This week we jump into the witchy world of The Coven by Harper L. Woods! Is it a fun student/teacher romance? Yes! Does it have great vampire smut? Also yes! Is it high literature? Absolutely not! This is part 2 of 2. Triggers: Dubious consent, forced feeding, graphic violence, rough and explicit sexual content, forced proximity, betrayal, references to past abuse and traumatic reactions to triggering stimuli, knife violence, graphic depictions of blood, physical harm inflicted upon the main character, ritualistic murder Tropes: Vampires, student/teacher KU: Yes! Recommendation: Both traders recommend! https://www.adelaideforrest.com/#/
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hey friends, just a quick reminder before we get into today's episode, come join us over on our Patreon. That's where we release bonus episodes every other week and we've already got over 20 episodes from 2023 that you can download and binge right now for as little as $3 a month. We've covered so many good books there, Haunting Adeline, Chateau, Gathakanna, and so many more. That's also where we'll cover any books in a series we continue, so Serpent in Dove, High Mountain Court, Serpent in the Wings of Night. You can continue those series with us on Patreon right now.
Finally, as a patron, we let you know what we're going to read every month so you can read along with us if that's your jam. Anyway, that's all from me, on to today's episode. I don't know, and that's where it got really Scooby-Doo at the end where I felt like it was building up to a lot of reveals that weren't actually reveals. Like Charlotte's entire purpose at the end of this book makes no goddamn sense. Makes no goddamn sense. And then she just fades away into dust. Like 12 students were murdered for her to be there for 45 seconds.
Yeah, that's a good point. It might have all been just to open the seal to hell, but I'm not convinced. I see what you mean. Welcome to Your Saved Space, the podcast your partner friends, parents, whoever thinks is dirty. Don't have time to read books, want to understand the jokes and the tics-hacks, we got you, we're the spice traders, and we deal in spicy books. I'm Katie and I need it to make sense. I'm Liz and I'm hypercritical. As always, we start every episode with three things.
The first is a generic trigger warning. You can find specific triggers for this book in our show notes, so please check those out. Also we do use foul language and talk a lot about sex. If you have sensitivity to any of this, please give this episode a skip. Secondly, we talk about books. The whole book, nothing but the books that helped me got us. If you plan to read this book and don't want something spoiled right now, don't listen to this episode. Lastly, we acknowledge that a good book can hit you at the wrong time. The views expressed in our discussion are our opinion and we absolutely don't want to diminish the work and the talent of the authors in our community.
That said, we have some notes. Katie, what are we talking about today? Today, we are continuing our discussion of Coven by Harbour L. Woods. This is part two of two and it will cover chapters 21 through 40. And so if you haven't read the book or listened to part one, do one of those things now because
we're halfway through the story. So we jump right in and we are at the funeral for the witch who was murdered. This happens on the cliffs near the school and Willow is again struck by how barren the land is. She is floored by the level of starvation in the natural world around her. She looks for gray kind of instinctively and she grates at the fact that she has indeed not been able to satisfy herself since he last left her. Ugh. Ugh. So rude.
So fucking rude. When the funeral starts, Willow is horrified by the fact that this girl, this witch, is put in a casket. Willow knows that the witch needs to be buried with her element. She's a white witch, so she needs to be buried with crystals. Again, this is the same kind of concept that we saw with Willow's mother where witches need to be able to let their bodies go back to the element that gives them their power. She intends to speak with the Covenant immediately, but gray is there next to her in a flash and says that she needs to pick her timing more strategically.
If she approaches the Covenant right now, outright in front of all these people, she's going to immediately fail. She holds her back by holding her hand and says that she asked him to protect her and that's all he's trying to do. The contact makes her emotions well up because the last person who held her hand like that was Ash at her mother's funeral. She also makes it sound like no one besides Ash or her mom has ever held her hand. She seems like she's very isolated. No one has touched this girl, apparently.
I mean, even despite the fact that she's been out in the world, the first couple of chapters, she's like, oh yeah, I had a job this one time at a newspaper, blah blah, and I'm like, okay, so you haven't been completely alone. Right. I mean, she had to be supporting Ash in some way, assume she had some kind of job. Yeah. Anyway, nobody's held her hand. She's got a lot of feelings. As she watches the funeral progress, she vows to herself that she will free all of the witches buried against the old ways in the cemetery that's around the school.
After the service, Willow approaches Susanna and George in the tribunal chambers. She can access the room because she's a future member of the board and the magic warding the room recognizes this. So I guess this is why it took a little bit of her blood the first time she entered. So I guess I misspoke we do get kind of an answer, but it's not explicit. It's not explicit. Susanna asks George to leave them to speak in private and he does. Susanna tries to tell Willow that what she is doing is for the good of the Coven. So she openly admits that they're not following the old ways.
Willow doesn't see how this is for the good of the Coven since the earth is literally dying around them. But Susanna goes on to tell her that essentially she is weakening the Coven on purpose so that she can weaken the vessels until she can rid the Coven of them completely and or strike a new bargain. The tribunal practices the old ways and secrets since the vessels cannot feed off of its members. Willow finds the idea of sacrificing the whole Coven to this end abhorrent and she tells Susanna that she won't have any part in this plan. Susanna tells her she doesn't have a choice that she will put Willow into a perpetual
slumber if she's not cooperative. Susanna is sure that I've been can be persuaded to mate with Willow even when Willow is asleep. This was so fucking gross. Like it's a terrible suggestion anyway but it's just additionally gross that it's her great grandmother with lots of grates but like she I didn't need the threat of Ivan raping her in her sleep. Yeah that's new and it's I think that's unfair to Ivan because Susanna just says this thing
Ivan has given no indication we don't even know if this is true or if it's just something that Susanna has said like poor Ivan. Poor Ivan well and it's weird too because like that's another thing that's a bit strange at the end of this book because Ivan just disappears like he's just no longer an entity. This is to be. But this like plants this seed in Willow's mind that maybe Ivan would be okay with this. Like but why right like why are you believing anything that Susanna says.
And her whole plan Diatribe was also wild to make. She's like yeah we're just gonna basically let everyone die off so we can make a new deal with the devil which by the way do you not know that the devil is the headmaster because you must. Okay that's a good point. I don't know how Susanna and George don't know that Gray is the devil. Like he's just been in all their meetings and she's like oh yeah we need a new deal with the devil. I wonder where he could be. And he's just like hey guys.
I've been here the whole time. So during this kind of argument thing that they're having Susanna holds Willow up by the neck as she threatens to have people rape her in her sleep and is essentially choking her great great granddaughter. Before she can make her pass out completely Susanna drops Willow onto the floor and then kicks her in the ribs a couple of times and then puts her bony ass foot on Willow's chest
to hold her down. Why I don't understand why she has to like assault her. Yeah this seems very I don't want to say yeah I'm gonna say out of character. Because it does seem out of character. Like Susanna is definitely selfish and will do anything to get like what she wants but physical assault feels like not her thing. No and it's continuous to seem out of character when we see her later in like a moment of
danger and she's like oh no the pants are taking me. Exactly. Where's your fight girl. Oh no. Oh no. I just don't understand Susanna at all. Yeah no I don't either. Again have to reiterate had a great time reading this book but I have a lot of questions. That's the tagline of this book. So before Susanna can make good on her promise to basically put Willow into a perpetual sleep
Gray appears and says that if Susanna touches Willow again he will tear her skull from her spine. George is next to Gray and it's clear that George is the one that sought Gray out to stop Susanna from going too far. Gray goes on to tell Susanna that she violates the agreement between witches and vessels if she harms Willow and he threatens to tell the devil himself about her violation. Susanna tells Gray to take Willow and get out of her sight. So he's going to go talk. He's going to give himself a stern talking story.
I just realized how idiotic that conversation is. Especially if Susanna knows who he is. Which there's no way she can't know. There's no way she doesn't know because it kind of answers the question as to why Gray has so much fucking freedom. Because we get all this information that vessels and students can't have relationships that they can't feed from one person. There's got to be all these safeguards.
