This week the Traders dive into what may be the spiciest hetero/monogamous book thus far: Priest by Sierra Simone. We discuss all things religious, holy, spicy, and sweet in this one! Both Traders recommend this one! Trigger Warnings: Mentions of sexual abuse and suicide Tropes: Forbidden romance, dom-energy, sex-positive characters For more of the author, check out www.thesierrasimone.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Once I was done with my one-handed reading club, I was like, I feel empowered. I feel nourished. I feel nourished in many ways. Welcome to Your Safe Space. The podcast your partner friends, parents, whoever thinks is dirty. Don't have time to read books, want to understand the jokes in the tics-hacks, we got you fam. We're the spice traders, and we deal in spicy books. I'm Katie, and I need it to make sense. I'm Liz, and I'm hypercritical. As always, we start every episode with three things.
The first is a generic trigger warning. You can find specific triggers for this book in our show notes, so please check those out. Also, we do use foul language, and talk a lot about sex. If you have sensitivity to any of this, please give this episode a skip. Secondly, we talk about books. The whole book, nothing but the books that helped me got us. If you plan to read this book and don't want something spoiled right now, don't listen to this episode. Lastly, we acknowledge that a good book can hit you at the wrong time. The views expressed in our discussion are our opinion, and we absolutely don't want to diminish the work and the talent of the authors in our community.
That said, we have some notes. So, Liz, what are we talking about today? Today we're talking about Priest by Sierra Simone. This was published in 2015, and it is the first in a completed trilogy with an additional novella. This book is 354 pages and a physical copy, so that makes it a midi.
The cover I had of this book is a man. But there are alternate covers that I found on her website that are very subtle. They're just like floral. Yeah, I like the floral one, but I also like the one with the man because that like the shoulder bicep combination, it just really gets me going. It's so hot. Like, usually, I mean, we've talked before that we don't like real people on covers. This one was... I don't mind this. I didn't mind this. It was...oh, it's so hot. Yeah.
Yeah. No notes on the cover. No notes. I'll let it go this time. I'll let it go. And I think it's because like, you kind of see his face, but his head is bowed in prayer because of Priest. So it didn't superimpose an image of someone in my head. Yes, exactly. It was very artsy, artily done. Yes, artily done. All right, well, I know we have a lot to say, so let's go ahead and jump into it. Katie, take it away.
Okay. So first and foremost, this book is not on Kindle Unlimited, which is a Bamaire, but it is also not like...I actually forget how much it is, but it's like under $10, I think. And worth it. I'm just gonna say right now. Yeah, totally worth it. I know I love UKU girlies. It's a bummer when something's not on there, but this one's worth it, trust me. Yes. So before we get into the book, we do get a content warning, but not for the sex, interestingly enough, but for mentions of sexual abuse and suicide, which I thought was good.
I feel like Sierra Simone was like, okay, if you pick up this book, you knew what you were signing up for from a sex perspective, so I'm just gonna cover the things that are not that. And I so appreciate that because that calls back to the... I'll quote on TikTok that was like, don't bash a book because you didn't pay attention to the trigger warnings, which usually revolves around sex. I'm like, if you're not here for a threesome, don't read a reverse harem. What did you think you were gonna get? Yeah, but things like abuse and suicide, I think was important to call out.
100%. Yeah, especially when it's tied with religion. I know that's triggering for a lot of people. Yes. We also then get this author's note, which is super clutch. And so I just copied the whole thing and I'm gonna read it here. So quote from Sierra Simone's voice. I spent the majority of my life in the Catholic faith and while I'm no longer Catholic, I still have the utmost affection and respect for the Catholic Church. While the town of Weston is real and delightful, St. Margaret's and Father Bell are inventions of my own imagination and entirely fictional. That being said, this novel is about a Catholic priest falling in love. There is sex, more sex, and definitely some blasphemy.
The fun kind. You've been warned. I also have that in my notes, the blasphemy, parentheses, the fun kind, because I was like, oh, I got like chills right now. Are you reading that? So I really appreciate this. So I, um, a fun fact about me, when I was in college, I converted to Catholicism because of a family thing. I'm not a practicing Catholic by any way, shape, or form or any stretch of the imagination. But it was interesting reading this book and like there's definitely like Catholic things,
but there's also themes of like people trying to convert to Catholicism. And I don't know, it just helped me like the way that Sierra wrote this book was very realistic to me and I, it was interesting from my own perspective having kind of gone through that myself in college. I was actually going to ask you about that, like if this reflected, I mean, not sex on altars, but reflected any of that like actual. Unfortunately no. But any of those like traditions, conversion, all of those themes that we get, I was going to ask you how realistic that was.
I mean, so the community of this church is definitely very different. It actually struck me more like, so I second fun fact about me, wow, we're not 15 minutes into this episode and you're getting two fun facts. Lucky you. Wow. So I, I watch a lot of British TV and this church actually struck me, this community in this church struck me as like an English countryside like Hamlet because like the people are just so like warm and welcoming and like everybody knows everybody and you can walk
everywhere for some reason, which you can't do in most of America. Yes. So obviously that was a little bit different. I got that same vibe like that like really close knit because I mean, I have spent very little time in Catholic churches and both times were for events like wedding and a funeral. But they're always like kind of big and drafty and eerie to me and like not this like sense of like community, which again, like that's my super limited experience as like not a member
of the church, but it always just felt like very formal and this felt like we're a family. Right. Which I liked. Yeah, I did too. So we begin with the priest himself who is bemoaning how archaic the reconciliation booth is. Reconciliation is essentially confession. It's just the fancy name for it. This booth is what you would picture out of period drama set in Europe and our priest is looking forward to getting rid of it. It's very uncomfortable. It's very doom and gloom.
He actually calls it the booth of death. I loved that so much. It's like heavy curtains and heavy wood with like the filigree. Yeah, I love that. I mean, so I really love old churches. I hate most of the churches that you walk into in the United States because they're like, they feel more like convention centers than they do like close to holy. Yeah, exactly. Yeah. So I very much like empathized with our main character here when he was talking about how his church has like this really old terrible red carpet and like these kind of hospital
like walls and he really wants to like brighten it up and modernize it a little bit like that just not my kind of place. No, I did. There's a line at some point where he says like the red carpet is great for hiding wine spills but not my gels. Yeah. It's like so funny. Which was then weird to me why this confession booth was so like medieval. Yeah. It's like, was it a gift from your diet piece or something? I'm giving you this very ornate confession booth.
Enjoy. You're welcome. I had such a clear image of this booth though just from like period dramas mostly. 100%. Yeah. So before we get much further into it, I will say that one of my primary gripes with this book is that we have no idea what Tyler looks like. We know that he is of Irish heritage and that he's fit but that's it. Yeah, you're right. We don't get any. He is the narrator which is I mean obviously but it is interesting that we have a male narrator because we don't have a lot of books where there's a male lead.
Yeah. And so I think I said his name was Tyler but the priest's name is Tyler. And it's told like you said primarily from his point of view which I thought that Sierra did really well. Yeah. I did too. But you're right. I didn't notice that that we don't get any sort of imagery for him and like we meet his family so I feel like very easily could have been like I look like my dad. This is what my dad looks like kind of thing. Right. Exactly. But we don't get a whole lot of that. You know, I'm not grading down for that.
No. No. That's fine. I just want to very few notes so let's get into it. So we learned that our setting is St. Margaret's of Western Missouri. Tyler, the priest, remarks internally how his current penitent and himself have things in common. They are restless and they are stagnant. This man's name is Rowan and he's a local teacher. Rather than giving Rowan Hail Mary's into our fathers, the priest gives him the homework of thinking about his life and understanding what gives him passion.
What's his reason for getting out of bed in the morning? He wants to push Rowan to be better and to pursue more happiness in his own life. Something that Tyler has struggled with and wants to help him out with. The next person who comes in is astonishing for two reasons. One, no one but Rowan ever comes to confession and two, it's almost time for Tyler to clock out so he's just like, fuck man, I really wanted to get out early today. Which I loved how relatable he was as a character.
Going to this book, I thought we would have a female perspective for one. But to come from the priest's point of view and he's like, I wanted to go for a run. I was excited to be done early and go do shit I like. Yeah, exactly. Relatable. So this person is a woman and they have a really flirty banter back and forth. Tyler finds himself enamored and intrigued immediately and this woman starts confessing that she's done something really terrible but she doesn't really elaborate on specifics.
She asks him whether everything's gonna be okay. She needs to know from somebody else that life is gonna go on and things are gonna be fine. Tyler tells her honestly that no one can ever really know that answer. He thinks internally about finding his eldest sister after she had completed suicide by hanging herself and feeling a similar position of helplessness as this woman possibly does now. He feels the urge to hold her, touch her, comfort her and immediately admonishes himself. He hasn't felt like that or felt that urge in over three years and he hasn't even seen this woman yet.
Just want to touch her? Yep. So before they can talk further, the woman leaves. The woman definitely leaves an impression on Tyler. But he ruminates that he has to be the pinnacle of restraint sexually due to what happened to both his sister and in the history of this parish of St. Margaret's. But we don't get any further information on that just a second. She did a great job of laying the cookie crumbs for the backgrounds without it being like too, I'm not gonna tell you yet.
Right, exactly. It felt natural. What is it? Yeah. It's like I wanted to know but I wasn't frustrated by like the delay in finding out. Right, exactly. So we go on to learn a little bit more about our priest. He has an active parish though a little sleepy. He personally runs every morning and makes a concerted effort to read outside of religion every week. He has a penchant for arguing with online necks about the walking dead. So he seems like kind of your not typical priest. Yes.
This was one of the first times that modern references like the walking dead and later we get like a Britney Spears reference. It didn't bother me. I feel like it did round out the character and not in an annoying way. Yeah, it made the character feel relatively younger. Yes. Yes. So Tyler has his routine and he's content with his sleepy bed and breakfast town in the Midwest. So he's surprised when the woman shows up again to confessional the following week.
He scolds himself to stay focused and this is finally at the point in the story where we technically learn that his name is Tyler which I found a little bit frustrating in the moment. He was just kind of referring to himself and priesthood and we didn't get his name. Yeah, that was annoying. But yeah. His name is Tyler. Tyler Bell. His name is Tyler. So this time the woman tells him her sins and she tells him in the next chapter which is a yield perspective shift and all of Poppy's chapters are written in italics for some reason.
I didn't particularly like this but it didn't bother me as much as I thought it would. Yeah, I didn't like it either and I think what confused me is that one it was an italics and two it kind of raised just like a stream of consciousness which makes sense in context but the first time reading it I was like this is a really weird way to have a perspective. Yeah, so her chapters are really set up to be confessions, right? So this one she's actually in the confessional booth I think a couple more times the same and the epilogue is written from her perspective as well also kind of written from a confessional
kind of perspective. Sorry. That's okay. I was here for this epilogue. I know I was too. Anyway so we learned that this woman's name is Poppy and she talks about having a job that could be considered sinful though it's not prostitution. We don't find out specifically what it is yet but it does have kind of a sexual side to it. That's the impression we get. I love the name Poppy. I do too.
Did you think that was short for something or did you think it was just Poppy? I think it was just Poppy but I had the thought Pip could be short for Poppy? Yeah, I did have that thought too or even Poppy could be short for Penelope. Oh yeah, because Poppy would be a really cute nickname for Penelope. Yeah, so we learned that Poppy feels torn between two parts of herself, one that enjoys this job that she has and the other side that craves acceptance from broader society. She lets her full name slip in this conversation as Poppy danforth.
