Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Spice Traders

Spice Traders artwork

Serpent & Dove by Shelby Mahurin

May 9, 20232 hr 30 minAudio

This week the Traders take a dive into magic and forced marriage in Serpent & Dove by Shelby Mahurin. Hopefully you’ll love the heroine as much as we did (even her manic pixie dream girl tendencies)! Triggers: violence against women, religious aspects/trauma Tropes: forced proximity, one bed, enemies to lovers For more, visit @shelbymahurin on Instagram!

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

There's also this thing that happens and I hesitated to say it because I think it's going to make all of us very self-conscious. When one of us makes a joke, the other one's repeated. Yeah, I do that all the time. Yeah, it's funny, except for sometimes it's not. Yeah, I do that in my life. Yeah, it's about... But when I'm editing, I'm like, do I leave it? I don't think that a reader needs to hear that. I listen or needs to hear that three times in stereo. You can take this out. It's called mirroring and we're on the spectrum for here. It's called mirroring and sometimes I want to repeat something because I want to know

how it feels in my mouth. Oh my gosh, yes. It sounds like it's going to feel fun to say, so I want to say it. The worst is sometimes the original person who said the joke because the other two repeat it repeats it again. It's like, okay, this part's really not funny anymore. Also, title of your sex tape. I want to know how it feels in my mouth. Welcome to your safe space.

The podcast, your partner, friends, parents, whoever thinks is dirty. Don't have time to read books? Want to understand the TikToks? We got you fam. We're the spice traders and we deal in spicy books. My name's Katie and I need it to make sense. Hi, I'm Dez and I would love to talk about feelings today. I'm Liz and I'm hypercritical. As always, we start every episode with three things. The first is a generic trigger warning. You can find specific triggers for this book in our show notes, so please check those out. Also, we do use foul language and talk a lot about sets. You have some sensitivity to that,

this isn't the podcast for you. Secondly, we talk about books. The whole book, nothing about the books, it'll help me goddess. If you plan to read this book and you don't want something spoiled, don't listen to this episode right now. Lastly, we acknowledge that a good book can hit you at the wrong time. The views expressed in our discussion are our opinions and we absolutely do not want to diminish the work and the talent of the authors in our community. That said, we have some notes. ["Sherpin and Dove"] So, Katie, what are we talking about today? Today we're talking about Serpent and Dove

by Shelby Mayer and published in 2019. It is the first in a completed trilogy and it is 513 pages in a physical copy. And this is another one of those books that is just really pretty in a physical copy. I have the hardcover and I have the hardcover of all three of her books and I bought them very specifically because they look very pretty on a bookshelf and I knew we were gonna read all three of them. And I just shout out to all the authors who put their foot down and get beautiful books because it matters. It does, even though I read it on Kindle, but, you know. Yeah, it matters.

And the behavior backs, so we represent all forms of this book. Hell yeah, diversity. Diversity, Shelby Mayer and Mayer. I'm sorry, Shelby. Mayer and Mayer and I think, Shelby, I'm so sorry for saying this. Please correct us. So because we're gonna read your next book, so if it's wrong and you hear this, I don't know why you would listen. We stan you. We stan you. We do stan you. Tell me how to say your name. Before we, we don't actually have to get into this, but, or maybe you're gonna start with this, Des,

but I read it on Kindle and I didn't actually open the hard cover and I saw Liz in your notes that there is a map. The map isn't in Kindle. Why just go do that? There's a map. I went back and looked. It's a really nice map, actually. It's a beautiful map. That would have been so helpful. That would have been great. Not in Kindle. I don't know why. Because you even see like where, I got distracted. Because you have like, accessories where like it takes place, but then you have like a blow up accessory, which I think is brilliant on a map.

We can like see just dropping things. So you can like see where the theater is, the park, the cathedral. It's a very lovely map. Fucking map, yes. I was a little bit, I was a little bit lost in some parts of the book because like I actually had the thought I really wish that I had a map. And I went back to check to make sure I didn't miss it. And I didn't. It's just not there. Why would they not put it in Kindle? And why would the editor not notice that? I don't know. Seems like a mess. What are these questions?

No, Shelby, it's not your problem. We all have physical copies except for Desiree and she can borrow mine. Fair. Just for next time, for the future books, we'll know to check in the physical copies for maps, even if we're reading it on Kindle. It's just so strange to me. I think I'd like to own the physical copy. Like, we'll get into it later, but like I think I'd like to own the physical copy of this book. Des has a very love-hate relationship with physical copies of books. I have a texture problem. With books? Yeah. So like, when I, so pages make my hands feel weird.

And so that weird texture in my hands, it's not all books. Some of them, it's okay. Not all men. Some of them, it's... God. But like, it's not worth me risk buying the physical book and then not being able to read it because I'm too distracted by how like, it makes my hands feel. So you need to buy physical books in person so you can like, test touch them. Yes, but like, it's more complicated than that because like, I can test touch them at the store, be like, it's fine. And then I get home and I start reading it and my hands touch them for a long period of time. I'm like, it's not fine. It's not fine. Nothing is very wrong here.

Okay, that is fascinating. Yeah, the more and more I live my life, the more and more autistic I think I might be. Aw, you sweet tropical fish. You sweet tropical fish. Okay, so quick anecdote. I have never been diagnosed with like being, I mean, I don't know if you get diagnosed for being neurodivergent or anything like that, but certainly haven't been diagnosed for being like ADHD or anything like that. And I was talking to James recently and he was talking about how he went to his doctor

and he went for another thing, but he asked him, he's like, hey, you know, I have trouble concentrating, blah, blah. And anyway, he got prescribed like a very low dose of Adderall and he's like sitting here talking to me about like, why Adderall helps him. And he's like, you know, the last minute, like I work good on a deadline, but like, you know, that's not normal. And I was like, whoa, what? Can we just back up? It's not, it's not normal to be like that. And he's like, no. What? You don't have to live your life like that. And I was like, what?

But that's wild. I just thought everybody was like this. Wait, no, but really in all seriousness, it's not normal. No, it's not normal. I woke up at four o'clock this morning to make my lecture for my class at eight a.m. Because. That's not normal. That's not. Maybe I need Adderall. Yeah. Why am I living my life like this? I need to try this shit. I'll have to. It's amazing. Oh my God, the days when I take Vyvance, like the amount of like, I'm productive

for things in the future. Like I'm planning on when I have a big day of editing. Like when I need to edit, I'm gonna take Vyvance. I'm gonna knock it all out of the day because I'm so productive. But it's like feeling like you have a deadline, but you don't. And so you just have time to do all of those things and you just do them because there's no like, distractions or like you're not, it's fantastic. I feel like my entire life has been a lie. So that was fun. How come no one, I am 32 years old. How come no one has told me this? No one told me either. Yeah. Except for my husband over lunch.

And I was like, you're lying to me. You're lying. That's not real. I'll tell you, it's a special day when I take Vyvance. Yeah. I have literally, I have a work test that I've been putting off for a month and a half. Oh, that's called executive dysfunction. I have to do it after this because it's due tomorrow on a deadline. I gave myself because I couldn't put it off anymore. The deadline you gave yourself. And then I made somebody on my team accountable for it. I was like, I'm going to present this to you tomorrow because you care about it and I have to get it done. And then because I know you're waiting on it, I'll do it.

Right. And he's like, cool, sounds good. And I'm like, thank you. That's called executive dysfunction and you both have it. You want to know how much work I've put in on my dissertation since I passed my proposal in December? Zero. This much. You say? Yeah. It's much time. Do you want to know how much work you're going to do about two days before it's due? Before you present it? None because that's not how dissertations work. Oh, it's just whenever. Well, so there's not like a due date. Like now I have to, I have to propose my study.

Now I have to get approval from the institutional review board and then collect the data. Like, so I can't even like do the next step until I do the step I'm on now. So like there's not a due date until I just do it. I'll just use an Adderall. I can just pay for school for the next 10 years until they're like, yo, you're not finishing. We got to kick you out. I'm sorry, we can't keep taking your money. They will. There's like a limit. I don't think there is. Capitalism has no limit. No, there truly is in a PhD.

Like if you make no progress in like five years, they will expel you and you have to start over. Oh my god. Yeah, like it's truly a thing. Shit. Yeah, so maybe it takes an Adderall or something. I got it. OK, so there's not a map in the Kindle version. OK, well, there is a map in the paper version. And my notes, all they say are, I'm a map. I'm a map. I'm a map. I'm a map. I'm a map. Definitely not a map in the Kindle version. I don't know why. Nope. I don't like that. No, it's a disservice because it's actually a good map

after all the shade I've thrown at shit maps. This map is great. And you missed it. I sure did. But instead, we start part one with a French proverb. We start all parts. There's three of them with a French proverb. And I actually really like this one. Misfortune never arrives alone. My note is which love. I love that. Yeah, I do too. Yes. So we start off from a perspective. We don't know whose perspective at this time. Talking about how magic always smells on a body that's

been touched by it. We figure out that this person, Lou, is at the Bella Rose. Sorry, Bella Rose. And she shares a little bit about the world around her. 13 bodies have been found at the Bella Rose over the past year, which is more than double the amount of bodies years prior. I don't think they've been found at the Bella Rose. They've just been found in Bell Terra. There's a lot of bell names here. One thing about this, the 13 bodies thing. I love that she starts this out, but it never comes back up again.

We don't follow this thread. It's not like a who done it aspect of why are these bodies showing up? It's 13, and then some other things happen, and that's never looked at again. I didn't think about that. I think it's witches taking, not taking, it's actioning against people they don't like. And that's where those bodies are coming from. It's just so specific for this art protagonist, Lou, for her internal monologue to be like they found 13, and it's like, oh, OK.

What is the timeline for this? Yeah, I don't. It's all very weird. And I think it sets the stage in a nice way, but it also never comes again. So I don't know. Yeah, they don't continue to find bodies throughout the book, unless we know why, like we're there for bodies. Yeah, there's one other instance where like another body is brought in as like a side part of a scene, but like that's it. Yeah. So as we get to do along, this is being told from Lou's perspective.

We meet Lou and Coco are watching a man at this brothel. His name is Pierre Tremblay in Madame Labelle's brothel. Through this interaction, we find out that Tremblay's daughter, Philippa, has been the seventh body found. The rumors that are currently surrounding her death were that the 24-year-old had had her throat slashed and was aged into an old hag. This is also shared that like her death was meant as a warning to her father, who had enemies. One did not exploit the witches without consequences.

Doesn't really get into like how he may have been exploiting witches or anything like that, but it does kind of give us a information on how witches interact with the world around them. Lou and Coco are disguised as men. We learned that Coco has rich brown skin and she has scars, but she's on her hands, but she's hiding them and dark black eyes. I, so this time I had a note about her being described as having rich brown skin and dark eyes.

The first time around, I pictured her to be like really white and pale. And I think that's because her name is Cosette, and I was just picturing Cosette from Les Mez. So I had to like readjust my mental framing of Coco to be not a pale white human. I had that impression of, so I had the pale whiteness of Lou, because one, I didn't pay attention to the little like breadcrumbs we get of what she looks like. And then her mom is described as looking like that sometimes. And I was like, oh, OK, she's a pasty white blonde person.

Got it. Pasty white person. Yeah, not accurate. Coco and Lou are meeting with a woman named Bebet, who has a lead on something they're interested in, but we don't know what at this time. We learned that Lou is short for Louise, and that Coco is short for Cosette. Coco and Bebet's scars have revealed their true nature. Basically, how do you guys want to pronounce this? Damn blanches is not correct. Damn blanches. Damn blanches.

Damn blanches. Damn blanches. They're white ladies, literally. Yeah, literally white ladies. Literally white ladies. The white whale witches. Great white whale. No, I'm repeating the joke. Sorry. God damn it. I knew it. I knew it would make you self-conscious. It's fine. I didn't want to say it. I made it self-conscious. I'm just going to be hyper aware of it, where I've never noticed it before. It's kind of like the time where we called out every time Desiree missed something because she didn't read the prologue. It's going to be this now. Yeah. No, but that was my favorite thing, though.

I'm upset that this one didn't have a prologue, so we could potentially do that again. I need there to be a prologue because the last time there was kind of a prologue, Des read it and ruined the joke. God damn it. Half. It was like four sentences. I know. Just so I can have nice things. So Coco will learn later on is not actually a white witch. It's going to not try to do the French. Coco is not a white witch. But it is implied basically that they can move throughout society undetected. Basically, they end up meeting up with Babette. She kind of like short changes them

on how much money they agreed upon for this interaction and this information and tries to get more money out of them. It's implied in this first part that Babette is a witch, too. Yes. I think you said the line, which is that the white witches can move through society virtually undetected. But Coco and Babette's scars reveal their true nature. So Coco and Babette are not white witches, but they are witches of some kind. Which is interesting because we find out that, I mean, this will be a little bit later, but we find out that the anti-witch crusades don't know

anything about these other witches. So like their scars shouldn't even reveal anything. Yeah. Other than women shouldn't be scarred, I guess, because dainty ladies. And it's kind of implied, too, that even though Babette is a witch, her employer, Madame Labelle, doesn't know. Because Coco and Lou are of the opinion that Madame Labelle would like gut them or sell them out to the authorities, essentially, if she knew. So I had the thought that, like, I wonder if the brothel is actually more of a haven than it

actually seems. And they're just kind of keeping up this air of secrecy. I have that same kind of thought as well. What they're paying Babette for is information, but specifically the opportunity to eavesdrop on a conversation between Madame and Eir Tremblay to get information on this thing that he potentially has. We find out that what they're looking for is a ring, is some sort of magic ring that takes them to the eyes and ears of the Bell Rose, which is a room with 12 portraits of famed courtesans of the past with peepholes in their eyes.

You have to be very quiet because it's not soundproof. So you can look through it. You can't speak very loudly. And I have this note because at one point Coco curses under her breath. And I'm like, is it soundproof or not? Because I feel like if these walls are paper thin, literally anything is going to be heard. And apparently it just wasn't. Yeah, so I had two thoughts. One, I did wonder how a not soundproof room would fly in a brothel.

And then also, how do you get to be one of the famed ladies of the night in one of these portraits? Because sign me up for that shit. And even Bobette is like, you'll see me here one day. I'm like, how do you get there? The other wish I had about this room. And you're going to get to this where it's kind of for security to watch people. But since it is a brothel, can people also rent that out for voyeurism tendencies? I think so.

I think it's voyeurism, for sure. But it would have to be a very specific, secretive clientele because I would imagine that you wouldn't have all of your clients to know about it. To know you're being watched, yeah. Yeah. But so before, as a part of this kind of like, they meet Bobette, they go, and they're about to watch or eavesdrop or whatever, I think it's Lou or maybe Coco, but I'm pretty sure it's Lou. She says this great line, I think, in her monologue that says, but the flames come first with the church, questions second.

