Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Spice Traders

Spice Traders artwork

The Sea Witch by Rebecca F. Kenney Part 2

Jun 24, 202548 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

This week, we go under the sea with a spicy Little Mermaid retelling as we cover The Sea Witch by Rebecca F Kenney. This is part 2 of 2. Triggers: From the author: “age gap between fantasy characters, violence, abuse, torture, gore, murder, sexual threat, self-harm, explicit intimacy/spicy scenes, inexperienced/virgin female main character” Tropes: Disney princess, grumpy/sunshine, “teach me how to kiss”, tentacles… KU: Yes Recommendation: Yes! Both Traders recommend and can’t wait for more from this author! For more of the author check out https://rfkenney.wixsite.com/rebeccafkenneybooks.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hey friends, Liz here to invite you to check out our Patreon. That's where we publish extra episodes every other week, and that's also where we will continue any series we're reading. So if you liked our coverage of Akatar, Guild, High Mountain Court, or Forthwing, check out our Patreon to continue those series along with us. We also let you know what we're reading each month in advance, in case you want to read along with us too. There might be a few other surprises throughout the year for our patrons as well. You can get all of this for just three dollars a month. So check it out. And we would really appreciate the support. Anyway, on to today's

episode. Welcome to your safe space. The podcast, your partner, friends, parents, whoever thinks is dirty, don't have time to read books, want to understand the jokes in the text box. We got you, fam. We're the spice traders and we deal in spicy books. I'm Katie and I need it to make sense. I'm Liz, and I'm hypercritical. As always, we start every episode with three things. The first is a generic trigger warning. You can find specific triggers for this book in our show notes, so please check those out. Also, we do use foul

language and talk a lot about sex. If you have sensitivity to any of this, please give this episode a skip. Secondly, we talk about books. The whole book, nothing but the book, so help me, goddess. If you plan to read this book and don't want something spoiled right now, don't listen to this episode. Lastly, we acknowledge that a good book can hit you at the wrong time. The views expressed in our discussion are our opinion, and we absolutely don't want to diminish the work and the talent of the authors in our community. That said, we have some notes. Anyway,

so we get into it. Yeah, what are we talking about today? Today we are talking about part two of The Sea Witch by Rebecca F Kenny and this part will cover chapters 29 through 55 and then at the end we're gonna do our ratings. So that's the disclaimer you're gonna get so if you don't know what's going on listen to part two or sorry listen to part one or read the book. So let's just jump right into it. So at the end of part one which is fully where I thought this book was gonna end, Avril gets the the little like

little fork thing for the sewage. And like I'm literally reading this book at 50%. I'm like, what the fuck is the rest of this book going to be about? Because that's what literally that's exact thought I had. I I thought that she would get the fork back to him and we would have like 15 % left like some weird wrap up save the damsel there and love whatever. But we solidly had another

200 pages left. And I had no guesses what was going to happen. No. Not really. Not really. And I will admit that it was probably a little bit more drawn out than it needed to be. But I was here for it. And it was good. And it was great storytelling. Yeah. It was compelling. Right. I'm not mad about it. I could have used a little bit light editing. Oh, light editing. It doesn't have to be 400 plus pages, but anyway.

So she's got the fork, and now she's got to get it to the sea witch, right? And so we cut to the celebration of the prince and Avril's engagement. And this is where she and the sea witch are going to try to meet. Avril's been dressed in this very modest, very hot gown by the prince because he doesn't want anybody else to look at her. And if that's not purity culture, I don't know what is. That was disgusting, because before they were engaged, he was dressing her in really low -cut gowns, showing off everything. But now that she's, quote unquote, his, no one else can look at the goods. Yeah. Yeah. Fucking gag me

with a spoon, dude. For real. So as they're at the celebration, they're very heavily guarded. And Avril isn't sure she's going to be able to get away to see the sea witch. But then, as they're watching a show, fireworks unexpectedly go off, and chaos ensues. The prince is ferried away by his guards, and Avril is left basically to her own devices. And that's so very telling, not just because the prince doesn't make sure that she's OK, but he hasn't even instructed his guards, OK, if something happens, you two stay with Avril. On her. Like, no. Yeah. No,

she's a piece of property. Yeah, doesn't give a shit. No, so of course the sea witch finds Avril and takes her to a secluded cave against the sea wall He demands the fork and she willingly gives it to him and they snipe back and forth But they can't resist this like almost physical pull between them and they end up making out against the wall Really hot and he even like uses his clairs to like rip off this like stifling gown that she's in So like her clothes are shredded and she's like basically naked And they're right

on the verge of having sex, but Avril makes this hesitation body language situation, and the sea witch is like, oh, OK, let's not do that. But we can still have fun, and he finishes against her stomach. Which was great. I love the way this all played out, because I liked how. She did think about it, and it wasn't because of her purity culture. It was just like, OK, I'm not ready. And he didn't make it gross. He immediately honored it and didn't stop the scene either. We can still do a lot of things without going

to the place that you're not comfortable with. And I really liked that. I did too, especially because they didn't even talk about it. She didn't say a word. He just read the situation and was like, OK, heard. We're going to do something else. Yeah, like, you're still into me. I could tell you're still into me. So I'm not going to drop you, which I feel like a lot of others would have done, read the body language and been like, OK, we're done here, cold turkey. And I'm glad that they don't do that. Or even go so far as to make it a thing where you interrupt the flow.