But Gray comes in and he's like I'm going to do this thing and Susanna's like wish you wouldn't. Domininium or whatever. Domininium. Yeah and she's like okay. And then later. Look at there. I'm sorry. Listeners has got to be chaotic to listen to. But when Susanna is talking to Willow later. She's very aware that Gray is like powerful and she almost all but says dude he's the fucking devil. Don't do this. Yes you're right. I'm going to tell on you to myself. And like okay so is he saying that for Willow's benefit or is this like a threat.
He has to be right. He has to. It's got to be in the context of like hey and she doesn't know blah blah blah but then also I'm reminding you of who I am. But just I'm going to tell the devil about this. In your journal you're going to write in your diary tonight. Dear diary. Dear diary today. Susanna pissed me off and broke our agreement. Therefore I must always remember this violation. Well and it also makes Susanna's response a little better too to be like get out of
my fucking sight. Yeah just get out of here. I can't. I can't. I can't with either of you. Just go. Oh oh I'm sorry I'm just thinking about so many other things in the context of him being the devil now that we know that. Yeah like when he runs in and she's got the mark and he's like what'd you do to make his list. What. Yeah. Although I mean like the method acting is solid.
Anyway so Gray takes Willow back to his room and he realizes that she's got a couple of broken ribs and some other injuries along with the bruised throat and he urges her to drink from him since her injury is internal and dirt can't heal it for her. She asks for dirt and he's like what are you going to do. Eat it. Yeah I'm sure that was pretty funny. I thought it was really funny. I do like that their banter never really ceases.
Yeah I do too. So she finally gives in and drinks deeply from him seeming to understand that if she's got to do it she may as well go all the way. And it's here that we get a little bit of information that when a witch and a vessel exchange blood they both get kind of a temporary benefit from that so a witch will get like some of the superhuman strength and like heightened senses that vessels have and then vessels will get eventually access to a little bit of their power. But it has to be more of a consistent thing for that to really happen.
So Grey pulls back before Willow can bleed him dry and compels her to sleep despite her protests. Remember Susanna just threatened to keep her in sleep forever so she's like not a big fan of this. No not only keep me in sleep but send men to rape me. Yeah. But Grey promises that she will wake up unharmed in a couple of hours and he vows to pay Susanna back for making Willow fear sleep. Okay. Yeah and remember from the last part one earlier in the book we learned that he can compel
her even with her special necklace on because they've exchanged blood. Yes. Yeah. Anywho while she sleeps Grey meets with K-Rose and Juliet in his office and he admits to having declared dominium over Willow and Willow is ignorant of that fact and she will remain so until he decides to tell her. And they're basically like ribbing him and not letting him live it down that he's like infatuated with this witchling which is also very funny in the context of him being the
devil. That is really funny. Now I'm thinking about like Juliet and K-Rose being basically his best friends but that is like demonic best friends like emerge from hell later. Like I need to know who all knows who he is because I think it's everyone. I think everyone. I think it's everyone. Because there's no way the other vessels don't know who he is because again they're literal demons trapped inside of a mud vessel right.
Yeah. So. Well. Well. Anyway. Willow wakes up a couple hours later as promised and sheds the remainder of her uniform in favor of one of Grey's shirts. Willow finds Grey in his study and thanks him for saving her. He tells her that he'll always come for her and I really wanted this to be a sex joke but it wasn't. It was serious. I wanted it to be a sex joke too. And it would have felt with their banter.
Yeah. But he ruins this tender moment by catching it in terms of their agreement so basically should he fail to protect her she would have ownership over him. I guess like kind of compulsion like he would have to do everything that she says. Well we kind of got that in the first part when they're talking about how you can like destroy a vessel and the only way is like for them to break a vow or something. Mm-hmm. Yeah. But he's the devil. I know. Also, okay, hang on.
Let me buffering. So okay, okay, okay, okay, okay, okay. I just thought of something. So the only way that a vessel can be unmade is two ways. One, a hackete which can unmake them or two, they can break a vow. We were told earlier in this book that the vessels fucking hate being trapped in these bodies. So why don't they just break a vow so that they can be unmade? Because I imagine when you're unmade you just get reunited with your soul and hell.
Right. Is that not what they want? I thought that's what they wanted. I thought that's what they wanted too. Which. Unless being unmade traps you in hell again. But your boss is the devil, can't he just free you? Not if.
Because his other, well, I mean, I guess because hell is sealed, because his other friends just come out and they're not in human vessels. Well not because, I mean, she opens the door to hell so it's like, right. So they just walk out. Maybe they need to stick around so that that happens? I don't know. Yeah. I don't know where the vessels get out of being on earth. Yeah. Anyway. Willow goes on to say that Grey was right about approaching the Covenant about the old
ways and they need to strategize. It's here that Grey admits that he doesn't give a rat's ass how the Covenant practices. He said that to get her to agree to a bargain with him. In her anger at being fooled, Willow throws a glass paperweight at him and Grey dodges it just barely, remember, because she's got some of his super strength and super speed. Yeah. And the paperweight shatters against the floor. And this is the paperweight that somehow had some image of a woman in it. Right. I picture this and this doesn't matter. But have you seen those like glass paperweights that have like a dog in them?
They're kind of like a holographic-y. That's what I picture. Yeah. I think you can get those at Disney or something and you can get your own ass picture in it. Yeah. And it's weird because they're like little like bubbles almost. Yeah. Very bizarre. Those always kind of freaked me out. Me too. It's weird. And that's what I'm picturing that he has. But it's okay. I pictured, so you know on the Haunted Mansion ride at the Magic Kingdom, the woman in the magic- Oh yeah. Madame Leota. Yeah. Exactly. Oh yeah.
That's what I picture. I like that. Okay. That's better than my creepy dog situation. So Grey does not like this. And so he uses his super speed to bend Willow over his desk and tell her that she's forgotten who and what she is. He says, quote, I tolerate your mouth because you amuse me, Willow. Tread carefully or you just might cease to be amusing. I am a demon. I may be trapped within a body that resembles a man, but you would be a fool to mistake me for one. I am not human and I will not behave as one.
I gotta say, like this, the author does a good job of like threading that line between like really being an asshole and like still being endearing. Yeah, she does. Which I'm glad about because she like made this big promise about like how this guy is actually evil and like getting a happy ending. Yeah. Good job. I'm here for you. I know. She did a good job. There's a couple scenes like there's one later where again, I know just like you're just a fucking gummy bear. Yeah. But then he will go back and do like kind of heinous things or at least make heinous
threats and I'm like, okay. Yeah. It's fun. Naked. Naked. So Willow accuses Gray of lying to her and he asks her to be specific, which I hate because it's so gaslighty. Like maybe you didn't say untrue words, but knowingly leading someone on under false pretenses is effectively the same thing. And he knows that. He knows that. Yeah. No, we know he knows that. We know he knows that.
Willow struggles against Gray and accuses him of lying about her being safe with him and he says, are you hurt? I did kind of like that. And she realizes that she's not hurt. And so he goes on to ask whether she's wet. Like, are you hurt or are you wet? She's like, well. So Willow realizes that Gray is being forceful, but not hurting her and she is indeed wet. Sploosh. Sploosh. I did like this scene because he like spins her around and like pins her against the desk.
But then as he's asking her, are you hurt? She kind of has this like immediate flashback of like, he moved me really fast, but I never actually ran into anything. Yeah, exactly. Even being bent over the desk, like his hand is on her neck, but it's not like bruising her, like Susanna bruised her, which again, I think I'm going to reference this at every book we cover like this, but the safe insecurity, the safe insecurity. Yeah. Like, I love it. 100% that. It's such a good term.
And it's, it's okay. It like, it invites us as readers in because we know that these two are like end game, right? And we know that this isn't the kind of book that's like haunting Adeline or something like that. No. And, and we know that he does want to keep her safe. Right. And that there are actual feelings in here. So Gray lifts up Willow's skirt and smacks her ass and tells her to say that she doesn't want him and he'll stop immediately.
But she says no such thing, despite continuing to threaten him with retribution for what he's currently doing. He tells her to beg quote, beg me to make you come. If you expect me to get on my knees for you, then you'd better be ready to ask me for it, witchling. Huh. So she begs. Yeah, as one does. Yeah, as one does. And he obliges and eats her out. He also bites the inside of her thigh and drinks from her again.