It's a dangerous time to be female. And I loved how that set the tone for kind of the gender dynamics that are going to come out to play in this book. Lou has a lot of great one-liners. There's so many that they have highlighted as we go along. Yeah. Manic Pixie Dream Girl aside, she does have a lot of good ones. She's like those greatest feminist one-liners. Yeah. So as they're standing there, they are greeted in this room by Andre and Gru, who is basically two big dumb brutes who basically

are security for the brothel for Madame Lebel. They are hired basically whenever Madame is concerned that there might be some nonsense that might put her in a dangerous situation. It was bothered by this because now there's additional people who have the information that she's looking for this ring. Basically, as they're listening to this conversation, though, they're asking for a big sum of money. Madame Lebel basically says that only the king could acquire that much money and kind of like swindles him through conversation into like taking less so she can get it off his hands, lest he be found with it, because otherwise

he could be targeted again. She basically blackmails him into like, oh, that's such a nice extra daughter you have down there. It would be a shame if something happened to her. It would be a shame if someone were to lose her. Basically, he confesses that he doesn't have the ring on him, but she agrees to pick it up from him at dawn the next morning. At his house, which is where the ring is. Correct. So after this, I leave to go kind of figure out what they're going to do about this new information.

And they meet up with Bass, who is a friend slash kind of lover of Lou, hanging out at a sweet tooth who loves sticky buns, so they're eating that there. I love that the Patisserie owner has a thing for Lou in a different wig. And that he gives like she is able to get free sweets from this person because he's sweet on her. Also, his name is Pan, which is Spanish for bread. I know. So cute. It's also the god of like the pan, the god that

have whatever, the sater. Yeah, the god of something. Sorry, I got distracted. So she loves sticky buns, and they smell like cinnamon and vanilla. And it didn't occur to me until like three quarters through this book that she smells like cinnamon because she eats so many sticky buns. Because we'll meet the male lead, but he gives out my heart. She smells like cinnamon. And I, every time I was like, I want to smell like cinnamon. Like I don't find perfume that smells like cinnamon. And then eventually I was like, it's because she's just fucking eating cinnamon rolls all the damn time.

I mean, yeah, that is one way to look at it. But also, maybe like calls to like, maybe she just is a cinnamon bun. She's not a cinnamon bun. Can kill you. Will kill you. I have a big sweet tooth. I do not like sticky buns, though. They are too messy. The juice is not worth the squeeze on them. The juice is? I thought you were going somewhere else with that. I love sticky buns. I would like sticky buns more if they were done better.

Like my favorite sticky buns and don't come for me. But like the Pillsbury, Doughboy ones that come in the tube. Yes. And then you put it in the oven, right? But you can't wait for them to cool down. You have to eat them while they're warm. Yeah, and so kind of doughy. Yeah, because as soon as they get like room temperature, they turn into like rocks on the inside. And that's my problem with most sticky buns is like I want them to be warm and gooey all the way through. So until right now, talking about cinnamon buns, and I realize I just called her cinnamon bun,

I was picturing these as like hot cross buns, which are not cinnamon rolls. Not the same thing. No. I really like hot cross buns. So I love Easter time because public sells them, and that's the only affinity I have with Easter because hi, I'm an E.T. Easter. I don't think I've ever had hot cross buns. They're delicious. They're kind of like fluffy fruitcake with icing on top. They're a sweet bun, and then they're glazed with icing, and then they have the thick icing in a cross too. They're delicious, but if you get them, you have to heat them up. So I like Easter.

I like all Christian holidays, not because they are Christian, but because they were co-opted from pagan religions. Fuck yeah, they were. Easter is a starra, such as the case for Easter. And so you see a lot of cross, like, symbology in Christianity, but you also see it a lot in pagan times. So I love that hot cross buns. Like, all the Christians are like, oh my god, Jesus. And I'm like, sure, Jan. And that's the same with like the eggs and the lamps for birth when like, no, which is the starra for spring. OK, but also chickens don't lay eggs in the winter time.

So you know that spring is upon us when chickens start laying eggs again, and that's why it's a holiday. Right. Come on. Well, that's also why embolk is a thing, because it's like the lambing season. It's when lambs start to get born, when chickens start laying eggs again. That Tuesday? All of that shit. That Tuesday. That Tuesday. Humpty Monday. So sorry. They're so early in this book. So sorry. We are in chapter two. We're interested in someone who's looking for her, and that's why she wants a spring. And she has more to be found.

They decide to do a heist at Du Tremblay's house or mansion or home. Home. I'm going to go home, settling at home. Chateau, if you will. No. Yeah. Every time the word chateau came up, I like literally got like goosebumps in a terrible way. The sweats. The sweats. The cold sweats. Just like not again. Just repeating jokes. So there's two things in this conversation that I love. One, it's very clear that Baz is like so into Lou

and like wants to jump her bones. And I love that energy. The second one is we learn what this ring does. It's implied that it can make you invisible. And then Lou clarifies that actually it renders the wearer immune from enchantment. And we learn later that it can actually turn you invisible too. You just have to rather than wear it, which is the immunity thing. You put it in your mouth and it turns you invisible. Which seems like a choking hazard. Truly. Oh my gosh. I was concerned every time she put it in her mouth. And then what happens if you swallowed it? Are you just invisible forever?

Or you have to be like on your tongue. Like once it passes your tongue, are you like, hello, I'm here again? I have so many questions. I have so many questions. Getting there, chatting about what they're going to do with the heist. Oh, the reason you're doing the heist tonight is because there's a king's bald who welcomed home his son. The chausers are seen, the chausers are basically guards that are sworn to the church. So they're not really like, but they're like church cops.

They're church police. They're church police. I feel like they're like above constables too. They're like the FBI to like normal police. Yeah, but like these guys are set, they are meant to protect Belterra, which is the kind of place that they live in, from the occult. Namely the white witches. Yeah, they kind of seem like if the, oh, I don't think it was the Franciscan monks, but like the Spanish inquisition, whoever did that, they kind of seem like those people,

but in more modern times. Whoever did. Shut up, I'm going to look this up. Whoever, the expansion, yes. I don't know who did that. It was just funny. I mock you and I have no additional information. I wish that Wikipedia would do me a solid and not give me walls of text. They keep going. I'm going to keep going.

I'll do respect. We're just going to move on. Things are getting crowded and the chausers are starting to appear. Louisa just meeting up at the theater, kind of be safer. Louisa's it's fine. She's disguised as a man. It's fine. Calls out that Andre and Gru recognized her when she was dressed as a man, so they should probably go. So they agree to leave. Baz wants to pit pocket anyways. Crowds are great for finding money and stuff like that. As Lou is leaving, she runs into a man. Physically runs into him.

Face first. Also, he sounds like an asshole just standing in the doorway of this petition. Why is he the doorway? And he's a giant. Like she cannot move past him. Yeah. Basically, there's a big crowd watching the procession of the royals go by. And he's weeping because he sees the royals. And it's what a beautiful moment. And he's ridiculous. So she's trying to get him to move it in the process. Is he weeping? Is he weeping? There's a part where she, I don't know if it's this. I don't. Hang on.

I don't think he was weeping. So she tries to avoid a man who is weeping. That makes more sense. Yeah. OK. She sees a man who is weeping out more. I don't think he gives a shit. Ha ha ha. Move him. Shoves him. He turns. And like in the process of turning, hits her in the nose with his elbow and like knocks her down. What a clumsy barbarian. Barbarian is also a triggering word. I hate how many words are becoming triggering. Clumsy barbarian. Book 23. It's probably one of them.

God, probably. And that she's run into is a chouser. She knows that he's handsome. He has a bandolier of knives, which is like the standard issue for all chousers. And he has copper and gold hair. He knows that her mustache is starting to fall off. And so the chouser makes her as like, you're a woman. Why are you dressing like a man? And she's like, of course, it's her awful. Have you ever tried them? Don't. I'm not going to do this. She kind of makes a scene. She's like, you broke my ass bone. And like kind of like runs away because he's so offended

that she's speaking in such a way. Helm vulgar. So this, I just read this in Hermione's voice because like her mustache is a skew, like you said. And the line is he didn't move. You're a woman. Well spotted. And I just picture that like, hey Hermione, you're a girl. Well spotted. Well spotted. I love that line. I just loved it. We'll say that he asks her name and she just kind of runs of the crowd. Bye. And there's honestly a lot of that

left him asking questions or her just being like, bye. That's their entire relationship. Yeah. Yeah. So Lou like climbs up on top of a building and like watches the procession go by. This is when she says the thing about fruits, sausages, and cheese croissants. Why? Why? Shelby, big fan. Why? Why? Which is King August and his son Beauregard. Beauregard. Beauregard. Beauregard. I just want to feel it in my mouth. I'm sorry. I know. That's the thing.

That one was just a true like, I just want to feel how it sounds to say Beauregard. Listeners say Beauregard. You won't regret it. You won't regret it. It feels great. Beauregard. It does feel pretty good. It's like he looks very different from his father. The King has fair skin and light eyes. Beauregard has a nice skin, black hair like his mom. Mom looks real mad. And Lou says this thing like, I'll be damned before chaining myself to anyone in marriage. And I was like, if that's not some foreshadowing, I don't know what is. It's also implied that the King is a notorious philanderer.

And that's probably why the Queen doesn't look super pumped to be there. And that the sun doesn't match. Yeah. I mean, it's clear. She does say that their smiles are the same. And so it's clear that they are related. But that's probably why he doesn't look like his parents. Looks like his mom. Oh, that's right. He does not look like his dad. So as Lou is watching, she hears the low hum of magic, and then there's some screams. Immediately shift over to a new perspective.

And he starts with, wicked are the ways of women. Have a smell, sweet and herbal, but too sharp. Basically, he is the chouser that Lou ran into. Some of the chousers that are at this procession are in uniform. Others are not. Basically, he smells the magic. And then here's the screaming that Lou had heard. He starts trying to figure what's going on. I was just going to say that we get some information before what happens next with him on witches. And they are truly fucking terrifying.

Like, their victimology. Though I prayed the victims weren't dead, I often wondered whether death was the kind of fate. The less fortunate woke without memories of their second child, or perhaps with an insatiable appetite for human flesh. Last month, the child had been found without its eyes. Another man lost his ability to sleep. Yet another spent the rest of his days pining after a woman no one else could see. It's fucking terrifying. It is. And I still wonder this through the end of the book. I'm not sure why the witches terrorize innocent people

like that. Like, it's one thing to go after chousers or the king and his retinue. But it seems like they're just going after the weak and the vulnerable. And that was kind of the first indication to me that the witches are probably not so high and mighty, or their cause isn't completely innocent, or I guess a peer of heart, I'll say. So he takes his place next to the royal carriage,

and he notices three witches are gliding up the street, hair billowing. He's kind of falling all around them. This is where we learn that thing about, you know, they're dead or not. Death may be the easier one. He comes a wall and runs into Lou, who's watching the procession from up top. And she's like, yeah, and runs away. She's like, oh, fuck you again? Right. He looks over the crowd and happens to see an old hag approaching kind of alone. He wants to send out a blast of air, but basically the weapon that the chousers use is immune to it.

It hit the citizens in the guards and kind of made them fall over. The hag makes her way towards the prince, but Reed tackles her. She puts up a good fight. He's one, but she kind of shifts out of this young, or shifts out of this hag form into a young and beautiful woman. And Reed is like frozen. He's like, I don't know what to do. You're really pretty. I kind of want to bone you. She's pregnant. And he's like, he's like, I'm pregnancy and like runs away. He's like, this is the first kind of example

of how I'm fairly certain that chassers in particular, but most men in this story just have never met a woman before in their life. So what I can't figure out is whether or not she's really pretty. I want to bone her feeling. Was an enchantment used? Or whether or not he was just a horny boy. That's an interesting perspective, especially considering what we learn about him later in the book. And I wonder if he successfully navigated an enchantment.

That's more interesting to me than just like, woman, my pants are tight. Right. Yeah, I would prefer to see it as like an enchantment. Yeah. Than just bing. And then he notices she's pregnant. And then we be like, wow. The baby is not mine. See, when she when he jumps off, she's now standing and like blood red clothes as opposed to what she was wearing before. And she like yells at the royals that the witches will

reclaim the throne. She changes back into a hag. But before she does, she blows, read a kiss, and disappears into the smoke. Next up after this, Reid goes to meet up with the Archbishop. Reid feels humiliated because now there's two dead. Dozens are injured physiologically, and many would end up being transferred to the asylum. In the conversation with the Archbishop, he tells Reid that he did well. It could have been way worse. And he did so well that the king wants to hold a ball and reads honor, reads like, why? Like I did a bad job. I wanted to bone the witch.

Yeah. And more than that, he didn't kill any of the witches at all. Let her go. He's like, I don't know why he would be proud of me because I literally didn't do my job. The Archbishop is very insistent. He's like, let's not have false modesty. He proceeds to explain the information that the Chaucers have about witches, which is that this woman was considered the leader because it's in their religion. They have the hag, the mother, and the maiden. Her name is Morgan Leblanc.

And she's the head witch, as I call her, because I cannot be bothered to say her French name. And her French name is just like the magic lady. The magic leader of the pack. It is. But she's the only one that can embody all three. Like she can shape shift between the three. Yeah. She is the mother maiden crown, that triple goddess. Right. Correct. But my favorite line, because this book continues to be kind of like a patriarchy vibe,

an embodiment of femininity and the cycle of birth, life, and death, among other things, is blasphemous, of course, as if God could be a woman. My note is literally like, I rolled to the patriarchy. Yeah, truly. Go fuck yourself, grandpa. Fuck yourself, Archie. But so this conversation was interesting to me. So full disclosure, listeners, we read this book before we started recording our discussions about books. And then we went back and reread it to talk about it today with you.

But reading it a second time and knowing what happens, if that was Morganne, Morganne, Morganne, if that was the queen bee, that's very interesting in the context of who all these characters are. They were very close together. And the whole rest of the story and where we think Morganne is. Yes, or isn't. Exactly. So basically, like Liz mentioned, Reed didn't really want to move away from the witch, wanted to bone her. Archbishop basically says, Reed, go confess.

