Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Spice Traders

Spice Traders artwork

The Destroyer by Meg Smitherman Part 3

Apr 30, 20241 hr 18 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

This week the Traders venture into the world of archaeology and magic in The Destroyer by Meg Smitherman. Part 3 of 3, chapters 28-41. Triggers: dubious consent Tropes: Dark Academia, Magic, Enemies to Lovers, Slow Burn, Touch Her and Die KU: yup Recommendation: Yes For more of the author, check out @megsmitherman on TikTok.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hey friends, just a quick reminder before we get into today's episode, come join us over on our Patreon. That's where we release bonus episodes every other week and we've already got over 20 episodes from 2023 that you can download and binge right now for as little as $3 a month. We've covered so many good books there, Haunting Adeline, Chateau, Gotha Canna, and so many more. That's also where we'll cover any books in a series we continue, so Serpent in Dove, High Mountain Court, Serpent in the Wings of Night. You can continue those series with us on Patreon right now.

Finally, as a patron, we let you know what we're going to read every month so you can read along with us if that's your jam. Anyway, that's all from me, on to today's episode. At some point Archie just turns into a shapeless beige crayon. He does and then he's just sort of like kind of in the background at the end. I know. I was like, why are you here? I don't know. Why were you ever here? Truly. I think it makes such a big point about it.

What's her face when? It's like, no, we have to go back and get Archie. I'm like, well, Archie's definitely going to die. No. No, he's just, because then even they get him and they take him to the place, which we'll talk about at the end, and he still just does nothing. He's just along for the ride. Welcome to Your Safe Space. The podcast, your partner, friends, parents, whoever thinks is dirty. Don't have time to read books. Want to understand the jokes in the tix-tox? We got you, fam.

We're the Spice Traders and we deal in spicy books. I'm Katie and I need it to make sense. I'm Liz and I'm hypercritical. As always, we start every episode with three things. The first is a generic trigger warning. You can find specific triggers for this book in our show notes, so please check those out. Also we do use foul language and talk a lot about sex. If you have sensitivity to any of this, please give this episode a skip. Secondly, we talk about books. The whole book, nothing but the books that helped me got us. If you plan to read this book and don't want something spoiled right now, don't listen to this episode.

Lastly, we acknowledge that a good book can hit you at the wrong time. The views expressed in our discussion are our opinion and we absolutely don't want to diminish the work and the talent of the authors in our community. That said, we have some notes. Okay, so shall we get into it? Yes, let's shall. Okay. So, welcome back to part three of our coverage of The Destroyer by Meg Smitherman.

This part will cover chapters 28 through 41. It sounds like half of the book is super not. It's a third of the book, just like everything else. It's a lot of chapters in here. Yeah, a lot of superfluous chapters. Standard disclaimer, if you haven't read the book or listened to part one and two, do that now because you're going to get be lost anyway. So, when we last left Rue, she was trying to find information about the children and she had written a letter to her brother Simon to that effect, which I still have the question of why didn't you do that earlier, but I digress.

Turns out Simon's not very helpful, so. No, that's another cryptic loose end that I hope we get closure on. Yeah, what the fuck is Simon? What is he doing? Okay. I don't know. And I really hope they land the plane on like, music is magic, blah, blah, like she's said it like three times. Yeah, she did, but we never quite get there. Nope, never quite get there. So the next day when Rue goes to the dungeon to start her day, she runs into Professor Caldwick at the entrance and he asks to be allowed in to share an announcement.

He reveals to the room that DeLuke is on his way. DeLuke has been notified of their breakthrough and wishes to see it for himself. Professor Caldwick basically is like calling Rue and her other fellow researchers out saying like, oh, I guess you didn't feel the need to share that with us. That's fine. Si. It is really like, all right, I guess, unless you use all our shit, but fine. I guess you don't love us anymore.

Rue feels on the back foot because it's clear that the children are eager to see her use the object again and have notified DeLuke. And she doesn't want to do that for obvious reasons. So she denies a breakthrough allowed to the room and her researchers back her up, right? They're like, yeah, I was just, she fainted. You know, nothing happened, but Inda, the kind of lead children spawn, won't be moved and insists that DeLuke is coming and expects to see a recreation. So Rue goes through the motions of the rest of the day.

She's put out about not being in control of her own destiny when it comes to the stone and she feels like a pawn in someone else's game because girl, you are, you agree to do this. You walked right into this. Yep. I don't know what you expected. But this is, this is what happens when you agree to do stuff for the regent or whatever. This is literally what you signed up for. Right. Also, why is it a regent and not, why, like, that's such a weird thing to add into this story. Well, and don't we get reference to a king? Yeah, it was her husband who died who has no blood relatives.

Oh yeah, I forgot about that. And like, so what is her role in this? What's she doing this whole time? I don't know. I wish I knew. It was, we didn't need to know anything about that part. No. So to make matters worse, Fen is also ignoring Rue. Remember, they had that little bit of a steamy moment and then he, like a robot, turned the switch and said, you should get some rest. And so she's feeling both not in control and also a little bit more than rejected. Which, Liz, I can't blame her for that.

I can't either. By the end of the day, Rue is tired and irritated and she's kind of avoiding any more peopling by like hanging back while everybody else leaves. She's like taking extra time packing her stuff up. But Fen also hangs back to talk to her and she's just like, not right now. So she ices him out after he apologizes again for the way that he behaved. She's like, yeah, no, I get it. You regret acting like that. It's fine.

Everything's fine. It's fine. Everything's fine. Don't look at me. Don't look at me. I'm so hideous. I'm just so very ugly. And back in her room alone, she's feeling more and more frustrated, more and more alone, and she screams into a pillow. And I don't blame her. I'm frustrated for her. Right. I do wish they would have like four conversations. Yeah. Just five more words. So the tower decides that a party will be held to welcome DeLuke.

Rue bristles that she's not been included in any of the prep or the circumstances or the planning or anything. And she's she ruminates that she's become the academic who not only staked her reputation on the existence of magic, but then when given the opportunity to prove its existence, failed at that as well. She seeks out one of the kinder, more emotionally empathetic professors for advice. This man's name is Professor Thorn.

But as she's knocking on Professor Thorn's door, Professor Acorn comes by and tells her that Professor Thorn has fallen ill and she won't find him in his office. So instead, Professor Thorn or Professor Acorn offers his assistance and they go to his office to speak. This conversation is rushed and cut short and very awkward because Acorn comes down with a severe migraine and ends the discussion. But it's clear that like he seemed fine in the hallway.

And then as soon as he got into his office, he became agitated and like he didn't even want to have this conversation with her. It's very strange. It's very strange. Almost like and I know he's not because everyone is falling ill, but it's almost like he's faking it like, oh, no, actually, my head hurts. You must leave. Right. Oh, dear. Because I didn't really know how to read that conversation because what Ru is asking for advice on is essentially like she's afraid that when Duluc shows up, he's going to be

disappointed with the findings because there's not much. She couches it as being a misunderstanding. And I couldn't really tell if Thorn was annoyed at her like imposter syndrome or if he was actually becoming ill. Well, and I was a little annoyed with Ru because so was she trying to talk to you, Professor Acorn? Professor Thorn. Professor Thorn. She's talking to who now? Acorn. Thank you. Why do they have plant names? I don't know.

