Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Spice Traders

Spice Traders artwork

Barbarian Alien by Ruby Dixon

Mar 28, 20231 hr 7 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

The Traders return to the icy planet of Not-Hoth, this time with some new characters. Dubious consent really kicks in on this one and many plot holes are explored. Trope: enemies to lovers Content Warnings: dubious consent, kidnapping. Recommendations: 0 Spice Traders recommend Let us know your thoughts on the socials @spicetraderspod and Patreon for more spicy content! Check out Ruby Dixon’s website: rubydixon.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

So one of the things that I think is really interesting is when we were reading the first book, we decided to read the second book because we were like, you know, the first book in every series is usually a little rough. Like we'll give her the second book to see if it improved. And she didn't. She doubled down on the things we had problems with. She was like, oh, you don't like that? Here's some more. Like, Jesus. You like that? No, I don't like that. Please.

Welcome to your safe space. The podcast, your partner, friends, parents, whoever thinks is dirty. Don't have time to read books. Want to understand all the jokes in the TikToks? We got you, fam. We're the spice traders and we deal in spicy books. I'm Katie and I need it to make sense. I'm Dez and I would love to talk about feelings today. I'm Liz and I'm hypercritical. As always, we start every episode with three things. The first is a generic trigger warning. You can find specific triggers for this book in our show notes. So please check those out. Also, we talk about sex and use foul language. If you have sensitivity to any of this, please give this episode a skip.

Secondly, we talk about books, the whole book, nothing but the books will help me goddess. If you plan to read this book and don't want something spoiled right now, don't listen to this episode. Lastly, we acknowledge that a good book can hit you at the wrong time. The views expressed in our discussion are our opinions and absolutely do not want to diminish the work and the talent of the office in our community. That said, we have some notes. So Liz, what are we talking about today?

Today, we are talking about the second book in the Ice Planet Barbarian series Barbarian Alien by Ruby Dixon. This one was published in July of 2015. It is the second, like I said, of the Songlin series. Currently there are 22 books in the whole series at the time of this recording. It is 248 pages on Kindle and 336 pages in a physical copy. There are some bonuses in the physical copy, which I'm going to talk to you guys about. I don't know if you saw it on Kindle. So again, you could probably read it in a day if you wanted to. So let's get into it. Des, you're going to kick us off today?

Yeah, I would love to. So one of the first things that is immediately noticeable in this book is last time we used parts. The book was divided into parts and now we're dividing into chapters. So my physical copy is still parts. Interesting. Interesting. Kindle is definitely chapter. Yeah, like it's parts and then names. Yeah. So that's strange. So we started off with some of the pieces that we saw from the last part of book one where we are seeing the girls get rescued from the ship and we're getting a bit more of a perspective from both Liz and from another alien that we kind of heard bits and pieces from in the last book.

I think of his name as Braha. I still hear Rajo. So some extras in this book. She actually provides a pronunciation list. Okay. So I did want to share that I didn't see it till I thought I was at the end of the book so it didn't help me. But it is Raha. Okay. And she gives a little descriptions of them. In case you missed reading the book, I guess.

I mean, at least for the men, does she give a description of what the fuck Liz looks like? Also, the author's notes, it just tells you the plot. Like you could just read about the character and like it. It's what happened in this book. Liz, this is Liz. Okay.

Well, that's the whole book. Yeah, there we go. And we still don't know anything about what she looks like. Good. Okay. So that's a running theme. I think my first impression starting this book was that you would be lost if you had not read the first one at all because it's just like, bam, we're right in the middle of the story. So I felt some of that way. One of the things that I struggled with is like, it was a recap, a lot of what happened before. So getting rescued, the like hearing the resonating noise, not knowing who that is, going after the Sakui.

The, the, excuse me. Sakosk. There's no pronunciation for anything but the males of the tribe. Of course not. Helpful. Great. Love that. The giant monster with the worms. And then. Worm boy. Wormy in here. Wormy in here. So. Gross. Sorry. Um, but after we've kind of gone through those, those things that we saw in the previous book, we kind of get Liz's perspective of like, not wanting to get a kui, thinking it's kind of gross and kind of her decision to not do that.

And thus begins the problematic pieces of this book because R'hosh grabs her and runs off with her. That's a slit in the back of her neck or whatever and then shoves that worm in there against her will all the while she is screaming no I don't want this I hate you I'm gonna hate you forever. You know, no means no but apparently only sometimes. So that was very disturbing and then also it was kind of insinuated that none of the other girls also wanted like nobody was stepping right up because to your point, for the last book does, you know, if I saw my friend or I guess my, my

kidnappy get this thing in her neck and then pass the fuck out. I would not be I would wait for her to wake up right. Yes, well, that's not what happens. No, and R'hosh even says like, they could be unconscious for days like we don't know. So we're really just gonna. We're just gonna wing it. We're just gonna. We're just gonna wing it. Yeah. So he shoves this worm in her in her neck and he passes out and he decides to take her to his cave.

It is his cave. No one knows where it is. It is his special cave that he spends time in his cave. His secret cave. Yes, his man cave. Really leaning into the barbarian thing. I see. Yes. Yeah. So he gets her back and like any sane human being decides to undress her. So I do, I do have, I have two points before he undresses her. One, he's talking to another Sakui and the other one, I didn't read down his name because

who gives a shit. And he asks like maybe they'll resonate when they're in season. And I know he means like hurdle or adult or in heat. Actually, I don't know what he means, but I just think of fruit. Like are they ripe? And that upset me. I mean, yeah, kind of. Yeah. Also, we do learn that. Rahuosh is a virgin. He is a big giant virgin alien.

Yep. Yep. So he undresses her and in the process of undressing her decides to look for that third nipple that we talked about for the first book. Yeah. And so this part was confusing to me because he said, he says something to be effective. He's not going to rape somebody while they're unconscious, but I was like, are you not though? Yes. This is not right. Because and I think this is an issue with the definition of rape because he certainly molests her. Like he touches her. He touches her clit directly while she's unconscious, which is rape to me, but.