And if you can't let it go, we'll just marry you off. Right. And Reed is deeply offended. Like his moral fiber has been questioned. Also, Archbishop mentions that Reed has previous transgressions. So speaking of marriage, do you guys want to talk about what the, does anyone want to take the explanation for what it means to be married or how they can get married versus celibacy, that sort of thing? I think it's pretty straightforward, right? That the chasers started as being a celibate army,

kind of like an extension of the priesthood. But they quote this Bible verse that basically they use to justify, like if they really, truly can't get it together and keep it in their pants, they can get married. But it's very recent and not done. They mentioned this guy who we never see. He's just kind of off-camera person who was a chaucer and then got married and then left the order soon thereafter. So it's kind of shameful in some way. And I think it kind of ties into,

are you guys familiar with, I think it's like Greco-Roman stoicism? Yeah. Yeah. Like it's very similar to that. It's like, oh, you're not a man if you can't control your base or instincts, like that kind of thing. And they're like loophole. Yes, you can get married. Their quote is, if they cannot control themselves, let them marry. It is better to marry than to burn with passion. Oh, is that really a quote from Peter and the Bible? Is it early in the Bible? So it is in the, first Corinthians is, I think,

in the New Testament. It's first Corinthians seven. And now to all the unmarried and widows. I say it is good for them to stay unmarried as I am. But if they cannot control themselves, they should marry for it is better for them to marry than to burn with passion. So it's interesting that he was talking about widows. Yes. And the unmarried priests. And not men specifically. We do learn also that Reed had affection or has affection for Cele Trumbule, which is the other daughter of Pierre

Trumbule that we learned about earlier. Yeah. Reed also thinks that he will never marry, which again, I just call that was foreshadowing. Well, and we get some background that Reed wanted to marry Cele and was OK with. We get that right here in the memory. You cannot give me your heart, Reed. I cannot have it on my conscience. Those monsters who murdered Pippercase out there, they must be punished. I will not distract you from your purpose. If you must give away your heart, give it to your brotherhood. Please forget me. I read it a little bit differently.

It could have been that he turned her down at this point. Because the start of that conversation could have been him saying, I can't love you the way that you want me to. Right. I could say that. Thank you. Those were the words I needed. In the context of his internal monologue, though, he very much sees it as a rejection. But he never cops to that in front of anybody else. So it's really just the best kept secret between himself and Cele. But it is very out of context.

We don't get a whole lot of information about what their courtship was like, why things ended it, or why whoever ended it, nothing like that. But it's not a secret that he was courting her to his other bandmates or whatever. Bandmates. You know, Mary Band of Robbers or something. Yes. Church police. So the Archbishop is about to go to the ball for the prince, and he's interrupted by Ansel, who is a young, younger trouser in training.

Ansel is perfect. He is the best. He is my favorite. He's just a little cinnamon roll. Can't kill you. He's what I want my son to be if I ever have a son. Yes. He brings a letter to the Archbishop that basically says that there is a witch report in West End near Brindell Park, which is kind of weird, near Trumblay's house. The report came from a beautiful woman with bright red hair, which we can intuit from what we've learned as that's Bebe.

Madame LaBelle. Right, Bebe? Madame LaBelle. OK. I was not sure which one it was. We can intuit is Madame LaBelle. Basically, he, so Archbishop sends Reed and says that he wants the witch brought back alive, which is against the rules. I don't know if it's against the rules, but it's definitely out of character, because usually they kill them on the spot and then just burn them. But it is against the rules, according to Reed's inner monologue. He says he's willing to break the rules for the Archbishop because he trusts him.

And so whatever will bring his mind to his ease based off of the worry that he saw from that letter, he's happy to do. Which just now, in this moment, I realize why he was so worried. Yeah, no, Reedy, at the second time, I was like, oh, she's good. She's really good. Yeah. One more thing before we move on. One of the things in this conversation that immediately made me hate Archie, the Archbishop, I'm going to call him Archie for the remainder of this episode, Archie slash the Archbishop slash AB,

he, like, I love how the author just leans into the Catholic, like, hypocrisy here, because the Archbishop is described as being, like, nicely dressed. He's in a nice study. And then he's like, oh, well, if you don't want to go to the ball that's in your honor, I guess I will. Even though it's a sin, right? Oh, what was me? And I'm just like, OK, dude, like. He does it quite a few times, like going to see the bat. And he was like, I'll go see the revelry in a minute.

But like, OK, OK, dude. Yeah. Yeah, I'm sure that's such a hardship on you. Yeah. The Lou's perspectives are preparing for the heist. Basically, they're getting in costumes. And Coco provides some information using blood magic, which is what type of, which is the type of witch that she is. She sees that something is waiting for Lou there, but she cannot see what. I think it's really cool how she can, like, tell futures or, like, fortunes from, like, people's blood. I really, I like that aspect of her magic.

Yeah, it's really cool. Yeah. So they go to the house. And they realize that there's several things that they need to get through to get into the house. The first are dogs. Coco uses a sedative on the dogs. And one thing that was really cute is Lou makes her to confirm that it won't kill the dogs. It's just going to knock them out, which I really appreciated. I do, too. I know. No dead dogs, please. No dead dogs. Then Lou uses her magic to break a lock. But we learned that magic has a price. So she has to choose between either breaking a bone or her relationship because nature demands balance.

Also, that seems like a lot to me. It's like magic was like, oh, you could sacrifice an entire relationship for this one lock. I was like, girl, that's, wow, that price is high. So I really liked how much information we got on the, like, laws and rules of magic throughout this book. But a lot of them do seem high. But I like that there's a cost. And we get that. I mean, we've mentioned before that the three of us are writers and as someone who's trying to devise a magic

system, it's really fucking hard. And I'm just like, yo, Shelves, can I take some inspiration from this? But I agree. Like, you could give up your whole relationship for this padlock. I know. Well, and I think that had something to do with, I mean, we'll learn later. Like, it's not spoiling anything in this scene. She'll talk about how she's repressed her magic for so long. And so I wonder how much of that specific offering that magic gave her that had to do with the fact that she was out of practice, right?

Like, she, because it is described as being somewhat subjective later in the book. And if she's not practiced, then magic's just going to be like, this is the simplest thing. Sacrifice one of your friends for one of those locks. Like, that's done. Also, kind of like, to that point, you just triggered, like, prove your worth. Like, you haven't been using me. So how bad do you want this? That's a really good point. I didn't think about that. That's a good point. She was going to sacrifice a relationship. But that was the last minute she decided to break her finger. Which, ow, I'm not sure I could do that. I don't think I could break my own finger. Hi, yay, yay. She, so she does that.

She breaks a lock. Is going to handle the three guards who are inside with his knife skills. And Lou will handle the three guards who are outside. She enchants them and then knocks them out. The price here is a night with that. So that's right, she has- Just give them memories for their memories. I like the idea of giving up individual memories. I thought that was good. Yes, I love that. And I really had the question of, like, how many other memories have you lost? Yeah. And it makes me wonder, kind of, throughout the book, like, what don't you know? Because there are some, almost like, it's not clear,

but some, like, allusions to things that, like, she just can't remember. It makes me wonder. Yeah. The inside, basically, Baz finds the safe. And there's another lock. And rather than having Baz pick it, he makes her do it. So she breaks another finger to be able to get into there. But they do find the ring. Yep. They find the ring. She's super excited. But right as they find it, the chausers show up. And so Baz looks at her and goes, can you get us out?

And she goes, no. And he's like, all right, bye. And, like, takes off. What an ass. I was, like, I mean, so she kind of alluded to the fact that he was a coward before. Like, in the patisserie scene, she said, something to the effect of, I knew that he could never protect me. Maybe that's why I stopped loving him. And so she kind of alluded to the fact that she didn't trust him. He couldn't actually do anything for her in that way. But it's still stung when he was just like, all right, peace. You're on your own. If you're going to get out, can't you just take me with you?

Yeah. And it was like, as soon as she couldn't serve him to save him, it was like, well, bye. Yeah. Yeah. So we switch back to Reed's perspective. And he and the other chausers are arriving. And Madame Lebel is there checking on one of the guards, as well as the Tremblay's. They're also there. He wants to go over and comfort Sealy, but basically he has to do his job. You know, pesky things like jobs. Madame Lebel informs the group that they don't remember

anything. Like, the guards are waking up and they don't remember anything at all. I'm Tremblay. So this is just a thief, not a witch. And they're like, it smells like magic. And she's like, it's the trees. We love the view, but it smells like magic all the time. Don't worry, just a thief. And I was like, I am not as concerned as you should be, but the fact that there was a thief in your home. Like, she's so preoccupied with making sure that everyone knows it's not a witch that no one's really focusing on the fact that there is still a thief at large in their home. I think there was big denial vibes there, too,

because she was like, this can't possibly be happening to me again, because of what happened to their daughter. But one note about the trees. The trees that she's referencing are called Brindle trees. And Lou and her internal monologue talks about how this grove was magical. And before the city was settled, it was a sacred place for witches. And then when the city was settled, they tried to cut the trees down. But the very next day, there was another forest there. And I just love the snark that is inherent to these trees. They're just like, no, fuck you. We lived here first. We're going to be stanky.

You can chill. We're going to smell like magic. And you're going to live here anyway. So I did with it. They are snarky trees. Yeah. But also in this, we meet Jean-Luc. So Jean-Luc is like Reed's deputy. And he seems like kind of a dick. Yeah. He's such a dick. Hi. If nothing else, he's insolent. And he's a whiny little bitch. He's a whiny little. He just struck me as like big incel vibes. Yes. Also like Jean-Luc, you can get married, you know? We just talked about that rule. You could just go do that. It's fine.

You have fuck bitches get hoes. They're sitting there talking and like happened to look up at the house. And they see two faces just staring back at them. And Reed sort of recognizes one of the faces. It's Lou. Can't really place her. But Reed immediately goes, oh, she's not a witch. I ran into her earlier today. And Jean-Luc's like, what does that have to do with literally anything? What? And so they stand around talking for a while about whether or not running into her earlier could

or could not be a witch. And I'm like, guys. She's still a thief. Yeah. Right? She's a break-in entering. You got to do something about it. No. It's fine. Kind of take off and go separate ways to go and try to get them. Jean-Luc captures Bass. And Bass, like the true asshole that he is, shouts for Lou, just shouting her name into the wood, trying to get her attention. I hate it so much. Like, what a coward. I mean, it was purely from like, no. Because he was asking for Lou's help. He was like, help me, right?

He wasn't trying to warn her that they were coming for her. No. He's such an ass. Right. Yeah. Because he's calling out for her, Reed happens to notice that Lou is climbing and having trouble climbing because something's going on with her hands. Because her fingers are broken. Right. And so they have this moment where like, he sends some people up after her and she's out climbing them despite having problems with her hands. And as she's about to disappear, she looks at Reed, salutes him, and then keeps climbing, and then disappears. She doesn't like, it's not that she's like there

and they see her disappear. It's that like, they just can't find her. Like, she scurries over the roof, they lose sight of her, and then they never find her. It's like, trying to catch smoke. It's like, trying to catch smoke with your bad hands. Does anybody know where that's from? OK. No. It's from the third Harry Potter movie. The third Harry Potter movie. Oh, yep. The poor kid has like, one line, but it's a great line. It's a great line. He's so earnest. My bare hands. So some other people found Coco, but she managed to get away

from them, Lou escapes. Baz also escapes. It seems like amateur hour in a big way. That's just like the fucking Amityville police or something. I don't know, like two town over here, just like, they can't keep, they can't do it right. They had Lou, they had, sorry, they had Baz. And then Coco. Right, like, and what happened? It's unclear. Like, somehow they just get away. Sorry, I was going to say, like Coco, they like corner her in a kitchen and they're like, well, where is she? We don't know. Like, no. She was, what?

And with Baz, like they had him tied up on the ground and it's like. He just like, rubs away. How did you fuck that up? And then later, the thing that pisses me off is like, somehow this is all Reed's fault. And I'm like, Jean, look, you were fucking there. Right. Like you went 12 other motherfuckers and you had two of them dead to rights and you couldn't make it stick. Like, I don't understand. And they clearly tied Baz up and then immediately all turned their backs on him to be like, God, his feet out of the ropes and just scurried away. I'm sorry. I realized that in the day and age of non-television

and no phones, like excitement is hard to come by. But one of you has to do your job. Watch the prisoner. Low man on the totem pole. Like, I don't fucking care who it is. Like, watch eyes on the prisoner the entire time. Like, it's not hard. At least like in your periphery, like. He's just behind them. Better yet, position yourself so you're behind the prisoner so you're watching the excitement and the prisoner at once. It's multitasking. And then he has to get past you to escape. No. And I think when he gets up to run away, I don't know if it's Jean-Luc or Ansel, but someone just like gesturing to him or running away.

I don't know how that happened. What do I do? He escapes by putting the ring in her mouth, which does turn her invisible. But you can still hear her if she's moving around. So she has to still be very careful as she climbed down and around and moved around people so they wouldn't hear her. It's far enough away. And she like takes the ring out of her mouth and immediately bumps into Coco. And I'm like, I, how big is this town? I don't shit. I wanted to interpret that more as like Coco's a sneaky bitch. And like she somehow saw her.

Yeah. Like invisibly. Oh yeah. Well, what's her like, mad blood magic? Well, she had read her blood earlier. So I imagine it was. Yeah. In my head, she could see her scent, right? Well, and she kind of alludes to like, once she tastes their magic, she can use it to like track them but can also kill them from within. Like because she threatens Baz with that. So I do wonder if she can like sniffer out because she has eyes on you. Yeah. Because she like, so Lou like ducks down in alleyway, like a random alleyway. And she takes off the ring and Coco's like, hey girl.

Just out of the darkness. Which is style. I love Coco, because first and foremost, she's stylish. She's so stylish. And she has like so much chill. Yes. She just like. Yes. So the ring that they sold or the ring that she was after and now has is called Angelica's Ring. The story for the ring is that of lonely which fell in love with a knight. He died and her tears flooded the land and made like a. Sorry, Lake. It's like, I think it's called like the melancholy lake. Like it's just.

On the nose. Yeah. When Coco finds her, Lou says, oh my gosh. I think I think I lost them. And Coco has this line that says they're far too busy looking for you to actually find you. Which is brilliant. Which I love. Because they are. Their heads are up their ass. So when they're reconvening, she sends Coco away because Coco was seen. Like her face was looked at. And she has no sort of protection. Coco invites Lou to go with her, to stay with her aunt for protection. And Lou says, no, absolutely not. Like, you're on as a blood witch.

Like they hate the way witches. I would not be safe there. So she sends Coco away and returns to her theater, which is where she's staying in the attic of this theater. And also, I like that she was staying in the rafters. Like, because it's like. It's very Phantom of the Opera, which is why I liked it. Because it was like, you know, theater is basically a hollow egg. And then there's like an air gap that people can like go and move around in and like store stuff in and move lights and stuff. And that's where she lives. And I just love that.

