This week the Traders discuss A Lady of Rooksgrave Manor by Kathryn Moon. Talk about a monster mash! Tropes: reverse harem, supernatural, who hurt you energy Triggers: brief non-consent and violence Both Traders highly recommend! For more of the author, visit www.kathrynmoon.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
So for both of us Well, yes, this book is right. It was a reread for both of us and I'm always a little nervous rereading. So I'm like, what if it wasn't that good? Uh-huh. It was still amazing. It was still one-handed reading club. Oh, oh my god. That's what took so long Seriously, that's what took so long Welcome to your safe space the podcast your partner friends parents whoever thinks is dirty Don't have time to read books want to understand the jokes in the tixx. We got you fam
We're the spice traders and we deal in spicy books. I'm Katie and I need it to make sense I'm Liz and I'm hypercritical as always we start every episode with three things The first is a generic trigger warning you can find specific triggers for this book and our show notes So please check those out. Also, we do use foul language and talk a lot about sex If you have sensitivity to any of this, please give this episode a skip Secondly we talk about books the whole book nothing but the books that help me goddess If you plan to read this book and don't want something spoiled right now, don't listen to this episode
Lastly we acknowledge that a good book can hit you at the wrong time The views expressed in our discussion are our opinion and we absolutely don't want to diminish the work and the talent of the authors in our community That said we have some notes So Liz what are we talking about today? Today I'm so excited today. We're talking about a lady of Rooksgrave Manor by Catherine Moon
This was published in 2021 and it is the first in the tempting monsters series Currently there are there are three full books and two novellas at the time of this recording It's unclear if this is a complete series or not as most recent book was published this year 2023 But it's unclear if this if more will come this book is 376 pages in a physical copy and that's a MIDI I Will say that you can fly through this book and you probably will but not for the reasons you think also
You'll probably slow down a lot because you only have one hand I know this This Katie and I have both read this book before and we were both so excited to read it again for this podcast I think we did similar things in the first reading where we read at the top of our lungs to get to the sex scenes and kind of Missed a lot of the plot Or I will say I will say glossed over there were definitely parts of the plot that were new to me
Which is reflected in my readings because I was like wow, this is a really well done I didn't think my writing some quality storytelling would be a five. I thought they were yours or even threes But like not the case Catherine Moon. She killed it I do want to talk about the cover because I do really like the cover it has a lot of Gothic horror vibes even though that's well, okay, this book is not a horror But it is we got a lot of monsters up in here. So we have that monster erotica, but we have
Presumably our main character Esther It's this woman with really dark hair in a long red like flowing down in like darkness I think she's holding a like a candelabra. It's a glass of wine. It's not a school issued candelabra But great I was going from memory on here and everything is a school issued candelabra in my mind the glass of wine is Even though yes, and it does set the mood it does I I mean so I'd rarely like books with real people on the cover but and this woman I think is clearly a real person, but she's like
She's stylized so it looks like it's not it's not like the Fabio books, right? It's moody. I like it like the vibe is immaculate and the three books that are out all have the same vibe It's not this like the same picture on the front, but it stylized in the same way, which I really appreciate I Do appreciate that and yeah, it's very stylized like it looks like an artist rendering of a real person Not just like I found this photo on Google and it's my book cover now. Also. I want her robe Oh my god, it is so gorgeous. She really makes me want to live my best Victorian like
Lady life and just exist in these outlandish robes like go to work in an outlandish robe I'm just yes that person. Yes I want to okay. I love my husband. I don't want to murder him But I want to embody that like this is my outrageous Fluffy pink robe that drags the ground after I'm on my fifth husband Yes, I want that but with my first husband Yes, with my first husband that I don't have any intention of killing. No, no, I want to be clear but like, you know
I know exactly what you're talking about. Yeah, I pick it up. What you put down. I really thought it was a very weird Lead into my point but All right, so let's get into this one because I'm so excited Katie take it away Okay. All right, so full disclosure. We don't get maps or anything. You don't need a map where you're going Don't worry about it. I will say that I started my notes and I didn't realize that I was at the back of the book So Liz mentioned we had read this book before but I I saw the acknowledgments
What's in this book are in the back of the book sometimes there in the front I wrote this down because it was really fucking funny Because in her acknowledgement Catherine moon says quote and finally my amazing parents who are so supportive and excited for everything I do even when I won't share the actual details because they are my parents and they shouldn't know about me writing sexy tentacle monsters Yeah, girl for sure. I fucking love that because I love the like I appreciate your support. I love that you love me Please don't read my book. Don't read my books. Don't fucking read my books. Don't you fucking touch them
Don't you fucking touch them? Which makes me wonder if she publishes under a pseudonym. I don't know. I think I definitely am Uh, yeah, no, I definitely am and like I don't even Want to like tell people I don't want to tell my mom that I'm published because like she'll find it I know she will find it and she will read it. She will read it I going on this like sexy tentacle monsters My mom knew that we were doing this podcast but very early on I had gone to this like book fair not like a scholastic book fair but like a like a local artist kind of book fair with my mom
and Stopped at this table with an author whose book is on our backlog. Um, and she does shift her romance And I told her about our podcast because you know promotion And she and I jumped into talking about ice planet barbarians and their giant blue penises And from my prerif my I just see my mom being like about face and like walk away I'm not gonna get out of that conversation real fucking fast and like two or three times since then she's brought it up
with like family friends where she's like, yeah, I didn't need to know about that Well, so don't come with me. Thanks for being a patron mom. Don't listen to my podcast That's fine. None of our patrons listen except for one. That's true. That's true. Um, oh I'm so sorry. I did have a comment about the dedication in this book. Okay, because I was confused Um, I might know just as what is this dedication and I didn't write down what it was. So let me um
We'll look it up. Yeah, so the dedication in this book Okay, so the dedication is to my fellow thirsty monster lovers whether you rank a one or a six on the scale What what scale is this? I don't know. I also remember reading that. I don't know what that scale is I felt like I was missing like I felt like I wasn't part of the cool kids club Maybe we're not part of the cool kids club. Maybe somebody will tell us and let us in Yeah, if you're part of the cool kids club, what is the scale because I want to know when I want to be part of this
I want to be on the scale. I feel like I'm I should I'm on the scale. I'm definitely on the scale I'm not at a one I might not be at a six. I don't know what a six is I don't know because why is it a six and not like a five or a 10 six seems arbitrary Yeah, I want to know what the scale is of monster lovers So that doesn't matter, but I was confused by that dedication Relatable. Yeah So when we jump into the story we come upon ester and delilah and they are house maids in a very posh house And they're eavesdropping on their employer mrs. Pickering while she is alone in her sitting room with a young dr
Underwood So dr underwood is one of those doctors that would come around to posh houses in the 1800s and deal with hysterics or nerves of women with Essentially vibrating machines So that's what's happening and so mrs. Pickering is getting tended to and moaning loudly Yes, that kind of moaning Delilah is mortified and leaves pretty quickly. She's both
Not okay with what they're overhearing but also terrified that they're gonna get caught But ester stays she is Very interested in sex. She makes no bones about the fact that she enjoys men Knows exactly what those sounds are that mrs. Pickering is making and wants Wants essentially to be in that position. She wants to know why that's happening and And why is it with dr underwood like all of these questions are racing around in her head I love how right off the bat. She's we get this character
That's just so open about her sexuality because it really feeds the rest of this book being comfortable to read and I just I like that we don't have this like oh, i'm gonna find myself. She's just like nope. I want to get railed Yeah, I want to get railed and ideally by that hot doctor. That was yeah, and I don't know what that fun buzzing sound is but also I Know Someone in psychology realm that we have come a long way from believing that women
Uh in hysterics have a mental illness. However I'm down for my anxiety to be treated by a hot doctor and a vibrating machine and why can't my insurance cover that Look, I have questions too because I'll pay those copays Oh my god So the doctor comes out of the room kind of flushed And discovers ester touching herself. So over the course of listening to mrs. Pickering and the doctor
Uh, she got a little horny and wanted some relief right there in the hallway right there in the hallway dr underwood Kind of pauses and then tells her that her mistress needs some water and esters like yep You betcha and Yeets herself out of that situation immediately Yeah So she goes down to the kitchens and she like shouts at somebody that mrs. Pickering needs water And then goes straight out to the stables to have her way with one of the stable hands there She's she grabs him by the belt and demands quote how fast can you get hard?
which is like this stable hand just What what a way to be greeted by a woman? I know the good old davie parks has a pretty cush gig I know good old davie parks Sometime later ester is watching dr underwood again, but kind of from afar He and other people are wandering around the house that ester works in looking at the items for sale We learned that the pickerings have gone under and are selling everything that they own of value to try to you know scrounge up
what's left And that all of the staff is imminently going to be let go Even with the good recommendation that she'll get from the pickerings ester is doubtful that she'll find another position as good as this one And so she's kind of musing, you know, I don't really know what my future holds blah blah, but Dr. Underwood is a good site to the hold while i'm doing so On be known to ester dr. Underwood has other plans for her He ducks into the servants quarters where she's spying on him And he tells her a little nervously that he's looking for her in particularly
He then asks her name and so we find out that ester's name is ester read Dr. Underwood is frequently described as being a little bashful and blushing and you know, I just I think more men should blush I know that they can't control that but like the idea of a man blushing is just Really endearing to me 100% yeah, especially on a doctor In his profession he We learn more about dr. Underwood, of course as this book progresses and he's just He just seems like such an innocent little lamb
I know For what he does It really is As he knows what he's doing 100% yeah, it's clear that dr. Underwood has some sort of proposition for ester So ester guesses first that it's a housemaid and he says no I have one and she's not nearly as pretty as you are And then she asks oh well are you in need of a mistress and This kind of catches dr. Underwood by surprise He's like, um, it's not quite that
It's so good. He's so nervous. I know he's so nervous He kind of like He like gets super nervous even more so and he's like looking around the hallway to make sure that they're not overheard and he like steps closer to ester And as he does so ester describes him a little bit more He quote has a gentle face with high cheekbones and lips for kissing reddish brown eyebrows and hair He tells her about a house where the girls are well kept There's work for girls who quote can't keep their hands off themselves in the hallway where anyone could see them
And quote kind of calling ester out on Noobin, uh-huh. Yep bombastic side eyes bombastic side eye In response to this ester asks what the buzzing machine does and he tells her he'll show her if she comes Round to his offices later that night As she agrees his eyes, which are usually blue flash green with delight Which is the first thing we get that all is not quite normal in the world of rook's grave. Yes
um I don't know at what point we get like more information about ester, but it's somewhere around here and Finally, we have a heroine that isn't the I am so ugly men don't care about me. Her vibe is very much like Hell yeah, I'm hot as fuck Mm-hmm, and people would be lucky to fuck me. Yeah It's actually when she arrives later at the study at damn Underwood's bigger kid when she arrives later at dr. Underwood's office. He like compliments her. He's like you're beautiful and she says I know
Do you agree? You know, you're pretty you think you're pretty what So when she does arrive at his office dr. Underwood escorts her into his private office and asks that she undress while he sets up Once she's ready. He directs her to kneel on the chaise that's in her in his office Which excites her right so she's kneeling away from him on the chaise This whole time that they're like moving around the room She's noticing how large dr. Underwood's shadow is on the wall like almost too large