Yeah. So he does decide to not like, I guess get her off and just finishes dressing her in clothing that he brought with them from the cave when they went to go rescue the girls. And so he put her in what a long skirt and a tunic situation. Yeah. I pictured like a menonite garb situation, which it's completed the entire vibe. He also talks about like, there's something he has to do like set a broken phone or something,

but he says strangely the thought of hurting her makes my stomach turn. And I'm like, but why though? Like if she's your mate, are you supposed to get excited at the thought of hurting her? Like, shouldn't that upset you? Right. I guess it's just physical hurt in this way, not psychological hurt from psychological hurt. We don't give a shit about, right? You did just hold her down and force a parasite into her against her will. And then you also molested her when she was unconscious. So like, yeah.

And he has a straight up plan to keep her in a cage in a cave until she's prejudice. His baby batter is what is repeatedly referred to the baby batter as it is referred to. But he literally says he's going to keep her in the cave until she is full of his child quote unquote before they return to the village, which is just it.

Yeah, it's pretty gross. I will say it. So moving along at the end of chapter one, we get Liz starting to wake up from being unconscious and recognizing that she now has the kui inside of her and feeling gross and not wanting that, but also feeling very horny, just the most horny that she's ever been for whole life. So I really have problems with how horny she is because I know we haven't talked about

guilt yet, but maybe whatever. It reminds me of the do in guilds where like, they're just drugged to be horny. And that's makes me feel like like she repeatedly talks about how she's angry and how she hates him and she doesn't want him. But then she's still super turned on like that gives me so much ick. Yeah, I think the line of consent here is like out the window because there's your body and you can't react to something and if your mind is not on the same page, it's still not consent.

No, right. This is like the false claim that men can't be raped if they got an erection. Right. Your physiological response is nothing to do with consent. Yeah, that continues. Yeah. We as speaking of which as we continue along lose the size as she is very horny and we're like, gosh, it's apparently outside doing she doesn't know what we know from his perspective that he's out like setting traps and like gather things like feed her take care of her when

she wakes up but she wakes up and starts to touch herself because she's very horny. And in this process of her touching herself for hush goes back and looks at her touching herself. And he says, you know, it's a great idea. I'm going to touch myself now. Okay. So can we can we just talk about I don't know if you guys got this yet. But Raj is touching himself to Liz touching her. But his inner monologue reveals.

He doesn't remember her name. Yes, he doesn't know her name. It's just like my mate or the human. And she's like, he says something to the effect of like, I know she said her name at some point. You've got to be fucking kidding me. You kidnapped this woman and you don't know her name. Oh my God. And then to compound the just the horridness of the scene.

The author chooses. I actually highlighted that specifically for you. I was like, oh, I got to make sure Katie gets an opportunity to talk about juices. I did too. Talk about juices. And the other thing so like, I don't know. Okay, so they finished so Raj climaxes onto the floor in like a puddle and just leaves it there. He does. He does says say her name when he. Oh, okay. Oh yeah, he remembers it. That's what it is. It's Liz. There we go.

Perfect timing as I'm ejaculating her name is right onto the floor. Just onto the floor. It's his cave. Come on. Okay, okay. How big is that cave? We have not the time nor the mathematical skills for this right now. There's a lot of. So, okay, he ejaculates onto the floor, which I have problems with that in and of itself. But when Liz wakes up from this encounter, because she like master rapes and then like

basically passes the fuck out. But when she wakes up, she she notices that the floor has been swept and I'm like, if you are familiar with semen at all, you will be aware that you cannot sweep it anywhere. No, no, you can turn into an industriality. It's just not sleeping anywhere. Oh, um, the other thing I did want to point out during this masturbation scene again, this is from our horses point of view.

My cock is the largest in my tribe. I've seen the other males bathing and they do not come near my girth or length. Good for you and your massive cock. So, after this whole exchange, they spend a few days together. And during this timeframe, Liz assumes that Rojas does not speak English and Rojas just never corrects her on that. She just kind of lets her talk at him almost incessantly like she just does not stop speaking.

And that's fine. He has a lot to work through emotionally. I get it. But the entire time she's, you know, mad at him or, you know, saying all sorts of like things about, you know, I need to get out of here and things like that, basically letting him know that she wants to run away, which is why her harsh decides and all is infinite to not give her shoes. Just wants to keep her pregnant and barefoot. Yup. Chained to the stove. Yeah. So I did wonder, so I had this in my notes.

I was like, why is she not, because it's like a couple of days this happens, right? And I'm like, why is she not more motivated to like leave and like figure out a way to make shoes? Because he's like bringing back kills and she talks about how he's keeping the hides and like she is dressed in a skirt of some kind. But then immediately in the next couple of pages, she starts making pants. And so I'm like, okay, well maybe you haven't gotten there yet. I think the emotional draining of recognizing that you have been, there's no nice way to say this, worm raped is probably a pretty like emotionally traumatizing thing.

So maybe your immediate thought isn't, I should leave. Yeah. She does talk about that at one point, which was like, I don't even know where I would go. It's pulled outside and I don't even know where I would go. Yeah. I think the other thing during this time period that I don't like besides the fact that Rehosh doesn't feel the need to tell her that he understands everywhere she's saying is that he says this thing, my woman talks a lot and like, why do you have to say it like that?

It's just very misogynistic sounding like, oh God, women never shut up. It's like, well, you're not talking to her. You're not attempting to talk to her. Right. So like what else is she supposed to do? He also has this mental thought about wanting to like court her and make her like him and says like, well, why didn't Vectel tell us more about human courting? Well, Georgie was just like down with it from the start. So there was nothing to tell. And I'm like, you're going to blame Vectel for this because you kidnapped her.