Back with Tyler, he suggests that maybe they continue next week after she goes quiet for a while and she agrees. Tyler steps out to meet her and we get this description. Quote, her voice was sexy, her laugh was even sexier but neither held a candle to her. She had long dark hair, almost black and pale pale skin highlighted by the bright red lipstick she wore. Her face was delicate, fine cheekbones and large eyes, the kind of face that peered out of fashion magazine covers. But it was her mouth that drew me in, lush lips that were slightly parted letting me see that her two front teeth were ever so slightly larger than the rest, an imperfection
that for some reason made her all the sexier. This was such, I just really love this description because it wasn't like this generic human being. Like she has her own traits of like wearing bright red lipstick which continues and I appreciated that. I did have a little bit of a like gag about her being like a model. I was like, okay fine, I'll push this like a model. But the rest of it, I was like, okay, all right, and she's not perfect so I did like that as well. I liked that too and I liked that.
So what I didn't have written down with this quote was that Tyler immediately thinks about her lips and how he wants to see them wrapped around his cock. Which I was like, there it is, that's what I signed up for. I did like that we got like, we pretty much jumped right into it, at least from his perspective. But that's a good example of something that I think this author does really well because she writes that Tyler is a sexual being and thinks about sex a lot. Like he's not just like this mindless oaf. He thinks about sex a lot and then he's like immediately like, oh fuck, that's wildly inappropriate.
Like get yourself together. What the fuck is wrong with you? Like. Yes. And I love that so much because he even has the thought of like get yourself together even outside of like, I'm a priest and I can't have sex. But just as like a human, like she's not an object which was also refreshing from the other times we've gotten male perspectives that are like, and I wanted her immediately. Right. I had to make her mine. Yeah. Like, okay, bro. Okay. Yeah. So as we've talked about, Tyler is immediately into Poppy in ways that he can't control and
internally berates himself for. Tyler tells Poppy that he's not going to give her penance this time since sitting in the booth kind of is a penance in and of itself and that they'll continue to talk next week. He says her name and he said it quote, in that voice, the one that I didn't use anymore, the one that used to have women dropping to their knees and reaching for my belt without me having to do so much as say please. And I really want to know what that voice is. I do too. I want to hear it.
Like I kind of want to listen to this on audiobook and hope it's narrated by a man. It's gotta be. And my note was like, he's, he was a dumb for sure. Uh-huh. 100%. Yeah. Spoilers he was. Spoilers he was. And this whole like thing my notes I have, he was a dumb for sure. Him being a priest gives new meaning to yes daddy. Oh god. Father. And then there's this song that I have on my playlist. I don't remember what it's called, but it starts out with this like soul tree voice. It's like, forgive me father for I have sinned.
It's been 666 days. It's my last confession. I'm just like, oh. I love that. So at the end of this interaction as Poppy is leaving, Tyler tells her that she doesn't need to drive all the way here to Weston for confession thinking that she lives in Kansas City and desperately trying to find an excuse for distance, right? Because he's kind of obsessed. He knows that he can't really control himself and doesn't really want to give into the temptation or give it an opportunity.
But of course Poppy tells him that she lives in Weston now, so it's no problem. She actually lives like right across the street. Whoops. Oh Tyler. So on a different day that week, Tyler goes running. He enjoys the peace of mind that it gives him, the clarity on how to deal with his to-do list including Poppy Danworth. He determines that the next time he sees her, he must cut things off. He can't stop thinking about her and desiring her. So he's taking the advice that he would give to any of his parishioners and removing the sin entirely. They'll point her to another member of the church, potentially a deacon or maybe a female.
I forget what they called it, but somebody that's able to take confession in place of a priest and then just be done with it. But then of course he runs into her while jogging. Like physically. But not in the sleepless in Seattle or whatever the fuck that book was called. Way where he literally runs into her. They're just stabbed at the door and waiting to cross the street. And she's like, hey I'm here. Hi. She remarks that she didn't really prank him as a Britney Spears type and that's what he's listening to on his jog.
Tyler is caught off guard in reeling and he's trying to master himself and she comments that it seems like he doesn't like her very much or it seems like she's done something to make him mad, but she gets a lot of peace out of talking with him. Tyler kind of comes back into himself and is like, you know, you haven't done anything wrong. I'm glad that you find Salas in our chats. And so she asks whether she could come by during his office hours rather than confessional. He tells her that that's fine, but he really only wants her to pursue religion out of a genuine interest because it's not for everyone, right?
And she follows up with, I mean, the hot priest certainly helps. It's in this moment that Tyler realizes that he is utterly fucked. Like I can't escape this girl. Yep. Also, this whole interaction, I just got to point out, he's shirtless, which is great. He's shirtless and she's just in a sports bra. And like booty shorts. Right. And this whole thing, like this is one of the first scenes where they're not in the confessional booth, right?
And he starts to notice things about her and then notice that she's noticing things about him, like when he swallows hard or something. And he notices that like her nipples are hard in her sports bra. And it's just like the physical reaction that they elicit in each other is really well orchestrated. It really is. It builds the tension in like the best way. Yeah. So Tyler goes home to get some space and to spend time with his parents. So leaves Weston to go visit his parents.
His brothers are all there too. He has an older brother in finance and a younger brother following in those footsteps. And he affectionately calls these brothers the business brothers. So cute. Yeah. And his youngest brother is still at home finishing out high school. The business brothers give Tyler a lot of their hand me down. So he's got really nice clothes like Armani belts and like cashmere sweaters that his brothers either give them because give him because they're done with it or give him because they're trying to make him look less like a caveman. So whenever Tyler doesn't dress like a priest, he's dressed really nicely, which I appreciated.
I did appreciate that. We find out that his only sister was named Lizzie and she is the one who completed suicide 12 years ago. How did you feel about having a namesake in this book? I got really excited. I literally said, Hey, it's me. I don't think I've seen my name spelled correctly in books because usually it's IE and this one had a Y. I mean, not correctly spelled IE. That's fine. But I saw the Y. So I've never seen it with a Y and I got excited and then bummed because she killed herself. Yeah. I mean, so not only did she kill herself, but it's also implied that she was abused
by a member of their church because Tyler talks about how her death and the ostracization of their family by the church after the story with public killed his mother. I got the feeling that she was abused by the previous priest. Yeah. So it's important to say that like Weston and this place where his parents are are not the same place. So but sexual abuse has happened in both places. So the previous priest, I think in the place where his parents live definitely was the one that abused Lizzie and other people, but then also in Weston where Tyler works, there
was a priest who sexually abused young boys. Which unfortunately is such like a real thing. But it was handled very well without tapping into the like cliched jokie. I mean, not if it's a joke, but like people suck, which I appreciate it. I did have a question and I don't know if you know. But so I'm a teacher and a therapist and so we're like mandated reporters. So if you come to me and tell me that you're being abused or if like you're threatening suicide or if you come to me and you're you claim that you're saying you're abused or
you're threatening suicide or harming yourself or others, like we have to notify someone like whether it's like Department of Children and Families or the police or whatever. Do priests have any sort of like mandated like if someone comes to you and is like, hey, I'm going to go kill myself. I mean, that's not what Lizzie did. But I was wondering if there was any kind of like reporting or if it's because it's the church like that is the report. I don't know. I know that like so I have more experience honestly with like Methodist or Baptist churches
and at least the ones that I went to did because there were instances not of sexual abuse, but of like self harm and things like that. Because I went to a Baptist school when I was younger and then my my mom and like I grew up in a Methodist church outside of that. And in both cases, like I don't know if it was mandated or if they were just decent people, but there was kind of that that chain of command in the Catholic Church. I have no idea if something like that exists. Okay, I was just curious about it because they have to get confessions like that I would
imagine. Yeah, but like if you come into my booth, say like if you come to my booth and tell me you just murdered someone like do I report that if I'm a priest? I feel like I should. I also know like from like I think there's a lot in order as to you episode about somebody confessing that they killed somebody. And that priest does go to the cops obviously because that's how the show starts. But I don't know if that's like a mandatory thing or just like a good human. Right.
Interesting. Okay. One of the other things that I liked about this book though is that there is a lot of sexual abuse in the setting, but we don't get into the details, right? And I can't help but compare this with haunting Adeline where sexual abuse, specifically against children, was a big part of that setting. But we just went far too deep into the details unnecessarily. And I just this book did such a good job of conveying the damage that heinous acts like
that inflict upon victims and their loved ones in the community without going into details of what actually happened. Yes. I had so much respect for this author for doing that because it was handled in such a respectful way because this is a real problem like people get abused by the church and others. And it didn't tap into the fetishization of it where I feel like haunting Adeline kind of did. And it made, haunting Adeline is uncomfortable for other reasons, but it made the sex that
we do get in this book more comfortable because I'm not comparing it to now details like odd about rape. Right. Exactly. So while Tyler is home, his eldest brother talks about how he got invited to this very exclusive strip club that no one knows the name of or where it is unless you get invited. Very very exclusive. And I 100% bet that Poppy works there and fortunately Tyler also makes that connection as well on his drive home, which I was like, yes. Smart boy. No, no, like cookie crumbs that were only that were the only ones picking up. Yes, I was so glad like way to go.
Yeah. Tyler goes running the next day and immediately runs into Poppy, which is good because he's determined to help her anew. He suggests that they meet later in the day during his office hours and she agrees. When she meets him, he asks what brought her to Kansas City. So she starts talking. She says that there that when she was younger, she was the apple of her parents eye until the day she graduated from Dartmouth with her MBA. And that's when she realized that she was just another asset to her parents, a thing, a trophy, something to be coveted.
She talks about volunteering and Haiti as a young woman. How much she enjoyed that, the giving back and interacting with people and making a real difference and the juxtaposition between that experience against where she was at that graduation made her realize that she didn't want to be anyone's adornment to a perfect life. She needed more meaning than that. So she left. She walked away from the money in the future and any other rich boyfriends. She mentions being heartbroken after her last one named Sterling and that pricks Tyler's ears, but she doesn't elaborate any further.
She reveals that she hasn't spoken to her parents since and it's been three years. She suspects that they are furious, but Tyler protests saying that surely they can't be. What did you think about this with her parents? Because to me, like they didn't seem bad enough to be cut off from her life. Yeah. I mean, I felt like we were getting one side of the story. Yeah. You know, like I was like, you do you, but it doesn't sound like they did anything bad to you. Well, it's one thing to be like an asset.
Like I don't know. I feel like two things can be true. Like your parents can love you and then also see you as like a success and like an asset to their lives. Like property ish love for you. Yeah. Yeah. I don't know. It did seem like kind of a knee jerk reaction. Yeah. It's kind of made me sad. I was like, even talk to your, I mean, it doesn't matter, but it was like three years before, like you just disappeared on your parents and like they didn't seem to do anything. Yeah.
But then again, I mean, she is really young. So graduated college 21, two years at an MBA school, 23. So you know, she's really only like 26, 27. So I could see if you've been under your parents thumb for so long, how you might be acting out a little bit. That's very true. That is a good point. And she does bring up later. I'm not sure if it's in this section. I think it's a little bit later where living her life, she was never really sure if people
wanted her for her own merit or if it was just her last name and kind of connections that was influencing them. Yeah, which I do. I get wanting that separation of like, don't associate me with my family because I'm my own human. Right. Exactly. So Poppy reveals that she hasn't spoken to her parents since walking away and then it's been three years and she suspects that they are furious. Tyler protests saying that can't possibly be the case and that they would understand, but she says that it's a different situation and he's a priest you wouldn't understand.