Like it doesn't seem to fit his actual physical body and she notices that in relation to her shadow. It's bizarre She also notices the way his eyes flash green when he sees her naked The way his voice growls when he tells her she's a very beautiful young woman, etc. etc This is also the point at which we get a description of ester. She quote has pretty delicate features and nice glossy dark hair And after a generous year with the Pickering she looked like a woman which pleased her as she was past 20 and felt that it was long past
due so she Had some food Got some curves Got some curves looks like a woman very confident And she's an adult like I'm glad that she is past 20. She's not 19 18, right? Yeah, exactly. I'm a solid adult here So dr. Underwood begins their session by touching her briefly with his fingers But then almost immediately uses the machine on her and it's a like I said an essentially essentially a yield vibrator
But it's like attached to like a box machine like poured Yeah, old vibrator Something I didn't really ask questions about I feel like they're at the turn of the century because it's like this thing is electric It's like motorized, right? Yeah Yeah, some there's electricity something something here. Don't think about it too hard Don't think about it. Yeah, because if I think about it too hard I'm thinking it's like a generator in which case it's like really loud is like running on gas Yeah, I don't like that. No, not in a closed space
No, it's fine. We're not really thinking about that So ester is a big big fan of this and he uses it on her a few times before adding his fingers until she comes At this point she is begging for more begging specifically for his cock and he gives it to her She remarks that at first, you know, he's not a big man, but she doesn't seem to mind that right like Dr Underwood is kind of average size, but as he starts growling and
You know earnestly fucking her he starts to grow So into a much bigger creature Inside and outside Uh-huh. Yeah inside and outside and she can feel this both inside and see it For the shadows on the wall and feel it where he's touching her, right? So For example where he was wearing pants before now it's smooth skin or I guess rough hairy skin, but it's skin on skin His hands were Dr. Underwood sized and now they're much bigger than Dr. Underwood sized
Much bigger and she tries to look to see like what's happening, but A rough voice not Dr. Underwood's voice tells her not to command sir not to He tells her that there's no doctor here just tanner, but that she can call him sir too Yeah, so this introduces us to our first monster in the style of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde And for these two characters Dr. Underwood and Mr. Tanner
Esther calls both of them sir, and they're the only two of her reverse hair men that she does so Oh, I didn't notice that Yep. Oh, I like that Yeah She has like one of the things that I noticed about this book Going back through it is that she has little specific things with each one of her guys that makes it like Special to them and so for Dr. Underwood and Mr. Tanner, it's the sir thing Oh, I'm excited to track these. I don't think I
Consciously paid attention to that. I'm gonna make some notes for our socials Okay So Esther and Mr. Tanner have a great time. He literally fucks her ragged And afterward She kind of like fades in and out of consciousness because she's having such a great time, right? But afterward she kind of comes to and she finds that Dr. Underwood is snuggling her And he tells her that the patrons of the house that he told her about are all what people would consider monsters
But not all are like him Esther is thrilled at this idea. She announces that it'll be a much better fit for her than service ever was We also have got some background at this point that Esther has been let go from at least one job for being a bit Permiscuous. Yes. She uh She tries her best to hide it, but obviously gets caught Sometimes Sometimes but you know when she's fucking instead of working, you know Oh, that pesky jobs thing. I'm sorry. I forgot I had duties that I had to attend to
And to my own duties Hey Hey, I'm so sorry I'm five. I'm five. Hi. I'm five You're acting five. I have the diet of a five year old. We're doing great. We are just thriving So Esther arrives at Rooksgrave Manor and finds it to be the finest house she's ever seen Sprawling in opulent and on the edge of a lock So we get the impression that they are in the north of the uk probably somewhere in scotland
kind of isolated The doors to the manor are opened by an enormous man with eerily pale skin and a scar across his face and he is dressed in all black We learn his name is Booker. That's a good name. I'm sure you've heard of him before He's dressed in all black. We learn his name is Booker And next to Booker Esther is greeted by the lady of the house who is described thusly Quote Elgin and strange in the doorway wearing a red velvet robe with black roses crawling up the sleeves and tangling around the Bodice
There didn't seem to be anything beneath the robe and it bared milky white skin down a lengthy neck and almost to her navel Her hair was wrapped in a red turban thin curls of black framing her face She had huge unnatural eyes that even from a distance seemed to catch light like some kind of jewel and she grinned widely at ester Teeth large and bright and straight I when I first read this book did not picture um Magdalena this creepily
No, I didn't either Um, I also pictured her much older Yeah, even though we learned that she's not but like this is terrifying I mean this time around Magdalena was much more of a richer character to me and I liked it like she's We learned later and it's not giving away anything to tell you now that Magdalena is a witch And she's like a creepy witch like might eat your face off kind of witch Yeah, I I had the same experience this time around. I don't think I clocked Magdalena like really at all the first time and
Her being a witch isn't even subtle like she has tarot cards. She has a crystal ball and like I don't remember any of that Yeah, so the thing that struck me the most about this creepy vibe that she has is her office the description that we get of her office is unlike Anything that I've ever read because she's got like small animal bones scattered and like hung around the room and like Piles of those and other little collections like a fucking raven or something like all around the room and I'm just like
That's creepy as hell That's also kind of my dream office Yeah A gremlin witch is what I that's what I want like I I want bones like bits of things I do have a jar of whiskers Evidence by the fact that you stuffed your purse full of sea detritus when we were in Massachusetts I did and then I regretted it. You told me I was gonna regret it and I did Look, sometimes you have to learn it for yourself. I get it my purse has just recently stopped smelling like sea detritus
Amazing That's been improved solidly a year ago go. Alright so once they go inside it's very dark and the Madam of the House explains that it's because some of the patrons find the Sun harmful. The Madam asks if Esther likes sex and Esther tells her without hesitation that she loves it. Yeah she does. The Madam finally introduces herself as Magdalena Mortimer and she tells Esther quote my promise to you is that you will be wonderfully spoiled and will care for. The only promise I ask for in exchange is
that you use that gentle open brave heart of yours to care for the gentlemen who come here to see you. This man is a really nice place. Can I be Esther? I would love that. I know because like she is spoiled. She gets a living wage, she gets a wonderful room which will get all these things and then she's just straight up spoiled by these men who adore her. I think a living wage is kind of underselling how much they're paying her. We don't actually get details on it but they're like it's a lot of money. Yeah and not by the suitors like by the
manner pays her. Yeah yeah yeah so it's not giving away anything to say but kind of way that Rooksgrave House works is that it has a membership fee and once you're a member the Madam Magdalena works to place you with a lady of the house with whom you spend time and in most cases like have sex with and so the girls that work in the house live there. They have their own quarters which are
very opulent. They you know their room and board is paid for. They also get paid a salary and then their men very often shower them with gifts etc. It sounds like a very posh arrangement. Yes not the kind of quintessential like brothel that we tend to get in this era. Like it's they're all well cared for. Yes. Oh and also the clients are all monsters. This is a monster of Adicapus. If you didn't know you should be warned. And that's why her open
brave heart matters. Yes it super does. They're not typical men. So Magdalena tells Esther that Dr. Underwood has requested to be one of Esther's clients and Esther obviously agrees to this. They retire to Magdalena's office for tea and as they do Esther finds Booker's blue white eyes upon her and she finds that intriguing. She's thrilled and fascinated by this creature. It's clear that he's not human but she doesn't quite know what he is. She's never seen anything
like him before and he's very stoic. At tea madam explains a little bit more of the inner way a little bit more about the inner workings of the house. Along with the room and board and the salary no one will touch her in the house without Esther's permission but she's also to extend that same courtesy to others. She will choose how many clients become you know how many clients she gets but she's asked to keep the happiness of her clients in mind as they can become a little bit territorial. So essentially madam's going to suggest clients and
she'll get a trial period with them and then at the end of it it's her choice whether or not she wants to continue the relationship. Which this continues to be a thing where like it's always her choice and I really appreciated that. I did too yeah I mean Esther's in control of this entire situation and she a hundred percent knows it. Yes and thrives on it. Yeah. Esther is allowed anywhere in the manner except for other people's rooms obviously and when she's in town she's asked to be discreet so there's a town nearby that she's allowed to go to
etc. Until her clients are finalized she's also asked to stick to her rooms when the nocturnal events of the house kick off. And madam Mortimer explains that this can be because or this is because other women can be territorial not just the clients. Esther signs the agreement and is over the moon with excitement and Booker shows her to her room. Inside her room Esther is completely in awe that it belongs to her. It's ginormous. It has a huge bedroom
and bathroom, a private dining and sitting area and it's more than she ever dreamed but she's a little bit out of loose end. She's like I don't even know how to act in this kind of space. I've never owned or been allowed in spaces like this freely. She's always just been a servant and so sharing rooms, small rooms, nothing just her own or this opulent. Yeah that was reserved for the gentlemen and ladies of society. So Booker leaves Esther to her own devices and as she's kind of unpacking her tawdry things in the grand bedroom and
feeling like a little bit out of place in a loose end she looks out she looks out onto the lock out her window and she sees a woman and a werewolf. They meet and they make love and she is enthralled. She's envious that she doesn't have a monster of her own yet to satisfy her so masturbates while listening to the pair. She is insatiable. She really is and I have never read a book that
describes female sexuality like this because in this particular scene Esther talks about how she's like racing the woman to the next finish line and I found that so oddly like full of camaraderie. Yes like just the way that female sexuality is explained in this book. Even though obviously our whole podcast is about smut and spice I think that Esther as a character and this author creates
such a like sex positive environment that it's just fun. It is. So the next morning Esther goes for a walk around the lock and stops on a bench to view the manner. She daydreams and is visited by a vision of a man who quote was a man that was not a man. He had a man's face the most beautiful one she'd ever seen with skin-length baked earth and thick dark eyebrows and a mane of glossy black hair but his eyebrows continued up into a feline brow softly furred and
his long neck led down to wide shoulders covered with more golden brown fur. The shoulders extended to a chest that was not a man's and long arms stretched down to the sand below ending with huge furred paws and glimmering black claws. Behind him unfurled wings feathers glistening in shades of black and gold rust and copper. So just giving nothing away here this is a sphinx that's come to visit her. The assortment of types of monsters we get I really liked because
the first time I read it and we got our Dr. Jekyll Mr. Hyde situation I kind of expected like pretty classic monsters but we get this fun mix like we'll get some classic monsters but then we also get unique ones like a sphinx and later we learn about Booker that like I haven't read about before. I haven't either and it's like you know it is unique because like even some of the Katie Robert stuff that we've read with like dragons and stuff is more like high fantasy and
this is really like I think kind of an untapped area. So the sphinx tells Esther that his name is Aman and he tells her that he is a sphinx that he's been waiting for her a very long time. He's traveling to her on the sea and will be there he says in one more day but it's clearly longer than that. Yeah like a lot happens before he shows up. Yeah so I feel like maybe days are shorter or longer for first sphinxes I don't know. Yeah I don't know that was confusing where he got
like lost. Yeah he asks Esther if she wants some relief while she waits for him and as he begins to try to satisfy her sexually Esther is woken up by a village boy Jacob Combs. Jacob presents nice enough but when Esther tries to leave him he turns mean and grabby and vitriolic. He grabs her by the arm and is like okay well if you're too good for me blah blah but fortunately Booker
