yeah, it was guild. And it was also that other vampire, like reverse. We're still not finished with. But yes. And she's just so she's just so puritanical about it. And I'm just like, oh, OK. Also, I

I got really tired. OK, so like she's a healer, right? That's her whole thing. Their whole thing is do no harm. But then that doesn't make sense to me that you're wishing for someone's death. Right. I don't understand a healer who wants to help people live, have such a moral qualm about saving a life. Because that person happens to be a dark arts. I don't buy that. No. It's

just like. peanut butter good for goodness sake and like even when like those bandits who are physically like promising bodily harm she was like don't kill them please and i'm like the okay the end result of you not killing them is that they are going to continue to do more harm to other people that's exactly it's the good for just being good and i don't right it doesn't make sense it's problematic and it's not interesting. And I do, I like what the author was trying to

do at the end. We're like, Ariane starts out with this, like, I'm all good. I only walk the white path, whatever. And now she's like, lied and stolen and also murdered people, but it didn't really hit the way it could. And I think it was because it was just buried under a lot of mess. Yeah. And a lot of like internal exposition that I didn't fucking. Oh my God. I know. And like, I think, I think that's the thing. Cause I, It was it was a lot of slapstick, but like the humor is funny. Like the wordplay is funny. I like

the banter, but it's all it's all tell and don't show like the whole book. It's the whole book. And there's certain parts that I know you've seen the the teacher, the teacher. Tick tock. Give it out. The T talker Raider. Who will like read romance and it'll be like she sauntered toward him. boobily boobily every line was it was like he said it blah blah blah it's like everything had like an adjective an adverb or

whatever yeah it was like and then there were parts where like the author would just describe a conversation without any quotes like they weren't talking anymore she was just like and then he said and then she said without quotes like i'm just gonna paraphrase this argument right here because i don't want to write it that's where i'm like it's fanfic I don't think she's a bad writer at all. I think it's really clever. But some of it I'm like, my lady. Yeah, because you can do the like, and then he said, and then she said, as kind of like a gentle reader, like kind

of a nudge aside, almost breaking the third wall. But you have to use it sparingly. And it happens not sparingly. It was like every single chapter. Yeah. Yeah. Also, why is he poor? I'm sorry. I know this is going to sound like such a nitpicky thing, but the whole thing about Malfoy is that he is rich and polished. He is as close as we're ever going to fucking get to a billionaire romance in the Harry Potter fanfic world. Okay? I needed

that to be retained. And it didn't make sense for him to be poor because... He's a fucking thief, right? Like his house is decked out with all of this art that he's stolen. So he should just have billions of dollars. Like he shouldn't have to sell off works of art and have these like gaping holes in his house to like pay the ransom. He should just have it and be like, here's your 20 million or whatever much it was. Right. Or sell a painting to get it because you don't want to like liquidize your other assets or whatever it is. But for him to be like, well, now I'm

penniless. I'm like, oh, Cool. OK. Because there's, that's really, I mean, like, I think that's why I'm struggling with this book a little bit. And I think at this point, I'm just going to leave our debrief into the episode, because this is pretty good so far. But like, yeah, it's great. They don't have lives outside of their, quote unquote, magic profession. No, they don't. And I get why she doesn't, but I don't really get

why he doesn't. No, I mean, I don't get why either of them like she has a family and apparently that she likes that family. But like that. Yeah. And what I meant by I get why she doesn't is because like the character we're presented with is fucking insane. She's like the epitome of a workaholic. Like she doesn't sleep. She doesn't eat. She just works and like yells at students. And like that sounds like you don't have a life because you don't deserve one. Right. Well, but also it's like you're you're on assignment, right?

Like it's like you're deployed almost. Right. So like the military base, the hospital that you were at is your life and your job. Right. But like, yes, they don't have like free time. And so like they don't have like hobbies. And so she has those two friends that we see once once. Yeah. And they drink wine once. But then like. So actually, we see them twice. Once they were drinking in her office and then the other time she met them at a pub and we learned that

they were getting married, which was a fucking wild thing to say. And also, where did this pub come from, right? Like you don't have a personal life. You told me many chapters ago that every time that you had to leave your fucking hospital, fortress that you had to go with a ward person. And so it's like, you're kind of prisoners in your own job. And yet you all got here somehow. Hermione, you got to your parents' house without a fucking ward guy. Yeah, I don't. So what's

happening here? But like, there's no, there's no, are there cars? Are we on horseback? Like, is this like a cell phone situation? Do we have shopping malls? Like, I don't, this world doesn't exist really beyond like, the cardboard boxes that we keep going into to steal things and get information. I think that's what bothered me about the silly names of the pubs, because I don't know why the lay portals are all at pubs and also that no one ever is also there and some

of them are abandoned. I don't know. It's like only one of them has a place and it's when they go to the brothel, right? And it's like the horny unicorn or whatever. Right. All of the rest are literally just like cardboard kind of stuff. Here is this Lace Stone. There's also this pub that has this name and no one else is here. And sometimes they're abandoned, but we're not going to talk about that. And no one else is using them ever either. It's just us. You should still tip the people who own the place. Why? Yeah. It's just very strange. And I stand by, I love

that line of whimsy, but it just feels so bonkers. Which is why I think if you're doing it in the world of Harry Potter where this originated, you don't really give a fuck if it's cars because people can apparate. Yes, but when you can't call it apparating, I need you to selt me on it. Yeah, or you're on a broom or some shit, right? Yeah. And then it's very much separate from the mocha world. It felt like, it feels

like... this book and the world that we're in is completely separate from whatever the rest of that planet is. Let's just say this is England, because it is. And England is warring factions, right? France could be in another fucking dimension. for all intents and purposes, right? Because we don't hear a fuck anything about France, right? Like we're just in England. It's like there's a giant stone wall and you could construe that

as being the magical world wall, right? Around where the story takes place. And that's why I didn't understand like, does everyone have magic? And like some are just like special and they have their like little palm signs or like just some people don't have magic. Right. Are you born with magic? Can you, like, learn magic? Do you choose that? Again, like, did he wake up and he was like, I'm going to be an assassin. Brand me. Yeah. Or did he wake up and he's like, cool, I guess I'm an assassin, like a sorting hat situation. Right. Well, and OK, but what

makes it, what is it, factions, orders? I don't fucking care. I don't know. What makes an order faction an order faction, right? Because the ward guys, the sentinel, you know what I mean, the guys that do the guarding of the palace prison. Yeah. They don't have magic. They're just good with swords. I know, but then in the back of the book, in the index, they are a faction. Right. So like, where's the line? I don't know. Is it magic or not? I don't know. We could have gotten

a little bit more fleshing out of that and a little bit less internalization from the characters. Yes, because it is an interesting world. Like, the magic rules also, I was really... okay with. Like you get the cost when you use too much. I think that was interesting. Yep. I like the like medical side of the magic. You could like see him in your body. Totally. But I didn't need her to say internally 37 ,000 times. I'm disappointed it didn't work. And I'm relieved that it didn't work because on one hand, he's not dead. On the other hand, he's still living. I'm like, I don't

care. I don't care. Also, what are you going to do if you don't want to save him? Just like Bring a warden with you to kill like why are you even fighting with yourself about this? I know you could bring a warden with you and like Have him kill him immediately and like be fine with it like exactly So like but also but why are you okay with that? Because she would be she would be but you're also do no harm. Yeah Yeah the the other thing at like I know I know

we're trying to fix his like ley lines internally or whatever, but like the I They have not convinced me that What they're trying to do makes any fucking sense. No. And honestly, I think that's like the thesis of the book. And she says it up front. She's like, we're going to go, like, stand in a river at the full moon with our, like, hopes and dreams. And like, that's really what the book is based on. Right. But I mean, tell me at least a one line fixer that's like, oh. That's

because that's where magic originated. And then as we got like more of a handle on it, it developed into the factions, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. She's fine. But it's basically, it's like she read one fairy tale and she's like, I can fix him. I can fix him. And then we get three whole maybe more tries and none of them worked. That felt stylistically like not a great choice. No, and it takes so long to get there, right? Like there's like months in between. It's like every

full moon, right? And I don't care what's happening in between, right? I don't care what's happening in between. Or like make those more effectual, right? Like develop the story around like this pox or whatever, like only when they meet or like whatever, but like. to have the last one that we see in this book where they go to the lighthouse and they have that moment with the birds and whatever. And it's like very close. And I was like, oh, this is definitely it. And maybe it was definitely, and it didn't work.