And then it's so easy to get in your head after that of, well, maybe if I had just let it go, we would have had more fun. Yeah. It's really well done. So perfect. But unfortunately, their tryst is being watched and this spy makes a noise causing the Sea Witch to go after them, leaving Avril alone and half naked in a cave. In that moment, Avril realizes that the Sea Witch doesn't really have a reason to see her again despite

needing to like give her voice back and she starts picturing a life without him and that makes her feel like she can't breathe. So she cries alone in the cave. And at some point, the sea witch has gone too far away, and her voice is painfully ripped away from her again. So when the prince's guards finally locate Avril, she looks the part like she's been raped and robbed, and she's just silently crying by herself. Oh, which is really sad. I know. And that's another thing I love, how the author crafted their relationship. Because

we know how they, I mean, they, of course, tell us too. But like, Just her realization of, oh, I'm never going to see him again. She doesn't give us a lot more internal monologue than that. But seeing how she reacts just at that thought tells us all we need to know about how she really feels without her saying, but I love him. We do get that later, but it's just so cleanly done. Yeah, it's so clearly communicated without giving

us the declarative lines like that. The declarative lines in this book are few and far between, and I love that. Yes. Oh, so good. So we cut back to the sea witch, who has caught up with the person that was spying on them, and we find out that it's Brixius. So Brix recognizes the sea witch and feels vindicated that he knew Avril was up to no good. He's like, I knew it. I knew it. I knew it. So the sea witch is like, okay, dude, I can't let you like blow our cover So he takes bricks out to a secluded rock in the

sea and leaves him there while the sea witch continues with his machinations Before the sea witch leaves though bricks tells him quote do not pity him Prince. Fear him. He has no honor, no mercy, no sympathy. None of the emotions that made Perindal your friend before he was your enemy. Ciaran is void of all feeling except love for himself, and he has no good intent toward the girl. I don't know what his plan is, but he's not marrying her out of love. Of course, someone as clever and clear -sighted as you must already know that." I really like Brixias, and

I wanted them to be friends. I wanted to see their friendship. I liked him too and he's such a complex character even though he doesn't have a huge role because it's clear that he has a very clear sense of right and wrong and that his current employer really tests that line for him. Yep. But yeah, I really like Bricks. So the Sea Witch briefly considers what Bricks means

by the Prince has a plan for Avril. But he ultimately decides that Avril can handle herself. And so he's going to refocus on his own vengeance. So he heads back to his lair with the intent of breaking the spell on his trident, which is not actually a hors d 'oeuvre fork. It's actually trident sized. But the spell that he has to lock it away made it shrink down. Made it dang me. made it tiny and cute, although it would be really fucking funny if he had a trident and it was just like magic wand sized. It would be much

more convenient. It's so much more convenient, especially because there's a lot of logistics of he's like, God's trident so big, like I need like a strap for my back, like I need my hands free. Yeah, like he talks about for the duration of the book, he talks about like carrying it. It just seems like a lot of work. I'm like, if you had a Nordur fork, you could put that bitch on a chain around your neck. Not worry about it. Exactly. And then make the chain just never leave your neck. That'd be great. It'd be way easier. So meanwhile, Avril is back at the palace

enduring the raging of the prince. He is furious that she's, quote, soiled goods now. But Cass, the apothecary, tells him to get a hold of himself and comfort his betrothed. Come on, dude. Don't be weird. Get it. Get it together. Yeah. And then after that happens, Avril is allowed to bathe and soothe herself alone. As she does this, she calls for the sea witch. He almost doesn't answer, but at the last minute, he stops his journey to his lair to answer her call. And Avril's

intention for calling the sea witch is because she wants to ask him why he wanted the trident slash or der fork at all. And so he tells her the whole story. So let's buckle up, Buttercup. So we learn that the sea witch used to be the king under the sea. He inherited this from his mother before him, and the fork is a trident of power that helped her and now him channel their magic. Tarion, Avril's father, was the sea witch's advisor. And during an attempt to broker peace with the humans via King Perindal,