You know, his parents must have been thrilled when he said that he was going to be a priest. But Tyler goes on to share that his own parents were furious when he took the cloth because of what happened to his sister Lizzie. He shares that story about how her suicide note detailed other victims which helped them bring the priest to justice, but that the reaction of the church was to deny an alienate which drove his family away from the church altogether. Hence the reaction to Tyler's own priesthood. I just want to say like, I love when we get a book with a character that is already deceased, but we get such like a clear image of who this person was.
And that is awesome for Lizzie to like name other victims so that like they could still be helped even though she's choosing this escape path. Yeah. Like, I just, I don't know. I liked that. I did too. And it was this and other times that Tyler and his family talk about Lizzie, it's very clear how strong of a person she is, even though she she entirely operates offscreen. And I that part of the book was just so well done. She has such an impact on the story and she is such a complex character in and of herself.
I don't know, it was just impressive. It's not often that you get that in these types of books at least. Oh, yeah, especially for like, this book is dirty, y'all. We're not there yet. It's filthy. But like, it is filthy. In the fun way. The best way. Oh, yeah. So Poppy goes on to say that she tried to work jobs using her MBA for a while, but this is where she says that she was never sure if it was her own skills or her last name that got her in. So eventually she chose to leave those behind too and drove until she didn't want to anymore,
which led her to Kansas City. She confirms that she works for the exclusive club that Tyler's brother had mentioned. Quote, it catered to a very specific clientele, and so I found myself stripping for the same men who would have employed me, married me, donated to my pet charities in another life. I loved it. I do love how sex positive she is and this book is because we do get some of Tyler's and her monologue of like, the church isn't against sex. Like I'm a priest, I can't have sex, but like, sex is a holy thing.
Like God made sex, like God is there, like sex is a thing that you guys should be doing. And I just really liked that because this very much could have gone into like a sex bad kind of way. And I was so glad it didn't. Yeah. And I also liked the parallelisms between like faith as being repressive sexually and also like the upper echelons of Waspe society being repressive sexually as well because like, poppy's not religious or even religious leaning at this point.
And she's loving the fact that she's a part of this world and also potentially ostracized by it because she's too sexual, right? But these men that live in her world would have like, married her like she says donated to her pet charities, etc. Also love it too. So she's like, yeah, okay, I'm not the only one. That does feel also like such a powerful position to be in. Yeah, exactly. From Poppy's point of view, I like that. Like I'm going to turn all these things that I've been judged for around and make bank.
So Tyler also appreciates the naughtiness, but he's also getting more and more turned on. So to distract himself, he asks her why Poppy liked that feeling. And she says it was because it was always clear that the patrons wanted her and only her, not her money or her connections or her family. She loves the way that they responded physically to her body. She got a kick out of refusing men and their ridiculous sense of money to become their mistress or whatever. She admits though just how starved sexually she was during that time.
So even though she was having a great time, dicking around with all of these, these old white guys, she wasn't having any personal connection or physicality herself. She would masturbate on stage just to get a relief, but that would just feed this cycle. And Tyler of course is picturing this whole thing and he can barely stand it. And I mean, and she's not subtle, like she is detailed in what she's talking about. Like there's no way that this poor man would not be turned on by this. Oh yeah, absolutely. And she keeps going on to say that she wants to be used.
And she asks Tyler what kind of sin that is because surely it is one, but what if it's a sin and what if she's not sorry? Does that mean there's something wrong with her? Yes. Tyler's like so turned on that he can't even respond properly. He's just like, yeah, but luckily Poppy's phone rings and she has to leave. So as soon as she leaves, Tyler masturbates to the thought of her words and the images that she had conjured right on his desk.
And to put a point on it, the first time he's touched himself in like three years. Are priests not allowed to masturbate? I guess not. I don't know. I know they're not allowed to have sex. I don't know if that includes masturbation. He had, I don't know if it's here. I think it is. He makes like a comment about how like, thank God he doesn't have anything else after this meeting with Poppy. And his inner monologue says the only meeting that was about to happen was between my hand and my dick. Yep. So he like blows his load all over his desk, right?
And afterward he's immediately guilty because there's this huge portrait of St. Augustine sitting kind of above his chair facing him. And he's just like, fuck. Sorry, bro. And so he prays and he's apologizing to God. But internally he ends with admitting that he's actually sorry that he's not sorry. I've been there. Yeah, I've been there. So a few days later we see Tyler in a coffee shop and he's looking over a spreadsheet that
he can't really decipher about church renovation budgets. Of course Poppy comes in and joins him. She looks at the spreadsheet and teases him about how I guess they didn't teach you how to use Excel in seminary school. And they start quoting Latin back and forth, specifically Seneca, because his perspective is I learned other things in seminary school besides spreadsheets. And the fact that she can quote it back kind of tells him like you can learn both.
And specifically she quotes this line, if you wish to be loved, love, saying that it hadn't really worked out for her. And Tyler can tell that this hurts her. So he reaches out and touches her wrist saying that maybe she loved the wrong person. They have this moment of electricity and Tyler's thumb kind of does that thing where you're holding hands with somebody and it rubs the inside of your wrist.
And Liz is dying. It's the whole Mr. Darcy hand clench. 100%. And Tyler even in his internal monologue is like what am I doing? I'm just comforting her, right? This is just totally platonic and comforting. Like I would do this with any of my parishioners. Right. And he sees the physical reaction that it elicits in her. Her pulse starts to quicken, her pupils start to dilate and he's like I have to leave. This is not going to go well.
I'm going to bend her over this table. Right, in front of everybody. But of course Poppy decides to walk with him saying that her house is close to the church and he's like of course it fucking is. And this is when we learn that she lives basically across a small park from the church and the rectory where Tyler lives. She tells him that she recently bought it after starting to work at the club, the exclusive club in their marketing and finance department rather than as a dancer. She alludes to having to quit the club because her ex Sterling showed up and he just seems
like a big bad news bear. As they part ways Tyler can't help but offer his assistants moving furniture or whatever and that makes Poppy so happy that she leans in and kisses his cheek. Tyler's praise that not seeing her in church the next day means that she's done with them. Her passing interest in Catholicism or religion has been done with and she will be out of his life. But then she shows up in confession on the following Monday and shares more about her
past. It's a poor boy. So in her confession Poppy says again how lonely she was at the club. She wouldn't become a mistress because she eventually wants a family and so she just had all of these offers that she kept refusing. But then Sterling Haverford the third came to the club. Her ex and her first kiss, her cigarette and her first orgasm. Though now of course she knows that he was screwing other girls when they dated before when they were younger but at the time she was convinced that he loved her and that they were going to get married. But then she gets an invitation in the mail to Sterling's wedding to another woman and
she is heartbroken. Which what the fuck? I just can't imagine being in a situation like that where you think that you're dating somebody and that you're going to get married and then you were so wrong about that. Like I would be mortified. I would be so mortified. And also like why invite her to the wedding? Like why not? Like I just it's so cruel. Well it's a controlling thing and he is a big work so.
I know. It's a big old piece of work. But like oh that would be, I would also run away. So Poppy confesses that she could have walked out of the club when Sterling showed up but that deep down she still wanted him to choose her over this other woman that he had married. She felt so satisfied when she saw the effect that she had on him that night when she was in her skimpy dancing outfit and that he wanted her physically. So she let him fuck her and despite herself enjoyed it.
She enjoyed the degradation when he told her that the reason he didn't marry her was because he knew that deep down she was a whore and not a wife. She finishes her confession by saying how ashamed she is, how she can't believe she did it and she regrets it. Okay so between you and me there were a lot of quotes in this book that like said things. One of them was in this confession she says, Sterling wanted me to be his calculated affair. I had loved him and he wanted to keep me as his pet mistress in a box that had no place for real love or a real future. To that I said, oof.
Oof. Tyler, hearing this confession berates himself for being just as bad as Sterling while simultaneously wanting to punch the dude in the throat. He compares himself to Sterling because he's sexually infatuated with Poppy and feels that what he's doing to her or thinking about her is the same that Sterling is doing, using her for his own desire. He asks Poppy how it felt and she takes that to mean physically and so she describes it and that brings Tyler to the point of wondering if he could jerk off in this confessional
booth without her knowing. He clarifies that he meant how did it feel emotionally and she tells him quote, I'd rather have sex without love than no sex at all. So what do I do now? How do I carry the shame of all this while at the same time knowing it's a fundamental part of who I am? Do you think? That's a question. That's a question. That's a question here. Do you think like, do you think Poppy has any ulterior motives? Like, do you think she's trying to turn him on or she just like genuinely like, I'm gonna talk about sex?
Oh, I think she's trying to turn him on because based on what she says later in the book, how she felt the same attraction that Tyler did after the first confession, I think she's absolutely trying to. And she admits later that after the first confession, she looked at what she, what he looks like. Oh yeah. And was like, oh, baby. Oh, baby. Okay, you're right. I forgot that she looked him up. Yeah. So I don't think she's typically this blunt because she's using language like, like, you know, cunt, pussy, wet, hard cocks, dilated eyes, yeah, not a way.
Flush slapping against each other. Not a way I would speak to a priest. Or anybody I don't know, right? Right. Anybody that's not like you. Right. Or my husband. So like, right. I think she's, she's being intentionally descriptive and a little bit crass to like get a rise out of him. Okay. That's what I was thinking too, but I wanted to. Curious. So at her question about, you know, how does she move on? Tyler tells her that God made them all sexual beings. And Poppy goes on to say something, but stops herself and tries to leave.
But Tyler absolutely needs to know what she was going to say. And so he rushes out of the booth to meet her. And they have this intense moment where he's caging her against the confessional booth. But masters himself enough to kind of move to the side so she can pass by. And he's essentially giving her one last chance to leave. But instead she stays close and they end up giving to, into their mutual lust. He bends her over a nearby piano and eats her out from behind.
After she orgasms, she confesses that no one has ever done that before. And Tyler is horrified that no one has ever taken care of her. But he tries to back out, reality pushing back in. But Poppy is in. She presses him that if they don't have penetrative sex, it doesn't count, right? So they can just keep going and have a little fun. She undoes his pants and draws out his cock, telling him that she touched herself to him after the first time that they met. He tells her to show him right there on the floor of the church.
And she does. He kneels between her legs as she does so and ends up rubbing himself against her clit without penetration, all the while biting her neck and feeling the weight of her beneath him. Then she flips them over and she makes him come by rubbing herself against him. This scene was so fucking hot! I've never, I've, okay. I've never been so turned on by a scene that was like this, I guess like non-penetrative,
I'll say. Yeah, because it's really like mutual masturbation. They're just like touching each other. Right. Yeah. Just like so well written and they're both so like into each other. Yes. And also there's like the little bit of the like exhibitionist, like anyone could just come into the church, guys. You are like in the middle. Oh my gosh, they do this so many times and I thought for sure they were going to get caught. I'm, I was so stressed every time they did it in the church. I'm so glad that that's not how things went. Yeah. I think they would have done it too, because that would have been just a little bit too
cliche, I think. Yes, it definitely would have. But oh my god, it was just no notes. No notes. Yeah. I mean, so this, this scene is obviously very explicit and specific, but Tyler also kind of lets this kind of former dominating persona come out and uses that in this scene and in others and it's really well done. It's not like some of the other like BDSM light TM books that you might read.
He just has like, like he's not using, I don't know, like call me sir and like what's our safe word. He just has a very commanding voice and directs her essentially and she just is super into that. And, and he gets off on like seeing that submission, but not in that like you said cliche or classic BDSM way. Right. I can't. No, no. Yeah. I mean, look, one handed book club for this one guys. They're like so much of this book. Yeah.