Because like she's talking about the misunderstanding, but it seemed like she actually wanted to get relationship advice. Yeah. No, she super did. Yeah. And so now I feel like she's in this conversation with Thorn that she doesn't actually want to be in either. No. No, because she wanted relationship advice on not just what's going on with her and Fen, but kind of this weird position that she's feeling like she's in, like she doesn't have control over the study, the like people who are observing her essentially and she

doesn't know how to deal with those interpersonal relationships. And she starts her inner monologue by saying like dealing with emotions and like identifying them has always been difficult for me. And so like I just need somebody to help me navigate this. Which is, I mean, I do appreciate that the openness she has about her own shortcomings, but this whole exchange is just so strange to me. It is. Yeah. And the subtext here, which were led to understand later in the book kind of is that

Professor Thorn and Professor Acorn, along with all of the other professors are somehow being made to be ill on purpose. By the artifact or the children or both something, but it's unclear and it's not, it doesn't come to fruition in this book. Right. It bothers me. Yeah. But only the adults. It's only the professors. Right.

Only the people in charge ostensibly. Yeah. So as I mentioned, the conversation ends and it leaves Rue without the reassurance that she was seeking. The most that she got out of Acorn was he said, surely DeLuke is a pragmatic man who will understand the miscommunication about the breakthrough and just be happy to see what she's got so far. So I think it's an overly naive answer for two overly naive people. It's such a naive answer. And again, that's kind of where I was wondering, like, I don't think he won't.

I got the vague sense that he was pretending to be ill, even though he's not. But it just felt like, get the fuck over it, girl. Just say it's a misunderstanding and it's fine. Yeah. And I had that thought and I also had the thought of like maybe, maybe he didn't believe her about the breakthrough being a misunderstanding. Yeah. Well, I also think they're all kind of a little butthurt that she didn't share any of this quote unquote breakthrough anyway, so that also felt kind of petty.

Right. Or ask if they were fine bringing this like depth device to the college at all. Why are we not at an annex? Truly. So after this route goes to the dungeons and she feels a somber mood in the room. She has put distance between herself and Fen and she begins to despair about that. She's, you know, the inner monologue is that she misread the situation and now it's awkward and she's losing him as a friend even.

Not really knowing how to navigate the awkward silences and the fact that the children are there in this ominous impending visit from DeLuc, she sends a secret note around the room to her peers asking to meet secretly after the day in order to prepare for this visit. This note and her research pals acceptance of it does give her a glimmer of hope, but it's like fighting an uphill battle. Everything has to be very subtle around the children. Yes.

Who get so much creepier right now. Yeah. But it's only a problem for, I'm sorry. It's just such a non problem. It seems like a big problem and then we're going to talk about it. But then Rue is like, we're not going to do this and the children are just like, okay. Right. But I think that she's allowed or she has that effect on them because we'll get to it, but she's using the power of the stone. Yeah. That makes sense.

I didn't really think about that and I was just like, I'm sorry. What? Because she gets like scary voice, right? And everybody in the room is like, oh, fuck, she does get scary voice. That's fair. All right. All right. So as they work, Lear ends up breaking through Rue's thought process to deliver a letter. There's finally a reply from Simon. She goes to her room to read this letter immediately in private, but it's disappointingly short

saying he might not be able to write for a while, which makes Rue worry. He doesn't give a reason. And he's also enclosed a leaflet for the children. There's really nothing of interest on this leaflet except for quote, a small illustration on the back, a night sky lit by the moon and a strange pattern at the bottom that looked like trees or mountains. Underneath it was a string of words in a language Rue didn't recognize end quote. And his letter is essentially like, don't worry about me. I'm fine, but I won't be able to talk to you, which I think she's a normal response to.

It's like, OK, clearly you're not fine. Right. Why won't you be able to talk to me? What the fuck? Yeah. And going out of your way to tell me you're OK just tells me you're not OK. Right. It's very like hostage video. Me things fell down, protest too much. Yes. So as she's trying to internalize this letter, Ranto, which is another one of the children, Trio interrupts her thinking and pressures her to go back down to work. He like literally knocks on her door and says, OK, well, I'll wait for you. Until you're ready to go back down and then accompanies her to do that.

I don't. I just do not like do not like. No, makes my skin crawl in a lot of ways. Yeah, I would have my hackles would go up if anyone was just sitting outside my door and I was like, cool, I'll be right there. And they're like, I'll wait here. No, you won't. You won't. Or like, OK, cool, I'm going to sit here for seven hours and have fun waiting. Yeah. There's no in between. No, I'm just being like hard spite. So Rue and the others finish the day without incident. But when they leave, the children announced that they will be guarding them from now on

since they've made this breakthrough. Rue at first goes along with this because she's thinking, OK, well, we need some way to make DeLuke think that we're compliant, et cetera, et cetera. And so she suggests that they all go to dinner together. Dinner is super awkward because the children aren't eating. And obviously the research pals aren't talking openly. No, the children are just sitting behind watching them eat. Yeah. And Lear is roped into this too, but he wisely stays outside the cafeteria.

He's like, you guys can have space while you eat. Yeah, like a normal guard. Right. So at this dinner while they're being watched while they eat, Gwyn ends up blowing up at the children for being in the way, essentially, and contributing nothing to the actual body of work. And the children are kind of emotionally taken aback. So they look to Rue and they're like, is that true? And Rue clearly is feeling emboldened by the artifact.

And she's like, yeah, you know what? It is true. And you guys are also stupid. And I hate your fucking faces. So we're going to do this and you're going to leave us the fuck alone. OK, cool. And also, I'm going to go back to my room and Fenn's coming with me and no one's going to follow us. OK, bye. So we're going to go and Yonk some away, which fine, what we get that happens next, fine. But you guys had a plan to meet together. So why wouldn't you all be like, we're all going to go now and you're not coming? Right. We just forgot about the plan.

The children are like, oh, they're like, the influence from the artifact clearly has sway over this because they are startled visibly, which is new for them because they don't show emotion. And I'm like, I had that same thought. You guys were going to come up with a plan later. What happened to that? Why aren't we doing that? And I feel like if I were Archie or Gwen, I'd be like us too, right? We had plans. Guys, you're not just going to leave us here, are you? With these creepy fuckers.

Yeah. Guys, guys. But no, it's just Rue and Fenn. So awkward. So they get to Rue's room and once they're there, Rue and Fenn have a similar interaction as the one that they had before where the emotions are heightened and they're affecting both of them. Rue is on this like power trip where she says she's the only one in charge of the artifact now and Fenn said that he'd protect her. So she's asking for that now, demanding that he do so.

And she tries to get him to kiss her, but he's like, I will gladly kiss you just not like this. Can you please come back to me? Because he knows that she's under the influence of this artifact. Come back to me. He says that the way that she's acting isn't the Rue that he knows. And again, he wants her to come back to him. I just really like that. I know. She eventually does. She comes down and kind of comes back into herself and admits that the artifact was influencing

her. Fenn seemed to be able to pick up on that and he comforts her, but goes to leave again. This time Rue was like, can you not do that? Run away every fucking time. For once. And he's like, oh, you want me to stay? All you had to do was ask. And I'm like, God damn it. Which like, I'm all for asking for what you want, but he never really gave her space to like say that. So it was like, all you had to do was ask.

What? When would I feel comfortable asking for that? Also I'm not convinced that if she had asked that he would have stayed because I think he's still navigating understanding when his artifact is influencing her and when it's not. That's a really good point. If that whole like faded mates thing, like do you actually love this person or is it like

biology? Right. Is there some magical thing inside your body telling you to love this person? Right. Is there free will or not? That's my problem with faded mates, but that's not what's happening here. And I do like what's happening. I do like what's happening here. I just, I hope we get more information on the logistics in book two. Yeah, I have like 75 follow up questions. Conservatively. Conservatively. A lot.