And costumes and stuff. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I will say when she's laying there, she says this kind of shitty thing, which is like, Coco and Baz abandoned me first chance they got. And I'm like, no, no, no. Baz, yes. Coco did not abandon you. Coco had your back. Coco stuck to the plan. And then she found you afterwards to make sure that you were chill. Like with like no fear for herself. Yeah. Go to Reed's perspective. He's training in the yard, feeling bad for himself with John Luke. There's shit talking. John Luke kind of like giving him a hard time.

And Reed makes a point to mention that they used to have mutual respect, but not now. Seems like John Luke is jealous of Reed and who Reed has become. John Luke gives him a hard time about disappointing Sealy and the Archbishop. And Reed gets so upset that he starts counting to 10 to kind of calm himself down and remind himself that he's in control. The Archbishop arrives in the training area and tells Reed that he's going to see a play with him, even though the theater is a devil, because this is required by the king to please a foreign dignitary.

And Reed feels that John Luke's jealousy as he leaves. Yes. OK, so one one minor thing that we forgot to talk about before Lou gets back to the theater and after she talks to Coco, Coco like leaves and they say their goodbyes. But then Lou gets attacked by Gru and Andre. So the bouncers. Oh, right. Yeah. The brothel. And they want the ring, essentially, because they heard the same shit that Lou did, Lou and Coco. And they try to overpower her. But Lou has some kind of episode where she pictures herself

with her own neck being sliced open over a basin to catch her blood. And she like flips out and overpowers them, like kicks him in the nuts, punches them at punches their nose and like gouges their eyes. But she's like beat up after this. So she's got like her nose is like all fucked up. She's got like two black eyes. She's got broken fingers like she looks rough. And so that's the state that she crawls back into her like humble abode. And she's just like, kill me. I mean, at least I have this ring.

I guess covered in blood lost my friends. And that's important because as we flip back to Lou, she wakes up and realizes that there is a performance going on, but she really has to pee. So she dresses up as best she can and was like had to kind of like cover her face and like makes her way to the toilets. But she gets spotted by actors who are like, girl, are you OK? And she's like, yeah, I'm fine. They're like, I don't know that you're OK. And she's like, no, I'm fine. I just I lost the toilets. Where are they? I love that that interaction. So like the the actor is like, you're not supposed to be back there.

And then they see her face and they go from annoyed to concern, like in no time flat. Immediately. Theater people are the best people. They are. Just going to call it a percent. I love that because they were like, because they were just like, oh, my God. What? And then they continue to be very helpful as we will see. Yes, absolutely. And so they're not. Yeah. Four shadow. She makes her way to the bathroom. They kind of like let her go, but are very suspicious. On her way back, she accidentally makes eye contact with Reed. Who goes you?

And she's like, yeah. And like they're trying to run away. She makes her way backstage, trying to get away from him. And he starts trying to tackle her and like does successfully. But they like end up rolling out on stage in the like, I guess in the middle of the performance and the audience is like, what is going on? Yes, she's like, you. It was like. But he like rips the front of her dress and she's like reaching out to this actor that like asked if she was OK. She's like, please help me. And the actor is just like the fuck. Is I can't.

I feel like it's kind of set up to the crowd that like this woman is being assaulted like on stage. Oh, yes. Not OK. So like as as the altercation kind of stops, the actor who kind of asked her if she was OK, like tries to like put some like cloth around her since her dress was ripped and is like, we will all give our statement like he he should be in jail for what he's done. And they all kind of like agree, but they all recognize that he's a chaser.

So he's probably going to be fine. They don't really say this, but like she's seen by everybody in the audience, but somewhere between like the five minutes that they burst onto the scene and then like the aftermath happening like the audience is just gone. It's like cleared out of the auditorium. Just like nothing to see here. Goodbye. Shows canceled. Like get out. But also they they crowd later. They crowd like in the lobby or whatever, trying to figure out what happens. Scandal, which is. Scandal, but so Lou is about to put the ring in her mouth

and like make a break for us. You're standing there, but the Archbishop shows up. Archie B. He calls her a thief and says that he knows that the other one is a witch. The other one being Coco. So they they know that she's the one from last night. Yes, correct. Lou is really funny. She mentions he says like we know that the other one you're with is a witch. And she's like. He asks how and then goes, how is she a witch? And when a witch and a man love each other very much. I love that.

She's so she's so snotty and I love it. Archbishop is informed that there's large crowds he can the fate of the girl and Chaucer. For some reason, this predicament means that Reed would have to resign. Otherwise, the Archbishop's holiness and Chaucer's like honorability would be questioned as a whole. And I I get where they're going, but it's such like a stupid bullshit thing. Like it's such a leap off of a cliff. It's such a leap off a cliff. Like I just but I think that's the point.

Like I think the Archbishop has his own motives and he knows that Reed adores him. And so he's cajoling both of these people into what he wants to happen. I think that if he absolutely wanted to, he could forsake Reed and like throw them both in prison, right? But that's not what he wants to do. So what he decides, what he decides to do is that they will both be married, of course, because if they're married, Reed can do whatever she whatever he wants to this woman because it's OK, this is property and the implication that like you can punish her.

So her black eyes are just part of the course. Yep. So importantly, in this exchange, when Lou says that snarky line about, well, when a man and a woman we actually love each other very much, the Arch Archie A B Archie smacks her across the face and is like, silence, you will not be like insolent in my presence or whatever. And so he proposes this thing and I don't remember what Lou said. Oh, Lou didn't say anything.

She's just so upset that she vomits onto the Archbishop and he moves to like strike her again and Reed is just like he grabs like the Archbishop's arm and prevents him from doing so. And he's like, if this woman is supposed to be my wife, you're not going to touch her like that. And I was like, oh, my God, I lived. Oh, my God, it was same. It was giving because she didn't even say yes yet. No, and it was already like they protect her man.

So Lou ultimately decides to do so for her own self interest and protection. Next thing we have is the ceremony from Reed's or next we move to Reed's perspective. They are walking because she has to be baptized before they get married. So they're walking to do that. And he doesn't like how broken Lou looks like her face is all busted and things like that. It upsets him. Pause. First, it's the fart attack. The fart attack. The fart attack. So they're walking to address the crowd because like this has caused a kerfuffle.

And like people in the audience are irate that this man has attacked this woman so publicly and like they're demanding retribution. So Archie's position is we have to go like placate them and like tell them that you guys are married. It's fine because you're married. It's fine that you're beating a woman and it's not just a random woman. Right. So that circumstance aside, Reed's section starts off with this couple of lines that I love. They're walking and he says blood roared in my ears.

It drowned out every other sound but not her footsteps. I heard every one of those. And I just, oh, the Mr. Darcy hand clenched like all day long, man. It was so good. Yeah. This is definitely another one of those books where we have like a lot of male restraint. It's done so well. It is. It really is. But fart attack. Importantly. So basically he, as they're walking, he also remembers Sealy, wants him to give his heart to basically the church to try and catch the people who killed her sister.

He announces to the people that they are married and that they're making their way to get her baptized. And that's when Derek Grisha gets the fart attack, laughs, and when this happens, Reed leans over and like smells her to see if like it's magic and smells, he finds that she smells like cinnamon, not magic. It's heavily implied that the stage hand that helped Lou incited the fart attack. Which I didn't get that until later, honestly.

Oh really? I thought it was like throwing daggers. Throwing daggers. I thought it was Lou and I was like, how should I smell the magic? Also, what's the trade for a fart attack? Probably peeing your pants. I don't know. I just have lots of questions about that. It's just my favorite part because, but because I'm sorry, it's a fair part because Archie B is like all flustered and Reed is like, can I help you? He's like, go, I'll meet you at the river. It just makes me happy.

And then makes them walk while he takes his fucking carriage. I'm right. God. I hate it. Reed tells her as they're walking to get baptized that she will obey him. She asked if that means that he will protect her and he says, yes, it's good because she's got a lot of enemies. I love this like thing that she keeps coming back to. She's like, yeah, I'm kind of a popular woman, right? Right? Like a lot of enemies. And every time she's described as saying it with like totally a deadpan expression.

And I just, I love the self-awareness where she's just like, yeah, this is a great, great offer. This is a great arrangement for me. This is actually really working out because people want me dead. So yeah. And you have that big fancy sword. So they arrive and they meet the Archbishop and John Luke is also there because he's going to be a witness for the ceremony. Kind of wishes that wasn't the case, but that's fine because he understands why he's there. It's his best friend. As he's standing there kind of having that thought, the baptism is taking place and he realizes that the Archbishop is holding her under for

a little bit too long and lunges after her. And as does John Luke, but right as like they're getting to him, the Archbishop kind of pulls her up and Lou is deservedly very angry and like cusses him out and like is trying to get at him and like very mad because she realizes that he was trying to kill her. Was he trying to kill her? I don't understand his motives for like this whole book. Yeah. So he says something like he just needed a little extra time to purge the demons from her

soul or something like that. So filthy. Yeah. And I believe that. I believe that's what he was trying to do. So they get married. So we are moving into part two or so we have another proverb and it's little by little, the bird makes its nest, which I also really liked. I also really like how the Proverbs and I'm sure this was intentional. They really are on theme for the parts. So like the first one, misfortune never arrives alone. Yes.

And then little by little, you build a nest. Like this is a very like sit and wait and learn chapter or part. So I like that. So they arrive at the cathedral or they arrive at like the the cathedral. They arrive at the tower. It's a tower. They arrive at the place where they live. It's connected to the cathedral. Yeah. It's like a church and a barrack situation. Yeah. It's really weird. Is it on the map? Yeah. It's on the map. It is. What shape is it? So it doesn't point out the tower.

It's just the cathedral. Saint Cecile desa saviens. Great. Yeah. So I think it's just part of the cathedral. So they arrive back at the tower slash cathedral where they live or going to live and they have some great banter between them. So she says they they I don't remember what somebody says to her, but oh I think the I think Archie B calls her a heathen and she says how dare you. I am a god fearing Christian woman now.

She's just really love that energy. Wonderful. What I love about that though is like read like that happens and reasonably like I'm just gonna and like takes her by the arm and like drags her out. He's just like nope not today. Not today Satan. No. So after they sign the marriage doc, which is what they were doing before when they had some good banter, she's led to the Chaucer Tower. Lou notes that feels like it lacks warmth. They arrive in Reed's room and it's tiny, simple, no trinkets or books. Bed is like a twin, a twin bed.

Also as they're entering the tower, it's really predominantly printed. The thou shalt not suffer a witch to live that she has to walk under because that's where she lives now. And that there is upstairs that she is foreboding of to going. I didn't even bother writing that down on my notes because I knew immediately she was just gonna go there. Also it kind of feels like keeping your piano in the top of the girl's dormitory. Nothing feels like that. Maybe find a better place. I don't know. Oh, real. It's also really pushed by RGB that they must consummate the marriage and that it will be

checked later. Which is kind of presumptuous. Like you don't know if she's a virgin. And she's not. Plot twist. Also even if she was, I have problems with the consummation thing. Also not everybody bleeds. Thank you. That's what I was gonna say. That's the thing. Especially if you're athletic, like you're much more likely to break your hymen playing sports than you are to actually having sex or using a tampon. Like I didn't my first time. I didn't believe it was not athletic.

I didn't. I didn't. I was athletic. You've yeah. Fucking athlete. I don't know how much like swimming broke my hymen though. That seems kind of gross. Those are kicks, man. Those are kicks. Not to be confused with scissor rig. No, different thing. I mean, you know, you know, you know, you know, you know, you know, you know, you know, different thing. I mean, similar abdominals, I guess. I'm gonna stop. So Lou says this, no, Reed says this thing. Like I didn't know you were gonna frame me and Lou looks at me and goes, I'm a criminal. I behaved criminally. Like what do you expect?

Right. So to consummate, she cuts her arm and puts blood on the bed and because she's like, I will not allow you to force yourself on me. And he's like, yeah, I wasn't gonna do that though. Like I really wasn't gonna touch you at all. Right. Neither of us want this. Right. So he makes her take off her bloody dress and she's like, I don't have any other clothes. And he's like, that's not my problem. That sounds like a you problem. Right. Very much. He offers her like a shirt to have and he's like, someone will bring you an eye gown later.

Basically, like that never happens because the places aren't open. So she's just hanging around on a shirt and her underwear. Well, so it's so he says that a maid will bring her an eye gown, but the maid comes to check the sheets and she's like, my husband said you might bring me an eye gown and the woman was like, yeah, go fuck yourself. And it's implied that like she was like, oh yeah, why would I expect a warm welcome here? But like that's the only instance of rudeness from the staff and one of the only instances where she interacts with the staff and I just I wanted that to be a little bit more fleshed out.

I wanted them to be a little bit more hostile. Yeah, or just have more interactions with like maids and females in general because like we never really see a maid again at all. There's like a handful of other females in the story and then it's just like a bunch of dicks. By dicks, I mean people who have penises. They could be nice. In the room there is a is a tall window. I'm surrounded also finds this journal. Oh, she snoops. Question. Is it is it a journal and love letters? I didn't understand that. I pictured a journal with like letters shoved into it. I also thought it was a journal and I got kind of frustrated because she kind of gives

him a hard time about journaling and I was like, how dare you journal is great. I was confused about that. But when he comes and when Reed comes back, he finds her in the tub. She doesn't want to sleep in the bed with him. He offers to let her have the beds and he'll just sleep on the floor. But she's staying in the tub. You find a leader that Reed insists on staying on the floor just in case she wakes up and changes her mind. What's her mind doing? She realizes through this conversation that she locked the door and he still got in and he just smiles at her and he's like,

and she's like, oh, should I find him a track? Yeah, he's like, you're not the only one that knows how to pick a lock and she's just like, wait, what? Yeah, that's kind of hot. Reed tells, so she basically like kind of should talk to the Archbishop and Reed says not to disrespect him. He also tells her in this conversation that the expectation that he has is that she's going to stay in the tower because she's basically a liability and that goes over about as well as you can expect. Yeah. This is also where we get their like first real interaction of how much Reed hates it when

she cusses and how much she cusses just to rile him. Which I mean, how could you not? I would do the same thing like, but it's God, woman, how can you speak so have you no shame? And then she essentially at some point, I don't know if it's now or somewhat later in the book, but she essentially goes into like, fuck shit, piss, goddamn Christ tell and he's just like, God, my ears. Can't cannot handle it. So Reed wakes up next morning, wakes up on the floor, he has a bit of a rough training session. Basically the whole yard is like giving him a hard time about getting married.

