This week the Traders enter Basgiath War College and discuss Fourth Wing by Rebecca Yarros. We start out salty but we end up being hooked! This episode is part 1 of 3 of our coverage. Triggers: violence, death, war themes. Tropes: enemies to lovers, dragons, forbidden romance, magic. KU: No. Recommendation: both traders recommend! For more of the author, check out rebeccayarros.com. Pronunciation guide we used: https://www.tiktok.com/@ceartguleabhar/video/7243851766578646299
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hey friends, just a quick reminder before we get into today's episode, come join us over on our Patreon. That's where we release bonus episodes every other week and we've already got over 20 episodes from 2023 that you can download and binge right now for as little as $3 a month. We've covered so many good books there, Haunting Adeline, Chateau, Gotha Canna, and so many more. That's also where we'll cover any books in a series we continue, so Serpent in Dove, High Mountain Court, Serpent in the Wings of Night. You can continue those series with us on Patreon right now. Finally, as a patron, we let you know what we're going to
read every month so you can read along with us if that's your jam. Anyway, that's all from me on to today's episode. Well, it's the it's the trope of like there's two types of fantasy books, one where like the dragons used to be here and maybe one day they'll come back and grace us with their presence and then the other type of fantasy is how the fuck do we get rid of these dragons? So true. I love that. Welcome to Your Saved Space, the podcast your partner friends,
parents, whoever thinks is dirty. Don't have time to read books, want to understand the jokes in the tics-hacks, we got you fam. We're the spice traders and we deal in spicy books. I'm Katie and I need it to make sense. I'm Liz and I'm hypercritical. As always, we start every episode with three things. The first is a generic trigger warning. You can find specific triggers for this book in our show notes. So please check those out. Also, we do use foul language and talk a lot about sex. If you have sensitivity to any of this, please give this episode a skip. Secondly, we talk about books, the whole book, nothing but the books that helped me
got us. If you plan to read this book and don't want something spoiled right now, don't listen to this episode. Lastly, we acknowledge that a good book can hit you at the wrong time. The views expressed in our discussion are our opinion, and we absolutely don't want to diminish the work and the talent of the authors in our community. That said, we have some notes. So Liz, what are we talking about today? Today we're talking about Fourth Wing by Rebecca Yarrows,
published in 2023, and it is the first book in the Imperian series. The second book came out November of this year, I think it released like last week, as at the time of recording. This series will be longer than the two books, but I think it's undetermined how many books Rebecca is going to publish. This book is 662 pages, which is a big boy. It's a chonker, which as a heads up, we will be breaking into multiple episodes. So this is the first episode
of Fourth Wing. Yeah, because I don't think I can sit here and record for six hours like we used to do. Like that's just a big commitment for me. Listen, doing it like this is so much better, and I think it's better for the listeners. I hope so. I sure hope so. I hope so. Hopefully we'll get feedback on that someday. Now, this book is absolutely gorgeous. It is like gold cover. We get some silhouettes of dragons. So we already get that fantasy vibe. I need to look at the cover
as I speak. It says Fourth Wing. So we have a golden dragon right in the middle with a black dragon up in the corner and these whimsical clouds around. It's really clean. It's really pretty. I don't have, I have no bad things to say about the cover. I don't either. And I also, I will mention some other aspects about the design of this book that I like when we get into the meat. But the other thing that I like that this book has, I don't think that it necessarily started, but it
definitely popularized the painted edges in mainstream media. Yes. So like I don't have a copy of that book, but I did order the second book with the colored edges and I just, I love the way that that looks. And I think it makes the book really special. It does make the book really special. This author did do a run of like limited edition painted edges, which I think, like you said, kind of brought that back into vogue. That's the only word in my head. Okay, good. I was like,
that's the only word in my head. You get it. But and it really has, I think, exploded in a lot of different ways because I've had books that I've sprayed edges where they're just colored. But I've seen a lot of really amazing authors, Jesus, I've seen a lot of really amazing artists on TikTok hand painting the pages. Like I've seen Lord of the Rings ones where they're painting like the shire on the edges. They're so pretty. Gorgeous. Yeah. It really makes me want to be intentional
about the books that I have in my library so that I can eventually have like a good collection of painted edge books or something. I don't know. I did see someone listen. I saw someone on TikTok that was like, I love painted edges. But now that means that I have to buy two copies of every book so that I can display one spine out and one edges out. God damn it. And I was like, yeah. And then they release special editions and that covers difference. And then I have to buy that one. And next thing you know, I just have like a library of just fourth wing. That's fine.
Because they're gorgeous. Stay consistent, bigger library. And that's you just see more bookshelves. And yeah, I am definitely guilty of buying slash keeping books that are just pretty, even if I hate the book. Oh, 100%. I have, I think it was the book of lost things or something like that, which was a really sad book. And I did not like, did not love the content of the book. But it's a beautiful book. So I kept it. Did not bring you joy. Did not bring me joy. I get that.
Yeah. Anyway, anyway, well done, Rebecca. Well done, Rebecca. Okay, so, Haiti, take us into the meat. You said that and that sounds gross to me, but I'm going to go with it. Let's get into the meat. Bring me into the meat. The meaty greedy. Wow. Sorry. So I bought two different copies of this book. So I bought the physical copy because it's gorgeous like we just talked about, but I read it on Kindle because it's just way easier to read on my iPad and take notes on my iPad at the
same time. Also, you're not carrying around a 600 page book. Yeah, for real. Like, I rarely keep a purse on me, let alone a 600 page book. Come on. Or a purse that would fit a 600 page book. That's the one really. So there's a couple of things more about this book that I love. One of them is that the map is actually integrated into the inside cover of the book, which makes for a really slick experience. I really don't like books or I find it a not optimal experience when there's a map that's across two different pages and then you can't really see the
inside of the map because it's in the binding. Or I hate when the map is super small, so you can't like see everything in detail. Yeah, this one is really just integrated really well and there's a lot of detail. There's a nice like border around it with some different symbols and then just really well done. I also like the idea of it being on just the cover because simply from an ease of use perspective, it's way easier for me to just flip the front cover open to look for it than to try
and hunt for it in the first like 10 pages of a book. 100%. Yeah. We don't get a whole lot of detail in terms of like specific cities or like roads or anything like that, but we do get a super continent and we do have a couple of places of interest. North is where it should be. The dimensions of the map are, they make sense based on what happens in the book, so I don't have a whole lot of negative things to say about that if any. No, the map is quite nice and I don't even remember
which book didn't have North in the right place, but it will never be forgotten. Oh, I do. It's Air Awakens. That's the one, it's Air Awakens. Oh, okay. Yep. And I think we did like it. It's just one of those ones that, one, it didn't have smut in the first book and then also there was a bunch of geopolitical stuff that wasn't meaningful and so this is boring. And I think we did some like digging and there wasn't going to be smut in the second book either. Yeah. Okay, so I think why I blocked out the map for that one is because in my head I just see the cover where she has three
arms and her elbow is broken. Yes. Multiple problems in that. But we digress. We are not talking about Air Awakens. This map is lovely. However, unfortunately, because the physical copy is so well integrated, it does result in it having a distinct advantage over the Kindle edition. Not only is the map really well done in the physical copy, you actually don't get a map of the world in the Kindle version and I triple checked this before we started to record this. Okay, good. I
was just going to check to be like, really? Yes, because it seems like kind of a miss, right? Like there are things that happen that you need some kind of physical orientation for that would be helpful and you just don't get that, at least in the version of the Kindle thing that I had. No, you don't. You just get the map of the college, which is unnecessary. Right. So yeah, I do think that having the kind of overall map would have been useful. I'm not somebody that's great with directions. So when they start talking about north and east and to the
west, it's like, what? And I like having a sense of space. Like with a well executed map, I have a sense of distance. So like when they go from the college to wherever the fuck they go and like it's snowing there, but not at the college, I like having, okay, how far did we travel? Right. Like all the way down to the bottom of the continent. Yeah. And like, what is that? Is it an island? Or is it like North America? Right, exactly. So as Liz mentioned, we do get the Kindle, a map in the
Kindle version, but it's just of the War College. So one note, I'm going to say the name of the War College. And I'm not trying to pick sides, but I am going to use the Gallic pronunciations of this, these words, because TikTok tells me that that's how I should pronounce them. So I'm sorry if this is not correct, but we will link the TikTok pronunciation guide that we are using because my God, I have no idea how to pronounce who's in my native tongue. No, and they're really beautiful
words. They really are. When you hear a Gallic speaker say them, I'm just like, oh yeah. But I have this chunky American tongue. Ham fisted. Ham fisted American tongue doing our best over here. So this War College is named Baz Skiet, and it is made up of two primary buildings separated by a river and connected by two bridges. So the bridges will become important later on as we get into the story. But the map of the college itself is more or less useless. Like the map is fine,
you just don't need it. You really don't. It's a school. It's a school. It is better than the map we get in, um, Gotha Canna. Anything is better than that. Because at least this map like, distances seem kind of appropriate. I don't fucking know. It's fine. Um, yeah. So our setting is a country named Navar. And this book is immediately already really into itself because it has this
disclaimer before we even get into the book. Quote, the following text has been faithfully transcribed from Navarian into the modern language by Jacinia Nailwort, curator of the scribe quadrant at Baz Skiet War College. All events are true and names have been preserved to honor the courage of those fallen. May their souls be commended to Malik. And I have to be honest. Between this and the setting of this book, I really chose violence when I was reading it for a number of reasons.