I mean, but, and maybe it was definitely it because the next time she checks it out, like his, his growth or his like recession is like stalled. So like, you know, it just, it feels like we're taking a little bit of a backseat. To the thing that they're trying to do to try to do the thing where I don't even know what we're doing. We're trying to figure out who tried to break into the castle. Who cares? They're dead. Okay. Her like, I'm going to blackmail you to get information on this girl. That's not your job. Like other

people are working on that. I promise. I don't care about this side quest that you introduced 400 pages into the book. Right. Also, the fact that they like, quote, unquote, didn't know anything or like they killed that guy and all of his guards and then they pretended like they didn't. I'm like. How are you getting away with this? They're all idiots. Well, especially because homeboys covered in blood because he like shadow walked inside of one of them. Also, the shadow walking needed way more explanation. I mean, I was fine

with it until he did that. Like, I don't even understand. No. Is he just good with weapons? How does his magic even like play a role in his assassin? Until that part. No idea. Yeah, I was like, OK, you could just get into somebody's shadow and then you can like just shake them really quick. That's how that works, right? No, apparently you can shadow walk into a person because that's also technically a shadow. Gross. Horrifying. It is horrifying. Our insides are

all shadows. Didn't we get that in another book? Maybe. Doesn't sound familiar to me, but that doesn't mean anything. I think you and I proposed that in some book that it would have been badass. Yeah. Someone who could manipulate shadows were like, I'm having such severe deja vu of us talking about like your insides all being shadows. And like, why is that not used? Some male character had the ability to like manipulate shadows. And I swear to God, I think maybe it wasn't guilt. I think it wasn't guilt. Yeah. Cause he could

manipulate shadows. We're like, just explode the shadows. Justice by the Shadows. Was it in Gilder? Was it in that first book that we've read, or one of the first books that we read, the Pokemon with Romanticy? Oh, maybe it was that one. When the Boy Scouts of America? Yeah, that book was great. That book was great. I wish they continued to be spicy, because I would have liked to continue that one. I know. I might continue it just for funsies, but I'm sad that they don't have any spice, and I don't understand why. Yeah. I mean, there's still my To Be Red shelf when I have free time at some point, but. Yeah. Alas.

Anyway, we should probably get into it. Yes, we should. So girl, what are we talking about today? Today we're talking about the irresistible urge to fall for your enemy by Brigitte Knightley. I'm not sure that's how you say her first name. Apologize. Apologies. I'm going to take this one. Apologize. Apologize. I didn't say anything. I know, but I know. That's why I was like, that's not what I wanted. I'm going to just say it. Brigette? Brigitte? How would you say that? Hold

on. Brigetta? Brigette? Brigitte? Brigitte? Brigitte? I don't know. I don't think it's her real name. I didn't mean that it sounds so shady. I just don't think that's her real name. Okay. I'm gonna try again. Okay. It was fine. I panicked. You got this. Thank you. Today, we're talking about The Irresistible Urge to Fall for Your Enemy by Brigitte Knightley. This was published in 2025, and it is the first in a duology, the dearly

belowed duology. This book is 416 pages long, and that's a midi. We're calling it a midi. Technically, in our terms, it's a longie, but... We're going to call that a rounding error because it's really not a long E. It's a MIDI. So we make the rules. That's right. That's right. We make the rules here. So whatever. I will say, OK, so the cover, there's two. Well, there's actually quite a few covers. There's at least like three or four that I'm seeing now. The cover that I have, because

I bought this as a hardback, it has this like pink border with kind of these like magical creatures on them. I just now realize that those creatures were the things on their hands, because I was like, I thought those creatures should have been their deafols, and they're not, and I was like, what the fuck is this bird? I digress. That's what it, it's their little fucking hand thing. You had to tell me, okay. I just got that, because I was about to go off on a rant on how the bird doesn't make any sense, and neither does that skull cat. Okay. Anyway. That makes more sense.

There's like potions, and there are these two cartoon people. This is a Germani fanfic. It's Draco and Hermione. Like, look at the cover. That's who it is. That's who it looks like. There's no pretending what this book is. And that's honestly why we're reading it. I mean, except for, like, Hermione, the character in this book, is a person of color. And J .K. Rowling speaks his shit and wouldn't do that. Exactly. J .K. Rowling would not do that. Or if she did, she would name her, like, Blackie McBlackerson, because J .K. Rowling

sucks. Oh my god. It's true, she named Cho Chang, come on. Look, you're not wrong, I just wasn't. Seamus Finnegan. Was not expecting that. I'm so sorry, I was just like. So, I do want to put, this is going over the top, we've just claimed that a lot. We both grew up with Harry Potter, J .K. Rowling fucking sucks, I don't want to give her any money, so I'm gonna give money to fanfic authors. Everybody else. Who have published, and I'm still going to enjoy this world in other

ways. And I love. some Jermini fanfic. So this cover is gorgeous. It's black and hot pink. The inside cover is hot pink. Like it's just, it's really, it's a really pretty book. I'm very happy to have it, even if it isn't my favorite book. There's this alternate cover that doesn't have the human characters. It just has the animal characters and like pink flowers, which is also really pretty. And I don't know if we're going to cover the second one. Probably not. But they

do look really great together. There's a couple other artistic renditions of this. And it's just quite lovely. I have no notes on the covers. I think they're great. I agree. And I like, I mean, the thing that you said about the two books looking good together I think is really important, because the second book is basically the same as this one, but it's just in purple. And the characters are in slightly different positions. I will say I don't usually like cartoons on the front of the book, but I don't mind these. I think they're well done. Yeah, the cartoons gave

me the same vibe usually as the like real people on a book and I don't love it but these are really well done and I I appreciated the like, you know what you're getting into. Yeah, exactly. Listen, you know who these characters are, right? Right guys. I also appreciate the attention to detail because I too got the hardcover and just like the I don't I forget what they're called but like the front cover inside the patterned pink

kittens and bombs and knives and quills and moths and things. That's just really pretty. So the form factor of the book is gorgeous. And I don't have a lot of notes. No, I think it's lovely. I have no notes either. You guys have heard me talk for a while now. I apologize for my voice. And for any stray stifles and coughs, I am sick. This is still Liz. Promise. I promise. And that's

it. I just want to put the little disclaimer out there. So should we say what the title is on AO3? I don't know what it is. Does it matter? Should we call it out? We should. I feel like we should. OK, so the original was called Draco Malfoy and the mortifying ordeal of being in love. Excellent. And I didn't actually get to do this. Um, but I, I really, cause reading this book, I had a, uh, okay, let's back up when,

wow, I really have to back up now. So we had another book scheduled for this time. Um, but Liz started reading it and DNFed it and said we shouldn't read it. So we didn't, and we subbed in something else. Uh, we subbed in this. And when Liz told me that it was the like published version of the morning mortifying deal. mortifying ordeal I can speak I promise. I was like awesome because I remember reading that fanfic and having a great time like it's good. I did not have a