You could just ask. Also, speaking of which you could ask to her. There are so many times where I'm like, how long is this going to go on? Why don't you just talk to her? Because I don't have words. I'm sorry. Just talk to her. So also during this, he takes to feeding her. She realizes now with the Kui that she can no longer face things the way she did face previously. And so Rehosh not only like will not allow her to feed herself, he has to feed her by

putting raw meat into her mouth, which apparently becomes a very sensual thing. And I just have to say cannot relate. Yeah. Okay. So in this scene, I wrote down very specifically because she like, he cooks this meat for her at first because that's how the human, human people like it. And she tastes it and she's like, man, this doesn't taste like anything. Can I try yours? And so he like gives her a piece and she asks for more and he's like, I'll give her any thing she asks for anything, everything.

And I'm like, except for shoes apparently or a conversation or freedom or freedom or the ability to choose whether or not you want to freaking parasite in your body. Like just give me five more minutes for what's her face. This like wake up like none of that, but everything. And so what, what is anything and what is everything I've got? Nothing. I will put my baby batter in you and feed you. That's all you get. I hope you want those fades. I made this. This will be good, but I like to make sure I made this is just like a handful of.

I made this. I made this for you. And then he puts it on the floor to sweep away later. I will say at least he swept it away. So did he though or did it just like, is that just what the floor is made of? Yeah. This is cause. So throughout this whole time, of course, because she has her crewie and because they are resonating for each other, there's a lot of intimate moments that spark a lot of arousal

between Liz and for her. And they don't really give into it. In fact, going so far as for Liz to be like, no means no, I don't want this slapping his hand away, like rejecting him at every possible moment. So he at one point, and I don't actually think I saved this quote. Maybe maybe you guys have it where she won't goes. Nope, like, no. And so he has decided in all his infinite wisdom that that is how you initiate.

This is how you're supposed to be in Iraq. You're supposed to be saying no, you're supposed to be saying nope when you want like someone to touch you or like to have these feelings. So really the wires just get real crossed and take some far too long in my opinion to get sorted out. So I had the new two and my note is like, I think the author wants us to be endearing, but I hate it. And I think that's the same thing with how much Georgie talks about like, physically wanting him, but it just feels like mental rape, like her body wants him, but she totally

doesn't and keeps saying no. That continues to be a problem. Yeah, like, even at the end of this book, I just wonder how much of their connection is real because I don't fully believe either of their perspectives. I mean, beyond the having a parasite in you that decides that this person is your mate and you're going to make great offspring, like, even in even at the end of this book, they get to get to the end and they know nothing about each other.

Like, I don't know. It's just not very believable for me. And also, I think at this point, we're like a third of the way through the book and I'm just bored. Like nothing is happening. There's this like push pull thing between Rahosh and Liz that just doesn't feel like it's going anywhere or that it's even interesting to read. So this was a struggle for me, this entire book. So as she's plotting her escape, she wants to get out of here and she just says that

she is going to escape. So she focuses on like getting a bow and shoes. Those are her two like big things that she needs to be able to leave. So she and like maybe I didn't see at any point that she may oh, she took his shoes. That's how it happened. So she went and she took his shoes one time to go out and look for some sort of material to use as a bow. So she gets up in the middle of the night, doesn't does her best to not really grow,

but he immediately knows that she's moving and up. So he follows her and she makes her way to the same, well, maybe not the same, but another stream with one of those bamboo fish from last time, which I don't think we got a name for last time either. I think they just called them fang fish. Is what I think Mectal called them. They don't have one name like Mectal. No, Metlac. Damn it. You're welcome. She is trying to get the bamboo from the water.

And of course, like, her host comes out and is yelling her name while she's like pulling this bamboo because he knows that it is a deadly fish and she thinks it's just bamboo. So she gets startled and like falls back, holding on to one of the bamboo up the fish and like yanks it out of the water, falls back onto the snow and Mahosh apparently like kills the fish next to them. And then they start having sex next to the fish.

Next to the dead fish. In the snow. Her pants are ripped. This scene is so problematic. It's so problematic. So she starts with saying the cootie is purring so hard. I don't think I could stop if I wanted to. Okay, but do you want to? Because it seems like you do. And then she continues to say no as she's like physically guiding him to do her.

And she says like multiple phrases of like, I don't want you to touch me there. I don't want you to do this. I don't want. So one of the quotes I have is I don't want this. I breathe even as I grab his horns and drag his mouth against mine once more. His moans of pure delight are swallowed against his tongue and I wrap my legs around his waist, feeling him stiffen against me in surprise. I totally don't want you tongueing me. I his it him. And it proceeds to tongue his mouth all over like a wild boob. Well, and it would be it would hit different if her internal monologue was not what it is. Right. Like if her internal monologue was even remotely close to, you know, he's so hot.

I want him so much. Like I think I'm falling in love or whatever it is. But her internal monologue is like this sucks. I hate it. I hate that guy. This coolly thing inside of me is stupid. Like what am I supposed to do here? Like how do I get out of the situation? I hate every second of this scene because listen, I know a lot of young boys are probably not reading Barbarian alien, whatever book this is. But like what are we teaching people about consent? Again, it doesn't matter what your body says. It's what your mouth says.

Right. And so continuing to say like, I don't want you to lick my pussy. I don't want you to lick me here. I don't want you to do this. And then like having him do that, like there is a, so I kind of wondered at one point in the book, I kind of wrote like this, every book have like a kink that like we're going to explore like in one form or another. And is this one, is this kink for this book consensual non-consent? But there's no safe word set up. So like even if it was, it's not a healthy relationship to be having here at all.