One, I'm tired of books that take themselves way too seriously. Because right up front, there's a number of things in this disclaimer that I just don't give a shit about. And I think it's a little bit of a spoiler to say, Hey, most people in this book die. Cool. Yeah, that part I was like, great. Amazing. And this is clearly like past tense. We're not really following as it currently rolls out. Exactly. The second thing is that I'm just really tired of books based around schools
that are based around social constructs that make no fucking sense. Like, we'll very quickly get into a construction day or whatever the fuck they call it. But it's just like, I still to this day, don't understand why we're here. And I honestly don't care. And so if I come up a little salty, that's why. And we will get into it. But the whole really the original issue in this book,
like the first conflict that serves the whole rest of the book doesn't make any fucking sense. So because the first point doesn't make sense, the rest of it is hard for me to take as seriously, because there's no consequences. There's no consequences. And I don't buy why we're here. No, we don't need to be here. Everything else. All of all of the other things just seem like trite problems of that are totally fixable and are totally under your own control and are easily fixable again with no consequences. Exactly. So it's like, come on guys.
Okay, so let's get into the story. We begin on this conscription day that I mentioned. And our protagonist Violet trudges along with a 30 pound pack. And my note here is, oh, the military of it all. Yes, my 30 pound pack that I couldn't put down. I needed to take with the stairs with me. Yes, yes, yes, quite my pack. So she's headed to the the kind of general of the school's office. And this is on the day that all young adults, so 20 year old idiots, choose what they're
going to do for their country for the rest of their lives. No pressure. No pressure. Also, we'll get some more detail, but there's essentially four options. Who's like delivering mail, making food, making clothes, teaching children, like there's I don't understand where what those people are. Yeah, growing food, like all of the infrastructure that you would need to support an economy and an organization of this size, none of those things exist. And we don't get a whole lot of
information on the alternatives to going to this war college. And so again, right off the bat, we have a social construct that again, makes no fucking sense to me. It has so much stress put on it for it to make such little sense. Yes, I can forgive things that don't make sense if they don't matter to the plot. This is what the entire plot is built on. It is because the impression that we get is that every single 20 year old goes to the school. It's not this is an option that you can do. No, every single person in this country goes through the school. So the choices are you
can become a healer, a scribe, a writer or part of the infantry. There is kind of a hierarchy here that's important and it will become more important as the story goes on. But essentially the writers are at the top of that pyramid and infantry are at the bottom and then healers and scribes kind of fall somewhere in the middle. Most people who want to be writers have been training their entire lives for this day. But our protagonist Violet has been training for six months and that's going
about as well as you can imagine, which is to say not well at all. It also seems like of the four choices that writers are the hardest to get into, like the most discerning as to who actually quote unquote graduates. A big part of the reason why is because a lot of them die at school. Yeah, discerning makes it sound like someone's choosing you and saying run along home if you don't meet the bar. Yeah, no, they're dead. It's like you graduate or you die. You don't get a second chance
or a second choice. So again, this choice is what the entire plot is based on and our protagonist has only been training for six months out of her 20 years on the planet. And the reason that she's only been training for six months is because she had growing up always wanted to be a scribe and that's what she was preparing for. So it's kind of like taking the quintessential high school nerd and making them try out for the varsity football team. Yeah, if the football team was made up of
dragons and murderers. Yeah. So yeah, it's, it's a bit problematic to say the least. Yeah. So we can. So I mentioned that finally was going to the general's office and we find out that that the general general Soren Gale is actually her mother. And she is in charge of the school, which exists to train an ever refreshing force of people who will keep Navarre safe from its
murderous neighbor, Pormorial and their Griffin writers. So okay, Navarre and Pormorial are two countries that are at war. They don't like each other. Navarre has dragon riders and Pormorial has Griffin riders. That's how they're conducting battle mostly. The other major issue I had with this social structure is that as we get into it, it is a war college. So we get a lot of
militaristic training and language and all of these things. We're never told why these countries are at war. Are we? Yes, we are. Okay. But it's been so long since I've read the book. I don't remember what it is. It's not super clear. Okay. And by the end of the book, you do get the impression that the whole basis for the war is a falsehood. Okay, right. I do remember that. So that's fine. Yeah. But you do. But we do know that they've been at war for a while. A while. Like 100 years
or something like that. 100 years war. That's a war. Okay, Charles Dickens. Okay, so when Violet goes to General Sorengale's office, she runs into her sister, Mira, and Mira is arguing with the general. They're arguing, particularly about what the general is going to do with Violet. Mira is of the mind that Violet is a weakling who will never be cut out to be a driver, dragon writer. She thinks this because Violet has trained her whole life to be a scribe. But for some reason,
now, six months ago, her mother assigned Violet to the writers, which out of the blue, out of the blue, because you don't really assign children to end because these are children to anything. It's like their own choice. Right. Her mom is just like, no, you're going to do this now because I said so because I'm your mother. Right. Because we don't ever get a good reason. Which is my biggest qualm with, well, maybe not my biggest qualm, but it's a really big qualm with this book. It's a really big part of the problem that I have with this book. And it
will come up multiple times. So like buckle up buttercups. So Mira is 26 and very fit. She is described as quote, her skin practically glowing with health and her golden brown hair sheared short for combat in the same style as the generals. Violet is not these things. She is pale. And she remarks that even her hair is pale. Quote, it's cut just above her shoulders where the brown strands start to lose their warmth of color and slowly fade to a steely metallic silver by the ends.
Her mother finds fault with this hair because it's a physical manifestation of a sickness that Violet contracted when she was working in the library. Something, something. I don't know. This seemed like just an excuse to give Violet weird hair. Yeah. And it's something that I don't like in these fantasy books is just like making them stand up for no reason, like giving them purple eyes or. Cerulean hair. Cerulean hair. Like she's enough of an outcast without giving
her this weird hair. And the hair really doesn't mean anything. Yeah. Well, so it's twofold, right? Like her hair is silver and got this weird thing going on. But then also as the book goes on, it gives nothing away to say that she also refuses to cut it, even though most female writers do, because it's a liability. Think about having a log braid down your back, somebody could grab it and cut your head off. So it's like notable for two different reasons. And I'm just like, you could have picked one. I promise we like this book at the end, guys. We do, we do. It's just,
I think it's fair that this book, especially at the beginning, gets a fair amount of constructive feedback because it could use some improvement. Yes. So we learned a little bit more about Violet and why she wanted to be a scribe, particularly her father was a scribe and he trained with Violet himself. And so Violet really takes offense at her mother's disdain for the profession. And she kind of feels it not only reflected back on her, but also on her father. This is especially painful because her father
has been dead for more than a year at this point, and they're all still kind of dealing and grappling with that loss. We learn kind of round about the reason why her mother is forcing this decision. And it seems to be this quote. This is the general speaking and she says quote, you're the daughter of a writer, you are 20 years old and today is construction day. I let you finish your tutoring, but like I told you last spring, I will not watch one of my children enter the scribe quadrant Violet. So it really just sounds like her mother's a bitch. Yeah. And
if this was a problem from the get go, why let her finish her tutoring in the first place? Because it really sounds like you're just setting her up to be dead. Well, yeah, it sounds like she'd rather have a dead daughter than a scribe daughter. And that's just like really problematic. Yeah. So like, why? Why does it matter? And we'll see later, but the scribes are not disrespected. Like they are held highly, they are valued, like they maintain all the history, all the knowledge, a lot of like the war documents and information. Right. The intelligence gathering, all of that. It's not like
they've all been CEOs and Violet's like, cool, I'm going to be a janitor, which like nothing against our custodial staff, like you work hard, but it doesn't make any fucking sense. It doesn't make any sense. No, or maybe a better way to say that would be like, you've been a dairy farmer all your life, and now you want to go work with pigs. Yeah, like, what? What? Yeah. So Mira continues to argue with their mother, something that always got her extra brownie points, but for some reason
had the opposite effect when Violet was talking back. Violet is at once grateful that Mira is standing up for her, but she also hates that Mira is calling her weak, while also recognizing that she is and this continues to be a theme. She hates to be called weak, but also fully acknowledges that she is physically weak. And I'm like, okay, which is it? Yeah, like humans are complicated things, but this back and forth happens far too often in the book, it loses its power, like just
decide you're not weak or embrace that you are. I don't understand. Or I wish she would have said or embraced a little bit sooner, like I might be physically weak, but I can do this because I'm smart. Yes, because it does come into play later. She should acknowledge that now. So in this argument, General Sorengeil says something to the effect that because Violet is used to dealing with pain well, she'll have a better chance of survival, which oof. And it should be mentioned here. And we get a little bit more detail as the book goes on, but the sickness that she contracted that
turned her turned her hair silver also left her with a chronic pain. So she has this disability that causes her chronic pain and then also makes her prone to injuries really, really easily. So like dislocated shoulders, broken things all over the place. And we're given to understand that this is a product of the sickness that she had when she was younger. Yeah, Ehlers-Danlos, the one of the most common signs and symptoms include overly flexible joints.
