Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Spice Traders

Spice Traders artwork

Threshing Day by Rebecca Yarros

Oct 14, 20261 hr 9 minAudio

Triggers: war, battle, hand-to-hand combat, perilous situations, blood, intense violence, brutal injuries, death, and poisoning KU: No Recommendation: Yes! For more of the author, check out https://rebeccayarros.com/

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Welcome to your safe space. The podcast, your partner, friends, parents, whoever thinks it's dirty. Don't have time to read books? Want to understand all the jokes and the TikToks? We got you fam. We're the spice traders and we deal in spicy books. I'm Katie and I need it to make sense. I'm Liz and I'm hypercritical. Before we get to today's episode, we want to encourage you to check out our Patreon, where we publish extra episodes every other week, as well as ad -free versions of our regular feed episodes. Also, any series we read past the first book, all that coverage is Patreon only, so think series like Akatar, Fourth Wing, Guild. Anyway, we really

appreciate the support and encouragement to continue doing something we love and sharing it with you. Thanks in advance for checking that out. As always, we start this episode with three things. First is a generic trigger warning. You can find specific triggers for this book in our show notes, so please check those out. We also use foul language and talk a lot about sex. If you have sensitivity to either of those things, our podcast probably isn't for you. Second, our episodes talk about books, the whole book, nothing but the book, so help me goddess. If you don't want something spoiled, don't listen to this episode. And finally, we acknowledge that a good book can hit you at the wrong time. Our views discussed in our episodes

are our opinion, and we don't want to diminish the work or the talents of the authors in our community. That said, we have some notes. So girl, what are we talking about today? Today we're talking about Threshing Day by Rebecca Yaros. This was published in 2026, which was... Literally published like a week ago. So this year, but it came out like the end of September now It is October 9th when you guys get it'll

be two weeks later, but we're very fresh. It's very exciting Anyway, this is book 3 .5 of the Empyrean series. It's a novella We're gonna Release it on our regular feed as if it's a standalone. It's not really a standalone We'll talk about some of that like in the book like there are spoilers, but like you could read it individually I guess we'll call out some of those parts. So it is on our regular feed, but it's technically book 3 .5. Yeah. It's also not very long, so

it's going to be a short episode anyway. Sorry. It's basically like a bonus episode just in our regular feed, so it's not a bonus. But the speed of it is a bonus. We're not there yet. We'll be there eventually. This book is 224 pages long, and that's a shorty. Oh my god, I'm immediately making noise that I'm trying not to do. I'm going to try really not to touch anything, but now I have to type, so. This cover fits perfectly with the rest of the series. It's silver. It

doesn't have the gradient that we were getting at some of the other, but I mean, it's a standalone, so I don't think it needs it. I mean, I guess it kind of does. It's lighter silver at the top, darker at the bottom. People are really reading into it. I'm going to talk about that because I think some people are crazy, but. It's got the like cloud motif and the dragons. There's two dragons on it. The little sub tag on it is just don't die, which is great. My edition has the sprayed edges. There aren't any like other

covers that I'm seeing yet because again, it came out seven days ago. Yeah. So, um, it's great. I have no notes on the cover. I think it's excellent. So one thing I'm going to call out just about people being crazy is like, Guys if you are one of these people and I am going to offend you. I'm really sorry, but some things are not They don't mean anything. For example on the cover. There's like some scratches and Someone I saw online was like what did the scratches mean Rebecca

and I was like they mean nothing It's a texture on the cover because like we're talking about dragons and shit. Like what do you mean? What do the scratches mean? They don't mean anything I don't think for real God, but The other thing I did want to say about this book is I read it in in hardcover because I pre -ordered it. And there is some gorgeous art in this book that I did not expect. It's this is unlike some of the other things we've done before. But it's a collection of short stories. And each story

of that character's threshing day has a portrait of their dragon. And there's like full cover art on the inside. Cover and it's just like the art is amazing that artist. It's such an incredible job Totally agree. Yeah, I mean I really enjoyed it so I'm gonna be really honest like I've enjoyed this series but like I really have a hard time kind of like Picturing so many different dragons in my head and so like the art in this was super

helpful especially because as you'll see each one of these installments is essentially the same so if we didn't have like that mental like picture aid. I would have been like, I would have not enjoyed it quite as much, I think. I would have too. I thought it was really helpful. And we'll get into the stories. But the other thing I found helpful was that at the start of every character's story, it had like their dragon's description. So like their dragon's name, their age. We got the picture of their color and what they were. But then like their lineage, which

we'll talk about. But even having their name was really helpful. Although on one hand, I feel like it was kind of a spoiler. where I was like, I mean, we already know who's connected to who, so not really. But if you are reading this book and not reading the rest, it's kind of like you already know who they're going to mate with, or mate with, who they're going to bond with. I mean, it might as well be mating. It's a very close relationship. It's a very close relationship. But I found that interesting. The other thing I want to call out, actually, actually listen. I'm going to be all over the place. So I'm going to turn it over to you. So let's actually get into it, because I already was like, let's start.

Let's start. Let's keep going. I mean, so OK, we'll just do some of the housekeeping up front. This is not an KU, because it just came out. And Rebecca Yarris is one of the hottest franchises right now. Sorry, girl. The book is worth it. It's gorgeous. It's, I think, like $12 on Kindle Unlimited. I think that's a lot for a KU, but that's fine. Especially for a 200 -page book, but it's fine. Right. But so this is Threshing Day and it is just a bunch of short stories or

snippets of a bunch of the characters that we've already met in the first three books and their experience on their own threshing day. So. I'll just give a reminder for those of you who it's been a minute the threshing day is when they meet their dragons So they do presentation which is when they walk single file down a line of dragons Which is actually what the the inside cover art is and that is intimidating as fuck It was terrifying enough to read about seeing it. I was like, oh shit Usually when there's art in books that doesn't live up to what I saw that I was like, oh that's worse than what I

saw in my head Yeah, especially the charred burning bodies. Yeah So anyway threshing day happens after presentation presentation is when they like See the dragons for the first time and the dragons see them for the first time and then threshing day is when they're all released into the woods all of the cadets and all of the dragons at once and you either come out with a dragon you die or You don't have a dragon and you live and then you have to go and repeat a year Which is what happened to one of the characters that we'll get into later. Yes, so that's that's the

kind of context for which this this thing happens in I'm not gonna go through like what's her face goes into the threshing and then she roots around for a tree and then she tries like I'm not gonna do that that would be incredibly boring we've got like 20 of these guys to go through so what instead Liz and I are gonna talk about is like the main things or like the lore drops that I think that she's giving us in each one of these chapters and then the things that we find interesting and then I think you said you had told me you had pulled out some fan theories that have been floating around the interwebs that we can talk about Yes. So there's a couple of things that

I want to call out. I'm pulling out the ones that I don't have a whole bunch. You could go down your own rabbit hole online, guys. But I'm pulling out the ones that I think are interesting. And I have one that I'm like, I don't see it, but other people see it. So maybe I'm stupid. So I want to get your opinion on it. I was seeing a whole bunch of people going really down the rabbit hole of family trees and who the fuck Eric's mom is. And I'm just like, I love that. I will love to be told what is happening when

it's available in the books. Yes. If you guys remember from, I'm so sorry, from the first three books, we get the little epigraph thing that's like, these have been faithfully translated by the scribes or whatever. And there's been a lot of allusion by Rebecca Yara's that we can't trust the scribes. This book specifically has been transcribed by the two like dragon kind professors.