And this is a really good point. I don't know if you said it or not, but she takes being eaten out from behind really enshrined for someone who's a virgin. Yeah. Like she even in this scene, like it's detailed. Like we get a lot of detail. We get a detail of her orgasming and like all of it. None of it is like, oh, I've never been in this position before. Oh my God. Like this is a little embarrassing. Like all like the thoughts that I feel like a virgin would have. Right. No, she's just like, yes, on your knees. On your knees.
I definitely want the feeling of your mouth on me. Like I've never not thought about this before. Right. So I don't know. Potentially she's had other exploits, but it just, she's very, very, very, very, very very chill. This whole thing. So after this encounter, will oh avoids gray? Again how he's your teacher. Yeah, somehow again, I'm not a teacher or no, they're avoiding each other.
Until it's the day of the first reaping and boy, is this a weird thing. This is not what I thought it was going to be. I just. Um, there are so many other ways you could do this. I thought it was going to be like, um, Oh, what's the name of that book with the other witch with the purple eyes and the Gothic Hannah? I thought it was going to be like Gothic Hannah, where it was just sort of like
this weird fucking orgy party that like everyone got in on. Yeah. That's what I was expecting. It's a school dance and everybody gets drunk and then vampire is he from you. And then it's an orgy like, look, it's that's fully what I thought the reaping was going to be, not this like weird fucking thing that happens. Yeah. Mm-mm. So let's let's get into, uh, what happens? Um, just say it's the day of the reaping and Willow is in her feelings because as much as she's avoiding gray, she hates the idea of him drinking from someone else.
She's like, well, obviously, like he take, he partakes, right? Vessels we learn are assigned to students once a week, but they never feed from the same student twice. This goes back to what Susanna is trying to do, keeping the vessels weak. The other part of this is that the students don't know which vessels have fed from them. That is unless dominium has been declared and that constitutes an exclusive relationship of vessel and which. So Dela ends up helping Willow prepare for the reaping. So they go to Willow's room and we find out that if you've been so
like to be reaped, you must be so sorry. You must be. It's so, it's just so fucking weird. You must be handcuffed and secured either to the bed or a hook in the ceiling. That is lowered with like a remote control. Yep. These are just BDSM bedrooms. Okay. With like leather handcuffs.
You have to wear a special outfit and you are given a choice of two outfits. One of them is just a regular silk nightgown and the other one is something sexier, which indicates to whoever is reaping from you that you are open to having a sexual experience with that vessel. What? She asked Willow does ask the good question where she's like, how can I know I want to have sex with them if I don't know who's coming?
Right. And Dela is just like, Pishpah, she would want to have sex. I know. It's like you clearly never had hate sex. Okay. But also like a vessel can make a feeding feel like ecstasy. So like, isn't that kind of like a date rape drug? I think so. And also also regardless of which one you're going to be, I think that's also also regardless of which one you choose, you're naked underneath. Like she talks about like this silk nightgown shows like leaves nothing to the imagination anyway.
Right. So and what's and and you're blindfolded, you're strung up. What's to stop the vessel from doing you anyway? Right. Exactly. Well, and I don't know. I think it's very it's a, you're, if you're signing up to have sex with a vessel that comes to feed off of you, you're signing up for either a very prescriptive way of having sex, which is hopefully very vanilla, or you're going to get violated.
Yeah. You have no idea what you're signing up for. No. And that's terrifying. Yeah. And a little, I mean, like, listen, I'm not going to sledge shame, get it off, but like, you don't know who's coming. It's never going to be the same person twice. So like, can vessels get STI's? I don't know. Yeah. Exactly. I don't know where you've been. Is there like, if you do have a sexual experience, is there a conversation about what you are and are not okay with? Like, how far does this go? Right. Is there like a safe word?
Right. So yeah, I've just like, honestly, I would have been, I would have been more okay with a school orgy. Me too, because this whole language is so fucking weird. Yeah. Okay. And the, okay, what makes this creepier is that it's not all students who are just automatically reaped, right? It's the vessels like select what students they want to reap. And so they're like, the way that the students find out about this is that
there's a big X painted on their door when they get back to their room. So like, Dela's not selected, but Willow is. And that just feels creepy to me. Well, the other thing that just adds a layer of creep is they live in quads, right? So there's like an apartment and like four rooms with her and her three roommates. One door has a red X on it. So you just have to like listen to her like the rest of you tonight. Like, yep. And the like the people who aren't reaped are like encouraged to stay in their room. Yeah. Like until morning. Well, and Dela's very flippant about this whole thing.
Yeah. She's like, you can use to it. You want. It's fine. I get it. You'd want six and well, and Willow is like, but I thought all the witches hated the vessels and Dela's like, that doesn't mean it's not fun. I'm like, OK, Dela, are you a red witch? Are you sure? Well, and it also makes me wonder, do they hate the vessels? Because the only person we hear of hating the vessels is Willow. Yeah, I don't. They say that there's like this hateful relationship between them, but it seems fine. We don't see them interact with that.
No, why? Just because they feed from them, maybe, I don't know. Yeah. And then everybody else. I mean, this the other students that have interactions with Gray that we see, like it just seems like they are afraid of him because he's the headmaster, not because he's a demon trapped in a mud vessel. Right. It's just very strange. Anyway, it's also I just can't get over Lucifer being the headmaster of a school. Why? Why is he there? How did he get put in a vessel?
What has his body just doesn't he have to rule hell? Like I don't you have a job? I mean, he has a job, but then he ends up doing paperwork for a school for witches. I don't understand like why he's in a vessel at all. No, I don't either. No, I don't either. It's very bizarre. And what he's not with Willow. Yeah, I see you just like grading term papers and dealing with like delinquent children.
Yeah, I mean, that's why the whole ending and I'm sorry, again, we're talking out of context, but like the whole end with Charlotte coming back briefly, like the only reason it makes sense for him to be like to agree to being trapped in a vessel is if he wanted to be with Charlotte in the physical world and like couldn't figure out how to like do that any other way. Yeah, but that's not what he wants. That's not what happened. So I don't know what, whatever. Anyway, I got to keep moving. So as tempting as it is for Willow to pick the sexier outfit, she does not.
As Daileah strings her up, Willow realizes that the last thing that has to happen is that she also must be blindfolded and this gives her a panic attack. Not the other thing. She was fine with those other things, but the blindfold is a bridge too far. And we learned that this is because it reminds her of the torture that her father would meet out upon her. He would put her in a literal coffin sized cubby hole in his cabin for hours on end. And it's like described as if you're in a morgue and you have those drawers.
Like she crawls in as if like horizontally and then the lock is like at her feet. Yeah, which is so much scarier to me than like being vertically in a space. Yeah. And for some reason there's dirt that like falls on her face too. Yeah. Like while she's in there, just oh no, very claustrophobic. So Daileah sees that something is like really wrong with Willow, but doesn't pry when Willow deflects and tells her to just do it and she'll be fine. By the time Gray gets there and he did take his sweet ass time just to kind of like,
I don't know, brew the tense like anticipation, I guess. Because I think he thought that she'd be into this and instead. She's very much not because by the time he gets there, the room is like coated with the smell of Willow's fear and Gray immediately knows that something isn't right, but he doesn't give up the roost to comfort Willow. So this is a scene where I had two other options that I think would have been more interesting. Yeah. I think one, it would have made for more interesting story if someone else did come
and it wasn't Gray, which I can't violate the dominium, but I think that would have been fun. Agreed. Two, I think he should have given up the roost and comforted her. Yeah. I think it would have been interesting if like he showed up, but then also like someone like Juliet was there. Oh yeah. And like Juliet did the reaping. But like under his like supervision. Right. Because like he knows that Willow's like not into girls, right?
So it wouldn't be like a sexual conquest thing and it could also be like a, I don't know, like a, I'm going to say fun ownership and I know how problematic that is, but like a fun ownership thing. Like, oh, you are a gift that I can share with like people that are loyal to me. It's kind of like being a cock. Like he kind of wants to like see that. Exactly. And I'd be okay with that. I think we would all be a little bit okay with that in this context. Anyway, exactly.