arrives and interrupts this interaction. Booker intimidates Jacob away and walks Esther back to the manor. She realizes that he's likely not human seeing him in the light. Some sort of stone golem he looks like he's literally carved out of marble. She asks if Booker has a lady at the manor as well and he doesn't quite understand the question so she asks him instead if he can feel and he tells her that he can. Esther determines then and there to ask Magdalena if she can play with the butler as well. I love this because again it's so much like sex
positivity and Esther just, Esther's gonna get what Esther wants and she is very indiscriminate on where she wants to show her affections. And we'll talk about this at the end because I don't know but I think Booker's my favorite. Aw, so I really like that Esther is such a sex positive character because she is indiscriminate sounds like the wrong word because it feels like she doesn't
have standards but she does. She obviously doesn't like Jacob. She gets bad vibes from him but she just has so much affection to give that she's open to a lot of different like types, right? That's a much better way to put it. I think that's what makes this particular reverse harem so interesting. Yeah, the different types and experiences. So at the manor Booker and Esther meet up with Magdalena who tells Esther that she's in no trouble but that Jacob boy was he's
being a nuisance, right? He's been on the property a couple of times when he's not supposed to be but every time he does Magdalena senses him and sends Booker to dispatch him as is what happened just then. Esther tells Magdalena about Aman and the madam is pleased that Esther has met one of her gentlemen. She has particularly chosen Aman for Esther. It reveals it doesn't spoil anything to tell you now that part of the reason that Magdalena has chosen the
particular gentleman for Esther are because they all have ultimately kind hearts and we learn most of them have been waiting a long time to be paired with somebody. It makes me really want to know about the other... we learn a little bit more about the other women in the manor and their suitors but I want to know more about how Magdalena like pairs people because it's implied that she does some magic around her pairings but like it just appeals to my spreadsheet
brain where I'm like I don't know how you do that. Like what are you looking at here? Right yeah. I also think that like I would be interested in the dynamic between the others because the the through line for all of the gentleman that Esther has is this the concept of acceptance like she really does accept all of them like warts and all and I wonder I mean we obviously see some instances of other girls being pickier but obviously that's not the case for everybody so I just be
interested in like some of those stories as well. Yeah I'm very curious. We do meet one character that like she's a bitch. She's a... whoa royal bitch. Yeah. So Magdalena also tells Esther that August Thibodeaux is arriving as well to try out as one of Esther's clients but before telling Esther anything more about August she says that she wants Esther to speak with one of the other girls of the house so she leads her to the breakfast room and introduces her to Cassie who tells Esther
all about her client George who is a vampire. She tells her about how lovely and wonderful they are and they'll only just take a little bit of blood when they bite you. I love Cassie. She's so here for George. Yeah she is. She's just so... I love Cassie too because she's described as again being a thicker girl who's like really enjoying her food and she's like oh yeah I try to eat sweets because that's what George likes. Right it is. I can stay away from things like garlic
because they can taste it and they don't like it. Yeah I love that so much and Esther's like oh okay I'm down let's do it. Obviously. Give me all the pastries. Right. She and Cassie and some of the other women at the table go on to talk about different types of men and Esther couldn't be more interested or happier with where she's landed. The next evening Magdalena brings Esther a gift from one of her gentlemen. It's from Dr. Underwood and it's signed Jonathan which is the first time Esther has learned of Dr. Underwood's first name
which I thought was endearing. Yeah and that plays into the sir thing because they did meet under a more classic meeting so her like default servitude kind of coming out not knowing his first name like not being privy to those things. Right exactly. The gift is a gorgeous dress for her first evening at the Manor and Esther Swoon's. She thinks she has the thought that the dress is too fine it can't possibly be for her but Magdalena kind of says you know you're
being ridiculous and helps her into it and of course it's a perfect fit. Dr. Underwood has a great eye for that and in this case I believe that because it strikes me that as a doctor he would know a lot of different types of women and like what their sizes are he sees them without their clothes on sees the insides of their clothes like their tags potentially and so has a better idea of what Esther's size would be. Yeah this one didn't bother me I also tend to have a lot more okay because if I haven't mentioned I hate the trope where men
just like pick out dresses and know their sizes. Right that doesn't happen. No but I have a lot more leeway for vampires because like they've been around a while they know things. Well this one's from specifically Dr. Underwood. I know oh fuck you're right disregard everything I said because I was still going on the George. Just cut what I said. Okay. Doesn't matter yes doctor. He has also seen her naked which like in the trope I feel like they tend to buy the dress before
they've had sex and I'm like no. Okay yeah. As Magdalena is helping Esther get dressed she reveals that Auguste and Dr. Underwood know each other which was somewhat intentional on Magdalena's part. She thinks that they'll be good clients together with Esther. Yeah they will. Esther goes on to talk about or to ask about Booker and Magdalena confirms that he is a golem a stone golem and that she made him but he's very much his own creature. He's also free to fraternize
with the ladies of the house as he pleases and Booker seems to be pleased with fraternizing with Esther as he particularly asked to be in her service when Magdalena asked his preference. He loves her. I like this conversation because it really doesn't matter but I think it's cute the way we get some information about Magdalena which is like I made him but like he's his own man like I'm not his mother I'm not his owner like I guess I gave him life but
like you do you girl and I liked that lack of ownership on him because he is a servant but he's not treated like a servant. Right yeah I like that too and I very much get the impression that like Booker gets paid well just like everybody else like it's very much his choice to be in service and like especially the the lead on about like okay well what do you want to do in at the house and he was like Esther. So once Esther is dressed Magdalena takes her to the kitchens to meet Auguste. He is in the kitchen and he's described as having
quote dark hair swooped back from his face and skin as pale as the finest ladies but his features were strong and wide and there was black stubble across his jaw. His eyes and eyes blue almost white but for the edges and normally I know we have this thing about blue eyes but with dark hair it doesn't bother me. No because it's less of that creepy Aryan race vibe yeah and again they're monsters so like the fact that he has somewhat spooky eyes it feels better
because he's not human. Right exactly he is a vampire. Yeah so Auguste and I just called him Auguste but I like Auguste better. Well he's French Auguste. I didn't make that connection. Yeah Auguste has a French accent because he is French. Because he is French. His name is Auguste Thibodeaux. Like Thibodeaux and you're right I just forgot. He glossed over those details I get it like you were trying to get to the sex.
I get it. Let's listen here. This is probably the longest stretch of no sex that you will have in this book. There has to be some amount of buildup okay. Yes and the buildup is fine because we do get interesting there's no information dumps it's interesting. Right exactly and it's all purposeful right like you never get information that doesn't matter it's world building in a way that you know it's not like hey I'm sitting in my room and I'm looking around no it's I'm in my room and I noticed somebody's getting fucked outside so let's do this. I don't know. Yeah and we get the information that there are like wards and that
Magdalena can sense them which comes in later like it all matters. Right and it's all shown not told. Yes. Which I appreciate. 100%. So back to Auguste and Esther. Auguste has made Esther a table full of desserts. He tells her that he was a patisserie chef in a former life again going back to the the thing about he's French and he's like shut up. He does this thing that I love where like she's in this gorgeous
dress right and he turns around and he's like he's got an apron on that's like full of like flour and he just like can't get it together to figure out like what to do with his hands so he tries to wipe his hands off on his apron and they just it just smears the flour around. He just gets dirtier. And at that point the madam is like well I think I'll leave you two alone to get to know each other. Just like how I think more mentioned blush I love Auguste's character because
we get typically vampires are very suave and very sure of themselves and he's just like I don't know too with my hands I made you a pastry. Exactly. And he does kind of have this very arrestingly disarming like charm about him because he's very nervous and very into Esther and he says as much he's like wow you're really pretty. And she's like thank you I know. And then they sit down and he starts to feed her all kinds of things. He starts with pomegranate seeds and
chocolate and he tells her the story of Hades and Persephone. And this goes on for hours right so he feeds her different things tells her stories that kind of align with the things that he's feeding her. And Esther is having a great time but eventually she grows impatient and she asks him whether he plans to fuck her in the kitchen or in her room. And she says don't get me
wrong your wooing is working it's just working a little bit too well so can we move this along? Also like I'm getting full. I'm getting full. And so he's like right noted got it. So they decide to go to her room. Once there a ghost undertakes a study in teasing the fuck out of Esther. He bites her in a couple of places her lip her neck her breasts and then teases her until she's begging
for release. And this is not something that Esther's ever had to endure before she takes her pleasure and like wham bam thank you ma'am. And she finds this teasing and this kind of edging behavior exquisite. There's a lot of things that Esther kind of finds about herself that it's kind of sweet like okay the edging great you do you girl but then later when she gets out of a goose I'm like I know. Yes, dear baby. Yeah. So a goose finally gives in and lets her come and
when he asks whether she's satisfied he's shocked when she says not even close. And obviously they continue the night. So great. One interesting thing about this version of vampire is that when a goose finishes it's a dry finish. Which makes sense. Yeah for sure I've just never read vampire smut that was a dry finish before. No. I mean maybe Christine Feehan because like that first book that
we read was painful. I don't even remember if there were juices. She had a lot of juices. Oh did she? Not the drinking kind. Not the cran-apple. Not the cran-apple kind. I don't remember. Yeah I think it's either like normal wet wet finishes to go on the opposite side or it's just like not talked about so the fact that he is like described as being dry. The other thing that that was interesting is that like when she tastes him like his or whatever he's also described as tasting
kind of like dry and dusty like not in a bad way but I mean he's dead. Yeah. And I liked those little details and he is cool to the touch. Yeah I like those details too. It was very it made the characters real. Yes. I feel as hard to do especially in a reverse harem when I mean she's got five of these guys right. Yeah. At some point there has to be some kind of discerning feature and you have to like stick to that and this author really does a good job of that. Yeah.
She 500 or she have six because she has five. It's Auguste Booker, Amon, Tanner and Dr. Underwood and then Ezra. Okay I was kind of Tanner and Dr. Underwood is like dose but they are one. They are technically that's why there's when they do dinner they talk about having seven people because it's her and then Dr. Tanner also. Oh yeah okay but there's just like six bodies. Yes. Yes. So Auguste stays for three nights before returning to London to conduct business or whatever he does and then but he promises to return soon and take her with
him to London to enjoy the city. This is the other thing that Esther kind of learns about herself is that she's used to taking her pleasure and also men taking theirs and then kind of going their separate ways. She's never had someone like stick around and like cuddle or sleep with her or like be there when she wakes up so that like aftercare emotionality she's really into and she's never had that beyond just the physical nature. Yeah and even just the concept of like a man wanting to have a conversation with her after they've taken
their pleasure. Yeah. Yeah. It's nice. As they sit outside on their last night Esther sees someone fumbling around in her room. When they go back inside to investigate Booker has been standing guard outside her room and says no one went inside but it's clear when they searched the room that someone was there. Auguste can confirm that he can smell someone that had been there and says that this person smells like a campfire. They don't really get much further nothing stolen they can't find the person so they just kind of drop it for
now. After Booker leaves Auguste and Esther fool around in bed and Esther tells Auguste that she wants Booker to kind of asking if he's okay with it and Auguste says he doesn't mind and asks if he can watch. Auguste is a team player. Auguste is a team player. Yes he is nasty. He a freak. He a freak and I like it. Yep. Esther loves the idea too so we're all on board with this. It's great. It's great.