And according to this is some of the fan theory, but this has come, this is from an interview I saw with her. She's Rebecca Yaris has explicitly stated that like you can trust them. So like every nothing in here is a lie. Where in the first three books, there might be things that are incorrect as like part of the plot. Everything here is like actually faithful, which I find Interesting. Oh, I didn't even consider that like part of the books might not be faithfully represented because they're transcribed. Oh,

I know. And I kind of hate it, but I also kind of like it. I don't know. OK, so like we've talked about this in the past, but there's there's just something about the author and like all tea, no shade girl. Like this is an incredibly complex world that she's building. And maybe it's because I've been burned by other authors in the past, like Martin, for example. George RR. George RR, if you're nasty. Mr. Martin, if you're nasty.

And I haven't gotten into the Brandon Sanderson of it all. And I'm sure that he's a really reliable author. But there's part of me who's just like, are you? to actually pulling off this thing like. Well, and where I'm getting nervous and we'll get into it. But again, this coverage will be kind of different than typical coverage. We're told pretty strongly, at least in fourth wing, that the dragons cannot lie. That's fucking bullshit, which is fine. That's fascinating. I'm so into

the dragons lying because from the get go, I was like, of course they lie. Right. But now when you have like lies on lies, like they're lying and the scribes are lying, I can't even imagine. A, as an author, how you like map that. And then how you make it make sense to the reader without just like pulling the rug out from under us and making it really fucking confusing. Right. Well, and I'm also I'm interested to see like how she ends the books, right? Like, do we ever get clarity on what is and is not true? Or is

it just kind of like because what I don't want it to be is like one of those things that's just like, oh, what do you think? And it's like, no, girl, I'm asking you. Like you tell me you made it. Yeah, I don't want it was like maybe he was dead the whole time. Like I don't want that bullshit. OK, Harry Potter. Like it's all in Neville's head. Like, no, no. And so I'm a little anxious about that. I'm all in for the dragons lying. I don't like this scribe translation thing. Yeah, I'm I'm a little bit like, I don't know. I think

it would be really interesting like I'm in for the ride. I'm really enjoying these books, but I'm also just nervous, right? Like I. I want this to be good, right? I want it to be like guild levels of good. Yes. And complex and all the best ways. I'm with you on that. Yeah. So we'll get into it. So we'll start off with Brennan, who is Violet's oldest sibling. And we're told like fresh out of the gate in book one that he's dead. We learn later that he's not dead. So this

is his threshing day, which happened before both of his sisters. And in this section in particular, we learn about Daddy Sorengale's secret research. And this guy, it's like he works for the goddamn CIA. He has to up and leave on a moment's notice. He's gone for fucking months and he can't talk about what it is that he does. And when Brennan interacts with Daddy Sorengale in this chapter, Daddy Sorengerel literally walks out of the woods like a goddamn slender man just to see his son

on threshing day and his son Brennan is like, isn't your wife going to be mad about that? And you're not allowed to be here. Oh, I can be anywhere I want. I'm like, what the fuck? Who are you? So most of the well, one of the biggest fan theories I keep seeing is about Daddy Sorengerel. And I'm just like, who is this guy? It doesn't matter. It obviously matters. We know it matters. I know that there's something up with him because of what we've learned in the most recent book. Yes.

With like him trying to partially commit Violet to that like religious order of Malik or whatever. Or whichever like God was. Yeah, there's definitely something weird happening there. But like this felt like a whole other level of like weirdness. Yeah, and he just like disappears and and Brennan makes a lot of comments about how calm he is like there's people dying basically all around you like you can hear screams and fire and Daddy's

horn Gail is just like unfazed by all of it, which is not only that he does this thing I mean he doesn't use these words, but he's essentially like no no look at me look at me I have to tell you something very important look at me. I'm so proud of you, and I'm like oh my god I know it's very weird. It's so weird and even Brennan internally. He's like What? You know, you're being awfully nonchalant about this. Yeah, even Brennan's like, I don't know how you're not freaking out because you're not even allowed to be here. For what? And I'm supposed to be here and I'm

terrified I'm gonna die. Yeah. So that was interesting. The other thing that we learn is like the whole reason that Brennan started the journal that he then gives to Mira and who then gives it to Violet is because he walks into this day and he's like You know, it's really shitty that my mom didn't tell me what to expect here. Like, anything. Yeah. Which is so interesting, because we get Brennan and Mira in this book, and, like, they're... And so we have Violet's perspective

in the rest of the trilogy. But all of their perspectives on their mom is so fascinating to see. Because, like, yeah, she totally could have prepared him. And, as far as it seems, Brennan is, like, the golden child. But she still didn't give him anything. Yeah, no, and like he feels that pressure immensely, but it's almost like the way that he describes it, it very much comes off as like a double edged sword because like there's a lot of pressure associated with being her favorite. Pressure that is not necessarily

supported in a very meaningful way. Yes. Yeah. So that's interesting. And then we immediately juxtapose that with Mira and her threshing day. And she's working off of Brendan's journal and is deciding to write in it herself. um she tells us right off the bat that she feels like she doesn't belong in her family because Brennan is mommy's favorite and Violet is daddy's favorite and so who does Mira belong to oh what the other thing the other thing that I thought was interesting

here was that in this chapter she alludes to understanding why the Tyrendor people like wanted to break away from Navarre so I thought it was interesting that even back then the propaganda machine was kind of wearing thin Yeah, I thought that was interesting too. I mean, I say back then, like it was a long time ago. I guess she really went up four years earlier. But still, I mean, it's a pretty quick demise. Because Brennan doesn't allude to any of that. I mean, like he's got his own concerns. But within like six years,

it goes from strong to gone. Yeah, exactly. So yeah, that was really the only thing that I got out of Mira's section. Was there anything that struck you as interesting? No, there wasn't that much for Mira for me. The biggest thing is that I don't think I realized how lost Mira was, because she seemed so confident. We don't see that much of her, but she seems so self -assured. And so it was interesting to be in her head and have her be like, who do I belong to? I don't belong

to anybody. Yeah, well, especially because in the first book, and even at later books she's just so protective of violet it's almost like she belongs to violet you know yeah but she doesn't see that herself no so the next person we get is zaden and my only note on this one is holy shit alec is the fucking worst god he's the worst

so for those of you who don't remember alec is um one of eric's brothers older brothers And he is so legitimately the worst. He is the equivalent of racist toward the rebels. He is a bully. He's snotty. He's not even smart. He runs in a pack of goons. He's the worst. He picks fights for no reason. He's so annoying. He's the worst. I fucking hate him. And so he picks a fight with