Like Juliet seems great. I don't know. But no, none of those things happen. He does feed from her and he does make it pleasurable and he does like, he gives her like a loving touch or something like on her face to make her feel better. Yeah, I don't know. Okay. We don't get like he feeds her and leaves. Who takes her down? Della? Yeah. She's there all night? Like, right. Like, and she's talked about being suspended like by her wrists, like on her tippy toes.
So like her shoulders are killing her. And her fingers have got to be numb. Yeah. I think I would, well, I'd rather be tied to the bed, at least then I can recline and sleep when this is done. Like, what if she do the rest and I just dangle there? I don't like, I know. Don't understand. No. So the next day, Gray calls Della into his office and tries to understand why Willow was so panicked. Della said that she got the impression that something bad had happened to Willow.
And when Gray asks her to keep an eye on Willow and let him know if she sees anything or Willow tells her anything, she asks him to let Willow keep her secrets. But Gray goes on to say that he's just concerned about his students. He tells her that he can make an accommodation if needed, and that he's acting in the best interests of the school to have Della spy on her friend. I love Della's response to this because she's like, I'm sorry. You want me to ask her about her trauma and then report it back to you? Excuse me?
Isn't there a counselor who should be doing this? Right, she's like, yeah, I'm not gonna do that. Della's the only adult in the room. She's like, this is beyond inappropriate. Also, this never comes back, right? He asks her to do this thing and then it's just like dropped, which is fine. Yeah, like he kind of finds out later when Charlotte is like, no one should hurt their children, but like he never really finds out. No. Well, and like, there's a lot of things in the story that kind of fall into this category.
And I would say that for books that are in this category, this is kind of par for the course, right? Like the author will show us something that the characters do to just kind of like give us like character building, but they're never followed up on. Because it's not what we're here for, honestly. It's not. Well, and I, we kind of mentioned this in the first part. I don't know if I got cut. But she didn't need this trauma backstory. No, she really didn't. No, like because you could have made, you could have made her motivated based on just the family and lore and like the sense of loyalty that she had with her dad.
But instead her dad is a piece of shit. And so well, and I continue to not understand her dad's motivation. And is she doing it just because she's afraid of her dad because she could easily kill him. Right. Easily. Yeah, I don't understand her dad's motivation. And this whole backstory of trauma just kind of feeds in to the damsel in distress trope, which I'm here for. Don't get me wrong. But again, I have a lot of questions. I think that's that's what my notes say when he doesn't comfort her.
I was like, oh, but I want this like damsel in distress moment. Like, let me take you down and hold you like I want to say that. Exactly. And I still want that. Because I feel like there are so many things that like, well, actually, I don't know. Great probably knows everything about her, but I still want this like damsel in distress moment to like be made good. Exactly. Because we don't actually get that. No, we don't. And it just, I mean, this goes with him being a true villain. And then I'll let this go. But the like, I'm going to feed from you anyway and make you have a great time, even though you're having a panic attack.
Like, right. Okay. I guess it's on par for the devil. Yeah. It's a little hypocritical. So next we get another trope and we see the students out on the lawn having hand to hand combat class because of course they are because of course they are. I did like in the scene because we know that Willow is curvy. She talks about how relieved she is to be able to wear pants because she's tired of putting deodorant on her legs because she chafes.
And I'm like, I like the representation because girl same without there being like a body shame thing. Like there's no like, oh, I hate wearing skirts because I'm fat. It's just like, no, I like to wear pants because my thighs rub together and it fucking hurts. Right. And I love that she puts it in the context that like we as women all know she says, I don't have a thigh gap. So I have to use deodorant because girl same. Yeah. Then like, look, I live in a hot state. I get it. I get sticky and damp and it hurts after a bit.
Look, I am no stranger to gold bond or deodorant down there. Nope. Nope. Anyway, I've been in Willow or facing off. Why? I don't know. What? What does I've been do? Why is he in some classes and not others? He has no magic. I just don't get it. Nope. I don't know. But don't, don't worry. Gray quickly intervenes saying that Ivan is going too easy on Willow and doing her no favors. Therefore he reminds them that there is a murderer on the loose. Okay, Lucifer.
Yeah. So Gray becomes her sparring partner and they fight. And they fight. And Gray puts her on her ass and then reprimands her by telling her that she's not human. So she needs to stop fighting like one and to use her magic. When she does, it's a much fairer fight just like the first time that they met. And of course, this is a spectacle for the rest of the students watching. They're like, oh, the headmaster is fighting with a student. I'm like, Jesus Christ. No chill. No chill. And it's stupid because we already know that she can fight with magic because she already has done it against Gray.
Right. We didn't need this scene to remind us that she's capable of going one on one with Gray. I don't understand why we had this scene. No. No. We could have had a different one like because this scene does serve a purpose for like what happens immediately next, but like they could be doing literally anything else on this spot and it would have the same effect. Exactly. Anyway, later when Willow takes a hot bath to ease her sore muscles, she remarks that
hand to hand combat isn't new to her since her dad used to put her in an underground fight club and bet against her to toughen her up. Wow. Okay. Okay. Again, she doesn't need this backstory. Like this backstory just gets more and more bananas. It's fucking bananas. And we get this sense that she's living in a traditional divorce parent home. So it's just her like every third weekend with her dad. He's just fighting her. Like I don't understand.
Well, and this is another instance of where she gives us far too much detail about this because I have questions because she mentioned that even though she wasn't of age yet, the dirt would still heal her cuts and bruises so that her mom would be none the wiser, which means that this happened before she was 16. So he's putting a 12 year old into fight club and somehow finding grown ass men or grown ass women to fight her. Well, that's what I was just wondering.
I'm like, who are her opponents? Are they fellow 12 year olds? I don't understand what's happening. Yeah. No, I, uh, the coffin wasn't enough. She had to do a fight club to it's fucking weird. And it's so soon be she doesn't, she doesn't need to know how to fight because she doesn't use that anyway. Well, and I think it would have made more sense for her mom to teach her because she has magic and she would be able to teach her like how to use both at once. Yeah.
Cause her mom clearly told her how to use her man. I just doesn't make fucking sense. No. Anyway, as she soaks, she hears someone calling her name and then she feels something slide against her like leg underwater. But in both cases, there's nothing in no one there to like blame that on. And then Gray comes bursting into the bathroom and asks if she's okay. This is so fucking weird too, because is it not gray murdering these students?
It is anyway. He bodily pulls her out of the tub and says there's been another murder. He takes her to see the body and it's in the same place where she was sparring with Ivan and Gray earlier in the day. This time it's a male witch and his liver is missing. There's also the word to written on the side of the school in blood. So the number two. I don't understand why he rushed into the bathroom and made her come see this and he comes in as if it's like, there's been another murder.
I had to make sure it wasn't you. I had to make sure it wasn't you. Even a couple of things here. Even if you weren't the murderer, you would already know it wasn't her because I assume you already saw the body. Great point. So this is when we learn about the prophecy of the daughter of two, a which born between two bloodlines who would restore what had been lost to time. Great. I wonder who that could be. There's no way to know.
As Willow leaves to return to her room, Daly catches up to her and asks whether she heard the voice calling Willow's name as well. Willow admits that she did, but she thought that she was just hearing things. However, both of them admit that the voice felt like it was trying to compel whoever was listening. Daly heard the same voice and followed the voice to the body. She was the one who found this student. Gray is convinced that it was none of his people, but says that if the daughter of two was part of the Hecate line, she would be able to compel people if she found Charlotte's bones.
Inwardly, Willow's like, well, it wasn't me who lured the witch from his bed. Looking back on this scene, I'm just like, why would you say that? I don't know. No, I don't know. Also, this whole fucking murder scheme is so weird because she gets to the school and is like, I might kill people and I'm gonna bury them in the woods. Yeah, where did that storyline go? I was like here for her murdering people. Me too, but now she's like appalled that anyone would think it was her.
I would be here for a murder conflict or a murder like thing that she was a part of where she just keeps accidentally killing people. Well, I kind of had that thought in here where I'm like, maybe she is doing it like in her dreams or something. Yeah. Well, and we never get an answer to like whose voice it was and like what she felt in the bathtub. Like, it's trying to do this gothic horror thing, but like we just it's never, never quite lands. No, it doesn't.