Sometime later Esther is outside with Booker and they get called into Magdalena's office. She tells Esther that she knows that her gentlemen are occupied but the cards are telling her to wait and you know on introducing her to anybody else and she asks Esther if she minds. Esther ruminates that if she waits on finding a new gentleman that allows her time to further her pursuit of Booker and so she agrees on waiting. This is again where I just like blocked out the fact that
Magdalena is a witch. Yeah very clearly like reading tarot consulting the cards like and I just yep. So Magdalena says great I just need to borrow Booker for an hour and so Esther says okay great I'll go back to my room so she does. There she encounters an invisible man with an Irish brogue. He she kind of flops down on her bed and he's also there so he flips her over and like holds her down to the bed and like has his hand over her mouth so she doesn't scream
and he introduces himself as Ezra McKenna. He tells her that he heard of this place and went to become a member but the fees are way too high and he can't afford them. Like highway robbery. Highway robbery but that he's already seen Esther and was enamored so he had to come and take closer look and okay a lot of the language that Ezra uses here normally I would be like but he's just so endearing. He's so endearing like I'm amazed by a lot of things and how this
author creates Ezra. First of which is that this scene could be really creepy like there's this invisible man that you just like flopped onto who's in your room that then pins you down but he's so endearing he's so sweet he's not creepy and I was also amazed we'll learn more about Ezra but Catherine Moon does such a good job of creating such a clear visual of an invisible character. Yes. Like I can see this character. Yes absolutely and she does that through
describing like Esther feeling how weird it is to see her hands floating above her but feeling the person underneath her hands. Yeah or like seeing her legs like hooked around his waist but they're just sort of like in the air not hooked around anything. Yeah exactly it was so well done. So good. And I think one of the things that makes this scene okay is again Ezra is you know holding her down so she doesn't scream and like reveal him but he doesn't do anything until he gets her consent. Right he's just like yo yo whoa whoa whoa whoa hey
hey let me just I have a proposition for you. Just listen but you can't see me so I gotta we gotta talk like this. Yes and he even says he's like give me give me one night to prove it to you like prove I'll prove that I'm worth your time just one night and Esther's like I'm kind of into this. Okay. And she she describes him as being big like a mountain and like like we said how interesting it is to feel a man on top of you and not see him at all. She says that she could tell
that he had full lips and a big nose that kept nudging against her cheek reminding her to pay attention to him and he reminded her of a puppy just like attention attention. Love me. I love it so much. I love it and that's for like he gets so endearing because he's not he's not like pushy or violent he's just like please love me. He's not even grabby he's like right now like holding her down so she doesn't go anywhere and just being like huh maybe yeah okay. I just gonna like nuzzling her neck a little. Like hands to myself. Like like she could
escape if she wanted to. She could say no and he would leave. Yeah. So she decides that she wants to try them out and they fuck. He's rougher than August was closer to Mr. Tanner and Esther finds it amusing that you can't see anything of him at all and she remarks that the next time they do this she wants to use a mirror. Which I don't I don't think I would want to. I would try it. I would try it. I
just I got stuck on the like clinical aspect of like seeing my body be stretched. I get that yeah. Yeah and I just picture like I don't know it kind of creeped me out but like there are things that I would want to try. She also remarks that some things are silly like her legs being in the air seemingly unsupported by anything. So and I do like a mirror so I mean I would try it. I just think I would
be distracted. Yeah I get that. Or laughing and be like that was weird. Yeah definitely that. However as they're having this fun romp in the sack right at the very end Magdalena knocks on the door for Esther and Aman has arrived and they open the door and man what a first impression. Compounding this despite his invisibility it's clear that Aman can see Ezra like no problem and is like who
the fuck is that dude. Which definitely takes Esther by surprise because she had the thought of like well I completed something I was just pleasuring myself right energetically. I can't. But nope there's very clearly a giant man in bed with Esther. Yep yep. So this is a bit of a scene and the men are ushered out by Magdalena. She goes on to tell Esther that she's not gonna throw her out it's just a situation they have to deal with. Blame is to be had all
around. Ezra and Magdalena for Ezra not being where he should be right so getting past the wards. Aman for arriving early and putting them all in the situation to begin with. Esther for encouraging Ezra like everybody has some blame right. It's not just you know one person at fault. This is the one plot hole I think in this book where Aman said he was a day away this is now four days later but also somehow he's early. I think I have to think that they he meant a week away. Yeah that would make way more sense. Yeah but it's fine it
doesn't matter. I might downgrade four. Can you do like a 4.5? Yeah I know right. Magdalena tells Esther that she'll have to apologize and she might lose one of the men but that she should bathe first and come out and they can all discuss it in Magdalena's office afterwards. In the bath alone Esther realizes that she no longer craves just the sex like we were talking about. She has never had a prolonged time to enjoy her bed partners and she rather finds that she craves the affection as well as the sexual intimacy. Which I feel that a lot. I know yeah. I
want I want the attention afterward too. Yeah the after attention I think is sometimes the best part. Oh it super is. Yeah. After the bath Esther calls in Booker to dry her off and he does so very studiously and thoroughly. As he finishes though he does swipe a finger over her sex leaving Esther pleasantly stunned. It's the first time that he's kind of initiated any kind of physical contact between the two of them despite her trying to you know poke and prod him in that direction over the last couple of days. And it's very like it's not
subtle but it's so quick and Booker is described as having I mean he's literally made of stone so he doesn't have very expressive features and so like there's the suggestion of a smirk but like it could also potentially be played off as an accident. Yeah it could be a smirk it could be a shadow there's no way to know. There's no way to know. When Esther enters Magdalena's study she apologizes to Amon for the shock but says that she made the choice and she doesn't regret making the choice and I loved this so much because she could have easily gone
in there and be like I'm so sorry I did like I don't know what I was doing but she owns the decision she's like no I wanted to do that and I'm not sorry I did it I'm sorry if you were shocked seeing it. Sorry you busted into my room. Right I did tell you to wait but yeah I didn't mean to hurt your feelings but A as or didn't take advantage of me. Nope and I'm gonna stand by what I did. Takes two to tango. Yeah Magdalena supports her in this decision too and
reiterates that Amon isn't actually one of Esther's clients yet right because Amon brings up the thing of like he's not even one of her clients like how like how did you let this happen blah blah and she's like well actually August isn't here and you're not one of her clients yet so I don't know why you're bringing that up. Because it's a trial period. Yep. I really hated Amon for like a while. Yeah. He's a difficult character. But I think it's good like it's so good for the for the sake of the plot to have such different characters that they don't
all get along. But in this scene I was like you're being a bitch. Yeah he is and it's clear in this interaction that Amon is territorial and he needs really like a firm hand to keep him in line and Esther has that firm hand right so like he's an ancient Sphinx who's used to getting his way and then this 20 something year old girl is just like yeah you can have me but I also want him. Right so like you can take her to leave it. Take her to leave it bud yeah. Magdalena says that
she will try to sort out the issue of Ezra's membership but until then Ezra mislead the manor. Magdalena, Booker, and Ezra leave so that Amon and Esther can talk and when they're alone Amon asks why a queen like Esther would waste time with a waste girl like Ezra. But Esther doesn't like this it kind of rankles her. She feels a kinship with Ezra right they're both common people they both don't come from anything right they're both out of place in a world of finery like this. They're two peas in a pod. So she tells Amon that she's no queen she's
just a girl who likes to fuck and at that Amon laughs and tells her that he will come back the next day so that they can begin anew. Alone in her room Esther mourns the loss of Ezra and of affection from anyone her encounter with him was so brief and it ended so poorly that she's really kind of at a loss. She kind of feels dirty but it's more that she's dirty that she didn't get to properly end the interaction not that she regrets doing it. She's determined to spend the rest of the day in her own company so as to not get herself into any further entanglements as far as she can help. The next morning Magdalena
wakes Esther up at an ungodly early hour telling her that Amon is here and that stingses our morning creatures. I love that Magdalena is like I know you know even Magdalena is like you just get the fuck out so I can go back to bed. Right like I'm here because you need to be down here if you could just hurry the fuck up so I can go back to bed that'd be great. That'd be awesome. It's like the sun's not even up. It's in my head it's like three or four a.m. Oh I think it's like six o'clock which is worse. So that it actually is worse since it's no longer
nighttime. No. So Amon has sent her a gift and wishes to breakfast with Esther and this dress is essentially sheer with delicate beading all over it. Magdalena tells her that it's very traditional for the upper classes of Egypt. Whether in this century or others we don't get clarification. I have no idea it sounds gorgeous though but also a little uncomfortable. Very uncomfortable yeah because she talks about how the beads like scratch against her skin which I am not into. No and she kind of explains it about how like wow that was a terrible
sentence. She kind of talks about how it's titillating at first like it's added sensation but it eventually just becomes grating. Yeah exactly. I know it's described as beading but I get the vibe of like did you ever have like those studded belts like that topic. Yeah where the back of those studs are like the four prongs. Like that's what I'm picturing against my skin. Yeah. Which is way classier than that but like that's the feeling I'm getting. Yeah no I get
ya. So Esther is led to a private room and meets Amon there and he apologizes for his temper the other day. He's caressing her kissing her as he does this and then he says he meant it when he told Esther that she didn't need to apologize anymore that they you know have an understanding but that this morning he'll make her earn her forgiveness. Also she's been invited for breakfast and there is no food in this room. There's no food and there's
only one chair at the table. So Amon proceeds to lay Esther on the table and tease her seven ways to Sunday but he does so just by keeping her on what she describes as a low simmer not even close to her edge. So while Auguste teased her like getting her right up to the edge of an orgasm and then bringing her back down Amon is just like slowly very slowly bringing her up to a boil like over several hours and she's just
like oh my god. Like torturously slow. Yeah so again this happens over several hours and finally like noon. Yes at some point Esther is delirious she's fully naked at this point she's like literally weeping from begging to have some kind of relief and at this point Amon finally relents and fucks her properly. She feels while he does so a little something extra inside it's like a little bit of a
tug when he moves and he tells her that he has a hook on his dick and it's a unique feature of Sphinx's. She loves the fuck out of it and is delirious with pleasure. She's like this is great this is great. Yeah love that. Afterwards so she's delirious she kind of passes out after you know the orgasms or whatever and she wakes up to like kind of being snuggled in a window seat and Amon is feeding her water. His tail is kind of wrapped loosely around her ankle and
this is something that will become kind of a habit of his but I absolutely loved it's just a little bit like a passive touch. Yes and like that level of possessiveness I think I referenced this many episodes ago where I was talking about something with a tail and I couldn't remember where it came from and it was this or like the little it's a little bit. Just a little bit yeah. Yeah I love that just the passive touch the connection and a little bit of possessiveness like I'm gonna I hold your foot now. It's mine. Yeah it's mine. It's mine. I have
this. It has this. I made this. As he's feeding her water Amon apologizes that he should have fed her first but he was too impatient. He asks if she feels pain anywhere but she does not and though she's specified she does not but she specifies that she doesn't want to repeat the show that happened that morning. Like it was not exactly fun but it paid off. Right exactly. Later that evening
Esther and Amon again talk about Ezra. Amon reiterates that he that Ezra is a scoundrel who will keep no promises to Esther and is not worthy of her and of course Esther doesn't have any evidence to the contrary she hasn't seen Esther since that day and doesn't really have anything to refute it but she's firm in her own position that she would take Ezra as a client if she could. Amon leaves the next day to look for a house nearby so he can be close to Esther right so he lives in Egypt but obviously needs a place to stay outside of Rik's grave
manor while he's there and so Esther has a proper breakfast with the other girls. During this she realizes that there's a new face and this is a blonde who's not quite into the whole idea of the manor as the other girls. She kind of mocks Esther for howling most of the day the day before when Amon was teasing her or earning her forgiveness and Esther tells her it's because Sphinx's have unique cocks and the girl looks horrified and Esther's like I liked it and most of the
other girls ask more questions they're like oh my gosh tell me more. Yeah or sure that their own suitors also have differently unique cocks. Yes exactly. We learned that this new girl's name is Mary and that she's going to town that day to buy herself something nice after having to spend an evening with a gentleman that she doesn't like. For some reason Esther agrees to go with her determined to buy nicer boots for herself. Which like okay girl get you some boots but Mary is unpleasant from the get-go so I know why are you going with
her. I don't know. I don't understand why she's going because Mary it's very clear as they walk Mary is not fond of her role at the manor she actually has a pretty strong disdain for both of her clients. She talks about how she had other clients who've moved on to other houses so I guess she's not exactly new it's just a new face to Esther but like now she only has two. She tells Esther about her dream of saving money enough to leave the manor and leave this way of life behind entirely. We get a little bit of information on Mary's suitors and
like maybe why she's not into them like it seems like one has maybe some more violent proclivities. Definitely more BDSM because he wants to chain her up. Yeah but what confuses me is that we do know that Magdalena puts so much thought into pairing people. So like Mary's one I was referencing earlier that I want to know more about her because like everything is in your control at least as far as we know so like why are you why do you hate this why are you here why are you
keeping these suitors and Esther even remarks to herself that sort of to soothe herself in hearing this troubling information that like maybe Mary and her men are both kind of terrible so they deserve each other. Yeah I have to think that that's something along those lines right like it strikes me that Esther and her companions are special in that Esther is kind of tenderhearted right but then her men are also tenderhearted as well like they can't just take they
wouldn't be happy with just anybody but there's terrible people everywhere right so like yeah maybe these men are also insufferable but to Esther's point like Mary's talking about how one of her clients wants to chain her up and Esther's like I mean are they nice chains. I know what do you mean I'm kind of okay with that. And also in her teasing with Aman he does chain her up but they're gold. But they're gold cups. Yeah they are. Yeah of course they are. That are like controlled by his magic like they're not actually like hooked anything. So if you're
gonna chain me up it better be in solid gold okay. Listen so I think it's a fair question to be like are they nice change or are they like rusty gross chains. There's a difference. There is a difference. She Mary does make a remark that one of her men the one that wanted to chain her up would have would dress her and nothing more than rags and have her think him for it or something like that. So it could just also be that he's also an asshole. Yeah which then they deserve each other and that adds some more to like how bad ass and terrifying Magdalena is where she's like all right yeah here you go. A little bit you two deserve each
other. Yeah and I picture one of the gentlemen just pestering Magdalena for like literally decades until she's finally like you know what fine fine there you go. Enjoy. Enjoy that. But also genuinely Mary is the worst. She's the worst. Yeah. Horrible. So there's one other thing about this conversation. It makes Esther think about life after the manner and it's something that she had never considered before. I mean she's only been there for a week but she didn't ever really consider the possibility of like moving on or what a future would
look like. She's not even sure what that future beyond the manner would look like or what she would even want. Later that evening Amon doesn't return so Esther decides to go down to the party, the kind of nocturnal events at the manner. But before she does she runs into Booker who realizes that Esther is sad missing her gentlemen. They kind of have a little bit of a stilted conversation back and forth. I say conversation Booker's very nonverbal. He speaks in one word sentences very often. Yeah. So it's really just you know Esther talking at him
and he's saying one word answers back to her. Yeah. I also have the creation of Booker though because that could very much come across as if he's like not intelligent which would seem creepy to me. Right. But like he's written in such a way that like he's there for the conversation. Like in there in the first conversation he was like missing what she was asking but he seems to like he seems to know what she's saying and engages in the conversation where it's not that he's just like being taken advantage of. 100%. Yeah. Magdalena comes
upon them and she seems distracted. She's like kind of muttering under her breath and like looking around like she's looking for something. But she ultimately tells Booker to take Esther back to her room because Esther is still kind of new and doesn't have a whole lot of clients and so she doesn't want her partaking in the nocturnal events. Sorry. Every time you say nocturnal events I think about nocturnal emissions aka wet dream. I'm laughing every time you say it. Amazing. I feel kind of
clarified. I was like this is a perfectly adequate way to explain this but I'm just like nocturnal emissions. Nocturnal emissions. Which is not not what's happening. No. I mean look. So before Booker takes her back to her room Esther asks the madam what's wrong but Magdalena just tells her she doesn't know. Like she's she knows that something is wrong but she doesn't know what it is to even tell Esther or herself. Back in her room Esther is disappointed to find herself
hoping that Ezra is waiting for her but he's not. But as she's undressing she does feel like she's being watched. She calls out for Ezra but she gets no answer and she feels uneasy as she goes to sleep. This was so creepy to me because they have when she first meets Ezra they do have a brief conversation where she's like oh I want you to just like sneak up on me and have your way with things you're invisible and so she kind of enters the room like hoping thinking he's there and putting on this show of getting undressed but when he's not there
she still feels watched and so I just like I could viscerally feel that like I thought I was comfortable and happy and sexy and now I'm just terrified. Right. Like such a shift. Who's watching me? Yeah and it's not who I want to be watching me. Creepy. Yeah very creepy. We don't get an answer to who might have been watching her but I think it's probably Bertha right? That's what I was thinking. Yeah. In the morning Booker is sitting on Esther's bed. He tells her that she has a visitor
waiting for her with Magdalena and so he's going to dress her. When she's dressed Booker holds Esther upright by her neck and fingers her until she comes twice. Esther remarks that his fingers are cool like stone and Esther finds them exquisite and I thought this scene was so incredibly just erotic. It was like this scene for how simple it is has no right to be as hot as it is. Yeah because
like it's so hard to explain but this offer has created this relationship between Booker and Esther to the point where like there are there's no communication as to what Booker wants to and then does to Esther but Esther is like a hundred percent there for it and it's just like the it's almost consensual non-consent. Yes because there's no it's towing that line. It's towing that line. I think that might be why Booker is like okay so there's five men he's in my like top two.