Zayden and I think it was Garrick. Yes, I think so. I think so. Zayden and Garrick, apologies, I didn't note who it was, but I think it was, I'm pretty sure it was Garrick. And like Zayden and Garrick ended up getting the jump on Alec and his goons and they kill them. Like we knew that Zayden killed Eric's brother, but we didn't know how or why. And so I thought that was really interesting that we got to see the whole thing. And then interestingly, Zayden and Garak are

looking at these dead cadets and they're like, fuck, that doesn't look like an accident. And then Sagale shows up, introduces herself as Zayden's dragon, and then burns the bodies to essentially cover up this murder. Which I thought was so interesting. So I get like, the murder, the prop, because you're allowed to kill whoever the fuck you want in Threshing Day. But the problem is that like, Eric is the prince, right? Like, that's why it's a problem that they're dead. Right. And the rebels killed him. But Sagale is just like, sup, I'm Sagale. No one can question me. I will toast this. I also thought it was funny

that we get the little description at the start of everybody's chapter of the dragon and Seagal has she's the only one with a note that says of note do not approach under any circumstances. I love that. I just love that she's so difficult. She's so difficult and she's mean like she almost she she like hits Zayden in the face with her tail like cuts his face up like yeah. She's not mean to him, but she's like, get up. I do not

enjoy repeating myself. I got things to do. We got to go. I got shit to do. Are we going to do this or not? Yeah. The other thing that was just stone cold was that she insinuates that Zayden might not actually be related to his grandfather. Yeah. That was really interesting. What the fuck? And I wonder if, because the whole thing about Zayden, I don't know if it's heavily insinuated here, but I'm pretty sure that we knew that Zayden was bonded to Seagal, which was a no -no because

she was bonded to somebody else in his family line. But if he's not actually in his family line, then that might be called into question a little bit. So what I think might be happening is that it was like his uncle she was bonded to. So it was like it was a no -no, but like less so because it was a direct path. I think it's still his family line, just a more direct path. Yeah, okay, like his like immediate grandfather versus like his great uncle Because she names him as the grandson I've turned the page she names him as the grandson of a maxim rear Ryerson and he says no I'm the grandson of Corbin Ryerson

maxim was my great uncle But I think Seagal saying that no, that's your grandfather. Not your great uncle. Oh Okay, I totally missed that. Yeah interesting So it's it's that's potentially his real daddy. Yeah. Yeah So much closer connection than it already was. Oh, girl. OK, that's juicy. It's juicy. I thought it was interesting, too, that we found out more about how Seagal's previous writers lived and died. She had three. One of

them was left for dead. One of them was allegedly killed. And then one died before graduation. So I'm wondering which of those was his great uncle slash daddy. Yeah, I don't know. And the one that was left for dead, I could be conflating other, but it was like, because he was not loyal, like Seagal abandoned him on purpose. Right. Which is, it doesn't seem to be a thing that dragons typically do because the bond is so strong and she's just like, later loser. Deuces. You fucked up. Yeah. I know, I'm curious about that

too. I wish we had a list of who the writers were. Yeah. Anyway, so that's Zayden. And then we see Garrick, which, holy shit, I didn't pick this up in the books at all. I don't know who you're supposed to, but Garrick loves Imogen? Okay, I don't know where I got this. I don't know. I think I was conflating a different character with Imogen. I thought Imogen was a lesbian. I think that's Rhiannon. Yeah, I think so too,

but I thought it was Imogen for whatever reason. And I definitely didn't pick this up, but Garrick is fucking obsessed. Yeah, with Imogen. Heart obsessed. Heart obsessed. It's honestly really cute. Yeah, it really is. I mean, if I'm remembering correctly, we don't actually know that it's Imogen in his chapter. We only find out from her perspective. Yeah, he just keeps talking about a her. And then his dragon even calls it out as like, who

is this her? Maybe I can help you get in on that. Get your game up. Because you're not thriving here. You're not thriving. My notes say that Krata is like hiding his name, but I don't remember that's I'm looking for that now because I also saw the note. So it's it's not that he's hiding his name. It's that he's like hiding who he is.

So like Krata is his name and says that he's OK. The description we get and that Garak is functioning on that he's only twenty seven. But Krata is talking to Garrick as if he's way older. Like he says, things like, like Krata says something like, I have no wish to lose you to Frostbite after finally having chosen you. Yet another reason I finally chosen to involve myself with your kind again. Like the things he says makes him way older. And Garrick says like, you're

only 27. Like according to Carrie, you've never bonded before. So like, why are you? speaking like you've done this before. And Krada is like, what even is a year? And just moves on. So it's like he's lying about who he is entirely, which another dragon does later, too. Yeah, another dragon does it. And it's like very explicitly made clear to us. But it is interesting that Krada is like kind of obfuscating like who he is a little bit in a different way. Yeah. Yeah. Like he just he seems older than he is. Yeah.

Yeah. I don't know why I should care. I don't either, I don't either. And when we get to the fan theories, I mean, there's so many out there. I didn't do too deep of dive because frankly, I got overwhelmed and kind of annoyed. And really no one's talking about the dragons and why they're lying, besides just being like, dragons can lie. And I'm like, yeah. Obviously. Why would they not lie to you? They're so obviously able to

lie. They're even obviously able to lie to each other, right? Like, yes. What do you think is happening here? Yeah. Yeah, I don't know. I still don't understand the motivations for the dragons because I think it was also insinuated in Garrick's chapter that either he had that he had at least this dragon had at least bonded somebody in his like extended family line before. Yeah, it was like implied, like Kratus says something to that

effect, but like the quote unquote history that we have of this dragon says that there have been no other riders. Yeah, he says, that's why I seek your bloodline. That's why I seek you. And I am wondering, like because we get this kind of illusion in several of specifically the rebel kids. So like we've got Satan, Garak, we'll go through the other ones. But like there's a lot of them who have potentially bonded with somebody in their direct family before. And for being such a big no -no, that seems pretty intentional.