So afterward, they kind of clean up, get a little bit more dressed and they don't speak. They each feel the weight of kind of the reality of what they've done, settle on their shoulders and they don't really know how to proceed. Yeah. As she leaves, Tyler realizes that Poppy has buried herself deep beneath his skin and he is way, way too far gone. And I appreciate this too. How from his inner monologue that we get how much it's not just sex for him.
Like he is way turned on, but like he also is just really into her. And I liked that. I do too. Especially from her confessions, he finds her personhood and like the struggles that she has interesting. And as the book goes on, they start to talk more about religion and other mutual interests and it's just clear that they have a lot in common besides this sexual attraction. Which makes, I mean, we talk about communication in these sex scenes all the time.
It like heightens that because they do have this connection. Exactly. So later that day, Millie, the very old bookkeeper for the church, comes by Tyler's house to drop off food. She's adopted him as kind of a project and so not just helps out with the books but also, you know, makes food for him, checks in on him, that kind of thing. Tyler describes her as being sharp as a tack and very forward oriented. For example, she advocated for fiber optic internet at the church before things like
that even existed in Weston. But I just, I love that Millie is this character. Millie's a badass. Like I, she's so great. In this visit, Millie knows that something is wrong and pushes Tyler to tell her. And when he won't, she guesses that it has to do with Poppy. She says that they saw, she saw them at the coffee shop and could tell that there was an energy between them. And Tyler confirms it with his body language more than anything because Homeboy has no chill. He's got no chill, no poker face.
Millie tells him, quote, I've always said that you were too young and too handsome to lock your life away. Trouble will come of it, I said. Mark my words. And nobody marked my words. I'm going to use that. Nobody marked my words. Nobody marked my words. And here we are. What did I tell you? What did I tell you? Tyler tells Millie that he can't simply abandon his life at the first sign of temptation. And Millie tells him it's not abandoning. Just maybe don't flagellate yourself about it. It might notice if only you knew. I know, I feel like that's also kind of Tyler's normal.
Like cool girl. Yeah. I'm just crushed. Totally not flagellating myself. Right. Like I'm, I'm fine. Everything's fine. Later that day, Tyler attends his men's group. It's a crowning achievement for him since he'd arrived that it had grown so big. The victims of the past priests were young boys and many of the men in town resented the church. Tyler made an effort to seem approachable manly. He bought a truck, he smoked cigars, he watched Royals games in the local bar.
He felt like he had a duty to this community to bring specifically men back into the church. And the fact that this had grown from two old men who had, were only coming because they had forgotten how to not go to church to over 40 men of differing ages, he was really proud of that. Because of what he'd done with Poppy, he feels like he's betrayed this group and his achievements. Like this one, he's giving his like lesson on male sexuality too. So he's like, cool. Or is that later? Yeah. I think it is, but we don't get any details about it. No.
But he's like, of course it's tonight that we're doing that. All right. He's like, I planned this months in advance and this is just terrible coincidence. Yeah. I really liked this just kind of casual portrayal of male companionship. Like. Yeah. I don't know. We talk about this a lot kind of outside of the podcast, but like how important it is for men to have friendships and interests and activities outside of like couple friends
or their wives. And I, I've heard of men's groups like my stepfather's a part of a men's group, which works really well for him. But this one is so interesting in this book because it is so multi-dimensional. Like there's old men, there's young men, there's fathers, there's teenagers. Like it's just a really healthy seeming opportunity for a lot of different types of people specifically male to come together and share time. Which is, it is so important. We do talk about that a lot. And it also like, it subtly addresses the toxic masculinity.
Like I'm going to portray myself as Tyler as like being a guy's guy, but then giving you this place like of support and companionship. Right, exactly. And like we can have both. We can have both. You can be in touch with your feelings and still be a manly man. Yes, two things can be true. So after his group, he goes for a run and he pushes himself to his physical limits. When he comes back, he goes to the sanctuary and begs for forgiveness. And it's the early evening, he's alone and he starts to feel the presence of God and
he interprets this as a forgiveness. He's made lighter over the next couple of days and he feels like he's shed the mantle of this temptation that Poppy has presented. But then on Mass on Friday, Poppy is there. She comes up during communion and he places his hand on her head for a blessing and the feeling of electricity is immediate and apparent for both of them. And as a result, Tyler feels betrayed by God. He thinks if he was forgiven, why was the temptation not also removed?
Like why do I still feel this way? I don't understand what you want from me. Why is she even here still? He says, quote, Father, if you are willing, take this cup from me. Even Jesus said those words. Not that they had worked out so well for him. I mean, why was God so willing to leave bad cups all over the place? I thought that was so funny. Yeah, I did too. That's a good question. Why are all these bad cups lying around? Yeah, like why aren't you helping me with this? I really love the evolution and use of Tyler's relationship with God in this book.
I'm not a religious person, but I felt it. It was so relatable even for someone who doesn't have a relationship with God. And it was just nice. Again, it was like another off-screen type of character where you do have this other entity. Yeah. Well, I liked it too because like we talked in our debrief, one, it's really rare to read this type of book that religion is such a big part of and not like a antagonistic part
of, right? Like not a villain character or a preachy character, right? It was just a part of who both of these characters are. And I really appreciate that portrayal of religion because I feel like very often it's not an option. You know? Yeah, very much. Especially because we do read so much fantasy, I feel like we do so often have that the church is the bad guy, the church is against magic. Whatever the church means in that context, it's always or even like you said, if we get
anything sort of positive about the church, it's some sort of preachy character. It's positive, but they're also like the voice of morality and you're like, okay. Okay. Yeah, exactly. I also really appreciated the way that this author wrote about how Tyler experiences God because I'm not like a part of formalized religion, but I do believe in God and I do feel I have a relationship with them and I feel like actually I've been trying to call them at least by they, them pronouns recently, if not her.
But I like that. The way that Tyler experienced the presence of God is very similar to my own experience and that was just very like validating for me. And again, in a book about smut, I was not expecting that. No. And we'll get to it at the end, but like this arc of his relationship with God is also so satisfying. Yeah, because again, it's an evolution, not a choice.
Yes, which just listen, like Sierra Simone, I don't know how you could write such filth and still make it so like touching. A wholesome, spiritually like. Yeah. Like I tend to fall more on the like witchy side. Like I do believe in like some universal power, whatever you want to call it. But even reading this book, I was like, I should set my altar back up.
Like I should. Yeah. Re like get back into those things, like make that connection again, like that meditation, all of those types of things. Yeah, absolutely. You should. So when Tyler goes to leave the church after Mass, Poppy is there and they talk about the macabre nature of Catholicism, how its rituals feel ancient. So they talk about how the body and blood of Christ, Catholics believe that those actually turn into the body and the blood of Christ and how all of these rituals are designed
to feel ancient to elicit those feelings. And Tyler realizes that he likes talking about his faith with her like he could do it forever. And in this conversation, he realizes that what he feels for her is a recipe for falling in love. In this conversation, she asks to help out with the pancake breakfast that the church holds twice a month. And it's happening the following day and Tyler gratefully accepts the help as they're usually very short staffed. That pancake breakfast goes off without a hitch and Tyler can't help but notice how much of a natural Poppy is in this context. She's interacting with people, she's having a good time, she's a natural volunteer.
As he's cleaning up and the other volunteers have gone, Poppy turns back up saying that she had lingered to help one of the attendees with the tax issues and she's a registered CPA. Tyler is surprised and Poppy kind of gets her back up about it. She's like, do you not think that I'm a good person? Like, why is it surprising that I would help somebody? And he tells her, it's not you, it's just that people from your background aren't usually raised to be helpful. And so it just, it's a nice surprise. Yeah, especially helpful for free.
Right. Poppy tells Tyler that Sterling called her last night and left a voicemail with all of the same stuff that he'd said before and also telling her that he's coming for her. Tyler says that he doesn't like that, that he thinks it's a bad idea for her to interact with him. And Poppy calls him out for being like Sterling and wanting what he can't have. And Tyler connects that to the priest who abused his sister Lizzie and I didn't quite follow that but I think it was just like Tyler doesn't really quite know where Poppy's like
rebuke is coming from. Yeah, I think he was a bit confused but it was a very strange connection that he made. Right. I mean, it is true that like Sterling and Tyler have this thing in common where they both want what they can't have but like I don't know how he got to abusive priests from there. Yeah, because that's, it's one way you can't have in a far different way. Yeah, very, very different. So then later that night in the middle of the night, it's like 3 a.m. or something like that, Poppy shows up at Tyler's house with a bottle of scotch. It's raining and she's in her basically her pajamas with nothing on underneath and she's
soaking wet. She tells him that she wants to apologize for earlier but it's clear that she's like nervous and Tyler tries to tell her that he is the one who took advantage of her but this just pisses her off because she feels like she doesn't get to have a part in the narrative. She's relegated to like an innocent bystander. But her anger makes something snap and Tyler and he gives in to her, his urges. He pulls her into his lab and asks why she came over in the middle of the night without any underwear on and she tells him that she wants him to make her come.
And he tells her that just for that night and no more they can be together and then tells her to kneel and suck. Which she does. With gusto. With gusto. Yeah. No, this, no notes. No notes. The scene is so good. Yeah. Yeah, cause again, Tyler's kind of warring with this. He calls it his feminist ally Tyler side.
I love that side because we get background that in college she was like almost a women's studies major. Like he took enough classes to get that major or minor. Right. Yeah. So he's like trying to thread that line but while also just really wanting to dominate her and she like when she says like, oh no, you don't get to take this from me. Like I'm not an innocent bystander. I just won't bother you with my body or my wants anymore. He's like, okay, you know what? Get on your knees. No more feminist ally Tyler.
So they have this blowjob scene in front of the fireplace in his living room and then they move to the kitchen. He puts her on the counter where he kisses her for the first time but she realizes that she's not as eager and he asks her if she wants him to take it and she tells him that she does. So he's rough. He dominates their kiss and he like puts his hand in his hair and holds her roughly that kind of thing and then he enters her just a little bit.
Just the tip. Just the tip. Just the tip. I promise. And she starts masturbating and moving back and forth on him enough to make him come. Afterwards he thanks her for what happened and kisses her again but softly this time. This scene, like if you told me that there was a sex scene in a book where the male just like stands still with like just the tip and a woman I'd be like, that sounds awkward as hell. No, this scene was excellent.
Yeah. I mean it makes me feel like I mean I know like teenagers and whatever but like, man I was doing it wrong for so many years. Right? So this interaction kind of opens the floodgates right? And as much as they both promise to stay away after that night, two days later they have plans to have lunch. I don't know who they were kidding. No, I don't. Look. Before Tyler meets up with Poppy though, he gets a call from his bishop, Bishop Boeve, who's asking whether he'll attend an upcoming conference.
This bishop is hopeful that he'll get approval for a panel on abuse that he's been advocating for for a number of years. And Tyler feels hugely hypocritical but agrees to go to this conference if the panel is approved. At lunch, Millie is also there and Poppy shares with both of them her ideas for raising money for the church. Essentially she talks about this plan where they're going to start to go fund me, they're going to use guerrilla marketing, like get people into the church, give them free wine and whiskey tastings and then they'll feel more obligated to give to the church. They'll do kind of a special interest piece within the local paper about the church and
how they want to revitalize it, how it's a really old church, historically important, et cetera, et cetera. And Millie and Tyler are both in and hugely grateful. They set this plan in motion and they're going to use an upcoming festival to start with this plan. I love that this also like highlights her because we get her background like she's a stripper and she loves it but she also has this NBA, she has the knowledge and I like that we get to highlight that knowledge too. Yeah. In such a like, I don't want to say innocuous but like, I don't know, I feel like some books
are like, I don't know. The thing that comes to mind is like, Phaera can't read and then one of her challenges under the mountain has to do with reading. Right. It was just like, I'm gonna slap you in the face. Yeah. This was just like, hey, thanks for coming to lunch. I've got ideas. How do you like them? Yeah, it seems like just like a normal interaction where like, you can highlight your intelligence without it being such like a big old flashing sign. Like I am smart.
