Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Spice Traders

Spice Traders artwork

Aisling: Breath of the New Creature by A.E. Jürgens

Jan 23, 20242 hr 47 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

This week we’re re-releasing a Patreon exclusive episode from last year: Aisling: Breath of the New Creature by A.E. Jürgens. Join us on a beautifully whimsical tale of a Mortal Queen (or is she…?) as she navigates marriage and intrigue in the Isles of Rinn Duin. Please forgive any pronunciation errors with the Gaelic terminology. Triggers: none Tropes: enemies to lovers, political marriage, slow burn KU: no Recommendation: All Traders recommend! For more of this author, check out aejurgens.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hi friends, Katie here with a couple of quick announcements before we get to today's episode. First, for the month of January, we are re-releasing two Patreon-exclusive episodes to our regular feed. The first episode is our coverage of Air Awakens by Elise Cove, and the second is Ashling, Breath of a New Creature by A.E. Juergens. We didn't get it quite right in our first year, but both of these are the first books in their series, and we're trying our best to keep our Book One Eps to our public feed. Also, both of these are older episodes, so you'll hear Des as a part of the conversation as well.

Next, speaking of Patreon, I wanted to drop a quick reminder to join us over on our Patreon. That's where we release bonus episodes every other week, and we've already got over 20 episodes from 2023 that you can download in-bin right this second for as little as $3 a month. We've covered so many good books there, Haunting Adeline, Chateau, Gothic Canna, so many more, and that's also where we'll cover any books in a series that we want to continue. So Serpent in Dove, High Mountain Court, Serpent in the Wings of Night, you can continue those series with us on Patreon right now.

Finally, as a patron, we'll let you know what we're going to read every month, so you can read along with us if that's your jam. Anyway, that's all from me, on to today's episode. Well, and then she meets him in the fucking field, and they're alone, and I'm like... Bang! Bang, bang, bang! This is a great time! Hello! Still not. No. Ah! I know.

We have a lot of great books out there that we want to share every episode with three things. The first is a generic trigger warning. You can find specific triggers for this book in our show notes, so please check those out. Also, we do use foul language and talk a lot about sex. You have some sensitivity to that? This isn't the podcast for you. Secondly, we talk about books. The whole book, nothing about the books that helped me got us. If you plan to read this book and you don't want something spoiled, don't listen to this episode right now. Lastly, we acknowledge that a good book can hit you at the wrong time. We absolutely do not want to diminish the work and the talent of the authors in our community.

That said, we have some notes. So, Liz, what are we talking about today? Today we're talking about Ashling, Breath of the New Creature by A.E. Juergens. This was published in 2022, and it is the first in a duology. The second book was released in February 2023, so it is fresh off the presses. It is 460 pages in a physical copy. This is a long boy. This is a long boy.

This one's a long boy. We usually talk about the cover, and I read this on my Kindle, and I honestly didn't really pay attention to the cover. My head saw something that it wasn't until I took a second to look at it, and the cover is really pretty. It is, but I bought the hard cover, and I feel like the publisher did her a disservice because the hard cover is... The dust jacket is just a little bit like...

Pixely? It's not high quality. Oh, that's a bummer. Yeah, I mean, it feels like something that I printed off on my home computer, and then just wrapped across a book. What is the actual behind the dust jacket? It's just a gray book. It's not entertaining at all. There's not anything hidden back there. So I'm waiting for... Now that the second book is published, I'm waiting for them to come out with a special edition, because I feel like this one lends itself well to that. Yeah.

So we'll see. The cover is very pretty. I'm looking at the one that Liz and I have. Yeah, it's different. It's like that, but in reverse. It's like red hands coming down onto a wolf instead of coming up. But I'm confused about that imagery. I also don't understand the imagery. It doesn't seem to track with what the story is. I mean, we get the whole like, he is a wolf, he's insatiable, but not really. That's just something her dad says. So the book's not about him. It's not about him.

It's not about him at all. It's not a mere breath of the same creature we've had. Oh my God. I wish it was. I mean, that's kind of the story. I mean, it's kind of story. We do also get a map, which is quite whimsical. There are some like fluffy clouds and like rabbit and a fox, but it's pretty. It's pretty. I truly forgot there was a map as soon as I moved past the map though.

Yeah, you don't really need the map in this book though. I like the map. It was very like approachable and I like the embellishments, but it is very clearly like Scotland. Yes. If Scotland was an island. And there is a lot of true like Irish, Scottish lore, which we'll get into our pronunciations. So did you guys read about the author at all? Yeah. She sounds very fascinating.

Yeah. I didn't read anything about her. She was a diplomats daughter. Yes. Oh, yeah. That's interesting. And she's lived in like six or eight different countries. Oh, yes. Huh. That kind of puts some different like spin on some of the topics in this book. She's very interesting and I really like, I like her headshot in this book. The only thing is it seems like something that somebody took over lunch because she's got her phone in her hands.

I honestly love these like super informal. Like I saw somebody else who did their author photo in like a cow onesie. And so like I love these like super informal like I'm just going to be who I am unapologetically author photos like get it. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. All right. Well, that was a very meandering introduction more so than usual. Katie, let's get into it. Why don't you take us on this journey? For sure. So we did already talk about the map,

but the only thing that I want to add to that is that the map is of the Isles of Rinduinn, which is the world that we're living in right now. And it's as the name implies, it's a group, but not a group. It is an island where the entire story takes place. Big ass island. That's a big ass island. Yeah. Okay. So it's an appropriately sized island because it takes them days to cross, you know, parts of it. It doesn't take them, you know, half a day. Right. Like some of the other books we've read.

Right. So in the first couple of pages, we meet Ashling on her wedding day. She is with her mother, Clota, who helps her dress. And as they're doing this, Ashling ruminates that the Aeosai. So it's Is she. Is she. Okay. How do you know that? I know that because I read this book. Quick shout out to the book called the call by paid our O Gillian.

And I'm definitely butchering that. Um, but this is, this is a fantasy horror book. If you are interested in the terrifying side of Fay, I highly recommend the call. It's not one we'll be covering on this podcast because it is not romantic. It is scary as shit. Um, but the group, it's again, very steeped in Irish lore, which is kind of what we get in this book as well. But the words for fairies or elves, whatever you want to call them is spelled S I D H E,

which is pronounced she. And they also use this, um, East she in the call to talk about it. And so when I was reading that book, I looked it up because I was like, Oh, that something is wrong. Um, so I was like, Oh, I'm sorry. So I looked it up. So it's the only reason I know that is because of that book. And yeah, none of it is spelled correctly. I mean, even the first, the name of this woman, this main character is a IS L I N G,

but it's Ashlyn. So it seems like Gaelic is just, we just like ease and she's when there's other letters in there. Ashlyn with her mother, Clota, getting ready for Ashlyn's wedding. And as they do so, Ashlyn ruminates on the ish she, which are this book's name for the fey. And they're described as a race of warriors, feral and powerful that were created by something called the forge.

And they are detailed in this world in something called the forbidden lore. We learned that Ashlyn is the only daughter of noble birth in all of the north or till rent, which is basically the mortal lands of Rinduyn. And that both her mother and father think her to be weak. As her mother is getting her ready, they're interb, interrupted by her brothers. She has four of them and they basically come dressed in tartans to take her away to the carriage that will take her to her wedding.

It just, I, from the get go, I was like, this government is corrupt. And there was this line. I don't remember it's like in the car or the car. Oh my God, the carriage or when they're there. But someone tells Ashlyn, you represent all of our kind when among them now, never forget that. And I was like, no pressure. Like just you represent an entire species. Don't forget. Yeah. I thought I immediately wrinkled at her internal monologue or it's third person limited through Ashlyn's perspective,

but her internal monologue that was like, oh, both my mother and my father think that I'm weak. I'm like, okay, wait, hold on. Let's just step out. They shouldn't be intimating that in any way, shape or form. So I don't think there's the best of parenting going on here. Well, and she refers to her parents as their first names all the time, which I thought was interesting. Yes. Yes. I was like, clada clada. I wasn't sure that was, I wasn't sure that was even her mother for the longest time. I thought it was maybe just like her dad's wife.

Yeah, I mean, if anything, she refers to them as their first name and then also in like commentary, her father slash mother. She never says, oh, my father XYZ thing. It's Oh, nemen or Oh, clada does this thing. Which was interesting. She also has four brothers that are named. She has four brothers. Yes. I don't have any of their names. So I don't either. I have, I have the names that are important. There's like one brother that's not important and I don't have his name.

The one with the A name. No, and is important does have. Yeah, he's important. Okay. I forgot about him later. Sorry. We'll get to a point where he's just like pouring wine and I was like, are you a servant? Oh, no. Okay. You're basically a servant anyway. So her brothers escort her into a carriage in which she'll drive. She'll travel to neutral territory and meet her family, the rest of her family and presumably her betrothed. Her family is the clan. Neemed. So I heard it.

Yeah. And as she travels, we get a little bit of a description of the countryside, which is described as wild and feral, except where it has been claimed by humans. And in those places, it is scorched and burnt. Naturally. We learn that when she was younger, it used to be much more peaceful and much more lush, but that war had ravaged the countryside and forced humans to be more careful, specifically forcing Ashlyn to stay within the castle walls, lest the Fairfolk steal her away. Her father, Neemed, is riding with her.

He is described as a battle-hardened man who has a scar across his face and two iron prosthetics for legs, courtesy of the Fairfolk. He warns her on this journey to never forget where she came from and that the Fairfolk will always try to deceive her, that they lie as easily as they spin cloth. When they arrive at their destination, it's basically a war camp that's pitched up in a field for the occasion of this wedding. Classy. So classy. We love an outdoor wedding. We love an outdoor wedding.

And what an outdoor wedding this is. So, to start. The Fae and Human alike have formed a circle in which Ashlyn and her father stand, awaiting the arrival of the King, Ashlyn's patrode. When the King and his knights arrive, Ashlyn remarks that they are not the terrifying beasts that she's been taught that they should be. They're actually incredibly handsome and good-looking, and this is a marked difference between the information that she's been told versus what she's seeing with her own eyes, which will be a theme that we see through the rest of this book.

The King and his knights dismount, and they all un-sheath their weapons and basically throw them into the ground so that they stick. And there's this awkward silence in which Ashlyn's brother, Anand, steps up and tells her that she needs to pick the correct weapon that she believes belongs to the King. It's kind of a test, so if she picks wrong, she doesn't really know what would happen to her. The assumption is that she's going to pick right.

The weapon of the King is not necessarily the one that he en-sheathed when they all stuck their weapons into the ground. So it's like two swords and then a battle axe. So like two great swords and a battle axe. And she acknowledged when they were pulling their weapons out that the battle axe was really nice, but battle-worn, definitely not the weapon that would belong to a King, because a King would have the nicest weapon.

And the least battle-worn, because her father, one of the things that she explains is her father rules from a distance. So she doesn't understand why a King would have any sort of battle damage at all, because he should be ruling away, not within or with his people. Yeah. So she looks at these three weapons and there's two very nice swords and then the axes are also nice, but battle-worn, as Des said. And rather than picking one of the swords, Ashlyn decides to pick the axe.

And she kind of places her hand on the hilt of the axe and nothing happens. So her brother says that she actually has to take it out of the ground if that's her choice. But it's too heavy, so Ashlyn can't do that on her own. And in this entire exchange, it strikes me that her entire family is decidedly unorganized for this entire thing. Like there was no coaching whatsoever going on. I didn't understand that, because clearly everyone else knew what she was supposed to do.

Or at least her brother, and it's like, give me a heads up. Like, come on, bro. So the thing is, at the time, I'm like, okay, is there multiple different tests, and so they weren't sure which test it was going to be. But even then, if you know that there are multiple tests, you should know, hey, it might be this one thing. Tell me it's that one thing, maybe. And if it's not, at least I have some information that can inform anything else that I... Literally any other choice I'm going to make. Well, at least give her a heads up that there would be a test, because she has...

Her entire inner monologue is like, I'm going to a wedding. I'm going to just get married. This is the end of my life, right? There's no talk about, like, oh, I wonder what my trial is going to be, how I'm going to be tested, blah, blah, like none of that. She shows up and this test happens, and she's like, I have no fucking idea what I'm supposed to do. Yeah, she essentially woke up and was just like thrown into this, like, shit show. Yeah, so because she can't pick the axe out of the ground by herself, the king kneels...

Okay, logistics, make it make sense. The king kneels behind her to help her pull the axe out of the ground, and they do so together. And I'm like, how tall is this fucking guy? Like, he kneels behind her, she's standing up, and then they're both at the angle that they can easily pull the axe out of the ground. He's got to be like twice her height. I would, yeah, like you don't have, even if he is very strong, which of course he is because he's Faye, that's just... You don't have the leverage.

I was confused at how tall or like the proportions between these different people, the entire book, because when she first sees the Faye, she remarks about how large they are. And this scene, the scene where he kneels behind her, I'm like, okay, well obviously you're like child-sized, comparatively. But then there are other scenes in the book where that's not the case, so I have not a good understanding of the height difference. Yeah, I don't either. Yeah.

So they pull the axe out of the ground, it's clear that she's picked the right one, and the wedding ceremony begins. So the two knights that have come with the king say the wedding vows for them, and they bind their hands together with ribbon and also some kind of flower that has thorns. I didn't quite understand what was happening there, but it's the kind of like traditional Celtic knotting ceremony, so they hold hands and they knot their hands together. And the words they say are, I vow to you the first cut of my heart, first taste of my blood, and the last words from my lips,

which I find very beautiful. It was beautiful. I did like that. After this, they each cut their palm and let their blood drip into a goblet from which they both drink. When Ashlyn drinks from the goblet, it at first tastes like blood, and she's just kind of like, but it quickly morphs into something more delicious and sweet that she ruminates that she could drink for hours on end and be perfectly happy to do so. Once this is completed, the ceremony is over, and she is both married and also a queen, which I thought was an interesting way to end that entire scene.

It was very interesting. One of the things that she talks about as she's like going through the motions here is that she always imagined that she would be wearing like a white gown, and she'd be bowing before her father and then marrying this other prince that we'll meet later on. Look at this great quote that she had always imagined that, but now she was basically standing in like a circle with like a bunch of fay. They're all barbarians and enemy, the antithesis of the world that she was born and bred into. And I think that that's very telling, the stark difference between this very regimented lifestyle and this more wild and fay kind of lifestyle.