Yeah I can't wait to talk about favorites. I know and also I change as we talk about it because like oh yeah they're all pretty delightful. I mean it's gonna be your favorites at the end of this conversation. I'm sure it'll change the next time we talk about it. Exactly the next time I revisit it. Right. After he pleasures Esther Booker cleans one finger off with his own mouth and then makes Esther clean the other off with her mouth and he tells her that he'd like to do
that every morning and that for anything further that she wants from him he'll be ready but obviously not that verbose right it's just like a couple of words here. The scene is also like unfairly funny because like he's made of stone right so he's just sort of hard but she like I think she wonders aloud like well can you like get an erection or are you just is it just gonna be the fingers like right because she can't really have a penis right because like
your mate you're stone doll down there yeah and that's where he's just like I think he like essentially flexes his dick like I can make it hard on command so like I'll be ready yeah yeah yeah it's great so great all right so after this one Esther is thrilled at the idea of getting fingered every morning until she comes twice. Girl say you! Especially like that god damn. Like you're gonna dress me first?
Okay okay sign me up. To do no work here? Yes please. So Esther goes to see Magdalena and Magdalena tells her that a member of another house is traveling through and has requested company for one evening. Magdalena offers the experience to Esther who asks whether her gentleman would mind right so Auguste and Amon and Magdalena puts her mind at ease even though she admits that it's a bit of an unusual case she said you know it's it's your choice fully I'm sure that Auguste and Amon wouldn't mind or Dr. Underwood but you know it's up to you. Magdalena
goes on to admit that things have been off and she has a funny feeling and that's why she would normally take care of this herself but she feels like she needs to be vigilant so Esther ultimately agrees. Later that evening Booker takes Esther down to a subterranean grotto to meet the client and we learned that the client is supposed to be a water demon. Booker tells Esther to enter the water and that the client will meet her there and Esther is trepidatious because she can't swim but she starts to enter the water and as she does so the demon or something that looks like a demon appears and he
communicates to her in kind of this eerie voice that's kind of coming from this figure but also kind of bouncing around the room and it's kind of hard to tell and it tells her to come deeper into the water. Esther realizes as she's going deeper into the water that this person is using the water already to caress her body so like touching her in ways that they haven't talked about yet and honestly she's not really comfortable with given that she doesn't feel safe in this situation. He also it's terrifying like even up to this point
it's still really creepy because she describes that she can like see him in the water but just kind of sees like a head with I think like long like dark hair floating in the water and just his eyes above the water. Yeah. That keeps like retreating into the darkness. Yeah like she moves closer and he moves back so they're always the same distance away. Which so creepy. I hated. It was so scary. So he asks her if she's afraid of the water and she says yeah I can't swim and he's like don't worry don't be afraid of the water and my note is like okay I'll
get right on that thanks dude. Right like what? Oh I shouldn't be afraid. Let me get right on that. Yeah it's like just tell me to calm down and I'll be fine. Right. Fuck you bro. As you might imagine this interaction takes a turn for the words pretty quickly. The water demon pursues Esther further despite Esther not being able to swim. The water is very forward pushing against her skin in a way that Esther doesn't like like I mentioned and then it pulls her under. Something wrapped around her ankle and pulls her under the water. She tries to call out
for help for Booker but the water pushes into her mouth and it's described as using her mouth almost sexually but it's water and just the description of what's happening to her is just so viscerally upsetting. It's horrifying. And also Kudos again to Catherine Moon for writing such a fucking scary essentially rapes scene with water. I know right. Truly. So scary. The water demon is speaking and it's kind of echoing around Esther as she's trying to
get away and not drown and he's saying things like he'll quote take her to him and he'll be pleased with her etc. As Esther starts to drown she starts thinking that if this man is kidnapping her that it might be best for her to die instead of to live through that fate but then as she's kind of losing consciousness an opposite force tries to start pulling her up and away from what's pulling her down and it's pulling on her arm. This force eventually wins and as she comes
sputtering out of the water we learn that it's Ezra who saved her. And I okay I love this for a number of different reasons. Of everybody who could have saved her I'm glad it was Esther because Aman had put that little like seed of doubt of like he's not gonna keep any promises to you. Yes. But he was staying close to her the whole time and like saved her and just I love that poetic like come back around. Yes and it's so good too because like Aman does place that doubt and Esther does kind of start to question it and part of the what
would draws her to Ezra in the first place is that he reminds her of like the other guys that she's fooled around with like the outtrimmonent fun yeah I'm trying to channel you're like we create we came up in the city together but we came up in the towel together. I couldn't remember the word tower. I was like this is wrong but I want to channel this moment. Also I think you
mentioned it before but like after the night with Ezra since he is not a member he was like banned from the premises until they could work it out but he's been sticking around to like watch her and keep her safe anyway without without actually like being in her room or like letting her know so it's like keeping her safe because he actually cares about her. And so to save her like you said like Aman you're wrong like he will stick around he's not just he didn't just use me for a moment. Right this is also a great way to kind of for
for Ezra to insinuate himself into like Esther's circle which is great. Yes. So when Esther wakes up she calls out for Ezra because she remembers him saving her and he's holding her in bed right so he's there and warm and keeping her safe and August is there too and August tells her that he is taking care of Ezra's membership so Ezra is allowed to be there like she doesn't have to panic right because she says you're not supposed to be here or something like that. You're gonna get in trouble. Don't worry about it I have more money than God.
I'm taking care of it. Which I love that August is so like girl get you some men I'm here for all of these men. I mean but August is also kind of into the bed so like it works for him too. Which is my fate oh yeah and I love it. Mr. Tanner is also in the room and he tells Esther that it was a water wraith and not the water demon client that it was supposed to be. The water wraith was masquerading as that client and that was what attacked her. It was a being that's very adept at
illusions. I wanted to know more about what the water we water women. The water women. The water women. I wanted to know more about what the water demon actually would have been like. Yeah and we might get that in further books. I hope so and the fact that there's water wraiths I can just be like I'm also gonna do this. Yeah no thank you. Like is there not a test for that? I don't know.