Right. And then this was just a conversation to build characters. It wasn't actually a plot point, right? Like this festival happens or doesn't but we don't attend it, right? It's just like another thing to bring Poppy and Tyler closer together and to show how invested Poppy is in the community that Tyler's a part of. But it doesn't feel like a waste of time. Like it not being a plot point isn't a fault at all. Like it's great character development. Right, exactly. So as Poppy and Tyler walk back from lunch, Poppy tells Tyler that she might actually
be interested in converting to Catholicism but that she feels foolish when she tries to pray. Before he can stop himself, Tyler's like, well, find me tonight after my men's group and we'll work on it together. And I'm like, brother. Like you're not even trying. No. After the men's group, Tyler finds Poppy in the sanctuary at the altar silently crying. He instantly realizes that she's communing with God. He feels it in the air just as he had before on his own. He holds her from behind and in silence they both experience the feeling together.
Eventually, when the light from the sun fades and it's solidly evening, Poppy turns and they both admit that they're falling for each other and they share a long, passionate kiss. Then Tyler walks her home. He tells her that he wants to hold her hand and hold her in public and not worry about who can see, but he can't and he doesn't know what to do. He tells her that he wants to see her again and she readily agrees, but she says that she has to go to Kansas City for work so they'll have to wait three days.
Tyler feels how long that is. He's like, holy shit, I thought I was gonna be able to see you like tomorrow. Like how am I going to, how am I gonna do this? How am I possibly gonna wait for you? Right. So he follows her into her garden and in the shadows, he gets her off with his hand over her mouth so that no one hears. He tells her that when she comes back, he wants to be with her, like biblically. And she obviously also wants that. I had to put that in there.
I'm so glad you did. Oh my god. Nailed it. This scene in the garden is really hot because it's like he, he doesn't get anything. He's just like fingering her and getting her off and he's like, next time when you come back, like I'll get mine, but this is just to tide you over. Yeah. Cause I think she even like offers to like get him off and he's like, nope, this is for you. I'll get mine. I love, let's put other people's pleasure before our own sometimes.
Right. I can't see that. Shocking. So the next day during mass, Tyler realizes that he's falling in love with Poppy. He oscillates wildly between feeling at peace with wanting Poppy and feeling deep, deep shame and guilt. He's confused and he spends hours praying to God for an answer, but he doesn't receive anything close to a confirmation of whether he's doing the right thing or not. Thursday arrives and Tyler can hardly contain himself. So he decides not to. He goes to his room to masturbate and he calls Poppy over the phone.
They both masturbate for a little relief. And at the end of it, Poppy says, Hey, Tyler, you can call me anytime. Oh, the phone scene is so good. I've never really been into phone sex myself because I feel like there's a lot of like, oh yeah, like, it feels fake. Yeah. And so I don't know. This scene was fine. Not my thing, but it was well written. It was well written. Like I also phone sex is not my thing because like, to be completely honest, I need to have
ever had phone sex. Like, I'm just sitting on my couch. Yeah, I'm faking the fuck out of it. I'm faking the fuck out of it. No matter how attracted I am to you, like I'm pretending because phone sex is weird. But I think like they were both so clearly actually into it that I was like, okay, like I'm here for the scene. I'm still not interested because it seems fucking weird, but like, all right. You do. It's great. That's a really great way to put it. When Poppy finally does come home, they meet at the church.
Tyler wants a plausible reason for him to see her thinking that his house would be too questionable. And he also reasons that Thursday has zero events. So literally no one should be at the church. And I like fine. They don't get caught, but I was still nervous through this entire thing. I was so nervous because they're, yeah, there's no events, but they're not in a private space. No. I feel like them being in his house would be less conspicuous. Right. And I like churches are not, I guess, like, I want to say defensible positions, but they're
not secure, right? Like there's windows all over the place. There's so many fucking doors. Like, I was just so nervous. There's also that like cliche that like you don't lock the church. Like it's like anyone could come in at any time. Right, exactly. So like, and it's not like the middle of the night. Like this is like evening. Yeah. Like like late early evenings. I'm like, guys, guys, and it's such an active church that I'm like really no one's gonna know. Okay. All right. And no one does.
No one does. Fear not. But fear not. Fear not, young reader. But so stressful. So Poppy arrives, she's wearing this like really cute, sexy red dress and Tyler realizes pretty quickly that she's not wearing any underwear and they just get right to it and he takes her right up to the altar and I'm like the altar of all places. Jesus Christ. I know on all caps, I notice on the altar. I know. But then I put swoon. I know. But then I put, oh, on the altar.
I know at first I was like, oh my God, you're not even trying Tyler. So okay, for those of you who are like not super familiar with Catholicism, typically speaking altars are consecrated with some kind of holy relic and this particular altar, they talked about at some point, there are bones of some saint in it. They don't specify what, but holy, holy bones of some kind in the altar to consecrate it. So they be fucking on some dead people and you know. And Tyler even kind of references that in his inner monologue in this scene of like,
the holiness of their union, but also like, this is a holy place for me to put her body and like, that was a little weird with the bones, but okay, not weird enough to ruin it. So I look, I did not think I was going to enjoy altar sex as much as I ended up doing, but we'll get into why at the end. So, um, so there's a couple of things here. The first is that he bends her over the altar, but he also uses like, they're a little like
sashes or like ropes that priests use to like tie their robes and he uses one of those to tie her, her wrists together as she's bent over. Unfortunately, that doesn't last very long. I was a little bit wanting that to last a little bit longer, but it does not. Yeah, it does not. So he kind of inspects how wet she is and how the fact that she doesn't have any underwear on and then he kind of pulls her up, makes her kneel before him and suck before fucking her right on top of the altar. And in the blowjob scene, he's rough.
So he's, she's asked him to essentially claim her and be rough with her and she'll tell him if it's too much. And wait, man, that blowjob scene was really nice. I love a good blowjob scene. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So then they get to fucking right on top of the altar. She begs him to be rough, like I said, but he's hesitant, right? So he's started to be rough, but he also doesn't want to be that guy. Feminist Tyler, feminist ally Tyler is kind of in his head about it, right?
So Poppy ends up goading him until they're both giving in to their base or desires and taking what they want from each other. Afterward, Tyler cleans Poppy up and wraps her in the altar cloth and on the stairs, he holds her in whisper sweet nothings into her ear. So the altar scene is great for a number of different reasons, but to your point earlier, Tyler has a sentan internal monologue that he feels like their union is incredibly hot, but then also somehow bringing them closer together. Like they are acting out like a consecrated act by having sex with each other and he feels
that like deep sense of spiritualness as they're doing it, which I really loved like making sex a spiritual like thing. I think that's really like an undercurrent of why I love this book so much because even though he has such an inner inner war of like, I'm a priest, I'm not supposed to be doing this like this is taboo. Their union isn't something he's like actually ashamed of like he's ashamed of breaking his vows, but he's not ashamed of like the act of sex.
And that like talking about like distinction. Yeah. And he talks about like feeling like like God's presence is like in sex as much as it is in abstinence. Like he's here all the time. So like in that consecration, like we can't be together, but we've now entered into some sort of union under the eyes of God. Yeah. And he talks about the act of fucking on an altar like this, almost like almost feeling like they've stumbled onto some kind of ancient part of religion that like we don't practice
anymore because it is taboo, but he revels in that feeling. Which I also loved. So as they sit on the stairs and Tyler essentially is performing aftercare, Poppy asks Tyler what he wants and he's afraid to say. So she's like, fine. She straddles him and starts writing him again and says, why won't you tell me? And he tells her that he never wants what they have to stop. She says that she doesn't either and that this feels like love. But before she says the actual L word, he asks her not to say it, not yet.
Because once they do, everything will have to change. And she asks, what's the difference between saying it and what they've already done? Like haven't we already reached the point of their return? Which is, you know, a valid point, Poppy. Yeah, and he doesn't really have a good answer for that. Later they lie in Tyler's bed and Poppy remarks how clean he is. He tells her then the story of how he found his sister and inadvertently got oil on her face and her body. She was found in the garage and so their garage was very, very dirty and there were oil cans
all over the place that she had used to help. This experience instilled in him a desire to always be clean and Poppy tells him that it sounds more like a penance than anything else. She asks him if he doesn't want to be rough with her because of his sister and he says no that he just has had bad luck with women in the past. Strong women don't like it rough or traumatized women feel like they deserve it. Poppy tells him that Sterling was the first person to be rough with her and she loved
the way it made her feel. Tyler bitterly remarks that it's a shame that it didn't work out between them. She reprimands him for being jealous and he admits it that he's jealous that Sterling can just come by and court her, be public about it when he can't and Poppy asks him what they're doing, right? Like what are we doing here? But he's still not ready to talk about it so he distracts her with more sex. Oh Tyler. This was one part of the book that I didn't particularly like because I understand that Tyler doesn't want to talk about it but he seems so mature in other ways that I'm just
not sure why he never is able to say the words like I'm just not ready to talk about it or like verbalize the way he's feeling in any way. Yeah, I didn't really like this either. He is so mature and even his inner monologue is mature like we get why he doesn't want to talk about it or like where the discomfort is but him just leaving Poppy in the dark and distracting her wasn't great. Right and it's the start of that miscommunication trope, right? Which is upsetting because obviously them not talking to each other makes them both
create these different narratives that they're filling with whatever, right? Yes, which doesn't help anyone. Yeah. So, I mean for example, when Tyler wakes up he's alone and the guilt and the doubt that he's been feeling creeps in. He convinces himself that he imagined the moment the night before when Poppy almost said the L word and that it doesn't mean the same thing to him or that this whole thing doesn't mean the same thing to her as it does to him. He is just a passing distraction to her and isn't worth her time. In the bathroom he sees his reflection, specifically a hickey on his neck and is disgusted.
He sits on the edge of his bath and cries. He knows he's a good man but he doesn't understand why he's done what he's done. He feels like he's putting everything that he has, everything that he is, everything that he cares about on the line for somebody who doesn't feel the same way back. Man, those narratives we tell ourselves. Brutal. They are insidious. Because he's facing this assumption on simply the fact that she wasn't there in the morning. That's it.
That's the only thing he's- And that she didn't say goodbye. That's it. Yeah. But I mean, and I say that knowing that I've done the exact same thing. So I get it. But like- It's a perfectly natural reaction. Yeah. But from the outside I'm like, dude, have a conversation. I know, just talk to them. Cause she tried and you didn't. And this goes on. So he doesn't hear from Poppy all day and tells himself that the space is needed. It's the wisest choice.
He's tempted to but ultimately doesn't end up reaching out and texting her. He thinks about his sister and how talking about her made the pain of her loss easier. For his convictions and his vocation, he can't help the pain of the thought that Poppy is done with him. Buddy. Dude, I know. Just luxuriating in his own narratives. Yes. That's such a great way to put it. The next day Poppy does show up to help with the pancake breakfast but avoids Tyler.