Yeah, that she was not raised for. 100%. So after the wedding ceremony itself, there's a reception, and during this reception, Ashlyn's kind of left alone. Her father and mother go off to talk to other royals who are there from the mortal realm, and her new husband is frolicking with his men. So Ashlyn has a conversation with two of her brothers, Anand and Iar Benal, which I'm sure I'm butchering, but they have a conversation in which we learn two things.

I tell her that if she had chosen incorrectly during the test with the weapons, that she would have been beheaded. The weapons. The weapons. The weapons. She would have been beheaded, and I'm like, thanks for the heads up guys. Yeah. Yeah. Warnabitch, next time. I was just saying, they say pretty casually too, they're like, good thing you chose right. Yeah. There's this other moment where she's noticing that the humans are all sitting there shuffling their food around on plates and being really quiet, and the fey are dancing and lively.

And it just reminds me a lot of my wedding. Yeah. My family is very reserved and quiet and not into the hubbub of anything. And so all of our friends and stuff like that were dancing and having a great time. My family was just sort of in a corner watching it happen. So awkward. Yeah. She also in this conversation, her brothers give her an iron dagger and on the hilt of it, there's a fist clutching a ruby, which is the symbol of mankind that they have.

They were born of nothing, but built themselves up into something. And as they talk, her father stands up on the other side of the area. They're, they're not. Okay. So this was also confusing. They're not in a field anymore. They're in a tent. Yeah. But when did that happen? Because they don't. Yeah, exactly. Yeah. So he stands up on the other side of the tent to give a toast and says, you know, so happy this happened. May this unity be the first of many and set an example for the rest of the world.

And Ashlyn kind of hooks up on the, the passive aggressive nature of this, but everybody in the crowd cheers nonetheless. Ashlyn observes the faking her new husband after the toast and he's having a great time and she kind of remarks on the dichotomy between her father and her husband, where her father rules with an iron fist, her husband seems almost to be a friend or, you know, a comrade of his subjects. We see a lot of large differences between like how they rule throughout this book and I think that was a really interesting dichotomy that the author works through.

Yeah, I agree. Like how she shows it. So as Ashlyn is making this comparison, she also has this really lovely line where she says the most dangerous of creatures were the lovely ones, which is so true, especially in Fae books. Yes, so true. So the evening wears on and one of the northern princes to which she was originally betrothed comes over and his name is Dagfin. Ashlyn's brothers kind of give them some space and some privacy and Dagfin tells her that basically Ashlyn's father is wrong for doing this to her and that she should be his queen, rather than the queen of the Fae.

He is the crown prince of the rocked Ling. I hated that KL combo. I wanted to be like, like, rocked, like, rocked king. It was in my mouth. The KTL. It was just bad. I did really like he had this line where he said, because they're talking about her being queen. And he says that name suited you then as this new title suits you now. And like, it's very clear that like he holds a lot of affection and while they were never like formally betrothed, it was always just assumed that that's who she would marry.

And they seem to have like a lot of like fondness towards each other. They do. And even though this conversation starts out kind of in that vein, it ends in a kind of awkward place because he's like really angry. And he's like, you know, if you ever feel uncomfortable, you just write to me and on the surface that seems fine. But he is exhibiting these physical characteristics of somebody who has a lot of anger and doesn't know what to do with it. And he's asking her basically for an excuse to like fuck some shit up.

And she's like, brother, this is my duty. Like I'm not going to give you the green light to just basically like steal me away or like start war with the people here. And he's like, fine, if that's the way you feel. And I'm like, okay, Daxin, there's no way that that's not going to come up later, right guys? Yeah, I got like immediate like bad news bears vibes from him. I'm like, you're going to be a problem, aren't you? And the thing is, it started off being really sweet. And I was like, man, this is sweet.

And then like it goes from nothing to 90. And I was like, Oh, like Daxin just like take a fucking breath, bro. Right. And I love the way so up until now we've gotten a lot of information, but it doesn't feel like information overload because the author weaves kind of like memories of Ashlyn and like kind of specifics of the political situation that they're in into her pros and into the things that are happening. And one of the things that she brings into this situation is, you know, Daxin has this anger that Ashlyn can see in the now, but she connects it with other times in their childhood where he would pick the wrong person.

And where he would pick fights with people or just like be angry a lot. And I'm like, Oh, so this is a pattern. Cool. You've told me a lot about this person and not a lot of words, which I appreciated. Yeah. Yes. And that I do like the there's so much information in this book, but I think the author handles it really well. Agreed. As Daxin and Ashlyn are talking, the king interrupts and like kind of approaches them and is not especially pleased that Daxin and Ashlyn are physically close in this conversation.

And Daxin like tries to bait the king into fighting him and he says this thing, like, you're not my king and or you're not king here and you're certainly not my king. And the fake king says it wouldn't take a title to put you in your place, which I was like, Oh, yeah, Panty drop. Yeah, I was like, okay, daddy. Yeah, but Ashlyn disarms the situation by physically putting herself between the two men and the king takes her away to their marital tent, I guess, for the rest of the evening.

So inside their marital tent, it's stunning and Ashlyn is kind of taken aback at how fine everything is. There's like rich rugs and furs and finery everywhere and there's like this actual big bed for them to sleep in. But the whole place is illuminated by flowers that are magically lit from within and she realizes that there's this kind of balance between magic and also physical like wealth that mortals would recognize. And she's kind of in awe of it. She's like, how did they manage to do this? This isn't something that she and her even as a princess in the mortal world would be able to muster, especially in a temporary space like this.

And so she's she's kind of taken aback and stunned a little bit and then realizes that the king is undressing and she's like, Oh, here we go. This is the thing and I was like, Yes, I was so here for this and he's even kind of flirting with me. And he's even kind of flirty. He's like, So are you going to sleep in your wedding dress? And she says this thing. She's like, Well, I don't have anything to sleep to change into. And he's like, Yeah, all your stuff is going to be taken to the place like where we're going to live. And the name of it. And when and when. Thank you.

But like, it's often assumed a bride needs no belongings the night of her union. Because what do you need? And her entire inner monologue is like she's been prepared for this. Like her tutors and her mothers are like, not her mother's her mother singular is like, This is probably going to hurt. But it's your duty. Don't scream. Like, it's fine. Don't panic. The part that drove me insane about this is like, I get this like classic like you have to make a baby. Hopefully you'll just have to do it once sex isn't fun for women. It's fine.

But then she's giving I don't like that. But yeah, it's like a historical thing. Yes, it's a thing. It's true. Um, it's wrong because sex is great, but it's true. But then there's like, again, this inner monologue, her being ready. There's this quote from her chambermaid like in her thinking back. Um, don't scream when he takes you, my lady, nor should you let your blood run freely too long menstruating or otherwise. How she's supposed to control how long she bleeds.

That's a great question. I read that too. And I was like, What do you mean by that? Like, my straightening or otherwise. So like, if you like slice my arm open, I'm supposed to just control how long that bleeds. What? And then it will only encourage a demon such as he and like, cause he likes blood, but they're not going to make a baby if she's menstruating. So like, but what? I don't. I didn't like that. I was just like, no, okay.

So in classic kind of trope fashion, not only has she been told all of these things, but also she's never seen a naked man before in her entire life. So he's undressing and she's like, I don't know what this feeling is, but I can't look away. I kind of like it. Well, it's a really like sultry scene because as he's undressing, he's like putting the lights out magically. I know. I know. Yep. And then he's, he's, you know, he's still got his pants on, but he's shirtless and he's just kind of like reclining on the bed watching her.

And he's like, All right, your move, funny man. And so she starts undressing and she's like down to basically her knickers. And when she goes to take those off, he extinguishes the light. But just before he does, we see that little moment of male restraint. Yes, where we have this flicker of, oh, what does she say? It's like tortured. It's some kind of tortured. Flicker of form is a flicker of cross.

And then he takes the lights out and he's like, you must be tired. And then they go to bed untouched. And I lost my mind. I also lost my mind. I was like, okay, respect. Like you're not a creep, but also like, I lost my mind because that was such a good way for like them to have a wedding night. And like he has this tortured look and it's clear that like he's interested, but he doesn't want to force her.

Yeah, I know. Yeah, it was written so well. And like, that's why I was so excited about this book. Like as we get, and I'm still excited. Like, that's why I was so interested in like making sure that I took the time to read this book. Because I was like, man, this is written so well. I can't wait for them to finally do it. Right. Yep. Yep. Spoiler alert. You're still waiting. That's on you. Okay, so at this point we're three chapters into the book. And I want to know what you guys think so far.

Like, it's clear that we dig this particular like vibe between the two of them. But how do you feel about like the storytelling, the setting that they're kind of building up? I really liked it. I felt like the world building was really good to your point earlier. Like I didn't feel like even though I had a lot of information about this world, I didn't feel like I was being assaulted with information or that like I was reading a laundry list of information. It felt natural. It felt appropriate. And like, I still had questions about the world, but I felt a lot like I was going along with the main character with those types of questions.

And so I felt really strongly about like the character development and the world development and the story at this point. I felt the same way I was really interested at this point. I liked. It felt like jumping into the story, which like most stories should do, but I like that we started like on her way to the wedding. That all happened like really fast. And now we're moving on. There wasn't like a bunch of buildup into this angsty like, oh, I have to marry a stranger. It's the bonding of the species like the races.

I was super into it. And I like Lear. I like the King. I was like, okay, you're fun. Like you're not weird and cold. Like I kind of expected him to be. Yeah. Yeah. He had a personality that wasn't just like touch her and die and also like frosty. Right. Cause I kind of expected him to just be like, okay, cool. I guess we have to do this, but I'm not going to look at you. But he was immediately just like, okay. I think the thing that I like the most about the world building up until this point is that it did feel really real and it didn't feel like it was too much.

But there were a couple of things where I was like, um, maybe let's, are you sure about that? Like we've mentioned a couple of things like the power dynamic in her family and in her clan and like some of the things that, you know, she actually met the Faye. And they weren't monsters. And there was just a couple of things that like planted seeds of doubt, which made me more interested in what's going on in this whole thing. Yeah. Yes. Yes.

Okay. So the next morning after their wedding, she wakes up and she is alone. But she hasn't attended to help her dress in trousers and a tunic. Trousers. I do have a question because like one of the things that we covered in other books is the fact that generally after the wedding night, there is like someone to check to see if like there's blood to see if the wedding was consummated, which is like a gross thing to do. But like, I kind of expected that here. And that didn't happen. And I was just like, okay.

So, okay, that is interesting that you bring that up because for all of the talk that they have in the first like, I would say 60 pages of the book about consummation and like the wedding and how she feels guilty that like they haven't consummated anything. No one's checking like no one's asking questions about that. And I kind of wanted there to be a little bit more pressure in that situation, because otherwise it's just totally self imposed. Right, because what I wanted to is like I wanted one of the things that I have liked in other books specifically Serpent and Dove is when like they addressed that concern and they didn't really work together to solve the problem but like they did all that.

They both knew of the plan. Right. So I don't know. I thought that was interesting. I thought that was going to happen. So when it didn't happen, I was like, oh, okay. Especially because it's very clear when they leave the like reception that people are like, yeah, go fuck her brains out. But like in a language that we don't understand. Right. I would have expected like a bloody sheet to be waving outside of the tent or something like that. Hung from like a flagpole or something. Right. Yeah. And then it kind of like you said, Katie, it kind of continues for a while. Like he even talks about it. Like they skirt around this whole we're both going to pretend that we consummated it, but then it just never comes up again.

Right. Like it's she says pretty frequently throughout the book and it's not spoiling anything to say this, but they don't consummate the marriage ever. And she says, you know, it's the secret that she's happy to keep with the faking and it's like, okay, but no one's like checking your work here. No one's asking that question. No one's like, did you bone? Yeah. But in fact, but did you know what is even really saying like, hey, like, are you pregnant yet? Like there is some some more of that later on. But like no one's really getting and no one's really asking that question or like getting up close and personal about it.

Right. And I would have thought, especially from the mortal perspective, that they would have made sure that like the goods were received and then also like used. You know what I mean? Yeah. Because I mean, traditionally speaking, if you don't consummate the marriage, then it's grounds for an annulment. Right. Yeah, it's not like a legal marriage. Right. I would have expected her father at least to be like, all right, standing outside the tent like, let me see that sheet. Come on. Or let me watch. Right. Okay, madame.

But we get none of that. Anyway, so the next morning, she wakes up, she wakes up alone, as I mentioned, and she's got this attendant to help her dress. And when she leaves her tent, it's very clear that like basically the rest of the party has up and left. And so it's basically her, the king and like a handful of knights to help them escort back to the Fae homeland. As she kind of is waking up and getting dressed, she remarks that she can hear and see and smell things much more vividly than before and and do so for things that aren't in her immediate vicinity, almost as if she's experiencing someone else's

experience or someone else's, you know, sights, senses, smells, whatever. Yeah, it's like heightened senses to the world around her. Right. And I have this note that I wonder if it's, if it has anything to do with them sharing blood at the wedding, but I have that same. Also, she also doesn't ask much more questions. She's just like, Oh, that's weird. And then movies moves on immediately. I was gonna say the other thing that she keeps mentioning that like is never really addressed is she is so hungry, like there's food she is like famished and it is never talked about.

I don't know why. No, we never find out she might note like three times like why is she so damn hungry. Right. So one of the things I think that she does kind of talk about this and I kind of attributed to this. She talks about how she is in a constant battle with not being enchanted by the Fae against her will. And so she believes all of the things she's feeling to be an enchantment or like an attempt to a chant and chant her. So like, she frequently says like, Oh, you know, I'm I'm experiencing this thing, but that must just be like a product of my time here with the Fae or like whatever they're trying to do with me or whatever.

And so that's what I kind of read and attributed to that too, because I too was like, you're not gonna like they get they try to give her food and she asked somebody like, Is this safe for me to consume? And they're like, there's gonna be a lot of food that you can't consume, but you can consume whatever I specifically was lear. I think was like, I you can always consume whatever I specifically give to you or whatever. Right. But that doesn't that doesn't explain why she's famished all the time. Yeah. There was like, I understand her waking up and having like this, this extra sense and her being like, Oh, that's definitely enchantment. But then later on in the book, she says something. And it's very close to here. So we can talk about it here. But she says, quote, she'd eaten nearly every hour since the morning she'd left, or she'd build, she'd build till ran farewell her

homeland. But never did it appear to slake her newfound appetite, even when offered Faye food. Girl, why? Why are you so hungry? Why is so hungry? And that implies that she was hungry for the dick. Hungry for the dick. I mean, I need to eat every hour, but that's just because I'm cranky. She makes it seems like she's starving. But that also kind of, oh, my mic felt sorry, that also kind of implies that she has been famished since like leaving her own homeland, which like means that there's nothing to do with Lear at all.