Tarion fell in love with Perindal's sister, Prella. But the human king forbade any contact with her. He was basically like, look don't touch, she's off limits. So the Sea Witch kept Tarion away from the human lands, but he ended up having a relationship with Prella himself. And eventually they were found out, and together Tarion and Perindal plotted the Sea Witch's downfall. They ended up paralyzing him and stealing his trident, and Tarion made himself king under the sea, and then he and Perindal cut ties and began spreading propaganda against each other. Tarion then instituted

the harsh religion for his kingdom. He even tried to have Prella cum - and be his bride underneath the water. But she couldn't really survive under the sea without a full transformation. And so she eventually died a really gruesome death. Basically, Tarian could make her breathe underwater, but her skin and stuff, it couldn't deal with being underwater that long, nor could it deal with the pressure. And so she basically just died from exposure. And we found out that he

was raping her. uh -huh yeah she wasn't there willingly either oh prella you did nothing wrong girl yeah totally so after prella died the high priestess of this new religion became tarion's quote one true mate and together they sired they sired avril and her sisters so one more thing we learn about this whole thing is that tarion's ascension to power was aided by the nobility at the time whom the sea witch had sought to destroy in favor of a more equitable society he wants there to be like a president and self

-ruling government. He's a communist. He's a communist and I love it. I know. Just like the redistribution of wealth, the rising up of the working class, taking ownership of the means of Making shit like, thank you. He's a communist. OK, so there's this thing that happens in my brain where whenever I try and think of the word communism, all I can think of is consumerism. And the word communist goes out of my head. So every time I want to talk about communism, I have to work around it. Oh my gosh. That's like

some brainwashed capitalist bullshit right there. I know. I know. I can't like. I can't say it happens a lot because I'm not talking about communism that much, but enough that I've noticed that I forget the word communism consistently and think consumerism. That's so wild. I know. So after Avril knows the truth, she begs the sewage not to kill her father or her sisters. He doesn't make any promises about her father, but he does

promise not to harm her sisters as long as they don't get in his way. And he then reveals that he never intended to give Avril the choice of returning to the sea. She is shattered from the knowledge that he used her, and in return he tells her, quote, consider it a learning experience. And now you have the skills you need for life on land. I wish you a full and happy existence as a human. And I mean that. What a dick. What a dick. The only thing that makes it less dickish is that we see how uncomfortable he is saying

these things, and he doesn't know why. He's like, why is that so hard to hurt her feelings? Is this love? Is this love? So their conversation is cut short because the sea witch is attacked by a shark, and he's like, gotta go. BRB. Gotta go, peaches. Bye. In the aftermath of their discussion, once again alone, Avril is most gutted by the knowledge that in the end, she really did mean nothing to the Sea Witch. So she takes the sleeping

draught left for her by Cass and falls asleep. Don't do it, girl. Don't take drinks left by your enemies. Right? So she's awoken in the middle of the night by someone that she can't quite make out. But this person is prodding her to take a drink to the king and force him to drink it to save his life, which she does. But when she wakes up in the morning she realizes that she's been manipulated into poisoning and killing the king and so she's arrested and thrown into the dungeons. So one thing that I I like about

her as a character but I found really interesting was Aphra is a pretty innocent person. I mean like she'll fight for herself. She has No guilt about murdering the king like obviously wasn't her fault. She was drugged but like she doesn't give it a second thought No, she really doesn't and between that and her total like I Don't want to say comfort it she literally doesn't think about it in except to tell us what's happening.

Like she has no problem being naked No, not at all. And I think that's because like No, never mind. I was going to say, I think it's because nudity doesn't really matter to her because those parts are new, but she wore a corset before. Yeah. At least the top half was the same. Yeah. But she does not. She doesn't care about being naked at all. But it is weird that she has these things happen to her that I thought would be more meaningful, and she just literally does not think about them. Right. Like, the most she

thinks about this murder plot is that her hands are still blistered from the poison. She's like, ow, that hurts. There's never even like, oh, the poor king. Like, he suffered. I feel bad that, like, that was my, like, nope. Nope. Like, fully does not take ownership of it. It wasn't my fault. It wasn't me. So back to the Sea Witch, who is finally in his lair to break the spell in the Trident. The process is taxing and intricate, but eventually results in the destruction of his lair because the Trident fights his influence

and I'm like, was it worth it, girl? Also, did you think, I mean, obviously he didn't know that was gonna happen, but maybe do it outside? Because he blows up his house. For real, and he needs this shit. In the process, he loses the shell with Avril's voice inside. And I'm like, you're the source of your own problems. And then all of his supplies that he needs to do magic are not there, because it's blown up, and it's rubble everywhere. It doesn't feel like this plan was very well thought out. No. And we find out later,

just as a side note, that his throuple friends, he blew up their house too, because they live in the same space. He just destroyed everything. And it's like, I'm not going to worry about that. I'll deal with that later. It's fine. Literally, I'll deal with that later. Yeah, he compartmentalizes a lot, too, because this whole losing the shell thing, he's like, I'll do that later. I have a priority list right now. And that goes, I have to depose Tarian and then I got I got to get bricks off that fucking rock before he dies. Like, let's go. And then I got to find her shell

and it'll be fine. Right. So back to Avril who had been knocked unconscious in her scuffle with the guards and she comes back to consciousness in the dungeon and the prince is there. He confesses that it was his plan all along to use her to kill his father and that he and Cas colluded for years to do so. He also tells her that he's willing to show Avril mercy if she's willing to make herself useful sexually. When it's clear that she's super not into that, the prince leaves.