It doesn't. It's worth mentioning at this point that both of the witches who have been murdered are a part of the group from Outside Crystal Hollow. So remember there were 13 of them, including Willow. So now they're down to 11. 11. That's math. Yeah, that's math, baby. Math, I bet it is. So later that night Willow was restless and so she roams the halls trying to get some clarity about what's happening, which seems like a great idea given recent events.
People are being murdered Willow. Go to bed. As she does this, she sees a vision of Charlotte Hecate walking through the forest and she is younger than Willow had imagined. She has auburn hair and purple eyes and is joined by a man with dark magic emanating from him. When Willow is released from the vision, she's met by a group of witches who are a part of the remaining group from Outside Crystal Hollow and they end up beating the shit out of her because they believe that she's responsible for the deaths of their classmates.
Willow doesn't fight back because she knows that they're not the enemy and she understands where they're coming from or something and when they leave her, she crawls to Gray's office for help not knowing where else to go. I don't understand why she doesn't fight back. Like, it's, yeah, it's couch like I'm, they're not the enemy, I'm not gonna hurt them. Also, I get why they're mad. Also, I fight back, they're gonna think I'm guilty. No girl, you can just like let them beat the shit because they almost like kill her. Like they punch her in the kidneys and in the ribs and like in the face like they break her nose.
Yeah, there's like seven of these fuckers too that like jump her in the hallway. Well, and like, okay, so I always have this question in situations like this in books because like there are like a number of people like you said in both genders, right? So men and women. Yeah. And they're just regular ass people. Like yes, they've been in hand to hand combat, but there's always something different about threatening to beat somebody up and then actually being there and being complicit in beating somebody up.
And not a one of them is just like, oh, maybe this is a bad idea. No, not a one. Which just seems unrealistic. Like they basically leave her there for dead and they're just like deuces. It doesn't make any sense to me. Also a thing I had with the issue in this book is the pacing because the reaping was to happen once a week. So you're telling me this whole book takes one week. Maybe a week and a half. That's you're right. Yeah. Oh, that's that's really weird. I have to believe that's a continuity error because she at some point says weeks ago.
Oh, when Susanna offers her like the out to leave and she's like if you would ask me that weeks ago, blah, blah. Oh, yeah. And I'm like, okay, so does the reaping not start when school starts? I don't know because I also I feel like I remember Gray saying something to to Della or vice versa of like, yeah, I mean, you're going to be nervous when you get chosen in the first week or something. Right. So we just going to skip all the other reaping scenes. I guess. I guess so. Yay.
It's bad. So Gray finds her and gives her his blood and heals her wounds. He asks who did this to her, but she didn't give she doesn't give up the students knowing that Gray would likely name or kill them. He's gonna anyway. He tells her that she could have died and she's like, yeah, and what difference would that make? No one would care and Gray tells her that he would care. He tells her to keep fighting, but she asks what happens when she's tired of fighting and Gray tells her quote, then you let me do it for you.
I kind of liked that. Yeah, I kind of like that too. He bates her and puts her in another one of his shirts and she sleeps. When she wakes up, she goes to leave, but Gray shuts the door from across the room. He reveals that pair bonding between a vessel and a which has been banned by the Covenant because it gives vessels access to some of the wishes powers, which is why he was able to do that. He then reveals that it was he who fed from her during the reaping. And he goes on to say that he now feels the magic within her, even the one that she tries to hide.
Willow is convinced that he's going to kill her when he tells her that he knows exactly what she is and has for some time. Like your whole life. Like your whole fucking life. Oh. Yep. Yep. Don't think about it too hard. Okay. He asks her what her plan was and she admits to originally planning to unmake all the vessels when she found the bones, but he can tell there's something that she's not saying and guesses that she can't admit even now that she's in love with him.
He pushes her back onto his desk during this conversation and they are getting very hot and very heavy. Very hot and heavy, which is okay. Yeah. They end up. So they end up, I don't remember if they're naked or what, but he ends up like, I don't know how to say this. I don't want to say as he pushes into her. Like, oh yeah. They, do they end up on the bed or they still have the cow?
No, they're still on the desk. Oh yeah. Okay. He has like a towel wrapped around his waist and she's just wearing one of his shirts. So like they're pretty much naked. They're pretty much naked. So they start to have sex, right? And as he pushes into her, he says that he'll help her find the bones but expect something in return. And rather than just easing into her, he just like goes full bore and realizes immediately that she's a virgin because she's in a lot of pain. She's not having a good time. She tries to breathe through it and he drops his knees and licks the blood off of her thigh telling her it's a dangerous thing to give a vessel your virginity because there's magic and blood and even more magic and blood that can only be given once.
It creates an obsession between the vessel and the witch. Okay. This is a point that I didn't like that she's a virgin. What I didn't like even more is that her father like orchestrated this. Like her dad basically was like, you need to stay a virgin and seduce him. Yep. And then later, like we find out more of what that means. I don't understand her dad's motive. I don't either because like the thing that Gray is not saying here is that it works both ways, right?
Like it's not vessels that get like that are the only ones benefiting from a relationship like this because the witches are also getting like superhuman strength and stuff like that. And arguably like the witches would have a better deal from this because they are now superhuman and have full access to their power, their powers. Whereas even Gray admits in the scene that vessels only get access to like essentially party tricks. Yeah, they can only do a little bit with it. Right. So it is a benefit for the witch. But it's also the thing like you said, like why?
Okay. Why are men so obsessed with virgins? I don't know. It's so fucking weird and it's like gross. It's gross. It's gross anyway. It's super gross that her dad was concerned about it. We also get this weird gross tidbit of information that when witches reach the age of 16, they're like instructed to sleep with someone who's not a vessel to avoid this happening. Right. Gross. Ew. What? Yeah. Yeah.
Anyway, they do continue and Gray is much gentler and eventually bites Willow to flood her body with euphoria. And the scene is fine. Again, not my favorite. No, it wasn't quite one handed reading club. Like it wasn't bad. It was fine. I just didn't like that she was a virgin and in pain and like not having fun. Yeah. Not having a great time. Yeah. No.
Anyway, later Gray watches Willow as she begins the long slog of reviving the grounds around the school. He's like in his office like watching out of a window and he's summoned Karros to his office and tells him that he, Gray, must go into town for a couple of days and Karros is to watch Willow without Willow knowing it. Mostly so Willow doesn't rip Karros apart. As they both watch her, they remark how no one like her has existed before because she is both life and death. We hop to Willow in the garden and she is joined pretty soon by Susanna.
Willow is wary obviously given their last interaction, but Susanna says that she has no intention of hurting her today. What? Today. Okay. Thanks. Thanks. She shows Willow a picture of Lorelai and says she finally figured out what it was about Willow that struck her as odd. She guesses correctly that Lorelai is Willow's aunt. Willow expects Susanna to kill her, but Susanna tells her to leave and to never return. To ward herself so that even the Covenant in Gray cannot find her. Willow considers this offer and remarks that she would have jumped at that chance just a few weeks prior,
but now she knows people here like Daela and is in love with Gray. This again doesn't make sense to me because isn't Susanna's whole goal is to let the Covenant die out. So why are you going to let her run away? And it's like because you're the last of my bloodline, but I was going to let you die anyway. I don't understand. Well, she was going to let her stay alive long enough to sire a child and then she was going to kill her. Oh, that's true. But now you can just go frolic off and start a whole new coven? Yeah, that doesn't make sense to me.
Like what? Just put her back in a dream sleep and put her in the Tribunal Chambers or something. Also, also, also, she had said, Susanna had said earlier that the Tribunal members practice the old ways in secret because the vessels aren't allowed to feed from them. Shouldn't that extend to Willow too since she is de facto a member of the Tribunal? It should. Okay, well, that's a really good point.
Good shit. Moving on. Good shit. Sweet in the deal. Susanna reveals that Gray has had Charlotte Hecate's bones this whole time. I've been here the whole time. Right. And Willow scoffs that that can't be true because Gray knows what she is. Susanna then is filled with fear and tells Willow to run. The Rosebushes pick up on Willow's emotions and begin imprisoning Susanna in their vines. Willow doesn't command them to stop and Susanna does nothing to fight them off.