similar experience in this book and I think there are a couple of reasons for it but what I wanted to do and I didn't quite get to it is to go back and like reread the mortifying ordeal and like compare and contrast what changed from the AO3 to the published version. And I think Liz teed it up, but we're probably not going to cover the second book in its entirety on this podcast. But I might do a TLDR and also do that, just so we can tie the knot on that. Oh, that'd be

fun. I'd be down to read the OG and do a compare and contrast, too. Yeah. So anyway, that's what I was calling AO3. Thank you for that. In case you. In case you want to check out the OG. And that's why I chose it. I was like, hell yeah, I get to read fanfic and talk about it. Let's go. Anyway, that being said, let's get into it. Katie, why don't you kick us off? For sure. So this is not on KU. But like I said, the hardcover

version is stunning. And if you're a book collector, definitely recommend. I did buy it on Kindle as well because it's easier. It's easier to I really don't mind supporting indie authors twice. Like, that's fine. It's big publishers where I'm like, give me the fucking digital copy if I buy the physical book. What is so difficult about this? I don't get it. Exactly. Look at you. Bloomsbury. I don't know. They're probably fine. Yeah, I also bought the Kindle one, which

is where I got the other cover. And I was like, these are both beautiful. Yeah. So the first thing we get a couple of things before we get into this book. And then there's a couple of things that we get on the back of this book that I wish that I had kind of understood that we had before. But here we are. The first thing that we get is a glossary, which was really important because there are a lot of terms that I didn't understand and I would have had questions about going into the book. and they cover kind of the the main concepts of like new things in this book like uh the magic what they're called um

magic users have a little thing on their hand what that's called uh we have little like friend boys like magic friend familiars those are those are covered in this too so that was all really useful yes we then get a map go ahead i was gonna say i don't know if it's there later but we get a pronunciation guide which I ignored immediately and I'm sorry in advance. You're so right about that. I was like, that's not how you say that.

So the next thing that we get is a map, which is just the map of England. But I guess it's useful if you want to know where things are located. There's this bit in the book, which at this point you've heard us talk about in our debrief. Probably. But like the pubs that they go to in here are covered there. Also, the kingdoms that exist in this world are also covered on this map. So if you need an orientation, that's great. I would

argue that the map is not necessary because the physical world of this book is not well fleshed out. Yeah, I never once looked at the map. Okay, so then the other two things that we get Liz mentioned one of them they're actually at the back of the book is the pronunciation guide Which is great because we do have a lot of new words and new names Or you can completely ignore it as she chose to do And then we get a Essentially

an index or a glossary of all of the orders and the orders are like different factions or like groups like kind of like the or the the index describes them as like guilds almost. And some of them have magic and some of them don't. But some of them are important for this book and some of them aren't. So read it or don't. Yeah, a little pat. It's a really rich world that I

almost wish wasn't as rich because it's just a little distracting. It is a little bit distracting. Yeah. So going into this, we do get uh third person limited perspectives throughout the book and it's mainly from our two main characters um Osric Mordaunt and Aryan Farron um they do this thing in the book where they refer to each other by their last name very similar to how Granger and Malfoy do in fanfics um but it was

confusing to me and I feel like maybe I'm just losing it because about two thirds of the way through the book, Osric began referring to himself as Osric. And I was like, who the fuck is Osric? Yeah, that got me too. Okay, good. I'm glad it's not just me. I was like, we were talking about Mordrent, Mordant, right? Yeah, that got me too. The other thing that confused me was, we'll talk about the factions, but like her last name is Farron, but like he is also a Farron and like

they're spelled differently. But like I said it the same and that like my internal narration that confused me a lot. I was like, who? What? And it also seemed like I have to do the book. Yeah, the first name would change. Like, are we are we using first names or not? And I'm struggling to articulate this. The dual POV made it confusing because. Like you said, he switched how he referred to us himself. And it's just like it's too many

names. Like we have four names across two characters and I don't like it. It works when it's like Granger Malfoy. And I can't really put my finger on why it doesn't work here. It's just confusing. Well, I think that speaks to something that we were talking about in our debrief, which is like I have not candidly read. Another fanfic that made the jump to broad publication. I have the Sen Li book, but I have not Sen Li Li? I think

it's Sen Li Yu. Thank you. I'm so sorry. The alchemized book. I'm so sorry for mispronouncing that author's name. Sen Lin Yu. Thank you. I do have that book. We haven't read it yet because it is so fucking long. It would take us literally three months to cover. We've talked about it. It's three months. of episodes for you guys. Maybe we'll do it next year. I don't know. But my point being, I haven't read one yet. I have them. I just haven't read. This is the first one. And it's interesting because the established

literature in a world that you are familiar with, that you are then going into a fanfic about, does so much legwork for that fanfic that goes unappreciated. So the names is part of it, right? I think we have a good understanding of who these people are, and then nobody calls Malfoy Draco. That's just weird unless you're being intimate. That works. And then it's like a special thing. Right. But at some point, Osric halfway through the book referring to himself as Osric and her

doing the same thing, I'm like, are you pretending to be somebody else because you're at her parents' house? I don't understand what's happening here. It was frankly confusing. All to say, um going into this book the tone is really fun it's very british um and it's very dry there is definitely that enemies to lovers kind of vibe um but it's it's it's a little bit dense so we'll get into kind of what happens yes so we open with our

male main character osric mordaunt being told by two terrified Physicers, which are essentially doctors called Fordyce and Shuttleworth, that he has something called Seathrot. So Seath is the like magical system, biological system that allows somebody to use magic and he is a magic user. So this is devastating. This Seathrot is degenerative and incurable and they estimate

that he has three or four months before his abilities start to go completely. I mentioned that he's of magic user. So he is a specific type of magic user called a fire in, which is somebody who's a part of the order of assassins, right? So the fire in our assassins. And so there he's given this diagnosis and he asked the physicals quote, do you know how fire in our retired? And the answer is death. Oops, whoops. Um, so this is

a big problem. It also points out one of our main, uh, first discrepancies that we run into because they give him a very definitive timeline for when they think that he's going to be able to not use magic. And we blow past that with flying colors and we don't even like, pay it any mind. Don't collect $200. Right. They gave him what? Like a couple months or something. three to four months they were very clear you don't have a lot of time you're gonna die right

or be killed as soon as you're caught right and and he knows that this is a problem because he started to feel like numbness in his extremities and he started to have like occasional lapses in his ability to use his magic so he's like this is a capital p problem These dudes go on to tell him that there is one person who might be able to help and her name is Arianne Farren She who is part of the the Hailen the Hailen. That's what I read it to Hailen the Hailen Hailen

healing order I'm sorry. I that's just how I read it in my brain. Like I'm probably gonna say it that way It's okay. I also read fire in as friend for a really long time and I had to like force myself to change it because it was like, hey friend, hey friend, yeah. Again, there is a pronunciation guide. I didn't use it immediately. Ignore it. Yeah, I'm going to be honest. I was like, no, I'm not sure that I heated it very

closely either. So I'm sorry about that. I know I say the thing on their hands wrong. I think it's like Tarkin and it's it's tech. It's Tassin. No, that made my brain hurt. Because a C and an N shouldn't be next to each other in a word. Yes, not like that, anyway. So we'll get there when we get there. So the problem with Aryan Faerim being his only hope, Obi -Wan, is because

Halence don't fuck with Firenze because Halens heal people and Byron's kill people. And so they're kind of diametrically opposed orders of magic. Cool. Cool. So he sends the the physicals away. Those two gentlemen leave and he has a conversation with his steward, Mrs. Parsons, who I think might be one of my favorite characters. Yeah, they're yeah. They're my favorite characters, too. Mrs. Parsons is the best. Yeah. And she's also. fully bought into this whole assassin's thing. And she's like, okay, well, what are you gonna do with that? And he's like, well, plan A, I'm just

gonna ask her. And she suggests having a plan B for blackmail and a plan C for coercion. And he's like, okay, well, maybe not blackmail at the start. Let's start with bribery. So plan A, ask, plan B, bribery. Mrs. Parson learns and tells Osric that the Highland need 20 million money things. I could say that word at all. Thrimsauce.