Thankfully. Ugh, disgusting. During this conversation, though, Avril realizes that this experience is exactly what led to the Sea Witch living for vengeance. She tells us internally, quote, the grief and anger in my heart, those same emotions made the Sea Witch into the person he is. That's why he can't care for me, why he chose revenge over the connection we have. He's broken the same way I'm breaking. I finally understand him. She continues, quote, He might never speak to me again. He might never beg my forgiveness or change his mind. He might tear apart my father's

kingdom and end my father's life and leave me stranded on land stuck in this form. All of that will hurt me deeply, but I will love him anyway. Not because he deserves my love any more than Kieran does. Gods know he doesn't. I love him because I can't help it. Because in the sea witch, I hear the deepest echo of my own soul. Oh, it gives me chills. I know, and I know it's a long quote, but I just, I love the poetic way that she ends. She ends up at the concept of a soul

echo. And I, I thought that was a stupid concept in the first part of this book, but the way that she brings it around and describes it here, I was like, okay, girl, I'm on board. I liked that too. And he basically says the same thing later, but I really love how it's done without. The author doesn't make the characters admit that there's such thing as a soul echo but shows us that that's what they're experiencing Right. Yes. Oh god. It's such a beautiful way to say it because even later Avril says to her sister

I'm not sure I believe in one true mate. I'm like girl. You're an idiot You clearly do. Yeah, I really do Okay Okay, girl, I it's such a beautiful quote. I highlighted this quote, too. There were quite a few things that I was like, okay, you are very lyrical in your writing. I think that's another reason why I didn't mind that this book kind of like, it was not edited as tightly as like, I like, think it should be probably because like, there's just so much beautiful prose that

I was like, I'm fine. Between that I'm good. I'm good. I'll take it. Yeah. So a little later, Brix comes to see her and threatens to tell the prince everything that he knows. But Avril begs him for a pen and paper so that they can communicate. And since Brix was a part of the negotiations with the Sea Witch when the Sea Witch was king, he can read merfolk writing. So she writes down her entire tale. And when Brixius has finished reading it, he tells her that he believes her

and promises to free her. Though he's uncertain what to do about the prince, he admits to Avril that he's suspected for a while that the prince is a vile, evil person. Unfortunately, they are interrupted by Cass, and she has books taken away to be questioned about what Avril wrote. When Avril's alone again, she realizes that because of what she's written and confessed to, once the prince knows the level of her betrayal, he will kill her himself and make it very painful. Because he's horrible, and Cass is horrible. Yeah, they're two sadists who have found each

other, like literally murderous sadists. For real and they get off on it, which is the scene later that I was not into No, and I'm glad we didn't get to see that like fully. I was just like, oh god. I might skip ahead I know I know I was getting ready to like hardcore just like skip skip skip. Yeah So back to the sea witch who invades Terrians domain easily with his trident restored like not a problem Once there, he finds that Tarion is packing and was intending to flee

from the sea witch rather than face him and his past sins. Fucking coward. What a fucking coward, dude. The sea witch imprisons the king and makes him confess his past misdeeds to his people while his daughters bear witness. During this, we learn that the sea witch hadn't gotten a chance to free Bricks yet. Rather, it was Tarion's men who found him and returned him to the shore. And when he finds this out, the sea witch is like, fuck. because he knows Avril is in grave danger now. Oops. Oops. Seeing his panic and

understanding, Elaine, Avril's closest sister and the only one that seems to be halfway decent, is like, you go do what you got to do with Avril. I'll handle things here. So the Sea Witch orders Tarion to be in prison and that Elaine be in charge until he returns. And then he leaves to go help Avril. Which like, I. What was I just going to say? I lost it. I really liked how the tension was built here, like seeing the dual POVs. And I always love a multi POV. But the

things happening at the same time and the reveals in each were just really satisfying. I agree. I'm stressful. And I think that honestly, some of the things that do happen could have been referenced and we didn't have to see them, but just the amount of time that we're building up to this big damsel in distress moment, I am not mad about it. Nope, I'm not mad about it either. Yeah. So we cut back to Avril who's being tortured in an attempt of the prince and Cass to turn

her back into a mermaid. Bricks held out but eventually caved and once he confessed to what he knew, Cass cut out his tongue and summoned Avril for this purpose. Eventually they find a tincture that turns Avril back into a mermaid and it's the same painful process that it was before, except now Avril's even more tired and broken down than she was when the Sea Witch first did it. So happy with their success, Cass and the Prince leave to plan how they're going to entrap the Sea Witch and steal his trident. What