Before Susanna is completely buried alive, she warns Willow, quote, your destiny is not to do what is right. Your destiny is to destroy us all, end quote. Which, fine. But isn't that what you were trying to do anyway? I just don't understand. Yeah, like it seems kind of like this Venn diagram is almost a circle. The call is going from inside the house. Right. So with that warning and the realization that Susanna would rather be buried alive than face whatever it is that is in Willow's destiny, Willow runs for the forest.
I was reading very fast at this point and I missed the transition from her being in the garden to being in the forest. And it was very chaotic for a while in my mind's eye. I was like, how did you get so far away? Yeah. Also, what the fuck are you doing? It feels very much like Gray and Kairos were watching from the window and then as soon as we flipped to Willow, they were just like deuces and Gray like bolted out the door and Kairos was just like, hey, Gray and looked away for two seconds.
I mean, he looked back, Willow was gone. Right. And you just see Susanna like getting sucked into the earth. Yeah. And Kairos is like, shit, God damn it. He's totally going to kill me for this. As Willow runs, she hears a howl cut through the air and she knows that she's missed something. She's trying to figure it out as she's running and the forest helps her revealing a path to Salem, but she knows that she'll have to outrun the beast that chased her in order to make it to safety. These beasts are wolf-like but can stand on their hind legs like men and they're huge, much larger than Willow or a normal wolf.
They end up surrounding her and though she tries to fight them off with her magic, ultimately one of them topples her. Just as it goes in for the killing strike, Gray appears because of course he does. Because of course he does. He soon dispatches the rest of the wolves and Gray asks her what the hell she was thinking. She obviously could have been killed. Willow doesn't say much and Gray knows immediately that something between them has shifted. Instead of telling him what was going through her mind, Willow instead asks how many of those beasts there are.
Gray tells her that he doesn't exactly take a census but that they are the cursed. They were originally created by Charlotte and they were men from Salem who were chasing her for being a witch. Charlotte decided that if they were going to kill her for practicing witchcraft even though she was innocent, then she was going to do the very thing they accused her of and subsequently made the deal with the devil. Okay. Yeah, okay. Moving on. Also, I thought Charlotte Hecate was a lot older than that.
Me too. Like I was thinking ancient Greece. Me too because the Salem witch trials were won in the 1800s. No. No, they were like the 1700s. But still. Yeah, I thought she was a lot older too. Okay, 1692 to 1693. But I think that's what's a little jarring in this book because and again, this is still very out of context, but we have Lucifer, we get like Leviathan and Beelzebub and like all of these like biblical names and then the Salem witch trials and it's just like these weird time jumps.
Yeah. I mean, I could also, I think it would be more interesting if Charlotte was like really ancient, right? Like, I mean her last name is Hecate, right? Like that's, I think that's what also made her feel really ancient because Hecate is a goddess in her own right. Right. So I would, it would be really cool if she was Hecate actually. Yes, which is what I was hoping for because Hecate is the goddess of death and stuff. Witchcraft. Witchcraft, magic, the moon and night. Yeah. Okay, not death.
Sorry. And or I thought it would be cool if she was like Lilith or somebody. Well, that's kind of the vibe I got with her like rib being put into Willow. Like it felt very like first woman, like, yeah, but she's just some woman. Just some woman who made a deal with the devil during the Salem witch trials. Yeah. Anyway, finally Willow tells Gray that Susanna knows what Willow is and that's why she ran.
It's not a lie, but it's not the whole truth either. Back in Gray's room, Willow is showered and refreshed, but Gray quickly pushes her to tell him exactly what Susanna said to her. Willow is evasive. So Gray summons Karros to corroborate the story and to fetch Susanna in order to hear her side of things, but Karros reveals that no one can find Susanna. I never saw her leave the garden. Gray immediately puts together what happened and tells Karros to search the dirt in the garden and dismisses him. Oops. When they are alone, Gray opens to safe behind the portrait of Satan behind his desk and reveals that he's had the bones all along.
He's been here the whole time. Also, can we just take a moment to appreciate that he has a self-portrait behind him. A self-portrait of the worst day of his life. Because we didn't mention this, but this picture is a painting of the fall of Lucifer. So it's him falling through the sky with wounds on his back where God ripped his wings off.
What a choice. What a mood, honestly. I actually love that. Earlier when Willow first sees it, she is caught looking at it and Gray is like, it's a reminder. She's like, okay. Then asks not to follow a question. It does maybe wonder if God is going to come into play in the subsequent books. Oh, that would be interesting. And Michael and stuff? Yeah, and then maybe it's a why choose.
Between God and the devil. Oh. I'm not opposed to that. I'm kind of here for it. Anyway, so anyway, as Willow comes into contact with the bones, pain rips through her as things shift inside of her to make room for this new magic. Willow is devastated by the betrayal and tells Gray that she wants no part of whatever is going on until he tells her the truth.
He does not afford her that luxury and forces her to interact with the bones, which form a permanent necklace around her throat. He tells her that she will be the last of the Hecate line and the bones will die with her. And then Porqueiros comes back and when he comes back to report what happened to Susanna, Willow immediately un-makes him. He just touches him and he falls into mud. Yeah. I love that. Gray is like, that was unnecessary.
Look at the mess you made. Right. He's just totally unconcerned. She tries to un-make Gray too, but he tells her, quote, there's so much of your blood in me, Witchling. You cannot un-make me because those bones recognize me as part of you. Which also was fortified by her like virgin blood? Yep. Which again makes me wonder why her dad planned all of this? Right. I have to imagine that her dad like just didn't really understand and was just like, yeah, dudes love versions for sure.
For sure. And this will work for sure. God. Ehh. So Willow commands that Gray take the bones off of her, but he tells her that they are a part of her now and to do so would kill her. And he very much wants her alive. Well. He then throws her over his shoulder and takes her to the tribunal room. As they walk, Willow accuses him of being heartless and using her as a means to an end like everything else in his world. He tells her that there are a lot of things that do indeed represent a means to an end for him, but quote, never you, Witchling.
You're the key to everything. You're exactly what I've been waiting for all these years. Because he has been waiting all the years. But I would prefer him to say who instead of what? Yeah, because she's not a thing. Yeah. But details. He goes on to say that only a hackete which can unmake vessels, but they are also the only ones who can end the corruption of the covenant. When Gray uses his magic to imprison George against the wall in the tribunal room, Willow is shocked that he can use her magic so easily.
He tells her quote, where do you think Willow, or he tells her quote, where do you think Charlotte got her magic? From me, obviously. Which should have been a dead giveaway. Uh-huh. But it wasn't. Uh-uh. In the center of the room, Gray lifts up a hatch revealing a mirror with the image of a woman on the outside rim. Willow at first thinks that this is Charlotte. Then a vessel arrives with Susanna's bones and her skeleton slowly reforms and Gray imprisons her on the wall next to George.
This vessel also brought a bag with two items inside which he places on the floor, and it is a heart and a liver from the dead witches. Grr. Willow is shocked and tells Gray that he was so convincing, seemingly genuinely worried for her safety during the murders. He tells her quote, I have had centuries of practice lying to naive little girls just like you. Oh, damn. It's still pretty comical to think about though. It's so comical. So, pretty quickly, the other ten outsider witches are shown in and one by one they are slaughtered in front of Willow.
From each, Gray demands part of them. Brain, kidneys, lungs, etc. Willow can't help but notice that Gray makes the death of the witches who attacked Willow particularly slow. As he does the grizzly work, he also reveals that he is the one who murdered Laura Lai? Why? She asks him why he murdered her when she was a hecate witch, and he tells her because everything he's done has been one step closer toward making her Willow. Laura Lai had to die so that Willow would become the daughter of two.
Uh, okay. I mean, sure, but I- This is where things got Scooby-Dooey and too convoluted. Yeah, Scooby-Dooey and a little bit off the rails, if I'm honest. It goes way off the rails. Really, really quick. So, Gray then commands Willow to bleed the Covenant and he can't compel her anymore because her hecate powers are alive and well. So even though his blood is in her veins, that works like he can't compel her.
He tells her that she can use her necromancy powers to give both of them flesh once more, but she refuses. So Gray has Ash and Willow's father brought into the chamber. Okay, so Gray says like, please don't make me force you. You're gonna hate me for what I have to do. And her first thought is that he's gonna bring Ivan in? I know. I was like, okay, Ivan hasn't shown up in about 50 pages, so I don't know why you think he would be here. And I also don't know why you think he would be a bargaining chip. Like, obviously it's gonna be your brother.