It's the consensual non-consent equivalent of 50 shades where like, is this BDSM? No, it's not. That's abuse. Right. This is rape. These are different things. Yeah. And again, with all of this in the snow. Bloody snow, bloody snow, dead fish. It's all oral sex, right? Like they're not actually having any sort of penetrative sex. That's true. Your genitals are very close to the snow and you're just doing it and also dead fish,

dead bamboo fish. The sexiest place to have sex. Oh, God, I'm so turned on. Before she, she pulls the bamboo fish and she's like having an internal monologue. She uses this word. I don't know if you guys got it. Squicks. Squick? Squick, it squicks me out. Yeah. Yeah, I underlined that too. Fuck. Never heard that word before. Never heard of it. Immediately circled it. Squick. Sounds fake. I looked it up. So squick is a verb. It's cause someone to feel intense discussed. Fine.

But the example is we get that bodily fluids can squick people out. Why is the example bodily fluids? Because that's, that's squeaky. They know what we're talking about. It's so squeaky. So going back to the book, they're pulling around. She's saying no. And they kind of finish. And as, as she's finishing, he growls at her or says mine.

And at first she's like, yeah. And then she's like, what? 80 pages into the book. Yes. It also like, for the record, he says one word. He only said mine. And so from this, she has determined that he speaks English. I feel like maybe he just has heard you say the word mine about things. But. Right. That's a good point. It's not a sentence. One word and she's like, you speak English. You bastard. It's like, hi. You bastard.

And he's like, you never bothered to ask. And I'm like, I hate that line so much because it's the whole household manager thing. Oh, what can I do to help? Bitch, this is information I need to know. Right. Yeah. You simply talk and assume I don't understand you is what he says. I have a mission is still a lie. Like this is ridiculous. Why would I assume you can understand me? You are a different species. So they go back angrily to his cave.

Wait, no, no, excuse me. Her pants are ripped. He makes her walk. Buckass naked. Oh, as he watches her. Cave. And she also, um, for more words, I hate along with juices. He calls her vagina wet pedals. And I'm not that you've called me. I didn't. I have words. I hate juices. Wet pedals. I don't have the sentence because I couldn't handle it. So what else was enough for me?

What pedals? So this is the problem between the words and between like the, just the weird dynamic between these two characters. I can't even enjoy this smut because I'm just like, Oh, yeah. No. Oh, yeah. It's very uncomfortable. So after she walks her naked butt back to his cave, uh, they sit down and she talks at him and he is not very forthcoming about anything.

Um, but basically they communicate back and forth about, you know, like, he's a jerk and so like he kind of gets mad and goes out to do, I forgot what, but like through this, they both like feel bad for each other. Like Liz is like, Oh, it's not his fault. Like that we were paired together and he got like a spitfire for a mate. And he's out there and he's like, it's not her fault that like she, you know, got resonates with this lonesome warrior man that I am with

trauma or whatever. And that's fine and good. But Liz still is like, I hate him, but also I feel bad, but I hate him. And it's the whiplash that this book gave me was exhausting. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Speaking of whiplash, I don't know if you guys got it. And for our listeners, this book is written in first person from both Rihosh and Liz's perspective, except for this one, this one part. Um, they're having this conversation, right?

And so, uh, they're eating also. And at some point the books, the book is written, not many will wish, will wish to risk their mates on a hunt, comma, he said, offering her another piece of meat. She refused it and he ate it instead. His expression thoughtful. I was like, I didn't catch that. Wait a minute. McFucking what? That's a big mistake. I didn't catch that. It was very jarred. So through this conversation that they're happening and the needles of the like, I hate you, I feel bad for you, whatever feelings that they're having.

Um, basically Liz is like, you don't even know what I want. And he's like, you want to hunt. And she's like, yeah, I want to hunt. Um, so he agrees to take her to hunt the next day if she lays with him. And as we all thought, like that's, you're asking for sex for go hunting, but he's like, no, no, no, no, no. I just want you to lay down next to me and sleep in bed. As a mate.

Totally just cuddles guys. And then that turns into how do you know I'm about to come? Are you not about to come? Well, the cuddles have to be naked. He, he makes her sleep naked. Like naked cuddles. Yeah. Like you should have gotten this and writing. Right. Like, but I'm glad we all got the understanding because I definitely have the thought of like, cool. So you're blackmailing her so she can hunt like sex me up and you can be an independent woman tomorrow. And then my next note is, oh wait, I jumped the gun.

He just wants a cuddle. Okay. No, he doesn't just want to cuddle. No, he does not just want to cuddle. It's kind of like when, I don't know. I'm, I'm blanking on an example, but like guys will offer something that seems seemingly innocuous. Like, oh, it's really late. Why don't you just stay over? Oh, there's only one bed or, oh, I'll take the couch or like whatever. It is, it is a lot like that. That's what happens. So they end up having more oral sex and Liz gets real into it.

Liz is like, how does this penis work? I want to like figure out all the bells and whistles. And so she spends a lot of time with the spur, which you guys remember is that little part up at the top of the penis that they have for no reason because their women don't even have clits. I, I was mad about it last time. I'm mad about it this time. Stop bringing it up. There's no reason for them to have that. It makes no sense, but she spends a little time with it. And apparently that makes them very excited. He does spur. And he spurts.

And he spurts. The spur bothers me too because it serves no purpose. And I think at one point, I don't know if it's now or later, but she even asks him like, does that feel good? And he's like, anything you do feels good, but like not really. Like it doesn't, it in itself doesn't really have any feeling anyway. But then it kind of does because she like goes back to sucking it off and then like flicks his knob or whatever. Right. So a lot of it feels good now. He also has this great line about consent that thinks I hate it.