they end up agreeing to do is they suspend Avril and Bricks over a cove with shark -infested waters, and the prince has summoned his entire kingdom to watch this, and it's clear he's determined to get the trident one way or the other. To Avril's delight and horror, the sea witch comes for them both. The timing was so stressful. I know, right? Because they're like hanging there, and she's like, he's not going to come for me. Why would he come for me? This doesn't make any sense. He's got his own shit to do. and he would never like trade all of his power for me yeah that

doesn't make any sense yeah so the sea witch is coming at them on this great big tidal wave but just before it smashes into the cliff where the prince stands the prince offers the sea witch a deal the trident for avril and brixias the sea witch agrees and avril's horrified she's also a little bit deflated that the sea witch referred to her as a friend a little bit like, girl, really, that's what we're going to worry

about right now. Girl, now is not the time. This is not the time. Also, he says like, my friend's, so like, her and Briggs. And I was just like, m 'lady. M 'lady. What is he supposed to do? Good friends confess his undying love in this moment? It's not the time. Not the time. Like, not the time nor the place. Right. And she's also having this internal monologue of, like, just give me my voice back. Give me my voice back so I can fucking help and tell you what I know and, like, all of this stuff. And he's just not doing what she wants him to do. Like,

I cannot. Sorry. Nope. So the deal is made. And the sea witch hands over his trident to the prince. But as soon as the prince has the trident, he breaks the deal and cuts the ropes suspending Avril and Brixius. And they fall toward the water with the sharks. Who could have seen this coming? Who could have seen this coming? I gotta say, this reveal, I did not see coming. I saw the prince reneging on the deal, but I didn't see how it resolves. Me either, at all. So what had

happened was, is that the sea witch on the tidal wave is not the real sea witch. It's one of his lackeys, glamored to look like him. The real sea witch reveals himself in this moment, and he's been disguised as a guard at the prince's side. So the real sea witch catches Brixius and Avril before they fall and brings them safely back to land next to him. He and the prince then square off, but the prince is prepared and has archers ready to attack, and when they can't

hit the sea witch directly because of his power, they aim for Avril. This causes the sea witch to panic and use himself as a physical shield, and he's hit by a number of arrows and severely injured. And I just have to say the whole damsel in distress thing still just hits every time. It's not old. Yeah, I'm so here for it. So then the prince kicks the sea witch off the ledge

into the water and Avril uses this opportunity to grab the trident that the prince has pushed aside to do so. She then uses it to shove the prince off the ledge by impaling him in the stomach on the trident. Then she follows him off the ledge as he plunges to his death. Also, I loved that. I did too. I loved that it was her that killed him. Yes, that's what needed to be done. Yes, and it was beautifully poetic because she

saved him at the beginning of the book and now is choosing to let him die. Like returning him to the sea. And this is probably just me reading into it because the Little Mermaid is my favorite. But have you ever read the original Hans Christian Anderson, Little Mermaid? So her deal with the sea witch, I mean, it's it's one of the old fairy tales, right? So they're like really morbid and gruesome. But I don't remember how it all plays out. But basically like. to stay a human, she

has to kill the prince. Like that's the deal is she has to stab him and she can't do it. So she like throws herself into the ocean and like turns in a seafoam or some shit. But I kind of liked that. Like, and I don't know if Rebecca F. Kenny, like definitely this is nodding toward Disney, but I did kind of like that. She stabbed the prince. Yeah, that's to keep her body. Yeah. It helps that the prince was also an asshole. Yeah, that's beautiful. I love it. Exactly. So once in the water, Avril makes her way to the

sea witch, but he's really in a bad way. His friends slash lackeys are there to help her fend off the sharks as she presses herself and the trident to the sea witch's unconscious form in an attempt to heal him. And that works. He wakes up. And when he does, Avril immediately demands her voice back and turns out the sea witch has found the shell. that her voice is in and gives it back to her. Finally. Finally. Once she can speak they argue about him putting himself in such mortal danger and then speaking of mortal danger they realize that Brixias is very much

still in mortal danger and so they determine to save him right now. I did like that that suddenly she remembers him and is like I have to go. Guy gotta go oh shit he's like your one friend dude you can't and the other three are just like excuse me. They're like why? Should we care? She's like, nope, we're going right now. Goodbye. Goodbye. He's like, my tentacle just got eaten by a shark. Can we not? Can we not do that? So the sea witch demands that Avril stay in the water, but she refuses to do that and let him fight alone because

she loves him. And she says it out loud. And the sea witch is stunned by this admission, but she keeps him on task. She's like, Brixias, then heal, and then we can talk. Like, we got shit to do, my guy. Let's go buddy So the sea witch grabs Brixias and before he goes back under the water He tells the guards and the rest of the bystanders that the king is dead and he's like do with that what you will deuces I Love that like good luck. Good luck. Don't fuck it up.