Thrimsauce's money things. Buckaroos. Buckaroos. 20 million shmeckles to develop an inoculation for something called Platt's pox, which is a disease killing almost exclusively poor kids, and nobody will fund it. OK, I could be wrong. Call me out. But the fact that there's a pox that only kills poor kids just gave me the same vibe as killing your gays. I was like, why are

we killing the poor kids? And we see them die tragically, like randomly throughout this otherwise jaunty book. It's like, why are we here? Well, it's not super well explained. This is the other thing that made me question like, what, what? What time is it? Because this feels very much like turn of the century, like industrial England, right? Like poor kids are living in coal mines, essentially dying because they can't breathe

fresh air or drink fresh water. And all of the rich kids can go to the country and have the airs or whatever and get out of it, right? The vapors. But we're not super clear on why this is only affecting poor kids. But literally people are scooping up poor... Poor kids with like a bulldozer and dumping them like on the front lawn of this hospital Yeah, it's very like bring out your dad, but with Yeah, I was like why is

this the backdrop I don't know I don't know all right, so Oscar's like, cool. He breaks into Swanstone, which is the Halen fortress. And this is why I have so many questions about the Halen fortress. Why is it a fortress? It should be a hospital. I don't understand why it needs to be guarded because so they have an agreement with another order called the wardens to guard it. And in order to leave, the Halens have to be like escorted by a warden. So it feels much more to me like a prison. Yeah. But that's just

me. I. this is just one of the many things that was overcomplicated because our main character even says it's not a hospital even though it's clearly a hospital yeah she's like no it's for research and i'm like then why do you have wards of dying people getting treatment why is this not fashioned more like a laboratory why are you bringing the children here Right, like you could get past the the like wardens and needing like protection if this was much more modernized and you had like key cards and retina scans and

then you also had like muscle who like sat at the front door and like walked you to your car at night. Yeah, it's very confusing. I don't understand. I don't get it. So in order to get to Ariane, Osric has to get into this fortress. So he gets past the wards, concusses Ariane's assistant and then sits in her office waiting to be menacing when she arrives, right? Like, I am mysterious. I have my hood up and I'm all slouchy. Right. Unfortunately, Ariane is immediately

a cold hard bitch. She walks in, dumps a sack of onions in his lap, and assumes that he's the new undertaker who apparently likes to get paid in onions. I didn't understand that. There's a lot of like, it's so whimsical, but sometimes I'm like, We don't need this much whimsy. Look, I'm not going to lie. I would be here for the whimsy if I had questions answered. Yeah, that's a thing. Because the whimsy was reminiscent of

T. Kingfisher in some ways. Yes. Ridiculous and so fun. Yes, very much. I think where I got frustrated was I was like, but I just want you to explain this to me first and then make it whimsical. Right. And I think that goes back to the legwork that the fanfic does or that the original fiction does for a fanfic, because we know what the world for Harry Potter is. And so if somebody likes to get paid in onions, that's fucking weird. Right. I don't know if this is weird. I don't

know if this is normal here. Yeah. Because 35 million schmeckles or whatever, like I don't know if everybody uses schmeckles or like if some people use onions, like it's clear to me that some people use children as like currency because they're killing off some of them, like their vegetables, like I don't understand. And that's where I got lost in the whimsy sometimes. Yes, I got lost in the whimsy. So Osric tries to seduce her with his cheekbones and fails. Then he threatens to kidnap her in the onion

sack. But that negotiation is interrupted by Ariane's mentor, Arianthi, who is over 200 years old. Why is she so old? Is she human? I don't know. There's a joke that, um, I was going to say there's a joke later where Osric says, like, what did she forget to die? Which is a funny line. Yes. But does that mean that she's like not human? Like that just, I don't. Are you supposed

to live to 200? I don't know. Like, I feel like there, like, Ianthe is supposed to be, like, a Dumbledore kind of, like, ormagonical kind of archetype, but, like... Yeah. Dumbledore was old, but, like, that was kind of atypical, right? Like... Yeah. And then the ones who were really old, like, Voldemort was because it was a problem. A death pack, right? Or Nicholas Flamel. Yeah. Right. Like, no. No bueno. Um... Yeah, I have no idea why she's so fucking old. And it wasn't

even a joke that she just looks old. Like, she genuinely is, like, over 200 years old. Right. Right. Abnormally. So that's an open question. But Ayanthe storms in, and she's, like, fresh off of, like, a bunch of rounds of funding rejections. And she, like, is talking about this with Arianne, just as Osric is, like, trying to offer his bribery for Arianne's aid, right? And so Ayanthe's like, Deal. Sold. Why is this not, this is not a problem?

Like, Ariane, why are you being so, we need the money. Come on, girl. Do the thing. Come on. We need the 25 million shmeckles or whatever. Right now, chop chop. Right. They want confirmation of who he is, and so they ask him to reveal his tak, taken, taken? Taken. Taken. Taken. Taken. Which is essentially the the symbol that all magic users have on their palm to indicate what order they're a part of we get this whole like right -handed versus left -handed thing essentially like The good witches have tackens on their right

hand and the bad witches have their tackens on the left hand He's a bad witch and so he's got his tack in for the fair fire in on his left hand And it's a hellhound skull that like glows red when he uses his magic Ariane and Ianthe have theirs on the right hand, and it's a swan that glows white. So very, like, in -your -face kind of symbology. Yes. Ariane expresses her displeasure about having to even just be in the same room as a fire in. Like, she's immediately at 100, and she says to him, quote, you're a

shadow -walking coward for hire. OK. OK. Racist much, but all right. Right. Well, and then, like, So this begins the thing of like, I don't know why she's so vitriolically opposed to firing. Because, yes, are assassins bad? Absolutely. I don't have personal interactions with assassins, so if I ever met one, I would be like, oh, that's weird. Can I ask you some questions? I'm morally

opposed to you just killing anybody, but I assume you don't kill grandmothers in their sleep unless there's a good reason. Yeah. And that's where, to pay back what you said before, the backdrop of Harry Potter in a fan, like, obviously, to me, this is the Death Eater, right? Like, he's a Death Eater. But I still don't buy that Hermione would be unwilling to help someone who's, like, sick and dying, even if they were a Death Eater. So that, like, moral opposition in his, like, weakened state just doesn't make sense to me

in this book or even in the greater backdrop. Like, would she save Voldemort? Probably not. Would she save Draco? That's what I'm here for. Right. I want like a modicum of sympathy. Right. Exactly. Well, and it just doesn't fit with her character because we'll see instances later where she wants people who fit into a similar category to actively live. Right. And so what he is asking for is for her to help him actively live. And she's just like completely shut down to the idea.

And and that's like we're here for the enemies to lovers. But I. I'm not sold in this entire book on why she's so vitriolic toward his order specifically and him. Right, it would have made more sense if the fire in had fucked up and killed her parents because they mistook them. Yeah. Or she didn't really know why, she just knew that fire in killed her parents and then as a product of the story, he was to uncover that it was a mistake. See, that would be fascinating.