Which could be, but I mean, like, why are you so hungry? You don't continue to be famished, right? And she's hungry all the time. Right. Yeah. I wonder, I just, I still wonder about that. We don't get a great answer on what's happening. No, we don't. So they've leave this camp and they start their ride to Anne Wynn, which is the, the, the king's seat of this Faye king that she's married. And they start on stags or what they call hearts. So H-A-R-T. So not horses.

And on the way we get some really beautiful imagery. And I think something that is continuous throughout the book is the author's use of whimsicality and magical language to describe kind of what's around Ashlyn. But this specific, this specific passage stuck out to me. It says, the land this far from Tillerin was wilder than any place Ashlyn had laid eyes on before. As if the queen could blink and the mountains would roll adjusting their slumbering positions like hibernating bears.

As if the trees would pick up their roots and dance or the caves snap their mouths shut after years of yawning. I just love the personification of everything around them. It's so beautiful. The writing is very pretty. And there's, that's why I have so many quotes because there's so many moments. I was like, that's just beautiful imagery or that's just a great line. Yeah. Yeah. Really good. Liz's favorite word does make an appearance around here. It does. And Sorsalmit. Yeah. And it's, they say it like three times and every time I have the note in Sorsalmit, God spare me from this word.

It all counts. But they use it pretty intentionally, right? It's just like, I'm in Sorsal. No, but can you guys guess the other thing that I counted through this book that drove me fucking insane? Mortal. Mortal Queen. Yeah. Do you know how many times? I think that's intentional. I mean, it's a little bit ham-fisted, but I think it's intentional. Okay. A little ham-fisted? Guess how many times they say Mortal Queen. Is it like 67 times? No, it's 341. Jesus Christ. I'm not surprised.

That is like every other page of this book. Uh-huh. And holy shit, I was like, you should have just called this book the Mortal Queen. Yeah. But it's Ashling, Breath of a New Creature. And so Hazard, I guess it's not about a mortal queen. No, because she's not mortal. So, yeah, so when I was thinking about like the new creature, I thought that it was like she would like discover or create a new creature. In her womb. Outside of, either in her womb or outside of herself. Which is not exactly, exactly that.

I really hope so, I, whether we cover it in this podcast or not, I need to read the second book because there are so many questions that I have that I hope are answered in that one. Also, I hope they bang. I need them to bang. So anyway, to move along a little bit, we learned that the ride from where they had camped to Anwen will take about two days. We learned this because Ashlyn is speaking with one of the knights who was there on the night of her wedding. And we learned that this person's name is Galad. He addresses her as Mollera, which is short for Bride of the Forest.

And it occurs to Ashlyn that she assumed that she would be queen and title only and she never kind of thought that other people would like kind of accept that. Call her queen. Right. But this is when I'm like, oh, that's likely why she's so attuned to the forest around her because she is the Bride of the Quote Forest. That makes sense. In this conversation, Galad compliments her on her writing, but caveats that, you know, Sorsha, the stag that she's writing is the most obedient and docile. And I love this line.

Ashlyn's like a little bit crestfallen that it's not like, oh, she's just such a great writer. He's like, yeah, you're a great writer, but also like this is a really docile stag. She's just like, oh, fuck. I love that too. When they make camp, she tries to sleep, but is kept awake by one fear and also the noise of the men outside who keep singing and like talking. Yes. Very relatable. So rude. It's like, brother, I'm trying to get some sleep.

I'm trying to get my beauty rest. I am a queen. But beyond the fact that she's surrounded by a fey, it's kind of compounded because she's a very sheltered princess and she's around the most men that she has ever been around in her entire life. The only men that she's been around before this have been her family and Dagfinn and Dagfinn's family. And so she's incredibly nervous. She's like, I don't know how to do this. I think it's improper, but also like, I'm a little scared. Like I don't really have a choice either.

Right. Right. I don't know how to act. So the king comes in, in her conversation with Galad earlier, we learned that the king's name is Lear, but it strikes me in this moment that he hasn't actually introduced himself to her yet. No, no, as I've said his name at all. No. Which is so. We're married. We slept together, at least in the same bed. Like, so I think he was, he was introduced at the ceremony. Not by name though. Not by name.

I thought it was for when he was introduced by name there because like he, I thought I had that highlighted. It might be, but it was like during this, she was like, huh, that's his name. I'm fairly certain this is the first time we learn his name. And I also find it weird because it's not like, you know, a traditional modern wedding when it's like, do you blah, blah, blah name take blah, blah, blah name to be your lawfully wanted, whatever. Well, no, because like she doesn't even say her own vows, like the knights say it for her. Yeah, so to be clear, she doesn't know his name.

He doesn't know her name. I mean, hazard, I guess he probably knows her name because he was a part of the negotiations, but she's like totally in the dark here. So the first time I have Lear's name in my notes is when they're talking about the stag that she's writing and she really likes her. And Gallaud says like, oh, whatever you covet, Lear will give to you. Yeah. So that's the conversation they just had. And that's the first time she's heard his name. But the thing is, I remember when I was reading this for the first time, for a second, I thought that was the name of one of their gods.

Oh, yeah. Like, who's Lear? Yeah, I can see that. So, okay, she's in this tent. She's trying to sleep. She's terrified. And the king comes in and is like, hey, if you're hungry, there's food outside. And she's like, okay. And this is when she says the line about how she's eaten nearly every hour, but she's fucking famished. And in this conversation, he finally introduces himself.

He's like, hey, there's food. She's like, okay. And he's like, oh, BT dubs, my name is Lear. And she's like, cool homeboy, my name is Ashlyn. Nice to meet you, I guess. Right. Like, this is so fun. So awkward. So awkward. So she does go with him. And, you know, the men are basically sitting around this fire pit and they've caught this thing and they're roasting it over a spit. And she wonders at like how quickly these people have like caught, found, caught, killed, and then prepared such a large beast.

And she compares that to the starving conditions that much of the mortal race endure. She's talked a couple of times before now about how many kingdoms don't have enough land or enough livestock or whatever to keep their people fed. And that's why they're trying to expand but having a hard time doing so. And, you know, these men that she's with have just basically easily plucked what is essentially a wild boar from the forest to feed them all.

As she approaches, it's really clear that a lot of the men don't fucking like her because they're just like, ugh, this bitch. Snir, snir, blah blah. Right. But she doesn't really dwell too much on it. She's just like, yeah, whatever they can think what they want. This, I'm doing my duty. It doesn't really matter. I'm just here. Also like to be expected, like I don't like you either. Right. And then the last thing that happens as she's approaching the men is that she kind of looks over at the stags looking for Sorsha. Her stag.

And she like briefly kind of picks up on like the stags mindset. But again, she's just like, I'm not going to think too much about that. Let's focus on the food. I'm so damn hungry. Baby. So most of the men are gathered around the fire, but there are some men who are kind of patrolling the perimeter and Ashland is like, why are you like, you guys are the most fearsome creatures in all the land? Like, what are you so afraid of? And this is another example of how like, very much feels like we're not getting, we and Ashland are not getting all of the information that we need to be at this time.

No. And much of that seems like her father's fault. There's some line in here talking about like how they're forbidden lore. So the Elvish fairy lore was forbidden. Obviously that was really redundant, but like they weren't allowed to read it. It was like treasonous to like read anything about it. And I just, that my note is any government that denies its citizens from seeking knowledge is automatically the bad guy in my book. Like it just seems so problematic. And also like, fine, it's forbidden.

Sure. Okay. But you're sending your daughter as this like emissary building these bonds and you're not going to tell her like anything. To be fair, we do eventually confront that problem. I know. But at this point we don't. And it bothers me. Yeah, I get it. Well, yeah, I mean, like it strikes me very much. Like there are so many instances from like real life history where like the Roman Catholic Church is one example where they wouldn't let people read the Bible because they only translated the Bible in Latin and only people who were in the church were taught Latin.

And it's like the fuck. Right. Controlling the masses through education or lack thereof is. The American way. What? Yeah, it just, it just, yeah, it creeps me out. Anyway, so they're around the fire and Lear, the King hands Ashlyn a leg of pork, something to munch on just to munch on. And she likes it and she's like, is this enchanted and he tells her that there will be as dead as a dead said food in the future that she can't partake in, but she can trust anything that he gives her to eat, but that she should never drink the wine.

He tells her that when humans drink. Faye wine that it makes humans experience life the way that the. She. And she. The she. She. It's she. It makes them experience life the way the she do. And again, she is. Is she for Faye? No, no, she is. Short. They call them the she, the humans call them the she. Got it.

Yeah, I was definitely doing it. In my mind. Got it. Yeah, it's she. Because he makes sense. That's literally how it's spelled, but she. Yeah, I don't know where that D goes. I'll show you where that D goes. I'll show you where that D goes. Yeah, I'll show you where that D goes. So please do. So she takes this leg of meat and she like. Observes it and she has this fleeting thought of like, this isn't very lady like, but fuck it. And then she just kind of like. Devours the whole thing.

And in this internal monologue, we learned that it was actually her mother. Clara. Who suggested to use Ashlyn as a pawn in this war treaty negotiation scheme. And I don't know if you can tell me about that in this book, but her mother beyond this is such a non entity. I feel like something going on with the mom. Because later. Or the fuck is she. Well, like she's sick and even even Ashlyn is like, she's not sick. But then we, we don't.

That's it. Yeah, I have so many thoughts about how this book. Might go in the second one, but also could be more interesting if it doesn't go that way. So I think we need to talk about it with you guys. Yeah. We may have to rearrange our backlog. Yeah, truly. Okay. So they're eating around the campfire and the men are kind of taking turns singing songs. And so this one man stands up and sings a song about the 12 fei kings and queens

that were the original she that are detailed in the forbidden lore that you're with because it's forbidden for her to read about as this person sings leer translates to her and kind of gives her the details. So we learned that these 12 kings and queens are the first to be cast into the forge and they were remade as the she and they were given specific weapons and kind of like kingdoms or remits in the mortal world from the gods.

Ina was one of the queens and she wasn't given a weapon but was allowed to peer into the forge and was given sight so she can kind of see the future. That was her weapon. And for Ashlyn, her father had always told her that the fei were aberrations and intruders in a world made for humans by humans and that there were no gods. And so she's listening to this and leer translating and she's just like her mind is blown. She's like, I, this is all new information to me. One of the men continues on this song that has ended and says that not only was Ina

special because she didn't have a weapon she had the sight but she also broke one of the rules and fell in love with another king which was forbidden. And one of the reasons that it was forbidden is that they were each king and queen was given sovereignty over a specific part of the land and the gods feared that if the kings and queens fell in love and married that they would stray from their lands and leave them unguarded, unguarded from what we don't know yet. The last bit of information we get is that leer is the king of the green wood.

It was at this point that I was like, yeah, so that's where humans came from. Yeah, I mean that that was kind of obvious. How was it? I think we're got hamphisted with that. Like what really did it to me was that throughout her inner monologue, Ashlyn keeps talking like she keeps reiterating these like stories that her father has told like these rules and one of the rules is like we came from nothing but we were here first. Like what? Finger guns.

Yeah, so at this point I'm like, no. I fully didn't believe that they were there first. Like that's definitely some like white male bullshit. Yeah, for sure. But I didn't get the impression that like they were somehow descended or related to the fey. So this struck me very much like a traditional creation story. And so if you have a creation story for one race, it should affect all.

And I was like, oh, Aina is like the fallen. She's like Eve basically. Yeah. And so I think that's where sin, that's where mortality comes from. I see where this is going. Yeah, I could see that now did not see that when I was reading it. We also get, I don't know if it's in this scene, but it's somewhere in here with the story that before Aina. Was like her password for revoked. She made one last vision.

And this is also kind of where I saw the an incoming because my note is I hope the vision isn't as direct as fairy Mary is in the world and slash brings salvation or some shit. Okay, so I also have the thought of like, I hope it's not that straightforward. But we do get some more information about Aina. She did leave her land to save her beloved who was one of the kings. And this guy, Ryan, who's the night that's telling this additional information to Ashlyn talks about a curse that befell Aina,

which is what we're talking about when, you know, I know basically created mortality in this prophecy that she bestowed upon her only son before she died. And he's tell Ryan is telling this to Ashlyn and leers right there and leered like is uncomfortable and angry to the point where he's just like, I'm done with this and like stands up and stalks off and like, Ashlyn doesn't see him until the wee hours of the morning when he comes back into their tent. So someone's a little testy about some folklore.

Yeah, his reaction like I didn't get that connection, which we'll get later. So I was like, this is your origin story. Like this is like me reading Adam and Eve and like storming away. Like, why are you so weird, bro? Yeah, I mean, I think if it had nothing to do with Ashlyn, maybe he would be a little bit less. Yes, no, like we find out why. But at this point, I was like, okay. Yeah. Okay, but that's fine. I just learned your name. So it's like, I'm not going to read into it.

Like, I know nothing about you. Right. That's fine, but I don't even know your last name. I don't even know my new last name. Like, let's start there. Greenwood. Ashlyn of Leer. Oh, I mean, but think about the reality of that. It's like you're sharing your life with somebody and you just learned their first name today. It's been like a couple of days since you were married. Yeah. You had blood in your stomach.

I was talking to somebody about this the other day where I say when you buy a house, it's really weird because you spend like at max 30 minutes in that house before you decide to move into it for presumably a long time. This feels a lot like that. Like it's an arranged marriage or like she's never met this person and then they're together for like 48 hours and she still doesn't really meet this person. Like at least arrange marriages. You usually get their name. Right. You've met before the wedding. Or you at least know the basic information about them like, hi, I'm this person. This is my name. I'm this old. I'm from this place.

We're getting married. Hello. Hello. None of that was happening here. No. I mean, the fact that she doesn't even know like his formal titles, she's marrying, she's becoming his queen and like no one has prepped her for you are going to be queen of the XYZ thing. And this is how this is going to benefit them. Like, I just felt honestly, like it wasn't realistic for me that like her dad, the ruthless king of the North person who is only out for his own benefit gave her no information about this.