He says, you say you do not want it. The only thing that says you do not want it is your mouth. That's all that has to say it, sir. That's the only thing that matters. I hate it. I hate it. I hate it. I hate this consent. It's awful. But that brings us to the end of chapter three and we are now heading into chapter four. They've done the deed. She kept up her end of the bargain. They're going hunting. So they go hunting. And as they're hunting for animals, Liz is trying to use her bow and trying to

put the round with it. She's using tools that she's not familiar with. She's using bow and arrow. So they're not quite moving the way that she's used to. So she, as they're fighting, she hears like a weird noise. And it turns out that they are under attack from the Metlux. Yeah. So this, this sounded, this entire scene kind of bothered me because like, I guess my impression is that they both must be pretty shit hunters because like, Rehosh, they're

like stalking this other deer thing. I think it's a divisdy. And Rehosh is like, stay here, blah, blah. And it's like five seconds later, there's like a Metlux behind her. I'm like, how did you miss that? Like, Rehosh, big, strong hunter, you're supposed to be good at this shit. And you just left your mate and you didn't realize that you were being tracked by a child. Like what is described as a youngling of a Metlux. And I'm just going to give you a guess that things not super great at play. And it's like clear, what happens here? I nearly emphasize that like, if there's one, then there's like a hundred of them.

So not only did you miss a child, but you missed like the whole plan behind the child. And they hoot. Yeah. It makes sense how this happened. In this battle with the Metlux, Rehosh is trying to do something cool. And I don't really know. It doesn't. It would be cool if it was all about it. Yeah. That's it. Like he's trying to like move in such a way that like he could protect her and like also kill some Metlux. But he like stumbles because it's not well thought out and falls down a cliff into like a pit,

basically, with like three or four Metlux, leaving Liz to her own devices at the top. So the way, the way that I read that is that he intentionally like committed suicide with that. That's how I read it too. Four Metlux. That in my perspective was, okay, great. Thanks bud. There's still like five of these fuckers. Also, can't reiterate this enough. Have no idea where the fuck I am. How, how like you just, you're her only lifeline and you just yitted yourself off of a cliff

and you expected that to like do the trick. Like how useless. That's why I think he was trying to like do something else. Like I could have sworn he was like reaching for something or trying to do something else to try and save her. And then he fell. No, Katie, I think Katie is right because he has a thought specifically that like as he's falling with a brutal cry, I grabbed the two Metlux in front of me. My fingers sink into Fist of the Shaggy Fert. I pitched towards the cliff.

She does not realize I planted it until it's too late. It will even the odds this way. Maybe she can escape with the two or three left. So like he's trying to take like multiple of them out as he just eats himself off of a cliff. So she can ostensibly kill the rest and then just like live in the snow alone. Great, love that. Because she doesn't know where she is. So her solution and all her impotent with them is to take a hostage.

Yeah. She takes the baby Metlux hostage. And they don't like that. But they also have no idea what to do. They're just like, oh, I guess we're going to stop now. Yeah, I don't really understand what her what her plan was. Like I'm going to take this child and you won't kill me. And then what? Also, like they're described as being like really violent and can like tear the flesh off of like a grown hunter's bones.

But they don't do anything when she grabs the kid. They just like. Are you trying to tell me that they care about their young so much that they're not like they they recognize that if they aren't if they don't harm her that the hostage will be okay. Like, are you are you trying to insinuate that Metlux understand a hostage situation? I don't know if I believe that. I don't think I believe either. So she gets away by throwing herself down somehow like she she doesn't throw herself quite as aggressively but she like scooches her way down this cliff is the way that I read this.

Yeah, with hostage and then she gets down there and then just lets him go. Yeah, I mean, we all know that the point of this book is not well written fight scenes right so I just kind of chalked it up to like this is a plot device. Yeah, it is. Yeah, now what's his face is on the brink of death. Yes. So she gets down to the bottom of the cliff or whatever and finds her house like basically comatose. He is not moving.

He is alive that she can tell he has to squish the Metlux underneath him with gross. And she decides that she is going to move him first just by trying to drag him which he like cries out in pain and she's like oh my bad. That's fair broken bones falling off of a cliff that's probably fine. She decides to make a sled of sorts out of things that she finds in her vicinity. And it's like a like a wood underneath the body and then some like rope like pull him and ends up pulling him.

I think at some point she says like three miles I don't think it's actually that far but like drags him for a fair amount of time while he is just basically next to death. And while all this is happening while we're host fell and was in while she's dragging him he's going through this monologue about how much he loves him and how she doesn't want him to die and how they're so good together and it's like I can't you've spent this entire book hating him and now just because he's almost dead suddenly you're in love.

I very much felt like her feelings were a survival instinct, not not entirely due to like her being in the situation that she is but like I'm sure the koi was like freaking out inside to like it just didn't make sense for them to It didn't make sense for her to immediately flip that switch. Yeah. So none of none of her feelings are genuine. But I think the authors like trying to make this like oh they love each other.

And he's like, leave me behind. I'm wounded. And of course she doesn't. But then like she. Okay, so it wasn't helping but pretend it was helping that now she loves him and is going to save him. And it ruins it by saying I decide bribery is the best weapon I have I place my mouth close to his ear. If you come out of this alive or hosh I'll fuck the hell out of you so help me God. But he remembers it even though he's supposed to be comatose.

Right. Yeah. So she gets him back to the cave and like he's taking care of him. And he's like moments of like being awake and then like passing out again. His koi should be like healing him but he says his internal monologue that because they have not sealed the mating bond or whatever by fucking a deal that his koi is not working as well as it should. But he didn't give a good reason for that. It was almost like the koi is mad. So he's just like, well suffer more.

I know I had a lot of questions because like it sounds threatening like he has two different lines like one is like we must obey the call soon. And then when it says like soon it'll stop asking and start demanding like, like take over your body and just like rape her like, I mean how is that really different that what's been happening but also, it's not. It's kind of what happens. And so she's giving him a sponge bath and getting just real turned on because her koi is also like very anxiously wishing to fuck.

So through this, they start like touching each other and like engaging in sex. So they do end up having sex and they have lots of it. A lot of it. There's a lot of several of my no seer just they're having sex like. Okay, but the way that they, so she gets him a bath and he like, they like get a little aroused but she's like, no, you have to rest because you're like dead or whatever. And it's been like nine days.