So Fen stays with Rue and they just fall asleep. There's nothing steamy or smutty about this scene. It's just sweet. Right. She goes to bed. She's exhausted from the influence of the artifact. And when she wakes up, it's clear that Fen has spent the night on top of the sheets on her bed, like just with her, like a fucking psychopath. Like he's just laying there. Well, he's not laying there like, like a vampire. I think his arm is like on her. Somehow. It definitely was at some point.

She does say like, I fell asleep with his arm around me, but I picked you're waking up like a vampire. I don't know why. Yeah. But I think he's trying to be a gentleman, right? Like he's not trying to make moves. It's the one bed trope, but the one bed trope doesn't deliver in this book. So sorry, guys. Yeah, it doesn't. It doesn't deliver. That is a complaint I have. The fact that there's no smut. Yeah, same. Yeah. But we get so close. Well, it does make me hope for smut in book two.

Yes. So they wake up like that and the next morning, Gwen kind of comes into the room and she's like, Oh, I didn't. Did I interrupt something? I can go and they're like, no, no. I'm just going to sign. We were just having a sleepover. Don't be weird about it. And don't be suspicious. Gwen essentially tells him that Duluc is there already. Surprise. And Rue takes this in surprising stride. She's just like, OK, cool. I guess we better prepare for the party. Let's get going.

Let's go. And they're just like, OK, OK, cool. Rue knows that there's a chance that Duluc will take the artifact back to the palace with him or at least try to, but she seems to have a newfound confidence about her. And I don't know where that came from. I don't know if it was just standing up to the children, but that wasn't natural. That wasn't her. No. And it's not like they did that thing where they're supposed to reconvene and talk about a plan. So I don't know. No, they don't know what's happening. They didn't talk about a plan at all.

And even she and Fendt didn't really get anywhere. No, because she had that episode and then they basically fell asleep. Yeah. And it was an episode. I don't know where her confidence came from either. And it doesn't really last. She hurt. I think that's another complaint I have about this book is that all of the characters, it's not that they're inconsistent. They just don't have enough complexity. I don't know because they're not.

I don't know. There's just something about them. They're very like they don't forward plan, right? It's like they're a fruit fly that exists for the next 24 hours and that's it. Yes. Yes. They are fruit flies. And they forget everything that happened before and they don't think that things will happen ahead of that. Which makes zero sense. Right. But they talk about planning. That's what makes me so mad. They know they need a plan. They know they need a plan. They know they don't have a plan. They know they have a reason to need a plan, but they don't ever actually land that plane.

No. No. Okay. So speaking of things that don't make sense, this is one of those scenes that could have not existed, but Rue and Fen just share a moment in a courtyard. They're like having a picnic or something. And Fen tells Rue about a woman named Althea, whom he met when he was young, by breaking into her house on a dare. And she's the one who taught him how to be kind to others was kind of like a present

pseudo parent since both of his parents were either dead or not there. But he reveals that as he grew older, he strayed from that path and began to forget what it meant to be kind and treat others with humanity. He shares that he's done things that he doesn't deserve to be forgiven for and that he'll certainly never deserve a home or someone like Rue. I feel like this conversation should have happened in bed. I don't know why they're in the courtyard. I don't know how they got away with Deluke arriving and not immediately going to the

dungeon to see them. I don't know because there's such a sense of urgency every other time Deluke is around. Right. Because then, okay, so like fleshwork a little bit, Deluke is like, are we going to go tonight? So why can't they just have this time to fuck around? And again, this is time you could be using to plan. Right. But you're just like, talk about it. Laying around. Yeah, which should have happened in bed the night before because this is a great conversation for like cuddles and intimacy building. Correct. But we don't really get that. Nope.

So then later, Rue is sitting in the dungeon contemplating the artifact. She resolves for herself to never touch it or speak to it again because bad things happen when she does that. And I'm like, that seems incredibly short-sighted and it makes me wonder what the plan is to learn its secrets. Then if you're not going to do the two things that make its secrets come out like, come on. As a scientist, I feel like that's ill-advised, but that's just me. Well, I don't know if she's actually a great scientist. Yeah, I guess she's just an archaeologist.

I guess there is kind of a difference there. I mean, the other ones seem to be doing science stuff and she's just like, I read books. So as she does this, Fen joins her and she asks him to sit with her for a while. They end up holding hands and saying their potential goodbyes to the stone in silence together. Fen's reason that makes the stone react with golden light rather than blackness. Fen and Rue themselves also glow with the stone and Rue enjoys it for a moment until she thinks about it too hard and then she's frightened and she like breaks the contact

with Fen and the glowing stops. He asks her to come back even though the glowing is gone. He's like, come hold my hand. So she does come back and she goes in for a kiss and they both react. But in her mind, her little intersepatory is like, this is the artifact influencing them both. Fen doesn't actually want this. So she says that and tries to leave. She's like, I don't know what's happening here, but I feel like this isn't genuine.

As she goes through the exit, Fen blocks her against the door and tells her that that's the last time she'll ever accuse him of not wanting her. They make out hot and heavy against the door, but Fen ultimately makes him stop because he says they shouldn't lose control around the artifact. So they part ways and get ready for the party with DeLuke and I'm just like, God, I know we get so close. I mean, get some really good lines from Fen. They're like, like that. Yeah. And we get this like, you could potentially be aggressive and dominant and then he's just

like, go put on a pretty dress and I'll see you at the party. Well, and we get some ass grabbing. We get some hard length mentioning like, yeah. Like they're like taking each other's like clothes off. Yeah. Yeah. And she's like, no, it's fine. We'll be fine. And he's like, we really shouldn't do this. It's like to my room with me. Can we just move locations? Right. Like fine. We won't do it around the stone. We'll go do it somewhere else. Right. But I'll accept it. They just end. So they go to the party and Rue finds Gwen immediately already talking to DeLuke.

When Rue joins them, she finds DeLuke as handsome and as charming as ever. And she takes his bait, hook, line and sinker when he flatters her by saying, quote, I feel as if your mind is the only one in Navani that can stimulate my own in matters of science. And I'm like, this is so obviously like a ploy. It's so obviously a ploy because you've had one conversation and it wasn't really about science anyway. And I don't see this. I don't see the science for one. It's so obviously ploy. He's so smarmy. Yeah.

Like you're an easy mark, Rue, and he is playing you like a fiddle. Yeah. Because you can see how, and I mean, it is a, I do like when we get a fatal flaw in our characters and so hers is very much pride, which is an interesting fatal flaw for her. But it is, come on, Rue. I know. It's pride, but I think it's interesting in this context because she's so starved for like validation and like accolades that getting it from somebody like this, she's like, see, I knew it. I knew that I was special this whole time and we as readers are just like, girl, you

are, but don't take it from him. Exactly. Like you very much are special, but it's also sort of the issue of everyone around you screaming at you for being special. And it's the one guy who like we don't need to trust. So she's like, the one person who sees me and her friends are like, what the fuck? What the fuck? What are we? ChatLiver? So Rue goes to speak with Duluc alone and he makes it clear that he's willing to continue supporting her research at the tower as long as he can see a demonstration of this breakthrough.