Right. And honestly, it's just her brother, right? Because her father is the one holding Ash like at knife point. Yeah. And again, I don't know why her father is there. Where is Ash's father? I don't know. He seems really chill about this whole thing. Because remember, he was at the bus station when that whole thing was happening and was just like, I don't know. It doesn't look like anything to me. And now he's probably just like, well, he's probably at somebody's house. He's probably fine. So Gray tells her to cooperate and nothing will happen to Ash.
Willow tells her father that she'll kill him for this and he cockily says that she won't live long enough to do that. Well, no, she's gonna be queen of hell. Right. Dumbass. Willow ends up complying and gives Susanna and George flesh again so their blood can be added to the ritual that Gray is conducting. That was gross. Yeah, very gross. Once she does this, they are unmade and they turn to dust. Then he stabs Willow in the stomach. I just... As he does this, he does say, quote, I'm sorry, it'll be over soon.
Yeah. But then he makes it worse because he reaches inside of her and pulls out a fabric pouch. Which is so fucking weird. Like, she grew up in the human world. What if she had previously like broken a rib and gotten like X-rays and there's like, what the fuck is in you? Okay. Isn't there a better way that Charlotte could be with her? Like she could just be on a necklace or something. I'm realizing in real time that Willow had a bone of Charlotte Hecate's which should have been able to give her the power of the Hecate line.
Oh, you're right. Why couldn't she just utilize the power? Is that why she could like sense the power? I don't know. There was so many questions. Okay. Anyway, we're just gonna drive right past that. Moving on. So, Gray gives her his blood to heal her, but inside the pouch is a rib and it turns out to be Charlotte Hecate's rib and he adds this to the offering of organs and blood already assembled.
Once he does so, a woman appears with Auburn hair and purple eyes and Willow recognizes her as the woman from her visions, Charlotte Hecate. Okay. Now, I thought for sure, I don't know if we're gonna engage in any of this. I don't know if we're gonna include the debrief in this. It's a wild one, so maybe. But I thought for sure, as soon as Charlotte Hecate appeared, I was like, oh, okay, Gray and Charlotte Hecate be fucking and that's his whole motivation here. That's what I thought and I thought this is where we were gonna get the true villain because this happily ever after could have been with Charlotte and I thought we're gonna get the true villain of like, fuck you Willow, this is all I needed.
Right, exactly. And then book two is gonna be all about like her being some side chick and then having this weird like push pull with Charlotte, but that's not what happened. No, that would have been a better story. Yeah. So Charlotte appears and Willow's father is I rate of all people because he thought Gray would bring back Lorelai. Why? Also, bro, why do you give a shit? Why are you so obsessed with her? Why are you so obsessed with me? And what are you gonna do with I just so Charlotte looks this guy dead in the eyes and says only the worst kind of man would harm his only daughter and raises a single hand and suffocates him without touching him without touching him.
Ash is released from his father's hold or from Willow's father's hold and runs to Willow they embrace and as they do so Charlotte entombs Willow's father in the stone floor beneath them saying quote let's see how you like living in the darkness. Which is a metal move, but also I don't think that was your place to do. No, and like Willow even says that as Charlotte turns back to look at her that it's clear that Charlotte knows that what what will his father did to her and what Charlotte did was an act of revenge for Willow but like I think that should have been Willow's place to do.
100% it should have been. And maybe in book two she'll like pull him out of the stone and resurrect him and do it again. I don't know that would be metal as hell. That would be metal I want that. Yeah. So the dance floor is kind of clear and Charlotte tells Willow that it's time to say goodbye and Juliet's going to take Ash back to his father now. Willow begs her not to make her say goodbye again but Charlotte tells her that this is for the best since Willow still has yet to fulfill her destiny. Ash will be safer with his father until she does that.
Neither Ash nor Willow are happy but Juliet takes Ash away. Willow had thought that her destiny was done now that Charlotte was back but Charlotte tells her that Charlotte's not her destiny. Charlotte is merely a gift from Willow's husband so that Willow can survive what comes next. When Willow balks that she doesn't have a husband Charlotte says that the mark on her back says otherwise. And there's so much to unpack here. There's so much to unpack. Okay so one, how does Charlotte know that the mark on Willow's back means that she's fucking married and is it just married to one guy?
Or that she even has a mark. Or is that like the marriage mark of the underworld? Oh yeah that's right. How do you know who her husband is or just that she's married? Right. Or did... I mean, look... If Charlotte knew it was gonna happen the whole time, she probably knew that Homeboy was gonna marry her great-great-great-great-great-great-great granddaughter. Ugh. Gross. Anyway. How were there only three generations of these witches?
Well, that we know about. That's true. Cause Lorelai wasn't Charlotte's daughter. No. I'm not sure. The lines between Charlotte and Lorelai because they were both, like, killed and they're both, like, hecate witches and the circumstances of their death are, like, unsure. And it's unclear how both of them fit into this storyline.
It's- I think that's my problem. I am unclear on how the three of them are, like, actually linked and, like, when the deal was made, why the deal was made, because it talks about- It's kind of implied that Charlotte, which we'll talk about, but, like, Charlotte is the reason the vessels exist. Charlotte is the reason that, like, magic exists. I just feel like there's a lot of missing bodies in this family tree. Right. Well, okay, and it's wild to me that magic has only existed for 300 years.
Right? That doesn't make any sense. No. Yeah, and, and, I think it would have been a lot cleaner if Lorelai as a character just wasn't so prominent. Like- Yeah. Like, her father could be obsessed with getting the power back and then his aim was always to kill his daughter so that he could have the power. That would make more sense. Right. Not to have this weird obsession with his sister to come back. Yeah, because, like, what are- what were you gonna do with her? Yeah. I don't know.
So, Willow is reeling with a lot of questions, not the same questions that we have, but she does voice one of them aloud and we get an answer to why the bone was inside of her. Gray put it there the night that Willow was born because Charlotte made him promise a long time ago to ensure that Charlotte would always be close with Willow. I don't understand. Was it all for this moment? Like, I just, I don't get why.
I have a lot of questions. So, Charlotte goes on to reveal that Willow is the daughter of two and she was always surprised for Charlotte's bargain with the devil. Willow asks Charlotte why Charlotte's face is on the mirror, but Charlotte tells Willow that it's not her face, it's Willow's face. So, it becomes pretty clear that Willow is the devil's bride and the queen of hell, which was the price for Charlotte getting magic. She was gonna produce this queen, right? But I don't, I don't understand why if Charlotte got her power from the devil himself, why the devil needed to make this bargain at all to get a queen.
Yeah, why wouldn't Charlotte just have been the queen? And if, so vessels like when they feed from witches have some access to their power, but if magic came from hell at first. Why can't, why don't they have power? That seems like a demotion. It does seem like a demotion. So then why would the devil even make this bargain to be like, oh yes, let me weaken all of the demons so that you have power so I can have a child bride in 300 years?
Yeah. Okay, also, I don't know if we said this, but I'm gonna say it again in case we missed it. Let's, let's, let's go through a logical exercise here, right? So, Gray knew about Willow from her birth because he put the fucking rib into her little baby body when she was born, right? Okay, that's weird in and of itself. What's weirder is that he doesn't know what happened to Willow to make her so upset the night of the reaping.
Also, also, he, they had a conversation previously, I think, where Willow's like, was this your plan the whole time? And he's like, no, you were a surprise. No, she wasn't. You've been planning on this for 300 years. Right, and you knew about her the moment she was born. So how was she, tell me how she was a surprise again. But then you just like didn't monitor her when she was at her dad's house. Right, like it, everything he says in this book has to be a fucking lie.
It does, because even in the beginning when the council or the covenant are like, go get this other one and he is like, huh, why me? Okay, but why would the council send the devil to go get his own bride? Don't know. How did he end up on earth? Why? Has he been imprisoned in this human body since Charlotte made the deal with him?