And so she's like, he like goes back to sleep. It passes out right. And so she's like, I'm exhausted but maybe I can indulge in a sponge bath and so she does and so she's naked. And then suddenly he's just behind her, like eating her out. And then. Yes, I forgot about that. That is 100%. I thought she was giving him a sponge bath. That's not correct. She was giving herself a sponge bath. And then like, he like, eats her out and she's like, no, but then he's like, but yes. And then so he like pushes her, like gets her onto the bed and then is just in her like no warm up period.

Like immediately right in there. Like, okay, if he's the quote unquote, the largest of his tribe. No, no girl you got to warm me up a little bit like a little tongue is not going to get me to a place where I can just accept the great American challenge like in my pussy. Anyways, so yeah, through all of this, they do that they have the sex that's just like immediate with no foreplay. And so after, I don't know if it was sometime during this first exchange or after this first exchange, but through the course of them having lots of sex.

Liz decides to teach him about foreplay, which goes about as well as you think it would. There are parts in this book and this is one of them where it very much feels like they have a mother son relationship. Like, she's trying to teach him the ways of the world or like maybe not mother son but like Cougar baby jail date situation, you know, At one point, he said, he says I squeeze her breast again and she goes no that's you honking my tit. And he goes that's what you said you wanted.

I love the scene after that where she says I talk and slang babe and he's like and now you say I'm a child now I'm offended. So okay, that that's a good example of it's very clear throughout the first book and this book that the sock kuih just don't understand sarcasm at all. And so at some point during the sex, she like gets up and she's like I have to go check the trap somebody's got to do the work around this blah blah and he's like not getting the sarcasm and she just gets mad.

And it just feels so avoidable because I'm like girl you know that he does not get your jokes he you know he doesn't get your slang and so like why are you mad. He's just asking a question and you're just like flying off the handle and being like this is why we're never going to work and this is why you and I are the same people we just happened to have sex last night I don't love you and I'm like what the fuck. And then he like, I don't know puts his hand on our cheek or some shit and the fights over and I'm like, are you mad or not.

I also don't understand. Like the whiplash is so bad. Also, I brought up ellipses last time. The grammar that so I understand that English is Rahash's second language, but Liz doesn't correct the way he uses words. So he says like I would foreplay you now and she never like corrects that and then they continue. He continues to use it like that like I will foreplay you or the mating with our mouths like she doesn't call like she doesn't tell him what it's called and they just keep using these weird words.

And I like why. So the other thing at the end of this section of just like a lot of sex and like again no plot points is that she's Liz is already talking like she's 100% pregnant. She's like, oh, I don't even remember what she says but I'm just like, again, this is not how fertility cycles work. It starts with him though because he's like you cannot go hunting now. Even now you might be carrying my child, our child.

Like yeah, no 100% he's also on board but I'm just like Liz you're supposed to be the one that doesn't want this and like has questions and like is a critical thinker and you're the one that's just like nope I'm already pregnant and I'm like we'll get a turkey baster out and fix that real fucking fast because it's just swimming around in you like it's going to take another 10 days for you to know. There's also a scene where like he comes in her and then intentionally like uses his fingers to like keep it in there and like says that's what he's doing and I I have the same problem of fertility cycles.

But then later we learn in the story that like you carry a child on this planet for three fucking years. So like why is the fertility cycle super fucking short and then you're like you have a life sentence of pregnancy with this thing. Yeah, it doesn't make any sense make it make sense. So this will they won't they story continues but she finally convinced them to like get out and check the trap and they get out of their cave and immediately they are found by somebody. They're hearing like voices that are calling to them and like Liz is excited because she's like oh my God I can finally leave this cave I'm so excited.

But she looks back at Rosh and Rosh is not happy he is not okay with these people having found them. And he's being really cagey about it. And so she decides that like it's because they don't like him or something and so she decides to put on like the sauce of like I love you and where together and it's all it's you and me baby against the world now. She's saying this to him and I think she does meet it to him, but at some point in the book like she's doing this in front of other people and it just sounds so fake because she spent most of the book going back and forth from moment to moment whether she does or does not like him.

Yeah, no I agree. So the two people that find them are Hayden and not his name but I read it as a Kiko. And they mention kind of in a veiled way the fact that like Rosh has broken the rules quote unquote. And for the life of me like this entire thing feels so contrived and as does what happens next when they get back to the village, because the storyline of this book is almost exactly the storyline of the first book. So whatever the fuck Rosh did, Vektel did too.

And so Rosh is in trouble for that. Let's get into that a little bit more. So basically, the people find them in the cave and they begin to track back to the tribal cave. And they have to stop for the night and at one point they stop and there's a fire and Rosh and somebody else go to like look for food and her and I have it so the word is for the name is A-E-H-A-K-O and I have it as I pronounce it as a Kiko. I have a Kiko. I also read a Kiko but according to Ruby Dixon it is I-H-A-K-O.

So I-H-A-K-O, Lukey and Liz are sat there by the fire and they are talking about what happened with Rosh and like what his quote unquote Theo is. His baby trauma. His mother only resonated for his father the one time and then never again. Um, yeah so like he, they resonated for each other and she was in love with someone else but they like made Rosh and then like years passed and she was in love with someone else and then resonated again and the chief was like okay you don't have to like live with Rosh's dad but you have to make a baby with him.

Yeah and so but that made Rosh's dad really angry and so he kidnapped both the pregnant mom Rosh and like fucked off from the village and they weren't seen for years until they finally did return and it was just Rosh's father and Rosh and his mother and the other child were nowhere to be seen and so his father was exiled from the village and Rosh basically had to grow up with this tragic backstory and everybody being like, skived out by his dad.

Yeah, I, this is not explicitly stated but I feel like his dad killed his mom and his sibling and then there was some like he came back with like the scars and stuff so it's like he was abused but no, the story doesn't make sense to me and I also feel like it kind of changes later, like it doesn't make sense. Well and so there was part of me reading this backstory and I'm like that's cool. I guess that's a plot device for why he's so overly protective of Liz but you don't really need that because Vectel did the same shit and he has sensibly had a great childhood.