She agrees to provide one, but in the morning, her thought is to use the golden light thing that happened between her and Fen as the example. When she finds Fen, they go out to the balcony to talk privately and she pitches this idea to him. But Fen is horrified. Both that she agreed to a demonstration and that she wants to use this thing between them as that demonstration. Rue can see that Fen is very aware of the danger she could put them in and bristles at the

insinuation. She's like, oh yes, I can just murder everybody. And so we need to be careful. Right. Of course, I forgot about that. He obviously didn't mean it like that and tries to walk it back, but he tries to tell her that he sees what happened between them with the golden light as an intimate act and is repulsed by the idea of sharing it with anyone. It also comes to light that he's jealous of how Rue acts with DeLuke and so both of these feelings are kind of warring in his heart of hearts, so making him react poorly to this.

Rue begs Fen to see things from her view, how she needs to continue this research to find answers, and how would he understand that as a bystander? He tells her that he would gladly let her use him, but this request is too much and he leaves. How do you feel about this request? I feel like it's a reasonable one considering the position that they're in. I think so too. And this is where I get frustrated because they're clearly looking at this from two vastly different sides.

Rue has no idea what happened and Fen does. Right. But so she has no way to know why he's so hurt by this. Right. Well, and I also think that there's something, there's another side of this too where Fen is trying very much to be a part of this and help her, but he does not want any attention drawn to himself for what will become obvious reasons as we go through the rest of this book. Yes. And because that does very much link him into this problem. Right.

Because we're going to demonstrate that they can do this thing together and then it's not a Rue thing anymore, it's a Rue and Fen thing. Yes. And Fen would like to stay anonymous. Correct. But I feel like to your point, he's just not, he's not giving her all of the information, nor is he coming up with better solutions. It's like, well, we're either going to not do this or we're going to do this and I don't like either of those things. So I'm just going to be out. I'm just going to leave. Right. Literally leave. Yeah. He straight up leaves the tower.

Like she doesn't see him again for a while. Yeah. It's not, I'm going to go to bed because I'm mad at you. It's I'm going to go and maybe never come back. Which like. Okay. Not, not a very mature way to deal with things. No, it's not. And in Rue's defense, again, she has no way to understand why he's being like that. Why he's being like this. Especially given the already kind of uns not unstable, but insecure internal monologue that

she has about what's going on between her and Fen because she's still not really sure that he is in for her. Right. Yeah. No. And in her defense, I think that's valid. 100% valid because they don't talk about it and he's not giving her the answers and reassurance that she needs except for maybe once and then they never talk about it again. Exactly. So the next morning, Rue runs into Gwen who's frantically searching for her since everyone is waiting for a demonstration, but Rue is violently hungover.

She drank her. She has like a secret bottle of wine that she keeps under her bed. Yeah. And she drank it all after and her fight, which is just a fun little personality quirk we get. Yep. Like she refers to emergency stash. Well, and I like this because this is also an example of like arrive late, leave early. Like we didn't see her drinking her sorrows. We just know about it after the fact. Yes. This one, this was a well done scene. Yes. So the reason that she's hungover is that she's certain that whatever was blooming between

her and Fen is now over. She acts irresponsibly and leaves it to Gwen to tell the gathering that they'll reschedule to tomorrow, all because she feels that the thought of losing Fen would be the worst pain of her life, even worse than losing the artifact. Alone in her room, she feels the thread with the artifact thinning. She thinks morosely that both it and Fen abandoned her when she needed the most and she cries alone at the loss of both. I can't help to think that him leaving in the artifact connection, getting weaker is related.

Can't help but think that I can't help but think that the strong influence of the artifact whenever she's around thinking about or interacting with Fen also might have some significance, but she does not think that. Not at all. Not even once. Those breadcrumbs are a random pattern for her. Later when all of her tears are dry, she hears students playing music in the courtyard and resolves that even if she lost a little bit of herself with Fen, that no one would take

magic from her. And this is like the third time she's mentioned like music feeling like magic to her and I just really hope that they use that. Especially with her brother being a minstrel. Correct. So, later that evening, Rue goes to the guest wing to Fen's room. She doesn't go inside but she feels an emptiness where a tether had existed between them before and that convinces her that he's left the tower. So she resolves to do everything herself and I'm like, I can't believe he just left.

I can't believe he just left either and I also, this is something that bothered me is like there is some physical tether that she can feel that like through the door she knows he's gone forever but still doesn't connect those dots. No, I'm like, I would have opened the door. I would have opened the door. She takes that at face value. She's like, oh, well, he's gone. I can't feel him. Because I've, okay, when I was reading the scene first, I was like, there's a difference between him like packing all of his shit up and leaving and just taking a couple of days.

Yeah. And we never know if he packed all his shit up and left because she doesn't open the door. Nope. We're led to believe that he probably did. Yes. Which I still have questions about. Yes. But here we are. The resolve to do everything herself also, I feel like does her other two friends a grave disservice? Yeah, she never thinks to talk to them. Again, you were going to use all four of y'all to plan and now she's gone. You're just like, well, fuck the other two, I guess.

Right. And I'm like, they have been helping you through this whole thing and it's just, it's another example of how totally self-centered and like entitled Rue is. She's just like, well, fine, if I can't have the object of my affection, I'm just on my own. Gwen Archie, let's go. Let's go. But don't ask me any questions because both of you. So the time comes for the demonstration and Rue tries to recreate the reaction from the stone without Fen.

But nothing happens and the demonstration is a dud. I am shocked. Afterward, Gwen finds her curled up in a library somewhere and Rue starts rambling about her connection that she has with the stone. And as she does so, she gets a bloody nose. Gwen has a reaction that she ends up slapping Rue just to make sure that she's not lost her mind and then quickly apologizes and suggests that they abandon the project entirely because whatever this thing is, it's clearly hurting Rue. Which I think Gwen is a good friend, but it just clearly did not listen to a word Rue

said. No, she slaps her and is like, well, you were being weird. So I feel like she thought that Rue was in like a fugue state and was just like talking about nonsense and so just disregarded all of it. 100%. I'm like, okay, but could you ask a follow up question? Just a couple. Nothing? Okay. So they're interrupted by Nell, one of the children, who tells Rue that Deluke demands to see her in his office immediately and so Rue follows them to that office.

In the office, Deluke asks Rue for a written summary of the failure and also for a second attempt. As Rue listens, she wonders how she ever found Deluke charming. His shine has officially started to wear off. She remarks inwardly that he's too perfect, unlike Ben, who has a too big nose or something like that. Like in sweet, it's like Fen, whose nose is a little too big for his face and his hair is always messy and his beard is not quite shaved. But the nose thing, I was like, okay. Okay, girl.

That's how you really feel. She tells Deluke that whatever he's asked her for is a fool's errand, but greased to his demands all the same. In the next two days, Rue attempts two more demonstrations, but nothing happens. The artifact no longer speaks to Rue, but she goes along with Deluke's demands because more than impressing others, she wants to prove to herself that she hasn't lost the artifact. This goes on for days and days and Rue is getting more and more physically impacted by

this. It's clear that it's taking a toll on her. And by the 10th morning, she's so exhausted that she barely registers that most of the professors of the tower are all sick and out of commission. Deluke has been pushing harder and harder, threatening more than simply to take the artifact, but to essentially ruin Rue's life without results, right? Her entire career, removing her from the tower, all that kind of stuff. One day, she reaches an impasse with the artifact, feeling it pull even further away. She ends up in a dark space with it, kind of as she's trying to interact with it without

actually interacting with it. And in this space, she has a vision of the headless Kingsguard and of Lady Maron, and she shouts down her connection with the stone that she hates it. After she does this, everything fades to black as she hears someone scream. I definitely thought she'd killed everyone again. I did too. I think it would have been more impactful if she had. Me too, or at least killed the immediate vicinity, like whoever was in the dungeon. Right. Or at least the people, because I feel like that would have killed Gwen and Archie.