Like, give me a reason for her to have some vested interest and not just, like, she's just prejudice. Like, that's honestly how it comes out. And it's so weird. Right. Well, and we talked about this in our debrief. Like, can you choose your magic path? Yeah. Like, did he wake up one day as a 12 -year -old and was like, I'm going to kill people for a living? I don't know. And just to add. A layer on this. We'll get into like what his problem is. Well, we already know his problem. So it's got that like see -through eye, but we'll

get into like where that came from. It sounds like the assassin order could really benefit from having some healers and the healers just won't help them. Right. And I don't, I just don't understand that. Well, and what really is the difference between being an assassin and being a ward? They kill people. Correct. We see it later. Just not, and technically. They get paid to do so. I mean, I guess you've already that an assassin maybe is killing innocent people, but like, who's really to say? You don't know.

Yeah. I mean, how many of the people that they kill are really innocent? I mean, if you've got somebody that hates your guts enough for you to put a bounty on your head, like, well, let's be real. The people who are people are getting assassinated are like shady politicians and stuff. No one's like murdering Mother Teresa. Or even if it's not like even if Mother Teresa did get murdered right like there's no conversation about like the quality of people That are or are not

being killed or are or are not being healed. It's really just She wants to think this way because it's good for being good sake Yeah, and it and it bothers me. Yeah So anyway, they're sorted arian's gonna try to help him As they're leaving, the real undertaker comes in and he specifically asks about the onions, which is just kind of a funny comic relief. And I like that. Yes, there's some great comedic beats. Like I will give her that. Yeah, there's there's

some great comedic beats, beefs. They are a little bit hidden sometimes. Yes. So Oscar goes back home tells mrs. Parsons that they are going to have to sell some of his art collection to cover the gold because originally he was like Well, I'm not actually gonna pay them and now he has to actually pay them He does say Quote we will obviously be stealing it back, but I don't know if that's true because later on he purports to be penniless Yeah, I don't like that. I don't

like that either. I wanted the billionaire romance I want him to be able to offer them 20 million schmeckles because it's like pocket change for him. Right. Exactly. Like fix, fix my problems. Money is no object. And that can even add more like tension to them where they're like desperately trying to get funding and like the assassins have all this funding. Right. Like that adds more tension, but no, he's just like poor now. Right. Well, and it could be, it could open the

door to like a more synergistic partnership where like the fire in do kill people, but they also fund the halons who fund like these, you know, inoculations and like, but no, okay, fine. It's fine. It's fine. It's fine. So then we get one of the first kind of views into Ariane's head and she says, quote, it was hard being perfect in an imperfect world, but Ariane managed. God, I hate her. Yeah, and like we we talked about this in our debrief, but like her just Thinking

like not not even thinking being convinced that she is the smartest person in any room She's having gift the planet right and having zero empathy for every anybody else was just not very likable No, and I was kind of surprised I Was surprised to okay. This is my own bias coming out. I was bummed that an author would create a character I'm supposed to read for and just make her untouchably perfect. Unless you're trying

to, like, lean into the fact that she's not perfect for, like, the audience. But there's no character arc here, so I don't think that's the case. I think she's just like, hello, here's my character. Isn't she lovely? Yeah. Totally unattainable. Like, nothing... You wouldn't want to be friends with this person, like... Do you like her? And she doesn't want to be friends with you. No, because you're not smart enough, dumbass. You dumbass doesn't want to look at you. How dare you breathe her air. So we go with her on her

rounds along the wards and specifically the pox ward is overflowing. But the anonymous donation arrives. Everybody rejoices. They're sobbing in the hallways. And she's the only one who's like really bad at faking it because she knows that it's in her words, blood money. So. Do you not wanna save the dying children? Really? I mean, honestly. Does the benefit not outweigh the cost? You don't even know who he killed to get that money. You never asked. Also, for all

you know, he's gonna die in three months and your problem will be over. Why aren't you stressing about this? I mean, honestly, that is a lot of her internal monologue. Like, about 100 pages of her internal monologue is, he's gonna die soon. It won't be my problem. I don't have to do this for very long. But I wish she actually like walked that walk. Yeah, same. It's just or not. Or I want her to care and be like, I'm a bleeding heart. Let me save the bad guy. It's just like her weird. Oh, I'm sad. I'm happy.

I'm like, I'm going to slap you. So then we get to their first session and it's in a literal barn at midnight. It's a dilapidated barn. It's totally abandoned. But this is the first kind of like. you have to go to this pub with a weird name and then walk this like mile and we get this introduction to like the pub system and the lay lines and it's just a placeholder because people can't operate. Yeah. That's what's happening. And that's fine. It's just a little confusing.

Yeah. And I liked the whimsy. I just. Yeah. Like I mentioned in our debrief, I just don't know what type of taverns we're talking about now. Are we talking about a sports bar in a strip mall with cars in the parking lot? Or are we talking about a cottage with horses outside in a stable? I don't know. I don't know. I should go with the second one. Other people don't exist.

Right. I don't know. Yeah. So, uh, Farin does her diagnosis and it's grim, right? So she discovers, and we learn through this discussion, that another firin's maul burst Osric's cervical spine during, quote -unquote, training, and a field medic set it in a bush. And so that has essentially crushed his seeth lines, and that's where the rot is advancing from. Which again, if the halen would work with them... This wouldn't happen. Why are

we not helping people? I know, honestly. So they talk and Osric latches onto an idea that he knows about through those other physicals that Ariane tried to push forward when she was really young in her career. She had abandoned it over 10 years ago, but it's essentially exploring what they call quote unquote the old ways in something called a monofil stone. And Ariane is like very reluctant. She's like, That was a bunch of who do magic. Like I don't that's that's nothing.

Like that was just an intellectual exercise. I already abandoned it. Like there's no way that it'll work. And you will you will die. And he's like, well, I am already going to die. So we're going to try anything. And I paid you to do it. So let's go. She's like, OK. When Arianne gets back to Swanstone, she debriefs with Ayanthi and Ayanthi is basically like Ayanthi started calling him Onion Boy, by the way, which that was also funny. Yes. I find it so interesting that you call her Ianthe. What do you call her?

Xanthe. Is it Xanthe? That's an X. I don't know how you say it. I could be wrong. I just thought it was interesting. I was trying to pronounce it the same way as literally Ianthe and Akatar, because I just thought it was a different way to do it. Which makes sense, but I was like... I just had to call it out, because we haven't talked about pronunciation differences in a while. And I was like, this is really, I had to ask, why? According to the Google, you're right. So it's Zanthe. OK, great. It could be Ianthe. I like that name. So Zanthe is more intuitive.

I just thought that that was wrong. So like, cool. I just thought that was wrong. I was like, that can't possibly be right. OK, I have a note about this author's writing. And that's a note on me, not on her. She uses a lot of words that I don't understand. Like, I had to use the thesaurus in my Kindle, like, a lot. And I would not consider either of us, like, particularly stupid. No, and I tried to mark some, but I think, you know what? You can, like, highlight a word and it'll

give you the definition. Yeah. I would do that. And I meant to keep it highlighted so I don't have any examples, like, ready. But there are quite a few words that I was like, what does this mean? Never heard that before. Moving on. Moving on. Yeah, I had that impression too. And it added to me to like the specific type of dry whimsy where like not only does Ariane expect everybody to be dumber than her, like the book expects you to be as smart as Ariane. Like it's

a double edged sword. Yeah. So Xanthe. Tells arian to actually try right because like look this ostrich dude is entirely disposable and like the worst case is that you're gonna fail and like nobody's gonna know about it because this is secret anyway, or you could learn something and Best case you like heal him and your theory works. Like there's not there's not a downside here. I don't see the problem, right? Except

arian's like I have to spend time with him. That's the problem. There's the problem. Yeah So, this is when we learn more about devils. I read it as deo -ful, like literally phonetically I had to like sound it out. They're patronuses. They're patronuses, yeah. But cooler. I like these better, I will say. They're patronuses that are a little bit more sentient. They're like, did you ever read, was it The Broken Compass books? Oh yeah,

because basically these are like, they're familiars. Yeah. Exactly. I don't know if it was the Broken Compass books, but something Golden Compass? The Golden Compass. Yeah, that one. They had familiars that they were given or assigned at birth, basically. And then there was this whole plot line where they had severed the tie between one of them. And it was very devastating. These are magical versions of those. If a patronus in those had a love child, that's what it would be. Yeah. So they can talk. They have their own personality. They have their own memory and image.