One person says that he heard that she was a whore. He hits that guy. Yeah. John Luke says that they need to interrogate her about the Tremblay's and the Archbishop has also said this. Reed sent out a letter in the night to Sealy, basically letting her know what happened. But through the conversation he had with John Luke, he says that Reed chose not to marry Sealy. It's unclear whether or not that is the case or not. The Archbishop wanders, sorry, the Archbishop wanders in confirming that Reed is going to

ask her questions slash interrogate her. So Reed goes to find her, can't find her in the room, the washroom, the tower, the cathedral. So he waits for her and starts reciting verses just to try and stay calm. But as he's doing it, he's also reflecting on her injuries and thinks that maybe she is just gone for good and won't come back. As he's kind of having that thought, she returns from shopping. She went to buy clothing. She returns wearing super tight form fitting pants and this is very sinful in Reed's eyes,

but he is also having a hard time like keeping his eyes off her. He finds it like hot, but also won't admit that he finds it hot. And she's like intentionally tormenting, like laying on the bed, flipping her legs around, like showing her legs in her butt. He asks why she bothered to come back at all and she replies, I have many enemies. Again, can confirm, a lot of enemies. He tells her to go change so she can go answer questions. She says no. Nope. She says I'd rather not. Yep.

She does agree eventually to go get questioned, but so they head down into the, I don't know what it's called, but it's like the command center. That's super not the right word. Kind of the command center yet. The council chambers. The council chambers, that's it. She didn't change so all of Reed's brothers are staring and he's just like, God stop. Again, haven't seen a woman. Have not seen their legs for sure. So basically Jean-Luc wants her to help them find the head lady of the witches or the white

witches. He asks a lot of questions and questions and Lou avoids every single one of them in one way or another. So Reed kind of has this moment where he's like, I should figure out who her enemies are because her enemies might know who the witch that was with her. And so he asks for a list of her enemies and she names Lou and Andreth of people who beat her up. Oh, sorry. Lou names Andre and Grew, the people who beat her up as well as Madame Lebel for trying to lure her in as a courtesan. I do like how she's like, oh yeah, my enemies.

Here's the list. This person and this person and oh, don't forget this person. Oh, and she's kind of a bit, she was mean to me one time. So hard to. But I also don't really understand their like the Chaucer's perspective of just like, yeah, I'm going to take you at your word. Like these people are totally fine. Like you could have been handing over like a patisserie, like Pan from the patisserie. Yeah. Yeah. You don't, they do trust her for no reason. Lou gives like a very abbreviated version of the night's events just to kind of saciate them.

And afterwards they go back to Reed's room and Reed assigns her a chaperone. It's Ansel. That really cute younger Chaucer in training that we met earlier. So I have a question. So we learned that Ansel is 16 and they talk about him being like really young, but how old are the rest of them? I don't think we know how old. I tried to calculate because like there's some illusion to like some time frame of Reed. And I got that he was 19, but that didn't seem to fit how he like acted in his position.

And I was just confused because they talk about how Ansel is like so very young compared to them. And I just, I wanted to know how old everyone else was. Lou was 18. Okay. Lou was 18. Oh yeah. Cause it's been two years and she was 16 when her problem fell. Her problems. Yeah. Her problems. So when they get back to the room, it reveals that she read all of Celie's and Reed's letters as well as his journal. Reed leaves very mad mad and sends it. And so literally breaks down the bathroom door.

Like he punches a hole through the door to get his journal back. And she is not the least bit phase. She's just like, well, you broke your door. That seems like a you problem. Through the conversation with Ansel, she finds out that Reed's last name or that Ansel's last name is also Dickery, which is apparently a name that's given to orphans. We learned that Lou has a mother who hates her. She, so she's trying to get Ansel to take her on a tour of the place. And so basically she figures out that she makes him uncomfortable enough.

He'll kind of do whatever. So she starts singing Big Titty Litty. Does anyone want to read Big Titty Litty? I would read Big Titty Litty, but I gotta find it. Okay, hold on. Big Titty Litty was not very pretty, but her bosom was big as a barn. Her creamery knockers drove the men off their rockers. But she was blind to their charms. And Ansel says, stop, stop. It's a pub song. And I think she continues. No, she moves into a new one. Big Willy Billy talked sort of silly, but his knob was as long as his. And Ansel panics because none of them have heard any words like this before.

Right. So she says it's a pub song. Ansel's like, you've been to a pub, but you're a woman. And she's like, oh my gosh. Just like, you sweet summer child. Yes, women don't like to drink. So she annoys him with more raunchy pub songs until he agrees to take her on a tour. They go on a tour and Lou quickly realizes Ansel is very smart and he knows a lot. But man, he has a lot of details and none of them are about the things that she's interested in. Kind of bow ring.

So they go around for a little while and then they end the tour for dinner with the promise of continuing tomorrow. The next day, Reed left when Ansel showed up and she got the rest of her wardrobe. Lou asks to see the tower. Ansel says no. So she just runs up the stairs. As soon as she gets out there, she can feel magic. Ansel tackles her and they're found by an older man. Right as they're kind of being confronted about like, why are you here? And like, what's going on? Coco shows up, but she's kind of disguised. And she disguises someone who her name is Brie Perot.

She kind of intervenes and she says they're here for me. Louise is here to help as a penance. The father kind of mulls it over and is like, I'll allow, you know, allows it allows her to kind of stay and help those who are sick. There are some very specific rules for helping out on the infirmary. Does anybody have that? I have them. Okay. The following procedures must be observed at all times. One, the infirmary must remain clean and free of debris. Two, a reverent language and behavior are not tolerated. Three, all guests must remain with a member of staff.

Guests found unaccompanied will be escorted from the facilities. Lawful action may be taken. Four, all guests must wear appropriate garments. Upon entry, healers will distribute white robes to dawn over layperson garments. These robes must be returned to a member of staff before departure from the facilities. These robes aid odor control throughout the cathedral, Saint Secile, Deis-Esserene, and Chaucer Tower. They are required. Failure to don robes will result in permanent removal from the facilities. And five, all guests must wash thoroughly before departure from the facilities.

The guest inspection form is located in the washroom near the western entrance. Failure to pass inspection will result in permanent removal from the facilities. So they kind of look over that and move on. Coco sends Ansel with the father to do some praying. The father mentions two patients that are heading towards a French word that I don't know, Fullermont? I think it's the asylum. That's what I was wondering if it was the asylum. We don't get clarification on that. That's just my assumption. Coco and Lou try to find a room to catch up.

They ultimately find one with an elderly man in it who's chained to an iron bed post. His fingers have been tipped in black. He's got long, sharp nails that he taps his body with. That kind of poke holes and his blood kind of pours out and it's too dark. Kind of indicating that it's poisonous. None of these holes are healing. Coco shares that the church has been experimenting with poisons for witches. And Lou kind of wants to know like how did you get here? And Coco kind of fills her in that she stepped in for a replacement.

That Coco's aunt has agreed to protect Lou. Lou opts to stay with the chousers for protection. And so that she can practice so that whenever the ever looming she comes for her, she can actually be strong enough to fight back. Coco says that she will stay and help her train. And importantly, they can practice up there because they're doing stuff with magic. Like all of the patients have an exposed magic. So it already smells like a lot of magic. So they can get away with practicing there.

Yep, exactly. So after this conversation, Lou goes back and takes a bath. Reed kind of comes in and is caught off guard by finding her naked in the tub. Because the door's broken. He says that they did not catch Andre and Gru, but they are still looking. Reed asks about the scars on her body and she basically just goes all the different ways that she's been injured, mostly by knives. Reed also shares that they're going to question Madame LaBelle and that they caught bass outside the theater. They're going to question him and arrest him for killing one of Trumbulay's guards.

Lou begs to be allowed to see bass. Reed says no. But Lou decides in her internal monologues who save bass to save herself and Coco because he would definitely give them away. The next opportunity, Lou manipulates Ansel into taking her to the dungeon. She wipes the memory and knocks out the guards and Lou frees bass, but takes all of the memories. So very quickly after that she passes out and this is what I was referencing earlier where she's kind of an unreliable narrator. And I'm wondering if she took his memories, but if the cost of taking it was for her to lose all of her memories of him too.

Oh. Well, she recognizes that bass is gone. No, she recognizes that the cell is empty. She actually says that bass is gone. It does say bass is gone. But I just don't know what to say. I don't know what to say about bass is gone. But I do wonder if she relinquished all her memories of their relationship beyond just his insistence. Because we don't really hear, do we hear about bass again? We don't hear about bass again, but crucially when she's found, like she's found shortly after this and she's accused of helping her lover escape by Reed.

And she's like genuinely offended. She's like, I was never this far. Oh, she is. And I can't tell if she's lying or if she wiped her on memories. Well, I know she lost the night of them together, so it's possible that they never slept together in her mind. But yeah, that's interesting. When she wakes up, bass is gone, Ansela is still out cold. She wiped his memory and knocked him out. But she doesn't want him to get in trouble because she does like him. So she tries to move him, but it's really difficult. She doesn't manage to move him up the stairs and into a library that she finds.

Which I just, I love when libraries are co-located near a dungeon. Yes. It's good vibes. It's my favorite thing. Ansela awakens and she feeds him a story just as Jean-Luc and Reed jump into the room. There's a smell of magic on both Ansel and Lou. Coco comes to the rescue once again. Appears out of nowhere. Right. She explains and co-operates a story that basically she didn't train Lou on how to wash the magic off of her.

And does say that she went to say goodbye to bass, but when she got down there, the guards were already out cold and bass was already gone. She panicked and didn't want to get in trouble. And Reed reveals that he knows that bass was a lover of Lou and this is when she says that they were never lovers. And Reed is like pissed. He is upset that he, that both, not only that Lou disobeyed his direct order, but also that Ansel did and allowed her to go up into the tower and help Coco, who's going this instance.

But Reed tells Ansel this and he's like, you're dismissed corporal, essentially. And Lou is like, don't talk to him like that. And Ansel pauses in the doorway and he's just like, you stood up for me. It's really sweet. I just thought you poor little boy. You need somebody that loves you. Lou goes to the oratory, which is basically a mass church service. That's hosted or led by the Archbishop. They go to church, but like, I don't, I don't really understand like what the church scene is all about.

It's weird. I honestly like, I read it and I was like, well, that was a big nothing burger. Let's move on. Reed wakes up on the floor the next day because he's still sleeping on the floor, but he finds Lou in bed. So Reed shares a secret with her where he shows her a book that he has stashed, which is a love story. It has a French name, but it translates to the fleeting life. And he shares the lover's die at the end, but that it's a beautiful story about hope. Lou ends up loving it a lot as she continues to read it.

As she's kind of reading through it, Ansel comes to get her because Madame LaBella is there and wants to speak to Lou. I hated this scene. Like, I mean, so angry. Yeah, I did too. I didn't understand Lou's motivations in this either. Yeah. So the Trousers won't let Madame LaBelle speak to Lou alone. So Lou kind of, sorry, LaBelle hugs Lou very quickly and tells her something in her ear. And because like Madame LaBelle moved to hug her very quickly or like grab her very quickly to tell her this thing, Ansel tackles her.

Well, because the whole thing like they arrive in the like entryway or whatever where she's asking to see Lou and Lou is like not interested, like nothing. So you can leave. Don't want to talk to you. And then there's like a bunch of other Trousers that gather around, including Archie B. And they're just like, yeah, she doesn't want to talk to you. I don't understand. Just leave. And so LaBelle like lunges for Lou and like the tension in the air is like she's going to attack her. And so everybody kind of freaks out and like yanks her physically away from Lou.

And it's like this whole kerfuffle that just like didn't need to happen. And I still don't understand why Lou was so reluctant to hear what LaBelle had to say. No, because then like she only gets a snippet of what LaBelle is trying to say. And they like drag LaBelle out and Lou's like, no, wait, I changed my mind. Well, like if you weren't being a bitch the first time, you could have just talked to her. And for no reason, because LaBelle is like, oh, I just want to talk to you in private. Like is there someplace we can go that there's not like a bunch of men around and Lou's like, nope, we're good.

Like I don't even want to hear what you're saying. And I'm like, so why are you here? Yeah, it's just weird. Immediately afterwards is like, I have to speak to her. Let her talk. And it's like, what a 180. Yeah, like no girl. This is you missed your shot. Okay. But also did she miss her shot? Like you guys are in the same city. You know where she lives. Like you could just go talk to her. You could just go right. But no, it just it didn't make sense to me. So next up we have a dream sequence from Liz who is sorry. Who is sleep. Dream sequence from Lou who is sleeping.

And I have a note that says, Liz, how did I dream sequence? Hey, I didn't hate this dream sequence because it's more memory than dream. Yeah, that's fair. Yeah. I don't like dream sequences that serve no purpose to the story. That's fair. So we learned that Madame LaBelle managed to get out. She is coming, which we can into it and Lou into it as her mother is coming. Kind of escaped the nightmare that she woke up with. She actually crawls onto the floor with Reed. He's kind of still asleep, but she kind of has this moment where she gets really close to him to kind of help her get through it.

She kind of shares with the reader that the scar on her throat was from her 16th birthday. She was supposed to die. And at the last minute she decided she wanted to live as the knife was pressing under her throat. Reed invites her to go see a show that is The Fleeting Life. And she agrees, but he can tell something is kind of off about her. Ansel finds Lou looking for a weapon they don't want to give her one. Lou goes searching for her husband to kind of get a weapon. And since she finds John Luke, who calls Reed the Archbishop's pet and accuses the relationship of nepotism, and John Luke says that Reed and the Archbishop are dealing with

luteins, which are like small hobgoblins. How do you guys feel about the addition of this like these other magical themes? Like these goblins and later werewolves? But like none of that ever matters in the book. Like why are we adding anything else supernatural? Well, I feel like it. So I'm holding out judgment because I did like the introduction of more magical beings besides just witches. And I wonder how much of that is going to come into play in future books. That's a good point. Yeah, I do wonder that as well. Because even in this conversation, I forget what the creatures are called,

but she talks about how she would, her memory is growing up with one of these like harmless creatures that the Chaucer's just assassinated because they were quote unquote not natural. And she's like, but they were harmless. Like is that justice? Yeah, which I think is vital to her view on a lot of things. Yeah. But crucially in this as a part of this conversation, like she's trying to speak her truth, but then also kind of forgets where she is. And John Luke kind of picks up on what she's putting down, but not in a good way.

He starts to he's got this like gleam in his eye that he's maybe suspects that she's hiding something. Because he's unfortunately not an idiot. Unfortunately, no. So next up Lou heads to the infirmary with Ansel in tow. We're informed that Ansel kind of has a crush on Coco. Coco and Lou go to practice enchantments in the room with the same old guy with the pointed nails. They nickname him Bernie. As she's kind of practicing, she learns that she can give secrets as payment. So this was the part where we learned that magic can be a little bit more subjective than

prescriptive, which I really liked. Essentially Coco is coaching her to think about the problem that she wants to solve in a different way. So rather than, you know, she's trying to soundproof the room so they can make noise and not draw attention to themselves. And so it's like, instead of taking a sense away from the people who might walk past, maybe the room is, or the magic is giving her something. And so just the framing of the problem in a different way. I just, I really found that fascinating and different in a magic system.