It's so it's almost like he was just thinking that she was going to die. Like all of them just thought she was going to die. Yeah. And so she didn't need any information. But like it bothers me that Ashlyn wasn't like, can I know something? Okay, but also fine because I think that there is some truth to what you just said, like everybody thought this was not going to work out. And that's totally fair. But the moment that it did, you had like several hours of a reception, maybe not several, at least an hour of a reception where you as your faja could have been like home girl.

Hey, we got 20 minutes every time. I have to download some information to you and we need to strategize right like, but that didn't happen. No, I didn't. The next day they approach a forest and Lear asks, okay, so picture this. Ashlyn is writing on her own fucking stag with Galad. They're having a grand old time. Lear is like doing his king shit up in a different place and then they approach this forest and Lear beckons Galad to him.

They talk and then Galad goes back to Ashlyn is just like, yeah, so your husband wants you to ride with him in this forest. And so like I'm supposed to bring you to him. Why wouldn't you just call for Ashlyn? Right. Like she's right there, you know, and it seems like such a well, Tabitha told Ryan who told Brittany who told me that your husband wants you to do this thing. The only thing I think that is that like they're next to a dangerous forest and he doesn't want to like call attention to their existence there,

but like you could have just ridden over my like my guy. He's on his own stag. Right. Okay. So moving on, Lear and Ashlyn are riding on the same stag now in this forest. And it's dark. It's weird. But Ashlyn is uncomfortable because of that, but also because her husband is directly behind her and she's electrified.

And so one of the things about this book that I loved and hated because there was no payoff is that the language that the author uses is very much the language that intimates to me that I'm going to get a payoff with some dick. And we didn't get that. I know the electrified the like heat against her back when he like puts his arm like around her. All of that was very much a lead up into like, wow, wow, and then we just get like a whole bunch of blue balls for like 400 pages.

Yeah. And then we get this weird manic pixie dream girl kiss. Yeah, the manic pixie dream girl kiss I have thoughts about anyway. So they're going through the forest and Ashlyn can't shake this feeling that they're being watched. As they ride Lear tells her to close her eyes and to keep them closed until he says otherwise. During this period, it gets really, really cold and the pressure changes so that her ears pop. So she hears these female voices. They're very alluring, filling the air insistently and kind of becoming this cacophony until suddenly they're just gone.

And Lear tells her to open her eyes and they're just back in the forest and it's like nothing happened. And Lear tells her that they were dry adds that had seen them and basically kind of attacked but like nobody's hurt. It's terrifying. Lear goes on to say that soon she will know all of the beings in this world and beyond. And Ashlyn, Ashlyn wonders why she was only ever told about this fey and humans and not seemingly this world of in between, right?

So there's much more that she doesn't know and we as readers are finding out with her. They continue on and they go into a deep gorge and they kind of split the party. So this gorge is beautiful. Think like Iceland vibes if you've ever seen like pictures of the gorges in that country. But most of the men kind of go away from Lear and Galad and Ashlyn. And Galad says that Lear wanted to show Ashlyn Annwyn from the front door, which I thought was really cute.

It is really cute. It is so cute. You have to show off this land. Yeah. So he's like bringing her in the proper way and they like go through this gorge in a boat on the river that's kind of in the bed of this gorge. And through a cave entrance kind of flanked by these giant statues of winged women. And on the other side, they behold a kingdom that's kind of in this very verdant and lush forest.

Think like Lord of the Rings, Elven lands. I got big Lord of the Rings like Rivendell vibes. So they get to the city and as they go through again, Ashlyn comments on how all of the people are beautiful and striking. And again, it strikes me as the reader and it must be striking Ashlyn to some extent, even though she doesn't verbalize it truly. How she could have grown up believing them to be ghoulish monsters when there's a war.

And at least her father and her oldest brother had encountered these beings in war. I'm just trying to justify the fantasy in my mind that no one told her else. Let's pretend that her father and her brother were in cahoots and wanted to tell her that everything, all of the fey are ghouls. There were other people that participated in those wars and those other people had family.

So how did no rumor get to her that like, maybe this is not a case. Maybe they're pretty. Yeah, I didn't really understand that either. I mean, unless she's just literally so sheltered because she's not allowed to go outside. I don't think she has friends. That's one of the things that they do talk about at one point is that she is extraordinarily sheltered. She is almost exclusively always with a select approved set of people.

So in some way, I think maybe, but like, she also tried to feel how she used to fuck off and do whatever she wanted. Yeah, she'd like sneak out with Dagvin. Right. As they go through the town up to the castle, we get this imagery of vibrancy and lushness. And it's contrasted in Ashlyn's perspective with the disease and the rot, literal rot. And she uses those terms to describe the human civilization that she has left and how these people are free and happy and playing and that there seems to be plenty, right?

There's literally berries and fruit growing from vines that are all around these buildings and these trees where the mortal populations don't have enough food to go around. And this is just very jarring for Ashlyn. Like she just doesn't, she's not prepared to see this kind of thing. The other thing she remarks about is the fact that she does notice that there were not as many beings as she expected to be in space. So like where she comes from, it's usually like wall to wall people and super crowded.

Here she is noticing that like the it's a little bit more sparse in terms of people who have turned out and they're all like, you know, there, but it's just not as crowded as she expected it to be. At the castle proper, Lear immediately gets pulled away by one of his advisors and as Galad takes her to Ashlyn's rooms, it's clear that all of the staff also hate her, like the rest of the people that she's encountered in the town and also most of the nights that she traveled with.

And she's introduced to her ladies maid who is a Martin, which if you don't know what a Martin looks like, please look it up because they're adorable. They they're like little like ferrets or weasels. They're so cute. But I assumed a Martin was a bird for a second. I had to go Google it. So Martin's are actually where Ermin comes from. It's their winter pelt. Yeah, they're they're so fucking cute. I looked it up too because I was pretty certain I knew what a Martin was.

But I have a picture of it in my notes and I was like, if this were my handmaiden, she would bite me immediately for trying to pet her. For sure. Like I'd be like, I want to snuggle with you. Thanks. So in this fair realm, animals have the ability to walk on to limbs and speak and they are sentient. And so this Martin is just one example of that. And she is it's my understanding that she's not Martin size, right?

Because Martin's like could fit in your pocket. But this is like a person size. Yeah, she says she is large, like large for her species, but even larger than that. Yeah, yeah. Something like that. Like I think she's like smaller than the fairies, but she is not teeny. I did have a question because as Ashlyn is meeting this Martin, it says the young Martin no older than Ashlyn herself. How could you possibly know how old a Martin is?

It's a great question. What is a 21 year old Martin look like? Also, she's definitely older than her. She's definitely older than her. So like what? Man, what? She's also described as being a little bit scarred. So like what made you say that? I don't know. There. I didn't mention this before, but we passed one of them. But there are some really interesting turns of phrase in this book that just I just didn't understand them.

Like I couldn't. Can you give me an example? Yeah. So there's another one that's going to come up later and I'll share when we get there. But there was one that I meant to talk about when we first met Lear and the line is even in the darkness, she saw how large his hands were. But to her surprise, they were elegant long slender fingers coiled in a primordial tongue, better left forgotten. What? Yeah. I don't. I. So I one thing that we should talk about.

And this is actually something that I saw in several of the reviews about this book is like there are some editing problems in this book where like there are things that don't follow like a linear. Like she'll say one thing and then later it'll be something different. Like, you know, I don't remember where it is, but at one point she's on the mount with Lear, but later she's on her own mount. And like there's no transition there and you don't. It doesn't really make a whole lot of sense. And like there's some pieces like that. And so I think this is just one of those things where like she was going for a certain thing and just put some words together to make that happen.

And yeah, it may not have quite accomplished what she wanted to her. Maybe she was going to go back and change it later and just didn't. Yeah, there was like later. So it is third person limited, but then later it's like kind of not. Yeah, it almost switches to third person limited for someone else. Yeah, I know what you're talking about. Yeah, and I'm like, what? So anyway, getting back to the Martin, the Martin's name is Gilrel and Gilrel leads Ashlyn to her chambers to Ashlyn's chambers, not Gilrel's chambers.

That would be weird. I would be weird. I wonder what her chambers look like. They talk. And in this conversation, we learned that Lear is Ashlyn's Cara, C-A-E-R-A. It didn't look up the pronunciation. I don't even know if it's a real word, but yes, I said Cara. I thought it was Carrera, but. There's too many R's. Yep. No, I know. I'm aware. America Carrera. So, so K-Rez to the Fae folk are essentially true mates. And we learned that Ashlyn and Lear could not have gotten married if they were not true mates.

So, Gilrel's assumption is that this is actually a union, whereas Ashlyn's assumption is that this is a political union. And all of that kind of makes Ashlyn's head spin. She's calling into question everything that she's thought about what, you know, her position is. And she kind of discards it out of hand. She's like, yeah, I just got lucky. Like he's lucky that I'm a smart person, right?

Like she deduced what his weapon would be. She wasn't pulled toward it. And so I think her thought process here is like, yeah, I'm not an idiot. Right. Where Gilrel is trying to be like, no, you literally could not have touched it. Right. Exactly. She's like, man, I'm just a smart lady. They're both coming at it from logic, but I feel like to your point, Liz, where Gilrel's like you literally couldn't have touched it. Ashlyn is hearing that like, but it's true love. Right. Which like, I don't blame her. So I've been like, yeah, okay, I didn't even know his name till 48 hours ago.

Yeah, for sure. You can't tell me this is love. But as a part of this conversation, Gilrel is like, oh yeah, there's another celebration that honors the union of your marriage. And Ashlyn in her inner monologue is like, okay, we haven't really consummated the marriage yet. So like, is that what we're doing here? And we kind of do get an out here where Gilrel tells Ashlyn that children are rare for the Fae and that there's never been a union between a mortal and a Fae before.

So she doesn't even know if they can conceive at all. So like, if somebody was trying to check their math via how long it takes Ashlyn to get pregnant, that is a totally unknown factor. But I think to our point to our point earlier, it doesn't kind of excuse them from having sex or like somebody checking their math on like, Ashlyn's a virgin and like, they got married and they should have sex and she's got a hymen and all of these things.

Right. Because they allude to all that classic stuff and they just like, never do anything with it. Right. So during this next kind of 48 hour period, Ashlyn sees nothing of Lear, despite the fact that they're supposed to share a room together. He just does not come to bed. And one day she's like getting ready with her chambermaid, Gilrel, and there's a commotion outside and she sees more knights coming to the castle who are wounded.

And she asks Gilrel what happened and Gilrel's like, well, it's another attack. And Ashlyn's immediately like, fuck, like, we just got married. I thought we like weren't doing any of this mortal Fae like bullshit anymore. Isn't that why I'm here? Right. And her chambermaid's like, oh no, no, no, no, no. This is an attack from the Anceli. And we learned that the Anceli are creatures that inhabit the Fae wilds and they are kind of this all inclusive moniker for a number of different species, including dryads, which is what Ashlyn and Lear encountered when they were coming back to and when.

Which is nice because in Coral Prince they dropped these words and we didn't know what they were. And nothing. But this, yeah, the Anceli, this like all-encompassing moniker for this wilder, more vicious, miscellaneous races. So in this period of time, it's clear that Ashlyn is not trusted because she's not allowed to roam the castle without an escort. And specifically, she's discouraged from leaving her room and her escort is either the Martin, Gilrel, or a series of magpies that just kind of follow her around, which I love that imagery of just these magpies making a nuisance of themselves,

especially when it's bad luck to see more than one magpie at once. She has like five? Yeah, she's got like five of these motherfuckers just bothering her. But the night of the celebration to celebrate her union with the king that she hasn't seen since they got married, she's left alone because basically Gilrel is called out for some reason and she's just like a well-known time like the present and she tries to ditch the magpies. She's only mildly successful, she's got three of them following her, but she kind of wanders along these castle halls that are described as almost being like the changing staircases in Hogwarts.

There's this sense that they're not always the same and that it's unsafe for a mortal like her to wander them for multiple reasons. She's the queen, so like no one ostensibly is going to harm her, but it's almost like the castle might like do some bullshit and like play some mischief with her. Just fuck with her. Yeah, and we kind of get that impression, right? Like there's these doors that are chained, there are these doors that she didn't remember before and like hallways changed as she's like walking down them.

And as she's in this kind of exploration, she runs into a snake, a black snake with violet eyes and it's important to note at this point that Ashlyn has violet eyes as does her father. It's something that she and she alone has inherited from him and so the snake is black, has violet eyes and basically does that little like tail come hither like, hey, follow me, let's go. Can we, what the fuck is the deal with this fucking snake? I don't know, but I love it.

I love it too. And I thought, I thought I knew what the snake was until we meet the snake like later and I was wrong. I think we haven't seen the last of this. I also think we have not seen the last of this snake, but I would like some more fucking details about this. I think personally my fan theory is that the snake is some kind of embodiment of Aina. Ooh, and I think that violet eyes are some kind of embodiment of Aina. Oh, I like that.

Yeah. So the snake leads her to a doorway and kind of through that doorway into this very damp, dank chamber, catacomb space where at the end of this hole, there is a statue of an owl with three eyes and a fountain. And the snake kind of disappears into the outstretched mouth of the owl. And she's like, okay, that's weird. And she's like immediately like, okay, piece on board.

And she tries to leave and immediately runs into Lear. Who's like, why are you here? Right. And Lear's pissed. He's like, what are you trying to steal from me? And I'm like, brother, there's nothing in here to steal. My thing is like, why are we going to thief? Like, maybe they sound like a good word for breaking and entering, but like, that's what's happening. It's not fever. Like literally, what would she be stealing? Also, she lives here. And she's the queen. Like this is my palace. Is it not?

No. Okay. And that's effectively what she said. She's like, I got bored, got lost. And here we are. Right. Like I was not doing anything suspicious. Don't be suspicious. Don't be suspicious. He gives up on that pretty quickly. He's like, cool, sounds great. And he like looks, looks pensively into the fountain. And then it's like, okay, let's go to the party. And that entire scene was very strange to me. And I think we get more information on why that might be strange later, but I still don't

fully understand why he was so weird. I, I don't know. But the next part that I do like is that Gilrel is at the party and it's like mad. I was like, you left her alone for hours. How can you match she showed up at her own party? Truly. How dare you? How dare you? We go to the party and one thing to know about this type of phase that they are the most active at night. And so this party takes place at night, but it's more like when you go to a Renaissance festival and there's like a jousting ring.