I feel like if she had killed like maybe one or two people, but not everybody. Yeah. Someone should have died though. Yeah. For such a dangerous thing, it's not very dangerous after the first two times it's used. No. Well, and I don't understand what causes the difference between like, because she said she would never speak to it again. The first time she spoke to it, the thing started to erupt. This time she shouts at it and it's clear that something happens, but like it doesn't erupt. I don't, what is actually happening? What's the mechanism? I don't know. And even once we learn what it is, I really don't know.

Yeah, I super don't know either. So when she wakes up, she's in her room and she can hear Gwen softly sleeping on the seti in her room and she feels heart warmed that Gwen never abandoned her. My problem with this is that we never find out what actually happened between this interaction and the stone. Like, did the children see something? Did Duluth get to see a demonstration or did she just pass out because she was exhausted? We don't know. She's very clearly sickly. She's not sick like the professors, but like she's struggling.

As she's lying there and kind of coming back to herself, she remembers a vision that she had just before passing out this time and this somehow draws the connection that she's needed between the rock, the destroyer and the children. Again, we don't get a whole lot of clarity on what that is, unfortunately. Gwen wakes up and they share a heartfelt reunion. Drew apologizes for being a shitty friend. Yes, girl. Yes, girl. That was needed. And then shares her suspicions. Firstly, that the destroyer is now synonymous with Festra, who is an ancient god symbolized

by infinite night in Meccan folklore, and that the children worship both as one and the same. The passage on the leaflet that her brother sent translates to, he cleanses with fire. The reason they can translate this is because Gwen can read the ancient Meccan that it's written in. She had used her friends before. Truly. Like no sharing of information actually happened in this research project. Well, and supposedly her and Gwen and Archie have been friends for so long.

And Drew's like, you can read that? And Gwen's like, yeah, I mean, when you're raised by the upper class, you learn shit. I'm like, why don't you know that? I just, it didn't seem like a weird thing for Gwen to know. Especially if they've been studying for so long together. Yes, because ostensibly, if you're an archaeologist, I would assume ancient languages would have come up. Right. I also don't really buy the vision connecting all of these dots for Rue suddenly, because

they're still kind of nebulous for me as a reader, right? Like, Festra now being synonymous with the destroyer. I don't understand if that means that they think that the destroyer was a physical manifestation of Festra, or if like, he's a disciple of Festra. I don't understand that. I don't know why it matters what the children worship, because it doesn't answer the question

of what they want to do with the stone. It doesn't answer the question. With there being so much prose and so much description, it's incredibly frustrating that we don't understand those things. Right. And even Rue, she goes on to admit to Gwen that she had misplaced faith in Deluke, which obviously. She now sees that he's not a man of science and that whatever the stone is, it means more to him than she had seen before, and she doesn't trust his intentions.

She doesn't go on to say what those intentions are. It strikes me that if you thought that this person was trying to use a weapon of mass destruction against anybody, that you should have a conversation about that with somebody besides your research buddy. Yeah, because even when doesn't do much with this, she's just like, huh. Weird. So are we going to go back to work now? What's also weird about this is this isn't like Iran Flamme, right?

Where you have all of this geopolitical drama happening that we know about. Right. Ostensibly, this world is at peace. So it kind of looks like, okay, Eva Varegian doesn't know about this and has no idea of the ill intentions. Or she does and wants to start a war, but there's no context for like, oh, the mechins suck and we hate them and we're like, like none of that exists. So it just kind of feels like we have this plot point that exists in a vacuum by itself. Yeah.

And that would be interesting because it would make sense for the region to be involved. But I don't know. I don't know. And like, so is Deluke just, he's just interested in things or like, is the region actually involved? I don't know. I think about even simple one-liners about like when we had Nettle and Bone and how that kingdom was described as being a small kingdom caught between two giants. Yes. Even if we got context like that of like, oh, this is probably just an insurance policy,

blah, blah. But like, this is where Rue and her compatriots exist in the existing 24 hours and that's it, like we don't get any ruminations from them about what this could possibly be used for. No, which is so strange to me, especially once they do have this breakthrough of the Festra and the destroyer. But no one follows any breakthrough to any conclusion. Right. She even goes so far as to say that she realizes in that moment that the children must suspect

what the artifact is capable of and that they intend to use it as soon as they know how to use it. For what? Right. To destroy. For why? And for why? Because also, I think the children always suspected what it was for because they know that you found it in the shattered city. Right. They, they, they follow the breadcrumbs from the beginning of this book, girl. Yeah. None of this is a surprise to anyone but you. Right. Because I think they always knew what it was for.

They just didn't know how to activate it. Right. And she goes on to say, she's like, oh, Gwen, we got to warn the professors. But then this is when she realizes they're all sick and she's like, oh my gosh, that must also be the doing of the children. And I'm like, but how and for why? And for why? And there's this line of like, yeah, the pressers can't stay awake for more than a few moments. So was that every adult in the tower? Because I would still go try and tell them. Right.

And because they're sick doesn't mean you can't communicate with them probably. Or at least attempt to do so. And are there not doctors caring for it? Like, how did you take out every adult and there doesn't seem to be like a mask concern about this? Right. Exactly. Because they're all just sort of like, oh, they're all sick. Well, even, even if you, even if they're all on bed rest and you can't communicate with them because they're all sleeping, leave a letter for like at least one of them. Yeah. And they have. A brawl or someone. Yeah. And there has to be someone else taking care of these sick people.

I don't understand. I really need to know about the sickness and it kind of comes up later, but like not really. I mean, it's confirmed that it is an intention. It's intentional, but we don't know why or how. And we know it's not poison. Right. So they decide in that moment that they must leave the tower and take the artifact with them. They decide that they'll go to Gwen's second cousin's estate just outside Mirith, hoping that it will not be the most obvious place for the children to look for them.

Cool. This is the plot point that bugs me because, um, Rue's like, we'll go to my parents house something in Mirith and Gwen's like, that's stupid. That's the first place they're going to go. Let's go to my second cousin's house and this other place outside of Mirith. But then from here through like where they end up going, they just talk about going to like Gwen's family, going to Rue's family's house. And I'm like, guys, like we're going to go to Mirith. I'm like, no, you're not. No, you're not. We just talked about how that's not where you're going. And I know that's such a subtle thing and it doesn't matter because they don't go either

of those places anyway, but it bothered me because it happens on the same page. Yeah. Yeah. So they split up outside of Rue's room. Gwen goes to grab Archie. She makes this big deal about like, oh, we can't just leave him here. I don't know why because he's like a beige crayon for the rest of this book, but that's fine. And he was kind of a beige crayon for most of this book. Like he sort of stirred the pot for like 10 minutes. The last time he stirred the pot was the last time that he had any meaningful contribution to this book.

And by meaningful, I mean, we saw it. Not that it had any impact. No, because nothing came of it. No. So Gwen goes to get Archie and Rue goes to get the artifact. Their plan is to meet up by the stables and right off into the night. Rue is successful in grabbing the artifact, but on her way to the stables, she runs into Inda who asks, what the fuck she's doing? Inda, remember, is one of the lead children. Why is no one guarding the artifact? Great question.