There you go. And not in like a convenient way, like in a your joints will dislocate easily and you're in a lot of pain. Awesome. So as the argument continues, we learn a little bit more about the world. So we learn that the general obviously as a writer, as is the sister Mira, and writers not only have cool dragons that they get to ride around on, but the relationship and the bond that they have with dragons allows them to manifest what there's what they call a signet
power, which is exactly what it sounds like. It's magic. It's unique to every writer. So the general signet power is storms. She can make a squall show up. I was really stoked to read a book about dragons. When I was younger, I was like super into dragons. I remember when that Aragon series came out, which in retrospect, hell yeah, maybe not the best. I don't know, not good. Yeah. But like, I fucking love dragons. And I feel like we haven't seen dragons in
fantasy in a while. I think they kind of fell out of fashion for favor of elves. Okay. So we also learned that Violet and Mira had a brother whose name was Brennan. Brennan died fighting in the Teary Rebellion. And Brennan was the general's favorite child. Mira froze Brennan's death in the general's face, asking whether she wishes to bury another child.
Oof. Which I think the general's answer, honest answer, would have been yes. Yes, I do. I'm fine with that. Yep. No worries. So this causes the general to tell Mira to leave, and she does. When the general and Violet are alone, the general tells Violet that as soon as she enters the Conscription Day thing that she won't be able to acknowledge Violet for three years since she'll be her far superior officer, and it would be inappropriate. Violet remarks inwardly that
it won't be much different than the current state of thing, which woof. It also seems like A, no shit. B, she does get acknowledged because they're going to school, so the general is there. There, and involved in, I don't know, choosing the elite military, so like, I can't acknowledge you is intense. I feel like... I feel like it's just an excuse for her to be a bitch, right? Yeah. Because acknowledgement is different than like favoritism. Right, like I can't talk to
you. Like we can't hang out or whatever. Right. Or can't, yeah, I can't favor you. I can't help you when you're there. Not that you would anyway, bitch. Right. Which is totally fair, but to not even look at her daughter, like she does sometimes in the future of this book, that we'll see, like, she's good god. Yeah, for no fucking reason. Yeah. So Violet leaves and meets Mira outside the office, and Mira does the same thing for Violet that Brennan did for her when it was her Conscription Day, which is to say, basically, to take her to a room, repack her things, and like, basically get her
more prepared than she is for this trial. Not at all. Yeah. So the theory that I had earlier, I am gonna voice because I'm curious. And maybe I saw this on Tic Tac. Maybe this is not an original plot. What if Violet is not Sorongale's daughter? Like, is like a bastard child from her husband? Maybe. I just why would it matter? I just want to know why she hates her so much.
That's all I want. I really I just want some explanation as to why her mom hates her. It feels like at some point in this series, if we don't get a satisfying answer to that question, it will significantly reduce how I think about this book. You too. Because it is such a pivotal concept in this book and like the flashpoint of why we're here. That if the author doesn't explain
it, like for me, there's two reasons. One, either the general is purely evil and fucking hates Violet and everybody else and is actively plotting against her husband. Everyone, yeah. Or two, she's, she actually thinks that what she's doing is good and she's trying to set her daughter up for success to like have this big future and like help everybody, but she doesn't want to let the evil people onto the fact that that's what she's doing. So she's like playing this part, you know. But then why would she support Mira? I don't know. I agree. If we don't get a satisfactory answer,
it's it very much could like ruin my ever even recommending the book. Yeah. I mean, it is telling I think that Mira and Violet don't look anything alike. Yeah. So I guess it could be possible. I just find it difficult to believe that like a person in General Soren Gale's position could get away with having a third kid and not being visibly pregnant. No, that's true. And like, I also don't think I would like that. It's pretty weak. It's, it's a little weak. Like why, why?
Why would you hate? Yeah. Yeah, like it feels a little game of thronesy. It does. Yeah. Um, just I just I need to know why. And I think I think even as we go through the book, like this question of why is going to come up more and more because so many decisions are based around this, this pivotal thing, like I said, and it's just I'm really hoping that number of the book number two delivers on it. Yes. I don't know why you dragged that SF for so long. That was creepy.
Anyway, in this process, we we find out that Violet is a yet another heroine that's good with daggers. Oh, goody. Oh, goody. Good, good. How unique. Never seen that before. Never, ever. So as I mentioned, Miraphasita rip out all the bullshit that Violet has put in her pack. It seems like the Rucksack is the only thing that they're allowed to take with them in this Conscription Day thing. So of course, Violet has put a much fuck ton of things in it that she doesn't fucking need. Like books. So like only books. Only books. And I'm like, ma'am, you're factually an idiot. Come on.
Also, we find out that like, I mean, I don't know about the actual students, but like there's a library. There is a library that they can visit. She has access to the mill. Like the whole college's library. Like there's no reason it just she's an idiot. She's an idiot. Like we do find one book later that like maybe is special, but she has like 37 books in this pack. Right. So the last thing is that Mira gives her a couple of things. So one of them is a pair of rubber sold boots that will
help her in the trial, which takes place on a bridge 18 inches wide and 200 feet off the ground. She also gives her better fitting clothing that so that Violet will be more agile and she won't have like fabric for people to grab on to right because not only is the challenge itself of getting through this this bridge harrowing, but it's basically open season for different different other competitors to try to kill you essentially. Yeah, everything leading up to and to the end
of the bridge is just a free for all of death. A free for all of death. Part of the clothing that she gives her is basically this breastplate made of dragon scales. And it doesn't really matter how but essentially dragons are huge, right? So it's not like one big dragon scale. Mira used the power of somebody that she knows just to shrink down the scales and their scales of her own dragons. So she like had this vest made for Violet to keep her safe.
Which is I gotta say without this help like Violet would be fucking dead. She would be dead 10 times over without this. Real dead. So Mira, one of the last things that she does is she braids Violet's hair because Violet refuses to cut it so she braids it in like a crown along her head so that nobody can grab it. And she tries to like pack in all of these nuggets of wisdom before Violet has to enter the trial. She tells her never to be without her daggers or her armor to always be aware and observant. The other cadets we're gonna are definitely gonna be harder on Violet because of who she is. She's a soaring gale and they're just not gonna like that.
And so they're having this moment but then the gong rings out or whatever and they know it's time to go down to the gates where the others are gathered to enter the trial. As they go down there there's also empty carts for the people who die for like the bodies. Bring out your dead! Bring out your dead! Very that. And Mira, Mira and Violet see this and it becomes a real right? So Mira hugs Violet and tells her that she loves her and I have prediction one which is that Mira is gonna die at some point. Yeah because she's the only friend. So as they walk Mira tells Violet
to find Dane Atoes who used to be Violet's friend and love interest before he joined the writers the prior year. Mira goes on to say that he will keep her safe but definitely don't sleep with him because she doesn't want to be seen as sleeping her way to the top and Mira is like or Violet's like yeah sure whatever. She does caveat that even though she shouldn't sleep with Dane she should sleep around but only with first years right? Like she doesn't know what the next day will bring. She should live her life and have fun and I like that sex positivity. Yeah. She counsels Violet to
seek not friendship but rather to forge alliances and to remember that everybody is out there for their own game. That bleak. In line for the roll call they see a young blonde man with markings on his skin and we learn that he along with all of the other children of the Tyre Tyrush rebellion were marked by General Melgrin's dragon as separatists. So General Melgrin is essentially General Soaringale's boss. He's the head honcho and this Tyrush rebellion was when a part of
Navar tried to rebel against the government and all of the rebellion leader's children were marked as rebel leader's children. You might think wow that sounds really shitty. It gets worse. Violet also finds this cruel but she admits that one of the first rules of the Basquiat college is to never question a dragon as they tend to incinerate anybody that they find rude. So it wasn't that necessarily that General Melgrin made this decision in a vacuum. His dragon
was the one that marked them and so his dragon was in on the decision. You can't say no to a dragon. Nope. So this conversation prompts Mira to remember that Zaden Rheorson is currently a third year writer and she warns Violet to stay away from him as he will kill her on the spot once he realizes who she is. This is because his father was someone named the great betrayer in the Tyrush rebellion. So he was essentially the leader of all of this. We go on to learn that not only
were the children marked but all of the rebel leader's children were conscripted also as punishment for the sins of their parents. So these children do not get a choice between faction so to speak. They have to join the riders and specifically the riders not the infantry. So like we're gonna put you where you're most likely to die but also gives you the most power if you don't die. Right. That's a little weird. No I feel like put them in the infantry if you wanted them to die.