But they're incorporeal, right? They don't, like, stick around unless they're summoned. And then you can use them to, like, send messages to other people. So, like, when you send your Patronus to somebody else, they're, like, their hand, they're tacking tinkles, and then they can, like, put their hand out and be like, yes, I'm ready. Yeah. Or ignore it. Like, reject. Rejected. Like an incoming call. Yeah. So. Ariane's daifle is

an albino guenette. It's like a cat thing. I looked it up. It's a real thing. Yeah. It's hideous. I don't like it. I think it's creepy as hell, and I like cats. OK, yeah, I thought this is... I didn't picture exactly this. I'm looking it up right now. That thing's a little bit weird looking. It's so weird looking. I pictured it more as a fox, but then every time I looked at the cover and saw the swan, I was like, am I an idiot? Thank you, and I would see the hellhound and I was like, is it a dog? I mean, that one

is at least closer to what his is described as being. Yeah, it is. The swan was so confusing. So confusing. Anyway, this diphyll shows up. It's an albino genet, which is basically a cat, and summons Osric to a rural clinic for, quote, acute buttock folliculitis. Uh, in broad daylight, right? So he's, he's a fireman and he likes the nighttime and shadows and he's more uncomfortable in broad daylight. But this is kind of payback

for making her trumpet out in the woods in the middle of the night. So when he gets there, she tells him to strip. And so he strips off all of his weapons. And it's that clear thing of like, you have far too many weapons on your person. Where did those come from? Kind of thing. Which was great. and then she tells him to put on one of those like medical gowns and he doesn't put on the adult ones he just finds the little girls like small ones and so instead of covering his entire body he just wears it as a kilt and when she comes in she's like you didn't notice the adult covered because he thinks that she's like

trying to get one up on him and it's like i'll show her she's like no you just seem to like look a little harder my guy yeah so she examines him and then also lays out her hypothesis, right? This stone that we were talking about is a lunar calendar with healing symbols carved on it. And the folklore says that miracle healings have happened on the full moon. And it doesn't happen just anywhere. It happens in quote, thin places and in between times. So thin places like thin veil and in between like dawn, dusk kind of thing.

They agree to try this and their first attempt is in March and so essentially what they're doing is they're trying to do this on full moons like I mentioned and so they only have a certain number of tries and they have to wait a long time in between. We're also told that Ariane is like taking data on this and has had a lot of data before but we don't get a whole lot of information on what that data is and it would have added to I think just the reader's experience of the attempts if we had just a little bit more information

about specifically maybe what she was learning after every attempt. Yeah, I wish we got some of that too. Like, give me that internal monologue. Right, because as it is, it just feels kind of random. Yeah. But their first attempt is in March and they go to a fairy pool at sunset. The pub next to this place where they like have to... winnow in or whatever, is abandoned and its sign just says shag him. Which I liked. Which was

delightful. Yeah. Ostrich is late because he was killing a man and it took too long and so he apologizes for being late. That obviously puts Ariane on the back foot. She doesn't like that. Well, he's gonna do his job. Right. They wait for sunset and then this is an example of like we read about them swatting midges for like three pages. so that's where i'm like i don't need this yeah we could have been cut back yeah anyway what they do is when the sunset is like

right at the the sun setting part right she places her hand on the back of his neck where his big injury is channels her seeth into him and hopes that that will do the thing that was really the thing that i didn't really understand why they weren't getting into the water like All of these will happen around water. It feels like they're just trying the same method at different times, expecting things to differ. And I think that's

what I was trying to get at with, like, I wish I had more data on, like, why she was doing that. Yeah, agreed. So they try this first time, and obviously nothing happens. So nothing happens. Ariane's like, great, we did. Check the block. Don't have to do that again. But he asks, please, let's try this again. And so they decide to try again that night. Which is one of the only times they do this they only try one dirt more than once once Yeah, which was weird, which was weird, right? And I don't understand because the the Sun has already set right like they're already

missed the in -between right But they decided to give it a second try and so they go to a set of curative hot springs that turn out to be the baths at a brothel at the Randy unicorn So they go into this brothel and I This was almost like a cue, the Hot Springs scene, but it was just really the cue, the public sex and Hot Springs thing, but like, not fully. Not sexy. Yeah. Because we don't get like any sex. Yeah. I mean, we just

see a bunch of naked people and it makes, it clearly makes Arianna uncomfortable, but like, that's it. But not even in like a, she's so weird. This character is so weird because she's not even uncomfortable in like a Puritan way. Like, I don't know if it's here. or earlier, but we get these allusions to her being bisexual and like there being a her, like she had or has had a person. There's like this dude who has a giant dick and they kind of like banter back and forth about like how big his dick is. So she's not

even uncomfortable as far as like, oh, sex makes me uncomfortable. She's more uncomfortable as like, this is a waste of time. Why are we here? Yeah. It's weird. And almost there seems to be like a why would anybody spend time here kind of vibe. Yeah, exactly. Which is just a very weird way for her to react, I think. Yeah, because she's not again. It would make more sense to me if she was like kind of a prude or like kind of inexperienced. But that's not it. She's just

like, can't you get laid somewhere else? Like, it's just. Yeah. But then she's like fascinated by a guy like blowing himself. And she's like, wow, look at that like. Lumbar spine flexibility like she's not appalled. It's but she's also not like sexily fascinated She's just like wow, that's interesting. Yeah, very clinical She's like a robot and not in an endearing way. No, definitely not So they go through to the baths the baths have a an explicit no sex policy, right?

But they do get naked and go into the water which was Weird. There was a lot less like about the nakedness than I was expecting. Yeah. Well, she never gets fully in the water. She likes this on the edge and like keeps her like towel on. Yes. But like he's naked. He's naked. But then at some point her towel falls down, right? Like. Yeah. And like nothing. There's not even like a heated moment. No. Yeah. It was at this moment

that I'm like. Are we just enemies or are we going to become lovers? Because I'm not sure. Yeah. At this point, I was like, you guys are just enemies. You're always going to be just enemies. Because there's not even like a acknowledgement that like they're attractive, right? Well, both of them are very much in their internal monologue saying they're not attractive. Exactly. I'm hotter than you are. Are you fucking kidding me? See, and I don't like that. I hate you, but the internal monologue is like, but you could drop that towel. But you fine as fuck. Yeah, those cheekbones

are nice. Yeah. Yeah, but she's just completely immune to him, right? Yeah. But that's part of the reason why he is so perturbed by her, but I just don't buy that. No, she could act like that, but I want to see the inside. I want to see the inside. But she's actually like, man, look, I'm not going to cry about having to look at him. Yeah. Touch him. Yeah. But no. But no. Anyway, they try again. It doesn't work. And they leave. That's it. Great. Which, like, why

are we here? It's a travel montage. We learn nothing. Yeah. We learn nothing. We just get more of their dynamic in between these things. Yeah. So we next see Osric going to the fire in HQ. And we learn that this thing, like, moves. And currently, it's at an abandoned pharmacy whose sign now reads Harmacy, which I like, but this is also going back to like the, okay, where are we in time and place? Because this abandoned pharmacy is like in a fucking war zone or like abandoned war zone where like everything is ramshackle.