They were all going to follow Rue and her friends 24 hours a day, but there's no one that stationed in the dungeon. Well, even, okay. So if you remember when they got their supplies, the Kings guard that were sent with the supplies were sent with the express duty of guarding the artifact, not just during the day. Like so Lear and the dooder that she would run into when going to the dungeon, like there was supposed to be guards posted at the dungeon all the time. Where are they? Where are they? Who knows?

And she just picks it up. It's wrapped in blankets. Like this is another thing where I don't know how big it is. Yeah. This is where it's a loaf of bread. It's a loaf of bread, but it also, if you notice, it changes from being in her backpack to being in her jacket. Right. Well, and it's like tucked away in her jacket. So it goes from being a loaf of bread that she has to shove in her backpack to being small enough that she can kind of tuck into her breast pocket. And it doesn't look like she has a third boob. Yeah. Like. And big enough that you don't notice someone pickpocketing you from your breast.

Right. Even if it's the size of the pot, like my palm, I would notice if somebody was like, I'm just going to yank that out the front of your jacket. Like I would feel it leave. I feel like it stayed in the backpack. That makes more sense to pull it out. Alas, where the logistics get funky again. Yep. So in does asking what the fuck she's doing and rules start stammering, but Fen of all people appears and tells in that that room was meeting him for a nice little romantic

evening picnic. A night picnic. Right. Uh-huh. And in takes the set face value and is like, I don't need to stay for this. Thank you so much. And leaves them alone. And Fen like makes out with ruin is like, do you want me to go on? And in is like, no, thanks. Respectfully no. Respectfully. That's going to be a note for me and just leaves, which. Why is there not more suspicion? You were suspicious a week ago.

I don't know. So when they're alone, Ruth's like, what the fuck are you doing here? And he hard deflects. He's like, oh, I had a thing to do. And she accuses him of leaving without saying goodbye. And he says he's sorry that the thing that he had to do took longer than expected. And she's just like so incredulous at his nonchalance. And I fucking agree. He's like, I grieved you for two and a half weeks, brother.

You just abandoned me when I needed you. Right. So I don't, I don't, frankly, give a flying fuck what it is that you were doing. And we don't nobody's doing anyway. No, we don't find out on this book. No. And I want to know. He goes on to say that while he was gone, he found clarity specifically that he's hers and that nothing can change that. He begs to talk to her, but Rue won't hear it. And that's when Archie and Gwen joined them and Gwen's like, oh, hey, back from the dead.

Wow, that's so weird. I love Gwen because even she is like, you abandoned her when she needed you. Right. I do also like Ruth's, I don't know if she says it out loud if it's in her internal monologue, but she has a clap back where she's like, I'm so glad you found clarity being away from me. No, she says that out loud. I was so proud of her for doing that. I have felt that. Yeah. So Rue's like, yeah, he's back, but he was just leaving. So let's get going. Ben catches up to Rue in the stables and he begs her to let him come with her.

Even though everything within Rue wants to say yes, even when the artifact reacts to his nearness and spurs back to life again in her mind, she tells him goodbye. Bye. Bye. Bye. And so he seems to take that at respecting that boundary. But as they ride away, Rue realizes that the artifact is gone and when she looks back at Fen, she realizes that he has it. He does some tomfoolery tracing a shape in the air with his fingers and then just disappears like a fucking maverick.

And there's just like this weird little black orb of lightning that also fades. Right. And I feel like they take this in way too much stride. They're just like, no follow up questions. Where did he go? Yeah. And he's like, oh, he's a sorcerer. Attracts. Sorcerers didn't exist five minutes ago. So no one believed in magic five minutes ago, but clearly he's a sorcerer and he stole from us. Right. Not a follow up question to be seen.

Not a follow up. I mean, so Rue in her entire monologue does kind of reel from the knowledge of being used of Fen actually knowing about magic and like not sharing that with her and all of this stuff. I don't think she's ever reacted to that, but I feel like I feel like she doesn't react outwardly enough to that. Like neither her nor Gwen nor Archie like not what the fuck to be seen. No.

No. They're basically like, what's the next move, boss? Yeah. And then so she's like, oh, he must be going to the shattered city away. And so they go. Okay. So they go and when they arrive, they see a projection of Ordelen by the sea and Rue can feel the nearness of the artifact. They go through the projection and in the center of the old square, a man kneels dressed in black as they watch his image waivers and breaks.

And it's clear that he's part of an illusion, right? It looks like a solid recreation of the city, but it kind of flickers. And that's when they know that it's not real. The illusion continues and they watch as the same darkness that erupted from the artifact when Rue touched it, seeps from the man's hands into the ground. Rue realizes in that moment that the figure is terriel, so the destroyer, and they are plunged into darkness for a couple of seconds. But just as quickly the darkness disappears and the projection kind of loops back around

and Rue realizes that she's watching essentially a rerun of the same scene over and over again. Which sounds terrifying. It does sound terrifying. So the other thing that I don't know what's happening here is Fen appears and tells them that the projection is his and that it's been doing this for two days. He says it in a way that makes it feel like it's not been intentional, though. Yeah, like he's stuck in this loop himself. Right. And that he has not slept for two days either, just like watching the loop.

Right. And it's like he doesn't know how to make the loop stop or go forward or anything like that. Yeah, and he's like trying to figure out the motivations of Terrell, but like Terrell. Terriel. Thank you. I was looking at the word and I was like, uh. Yeah. Um. Right. Yeah. But I mean we quickly realize or he quickly cops to being Terriel, so it's like, you don't know what happened? That's what I'm so confused about because he even says something I think to the effect

of like I've been watching it trying to figure out what happened to the more I watched the less I understand, but also that's me. So do you remember this happening or not? Yeah, brother. What can you say a couple more words about that? Like how? I don't know. So Fen goes on to say that he's surprised to see them. He thought for sure that they'd alert the region or something. Gwen asks why Fen didn't just say he could do magic and he tells him he didn't want to

be studied like the rock. I mean, it's fair, which is totally fair. I understand why Fen kept them in the dark. I really do. But I still don't understand his motivation. So let's let's get into what he reveals and then we can talk about his motivations. Big mask reveal. Mask reveal. Mask off. So he reveals that he is indeed Teriel, that he's been alive all this time and never aging, that he had the exact same experience as Rue after the destruction.

He woke up naked and blind and alone. He came back here this time to try and understand why, but it's been futile. He tells Rue that the stone, the artifact, is actually his heart, which was ripped from him the day of the destruction and he was totally unaware of that fact until the day that she found it. She realizes, Rue, in this moment, that what she feels for him is actual love and whatever magic bonds them together, the love is separate. And I just have 75 follow up questions.

And he talks about how he wakes up and he like, it seems like he was just waiting to die and was like not dying. Right. But also Rue acknowledges that Fen has a beating heart in his chest like she has felt it. Right. And so is this more like a soul situation? Also is Teriel Festra, are they the same? Is he a god? Because he does say like that by mortal form or whatever. Right. Well, and he doesn't answer the core questions of why were you going to destroy Ordelen by

the sea to begin with? Yeah. What was that about, brother? I don't know. Well, and I also have a question of whether like, can he do magic without the artifact? Like is the heart the source of his magic? Right. But does that mean that he hasn't had magic? Because he says that he's been in this, Ordelen by the sea was destroyed 500 years ago. 500 years ago. Yeah.

Plus 20, I guess, how old he was. Yeah. And he's been unable to do magic this whole time. That's my question because we didn't see him do it until the artifact was back in his possession. Right. Although, I guess that's not true because later it does get taken from him and he does magic without it. But it's still like near him. Yeah. Is it a proximity thing? And I don't know what his motivations are when Ordelen by the sea was destroyed.