So it just, I read this and I was like, do I care? I don't really care. It seems like this is very convenient for the next thing that happens in the book. But basically, Rosh comes back from hunting along with other guys and they are going to bed and Liz and Rosh decided to have sex behind a bush. Such privacy, wow. And like purposely trying to make a bunch of noise so that the guys that they're with know that they are mates. And so it's a little awkward for everybody involved except for apparently Liz who's apparently thriving on this sort of voyeurism like wants him to make more noise, wants him to like really drive home to the point that they are mates because she is his and really tried to drive that home.

But they get back to the caves the next day, the tribal cave, and all the women come out and are like very excited to see Liz and make sure that she's okay and Rosh is kind of being escorted off with some of the other men of that species. And he looks a little uncomfortable, but the Liz gets distracted by the Liz. Liz gets distracted with the women there and getting like a kind of status check and like who's with who now who's pregnant.

And she gets this as they are going to go see the healer with Georgie. So it's Georgie and Liz going to see the healer and having her get back up. And that's where we learned that Liz is pregnant. Yay. Ooh, that baby batter worked. Yeah, she gets back in this like one of the first things that she tells Georgie is like, yep, I'm pregnant. And like all of the women are kind of asking her like, are you okay? Nudge nudge, wink wink, like it's okay if you're not okay, you can tell us.

And like they take her to the healer to check out like basically if she's been hurt. And that isn't something that Liz catches on to immediately. But she does kind of sense that something is not right here. So through all of this they do confirm that she's pregnant and she's very excited to tell her host because all he's wanted forever and he knows this because that's all he's talked about. But let's be clear, 12 days. They're entirely. Yeah, so long. It's like an eon. That's twice as long as Vector and Georgie.

I mean, true. I mean, so they get done at the healer and then basically Liz wants to tell Rihosh. They're reunited with the men's is and the men's is announced that Rihosh has to be exiled because he broke the fucking rules. And I guess the fucking rule is you can't kidnap somebody. But like I I just want to know where the evidence is for this. Like it seems all very contrived. It's super contrived. And they keep talking about like laws.

But the only time they really talk about anything being a law is one when they were like giving all of the girls their kuih. And then there's this like unspoken law that you can't put the women in danger. Yeah, I mean, so that that's what I I have so many questions because like you can't kidnap, but you also can't put them in danger. I guess like there's a big middle ground there between like putting them in danger and then like also putting their mental health in danger because I mean ostensibly forcing them all to take a kuih when like you didn't know if you were going to survive.

Could be very traumatic. So I don't know like Rihosh gets exiled and Liz is upset and they're they're Georgie is trying to console her and basically says like, Oh, that girl is trying to look strong in front of the other hunters because he doesn't want to set the president that like they can just cart one of the women off to a cave until one of them resonates and like yes, that makes sense. Fine. But like, no one asked Liz what happened at all. And they all just kind of assumed that like, yeah, Rihosh is his father.

Yes, which again, makes the whole backstory seem very convenient. I also so Liz keeps trying to defend him even though no one gives two shits what she says. But she does say this phrase at least once where she says he did what he had to do. So did he really have to kidnap you like we're on board with that now because I don't think she was exiled and that's a stupid rule. But like let's be clear. There was no reason for him to kidnap her. No, even with the backstory, because this is where the backstory to me doesn't make sense because the issue is that his mom never loved his dad.

Locking her in a cave isn't going to ensure she actually likes you know. So like the backstory doesn't do anything for that. Also, going back to me being hyper critical in the first book where Georgie likes to claim Stockholm syndrome. I think Liz actually has Stockholm. Yeah, 100%. But she never says it. It hasn't been that long. But yes. But she was not voluntarily taken where Georgie's like, let's go to the river. I have Stockholm syndrome.

Liz was like tied up and put in a cave. So the other part of this punishment to me that seems very like one sided and really grinds my gears is that Liz is effectively being punished now too because Stockholm syndrome or not. She just wants to go with Rehose and they like won't let her leave the village. So she is de facto a prisoner and I'm like, okay, I'm confused. Can you put the women in danger or are they just cattle? Because this very much seems like they're just cattle because they're trying to wife her up with another dude now to like take over the baby that's in her whatever.

And it's just like this culty tribal bullshit. Can we just let them both leave? I don't understand. I yeah, I had this same right issue is like, why is them forcing her to stay? Okay, though. And like isn't the point that you need to repopulate so like why are you getting rid of someone that like she wants to do and make babies with? Or like your cave is already too small for the people that you have right here. It's overcrowded. They say that a number of different times in a number of different ways like what's to less people. They want to leave let them leave.

Yeah, the other thing that I think is interesting. You guys are all making some really great points. But also, when they kick her hush out, he doesn't leave. He just stands at the mouth of the cave for far too long. And then eventually he'll go and hunt and bring food to the cave and then just sit there and watch the cave like a weirdo. Yeah, he doesn't you're right. He doesn't actually leave. The one thing so Liz you had said that you started this book really liking Liz and then by the end you hate her. I do agree with that. I don't like this character. But I didn't start out liking her.

The one part about this character that I like is that as soon as like she doesn't get what she wants, she is down to bring everybody into hell with her. She says seat of descent firmly planted. I bite back my smile and so cheerfully if I'm going to be fucking miserable I'm going to take them all down with me and like that energy I can get behind. I also really like that energy because her she reeks havoc like not even like in any way to really like get her goal of getting her hush back she's just like fuck all you I'm going to make all of you miserable including like the fellow humans.

Yeah, but at one point she does have an idea on how to get herself exiled so she can be with brahash. She decides to hit nap. I. Hi oh hi, hi, hi, I Kiko. I Kiko. I Kiko. I, I, I, she decides to kidnap I Haka Lugi. She has figured out that if she just does what we're hosted, which is like drag someone out into the snow against their will quote unquote, so she does this.