Yeah. And it was really cleverly done, like just that clear thought process that this author put into the magic system. So I feel like so often books that have magic systems, they're rough because the magic doesn't make any sense. Yeah. And this one, like it, it did such a good job of like laying out the laws without being like, here's a list of rules of magic. Agreed. So Lou and Reed go to the theater. Oh, because they're showing the, the ephemer. Yeah, the fleeting life. Sorry, I missed if you said that.

You're good. So they go to the theater, Reed brought, oh my God, I said the same thing. Reed bought her a dress and she magic away some bruises and powdered the rest. She did wear her hood up and a ribbon to hide her scar. While they're there, she kind of bumps into an old man and Reed kind of gets really territorial of her. Well, so she, he gets territorial of her because there's, they sit next, they sit down and the guy next to her like, essentially starts hitting on her because she's not wearing her wedding ring on the right finger. She's intentionally, it's not even a wedding ring.

She still just has Aunt Angelica's ring. Yeah. And she wears it on her right hand just to bother him. And he's like, okay, you know what? We're switching sir, my wife and the dude's like, dude, I didn't know like, I'm sorry. How would I know bro? Yeah. Yeah. As they're sitting there watching the play, she recognizes the girl who was checking on her when they had their first altercation at the theater there and she's singing really well. Wait, but she's not just singing really well. She's weaving an enchantment on stage. So yeah, I just, I didn't put that in there because like,

Lou doesn't realize it in this moment. She does. Really? She realizes that she's a witch. I guess, I guess you're right. She does realize that. That's a problem later. Well, she realizes that she is a witch and she's like, oh, that's really ballsy. Like, and she's kind of impressed and then there's something at the back of her mind that tickles. Like, there's something familiar about this situation. That's where the memory is where like, I question like, what have you given up? Right. Because there's something, like there's something wrong here and I don't know what it is. Yeah. Yeah. So while they're sitting there, Reed asks why she was looking for him and she informed him

that she was looking for a knife. Couldn't she just leave him by one? Like she went out and bought clothing. Like, I guess maybe with Ansel, maybe she can't, but I don't know. It's unclear. They are holding hands during the performance and Reed is kind of moving. First he just starts drawing patterns on her hand and then he's kind of moves up her elbow and then up her arm and then like, he's kind of touching her neck and the first act ends and they're both just sort of like stunned because they're like, oh, I'm a little horny and like, we're touching each other and I don't know what's happening. It's very like we're going on a field trip and sitting next to each other on the bus kind of thing.

Yeah. She starts to say something. What do you guys think she was going to say? She's like Reed and he's like, hmm. And then like she starts to say I and that's when she remembers and then the next thing happens. But what do you think she was going to say there? I mean, she could have even just said something as simple as I'm having a great time. Yeah. Because that's kind of where it is. It's like, but it also could have been something more serious. Like, you know, I really like you or I'm a witch. Like, I don't think it was that at all. I'm not a witch. I'm your wife.

That's such a good quote for this book. I know, right? But anyways, she as the play starts up, she instantly recognizes now the thing that was kind of tickling the back of her head. The woman who was singing is someone that she has known for when she was younger. Her name is Estelle. She was so, Lou wants to leave like immediately. Like as the show is ending, she's like pushing Reed out the door. She's like, no, I don't want to. We should just go. I feel so bad for Reed because I feel like he just wanted to share this with her because

they like bonded over the book. Yeah. Like they don't have a moment to like share the. No. Well, and it's almost overshadowed by the fact that like she, they were having this warmth and like this connection physically and then she just kind of locks up and it's just like. Yeah. Nope. Nope. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Like Reed's point of view, it just feels so bad like that like what the hell just happened? Yeah. Yeah as they're leaving a cell kind of corners them and asked how Lou is recovering. And you know she says I'm fine.

You know thanks for asking. And like keeps trying to leave and Reed says Lou's name. And that's when a cell recognizes like, oh hey, nice to see you. Like recognizes that they know each other. But she says hello Louie's. Yeah. So they keep trying to leave the theater. Lou struggles to like make a path out and so Reed moves in front of her to like move people out of the way which I thought was sweet. Estelle corners them again and says Lou shouldn't leave and Reed steps in and is like, nope, she absolutely can leave and we're leaving right now. Estelle uses magic to have a sign

fall on Reed's head. Reed tries to go after Estelle but Lou, Louie's begs him not to and then Estelle uses the sign again to like bash Reed's head again. Also where is this happening? Like how is no one seeing this? This was a crowded theater two seconds ago. But also like he gets bludgeoned in the head and then like he's fine. Oh yeah, he's never mentioned being wounded. She has bruises for like the whole book. Yeah exactly, she's like physically wounded and he's just like well signs are you know, Charles play. Flimsy. Estelle basically wants Lou to come back

because like this is an honor. Lou will not go back. Reed chokes her out and Lou asks is she dead and Reed says no. But Lou asks what are you gonna do when Reed says burn her. Basically on the way back to the tower, Reed does not speak to her and Lou just feels terrible because like she's a witch killer because she brought this on Estelle. Basically she also finds out when they get back to the tower that the charters have been wanting to test a poison on a witch and they do, they test the poison on Estelle. The archbishop has Estelle tied to the stake. Lou feels like a coward because

she was too afraid to face her own death to save Estelle. Ansel says she doesn't have to watch. Lou says yes I do, no one's to die this way. Ansel says witches do. And Lou asks have you met a witch? And Ansel of course says no. And Lou says of course you have, they're everywhere. They aren't all evil and he mentions that like they're wicked and unnatural. And Lou says you're right just during to the fire. Behold the natural way of things. Lou feels really bad for Estelle so he, she, he, Lou takes the fire pain away. She performs some sort of magic that makes it feel

like she is burning so that Estelle does not feel the the burning as she dies. And Lou awakes later, we find out that it's three days later, with Reed having fallen asleep holding her hand and there's a cool cloth on her forehead. Ansel shares the story that has been told by Ansel is that Estelle did this to Lou and Reed kind of doubles down the fact that he thinks witches are not people, they're demons. I won't even use pronouns, they're just it, right? Yeah. And Lou says what would you

do if I were a witch? And he says, and she asks like would the stake be what I deserve? And Reed says yes. If you were a witch, if you were a witch. Yeah. We also learn at some point here that it's confirmed that Lou's mother is the leader of the white witches. So Margon, the person that we think we saw earlier in the book, and that she wove a spell that would end her line and King August's line, Augustus, August, I don't know. I think it's just like August. Yeah, August. But

she did that in order to free her people of the persecution that they'd endured under his family's reign. So that's why she's having these flashbacks, all of the things that have happened to her. The her that is hounding her, that she's afraid that we'll find her is her mother and the scar in her neck is ostensibly from that. Additionally, one of the things that would happen is it would kill the king's heirs, legit or bastard, one life to end 100 years of persecution. But once this

was the king was in mourning because that's a loss of his heirs, that's when the witches would attack while he was grieving. Coco visits later and says that Lou has a soul ache. I loved that. I did too. And I definitely know what it's like to have a soul ache. It can be really tough. Coco says it can be solved with sticky buns. I argue that you might need something different or more, but you know, sticky buns is a great start. I mean, it's better than crack. Can't hurt. Yeah, better than crack. Yeah, that's wow. The bar is so low. Coco is pretty open talking about

like the mother situation with Lou, even though Ansel's in the room and Lou realizes that he would have smelled the magic on her when she performed the spell where she was taking the fire damage from Estelle, but that he didn't tell on her. Ansel says it's really nice thing where he says you can't forcefully to believe that not all witches are evil. There are some things that cannot be changed with words. Some things have to be seen, have to be felt, and I really liked that. So Lou hatches a plan to convince Reed that she isn't evil, but in order to do this, she needs

to figure him out first. So she goes to read his Bible, but it's just covered with notes in all the margins. And she's like, well, this is overwhelming and exhausting. And no, thank you. Lou goes to the library to get a Bible and she runs into the Archbishop. The Archbishop has a sticky bun. He's like trying to hide from her. And Lou shares that she wanted to borrow a Bible and he is very suspicious and acts a little weird about the whole thing, but does give her a Bible to keep as a gift, which she also finds weird. This whole interaction is very weird for everybody

involved, including but not limited to the reader. Until you read it a second time and then it's like, oh yeah, makes sense. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Reed comes back to the room to find her reading the Bible. And she asked him to braid her hair because she doesn't like it on her neck. And she teaches them how to do that while they're kind of sitting there having that while she's teaching him. And afterwards they kind of have a conversation about how he became a captain. And he explains how he killed something or someone like a pack of werewolves in some

like village that he led a charge into slaughtering. And it's just another example of the Chaucer's slaughtering magical beings that not that aren't necessarily like bothering anybody rather than finding a better, more peaceable like means to an ends, they just kill them all. Zero tolerance. Yes. We go back to Reed's perspective and it's the time and Lou wants to go to get a

sticky bun. She makes him leave his coat behind because she wants to spend a day with Reed, not Chaucer. Start of the manic pixie dream girl montage. Yeah. Yes, so much. But their date is really cute. It is really cute. I like it. It is really cute. Maybe it's not cute. They have a nice day out. They share her cloak because again, he didn't get to have a coat. I don't understand how he only owns one coat and it's his uniform. They go to the bakery and they run into Pan who recognizes her as Lucinda and she introduces Reed as Bass. She has shared with Pan in the past

that has been terrible to her and breaks her heart all the time. And so Pan is like, this is the bass. And she's like, yeah. And he's like, you better be good to her. You better treat her right, that sort of thing, which was really cute. And she's only done that to get free food out of Pan. Like not for anything Bass actually did. Like she just creates problems. Right. She gets her sticky bun for free. Reed has to pay. It's thrown in his face. She ends up eating both of them anyway. So it doesn't really matter. It doesn't. They eat sticky buns. They kind of learn about each other.

Hang on. Hang on. The note is we're at cue the question game. Yes. Yeah. Question game. It's just my favorite fucking part of any of these books. There's always a question game. Hi. I hate it. It feels very realistic to me. But I understand that you that's your thing. You do not like a question game. Liz hates the dream sequences. We all have our things that we can't stand. Mine is a question game. We thankfully have not gotten to the thing that I hate yet.

The problem with the question game I have is that it's like, it's not even a question game. It's like an interview. Like they don't both answer the question. I mean, they kind of do. But like my problem with this is that they don't actually, it's just a question game for the sake of a question game. We don't learn anything interesting about it's like, what's your favorite color? Well, I'm just like, okay, we learned their favorite color. We also learned that the Archbishop once caught Reed kissing another kissing a girl, I think presumably, Sealy, which I think is what they consider to be his like past incidents with this compromising position. God, the patriarch

he is exhausting. Yeah. So they go to see the Yule Tree. Lou wants him to dance and he's like, no, man, a pixie dream girl. Yeah. So she kind of dances a little bit and then they go back to the tower, where Coco informs them that Bernie is missing Bernie again being the patient the elderly man with the really sharp nails. Chosers are searching for him. But all trace of him is gone like the chain the bed all of a back and lose perspective. It's time for a ball. You the ball scene. Yep. This is the ball that's in Reed's honor. Reed goes to meet the Archbishop Coco

helps Lou get ready. Coco will also be able to go one line fixer because they're such good friends. Such a one line fixer. Yep. Ansel sees Coco and just like falls all over himself at how beautiful she is and Lou's like, wow, I kind of feel like nothing over here. And he's like, no, you look great to but also Coco. You're fine. Shut up. He only has eyes for Coco, which is the girl same. Yeah. And so is going to escort Coco and Lou because Reed is going to go with the Archbishop

get there and Lou is supposed to be formally announced and lose like absolutely not I will not be formally announced to anyone anywhere ever pass big pass. And she like goes into like a side door on her own. This means that Reed does not recognize that she's there. And Lou sees that there is a woman with dark hair kind of hanging on him. And she starts to try to make her way over but she is cut off on her approach by Prince Beauregard. Beauregard. He approaches Lou and

wants to know how slash why she got married and Lou says we're in love. And Beauregard's like, that's gross. I love both so much. He's such a little man fuck boy. Yeah. And so look over and see that Reed is being flirted with by another woman and bows like do you want to make him jealous and lose like no but bows is won't be change your mind. Let me know. Which is cute. I kind of want to make I kind of want to see that happen. I would have gone with Beauregard. I would have

gone with Beauregard too. I'd be like yeah let's make him jealous. So the woman that is crowding or hanging around Reed is Sealy which they kind of figure out Lou starts to follow them but the Archbishop kind of intersects again. She just cannot make it to her man. Can't make it happen. And he says you know hey don't don't follow them. Let Reed enjoy this small pleasure we stole his future from him. I lose like fuck that and goes anyway. I know well they have I like their exchange. The Archbishop is like envy is immortal sin and her immediate clap back is so is adultery.

Yeah. My husband's leaving with another woman. And I love how she's just is not here for his shit. She's just like hey how about you stay in your lane and I'll stay in mine. Okay great. Great. Like you put me in this position. I'm gonna follow my husband. Bye. The husband that you forced me to marry by the way up to this point. Okay. So like I know that there's this whole thing with Sealy. I didn't have any emotional connection to like that relationship. How did you guys get there. Wait which relationship the relationship between Sealy and Reed. Oh I didn't either. And I still don't. I just no I just give a shit. Yeah. No.