I don't know his motivations. Now I don't understand if Festra is like its own God or if he is like a conduit for Festra or if Festra matters at all. Right. I don't know how much he remembers. Like, clearly he doesn't remember anything except for like wandering the earth for 500 years. Right. I don't know if that's true. I don't know if that's true. And yeah, I mean, I don't know what he means by heart because it's not his physical heart. He's not like a vampire that doesn't have a beating heart. I could see that maybe it's his emotional heart because it like reacts to Rue so strongly.

But then why does that happen? Why is it tied to his magic? Is it tied to his magic? Why did it respond to Rue at all? How was Rue related to Fennin anyway when she touched it? Why she even felt drawn to it in the first place? Because she had some weird connection to it before she ever touched it. Right. And if magic exists outside of this one thing, does Rue possess an innate magical ability or is it just the artifact? I don't know.

And even if I feel like, if it's just the artifact, why can she use any of that anyway? Because they're just because they're in love. And it's like a like a light-lark situation where like, if I love you, I can use your magic. But then how did you end up loving him without knowing him to begin with? And I also don't know why in this moment she's like, oh, I'm actually in love with you. I'm like, if anything, this would tell me that I'm not in love with you in actuality. Right. It's just the thing influencing me.

Yeah. I don't know. I have so many questions. I do too. And I'm interested in these questions. Like I want to know the answer. I do too because I still feel like this story is a unique presentation of a magic system and of like fated maids adjacent, like kind of thing. Like there's good bones here. I'm interested. I want to see how this resolves. But like, girl, I got questions. I got questions and they could either be really interestingly revealed or they could be massive

plot holes. Yeah, exactly. So we have a couple of housekeeping things that happen. So they go through this big reveal, right? Rue decides in that moment that she needs to get the artifact away from Fen. So she draws near to him as he's talking. He looks at her and tells her that whatever happens, he's hers. She kisses him and steals the artifact at once agreeing with him that, yeah, you're mine and also saying now you're my bitch.

That's basically what she does, which is, I'm awesome. That's okay. Yeah. Rue tosses the artifact to Gwen and tells her and Archie to run, but just then Deluc announces himself and he's there with the three children. This wraps up relatively quickly, which feels like a little bit of a disappointment because Heat orders the three children to grab Rue and her friends and they put up zero amounts of fight. No, they're just like, okay.

But they don't go for Fen. The Rue looks over to Fen who only smiles and uses his magic to disappear again. So did no one see Fen there? No, they did because even Deluc remarks, he's just like, that's weird, but not a follow-up question. I'm just like, oh my God, wouldn't you be more interested in the dude who actually knows magic than this chick? But no, apparently not. So Rue and Archie and Gwen have no choice but to go with Deluc and the children back to the tower. And then we see this happen.

I don't know why this last chapter should not have been a part of this book. Because they are essentially traveling and it's a conversation between Deluc and Rue. Deluc tells Rue not to worry. She has a bright future to look forward to, many, many experiments and many, many like accolades awaiting her. She'll be a celebrated archaeologist and scientist in her time. He alludes to colluding with someone to make all the professors sick, but we don't get

an answer as to who or how. And so Rue's like engaging in this conversation and she ends up asking what about Fen and he's like, what about him? Do you think he'll come back for you? And she's like, I don't know. And I'm like, how are you so uninterested in this sorcerer? How are neither of them interested in him? I don't know. Because even she's like, I don't know. I guess it was true love and now I have his heart. Well, so Rue ends her internal monologue by saying what she does know is that she'll never

let Deluc control the artifact because Terrile's heart called to her and it belongs to her and she is Ruellian Delara the destroyer. And then that's how the book ends. I hate. I hate it. I hate it. I wish they would have just left it with up Fen disappears and they don't have a choice. They have to go with the Luke end of book. Yeah, that would have been much better.

It is just they still could have had that that line about I'm Ruellian Delara the destroyer. Yeah, that line is fine. But this like they have such a casual conversation, such a casual conversation. And it feels like this conversation should have happened when they were back at the tower. Yeah, it's like at the start of book two or whatever. Just like, well, what are we doing here? I also feel like I mean, they go with him willingly, but I don't know why they go with him willingly. And so who is actually holding the artifact either was that taken from them or she just

like it's back in my bread box. Right. Yeah. I, I don't know. I have so many questions because if she's like, I'm never going to let you control the artifact, but she doesn't actually have the artifact in her hand. Does he have it or his creepy children? Yeah, you're starting on the back foot there. Oh, sorry. I was looking at the second one to see it. At least there's only one more book. Okay, good. So there's not, there's not a middle book. There's not a Jan situation.

I just, it's just so fucking weird. It's so weird. Where is Fen? What is with his creepy smile? Like you said, why is no one interested in him? Is he a God? Right. If, if, if you follow the thought process through to fruition that like DeLuke and his children are worshiping Festra slash to the destroyer, wouldn't they put two and three together to get five and that would make Fen the object of their desire?

Yes. Like that, I just, what are we doing here? I don't know. Like I'm annoyed because this book was tough. It was like a bit of a slog, but I also kind of want to read the second one like right now. Like, right. I want to be this year, even though it's not on our schedule because like I want to know what happens and I, I want it to be good and I'm just so angry.

Yeah. Yeah. I feel that. All right. So let's get into our ratings. I don't even fucking know. I don't even know. So all right, let's get into it. Liz, how did we rate the spice level? We gave it a one.

It's not quite non-existent. There's nothing really spicy, but there are some mild scenes. Yeah. Like there's, there's potential for spice in the second book. We have built a relationship that I'm interested. We have built chemistry between them. Just nothing really happens. There were a lot of cock blocking. There was a lot of cock blocking and a lot of instances that didn't go anywhere that could have, but I mean, I get why they didn't also.

Yeah. And I appreciated that those scenes that we did get were specific, right? Yes. So on the, on the scale of like spice or no spice, there was definitely some ass grabbing and some shaft like existence. Yes. So it wasn't not there. It was just not like full on. We just didn't quite get to like actual sex, but I do think the specific scenes that we get do tell me that it's not like the author is going to be a closed door.

Like we get enough that it's just in the process of this plot. It wasn't appropriate. Maybe. Right. So hopefully in the next one it will be agreed now that we know it's nerve. So moving into writing style, I had originally rated this as a two, but I think I agree with you that it's a three because, and I think we've talked about this at length in our coverage, but the writing's not bad. It is technically good writing. The sentence structures are complex.

It's descriptive. It's just not very interesting. So it's not. And sometimes the semantics, the body mechanics are kind of weird. Yeah. So I would say the two things, my two biggest critiques for the writing style here are those logistics. They get a little weird and not consistent. So like the size of the artifact, for example, what plan we're actually going for, for another example, and then just the other side of that is they arrive early and they leave late.

Like there's just so much of this book that I don't need to come along for the journey. We could have referenced it in a conversation. And frankly, I think if you did that, it would be an easier read, a more interesting read, and it would be half the length. Yes. Because, and that's the problem too, is that we could reference things later in conversations, especially because the journeys we go through, we don't even really learn anything. No. Yeah. Most of those conversations, I guess, serve to like flesh out the world and like character build, but they're not, they're not really well executed to the point where I give a

shit about those characters. No. Case in point, as we've said before, like we hard skimmed those big blocks of text and didn't miss anything. No. Yeah. And I think that's when her brother just like Spider-Man's into the carriage. What the fuck was that? It just makes no fucking sense. Makes no sense. Yeah. There's just some weird semantics. Like, I don't know why you made that choice, but. Man, there was a choice to be made and you made the fuck out of it. You made the fuck out of it. Because he made an entrance and then said nothing.