That's kind of what I picture is where they've ended up. And then there's like a platform where the royalty stay and they can like kind of see the entire ring. And then there's like crowds of people in stands outside of them. Yes. But in this field, they see three acts. First, the first act is basically a fertility dance where these Fae women dance in a circle with their fake magical rain and Gilrel tells Ashlyn that they're basically blessing her

womb to be fertile. And Ashlyn's like, super cool. Awesome. There's other things that must happen, but thanks for the rain. Yeah. Awesome. I love that. I wish that a penis penetrated me ever in my entire life. Anyway, the second act is female warriors and they do some mastery, but the important part here is that the leader of this fae, this female warrior troop is Petho.

And we learned that Petho is a princess from a different Fae realm or Fae kingdom and was once betrothed to Lear like Ashlyn was once betrothed to Dachvin. And Ashlyn feels some kind of way. She's like, oh yeah, I guess that makes sense. Yeah. Cool. Cool. Cool. Cool. Cool. And she's really good at being a warrior and Ashlyn is very bad at being a warrior. Was not trained to be so. No, she was trained.

She trains with her brother. She was just bad at it. Okay, you're right. Yeah. Which makes it worse. That does make it worse. Okay, but I have a question about that. And I guess we'll kind of get to that when we get there. But like she trained to fight. She wasn't good at it. The only thing she was good at was like horseback riding. Fine. But then later she has to hold a bow and arrow and she's like, oh, I've never seen one before. Like what? It looks like you have seen one before. You have to have like. The concept of what this is. Like there's some middle ground between like being bad at something and being good at something

and not having held like a weapon before in your entire life. Right. And like, right. They all use the same kind of weapons. Like it's all like swords, bows, spears. And in that scene to your point as I was waiting for her to be like, oh, how does this? This work actually, I'm a goddess at this, but that didn't. Right. Exactly. She just like, right. So the third and final trial is. It's a trial that requires both Lear and Ashlyn's participation.

And essentially the gist is that Lear must battle both his own warriors and some unsealing fey beast to prove himself worthy of being Ashlyn's partner. The problem is that Ashlyn also has to participate and be like an active damsel in distress character. And essentially Lear's like, do you trust me? And Ashlyn's like, we've spoken seven words together. No. And I'm like, girl, yeah, that's appropriate. Well, and then she sees that he has like a rope behind him or like a chain and she's

like, well, now I trust you a whole lot less. You want to fucking talk about that? What's that about? And he essentially says that like, you know, my people think that I should tie you to the stump because otherwise you're going to run away. And she's like, make fucking excuse me. She's like, you are not tying me anywhere. I will stay right. McFucking here. Thank you. And he's like, no, and to her credit, she does, but she gets real close to being eaten. So they bring out this unsealing beast and it's called a trowel and it's horrifying.

Like nightmare fodder kind of thing. And basically they give the trowel a head start and the rest of the nights have to kind of find their way through a maze and fight each other to get to Ashlyn to save her both from the trowel and claim her for themselves. And that goes about as well as you could expect. The trowel gets really close. Ashlyn gets a little bit splattered with blood, but Lear does eventually like stay true to his word and defeat both his nights and the trowel.

However, instead of killing the trowel outright, he incapacitates it with his vines, which are magic. And he goes up to her and the crowd is cheering like, kiss her, kiss her. And he's like, you know, the crowd wants me to kiss you, but first we got to, you know, kill this thing. And he hands her his axe and is like, kill it. She couldn't lift it before. But now she can. Right, but now she can. She doesn't, she doesn't think twice. It's just later now.

I have to believe that it was stuck so hard in the ground that it was like the sword in the stone kind of thing. Yeah, and not that it was just like really heavy with her noodle arms. I mean, I guess. Anyway, she beheads the trowel, but we don't see it. We just get like glimpses of memory. She kind of like, it fades to black a little bit. Yeah. And I wish that we had seen it because she balks. She's like, you're trying to corrupt me. Like, I'm not like that. I can't do this. And he's like, yes, you can. I'm trying to show you, I'm trying to show you that it's better to eat than to be eaten.

And I really like that perspective because he's like, look, look with your special eyes. You're being lied to. I know you're better than this. Yes. And he says something else to the effect of like, I'm not corrupting you like I'm showing you who you are. Yeah. Which I also really liked. So after these three trials, there's a feast. And at the feast, Ashlyn is left alone and Petho approaches and asks to call upon her at the Queen's earliest convenience. And Gilrel is with the Queen.

And as soon as Petho, like they exchange barbs, like Ashlyn and Petho are not saying nice things to each other, but it's that whole like political politeness thing going on. And as soon as Petho leaves, Gilrel is like, I'll make sure to prepare your clothes for the occasion and maybe I'll include some chain mail just in case. And I really like that was the first point at which Gilrel went from like totally hating her to kind of being like, we're on the same side. I fucking hate her.

I also hate her. Yeah. Yeah. So they, they continue on. Gilrel is like kind of in charge of babysitting Ashlyn. And at some point Ashlyn's like, you know, Gilrel, I'm not going to like hurt myself. He should go and enjoy the party. Mostly that she feels bad that she's keeping Gilrel from the party, but also so that she can get a moment of peace and alone time to herself. So Gilrel goes and Ashlyn goes deeper into the revelry. She finds a circle of dancers and is so enchanted that she wants to join.

But as she does so, the King finds her and prevents her from doing so. He warns her that it's probably unwise for immortal to join because it's a very intimate act in that they share power and she is immortal, mortal is not prepared for that. He brings her to the side of the forest. So if we picture kind of this festival happening in a Glen, the forest is kind of surrounding them and so they go to the edge of the forest so she can get kind of her head cleared from

the enchantment. And again, I see this great imagery and it says quote, her eyes rolled as she struggled to reply to the oaks who hung their heavy heads to ask her name. And I just love the, I know that he's the King of the Greenwood and but just the fantastical personification of trees and boulders and mountains. Like it just made it so magical feeling. Yeah. It was so magical. It did and very immersive because like it just felt like I was a part of that world and

I could visualize it that much clearer when she personified it. Yes. And it was consistent, which I appreciated. Like it wasn't just sprinkled in. It was like, this is what the world is without beating us over the head with it. So they have this conversation as Ashlyn is kind of trying to get her head right and it's along the lines of this push pull of power and truth that kind of begins to characterize their entire relationship in the book where he's pushing her to like understand what her perspective is and understand what she thinks.

And she's just beyond wary of everything that he says and has been taught and indoctrinated by her family a certain way about the Fae. And so they, this is one of those conversations where it feels like they're just going in completely opposite directions, but they're interrupted by a creature of the woods who attacks them. It's basically this big spectral wolf and in the attack Ashlyn takes off into the forest

and the beast pursues her. He eventually catches her and bites her. He bites her before Lier can get to her and save her. And in the fight she would have died except that the snake that lured her into the room before the celebration helps her. It's the same snake. So this is the black snake with the violet eyes and he like is distracting this wolf before it can totally devour Ashlyn in time for Lier to get to it and slaughter it.

And I just really love this snake. I love little snake boy. Okay. I'm not a snake person. They scare me. Fucking love snakes. I do like this snake, I do like this snake, but it is very clear to anyone with a brain that there is something going on with the snake and I just wish I had like any information at all about what is going on with this snake. I agree too. Yeah. Because also the snake appears and then like in the back half of the book it's just not there. Yeah.

We never, we don't see it anymore. Right. So you get this imagery and this foreshadowing and this theming and then it's just like dropped. Yeah. That was a bummer. Yeah. So after this attack she is brought back to the castle and is in recovery and she's being made to drink Leshy's tears and we learn that Leshy is an ancient tree elusive to all but the king of the greenwood and his tears which I have to assume are some kind of sap has healing power that will work to heal her wounds within essentially 24 hours.

And she in this process you know she's kind of reeling from this knowledge of knowing that they're unsealing it's a different type of fate different from this enemy that she has been brought up to believe her entire life is a single enemy and so she pens a letter to her father to that effect and is basically like haha I found this common threat to fate and mortals alike and at this point I can't help but think that her father is he has an old terrier motives at least yeah.

Did either of you play Cult of the Lamb? I haven't yet it's on my list. Well then this isn't going to matter but for any listeners who have played Cult of the Lamb one of the first couple bosses his name is Leshy and it's like this gooey creature blob-o thing and like that's all I could picture and it like kind of ruined the like magical tree tears. Okay but also the other thing that kind of ruined the Leshy's tears thing is that I

just couldn't help but make the comparison of Leshy's giz because it doesn't taste good. It doesn't taste good. I'm like how do you get Leshy's tears? And it's hard to get Leshy's tears. Apparently. I don't like that. Come on Desk. Thank you. This whole podcast is about reading sex books. All right. It's not what you're saying. It's the taste visual. The taste visual.

That I'm just hmm. So back to this letter that she wrote to her father. She asks Gallagher. She's like hey I want to send this letter. He's like cool. We have to have it reviewed first and so he brings her on this magical journey through the palace that doesn't matter and they find this other guy whose name I didn't write down until several pages later. Oh wait. This guy. Phil Varel. Phil. Phil. This is his name. Phillip. Phil Varel. So Phil.

Yeah they do call him Phil. So. Phil is like one of the top advisors to Lear and clearly not a fan of the union. But the best thing about this entire encounter is that Phil is like I don't think we've been formally introduced. But Ashlyn's inner monologue is like actually we've met twice before. We met at my wedding and then also last night. But that's cool. Okay. You do you. You do you buddy. Douchebag. He asks her what makes her think that her father doesn't already know about the unsealing

and she's basically like why would he lie to me and he's like fine I'll post the letter if this is what it takes for you to believe that your father said douche. And that's the end of that conversation for now. A few days on she's still waiting for a reply and hasn't seen Hyde nor hair of Lear since the night that she got attacked. But he finally does return and with him brings her her dagger. So she had thrown this dagger at the the beast that attacked her and had considered it gone

forever. And she thinks that she's basically dreaming when he comes back because she's like half asleep half awake and he sets this dagger on the nightstand and basically sings a lullaby to get her to sleep. And in the morning she is again alone. It was so this is again where I was like we're getting there like this is so like she thinks she's dreaming and he's like watching her and she even says like if it's a dream then I can do whatever I want and I can touch you and I'm like so touch and then she doesn't

touch her. I know. Right. And it's just it's it's the slow burn which I love I love a slow burn. However, generally that right this is like at some point it does have to. It's like a smoker. It's like 35 hours or something. Yeah, you're waking up super early to put it on and it's got to sit there for like six weeks and yeah. I'm hungry now. Right.

But they don't catch fire. Don't they don't catch fire. Instead when she wakes up alone, Gilrell informs her that today is the day she goes to the training grounds to meet with Petho. Remember Petho asked to meet with her at her earliest convenience. I think this is her earliest convenience. So why I don't know. Why she has nothing else on her agenda. Nobody checked with her schedule. It feels like she's very out of control. Pethos convenience. Yeah. Pethos convenience. So they play this game where essentially they ride stags toward a dummy that's nicknamed

after Ashlyn's father, the firehand of the north and they have one arrow and whoever strikes its head first wins. I thought this was really cool. I thought it was like a neat game that I would love to like see Don at like run fairs and stuff like that. Like I think this could be really, really neat. Yeah. And then talk about the strategy like you can either like speed run to try to get closer to have an easier shot or you can shoot from farther away and like pull first.

Like I liked all the inner workings of that strategy. I did too. Yeah. And this was the scene where Ashlyn acts like she's never held a bow before and it's like okay but you've actually talked about holding a bow before so I don't know why that's a thing and I really wanted her to be like, haha I'm actually a badass at bow and arrow and also writing. And she's not. She's good at writing. There are two rounds before Gilro goes against one of Paytho's people and wins and then Gallad goes against the other lackeys and I forget who wins it doesn't matter.

And then of course Ashlyn goes against Paytho and she does ride really well. She catches up to Paytho even though she kind of balks at the start and is like a league behind her. But when she shoots her arrow she misses miserably. Really though before they start the match, Paytho shares that Lear had been like not only was he once upon a time like we learned that he was engaged to or supposedly going

to be engaged to Paytho but before that he actually had another marriage to I forgot her name. We don't get her name but it was she was her his Kara. And she was. And they lost her in childbirth. They lost both the baby and her in childbirth. I also like okay Paytho's a bitch but I did like the Mean Girl vibe of like I'm going to tell you this okay let's go race now.

Like she just drops his bomb and is like you ready? And I was like I did too. And I also liked I mean so I don't know I'm torn a little bit with Paytho because based on what happens later in the book I actually don't think Paytho's a Mean Girl. I think that she's a little bit put out that she didn't get to marry Lear but like she says you know I'm telling you because I don't think anybody else would. Which is fair. And Ashlyn should know.

And she's right nobody else did tell her. And wouldn't have. Right. Because I mean Lear didn't even tell her his own fucking name. So we're not going to talk about his like baby mama. So Paytho wins and Ashlyn is like I guess I better go find my arrow but she does this more to like get some space from people because she's like fucking pissed for a number of reasons. So she's like thrashing around in the forest trying to look for this arrow that she doesn't need to retrieve herself and she runs into Lear.

And Lear like does this hot thing where he like corners her against a tree and he's like you shouldn't be out here alone and I'm like now fuck. And they don't. And they don't. He's just like. And then he goes I'll meet you tonight and you can tell you can explain to me how a mortal princess learned to ride like that. And I was like oh yeah. Oh yeah. And then nothing comes of it. No they like don't even talk about it. I'm not even sure. I'm not even sure they meet that night. They go to dinner.

They go to dinner. But it's not. She thinks it's going to be just him and her and it's like him and her and like 14 other motherfathers. Like his entire court. It's like what happened to me showing you how I ride that well. I'll show you how I ride. I yeah. No it's a bummer. Yeah. Because she even comments she's like are there always this many is she attending with the attending dinner with the king. And he's like oh yeah to celebrate his return and she's like. Fucking. Can we just not celebrate for like a hot second.

We have no personal time like can we have no conversation like that's what I'm saying at the beginning of this. Can we not just have lunch. Can you not just have a normal fucking conversation with me for like two hours. And then and then so she arrives. Wait hold on before they arrive to dinner. There's one thing. It's the last time we see the snake. Oh yeah. Lear leaves her in the forest and remember she was looking for the arrow. Lear leaves and she watches him leave and then the snake like a good fucking golden retriever

drops the arrow at her feet and is just like I did this for you. I did this. I got this for you. I made this. And I was just like yes I'm so here for the snake and then it never comes back again. And I'm like motherfucker. Where's the snake. Where's the snake. Anyway back at dinner. But the line when I don't know if it's dinner or I think they're dancing before dinner or maybe it's they're dancing afterwards. I don't really know but when she shows up and Lear finally like makes his she shows

up and Piazo. Not Piazo. I like that name. Petho and Lear are dancing together and she's kind of like put out by this but then when Lear eventually makes his way to her the first thing he says to her is you drive me mad waiting and I was like yes. I know but then okay okay okay okay let's talk about this fucking scene okay because he requests her presence at supper. It's the first time that she has had a meal outside of her chambers.