Afterwards, Millie asks if something has happened between them and he lies and says no. Millie essentially tells him not to fuck this up because this community needs both of them. Later Tyler decides to text her but she doesn't text back and Tyler is crushed. Also been there. Millie is so sharp. Like she's seeing all of this go down and all the bullshit. All the bullshit. Um, all the bullshit. And okay, so talking about the narrative, I can, we don't get Poppy's point of view
on this but I can only imagine that her narrative is that he didn't want to talk about what we are because he also doesn't want anything. So like that's probably why she's avoiding him because they're both thinking the same thing. Well, and I mean like beyond that, and we do kind of get this a little bit later, but like Poppy knows how much his vocation means to him. She knows he loves being a priest and he gets a lot of personal satisfaction and meaning out of that. So she's weighing like who am I to come in and fuck that up like it doesn't matter what
I want and if he loves me like I don't want to be the reason that he walks away from something that he's so passionate about like what is my future like what's what's the end game here and he won't talk about it which means he's already made his mind up. Right. It's my episode like I'm not worth it and also who am I to even ask for him to give that up. Right. You're right. I'm not worth it. Don't give it up. Don't give it up. But then what am I doing? Right because it looks like but I still want you so what am I doing here? Oh boy this is so relatable. Yep.
Jesus. It goes down. I'm not crying. You're crying. I'm not crying. The next day though Poppy shows up for confessional. Tyler asks where she's been and she tells him she's been right here the whole time. He tells her it doesn't feel like it. It feels like he's risking everything and she's the one that's walking away. She asks what am I walking away from though? Asks him whether he thinks about how it crushes her to know that what she wants from him
will ruin him. Right. So this is exactly what we were talking about. Like she's fully aware of what they're doing and what the consequences will mean if it if he chooses her. He doesn't exactly know what to say to that because he hasn't thought about it from that perspective and so instead they go into confessional and she talks. She tells him about the guilt she feels about how torn she is, how every moment she feels she's made a decision to walk away or to ask for more she changes her mind. She talks about how it feels so right being with him even fucking on the altar.
Like they stumble into an ancient forgotten part of religion that allowed them to be close to God and close to each other at the same time. She can't stop thinking about him or wanting him but she doesn't know what to do because either choice that they make will result in one of them giving up something that they love. Yeah and potential for resentment. Right. Tyler after this confession can't contain his desires any longer and tells her to get into his office which they do.
So they go from fighting to confession to fucking really fucking quick and I don't have a problem with that. I don't either. I mean it for how the relationship has been built it honestly makes so much sense. Oh yeah. So he locks the door and they are going to the desk but they end up falling on the floor and fucking. He can't help but be rough. He can't help but be rough with his need and Poppy is all about that. Then he asks if he can take her ass and she eagerly accepts. He goes briefly to get some sacramental oil to use as lubrication.
I love how often he uses like consecrated things. Yeah and he literally feels guilty about it. And then he's like man because even when he tied her wrists that was part of his priest robe. Yeah it's priest robe. After the duck he wrapped her in the altar cloth. He cleans her up with like there's this cloth I forget what it's called but they use it like to wipe the rim of the wine jug.
Like he used that to clean her up. He's using all of the things that are supposed to be for Jesus. For Jesus. On her. And now the oil like. Oh my god. Buddy. Yeah so he gets this consecrated special ceremonial oil and he uses that to lubricate them both and he fucks her in the ass and finishes on her back and wow. Look I don't think we've had a book that talks about anal in this way and look I'm here for
it. It was intense. It was intense. It was it was real hot. Yeah again no notes. Yep so he finishes on her back right and she's kind of lying there on the floor like very happy and satisfied and she commands him to clean her up and he says quote like the little queen she was and he does and he's just like so happy to do so and then he engages in other aftercare like praising her with words of affection and massaging her body and he can tell based on her response to this that aftercare is never something that she enjoyed with Sterling.
And I love the show the aftercare because again even though this isn't like explicit BDSM you don't need BDSM to have aftercare like there should always be aftercare and like we rarely see it aside from like cuddling. Right. So I haven't mentioned this yet but he uses terms for her like lamb and little lamb. And which taps into the religion of it all but I was really here for that lamb.
Oh boy. I like that of a princess any day. Oh yeah. Oh yeah. No it was great. The forbidden fruit themes here just very very good. Just prime. So Tyler is slowly accepting that he's in love with Poppy and so he decides to give her something to show her what she means to him. So one evening he goes over to her house and gives her his sister sorry.
So one evening he goes over to her house and gives her his sister Lizzie's rosary and he teaches her how to use it together in a surreptitious way as they do so he tells her that he loves her. I found this I love you to be a bit weird because he's talking about Lizzie and like why he is comfortable like giving such a like powerful connection to Poppy and says she would have loved you like I do.
And I was like I mean hopefully not quite like that. Hopefully not quite the same way. Yeah. I just I was like I get it I get I get the sentiment but I was like I for the first I love you I it was a bit weird. Yeah it was a bit weird and like I wish that it was phrased differently like I know what he was going for but I don't think that for the first I love you that's what he meant you know. Right. It can't like those should have been separate thoughts like she would have loved you so I want like you to have this and then a separate I love you in a different way in
Biblically. Biblically. I want to get your digits girl. Yeah I just I was kind of bummed. So after this Tyler goes to see a priest in Kansas City named Jordan. I thought it was interesting that both your names were in this. I know. It was so weird I was here for it too and Jordan is also awesome. I love him. Yeah. Jordan is a very intense priest about the same age as Tyler whom he'd met in seminary
school and so Jordan is the priest to whom Tyler goes to for his own confessional. But when Tyler arrives Jordan refuses to hear him confess at all because he says Tyler isn't ready to give her up. He says that God told him about Poppy and that until Tyler is ready to give her up and confess and be forgiven he can fuck off. He adds that he won't tell the bishop but that Tyler should be exceedingly careful. This was so badass because like he Jordan knows about Poppy without like Tyler doesn't
say anything to him. No Jordan has a very close and intense relationship with God and so God is the one that told him everything about the situation that he needed to know. Which I love like it was also so realistic in a weird way. I was like this makes sense to me. Yeah. Yeah. I mean like on the witchy side of things right it's like having a very intense and specific premonition. Yes. Yes. And I mean again like I believe in that and so universe God whatever you want to call
it it makes sense to me that Jordan's like that's not worth you confessing to me because you're not ready. And I know I know your problem you don't have to tell me. Mm-hmm. Yeah. No I don't want to hear it just whenever you're past this. And it's such a good point like in a religious confession way but even just in general like sharing something like even like conversations I've had with you like are you saying this to feel better now or are you saying it to like actually be absolved because if you're not going to change anything why are like why are we talking about it which like.
Right. Yes I am Queen Hippocrate over here but I get it makes it so relatable. It does. Yeah. I don't know to that point like there's a difference between like talking about something knowing that you're not going to do anything about it and talking about something to the end of getting to a place where you can do something about it. Yes. And Jordan in this moment realizes that Tyler isn't ready to do either of those things. No he just wants to feel forgiven without actually doing the work. Right. Exactly.
He wants somebody to tell him that everything's going to be okay. And Jordan doesn't do that. So Tyler ruminates on Jordan's words but acknowledges that there's nothing careful about the way that he's acting right now. And later as he lies awake in bed with Poppy he thinks about what it would be like for him to tell the Bishop that he quit to be lay sized. Lay as in laymen. Lay sized the act of being removed from the priesthood. He thinks about having a family with Poppy how he would follow her anywhere and be glad to do so. But he thinks about what he would do.
Initially he's at a loss and he feels that his degrees in seminary would be useless but ultimately he thinks about teaching which excites him. He then thinks about a future without Poppy on the other hand. And that thought makes him so sick and aroused at the same time. Aroused in the sense that he feels like he needs to claim her and prove to himself that she's still there. And so he does. He rouses her from sleep with a nice solid fuck. Oh yeah. Which I always like the claiming language and I liked it in here too. Yeah I did too.
And I also liked that she was into it. Like it's one of those things that could have been a little bit problematic because they hadn't talked about it before but she was like you know what I love this you can do that whenever. Yeah and she even like I think vocalizes that like you can wake me up any time you want. Yeah. Afterwards though she tells him that she's not sure how much longer she can do this right be in this limbo. Tyler doesn't tell her what she wants to hear though because he still hasn't really made his mind up even though it's killing them both. She tells him that he should probably leave since it's getting to be morning and he feels
like he's being dismissed. Back at the ranch. Tyler's house. He runs into Millie who's just sitting in his kitchen. She tells him she knows about the two of them, tells him that the town needs him and not another sex scandal even if it is between two perfectly consenting adults and so she tells him to be careful. And he's just like fuck me running. I do really love that she and Jordan both tell him just to be careful and not actually to stop.
Right. I think they both realize that if they were to tell him to stop it would be a useless thing and also they respect him as an adult to make his own choices right. Yeah. Like he's a priest. It's not like he's killing anybody with his actions but he does need to make a choice between what he wants and what he's committed to do. And I think that again this book does such a good job of looking at him breaking his vows this whole sex all of these choices without demonizing him.
So the next day Sterling of all people come to see him after Mass. He is smarmy and gross and Tyler at first tries to play dumb about Sterling's sizing up his competition but Sterling has pictures which he gives to Tyler. He tells Tyler that Poppy will be coming back to New York City with him because they speak the same language currency prestige status and it takes everything Tyler has not to beat this guy's face in but somehow he resists. I wanted him to punch him.
I did too man I really don't like the Sterling guy. Also like you're fucking on the altar can we just hit him? I know but also like I mean Tyler kind of calls out this guy he's like this is the definition of stalking you just you don't you don't just have people followed like who the fuck do you think you are and Sterling's like I don't understand what you're asking and then like Tyler does nothing to back up that statement which felt a little bit disappointing. It did. I did appreciate in this scene that even though Sterling has these pictures like Tyler's first
thought is concerned is concerned that Sterling is like here for Poppy and that like Poppy is going to be threatened and not so much for himself in the pictures which I was impressed but yeah it was like come on buddy back up what you're saying because you do look a little weak regardless of what you're saying. You look a little weak and you look like you're not you're not ready to defend this person that you claim to love. Right like you're really just gonna let her walk away. So he doesn't do anything and he doesn't hear from Poppy for the rest of the day even though
he texts and calls. The bishop Bishop Bobe Bishop Bobe who wanted him to attend the conference does call though and Tyler doesn't answer or call back. Later that evening he gets a text from a blocked number which is a picture of Poppy in the back seat of a car asleep and he knows immediately that it's from Sterling and a green jealousy rages through him. He feels so incredibly powerless and like he's losing Poppy to this man and so he turns to whiskey to help to help soothe his anger.
The next day he still doesn't hear anything so he just punishes himself with exercise and more booze and in the afternoon, the middle of the afternoon, he's drunk and doing so many push-ups that his arms are shaking and that's where Poppy finds him in his basement. She kisses him and he immediately wants to fuck her but wars with himself knowing that he's angry and drunk and she doesn't deserve that so instead he just ends up masturbating onto her back. She realizes that he's a mess after this when he won't like touch her or look at her because
he's ashamed and also incredibly angry and so she drags him to his bathroom to bathe him and take care of him so she's doing essentially aftercare for him in the way that he usually does for her. She puts him to bed, gives him some Advil and some water and says we'll talk when he wakes up. When he does wake up, she ends up driving them into Kansas City. They talk about the Sterling thing. Poppy tells Tyler that she told Sterling that she is unequivocally not interested in- Interested did did did did did did did did did!