And yet we were along for the ride for 15 pages. Anyway, that brings us to quality of the storytelling. So Liz, how did you rate this? So I may change this after we talk, but I rated it a two. And I think this is, it goes into a lot of writing style because there are so many questions that I have that I feel like we could have gotten answers to in this book that I could see where it's setting up plot in the second book, but I can also see them just being plot

holes. Like everyone getting sick. I could see that it's just being, because we got the admission that that was DeLuke. But if that's just an implied to take out the adults, like that's not satisfactory to me. This book is a hard one for me to parse the writing style versus quality of storytelling because so much of what I don't like in the writing style affects the storytelling because we just get so much superfluous detail that don't matter. Yeah.

And we don't get a lot of world building. This is one of those things that you usually bring up where it takes place in two places, mostly just one. Yeah, but I also wonder, because it's not that we don't get descriptions of those places. No, we do. And it's an interesting story. So I rated it a three and that's why I rated it a three because like we were saying towards the end of our coverage, the building blocks of this story, I think are unique.

They're so unique. Like I haven't, the magic system, I have not read something like this. I haven't read something that has like this interaction with the between the two main characters. Like I like the setting of being at an archaeological dig and kind of an academia. Yeah. The execution of those things leaves something to be desired, but I'm invested enough in the story that for something that we're going to rate pretty low, we do end up recommending it, right? Because I want to know what happens. Exactly.

And I to your point, like if it's a duology, I mean, it is a duology, like just one more book is not that much of a commitment. It's not like Night Bane, which has like an unknown amount of books, which I'm very concerned about. Yeah. I don't know if I'm committed to that. No. So either we're going to get a satisfying story and it's going to be worth the read just because it's got some of these unique elements or it's not. But either way, it's done. Right. I did bump mine up to a three mainly for the it is so unique.

It doesn't remind me of anything else. And we read so much that that's a pretty big feat. Yeah. It really is at this point. It's huge. Kind of hard to do. Yeah. And so I am really, and it does get me with, we do get that dark academia vibe, which I'm into. It's a very unique female lead. We don't have, I'm going to be a warrior. There's no training montage. Training montage. Yeah. I'm glad we don't have that because we don't need that. And hopefully that stays the next book. I don't want to suddenly go to war and now we're going to be like magical soldiers.

Right. And even what you were talking about earlier with like Rue's fatal flaw being the fact that she's easily flattered, I feel like is unique. That is unique. Like usually the fatal flaw is like I don't talk about my feelings or something like wrote at this point. Yes. And that we have this one moment of therapy and everything's fine. Right. Looking at you, Nightbame. For real. For real. Or I love too hard or too easily. No. She's just like, I have a big ego and no one strokes it.

And no one seems to recognize it, but me. Yes. And I think that's interesting. Because they go with DeLuke freely, I can see that continuing to be a problem because she doesn't trust him, but I still think she's really susceptible to him. Oh, 100%. And I hope that they lead into that in the next book. Me too. Yeah. Where the fuck did Fen go? Okay. I wonder. Yeah. I'm more mad at him now than I am at DeLuke. I am too. Because I don't really know DeLuke's motivations, but like at least I know what side he's on. I don't know.

Is Fen good? Is he bad? Is he chaotic neutral? I don't know. Okay. And one more point that I didn't bring up about that. So Fen leaves, right? He just said like, Rue, I'm yours. And she's like, that's cool. Give me my shiny thing back. Give me my rock. And as they're being like taken control over by DeLuke, like they're getting kidnapped or whatever, Rue looks to Fen for help. And I'm like, girl, you just stole what he just told you is his heart and you want him to save you?

I know. You literally stole his heart and then looked him for help. So and I kind of respect that he's just like, I'm just going to smirk at you. Fuck you, girl. I couldn't be mad at it. I'm like, yeah, I would have done the same thing. Yeah. And that's I'm going to let you sweat it out. And that's twice that you've rejected him in like two days. Like, right. All right. Bye. Have fun. Also, clearly I can teleport. So I'm not worried about following you. I know where you're going. Right. I know he's going to take you right back to the tower. So I'll see you there in a little bit.

Right. Like I got to go do some other mystery journey, I guess, but bye. Live this long without my heart. Yeah. That was so funny. And I think just a really consistent like illustration of Ruth's character being self-centered. She's really self-centered. And yeah, I'm interested in how that goes on to you. I wonder if Archie and Gwen will become colored crayons or will just fade more into the background. Well, it's interesting because they trade off colors, right? Because Archie started off as a colored crayon and then he faded to beige and Gwen became

a colored crayon. Yes. She started off as a beige crayon. That's interesting. That's true. So I don't know if it's just like, if it was just a new author thing, like difficult to keep both of those things going at once or what. Or give them like solid personalities because that is hard like as a new author to create well-rounded side characters, essentially. Right. Exactly. And make them matter. Anyway. So do we recommend this book? Yes. Astros. Yes, with reservations. Yes, with reservations.

Like I feel like I'm going to recommend it now, but if the second book leaves all these things unanswered, I'm going to un-recommend this one. Yeah, same. Big same. So we'll see based on the second book. No pressure. No pressure, Meg. Sorry. All right, guys, we did it. Those are our thoughts on The Destroyer by Meg Smitherman. Thank you as always for joining us on this journey. What did you think? Let us know on the socials. You can find us on Instagram, Facebook, TikTok, and Goodreads at SpiceTradersPod.

And if you like our podcast and want more, consider joining our Patreon, where we release Patreon exclusive episodes on our off weeks. And if you really, really like us, drop us a review wherever you listen. Until next time, we'll see you. Bye. Bye. Thanks for watching. Thanks for watching guys!

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Irresistible Urge to Fall for Your Enemy By Brigitte Knightley Part 1

    Nov 10, 20261 hr 35 minAudio

    Triggers: graphic violence and gore, depictions of a fictional plague, on-page sexual content (including masturbation), and themes of parent death and chronic illness KU: No Recommendation: No, (give the author money...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Surrendering to Scylla by Wren K Morris

    Oct 27, 20261 hr 10 minAudio

    Triggers: (From the author): kidnapping, violence, discussions of abuse, BDSM dynamics and play, tentacle play, brief descriptions of injured animal (that receives aid), breath play, bondage, depictions of sub drop,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Threshing Day by Rebecca Yarros

    Oct 14, 20261 hr 9 minAudio

    Triggers: war, battle, hand-to-hand combat, perilous situations, blood, intense violence, brutal injuries, death, and poisoning KU: No Recommendation: Yes! For more of the author, check out https://rebeccayarros.com/

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Court of Heathens by K. A. Knight

    Sep 29, 202652 minAudio

    Triggers: from the author: “explicit violence, explicit sexual violence, dubious consent, murder, gore, torture, kidnapping, and more.” KU: Yes Recommendation: No For more of the author, check out...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Under Loch and Key by Lana Ferguson Part 2

    Sep 21, 20261 hr 4 minAudio

    Triggers: death of a parent (off page), grief, fantasy violence KU: No Recommendation: both Traders recommend! This is part 2 of 2. For more of the author, check out https://www.lanaferguson.com/

    Credit the people on this episode