Alone in her chambers. Which like makes fucking no. And to the point where Petho remarks on that during that celebration where she had to like be saved or whatever. And she's like oh we haven't seen you at blah blah and she's like yeah I've just been acclimating whatever. Meanwhile she hasn't been allowed out of her chambers and this is the first time and then when she shows up when she shows up he didn't even have the decency to escort her from their own fucking room to the dinner that he requested her attend.

She shows up and he's dancing with his former fiance and he has the caucasity to walk up to her and say you drive me mad with waiting. Jump off a fucking bridge Lear. Go fuck yourself. You know I didn't even think about it like that. That is some bullshit move. I didn't either. That's some fucking bullshit. No no ma'am. You can miss me with that. Oh no and she says something quippy back and I was like girl yes but it wasn't quippy

enough and it just like I think that's the problem that I had with this book. It's like the author built and then just like left it right like we didn't go anywhere from there. The protagonist Ashlyn has so much rage and so much grounds to be that bitch and just be like you know what you're actually a fucking douche and I hate you and it has nothing to do with the fact that you're a fay and I'm immortal it's got everything to do with the fact that you haven't said a fucking word to me. I know nothing about you and the first time we went to dinner you were dancing with your

fucking fiance that I didn't even learn about from you. She told me herself and I don't know where you sleep most nights but all of that angst just goes nowhere. It goes nowhere. It goes nowhere and so I'm sitting here fucking blue-balled. Not only do they not have sex but she doesn't even get to appropriately like express any of those feelings. No yeah. You're right. So the quip that she says back is you shouldn't claim to wait upon which you dread.

Oh yeah. And like she spends so much time. One of the things that did kind of aggravate me is she the author spends no spare moment telling us how much the people and everyone hates her and I don't think we get enough of like her to your point Katie being able to hate back. Right. Like she can't or shouldn't because they're justified and therefore she somehow is not justified. So we have to move on and I know that we've kind of talked that this whole scene has

happened but before this whole interaction with Lear and Ashlyn happens Phil meets Ashlyn and it's just like taunting her about her father like hey have you heard back yet even though he knows the answer. Yes. I just do. I hate him so much. It's like baiting Ashlyn and Ashlyn's just like fuck off and not here. Lear shows up and she says that sassy thing back like you shouldn't say that about something that you so clearly dread and Phil says this thing.

He says perhaps this perhaps the fledgling requires sustenance and just like walks off the flesh. The flesh. Yes. And he just strikes me as the sassiest of gay friends to the king. He's just like I don't know maybe feed it or whatever. I'm going to go have fun. I don't know. It seems cranky. Yeah. It seems cranky but I don't know why fleshlings are. Fleshlings are weird like that. I think maybe maybe feed it. Yeah. So all of this angst happens and then they go and they eat and like the author does a

really good job here of illustrating how isolated Ashlyn is because she's at this meal surrounded by let's not even go into the fact that they're Faye versus mortals but she's just in a different country and everybody's speaking in their native tongue that she doesn't understand because her fucking shitty ass two disaster of a family didn't decide to teach her Faye. And so they're all talking and she's just like I guess I'll go fuck myself here by myself

with no one to talk to you until eventually they do speak in her tongue and they briefly talk about how well she rode the stag against Petho but then immediately go into this topic of the unsealing and how Lear wants to use her as bait to negotiate with them. And I'm like again you're put into the situation where it's like how about you could just go fuck yourself dude like no. And it absolutely not. It felt so manipulative like oh I'd love to see you for supper and you could talk to me about how well you ride.

Oh I'm going to say how you drove me mad with waiting. Hopefully I just want to use you for like this really dangerous thing. Cool awesome. Great. I love that journey for me. It's fantastic. So that's it. I mean she's basically like okay yeah I guess do I have a choice because she's had this lawful good subservience beat into her from the patriarchy and so she like is getting

ready in her chambers and Lear comes to see her and finds her dressed and ready and is like oh man half my men are going to be disappointed that they lost that bet and I'm like you're such a fucking douche. That was so rude to me and like when has she ever bulked? Like she stood there waiting to almost be eaten by the thing. Like she why do you think she wouldn't be ready? Also you know nothing about her. You know nothing about her. They have an experience in the forest where like they were hanging out the best opportunity

they had to chat with each other and like got attacked by that spectral wolf thing and she stabbed this thing. Yeah right. Like she was trying so like why? And she stabbed it to try and save him. Like that he would save herself so why are you giving her zero credit? Yeah right. She essentially says that she's like oh yeah have a good laugh like why don't you just put me in front of these unsealing and have me killed and get over it. Do us both a favor so we don't have to fucking pretend anymore and he's like despite what

many of my people might wish I won't let harm come to you and I'm like fucking why? Like you're the only one that seems to be at all to have any affinity for this person at all and even that is like right passing it. It seems very passing at best. And Ashlyn in this conversation is still warring between her like learned doctrination from her family and what Lear is telling her and what she's observing with her own eyes.

So in their journey to go and try to bait the unsealing they ride in the forest and Lear and Ashlyn are riding together. Of course. So in their ride Lear says you know I'm bored tell me a story tell me of the things that the mortals say of our kind and she tells him that the lore she tells him of the lore that she knows which is mostly untrue or kind of blended with what the unsealing versus

the the high fay are and suddenly out of the blue Lear asks about Dagfin and she deflects and he pushes more. He's like the fact that you won't answer a simple question makes me all the more curious and I'm like the fact that I don't know anything about you makes me want to smack you in the fucking face. So no. Who are you to like quiz me on Dagfin who you already like you've met where I only found out about your past two exes from one of those exes.

And let's be clear Lear still hasn't told her about those exes himself. He's not even aware that she knows I don't think. Nope to be fair the first so finding out about Pytho she learned about from was it Gallad or the Gail real Gail real yeah got it yeah yeah but it's still not him and that's problematic. Yep. And so they're talking and then abruptly he's like wait stop talking and he like presses

his hand against the tree to like listen to the trees or whatever and he can be into the tree Ashlyn is aware of the language that they're talking but she can't quite get like the specifics and that's part of her ostensibly queen of the Greenland power but then when Lear is done he kind of has this moment he's like what if I just and he grabs her hand and pushes it against the tree itself and she has this moment where she's like she's inundated with the magic of the tree trying to speak with her to the point where she's

so overwhelmed she can't move her hand because he's not letting her and so she brings out the iron dagger that he returned to her and slices his hand so he will let her go. I love that. I did too. It was her owning some shit and like finally like standing up for herself a little bit and I really appreciated that. I did too because she's like no you can't force me to do this I this is uncomfortable and I don't want to. And I don't understand what you're doing anyway. So Lear is like ow and reveals that the trees don't lie and that they told him that she

is not quite mortal and not quite fey. This is the first indication that we have that this narrative that we've gotten of this mortal queen might not be so true. He has this really great line that I highlighted that's somewhere around here and again trying to show like Ashlyn like okay well you're not who you think you are and he says the skin of a lamb will never flatter a wolf. I really like that.

It was such like an interesting twist on like the wolf in sheep's clothing but more of that like don't make yourself smaller than you are which I think for all of Lear's issues he is very much pushing like you can be more than you think you are and I do really like that. So they're out in the wilderness and they made this big show at dinner they're like we leave tonight so we can meet with these unsealys but they can't for three days and they don't see any sign hide nor hair of the unsealys and I'm like was this really that like we had to leave like that night?

Right like they're just kind of traipsing through the woods. Yeah Lear's men are growing impatient and they're basically making comments like we should just leave her out here if we're really using her as bait why don't we do that and Lear's basically like be patient I've got a plan blah blah. As they make camp for the third night Gilrel is like applying a salve to Ashlyn's face because she's gotten sun burnt and so this is the first time that Gilrel is just like oh oh that's not good oh I'm so sorry that's oh I pity you.

Okay so I really liked that scene but I don't understand how she's sun burnt when they only travel at night. Well I don't I don't know when they travel actually because they are most active at night but it's clear that they're making camp at night now so I don't. Is it later that they like sleep during the day? That switches at some point. It does. Yeah because at one point they say like making camp or they were asleep just before dawn

and I'm like did you just go to bed or did you are you gonna wake up soon? Yeah I don't know. But I think this is one of those examples of the continuity things that could have used a little bit more editing it's like what time are we in? Yes. I will say the sunburn thing makes sense to me because if you're sleeping outside when like you are not used to being like if you're sleeping outside during the day. I think I just pictured her in like a tent but maybe she's not in one. Yeah I don't think they had tents this time. No that's true but I did like the scene of like oh.

It doesn't really matter the point here is that Gillrel is starting to form a relationship with Ashlyn and like not hate her so much which is endearing. It is endearing and it's also kind of funny too because I mean I read into this because they're fey and magic but that like this realization of like oh yeah you're mortal like you can burn like oh. Yeah. Curse. So after this it hated the scene they like make camp and this was rough.

Phil is there and Ryan is there. Ryan is the guy that was talking about the the original curse Phil is the asshole advisor guy and then Gallaud's there and I think a couple other people and they essentially take turns telling her how her father murdered a bunch of people like murdered and tortured. Yeah. Yeah. This was rough. And I was like why are we doing this like okay let's assume for one moment that her father

is absolutely a tyrant who is just murdering and pillaging because he likes to do so. Let's not pretend that in war both sides are blameless one and let's also go a step further and realize that this person knows fuck all about any of you and probably has no idea what her father is doing like to put the sins of one person on somebody like this felt very

bad and I like I just this I didn't like the scene at all. Well so I think the thing that's most troubling is like so they're talking about their experiences with this and like they're being prompted to by Phil and he gets to one person I forgot who it is now who was like severely tortured by her father. It's glad. Phil is one who's been like yes to her. And he doesn't want to talk about it because he realizes that like this is upsetting to her and like yes they want her to understand what's truly going on but I think one there's a better way to go about it and two like Gellad says like no I'm I'm all set like I don't

need to tell her and Phil goes over and like lifts up his shirt so that she can see these like horrible scars and it's like whoa man like that's not like you're not respecting anybody's boundaries at this point you're just being a dick. Yeah it made me really uncomfortable like none of it like there were a couple of them there were like yeah let's twist the knife but that like hey I'm just gonna forcibly remove your clothing so that we're gonna like show the worst moment of your life to this girl who had nothing to do with it like I get trying to show her like who her father is

but there were better ways to do that and this did not feel like the moment for it or the way to do it. It felt very much like it it was just jarring right like this scene maybe would have been more impactful if like she had actually a relationship with like anybody around that campfire but it really felt like mean girls like at high school being like oh you're fat and also you're ugly and also I slept with your dad like okay Gina I just got here like

can you fucking let up for a minute like she's alone she doesn't understand your language she doesn't she has spoken five words maybe with her husband she's friendless she knows that you all hate her thank you I don't need you to tell me that you all hate me I can see it in your fucking eyes like it just felt like why are we piling on here like there's more ways if you wanted her to understand what her father was doing you could have done it in a different way and to follow on to that why do you care that she understands what

her father is you all clearly hate her anyway what does it matter what she thinks. So from my perspective like I found the scene really jarring but I can also understand kind of where they're at a little bit in terms of like I think they are afraid that she will that she is still being used against them and so they are trying to get her to see the quote unquote light before she enacts any sort of plans that might be to their detriment and so they're trying to get her to understand the severity of what they're dealing with

it's not just like them versus the human it's like these are actual lives these are these are actual people because it's very easy especially if someone who like if you are not directly involved with like your people which she clearly isn't she's been sheltered for forever it's very easy to be like oh yeah like I know people are dying but like it's you know whatever I think this was a moment of like trying to get her to really understand I agree the placement was wrong and I agree the severity of it was wrong and I think like it just it wasn't okay but I understand to a certain extent why they did it I just wish they would have gone about

it in a much better way and to tack on to that Lear's response to this afterwards does not make the situation better no and that's kind of what I'm saying it's like they're piling on and they're like oh yeah they tortured us and like at this point with Ashlyn I would have been like yeah and you guys are kind of a bunch of assholes like right why the fuck should I care like that so like that's why it was so jarring like yes it's awful and but like and I understand where maybe they're coming from but like they've also given her

no reason to sympathize with them it's like okay cool yeah I've got you've also murdered my people right exactly that's what I'm saying it's like okay cool thank you for showing me all of the torture that happened but like also we're like what do you want me to do about it right I'm here I'm here with you guys are actively trying to use me as bait like I'm trying to make it better and I'm here willingly like why yeah I'm not trying to kill y'all I guess yeah but so speaking of Lear's like reaction they stop like assaulting

her with all of these stories of torture and she kind of goes to bed and cries and Lear approaches her and realizes that she's been crying and realizes that she didn't know what her father is doing and but but basically offers her no comfort he's just like you know it was important for you to know and it's like okay well it's important for me to not cut your dick off and yet I'm restraining myself every moment and yet here we are we also learn

that the one who was branded the Gail Rell and Gailad like I know the whole time yeah I was like if you're gonna have two characters that are gonna be close to the main character please don't start them with like the same three letters almost but it was her brother Starn the heir who did that which I think was also like shocking to her and I only bring that up because it comes up later in like the weirdest fucking way so instead of

trying to get the unsealing to come to them they end up going to the unsealing's territory and specifically they go to a series of caves the mouths of the caves in kind of this clearing and they try to lure them out these specific unsealing are called Fomori and they're kind of like ogres like big ogres and Lear essentially baits them by cutting Ashlyn's palm so that she bleeds I did think it was funny we're like I think he was gonna do it anyway but

he cuts her palm and he's like that's for stabbing me at the tree okay sassy pants you deserve it right so they smell her blood and then Lear like glamours himself so they can't see him and these Fomori come out and are basically like oh my god it's her we could just eat her and nobody would know and so Lear's baiting them into breaking his law which they do and then a scuffle ensues and in the chaos Ashlyn is attacked and this voice