Right or if you don't want them to have any power because those are just like runs I would imagine. We don't really know. We like never see any. Well and okay so going back to one of the main problems that I have with this book is social constructs that don't make any fucking sense. So we learned from Violet's internal monologue that the riders is the only quadrant of this school that does and the military by extension that doesn't accept conscriptions. They only accept volunteers except when it comes to the children
of rebel leaders I guess and there's a lot. It's not just like five guys. There's like 80 fucking kids. It's a ton. It doesn't make any sense like make okay you don't accept conscriptions but you're gonna accept this large group of conscriptions over here that are gonna take place for the next 20 years or so. Yeah because there's still like children of traders that are like six so they're still up and coming. Yeah that doesn't make sense to me. No it doesn't make
sense to me either especially when we learn like the power that you do get like. It seems like a big liability. Yeah also let's not punish children for the sins of their fathers but if you're going to make it make sense. So they're standing in line and at this point Mira is recognized because she's kind of famous not just for being a Soaringale but also for being kind of a fearless warrior and this kind of makes Violet shrink a little bit. She's like oh I really didn't want this to happen
and she really just didn't want to be recognized as a Soaringale. So there's some person in line behind them talking shit and Violet just kind of rolls her eyes and brushes him off doesn't let him get to her. They also run into two people that they're introduced to so one of them is named Dylan and one of them is named Ranin and they're essentially the two people in front of Violet in line so when Violet signs in and she has to say goodbye to Mira she talks to them and we learned that both
Dylan and Ranin have been training their entire lives to become writers and they're so fucking excited and this is in direct contrast with what we just talked about with the constricted rebel children like not everybody's happy to be here. Oh also should be mentioned Violet doesn't have a choice either. No also the other thing that I feel like can be mentioned is because the rebel children are conscripted they did have the luxury of training their whole lives. Yes yes they did not. So it's at this point that I want to bring up my other major issue with this book
that lasted for most of the book. This book is essentially Divergent with Dragons. If you've read Divergent there are so many similarities and like yeah okay we can argue all day that they're different stories fine but allow me to tell you the similarities that we have thus far and I will keep going throughout this entire episode and series of episodes because I have at least 10 points so I'll bring them up as they come up. First of all we have the main character who
is a weak girl joining the hardcore career group that's what happens in Divergent and that's what happens here. Granted in Divergent she chooses that here Violet doesn't I don't give a shit. Everyone expects them to fail immediately so there's this test right away which we are getting to the test of crossing the bridge and in Divergent they have to jump onto a moving train both of which if you miss you die the first test of like you chose the thing cool. We also have the
general plot of like war and rebellions going on um so that's three points I just hand up like five fingers and had to bring it down to three. I have more that I will bring up as we go but I wanted to start now so that it can be fresh in your minds as we continue. I remember when we first read this book you were saying how some of the scenes even word for word or scene by scene feel like they came out of Divergent? Yes so when we get to a little bit later this is a spoiler I think
because you know like it's war college and Violet is our main character she's not gonna die. Yeah I don't know if she dies later. They get two scenes of sparring on mats and those scenes I swear are almost verbatim from Divergent just with different names put in like the way that they're partnered up to fight each other and then the rankings of that and it just it seems all the same. Also one point I forgot to mention is we have Dane who's like this childhood friend that
love interest that's also in Divergent there is a childhood childhood friend that is in the like badass faction that was a love interest and it just it's been a while since I read this book so the scenes that felt identical I can't call out as quickly but the ones that I do really think about are the sparring mat vibes and when they eventually get to like their bunker it's the fucking same it's the same. Yeah I'm really surprised with that many similarities that there's not like a
a copyright infringement or like an intellectual property suit filed. I know and I even tried to when you first saw this book I was looking online to see like am I the only one who sees this like is it me and there's not a lot like there were a couple um book reviews that are like hey guys is this is this like Divergent to you but no one seems as like fiery I've never seen it on TikTok like I've only it's not that like I know everything that's on TikTok but I've never
seen this issue come up and it kind of bugs me because I really liked Divergent and I just fine and I don't know for Becquioiros got inspiration you can pull inspiration it just feels like she took this entire story and added dragons. Yeah and I will add more points I'm not done there are more. Thank you for coming to my TED talk this is intermission. This is intermission we will return the bar is now open. So Violet and Dylan and Rhiannon and then the jerk behind them
are all ascending this tower with the preparation of going to this bridge and they're talking not the asshole but Dylan and Rhiannon and uh Violet and as they talk we learn that writers are at the top of the hierarchy in this military order and they get perks along with that so some of those perks are dress code the dress code is not as strict as long as they're wearing black they get status right so kind of that prestige and then they also get the right to marry someone sooner than other officers in the military and that has to do with the fact that they have a
much shorter life expectancy. Dylan in particular has someone waiting at home for him and he's very excited to graduate and be able to go back to them ASAP. As we get to the top of the platform the jerk behind Violet that was talking shit catches up and continues to talk shit. He says things about Violet like she doesn't look like her family she's gonna die immediately what a weakling blah blah blah blah. As Violet's kind of tuning this out she looks down and she realizes Rhiannon's boots are smooth so she makes Rhiannon swap left boots with her so that they can each
have one rubber sold boot. This is just for the bridge crossing and she says as much and Rhiannon's just like oh okay but it goes along with it. We learned that the bridge and the ravine so the crossing this entire thing claim about 15 percent of all candidates who want to join the writers. When Violet and the other two get to the front there are three writers that are taking names and metering them out on the bridge right so they all just don't go out on a crush they like basically time them so if somebody wants to sabotage somebody else they have to like either catch up or slow
down to get to them. Which is doable but I did appreciate that it's not just like 47 people go onto this essentially tightrope balance beam situation bye bye. One of these writers stops Violet dead in her tracks he's described thusly quote he's tall with windblown black hair and dark brows the line of his jaw is strong and covered by warm tawny skin and dark stubble and when he folds his arms across his torso the muscles in his chest and arms ripple moving in
a way that makes me swallow and his eyes his eyes are the shade of gold flecked onyx the contrast is startling jaw dropping even everything about him is his features are so harsh that they look carved and yet they're astonishingly perfect like an artist who worked a lifetime sculpting him and at least a year of that was spent on his mouth. I knew immediately that this was not only a love interest but the boy she's supposed to stay away from. The forbidden fruit as a toy. Zaden Rheorzen.
Big trouble in little china she even says he is quote get you into trouble and you like it level of hot. Which I feel like we've all known at least one of those and it is it is a what's word I want to say like a tempting fruit. Yeah it is it is something that's hard to say no to for sure. Yes and Violet finds that it's it's like an electric shock down her spine that she sees this person is and it is that is attracted to him. Rheanna and of course Alts Violet because they're
taking names and Zaden is immediately like oh you're a sorengale. He seems to know Rheanna though and is intrigued by the fact that Rheanna is looking out for Violet so he like notices the fact that they're both wearing the same pair of shoes for example and Violet has absolutely no chill because she immediately asks Zaden if he's gonna kill her. Which like girl come on are you going to murder me right now because my sister said you were gonna murder me on site and you haven't killed me yet so like how long do I have to live. Also you're pretty okay okay but just then they
look out on the bridge and they see Dylan who slips and falls to his death and that's when Zaden remarks that he doesn't have to kill Violet because the bridge is gonna do it for him. Damn. Rheanna goes and tells Violet that she'll waver her on the other side and then it's Violet's turn. As Violet starts her turn she hears one of the other writers remarked to Zaden that he thought that the general sorengale only had one daughter and Violet tells him kind of over his shoulder that she gets fed a lot and I love the snark of Violet. It's one of the things that I did appreciate early on in this book.
Yes and I will say that in my comparison tonight too divergent Violet is more quickly an elicable character I think. She has more of a like rounded personality um yeah and her snark is legit but may I just say that that comment does lend a little bit to my theory I made that maybe she's not her daughter. It does kind of yeah so as Violet starts her turn she hears the jerk
behind her give his name and we learn that it's Jack Barlow. He is going to be the grade A bully for the book spoilers and as she's kind of cautiously moving out he goes to push her and Violet like really starts moving after that she moves a lot faster. Yeah she feels herself start to panic as she's crossing the bridge because not only is the bridge small but it's also storming out and I've also read fan theories that say that the mother called the storm to intentionally kill Violet which I think is very interesting. I do think it's interesting because the storm does
come up when she is like halfway across and then seems to fizzle out when she finishes. But again why if that is true why? I know why do you why why are you so obsessed with me? Why are you so obsessed with me? So as she starts to panic Violet's crossing the bridge and she starts to calm herself by reciting memorized history which I think is a clever bit of information dumping. Usually like we get it in like conversations or just block text but I liked that we got a little bit of context in this in this particular context so what do we learn? Oh no I thought
you were asking what we learned and I was like I'm not ready. No I was gonna say we frequently hate on information dumps but like you said this is a really interesting way to do it. It gives us good background of the world that we do need without being boring and it makes sense for the character because again she trained as a scribe she knows all the history and all the knowledge. Yeah she's a bookworm. She's a bookworm and it's it's such a natural it's a realistic coping mechanism too. Yeah that's the one yeah. So we learned a couple of things. First we learned that
the continent is home to two kingdoms who have been at war for 400 years. Navarre is the larger of the two and Tyrendor where the Tyrage rebellion took place is the largest and southernmost province. Tyrendor shares a border with Pomoriel which is the other kingdom that they're at war with. These kingdoms have different and complementary economies and despite the war they have agreed to like trade between them four times a year which seems relatively civil I guess. It just seems so weird to be like okay we're at war except for these times when like we actually really need each other.