And I wonder if it has to do with the fact that if you consecutively bond within a family, that you're more likely to channel multiple powers. Yeah, I wonder. That's kind of what I think the dragons are lying about their identity. That way no one questions them clearly seeking out the rebels to strengthen them. Yeah, because it makes sense that, like, if you had repeated history with a specific bloodline, like, one, the traits or the bond, like, mechanics might be similar, but you could, like, foster that

specific connection rather than having to start fresh over and over again. Yeah, and then you get those multiple powers, which is, like, Zayden already has, even with his, like, adjacent bloodline. But that's an interesting point, because Violet has one. Has to to but she has two dragons. So is it because she has two dragons one from each? Oh, I forgot that she has two targets Yeah, I think that's kind of like the one -liner for her. But like who knows? I don't think it's in Garrick's chapter, but I want to say now before I forget With because you mentioned the rebel

riders and those dragons It's almost like those are all predetermined like outside of threshing day. It's like those dragons have already picked their riders Which doesn't seem to be how it normally is but it's like all of the rebel kids like are assigned a dragon almost Yeah, so and and we see that specifically because it's like we see Zayden and Garrick and then Bodhi is the is the next chapter and then the first like second year of rebels that get their dragon. And from him on, their dragons are predetermined. Either

the dragon has reached out before actual threshing day and has made it known that your mind, come find me on threshing day. We're going to get out of here. Or Seagale is giving orders of, oh, yeah, this dragon is picking you. Go to that one. It's a blue whatever blob. Yeah, right. So go. And so I thought that was interesting. And then Zayden says something where It's clear that the dragons are picking the rebels because they are trying to like heal the evil in the world. Whatever that means. Yeah. And some of

the other dragons even not of rebels, like I think Mira's dragon says something like, is it Mira who says she wants to like burn it all to the ground? And her dragon's like, hell yeah, let's go. I don't think maybe it wasn't Mira. Someone says that like they're motivated to like burn everything and her dragon is like dope. I mean, Eric's dragon, Eric definitely says that an Eric's dragon is like dope. But yeah, I mean, that's that's really the thing that I still don't understand. It's like the dragons want to burn

it all to the ground. And it's just like, so then do it like why do you need these people? You have the keys to the kingdom here. And like if you're if you're saying that it's like Melgren. and his dragon, who's the one that's like calling the shots and like doing the evil thing, then like just kill Melgren. Right. Like kill the human so that the dragon can't channel anymore. And then like, you're fine. I don't understand. I don't understand. Don't understand. So that,

yeah. But. So we did Garrick and then we'll move to Dane. And Dane also has a doozy of a dad. For real. He is literally the worst. Almost, I mean, similar in Eric or Alec or whatever his name is, but in a very different way. He's like manipulation station, like in a big way. Yeah. He asks at threshing for Dane to start spying

on Violet and the Rebels. Like, what the hell? And he's like... He's like sweaty palms, like Jones in for his next fix. He's like, you trust me, right? Like, come on, you're my son. I'm your father. You trust me, right? I'm like, that's weird. It was gross. Well, he like also uses Violet kind of against him by being like, you care about Violet, right? You got to protect Violet, right? Because at this point, Violet's not a writer yet, but right. It's God, his dad's the worst. His dad like tells him what kind of dragon to go for. But you're right. But Jonesing

is the vibe I got too, where he's like, OK, yeah, we're going to do this, right? You got this. He's trying to convince himself almost as much as he's trying to convince Dane. And then he catches himself on almost how weird he's being. And then he dials it back. He's like, oh, yeah, by the way, you should bond a green, because a red or whatever is too much for you. Yeah, you can't handle that. Yeah. And then Dane bonds a red, which is great, because I'm like, oh, you're a little rebel, aren't you? Which I love and even even the dragon is like going against your father. Are you? Interesting and he's like,

yes So yeah, I mean I thought I thought it was interesting that like Dane's dad was crazy Even here like ostensibly before the events of book one, you know, yeah, he's clearly crazy and it was I liked getting That seeing more because it kind of makes Dane more forgivable. Also. Yeah, it definitely shows how like much of a weird home life Dane has, even if he doesn't realize it in the moment. Yeah, which I thought was interesting. And it did make him, I mean,

Dane does sort of come around in book three, but it does make me look at Dane in book one and two a little bit differently, where I'm like, oh, you've been really built to be the piece of shit you are. Uh -huh, yeah. You've been really indoctrinated over here. Yeah. So. Then we go to Bodhi. And like I said, this is the first one that we see from like the second year of Rebels. And then this is when they're like told who they're bonding to. Like the dragons are intentionally seeking them out, which is just like my line here is, quote, I don't trust those

fuckers. I swear. Like, I just don't trust the dragons. I don't trust them at all. And what it was also interesting to me in this chapter was that Bodhi, I think it is Bodhi. Well, too, it's hinted that he also has a family who bonded with his dragon. And then he and Zayden read like really close. Well, they're cousins. Yeah, but they they read like cousins. Yeah. Well, I don't fucking know. Maybe they're brothers.

Oh, I see what you're saying. Maybe they're actually brothers. Right. And and he talks about how much they look alike. Right. Which I don't look that much alike. No, they don't. But if Zayden's granddaddy or daddy or whatever uncle daddy. is also if that was Bodhi's daddy yeah interesting and like they don't know just the dragons know for some reason yeah like people literally call them doppelgangers

and so i just i thought that was weird and it was so overt in this chapter it was really over in this chapter you're right it comes up a lot to the point where i was like did i miss this in the books but i think i just maybe wasn't paying attention but um i thought that was interesting so i think maybe they might be brothers I think they might be brothers, too. I missed that until you said that. We already talked about Zayden's lineage, and I was like, they're cousins, Katie. They tell us that. We know this. Listen, this is why I'm not good at fan theories, because

I need other people to tell me the theories. I will know what I'm told. My problem with fan theories is that unless we get hard evidence, you could just do this forever. I know. And there's like one theory I'm going to share that I'm like, oh, I totally buy that. That one's interesting. And then there's like three others. I'm like, you guys are trying too hard. Maybe it matters. I think you're just stressing yourselves out. Like the scratches on the cover. I guarantee you that doesn't fucking matter. That was a stylistic choice. Yeah, I would bet money that that doesn't

mean anything. And also, it just reminds me of like, I think there was a TikTok that I sent you about somebody talking about like the Akatar theories. Talking about the fan base being playing 3D chess and Sarah J Maas is over here playing checkers. Like, it's really not that serious. I'm just trying to write a book here, guys. Yeah. All right. So then we get to Imogen, and we learn that she is also madly in love with Garrick, like mad mad. But she is so unpleasant. And I know I sound like a fucking boomer, but Jesus