inside her is like let me help let me help let me help and she essentially hands the reins over to that voice and she engulfed her assailant in purple flames which is a manifestation of the fey wild magic around her that the fey wield but mortals typically cannot and so Phil comes over sees this and is like girl what the fuck and then I guess like they just don't ask a follow-up question because they stay out for another couple weeks

looking for other unsealings and like no questions like nobody has a conversation about this nobody's like hey what's up they wait a couple of weeks and they're like hey can you do it again and she's like no and they're like cool no follow-up questions and I'm done here thank you girl what it's like so okay they argue about what happened and they're like there's no way that could have happened and Phil's like I saw what I saw and they're all talking across Ashlyn and then they finally do like I say ask if she can do it again and she's

like no I don't think so and then they're just like okay I guess we're gonna move on yeah that's the extent of the conversation and she's even like I don't even know if it was me like what but we don't know when talks about it yep so the next unsealings that they encounter they go into some sea caves and they talk to the marrow who lives there who lives there that are essentially like mermaids picture the scene in Peter Pan where they go to mermaid lagoon like that's essentially the scene that happens where the marrow were

like oh my god Lear who's that ugly hag you have with you and he's like it's my wife you're so right and Lear asks them two questions the first is he asks where Danu queen of the dryads is because apparently Danu has the sight and has seen the end of the war between the fey and the mortals and the second question he asks is what is Ashlyn so they answer the

first and they tell them where Danu is but for the second they have no answer they like cut her palm again bring it into the ocean so they can like see her better quote unquote but they essentially say that the seas have not seen anything like her before and so they can't tell him what she is but she's not quite mortal and she's not quite fey which like great the trees said the same thing which is not helpful they counsel Lear though that he should kill her before others do it for him and I was like oh it's dark in here it's so dark

in here oh my god I know and poor Ashlyn is just like how there's so much going on that I'm thinking in her head like if I'm bop around with my husband that I don't really know and he just keeps asking things what I am and now everyone wants to kill me because I'm not human what and they're telling him everyone's also once again I just had this thought so

he calls her a thief when she's in that one room when she first arrives at the palace or whatever and now she's being called a thief again because it she has stolen power that she should not have and I wonder if there's any correlation there probably not but I think it's interesting I think there probably is like I think that Lear knows more than he's letting on even after the end of this book agree so after this encounter their party travel to the Isle of Mirrors where Danu is said to reside and on their way they make

camp once and Lear takes Ashlyn to a hot spring and he's essentially like alright this is where I'm gonna start training you to use the Feywild magic and we're gonna do it in water so you can't kill me or set anything on fire. He also tells her she stinks. Yeah he does tell her she stinks and it's like okay cool also so do you. Also I don't give a flying fuck because we don't talk. We don't talk. We don't talk anymore so okay one thing that we should mention is that the Fey don't like

fire categorically they don't have fires in their homes they don't like fires to keep warm they don't possess fire magic that's like fire is very much a symbol and a weapon of humans and so when Ashlyn uses Fey magic to conjure fire that's like unheard of nobody does that. And so we'd learn about later.

So that's one of the reasons why everybody's super wary but anyway just to kind of call that out. In this first teaching she's successful she conjures fire almost as a product of drowning almost. Right yeah. So I mean so Lear brings them both underwater and he's like if you use magic you can breathe and she's like yeah let me work on that and right as she's about to drown because he's

holding her underwater she is able to use the Fey magic and learns how to wield it. Also I'm sorry he's going to teach her how to wield it and that essentially is like I'm going to hold you underwater I promise you can breathe not going to tell you how and then you're just going to also find your fire. I'm a great teacher. So the other thing about this one scene is that they kind of make reference to like Lear training her subsequently and so she has like kind of a passable hold on her ability to

like channel Fey wild magic but it's a very loose magic system here. I really wanted more information about it because it sounds like the magic is sentient and even in her in her monologue as she's training she's like oh I like I've learned how to like coax it and I've had to scold it and praise it and I'm like I want to see that like I want to see your relationship growing this magic and even Lear's like it's immature like you have to grow with it.

Like show me how that works. Yeah I would have liked that too because in the couple of scenes that we do like when she was fighting off the Fomori she almost has a conversation with the magic because the magic is like speaking to her and is like let me in or like let me help and it feels like she could actually have that kind of internal verbal conversation with magic but we just don't see any of it. Yeah which was kind of disappointing to me.

So Des are we at the part where she sees the snake? Yeah so I'm trying to understand exactly like what's happening here but basically he's having her hold out her hands while they're in the water and she does that and then he like looks up to the forest as though he's waiting for someone or something and the snake slithers out onto the branches of glass littering this is so weird a familiar snake slithered through

the branches of glass littering the forest. Yeah it's a weird turn of phrase. There must be a typo I think it might mean grass. The branches of grass? Yeah maybe hissing excitedly as it dragged its sinuous form down the rocks and into the waters and this is on page 302 basically the snake like quail between her hands and she talks about how like sometimes she can sometimes sense something a feeling that is not her own a sensation separate from herself like pangs of hunger from a fox or the anxiety of a doe

and he says that's you know how it begins and then he says you remind me of this serpent scales as black as the crow beddines with rare shades of violet this is the most venomous creature in all of the isles of rindern despite its size. Yeah and then the snake just goes away. It goes back into the rocks. Yeah yeah I remember reading that too the especially the venomous part. I did like that I was like oh interesting what's a twist.

Yeah it like untingles itself from her hands and then just fucks off. Just like fucks off. Yeah I really wanted the snake to be more and I think it is we're just not there yet I guess. Yeah I hope so on their way to the Isle of Mirrors Ashlyn does finally receive a letter but rather than it being from her father it's from Dagfin who says that her letter to her father caused an uproar and that the mortals have been kind of talking about it ever since

and that they're calling for another union between the two species specifically between Dagfin and Petho which is dun dun dun. This causes most of the party to basically split up right so she gets the letter and then everybody reads it because they're basically like oh what she got there I'm gonna read that myself. I just like toss it around. Yeah found very immature but essentially everybody but Ashlyn

Lear and Gallad and rain. Like go back. This is the fourth one. Is it Ryan? I think it's Ryan but it doesn't matter because we don't see anything. Yeah so essentially there's two people there's four people that stay to pursue the Isle of Mirrors and Danu and the rest of them go back to the kingdom because essentially Lear's entire court or most of it is kind of out in the Feywilds just fucking around and if these negotiations are gonna go on he wants a presence in those discussions

and so he sends them all back. When specifically Gilrel departs it's clear that Gilrel's become really fond of Ashlyn and she's like I'll be waiting for you when you return which I thought was really cute because Ashlyn's like no go it's fine I'll be back soon I'll see you when I return and I was like oh I think maybe Gilrel's gonna die that's not what happens but it was they made the scene so like important and like not a part of the narrative like they called it out a little

bit. Yeah that I was like oh this is gonna be something about this isn't right. Which I'm glad that that's not what happened because I really like Gilrel. I know me too so after most of the party has come has gone back to Erwin or Ann-Wynne sorry not Erwinne. You're close. Ashlyn can't sleep and so one morning she sits on the ledge of a cliff which like hello ledge vibes like who who just dangles their legs off the edge of a cliff. Tra la la la la I like death so Lear joins her and they

talk about true mates and Lear asks her if she really knows what that means and she's like I mean not really like no one's talked to me about it and he's just like well my father and mother were the first true mates blah blah and this is where we learn where Lear's parents are Aina and that other king who basically foresuck their responsibilities and fell in love and had such a doomed fate.

Doomed mankind. Yeah do we learn that here? Yeah. I mean he says that his first his his father and mother were the first true mates that the gods experimented with. Yeah she makes the conclusion she's like oh I know it's your mom and he's like yeah. Yeah interesting okay I did not catch that I didn't catch that until we covered it later with Danu. Yeah they don't explicitly say like oh my gosh I know was your mother but she's like oh I've heard this story before. I've seen

this tree. Right so she accuses Lear of going into their wedding ceremony knowing that he would kill her because she was not his true mate because he's already had one and like having two true mates is basically unheard of and he bristles and he's like you don't know what you're talking about and she's just like well fucking fine I guess I don't know what I'm talking about and like stands up and walks away and I'm like good you should do that I would be on the same exact page as you like fine I don't know what I'm talking about fine you don't want to tell me we don't have to talk.

Bye. Well so he also gets mad because he says like it's easier for you this way isn't it so be it believe me you're wicked fey legend your nightmare come to life and then like gets mad and leaves. So glad we could be adults about this. I know like I feel I don't know I feel like at that point they're both just digging their heels in like I see where she's digging her heels in and I totally

get that I don't understand why he's just not like hey can we have a can we talk about like several things. Right because she has no reason to trust him like he really hasn't given her any reason to trust him. Well and like okay we should talk about this when we get to the the point where the big reveal so let's get to the big reveal and then we'll talk about this. So they go they see Danu and it's revealed that Lear is like we intuited the son of the two original

rulers and heir actually to two kingdoms the greenwood and the mountains and therefore the most powerful fey. Danu tells him that the mortals will overrun the world but she doesn't know when and she says that Ashlyn is a new creature and she's she says that Ashlyn is a new creature as was Lear's mother and there will be more like her but she can't say what side Ashlyn specifically will be on. Danu decides to leave like leave the conversation and basically sends all four of them

flying backward into different tidal pools around her and then we kind of wait do we know do we find out what she knows about the prophecy at this point? Yes. So it says uh so your mother's prophecy at last came to be did you know that when you fulfill when you agree to the union did you foresee your mother's prophecy or did you intend to behead the moral princess and he says I knew of the prophecy and Ashlyn's like what prophecy and Gallup's like hey maybe don't ask any questions

but then Danu says like I guess I'm the one best able to tell this um basically uh before his mother and the people of Odd, Iod, yeah yeah were cursed she gave one last prophecy for she was blessed with a sight like my own a warning to her only son heir of Greenwood a promise that he'd be bound to not one but two careras and the second would be a love unmatched reckless ruinous love capable of destroying kingdoms and playing with the earth plaguing the earth a harbinger of great

upheaval and certain death. Yes okay so now that we're here let's have this conversation because I don't understand from Lear's perspective if he goes into this knowing that prophecy why he wouldn't have a conversation with Ashlyn and like try to get to know her and impart this knowledge because he's fucked yeah like he knows he's fucked so like you're doing yourself no favors by like keeping her in the dark. No especially because like Danu doesn't know what side she's gonna be on so

you think they're beating Ashlyn over the head with like hey mortals aren't great your dad sucks but without any like but this is our counter like they're not there's no carrot to the stick it's just stick it's just stick. Well and so the other thing too is like two pieces one I wonder if there's a reason that he stayed away it was like try and make sure that she got to have a say in like how she felt but like you could have a conversation with her without like that being a thing two

I also wonder like how she gets mad later on at some people who knew things and didn't share them with her but I also wonder how many people because yes the prophecy was only shared with Lear but it indicates that Galad knew the prophecy as well and it's like okay so all of you knew and also oh this is my second point how are y'all gonna have that kind of love because you haven't spent more than two fucking seconds together yeah like in any sort of like kind way so like how this

is a love to like end all loves right yeah I'm gonna need some convincing yeah exactly and I just when I got to this point in the book I was like I was very confused because I'm I was here I was buckled up I was here for the story and then I just got lost because I didn't understand why specifically Lear was acting the way that he was or chose to do the things that he did because it's

like it's in your best interest to do the exact opposite of what you've been doing especially because you did have all the information right so and then and then and then he's still he's still okay he still chooses to let things happen and put specifically Ashlyn in a position where she is at a hundred going into a very volatile situation so let's let's get into the volatile

situation uh so Danu like retreats flings the four of them into different tidal pools and when Ashlyn wakes up she's in a different place she's in like this cavernous kind of reservoir looking place and she feels in her mind more than she sees a beast approaching her and this beast tells her that she can call them friend but instead of like I don't know asking a follow-up question

she immediately summons fire and like sets herself on fire to like help to to basically fend off this this this friend fey fire yeah yeah this friend um and as she does this Gilrel and Petho kind of come like repelling down from the skylights and find her and they're like oh my god you're on fire you're alive and also you're on fire and they tell her that she's in the aqueducts of Anne and when Anne when thank you she's in the aqueducts of Anne when and that

she's been missing for two months and so um Danu must have flown her forward in time rather than just like away from her physically at the moment they tell her that when she couldn't be found Lear lost his ever-loving mind and searched the gorge where they met Danu searched the city searched every place um but now two months later they're on the eve of Petho's wedding to Finn

and Lear is on his way to tell Ashlyn's father that Ashlyn is dead and I'm like wow we really peer through right not yeah what who did I say you just said Finn and like that would be a completely new character for us yeah no Dagvin yeah Dagfin nicknamed Finn in the book um and I was like wow we really went from zero to a hundred really quick I hated this so much yeah it's worth

noting that like we have about a hundred pages left right I like the concept of this but I really wish that we hadn't spent 200 pages in the middle of the book doing fuck all right I wish that had been edited a little bit more so that we could just go a little bit further in this storyline because it feels very much that there was action in the beginning of the book and action at the end of the book and then like a whole bunch of nothing in between yeah or use that time to actually build relationships right any meaningful way right but no and I think what really bothered me and we

talked about this a bit in the beginning is it just felt very plot-devicey it's like okay I'm tired of filling time we gotta get two months in the future so let's just like have her disappear for two months and we don't see any of that time and then there's zero fallout from her being missing right okay but that's the other thing because there's there's zero stakes in this particular timeline because Petho herself it's the eve of her own fucking wedding and she's stayed behind okay back to what I was saying before about Petho not being really a mean girl she chose to stay behind

to search for Ashley yeah she actually gives a fuck she does give a fuck I think she gives more of a fuck about Lear than she does Ashley and though because like fair because and that's so here's the thing I love a like tear the world apart to find you kind of thing like I also love that trope and I think that's what this was trying to get at but the payoff again is just not there no and like I like the idea that like he is so enamored with her that he tried to find her

blah blah blah but again I just don't understand it because I don't I don't see I don't see that undying love I don't see that madness ever in this no we don't see that and that's what I'm saying earlier like at the reunion we still don't see it he's just like oh hey us uh yeah well and and even in this situation like she's been gone for two months and like maybe he tore like the earth apart to find her but like we don't see any of that and also I was thinking oh he's gonna show up to this place tell her father that she's dead and then her father's gonna be like you know what let's let's