Right peace for like two days thank you. And then we're gonna go back to fighting like maybe that's a good um crutch to start I don't know building an alliance since you clearly need each other. Right. What. So as Violet's making her way and reciting and trying to bring herself down she makes for the sake of looking back at Jack and she sees him throw the candidate behind him off the bridge to this person's death. Like eats him off the bridge. Yeah not a great guy. And then Jack starts coming for her so Violet starts running from him and she's determined either to fall or
succeed but to not let the asshole kill her which I appreciate. So much respect for that. Right. As Jack gains on her he keeps talking shit like a homicidal maniac and he catches her at the entrance of the other side of the bridge. He tries to tackle her but she grabs a dagger and holds it to his balls. Cut his balls off. Sorry. She's been given the option of what to do because she's technically made it across the bridge and she's a fully fledged cadet but as Jack hasn't crossed the finish line yet he is technically fair game. If she were to harm him or even kill him she wouldn't
be violating any of the rules of the college and so basically the people who are there the writers are like your move funny man. But Violet ultimately decides to be merciful and lets Jack go and I can't help but think that was a mistake and looking forward into the book that I've already read it was a mistake. Also here's my next point on Divergent. There is a clearly psychotic male character that is gunning for the lead female for no real reason. Yep. Other than spite. I've
been I've been he's a psychotic idiot. Yeah. So yeah. Awesome. Awesome. Awesome sauce. Also I do like the your move funny man and she should have cut his balls off like fine make him she should have at least stab him but she should have at least stabbed him in the testicles. Yeah stab him in the testicles and then hit his carotid artery. Yeah. So he bleeds out. Yeah. Yeah. So at the beginning of each chapter we get a little excerpt from what we assume to be literature from in world
and I have not been writing them down but I am going to read you one now and a couple later on because they tell us something about the world. So this one is quote blue dragons descend from the extraordinary word I can't pronounce line known for their formidable size. They are the most ruthless especially in the case of the rare blue dagger tail whose knife like spikes at the tip of their tail can disembowel an enemy with one flick. So this is the first information that we get about dragons and what kinds there are. We go on to learn that there are also red dragons green
dragons black dragons etc. It was so stoked to meet the dragons because again I love dragons because it's dragon tales dragon tales let's suck nope I fucked it up. Okay. So Violet reunites with Rhiannon inside the writer's side of the college and they celebrate that they both made it alive. Rhiannon is incredibly grateful for the boot. She says that she surely would have fallen to her death without it. As they go further in Violet is clearly injured
and lightheaded from all of the adrenaline and she's like kind of almost fainting. They quickly run into Dane who has gone from cute to gorgeous in Violet's estimation. He's got a beard now and some scars and he's harder than the last time Violet remembers him so no longer the soft boy of her childhood. Dane and Rhiannon kind of get into it over feeling protective over Violet which I do love. Like Dane's like who the fuck are you and Rhiannon's like who the fuck are you bro? I do really love that. Yeah and Violet's just like Dane, Rhiannon, Rhiannon, Dane. Chill. We're all friends
here. Yeah and Dane even asks like do you even trust her and Violet's like yes I do. Can you calm the fuck down? Dane for real like if Mira treats Violet like she's a drinking Violet put them. Dane super does. Oh 100%. So much like it's it's disgusting. So Dane accepts that and he tells Rhiannon to go tell the person in charge of roll call that he's admitted them both to his quadrant. He is a squad leader which is unheard of for a second year so he's got a very impressive track
record apparently so far. When Dane and Violet are alone he curses the fact that she's even there and he clearly still cares for her. He's out of his mind with worry that she was crossing the bridge, he doesn't understand what's happening and he takes her to his room for so they can talk privately. Violet is very happy once they get there that the only thing of personality in his room is a book that she gave him in the Kroflin language. At this point I was wondering if this was YA or Y
Choose because there are at least two potential love interests of course of Dane and Zaden but I was also a little afraid that Jack might be a potential love interest I'm glad he's not but you know books do that, books do that. Books do be doing that and honestly I would even be fine with the Y Choose with Dane and Zaden at some point but I really don't think that's gonna happen. No and it better not. We'll talk about fan theories at the end but I'm not a fan of the fan theories.
I'm not either at least the ones that we have right now in the beginning of November. Correct I'm sure there will be spoilers galore. Once they're alone Dane and Violet confess how much they've missed each other and Violet starts tending to her knee so this is where we learned that not only is she weak physically but her ligaments are weak too because she has that that chronic disease and so the knee injury that she got when she was crossing the bridge and Jack tackled her is worse than it would be otherwise. As she's tending to her knee Dane and Violet
flirt with each other and Violet is ecstatic that they both seem to be on the same page in terms of wanting the other or at least being interested but all too soon they have to hurry back to the main area because they don't want to be caught essentially alone in a compromising position. And like they got places to be I presume. Well it's kind of a like a big adieu in the the main area it feels like Dane should be there to be like I don't know coordinating his people or something. Yeah yes. Yeah on their way back Dane again tells Violet that she that he can't believe she's there
and he's clearly very angry with her mother at forcing her to be so. Yeah. He tells her that there's a back way from the writer's quad into the scribe quad and he'll take her through that but this raises Violet's hackles. Dane skirts around the fact that Violet's weak and that she you know won't really survive and Violet takes a lot of offense at this and Dane tells her eventually that he's just trying to protect her because he doesn't want to see his best friend die.
He asks her to please let him save her. Violet tells him that her mother said she'd haul her back to the writer's quad if she left so she'll either leave as a writer or a name on a stone. Which again this is this is well this is the first time we see that Violet does have a way out there is a way out the last time we're gonna see this and she says no I mean sure we get sort of the consequence that her mom would bring her back anyway but we'll learn later that like she
couldn't even do that if she wanted to. Well and okay what happened to not acknowledging her right like yeah so like she wouldn't if you can't be acknowledged you're not gonna be dragged back. Right I mean come on be consistent. It doesn't make any sense. So they go back to the main area where everybody else is but they go through different ways as they're not keen to give everyone leverage that they know each other or they might even be you know close. Violet meets back up with Rihanna who introduces her to another woman Tara and Tara is confident like Mira and Violet kind of gets the impression that Rihanna might be into her. After the trial we learned that
301 candidates survived to become cadets and 67 did not. Bring out you dead. Bring out you dead. I'm not dead. Sorry. I'm feeling better. I'm feeling better really. So there's a common daunt leading the ceremony that closes the trial and this man's name is Pancek. We learn a little bit about him that apparently he's angling for General Sorengeil's position and then he wants to go for General Melgren's position but Violet reveals that Melgren's signet power allows him
to see the outcome of any battle before it happens basically seeing the future and there's no fucking way that anybody else would lead the the military without that power. Right. Like he would have to die before anyone came next. Right. Do we know what Pancek's signet power is? Um I don't think we do. Interesting. So we learned through this ceremony that only about a fourth of the cadets will live to graduation. Jesus. So this is where we were talking about before.
Like you don't get a second chance. Like once you're here you either become a writer or you die which again what are we doing here? What are we doing here? Why are the stakes so high for a character whose stakes don't need to be this high? Right. It's just immediately everybody's at 100. Yeah. We also learned that the wing leader's word is law. So the way that this school is organized is that there are four wings so there are four leaders and then they of course all have their
leadership team. So when we say the wing leader's word is law there's four of these people. So each of the four wings has three sections in it and each of those sections has three squads. So it's it's kind of that pyramidic pyramidical. It's the pyramidical kind of hierarchy that you usually associate with military. Each squad has about 15 to 16 people in it so 15 to 16 times three times three times four that's how many people are in the college. Which makes me basically wonder
what happens if I mean so 67 died and I guess there's not a lot of candidates to volunteer. But these are very evenly spaced and there's there's like three years of school right there's like first year, second year, third year. So I wonder like and this it surely doesn't matter but I'm curious how big the squads have ever been or how small they've ever been. I am too and we kind of get a little bit of indication that they are smaller than they used to be because the number of dragons has been old. Oh right yes. But we don't get proportions right so of the 540 people
ostensibly that are in the school right now, 301 of them came from the new fresh recruits. So that means that the death rate has to be pretty high which kind of speaks to the quarter of cadets will live to graduate thing but Jesus. Yeah. So anyway we learned that Violet and Rhiannon are in the second wing of Dane and that Jack Barlow is in the first wing so they're in completely different sections. Hopefully Violet doesn't have to worry about him too much. During this kind of organization of the new cadets Violet catches Zaden looking at her and she squares her
posture trying to show that she's not intimidated but then for some reason this kind of interaction leads to their their whole squad Dane included being moved into Zaden's wing so they were not in Zaden's leadership and now they are and Zaden seems real fucking smug about it. And like Zaden orchestrates this right like oh very clearly he goes to talk to the other wing leader and he's like hey I want that that squad and the wing leader's like sure bro sure bro I don't give a shit this sort of and I'm just a little salty at least we can in this book this sort of taps into the whole
like this book didn't need to be this long this didn't need to happen because it doesn't mean anything like they could have just been assigned to Zaden from the get-go and you have the same issues. Well and you could have if you wanted it to be the thing that Zaden was looking out for Violet fine but you could have said like oh you know Zaden made that request before like the ceremony even happened right like you could have woven that in still yeah yeah so in this as kind of the final part of this ceremony we learned a couple of things about dragons um as the ceremony rinsed down