Everything, it's like they describe like iodine bottles rather than like prescription containers. So it feels like we're in the early 1900s rather than like the late 1900s. Yeah, but we understand but they have like magical medicine so they know enough about the human body right so weird We meet a couple of the of the of the other fire ends Specifically a gentleman named sycamore who is second -in -command and a fabulous fence

We also meet the head of the order whose name is Tristain who and she's French and terrifying She's also eating a penis shaped pornish pasty, which I thought was clever And then the third person that we meet here is Brythe, who's the guy who's Maul caused Osric's injury. They joke about it because Osric can't let on how bad that injury actually is, but put a pin in Brythe because he'll come back later. They're basically talking about the ins and outs of the order. It's not important. They'll just, we'll meet them later and they'll become important. And it's basically another reminder that if anyone knows the state

that Osric is in, he'll be put to death. That would be a problem for him, yeah. The next time we see Osric and Farin Sorry, I've been calling her Arian. It's confusing. Her name is also Arian. Yes. He calls her Farin. It's whatever. It's fine. Anyway, they meet up for the April moon at midnight on some burial barrows. The thing

about these burial barrows is they're in a place called Hedgewitch territory. This is the first indication that we get that Hedgewitches are a thing. and they kind of fall into the gray area between the good witches and the bad witches. They're pretty fucking scary. They're really scary. And this is where like either give me more of them or give me none of them. Why do they exist? Who? What? Which kingdom? If I was that powerful, I would be causing some shit. Yes. And do you decide to be a hedge witch or

is it like a familial thing and you're born into it? Great questions. All great questions. I don't know. One thing I like about going into the hedge, so we see a hedge witch and she's fucking terrifying. She's just a little girl who disappears. But we also meet the critique crickets who just insulted from the grass and that was fucking hilarious. Though one of the critiques that you have in your notes that I also pulled out was the posture like a damp croissant. I know. And that's when this book is really delightful. Just like that that part like you were saying before is very

reminiscent of T Kingfisher because it is very like whimsical and also like pointed Yeah, it's great. Yeah, so they meet this hedge witch who just basically gives them a warning and it's like hey the veil is thin up at the top of the barrows like Do without what you will I? Picture have you ever seen Horton? Here's a who? Yes Okay, so do you know there's the little, her name's Katie, she's like this puffball, pink puffball, and she comes out of the hedge and goes, ah, and like disappears backwards. That's

what I pictured here. Oh my God, I had forgotten about that. Do what you will. Just like backs away. Yeah, uh -huh. That's very much what happens. But crucially, Osric tries to like find her with his shadows and like she's nowhere to be found in like a two mile radius or something ridiculous. Good. Cool. When she's gone, Ariane mentions that she once knew a head witch. And then we

don't learn more about that right now, but we'll come back to it. Yep. They go up to the top, they try the thing again and it fails. Three for three. Yeah. After this, Osric pushes that they need to try something else, right? Like they should go and talk to this disgraced... Philophilologist? Philolologist. I don't know if that's a word. Anyway, he's a disgraced professor

who used to work in this field, wrote some shit about this stone that they're trying to use and got laughed out of his order and then got his doctorate taken away, which seems egregious. That seemed so egregious. Like, okay. so he's like we should go talk to this guy and she has been pushing for not doing that because this guy is a crank and finally she's like fine okay great we'll go do that so they go do that and they go to nether wallop which osric remarks

quote is this a place or a kink the sexy banter is very funny i just wish it went both ways yeah same so they go to this guy's house winter shins He answers the door with a colander on his head and gives them an etymology for just like random words that they say which is really fucking confusing. He is unhinged. He is truly unhinged. They tell him what they're there for and he beckons them closer to give them some advice and instead he

just shouts in their ear quote fuck off. Okay. He then goes to the back of the house and wades into a creek to go tadpolling at midnight. This is when they realized that this dude has no nipples, and I don't know why that was included. He lost them in the fire, obviously, Katie. Right. Don't ask me what fire. What fire? Yeah, I mean, cool. Why? Why is it just your nipples? I don't know. It's fine. It's so weird. Cool. And it's things like that that I'm like, that's whimsy I didn't

need. No, I didn't. He's already whimsical. to be that that extra level of weird. Yeah, I just it's too much. Yeah, calm down. So they have a nonsensical conversation, but ultimately, Wendershins points them to a galvanized bucket in one of his sheds that holds a plaster cast of the stone. And this also has his translation notes pinned to it, which Arianne finds very helpful. So she they put the puzzle pieces together and she takes down the notes. And what we realize is that there

are cryptic phrases for each of the 12 moons, like quote black and sun at land's end and quote running waters cross arian finds that this is good data she's energized again and they'd go to leave as they're leaving the garden they end up physically close almost nose to nose and they're fighting but this is one of those times where like the fighting kind of bleeds into a little bit of desire but it doesn't go anywhere in this moment but it's like the first time they're like

okay there's some tension here right there's something here there's something brewing besides just horridness yeah so back at the ranch the ranch being swan stone xanthi learns that there's no lab anywhere in the entire kingdoms that has any real money, right? So she's written to the other heads of research labs, and they're like, nope, we've all been rejected as well. She's telling Ariane that she's gotten rejection letters from every single monarch, and then she's drafted

new letters that essentially insult them or try to blackmail them into giving them money. And she poisons the letters. Yeah. She anthraxes them, but not that severely. And Arianne has to be the one that's like, this is a terrible idea. You know this is a terrible idea. This won't help anything. This is not going to help. This is only going to have our lab shut down. What are you talking about? Our lab castle prison. That we can't leave, except for whenever I want

to. So Xanthe reluctantly leaves. And this is when we meet Arianne's other two friends, best friends, I guess, Cath and Elodie. We learn later that they are Going to be married and so that seemed like a wild turn of events given this interaction because they just present as friends Yeah, I think there's like one line in here of them being partners like but it's it's unclear like um Ariane says something about how like they kind of they like mirror each other their opposites and there's like it's one thing like

opposites attract but when suddenly they're in gudged to be married I was like What? Also, everybody in this book is gay, which is fine. But like, she's bisexual, Osterk's bisexual. And like, that's cool. Make them all gay. But like, show me. Show me the gay, right? Like, show me the gay. The thing that was that I didn't get in this in this exact instance is because she referred to them as partners. And she's also referred to other people like in the lab as like lab partners. And so I was like, they're clearly Colleagues.

Lab partners. Yeah. And they don't show any affection here, right? No. They're all just eating grapes on the floor or something. Exactly. I was so confused. I was confused too. Fused with corn. Fully. They are eating snacks on the floor of Ariane's office, quote, coping, because there's pox and dead children everywhere. But their moment is interrupted because the wardens have killed four intruders. at the Swanstone gates, essentially. And these intruders were carrying incendiary

devices, a lot of gold, and they had no tacking, no magic thing. So Ariane's immediately like, that was ill conceived. What the fuck were you thinking? But they couldn't, they can't ask because they're all dead. Yeah. Whoops. Yeah. But what this does tell her is that somebody is funding this and they need to understand who. I didn't need any of this plot line. I didn't either. I don't understand. I mean, like, I think we're given hints at the end of this book as to why this is going to come back. But like, it feels

very much like a wild subplot that vies for full plot standing. Yeah, exactly. And I just find that to be a little distracting. Yeah. Meanwhile, Osric's daifle turns up and asks for Aryan's help because... Osric is having a quote Seath constipation episode. So Ariane agrees to go and help. She goes to Rosefell Hall, which is

Osric's crumbling family seat. And this is really where like the fall from grace, like no billionaire romance thing really hit home. Cause like he just, here's the thing, right? Like he says, oh, I've... I've gone into this way of life for money, but obviously that money hasn't gone anywhere productive except for like one room that's decked out with a bunch of art a la Howl's Moving Castle, right? Like, yeah, I just don't know. It gave kind of this between that, the harmacy and like

how the rest of these places are described, like the inns and the pubs that they go to, and the fact that the Swanstone is a fucking fortress. It gave this impression that there's this shabbiness, like this war -ridden rubble. There's not a stable society here, actually. Yes, exactly. And almost like dystopian. Dystopian is a really good way to put it. It felt like an odd choice. Yeah.