fucking wrap it up here guys we're at war again and then it's gonna be this whole other storyline of trying to like make peace but she's like fully bought in on the fey and nobody believes that she's alive like that would be interesting yeah that would be interesting but no she fully can get to the like wedding fair grounds like within enough time and she shows up and appears physically before everybody and everybody's just like oh my god you're there and even lear is just like oh good

you're here so glad you're here so glad yeah so yeah I mean so she shows up and they're just like oh my god hi but it's not like fall to the the earth wrap you in my arms kiss you until you can't breathe anymore it's just like I'm gonna take your hand and we're gonna calmly walk up to your family now that I don't have to tell them you're dead and so the line specifically is you offered Ashlyn a hand a hand she accepted without thought as he lowered her to the earth

lower her to the earth clasping her waist as he did so his touch protective desperate the will to hold more than her mere hand harrowing his red rimmed eyes eyes riddled with the signs of sleepless nights and rumored mania and that is all we get yeah that's it I wish we had gotten so much more the only thing about this kind of um return I guess there's two things one the people who see her the like common people that see her call her scala which means thief and I love that I do

love that but also Gilrell tells her they think that you rose from the dead and so that's introducing kind of like an origin christ story element that I hope they go into in the future but they don't in this book so I can't speak to that no and they also move on from that really quick they're like oh yeah they think you rose from the dead but they're gonna call you thief like the whole it was just sort of like this is also happening but we're not going to talk about it well because it feels like this book like this thing happened where she was missing for two months and then suddenly she appears

but we're immediately into a situation that's filled with minutiae that has nothing to do with that no and it doesn't give us time to process any of that either right because they are basically they've met on this wedding ground battleground neutral territory thing and her father's like oh we have much to talk about like you should stay with us and she's and lear's like no she's good and he and Ashlyn's like okay well I'll stay with you until dinner until she goes and she has some time with her brothers and her father and it's just like this really awkward

confrontation moment that feels like the culmination of something that happened like seven chapters ago because she realizes that everybody that in her former life was lying to her and I'm like girl yeah like I don't know what to tell you like I'm glad we got to that conclusion essentially her brothers know everything and she accuses them of doing so and then her father arrives and again we're reminded that they share the same eyes and in this moment it hits me that he too must be able to use wild magic yes they talked about that for a second because they

talked earlier it hits me in this moment too because they talk about friends he burns the forest yes frequently how does he burn the forest with fame magic right and yeah yeah okay yeah we don't get confirmation of that but I swear to fucking god if that's not I'm gonna be so mad yeah yeah no same because they talk about it constantly like he's the fire hand of the north they have the same purple eyes no one can wield fame magic he's got to know right and that will so at some point so

basically they push her over the edge with like these really accusatory questions and like she's asking them return questions and they're just like yeah we knew like you didn't need to know whatever blah blah blah and she gets so mad that she like lets her fire loose and everyone's really rooted out by that except for daddy well he says what have they done to you right but he's not as freaked out as everybody else like everybody else is like grabbing for swords and like trying to

subdue her and he's like whoa whoa guys guys guys this is your sister my daughter she's clearly fine like we don't need to even though she's on fire right well and like one of the suns is even like but you said that like magic is an aberration and like born of like terrible things and he's like well yeah but but when it's used for evil and it's like okay which is it yeah so as as we mentioned

she does show her power and um oh i forgot dagfins also there it's not just her brothers it's her brothers and dagfin i think i think it's i don't know if it's dagfin or not but one of them like puts iron shackles on her dagfin because he's like a like a fey hunter now a fun dirt so dagfin shackles her with iron iron and that like culls her magic but doesn't actually harm her in any way it just drains her and then is immediately like comforting her in the same moment and gallad

who has gone with ashlyn to basically protect her threatens the crown prince of um tilren so basically ashlyn's older brother if they don't release her and so the the situation kind of diffuses they release ashlyn gallad let's go of the brother and this entire time nemid ashlyn's dad is like cool as a cucumber he's like guys guys can't we just work this out be friends guys but on the other hand this is where i was saying earlier that like

leer your life mate has been missing for two months you saw her for five seconds and then without like i don't know checking in you let her go into a situation where she was with her very toxic family and now in the aftermath her entire fucking family knows that she wields fey magic which is the one thing that you were upset and concerned about because you thought that her father was going to use her as a weapon girl what maybe just hey y'all we need about 20 minutes

you're a king you can do that like i just i can't that was a bad decision and i don't know why he made it i don't i don't know why he made it either it was very odd so then after this like ashlyn is taken to the feast which like okay did i miss this or is this the feast before sorry okay backup i didn't miss this this is the feast before the wedding and ashlyn's taken to the feast full of healing juice full of leshy's tears or whatever

you and my note is but like where is the reunion between her there isn't one right like where is it where is it yeah oh yeah it's a great question she dances she's like drugged on leshy's tears and she dances and she dances with dagfin and dagfin's like okay the the plan to like usurp the fey is still on i'm still like your guy we're gonna go to this place there's a weapon of ina secreted away in some temple in the mountains that's guarded by a three-eyed owl and like they're lying to you

that ina didn't have a weapon and i can take you there and it's a it's a curse breaker so we can get you out of this arrangement and it's just like chaos what are we doing here tom it's chaos in here tom yeah very very bad like i like we are now less than 50 pages from the end of this book for me we're less than 15 pages what are we what is happening i thought i missed like a whole chapter like i went back and i was like did i like just hit the kindle like what the fuck is going on

yeah this this book took a hard exit onto a different freeway that we were not on and here's the thing like if we had ended the book at the end of like the last chapter like she's on her way to see lear and you know she like pulls back the tent flap or whatever and sees him there and that's where the book ends and then we picked up the next book here short oh yeah absolutely sure yeah but that's but instead it's just like what what is happening what the fuck is

going on it's all the like it feels like we're starting a whole new series it does it feels like we're at the beginning of the book and we're just like okay remember all of those characters that you haven't heard about for the last 200 pages while they're all back yep okay so speaking of things going buck wild the dance ends i guess in it's the middle of the night and she sneaks out of her tent to go oh this is also where the snake is the snake leads her to lear in the forest well so it bites

her guards too it bites her guards the snake bites her guards and gets her kind of the distraction that she can like get out of her tent without being followed and she finds lear in the middle of a forest and he's like communing with the trees yeah he's like in a fairy ring no pun intended rather than him falling to his knees and having any kind of meaningful conversation with her they talk about power and whether she's mortal or not and then they just dance to silence until like the sounds of the forest the colors of the wind play and i'm like what why why would you why okay let's just say

i'm in uh let's see i'm ashlyn i've been missing for two months but in my mind it's just been a day and i have all of the memories that i have for lear and none of them are particularly um we'll say romantic i would i would have about five follow-up questions that she just doesn't get to and he's i don't see the torture here he doesn't act like somebody who's been scouring the earth for his life may for the past two months like this just my notice the blue balls jesus fucking christ

so we do get some wolf uh metaphor here which might lend itself to the cover a little bit more i don't know who says this i think it's i think it's lear to ashlyn so you must allow your wolf to wander freely to strengthen itself in the wild so that you when you call upon it it is most powerful in your name drop it to your blade rather than dull it which okay cool but but again the why are we

not like getting any romance here like they're dancing but also like why are they dancing why are they dancing i don't get it so then and it just ends well no there's chaos more there's more chaos well um it it fades to black and then they go to the wedding and fin is gonna be paid though right it ends like the interaction ends like they don't be like let's go to bed together or no it just they just stop speaking and that's the end of the chapter and you're like i but how

did you guys get to bed and did you sleep in the same place like i don't right is that still a thing so i don't know if it's the next day or the next night and it doesn't really matter but it's fin's wedding day to pay though and pay though in her three butt buddies come over and put weapons in the ground and fin chooses incorrectly and so he and pay though must duel pay though strikes but misses and he dag fin strikes back but gallad puts himself between dag fin and pay though and takes

the blow instead um and then all hell breaks loose and then there's just like fighting and then the unsealier there because lear asked them to be there last night when he was in the fairy ring when ashlyn found him and in the chaos ashlyn flees but before she does they finally kiss and like ashlyn acknowledges the bond so order of operations yeah the duel happens and gallad

stands in front of uh pieto or pieto and like saves her and everyone's worried that he's dead he's fine right she's i don't know how he lives but he lives they say that magic uh is owed basically because of the like magical agreement of this duel and so now the prince the prince is cursed because he like he should have died and so they're like having this discussion and then like

the unsealier start like like you can hear their like footsteps of the distance your ashlyn can feel like magic in the air and knows that they have been summoned and he basically had done that to betray the alliance and i the understanding that like i kind of got is he did this because she thought he thought she was gone and so therefore like the alliance didn't matter anymore but like she's clearly back and like he called them last night like before they were dancing together so like i don't understand that but yeah in the chaos of the fighting she like finds dagvin and dagvin's like hey do you still want to like peace out and she's like

yeah but like one second i gotta go talk to lear you're gonna tell my husband i'm leaving right and it's like raining and he's in the middle of the battle like making his way to her and they like talk for a second about like hey i'm gonna go and he's like but why but why and so like they kiss for a second and then she's like all right bye and he's like well no wait i'm gonna hunt you down and she's like maybe one day we'll meet again on equal footing but not today and he's like stay with me and she's like no let no yep and then and then the last scene is like well they say

they're vows to each other again too in this moment which like okay great because now you're in love oh sure okay spectacular so then the last scene that we get is ashlyn with dagvin and then two of ashlyn's brothers in the forest and one of her brothers is like man i didn't think you were right dagvin when you said that she would flee with us ha ha ha and i'm like what the f*** is happening and so they're all gonna go to ina's like shrine or whatever the three eyed owl and find the curse

breaker to break the curse of ashlyn's life mated this question mark what curse who cares wait wait it's the curse of the humans but the so she's gonna turn all the humans into fey again but they hate the fey yeah but if you are fey it's really hard to hate the thing you are but why does dagvin want that oh i don't think dagvin fully understands but he's the one who found the curse breaker what

does he think they're gonna break i think he thinks her marriage break huh her marriage to which is not a curse he doesn't know that he's such an idiot i mean but only this question with her what the f*** is happening oh wait no maybe they'll break his curse maybe he thinks they're gonna break his curse because he wants to go although they talked about this before he was right yeah before he was even cursed it doesn't it's chaos in your town why are the two other brothers here why are the two other brothers here it's like i think it's no they don't know either they're just

like well i guess i'll go and then everyone's like well i guess i'd feel stupid if i don't also go isn't stern one of them starne goes and use the air so like what the f*** are you doing starne yeah also like they made they made their father aware of their plans for why that seems like a bad idea also starne's the one that branded galad like why the f*** is ashlyn okay with being in the same room with him we would pass that real quick but like galad and starne are like escorting her to

like the king's tent whenever they go have that before her fire comes out and how strong is just like i didn't think i'd see you again and galad is like i said i'd kill you if i saw you again what i mean it was more hostile than that but it was what the f*** this book was really good but they're like the the last hundred pages or so i was like wait what what it's like that meme or it's

like the tiktok thing that at by this point is like at least a quarter old where it's like merry christmas merry christmas merry christmas merry christmas that was the last hundred pages of this book where it just went off the f***ing rails real f***ing quick yeah which is also now gonna be a tiktok that we need to make for this but i i do want to read the next one because there's so many the story is interesting and it was very well written up until the point where it

was confusing yes up until the point where it wasn't until like i'm curious i want to know where we're going next all right so let's get into our ratings let's i did lower one of mine to be more closely to liz at this point because i agree all right so um i can go ahead and speak to spice level because there was none yeah we gave it an n a unfortunately fingers crossed for there being

spice in the next book but um des why don't you talk to us about the writing style how did we rate it we gave it a four um and i think that's just because like the like we talked about throughout the book the imagery that they that was provided and like the world building and the the language that was used to take us on that journey was really well done and very beautiful and very immersive and very emotive uh so yeah four excellent liz how did we rate the quality of the storytelling um well

des and i rated it about a three and i can only speak for myself because it was just i felt like the pacing was wild like i got so bored in the middle and then it was just like i'm gonna dump all this random shit from like a whole different story on you at the end that like i was here for the story and i was into the story and then the end i was just like what is the story like am i even in the same book anymore so yeah i initially rated it as a four but i think based on this

conversation as usually happens i will downgrade it to a three because uh the last hundred pages were totally it's like we went we took an exit onto a freeway that i didn't know existed exactly and now i'm not sure where i am and everything looks different everything looks different i'm in a different fucking state maybe a different country i can't read the road signs so overall we do recommend this book um and i think that that shows out through our our review of this book um it was

a really good time unfortunately not a lot of spice and so true to our our moniker um we're not trading in spice in this particular one but i think that means we're reading book number two and so stay tuned we'll let you know if there's spice there yep figures crossed so no more blue balls figures crossed my blue balls are so painful at this point so those are our thoughts on asling breath of the new creature by ae jergens thank you for joining us as always on this journey

let us know what you think on the socials you can find us at spice traders pod on instagram at tick tock and on patreon and until next time oh and good reads yes moving on until next time we'll see you later bye

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Irresistible Urge to Fall for Your Enemy By Brigitte Knightley Part 1

    Nov 10, 20261 hr 35 minAudio

    Triggers: graphic violence and gore, depictions of a fictional plague, on-page sexual content (including masturbation), and themes of parent death and chronic illness KU: No Recommendation: No, (give the author money...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Surrendering to Scylla by Wren K Morris

    Oct 27, 20261 hr 10 minAudio

    Triggers: (From the author): kidnapping, violence, discussions of abuse, BDSM dynamics and play, tentacle play, brief descriptions of injured animal (that receives aid), breath play, bondage, depictions of sub drop,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Threshing Day by Rebecca Yarros

    Oct 14, 20261 hr 9 minAudio

    Triggers: war, battle, hand-to-hand combat, perilous situations, blood, intense violence, brutal injuries, death, and poisoning KU: No Recommendation: Yes! For more of the author, check out https://rebeccayarros.com/

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Court of Heathens by K. A. Knight

    Sep 29, 202652 minAudio

    Triggers: from the author: “explicit violence, explicit sexual violence, dubious consent, murder, gore, torture, kidnapping, and more.” KU: Yes Recommendation: No For more of the author, check out...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Under Loch and Key by Lana Ferguson Part 2

    Sep 21, 20261 hr 4 minAudio

    Triggers: death of a parent (off page), grief, fantasy violence KU: No Recommendation: both Traders recommend! This is part 2 of 2. For more of the author, check out https://www.lanaferguson.com/

    Credit the people on this episode