eight dragons joined them and perched on the outer walls we learned that dragons don't tolerate humans who aren't bonded to them and so they really don't like going near strangers they've got a big stranger danger thing. Stranger danger! Not only this but they need humans to develop signabilities from bonding and that allows them to weave protective wards that power um basically the protection of all of Navarre so in this war that they're locked in these protective wards are crucial and that's why writers are such a big component of the military. I did I do really like the way
um the author creates this symbiotic relationship with the dragons and the writers because we do learn later that the dragons have their own social hierarchies so like they don't serve the writers nor do the writers serve the dragons like they're very much separate entities that have to work together and I just I really liked that it was a really interesting way to look at it. I feel like so often the dragon is just essentially like a pet, a tool. Exactly. Yeah
not a sentient being of its own. Right or not a sentient being that has like its own entire political structure. Right so once the dragons join them this intimidates some of the cadets and they run screaming toward the doors to this kind of arena and over these doors the there's this motto carved quote a dragon without its writer is a tragedy, a writer without their dragon is dead which you probably have heard in relation to this book. It's a nice and succinct way to describe the world but basically the reality of this is that once you're bonded to a dragon
you cannot live without the dragon so if the dragon dies and you're perfectly healthy guess what you're dying to but dragons live just fine without their bonded right so if one of their current bonded writer perishes they'll go on to bond with another writer. These I understand why the scene happens because it also shows like the fearlessness of the dragons. What did these people think they were signing up for? Did you think you were gonna ride puppies? Like of course they're scary. I don't I don't understand what you thought you were here for. I don't either and the
people who flee are incinerated by the dragons. This is their fluke. Can't be tolerated, can't be given a second chance no no no no no they must be killed immediately and during this whole thing Violet has a staring contest with the biggest dragon ahead of her which is a blue one and finally Zaden makes closing remarks that half of these cadets will be dead by the same time a year from now a third of them a year after that and he pointedly says that no one cares who your mommy or your daddy is that everyone's treated the same. He remarks that even King
Tauri's second son died in the threshing the threshing is of course when they choose a dragon and King Tauri is the king of Dvar. Which oof sorry I was just saying did make a prediction here that there was going to be some bonding cross bonding thing with Violet and the blue dragon. I didn't make that prediction at this point I just predicted that that was definitely Zaden's dragon. See I actually didn't make that connection I just assumed there was going to be some issue with Violet and this dragon like the dragon was going to bond with her and like
project their previous rider or something. Oh my god that would be wild. I know! So the college is in full swing now and some morning later all of the cadets are in regulation gear they've slept in communal barracks and they're all at an assembly listening to the names of the dead who didn't cross the bridge. Which is such a fun way to start every morning. Exactly. So fortunately for Violet Jack Barlow is on a completely different floor of the barracks than
she is so she was not harassed essentially in the middle of the night. Dane meanwhile is really good at pretending he doesn't know Violet doesn't even give her the time of day which she's fine with. It seems like this is the first official day of class and so they learned that they will go to whatever they have for class and then they will spar in the evening and that is considered quote gym class. Yep. They're all preparing for the next big challenge which is called the gauntlet
and this is a terrifying vertical obstacle course that will happen in two months and then after directly after this gauntlet there will be a presentation where the dragons will get their first look at the cadets. Two days after that will be the threshing so they're preparing for ultimately the threshing which is when they will be hopefully bonded with the dragon. I was so glad that we get this like sequence of events and that the sequence is short so it's not like yes
it's just a couple months to get through this it's not going to be an unreasonable amount of tasks and like wild things that getting through it is going to take six books just to like get to your dragon so. Well and it kind of makes sense too because like not only is there a high death rate but not everybody's going to bond with the dragon and so essentially they don't want to teach you all of the like advanced dragon earring if you will if you're not going to bond with a dragon and we we see an example of what they call a repeat cadet so somebody who joined the prior year but
then didn't bond with the dragon and so basically he's having to go through the whole process again because you can't quit unless you die. Yeah. Um but yeah so I I appreciate it too that that was succinct and it doesn't feel like it takes forever right at the pacing of that particular part is good. Yeah and it also doesn't feel rushed like it feels like a realistic pacing of getting through these trials to get to your dragon. Yeah so this repeat cadet that I mentioned his name is Sawyer and he's kind of tasked to lead the new cadets in Dane's section around so they don't get lost.
Maybe. So as everybody kind of breaks off to head to class Dane signals for Violet and Rhianna covers for her so that she can meet with them. She meets Dane in the rotunda where there are six statues of dragons prominently in their different colors red green brown orange blue and black. When she meets him Dane asks if she's okay whether anything tried anything with her and for Violet she describes Dane's worry as sitting on her chest like a stone and this is the first indication that we have that Violet's really chafing under
this kind of suffocating amount of worry and angst that Dane is putting upon her. And complete lack of any sort of belief in her. Right. She protests to Dane that she's fine. She ate. She rewrapped her knee. Everything's fine. She goes on to ask him why their squad was moved and he confirms it's because Zaden wanted her dead. This fact is apparently also common knowledge in the leadership cater which super comforting. Right. And this is where Dane also confirms that the dragon that Violet had a steering contest with is Zaden's dragon. So.
He describes this dragon as being vicious and says that that's a perfect pair for Zaden so there are two peas in a vicious pod. Which damn bro tell me how you really feel. Truly. It feels very much like I don't know. Dane's at a hundred with this. From the get go bro. Like it really blows my mind that for a college that's supposed to be eventually working as a team there's a lot of self motivation and backstabbing happening here
like even amongst the bonded writers. Yes. And it that that also doesn't make sense to me. No. And it goes back to the whole thing of like the only reason that Zaden does like that Dane doesn't like Zaden and that Zaden and you know like his posse are like outcasts is because they're writers. They're sorry not their writers because they're rebel kids. Right. Like it's this inherent prejudice. It's not that they're actually assholes. It's that they showed up and everybody had this preconception notion about them. Yeah. And we see that too. Like even when we see other rebel kids
like they're kind of portrayed to be like harsher and harder but none of them are assholes. Like they're just no other students. I mean Jack is not a rebel kid and he's an asshole. Right. Exactly. Yeah. Prejudice is a good word. Just that it's just based on that and nothing in like reality. So Zaden's dragon's name is scale and I'm probably saying that wrong. It's S G A E Y L and I'm so sorry but the TikToker didn't have that one pronounced so we're going
with scale. We're doing our best. If we figured out before the next episode we will make a correction. Yes. We go on to learn that Dane's own dragon is a red sword tail named calf and Violet admits that she's having trouble reconciling this Dane that she's seeing now with the old Dane that she knows. Right. He's definitely more mistrustful more hard around the edges. Right. Like a war hardened person and Dane tells her that he's still the same on the inside. Okay. He tells her
that his sign of power is the ability to read a person's recent memories if they touch if he touches them but that it's not common knowledge because they want to use him in intelligence. So basically keep it on the the down low. Dane goes on to say that whatever Zaden will end up doing to Violet he will likely stay within the codex because he respects the rules of the school and the last thing that he admits to Violet was that he was quote really close to a now third year wing leader which I immediately intuited meant that he and this person were sleeping together. 100%
Hoba. Zaden staying within the codex also means that he can't just outright kill Violet. Right. Yeah. That's against the rules unless it's in a challenge. Yes. Situation but also telling me the wing leaders won't will very rarely be in a challenge situation with the cadets. Yes. But I've seen foreshadowing before. I've seen foreshadowing before and I I know this book. Yeah. So when they exit their tryst of course they run smack and is Aiden who accuses them of
being way too obvious and for some reason Dane tells Violet to run and she does which we just talked about how he can't do anything to you. Right. Like way to have zero chill and it seems just like run like why also do you know how suspicious you look running like you're allowed to talk to him. I just Dane just Dane. I have to file it like why are you running I would be like why. Yeah. So at the beginning of the next chapter we get an intro bit that is from Lilith
Sorengale's deposition essentially and we learned that Lilith is the first name of Violet's mother so General Sorengale is General Lilith Sorengale and in this deposition we learned that she objected to the forcible conscription of rebel leaders children into ridership and that's the only thing we get out of it. We don't know the context we don't know the questions we don't know anything more about this. Which is interesting in retrospect. Yes. Then we're in battle brief which is the
class that everyone takes together so it's the only class that this happens all first through third year cadets. Violet ruminates that she's happy to be sat with all the first years though she wishes she could remember all their names and I'm like girl why. I know why because again most of them are going to be dead so why waste the brain power. Yeah it seemed like this there was a couple of other things and I'm kind of blanking on what the specifics are but this is a really specific thing that I call out. She has these like moments that I think are meant to give her kind of a bleeding heart that just don't quite land because she says things like oh I wish I could
remember all their names but then she doesn't go out of her way to like get to know any of these people. No. And she actively is like watching her back and I'm like so then why do you care about who these people are. Yeah you're right those things are a bit contrary to her personality or like what they're trying to do. Right it's like she's trying to be like a peace love and everybody but she's not. Doesn't act that way. Well and we'll find not in this episode but later like the only time she really is in a way to learn about people is to use it against them.