Like, she goes out to like with, I think it was Kira, Kira and her go out into the snow to like pick some sort of fruit or like the soap berries, the soap berries. And while they're out there, she takes a Kiko. She goes like, I Kiko. hostage with his knife and tells her to go back and like tell them this is also probably my favorite time because they just decide I think it goes like you're not going to do anything to me and they just decide that like they're just going to sit there and have a nice conversation while they wait for someone to come back to find them.

And he even she even gives him back his knife. Like, yep. I love that scene. So much like he's she says, Oh yeah, as soon as Kira left, Kiko took his knife back and then we just, you know, sat around and chatted about Kira, mostly yes, but then like the people come back out and they stand back up. And Liz is like, Hey, buddy, give me the knife, you're supposed to be kidnapped and he's like, Oh yeah, sorry, and like gives her the knife again. He okay so like, I have zero interest in reading any more of these books. But I like him I would have read his book. He's a delight. Anyway, we're so close to closing this one out.

So, does bring us home. Basically, much like she planned. She did commit the wrong bad thing bad law things and she gets exiled, but also only kind of. So what they decide on is that they're exiled and they have to hunt together. And they can come back to the cave for like a certain amount of time until the baby is born and then once the baby is born they can live there. But when they stay in the cave they have to stay with the other hunters so it's not like a private room for just them, which flash forward a little bit once they've agreed to this sort of quote unquote,

banishment or exile sort of. They do go back to the hunters cave to prepare to set out to hunt the next morning. And Liz decides to make it as awkward as humanly possible or as a really possible for anyone to stay in that room by having loud and aggressive sex. So that she can't have one night without sex like they're going to leave for a week tomorrow and be alone. So the whole the whole thing with this like new punishment that just so much I roll is that Bechtel makes this big show of like, just because it's the sock way does it mean that it's the right way blah blah blah women are people to if they want to hunt I guess they can hunt I roll.

Oh my god. Are we done. I'm so over it. So my point is, when they're having a lot of aggressive sex about your cave. It's doggy style, because Georgie mentions to Liz like hey, you know you could do doggy style they've never done that before because pale. And the question I have is will every book and a doggy style will every book just end with a nice doggy style fucking. That was my exact comment. So yes, will every book and and a doggy style.

The world may never know because we will not be continuing on. This is why we have a podcast. So let's get into our ratings. I'm going to do our ratings a little differently than we did the last time I'm actually can have you go through all of them. So, what would you recommend it from price level here.

Yeah, I could do that. How did you rate the writing style. I also read this one lower than the first book. While I thought the first book was really well written. I don't know I still find the writing style of this author very approachable but it's more of the same it wasn't very varied. There were some very obvious errors in the editing of this book and so it just kind of knocked it down a couple of times for me. And finally, how would you rate the quality of story.

Well, there was no plot and so I rated it a one. And overall, I would not recommend this book. There you go. Great from Katie's mouth to our ears. Liz, you're up next. Spice level. So I actually rated the spice level higher than the first book because at least it wasn't all missionary and I do like the oral sex scenes, pulling out the consent issues but once they were consented.

Kind of there's lots of dubiousness. I liked the, I like the oral sex scenes. Those are fun. I gave that a three out of five. There's a lot of great I wouldn't reach for this book, but how did you write the writing style. I rated it a two. I agree with Katie that I think the her style is really approachable but the content kills it for me like I like the way she writes but I can't get past the.

I can't get past her plot. A quality of storytelling. I also rated it a one. It was a big ol nothing burger and like Katie said I love that word so I stole it. And the plot that was there was just upsetting to me. The plot revolves around non consent and I. So would you recommend this book. I would not especially if you have any potential triggers for any kind of assault rape or molestation because it's all up in there.

Yeah. So moving on to my recommendations I'm not going to get too far into them just because mine completely math. Liz's I give it a three for spice a two for writing style and a one for quality of storytelling and I would not recommend it. I didn't recommend the first book. I don't recommend this book. There are too many triggers. I don't find the writing to be that compelling like yes it's approachable but compelling it is not and the story is full of full. So for one split moment in the book like when he was getting exiled. I was like oh this could be interesting and then it wasn't it was really anticlimactic because like they were just exiled together through like a fake kidnapping.

I have nothing but I have a lot of feelings about this book and most of them are negative. So with that we did it guys we have done I split our variants to which is our variant helium by B. Dixon.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Irresistible Urge to Fall for Your Enemy By Brigitte Knightley Part 1

    Nov 10, 20261 hr 35 minAudio

    Triggers: graphic violence and gore, depictions of a fictional plague, on-page sexual content (including masturbation), and themes of parent death and chronic illness KU: No Recommendation: No, (give the author money...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Surrendering to Scylla by Wren K Morris

    Oct 27, 20261 hr 10 minAudio

    Triggers: (From the author): kidnapping, violence, discussions of abuse, BDSM dynamics and play, tentacle play, brief descriptions of injured animal (that receives aid), breath play, bondage, depictions of sub drop,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Threshing Day by Rebecca Yarros

    Oct 14, 20261 hr 9 minAudio

    Triggers: war, battle, hand-to-hand combat, perilous situations, blood, intense violence, brutal injuries, death, and poisoning KU: No Recommendation: Yes! For more of the author, check out https://rebeccayarros.com/

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Court of Heathens by K. A. Knight

    Sep 29, 202652 minAudio

    Triggers: from the author: “explicit violence, explicit sexual violence, dubious consent, murder, gore, torture, kidnapping, and more.” KU: Yes Recommendation: No For more of the author, check out...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Under Loch and Key by Lana Ferguson Part 2

    Sep 21, 20261 hr 4 minAudio

    Triggers: death of a parent (off page), grief, fantasy violence KU: No Recommendation: both Traders recommend! This is part 2 of 2. For more of the author, check out https://www.lanaferguson.com/

    Credit the people on this episode