Christ, Imogen. She's also, yeah, I mean, so she's also not only is she mad madly in love with him, she's also mad mad that he left her without saying goodbye. So she like has iced him out for two years, essentially. Right. Six months, however long it's been. Which it doesn't make sense to me because, like, you love him. He literally says, like, you just you just name the time and the place, baby girl. And like we can be exclusive. We can do it. All the time,

like you just say the word. I will never look at another woman again. Right. There's no reading between the lines. Talk to me. It's so fucking weird. The other thing that I thought was interesting is that, like, she's almost literally haunted by her dead sister and mother. Like she talks to them constantly. Yeah. Which I didn't. This book. OK, I'm going to say this overall. This book has been really fun to get into some of these characters heads that like. It's fun to

see these characters from violence point of view and then see the characters as like who they're written Because it really points the whole like you should know your characters backstories even if it's not like relevant to the book because it shapes them Yep, and she's a big one for that. Like I didn't think she had a family she cared about Well, they're all dead so there's that The other thing that's interesting about this is her dragon is actively hiding her identity and basically bonded her at presentation to the

point where she's almost channeling at thrashing and she has to learn how to mind block or whatever that thing is. Yes. And her dragon was her grandmother's dragon. So that is a confirmed prior bonding. Yes, but will not admit it. Right. Imogen knows it. The dragon fucking knows it. And Imogen's like, I know who you are. This isn't your name. And she's like, nope, you're going to call me fucking Glaine. I've never had another writer before. What are you talking about? Yep. Even

though Imogen has solidly met this dragon. Yep. Already, like as a child. But this dragon Glaine, putting in air quotes, is supposedly 19 years old, has had no previous writers. And Imogen's like, you're a fucking liar. And the dragon's like, don't you question me. Don't question your elders. And Imogen's like, I'm fucking older than you. Supposedly. Supposedly. And, Glaine, I think Glaine goes on to say, like, I've killed so many in Imogen's, like, nobody because you're

19 years old and you've never seen active conflict. Is that what you mean? You never had a ride before? Right. I think I thought it was so funny because one of my favorite scenes in whichever book it is, is with Imogen and Glaine when they're having that, like, Lord of the Rings, like, kill off and they're keeping count. And I love seeing that that started here. Yes, I love that too. So yeah, I mean, this is the pre -bonding thing, right? Like, bonding somebody who is in the same family as somebody that you've already had as

a writer is a big no -no. But it feels like, at this point, everybody and their mother is doing it with a rebel, like. Yeah. Well, the other thing that was. Which is it? And the other thing that was interesting with Imogen is that it seemed like Glaine, like, pre -marked her. Like, Imogen has a tattoo before, like, Threshing Day. Yeah. Which, like, I know that was the thing. So yeah, fully channeling before they've even completed the blonde, completed the bond. Yeah, I thought that was interesting. I don't know why I got the impression that they bonded on presentation day, but I don't know that for a

fact. Yeah, I don't know that for a fact either. I'm trying to look at when she says that the tattoo was on her, but way earlier than it's supposed to be. I also love how just like all of the other chapters, they're so worried about offending their dragons, with the exception of Sloan. And Imogen is just like, fuck you, you're full of shit. I'm mad. You're full of shit. Like,

no, absolutely not. She's like, unconcerned. Amazing. So then we get Rhiannon. So I wanted to say something. So when we get to Rhiannon's point in the book, there is now a like... Spoiler warning that says the rest of the stories this question contains for fourth wing and then we get another warning for like onyx storm yeah, which I kind of went back and forth on because like I Guess what it's saying is that the rest of these characters as a fourth wing You don't know if they survive or not on thrashing day

until you read it Whereas like if you read this in thrashing day, obviously they survive and get bonded like Sawyer and those things but the whole thing is kind of a spoiler. I mean like in Zayden's chapter we get the whole thing with like the scars on his back and how he's responsible for everybody where that's a reveal later in fourth wing so like the whole thing is kind of a spoiler yeah i didn't know i thought it was an interesting choice to call like just specific part spoilers like i would just put a big spoiler warning on this entire book yeah me too so i

just wanted to call it out because i thought it was interesting where i was like and some of the other chapters are not like really spoilers like dane's chapter doesn't really give anything away um But like Zayden's chapter in particular, I feel like does. And I think something in Bodhi's chapter does like there's just a couple of little things that I know are revealed in fourth wing and like, well, yeah, I mean, well, Zayden killing Alec feels like a big giveaway. Yeah. So. Yeah, I mean, just big spoiler warnings, I guess. So also, but if you're listening to this episode

and you haven't read them, like, I don't know what you're doing with your life. Exactly. And I don't think anyone's starting with this book by any means. That would be a wild choice. It would be a wild choice. But that's what made it even weirder to put, like, explicit spoilers in here, where I was like, what? What are we doing? So then we move on to Rhiannon. And like, I didn't get a whole lot out of her chapter besides the fact that she's probably the only person who actually enjoyed Threshing Day. That's all I got it like I don't think we learned anything in her chapter. There's nothing shady or her her dragon is her dragon This is gonna sound

really mean but like so I think it's maybe it's on a storm where we get like other characters perspectives at the end for the first time I Thought this then and this reiterated for me that like brain is just kind of boring Yeah, she's I mean, she's very like golden retrievery. Yeah and like It's great. It's great. Yeah, we definitely don't learn anything. She is the only one who has fun. She's in it for the whole time. And she's like, all I want to do is fly a dragon. Who wouldn't want to fly a dragon? Her dragon

is whispering in her ear, come find me, starting at the beginning of threshing. So she knows that she's bonded to somebody, right? Yeah. There's no stress for Rhiannon. No stress. So then we move on to Sawyer. Sawyer's the one, if you remember, had to repeat year one because he went through Threshing Day once and he didn't get bonded, nor did he die. He's very big mad about it. He's got a lot of big unhappy feelings about that. Listen, okay, I can't possibly understand, but

I get it. I also wanted him to shut up about it. I know. He's like, my guy, you got to get over it. He does. I didn't get... that Sawyer was that mad in book one, like he could just kind of came off as like a like puppy adjacent. Yeah. Maybe I'm misremembering, but like the the reveal of like his anger in this book made him gave me like big incel vibes. Yes, that's the vibe I was getting. And I was like, oh, Sawyer, I liked you. And now I'm just kind of like, can

you not? Yeah, I'm not into it. So, yeah, I mean, when his dragon shows up, his dragon does say something that shifts his thinking. He says that like, look, buddy, I wasn't available. And so we didn't bond, right? It wasn't a you saying it was a me thing. So that flips like the narrative and show in Sawyer's head that it's not that he's not good enough. It's just that his dragon wasn't ready. And I thought that was a little bit endearing. I thought that was endearing, too. And I like that his dragon says that. And his dragon base says, like, my writer died. OK,

like that's I need a time to get over it. I wasn't ready for you. I'm sorry you had to wait. And the dragon himself, I don't know, resume right now. But the dragon himself is like, you're going to need to get over it. Like, I'm here now. You got to get over it, but we've got to move on. There's bigger fish to fry. Like, we got to like, I'm really sorry that I hurt your feelings, but like, we're here now. Let's wrap it up. Let's wrap it up. Yeah. So, yeah, I mean, Sawyer's chapter was a little bit annoying to read, but

I think maybe that's why I had such like a better impression of him through the books, because like this happens relatively early in the series. And then he's like, Fine, right? He's a fine person. He's a fine person because he gets what he wanted, and he understands the reason for the delay. Right. So then we get Riddick. And the only thing that I have out of Riddick's is that he and his dragon are exactly who you think they are. I think I sent you an Instagram reel today about Riddick and his dragon. And honestly,

I could read a 200 page book just about Riddick and his dragon's antics. Give me that. I just thought it was so funny. Well, Riddick goes into it hoping for an older dragon who can balance him out. And he just gets a bro dude just like him. Yeah, they're exactly the same age. They're exactly the same person. Yeah. And, like, the dragon tries to, like, start the relationship through a prank. And then Riddick is like, no, no, no, no, no, you're not the right dragon. Then this dragon gets offended and starts walking away. And Riddick's like, OK, wait, no, sorry.