Yep 100% which like girl get it but but let's not pretend. So Battle Brief is exactly what it sounds like. It's a historical and strategy based class meant to prepare the cadets for war and they take this class every day. It's the only class that they have every day. There is a scribe that assists Professor De Vera and this scribe's name is Professor Markham. Both Markham and De Vera recognize Violet and Markham
visibly mourns philosophy of Violet as the star pupil through a brief but public sigh. Zero chill. Zero chill just like my disappointment is palpable. The two professors go on to talk about how important scribes are to continue the education of writers and Violet remarks that that is precisely why she wanted to be one but this is why we can't have nice things. But again scribes are so valued so I don't understand why it seems like such a
problem for her mom because they're clearly respected. Like he is in Battle Brief. He is privy to all of this. He's preparing the material for Battle Brief. So like what is with the disdain? I don't get it. What is with the disdain? What is with the timing of the disdain? You were married to a scribe. And yeah you let your daughter do scribe training for 19 and a half years. Right. I have to think that something changed because it's a very specific time window. Six
months right? Yes it is. So like I really hope that between Brennan's death a year ago or sorry but they don't they don't really give us a timing on Brennan's death. No I don't think so. If I remember correctly. No we. It was her dad that died a year ago. Yeah. So between the dad's death a year ago and then six months something had to have happened to make the mom have this wild change of heart. Yeah and I really hope we get an answer to that. And I hope it's a good one. I know because getting a bad one is going to be just as bad as not getting one at all for me.
I would rather not have one. Me too because then I could just have my own theories and be like well at least my theory is good. Right. So in battle brief they get they get briefed about an attack along the border and we learned that griffins were part of this attack. Griffins can also bond with humans and channel signet powers but dragons are the only creatures able to power wards that make all other magic but their own null and void. So it's important to understand this concept so I'll say it a little bit differently. Griffins and dragons have magic. They both bond with humans
and this allows those humans to have signet powers but dragons through bonding with humans can create magical wards that once other magical users cross that they can't use their magic. So dragon writers and dragon magic users are good but if you write a griffin or if you write a donkey and you channel magic you can't do it inside these wards. A magical donkey. I was curious. I really liked that we see griffins because I feel like that's not a very common mythical creature that we see in these books and it made me wonder what other creatures are out there. Yeah it made me wonder
too. I was like oh that's interesting. I really hope that we get more exposition on that world, that part of the world in the next book. Me too. So Violet at first asks questions through Rhiannon and then gets called out by Professor Markham and starts asking directly. The gist is that the griffins during this attack were clearly looking for something but neither professors know what that thing was still. And this um Violet's questioning does serve to show how shrewd she is to like
kind of read between the lines. Mm-hmm yeah she has a sharp brain. Later they go to sparring class and Violet strikes a deal with Rhiannon and Sawyer to help them with their history work if they help her with hand-to-hand combat because she's woefully bad at it. This is another divergent where some friend steps up to help the weak one learn to fight after hours. Wow friendship. Magic. Violet also witnesses Jack sparring and he ends up snapping the neck of the cadet that he's sparring
with but it's unclear if the cadet actually died. Have you to guess he did? I don't really know how you can snap someone's neck and then they don't die but yeah never tried. It's very clear that these sparring classes and the sparring like competitions that we'll get to is one of the ways where people can lose their lives. Yes. Violet spars with a rebel kid named Imogen who clearly wants Violet dead because of who her mother is but Imogen easily bests Violet and breaks her arm because Violet doesn't yield like a fucking idiot and this causes Dane to completely overreact
and carry Violet bodily to a healer. Oh my god Dane it is her arm she can walk. She's fine. Violet admonishes him for doing so because he freaked out like she meant something to him and now everybody knows it. Um he was also like screaming at her to yield. Even before the arm breaking so then like come on man. He says that she does mean something to him and she ruminates yes that's abundantly clear and now everybody else knows it too. Way to go bucko. Right.
The healer Winifred comes in and it's clear that Winifred knows Violet well. We learned that healers don't have magic but menders do so Violet's brother Brennan was a mender. And it appears that menders can like manifest in any faction right. No menders are or dragon rangers. Oh menders are dragon rangers. My bad disregard I forgot. So Winifred is checking Violet out and determines that she needs a mender and so she calls her husband Nolan over who is a mender. So
to be clear menders must be bonded with a dragon to be able to channel their mender magic. Gotcha gotcha gotcha gotcha. Dane doesn't want Nolan called. He wants to use this injury as an excuse to send Violet to the scribes but Nolan arrives and chastises Dane for doing such a good job of keeping Violet safe and Violet essentially says like Dane get the fuck out of here I'm getting mended. So Violet is kind of fading in and out of pain and she slurs her assent to be mended and this is where Nolan tells her quote I will always mend you and I just have this note why am I a sucker for
grandfather figures like we hardly see Nolan this is like one of the only scenes he's there and it was just so touching. It was just so touching though like I'll always mend you it's just I'm such a sucker. Like it's clear he was mended her before and like all of that stuff. Yeah and like knows her history with her like loosey-goosey joints it's just we love we love a grandfather figure. I know so Nolan mends her and he tells her to expect it to smart for a while and Violet says this thing quote when you're as brittle as I was born the pain of mending is only second to
the pain of the original injury and I'm confused was she born weak or was the fever the thing that made her weak? I don't know I think that was a bit of a mistake. Okay because like if she has this disease it makes sense but then why give her a fever that also like gives her the the hair I don't know. Yeah it was kind of redundant. We learn that mending is incredibly agonizing and so they give Violet leather to bite down on. The subtext during this entire scene is that the writers only
want the absolute strongest people in their ranks and are constantly sniffing around for weakness whether it be physical, mental or otherwise and so not only does Dane want to use this to get her out of the scribes he knows that it's just going to put an even bigger target on her back and Violet knows this too because she is so frail essentially. When Violet gets back to the barracks Rhiannon promises to help her because she's her only friend and Violet crawls into bed and is intending to go to sleep but she ends up finding a journal with a note from Mira under her pillow. This journal is a
combination of Mira and Brennan's combined wisdom during their time at the Basquiathe school. Mira writes to Violet that Brennan would have wanted her to live that she, Mira, wants Violet to live and that she's so proud to be her sister. Meanwhile Rhiannon's checking Tara out across the room. She's just like yeah that's nice girl what? Yeah I do I do like Rhiannon just like. Rhiannon's just into anything with tail just like so sex positive. Which I do really appreciate and I
love how openly gay she is or bisexual. I think she's bi because we just kind of see her around and I love that. Anything with a pulse. Anything with a pulse we're here for it. You have a pulse and you are breathing. Which again we could get a wide choose with Rhiannon up in here I'd be okay with that. I'd be fine with that. So Violet's looking through this journal and she's getting emotional seeing her brother's handwriting. We learned that apparently it's customary to burn
the things of the dead which seems like an overreaction to me. It really does and we don't really get a reason why. It doesn't appear to be like a superstitious thing it's just customary. Which is fine we don't need detail but damn. It felt very utilitarian like as a product of being in the military like you don't need superfluous things kind of feeling. Yeah. But then you don't have anything to remember people by like I just I don't know. I like having things. Yeah. So in the journal Brennan writes that the instructors stack the hand-to-hand matches
intentionally to weed out the weakest quickly. If Mira slash Violet watch earnestly they will know who are pitted against each other and this gives Violet hope to survive. I think they also in this book tell her where the matches are posted I think. Yeah like I don't really remember that. I think it wasn't here to like where and when she can find them. Yeah because she knows like concretely who she's going to go up against like a week in advance. Yeah and I couldn't it does go a little confusing to me later too like if they're publicly posted just like where people
don't really check out or she's like breaking into an office to see them. I feel like she's like breaking in. I think she's breaking into an office. Okay that's kind of what I thought too but I'm pretty sure it's in this passage from Brennan that says like where and when that goes up. So we get another little excerpt and this is an edict that tells us that gatherings of three or more Kdebs carrying rebellion relics so these are the markings that they got from General Melgren's dragon that gatherings of this type will be considered acts of sedition. Okay umbridge. Yeah right.