I guess I Guess not my problem anymore So the group of them go to a nearby beach intending to go to the Sea Witch's rooms on land and use what he has there to heal instead of going all the way to his lair. Also, they got to heal Brixius and they can't transform him into a mermaid and so like it just makes more sense. It's a whole thing. On the shore, the friends slash lackeys help get the arrows out of the Sea Witch before they set off on land and to distract him, Avril asks him questions. I have to say that this was

a really sneaky question game and I wasn't mad about it. I was wondering if you were gonna clock it as a question game, but I wasn't mad about it either. And it fits with her personality because she is so inquisitive and he's in pain, so distracting. It all made sense. Yeah, it did. And it was so seamless because she doesn't even say. She doesn't start it by saying, I'm going to distract you by asking questions. She just starts asking questions. And he's like, is now really the time? She's like, yeah, it's distracting you. Yeah, and he's like, damn it, you're right. Damn it. OK, fine.

So as a product of this conversation, we learned that the reason that he and his friend slash lackeys are differently formed is likely due to a heritage of magic in their genetic line. And Avril ends up calling that beautiful in the sea, which realizes just how different she is from when he first met her. point of order that this is also why he doesn't need gills to breathe he tells her that it's like a genetic like oddity of his birth that he just all of his breathing mechanisms are interior which i liked getting that explanation because i was curious too i

was curious too and i also just think that it's illustrative of how well thought out like the underwater part of this is yeah it's nice so The Sea Witch then apologizes to Avril for leaving her in the cave and for making her believe that he could hurt her by like leaving her on land and killing her father, all of that stuff, but he confesses to her that he could not betray her in the end and hasn't and does not intend to kill her father. Oh it's so nice! I know.

So finally the three of them hobble to the inn. Avril helps the Sea Witch heal with the potions that he has there, and then the Sea Witch goes to heal Brixis? Brixius? Brixie? Boy? Brixiboy. And importantly returns Brix's tongue. He's gonna need that in a second. Which is quite nice. So then the Sea Witch and Avril get some much needed sleep before they be fucking. And as they do, the Sea Witch says the words back to her, I love you. It's so good. Also before they get sleep

or as they do is one of the key scenes that Avril gets tired of waiting and just literally naps. And I just love it every time. I love it too. And I especially love it here because she's literally been tortured and then put through hell. And I'm like, girl, you can't, you need to, you need sleep. Like they both need sleep and I'm just glad that they didn't get immediately to fucking. Exactly. Even though they get sort of like handsy, both of them were like, okay, we have stuff to do. We can come back around to this. And then they do focus up. But yeah, girl, I mean, this

scene was great. It's specific long enough. I don't have a lot of notes for this scene. I don't have a lot of notes either. It gave me everything I wanted. Yeah, totally. One handed book club over here. Yep. So they do that and then they fall back asleep. But. In the morning, they are immediately in danger again from that bitch Cass, because she wants... Get out of here. Girl, like, leave them alone. Cass tries to get the trident, but this is really a big, like, nothing -burgrim

-non -issue because Avril and the Sea Witch outsmart her and the guards easily. This experience does make the Sea Witch realize that he needs to take a stronger hand in determining what happens in the human lands, though, and so he announces to Avril and Brixius that he intends to install Brix as king. Okay, girl. Okay, girl. Okay. So I do, I want to talk about the Bricsis King, but I do have a note. There was, it was kind of a one line fixer and I hated it. So this, and really the end of the book is where like editing could really come in. So I think Avril

even says like, are we safe here? We're so close to the kingdom and the sea witch is like, yeah, yeah, yeah. I glamored it. It just looks like a thicket of trees, but they're solidly at an inn. So we get a one line fixer of how cast could like see through the illusion for whatever reason. But don't you think they would notice that yesterday there was an in here and now it's a forest? That's not sus. Yeah. What? I had that too. I was like, shouldn't you just glamor the hallway so your

doors don't appear? Yeah. That feels easier than the whole ass building. It was just so weird to me. I'm like, you don't. OK, whatever. It didn't matter. But I was like, that was odd. Yeah, I thought that too. I was like, um, what are we doing here? Like, I would rather not know. Right. Just have it be like, no, no, no. They're busy. They're scrambling. They won't come looking for us. Totally. But then also, the install bricks

as king, like, it wouldn't be that easy. And I don't need those administrations. But you can't just make him king. Yeah, like literally kingmaker over here, both on land and under the sea, which we'll see in a minute. Just like, yeah. And he basically is like, well, if they don't, I think they have a conversation where he's like, anyone who disagrees, I'll just kill them. And Avril's like, maybe don't kill everybody because they