And even in this scene like I I felt for kind of Lou seeing her husband with another woman and like in this potentially compromising situation but like Sealy just acts like a child the entire time. She's a baby. Like she is just a toddler and it's her own fault that like and Reed's just trying to be a good man. Right. So basically they go Lou follows them out of the garden and kind of can hear the hear the conversation and Sealy wants the archbishop to annul the marriage

or the king and Reed reveals that Sealy didn't want him. She he tried to like be there and like have that relationship and she didn't want him and she says oh I was heartbroken. I didn't mean it and I want him now and she doesn't even say she doesn't even say that she was heartbroken. She said she wanted to do do right by her sister. Like oh yeah. She wanted to like go through the morning and like have that moment and it's like girl that's incredibly selfish. Also you could have just said that. You could have just said that like I need time but it was you didn't have to end

it. It was very clear that she was trying to be like the melodramatic like no you can't love me with your full heart. And I also got this feeling that like she pushed him to like focus on the brotherhood so that her sister could be avenged. Like the whole theme seemed to really selfish. Yeah. Somehow like don't marry me. You need to go avenge my sister instead. Well and I wonder how like if she ever would have let him back into her life or if now she's just upset that he's with

somebody else. I think that's it. Yeah I think it's that one. Me too. The important thing that we learned in this conversation is that Reed basically says that he thinks that he could love Lou which is a nice thing to hear. It's a nice thing to hear. It's nice to hear that your husband might love you someday. How romantic. See that he basically runs off and like a baby. Reed runs into Lou for the first time and asks to speak with her privately. He's such a good man. Like he doesn't try to hide

this conversation. He was immediately going to tell her about it. Yep. Yep. No miscommunication show ups except for the big one in this book. Well to be fair that's a survival problem. All right. So basically he explains the conversation and she's like yeah I heard I was in the kitchen and he's like not the way that I would have wanted you to hear that and she goes yeah but it's a little easier. And he's not mad that she was eavesdropping like this is it's just this book does such a good job of the enemies to lovers like such this like slow build of trust

and it just makes me really happy. Yeah. They both at the end of this conversation confessed that they wanted to work out together which is also nice to hear. I also really like that they started from that position like hey we're married we both want like an actual marriage out of this and didn't start with like hey let's let's jump each other's bones and then get it get to know each other a little bit. Yeah very much. Yes. Let's actually try to make this work and then the physical stuff comes. Yeah I mean it comes quick but it comes later but it's not the it just felt like such

a mature place to start from. Yes they don't fall into bed together and then go like oh I guess we should make this work. Yeah. Oh I guess I should know what your middle name is or something. Right or your favorite color. So basically they agree that they're not going to do any more secrets between each other. Secrets or lies and she kind of like gets her way out of this by saying she'll try. They go back in, Lou is a little bit champagne, she wants to dance and she has to convince him to do so. Maddox the drink girl. They dance and he's actually a good dancer. They're getting ready to leave and

she goes to find Coco and Coco is basically like I'm gonna go sleep with the prince. It's already went home. I can love Coco. Yeah Lou's a little shitty here. She's like hey Coco maybe don't sleep with the prince because he's gonna like know you're a witch and she's like really girl. You're married. Don't come for me. We can talk about that if you really want to go there but I don't think you want to go there because this is a one night fling and I don't know what the fucking is that you think you're doing over there. Yeah. Also like listen if one of you was Coco I'd

be like get it bang the prince. I would be like shouting on the other side of the door like get it. Yeah absolutely hype people up don't tear them down. Yeah this they're arching. Bring him do his knees. They're argument is just like stupid. I don't know. So later that night Lou was tossing and turning in bed and she kind of looks over onto the floor and she invites him into the bed with her. They kind of like snuggle together. It's again a twin bed so it's not a lot of room.

And he's giant again. Yeah we learned a little bit more about Reed and the chousers. Reed was found in the garbage orphaned. There are only ever a hundred chousers at a time because when one dies or retires there's a tournament and the victor gets the open spot. Reed beat John Luke at first and John Luke presents Reed for it. He we also learned about Ceeley and Ceeley and Reed and Tony should have been children and Ceeley would help to temper Reed's anger and he was an angry child and Lou also asked how many witches he's killed and he

shares that he's killed three witches. Through this conversation Lou also shares some of the information that she quote unquote got from her friend the witch which is that witches get their magic from their ancestors. They're always a she. Males are sent away and the magic only passes down to the females. Which is all brand new information to read. Yes. And she's just basically like wow I can't believe that all of the thieves in the east end know more about witches than you guys do even though it's kind of like I don't know your job. Yeah. To know about witches. Yeah. Like you know nothing about them. John Snow. You know nothing John Snow. They're snuggling in

bed and Reed makes a joke and they have some playful interactions with each other and it's very very cute. They they're banned here back and forth is precious. That's very good. We also get consent which is so great in like a really sexy way where like she wants them to start canodaling and he's like I'm not gonna try anything and she kind of whimpers and is like why not. What. And he says I seem to remember you threatening to cut me open if I touched you without permission. I won't touch you until you ask. He's like teasing her with a kiss but like doesn't actually kiss her

and A. I love the consent. B. I think it's that's I think that's really hot though like I won't touch you until you ask. Yeah. And she tries to kick him out of the bed which I think is really funny. And then he's like no you know what this is my bed our bed. Yeah like I'm gonna be here good night. Yeah. Yep. So she wakes up in his arms is excited to celebrate Christmas. They go to the festival together and have some food. They split up to go buy each other presents. She wants to buy him a copper dagger and while she's waiting for it she's attacked again by Andre and Gru. She's like set up

too by the shop owner. Yeah. Yeah. Basically this is the altercation she she was gonna put on her ring but she drops it and Gru takes it and she uses some magic to get away using like coals to like burn them but also herself. Reed shows up and she like recognizes his voice as he's calling in and she uses the bellows to mask the magic smell on her and she's like why are you like how did you find me like why did you know I was here and he's like I was actually coming here to buy you a knife and

I was like that's really cute. But so she she kills both Andre and Gru. Yes. And gets her ring back. Yeah like they're laying there in bloody piles. And they so this is the first time they kiss like they're just so happy that they're seeing each other and so they they confess that they were both gonna buy each other a knife and rather than like buying each other a knife after this Reed just takes the knife that she stabbed into Andre and gives it to her. He's like Merry fucking Christmas.

Yes. It's like covered in blood. Here you go. But I honestly think that's really nice because it's it's very much just like a she can handle her own like it's a weirdly sweet moment for how gruesome it really is. Yeah. The part that loses me though is like they kiss but then like Reed kind of like takes her to the floor and they're like kind of getting hot and heavy and then she realizes that she's laying in a pool of blood. Uh huh. Yeah. And they're both like uh let's do this somewhere else. Yeah. But then they're just like I don't know wet with blood and like traipsing around.

Yep. So they return to the tower. Lou is questioned some more about like what her interaction there was and like the murder of Andre and Gru. And eventually they're released from questioning I guess and she takes him to the theater up into the attic and he's like doesn't want to go up there because he doesn't want to get caught and she convinces him to go up there and it's a lawful good. Yeah. She explicitly tells him that they're not going to break the law and then proceeds to break the law. She's like no no no no no it's fine it's only breaking the law if you get caught.

Right. It's like motherfucker. Although he would never say. No. I would never. Reed asked some questions about Lou's past and she kind of dances around some answers but does eventually give him some details. She's not from this particular area. She grew up somewhere else. She never knew her father and she's estranged from her mom and that the scar on her neck is from her mom and she became a thief to get away from her mother. Lou takes him out to the rooftop and they stare at the nighttime and the city is beautiful. Basically she's talking about how God hates women. They were an afterthought

and that like the religion views women as property and Reed says he doesn't agree with that. Reed gives her a Christmas present. It's a wedding ring. He thinks it's his mom's. They found him clutching it when he was a baby and Lou realizes it's the woman that she loves him. He says this great quote or I think it's a Bible verse. Isn't it a Bible verse? The deep I have it. Do not urge me to leave you or turn back from you. Where you go I will go where you stay. I will

stay. Yeah. It's so beautiful. It's really sweet. Yeah. I mean there are books of the Bible that actually are essentially love stories. Ruth is one of them. I love a love story. I mean it's not it's not like it's money Bible. I would so read that. Who wouldn't? Oh my god. You know that might help the church. Oh they basically go back to like the like and said thing where she wants Reed to do something and he's like he says tell me to like ask me. But wait wait the ask me the ask me thing

was my favorite part because she says he's telling her like ask me ask me and she says touch me Reed please touch me and he says that's not a question and so her and all of her infinite snark goes fine. Would you brave a virtuous chaser stick your tongue down my throat and hands up my skirt my ass needs grabbing. Yes. Too much. Is that good enough for you? And he's like that'll do.

And he's a virgin. Sorry you can continue. Big big old Bible virgin. So Lou basically like takes over and takes charge because he is such a virgin and like wants to show him a good time for his first time. But after they finish they leave and she says the theater is not her home anymore. Now she has another one being the being with Reed. They're enjoying the Christmas party and Madame LaBelle approaches them to chat for a few moments and Lou realizes that Madame LaBelle's eyes are the same as Reed's eyes and that Reed, Madame LaBelle is Reed's mom. And LaBelle recognizes

the ring that's on Lou's finger. That's I mean so Lou is cute because LaBelle has like a change a marked change in posture after seeing her ring and then starts asking her like you know is he a good man is he a good one is he a kind one yeah and Reed is like just offended like how dare you talk to my wife about me. I'm right here because he doesn't know. Does no idea. She also is asking again in front of Reed like does he truly know you like alluding to does he know you're a witch but she

doesn't say that and he's like I don't know what you're talking about back. She also warns Lou that her mother's in the city. Yeah and to keep Angelica's ring on all the time. But we've known that Morgan is in the city since basically page 30. Yeah the two of them returned to the tower of the two of them being Lou and Reed. On the way back they see movement in the alley and Lou recognizes Bernie there. He tries to talk to him to like convince him to come back and this is the first time we've ever heard Bernie speak but basically something is channeling through him

that says I'm coming for you darling. Lou recognizes this is to be her mother speaking through him. Reed kills Bernie and accuses Lou of hiding something. Yes, thank you. Lou does eventually come clean about the fact that her mom is looking for her. She's about to confess to being a witch when the archbishop bursts in and says that there are dozens of women amassing outside the castle. There's no confirmed magic yet but they don't want to wait to find out and send Reed away. He says that he will stay with Lou to have an urgent conversation. Before Reed leaves he looks back

and says I love you to Lou. All right strap in listeners because it gets wild for this next little bit. Yeah wait before we get into that I did have a comment about the Bernie thing because Reed essentially says I have a blade that cuts through enchantments and I'm like why don't you just use that with all of the people in the infirmary then? Yes why don't you just put that too because it's murder. But you could like you could like cut them a little bit right and then

heal them. What? You could cut them cut through the enchantment and then heal them like naturally since they're no longer enchanted. I see. Right like fucking spider man that we didn't talk about who's terrified. Yeah I glossed over that on purpose. I didn't it's scarred me forever. I mean like in terms of the podcast I knew. Locust woman close second. Sorry that's me being a locust. Yeah love that impression nailed it. In this next conversation the archbishop accuses Lou of deceiving Reed

and says that he won't be fooled twice. Someone knocks on the door and says hey the performance of the old sister is supposed to start and I was just like I'll get to it in a second and then like drags Lou along with him. These last couple scenes have just been like a study in cock blocking because like Reed and Lou were talking Lou was going to tell him and then they get cock blocked and then the archbishop was trying to tell her something and then they get cock blocked and it's just like god no one knock wait like two seconds. Just give me like a hot second. Right

right we'd avoid so many problems. So they go to see the acting troupe and all of them are women and they tell the story of the archbishop. He is an orphan who found his way who found his call with the lord as the story is being told Reed returns with John Luke and looks very concerned but he can't quite make it to the group. Lou tries to go to his side but the archbishop says that she is not. Back to the story basically saying that a witch disguised

lured the archbishop into falling in love with her. He bed her forsaking his oath and then the witch revealed herself and then ran but the witch bore his child and the witch was born to the to the head witch of the white witches and that child is Lou meaning that the bishop is the archbishop is Lou's father and the person who is telling the story in this troupe is Lou's mother. Archie daddy yeah I I loved the this use of a like traveling troupe

to give us this backstory because I think it was such a clever way to get all this information without just doing like an information dump and importantly we realized through this that the archbishop already knows that Lou is his daughter like this is not a surprise to him though it's a surprise to everybody else yeah including us so we talk frequently about like did you suspect the answer is a resounding no we all the first time we read this did not realize that until we were told just now yeah and that's where we've been alluding to like when you read it the second

time like the archbishop and his love for sticky buns and wanting witches to be brought back alive because he wants to see the find out if it's his daughter like when you read it again you're like oh well yeah okay that's right yeah but the first time this was very startling information even the even the conversation before this like he was trying to tell her that he knows that she's a witch yeah and that she should not like lead read down this path like he had been led down by her mother but he's so conflicted because like louis's daughter and read is his like adoptive son or

whatever protege and he weirdly cares for lou even though he also doesn't it's very strange yeah so after all this has happened there's immediately screaming and chaos down here tom basically there's people running around and the archbishop pulls lou behind him i'm not sure that the fighting necessarily like there's a big fight right like so the the troop reveals themselves yes and they start fighting with the chousers um read throws a knife into the main actress and read kind of

gets close to lou and asks why the witches are after her the two of them are cornered by a witch the witch wants lou to give up and be sacrificed makes an attack on read lou uses her magic to move him meaning that he now knows that she is a witch the witch that is attacking holds a knife to his neck and basically says like you need to come here or i'm gonna kill him so lou gives up and goes with the witch to save read read looks at her and like she sees ice in his eyes and hatred and as she looks to him she tells him that she loves him lou passes out because she's been drugged by the other

witch yes right so she passes out and when she wakes up ansel has used a partial antidote on her so she's still super groggy can't really get around very well um but she sees that the read and the witch are still facing off and read is really struggling to move tells read that she is too weak to win this fight and read says to use him and she doesn't want to um but she does eventually use him and manage to kill the yeah so she uses read to subdue the witch like she physically

takes over his body with her magic and he overpowers the witch to get her into like a submiss submission position or what sounds bad he she uses him to like basically wrestle her down and then lou has enough strength to come up and finish the job herself and kills the witch yeah be heads the witch read basically they come to and um or they kind of finish this off and read tells ansel to

get out and he's like i think i should say and he's like get out um and then they're just kind of silent with each other for a while um read basically says a lot of really nasty things such as like you know lou says i'm still me and he goes nope you're a witch um and that means that you can't love me and he's frustrated he fell for the same tricks as erich bishops um and it sets in that lou is the archbishop's daughter lou reminds him of his wedding vows and read says that she is not his wife and lou runs away heartbroken and upset and still mostly drugged and so she gets caught by her

mom immediately well so in in that conversation like i think read is grappling with the fact that like his dad and like the person that he looked up to most also succumbed to the witches in a way that they've been taught not to and that is sinful and like shameful their entire lives and read himself also did but lou says you made an oath to protect me like is that not still valid i'm your wife and read looks at her and says you are not my wife and that just broke my heart yeah because she didn't

want this and then they finally got to a point where they had a mutual understanding and then this happened so she flees and then as dad said she's captured by her mom back to read's perspective antelos mad mad and like pushes read to help and says you know even if you don't like her this is bigger than him i think they're planning something really bad with lou john lou confronts him saying that he knows that she's a witch and they fight a bit again the archbishop manages to walk it at the right moment and breaks it up once read to go find her and read doesn't want to so the

archbishop sends John Luke read realizes that he still loves her i'm so glad that he came around on being like okay actually do you love her like yeah same because the first time reading this i was afraid that it was going to be like the rest of the book is read grappling with like i don't love her and i i also love that ansel was just like no you're being an idiot like yeah you know her like respectfully sir like can we can we all just take a step back here and like