So Tanner is there and it's also clear that he and or Dr. Underwood have like addressed her wounds so like her ankle is wrapped and things like that so he they've been taking care of her while she's been recovering. Booker is also there and he is like mortified and just totally bereft and tells her that he can't swim as a way of explaining to her why he didn't come to save her and it was it had to be somebody else. Which bro you're made of stone of course you
can't swim. And Esther even says that but Ezra says that you know he found he came upon Booker screaming for Esther like basically underwater trying to get to her. Which is just so so sweet. I know and then with Ezra pulling her out and like sends Booker to like go get help and Booker's like okay. Yeah I help. I help. But I help. Yeah it's so sweet. It's at that moment that Magdalena joins them in the room
and is apologizing profusely to Esther for the attack and she should have you know had better words etc. But Augusta's having none. He is furious with madam and asks her what the fuck kind of establishment are you running here. I thought everybody was supposed to be safe. What the hell. Esther tries to diffuse the situation by asking whether anyone's interested in what the Wraith actually said to her and it kind of works right. Yeah. And then turns to look at her but
then of course right on cue Aman arrives. He's equally furious as Augusta's but he says something to the effect that the madam the madam needs to take better care of their property which royally pisses Esther the fuck off. Does not like that. No and she orders everyone to one calm the fuck down to take a fucking seat three shut the fuck up which they all do. Which like she's got that power
move. And I love that Aman like didn't get a spot on the bed so he's just like pouting in the corner with his arms crossed. I know. Because he came in like a little bitch. It is. What I found interesting here is that we again this is kind of like her feeling of being watched. I don't know if we get confirmation of like what the Wraith was going to take her to. But I think it's the same answer we get at the end. But what's odd is that we do get we do get that there's the question
of like did you set Esther up for this. And my dam is like no like I was going to do it myself. I even offered it to two other people before her so like so she wasn't being targeted. But that makes me wonder was the Wraith just going to take her to like the Wraith or was it going to take her to someone else. Well I think I don't know. So this is where some of the there are some questions in this plot right like so I don't know actually if it was Bertha watching her if it was the
water Wraith that was watching her in her room because I think the only reason that Bertha gets interested in Esther is because she like fouls his plan of bringing down Rick's grave house right. She escapes the kidnap attempt. Okay right. The girls at the other two houses did not. I forgot about that. I've only read that part once okay. Look I get it. In the same conversation Amon proposes that Esther moved into his new property that he's just bought down the street and Esther flatly refuses. She's like nope look but just what she said
Liz the madam offered this visitor to two other people beforehand. It's not me that's being particularly targeted plus if I go to your house you're not going to treat the other men fairly and I don't want that. And Amon's just like you're right fine. And up to this point bro like you're not earning a lot of by endearment. No. Except for your special dick. Right your special dick is fine. He can stay. He can stay. So the matter is kind of settled right they kind of have their marching orders to go into you know researching into a little bit more
digging what happened, focus on the wards that kind of thing. So August and Booker go to cook a meal for the group. There's always one or at least one that cooks in a river of sarm which I love. Always. The madam excuses herself to basically take another look at the wards and make sure that they're intact. And Esther asks the remaining men if she can speak privately with Amon. So they move into her private sitting room and she asks him whether he's angry with her for refusing to move into his house and he says not. She asks whether he's
coping with the others and he admits truthfully that it's hard but that he'll do anything to keep her at his side. This is where he starts to come around to me. Right. Crucially she asks whether he'll do that as a lover or as a possession and he unconvincingly says lover. And she says oh boy we're gonna have to work on you. They kiss and make up but they stop short of doing anything else because Amon says one if I'm going to start learning to behave I should
start now. It's not my night but also you are injured. You need to rest. You need to chill. Right. So he deposits her back with Dr. Underwood and Ezra. So Dr. Underwood is back and Mr. Tanner is gone. Which this also in a long way went a long way for me to come around on Amon because he does like give her back to Ezra and doesn't put up that fight about Ezra anymore. Right. Exactly. Which is I so I love this kind of this it's a plot device but I love that it solved two
problems at once. Right. It gives them on a reason to not hate Ezra and it also gives Ezra a reason to validly be in Brooksgrave manner. Yes. It was a great way to do a plot device. Yes. I loved it. So Dr. Underwood tells Ezra to see to ester in the bath even though it's supposed to be the doctor's night. He admits that he'll have plenty of time with her when they're in London together in the next couple of days and he's aware that Ezra's first time with ester was cut short. Ezra tells ester quote what I think he means is that I owe you a
proper cuddle. I love me a proper cuddle. I know. And again like going back to the ester learning things about herself like just the amount of like physical intimacy that's not sexual here is just really meaningful because she gets it with every single one of her gentlemen companions. So in the bath ester feels a little bit uneasy both from what happened and from the uneven footing that she has with Ezra. She's not really sure what to do with herself. She asks him whether he's being nice because she almost died and he vehemently tells her
that a place by her side is a privilege that he would not easily part with. She tries as they are in the bath to get a rise out of him and get him to engage with her sexually but he tells her that he wants her to rest. He bathes her and afterwards deposits her with a goose to feeds her actual food. In the morning when ester wakes up dr. Underwood is there and they talk about his relationship with mr. Tanner. He tells her that Tanner is mostly in control most of the time and
maybe one day he'll be able to share ester with Dr. Tanner or with dr. Underwood right like so they'll be able to share her equally but that right now neither of them could be as gentle with her as they need to be and so they're kind of holding themselves back. Swoon. The Darcy hand clenching of it all. Every time. That evening ester travels with Auguste and dr. Underwood to London. London. The next morning ester
wakes up in one of Auguste's houses and she's woken up by one of his staffs who is a non-human woman named Cork who is gruff but not unkind. Okay I hate to reference this book right now but in cool friends wasn't one of the servants named Cork. I think so. Okay I was like fuck this name. I know I know. It's fine but it doesn't matter. So Cork gets her dressed and takes her to breakfast and after ester eats dr. Underwood comes in
and tells her that he'll be dropping her off at the seamstresses to go to the theater that evening. She's got nothing proper to wear and the seamstress will see to that. The show that they're seeing he shares is not one that she'll see on a marquee but she can't get any more details out of him than that. She even goes so far as to try to seduce him into telling her what the show is about but he resists telling her that there will be no orgasms before dinner. I love this all. Okay the scene that's coming up is the scene that I most often
revisit. Oh okay so Esther goes to the modest and is fitted for six dresses. She muses that perhaps Auguste and Amon aren't so different from each other each trying to make her into a fine lady and she admits to herself that maybe she doesn't mind the attention so much. No girl. I know I wouldn't. I would love to just be taken and fitted for dresses. Right. Later Auguste loves the dress that she chooses for the evening even if Esther doesn't. It's very tightly corseted and she's like very immobile and uncomfortable but she looks like a
million bucks. As we ladies do. Look beauty is pain I guess. Before they go to dinner Auguste gives her a set of sapphire jewelry and Esther is taken aback. She's like I you know you don't have to give this to me right like I just want you and he says I want to spoil you and so I will. Which I love her like ever since her conversation with Mary though she doesn't like acknowledge that conversation with her gentlemen I feel like that's kind of in the back of
her head like I'm not here just to use you like I genuinely like your company and I like that. I do too yeah I mean she at every turn she's like this is a lot and it's very unnecessary right like you know that. Right and like I'm getting paid very handsomely beyond the fact that I'm just happy to have all of you. Right exactly. He also makes a comment where he's like I think it's like an earrings and a necklace he's like you can wear whatever you want but I prefer if you did if you left your neck bare. Yes okay. I wonder why. No no we'll never know.
I'll never know. So that evening over dinner Esther gets to see how Auguste guss to the doctor and Dr. Underwood bicker like an old married couple and she finds it incredibly charming it's clear that they're good friends and they go back a long way. They go to the theater and the theater that they go to is in a dingier part of town which surprises and intrigues Esther and to get to it they have to go into this maze of alleyways because the theater is physically and
magically hidden back in this maze so they go back into this alleyway and then suddenly they're just in this big grand theater. We learn that the presentation are to show that they're about to see is going to be given by a troop called the Company of Fiends. Interestingly enough the second book follows some of the actors or I'll say performers in this company. As they make their way to the box that Auguste and the doctor share Esther feels a chill down her spine that reminds her of the Wraith attack but she shakes it off and in the box the men
brief her on what's about to transpire. They feel that she might find some of the scenes triggering after the attack so they just want to prepare her. They tell her that everybody participating is a hundred percent consenting and no one is in danger but if she ever wishes to leave she just needs to say the word and they absolutely will. Which the communication here like they probably would have given her this disclaimer anyway but on the heels of her being attacked like you might be a little more sensitive than we originally thought you would be to this because of recent trauma so we're just gonna make sure
you're good. Everyone's safe. So the first the show begins and the first act is a chase scene. A woman in a flimsy nightgown is pursued and captured by two were bears who chain her to a stone altar and have their way with her. Were bears. Were bears. Is this one of the scenes that you revisit often? It's this entire theater like montage honestly. Because it is very like bam bam bam.
Yeah like it's there's a there's a for it to be a bookmarked place in my book you get a lot of diversity. Uh-huh yeah I can see that. So they're having their way with her but before things can get too hot and heavy the second act begins and Esther complains that they didn't even fuck her properly like what kind of show is this? Like what is this cheap show? And August kind of chastises her he's like that was just an appetizer be patient. Like calm the fuck down girl. Yeah. The
next scene is more of an orgy so seven humans are in varying stages of a strain on stage and two demons who are winged and horned come out and begin pleasuring two of them. They're quickly joined by a clay golem with a paddle who uses that to spank several of the humans on stage. Just air buddy. Yep so this scene includes the spanking and obviously group sex and Esther is fascinated it's the first time she's ever seen something like this and both
August and Dr. Underwater just like see I told you she's like it. And they're also like they're starting to like touch her and like loosen our corset and she's just like in raptor she's like okay fine do whatever you're doing but like I'm looking at this. Yeah I mean especially the loosening of the corset she's like oh thank god I can breathe that's fantastic. Right. Do more of that. Keep doing that. Yeah. During intermission her men still tease her even though she's begging for more she gives August a blowjob while Dr. Underwood fingers her but she's
dissatisfied. They don't actually like give her what she wants and the doctor asks if she would like to participate in the final act as it's open to volunteers and she absolutely does. Like without hesitation she's like do you want to she's like yes. No further questions needed. No follow-up questions it's fine. The second to last scene involves a tentacle monster and five women so you guys have all seen tentacle porn right guys. That's what this is. That's what this is. You guys have all seen tentacle porn right guys. It's pretty
straightforward. Yeah I mean there's nothing even if you haven't seen tentacle porn. Yeah. Even if you haven't seen tentacle porn just use your imagination for 2.5 seconds that's what happens. Uh-huh yeah this thing has like suckers on the end of it so it's not like an octopus kind of tentacle it's like a tentacle with a sucker optionally. It's like is it called anything is it like a kraken or am I just thinking of Katie Robert? It's it has a Japanese name. Oh
yeah yeah okay yeah which I think is its own porn search term actually. Oh of course it is. That name I don't frequent tentacle porn but that name looks like a name that I've seen before. Yeah sure Dan okay. Alright so my note here is cue the public sex act scene. Okay so I am not into public sex acts but every single one of these books seems to have one for some
reason. They do. Esther does the scene with Dr. Underwood and Mr. Tanner. So before they're slated to go on Dr. Underwood tells Esther what to do. She becomes uncomfortable and wants to end the show so it gives her you know kind of that safety net of like anytime you pull the ripcord we get out of there. In their act the doctor uses another different vibrating machine on Esther and they do the whole sir bit like they did when they first had a sexual
encounter. So this vibrating machine is more like electrical shocks? Yeah. I wasn't into that. No this whole scene is not it's not my vibe for a number of different reasons. No so like everything up to this point is like my bookmarked because I like I do have that like voyeurism exhibitionist but then the I don't want to be on stage. I want to like be with my men in the background like knowing we could get caught but also knowing that like we're in a private
box and fuck everybody else. Right and like if I got caught it's also like everyone else is fucking do so yeah exactly. At some point the doctor is overtaken by Tanner and this is when the machine is put to the side and it's minimorph in fucking time. Esther begs to see Tanner and Tanner finally relents bracing himself for the rejection telling her that he is not her gentleman but obviously Esther pays no mind right. She loves the way that all of her men are and look and treat her and so she accepts him wholeheartedly and this is
the point at which Esther wins over Mr. Tanner completely. Which is just palsy to do like on a stage. It's super is because they're having this kind of like intimate moment for their relationship in fully public view. Yeah and like for Mr. Tanner to like have this vulnerable moment and he's prepared for rejection I would be like no no no we're gonna do this in the privacy of like your own room where I can cry if I need to. Right. Doing this on a stage. Right. They're crazy. But so in in the kind of physical logistics of Tanner like bringing her up
and like turning her around to face him she gets a good look at the crowd and in this moment Esther realizes someone in the audience is watching her in a different way than all the others in a much more hostile way and she gets that feeling of ice down her spine again reminding her of the wraith and she tells Mr. Tanner mid-performance that someone's watching them. Tanner immediately understands what she's talking about in Auguste and Tanner immediately understand that this person is someone named Bercha. This person
makes them hurry Esther off the stage and out of the theater as quickly as possible and in the carriage they tell her that Bercha was the king of Gomorrah as in Sodom and he owns clubs like Rooksgrave but his clubs are open to all and they take no consideration of the women working there so they're more like indentured servitude sex clubs. Oh. They tell her that Bercha would destroy someone like Esther because he would take something that she loves and turn it into something that she hates. Which is horrifying. Yeah. In the morning or
early afternoon Esther wakes up snuggled with a doctor and they finally are able to copulate without Tanner or someone else interrupting so this is important because Tanner is deciding to share Esther with Dr. Underwood and kind of the undercurrent here that we don't really get verbal confirmation on is it feels like Tanner is protecting Dr. Underwood from people who wouldn't accept him and once Esther accepted Tanner he realized that it was okay to let Dr. Underwood in as well. Yeah. That's undercurrent I got and it's really sweet.