I'm sorry. You're right. I'm sorry. Let's start over. I can even go back to the water and we could we could start it again. Like, we could start if you want to prank me again the same way. I could be better this time. Yeah. And the dragon's even like, I'm getting bored. And Riddick's like, no, you're fucking not. You love this shit because I love this shit. I thought his chapter. was a delight. It was also it was really nice to have read right after Sawyer's chapter, which was a bummer. Yeah, such a big bummer. But yeah, I'm I had a great time reading Riddick's chapter.

It was he had fun on threshing day in a more interesting way than Rhiannon for me. Yes. So then we get Liam and Liam is interesting because he wasn't told who he would bond with because he already knew. He knew at presentation that it would be his dragon, Dee. But he's cagey as to why. It's clear that Dee made himself aware. And we're told that Dee favors people with the

Mary last name. But we don't know if it's directly one of Liam's former family members. I would hazard a guess that it is. And I would hazard a guess that Liam has met this dragon before. Yeah, that's what I'm going to assume, too. I think everybody was worried about how heartbreaking Liam's chapter would be because he dies. Spoilers, you guys know he doesn't die in this chapter, but he dies. And there was one line that did kind of get to me. Or there's two lines. He says

something like, OK, finally someone that can't be taken away from me. And he dies. The last line is, like, I'm out to begin the next and last chapter of my life as Dee's writer, which, like, that's true for all of them. But, like, screaming, crying, throwing up. Yeah. I went into it. I was like, it's fine. I know he dies. It's not a big deal. Whatever. I'm the one always like crowing that people should die in books. And then I was like, OK. I also really liked

because he and Zayden have a conversation about Violet, right? And yeah. Liam's like, you're too hard on her. I bet if I knew her, we would be friends. And I just was like, oh, you're going to be friends because you're going to be friends. Something that was funny about his conversation with Zayden is Zayden's like bitching about how annoying Violet is. And Liam's just like, OK, you keep telling yourself that you're annoyed by her. Yeah, we all believe you, buddy. So obvious.

Methinks the lady doth protest too much. Yes. So then, get ready. Speaking of a big bummer, we have Sloan's chapter. Jesus Christ. See, I thought Liam's chapter was going to be a bummer, and those two lines made me sad. Sloan's chapter straight up made me cry. Yeah, I mean, like, I didn't know she was so sad. I don't know. Maybe it was just the headspace that I was in. I had a similar reaction to reading Sloan's chapter

as I did to Sawyer's. I was just like, just shut up. Just shut up. Just shh. And that's totally fair. I don't know why it hit me. Maybe because my period was starting. But I was like, ugh. And then also, Mr. Dane looking my eyes atos coming in hot. Oh my god. That was the part where I sat up at my chair. I was like, oh. Oh, okay. And I remember he does that to her again in one of the books. Yes. I think it's the third book when he starts to come back around and we were

like, oh, wait a minute. Yeah, and so it's like they already actually have this connection really made me. Yeah. I also sat up. The eyes here, Myri, I was like, huh, huh, okay. Yeah. Yeah. And then Sloan again is also... with a dragon that is hinted at having bonded with somebody in her family before. Yes. So it's like most of the rebels that we've read about Threshing Day have that thing happening with them. Yeah.

Well, and there's there's probably a deeper connection, but the connection that we do get explicitly is that Liam's dragon is her dragon's brother. Yeah. So like, is that not still the same line? Because I think it is. I feel like it's the same line. Yeah. Yeah. Anyway, Sloane does try to commit suicide, complete suicide. By dragon. By dragon. And Dane saves her. And that's where the eyes up Maori thing comes. That was so hot.

It was, yeah, it was super hot. It's also fun because when Viola goes through the Shing day, Dane does not intervene because he's Mr. Rule Follower. But when Sloane comes in, he's all about breaking the rules for her. Yes, I also think it's fair to acknowledge that he's in a wildly different headspace. Oh yeah, he's grown a lot in the last two years. This is after the betrayal of his father also. Yes, so he's like, fuck the rules. Fuck them rules. But yeah, so then Sloane has like a come to Jesus moment.

Oh shit, I almost did end my life. And then her bond with her dragon, like makes her take a step toward like wanting to live again. Yeah, the line that got me is she's talking about how she doesn't have any friends throughout this whole thing, and she's very sad because her brother's dead, she has no one. But then after she bonds, her dragon's like, would you like to fly back to your friends? And she just says, yes. And I was like, oh. I don't know why it got me, but it really did. All right. And then the last person

that we see is Eric, who is. I forgot about this guy. Honestly. Until this chapter, I was like, who? Oh, right. I didn't. I still want Eric and Violet to kind of be a thing. I'm not mad about that. Because I think Zayden is kind of like, I don't know. I just have such mixed feelings about Zayden after the end of the last book. Yeah, I think we all do. He feels like someone she has to manage rather than like an equal. And I just like, I always hate that dynamic.

And it feels like Eric has his shit together. Yes, it does. And he's confident and he knows what he's doing. He has a plan. Yep, I'm with you on that. So he goes into threshing wanting to bond Mulvick. And Mulvick is like, all right, heard. My next writer is going to rule Nevers. So is that you, girl? Because I tried. I had eyes for your brother, and he was really disappointing. He died suddenly. Whoops. Whoops. And so Eric's

like, yeah, I'm down for that. But I have to let you know that I'm going to burn this place to the ground. We'll rule it, but it'll be wildly different. But they're essentially making a pinky swear to burn the patriarchy, which I appreciate. Yes, I did love that. One other interesting thing that we learn about this is that Eric is different from his brothers because his mom made sure that he got different schooling. Yeah, for some reason.