Poppy tells Tyler that she told Sterling that she's unequivocally not interested in being Sterling's mistress or going anywhere with him and that Sterling accepted that supposedly. She thinks that Sterling will back off and do nothing with a black mile but Tyler isn't so sure and honestly, who would be? I think Poppy's got a misjudge of character here in a big way. Yeah, like here it was like girl you're being really naive because and Tyler even says like did he offer to destroy them? Did he give them to you? Right. And she's like no. Right. Come on girl, come on.
I mean to be fair she's like 27 so she's a baby. She is a baby which fine but also like- But still. You know how manipulative this guy is and you think he's just gonna be like oh you don't want to come back with me? Okay. That's fine, delete. No ma'am. Tyler also tells Poppy about all of his fears when he didn't hear from her, all of his jealousy and all of the anger that he has and she tells him that she's not the cheating type and he's just like okay. I mean it doesn't help the way I feel but thanks. Yeah, which was such a valid response but I do appreciate we get into the miscommunication
later but I appreciated how upfront he was with like this is what I thought was happening and this is I'm pissed. Regardless of what you say to me like I'm angry. Right. Yeah and I appreciated this conversation because it did feel like an adult conversation. Like you know we have this problem, we have this miscommunication like how are we gonna get past this? Yes. So Poppy ends up taking Tyler to her job and in a private room she dances for him in a cotton candy blue wig and champagne colored lingerie.
She tells him that they're playing it being just a client and just a dancer and Tyler is immediately into this. Uh-huh. He draws comparisons internally between King Herod and himself. King Herod who famously offered Salome anything that she wanted after she had danced for him. So in this case obviously Poppy is Salome and Tyler is King Herod. I will give you anything. Right. They go through a game of paying for more so more to touch, more to see her naked, more
to fuck and Tyler gives into his rougher side the way that Poppy asks him to but when it comes to fucking her roughly he thinks of how she did the same thing with Tyler and it makes him want to hurt her. With Sterling. Yeah. Who did I say? You said Tyler. Oh. Tyler gives into his rougher side the way that Poppy asked him to but when it comes to fucking her roughly he thinks of how she did the same thing with Sterling and it makes Tyler want to hurt her and at that instinct he balks. He doesn't want to do that. He doesn't want to be like Sterling.
She tells him that if he trusts her to tell him when it hurts she'll trust him to stop when she asks. And that makes him give in to the game completely. Afterward he realizes that this game has burned away a lot of the jealousy that he had felt for Sterling and that his love for Poppy was as sacred as the sacrament of marriage itself. Which, ugh, so beautiful. I'm gonna bring it back to some spice real quick because this scene. Uh-huh. Please do. I loved. So in this scene Poppy has her champagne lingerie but she also has this like bow tied around
her neck. It's unclear if it's like a ribbon or a scarf or like part of lingerie. But Tyler unties the bow and ties it so that it's like a collar around her neck. Like tie it in a way that it's around her neck but it won't tighten and then like uses the rest like a leash to make her like crawl to him. And oh my fucking god. Ow! It was so hot. Yep. And he also uses it to control her. So like she gets him a blowjob. He controls her using it that way, et cetera, et cetera.
Oh my god. It's wonderful. Well done. Yeah. Well done. And I appreciated that they make the point of like he tied in a way to keep her safe. Like I can direct you with it but this isn't tightening on your throat. Right. Like. It's controlling but not pain inducing. Yeah. And then she still has this like realm of safety and I just, oh my god it was just so hot. It was, yeah, very well done. And I appreciated that like not only do they have just like really filthy sex but they also do like role playing in a very like seamless way.
And I don't, I feel like we don't get a whole lot of that in some of the books that we have. Like there's hot sex and like usually when we have like these power plays they're usually pretty explicit about what they're doing either before or during or after but this is just kind of like oh we're role playing now. Okay. Oh yeah. So what am I doing? I know I really liked that. And it kind of made me want to like explore role playing more but I just feel like it wouldn't be the seamless. I feel like it would be awkward. I feel like you would have to talk about it beforehand. Like hey. Yeah.
What do you think is hot? Yeah. What do you think hot? What do you think? It was so good though. So on the drive home Tyler admits to himself that he wants to marry Poppy. Specifically he wants her to be his bride. He realizes that he can be a man of God and also be with her. He asks God if this is what he had wanted for Tyler all along and his answer is an overwhelming sense of peacefulness devoid of the guilt and shame that he'd been grappling with over the last few weeks.
And again going back to what we were talking about before with his evolving relationship with God like I just love this portrayal of having deeply religious main characters who are freaks. Yeah. And like both of those things are okay. Yeah. Because both things can be true and both of them like they do have a lot of conversation about God and faith and religion but they are freaky. Oh yeah. And it's a seamless like they don't it doesn't feel like two separate characters for each
of them. Right. Because they're also a little bit religiously freaky in bed like he's calling her a lamb. They're giving it to the priest things. Yeah. Like she says like Father Bell or like yes Father. Oh it's so good. So Tyler resolves at the mask that he will give the following day will be his last. And when he gives it he ends up changing tact from a homily about self sacrifice to please God and discipline to a sermon about how God wants his children as they are.
Words and all loves them. All he asks in return is that equal amount of love. And he's speaking from the heart because he feels this as a product of the verse that they read personally. Right. He knows that God loves him as himself even though he is going to leave the priesthood and intends to marry this woman. Yeah. And that God's okay with that. That's what he wants him to do. Right. I also like the message in this that's like you're allowed to change like your relationship
with your religion your God is changeable. Like you might be called to do one thing for a little bit but that doesn't mean it's forever. Yeah. And that I again I keep saying like I love that Tyler is this character and none of these changes are demonized. Like the fact that his relationship with God changes in a way that he doesn't have to give up his faith. Like he doesn't end this book feeling like he's going to go to hell. Right. And it feels like he's still doing what he's called to do and that God's like yes like
do this. Yes. Exactly. Like I want you to be happy. Do this thing. The priesthood isn't it which is fine. Right. You did the thing that I needed you to do as a priest and now I need you to do something else. Yeah. So after Mass Tyler calls Bishop Bove but gets a voicemail. He knows that he should wait until talking with this man directly but he can't help himself and leaves a message to the effect that he's leaving the priesthood. He then goes to Poppy's house to see her and intends to tell her that he's decided to leave
and ask her to marry him. But when he arrives Sterling is there and he sees them in her bedroom. Poppy is laughing Sterling is laughing and Tyler watches as they kiss. I knew when he was walking over there that something was going to go wrong with his proposal. I didn't expect it to be this and what did you think? What did you think of this scene with Poppy and Sterling? I didn't like it. I especially didn't like it coming off of the heels of the conversation they just had when Poppy was very adamant that she would never cheat on him.
Yes. I thought it was a little bit out of character and even when we get her explanation later for why she did it it just strikes me that she could have just she could have done all of the things that she had done after this without the kiss. She could have left him a note. She could have done a thousand other things besides doing this specific thing. This is that trope we talked about in our last recording of kicking the dog to make it run away and save its life. Right. Exactly. Why make it so painful?
But I did for a split second I was like Poppy's a bitch and if this ends we're like she's just genuinely fucking Sterling. Ooh I was gonna be this is what I texted you and I was like I'm gonna throw this book in the road. Yeah. Yeah. Into oncoming tragic. Yes. I was like I'm about to be done with this. Yeah. And I'm glad you did tell me because I was like okay it's gonna get better. I was still kind of like reading at the top of my lungs but I did have the light at the end of the tunnel at least. You're welcome. Because I was reading at the top of my lungs to make sure that this is not how it ended.
Yeah. So Tyler loses it and just takes off. He drives to see Jordan. His head is spinning. His world is in tatters and he tells Jordan everything. How he thinks that he's done all of this, made his desire to leave the priesthood known, betrayed his vocation for nothing. Poppy's betrayed him. Jordan asks whether Tyler would still leave the priesthood without her and Tyler says no. Jordan goes on to say that Tyler's penance whatever he chooses right to leave the priesthood
or to stay or whatever is to spend a full day devoted to God. That God needs to speak with Tyler, needs the time and Tyler agrees. But before they can end the discussion, Bishop Bove calls the pictures that Sterling has of Tyler and Poppy were released. Shock, gasp. Never saw that coming. Definitely thought those were deleted. Never in a million years. Bishop Bove tells Tyler that he either needs to quit or be fired and Tyler thinks that this is terrible because his relationship is over, right?
Like he's not without Poppy, he doesn't really necessarily want to leave the church. And he tells Bove as much. Bove is upset but willing to take the steps to go through discipline and relocation if Tyler is repentant and keep him in the priesthood. That night Tyler sleeps on Jordan's couch and thinks about everything that's transpired. The next day he goes to Mass at Jordan's church and afterwards he calls Millie and asks whether she'd seen Poppy. She tells him that her car has been gone since the day before.
She also tells him to take care of himself and that no matter what, the parish will still love him. In Jordan's old sanctuary after Mass, on his own, Tyler remarks that Poppy would love it. He asks from guidance from God but there is only silence. He sees himself as a failure. He feels far from God, far from his flock, far from himself, utterly alone. He halfheartedly thinks about the freedom that leaving the priesthood would grant him, the ability to go anywhere and fight poverty or famine or any other sin. But everywhere he pictures, Poppy is with him.
He can't shake her. He sees them helping people, feels excited about that fantasy. It's the same excitement that he did felt when he decided to join the priesthood itself. He realizes that this is a sign that God wants him in the real world helping people. Which is so nice because it's not actually tied to Poppy. Again, it's like evolution of his relationship with God. It doesn't even have anything to do with Poppy.
You're right, being in the priesthood isn't right for you anymore. Whether she's there or not, this is where you need to be instead. Right. And you've done the penance of helping a community heal after a similar thing that happened to your sister and you've righted that wrong, essentially. So now it's time to go and do other things. Yeah, you did what I put you there to do. So the next weekend is a festival. One of the ones that Poppy suggested they use to drum up funds for the church, but Tyler doesn't plan on going. Despite the fact that his parish has done exactly the opposite of rejecting him and
they tell him that they want him to stay, he feels that it would be wrong for him to do so. He answers all of the questions that people have for him honestly and is incredibly touched by their outpouring of support, but ultimately does decide to leave not just Weston but the priesthood itself. As he packs up his place, he tries to see Poppy, but her things are all gone from her house and he realizes that she is gone, done and dusted. I hated that. I hated this whole sequence. I did too. I was like, especially with the kiss, like you could have left without the kiss.
Yes, this all could have happened without the kiss and I was just like, I didn't like any of this part. So back at home with his brothers, his brothers tease Tyler about the women online who are throwing themselves at Tyler for his good looks. What do they call this? Sorry, they call it the Tyler Reds. The Tyler Reds? He is like a fan club? Yeah. And so these Tyler Reds and all of this other press that the scandal has gathered, he's like kind of internet famous. He's like the hot priest meme now.
Right. Jesus. So his brothers ask whether he'll still be celibate now that he's not a priest any longer and he tells them to fuck off. They ask whether he's heard from Poppy and he hasn't. They encourage him to find her for some closure. And so in December Tyler goes to that exclusive club that she works at with his brother. While he's there, he asks the bartender about Poppy and she immediately knows who he is. She's like, oh my god, you're the priest. You're the hot priest.