So like I mentioned, this place is stuffed with art, but only in like three rooms because the rest of them are like closed up. Cool. She does see empty spots where her 20 million Schmeckles came from. And she also - And he's got like 19 dogs? Yeah. She also discovers that he's a dog rescuer. Which was cute. I didn't hate that. I didn't hate it, but also what? Why? Why? Why? I have a lot of questions about that because he says specifically that like these dogs show up after like he's killed people and he'll like

take them home. Can you teleport with dogs? You having to walk back? Like, what are we doing? Yeah. What are we doing here? So the other funny thing about his house is that one critique cricket followed him home and won't shut up and he can't find it to kill it. So it's just like in his house mocking him. Yeah. Excellent. So Aryan comes in and sees him with blocked Seath right and it is a little bit taken aback because Osric

is scared and shirtless and it's the first time that she's seen him as like purely mortal because the thing that makes him special is not working and this is why She decides to use this as leverage She specifically wants him to investigate the intruders at Swanstone. And if he can do that She will unblock his Seath constipation before he can agree His drunk firing partner, Lofric Barges in. We met Lofric at the Harmacy just

in passing. This feels like it's supposed to be like Blaze from Harry Potter. Yeah. Yeah. Which is wild because this is presented as one of his only like quote unquote friends, but just doesn't quite land that way. No, because he's just demanding that he get out the whole time and like. If I'm your only friend and I show up at your house and you're just kicking me to the curb, I'd be like, there's something wrong. Yeah. Well, and this guy starts asking him about

whether he has different sized balls, which seems like only something you would do to somebody you're close with. Yeah, he drops trowel and he's like, I'm not going to look at your balls. He's like, come on, show me. I need to know if mine are normal. So obviously like Arian is hidden for this and Osric does eventually get him out of the house and when she comes out of hiding she's laughing Which I would do They move right past this and then Osric agrees to her terms.

She fixes his blockage and they move on which like okay, listen that's not how you blackmail people like She's like, hey if you give it this information, I'll fix it and then she just fixes it anyway So like he doesn't have to do anything. I know She kind of has a one -liner of like, it's going to happen again and next time I won't fix it. But I was like, but that's not really what blackmail is. Right. But like, I had the same thing. I was like, are you expecting him to go and get this information now when he's powerless? Like, yeah, that also doesn't work.

No, no. I'm surprised she didn't get it in writing or something or like a blood oath or whatever the fuck. Something, yeah. So we fast forward to May's Moon, which is at a lighthouse at Muckleflugga. Excuse you. Excuse me. They get there and they realize that they have to go into this lighthouse for some reason, but this lighthouse is occupied by bandits who are squatting there. And like, this also adds to the air of like, why are there bandits in a lighthouse? What are they squatting?

What are bandits? Why is all their food rotten? Yeah. So there's just two of these guys, like, there and Osric very effectively intimidates them to get the fuck out. So they get into the lighthouse and they go up to the top. They do barricade a little bit just in case the bandits come back, I guess, but when they get up to the top, they're like, right, okay, so this one was the one about the blackout sun. What does that mean? And as the sun sets, a cloud of birds flies at them and... kind of blocks out the sun, which

sounds like the scene out of the movie, The Burt's. Yeah, it sounds terrifying. Yeah, but they realized that Winderson's was right. This is the black sun because they can't see it anymore. And so they do the thing again, but it's much more intimate this time because they're facing each other when usually Arianne's behind him and they have this moment where they look into each other's eyes and they go into like this existential place because they're surrounded by birds and there feels like there's a buzz in the air, but again nothing happens. No, they like both feel like

it worked and then it didn't work. Yeah, and I thought for sure that it would work a little bit this time. I needed it to work a little bit this time. When it didn't work, I was like, OK. I was like, what am I reading? What are we doing here? Yeah. How many times are we going to do this? Apparently a lot, because we're still not done even after this book. For real. So they're both dejected. They go inside, and they realize that Arianne has kind of drained herself. And

this is when Osric sees her cost for the first time. So the cost is when you use too much of your magic. It has a physical manifestation. And hers is split in bleeding, like chapped hands, which is gross. Yeah, seriously. So they're like, OK, we're just going to take a break. And she falls asleep on his shoulder for a little bit. And this is the first time that she's willingly been close to him. Yeah. It's cute. It's cute, but it's also like, man, we are really taking the inches out of this enemies to lover thing, huh? I know. I think I was so relieved at this

point because I was like, finally, Jesus Christ. I know. I know. When she wakes up, they realize that they're kind of peckish. So this is when they go into the bandit supplies and realize that it's all rotten, which also feels like an air of shabby dystopian -ness. Yeah, I don't understand it. And so they're like, OK, I guess we'll just go home. And on their way home... They get to the pub and all of the like bandits are there like the two that they intimidated went and got their daddies or whatever. And so there's like literally 40 bandits here. That

Aryan begs not to like get in a fight, right, because she actively wants these ruffians to live and knows that her fire and will kill them. They don't listen and Osric kills them all 40. Also, if you killed the first two, this wouldn't have happened. And you're just going to let them go be bandits. Well that's really the thing like she actively wants them to be alive and we'll see that with a much more egregious example in part two but like I just she to your point at least internally if not out loud wishes for Osric's

death yeah it just seems like a an inconsistency in her character because like the bandits aren't great but she wants them to be happy and thriving I guess So this is where we're gonna end part one and I'll end with the line that ends this chapter that we end on chapter 11 It says quote all 40 died Ariane clutched at her pearls So that is the end of part one Join us in two weeks

for our coverage of part two part two will cover chapters 12 onward and then at the end we're gonna do our ratings But yeah, we did it those are our thoughts on part one of the irresistible urge to fall for your enemy by Bridget nightly Let us know what you think, or thank you for joining us on this journey. Let us know what you thought. You can find us on TikTok, YouTube, and Goodreads, the spice readers pod. And if you really like our podcast and want more, consider becoming a patron where we release Patreon exclusive episodes on our off weeks. And if you really, really like us, drop us a review wherever you

listen until next time. We'll see ya. Bye.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Surrendering to Scylla by Wren K Morris

    Oct 27, 20261 hr 10 minAudio

    Triggers: (From the author): kidnapping, violence, discussions of abuse, BDSM dynamics and play, tentacle play, brief descriptions of injured animal (that receives aid), breath play, bondage, depictions of sub drop,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Threshing Day by Rebecca Yarros

    Oct 14, 20261 hr 9 minAudio

    Triggers: war, battle, hand-to-hand combat, perilous situations, blood, intense violence, brutal injuries, death, and poisoning KU: No Recommendation: Yes! For more of the author, check out https://rebeccayarros.com/

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Court of Heathens by K. A. Knight

    Sep 29, 202652 minAudio

    Triggers: from the author: “explicit violence, explicit sexual violence, dubious consent, murder, gore, torture, kidnapping, and more.” KU: Yes Recommendation: No For more of the author, check out...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Under Loch and Key by Lana Ferguson Part 2

    Sep 21, 20261 hr 4 minAudio

    Triggers: death of a parent (off page), grief, fantasy violence KU: No Recommendation: both Traders recommend! This is part 2 of 2. For more of the author, check out https://www.lanaferguson.com/

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Under Loch and Key by Lana Ferguson Part 1

    Sep 1, 20261 hr 8 minAudio

    Triggers: mild violence, grief, and abandonment KU: No Recommendation: Yes! For more of the author, check out https://www.lanaferguson.com.

    Credit the people on this episode