don't agree with you. And he's like, yeah, yeah, yeah, it'll be fine. Yeah, yeah, yeah, I guess you're right. Fine. Poor Briggs is like, I guess I'm king now, question mark. Oh. But the note I wanted to say, they get to this inn, and Briggs doesn't have his tongue back yet. And he points to his wedding ring. And the sea witch straight up just assumes he's gay. And I loved that. Briggs points to his wedding ring, and the sea witch is like, oh, you have a husband or a wife? And he nods at the wife. And I was like, I love that

husband was your first guess, not wife. I know. I mean, to be fair, his three closest friends are in a gay throuple. So sure. Right. So that's his default, but it just made me laugh. I love that too. Very inclusive. Yes, super inclusive. Well, so speaking of administrations I don't need to see, we fast forward three weeks later and things in the human realm are, quote, largely settled. Brix has a lot of support in the people and he's generally known to be a fair and good man. So I guess like him being king is just cool

with people now. Yeah, I mean, Kingmaker over here, at least he picked a good guy. Yeah, it could be worse. It was worse. So with that settled, the sea witch and Avril finally leave the summer palace city to head back to the kingdom under the sea. But they take the long way, including a horse ride along the coast long way. And look, I'm not mad about it because it involves a lot of really great sex, including a scene on a horse and then there's one in a field with a splash of maybe voyeurism. Yeah, no notes again. There's

also like a really tiny chase scene, like not the chase scenes we get in the Lost Boys book, but a little bit of a chase scene, like a little bit of that play resistance. And I just literally no notes. Yeah. Yeah. Same. No notes. I was here for the whole end of this book. Same. Is it a little bit drawn out? Yes. Is it the bonus scenes that I wish more books had? Absolutely. Absolutely. I will take the drawn outness for the bonus scenes.

That's a fair trade to me. I absolutely will. Yep. So during this kind of time, these scenes, the Sea Witch promises to teach Avril everything that he knows about magic, as she's asked him to. And there's no bargain required. And specifically in that last sex scene, they both admit that they want to be with each other forever, not just as some passing fling. So they both admit to this concept of mates for life. Forever. Forever.

Forever, ever. So then right before they go back into the ocean, we get one more blowjob scene. And just like, if this book didn't deliver already, I just really appreciated that. I love a good blowjob scene. Yeah. No notes. It's so satisfying. No notes. So once they're back in the ocean, they race each other to the kingdom under the sea. But the race ends in a tie, which I also thought was cute. Yeah, because they have the whole, like, don't let me win thing. That was

adorable. So Avril is delighted to see her sisters again, especially Elaine, who's the only nice one. Then she sees her father, who is just terrible. Her father ends up berating Avril for letting the sea witch overthrow him and touch her. But she just tells him to enjoy his solitude and walks away. She's so strong about it. And that's where we get the line. I don't have it in front of me because I walked away from my phone. But the Sea Witch in his interim monologue says something about his adoration for her. And children don't,

they're not required to give their parents peace, especially after a shitty childhood. Yeah, I loved that so much. And it was so poignant. And it kind of came out of nowhere. I was like, OK, girl, jeez. Yeah. And it was one of those things that Kendall showed me. like it's been highlighted before. And I was like, yeah, I'm sure this line speaks to a lot of people. Yeah, no kidding. So speaking of Elaine, she is the one that's been installed as like the person that's going to help the transition from a monarchy to more

of an equitable society, which is what the Sea Witch originally wanted. And so that leaves the Sea Witch in Avril kind of more free to do what they want. And so rather than staying in the kingdom under the sea, they return quote, home. And it turns out that home is the repaired lair that the sea witch has been working on in the past three weeks, which is still in that poison fauna forest. So he's made some additions to this new cave, including a whole separate wing for his threeple friends and a separate wing

for he and Avril. And in their wing of the cave slash house, all of Avril's collected human trinkets are on display, which is something we really didn't talk about. But she does make reference to the habit that she has of collecting. Look at this stuff. Isn't it neat? Wouldn't you think my collection's complete? That whole thing. And I liked how that came back around and he like... gathered them, Elaine told them where they were, and he displays them. He doesn't brush her off as being silly. He decorates their house with

this human stuff. Yeah, I think that's really cute, especially because she's like, and there's a chaise that's got algae on it. Isn't it cool? And I'm like, sure, girl. Sure, girl. All right, and there's a fiddle. And now she doesn't have to wonder what it sounds like because she's heard one before. Yeah, it was very cute. and so then we get one final scene with the two of them in their merfolk forms and even that was pretty darn good i gotta say i was so curious how that scene was gonna go because it could have been

really weird and icky but it was hot it was honestly still one -handed reading club for me yeah and it was just like a great way to end the book with that physical and emotional intimacy like it just Great, great ending. It was literally, I just, I have very few notes on this whole book. I'm so pleased with it. I'm so glad we read it. I don't know the TikToker that recommended it, but I am so here for it. Same. All right, so

let's get into our ratings. Yes, let's. We are in unison. I see oopsies. Yep, we are in unison. All right, so let's talk about our spice level rating. How do we do there? We both gave it a five. We get ample spice in this book. This book is a little over 400 pages, but we get a multitude of scenes in different spaces and body forms.