A few days on we see Violet sneaking around after curfew gathering ingredients for poison. Her book of poisons was the only book that she and Mira decided that she would take with her because it was useful. She knows the challenges begin the following week and she is determined to have an upper hand against her first opponent. On this journey she must climb a tree to retrieve particular berries from a vine and as she starts to head back down berries in hand she sees the woman who broke her arm Imogen and Zaden who both have rebellion relics right and they're just kind
of hanging out near the base of the tree. They speak but Violet can't really hear what they're saying over the rushing river that's nearby but they're soon joined by other writers with rebellion relics almost two dozen in total. Way more than three. Way more than three and Violet is very familiar with this edict and she's like oh this is a problem. This is bad news buyers. In this scene we're introduced to another student named Garrick as well as another second year who is Zaden's cousin and his name is Bodi. The two of them in Imogen seem to be running things along
with Zaden. They are infested in the first in the survival of the first years and this whole thing is basically the four of them checking in on the newest cadets. They're cautioning them not to get into any acts of treason. Don't draw attention to yourself etc etc. It's a pretty innocent conversation just like don't don't fuck this up guys. It's pretty wholesome. They're really just like everybody good. You don't have any problem? Okay everyone doing okay we're here for you. We're all this together. Yep. Don't break the law. One of the new cadets asks Zaden when they get
to kill Violet but Zaden tells them all that Violet is his for the taking. Garrett of all people dissents saying punishing children for the sins of their parents is the Navar way and not the Tyrish way. Yes thank you. Thank you. When they disperse Violet waits a long time before moving because she doesn't want to get caught but of course when she finally does move Zaden catches it. He reveals to her that shadow wielding is his signet power because of course it is. I've read Akatar before and I know that the main love interests always wield shadows. We love these
shadow daddies up in here. Look. They go out to have a surprisingly flirty conversation for two people who are mortal enemies. Yeah it's pretty quick into like the maybe we don't hate each other. Oh very quick. He makes well to you know encourage that he makes no move to kill her or hurt her for one and he even tells her that she should handle Jack Barlow sooner rather than later because he's going to be a problem like giving her advice. Yes. He ends up asking her if Violet's
going to tell on their gathering and she truthfully says no so he ends up leaving her telling her to hurry back to bed before her wing leader realizes that she's broken care for you but of course he's her wing leader. Which is fun. Like don't let don't be cut out here by your wing leader. Me. I love that too because so Violet in her head is just like this is definitely a trap. He's like evil and violent. I'm like girl he's kind of cute. He's real cute and which I he's clearly flirting with you. Yeah and I like this because it's sort of enemies to lovers but they're never
really enemies. Which makes her a better story. Yeah Violet's just the one that's like oh he definitely hates me and he's gonna kill me and Dane is the one that's perpetuating that way. Yeah and Zaden's over here just like what's up girl I like your hair. Hey I'm trying to holler at you. Can I get you. Can I get you. Can I get him. Can I have him. So the next day the challenges begin and Violet wakes up early for breakfast duty and Dane meets her on the way. This seems to be a habit of theirs. They run into Rhiannon and Tara who clearly spent the night
together. Wow wow. Get it Rhiannon. And as we continue on Dane asks endearingly if Violet has been with anybody but she doesn't give him an answer. She's kind of like that's none of your reasons. I love that she doesn't give him an answer. She doesn't do the like of course not Dane. She's just like none none yeah. Yeah none yeah. She's not like I only have eyes for you. No she's like I wouldn't tell you if it was true. He goes on to ask if she'll be okay in the challenge and she tells him not to worry that she has a plan. She knows her opponent will be this kid Orin and
he's not great with a knife or any other weapons but he's got one hell of a punch and I make the prediction that she's going to poison him. It's the telegraphing has been pretty obvious so that wasn't a very difficult prediction to make. Right. So Dane tells us to be careful and to especially avoid Jack Barlow. No shit. Right. Thanks Sherlock. But Violet ruminates how different that advice is from what Zaden told her right. So Zaden told her handle him and Dane's like stay away from him. Which again speaks to maybe we don't know a lot about what
Zaden feels toward Violet yet but it speaks to the complete lack of faith that Dane has in not only Violet's strength but just her like intelligence. Right. Her ability to handle her own shit. Yeah. Or even like her self-preservation like of course she's not going to go fuck around with Jack. Looking for trouble. Yeah. Absolutely. So during her breakfast duties Violet does indeed poison Orin's eggs. Before the challenge we learn in Professor Cowrie's class that red scorpion
tails are the easiest to temper of all the dragons. He cautions the cadets to keep the temperament of dragons in mind during the threshing. And we learn that there are a hundred dragons in total willing to bond this year so far. Though some might change their minds in the two months that remain before the threshing. This 100 dragons is less than last year which is less than the year before that and they don't really have an understanding of why. All we know is that there are fewer and fewer dragons and more attacks on their borders and
a steady supply of writers. So this juxtaposition or this situation doesn't make sense to Violet. Dragons don't share their reasons for not wishing to bond either so there's just kind of this black hole of information that they're trying to make sense of. Though not scientifically proven anecdotally it seems fewer dragons has correlated with more failures of the wars that they helped to power. This is interesting and this is where we get the first inkling that something is not right and that the dragons function under their own decisions. Right and they're not exactly being
100 forthcoming with the humans. No because it and correct me if I'm wrong because I could be misremembering but it doesn't seem like the dragons are dying out it just seems like they're less willing to bond. Correct. Which is really interesting. Crucially and we learn this a little bit later on humans don't know a whole lot about dragons and they aren't allowed into the veil where the dragons breed and essentially live. So actually humans don't have a good idea of how many dragons there are even. Which is fun. I like that the dragons have their own secrets. I do too and I love that
they can have such these these intimate relationships with humans where they literally share minds which we'll get to but can keep secrets like that. Yes because it seems like the humans can't keep secrets from their dragons. Not at all yeah so just really interestingly constructed in this book. So they go on to talk about in this dragon class about Segeal, Zaden's dragon, and we learned that she is one of the rarest dragons. That unfortunately there are no blue dragons this year that are
willing to be bonded but that they should be wary of any blue dragon that they ever come across. Segeal in particular breaks the rules dragons follow like bonding with ancestors of prior writers meaning that she bonded with one of Zaden's ancestors somewhere along the way but we don't know who. She's described as doing whatever she wants whenever she wants because she is the most powerful dragon of all of them. Which I love she just does whatever she wants. Okay but then they move on to black dragons and they're like just kidding black dragons are more powerful. Right!
Okay great they're like blue dragons are definitely the rarest and most powerful except for these two black dragons that exist. Where one hasn't been seen for five years and the other one is like big captain melchron's dragon. Right exactly it's like oh okay so they're the second most powerful and rarest. Right. Can we just be factual? And in another vein Zaden a rebel child has the most powerful dragon so again what was the point of conscripting the rebel children like who let that
happen? Right I don't understand I don't understand. Especially because like we go on to kind of get a little bit more into this and we'll talk about it in the next episode but like Segeal is regarded as we're seeing in this conversation as being a little bit of a loose cannon and people are wary of her because she is so powerful but also we're told that dragons have a good sense of people and don't bond with like essentially serial killers mostly. Right but it also- So which is it girl? I don't
know and it also makes me wonder about the whole marking of the children anyway if that was a dragon's decision but like clearly the dragons can still bond with them so like what did that marking actually mean to the dragons? I just- That's what I'm interested in because I don't think it's what the general thinks it is. I don't because it doesn't make sense for it to be that. No. So we do move on to the black dragons. General Melgan's dragon is black but there's only one other one that we know exists and he hasn't been seen in five years and my prediction
here is that he's gonna bond with Violet. I also had that prediction. We learn that black dragons not only are the most powerful and the rarest but they're also the smartest and most discerning. None have been born in the last century that the humans know of. We learned that the dragon that hasn't been seen in a while so the last black dragon that could be bonded has refused to bond since his last rider was killed during the Tyrus rebellion. Nalyn is the dragon's rider's name
and we learned that Nalyn's power was to siphon the power of other dragons and redirect it so he was basically a mirror of everybody's power which is fucking badass. It is badass. Some of these powers that we learn about are so cool and other ones I'm just like yeah okay. Yeah okay. We learned that Nalyn died trying to bring Brennan back from the dead with his power and died as a result so Brennan and Nalyn died in this interaction. Violet when she learns this feels the grief of Nalyn as
her own and Professor Cowrie tells her that it's because she's probably feeling Brennan's loss but I have to believe it's more than that and this is when I start to think that maybe Nalyn and Brennan were lovers. Yes because I mean as we get into like the bonding where they made the prediction they feel each other's feelings. Right. It almost speaks to like a predetermination of bonding. Yes and again that they're lovers. The father no. Yeah no no that would be weird. That would
be so weird. Do not like. So where we'll end this episode is as Violet turns to leave from class Professor Cowrie pulls her back and tells her that she's smarter than both Mira and Brennan so both of her siblings and he adds that she might be more compassionate too and that's why he believes that she'll make a great writer. Which again continues to show like how shitty Dane kind of is because other people do have faith in her. Absolutely they do yeah and I mean Violet too
a certain extent she's kind of gaslighting herself on this but she believes she can do it too. Yeah and she comes around on that and becomes more determined and in that that Dane I do appreciate her digging her heels in on like not running away because we're not even done with the option she has to run away like those aren't over with. Exactly well we'll come back to that. We'll come back to that yeah. So I do appreciate her digging her heels in like no like I'm gonna prove it to myself that I can do this or die trying.
Yeah exactly yeah which I respect. I don't understand why she has to in the first place but now that she's here I'm like okay fine. Now that once she's there and she starts to enjoy herself and especially after she bonds with her dragons I can understand why she stays but before then I'm like girl why. No well like the day after the first trial and you have like this Jack Barlow coming after you and like everyone you just think everyone's gonna murder you at any second I'd be like I'm out. I would have been like bye. Show me that backdoor. I don't need this in my life.
No goodbye. So anyway as I mentioned that's where we will end this episode. We are planning to cut this book into three parts so join us next week for part two where we will talk more about the story. Until next time we'll see ya. Bye. Bye.
Triggers: graphic violence and gore, depictions of a fictional plague, on-page sexual content (including masturbation), and themes of parent death and chronic illness KU: No Recommendation: No, (give the author money...
Triggers: (From the author): kidnapping, violence, discussions of abuse, BDSM dynamics and play, tentacle play, brief descriptions of injured animal (that receives aid), breath play, bondage, depictions of sub drop,...
Triggers: war, battle, hand-to-hand combat, perilous situations, blood, intense violence, brutal injuries, death, and poisoning KU: No Recommendation: Yes! For more of the author, check out https://rebeccayarros.com/
Triggers: from the author: “explicit violence, explicit sexual violence, dubious consent, murder, gore, torture, kidnapping, and more.” KU: Yes Recommendation: No For more of the author, check out...
Triggers: death of a parent (off page), grief, fantasy violence KU: No Recommendation: both Traders recommend! This is part 2 of 2. For more of the author, check out https://www.lanaferguson.com/