It's really nice. In this scene Dr. Underwood tells Esther that she has both he and Tanner willingly and Esther is incredibly over the moon. Of course. Of course. Later they talk about Bercha and what to do. The doctor lets on that Bercha had tried to add Tanner to his collection and was furious when he couldn't. The conversation is short-lived though as they decide to wake August. It's then that the doctor shares with Esther that he and August also have a
sexual relationship and Esther is intrigued by this. This is my second bookmark. Yeah. Actually they're all bookmarks but this is like my second visit. Yeah. So Esther starts to wake up August with a blowjob but this quickly turns into a threesome with the doctor as well. Highly recommend. Highly recommend. Highly recommend. Yep. So they travel back to Rooksgrave right? It's because they've been in London this entire time and they meet with Magdalena and the heads of two of the
sister houses to Rooksgrave Manor. They talk about Bercha and the threat he poses and we learn that he stole two girls one from each of the other house in a similar manner that Esther was attacked. Bercha seems to be targeting the houses to put them out of business and steal their clientele and make, put his houses in a better position to have a monopoly on that kind of business. Just gross. Very gross. Esther and August bathe with bookers help and talk about the situation. It's not sexual. No it's not. It's just. It's really just a bath. Like
he's just there to help. Yep. They talk about how with the help of the other houses they'll be stronger and how Bercha was human but is somehow immortal now and it's clear that August is worried about whatever is brewing. He also shares with Esther that there's kind of a hierarchy to her posse of men with Amon being at the top because he's so ancient and so powerful and August is second. After that would be Dr. Underwood slash Mr. Tanner. After that would be Booker and then Ezra's at the bottom because he's essentially just a human who's been cursed. Yeah. I don't know if we mentioned that but he's
invisible because he went to a witch. He asked to like be stealthy because he's also a bit of a thief and she just made him invisible. Yeah. Which is great. The next morning Esther wakes up and she's being pleasured by a man who she doesn't recognize but soon realizes as Ezra. He has quote a big nose massive full lips for sucking, blondish red hair tossed messily around his head, the sides shaved freckles over his nose and cheeks and down into his red beard and we
learned that Magdalena has bestowed a gift upon Ezra that allows him to be seen or non-invisible visible if he concentrates hard enough. Obviously that gets more and more difficult as he's in the throws of passion. Which is hilarious. Right. So like they have a romp and in the scene Esther even makes a game of it. She's like let's see how long I can see you during this. It starts to kind of like flicker. Yeah exactly. After this Esther meets with Magdalena again and she tells Esther that Amon is
on his way. She also tells Esther that she's working hard to secure the safety of the manor working on the wards and making sure that there's no way that anybody can slip through. Esther thanks her for helping Ezra and for doing all that she does. And this scene really brings them together a bit more than madam and employer because they're having this conversation over tea right. It's very much a social visit. They're sharing kind of where they're at in their different places. Sharing information about the the things that the issues that bring them together. And it's a continuation of a friendship for
Esther which I like because it's not just about the sexual relationships that she's got with her gentlemen. Which is good because I also get the vibe that she doesn't have a lot of like she's never had a lot of female friends or friends in general. Right. Later Amon and Esther walk around the lock. Amon tells Esther that he doesn't know where he stands with her. He's kind of feeling like on uneven footing. And she tells him that she knows he will be good to her but she also needs to know that he'll be good to the other men. She says that
she's falling in love with them and that she could fall in love with Amon too. But she doesn't want to jeopardize what she has with the others. Amon eventually agrees that he will try and she asks that he learn from the others and from her as she's sure that they will learn from him. And he agrees. As he leaves, August meets Esther kind of at the front steps and they watch Amon's carriage pull away and August asks Esther whether she's decided to tame him and she says she has. And August is pleased about this because between Amon and Tanner no one would
dare bother Esther and so August has very little to do in the way of protection himself. Which I love that he's just like great. Works for me. I don't have to worry about you. I can just enjoy you. Wonderful. And all these other men. Right. In the morning Booker is in bed with her and proceeds to do his duty with his index fingers as he promised he would. And Esther asks for more but Booker tells her that August told him to wait until that evening and Esther
realizes it's because August wants to watch. Which I love that he like orchestrated that. Right. Like he heard her clock that but also really wants it for himself. Uh-huh. Later Esther goes out walking to meet Ezra and when she meets him she's expecting kind of a sexy like sneak up upon me you know Dantle and distress kind of situation but instead they are interrupted because they come upon Mary and Jacob poems the village boy fucking in the woods and it's clear after they
finished that Jacob paid Mary for the romp so she's like moonlighting is just like a regular sex worker too and Esther has no idea why she's doing this. No because it's there's no way that Jacob is paying her near the rate that she is getting paid and like she could just leave she's not indentured. It's like being paid 200 bucks an hour at your day job and then taking a side hustle for $5. Yeah. What are you doing? What are you doing? And she doesn't really seem to
enjoy sex so like really what are you doing? Right. Later that evening Esther and August are in the sitting room with other couples so this is the first time that Esther's been out in one of the evening kind of nocturnal events and Esther is peeved that she didn't get time to spend with Ezra and that Ezra's been kind of kept busy by Magdalena testing the wards and doing some other kind of erranty things for her. She's also peeved that Ezra's not there this evening with them to spend time with them. August won't say whether he knows why Ezra's not
there and he prods her to just enjoy the evening but she asks whether they can go to bed and get the night over with and he tells her I want to show you off so just stay with me. Okay. August offers her a drink and Esther asks whether she would make a pretty vampire and August tells her to ask him again in a year. Esther is surprised at her own brazenness and August's own openness to the idea. She realizes that what she's asking for essentially is literally forever. And the acceptance of August being like maybe. Okay. Yeah. Ask me in a year. Yeah. Sounds great.
I'm cool with you being here forever. So as the evening progresses the couples get more and more intimate and Esther is enthralled. So this very quickly becomes one of those if you've read a book like this before it's a scene where it's a room where people have public sex but there's not a show right so it's just kind of like a lounge area. Some people are having sex some people are watching some people are just having cocktails some people are doing all three. So Esther Esther is enthralled and she tells August that she wants to watch and at that
point Ezra has come up behind her and whispers in her ear that they can do much better than watch. I think this is probably bookmark number two. Yeah this is a really good scene. So Ezra, August and Booker proceed to have their way with Esther in the middle of the sitting room while other couples watch. I think they just we're gonna go to the middle okay. The middle I mean it's the only place where they can all three have like enough space. That's true. You're right now. Of course not. So this scene is great. It has some amount of teasing. It definitely has oral. Definitely has
double penetration. Booker's there too with his stone stuff. It's it checks so many boxes. Indeed it does. Afterward Esther and her men snuggle in bed. So August, Booker, Ezra. She tells a goose that she would never give up any one of them for just one fearing that he might have taken her taunting during their threesome or foursome I guess to make him jealous too seriously. So in that scene he had told her to make him jealous to make everybody jealous and she really went for
it right and she doesn't want to have any misconceptions that she would ever actually do that or betray his trust in any way. Which I love the communication. I know because he goes on to say that everything's fine. They both had like they both admit to liking the headiness of that possessiveness but only because they know that they're safe with each other right that there's not actually a reason to be possessive in a controlling unhealthy way. Yes or a way to like taunt you in the trying to make you jealous toxic kind of way. Exactly. In the
morning Ezra and August are gone but Booker is there. He comes to hold her and holds her throat right so she's thinking that she's gonna get her morning fluff. And Esther is at ease until he starts to tighten his grip until it's uncomfortable and it becomes apparent that Berja has possessed Booker to get to Esther. Which is terrifying. Yeah using someone she trusts and potentially loves to get too close to her in retaliation for escaping his kidnapped attempt. And specifically I mean they're all incredibly strong but using someone made of stone like she can't she's not gonna be able to fight
this guy off. No. Physically. Berja through Booker is telling her that Booker is just an empty husk waiting to be filled with somebody else's magic but Esther doesn't believe that and she reaches up to soothe Booker's face and try to make him fight back. And it works. Booker does fight off Berja and pushes him out of his mind and as he's doing so Dr. Underwood comes upon them and is horrified. He sees Booker hurting Esther but Esther tells him that Booker's done nothing
wrong, that Berja has taken control. And finally Booker lets her go. Berja has been pushed out completely. Tanner comes out so the doctor loses his shit a little bit and Tanner comes out and he grabs Esther and cuddles her to him while most of the other men arrive and Magdalena does as well to confer. Magdalena suggests that they tether Booker again because he's lost his tether to Magdalena and since he's a magical construct it makes him susceptible to attacks like these. But
she pauses that rather than tethering her or tethering him to Magdalena they tether him to Esther. Esther at first protests not wanting to infringe on Booker's free will but Booker ultimately tells her that it's okay it's what he would want and Esther is persuaded to do so. This is a really sweet moment with her like I don't want to control you I don't want you to be tied to me. He's like no please. Yeah it's really cute. He says something to the effect that he just wants to serve her. I know. I know.
Later that day Amon arrives and heals Esther's necks because it's you know really bruised. A little tender and in the hallway they overhear Mary being thrown out of the house. Amon tells yeah fuck you Mary. Amon tells Esther not to worry that Mary's gonna survive and land on her feet and he shares a bit about why she came here in the first place that she had an older husband to whom she was betrothed and he hurt her and so she ran until she found Rook's grave
manner and he tells her he knows all of these things because it's the power of the Sphinxes to know. Later that evening Auguste reacts to the news of the attack by Esther by trying to bite Booker and it doesn't go well with him. Because she's made of snow. You can't bite that even if you're a very strong vampire. Right so once Auguste comes down the ceremony to tether Booker to Esther takes place and of course Bersha tries to sabotage it but Amon
lends his magic to Magdalena and the ceremony is completed successfully. Esther through her connection with Booker feels the affection and appreciation that Booker feels for her and taking a genuine interest in who he is and that's why he's been so drawn to her. And recognizing that he is like his own person. He's not just this vessel for magic. Yeah exactly. Later they all form a cuddle puddle in bed and Amon invites them all over for dinner. It's like the first olive branch that he extends because Auguste even remarks like I'm
surprised you don't want to take Esther for yourself since it's like your night and Amon tells him simply that a dinner with all of us would please Esther and so that's what I'm gonna do. He really comes around. I'm like this is great. This is fine. Yeah he goes from asshole to like cuddly asshole really quick and I appreciate it. Yeah but he also like keeps his personality like they all keep very consistent personalities. Yeah I like that he wasn't like an asshole for 3,000 years and then it suddenly just like fine. No and like his struggle with it all does make sense like culturally for who he is but his like well I don't
want to lose you so I guess we're all one family. Right so then between that scene and the dinner scene we get a scene with Ezra Booker and Dr. Underwood and my note is just holy hell this book just keeps going holy fuck. It really does and we get so many different combinations which I appreciate. I know so this scene Ezra has like done the thing where he sneaks up on Esther and like is sexing her like very close to being caught. Sexing her. And then like after
he's pleasured her he like tells her to stay on the couch and like wait for someone to find her and she's like what if it's not one of my gentlemen and he's like I'll be here to make sure that it's fine and then it comes out that like Booker and Dr. Underwood and Ezra have like planned this whole thing because those are the people that discover her and it's just it's a great scene. It's a great scene. It's wonderful. Yep so the dinner at Amon's place arrives. The house is ginormous because of course it is and as they drive up to it Esther and Ezra
bond over the knowledge that in their old lives they would never be allowed even at the back of the servants entrance like this house is just totally out of their league like never. This this life that they're living is a dream that they could not even have dreamt before. Over dinner Amon wants to talk about the future for all of them. He proposes that they continue as they are but suggests that Esther doesn't need to stay at Rooksgrave. He wants her to see his home in Egypt and others are amenable and have their own things they wish to do with her as well but they all agree that they want the group to remain
intact and they don't pressure Esther on timing at all. Which I also love because they could be very it seems a little bit like of a departure from what Rooksgrave is set up to be where they kind of have their scheduled night and they can come and go but they really just form their own little family. Yeah and in this conversation I think it's when Esther recognizes that she's like well what would Magdalena think and then she realizes that Magdalena just wants all of the parties involved to be happy whether it's at Rooksgrave or elsewhere
and so I don't she realizes that this is the ultimate happy ending for this situation. Yeah. So she's filled with emotion at the prospect but she asks whether it would be okay if she tried to pursue some other sort of hobby besides being ready for sex at any given point in time and all of them and absolutely agree that they don't want to be her cage they just want to be by her side as she experiences the world and even Ezra says and I'm gonna say it in the the like terrible nasal English accent that it says he does in the book
he says I suppose he might be permitted a hobby or two. I love that. Which is again something I didn't catch on the first read around. No I didn't either the first read around which is just adorable because again Ezra is not English. No. And he just kind of makes fun of like all these other Englishmen in the room. Yeah. So they celebrate that unanimous decision that night and the way that you would expect the characters in this book to celebrate. And this is the first time
that they are all intimate together though even though it's in the same room it's not all at once right. So like some of these books you'll read and there will be a six some and they're all participating at the same time but this is very much like I don't want to say like prioritizing Esther's like pleasure because they all these books do that but like it's not wild right like they're giving her a massage they are supporting each other like taking turns. Like just like fading out. Right exactly. It's nice. So like one of the
running things with this scene is that the men are like having her first in a mon is like being cuckolded essentially. Which is hilarious considering where a mon came from. I know exactly. In the start of this book. Yes. Scene number three by the way. Yeah. Honestly this book like it just gets better. It just gets better. It does. That's why I wanted more of this. I was like yes I'm invested in all of these people. Great. Yeah I was so disappointed with you so the second one isn't them.