check your ego please yeah right so that i thought i was looking for lou in all the wrong places he like goes near the theater like he tries to like find all the places that she would have been and then ansel finally suggests like we should go talk to brie who's cocoa um and at that exact moment cocoa like berson is like where is she she always just like i'm here guys yeah speak of the devil you see her tail and so basically uh they kind of share with cocoa what the plan is and

she says let's go meet at the brothel the bell rose um we're gonna meet the prince there um and somebody else who will help us know where to find her i mean so they're they're a merry band of um going into mortar at this point right so they meet at the bell arose um they're trying to locate or understand what happened to lou and did we say that bo is gonna meet cocoa there because he's there bo is there we did the one okay because they're like a thing like they're just they are i love it so

much i love it too but so cocoa reads the blood and realizes that lou has been taken by her mother the queen of the white witches and they're they're sitting at this table picture this so it's cocoa picture it's it's cocoa bo the prince who's just like can't be bothered but is here because he's infatuated with cocoa ansel and read and they're having this conversation and cocoa's like yeah she's with her mom that sucks and they have this conversation to the effect of like yeah you'd have

to be an idiot not to see that lose a witch i mean ansel knew and like he didn't say anything about it and read is having this internal monologue that's just like how did everybody know but me yep and i just love how self-aware that is and the prince is even like i don't understand why we would want to do anything to these divine creatures like he knows our witches couldn't care less he's into it he's so into it um so read kind of gets it gets his temper up there's a lot revealed

in this conversation that i didn't care to write down but madame labelle joins them and she reveals a lot namely that read is the bastard son of the king and that she is a white witch and so if they want to find lou in the heartland of the white witches she can find she can help them find it because only a white witch who's been there before can like can find it and find it and that with read being a bastard child that if the queen of the witches goes through with her plan to sacrifice lou that would also end in reed's death right correct so they all they all agree they all

put their hands in the middle of the table and say ready great and then they all agree to save lou or die trying do you have any other notes on that particular me i don't um besides there's yeah no there's not the next several chapters like from the first i remember from the first time reading it we're like there's going up the mountain and like there's not a lot of interesting things that happen no no no there's not the only thing like the next big thing i remember is like when they're traipsing through the forest there's just like all of these men going to this party because they're all

just like fuck buddies of witches question mark yeah okay so a couple of things happened before that okay so we switched back to lou and we realized that she's drugged she's in the possession of her mother and they're going to bring her back to the homeland of the white witches to sacrifice her to fulfill the spell that her mother is woven and like kill both of their lines and free the witches or whatever the merry band of assholes ends up going through the forest to try to save her at the chateau but they encounter a couple of things along the way the first one is they run into the

other cheshire chassers that the um that archie has sent they decide to not engage with them because that's probably a bad idea so and that's being led by john lou yes so they kind of keep themselves hidden from that and then when they reach the area of the homeland this chateau that the white witches live in or that at least the matriarch lives in they have to have like a credible reason to be there and the sacrifice of lou is coinciding with a festival where witches from all over are

arriving and they're also bringing in like escorts so we read earlier that they banish all the males because they're not magical and they're kind of a threat this is one of the only times that men are allowed into this castle and they're mortals so they usually go to the village nearby and pick up these guys but some of our merry assholes disguise themselves and go as escorts as well just kind of like for funsies yeah it feels like so madame labelle like disguises them so they're

not easily recognizable because like the prince is a pretty recognizable face um and at this point like at least the queen would know what reed looks like yeah so they infiltrate the castle i don't have a lot of information on what happens when they infiltrate the castle but it's it's basically like a big festival and so there's a bunch of witches everybody's partying and they're all kind of waiting for this big sacrifice and when that finally starts to happen they see lou being brought out by her mother and it's clear that she's going to try to sacrifice

her daughter again so labelle tells them that she has a signal and tells reed and bow and ansel to kind of wait for her signal before acting but before she can kind of give the signal morgana brings up labelle on stage and is basically like ah yes a gift for my daughter one of her friends also sacrificed and basically kills her on on the the stage which is really upsetting because like reed just found his mom and now and they like had barely even begun to

be cordial or him to her at least now she's gone exactly um so this act of seeing his mother be slaughtered on an altar causes reed to like blow his cover essentially he cries out goes to his mother's side to try to stem the tide of her her bleeding out essentially and morgan morgan how are we saying her name morgan morgan morgan morgan morgan morgan morgan morgan so morgan

seems to have anticipated that reed would be there seems to be able to see through his disguise sorry definitely can see through his disguise because the person that was weaving it just died calls forth the other two so calls forth bow and ansel so that they can also be sacrificed on the on the altar and just as she's about to kind of do that koko springs from the air like a spider monkey and attacks morgan she's a spider monkey she just emerges at the perfect

time she's fucking love koko she always has great timing so she's like assaulting morgan stabbing her in the throat but as this is happening morgan like motions to one of the attendants who brings out the arch bishop and he's like being held captive and this kind of creates a diversion everybody's confused but essentially it gives everybody enough time or not everybody it gives morgan enough time to reach lou and slit her throat open in that moment

time slows down reed sees the love of his life bleeding out and his heart rate slows down he sees his life flash before his eyes but also he sees a golden thread linking the love of his life to his mentor so he sees a gold thread between lou and archie b and only witches should be able to see right this is the same symbology that we've been introduced to for how lou sees magic and he

kind of instinctually knows that if he follows this thread that he can make a trade for lou's life by taking his relationship in the life of archie b and he does that a life for a life a love for a love yes so once he does that lou's throat starts closing up she is alive but of course at that exact moment the other chasers show up john lou has to show up like a true cockpaw they're all the

damn time god such a jerk so john lou sees john lou can the rest of the chasers see reed basically assassinating the arch bishop isn't a good look no not a good look ignoring everything else like the context is important here i feel like and they're just kind of glossing over that yeah but they start attacking the crowd kind of indiscriminately trying to kill everybody all of our heroes shelter and eventually escape including with labelle's body and in kind of the wrap up

they escape the castle and they're able to nurse labelle and lou back to health so nobody died which is great whoo they're still hiding out in the woods they don't really know what happened at the chateau after they left morgan was wounded john lou was not but the chasers were assaulting a fortress of witches so i hazarded guess that didn't go super well but they don't really know they are warding themselves against being found um with coco's magic and basically

trying to wait until labelle and lou can move under their own power again both of them eventually do wake up and we have some kind of housekeeping discussions that happen between some characters so the first housekeeping discussion that happens is between labelle and reed and they talk mostly about read using magic and how he's the first male witch in like forever and like how the fuck did that happen guys cool right um but it also seems like they come to kind of uh

a better place than where they had originally started like he had totally disavowed her as his mother but it seems like he kind of accepts her now what did you guys think so i will say that like him being able to use magic is one of the reasons i'm most excited to read the next few books because i'm super excited to see what that looks like from that perspective and like 100 percent super pumped about that i'm glad he reckons i was his mother like that's great i guess but i'm really excited about his magic yeah so that's that's okay so we mentioned when he had that scene in the beginning where the king was attacked by witches and he was kind of almost enchanted by

morgana or mark morgan whatever the fuck her name is but resisted and so that experience we'd seen a couple of times so when like lou enchanted the prisoners to see baz before he was like questioned or executed she did that and it's very difficult for like almost impossible for a regular person to resist but if he was being enchanted he did resist it and so that's an interesting plot point that i'm sure or i'm not sure i hope will be explored in the next book it is an interesting plot point

and i am glad that um labelle is alive and they kind of reconcile because i'm interested to see how like their relationship evolves too especially now that archie is dead yeah so like orphan boy is not an orphan anymore also was royalty i don't know that's gonna come around yeah i'm just glossing over that fact yep the other housekeeping discussion that happens is between lou and read so lou does wake up and they talk lou i have several problems with this conversation but the first one

is that lou tells him he apologizes he's like i'm so sorry i said some awful things and she says you did nothing wrong bitch yes he did and it's okay that he did just let him be sorry exactly you can talk you can talk things out without glossing over the severity of what you both did yeah i just i hated that so much but they get back to a good place um they're both very happy to be alive and and that's it like i don't know they kind of talk it out they say they reaffirm their love for each other and like it's very touching but the last thing that happens in the book is that they kind

of lay out the plan which is where i think the next book will pick up which is essentially that labelle will return to the city with bow to have a word with august her former lover and reads father and the king daddy um and try to talk yeah try to talk some sense into him because the assumption is that he's probably gonna want to try to kill lou because she's the threat to like i don't know his entire line yeah but then the others so coco lou and read and i assume ansel as well

yeah he's will take shelter i think he's in there they'll they will take shelter with coco and her aunt and it is revealed that coco's aunt is the leader of the red witches which is badass yeah so bad and she's got the her aunt her aunt has like a pretty renowned reputation kind of almost the level of um morgan um but we don't really learn a lot about her and i'm really interested to learn more about the red witches and i also know if there's other kinds of i am too because it strikes

me because she says like oh my my aunt is this person and i think it's ansel who says shit no it's read because that's what pissed me off the first time it's read oh yeah so okay i it doesn't piss me off that he curses it i i'm not quite sure why he says shit maybe because he's just like can we just get past like the leaders of the pack over here it's also not the first time he curses like when lou wakes up and they're having their house keeping he says why the fuck is everyone in this kingdom trying to murder my wife yeah i love that that line i liked but the very last line of

the book is him saying i think i don't like it because he already cursed one it felt like he said shit purely from a place of exhaustion because like 30 pages back he had no idea red witches existed no and now he like understands how complicated it is that they're gonna go hide out with the leader of the red witches yeah or like i don't think he could possibly conceive what that means no i'm interested to see because it strikes me just based on the context that we get from this book that like the white witches are kind of flashy and like attention seeking in a certain

way like they have this main this big beef with the king and the fact that white witches in particular are the ones that are the most known by the chaucers like makes me wonder what the vibe is going to be like at the the bloodwish camp well and it also seems like that there is some kind of rivalry between the white witches and the red witches yeah like koko had to get explicit permission for the coven to protect lu and lu's like they're gonna kill me like i'm not gonna go there yeah that's a good point i think some of it is locality based like i feel like the white witches frequent

this particular place but maybe there's other parts of like the map that is more common for blood witches to maybe potentially hide out based off of like location because we only meet the one blood witch which is koko well too bad but but we don't really it was right yeah but the last note that i have is onward to book two yes definitely onward to book two blood and honey let's do some ratings uh lu's we'll go ahead and start off with you what did you give the spice

level i give the spice level a two um there is only one scene but it is just i love this scene it's so romantic it's spicy like it's just it's like it's like the perfect level of like romance and spice for me like it's detailed enough that i'm into it but i wanted more spice so i'm hoping now that they have broken that barrier so to speak there'll be more spice in future books yeah uh what did you give the writing style i gave it a four i really love the writing style um i i like

the way that this author provides information without just doing info dumps like i mentioned the troop and the way to like give all that history um in a really unique way without just being like here's a soliloquy on your background i liked like all the cookie crumbs going back and reading it it was fun kind of like reading harry potter and like you see all the like red flags and hints it was kind of fun to be like oh i know what's going on the second time around yeah yeah i liked that too definitely a lot of uh showing rather than telling so much showing rather than telling

read the quality of storytelling i also gave it a four um the characters feel really well developed like none of them are perfect um lu goes into like adi said her manic dream girl like phase um read has his own temper problems but i feel like just the way the characters work together the plot is really unique it was a really interesting take on witches and i liked that neither side is clear cut good or bad like we see that both sides are not great so that makes it more of an interesting

story to me yeah for sure and then do would you recommend it yes uh adi what did you write the spice level there we go i rated it as a three i would have rated it higher except like lid said there was really only the one scene but it was really good so i solid three uh how about the writing style writing style i've rated it a four problems aside with the french and manic pixie dream girl like like you just said there was a lot of show not tell and it was just so well written that even though i had read it before i found myself not skimming but actually

reading the book again and that says a lot to me about the the writing style and the quality of storytelling yeah so what did you give the quality of storytelling i gave it a four for a book that is relatively straightforward on its surface like there could have been some massive plot holes here and i think because it was so simple in a lot of ways like it didn't open itself up to a lot of criticism in that way and so there wasn't like plot holes that you could find the city of atlantis in for example yeah and i was engaged with the characters and where the story was going

it so much so that i'm i'm buckled up in i bought the t-shirt for the second book not the book just the t-shirt absolutely so does that mean you recommend it i absolutely would recommend this book i bought the t-shirt and the second book so buckle up wonderful um my ratings are pretty similar to liz i gave it a two for space level just because there isn't a whole lot of it i gave it a four for writing style and a four for quality of storytelling for all of the aforementioned reasons and i 100% would recommend this book um it was just such a pleasure to read um to katie's point

like i found myself like i was trying to get my notes done for this podcast and i was going trying to go fast and i found myself actually reading it just because i was enjoying reading the book so it's a great read yeah um we did it those were our thoughts on serb and dove by shall be hey i'm a hero my hero thank you for joining us on this journey what did you think let us know on the socials you can find us on instagram at spice traders pod bye bye see your group too why am i why am i waiting at you guys i don't believe every single time

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Irresistible Urge to Fall for Your Enemy By Brigitte Knightley Part 1

    Nov 10, 20261 hr 35 minAudio

    Triggers: graphic violence and gore, depictions of a fictional plague, on-page sexual content (including masturbation), and themes of parent death and chronic illness KU: No Recommendation: No, (give the author money...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Surrendering to Scylla by Wren K Morris

    Oct 27, 20261 hr 10 minAudio

    Triggers: (From the author): kidnapping, violence, discussions of abuse, BDSM dynamics and play, tentacle play, brief descriptions of injured animal (that receives aid), breath play, bondage, depictions of sub drop,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Threshing Day by Rebecca Yarros

    Oct 14, 20261 hr 9 minAudio

    Triggers: war, battle, hand-to-hand combat, perilous situations, blood, intense violence, brutal injuries, death, and poisoning KU: No Recommendation: Yes! For more of the author, check out https://rebeccayarros.com/

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Court of Heathens by K. A. Knight

    Sep 29, 202652 minAudio

    Triggers: from the author: “explicit violence, explicit sexual violence, dubious consent, murder, gore, torture, kidnapping, and more.” KU: Yes Recommendation: No For more of the author, check out...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Under Loch and Key by Lana Ferguson Part 2

    Sep 21, 20261 hr 4 minAudio

    Triggers: death of a parent (off page), grief, fantasy violence KU: No Recommendation: both Traders recommend! This is part 2 of 2. For more of the author, check out https://www.lanaferguson.com/

    Credit the people on this episode