Yeah, so like where Brennan was like mommy's favorite, right? Like Eric was also mommy's favorite and she made sure that he didn't turn out like his dipshit brothers. Is he the one? I might be thinking about a different book, but is he the one who says like I wasn't the heir or the spare so I could like my parents like afforded me to do these other things and now I'm the heir? That might be a different book. I don't know

if that's the case, but I do know that Eric was the youngest. He was never expected to be. But then one of his, yeah, I mean, I think one of his brothers died in battle and we know what happened to Alec. Yeah, it doesn't matter. But wherever that line came from, I thought it was a great line. Yeah, a super great line. But I just thought it was interesting that, like, he had the least amount of expectations on him. And now, whoopsie, you got to have those again. The other one that I thought was interesting

in his chapter in Mulvick is, Mulvick asks him, like, you think you know the future? And Eric says, I know mine. But isn't it, doesn't he get, like, clairvoyance? Or isn't it, like, his suspected power? Like, he will be able to see the future, truly? Yeah. I think that is what his suspected signet is. I don't think we ever get confirmation that that is his signet. Not yet. But I think that... That would be fun if his dragons already like you think you know the future because you will. Yeah. So that was cool. That's that's the

end of the kind of short stories that we have in this book. So what are some of the fan theories that you came across? OK, so the first fan theory that I find very interesting that people are calling out that in every almost every single one of these. Stories the rider bleeds like the dragon makes them bleed in some way like Zayden gets it in the face Sawyer gets cut up like they all bleed for like some reason or another and The theory is that the dragons are doing that on purpose to test their blood to make sure they're

not like Venin before bonding but Dane's chapter he's the only one who doesn't explicitly get called out as bleeding so But I thought Zayden was already turning Venin like. Not in his threshing day. Not in his threshing day? Oh, no. What's his face was that like Jack, Jack already was.

Yeah, I guess that's true. I guess what I was, what I was conflating is that Zayden was already doing Venin things in Violet's first year. Not his own first year. And I was conflating those two things. Yes, but not his own first year. But that's interesting I but I don't understand like if they're so insistent on them not being venom if Like once he started to turn venom why segale wasn't just like deuces You know, I don't know maybe like their bond is too strong or like

other things happened. I have no idea That's interesting. I like the idea or I like the call out that they are making them bleed I almost I could see it the other way of like developing a blood pact or something, right? Yeah, or it's just like they incidentally bleed because they're fucking dragons and it's dangerous. It's dangerous, yeah. It's danger. But I did think it was interesting because I did notice it in his chapter that he didn't bleed because everyone else, oh my God,

they talk about them bleeding so much. Yeah, they do. Well, and it's almost weird. I think it was Imogen or maybe it was Sloan. pricked her hand on like fucking a rose thorn or something like that. Yeah. Talking about this. Yeah. And so that's where like when I read this theory, I was like, I mean, it did seem like there was a lot of focus on bleeding and like Dane does like hit his chin. Just blood is never mentioned. Yeah. Interesting. So like it could just be a mist where like blood wasn't mentioned because then a person responded to the fan there and

he was like, yeah, but then when Violet sees him again, she mentions him having a scar. So like just because we didn't see the blood doesn't mean he didn't actually bleed. Yeah, that's fair. Also, wow, people be having a detailed memory of what happens in these books, huh? Listen, that's where I was starting to get frustrated with the fan theories because I was like, I could barely tell you the plot of the first three books. Like, I don't know. I don't have tabbies to go

back and like... reference like I'm just I'm here for the vibes man even like the vet that the Zayden invented thing I just had a Google X was like when did that happen it's not till the end of iron flame so like he is with segale for years before that starts well that's when we see it but I think it's insinuated that it happens earlier than that I specifically remember something about violet finding out in onyx storm something that made her think that Zayden was becoming venom when she first met him I have

no memory of that. The Google says no, but that's just the Google. Yeah. The secret that she thinks back to is that he can read people's minds, basically, that she finds out later. But it definitely could be. I'm just looking at the AI Google. And I don't know. As I just said, I'm not the one to ask. I'm also not the one to ask. So I could be blowing smoke out of my ass. Who knows? Who knows? So that one I just thought was interesting.

There could be something to that. I think it's really subtle. I don't think it really matters. I don't think Dane is like secretly Fennin by any means. No. But the one that I really liked was in Brennan's chapter when Daddy Sornagale gives him the bracelet. Yes. Brennan talks about how he's like always wearing the bracelet and how he can like... Kind of faintly smell like parchment and he like just kind of chalks it up to his dad basically being a librarian So his dad just always kind of smells like parchment, but then someone come called out quotes from

Like fourth weight or one of the other books when Mira is wearing a similar bracelet may or may not be the same one but at least a similar one and Violet smells parchment And then there's there was like a third example that I'm blanking on because I didn't write it down But again, like seeing the bracelet and smelling parchment. And so someone proposed that maybe that bracelet, those like black beads are actually parchment and they're the missing pages or missing pages to something we need that are like rolled up into beads. Oh, oh, I love that. I know that

one. I was like sold. I'm sold. Yeah, sold for sure. That one. I was like, yes, yes. That would make that would make me like. Respect her parents more. How do you sorry? I was actually doing something useful me too So I that one was that one was the big one that I was like, okay. Okay, I buy that Now I'm looking through like the ones that I wrote down Okay, there's there's another

one that had some water but this is the one that I keep seeing over and over again that like I just I've seen it three times I keep reading the post on it because I I don't see it at all and I need someone to explain it to me where people think that Daddy Sorengale had a dragon and was bonded to a dragon as a scribe and they all think that he like secretly had a dragon and that's why he is more comfortable with dragons and that's why he's like knows more things about threshing day and that's like how he can like

travel to all the islands like as fast as he does I mean like some of it holds water but some of it I'm just like yeah But also his wife has a dragon. That's what I'm saying. He's just been around dragons, has he not? I mean, the only thing that I could see is if Tanana, Tarrytown,

Tag Narak, whatever his name is. Was his dragon and nobody knew about it and so he's not registered as having bonded, right? But like that's but Violet is now bonded to the same dragon that her father bonded to and nobody knew about it Which is gonna make her like uber powerful or something Yes, I think someone said that like a similar thing of like that was His previous dragon and so I'm like googled sorry I was like trying to answer you like yes, someone did say that thing. Um And some of the other evidence

people points out is that he comes in and out of Threshing Day, no one seems to notice, the dragons don't care. This one was weak to me, but as soon as he disappears into the forest, Brennan sees a brown dragon launching into the sky. And Imogen's point of view does tell us that dragons can bond outside of Threshing, so he doesn't have to go through Threshing. Yeah. I just, I don't. Does it but does does that open

up the door then that? Anybody can have a fucking dragon. I mean kind of right like yeah, I Yeah, I mean The the same reason what that they're saying that it makes sense for him to have a dragon I could just you fill in the blank with mommy soaring gale and like that's the same answer right like that's where I'm dropping him off at the islands right like He's been around. What's his face for so long? And it's just comfortable, right? Like the dragons know that he's married