I was like well yeah whatever. So the one thing that Esther is unhappy about is that August still needs to go back to essentially his crypt every morning. Right. He's dead. Do the day rest. Right. So he goes he leaves the group to go back to Rooksgrave since his accommodations there are more secure than they would be at a mon's house. And sometime later in the morning the rest had back to the manor as well. But on the way a mon has a premonition from his sight and he flies out of the carriage literally using his wings. It becomes clear as they get
closer to the manner that the manner is on fire. And Esther is frantic with worry over August and the other ladies. But as they get closer it's clear that most of the other women are out front but there's no sign of August. And it's daytime. It's daytime. Yeah. In the aftermath Ezra and August are unaccounted for so Ezra had gone into the fire to try to help people and specifically to search for August. The manor inhabitants move into a mon's house temporarily and the men go back to the ruins to look for August and Ezra as Esther helps the
staff around the mon's house to keep herself busy. We learn that Cassie the woman who told Esther about her vampire gentleman George was the only woman that was lost. We learn that she was lost trying to get to George in the crypt. I feel like that one was also a genuine love story. Yeah definitely. So Esther at some point runs into Magdalena and she ends up tending to Magdalena's wounds. And as she does so the madam laments that she's become a total failure. That
she this whole thing is her fault and she's so sorry but Esther comforts her that all is not lost right? Like she couldn't have predicted all of this. She's not a failure. She does a lot of good work you know that kind of thing. And it again just solidifies the bond that they have. Later that day Dr. Underwood arrives back and tells madam that there is good news waiting for her downstairs. But he shares with Esther that they haven't found Ezra or August. Though he thinks the vampire chambers may be unharmed and he thinks that maybe
Ezra made it safely to them but nothing is certain. Downstairs Aman's sister Keppri has arrived and offers her assistance in protection for Rooks Grave. So Keppri obviously is also his thanks and her magic is in the form of some kind of protection spell. Stuff. She says that Bertha has never moved against to Sphinx and Aman adds that he will personally punish Bertha for this offense. So between those two things they're hoping that they'll be safe from
Bertha's continued attacks or whatever. The group agrees to go back to the ruins of Rooks Grave Manor in the evening and renew the search for August and Ezra with Keppri's help. The plan at the ruins is to tunnel into the vampire chambers so kind of try to get in from a different way than where all of the rebel is. And it's long and tough work. The men take turns guarding the ladies who came with them and it strikes me that like why did you bring the ladies with you to stay at the house? Right because like they're not gonna help. No. Just gonna watch the four of you work? Yeah no that doesn't make any sense and it's more
than just the four of them because there's other gentlemen like. Oh that's true that's true. That come with them but they don't matter. It's still just kind of weird. Right. Yeah. Eventually Esther does ask to go down and see the work so a different gentleman who's not one of hers leads her down to where they are. But before they reach the site Esther hears August shouting for her and so she blindly runs into dark dilapidated tunnels following his voice. Man. To find him. Yeah. She is led into kind of a catacomie type room and she finds August
tied and knifed to a tree. And Berisha is there sitting at a table nearby. He's drinking some kind of red substance in eating a bloody piece of meat. Gross. I was also confused why there was a tree down here. I like for a second thought they were in the forest. I think it's like the roots of a tree. That makes sense. Okay. So I was like I thought you were why are you outside now. That makes sense. Yeah. So Berisha invites Esther to sit. It's not really an invitation she can refuse. He boasts about how much smarter he is than everyone else. The
usual villain stuff. But Ezra at some point in this conversation lets Esther know that he's there. So Esther tries to turn the conversation to her advantage in a way that she could distract Berisha enough to get the steak knife that he's using out of his possession. And in order to do that she tries to seduce him. And he's like mocking her this whole time but it works. Like he puts the knife down and is completely focused on her this entire time. It doesn't not work. Right. And with Ezra's help she takes the knife from
the table and plunges it into Berisha's heart. And Ezra helps her push it in further and twist it which like yeah it gets on Ezra. Yeah. Before the others can arrive though and kind of like make sure that they have a handle on Berisha he uses some kind of magic to disappear and escape. Bitches. Bitches. So the rest of Esther's mind men find them and are happy that everyone is okay but desperate to get out of there because they're convinced that Berisha's gonna send some more reinforcements and like this is not stable place to be like we got to go.
Got blown with popsicle stand. Esther is desperate to get August like back to some kind of health and so he she like forces him to feed from her. He's like resisting and she's like you're being an idiot can you just do this for me really quick. Get over yourself. And even though he gets his strength back and he's like it's helpful they realize that their time is up because sunrise is upon them. At this point Aman extends his hand to August and asks him to trust him and he
leads August into the early morning sun shielding him at first by his sphinx wings but then Aman encourages him to stick a finger into the light and when he does nothing happens. August doesn't burst into flames he doesn't turn to ash like nothing happens and at that point August like realizes that he has been gifted something from Aman that allows him to be awake and present
in the sun without dying. He asks Aman how long it will last and Aman tells him it is a gift that I have given you it can never be taken away. Which again like Aman coming in hot at the end. Truly like such a selfless gift like he's not gonna get anything out of that. No and he doesn't even have to do it like he could just protect August until he's somewhere safe and like continue to let him not have his day times. Right exactly. So obviously August and Esther are both ecstatic right it's great. Yeah it's so great. In the aftermath they all
snuggle in bed and Esther tells particularly August you know she wouldn't she didn't know what she would do if she lost him or any one of them and she confesses that she loves every single one of them and they all confess their love for her in return. They decide to go to Egypt both to keep the madame and remaining women safe right their presence away from them will not make them a target any longer but also to find out more about Bersha. It's where Bersha's from it's where he avoids like the plague and so there might be something
about his past that they can dig up. Esther and Magdalena say their goodbyes and as a parting gift Magdalena gifts Esther a deck of tarot and tells her to consult with it whenever she feels lost. She tells her that she and the rest of the girls will be staying at the house Aman bought and that he named the house Star Manor after his pet name for Esther which I also missed in the first read around. Listen everything after they're like saving of a goose like that was all new to me. I was like well the sex is done. Honestly most of that I was like well
there's no more sex okay. Right but it's really nice. It is. So in the epilogue we see the gang lounging in Esther's chambers along the Nile somewhere. They've been investigating Bersha and looking for answers and having what feels like a riot of a time. I want to read more about that. I know I wanted that to be the second book. Right Aman announces that they've had a letter from the company of fiends who are having trouble with Bersha as well and this is what book two is about and they decide to go help. As a final bit August asks Esther if she
would like to be a vampire because it's been a year and she says she wants forever with her family and they resolve to bring the option to the others. They choose forever but whether it's turning her into a vampire or whether Aman has a different solve they're really open to anything. Which it's just such a nice ending. It really is. It's so wholesome. This book has no right to be so goddamn wholesome. God I know. Okay so who's your favorite? You have to pick one. Fuck
okay. I mean it's probably August then just because like he makes pastries and he's a vampire I mean like it's gonna be hard for me not to choose the vampire. Yeah. And he's also bisexual which I mean too. Yeah it's also August for me. Okay okay. So don't you laugh at me. It's tough because it's like I really like Aman too. I really like I want it I almost want to choose Aman just because this character arc is so good. I know but it's
definitely August. It's definitely August. You know I can't resist the vampire. Come on. No and also like the Doctor and Mr. Tanner aren't so lovely. As for Spine like he's not my favorite but like he's fine I'm glad he's there. Yeah. He lends Esther a sense of normalcy which I think is helpful. Yeah she's the one that like or he's the one that she most like relates to. Yeah and I think that's healthy. It is healthy and I just I just like book her just how like stone walley
he is but I'm. Thank you I'll be here all week. Try the feel. Alright so let's get into some ratings. Alright Liz how did we write this? The Spice level is a no-holds-barred five. It is so good. There's so much of it. It's detailed. We have emotions. It's really varied like it's certainly not vanilla but it's also nothing that's like for a monster erotic book it's pretty approachable like
yeah there's nothing wild in there but immaculate smud. It's immaculate. I literally no notes. Yep no notes. One-handed reading club bookmarks for days that have been returned to. Yep so that brings us to the writing style. We also rated this a five and the reason is I mean so there's none of the things that we would typically like harp on like there's no there's no typos there's no grammatical errors there's no like formatting issues but then also the
sentence structure is like relatively complex right this is set in the Victorian era and there are descriptions and sentence structures that are kind of decensin or harken back to that so it's it's a complex writing style it's not unapproachable because it is very like it's told from first person those types of things but I appreciated that this book was so dirty but then also treated its readers like they could graph a compound sentence which I appreciated. Yes agreed and it's nice because sometimes I mean we've read books that are
just like smud for smud's sake which is fine but they tend to be like very simplistic they're not complicated and this one does have like really beautiful writing it is complex and get a lot of smut. Yep I'm here for that. You get complex writing even with the smut. Yeah I mean this is like a gold standard for me. Alright which brings us to quality of storytelling. We both came into this recording with Edita 5 this book was Fives Across the Board however we did
downgrade it for a bit of some issues specifically with Amon and his continuity errors was like when he was supposed to be there like that was kind of weird so unfortunately because it is like the first plot point really in this book or at least issue for there to be continuity or it's kind of a bummer. Yeah it is kind of a bummer and honestly without that I would have rated it a five because that's the only continuity error and for such a rich world for Catherine to have
developed like I'm shocked that there weren't more. I know me. It's just a really well put together book. Because there really could have been a lot more like the timing through the rest of the book makes sense like when they go to London that timeframe makes sense there's not a lot of wasted travel time or shit like that but that one word man make day a week and it would have been fine. It would have been fine I'm just gonna cross it out on my copy and just say week. Exactly. Yeah and it's perfect. So as you might have picked up on we absolutely recommend
this book hard hard recommend like go read it right now. Go read it right now. Like you won't regret it. You won't regret it. It's yeah but be prepared to take some sweet time with yourself. Don't rush it. Don't rush it. Don't rush it. Don't rush it. Enjoy it. Yeah. You can always come back. And it's just as good the second time if not better because there's new information. Oh my gosh it's amazing how much more book there is outside of the sex. Shocking. Alright we did it. Those are our
thoughts on a lady of Rooksgrave Manor by Katherine Moon. Thank you for joining us on this journey as always. Let us know what you thought. You can find us on the socials. Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, Goodreads, at SpiceTraderFun. And if you like our podcast and want more considering joining our Patreon where we release Patreon exclusive episodes on our off weeks. And if you really really like us drop us a review wherever you listen. Please. Until next time we'll see you. Bye. Bye.
Triggers: graphic violence and gore, depictions of a fictional plague, on-page sexual content (including masturbation), and themes of parent death and chronic illness KU: No Recommendation: No, (give the author money...
Triggers: (From the author): kidnapping, violence, discussions of abuse, BDSM dynamics and play, tentacle play, brief descriptions of injured animal (that receives aid), breath play, bondage, depictions of sub drop,...
Triggers: war, battle, hand-to-hand combat, perilous situations, blood, intense violence, brutal injuries, death, and poisoning KU: No Recommendation: Yes! For more of the author, check out https://rebeccayarros.com/
Triggers: from the author: “explicit violence, explicit sexual violence, dubious consent, murder, gore, torture, kidnapping, and more.” KU: Yes Recommendation: No For more of the author, check out...
Triggers: death of a parent (off page), grief, fantasy violence KU: No Recommendation: both Traders recommend! This is part 2 of 2. For more of the author, check out https://www.lanaferguson.com/