And we get all of the communication and the way this author builds the connection between the two of them and their chemistry. Like every scene we get is just so good. Like there's a whole scene in part one that they don't even speak at all. And it's still so good because we know how connected they are. And I just, I have no notes on the spice. I want to read more of this author just because I can trust her to write some damn good smut. Same. And I think it's incredibly telling too, because I mean, with the exception of like the whole tentacle thing, which is definitely

not. vanilla like it's pretty vanilla right it's it's a heterosexual couple it's just the two of them but she she creates that that intimacy like you were talking about and like desire and like pull between them and the way that she writes about it is unique like i feel not that i'm mad about this in any way shape or form but i feel like a lot of the romantically stuff that we read nowadays kind of has a predictable like cadence to the smut like it's he'll eat her out and then they'll have mind -blowing sex and then

maybe she'll blow him once or twice and then they'll have mind -blowing sex but he spends a lot of his time on his knees in front of her like I'm not mad about it but it's kind of like the same thing over and over again yeah you're right that is that is the secrets we get in a lot of the romanticies and this one changed that yeah they even had just like I don't want to call it mutual masturbation but like kind of close which you don't see a lot No, you don't see a lot or him just hit okay the horse scene or she just like Makes them come in his pants

from like rubbing her butt on him. You and that I was like, I'm here for this We don't see a lot of this same totally same. Oh Great So moving into writing style, we both rated that a four There's no major formatting issues. I'm no major. There's no formatting issues in this book there were specifically a couple of things that we liked about the The style of the book like one of them that comes to mind is like the way that the headings were in each chapter So it was super fucking obvious who was speaking really appreciate

that with my executive dysfunction over here Same The voices were distinct and engaging Yeah, just no notes on the writing style at all. So quality of storytelling similar thing Yeah, we both also gave that a four for very similar reasons. I mean there aren't any major plot holes. There are a couple of things they called out that were just kind of weird, like maybe errors or the author just don't really think about it, but they don't detract from the story. And I think for me and I think you'll agree, the biggest

thing that made it a four and out of five was just they could have used some light editing. There was some of the cleanup at the end that like just went on a little bit longer than it needed to. But. In that same sentence, I'm still going to say that pacing was nice for all of the extra smut we got that wasn't like, here's three chapters of them fucking. Yeah. So like, the fact that halfway through the book, the 50 % mark was where I thought the story would end and it wasn't over was amazing. Yeah, totally.

Totally. So do we recommend this book? Yes. Yeah. I cannot wait to read more by her. Same. Wholeheartedly recommend this to anybody who's a fan of the genre. We did it, guys. Those are our thoughts on the Sea Witch by Rebecca F. Kenny. Thank you, as always, for joining us on this journey. Let us know what you thought on the socials. You can find us on TikTok and Goodreads at SpiceTradersPod. And, of course, if you like our podcast and you want more, consider becoming a patron where we release Patreon -exclusive episodes on our off

weeks. And if you really, really like us, drop us a review wherever you listen. But until then, we'll see you. Bye. Bye.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Irresistible Urge to Fall for Your Enemy By Brigitte Knightley Part 1

    Nov 10, 20261 hr 35 minAudio

    Triggers: graphic violence and gore, depictions of a fictional plague, on-page sexual content (including masturbation), and themes of parent death and chronic illness KU: No Recommendation: No, (give the author money...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Surrendering to Scylla by Wren K Morris

    Oct 27, 20261 hr 10 minAudio

    Triggers: (From the author): kidnapping, violence, discussions of abuse, BDSM dynamics and play, tentacle play, brief descriptions of injured animal (that receives aid), breath play, bondage, depictions of sub drop,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Threshing Day by Rebecca Yarros

    Oct 14, 20261 hr 9 minAudio

    Triggers: war, battle, hand-to-hand combat, perilous situations, blood, intense violence, brutal injuries, death, and poisoning KU: No Recommendation: Yes! For more of the author, check out https://rebeccayarros.com/

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Court of Heathens by K. A. Knight

    Sep 29, 202652 minAudio

    Triggers: from the author: “explicit violence, explicit sexual violence, dubious consent, murder, gore, torture, kidnapping, and more.” KU: Yes Recommendation: No For more of the author, check out...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Under Loch and Key by Lana Ferguson Part 2

    Sep 21, 20261 hr 4 minAudio

    Triggers: death of a parent (off page), grief, fantasy violence KU: No Recommendation: both Traders recommend! This is part 2 of 2. For more of the author, check out https://www.lanaferguson.com/

    Credit the people on this episode