to somebody who's bonded to one of them. So they're comfortable, right? Like, who cares? Yeah. So I'm like, what is this? And honestly, I think he's sketchy enough that, like, I don't think he needs that level of it. Right. Yeah. Well, and plus, like, I just I don't know what. what benefit like I'm trying to like play it forward with like if he had a dragon why would he have a dragon and why would it be like why would that happen right like he's going on secret missions but he's still a scribe like he's going on secret

missions for the college right it's he's still working for the government right so I just don't think that he could get away with having a bonded dragon yes unless that dragon was outside of the the current clique whatever that special secret super dragon thing is that they found the, like, shimmer hatching grounds. Oh, the eareds. The eareds. Like, maybe he bonded to an eared, but I feel like that would that there's no way that would go unnoticed. It's not like a dragon is something you could put in your pocket, right? Like, exactly. Like, how would no one

notice? And like, I don't know. I keep seeing it all over the place. People really, really like it. And I'm just like, ah, sure. Sure. But tell me why. Tell me why that would be important, right? Like, that's that's the thing. Tell me why I should care. There was one more. Oh, the only other one. Well, two things going to Zayden's blood. These are less fan theories and more like notes that pulled out. You know how the end of Onyx Storm ends with like the mysterious like Zayden's brother and trying to figure out who that is? Oh, yeah. Yeah. Well, like you pointed

out with like, oh, it's probably Bodhi. But also if Zayden's lineage isn't really what it is, then he's not like the Duke. He's not the Duke. So then who's the Duke? That's a great question, but he's an only child, right? Yeah, but like if his, if his uncle, how do I say this? If who

he thinks is his dad is actually his uncle, does his uncle have kids? Because he's an only child, but like he has cousins. So like, are they like reverse cousins? Is that what I'm saying? I don't know. I see what you're saying. Yeah, I mean, obviously, at least one of his uncles has Bodhi, right? Yeah. Oh, man. Now there's a succession thing. OK, that's interesting. I know. So those were the major ones. There were others, but those were the three that I thought were the most interesting.

I'm really curious about the Daddy Sorengale one. Yeah, I'm interested to see. There's definitely something up with him. I just don't know if it's the fact that he has a dragon. I don't think he has a dragon. I do think he's hiding things. We know he's hiding things. Right. And I don't know why he's hiding those things. It just feels like if you wanted to, I don't know. I still don't understand the motivations of half the characters in this series. Me either. Which is great. There's a lot of mystery there. I like the political side of it. Yes. Yeah, yeah. The

only other thing I wanted to call out, because we've thrown a lot of shade at Rebecca Yaros, just because I don't like the way she talks to people. That's really my only problem with her. I know people don't like her because she uses the Gaelic words. I could take that or leave it. I don't know how to pronounce them either. I did look it up. I saved a video on it. Fine. But my point is that I don't really like how she interviews. She did say one thing, and it was the only time that I was like, OK. Not the only time, but it was a big time that I was like, I respect this. She was talking about Threshing Day. And the interviewer basically asked, OK,

what do we need to know? Is there anything in Threshing Day that changes the way we're going to read the rest of the series? Are you hiding things in here for us? And her response was really explicit, where she was like, absolutely not. Anything you need to know, I'm going to tell you when you need to know it. If you never read Threshing Day, you won't miss anything. Oh, great. Yeah. And the way she was like, worded it. I think I sent you the clip on Instagram. But the way she worded it, and this might just be mirrored into it, it kind of felt like a little bit of shade toward SJM. She was like, I'm not going

to bury all these Easter eggs. You've got to read all these books to figure it out. She's like, I'm going to tell you what you need to know. She's like, this is just like, if you want to go back into the world, you don't need to read this book. And I was like, thank you. I really appreciate that. That's very refreshing. Yes. I really do enjoy these books, but I don't want to do the Marvel universe of it all, and I don't want to have all of these Easter eggs and things that I have put the clues together and scooby -doo my way into what's actually happening.

Just tell me. I'm fine if you lead that up to the place where you eventually tell me, but I need you to eventually tell me. Yeah, I don't want it to be, and this is what Chase was like, she's like, don't. Don't make it be that if I don't read this book, I won't be able to enjoy the other books or understand them. Yeah, that's kind of like that. She was like, no. So I had to call that out, because I know in all of our other recordings, we've definitely thrown some shade at her and her interviewing practices. That one, I was like, thank you. Also, you better

not be lying. Maybe she's one of the scribes that we can't trust, dude. Right. I don't think so. She seemed really genuine about it. But like, who knows? Who knows? There's no way to know. There's no way to know. So I I don't think we're gonna do readings right cuz like no, how would it be? It was just fun. I recommend it I'll say that like it was yeah, and if you like the fourth wing world read it totally. Yeah, I had a great time I think the book is really beautiful and like it's one of those hard covers that like lies flat So like I was literally sitting at

a bar the other day drinking wine and reading like the book on the bar It was great. I make all they recommend make all of them lie flat I know some of them are like a density thing, but like you could just make them a little bigger you could You could, yeah. But yeah, totally recommend. Super fun ride. But those are our thoughts on Threshing Day by Rebecca Yaros. Thank you, as always, for joining us on this journey. Let us know what you thought on the socials. You can find us on TikTok, YouTube, and Goodreads, the Spice Traders pod. And if you want to hear our coverage of the... Iran Flammé and Onyx Storm,

hop over to our Patreon, where you can listen to those right now. And if you really, really like us, drop us a review wherever you listen. But until next time, we'll see ya. Bye!

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Irresistible Urge to Fall for Your Enemy By Brigitte Knightley Part 1

    Nov 10, 20261 hr 35 minAudio

    Triggers: graphic violence and gore, depictions of a fictional plague, on-page sexual content (including masturbation), and themes of parent death and chronic illness KU: No Recommendation: No, (give the author money...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Surrendering to Scylla by Wren K Morris

    Oct 27, 20261 hr 10 minAudio

    Triggers: (From the author): kidnapping, violence, discussions of abuse, BDSM dynamics and play, tentacle play, brief descriptions of injured animal (that receives aid), breath play, bondage, depictions of sub drop,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Court of Heathens by K. A. Knight

    Sep 29, 202652 minAudio

    Triggers: from the author: “explicit violence, explicit sexual violence, dubious consent, murder, gore, torture, kidnapping, and more.” KU: Yes Recommendation: No For more of the author, check out...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Under Loch and Key by Lana Ferguson Part 2

    Sep 21, 20261 hr 4 minAudio

    Triggers: death of a parent (off page), grief, fantasy violence KU: No Recommendation: both Traders recommend! This is part 2 of 2. For more of the author, check out https://www.lanaferguson.com/

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Under Loch and Key by Lana Ferguson Part 1

    Sep 1, 20261 hr 8 minAudio

    Triggers: mild violence, grief, and abandonment KU: No Recommendation: Yes! For more of the author, check out https://www.lanaferguson.com.

    Credit the people on this episode