Yes, I think so. Why would he ever agree to that? I don't know. Also, why was he not courting Willow before he showed up on her doorstep if he knew about her? Right, wouldn't you think that if you as the devil wanted your wife to like you? And your plan was to give her back the bones the whole time. Why even do any of this gaslighting? I just don't understand. Me either. Anyway, we're so close to the end.
So Charlotte takes Willow's hands and presses them to the mirror and tells her to not let go until she says otherwise. Because if she does, Willow will die. The mirror disappears and a spiral staircase is revealed that goes down into what is seemingly a bottomless pit. Willow asks to be allowed to die, but Charlotte tells her that she is the only hope of fixing what Charlotte has done. What? As Willow watches in horror, several demons ascend the stairs from hell and enter into the mortal world.
We get actual names here, but I'm unfamiliar with the lore, and so I don't know if that matters, or if their descriptions are true to the accepted lore. But the names that we get are Beelzebub, Satanus, Leviathan, Mammon, and Asmodeus. Whatever. I've heard those names, that's all I know. These guys show up, and in between the last two, they're carrying a bed with a figure lying face down on it. This figure also has wounds on his back where wings used to be. He quickly realizes that this is the devil, but is confused as to why he's not moving, and Charlotte tells her, oh honey, that's because his soul's already here.
Okay. Gray puts a hand on Willow's shoulder and asks whether she's ready to hear his true name yet. Lose fur! Before she can answer, Charlotte begins to disappear and Willow starts to panic. In her mind, Charlotte was the one person who had ever helped her, but there's nothing she can do to stop it, and Charlotte is gone. So again, Charlotte only brought back so that Willow opened the gate without dying. Yes, I think so.
That just seems so unnecessary. Yeah. So once that happens and she lets go, Willow rounds on Gray and tells him she'll never forgive him for this. He tells her, quote, you will. In time, you'll realize just how fleeting human life is, how little it matters. When everyone you know has died and lies rotting in the earth, you and I will remain. You will find that anything can be forgiven if given the time for memory to fade.
When she protests that she is human, he tells her she won't be like that for long. What?! And then asks slash commands her to put him back into his body and she initially refuses, but he says, quote, I cannot love you in this form, but I can in my own. Let me love you as you deserve, witchling. So she puts her hand on Lucifer's chest and let her, let's her necromancer magic flow, and as she does, Gray's vessel unmakes and Lucifer's chest begins to rise and fall. And that is where this fucking book ends. This book is a wild ride.
Like, I felt that as I was reading and now actually going through it, I feel very much like, what the fuck is happening? Yeah, like, I stand by the sentiment that I had a great time reading this book. I had such a good time, but it's not, it's not good. No, I'm confused and disoriented. I have many questions. Yes, many questions, many thoughts, many thoughts.
Let's get into our ratings. Okay, so we have a little bit of a disagreement here and so I think it'll be interesting to talk about that. So let's start with Spicevill. We agree here. So Liz, how did we rate that? We both gave it a three. We do get some spicy scenes. I do wish there were more of them, but we get the banter. We get the detail. If she wasn't a virgin, I think the sex scene, the one that we get, could have made this a four,
but it's just her weird virginity kind of trips me up. And we got a bunch of lead up to her being on her knees for him, and we never got that and that kind of bummed me out. Yeah, and as much as he said that he would be on his knees for her, I guess he kind of does when he eats her out for behind, but I really wanted that to be like leaned into a little bit more. Yeah, because she's not in power in that scene at all. No, not at all, which kind of makes for an interesting, like I'm on my knees for you, but I'm not like I'm still in control, which is fine.
But I do hope in the next book we get more of that like worship kind of conversation. Same, and I hope we get more more more as in quantity and then more explicit, like more explicit than they were in this book scenes in book two. Yes, because we do. There's a lot of promise for it because even like after they've sex the first time, he says something.
I don't know if it's in his inner monologue or two willow, but like, oh, you made a mistake. Like I'm going to want to be inside you all the time now. Yeah, follow through on that. Right. Cue him not being inside of her for the rest of the book ever again. Okay, so moving into writing style, we had a bit of a disagreement here. So I rated it a two and you rated it a four. So tell me why you rated it a four. Listen, so now I'm all of my.
I think, and I could just be really wrong because I did read this with the top of my lungs, but I didn't notice a lot of like formatting errors. There weren't a lot of like typos like functionally the book was fine. Like I, okay, so I think it was well edited from a grammatical standpoint, not from a story standpoint. But now I'm wondering if that's true or if I just read too fast to catch any errors.
So I will say that it definitely got better. Like in the back half of the book, but in the first part of the book, there were just straight up words missing from sentences. Oh, really? I just didn't notice that. I just didn't clock that at all. So you're right. Like the formatting is great and like the like sentence structure is fine and it's very approachable. The story isn't edited well. No, but the the words just missing out of out of sentences.
I cannot read it higher than a two for that. Okay, I'm going to come down to you because I missed that and I fully trust that you are correct. Okay, so we have Corum there moving into quality of storytelling. We rated this a three. So walk us through that rating. Okay, so as you probably followed, this was a chaotic journey for many reasons. There are so many plot holes like you could find Atlantis, you could find the fucking so many places.
I was trying to think of El Dorado. There's so many places that are hidden in these plot holes. We have so many questions. There are so many bits of information that are introduced and never followed up on like we still don't know what happened 50 years ago. What massacre? Who died? Who did it? There's no way to know. Why is the devil in this vessel body? Why is he headmaster? What did the Covenant really want to do? Also, we didn't mention it, but Charlotte says something like the vessels were just a distraction.
Girl what? Girl what? Also, why could she not access the necromancer powers when she had fucking Charlotte Hecate's bone in her life? That doesn't make any sense. What is her dad's motive? There's so many fucking questions and I think the only reason why it's a three because really for the amount of questions and chaos we have, it should be like a one or a two, but it was also fun. It was just fun and I think it's worth mentioning that this take on like magic and witchcraft and vampires honestly is a refreshing take.
It's something that I haven't seen before and I'm invested like for all of the plot holes in this book, the way that she described and like made the world feel real and makes sense worked. I don't have a problem with the way magic works in this book. No, I have a bit of a problem with where magic came from in the first place. That's a little confusing, but the rules of magic all make sense. Correct. And I'm intrigued by that and you're right. The take on vampires is really interesting. Even this like Hecate, Lucifer combo, like it's just a really interesting take on like where witches come from and all of this stuff.
But I have, I have a thousand questions. Yep. Yep. So this might come as a surprise, but do we recommend this book? Actually, yeah. Yeah, actually, it's a great time. I had and we're going to read the next one like I'm fully prepared for it to have many more questions, but I'm hoping it'll be fun. I think it's going to be a great time. I mean, look, I read at the top of my lungs in this book. I haven't done that for a lot of the books, even the books that we liked.
It's just a different category of book for me. It was refreshing. Yeah, it was refreshing. So like this book was fun. It was a different take on the fantasy. It was, I mean, I'm stoked for the next one. Yeah, me too. Cool. All right, we did it. Those are our thoughts on the coven by Harper L Woods. Thank you as always for joining us on this journey. Let us know what you thought on the socials. You can find us everywhere at spice tutors pod. And if you like our podcast and want more, consider becoming a patron where we release Patreon exclusive episodes on our off weeks.
And if you really, really like us, drop us a review wherever you listen. But until next time, we'll see you. Bye. Bye.
Triggers: graphic violence and gore, depictions of a fictional plague, on-page sexual content (including masturbation), and themes of parent death and chronic illness KU: No Recommendation: No, (give the author money...
Triggers: (From the author): kidnapping, violence, discussions of abuse, BDSM dynamics and play, tentacle play, brief descriptions of injured animal (that receives aid), breath play, bondage, depictions of sub drop,...
Triggers: war, battle, hand-to-hand combat, perilous situations, blood, intense violence, brutal injuries, death, and poisoning KU: No Recommendation: Yes! For more of the author, check out https://rebeccayarros.com/
Triggers: from the author: “explicit violence, explicit sexual violence, dubious consent, murder, gore, torture, kidnapping, and more.” KU: Yes Recommendation: No For more of the author, check out...
Triggers: death of a parent (off page), grief, fantasy violence KU: No Recommendation: both Traders recommend! This is part 2 of 2. For more of the author, check out https://www.lanaferguson.com/