Right. But she tells him that Poppy had given her notice and no one knows where she went. She does give him something Poppy left for him. It's an envelope and inside is Lizzie's Rosary. In that moment Tyler is faced with the knowledge that it really is over. Poppy is gone. Which was so shitty because there's not even anything else in the envelope. Like there's no note. It's just her Rosary. I know. It feels so impersonal. Yeah. It was really, it just, it was just so cold and I do feel like it's kind of against Poppy's
character and I get that she was doing it. I get why she was doing it, but I think it was stupid. It was a bit heavy handed. Yeah. Yeah, it definitely was. So for a few weeks after this, Tyler grieves and mopes until his brothers prod him into doing something. And so he goes to Africa and for seven months he volunteers working with people, helping people, building communities, etc. And the only reason he ends up coming home from this is because his mother has told him about all of these acceptance letters from universities that he'd applied to to pursue
his PhD. He ultimately decides to attend Princeton, but I don't think it actually specifies what he's going to study. No, it doesn't. He still thinks about Poppy. It still hurts that all it meant to her was so little. But he had poured all of his anger specifically about the jealousy aspect into the work that he'd done in Africa and he just feels exhausted. He says goodbye to his family and heads for the East Coast to study. And he settles in. He does try to find Poppy, even calls her parents or tries to, but he doesn't get anywhere.
Finally, as kind of a last resort, he goes to the building in New York City that Sterling's family owns. And at the reception, he asks to see Sterling, but the receptionist won't let him in because he doesn't have an appointment. But then she's like, wait a minute, are you that hot priest? She's like, I was one of those Tyler reps. You know what, Sterling doesn't keep track of his schedule. He won't know if you're on it or not. I'll just let you in. I'll just let you right on it. Right. And as he's like, thanking her or whatever, she slips in her phone number.
She's like, by the way. She says something like, if you ever want to break your vows again. Right. Like, damn girl. Wow. So in Sterling's office, he's still a self-satisfied prick, but we find out that Poppy isn't with him, which surprises Tyler. And it also surprises Sterling that Poppy's also not with Tyler. I just thought that was so funny that Sterling's like, are you asking me about her? Like, don't you know? Right. Exactly. They both kind of come at it with this hostile energy. Just like, okay, you won.
Where is she? How's she doing? And they're both just like, wait a minute. Wait a minute. Then where the fuck is she? Yeah. Sterling tells Tyler that after she let him kiss her, she kicked him out. But of course, Sterling doesn't actually know where she is now, or at least she, he essentially says something to the effect of like, we weren't what I thought we were. And like, he's finally accepted that she's rejected him for some reason. But this end to the Sterling thing also really didn't feel true to the character.
No, it didn't. It felt way too easy. Yeah. Because of course, like Sterling stalked her still. But like, he essentially tells Tyler like, I mean, I know where she is, or at least where she was a year ago, like she's at this dance studio, blah, blah. And I'm like, there's no way that Sterling would just like, let this go, especially if she's in the same city. Right. And he also seems like, I mean, we don't get, he's not abusive, but he's so manipulative that I can't see him just like, taking being kicked out of her house and being like, oh,
we weren't what I thought. Also, what you thought was that she was going to be a toy. So like, why are you suddenly treating her like a person with your own decisions? Yeah, it, I, it wasn't true to the character. This is where I felt like this was just whoo. This is where I felt like the ending was just really rushed. Right. Yeah. It just felt really rushed. I feel like after all of this build up, after all this character development, we have like this miscommunication show, this like multiple miscommunication, all like shoved into two chapters.
Why? Right. Because the whole like Sterling Tyler antagonism doesn't get a satisfying ending because Tyler like basically says thanks, bro, and has decided that he's forgiven Sterling. And I'm like, that's it. Like your, your whole like conflict and resolution with Sterling was resolved without any action on your own part. Like that, that doesn't feel good. Right. And even know like, he still doesn't even stand up for Poppy, like ensure that she's
safe. Like, and then they have a handshake and they're like, cool now. Cool bro. Yeah. Like I'm used to the, the romances where like somebody gets like knocked out or like loses a tooth or dies or something. Right. Yeah. What I, it felt so lukewarm. It felt so lukewarm. I wanted this to be one of those like, okay, do you remember in Gilmore Girls when Lorelei was engaged to Luke, but then sleeps with Christopher and we see Luke like drive over
to his apartment, Chris opens the door and like before he says anything, Luke just like knocks his lights out and then walks away. I wanted that kind of ending. Like I wanted like the handshake. Tyler goes to leave and comes back and just like clocks them in the face and then pieces out. Yeah. That would have been great. One more thing. Yeah. That would have been awesome. Right. That would have been, it still would have felt rushed, but it would have felt a little bit more like satisfying. Yeah. There would have been some closure at least. Not just like, like, are you going to hang out now? It was weird.
So Tyler again, thanks him, decides that he's forgiven Sterling and he intends to do the same with Poppy and return the rosary that he gave her as a sign of his forgiveness. So he goes to the studio that Sterling directed him to, but before he enters, he decides to go to a nearby church to kind of gather himself. And there of course he finds Poppy who is praying. They have a reunion, Poppy immediately recognizes him and starts crying. She tells Tyler that she knew that he was there the day that she let Sterling kiss her, that she couldn't bear to have him leave his vocation for her.
And so she felt that she had to leave him to force this thing to not happen. Right. Yeah. So she orchestrated him to walk in on the kiss. Right. And all this time she's felt guilty that even through it all, the pictures were still a part of the reason that he had to quit. Right. And so she's starting to push him away and have him choose to stay of his own accord. But he ended up having to leave because Sterling released those pictures anyway. Tyler tells her that he would have left either way, that he was going to propose that day
and leave on his own, that God was looking out for both of them and wanted him out in the real world. And he ends this by saying that he still wants to marry her and she accepts. And they fuck in the church a little bit. That also felt so rushed. You guys have a lot to talk about. Yeah. What? Like you're just fine with the manipulation. Like a year later I still want to marry you and like we're not going to talk about our problems. Yeah.
It would have been, I don't know, I feel like it would have been more believable for him to do this if she had been writing to him or if they had been corresponding in some way. Yeah. Or he came home to like a box of letters from her. Right. And just for her to like cut him out cold turkey like for an entire year and then for them to pick up right where they left off felt a little bit not right. No. And even for her to like suddenly see him burst into tears and like run into his arms like you did this Poppy. Right. Exactly.
You fully made this choice. Yeah. So that seemed like a weird reaction on her part too. Like you don't know why he's there. Like he and he didn't even go there to get her back. Like he just went there to return the rosary and now he's like proposing because he just believes that also I listen go girl get all the sex but he knows her and she's a sexual being so like have you been waiting for me for a year because I don't know if I believe that like are you with someone. Yeah. Exactly. Like we have there's there's so many other things other loose ends that we have to tie
up here. Yeah. So I I didn't like this ending but. But that that is how the book ends right. And so yeah the epilogue that we get is told from Poppy's perspective and she and Tyler are getting married. They're in a Catholic church and they're getting married in a Catholic ceremony. But before the ceremony itself they are locked in a small chapel running around like two teenagers on prom night. We find out that Poppy has reconciled with his with her parents who are paying for the whole thing and she ruminates how happy she is to finally belong to Tyler how she had
always belonged to him since the day that she sat in his confessional. This epilogue would have been so much more satisfying because like they have they have sex before the ceremony. It's great. It's fine. It's fine. I was just so disappointed like it just wasn't as satisfying with like these sudden loose ends. Yeah. I kind of I mean by the time we got to the epilogue I kind of had to cut out the end to enjoy it because the epilogue is good.
The epilogue is good. The epilogue is good. I mean it's more true to the characters. Yeah. They have like great sex. They like joke about how they're like doing it like a couple feet away from like everyone at the wedding. Right. Like kind of coming full circle and like they can have sex without guilt now. So if it just went from like he proposed to her and we cut out all that other bullshit and we had to tear that would have been great. That would have been awesome. Yeah. I didn't need this conflict. I didn't need this conflict in the last 20% of the book. It was super flawless. Yeah.
Or even if the conflict had been like I love you and I feel like you're leaving the priesthood for me. Like can we have some time to just make sure and then he goes off to Africa and does that thing and they correspond the whole time and then they come back they still decide they want to be together. Fine. That would have been great too because I could see that like I want to make sure you're not going to resent me for this. Right. But the whole like kicking the man when he's down and then being like oh yes I love you.
What? Yeah. Okay girl. So let's get into some ratings. Yes. Liz how did we rate the spice level? We both rated it at a five. The spice in this book is just like chef's kiss. Yeah. Even the things that like I didn't think I would be into was so hot and like their communication
is great. You get a little bit of that like Dom stuff. Like their connection is so good. Oh just and it was detailed and like versatile or just. It's great. No notes. And I think that I mean in our debrief we talked about how we think this is probably the filthiest book that we've read that takes place between a monogamous heterosexual couple. Yes. And I think that's right. And I think part of the reason that at least I liked the spice in this book so much is that it takes something that I personally am familiar with and then adds to it in ways
that I wouldn't necessarily do myself right. But you get to enjoy that and like live that fantasy in a very like explicit way and this book just does that really well. It does it so well. So moving into writing style rated in a four and you know that's that's kind of our like that that's as high of a rating as you're going to get for writing style without being like the top tier like. Nettle and bone kind of. Yes. Right.
The writing was good. It was approachable. It obviously was very very well written smut and the world building was really good. Like descriptive writing. But there just wasn't lines in there that stuck with me. Right. I didn't feel evangelical about the writing style in this book as I do in some others. So rating it a four. Very very good writing. No notes. Agreed. So moving into quality of storytelling. Liz how do we read that? We both read it at a four and for me the only thing that made the story not a five was
the last 20%. It just it didn't need to happen and it and it knocked it down. Like otherwise this would have been a five for me. It just felt so unnecessary. Yeah. It felt like we took like the like the highway had like some construction and we took like a really weird detour and then got back on the highway. But I don't know why we took that backcountry road for no reason. Right. Because like there's already enough conflict in this book without having that entire part. It just. Right. Exactly.
Yeah. It was just it was weird. It was weird. But it's still a four. It's still pretty high. It's still pretty high. Right. This is not a poorly rated book. Oh no. So if you have not been able to tell we absolutely recommend this book unequivocably. Oh yeah. Highly recommend it. One handed book club reading for sure. It's a quick read too. So I mean. Yeah. You're just you're doing yourself no favors by not reading this book. And we will be revisiting Sierra Simone in the future. Guaranteed.
Yes. We have a trilogy so we are definitely going to be reading the next book in this series. Yes. So stay tuned. All right guys we did it. Those are our thoughts on Priest by Sierra Simone. Thank you as always for joining us on this journey. What did you think? Let us know on the socials. You can find us on Instagram, Facebook, Tiktok and Goodreads at Spice Traders Pod. And if you like our podcast and want more consider becoming a patron where we release Patreon exclusive episodes on our off weeks. And if you really really like us drop us a review wherever you listen.
Triggers: graphic violence and gore, depictions of a fictional plague, on-page sexual content (including masturbation), and themes of parent death and chronic illness KU: No Recommendation: No, (give the author money...
Triggers: (From the author): kidnapping, violence, discussions of abuse, BDSM dynamics and play, tentacle play, brief descriptions of injured animal (that receives aid), breath play, bondage, depictions of sub drop,...
Triggers: war, battle, hand-to-hand combat, perilous situations, blood, intense violence, brutal injuries, death, and poisoning KU: No Recommendation: Yes! For more of the author, check out https://rebeccayarros.com/
Triggers: from the author: “explicit violence, explicit sexual violence, dubious consent, murder, gore, torture, kidnapping, and more.” KU: Yes Recommendation: No For more of the author, check out...
Triggers: death of a parent (off page), grief, fantasy violence KU: No Recommendation: both Traders recommend! This is part 2 of 2. For more of the author, check out https://www.lanaferguson.com/